#Should draw offers be banned?

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

eternal moss
#

and why? 👀

carmine cedar
#

no

weak zinc
#

naw

uneven panther
#

NO

minor shard
#

No

pale hearth
#

no

worn ether
#

no

coral thistle
#

no

minor shard
#

no way

hard echo
#

Heck no

crystal marsh
#

nah

minor shard
#

dude

crystal marsh
#

No

round laurel
#

at least this one is clear

karmic thunder
#

Never

pale hearth
#

NO way

rustic orchid
#

no

wary sundial
#

It shouldnt'

round laurel
clear totem
#

no

worn ether
#

heeeeell nah

drowsy sparrow
#

no cause draw

eternal moss
drowsy latch
#

but why tho?

pale hearth
#

never

dapper breach
#

NO TF

fleet dawn
#

there should be an option for draw, and draw and keep playing

lone plank
#

nope.avi

crystal marsh
#

if a party gtg then a draw offer is a good thing

spiral surge
#

yes, before move 30 in high level chess

round laurel
#

no debate lmao

brazen zinc
#

No

unique cedar
#

who was author of that genius idea

half dove
#

they should?

static lodge
#

when im in school and i have to leave a class so i can ask to draw and someone can be nice enough to draw 🙂

half dove
#

obv

velvet cypress
#

If it is a certain draw why wait

zinc scaffold
#

Really close vote there!

jolly mango
sly meteor
#

hell nah

frosty walrus
#

ig the opinion is just that unpopular (real)

undone wharf
#

Why would it? Hard no.

polar gyro
#

bro draw offer is like a main thing of chess

wary sundial
#

As some positons are dead even

zinc scaffold
#

Really close vote there!

glad wraith
#

make it like irl

wary sundial
#

draws will be necessary

frank canyon
#

No but if you excessivily offer draws it should be temporarily disabled for you

vast girder
#

this is such a bad poll lmao

unique sinew
#

I think the better question is "should @eternal moss close previous threads before opening new ones?"...

haughty cedar
#

Why should they be banned? it's an offer that the opponent can accept or decline so there's nothing wrong with it

wary sundial
#

Draw offers are rarely accepted

sharp dagger
#

real?

knotty sundial
#

They can just do draw by repetition KEKW

sharp lance
#

literally ingsoc

potent pawn
#

litteraly 1984

marsh rock
knotty sundial
#

but if it was banned then they can

supple depot
#

why would you want to ban it though?

wary sundial
#

at my level

#

im 1100 so yeah

digital pollen
#

hell nah

burnt mica
#

especially for top level chess

#

as they always say, "chess played perfectly is always a draw"

unique sinew
haughty cedar
peak ledge
#

draws by agreement are useful for the reasons if someone has to go and is in material, if a game is going too long and its even, or if the two players are in an endgame where theres little to no pieces on the board and they just want it over

rustic apex
#

nah and it dont depend on shit

lusty ruin
#

No, of course not

peak ledge
#

repetition takes more time, and stalemate is dumb..,

burnt mica
#

and then 50 move rule takes forever

vast girder
#

i cant see that

eternal moss
# vast girder this is such a bad poll lmao

it's a really big discussion in top level chess. when you're watching a tourney and people agree to a draw after 4 moves cause idk. they only need a draw to move on to the next phase. it's not winning half a point because of a perfectly played chess game

haughty cedar
vast girder
west nymph
#

No it saved 45 elo 💀 for me

eternal moss
#

then it should be banned

#

??

barren spindle
#

bruh why are we banning this?

eternal moss
west nymph
#

what if I goytta go eat dinner randomly and dont want to lose my elo? @eternal moss

lusty ruin
#

draw by agreement should not be banned online or in person

dusk forge
#

most supergm tournaments already ban draw offers in the first x amount of moves this poll sucks 💀

burnt mica
marsh mason
#

If the game is going nowhere, then offering a draw is a good idea.

haughty cedar
barren spindle
#

if me and my opponent blunder our queen im pretty sure neither wanna play

unreal shale
#

this is the dumbassest question so far here. literally if there is no move anymore and you gonna get stalematted with your opponent in like 6 turns just draw by agree

peak ledge
west nymph
#

WHat if I gotta take a shit and I don't want to resign?

desert valve
#

they shouldnt be banned

west nymph
#

Elo gone then

unique sinew
quartz needle
#

no

peak ledge
#

draw by agreement are (imo) the best method of drawing, when i want a draw

queen sleet
#

NEIN

west nymph
#

if you want it to be banned then atleast have a move limit (below 20 moves imo) and also draws are really useful in emergency situations like dinner, taking a shit or a piss, going somewhere

unique sinew
west nymph
#

GMS shouldn't be allowed ig if you are talking about PROFESSIONAL chess

west nymph
#

but we sure need em in online chess

#

because when you go to the tournament, you got no emergencies

#

you take your time to go

#

your mom wont call your for dinner in a tournament

#

but in home she will

#

so we need draw by agreeement atleast online

#

your a outlier

#

80% of the people I asked to draw, they accepted

#

people aren't assholes 💀

peak ledge
#

stalemate is only a reliable source of drawing if your losing, and draw by repetition is only reliable if your opponent agrees to repeat not one, not two, but three moves in a row, thus drawing by agreement is the base for repetition and stalemate only occurs once every so often

unique sinew
#

These polls are becoming more and more boring, unfortunately Sadge

lilac jolt
#

Lol he called u a asshole technically

peak ledge
west nymph
peak ledge
west nymph
#

💀

peak ledge
lusty ruin
#

no offense but thats such a scumbag thing to do

Its usually not their fault they have to leave, why penalize them for something that's out of their control

unique sinew
west nymph
#

What if I get a random shit

peak ledge
#

what if you dont think you alhave to go..,

west nymph
#

White sadly

empty fern
#

nobody ever accepts draws so

raw walrus
#

why would anyone say yes lmao

west nymph
still sorrel
west nymph
#

mfs saying yes have enemies

lusty ruin
west nymph
#

I got no enemies

raw walrus
#

dont accept if ur winning

peak ledge
#

usually drawing only gains and loses a VERYYY small amount of elo points, if not stay even

#

so its fine, right?

raw walrus
#

if they really had to go theyd probably understand

lusty ruin
west nymph
#

I randomly proposed a draw to a Kazakh dude, he said no, I said "for the boys!" he instantly accpeted

#

the duality of men

west nymph
#

he was up 12 points of material 💀

pure juniper
#

there shouldnt be any debate on this 💀

west nymph
#

he's a real one

peak ledge
pure juniper
#

who are the bozos voting yes

west nymph
#

@eternal moss do you come up with this poll

lusty ruin
#

i only offer draws when the material is exactly even and the position makes it a draw (opposite color bishops, for example)

pure juniper
lusty ruin
#

??? the majority voted no what

#

25 yes to 313 no

#

oh lol

wicked cipher
#

Hell nah

manic stump
#

This is the worst idea I've heard in a while

dull mesa
#

hmmmmm

solid thicket
#

no

eternal moss
#

but I agreed with it for sure

#

cause it's a big discussion it top level chess

fierce radish
#

no because it's present in all forms of chess and it would be classed as one less draw situation and therefore classed as "changing the rules"

sick sentinel
#

Yes. Fight to checkmate or stalemate ⚔️

fierce radish
#

also what if you have to leave halfway thru a match?

sick sentinel
rotund tangle
#

yes because yknow how you have queen and queen and 2 lonely kings or something like that? yeah what u gonna do if your opponent aint gonna draw by repetition

vivid cape
#

What do you do

#

Do you wait for hikaru to blunder

crystal marsh
#

not banned

#

dumb ass pole

acoustic roost
crystal marsh
#

literary even if it is banned then players can jus agree to repeat moves

#

therefore it cannot be banned

acoustic roost
#

repeating moves will get u banned from chess.com

crystal marsh
#

what shit logic is that

acoustic roost
#

100 elo logic

crystal marsh
#

its my choice my move

#

if i repeat its my choice

#

u cannot force me to play on in a different way

acoustic roost
crystal marsh
#

u can never ban draws by agreement

#

players can just disscuss how they will repeat moves

acoustic roost
crystal marsh
#

at top level people have pride to not scam the opponent too

acoustic roost
grizzled carbon
#

No

sick sentinel
vivid cape
#

Nah also theoretical draws could contain checks

silver thorn
#

Well, no, for fairly obvious reasons.

fickle grotto
#

No, I've sat thru enough RvR lol

high nest
#

no wtf
what if the player has to go or something

tropic quiver
#

ironically I’m the kind of guy who doesn’t offer a draw in a rook vs rook endgame with no pawns

#

still shouldn’t be banned though

#

in my defense my elo range blunders half their moves so it’s worth playing on

sonic bear
#

okay who came up with this NOOOO

hushed raven
#

to be fair, it is by agreement so i feel that its pretty fair

violet relic
#

No, that's crazy to even think it's a thing

silent wolf
#

if two people want a draw, why force them to play into a position where repeating moves is even good?

long palm
#

2️⃣

compact citrus
#

no, if u dont wanna draw, just deny

crystal marsh
#

no, because its by agreement you arent forced to accept said draw. If both players agree to a draw then thats on them.

#

Its completely optional, I would however, like to hear the other side of the argument

#

if a games going to end in a draw then you could argue the players should play it out, but at that point its just a waste of the players' time

#

plus, one could lose by time, resulting in a (kinda) unfair loss.

vocal crag
#

even if there was no draw offer there would be draw by 50-70 move

#

so there's no point to just waste time to wait till then

true comet
#

draw is only needed if the player has to go but it worried abt losing elo

vocal crag
#

well if the opponent was losing time (or losing position) we would just not accept it

#

and also in the tournaments there are rules that ban draws till 40th move which justifies the aggrement even more

true comet
toxic dagger
#

No because if there is a draw like 15 moves later then you should draw just to save time

random flower
#

?

grizzled carbon
#

No

#

This is a silly question

thin prairie
#

if both players want a draw the game is gonna end up a draw anyway, you can make a case that some people blunder at the lower end of ratings but in 2000 games if both players think it’s a draw it’s gonna be a draw

sly kestrel
#

**Should draw offers (draw by agreement) be BANNED? **
Why tho?
Maybe the original intention of the question was not understood correctly, but as it is wrote, it's an absolute no.

wintry bough
#

nahhh cuh

crystal marsh
#

**Should draw offers (draw by agreement) be BANNED? **
I think it is just annoying to ban draw by agreement.

#

If both parties see it is a draw but are forced to play further they will just repeat moves.

#

PS: I do think Armageddon is a great solution to the stale landscape of only draws in professional chess

crystal marsh
#

would rather die than see draws be banned

unkempt karma
#

No, saves time

crystal marsh
#

whoever writes yes is seriously braindead

dire flax
#

no

tall burrow
#

No

#

Because why wouldn’t you have rules that are in the federation?

ebon pollen
#

No

molten fossil
#

No

silent anvil
#

no

gaunt spindle
lyric path
#

Nah. Draw offers can be seen as a sign of sportsmanship when you offer it to a weaker player while in a winning position

dull mesa
#

given that the majority say no, im gonna say yess 😂

gaunt spindle
dull mesa
#

ye im write an answer when im not lazy and ready to type 😂

gaunt spindle
#

alrighty

crystal marsh
fleet sentinel
#

same with the 2 next to it

crystal marsh
#

yeah ik i made it in arush

#

@fleet sentinel

#

is it better

#

wait

fleet sentinel
#

the 3

#

bottom row

#

and the 2 on bottom left

#

and the 1 between the 2 bombs

crystal marsh
#

check again

#

i check again

#

i fix the bottom left

#

but is there any others

fleet sentinel
#

hasent updated for me yet

crystal marsh
#

sorry to bother but can u screenshot and draw where the error is

#

ty

fleet sentinel
crystal marsh
leaden schooner
#

it is a good sport to mutaily agree with the other person to send the offer and if they accept that is good sportsmanship

humble talon
#

no bc no... 👍

dapper sleet
#

No draw offers shouldn't be banned what If in the start of a game i have to go somewhere i can offer a draw people might accept if they don't that's their choice but u see how draw offers can be helpful in many ways . An example from a game
Magnus and vidit were playing magnus offered a draw at move 4 and vidit accepted because magnus idk had a not healthy stomach.
Also removing draw offers can cause decrease of morale in the players because even in an drawn position both would have to wait till the end untill a draw is caused why not just ask for a draw?

dawn tundra
#

No. Because if draw offer is banned, it would be annoying. Also, you might accidentally pressed play a game, but you don't want to lose points. Therefore, a draw would useful, and if the other player says no then explain in chat. That's what makes draw offers useful!

bold zephyr
#

If two players play a chess game then they should have the ability to offer and accept a draw. It may be less exciting for the audience but banning draw offers is no good point to make it more exciting. First of all player could still play forcing draw lines (e.g. Berlin draw) and secondly the players should have freedom to do what they want on the chess board when it's their game. Of course it's harder to sell chess to a big audience this way but it's not like everyone plays for a draw/offers a draw early at the highest level.

tropic quiver
#

chess players after playing 57,000 moves in a completely drawn endgame 💀

halcyon storm
#

drawing is a part of many large tournaments and games without drawing a tournament could go on forever in a stuck position while drawing might seem useless at first its its worth to the game is highly valuable to some players who have mercy on players and for those who want to try save a game thats losing by trying to play a draw and during tournaments drawing is often common for some reasons: A:both players are low on time B:the Game is stuck in a position where no one can lose now drawing is important because by doing 3 fold both the players lose by doing stalemate both the players lose aswell but with drawing both players are to come back the next day and should be kept in the game so no drawing offers should not be banned i rest my case

bold zephyr
#

The question/poll is only about draw offers but people talk about no draws at all. I am confused

exotic mango
#

Why should it be banned? It's an agreement and sometimes two players can both see a draw coming and there's no ned to waste time getting to it.

barren spindle
#

exactly

#

when someone blunders their queen in the first 10 or 15 moves sometimes i just offer a draw

violet relic
#

Banning it makes no sense. If neither player wants to move forward, then it should end. Simple as that.

humble epoch
#

No, if both of the players see the draw they can just finish the game early

violet bridge
#

there is zero reason for draw offers to be banned

#

they are mostly for convenience

sly kestrel
#

_ _
I would love to vote "3️⃣ why?" xD because without any explanation, almost no one is even going to think on a good reason for thinking about the possibility of voting "1️⃣ yes"

bold zephyr
cyan glen
#

totally legit okayge

grizzled carbon
#

Lmfao

true comet
#

Should resign offers ( resign by agreement ) be BANNED?

dapper sleet
ashen bone
#

Hell no

fresh herald
#

I don't see why... it has to be a mutual agreement anyway, and its just an option you don't have to use it. it doesn't really hurt anybody... does it?

grizzled carbon
#

Stop writing essays here

unique sinew
dull mesa
#

draw offers should be banned
its just laziness, it isnt exactly what id say goes along with the nature of chess, chess is supposed to be about fighting and figuring stuff out to the end, that is the soul of chess and draw offers basically go against that, there r no draw offers by engine, and there is no player better than an engine

chess is obv draw when played perfectly, so an equal position is not an arguement for lazy draw offers, might as well not play chess then. if u want a draw or a win, work for it, force the result.
there r no draw offers in other sports, i dont see 20+ players being lazy and agreeing to draw in a field of cricket or football or something else

and draw offers dont do much favor to get people excited in the future for chess, wcc 2023 was gr8 because there werent boring draws, obv draws after playing the game out to last pieces all the way to tablebase is understandable, but otherwise draw by agreement is for cowards and the lazy

the core of eveyr popular player should be to serve the game and the fans (and obv make a living) but draw by agreement is the opposite of that and very self serving for when u r just unwilling to play the game, which shouldnt be a habit of professional player in any sport

there r lots of other rules for draws when/if game gets too long, draw agreements arent exactly objective draws (because objective draws leave no room for mistake), they r subjective draws cause the players dont wanna risk it

ban the draw by agreement

#

we came up with armageddon cause wedont want draws, that should speak enough about the mentality of literally everyone else except the players drawing with agreement repeatedly

#

||idk if i was repretitive or not 😂 wasnt exactly checking it to be perfect, just spitting out whatever came to my mind 😂 ||

bold zephyr
#

You mention yourself that there are many other ways to draw so how would a ban of drawing offers make a big difference for the fans for example?

dull mesa
bold zephyr
dull mesa
# bold zephyr You mention yourself that there are many other ways to draw so how would a ban o...

frequency of middlegames and endgames would defo increase, and as a fan those r the defo where it might be out of our understanding and hv exciting oppurtunities

and if there r no draw by agreements, then whoever plays solved drawn lines will defo hv that reputation, and they r more likely to try non solved drawn lines to the end if there is no draw offers

sure it might not make a difference in the short run cause of behavioural habits, but feels like its defo be a better practise in the long run, and more to learn for us

dull mesa
#

the game is about all the permutations and combinations possible, and gameplay should be about that, not about self serving comfort zones of players

bold zephyr
#

Interesting opinion. My view is that you shouldn't be able to violate the freedrom of the players. If I play a game then I should be able to make a choice without anyone else telling me what I should or shouldn't do

dull mesa
#

obv everyone has their own opinions, thats just wha t i think

crystal marsh
#

So in conclusion draw offers are alright in such scenarios but early draw offers will definitely kill the game is what y’all are saying right?

grizzled carbon
#

No

tulip sequoia
#

No

dull mesa
bold zephyr
#

If a game is gonna be a draw anyway then let the players offer one

crystal marsh
#

I mean it might save time tbh

tall burrow
#

And it shouldn’t even be our job to vote, it should be titled players

dull mesa
bold zephyr
dull mesa
#

resignation is when u can clearly see u r losing, but draw is when u see that its equal
theres a difference between blundering a win and blundering a draw, atleast at the higher level

crystal marsh
#

But in drawing you also asume your opponent will play till the draw so i still don’t see the point

violet bridge
#

draw offers can just allow for a quicker way to draw a game, such as a rook vs rook endgame. noone wants to sit through a bunch of checking because that would be boring and take too much time

#

or a king vs a/h pawn

wind thunder
#

no

bold zephyr
dull mesa
bold zephyr
#

What

crystal marsh
#

How is that possible

dull mesa
#

well if u hv a winning advantage, its probably some sort of material imbalance or weakness or something, u r less likely to miss that than just a balanced equal game

rain token
#

I definitely do not think that draw offers should be banned, especially in high-level play. Most players I've played against don't even accept them anyway and I think they are good if you trust your opponent and yourself to not blunder.

hybrid remnant
#

Before move 15 ban

hallow dock
#

Bruh you can just ignore it KEKW

earnest cedar
#
  1. No. Why? It exists irl too.
stiff cedar
#

Bro wtf is this topic fr

#

What's the problem with draw offers

grizzled carbon
#

Fo real

fading steppe
#

Naw dude

grand current
#

bruh this question is unnecessary bruh

grizzled carbon
#

Fr

supple lance
#

No.

grizzled carbon
#

We're not high level pros unfortunately

crystal marsh
#

Noo

rain token
vocal crag
#

well there are some tourneys that say that the draw agreement is only available after 30/40 moves

hollow shore
#

WTF

#

Most boring poll ever

dull mesa
#

Not boring, but one sided

nimble cedar
#

no

undone trellis
#

No, they have that in normal chess, so I don't see the problem with it in online chess.

bold zephyr
undone trellis
#

oh

#

Still no

dull mesa
#

420 messages 😂

grand current
#

Ded

#

Hehehaw

lost frost
#

bruh if u want draw then just draw in game

delicate karma
#

If the position is a draw... prove it

grizzled carbon
#

lmao

#

fair enough, if ur winning, prove it

dull mesa
#

😂

uneven panther
#

bwomp

haughty cedar
#

goolgoolgoogle

mystic venture
#

NO

hushed pumice
#

TO be fair, while draw offers can be spammed, users can just simply ignore and block then. And if the position is actually a draw then both players can like, agree to it and not just run out of time

hidden creek
#

This is the worst poll ever.. I had an OTB game that lasted 4 hours, and could've lasted only 2 if my opponent had accepted the draw. Imagine if there was no option to make it 2 hours, and we HAD to play the whole thing out

lucid herald
#

No

river fractal
#

Ain't no way

crimson pebble
#

Nop

ashen bone
#

Idk

ebon pollen
#

Hell no

hidden creek
hidden creek
#

Lemme ask you this, is there a single sport that you've watched where you've said "Yep, this is gonna be a draw"?

dull mesa
dull mesa
hidden creek
#

(Actually happened to me)

hidden creek
#

In chess, there are times where the game is literally guaranteed to be a draw

dull mesa
# hidden creek (Actually happened to me)

Then nothing u can do lol, doesn't matter whether draw offer exists or not, it's upto the opponent, if it's truly a draw, there's prilly a repetition, if u both want it

dull mesa
dull mesa
# hidden creek In chess, there are times where the game is literally guaranteed to be a draw

If it's guaranteed, then prove it 😂as simple as that, technically speaking that guarantee only exists if it ends in a draw, if u mess that up, then it wasn't guaranteed
U can argue all about being exhaustion, but that's not exactly the point of this, it's about not avoiding to play out the game to the place where no one ever had chance to win, aka stalemate or insufficient material

hidden creek
hidden creek
#

There was a time in an otb game where I drew a game where we both had 1 rook and pawns on the same side of the board (not pushed yet and kings on the same side) 90% of the time that's gonna be a draw, so we just drew it and called it a day. It was the last round anyways, so we both wanted to go home

dull mesa
dull mesa
hidden creek
hidden creek
dull mesa
hidden creek
#

I drew in this position

#

How do you win this?

dull mesa
#

u push pawns and bring ur king in and wait for ur opponent to give u chances, thats basically what chess is,
of all the possible drawn endgames, u chose one with 10 pieces on board to say that u need draw offer?
not trying to play that position is just unwillingness to try to grind out the endgame, thats a player's problem

#

i can see that this is just gonna go in a loop now, just read what ive written bfore lol

hidden creek
dull mesa
#

ye u r just being lazy 😂
i literally saw knight+rook vs rook endgame being played to win in world cup, if GMs can play that out, then its ur opinion if u dont wanna play, its not objective, its ur subjective opinion if u think people cant blunder, u r basically saying that anyone shouldnt play chess except opening theory after 2k if ur opponent wont blunder an equal position

dull mesa
#

u clearly dont wanna try to understand another perspective and just wanna stick to ur opinion and argue about it pointlessly, so i wont bother replying to next one

#

u literally dug this up from june 😂