#Feedback Requests

1 messages · Page 27 of 1

turbid radish
#

this is visual kei deathcore for ya. from a classic album at that

fringe geode
#

This is sick

turbid radish
#

@vale vapor this must be way better. i got the synths and ambience guitar actually turned up now and better mixing. this snare is better i think, i took everything off the cymbals too so its back to its natural kontakt joey sturgis state

#

i think i made the kick and guitar unmatch in the verses though for a more prog feel now that i hear it rn

#

at first its on beat then goes off beat halfway through then repeats

#

but as for the djent maybe thats what should actually just match completely if i can

runic adder
#

Nocturnal bloodlust mentioned

vale vapor
#

snare is still kinda Doofy

#

and the kick still sounds like its being clipped

viscid summit
vale vapor
#

Could use a tube screamer before the amp

#

To give the highs a little more fizz and sizzle

#

Other than that sounds good

finite finch
karmic plinth
turbid radish
#

@vale vapor i think that just by lessening how many samples i use layered for the drums down to basic amounts of 1 each, i got it sounding like soasins first album now or something lol i think it was called translating the name

vale vapor
#

Translating the name is definitely less processed haha

#

There's a lottt of ducking going on

royal dock
balmy forum
#

HES BACK

royal dock
#

i will not give up 😉

balmy forum
#

Great

#

Well can you at least put ur ego aside for now

royal dock
royal dock
turbid radish
#

I think I just need to simmer how sharply the shell hit

#

My leads too loud too

royal dock
fringe geode
vale vapor
#

kick also has too much mids and lowmids

turbid radish
vale vapor
# royal dock lol

guitar tone is very muddy, and it seems like there's only one guitar track

#

there's a lot to be fixed here

#

but an interesting idea

royal dock
inland anchor
turbid radish
wraith hare
royal dock
#

What is the best way to record multiple guitar tracks? 2 Stereo, and 2 left right ? or just 1 stereo track, and 1 left 1 R ?

formal hedge
#

That's the industry standard afaik

balmy igloo
#

Yep

formal hedge
#

Also just sounds really good

#

Make sure it's a different take for each though

balmy igloo
#

Sometimes triple tracking with one in the middle is cool but yeah just left and right is like pretty much every mix

formal hedge
#

I at one point thought that you could copy paste and it would be the same as double tracked guitars

#

That was one of my biggest mistakes in mixing

balmy igloo
#

lol so true

#

I've used an imager plugin on a single mono track to turn it into a stereo before

#

Works pretty good if all you're sent is a single mono track to work with.

formal hedge
#

My old mixes were single tracked guitars with presets, bass turned too far down, drums with no multi routing and reverb on max whack, all brought to you by FL Studio

royal dock
#

aight thanks. im unsure everytime when i record stuff.

balmy igloo
#

FL studio is so based

formal hedge
#

Not great in my experience

#

Great for hip hop though

balmy igloo
#

If you're a trap producer it's pretty good.

#

Yeah you get it

#

That's how I got into production trap and rap music.

wraith hare
balmy igloo
#

I could not get into reaper. I'm too Ableton brained to figure it out.

#

Reapers Restream plugin is goated for streaming on OBS.

#

Ableton cannot route into OBS for some reason and that is literally the only fix.

inland anchor
#

I realised it kinda sounds like a Godhood

wraith hare
inland anchor
wraith hare
#

I dunno

karmic plinth
#

I personally use cakewalk sonar, and it doesn't do too bad, it does what I need it to

finite coral
#

well my fingers hurt so im happy

wraith hare
#

is that hammer++ in the taskbar

finite coral
#

YES

balmy forum
finite coral
#

i love paying for every update!!!

balmy forum
#

We don’t?

finite coral
#

ableton hate is tolerated cuz lse uses it

#

ive been told for every new ableton version u have to pay

balmy forum
#

We pay for every major version

#

But so does fl bro

#

It’s worth imo

finite coral
#

no u dont

balmy forum
#

It’s like fl 22 now or something?

finite coral
#

fl studio doesnt charge for version updates its a lifetime thing

balmy forum
#

It’s like every 5 years a new software comes out

#

You can pay for it

#

Or just stay on the old one

#

I do agree that ableton is bad with pricing

#

But its also breaking the grounds of the daws imo, I’ve never seen effects that ableton has anywhere else

finite coral
#

idk man i opened it once

#

and it was broken so i just gave up

vale vapor
vale vapor
versed remnant
#

Gojira was right all along

Brand new weed
Plant the seed
To let it grow
After the snow

It will need light
The burning atmosphere
Will provide
A source of feast

It needs some water
But don’t you drown it
(There’s room for error)

Feed below the leaves
Cuz the roots need
(but not the green)

Plant it
Then water it
Plant it
Then watch it grow
Plant it
Look out for pests
Plant it
Put on a show

See the sprouting fetus
Little baby plant
Needs no extra care
Just watch its back

It needs some water
But don’t you drown it

Feed below the leaves
Cuz the roots need

Plant it
Then water it
Plant it
Then watch it grow
Plant it
Look out for pests
Plant it
Put on a show

Plant it

Plant it

Plant it

Plant it
Then water it
Plant it
Then watch it grow
Plant it
Look out for pests
Plant it
Put on a show

Plant it
You made it grow
Plant it
You made it grow
Plant it
You made it grow
Plant it

tender oak
finite coral
#

whole lotta nothing

#

havent really done anything in 5 years

#

tried cs2 hammer its really hard

tender oak
#

I used to be a source mapper back in the late 2000s to 2010s. Made a pretty popular survival map for l4d2 which was my claim to fame back in the day lmao

finite coral
#

on paper its easier cuz its modernized but im too used to source spaghetti

vale vapor
#

You do anything for gmod?

tender oak
#

I think one of my counterstrike source maps was ai noded for gmod

#

Cs_office_urban is the one someone ai noded for gmod. The l4d2 map is Mansion Survival, both are on the steam workshop. The upload of the counterstrike one isn't from me but I'm glad someone took it from CSS and put it up for the workshop.

vale vapor
#

Yooo

versed remnant
royal dock
#

Thanks to everyone who gave me a lil feedback on the other audio. Im trying my best to improve 🙂

wraith hare
worthy sail
#

recently got the misha mansoor nerual dsp plugin and was trying to make a djent tone, not really experienced with this stuff, guitars probably a little out of tune because i used a pitch shifter. Its the right idea though right? im gonna try covering one of my favourite songs

#

i dunno, i feel like its missing something

#

i just dont know what it is

balmy igloo
balmy igloo
runic adder
#

might be in my head, not sure

halcyon holly
runic adder
#

woah ross appearance

halcyon holly
#

i have awoken

runic adder
#

welcome to the land of the living

halcyon holly
#

Unfortunately

runic adder
#

real

#

hows the studio going

halcyon holly
#

Acceptably. They're on about getting a new mac pro m2. I think they're all idiots.

#

One of my closest mates left the studio, so i've not been enjoying it too much

#

But it's been fine

#

hows your life going

runic adder
#

decent

#

finally remembered my youtube password so i can start making content again

halcyon holly
#

i saw that and meant to check it but i forgored

#

send

runic adder
#

i got another cover lined up with a mix that isn't two years old this time

#

but I recorded and edited this all of last night instead of sleeping

#

my morning alarm went off while I was making the thumbnail lmao

halcyon holly
#

Good mix

#

well done

#

Maybe work to be done with the vocals

#

But you're using an SM7B so it's probably just that

runic adder
#

oh yeah that mix was done a year ago, i have a much better vocal mix recently i think

halcyon holly
#

Nice performance though

#

very tight

runic adder
halcyon holly
#

still a bit dry

halcyon holly
#

disgusting!!

halcyon holly
#

Yeah

#

very cool mix

#

got better fr

#

Or maybe you was always good and i'mm just an asshole

runic adder
#

multiple things can be true at once

#

but nah i def got better recently

halcyon holly
#

I can hear it

#

good job

#

i dont want to go to the cinema

#

but i must

#

so cya

runic adder
#

for the wifey ofc

halcyon holly
#

exactly

runic adder
#

have fun, see you in another 30 years when you wake up again

halcyon holly
#

yep

wraith hare
#

Yello

runic adder
#

greem?

turbid radish
#

@vale vapor its like this now

#

trying the fortin nameless vst too now instead of thall amp even

#

this is certainly more flavorful in some kind of way even if the eq could be better on the guitars

runic adder
#

ive seen more hate for thall amp and odeholm drums here than anywhere else 😭

#

but I agree nameless is better

balmy forum
turbid radish
#

Omg that's awesome I'll dl it when I'm home

finite coral
halcyon holly
#

i really don't fuck with nameless icl

#

in my old age i have started a vendetta against it

#

It sounds very clanky, harsh and empty

#

Scooped too

#

And it has that weird pick attack thing going on, which can be cool, and can compeltely ruin mixes

formal hedge
halcyon holly
#

It very much does

formal hedge
#

That and it was a single audio file

balmy forum
#

(programed vocals)

#

the music def issnt

#

unless ai uses buster kit too

formal hedge
vale vapor
#

100% ai

vale vapor
balmy forum
vale vapor
#

I'm on phone speakers but it sounds way different to me

balmy forum
#

nah thats buster kit, it could be mixed differntly

formal hedge
balmy forum
#

at that point its just too much effort

formal hedge
balmy forum
#

and lets be real any ai user does not have enough attention span to be bothered

formal hedge
#

You'd be surprised the length people go to to not make music

turbid radish
#

i have just finished yet another mix 😈

vale vapor
#

i hear it

#

It sounds like guitars and buster drums over an ai vocal

#

The vocal could also just be badly mixed

vale vapor
balmy forum
vale vapor
#

drums are clipped a little too much

turbid radish
#

im trying some kind of

#

orange 412 cab now ir wise

vale vapor
#

but it could still be ai

turbid radish
#

i just wanted to try an old post hardcore tone. i think i made it worse possibly lol

turbid radish
#

1 seems safe but i thought 3 sounded good like this

balmy forum
#

#HALFME #fatalist #ArisingEmpire
HALF ME’s brand new single 'Fatalist':
Stream, download: https://arisingempire.com/fatalist

SUBSCRIBE to our channel and hit the notification 🔔 to not miss new music:
https://arisingempire.lnk.to/YTsub

FOLLOW ARISING EMPIRE and keep yourself up to date about your favourite music:
Spotify Official Playli...

▶ Play video
#

played it over the PA at work it sounded insane

turbid radish
#

so yea hows that new guitar tone

#

@balmy forum i am trying an orange ir

balmy forum
#

its very cab sounding

#

did you take off fortins cab

formal hedge
#

@buoyant summit get this IR, best one I've ever heard

#

XENON sent it a long time ago and I've been using it ever since

balmy forum
#

nu uh this one is better

formal hedge
turbid radish
#

i took off cab 2 and replaced cab 1

formal hedge
#

But the one I sent works better w my stuff that I use

turbid radish
#

what does very cab sounding mean o_o LOL

halcyon holly
#

probably resonant

balmy forum
#

why cant i write anything

#

i just have no motivation

#

wtf is going on

halcyon holly
#

Because writing music is exceptionally difficult, and extremely low reward

#

You don't enjoy it, because everyone who is a human being is overly critical of their music, no one else enjoys it, because to get people to hear it you need to be fluent in posting everyday for 3 years on tiktok, and your parents won't be proud, because you're a musician

#

joking btw

#

or am i

balmy forum
#

awh

#

but seriously wtf is going on

#

blame canada

runic adder
#

Helps get me out of a writing block sometimes

turbid radish
balmy forum
#

lol sorry im just taking the piss out of trump

vale vapor
vale vapor
#

The reward is me hearing it

#

And being happy cause i made it

balmy forum
#

i have no motivation at all and just cant come up with things

vale vapor
#

Try to make a genre you don't listen to

turbid radish
#

from translating hte name ig

vale vapor
#

You're using fortin nameless and playing in what sounds like drop G

#

that already is off to a bad start if you wanna sound like saosin

#

if you want to sound like translating the name, play in D standard or drop C, use WAY less processing, and use an amp from the 90s/early 2000s

turbid radish
#

just meatn the drums sorry

vale vapor
#

then i would use less processing overall

runic adder
balmy forum
#

@vale vapor ive been trying to get better at balencing

#

how is this

#

holy spelling

#

why

balmy forum
finite coral
finite coral
#

With another amp forgot whixh one

finite coral
balmy forum
finite coral
#

No lmao

#

It's just a cover

#

I'm not a fan of anything ai in music and I've heard a lot of it and I don't get how this sounds like that lol

finite coral
finite coral
#

There's a yt vid about it cuz ai gets confused with the instruments so when you split them you get weird results

finite coral
balmy forum
#

whered my high end go

balmy forum
#

im so happy

#

my mixing is back

#

and its pretty good imo

fathom jewel
balmy forum
fathom jewel
# balmy forum Censored?

the last line was censored (F*ck it, I'm done, this is a waking nightmare), there was supposed to an f word there

#

nice mix tho

balmy forum
#

really?

#

maybe i was side chaining it too hard so it sounded like that lol

balmy forum
#

thats weird lemme check

#

wtf it is

#

strenge

fathom jewel
#

very nolly coded mix, almost sounds like it belongs in holy hell by architects

balmy forum
#

well im currently mix prayer position so if you like nolly your in luck haha

fathom jewel
#

the bass and guitars need a little high mid boost, overall everything needs some more brightness

#

just a nitpick

balmy forum
#

cool, ive just started with balanceing first and then mix bus

#

its ended up really well

#

sorry if that sentence make so sense at all lol

pseudo rain
#

Wrong key but it works I guess

balmy forum
turbid radish
#

but i may as well take out that subtle transient shaper too i guess that i have on my drum shells

turbid radish
#

xD

fathom jewel
#

the cymbals do be sizzlin

royal dock
runic adder
#

Is it fine? Can I stop tweaking the EQ and comp?

vale vapor
vale vapor
turbid radish
#

after the clipper. you meant with a compressor?

#

damn i was just doing what joey sturgis did in a past video xD

#

but i do hear my drums are lacking something. i'll follow this advice

turbid radish
#

i took the clipper and the shaper out. its sounding better now

hollow tulip
#

i like the short transitional section at 0:49 to 0:53

#

and i love that piano arpeggio thing placed against the djenty riffs

hollow tulip
# turbid radish

and yeah i think this mix sounds better than the older one (which i assume is this one #1095992147968262144 message)

turbid radish
#

ty

balmy forum
turbid radish
#

my guitars are too fizzy but meh

balmy forum
#

they are irs

turbid radish
#

what cab sims

balmy forum
balmy forum
tidal stream
#

hey, i have this kinda song, but something feels off, dunno exactly what

hollow tulip
#

wip extend after not updating this thing for a while
still need to add a pre-2nd drop section in 2:17 (idk what to put in there but it's roughly gonna be like the chill section at 1:00 but i have to figure out a way so it doesn't sound too samey. suggestions are welcome) and add outro
writers' block hitting too damn hard but something is better than nothing

hollow tulip
#

it's kinda like when korn or some nu metal band plays the non-distorted version of a riff before switching to a more distorted one

hollow tulip
tidal stream
#

aah, i kinda get what you're trying to say

tidal stream
hollow tulip
#

i see

tidal stream
#

i mean, i added something there to act as a bass, but just very slightly to be able to have a rough idea

turbid radish
#

down to even what i think seems to be some sort of mesa sound or possibly just 5150

#

i just want a good solid djent amp like this

#

the closest ones were probably jason richardson from mixwave or maybe ndsp misha mansoor but i couldnt quite get it as good as your sound legitimate djent tone wise

#

i dont even think the fortin nameless i use though cuts it. it was somewhat an experiment, lowk lol tbh

hollow tulip
turbid radish
#

thats ok i just got pod farm on my guitars now. no one will like this tone probably but i think its pretty classic escape the fate type toned LOL

vale vapor
#

How will no one like it if it sounds like ETF

#

lots of people like etf

finite finch
#

U never misss with these tones

runic adder
#

Evergreen was the IR

finite finch
#

Will putney irs are peak

runic adder
#

On that specific demo I kinda neutered the tone with my weird EQ choices, returning it to form once I get home

finite finch
#

I wonder what exactly are the cabs he uses

turbid radish
#

very fuzzy n stuff

#

and it doesnt have the same kind of body to it. people would assume its a practice amp tone from what ive seen or heard

#

but here goes in a min or two. my pod farm uberschall tone

turbid radish
#

god my drums are some bad i think lol

karmic plinth
#

I started writing this one the other night, im like the direction but not sure if tone needs to change on any of the instruments

balmy igloo
balmy igloo
karmic plinth
turbid radish
runic adder
#

any feedback?

balmy forum
vale vapor
turbid radish
halcyon holly
# balmy forum best mix ive done in a while

I reckon the kick could have it's presence focused from the high-treble range (8khz+) to the low-mid treble range (1-5khz). It's sounding a bit clicky here. It could also come up a bit. The vocal doubling is cool but maybe a bit overdone - something in the middle would be nice

#

Overall yeah, sounding good

hollow tulip
# turbid radish is it ok if i try this same amp and cab setup? do you mind telling me what that ...

sorry for the late response but here is my settings n stuff
you can ignore the "rock and metal pre-eq" preset since it doesn't change too much if not included and it's meant to be run before the amp (i think)
the "odin guitar" preset is just a sort of a/b amp thing
btw the guitar is from a plugin called Odin 3 by Solemn Tones. all instruments are virtual bc i can't play shit and fl studio piano roll is my lord and savior

granite mist
#

i wrote this whole thing literally from end to start

#

still need some kind of intro

surreal wharf
timber forum
#

Anymore mixing tips before I say fuck it. I feel like I’m surpassing my skill level here. I don’t care if it’s perfect. I’m not trying to be Lorna shore or whatever. I just want to make sure it’s listenable lmao

vale vapor
#

overall mix sounds very muffled

#

Guitar is a bit too shrill in the 5k range

timber forum
#

How to clear it up?

vale vapor
#

sounds like you're taking the highs out of the entire song

#

especially the vocals and cymbals

#

if you have any weird EQ curves doing that, take them off

#

bass is also muddy around 150hz, id make the bass more focused below that

timber forum
#

Sounds good, will adjust. What ranges you suggest I boost or keep close

vale vapor
#

and possibly use a guitar tone that's less scooped

vale vapor
timber forum
#

Probably not gonna change the guitar tone. Might unscoop the mids a little . This is the same guitar tone that everyone in here a month ago said sounded great so idk. Maybe it’s the other mid-high range throwing it off

vale vapor
#

I do not remember that

#

lol

timber forum
#

To be fair you didn’t comment on it but we did talk a little through dms

#

I know it’s not going to sound as polished as your band or anything. Just need it a little better

vale vapor
#

ohhhhhh

#

youre this guy

#

what are you using for guitar tone?

timber forum
#

Namu with the highest rated 5150 and a mesa 4x12 ir

vale vapor
#

do you have EQ on it afterwards?

timber forum
#

Yes

vale vapor
#

what does the EQ look like

#

send a screenshot

timber forum
#

I can’t right now I’m already chillen in bed for the night haha. But the mids aren’t too scooped. You suggesting I pull them back up a bit and boot the high end a tad? I’ve been watching a lot of freightbox so using his methods

vale vapor
#

Yeah it just sounds like the whole focus of the tone is just that shrill bit

timber forum
#

What’s shrill ? Sorry lmao

vale vapor
#

around the 5k range

timber forum
#

This is literally my first time mixing or doing anything with a song so it’s been rough 😣

vale vapor
#

i mean first time ever it's not bad

timber forum
#

I appreciate that 🙏🏼 I’m slowly learning lol

#

Hard to juggle 60hr+ workweeks with 2 kids. Only usually have an hour or so a night

#

New album slaps btw!

#

Just to confirm. You are saying around the 5k range is too low or high?

vale vapor
#

Too high!

timber forum
#

Awesome thanks bro

vale vapor
timber forum
#

I do bro 😭😭😭:

timber forum
# vale vapor Too high!

That goes for the whole mix yeah? Or just especially cymbals and guitar (sorry for so many questions)

vale vapor
#

Im pretty sure it's the guitar

#

Just sounds like everything is kinda fighting itself, can't be too sure

timber forum
#

Only had about 10 mins to mess with it. I focused on the things we talked about (vocals, unscooping some mids on guitar and and lowering around the 5k range, giving the cymbals more room) to my ear it sounds a little better for sure

#

@vale vapor

balmy forum
timber forum
runic adder
timber forum
#

Yeah I’m older. 30 😭

wraith hare
hollow estuary
runic adder
#

2.2 is more "rrrrrrr" and 3.1 is more "aaahhh" but I can't decide between em and running them both would sound like shit

karmic plinth
#

I tried playing wtih Eq and such for my mix, hows it sounding?

tender oak
finite finch
#

but

#

doesnt fit in mix i think

#

2.2 would be good for this mix imo

runic adder
#

what makes it not fit?

#

probably gonna keep the 2.2 one but just curious

runic adder
finite finch
#

while the other stuff like drums aren't

runic adder
#

Ah

#

Fair

runic adder
#

Lmfao I get it

turbid radish
#

this was made with only vst instruments in this one and i mixed from scratch

#

@vale vapor was right it was a good idea to start fresh lol

#

im not used to mixing cymbals though so it might be iffy but i used to use jst cymbals

#

i lowpassed my cymbals very muchly cuz i hated the high end on it

#

@runic adder xD mix update pinging you since you happen to hear so many of my mixes

#

this one is actually by far the best drum-wise

#

as for the shells at least

#

i feel impressed even by the intro fill

#

i should probably just harmonize those guitars too when it goes octavey. ahh i forgor. maybe in a next mix i post

vale vapor
#

Crazy amounts of ducking but from what i can tell (phone speakers) it sounds alright

#

Sounds smashed tho

turbid radish
#

i tried an exciter. idk how to get that joey sturgis sound :(

#

or my comp settings are ass

runic adder
#

Lmao one sec I’ll give it a listen

#

gives me an escape from drum programming hell

runic adder
# turbid radish

guitars are a little dark fs, loosen the compression on your drum room and/or cymbals

#

the mix is good though

#

when you loosen the comp on the cymbals turn em down a bit too

vale vapor
#

Joey doesn't do anything nutso with exciters or anything like that

#

Just compress, eq, and good balance

turbid radish
#

i could have just been over thinking it. but i havent done cymbal mixing in a long time

#

so im out of practice

tender oak
#

Less clashy with what's around it while maintaining the grit and anger

runic adder
#

i see

#

ty

turbid radish
#

got one last post to put here for now lol

#

@vale vapor way more pleasant now lol

#

i dont think its ducking anymore most of all

vale vapor
#

All the og guys like him are just good at what they do

#

It's all about balance and experience

turbid radish
#

yeah. somehow my shells sound amazing in this song i sent btw

#

idk what it is. its just so dimensional and pleasantly balanced

#

i never achieved this but its done from scratch and not just a worked on preset

#

@vale vapor my secret sauce is linear phase eq for phase preservation but i was just trying it out. what do you think? lol

vale vapor
#

Idek what that is twin

#

I just use a regular eq

turbid radish
#

its a waves eq

#

but it preserves your source material as it eq's so the freq spectrum itself doesnt mess with itself

vale vapor
#

Phase preservation 😭

turbid radish
#

xd

#

and i love how my snare turned out this time around finally

turbid radish
#

so thats basically what this specific eq is doing

vale vapor
#

I don't think that actually does anything

#

Or has an audible difference

turbid radish
#

not very much but its better than nothing

vale vapor
#

??

#

I disagree

#

I've never used any phase specialized eq

turbid radish
#

🫡

#

this is just gonna be my go to eq from now on

#

it just works that way, i am thinking

#

theres also a version thats multiband compression but it is linear phase as well

vale vapor
#

Sounds like snake oil😭

#

@halcyon holly thoughts? Any actual use for linear phase eq?

#

Maybe not snake oil, more like fluff

#

I feel like if you feel like you need to use a specialized EQ to get a certain sound, you just don't know how to use an EQ very well

runic adder
#

dude

#

programming and humanizing drums is so tedious 😭

#

finally got the drums in for the full song, so at least I don't have to worry about it anymore

#

now I just gotta record guitars and work on sound design for the rest of the track

vale vapor
#

I don't find it tedious anymore cause i added custom buttons in reaper and custom keybinds that accelerate my workflow

runic adder
#

what keybinds did you add?

#

a lot of it for me just comes down to when i'm doing a cover and trying to get the drums 1:1 or something similar

vale vapor
#

I added buttons that switch between 1/8 1/16 and 1/32 grid, as well as regular vs triplet

runic adder
#

that is convenient actually

vale vapor
halcyon holly
#

Snare tops and bottoms

#

Spaced overheads

runic adder
#

esp this song where they went fucking crazy with the fills and shit

halcyon holly
#

Dual guitars

vale vapor
#

Gotcha

halcyon holly
#

With different amps

vale vapor
#

William was claiming that he just used it on everything to "get a certain sound"

halcyon holly
#

Any eq move where there is another layer with similar properties needs a linear phase

vale vapor
#

And to me that sounds like he needs to read up on EQ in general

halcyon holly
#

Linear phase sounds the same unless something is phasing due to shifting between identical or similar layers

vale vapor
#

LMAO

#

I figured so

halcyon holly
#

Say you had 2 nameless instances of double tracked guitars

#

If you eq the low end out on one of them, you’ve fucked the low end on the other too

vale vapor
#

Ahh

halcyon holly
#

If you high pass (god forbid) and there’s only one layer, you’re not gonna hear a difference between linear and not

vale vapor
#

Yeah makes sense

halcyon holly
#

Comes form the fact that EQ is essentially a Fourier transformer time shifting filter

vale vapor
#

Fourier transform my beloved

halcyon holly
#

Take a layer, duplicate it, shift it over by the smallest amount possibly in your daw, it’ll sound like a slight low pass

#

Then all the other eq moves are just similar concepts

#

Part of the audio being shifted by some time amount

#

So yeah

#

No, not true

#

Only true in very specific instances

vale vapor
#

Yep

turbid radish
# halcyon holly Only true in very specific instances

so correct me if im wrong, but if there is always one input into the vst despite layers or not, and if i having an frequency range that can phase cancel itself at any specific moment in time on my snare for example, my linear phase eq wont really make any or much effect at all for my snare?

halcyon holly
#

What

turbid radish
#

i was just wondering, if it really makes 0 difference in my case at all but i wanted your own personal, straight, yes or no, opinion

#

@halcyon holly

#

but what i said, is a challenge at what you said about it being only for certain cases

#

i want to see if im wrong truly

#

because i can't currently tell very clearly

turbid radish
#

if that is incorrect, then i am wrong

halcyon holly
#

I don't particularly understand what you were trying to say in that paragraph

turbid radish
#

i just want to know, if you also believe aside from xenon that i should just use a normal eq because a linear phase eq will do nothing at all like 0% effect on my single sample drums, which i have a linear phase eq on each track individually routed from the vst of course

#

because i believe that a linear phase eq still does some sort of subtle magic even if its not double layered or spacially mixed or sampled or anything

halcyon holly
#

But like, run the test yourself

#

Which is what i ALWAYS reccommend from this kidna thing. But no, the science / physics / maths / general audio engineering knowledge says no, no difference.

#

To set the test up, create a mix using a normal phase EQ, then render. Then, render the mix again using the SAME eq settings, but chance it to linear phase

#

A linear phase EQ may sound different from a normal phase EQ because all EQs sound very slightly different. I'm suspecting thats what you're hearing. You've heard something liek pro-q, switched to analog-based linear phase eq and gone wow, this sounds great!

#

Yeah, because it's a different EQ. Not because it's linear phase.

#

Lmk your thoughts

turbid radish
# halcyon holly Lmk your thoughts

i think you are right and that my linear phase eq hasnt really made a difference but i like how my eq settings sound at the moment so im probably just keeping it as is haha xD

#

ty for the insight

finite finch
#

thoughts on this mix?

vale vapor
# turbid radish

guitar tone is super weird sounding to me, sounds kind of narrow too, as if it isn't fully panned

#

there's not much note clarity and it's pretty muffled

#

snare is a bit loose in the high end it sounds like, kick is alright though it's lacking a bit of body

runic adder
#

hell yeah

turbid radish
turbid radish
#

i tried to tighten up on the snare comp even as you said it sounded loose

#

ducking of the cymbals? true i managed to overlook it this time

balmy forum
#

the gtr tone is stil a litlle weird

turbid radish
balmy forum
#

gtr

turbid radish
#

just a fake guitar that can never replace the real thing

balmy forum
#

ewwwww

turbid radish
#

but its good for what it is

balmy forum
#

its ducking way to much tho be carful

turbid radish
#

the guitars right/?

finite finch
turbid radish
finite finch
#

I cant help on this i never had that heavy of a ducking in my mixes so idk how to fix

#

I suppose it has to see with balance

turbid radish
#

it must be the mastering and maximizer

#

specifically

#

or the compressor

#

so it shouldnt be too hard to fix

finite finch
naive owl
naive owl
balmy forum
#

thall amp

naive owl
inland anchor
#

another weird bass tone

turbid radish
#

i could add some extra effects here and there but i gotta add vocals and real guitar still

fathom jewel
runic adder
#

My ego is telling me I can pull it off

versed remnant
#

can someone slide some bass drops and impacts

#

i only have crappy ones

vale vapor
vale vapor
# versed remnant it felt quiet

really cool idea, cymbal sound good, kick is pretty clicky and needs some more body. snare sounds overprocessed/not dynamic enough. sounds like a singular sample?. guitar tone also could be more rounded and less trebly

#

overall mix needs more mids

vale vapor
#

the best bassdrop i own

versed remnant
versed remnant
vale vapor
#

i'd ease up on the guitar scoop, at least a little

versed remnant
#

i want heavy

vale vapor
#

mids are what make it actually sound full and well rounded

vale vapor
#

Vocals sound great, but that's about it

versed remnant
#

hold on

vale vapor
#

snare sounds a lot better though its a bit quiet and i think its a bit too wet

versed remnant
#

noted

#

i feel like my kick is missing something now too

vale vapor
#

yeah it feels a bit thin

#

id ease up on the processing and let the lows and low mids come through more

versed remnant
#

i

#

looked at my kick eq

#

uhhh

#

this is better

#

pray

#

okay i look schitzo

#

hold on

#

my snare feels really dark now

#

what did i od

#

do

#

sorry i send it so much i mix on a fucking digital piano for my speajers

#

i like to send it and hear it in my airpods

vale vapor
#

that migh be your problem LOL

vale vapor
#

vocals could use a lot more compression

versed remnant
vale vapor
#

overall a lot better

versed remnant
versed remnant
vale vapor
#

can you pair your airpods to your computer?

versed remnant
#

its

#

terrible

vale vapor
#

Ahhh

#

😭

versed remnant
#

i had headphones but their also shit

#

have*

vale vapor
#

save up like $50 bucks get a cheap pair of mixing headphones

versed remnant
#

fixes r rendering r

#

rn

vale vapor
#

like the AT M20x

versed remnant
vale vapor
#

Cheap and reliable mixing headphones

versed remnant
#

im graduating soon so i'll have some banroll

vale vapor
versed remnant
vale vapor
#

yeah sounds muchh better

versed remnant
#

i might need to turn up the vocals?

#

idk tho

vale vapor
#

i think if you compress them more it would fix your issue

versed remnant
#

fuckass piano speaker

versed remnant
#

on theb us

vale vapor
#

throw on a third

versed remnant
#

and comp on each vocal track

vale vapor
#

maybe OTT at like 20% depth

#

probs a little less

versed remnant
#

i dont even have ott

#

should i grab it

#

i think its free

vale vapor
#

yep its free

versed remnant
#

swag

#

hold on

vale vapor
#

OTT works great in a pinch if you don't have JST Gain Reduction

versed remnant
#

i don't i don't have any legit jst stuff

#

only

#

uh

#

borrowed copies

vale vapor
#

lol

versed remnant
#

i have so many viruses send help

#

how do i use ott

#

like what does the depth knob do

vale vapor
#

depth is the mix/wet knob

versed remnant
#

im used to my reaper built in plugins

vale vapor
#

its how much of the processed signal is blended in

versed remnant
#

ahhh

#

swagger ok

vale vapor
#

yeah OTT has a tiiiny bit of delay, so if you use reaper's wet knob it will introduce phase problems

#

use the built in knob for compensation

#

best OTT settings:

default everything
turn UPWD and DNWD comp to 45% each

blend in depth to taste

#

@versed remnant

versed remnant
#

swag

#

thank you

#

i think this sounds way better

vale vapor
#

Yuhhhh

versed remnant
#

im waiting on my render then i'll shoot at @vale vapor

#

thank you

#

btw for everything today

#

albums gonna be sick

vale vapor
#

ofc bro

#

I actually do lessons on production so hmu if you ever get the chance

versed remnant
#

oh swagger dude

#

i'm tryna start producing for other people and local bands so i've been spending ungodly amounts of time working on mixes and shit

#

its terrible

vale vapor
#

Real

#

that's the grindset lol

#

took me a while before i was good enough to accept clients

versed remnant
#

hopefully i'll be at a point soon enough where i'll be profitable from it

#

bc im poor as shit

#

its terrible

#

all my money gets spent on new pedals on amp locker

#

they're all on sale

#

i want more

vale vapor
versed remnant
#

btw

#

i do wanna say

#

with the guitar

#

it's a six string

#

jackson dinky

#

i bought for $300

#

in drop E

#

26.5" scale legnth

#

i'm doing the best i can with that guitar tone

vale vapor
#

i mean guitar doesn't matter

#

it's just a hunk of wood

#

pickups matter

#

and string tension matters

versed remnant
#

im so happy it has bright ass pickups

vale vapor
#

my band's brand new album was recorded entirely on a $110 harley benton

#

Gear price means near nothing

versed remnant
#

in g# i get like near identicle misha tone

#

its so awesome

vale vapor
#

based

versed remnant
#

its a floyd rose

#

which

#

is weird as hell to have

#

in low tunings

vale vapor
#

ohhhh yep

versed remnant
#

i also don't have the nut locks rn i lost the pieces

#

so i have to tune it every 5 seconds in these low of tunings

#

its terrible

#

but i think the tone sounds fucking sick

vale vapor
versed remnant
#

LMAO

vale vapor
#

and i mean

#

you can tell me how it turned out

#

oh yeah guitar tone is 100% free plugins too

versed remnant
#

I need a new hard drive before anything because my external drive has been in use for 4 years and is giving out i've lost about 30 projects to parsing errors

vale vapor
#

cooked bro

versed remnant
#

fucking peak

vale vapor
#

thank you!

versed remnant
#

holy shit

#

playlist immediately

vale vapor
#

if you like heavy stuff we have some heavier ones on the record too lol

#

straight deathcore

#

recorded on the $110 harley LOL

versed remnant
#

i can't get good tones on my 7 its so sad the pickups are so dark

versed remnant
#

holy

vale vapor
#

well you can 😈

versed remnant
#

one day </3

vale vapor
#

just gotta git gud really

#

LOL

#

nah it takes a trained ear

versed remnant
#

yeah thanks man great advice

vale vapor
#

LOLL

versed remnant
#

i've gotten pretty good with eq stuff

#

yo lemme feature on vocals with your band one day

vale vapor
versed remnant
#

LMAO

versed remnant
#

i can't put my finger on why i did messhugga vocals on this song

formal hedge
#

I use those and it's so good for mixing (and overall great for listening as well)

balmy forum
balmy forum
#

its like a mental gate

#

god himself gives you a threshold before he lets you mix

#

trust

runic adder
#

What the fuck lmao

#

Entirely not what I expected

vale vapor
#

you can't be serious lol

#

"great for mixing"

#

Look at this frequency response bro 😭

#

compare that to any actual good mixing headphone frequency response

halcyon holly
#

They are good for mixing

#

(At that price range)

#

But not as good as IEMs. So just get those

#

If you’re looking for mixing headphones you shouldn’t be getting closed backs. And if you are looking for closed backs you should get IEMs lol

#

770s, AT-20/30/40/50x, k371, they all equally suck

fathom jewel
vale vapor
#

either the master or the guitar/instrument bus is clipping

#

very noticeable around 0:50

#

composition is fire though

fathom jewel
#

I knew I was doing something weird when i put an reaper stock exciter on kick and snare 💀

vale vapor
#

i do that sometimes but you have to make sure it only hits a certain freq range

runic adder
#

Yeah tame the clipper on the drums

vale vapor
#

would you guys buy a sample pack if i released one

#

mostly impacts, fx, glitches, ambience, textures

#

but also some synths, drums, and stuff like that in there

runic adder
#

Probably

fathom jewel
# vale vapor

is this done with your audacity .exe importing raw data technique

runic adder
#

Is it the xango studios pack lol

vale vapor
#

Xenon studios sample pack

vale vapor
#

to make it sound alien

#

diffusion filters, ring modulation, compression, hyper dimension, etc

fathom jewel
#

there was a plugin au5 used that did something similar, morph by zynaptiq audio I think

fathom jewel
vale vapor
#

yes

formal hedge
fathom jewel
formal hedge
vale vapor
#

What is that

vale vapor
#

LOL

fathom jewel
#

I think I did yeah

vale vapor
#

ok dont do that

#

that might be why your drums sound like theyre clipping alot to me

fathom jewel
#

are they still clipping? I turned them down like 15 db

vale vapor
#

sounds better to me

#

just make sure the faders aren't redlining

#

that's all you need to do really

#

give yourself wayyy more headroom, then bring it up in the master chain

#

bass or guitars might be clipping a bit

vale vapor
#

its very helpful

fathom jewel
#

I think I turned the snare down too much, the bass might be clipping becuase I spapped on BUSTERse on that too 💀

vale vapor
#

what is buster se

fathom jewel
#

BUSTERse is a free clone of SSLcomp

vale vapor
#

i dont see what the use is

fathom jewel
#

apparently it glues mixes together, for a more cohesive sound, only if I ever used it right

#

I've been second guessing ratios and attack/release knobs by ear for years, winging compression

vale vapor
#

I tell this to people alot in this server, but just stop using specialty plugins when you don't know what they do

#

it's shooting yourself in the foot

#

You can get a GREAT mix using only EQ and single band compression lol

#

and multiband compression if you want it

#

you can do all that with stock plugs

#

you don't need any crazy specialty plugins

runic adder
vale vapor
#

gotcha

#

then the best thing would just be to learn exactly how it works so you arent just using it to use it

#

or guessing

runic adder
#

I used it for bus compression until I got my hands on the waves one

vale vapor
#

i just use TDR nova and reaxcomp

#

or realimit

runic adder
#

typically my go-to comps are SSL style, 2500, and 1176

#

though I only use the ssl for bus comp so my go-to is the 2500

#

76 to really slam shit, and ssl for bus

vale vapor
#

1176 the GOAT

runic adder
#

but then again that's just cuz I was able to get my hands on em

vale vapor
#

i gotta try that on my busses ngl

#

what settings you usually do on the 1776 for an instrument bus?

runic adder
#

i don't put a 76 on my bus lol

#

though that is an interesting thought

vale vapor
#

ohhh

#

i misread

#

myb

runic adder
#

all g lol

#

might play around with that though

vale vapor
#

yeah facts lol

runic adder
#

well i mean I put it on my vocals bus but that's because I process em all on the bus lol

vale vapor
#

1176 + la2a combo on vocals is the method

runic adder
#

i see

vale vapor
#

my chain is typically

runic adder
#

haven't whipped out the la2a in a minute

vale vapor
#

reacomp doing about -6 gain reduction, EQ, 1176 into the la2a, then final EQ with Deessing

#

i dont usually use a d esser plugin, i just do it with a dynamic EQ band

runic adder
#

I made a preset for it in pro mb lol

vale vapor
#

lol

runic adder
#

just high shelf that goes down sometimes

vale vapor
#

yep

#

same thing for me but in TDR nova

karmic plinth
fathom jewel
karmic plinth
untold knot
#

Did that recently, any thoughts ? Don't mind the video, it's kind of all over the place lmao
(lyrics and vocals by me, instrumental and mix-master arent)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ox-jqpX5lNk

In pertpetual motion they remain
Bound by the oath they swore to the purgatory

Put down the foolish hopes of a greater
Design for us to follow blindly like a
Bunch of zombies destined to a war thats not ours to fight

Like a hand of card in the palm of a man made god
Like a bunch of chips on the devil's table

Oh my fucking god, oh god

Like...

▶ Play video
vale vapor
#

you most likely aren't giving yourself enough headroom

#

so all of the instruments are being pushed too hard into the limiter

formal hedge
#

How's this sounding so far?
Yes I am aware this is a complete Turnstile rip-off lmao

vale vapor
#

guitar needs to come up a ton

#

kick is too boomy

#

whole mix needs to be more glued together

formal hedge
runic adder
#

I’d recommend fixing that before fixing the mix but as long as you get to it

formal hedge
#

MIDI editing is a pain in the ass especially when it comes to trying to make things match up

runic adder
#

Is it not on a grid?

vale vapor
#

It should be dead easy lol

#

It aligns to a grid

#

🎹 First MIDI Song in REAPER | 🎧 The BEST Way to Make a MIDI Song in REAPER FAST!

Are you new to REAPER and want to create your first MIDI song without getting overwhelmed? In this video, I’ll show you step-by-step how to make a full MIDI track in REAPER—FAST and EASY!

✅ Whether you're a beginner or just looking to speed up your wor...

▶ Play video
runic adder
#

So the bass is MIDI, are the drums MIDI too? Why not just align it the same way you aligned the drums?

vale vapor
#

Yeah exactly

formal hedge
#

@vale vapor @runic adder I think I got the balance better, bass is on time with guitars now as well

runic adder
#

The balance is better

#

There’s still something off with the timing though

#

You said you aligned the bass with the guitar—is the guitar live recorded?

#

I’m assuming recorded guitar, MIDI bass and drum?

formal hedge
runic adder
#

Align the bass with the drum and re-record the guitar

#

It falls off in some spots

formal hedge
runic adder
#

If the bass was to align with anything it should be the drums

vale vapor
#

so what is the difficult part of aligning the bass midi on the grid?

runic adder
#

When you get the chance that’s what you gotta fix o7

fathom jewel
runic adder
#

That guitar tone is crunchy af

#

Nice

karmic plinth
vale vapor
#

Yeah just sounds like everything is fighting for volume

#

Make sure no tracks are clipping (redlining) and that they aren't all too loud being slammed into ozone 12

karmic plinth
#

I think all track are only just just clipping amber, but perhaps too much gain in my interface too just clipping over to Amber in some parts on the interface gain, but definitely no red

karmic plinth
#

Alright, how's this?

I have tracked out the drums and put a played with the EQ, and lowered the volume of the guitars, the snare is now the only thing hitting amber, everything else is what the DAW looks like

vale vapor
#

hitting amber? what does that mean

karmic plinth
#

The colour on the bar, goes Green, Amber, Red

#

Like this

vale vapor
#

that isn't a good measure to rely on because almost every single daw displays that differently

vale vapor
#

guitars could come up a little bit

karmic plinth
vale vapor
#

just keep learning youll do great

karmic plinth
karmic plinth
vale vapor
#

hahaha

vale vapor
#

watch Frightbox recordings on youtube, he has so many good tutorials for beginners

karmic plinth
#

Thanks dude, I'll check it out!

balmy forum
formal hedge
# karmic plinth That better?

For a straight-up beginner I'm impressed. I was making hot garbage when I first started and it took me like a year to even get to this stage.

#

Are you only using one snare sample though? Because to my ears it sounds like a one-shot

timber forum
balmy forum
karmic plinth