#[SOLVED] Headphones never work [Wired JACK]
101 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
i think there is a package named pipewire-jack
its installed
im out
I will love you till you keep this up,
most other people just like to waste time
can you see and/or switch to the wired sink in something like pavucontrol?
Could be that the device and sink is up and live, but it is not auto-detecting and switching
no, built in to the laptop
the system acts like nothing is wrong and keeps playing audio through the headphones [there is no actual sound]
for example
So with headphones selected as in your screenshot the audio does not come out of the headphones, and the speakers still work?
yeah
If someone could please report this, Its too hard for me
its been like this since I started trying linux 3 years ago
debian based distros would have no sound at all but fedora and arch gave me sound sometimes
for 3 months sometimes
debian distros not having sound is semi-expected as you have to jump through some hoops to get proprietary drivers in it
Sound drivers are often closed source
yeah
I hate to say it but if it is not working across different distros and with different desktop environs (gnome vs kde) then it's starting to smell like hardware to me
obviously not, my headphones work on all devices [android phones] and on windows
Not your headphones, the laptop audio stack
but it works on windows
It'll work in windows because they sell that machine with windows
without hickups
The manufacturers actually have to care with windows
do you have sof-firmware installed?
yeah thats true
if that were not installed I won't be getting sound through my speakers either
Yeah, I'm clutching at straws
I've had machines with similar symptoms in the past and I ended up giving up and putting it down to shitty audio firmware from the manufacturer.
I'm curious if anyone else knows a secret trick for it!
.
these few problems make me not want to be on linux also I hate my father, I knew I'd have many problems with a laptop and told him to buy a computer but nope
HDR does'nt work, display color calibration does'nt work either
BTW if I boot live fedora right now, sound would work through my headphones @elfin granite
You mean it works fine in the iso environ?
I told ya guys it works for a random amount of time
on fedora or arch on first install
If so, try lspci -k | grep -iA3 audio on each and compare. It will spit out what audio devices, modules and drivers are in use. If they're different in the iso vs install then that might be a clue
and yes I do not do any funky shit on the system after install
00:1f.3 Multimedia audio controller: Intel Corporation Meteor Lake-P HD Audio Controller (rev 20)
Subsystem: Hewlett-Packard Company Device 8c58
Kernel driver in use: sof-audio-pci-intel-mtl
Kernel modules: snd_hda_intel, snd_sof_pci_intel_mtl
00:1f.4 SMBus: Intel Corporation Meteor Lake-P SMBus Controller (rev 20)
Subsystem: Hewlett-Packard Company Device 8c58
01:00.1 Audio device: NVIDIA Corporation AD107 High Definition Audio Controller (rev a1)
Subsystem: Hewlett-Packard Company Device 8c58
Kernel driver in use: snd_hda_intel
Kernel modules: snd_hda_intel
I don't have fedora right now
hmmmmmmmmmmm
I see two audio devices 👀
I wonder if they're fighting each other. That might explain this
NOPE, not at all
How can you be so sure? :P
nvidia is used when hdmi is connected, to control TV / Monitor audio
That's sensible
I will test on fedora in 2 min
00:1f.3 Multimedia audio controller: Intel Corporation Tiger Lake-LP Smart Sound Technology Audio Controller (rev 20)
Subsystem: Lenovo Device 3838
Kernel driver in use: snd_hda_intel
Kernel modules: snd_hda_intel, snd_soc_avs, snd_sof_pci_intel_tgl
``` my lspci for comparison, just as a datapoint
the biggest reason for my shit not working because it is more bleeding edge than arch itself
lspci -k | grep -iA3 audio
@elfin granite
Yeah that's frustrating. I was hoping to see something different we could work with
it started working again lol
Fun! If it craps out again, check dmesg. It might have some logs saying what happened
It stopped working again, I think I might know why, I booted windows then I went back to linux now they are not working
Damn, I fixed it by restarting windows without headphones and saved and exit bios settings without changing any which resets some devices and now it works again. WTF my laptop or windows is so weird
that means removing windows from my laptop would fix this problem forever LOL
my wired jack headphones stop working on linux if I open windows even once, but they start working on linux when I go to bios settings and change nothing and do save and exit, that might somehow reset the device. can I add a kernel parameter to automate this specifically for jack audio?
maybe you have fast startup enabled on windows, so it leaves your sound card (and the rest of your hardware) in a weird state
@inland dawn
nope
i'm clueless then
@hearty nova
are you certain?
the settings are in quite an obscure place in windows. Hibernation also needs to be disabled
hibernation / fast startup was always disabled and yes I am 100% sure I tried this 5 times
@elfin granite
what do you mean windows settings? Ive nothing to do with them
These badgers
😭 Ive had to fix 10 different "niche" problems in linux on my own
bro I know, I am literally a power user running a personally customized windows ISO using NTLite and multiple powershell comands
I interpreted this as asking what windows settings I meant
K understood
The idea is that windows doesn't actually shut down properly when those are active, so it can reserve hardware and make it unusable in another OS
You going into the bios and it working after really really hints to that
But if you're sure they're off then 😞
I understand what your saying, Ive done the disabling fast startup and / or hibernation and it has'nt worked, that is why I was asking for a way to reset that specific device at startup of linux
I tried snd reset param in kernel options, did'nt work
It's a layer before the OS really. ACPI tables. Im sure it's possible though
At least I can use my headphones fine for the most part now so thats good, I only use windows to watch netflix due to linux drm restrictions
try to research or ask some smart guy, I feel this is possible
I will keep this thread open forever IDC how long it takes. BYE I am gonna study math
could it be due to dts headphones x enabled its done through a propriatary app
@elfin granite
@elfin granite ping number 2
I found the fix
shutting down works and restarts dont
So much for studying lol
That tracks