#Starship Orbital Test Flight

1 messages · Page 8 of 1

gleaming schooner
#

kemp approves

whole hawk
#

Very steep from liftoff

compact tinsel
#

You can still shit on SLS. I did this morning. shrug

whole hawk
brittle spire
#

I should've remembered the stupid flip stage seperation manoeuvre and realized it was going to be the killer

white oyster
#

Wwwooo

#

I was about 5 mins late, but at least i saw the FUN part of it

vagrant moat
#

So how many launches do y'all think it'll take for the thing to actually work

white oyster
#

Anyone notice what happened around stafe 0 though? People are going to be MAD

vagrant moat
#

I say 5 before it reaches orbit

white oyster
#

I would say 2 more before it can sucesfully do an orbit
About 7 or 8 for landing (both)

vagrant moat
#

Yeah, 5 total I mean

#

So success on the fifth flight

reef cobalt
#

I'm thinking next will separate successfully but something will fail during re-entry. I don't trust the tiles atm.

white oyster
#

I mean, if whatever caused it to spin out didnt happen, i think it could have made it

zealous crystal
#

I say two or three launches

vagrant moat
fast meadow
white oyster
#

Not sure why they didnt sep

modest heron
#

They forgor the decoupler

whole moat
south spindle
fast terrace
#

they replaced Starship with Polyus

white oyster
#

At least its making my KSP look better XD at least i dont flip out THAT badly lol

remote onyx
#

Spin

fluid bobcat
rich blade
#

ok I am here

fluid bobcat
#

wait

#

I'm not a thing anymore

modest heron
#

No

keen plover
#

You died

rich blade
#

still processing what I watched

#

i need to scroll back in this chat to see what the reaction was to liftoff kekw

fluid bobcat
rich blade
#

actually cannot believe ther it went

rich blade
#

new crater in south Texas

rich blade
#

haven't looked at twitter or the other streams

oak sable
#

We don't need flame diverter™️

rich blade
#

literally just managed to watch it

fluid bobcat
whole hawk
hollow plaza
whole moat
#

It also was running like, what, 2100 km/hr at stage sep? That’s not even Mach 2

#

580 m/s

rich blade
#

still speechless kekw

#

I'm happy it managed to fly

#

and it was funny when it started tumbling

#

tbh I knew it was gonna fail when I saw how slowly it was accelerating

#

love how like 5 engines failed in the first few seconds

brittle spire
#

I knew it was going to be funny when the stage didn't seperate

rich blade
#

haha yeah lol

gleaming schooner
tacit kite
#

MY MODAMERICA TEACHER PUT IT UP ON THE BOARD

rich blade
#

WAIT DID IT POWERSLIDE OF THE MOUNT??

tacit kite
#

yep

rich blade
fluid bobcat
#

no joke

tacit kite
#

hpu did a funny

rich blade
#

watching NSF replay

fluid bobcat
#

did one of the cameras fall off inside one of the tanks?

hollow plaza
whole hawk
rich blade
#

and I can clearly see the POWERSLIDE

hollow plaza
#

Not as much as rocket 3 but it did a littlw

tacit kite
#

WE HAVE JONE

rich blade
#

yeah

#

WE HAVE JONE

#

I'm so happy

#

this is so cool

tacit kite
#

i’m not getting shit done the rest of the day

whole hawk
rich blade
#

NOOO hoppy r u ok

reef cobalt
fast terrace
#

ASTRA NUMBAH ONE

slim kelp
#

isn't that just NASA?

rich blade
#

Spacex managed to pull off an Astra and a Firefly in one launch kekw

fast terrace
#

N1 and Polyus too

rich blade
#

yeah

slim kelp
#

what are all those number roles you got?

#

1-5, 5-10 and allat

white oyster
#

in nsf chat someone mentioned at 33s the HPU exploded, which you can see in the spacex stream

whole moat
white oyster
#

so NSF van has a few dints

#

SB, thats 33 seconds of initial success

reef cobalt
white oyster
#

i mean, how long was it ""flying"" for?

fluid bobcat
fast meadow
#

The debris!

raven scroll
#

Sooooooooo lmao

#

How'd that happen

white oyster
# fluid bobcat What's the hpu and where can u see it

think its hydraulic preassure unit, the box thing on the side with batteries

timestamped, at +33 on their clock, the units facing the cam

https://youtu.be/-1wcilQ58hI?t=2720

SpaceX is targeting as soon as Thursday, April 20 for the first flight test of a fully integrated Starship and Super Heavy rocket from Starbase in Texas. The 62 minute launch window opens at 8:28 a.m. CT and closes at 9:30 a.m. CT.

Starship is a fully reusable transportation system designed to carry both crew and cargo to Earth orbit, help huma...

▶ Play video
raven scroll
#

It's meant to flip but then it just didn't shut down?

white oyster
#

actually its +29

#

+33 seems to been fire from it when one of the engines flamed out

whole hawk
#

Yeah

white oyster
#

also from the sopacex cam looking up into the engines, you can see fire inside where the engines are

fluid bobcat
fluid bobcat
white oyster
#

theres going to be LOADs of analysis of this

#

cant wait to see what scott manley has to say

white oyster
#

unfortunately, there was worse things than dirt falling it caused 😦

fluid bobcat
white oyster
#

like a lot of mess that EPA wont be happy at

#

i missed the launch, got it a few mins in, which is arguably the better half

#

rewound though and pretended it was live so i was fully up to speed XD

fluid bobcat
#

How come the engines never shut down?

white oyster
#

5 of them did, at one moment a 6th failed but they managed to turn that back on

tacit kite
#

engine failure? Just fuckin turn it back on lmao

white oyster
#

on the spacex stream they have a display of both heavy and starship engines with white/black circles depending if theyre active

white oyster
hollow plaza
#

At least on the diagram

white oyster
#

propably fuel flow issues as they never tested raptors (or booster) in motion like THAT

tacit kite
#

suprised the damn thing lasted that long

white oyster
#

im suprised stage0 is "intact"

tacit kite
#

structural team popping off rn

fluid bobcat
white oyster
#

when we get close images its propably got more kinks, dints and breakages than a scrapyard

ebon stratus
#

Why was it held down so long

white oyster
#

interstage? the bit that disconnects booster/starship?

tacit kite
#

the bit that allegedly disconnects them

#

not very good at its job

white oyster
#

NSF say it looks like it was fuel rich, would a fuel rich cause more thrust than otherwise be expected?

hollow plaza
fluid bobcat
hollow plaza
#

Then they have to all come to power

white oyster
raven scroll
fluid bobcat
raven scroll
#

Unless they have some in flight restart system

white oyster
#

where they test raptors individually,t hey have been testing restarting engines repeatedly

#

mcgreggor*

raven scroll
#

Yeah but what I mean is restart to recover from shutdown

#

Not just restarting

white oyster
#

propably computer controled, the computer would check all sensors to make sure it seems fine, and if the sensors read ok it will keep trying

ebon stratus
#

Jesus Christ

fluid bobcat
ebon stratus
#

Lmao yeah, a diverted would’ve been so cheap too

rich blade
#

what a shot

#

John kraus photos

#

@timber relic so how was it 😁

thick sphinx
#

It's time to install a flame diverter and come up with Raptor 3

white oyster
rich blade
#

yeah ik maybe he will see it later

timber relic
rich blade
#

same kekw

zealous crystal
#

LMAOOOO

rich blade
#

LMAO

#

don't worry SLS is still the most powerful rocket to get to orbit

compact tinsel
whole hawk
whole moat
white oyster
#

everyday astronaut "im going to be on that thing!!!"

uuhh maybe you shoulv kept that though till later lol

whole moat
whole hawk
compact tinsel
thick sphinx
#

Bad for the concrete and rest of the structure more than anything

#

Is my understanding

zealous crystal
#

I hope it's real

white oyster
#

think i saw that shot, but mirrored

whole moat
compact tinsel
#

Pretty high for 420

ebon stratus
#

Undermines the foundation of the structure

zealous crystal
whole moat
#

also btw starship tiles don’t look like TUFROC to me

pulsar pollen
#

Reading the public perception of this is a struggle

#

Everyone be like “Haha Elon stoopid penis rocket go boom”

zealous crystal
zealous crystal
#

In one week, we had JUICE and the Starship. Eight years of work and a revolution for the launchers respectively.
I need a lemonade and a night of rest

white oyster
#

might be a real pic? there are confirmed cameras on the flaps themselves (from the last attempt)

zealous crystal
#

(The author of the tweet worked on JUICE)

compact tinsel
#

The public should just go back to watching their reality tv shows and stuffing their face with junk food.

pulsar pollen
pulsar pollen
#

I’m kinda still processing that Starship has launched

white oyster
#

i hope spacex releases the full dfootage of flap-cam

zealous crystal
pulsar pollen
zealous crystal
#

The most powerful rocket in history went kaboom

#

and things happened

#

Oh my god

pulsar pollen
#

It was so fucking cool

zealous crystal
#

I JUST FUCKING LOVE IT

pulsar pollen
#

It reminds me of one of the N1 launches

ebon stratus
white oyster
#

i just loved how it clearly went out of control, but spacex were still trying to kerbal it back on course

zealous crystal
#

💀

pulsar pollen
#

All I’m saying is that SLS had a flame diverter and it still damaged the pad and tower

#

Starship is more powerful than SLS

#

I connected the dots that Elon couldn’t?

white oyster
#

what if they make a diverter thats 145 degrees? so its not blasting the nature reserve or equipment, just straight back upards at an angle awat?

remote onyx
pulsar pollen
#

It’s been done before with early American rockets

white oyster
#

its odd how the pad legs have the beams that connect them appear to be intact in a perfect hex shape

ebon stratus
remote onyx
#

It seems all the concrete is good though, just rather exposed

pulsar pollen
#

I wasn’t legitimately criticizing Elon, I know what his thought process was

white oyster
#

spacex are experimenting on the concrete though?

ebon stratus
tacit kite
#

my only hope is that the IMAX camera survived

pulsar pollen
#

We NEED the footage

white oyster
#

imax? XD you mean were going to get a cinema 4D of it? XD

pulsar pollen
#

SpaceX’s edit of this will be phenomenal

remote onyx
pulsar pollen
rich blade
#

@zealous crystal are you alive

zealous crystal
#

Everything about that launch was bonkers

rich blade
#

yes it was

whole hawk
#

Bruuhh

rich blade
#

lol

#

#orangerocketgood

zealous crystal
white oyster
#

sure new vehicles are more efficient and better

but nothing beats an ol' classic

pulsar pollen
#

Is this the fella who hates starship and loves SLS?

ebon stratus
#

No

zealous crystal
pulsar pollen
#

Oh

ebon stratus
#

He doesn’t hate starship

zealous crystal
#

He has an unconditional love for SLS

pulsar pollen
#

Got it

rich blade
#

my lock screen is SLS and my home screen is starship, two SHLLVs, god bless

zealous crystal
#

But he likes Starship too

ebon stratus
#

but he’s the biggest pro-SLS guy out there

pulsar pollen
zealous crystal
#

(He even rooted for a success earlier this week)

ebon stratus
#

Yeah

pulsar pollen
#

Well yeah

#

Any spaceflight nerd loves both of these rockets

ebon stratus
#

And agreed with the sentiment that making it past the tower would be good

zealous crystal
#

We live in crazy times

white oyster
zealous crystal
#

Two SLHVs entering operation in less than a year

pulsar pollen
#

RIGHT!?

#

I wanna make an edit of it

ebon stratus
#

I’m not sure Starship is entering operation any time soon

pulsar pollen
#

But I need the good footage of the launch

rich blade
#

idk if this is operational for starship

shell python
rich blade
#

but we can say that two SHLLVs launched within under 6 months

zealous crystal
#

Should have said "launched"

pulsar pollen
#

Starship probably won’t be making a human spaceflight until the end of next year at earliest

zealous crystal
#

instead of "entering operation"

#

Two SLHVs launching in less than a year

#

oh my fucking god

pulsar pollen
#

And then falcon heavy on Wednesday

whole hawk
pulsar pollen
#

Not super heavy but cool

whole hawk
#

Future astronauts 🥹

zealous crystal
ebon stratus
#

Technically SLS isn’t in operation yet either

rich blade
#

i need more images pls spacex

#

yeah SLS will be in operation once A2 launches

pulsar pollen
#

I need the engineering cams from SpaceX

#

THEY also need the engineering cams

rich blade
#

I just need the pretty pictures from spacex

zealous crystal
#

We all need the engineering cams

pulsar pollen
#

One of the engines straight up exploded on the pad; I need to see that up close

shell python
shell python
rich blade
rich blade
pulsar pollen
#

I love how I immediately adopt a professional engineering mindset when launches like these happen

obsidian spoke
#

ik some people are saying starship wont land on moon

pulsar pollen
#

But when I’m in an exam I’m a fifth grader again

obsidian spoke
#

im sure some politicians (spacificly in wa and al)

#

will say we need a new lander

#

does anyone here doubt it will eventually be sucsessful

thick sphinx
rich blade
#

need to remember, this is a test program

obsidian spoke
#

i agree

pulsar pollen
rich blade
#

many more tests to come

obsidian spoke
pulsar pollen
#

Unless Congress says “FUCK STARSHIP, PICK SOMEONE ELSE” then Starship remains the chosen option

thick sphinx
#

I'm gonna say they get orbital next time but botch re-entry

pulsar pollen
#

I’m thinking that engine flameout will be the issue that plagues starship

thick sphinx
#

Probably 5-6 tries until we get the first completely successful flight. Gotta work on Raptor reliability and a flame diverter

#

And pressure issues with stage sep

#

Ofc

rich blade
#

guys

#

what now

pulsar pollen
rich blade
#

pad looks lonely and hurt

obsidian spoke
pulsar pollen
#

They have to rebuild the pad, which will take a while

shell python
#

this makes me quite worried because R2 was supposed to solve the reliability issues

thick sphinx
obsidian spoke
#

i definently think they will

pulsar pollen
vagrant moat
obsidian spoke
thick sphinx
pulsar pollen
#

We give politicians a lot of shit in spaceflight but they know that this is a test

rich blade
#

all the engines would shut down violently

pulsar pollen
#

We’ll be fine

zealous crystal
pulsar pollen
#

(Kinda?)

zealous crystal
#

oh

thick sphinx
#

Every state has 2 senators so yes

ebon stratus
#

@obsidian spoke already working on a second lander

zealous crystal
#

Oh wait

pulsar pollen
#

Its unlikely tho

zealous crystal
#

there are only 100 Senators

thick sphinx
obsidian spoke
celest silo
#

they should on ramp another lander asap

rich blade
#

just realised next starship flight with tiles and flaps will be 28 and whatever booster will go with it

zealous crystal
obsidian spoke
thick sphinx
ebon stratus
celest silo
pulsar pollen
#

Digging next to the ocean is always hard

zealous crystal
rich blade
#

sea launch it TrollPolite

zealous crystal
#

But you do have local Senates

obsidian spoke
zealous crystal
#

so I guess it's ok

thick sphinx
vagrant moat
shell python
obsidian spoke
#

people in enviromental groups are gonna have a hay day trying to stop

shell python
#

i want to here the lcc loops

ebon stratus
rich blade
#

"we dont need any more of these"

vagrant moat
pulsar pollen
#

Anyways this delays Artemis III by a lot

obsidian spoke
zealous crystal
obsidian spoke
#

and amerispace is saying same

pulsar pollen
#

Hm

zealous crystal
#

Stage Senator

pulsar pollen
zealous crystal
vagrant moat
ebon stratus
pulsar pollen
#

Wdym?

#

HLS will be the lander, won’t it?

zealous crystal
#

Artemis III is already delayed anyway, so who cares

rich blade
#

A3 would be delayed if this detonated on the pad

ebon stratus
rich blade
#

fact that yes, some damaged happened, but the pad and tower are mostly good

ebon stratus
#

But SFT failure doesn’t affect the schedule for HLS

#

Assuming they prepped the schedule to be ready for a fail like this

shell python
ebon stratus
#

Well, NASA did expect this to fail

#

And yeah, NASA is already working on a new lander

celest silo
vagrant moat
ebon stratus
#

the second lander won’t be ready until at least 2028

rich blade
#

is it national team?

pulsar pollen
#

HLS will only be used for Artemis III then, right?

ebon stratus
celest silo
#

Maybe we could buy one lest b2 bomber and send that money nasas way

ebon stratus
celest silo
vagrant moat
whole hawk
ebon stratus
rich blade
ebon stratus
#

And the money from that wouldn’t be enough to fund a second lander

zealous crystal
ebon stratus
#

The second lander is supposed to have more human capability as well

whole hawk
celest silo
ebon stratus
celest silo
rich blade
#

yknow im so surprised the thing didnt break apart when it was spinning

ebon stratus
#

Also we need the B21 to replace our aging bomber fleet

celest silo
#

AHHHH no we dont, we wont be bombing anything for the next 5 years we can weight

#

wait

next sierra
rich blade
#

id love a more detailed shot like this

west umbra
#

I wonder if some of the engine issues were caused by the concrete explosion

rich blade
#

possibly

#

ive heard something happened with the HPU

shell python
shell python
# rich blade id love a more detailed shot like this

Watch in HD.

Celine Dion - My Heart Will Go On
http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/stroheim/163/celineposter.jpg

Celine Dion Official Site :
http://www.celinedion.com/

"My Heart Will Go On" is the theme song of the 1997 blockbuster film Titanic. With music by James Horner and lyrics by Will Jennings, it was recorded by Céline Dion. Or...

▶ Play video
vagrant moat
#

Today really is attracting the lurkers to this server isn't it

whole hawk
rich blade
#

the coundown went really well today

oak sable
rich blade
#

tim and marys reactions to the launch are so funny lmao

tacit kite
#

B7 died as it lived: surviving increasingly severe failures

shell python
vagrant moat
#

So just HOW fucked is the OLM?

#

I saw the crater

zealous crystal
rich blade
#

big crater

obsidian spoke
#

do we know how damaged the tower is

rich blade
#

havent seen the BQD or the hold downs

obsidian spoke
#

that is prob hardest to rebuild

rich blade
#

tower seems to be fine

obsidian spoke
#

i love all the starship will never launch from texas takes

rich blade
#

well it did

vagrant moat
#

I mean tbf it probably won't launch from Texas a lot

oak sable
#

well, almost KEK

rich blade
#

test flights will occur

vagrant moat
#

Operations will likely move to Canaveral down the line

#

But yeah

#

Test flights will of course happen from Boca

rich blade
#

HLS will probably launch from Florida

vagrant moat
#

Yeah

whole hawk
rich blade
#

EDA has some sick footage

rich blade
whole hawk
ebon stratus
rich blade
#

fair

obsidian spoke
rich blade
#

lot of work to do

rich blade
#

cancelled

#

just like terran 1

#

better start tearing down all the purpose built infrastructure and GSE

vagrant moat
obsidian spoke
ebon stratus
#

I’m curious how SpaceX will manage to get Starship reliable enough to support the HLS refueling flights

rich blade
#

thats a bloody good question kekw

#

im sure they will manage (hopefully)

pulsar pollen
#

the space cowboys will find a way

#

the space cowboys always find a way

#

I REALIZE WHY THE ROCKET FLIPPED

rich blade
#

hold on i need to scroll back in this chat to see the reactions to the flight

whole hawk
pulsar pollen
#

The separation command was given, but the computer didn't know that B7 was still attached (because of broken sep joints)
The Booster then began it's turnaround maneuver with the upper stage attached

whole hawk
#

🇺🇸 | NOW: Tesla shares plunge 8% after failed Starship launch.

vagrant moat
whole hawk
#

While the price of SpaceX is rising right now.

pulsar pollen
#

Well yeah

#

They just launched the bigges rocket known to man

#

Telsa shareowners and SpaceX shareowners are very different breeds of human

whole moat
#

“We blew up the biggest rocket ever made” -SpaceX

rich blade
#

not gonna be seeing any testing for a bit now

whole moat
#

and yet the tank watchers will never have rest

rich blade
#

that plume is like 200 metres long

#

maybe not quite 200

#

like 180

burnt bloom
shell python
#

No injuries

brittle spire
#

How extensive is the damage to the launch site?

I've seen the crater and the tank farm damage

#

But beyond that is there more known?

shell python
brittle spire
burnt bloom
#

For sure

#

I was just wondering

rich blade
#

actually kinda makes sense

#

i thought it was cuz of the asymmetric thrust and tat apparently the "interstage" crumbled a bit

burnt bloom
#

Ywha. That crumble was bad

rich blade
#

i mustve missed it but it probably was

thick sphinx
#

yea

#

I'm really not worried about the vehicle issues, SpX can fix those and rebound in a month or two

#

I'm worried about the launchpad issues

whole hawk
#

One of GSE's LOX tanks is leaking

brittle spire
#

I think it's not weird to say that interstage crumbled, which meant the seperation mechanic didn't work

And then the first stage tried to do it's return to water, which got overcomplicated about that pecky Starship not wanting to let go

rich blade
#

i think structural stability is overall mostly positive tho(yes ik the interstage was screwed), the thing stayed as one piece as it was flipping,

rich blade
brittle spire
#

Of all the Elon quotes, "we don't need a flame diverter" must've aged the worst

rich blade
#

yeah true kekw

whole hawk
#

Another leak

brittle spire
#

What am I looking at even

thick sphinx
rich blade
whole hawk
#

It's jumping all over the servers

rich blade
#

also suboptimal

brittle spire
#

I think we'll see reinforcements to the interstage

rich blade
#

yeah haha

thick sphinx
#

That one is one of the easier problems to solve here yea

vagrant moat
oak sable
burnt bloom
brittle spire
whole hawk
#

Another milestone

rich blade
#

just realised, we still havent had a ful 33 engines fire

#

maybe we did for a brief moment

whole hawk
burnt bloom
#

Ah. All buckled

rich blade
#

spacex demonstrated today what a typical KSP2 launch looks like

#

evidently forgot to add struts between booster and ship

brittle spire
#

TBH it was such a KSP failure

remote onyx
brittle spire
#

you can easily make a joke about "check your staging"

pulsar pollen
remote onyx
#

recration in vc

ebon stratus
#

Im a little worried about the environmental repercussion from environmental groups

brittle spire
#

ye

#

but we'll see

whole hawk
thick sphinx
#

Like it can be rebuilt as it was but then you have the same problem set up to happen again

shell python
#

yikes.

ebon stratus
rich blade
#

saturn vibes

thick sphinx
ebon stratus
#

There’s also the issue of the fact that particulate dug up by the launch vehicle during ignition started raining down miles away

whole hawk
#

Telemetry

thick sphinx
rich blade
shell python
rich blade
#

life

shell python
vagrant moat
#

So why didn't they want a flame diverter again?

modest heron
#

Because Elon tought he was smart

thick sphinx
ebon stratus
remote onyx
#

how is is this hard to acuratly recreate the death

thick sphinx
vagrant moat
#

Gotcha

thick sphinx
#

so they thought they could get away without it

#

they could not

rich blade
#

look, theres a lot of problems now, but lets enjoy the moment before we have to worry about the issues

ebon stratus
#

And you need to set up retention walls

#

Because the water is gonna wanna see in

thick sphinx
rich blade
thick sphinx
#

my heavy worry is for stage zero

ebon stratus
#

To have a flame diverter it would look a lot closer to LC39

vagrant moat
#

So... what do we do now?

thick sphinx
#

We? Watch

remote onyx
#

wait for news

vagrant moat
#

What do they do now?

thick sphinx
#

SpaceX's civil engineers responsible for launchpad infrastructure have a time and a half ahead of them

shell python
#

with ship anyway?

rich blade
#

watch them repair stuff and wait for S26 or B9 to rollout

thick sphinx
thick sphinx
#

landing mayhaps but thats a different story

rich blade
#

this is THIRTY THREE

shell python
shell python
shell python
rich blade
thick sphinx
vagrant moat
thick sphinx
#

S26 and B9 shouldn't take too long. Next raptors may take a sec. Stage 0 could take years in the worst scenario

shell python
vagrant moat
#

Gotcha

rich blade
#

well, at least the stack didnt rud on the pad

thick sphinx
#

the tower stays, that's fine

#

the tanks get replaced

shell python
#

Raptor 2 was supposed to solve flight reliability issues

vagrant moat
#

This went about as well as I hoped it would TBH

thick sphinx
#

worth pointing out it was on a nominal flight path even with that many engines out

shell python
#

losing 25% of engines in first stage flight is not acceptable

#

for today, sure

thick sphinx
#

but not for humans no

shell python
#

redundancy is great but saying one engine going out is fine is gonna fuck them so hard

thick sphinx
shell python
#

if one engine can fail every engine can fail

rich blade
#

i saw 5

#

at one point

vagrant moat
thick sphinx
# modest heron Was it tho

i mean the trajectory was good up until it got a little spinny but that wasn't cos of the lack of raptors

shell python
shell python
keen plover
thick sphinx
shell python
#

abner gets to swim with rocket parts 🥰

rich blade
#

was kinda hoping for sep

vagrant moat
#

Who the fuck is abner

thick sphinx
#

but sep is hard

rich blade
#

but idk if it staged so early i dont think te ship would ave the TWR to get to orbit

keen plover
#

it could be that w/o the concrete damage we would have had a flawless s1 performance, who knows

shell python
keen plover
#

who says the effects have to be immediate?

rich blade
#

true

shell python
thick sphinx
#

it's not something we can say for sure but yea it's worth pointing out

vagrant moat
#

I still don't understand

thick sphinx
#

cos at the launch mounts the raptors have been very reliable recently

shell python
rich blade
#

certified "yikes, you bet, concur, we dont need any more of these" moment

keen plover
#

engine damage doesnt always happen immediately. This was something that happened a ton in SSME development

shell python
keen plover
#

at leats on the + side it seems the failures, w/e the cause were well contained

vagrant moat
#

Ah

shell python
shell python
rich blade
#

could be

#

loss of pressure in engines

#

or something like that idk

keen plover
vagrant moat
keen plover
#

though ideally non of its neighbors are taken out

#

but again we wouldnt even know for sure if that was the cause

shell python
keen plover
#

SN11?

shell python
keen plover
#

That was a hard start of the raptors during the relight

shell python
#

interesting

#

thought it was inconclusive

#

that actually makes me so mad then

keen plover
#

apparently some electrical stuff for engine control avionics got burned on ascent from a methane leak

shell python
keen plover
#

im still salty SN11 launched in fog

shell python
#

well that took a minute jeez

rich blade
keen plover
#

we could have seen an epic RUD

oak sable
oak sable
zealous crystal
#

FTS did its thing

craggy adder
#

so, just roll it out to the road, and since there's a slope on the road it can act as a flame diverter

#

launch from asphalt

zealous crystal
whole hawk
#

LOX leak from Ship

#

QD failed

#

No closed

shell python
#

that’s not engine chill?

whole moat
whole moat
rich blade
whole moat
#

plus if the QD didn’t close and it was leaking lox it wouldn’t have the propellant even for a normal flight to orbit let alone this barely boosted situation

rich blade
#

EPIC FAIL!

shell python
oak sable
white oyster
#

wow the tank farm took a fair beating

whole hawk
#

Update post launch

#

39 Km

rich blade
white oyster
#

"closed till tomorrow"

#

i wanna see all the nuked landscape

shell python
#

so is it just me or did it start weird

#

no engine ignition at 8 sec

white oyster
#

doesnt it take 8 sec to light them all?

#

i think there was a slight delay at T0 though?

shell python
#

yeah

#

just like with booster sf

rich blade
#

maybe they were counting down to ignition like ariane 5

oak sable
undone gull
#

yep

oak sable
#

(tho I'm too to confirm)

white oyster
#

RGV?

#

oh drones out?

undone gull
#

no, he does flyovers above the tfr

white oyster
#

oohh plane guy

oak sable
#

the guy who provides aerial photographery, been doing it since early Starhopper age

tacit kite
#

that was certainly the flight test of all time

undone gull
#

so just to mention it, this was only 90% thrust, plus they plan to increase the power of raptor

#

im honestly terrified

white oyster
#

💥 🍄

#

tbf we got an upsidown mushroom cloud XD

undone gull
#

starship is scarily powerful

white oyster
#

the blue flames were cool, though oddly i think only one half was blue? the other half was more red?

tacit kite
#

at least I got a new lockscreen

white oyster
tacit kite
white oyster
#

OOOHHH

fluid bobcat
white oyster
#

nature people are going to have a field day of suing spacex for killing wildlife

true aspen
#

Damn the engines were dyinnng

tacit kite
#

one of them died so hard it started working again 💀

oak sable
true aspen
oak sable
#

just like me every monday TrollPolite

modest heron
next sierra
true aspen
#

Yeah that definetly makes more sense, kind weird that the UI was showing extremely low fuel levels on super heavy near when the boom boom happened

shell python
true aspen
#

Oh damn so it went kind of a bit worse than I thought

next sierra
shell python
#

you sure that wasn’t 100 with the dead ones?

pulsar pollen
#

nope

next sierra
true aspen
#

Was watching it in school with no volume

undone gull
pulsar pollen
#

They only went to 90% thrust

true aspen
#

Time to rewatch it

undone gull
#

That was only 90% thrust

next sierra
keen plover
#

I though they throttled up to 100% once they cleared the tower?

next sierra
#

With 8 engines out and probably reduced performance on the remaining ones... yeahhhh

true aspen
#

Any reason why so many engines were hmmm like acting a bit weird?

undone gull
#

Concrete

pulsar pollen
#

and one or more of the engines prob exploded before liftoff which may have damaged others

next sierra
#

Concrete or imo more likely issues with the propellant feed system

pulsar pollen
#

(or maybe they just failed to light)

true aspen
#

Guess it’s time to get a flame diverter

pulsar pollen
#

I cannot believe that this thing had TWICE THE LIFT AS THE SATURN V

#

16 MILLION POUNDS HOLY DHIT

shell python
#

in flight

next sierra
keen plover
#

so when John said on stream that they "throttled down and throttled back up" was that some sort of max Q throttling?

next sierra
pulsar pollen
#

"only"

#

I get what you mean tho

#

but still that's probably the heaviest launch we'll see for a long time

#

(As in heaviest type of rocket)

next sierra
true aspen
#

One hell of a launch that’s for sure

shell python
shell python
#

yes

#

i wonder if they knew with certainty it would fail internally

loud spire
#

Glad I got to watch it

#

Only was a little late to test witch didn't matter

pulsar pollen
placid nova
tacit kite
#

the IMAX camera at the top of the tower

shell python
keen plover
loud spire
#

Already dug for them

white oyster
#

who needs an excavator

indigo frigate
#

Any ideas why the raptors failed?

#

They seemed to fail in clusters

keen plover
#

clearly we need to bring atoms for peace back

keen plover
indigo frigate
#

Did you guys see the raptor that supposedly restarted in flight? Same one 5 seconds after restart made a big orange plume

keen plover
#

I would imagine at least part of it is damage from flying concrete but we have no idea how much was/wasnt caused by it and how much is just raptor moment

white oyster
#

how deep is the hole? like a few stories?

keen plover
#

clearly we need to launch super heavy heavy to dig out the rest of the trench

keen plover
#

so uhh

true aspen
#

Starship just pulled a firefly aerospace alpha flight 1 TrollPolite

keen plover
#

pretty deep

proven field
# indigo frigate Any ideas why the raptors failed?

Probable reasons:

  • Several engines at launch got hit by flying debris or damaged by unplanned acoustic levels, leak fuel and started engine bay fire that damaged a few more and the HPU.

  • One or more engines blew and started a fire (physical barriers are to be added from B9)

  • One or more engines shut down due to excess vibrations or pogo oscillation

  • Just random internal early Raptor 2 failures happening at once

pulsar pollen
white oyster
#

im suprised the foundations seem intact compared to the concrete

remote onyx
white oyster
#

not sure, all of them seem dinted though

indigo frigate
#

I found out that starship actually didnt lose directional control at all until attempted flip separation. Only reason it started tumbling was the failure to separate

loud spire
#

Nsf van got bonked by pad peices

white oyster
#

it was strafing a lot though, so that wouldnt have helped it to detach

white oyster
shell python
indigo frigate
#

I assumed at first the asymmetric thrust caused the tumbling but the tumbling was on a different axis to the engine outs

shell python
#

plus a good ol leak

indigo frigate
#

engine outs seemed to be biased to one half

loud spire
#

Fuel delivery issue maybe

remote onyx
#

How is it supposed to sep, I'm still confused by that

true aspen
#

Didn’t outer and inner engines fail

indigo frigate
#

supposed to LOB the starship lmao

white oyster
#

hey, yes the rocket had 33+1 problems

but at least it left the pad nd spacex has a lot of data to learn from

true aspen
indigo frigate
#

overhand throw that mf

remote onyx
#

With the engine out in pairs I feel that's definitely pointing to concrete damage rather that mechanical issues

indigo frigate
#

The idea is, they dont want ullage thrusters or to have to relight stage 1 engines, So they throttle down the stage 1 engines, start starship upper stage, begin turn and separate all at the same time

keen plover
white oyster
#

starship doesnt have anything to "push" it from what i know, spacex let gravity and momentum to carry starship on, but i heard the locking pins got crushed so they were stuck together

indigo frigate
#

The first stage engines arent meant to relight until final landing burn

#

I wonder if pogo oscilations caused pins to be crushed

next sierra
loud spire
#

Also interstage crushed right

white oyster
#

yeah would have been oscilations or something causing the pins to "bite in", a bit like an impact driver

indigo frigate
#

can see its biased toward one side of the vehicle

remote onyx
#

Yeah, could also be that the lack of power meant it didn't turn fast enough and all stuck together

indigo frigate
#

I wonder if that side is the one which faced something on the ground

#

Lets try and figure out

white oyster
true aspen
#

That flip was insane for such a large vehicle

indigo frigate
#

Would ya look at that, the side with the engines out, faced the big concrete block on the base of the lift tower

true aspen
#

Those 15 degrees really do a lot

indigo frigate
#

clearly would have higher debris, and higher sound energy on that side of the vehicle

#

Do yall concur

remote onyx
rich blade
indigo frigate
keen plover
indigo frigate
#

Yeah absolute chad photographer

shell python
remote onyx
#

I'm still confused how they thought the thin layer of concrete would work on the pad, clearly the big blocks of the foundations were strong enough, why not all that depth

shell python
indigo frigate
#

thats a lotta engine outs

next sierra
#

Eight engines in total

remote onyx
next sierra
#

The pitch up is intended

umbral karma
#

I thought they fixed all the raptor problems stare

next sierra
#

The ship is supposed to actually let go though

umbral karma
#

The rapidly reusable engine can't even be used once

white oyster
#

hmm i wonder if my minecraft cave is deep enough to put B7 into

indigo frigate
keen plover
#

I am curious, if the interstage collapsed on B7 (which it appears to have), do they just intend to fix this issue on B9 (assuming this wasnt known before and rectified), or just forget about the current gen boosters

shell python
indigo frigate
#

It looked very real

#

currently trying to find it

modest heron
rich blade
#

this pic is so cool

rich blade
#

literally so many cool pics from today

indigo frigate
shell python
#

cant believe they actually flew it in april

shell python
#

wobbly camera

#

no other shots show it

remote onyx
loud spire
umbral karma
#

Disappointment on the big screen

#

I like it

shell python
#

might do it in physics too

loud spire
rich blade
#

wait ur teachers/friends care about spaceflight? TrollPolite

loud spire
#

Yes

shell python
#

she was proctoring staar this morning so she couldn’t watch so i convinced her to pop it on the projector

white oyster
#

i see an aristotle thing

shell python
#

so then we could talk about it

#

i was giving commentary on it talking about the failures and the HPU blows and stuff kekw

indigo frigate
#

God damn this guys photos are insane

rich blade
#

clicked on SBL expecting to see a fullstack 💀

indigo frigate
shell python
#

REAL

indigo frigate
#

damn even with reverse search I cant find where that image came from

rich blade
#

this is my favourite john kraus photo i think

rich blade
indigo frigate
#

beautiful

rich blade
#

these two are beautiful

umbral karma
#

Any pics of pad damage yet?

vagrant moat
#

Someone send the crater

rich blade
modest heron
modest heron
umbral karma
#

Good lord

#

No wonder hoppy got killed

rich blade
#

hoppy is not dead

pulsar pollen
#

hoppy just got a small bruise is all

white oyster
#

someone hurt hoppy? WHO HURT HOPPY?!

pulsar pollen
#

They better put a comically large bandade on Hoppy

whole moat
umbral karma
#

A lot of good the 'virtual flame diverter' snakeoil did

#

I knew that sounded stupid from the start

#

It basically dug the OLM out the ground

#

Thats insane

#

Good job they made the piles very deep

tacit kite
indigo frigate
pulsar pollen
indigo frigate
#

deepfried.png

tacit kite
#

too many pixels

remote onyx
tacit kite
#

X TWEET

umbral karma
#

Nah because shit is getting destroyed

tacit kite
umbral karma
#

And explosions are cool

tacit kite
#

GOOD LORD

next sierra
umbral karma
#

I still can't believe it actually flew

indigo frigate
#

same man

#

people that arent astonished have never built anything in their lives. Took me like 4 attempts just to make a phone holder for my car while 3D printing

remote onyx
next sierra
indigo frigate
#

OOOOOOOOOO BLACK AND WHITE IS WHERE ITS AT

umbral karma
#

chem trails

rich blade
modest heron
brittle spire
#

Now watch SpaceX reinforce the stand

#

And then just cover the hole with a bunch of concrete

modest heron
umbral karma
#

Its interesting, a long time ago. Like a few thousand years ago we developed something stronger than concrete

#

Its called metal

#

And its surprisingly good at not turning into shrapnel

#

Maybe put some of that under the pad

#

Just an idea

indigo frigate
#

yeah the amount of scrap panels they got laying around would do just fine

#

get the water tower folks in one last time

brittle spire
#

Well they now have some tanks to scrap

indigo frigate
#

did the tanks nearby get busted

keen plover
#

well here goes another 2 years to rebuild everything /s

indigo frigate
#

THEY SHOULD JUST GIVE UP, ALL THAT MONEY COULDVE WENT TO SAVE THE TURTLES. NOW ITS ALL BLOWN UP. ELON IS A SCAMMER

#

/s

#

people seem to think when you buy a rocket the money just vanishes into thin air

pulsar pollen
#

Hold on hold on

brittle spire
#

I think in the end how good/bad this launch was depends on how long the repairs to the launch site take

pulsar pollen
#

^^

indigo frigate
#

fax

#

its all that mattered

brittle spire
#

If they can have the next launch prepped in let's say a month, this is just a huge victory

pulsar pollen
indigo frigate
#

thats great

remote onyx
#

Also what they learn from it

white oyster
#

i mean, the next starship and booster ARE technically ready?

brittle spire
#

Like you have to realize that I think B7 is very outdated