its in defensive category
#rdo-chat
marsh dirge
quiet whale
The only defensive card i use is fool me once
Can't wait to lvl up my slow and steady to lvl 3 for them lvl 100 griefers
quiet whale
I hate when girefers downed my horse because it's a pain in the ass to revive em
I don't give a shit if they die because they seem to wanna kill themself by running into trees and running wilingly off a cliff
I just need a ride
tight marsh
Is Halloween pass worth getting?
thorn sentinel
Depends what level you are and how much good you have
marsh dirge
It ends on november 16th so you better finish it quick, even tho you can manage to complete it within one day if you know what you're doing
quiet whale
It's extended till 30th now
tight marsh
Well, I have almost 1 gold 🤣, but can grind it easily until the 30th,
I am level 20 on the pass
marsh dirge
Oh i didn't even notice it's been changed
quiet whale
It's not worth it then
Better off getting the next outlaw pass
But idk
It's your decision
marsh dirge
I only have to find a treasure hunter now for my last daily which is a pain in the butt
Out of treasures to..
marsh dirge
@tight marsh Atleast a couple of months until next pass
tight marsh
Thanks
honest obsidian
ayo so is there anyway of like donating money from one person to another? because i’m so broke lmao
just @ me
thorn sentinel
Nope
marsh dirge
Earn your money
safe hinge
Buy gold bars 😂
marsh dirge
Its no fun if you have someone just give you money
Go hunting, fishing, sell moonshine whatever
honest obsidian
just wondering. also ive been doing some bounty hunting, what kinda bounty tips do yall have
honest obsidian
well yeah. also when u wait until the last second does that get u more money?
heard thats a thing
marsh dirge
yes
honest obsidian
bet. thanks bro
wooden ravine
New to the channel, looking for some specific help.
novel iron
@vapid robin on the jeanropke map, you will see a number next to each collections, that's the cycle number
wooden ravine
Playing on PC, I own a G19 Logitech keyboard and I'm looking at creating a macro for breaking out of a lasso (hogtied and just being roped). Can someone tell me which key it is to break out when roped, which key for hogtied, and if using a and d or left and right helps with this, or equipping the knife helps?
Thanks in advance.
vapid robin
@vapid robin on the jeanropke map, you will see a number next to each collections, that's the cycle number
@novel iron Iknoww but how do i know it ingame??
wintry dagger
if you make a macro that holds a and d and spams r? I think its r to escape
novel iron
but you dont have to
its an option in the game
that lets you hold instead of tapping
wooden ravine
Is it not a different key when you are just roped up? @novel iron Is changing it and holding faster than escaping in under 10 seconds?
novel iron
i have no idea if its faster, you are gonna have to test that yourself
the holding thing works out for me
wooden ravine
Just watched a video of a ps player breaking out of a reinforced lasso in under 10 seconds. . . Like some kind of illuminati/wizard.
I was floored.
My old macro could get me out in under 20 seconds. . . But I can't recall which buttons they were.
novel iron
i believe its R
but not 100% on it
cant be that hard to change the macro if its not R
wooden ravine
Is it f or e when just roped? Or is it also r?
novel iron
if you want you can add me and ill hogtie you lol
wooden ravine
Can't right now or I seriously would.
marsh dirge
Anybody have tips on leveling?
I'm only at level 28 and I've been playing for a 6 months to a year now lol
marsh dirge
Yeah I bounty hunt
novel iron
im 390 in 3 months lol
marsh dirge
damn
wooden ravine
@marsh dirge next get collector, bounty hunting takes you to off the path spots where there is almost always something to collect, dig up, whatever. And that adds 100 -300 xp for every item.
Its bonkers xp if you do the whole map.
novel iron
if you dont play much, moonshiner is good for you, you can make a delivery once an hour
you can have trader working in the background
but yeah collector is definitely the most money and xp
vapid robin
why do you want to know it anyway?
@novel iron Im a collector in rdr O. But i have too know which cycle i am. I can hardly search for cycle 6 items if im in 2. like baka
wooden ravine
If you have trader, and collector, you can, of you stop frequently to your camp, make great exp and money doing all three at once.
thorn sentinel
@honest obsidian there is some useful info in the pins in #bounty-hunter
marsh dirge
the only problem is I've tried most of the roles and I hate them all so much 😩
novel iron
@vapid robin you are confusing me, either use the map and collect, or dont use the map and run around. unless you know every location in every cycle, then you should know right away which cycle it is after finding a single item
vapid robin
That was the only thing i needed too know `` which cycle it is after finding a single item
wooden ravine
@marsh dirge another thing, the split point ammunition pamphlet isn't all that expensive. While riding a horse, and shooting someone in the head with split point ammo, is 5 xp for headshot 5xp for death rider, 5xp for special ammo, 5xp for the kill. 20xp doesn't seem like much but it adds up superfast.
novel iron
well i dont know a good way to figure out which cycle it is, you are gonna have to make a guide for yourself, or look for one if there is one
wooden ravine
@novel iron is right as long as you are using the jrpoke map or whatever you don't need to know which cycle it is.
novel iron
if its about immersion, then try to get to each location without marker or pins
honest obsidian
@thorn sentinel hey so where do i find that?
wooden ravine
@novel iron I could see where, if you were say, playing on ps or Xbox, where it could be difficult alt tabbing to the map and alt tabbing back in, so needing to know which phase you were in could make a difference
novel iron
also another thing is, you will have to find out the cycle for each set. so for example the cards today are on cycle 5, but the jewelry are on cycle 3, alcohol on cycle 4 and so on
wooden ravine
Yeah, could be a nightmare of map comparison. Thank you jrpoke.
novel iron
like you are gonna have to do some serious mind gymnastics to remember all that
wooden ravine
Or have 7 pages of maps, for each collection. . And an enormous empty wall.
wooden ravine
Empty wall has to be behind your tv/monitor.
So you have a 13 inch screen. And what. . .23 feet of maps?
novel iron
lol so you have multiple maps of each set hanging there, you still have to use the right combination of maps for each cycle and each set
wooden ravine
I suppose for each collection you could make a flip book like a calendar for each set and just flip it to the cycle you are in . . .it would be only like 12 feet of empty wall you would need.
Oh reminds me of the good ol days of Nintendo power maps.
marsh dirge
story missions are kinda dead not gonna lie
marsh dirge
and if i meet someone its usually a level 5 guy that dies in first two minutes
novel iron
yeah but these games didnt have 18 sets of collectables with 6 cycles or so each
honest obsidian
@thorn sentinel cheers
thorn sentinel
Np
thorn sentinel
The story missions mostly everyone has already done
marsh dirge
we need new players
wooden ravine
Gather a posse or just one more player and you can go do the missions no problem.
Especially if that other player can aim and use food and tonics like a human being.
wooden ravine
I would rather someone use a tonic than die, didnt say I use them :)
But I do gobble plain venison like a man trying to get deer poisoning.
marsh dirge
I usually dont die unless its a road block, the revenue agents uses lancaster, bolt actions, pump action and sometimes even explosives
I have a bunch of liqour in my inventory in singleplayer incase my health gets low
wooden ravine
Skinners can use dynamite.
marsh dirge
Im like jim lahey when i get low on health
wooden ravine
I've seen it twice.
marsh dirge
Revenue agents use dynamite aswell, never seen a skinner doing that tho
wooden ravine
Yeah once when I went up north for a trader supply run and once while delivering a legendary pelt on horseback
The former blew up the wagon the latter destroyed the pelt and killed muh horsie.
thorn sentinel
They do use toxic moonshine tho
wooden ravine
Thats when you switch to your knife and say "You fellas aren't going out easy."
marsh dirge
Never seen npcs using toxic moonshine, that's something new for me
wooden ravine
Oh yeah around rhodes. . . There's a moonshiner thing for burning fields? Stick around, they'll use it on ya for sure.
The other day I was doing a trade resupply at Wallace station, something bugged about that one because you always get a wanted level, anyways, got the bag on the horse, roped one of the guys and made a b line for camp, through the woods and what not, it was night time, wolves spawn on top of me. I let the guy go, wolves go after him instead. 10/10 would wolf troll again.
verbal epoch
xD
marsh dirge
Anyone know if the 5 star bounty with the guy in the swamp only has one target?
wooden ravine
Then there was this other time, northeast of brandywine drop, some collector items in a house up there, rode past this other player, standing still outside the house, I assumed he was also doing some collecting, but didn't react to my whistle, or my ride past him. I go into the house, get my collectible, turn around and he's busting into the house, shotgun in hands. (Obvious aggression is obvious). I stand out of the way of the door, watching him train his gun on the door. I switch to my lasso and get on the mic "You've done this to yourself." I rush him, he fires, misses, he's on the ground and hogtied as I say to him "you're gonna die hard." I start kicking him, just a few times. . . Throw two throwing knives in his legs, then a stick of dynamite and run like hell. The windows blow out, I get the message you killed so and so, and almost instantly get the so and so parlays with you. 10/10 would troll the troll again.
@marsh dirge do you mean the legendary gator guy?
scarlet anchor
anybody want to play together online? i haven't played much and still very new
wooden ravine
Its only one target but its like 50 gators
@scarlet anchor I can play for about an hour and a half starting in about 5 minutes.
north willow
red dead redemption is boring now
wooden ravine
Will look you up in a moment.
Much what? Gold? Money? Exp? Existential dread of newbs?
@scarlet anchor friend request sent
I think all of them together is 7 or 10 gold.
verbal epoch
red dead redemption is boring now
@north willow it aint if you got awesome people to play it with 😄
north willow
no it still is boring
scarlet anchor
@verbal epoch thats what im looking for!
north willow
i have don the same thing 3 times today
i open red dead redemption
and close it
because theres nothing to do
verbal epoch
there's tons to do tbh, Virgo
scarlet anchor
dressing up is funny
verbal epoch
its just it gets slightly repetitive, but there's definetly tons to do
north willow
like what though
verbal epoch
any role, exploration ovservation, siteseeing
bet you havent got all samples from legendary animals and all the collectables stacks handed in
north willow
my monitor is shit tho
wooden ravine
Crafting/hunting/playing cards/horse races/bar fights. . .
north willow
the game doesnt look nice on 60hz and 720p
verbal epoch
xD
wooden ravine
Going up to Colter and drawing a dick in the snow.
north willow
and yes i have most of the compendiums completed
verbal epoch
Going up to Colter and drawing a dick in the snow.
@wooden ravine ^
like a bazilion freeroam events
north willow
i guess but who is there to laugh at it with me
its just me drawing a dick in the snow then isnt it
verbal epoch
make a screenshot and send it to your buds xD
north willow
what buds 😔
wooden ravine
@north willow and again back to the first responder referring to "awesome people to play it with"
verbal epoch
or ask'em to come with you, 1 draws the pee pee others draw the "satchels" 😄
north willow
😔
verbal epoch
if you refuse to have fun you cant have fun 😄
verbal epoch
thats your problem 😛
north willow
sure is, but cant help myself from blaming rockstar a little 😆
verbal epoch
there's definetly something they could do, the game has limitless potential
verbal epoch
bank robberies, train stickups, ambushes for people doing stuff idk...there's like 100's of things they could do
verbal epoch
quadruple RESPECT
north willow
honestly if they just keep the roles there is now but add more content i would be happy
because its less things to multitask but more things to do
verbal epoch
there's enough roles ya tbh
north willow
maybe another passive role would be cool that doesnt requre as much attention as moonshiner and trader
verbal epoch
wdym moonshiner takes nothing to do xD
north willow
bro i need a shit again
thats my second shit today
ya u have to do bootlegger missions
for the mash to be worth it
lol
verbal epoch
even if you dont
and sell it for 247$, - 50$ for mash its still ~200$ pure profit every 42minutes
better than trader
north willow
true ig
verbal epoch
you're just lazy to do shit, and on the other hand you're complaining there's nothing to do xD
north willow
how am i lazy though i just dont want to do anything because its not fun
verbal epoch
unistall then, nobody's forcing you to play lol
north willow
ya i know
i am just complaining man rockstar needs to add more shit
or everyone will go
verbal epoch
you're like an online Karen ,just less agressive xD
north willow
howwwww
marsh dirge
Need heists
north willow
you have to admit this game is fucking dry sometimes
marsh dirge
has anyone found the legendary mud runner buck before
tawdry burrow
DM me if anyone here needs support on a trader wagon delivery run.
novel iron
lol just survived dynamite arrow with defensive build and special health cure
though maybe it wasn't a straight hit
verbal epoch
thats a hard one to survive
north willow
@novel iron built different 😈
thorn sentinel
Go to #roles and get a ps4 role then go to #645335430006439936
north willow
i just checked every trasure map location and found nothing
i am taking my anger out on valentine this is the most fun ive had with rdo in so lonf
sand plaza
@thorn sentinel Well sorry thank for advice
thorn sentinel
Nah your good
north willow
how do i start a barfight without getting wanted
thorn sentinel
You can't
north willow
bruh
thorn sentinel
There is that moonshiner mission
thorn sentinel
north willow
hm what should i do with em
i got 2 people kidnapped in an ally in saint denis
they died to a revolver shot in the foot.. wow
verbal epoch
lmfao
hazy cargo
Horses don't make significant differences so I would say until mid game that's when it's good time to buy
novel iron
do wolves count as deadly predator carcass and large carcass?
hard torrent
Yes
Gators are easier if you’re doing the daily
Oh you mean carcass too
I think they should
novel iron
yeah im trying to finish both
marsh dirge
Gators are lazy
grim parrot
Guys after the Mission of the story mode of online the mission when you kill Amos lancing in blackwater doesn't apper more missions of the story mode
novel iron
no, thats the last one for now
they might add more in the future
if you want more story, moonshiner role has a few story missions
but i recommend going with bounty hunter first
gilded crag
no need to use real money, getting gold is very easy
assuming the game isnt crashing for u like it is for many right now
hazy cargo
are gators count as deadly predator as well?
thorn sentinel
Yes
hazy cargo
bruh how haven't I realized it I've been ignoring that daily unless I found a cougar or something ;-;
it's so easy now
hard torrent
Oh ye the gators are way easier
hard torrent
Plus if you pop a three star in the noggin you’ll get 5 big game meat
And a perfect pelt : P
hazy cargo
transforming into an alligator would've been way more fun than some rabbit in the woods
Also I once killed an animal with bolas
because they deal some damage and that builds up and killed i think it was a rabbit
hazy cargo
If you notice bolas give damage in the stats
But of course it didn't tangle them it just dropped and leave the damage on them lol
hard torrent
That’s awesome I would’ve never known
hazy cargo
I'm gonna try that now see if it effective
hazy cargo
I just kicked them
hazy cargo
also the reason how I somehow killed a rabbit with bola was, I was trying to throw lasso at them
but bolas was still on the slot and I didn't change it
holy christ bolas one shot rabbits
or maybe it's my landon's patience and peak condition
marsh dirge
🤣
hazy cargo
it doesn't one shot those bigger ones of course
but it ragdolls them
but the really big one it doesn't
hazy cargo
also the rabbits and medium animals don't have aim assist so it's a bit harder for consoles
marsh dirge
Is the rare shotgun actually limited?
marsh dirge
lol
hazy cargo
It's only fit in story mode, in online it just not worth buying
marsh dirge
Are there any limited items?
marsh dirge
Which items
marsh dirge
You get that from the pass right
hazy cargo
and the items in outlaw pass (halloween pass right now)
you buy them from madam nazar
patent gazelleBOT
Lookin' fer the Madam? Check here #dailies-nazar
marsh dirge
Oh
hazy cargo
Expensive but they are once a year
marsh dirge
I hate life
hazy cargo
yeah well then right now the only limited items are in the pass
heady river
They'll be back around eventually.
They did bring the masks back out of season a while back too.
So just keep an eye out.
hazy cargo
ok
novel iron
so when donating cougars from the hunting wagon, they dont count as predator carcass 
hazy cargo
they count my panther though, from the wagon
just do gators
because pelts also included
novel iron
idk maybe it just glitched out or something
it only counted towards the large carcass
hazy cargo
oh
wooden ravine
Thats messed up. . . Are you saying that the seven moonstone wolf pelts, the 6 iwakta panthers, and the 6 Sapa cougars I have in my wagon won't count as predators?
@novel iron
novel iron
no idea might have been just the challenge not working properly
hazy cargo
I just posted rabbit hunting using bolas in #red-dead-media
wintry zealot
You can hunt rabbits using bolas?
hazy cargo
have a look #red-dead-media
novel iron
lol
hazy cargo
It gets a kill
novel iron
does it lower quality?
hazy cargo
yes
novel iron
shame xD
wintry zealot
Oof
hazy cargo
It just that it sound funny "you so good at hunting, you only use bolas to hunt" lol
hazy cargo
same
but I don't use them so I don't really craft them much
rabbits are pretty much everywhere anyway so I can always get their samples at any time
novel iron
true
hazy cargo
Just the skunks they are not so common
once I see one I will always take its sample
is it rabbit skunk wolf?
hazy cargo
yeah any kind of wolves
they are also super common (at night)
and they spawn in packs
novel iron
exactly you can get like 3 or more at a time
hazy cargo
How many pheromones you can make depend on spawn rate of skunks
novel iron
and since you can have 20 instead of 10 makes it even easier
novel iron
yeah
hazy cargo
Welp time to go afk for 30 minutes on etta now
novel iron
lol enjoy? xD
hazy cargo
Basically a short break while the game still makes money and gold for me
novel iron
you gotta press something in the middle of the 30 mins though to not get thrown out
hazy cargo
I just look in my hand held catalog and I can stay in the game forever without getting kick for afk
novel iron
huh i didnt know that
hazy cargo
basically if you are browsing in catalog you are not consider idle
even if you didn't flip a page
novel iron
nice trick
prime tulip
marsh dirge
Yeah pretty much
hazy cargo
Most say rolling block better because it allow you to one shot but I would still say carcano is the way for me it's not like I can land a hit that good anyway, and with much better fire rate there's better chance for me to land to hit consecutively
marsh dirge
Gave up on the rolling bc i got tired of it shooting marshmallows against ppl using tonics lol
hazy cargo
With maximum damage build in pvp if you happen to picked up rolling block (of course with only reg ammo) you can still one shot players with no def cards
hazy cargo
yeah and it doesn't matter if it headshot too, if you can really do a lot of headshots carcano gonna be the go
ionic mural
hey guys I play on pc and im trying to do a mission and it starts matchmaking and then it says no one joined in the time alloted or something, can someone join me or something idk how this works, i downloaded the game on epic games
muted scaffold
hazy cargo
I don't think there's private lobbies and this is not lfg channel either
scarlet anchor
lfg?
hazy cargo
looking for group
scarlet anchor
ahhh i see
hazy cargo
basically looking for people to play with
there's a specific channels for those already
they are organized in platforms so that you can look for people who are on your platform to play with easily
scarlet anchor
wheres this?
hazy cargo
Get your platform role in #roles scroll up if you don't see it
after that you will be given access to your platform specific channels
this channels are for everyone so doing lfg on this already harder since not everyone will be on your platform
north willow
if i kill an alligator next to my camp can i donate its carcus
hard gale
Nope that won't work, a carcass either has to be on your person, wagon or horseback unfortunately
marsh dirge
i was in the mountains and i killed some animals and a line appeared that said "You monster! Dont kill these creatures" or something like that
lol harriet is everyhwere 
quiet whale
Harriet is the mother nature herself
high beacon
lol no she's just an angry, high vegan
native vine
quiet whale
short cedar
Hey peoples. Has the new outlaw pass started yet?
marsh dirge
no
its not going to start until next month
which is dumb because literally everyone bought halloween pass now and you can max it out in 1 day
short cedar
Well that's been rdo's problem since forever. All content is made for casual players. So 'full time' players finish everything within a week or two. I sent a passionate letter to the devs about it months ago.
quiet whale
Passionate letter sounds like a love letter
marsh dirge
week or two? Bro when i started this game like 3 weeks ago i was level 5 and when i went afking for gold in halloween mode
i maxed it out in few hours
and as level 20 i had trader, bounty hunter and already maxed out collector role
quiet whale
Halloween pass can be completed in less than a day
marsh dirge
i mean i maxed it out when i was level 34 but still its very easy to level it up
safe hinge
Imo, just a novelty thing for Halloween tho.
Don't see why ppl expect it to be lengthy
short cedar
I was talking about rdo's content in general 🙂
safe hinge
I understood that. 👍
...I was more referring to Ori, and cat plans replies
short cedar
I've never had issues fishing in rdo
quiet whale
And it's laggy af
verbal epoch
which merchant would buy herbs?
short cedar
All the doctors
verbal epoch
right, thanks
short cedar
Collector herbs it might just be the madam though
patent gazelleBOT
Lookin' fer the Madam? Check here #dailies-nazar
verbal epoch
nah its "sell 5 herbs" daily thing
hasty wedge
verbal epoch
xD
marsh dirge
Is it worth investing in the shovel and later on in the metal detector?
verbal epoch
yup, otherwise you cant do 2/3's of collection role
marsh dirge
same for everyone
unless you don’t have some of the roles, then you won’t get those dailies
tight marsh
Does anyone know what are the select free Role items for the coupon? Currently it displays none
thorn sentinel
All
marsh dirge
Collector is fr easy money since the locations are on the internet everyday lol,
karmic ivy
So is it bad to kill player horses?
I saw a player murder civilians so I tackled them, then another one started shooting at me. He killed me, I respawned and killed him. Why did it say "murder"?
clear ice
brah you did you srsly kill him because he killed a civ?
karmic ivy
No, I tackled him, wanted to capture him. I thought I could put him to prison because the civilians cried for law. I bounded the person but a friend of them just murdered me. Then I basically fought them and in the process killed both their horses.
novel iron
what do you mean with bad? it will cost you $4
karmic ivy
Why???
novel iron
and thats not how it works in online
karmic ivy
How is it my fault their horse is killed while they try to murder me?
novel iron
thats just how it is, you are not the law
karmic ivy
I'm not the law in SP either and I get paid
novel iron
and if you kill a player horse it will cost you as i said
karmic ivy
That's dumb
novel iron
in sp the ones you can capture and take to the cops are scripted encounters
karmic ivy
if I am bounty hunter I can capture them and get paid though?
novel iron
no
unless they have a big bounty on them
then you get a notification that theres a player bounty nearby
karmic ivy
Is 100$ a lot of money?
novel iron
bounty goes up much slower than in sp
karmic ivy
no I mean in general
novel iron
killing the cops will only make it go up 10 cents
karmic ivy
is 100$ considered to be much or is it like SP?
novel iron
depends on your level and how much you play
karmic ivy
How much is it compared to SP?
and what is level cap and how long does it take to reach it?
novel iron
theres no level cap i think
karmic ivy
to reach level 30 how long?
novel iron
dude that depends on how you play, how long you play and maybe even luck
marsh dirge
you rank up by killing, doing missions, etc. if you don’t do that a lot then it’s going to take longer
marsh dirge
What the heck does sp mean😅
karmic ivy
singeplayer
ornate swift
Now that the lobby has large amounts of people again, idk if I should take the risk and go distant or keep it short.
Is the 125k difference worth the risk really?
novel iron
you can ask for help in #deliveries-pc
ornate swift
Hmhm. Well imma do so tomorrow then.
marsh dirge
i just met some loosers that were level 15 and tied me when i was searching for a treasure so i just changed the session
i didnt have time for that
marsh dirge
well
are you desperate for a horse?
i have the grullo dun I think that’s a rank 10
Then yes I’d get the Breton
It’ll have max stamina
I love my Breton but I have a Missouri Fox Trotter now
I just got moonshiner and everything seems so expensive... few thousands or more and little profit i think
i saw a price of moonshine and it said 75$
does that mean 75 $ for 20 bottles or just for one?
If for one the brueh thats a lot of cash
75 $ * 20
1400 dollars
if for 1 max delivery which is 20 bottles it sucks
thorn sentinel
Nope it's 75 for 20 bottles
marsh dirge
everything costs like 900 dollars and for 1 single delivery you get 75 $ 
thorn sentinel
It can make 1000 in half the time it takes for trader fully upgraded
But at the start yeah it's ass
marsh dirge
i dont know if its worth for me to upgrade it
i have 400 dollars left
i have every other business
thorn sentinel
Do those first it's one of the hardest to fully level up
marsh dirge
moonshiner horse is great but upgrading all these things is pain in the ass
marsh dirge
i just got disconnected coz R* while i was doing a treasure map will my treasure map disappear now
ok thankfully not
novel iron
btw moonshine makes more money than trader (strong, 2 star moonshine)
novel iron
yeah but you can make the moonshine 4 times
thorn sentinel
It makes it faster
novel iron
225*4=900 -200 for mash is 700
if you wanna take into account the other material cost
thats a couple of dollars tops
if you do any bootlegger thats makes even more money
marsh dirge
well
if you have enough gold and get all of the other roles
then yes I recommend naturalist
but do it once you have every other role
then get trader next
then collected, moonshiner, naturalist
Collector*
15
Collector and trader are 15, naturalist and moonshiner are 25
Collector is easy to max out though. Just time consuming
Spent $1,500 to upgrade my cards. Back to being poor lol
mood
novel iron
how about a loan shark role
hazy cargo
gawr gura
novel iron
not as cute lol
silent peak
how about a loan shark role
@novel iron yes
marsh dirge
laughs in 1 gold bar and 1.3k
still frost
novel iron
silent peak
2 gold bars and 15 dollars. Anyone match up?
novel iron
seriously though if you guys play a decent amount, in 2 months you will be rich
in one month gold wont be a huge issue thanks to dailies
marsh dirge
I was only able to do bounties because I joined random posses
Now I solo most of my bounties
ionic mural
i have a question, i just completed the story mission destroyed by grief yesterday and a new mission hasn't come up, is this a glitch or what
silent peak
i fucking hate that the longer you take to bring in a bounty the higher the reward is
ionic mural
can anyone help me i'm stuck
marsh dirge
It would make more sense if you did it quicker then you would be able to earn more
silent peak
exactly
marsh dirge
It would take more skill to bring it in faster
silent peak
These are dangerous criminals not grandmothers who die if you flick them. Why do we need to take our time? Its bullshit
woeful jackal
anyone on ps4 wanna play?
woeful jackal
65
silent peak
oof nvm im a level 15 😔
woeful jackal
nobody checked the lfg so i put it in here quick
it’s alright ! i’m still down to play
silent peak
Alright
woeful jackal
yeah i don’t mind
marsh dirge
nope, more gold = less cash
less cash = more gold
so when i got fuckin 2 gold bars that 1 time i got like 10 bucks
also theres a 5% chance you get a pamphlet
i got that chance once
pamphlet instead of cash that is
coz pamphlets (the important ones anyway) can cost so much money
so its actually pretty epic to find them from a treasure map
hazy cargo
It's quite handy with dealing with 2+ bounties and bounties can't escape but other than that not really
For normal bounties I wouldn't say say it's worth much
marsh dirge
and if you for some reason like the regular bounties then yea the 3+ bounties are very good to do with them
hazy cargo
although I do get sometime like 0.36 gold for 4 bounties
marsh dirge
i said 3+ cause theres like 2 good ways to do 2 bounties without a wagon
hazy cargo
never done 6 because it's like almost impossible
marsh dirge
pre much impossible ye unless u got a perfect everything
hazy cargo
When I said 2+ I mean any number of bounties more than 2 so 3-6 bounties
hazy cargo
It's kind of optional
marsh dirge
do you have money to spend?
would say save the money then if you dont have money to spend
def better getting something like collector shovel/metal detector or larger trader wagon or stronger moonshine production
hazy cargo
You not gonna make money back as quickly if you think the wagon gonna do that
marsh dirge
ronin compared to the other roles its not good
even in money
but $225 is nothing to scoff at still
hence why its barely good
hazy cargo
other roles don't give anymore gold than 1.5 gold per day
marsh dirge
honestly i'd just do dailies and treasure maps and call it a day
having to wait 30 minutes for 0.48 gold is bruh
marsh dirge
lol i meant afk tho
hazy cargo
because I just set it up and go do my job around the house irl
marsh dirge
like im not just gonna be bored out of my mind for 30 minutes
hazy cargo
They force you to play like that
marsh dirge
yeah having a role that rewards you for playing worse is just stupid
i say playing worse because if you were good you would do it fast
but if you aren't good then you'd do it slower
hazy cargo
They think weirdly that slow people and fast people should get the same amount
marsh dirge
yea it makes no sense honestly
but it means that like
in terms of profit
its good i guess
hazy cargo
fast people are literally "suffering from success"
marsh dirge
😂 exactly
hazy cargo
and slow people can just get on with their life being success somehow
marsh dirge
ok i nearly broke something from rage my autoride (cinematic mode) didnt work for like 30 seconds straight
why wont you be able to do them
etta doyle can be done 5 stars as a solo low level
theres just a glitch type trick you need to pull off
hazy cargo
theres just a glitch type trick you need to pull off
which is actually to follow the game(npc) instruction
plain oar
does fishing count as killing animal?
marsh dirge
does fishing count as killing animal?
@plain oar no, but if u shoot the fish then yes
plain oar
that makes sense ty
marsh dirge
no problem
winged valley
anyone able to tell me why i cant find the improved arrows pamphlet at the fence, or can tell me what I should use for a perfect alligator pelt.
marsh dirge
sometimes its the server u r on because i remember i was trying to purchase the butcher table for the trader roll and it was not popping up
but for the alligator pelt idk id sell it and look at wat u can use it for at any where gus is located look up on buying items and check wat type of pelts r needed
plain oar
what is the cooldown for stranger mission?
marsh dirge
i think once every hour
plain oar
dan that's pretty long
marsh dirge
yeah its because rockstar wants u to wait for the gold
dan that's pretty long
@plain oar anything else u wanna know
marsh dirge
no problem might as well help others since i have so many hours on the game
marsh dirge
Thats why your first role should be bounty hunter
hazy cargo
I kept getting disconnected ;-;
marsh dirge
Why are some people stars✨ on your map instead of dots
verbal epoch
they're posse leaders
proven mortar
How many hours until the Halloween Pass ends?
marsh dirge
two weeks @proven mortar
marsh dirge
Its extended till 30 november @proven mortar
orchid hare
Hopefully the next day we will get the update whatever it is
Because at the moment apart from keeping my streak I’m not really that interested in online now
near mirage
hello everybody , im looking for ppl to play with (doing missions , chilling etc) on pc
marsh dirge
How tf do people have 1000 gold
Its hard enough to get 1 gold bar let alone 1000
you can buy gold
sweet forum
Why the fuck is fishing being such a pain in the balls today?
Did they fuck up the special lures or something as it's attracting fucking nothing
marsh dirge
You need the right lurendor the right place
sweet forum
I was up at Lake Isabella with Special Lake Lure equipped.
Literally nothing was biting.
marsh dirge
I had a lake sturgeon on the line, I was near Rhodes fishing, but then some asshole came and choked me to death
lmao
I killed him 10 times after that
sweet forum
Also, Kinda really wish that muskies and fucking northern pike didn't look so similar.
marsh dirge
Navy
sweet forum
Personal recommendation, Double Action Revolvers
faint jetty
Navy @tight marsh
tight marsh
While I adore Schofield, I am probably gonna go saa (cattle) or walker (navy) for that extra old west feeling
tight marsh
Bonus points for cattleman as it's Ocelot's favorite
novel iron
well he likes it thanks to big boss recommendations lol
high beacon
yes
marsh dirge
cattleman is trash, schofield is a bit better, navy feels slow and lemats are great
big damage, shotgun mode etc
pallid wagon
You can make the Navy look like the Scorpion Revolver from Red Dead 1, so that immediately makes it better
sweet forum
Lemats are a pain in the ass reload wise, even slower than the Navy's
marsh dirge
Are the skinners also in online?
thorn sentinel
Yes
marsh dirge
F
marsh dirge
bro I need to stop spending my money. I had 2.4K and then I bought a covered tent, a Norfolk roadster, and a new theme for my camp and now I have 115 dollars smh
Anyone wanna do some bounty together
I just got the role
high beacon
@marsh dirge you gotta grind man
sweet forum
Kinda wish you were able to give horses the best equivalent stats, like giving a Dutch Warmblood of any coat the stats of Buell
marsh dirge
yeah but still I need to stop spending lmao
that would be dumb tbh
imagine this worst trash horse with breton brave stat and black arabian speed etc
sweet forum
...Not quite like that, more of; you give the horse of that breed the best stats for that breed.
Kentucky Saddlers having the stats equivalent to the Buttermilk Buckskin for example.
A Shire having the stats of the Raven Black Shire.
Bravery in online seems to be a load of bunk however.
Being able to have a Black Norfolk Roadster with the stats of the Level 20 horses.
That sort of stuff.
north willow
fuck arabian horses
sweet forum
I can agree, skittish shits.
sweet forum
Man I still have the black one sitting in my stable as I don't wanna get rid of it since I had actually gotten it on sale.
But It's just so...Garbage.
north willow
sure you have a fast horse, quick accelerating but you get bucked off when your horse sees a beaver and its stamina is dogshit
yesss its so bad idec about speed
i just have my black breton i purchased a while back
does me just fine
sweet forum
Seal Brown or the Steel Grey Roan?
north willow
steel grey obviously
you know the color of the level 1 breton
the brown one
they should make a level 20 that color
i actually loved it so much
sweet forum
I honestly like the Seal Brown coloration of the Dutch Warmblood, which irks me that I can't get it with Stats like Buell's
north willow
never heard of that ill have a lookie in a momento
sweet forum
Buell is a tank of a horse.
9 health and stamina with speed that puts him pretty on par with race horses.
sweet forum
Now, that would actually be an ideal way of doing it, Equestrian Trials
Instead of just, paying a gold premium like I had said in the past.
north willow
my breton has pretty much max stamina i think its 9 but the health is at 8
sweet forum
Hm.
north willow
its stamina bar looks like it is just an inch away from full all the time
so im guessing its 9
and the health is a couple lower
i could get 7 or 8
sweet forum
Well, usually a full circle is 10 of 10
north willow
guess*
sweet forum
This is the Seal Brown, Right?
sweet forum
I personally use the Tiger Striped Bay Mustang.
vapid robin
Oh
im using the jeanropke collectors map. But i cant find the cycle 2
Does that mean that there isnt a cycle 2 ??
novel iron
do you have manual cycle input enabled?
vapid robin
Wait, Am I allowed to sent you private? I cant send any pictures here
sweet forum
post in #red-dead-media
vapid robin
Ooh thanks
novel iron
you can dm
what you posted shows the cycles of today which are set automatically
if you want to change any for research or whatever you have to tick the option to enter the cycle manually
vapid robin
Oh
novel iron
the cycles change everyday
vapid robin
Yes i know that
but i tried to search every item from different cycles
and im not in all of them
marsh dirge
rockstar let us dodge harriet attack and kill her instead
hazy cargo
Who else gonna supply us with unlimited legendary animal pelts then
Oh wait actually let Gus do that
marsh dirge
yes
marsh dirge
bro the fuck is wrong with this game i had black screen and i didnt see anything, now i restarted the game and i still have it
north willow
high beacon
shame
tawdry cliff
So small missions wtf is this is there a continue or thats it from the story ?
Or replay only
tawdry cliff
Damn what a shame....weeelll go8ng back on low huntings
marsh dirge
after you do the main missions once you get moonshiner there’s more story missions
tawdry cliff
Is it good
novel iron
for your first role? then bounty as its the only role that gives out gold as reward
and moonshiner will cost you 5 gold bars just to be able to buy it
unless you have trader rank 5 already
wintry zealot
You don’t have to go with bounty you can go with trader just do dailies and get gold bounties aren’t a must. Bounty was actually my first role as well
Also as long as you’ve done a trader sell mission you’ll get the moonshine mission I recommend trader it gives good cash but no gold
tawdry cliff
So bounty it is i guess
wintry zealot
Well go with what you want
tawdry cliff
Well looking a proffit start for a profit
wintry zealot
Bounties is fun for a bit but you’ll soon realize that they will be boring asf just like collector
pallid wagon
Bounty is potentially the most boring
wintry zealot
If your looking for profit don’t go with bounties lol
pallid wagon
Collector is a close second, but while doing your collecting you can do some other stuff on the way.
novel iron
wintry zealot
Bounties was my first role as well I don’t really remember what I did to get gold before that I swear I didn’t know what dalies were
Maybe I did
But when you level up you get more dailies so that’s probably why
tawdry cliff
What ia most profit of them three
pallid wagon
The most direct profit is collector, but you need to get a full collection to do it. Trader is more of a slowburn profit, and it unlocks Moonshining on the way
Not sure about naturalist, and what kind of cash that brings in
tawdry cliff
I bought the edition upgrade
hard torrent
Naturalist is for content, not a good money maker
tawdry cliff
I have all three unlocked but to start i need 15 bars thats what i have
Now i am looking to start something to get profit as well
hard torrent
If you want cash and xp, pick collector if you mostly play solo, trader if you play with friends. If you want gold pick bounty Hunter
Do daily challenges for gold tho it’s easy
tawdry cliff
So i guess collector it is....
pallid wagon
Collector isn't bad, even just selling singular pieces. I made at least 200$ from a Saint Denis run
tawdry cliff
And how i start the collector
hard torrent
Go to madam Nazar and buy the collectors bag for 15g
patent gazelleBOT
Lookin' fer the Madam? Check here #dailies-nazar
pallid wagon
Find madam nazar, and buy the collector's bag.
patent gazelleBOT
Lookin' fer the Madam? Check here #dailies-nazar
hard torrent
tawdry cliff
She is not there at my map
fossil tide
@marsh dirge Honestly, for me it's quicker to sell randomly. Esp in a full server. It's a preference I guess, but I still get a decent amount of money regardless so...
marsh dirge
Theres so much work on moonshiner business, i hate it
Also since i got all businesses i have no idea what to do with gold, any ideas
wooden ravine
@marsh dirge what i do is i go collecting, if I make a full collection, I go sell that, and I sell any duplicate items, that way I'm not reducing the opportunity to sell a collection, I just haven't got all the items for that bit yet. Still make great money and xp, but I don't hinder my opportunities for selling full collections.
wooden ravine
@marsh dirge do you have an arabian? If you do then save it for the next role/xmas thing they do.
marsh dirge
i have white one and its trash, i would sell it but i dont want to loose cash
wooden ravine
I meant the black.
wooden ravine
Its the best all round horse in the game. Cept its skittish as hell.
marsh dirge
its definitely not the best
its pile of shit
every arabian is bad
gets scared easily
wooden ravine
Google: rdr2 online horse spreadsheet.
marsh dirge
and killed extremely fast
wooden ravine
Black Arabian has the highest stats. Period.
marsh dirge
maybe it has good stats but other horses like missouri fox trotter are literally the same except they have more hp and they dont get scared 24/7
nacogdoeches saddle with best stirrups on a horse = +4 to speed if im not wronmg
wrong*
wooden ravine
At max bonding yeah I think so.
Look i own a mft and I'm typically running around on the Ardennes or the arabian.
Because the Ardennes will run over a wolf pack like a champ.
marsh dirge
arabian is big shit if you want to do bounties, its just a friendly horse that you can ride in free roam
wooden ravine
I do bounties all the time with my arabian.
I never get bucked when I'm shot at, just when like an alligator farts nearby.
marsh dirge
then you get off a horse and it runs faster than lamborghini
wooden ravine
So whistle and it stays?
marsh dirge
bounties with arabians are harder
wooden ravine
Also all of the horses run from gunfire and predators after a dismount
delicate dome
sorry for interrupting lmao
I have Missouri Fox Trotter, love him totally, It may not have biggest stats, but it's really nice horse, nice coat and it's pretty brave tho
safe hinge
Idk. I hear ppl bitch about arabian all the time, but I nvr have any probs with it
marsh dirge
i always had problems with it
wooden ravine
I do like my mother, but after I got my black, I was hooked.
marsh dirge
one time i killed it with dynamite because it annoyed me so much
wooden ravine
Mtf not mother.
safe hinge
My only complaint, is it's small af, so looks silly as hell.
But I use one as my main horse on 2nd (female) character.
wooden ravine
Again the white is a cheap imitation of the black, and also the Missouri fox trotter is a better horse than the white, but not the black.
delicate dome
yep, I have arabian horse in story mode and Arthur looks just ridiculous on his back
patent gazelleBOT
wooden ravine
The only thing about the horse spreadsheet that isn't taken into account is bravery.
Which is stupid.
marsh dirge
arabians bravery is below zero
safe hinge
I swear the bravery aspect is just in players heads. Lol
delicate dome
jesus yes, my arabian spooked just because I shot bird
wooden ravine
Well the whites might be, but on my black I have never been bucked in a gunfight.
safe hinge
Same
wooden ravine
Just around animals
safe hinge
And I've been bucked off other breeds just as much or more
I don't get the hate. But wvr
delicate dome
Arabians have really nice coats and stats but their bravery is l o w
marsh dirge
i hate arabians for it being small, for being dumb cowards and they will fall a lot
delicate dome
this
wooden ravine
Honestly imo Ardennes is the single bravest horse, I run over wolves and alligators with loctite.
safe hinge
Well everyone's entitled to play/like as they see fit
marsh dirge
i like big horses
delicate dome
me too
wooden ravine
Indeed. Just trying to let people know the black arabian is better than people believe.
safe hinge
Bretons are ridiculous in size too imo tho. Looks silly too
marsh dirge
shire is the biggest
delicate dome
I have gray dappled or whatever you call it in english language, English throughbreed or smth lmao, it's really cool
omg I remember when I was running around on that black shire that youre getting from hosea and someone just shot it :(
wooden ravine
And honestly, if they would let me buy and ride a donkey, the worst mount in the game? Main horse, 10/10 would heehaw again.
marsh dirge
i killed it with dynamite
delicate dome
donkeys are the best lmao
wooden ravine
What i don't get, is why you can't go bull riding. . . Or cow tipping.
wooden ravine
And how come you have to clean your guns and never sharpen your knife?
delicate dome
yesss
marsh dirge
i never clear my guns because its pain in the ass
delicate dome
lmao
marsh dirge
i just go for headshots
wooden ravine
Cat plan der lind is a negative nancy.
marsh dirge
theres the trinket from Gus that helps with gun conditions
where it negates the rate at which it wears by 10%
also the wraps help
wooden ravine
I would put a wrap on my weapons but I just think they all look so dumb. :(
Like I put it on my back and mentally frown when I see it. :(
wooden ravine
@marsh dirge I believe there is an Xbox channel.
marsh dirge
scrawny nag is the best horse
fossil tide
I'd rather see my engravings, tbh...
marsh dirge
i like riding a scrawny nag and jumping off a cliff
fossil tide
We don't deserve the nag. It's too op. :p
wooden ravine
@fossil tide exactly
I want to be able to buy a donkey, sharpen my knife, ride a bull, pan for gold (in game money not gold bars), own a working gold claim, do claim jumpers missions and the like, and also own/operate a brothel out of one of the various saloons with all the missions and various ridiculous bs that all that entails.
And if not a brothel then a casino or something like that.
Or both, and rockstar can take my ideas and make a boatload of money off of it with all the various upgrades/personnel/location costs any of those opportunities for spending gold that all entails.
fossil tide
Anyone know the best place to find a cat? For my daily and I never see them. :/
wooden ravine
Strawberry near and around the butcher.
Or emerald ranch near the big house usually
novel iron
or theives landing
wooden ravine
Hunt it down and sell the whole carcass to him.
novel iron
NOOO
dont sell whole carcass
that wont unlock the garment
you have to skin it first
and sell the pelt!!!
fossil tide
Found it thanks.
novel iron
you can find marble fox around colter
use #rdo-compendium
its much lower chance if you dont have naturalist rank 15
safe hinge
Ya it's just cosmetic. 
As u rank up and unlock other ammo types, I guess that's a way to carry more.
wooden ravine
I only use split point ammo and I only seem to run out after three large gunfights (15 enemies or more)
And if you get your cards set up right you can just rush everyone and knife em. Sometimes that's just more fun to do.
Like "Yes I did bring a knife to a gunfight, and you all are gonna die hard."
marsh dirge
Life hack incoming
When you get a mission to steal something without killing the owners, run in like a mental person with a lasso and tie everyone up
You probably wont die
quiet whale
Shotgun npcs are op
Rolling Block and carcano npcs too
Springfield and bolt actions are easy to handle
Not if you have ability cards
Shotgun and carcanos still hit hard even with max defensive ability cards
marsh dirge
Buy a bolt action rifle
Row a boat, fist fight, and fishing to level up
For the low price of 200 dollars you can have a bolt action rifle in your hands today!
2 shot kills GUARANTEED!
They have close stats its just preferance
marsh dirge
Also bolt action is half the price of carcano and doesnt need high level to unlock
atomic quest
Any other traders here?
marsh dirge
Im just tryna level up to get a god darned fishing rod
quiet whale
Regular bullets is ok
marsh dirge
Like lvl 14 seriously
atomic quest
I need 1 more trader levels
quiet whale
I only use express ammo for Players
I forgot that you don't have ability cards except pib
marsh dirge
Im not a fan of pvp
Player can suffocate you in 2 second without a chance to escape
One time i cut a player out from a hogtie then slashed her 3 times
She was on 2 HP and still killed me
So in general horse shit without guns
Its like mortal combat, button mash-fest
Yea as long as you can spam your button at twice the speed of a bugatti you will make it
quiet whale
The lags in fist fighting in online is real
wooden ravine
I made a "breakout of stupid shit" macro. It presses all the buttons required to break a choke or a hogtie or a lasso in 1 ms on repeat.
It has made me lag out of the game before though. Maybe I should slow it down.
sweet forum
I sound like JeV when I do RDO PvP
wooden ravine
What is a JeV?
sweet forum
FaZe JeV
wooden ravine
I'm not googling that, too many bad experiences so. . . What is a FaZe JeV?
sweet forum
@'d you in #general-media
short cedar
Hi peoples 🙂
novel iron
you have unreleased role?
ornate trout
no thats just my playstyle
novel iron
i was joking xD
get a role from #roles
then use lfg channel
when you pick platform, lfg channel unlocks
ornate trout
so confused