I’m not sure if drinking from the barrel counts
#rdo-chat
modest crown
modest crown
Yup
winged ember
Rip
modest crown
You can do moonshiner missions for Maggie to lower the production cost
high beacon
If you get 36 dollars for your moonshine then your driving must not be too good-
winged ember
I'm so glad they did the corset thing
modest crown
No more shirts underneath eh
raw veldt
Are y’all having problems where Npcs get aggro for no reason
modest crown
Nope
jaunty belfry
Npc's are as aggro as ever
modest crown
were you openly carrying a firearm?
winged ember
No
jaunty belfry
sometimes npc's can get whack even if you run past them or block their pathfinding
winged ember
I was in the player menu in the side street between the shop and the saloon in valentine
shadow berry
Psn friendlyplayerz need friend to play
raw marsh
has anyone game just randomly alt tabbing and goes back immediately in quick succession? always happen to me in town for some reason
never happened before the update
plush prawn
What's the cooldown on naturalist lady spraying you and telling ya to go away
sly schooner
Pro Tip: Dont revive wolfs.
tepid hemlock
Is the collector map broken today too?
tawdry token
Anyone getting disconnected after the update more often than before?
tepid hemlock
No
shell snow
i’ve been getting 2 different errors sighh
tawdry token
Anyone else gets stuck on the poster while trying to do a legendary bounty?
broken apex
I wish i could tell you but I can’t even connect
tawdry token
My game has never been this broken
broken apex
Yeah... i hope it maybe fixes later
tawdry token
Can't even do the showdown because it's all greyed out ffs
broken apex
Damn
tawdry token
I'll probably take another bream lol
raw marsh
well my game is alt tabbing constantly on its own..
broken apex
I’m just going to do dishes funnier than just disconnecting all the damn time 
low garden
lmfao
jaunty belfry
turned a 3 star bear into a 1 star
devout cliff
What'd you do, obliterate it?
low garden
lovely
devout cliff
If you ever run into Jonk, do the same
modest crown
anyone know what the starter saddles are?
tryna redeem this goddamn coupon once and for all
low garden
No idea, I don't purchase starter tier trash.
modest crown
nah you'll miss. cause the recoil is rubbish
jaunty belfry
when your crouch it throws you
modest crown
i unknowingly killed 2 legendary elks
and i now wear their fur
i am, The Destroyer of Elks
jaunty belfry
how did you "unknowingly" do it?
modest crown
Katata, used an Elephant Gun on it, took 4 shots lmao
Inahme, was a mission from Davenport, decided to kill it
bitch sprayed me, but it was worth it
jaunty belfry
walked into Harriet's tent wearing a full bear coat and a ram bandolier.
safe to say i dont think she likes me
delicate valley
cobalt coyote
how much does the advanced camera cost?
high beacon
Around the same as the gun
cobalt coyote
is the game down rn? i cant join any lobbies
nocturne flame
what's the good thing about the improved bow?
twilit hemlock
same and when I do manage to join I get disconnected
cursive sapphire
Where did the naturalist channel go lol
jaunty belfry
its still there #naturalist
select the naturalist role in #roles and it will show up
rustic rapids
hmm are the legendary animals timed limited ?
silk mirage
Games not down just having major issues dcing people randomly
jaunty belfry
the servers are probably rather populated right now, so chances are there will be some hiccups here and there.
will probably go on for the next week as people come back for the patch
silk mirage
Guess takes a while for roles to update
graceful juniper
Disconnected due to a network fault, is that an issue on my side or rock*
tepid hemlock
Bruh, am I the only one who's actually bothering with the collector role now
tepid hemlock
Yeah exactly, just need a bit of money for the new weapons but was wondering if anyone managed to find a way lol
Wonder how long it'll be broken for
marsh dirge
Is the collectors map still accurate after the update?
graceful juniper
Nah
jaunty belfry
they said something in the patch notes about moving around some diggables
so I doubt
they always try and get themselves ahead of the collectors map since they dont like it
graceful juniper
Yeah well I don’t think anyone wants to run across the entire map looking for 1 coin
graceful juniper
Yeah rockstar sucks, they wait 7 months to give us content and then try and ruin previous content
Just because they don’t like something smh
marsh dirge
Yep..
jaunty belfry
its because the collectors map takes away the need for madam nazars maps
patent gazelleBOT
Lookin' fer the Madam? Check here #dailies-nazar
jaunty belfry
if you use one of her maps you get an xp decrease
if you dont you get a bonus, which while using the online map it counts as finding them without a map meaning xp gain is OP
safe pagoda
Will there be a legendary animal map like the collectors map. Not the in game purchasable one but the community’s map?
graceful juniper
idk maybe but i think it would be very broad
like i dont think an animal is gonna spawn in a specific spot
more of a region
marsh dirge
Bruh now I can’t even kill any animals or Harriet gets mad
I can’t even hunt for my traders role
harsh steppe
Does anyone in australia wanna play?
harsh steppe
alright, sorry i only just joined
jaunty belfry
no worries
tidal surge
is it just me or does the Pellé Pearl Necklace - Cycle 1 just not show up on twin stack pass?
high beacon
The map wont be accurate since the update
tidal surge
it was the same before the update though
and every other one has worked fine
¯_(ツ)_/¯
high beacon
Its been said the map wont be accurate, especially for diggables
They already mentioned in the patch notes that has been changed so
high beacon
Maybe
If it worked for others it should work for the rest
Try to mostly focus on things like cards and so on
tidal surge
well i did like half of them the day before the update so
high beacon
🤷🏻♂️ You can try
broken apex
I’m about to try now again
marsh dirge
Ah, no links.
graceful juniper
i was able to get in
marsh dirge
are the servers fixed
graceful juniper
do i need to hold onto 1 of each sample or no
marsh dirge
been playing for hours with no disconnects
doees the wagon 'trick' still work?
heard some say yes some say no
nocturne flame
why are people such fucking dicks
i go afk with a bounty and come back to a shithead killing my bounty and me
then fucking runs away like a little bitch
marsh dirge
stand closer to the drop off point. it'll make you invunurable
nocturne flame
i was afk in the cinematic camera heading there
marsh dirge
ooo
faint loom
When your 5GB rdr2 update took 24 hours to complete 😭
oblique citrus
so bandoliers are still only cosmetic, right? even the hunter ones?
marsh dirge
Yikes
raw marsh
yep
split lotus
is anyone else’s vehicles unable to be summoned?
high beacon
You can go to the stable and get them manually from there
safe pagoda
I was just about to put that too, my vehicle won’t summon either
raw marsh
looks like cheaters are back on PC
graceful juniper
did they ever leave?
raw marsh
well that was a fun 12 hours of clean online experience
ye when the game got updated yday the cheat needs to as well
final tinsel
@marsh dirge You can post the links at #general-media
tidal surge
what is the best reasonably priced horse?
i want something that wont buck me off every 5 seconds
oblique citrus
what are vitalism studies pamphlets? i have an offer - 5gold bars off, but i dont see where to buy that and what is it?
heavy glacier
Can you buy a house in rdo?
thorny viper
So from what ive gathered Herbalist is just studying, tracking and skinning animals?
marsh dirge
No
heavy glacier
What can you buy?
thorny viper
How do you get the big xp?
marsh dirge
And sampling. I don’t know for certain since I’ve ditched the role, but from what I’ve read after you reach lvl 5 you can do legendary animal hunts for big xp
thorny viper
I was at camp and it said there was a Legendary Animal near by
but my wife made me come to dinner
!!
modest crown
@marsh dirge you ditched that fast? lmao i regret buying the elephant gun, what a gimmick
marsh dirge
Yeah I got to lvl 5 for that camp thing and stopped playing it Gelak
Yeah
I’ll probably eventually go back to working on it but it’s not my kind content
And yeah, ERifle is very underwhelming
Still trying to get someone to damage test with/for me so I can be done with the darn thing
thorny viper
Im not having issues finding animals anymore i suppose
trail nexus
Just bought my Dynamite Arrow Pamphlet 
twilit hemlock
Anyone know why the new like clicking sounds are made when you're in the wild
marsh dirge
Yeah I’ve heard that, thought it was my headset acting funny
thorny viper
"We've fixed all the game issues, but now there is a clicking sound we wont fix for another year"
lol
marsh dirge
I feel like it’s some sort of clue or something. It has directional audio so it could be checked out
twilit hemlock
Pretty sure it's meant to be there not a bug
marsh dirge
But I’ve always been in the middle of something when I’ve heard it- wagon delivery, moonshine, bringing in a bounty, etc
high beacon
Im at the bounty board afk'ing cuz I can hear a literal player out there waiting to kill me and I heard it
thorny viper
Murder them
I haven't played in a long while, but when i got on last night
i just went on a killing spreed
IT MOVES IT DIES
Drowning fools in the river, shooting exploding arrows into saloons. Good shit
high beacon
raw veldt
Is anyone have network problems since like I’ve been having them since like 3 am central which all day yesterday I haven’t been
high beacon
Nope, I been fine
thorny viper
I haven't been DC'd at all
which is jawesome
cause thats the main issue i was having prior to quitting
acoustic notch
Should I buy the new role in order to hunt the legendary animals?
oblique citrus
what are vitalism studies pamphlets? anyone?
junior canyon
I don't have a character no more, when I try to make new one I get an error when I finish creating. it won't load to the next process
When I get back on it takes me to the game where nothing is marked in map, prison outfit, no gun, idk what to do
pulsar arch
@junior canyon and you're on xbox? that sounds really weird
junior canyon
It's happening to alot of people since this new update people can't create a new character
pulsar arch
that sucks, hopefully people are reporting directly to R*
had you deleted your previous character or is this your first time?
junior canyon
I delete my first one because I could not get the butcher's table to show in cripps I looked everywhere
ripe sorrel
how much does the naturalist role cost?
final tinsel
25 gold
final tinsel
Ye
ripe sorrel
okay
then
im gonna pay the 10 bucks then
but
im just not sure what to spend it on
the moonshack or naturalist
final tinsel
Moonshiner doesn't give you gold
ripe sorrel
what about naturalist?
quasi wigeon
How do i hunt for the legendary animals?
Like do I just go to the place in freeroam and look for it?
versed roost
only bounty hunting gives gold I think
ripe sorrel
or does that not give you gold
ripe sorrel
mmk
final tinsel
Not even naturalist gives you gold
versed roost
easiest way
ripe sorrel
thx
final tinsel
ripe sorrel
i need gold for roles lmao
versed roost
gotta start doing the daily challenge streaks and you'll make plenty of gold very fast
bronze falcon
hey
anyone want to do bounty hunter missions
i need to level up bounty hunter role
i am on xbox
deft spruce
What’s the leopard looking animal they had in all the promos?
Is it one of the legendary animals?
fast kettle
Anyone know the point of photographing animals ?
marsh dirge
I’m hoping this daily works with fast travel...
The armadillo and annesburg one?
It does
twilit hemlock
I was disappointed with the update at first but it's nice to have tons of animals and dynamic events
woeful moat
How do you see your rank, for a certain role?
pulsar arch
pause menu > progress > roles
woeful moat
Thanks
pulsar arch
np
pulsar arch
yea, seems more legendaries come out in the "weeks to come"
hallow plume
are you able to skin the legendries in naturalist missions?
oblique citrus
For how long does Harriet get pissed?
hallow plume
not very long. less than 5 mins
cinder oyster
Is there a limit to how many bounties you can do as bounty hunter in a certain amount of time or can you continuously do bounties?
oblique citrus
i get the same missions with Harriet: boar, beaver, elk and fox. nothing else...what the hell?
wet surge
Hello
woeful moat
Hello @wet surge
sudden mica
Anyone want to grind out some gold?
woeful moat
Where can I find a perfect bear pelt
modest crown
There’s usually a bear spawn near Harriett at Wallace Station
marsh dirge
We have a damage value for the Elephant Rifle now!
It deals 112.6 damage from 0-50 steps. For comparison the Rolling Block deals 118.8 damage from 0-100 steps.
Past 50 steps the bullet vanishes.
modest crown
Make sure you hit it in the head and use a bolt-action
lol so it’s a glorified slug shotgun Captain
marsh dirge
Basically, aye
raw veldt
So how do you exactly get the pelts for the legendary wolves, is it like you have to find them in the wild
modest crown
I so regret spending $580 on that. And more on the upgrades. Sheesh
marsh dirge
Slugs deal 61.7 damage under 25 steps
junior rock
Can you lose lures and spinners?
I noticed lures have a stack size but I've never lost one
modest crown
@raw veldt you gotta use the legendary map. There’s one legendary wolf that spawns around Cotorra Springs. But don’t get your hopes up.
R* seem to have fucked the spawns
Changing sessions doesn’t help
hallow plume
@twilit hemlock it doesnt make the mission fail before you can skin it, or you dont lose the skin when you instance out of the mission?
raw veldt
Damn, all I got them for pelts are the ones for missions, so those are just four or five you can really get rn
twilit hemlock
no once you kill it it changes objective to skin it instead
modest crown
Yeah only the beaver, boar, elk and fox are attainable via missions
And they’re a different type compared to their free roam counterparts
Correction: the legendary wolf either spawns at Cotorra Springs or Moonstone Pond. Idk.
Gotta see your own luck
modest crown
The one near Colter is a fox.
twilit hemlock
Check red dead fashion there is a gray wolf and there is a black legendary wolf
modest crown
It’s just infuriating that they don’t appear when you want them to.
raw veldt
I want both of them tbh, they gotta fix the spawns and will they like have drip feed for adding new animals for legendary ones
raw veldt
Is there a buffalo one
faint storm
How do I get the survivalist role if I said no the first time
pulsar arch
head to one of Harriets three campsites around the map
pulsar arch
np : )
raw veldt
There’s actually a moonstone wolf mission but you might have to be a higher level for the role
oblique citrus
i just had it, pretty scary mission 🙂
gleaming tusk
damn I just seen the update to the jeanropke collectors map. They randomized what some locations give you now 
twilit hemlock
@oblique citrus what naturalist level are you
nocturne flame
hey where can I find bears?
oblique citrus
13
sweet orbit
The bear coat is nice but you can't see bandannas or neckwear that you have on which is strange
craggy coral
There's grizzly bears in tall trees
sweet orbit
And there is always a bear at Bear Claw but it usually is poor and the eastern Hanging Dog Ranch area is good
craggy coral
I also find American black bears too
sweet orbit
Black bears are easy
sweet orbit
North of Strawberry
nocturne flame
is it not marked on the map?
paper canyon
Ok. This might be a kind of bad question but bare with me please. I just suddenly explode alot of times and a cage drop on my spot. Is this like the cheats on gta? I'm minding my own business hunting and I suddenly explode. Like wtf
nocturne flame
@paper canyon modders
hey @sweet orbit any idea if the bear coat can be crafted with Black bear pelts aswell as Grizzly bear pelts?
paper canyon
Hope they get banned.
mint coyote
If I don’t have the naturalist role can I still find legendary animals in the wild or do I need that
high beacon
You can
And
You can also sell them to gus
For a decent price
But if someone inspected it or whatever you cant skin it
sharp elk
is anyone having problems with the mic voice chat on PC as well? my mic is not being picked up properly unless i talk really loud or close to the mic
golden sky
foggy dome
whats in the new update?
cinder oyster
Main mission markers aren’t showing up I’m only at 50% why isn’t it there?
foggy dome
pretty sure you need lower/high reputation to unlock the other half
high beacon
It might be cause youre honourable/dishonourable
foggy dome
^
high beacon
At a specific moment in the story mode you need to alter that
cinder oyster
Oh I’m very honorable anything I can do to quickly lower it?
cinder oyster
Hahaha just go on a mass shooting?
high beacon
Yep
foggy dome
pretty much
high beacon
Thats a way
cinder oyster
Lmao that’s the weirdest story requirement
high beacon
You can also do dishonorable free roam missions
These come from people like Black Belle, Joe, Tammy, Trelawny, Shaky etc
Wait
I dont think Trelawny is dishonorable
But you can try
cinder oyster
Ima pull a Micah and shoot you strawberry and see where that gets me 😂
foggy dome
you can also spend gold to lower it but i cant remember how much it is
foggy dome
oh they must of lowered it, it was way higher when i last olayed
*played
i want to get back into red dead
high beacon
Sure thing
Although many friends said that xbox is more toxic after they've transferred to ps4
foggy dome
wdym?
high beacon
Griefers, etc
foggy dome
ah
foggy dome
ok i havent played in about a month or two
cinder oyster
Jesus I must have killed a dozen people and looted them and it barely went down 😂
foggy dome
i had some decent weapons and a couple of the roles so i shouldnt have too much trouble getting back into the swing of things
high beacon
Yeah you should be fine
cinder oyster
My bounty is going up quite fast 😂
Yeah there’s a little more in st Denis but not a lot idk why it’s weird
raw veldt
Honestly, doing the hunting is relaxing for once since like I don’t have to go to my camp after a few animals
carmine trench
Phil
i just stock up on shotgun ammo and theres a hallway next to the gun store that has cover and forces them to funnel in 1 by 1
its the easiest way to get bounty levels, and occasionally find rare liquor bottles on the bodies
last night i hit 40$ just sittin in this hallway and finished the last of my liquor collection
so gotta sell that too
cinder oyster
Yeah I just got the honor I need but yeah I will try that next time
Thx
Do you get the same amount of gold for replaying a story mission?
high beacon
I think you get none for story mission redos idk
Just do daily challenges or free roam missions
carmine trench
daily challenges with how many there are probably the best source of gold. Wasnt paying attention yesterday and finished 4 of them back to back without realizing i was doing it.
also, bounties usually give a decent amount of gold
roughly 0.18 to 0.2
and legendary 5 star bounties usually do 0,25 to 0,3 and are a good source of cash
marsh dirge
as soon as you start a bounty, start a stopwatch timer on your phone
hand the bounty in after 12 minutes, and you'll get 0.36 gold for normal bounties
u can wait for more, but after that, it increases by a little amount of gold nuggets every few mins so not worth it
marsh dirge
yep
cinder oyster
Yeah I’m saving up for the license lmao
marsh dirge
every role except moonshiner and naturalist are 15 gold
moonshiner and naturalist are 25 gold
static hound
wtf
marsh dirge
good luck on the gold bro, im saving up for moonshiner, naturalist and outlaw pass
static hound
And Gold Bars are the exclusive currency you can only buy with irl money?
marsh dirge
lost my streak sadly so i gotta start again with .20 nuggets a challenge 😦
yeah, but I suggest just keepin doin dailies every day to keep a streak going
after a couple of weeks of doing that, you get .50 nuggets a challenge
so 1 gold bar every 2 challenges, which is really good
carmine trench
also guys
ive learned something thats kinda OP
the elephant rifle can leg shot OHK any player thats not full health bar and core if im not mistaken
so if you get into any extended gunfight
its really good for confirms
especially since you can deadeye with it with paint it black if need be
woeful moat
Do bears go for predator bait
runic elbow
Guys, whats the way to socialize in this game, perhaps I would like a hand in my posse for bounty hunting or just activity
twilit hemlock
Shoot people on sight
runic elbow
Tried didnt help
slim pagoda
guys did anyone else get 1K ingame cash out of nowhere?
i was buying some clothing and it just popped up
twilit hemlock
Maybe twitch prime benefits
slim pagoda
i cancelled twitch prime a few months ago
woeful moat
Can you buy pelt
slim pagoda
so it can't be that
slim pagoda
it was rockstar then
twilit hemlock
Think they mentioned giving out free benefits for people who buy the naturalist
woeful moat
I bought it
slim pagoda
i don't have naturalist tho
twilit hemlock
Idk then
Is your social club linked
They somethings just give away free stuff to people with linked social club accounts
slim pagoda
yea i got twitch prime benefits
but i don't have twitch prime
the wilderness camp for free etc
twilit hemlock
Happy accident
slim pagoda
im pretty sure i deactivated my subscription a long time ago
twilit hemlock
Did you receive the last twitch prime benefit you claimed
slim pagoda
of course i did
marsh dirge
why a varmit?
woeful moat
Unpopular opinion, it’s my favourite gun
slim pagoda
this is starting to scare me tho
how the hell did i get the twitch prime benefits without a twitch prime subscription
marsh dirge
got gifted it maybe
woeful moat
Can I buy pelt?
carmine trench
Hazza, the rolling block rifle on a bear with a clean headshot would likely do it
carmine trench
thats just luck
slim pagoda
it looks like it was a mistake from rockstar
i contacted a few pc players and one of them also got the 1k cash and all the twitch prime rewards without a twitch prime subscription
raw veldt
Well, it turns out that there’s more than those four missions for legendary hunts
carmine trench
are we gonna get punished for using the money they fucked up with?
velvet plinth
idk
raw veldt
Well why would they, it was their fault not the players
slim pagoda
did yall also get it?
slim pagoda
damn, rockstar fucked up
carmine trench
I mean, its rockstar. My friend had a hacker spawn a chest with 3 cents in it where a treasure map chest would be, opened it, and get banned the next day
velvet plinth
why is goat exclusive to ps
carmine trench
he tried to appeal but got screwed
velvet plinth
i mean ram
marsh dirge
Sup
viral hemlock
How i use the new camp? I dont see it under camp menu 🤔
velvet plinth
i cant buy it until rank 5 tho
gloomy bramble
Is harriet worth 25 gold?
woeful moat
Nah
gloomy bramble
She kinda cute tho
viral hemlock
She's priceless
gloomy bramble
Yeah I mean I took a liking to her as soon as I stepped into strawberry
viral hemlock
Oh no she's a nut case
Someone downs my horse i get blamed for killing it then she doesnt wanna talk to me
😭
hard torrent
Harriets moody eh
From what I hear it’s worth it if you’ve gotten all the other roles already, but apparently it’s aimed more for end gamers. Haven’t tried it yet myself
gloomy bramble
@viral hemlock I'm kind of a nutcase myself so It's good
viral hemlock
gloomy bramble
Can you not kill a single animal without her knowing?
viral hemlock
Sometimes
safe vine
is anyone else having network issues
gloomy bramble
So no more killing alligators for food?
viral hemlock
No clue
high beacon
Report it to r*
dapper walrus
wary crown
It's Zorro.
lime finch
it's the Lone Ranger bruh
slim pagoda
yea lone ranger is the closest to it
woeful moat
I has it yesterday @safe vine
On Xbox, non stop, rockstar games live chat said to talk to my ISP, but all I did was restart Xbox and wait half an hour( and I came back and it worked
woeful moat
Ik, I have that problem sometimes @marsh dirge
marsh dirge
Try to possee up
slim pagoda
so what happened to the collector role?
marsh dirge
For some reason, it works better
@slim pagoda alot more collections have been added and alot of locations
Went from 1k to 2k
woeful moat
Nice
woeful moat
They added fossils
slim pagoda
the map is broken
sharp elk
so the best way to make gold currently is still bounty hunting right?
woeful moat
Or Dailies
slim pagoda
@woeful moat yea
twilit hemlock
For a role yeah
woeful moat
I’m doing a jewellery run right now and it’s working fine
slim pagoda
i will try tomorrow maybe
sharp elk
so besides bountyhunting and dailies what other choices do i have for making gold?
lean silo
Bro I don’t like this update at all they ruined the only decent way of making money
And instead of giving us a decent role they give some shit they pulled together from already existing stuff in single player
marsh dirge
Hunting ? @lean silo
lean silo
Hunting is decent if you go after alligators and fish a lot
twilit hemlock
I mean the role was broken it wasn't meant to get that much money
lean silo
Other than that I don’t see much money being made in it
lean silo
I mean hey I’m down what’s your gamer tag
marsh dirge
Miami life153
lean silo
Alright I’ll add you
twilit hemlock
You dont rly need over 5k in the game
twilit hemlock
People were asking for the trapper and legendary animals to get added into online for awhile also
lean silo
I was gonna say I made my name when I was a fortnite nerd so don’t judge
marsh dirge
Invite to party G
lean silo
@twilit hemlock yeah but I feel like making a role solely based around legendary animals and trapper is worthless
They could’ve just added it to the already shit hunter role
twilit hemlock
true
lean silo
Really they should’ve just added an outlaw role
Or just the ability to rob a store in general
marsh dirge
@twilit hemlock you down to play with us ?
lean silo
Yeah we’re gonna do the new role
twilit hemlock
Prob when they add a new role since it will he the t2 of bounty hunter role but who knows when that'll be
Uh sorry kinda busy rn cant play
marsh dirge
Yo, so I'm mainly a dual-wielding PVP player. Should I switch out my Gunslinger's Choice III ability card for Winning Streak or no?
ruby laurel
is the new update good?
twilit hemlock
The role is a slow grind at the start but gets better once you reach level 5 and they fixed the majority of the bugs
I think it's ok but could be better
marsh dirge
Aaand I disconnected
Fixed disconnection issues my ass, rockstar
Yo, so I'm mainly a dual-wielding PVP player. Should I switch out my Gunslinger's Choice III ability card for Winning Streak or no?
@marsh dirge What pair of sidearms are you using?
@marsh dirge Schofield revolvers
woeful moat
I just disconnected then aswell @marsh dirge
woeful moat
Oof
marsh dirge
This is a god damn joke
woeful moat
I will probably
marsh dirge
The servers are awful, even more than yesterday
I’d go with Winning Streak. Gunslingers Choice will net you less damage overall and while the accuracy bonus from it is comfy I don’t think it’s necessary
Paint it black for accuracy man
Yeah, I've got Paint it Black III equipped as well
Then you dont need more accuracy
Then definitely WS
I usually use slow and Steady and headshot people myself tbh
But whatever works for you
That's what I was thinking. Just didn't know whether GC or WS would inflict more damage overall
4th time trying to join, wish me luck, bois
It takes me 10 minutes to join a session with a friend normally
With this, I will be lucky to join in 20 mins
And we will disconnect in the server
Idfk if it is my internet or what
So once I switch the cards out, my setup will be Paint it Black, Winning Streak, Eye for an Eye, and Strange Medicine. Thoughts?
Lose SM and EFAE for PvP
Health fortification is what you want especially since PiB offers no survivability on its own. And snake oils are faster and simply better for dead eye restoration
Iron Lung, Fool Me Once, Never Without One, Sharpshooter (if you have a sniper equipped as well)
Some cards that would be easy replacements for those two
NWO has been nerfed but even for that chance to deflect a lethal headshot that hits the top part of your head- worth a slot. Doesn’t matter how much damage reduction you stack or how much tonics you drink if a single headshot kills you y’know?
Well, the reason I have Eye for an Eye is because I mostly go for headshots; body shots are the "backup" of sorts
Sharpshooter is a must if you run a sniper.
Iron Lung is a 10% damage reduction. More immediate useful than Fool Me Once if you kill your attacker quickly since it doesn’t need to ramp up damage reduction.
Fool Me Once caps out at 30% damage reduction after taking 3 instances of damage. Better in the long run over Iron Lung if your attacker can’t be killed quickly and of course, doesn’t simply headshot you.
Y'know, in case I come across those players using cards like Slow and Steady and Never Without One
Lmao disconnected again
Fair enough. I find tonics much more efficient for that without using a card slot, but if you aren’t having an issue with survivability then you don’t need to make the switch.
My ability cards are SnS, Fool me once, Iron Lung and kick in the butt
I usually play in freeroam though
marsh dirge
With 60 percent more health?
I feel like my current setup complements my playstyle pretty well. Deadeye is a big component of my style (which is a given for any player using PiB), and Eye for an Eye has proven to be an efficient way of restoring my Deadeye
I was just asking because you never know, there could be something that works better for me
Since I am SnS, i take on alot of damage which restores my deadeye with kick in the butt
However, when the damage I take is reduced, does it reduce the amount of dead eye I take from kick in the butt?
Cause I have iron lung plus fool me once and sns which reduces alot of damage
Kick in the Butt is based on damage taken
I don't know how drastically it reduces it once you are fully ramped with that build. I just know it does change based on damage
lean silo
Hey who wants to try and hunt the new legendary animals
small jay
Is the hunting wagon broken now ? I can't call out my hunting wagon.
marsh dirge
So I went and got the Improved Bow at max famil. It doesn't have a reduced stamina cost feature like it claims. Both it and the Bow can be held for 50 seconds before all of your stamina is depleted. Nor is it more accurate like it claims.
fringe cloak
Anyone know a good way to get gold
marsh dirge
Daily Challenges. Bounty Hunting. Treasure Maps.
fringe cloak
I've done like 15 treasure maps today
kindred ravine
Reset your awards too
solid hull
hey all - are we allowed to look here for help regarding disconnection error codes? or is that a no-no?
kindred ravine
Would recommend #rdr2-online-support
solid hull
cool! thx
ornate cloak
uh, i am just getting blown to pieces, is this a bug?
out of nowherfe
or a hacker/cheater
fiery canopy
@ornate cloak Sign's of someone being a hacker or modder that blows people up, juding from what yer explainin- ye
Best to change sessions
ornate cloak
how do i do that? just select Free Roam on online options?
raw veldt
Alright if y’all didn’t know, don’t use explosive or fire on the legendary animals in the wild or you can’t skin or sample them, it just happened to me since I didn’t know that
oak jolt
Do we know the rate at which legendary animals spawn? Or is it pure luck?
marsh dirge
I just started playing red dead online
crimson briar
Anyone had issues spawning their hunting wagon?
dusk charm
Is anyone else having the same problem where when you go to Gus the garment sets are grayed out?
crimson briar
nvm got wagon, wasn't active, odd lol
winged ember
my GOD animal samples are a money maker
paper canyon
WTF! Why was the ingame suddenly changes from night to day? Is that a bug?
south bay
Is the game down?
gusty bear
Servers down or something, I can’t even load in
spark light
Damn they hit the online map
Coins and other affected items are going to hard to find
pliant owl
nooo that sucks fr
hollow lynx
What would happen if you killed a legendary animal in a legendary animal mission that Harriet gives you
marsh dirge
Anyone having problems with connecting?
hollow lynx
I haven’t had any connecting issues @marsh dirge
raw marsh
great i just got collector role 2 days ago and now the item spot doesn't guarantee the collectible drops anymore but instead they randomize it so it's more like luck based now to complete all the set instead of guaranteed drops... fml i guess they nerfed the online map
hollow lynx
That’s a rip
raw marsh
well i guess they needed to do this at some point given at how easy it is to get reward from the role... but why it has to be after i just bought the role lol
hollow lynx
I wonder if you can get the same coin vie randomization
hollow lynx
What would happen if you killed a legendary animal in a legendary animal mission that Harriet gives you
paper canyon
How long does fucking harrieta take to cooldown? Bitch fucking mad at me for defending my self from the wolves
fiery canopy
@paper canyon I think it's around 10-15 min before you can talk to her again, I only had it once so I couldnt quite remember oof
safe vine
can anyone log in ?
pliant owl
i wasn't able to earlier, my game kept crashing
grand mural
I’ve not been having issues with crashing or not being about to log in (on PC)
pliant owl
might be an xbox thing, i've seen a lot of xbox players in the chat saying their game is crashing
hollow lynx
What legendary animals can be made into pelts
rare nebula
@hollow lynx all of them....🤦🏻♂️
uneven warren
Best way to lvl new role?
quartz sun
Anyone wanna grind some bounties HMU
mellow patio
if anybody has or is in any roleplay servers for ps4 hit me up i've been looking for ages
woeful moat
What’s the easiest Legendary Bounty?
modern rock
severe sand
Anyone else having trouble logging in on ps4 eastern time
marsh dirge
Yeah keeps saying network error
crude osprey
whats the best money maker early game?
olive nimbus
Collector is easy money and XP
woeful moat
Does a buck count as a deer carcass?
olive nimbus
Nope a buck is a buck
lusty berry
Does anyone know where to find third and fourth(starting from end) animal in desert habitat animal field guide
marsh dirge
no
mellow patio
god above i just started playing online yesterday and literally everyone is being a dickhead
mellow patio
i was about to finish 3rd on a race and some fuck shot me at the END OF THE RACE
then i finished 8th
marsh dirge
damn
marsh dirge
Hacker
velvet trench
i got 6k naturalist xp, 5x legendary animal pheromones and a free wilderness camp
i mean, i'll take it
mellow patio
does anyone here play on ps4
marsh dirge
me
mellow patio
do you know any good servers with normal fucking people
marsh dirge
WHat server do you play on right now
mellow patio
some random one
marsh dirge
I dont know any
mellow patio
alright thanks
marsh dirge
np
slim pagoda
i think im going to attempt to send a ticket to rockstar
to change the whistle of my character somehow
final tinsel
You can find a link for that at #rdr2-online-support
slim pagoda
ye i know
final tinsel
Check the pinned messages there
deft torrent
consensus on naturalist role? Worth the starting 25 gold?
pulsar arch
it really depends on where you are at in the game
naturalist should be the last frontier pursuit you pick up and expect to have to put in a lot of rdo$ (on top of the 25 gold) to get much out of it
is very much an end-game, completionist / fashion role
graceful plank
If you’ve been playing for months or over a year it is yeah
twilit hemlock
The start is a slow grind and you might have to watch some vids to understand it
graceful plank
Most people I know have over 100 gold and thousands of dollars
But don’t start with it for sure
pulsar arch
and stock up on Horse reviver + Ginseng
animal revival tonics are far too expensive to buy, crafting em saves you $1.5 on each bottle
but crafting sedative ammo yourself turns out to be more expensive than buying from Haz, go figure
pulsar arch
best to wait out the timer til the last 30 seconds
you can find a chart of payouts across all kinds of standard bounties, pinned in #bounty-hunter
raw marsh
should i get moonshiner or naturalist, naturalist looks very boring to me as i've already had enough hunting with trader but this week's benefit is for that particular role, are the benefits good enough that i should get naturalist first to get those discounts and other rewards
pulsar arch
what's your balance of rdo$ like?
jaunty belfry
naturalist I feel is a little more fun with hunting, but moonshiner makes more money
pulsar arch
naturalist is very end-game oriented, more for fashion rather than consistent income
my recommended order is: Collector / Bounty Hunter > Trader > Moonshiner > Naturalist
if MS and Naturalist are your last two, not too important relative to the others
marsh dirge
Dudes
How to stamp animals
@pulsar arch I disagree now on the collector being second
jaunty belfry
animals get stamped when you sell their samples are sold
marsh dirge
Because trader is much much better
Oooh
Damn
I have 11/14 desert animals and I cant find the last 3
Smh
Does selling an entire set pay more?
pulsar arch
Trader only beats Collector for rdo$ income IF you have enough friends to regularly run wagon-trains
Collector is hands down better for solo players, there's never been an argument about that ;)
but yea, Trader + an active delivery channel on Discord is OP af
brazen swan
I forgot, how do you get volatile dynamite and fire bottles?
oblique citrus
anyone knows what are vitalism studies pamphlets?
pulsar arch
@brazen swan Fence sells ammunition pamhplets
@oblique citrus those are the pamphlets that teach you to use tonics like the Hardy tonic, or the few which affect your weight
brazen swan
Alrighty, thank you, my supply from one of the outlaws passes or something just ran out
pulsar arch
could be worth waiting for an inevitable sale on pamphlets btw
dynamite arrow is $1000 from memory
brazen swan
Will do
oblique citrus
could be a long wait, esp on the new ones
oblique citrus
so, if i decide to pay for the pamphlets in gold, then i get the discount, i guess that's the key? cause i have a coupon that says "5 gold bars off vitalism studies pamphlets"
pulsar arch
that would be ideal, yea
oblique citrus
well, another worthless coupon then
pulsar arch
they almost all are
especially for end-game players
what do i need stable or camp dog vouchers for lol
oblique citrus
i don't have a dog at all. want a husky but r* wouldn't give it to me. wasn't playing back in outlaw pass No 2 days, so I'm scr*wed now
velvet acorn
can anyone help me doing quests, i can't find ppl :/
raw marsh
do you know the numbers for ability cards @marsh dirge like how much damage reduction is max level SnS, Iron Lung, Sharpshooter and fool me once?
also do they stack on top of each other
pliant owl
aw i'm sorry for that uni
mint wraith
So, I just browsed the r/RedDeadOnline subreddit...
Glad I'm not the only one who hates Harriet.
pliant owl
she's like the old timey vegan the bad ones, nothing against the vegans that don't force their thing on others
pliant owl
yeah
i could understand to fight for the rarer animals, but legit she gets mad at you for killing common animals
mint wraith
I dont think she understands that the pelts literally are part of our living. Its what makes us money.
Speaking of that, do people still hate Cripps or has that just kinda died down?
pliant owl
wait why were people hating on Cripps for
mint wraith
I have no idea either. He's nice tbh. Actually keeps me company on my friendless, lonely Rockstar Social Club account... apparently hes a great shot, too.
mint wraith
I suppose he does. I just wish Rockstar would give him more depth and personality in a future update, or something. With, like, missions.
pliant owl
yeah
mint wraith
You only ever meet cripps outside of your camp in the first mission where you get broken out of that prison wagon and in the mission where you can buy the butchers table.
pliant owl
mhm
mint wraith
After that, he just repeats his old voice lines over, and over, and over again... fuck.
pliant owl
I hope they add a thing where you can hunt with your dog
and yeah
also with this new role
it doesn't fall right in with the current story line
like if you have a rank 20 trader
pretty sure she would know you..
mint wraith
Yyyeeeaaaah, this naturalist role is kinda just filler if you ask me. I hope they got something good for december.
pliant owl
yeah
i would love to have a rustler role
stealing cattle and horses would be fun
and would fall into the story a bit
cinder oyster
So rn there’s like 3 minutes left to a timer for a side quest do I just wait til there’s like 10 seconds left and finish the actual objective?
To maximize gold
pliant owl
when you play the mission where you get your first shop, clay and clive they talk about setting up their shop
uhh i would wait in till 30 seconds
cinder oyster
Oh ok perfect
pliant owl
in the story mode they're pretty much animal rustlers
marsh dirge
Naturalists - Rank 20
Moonshiner - Rank 20
Trader - Rank 20
Collector - Rank 20
Bounty Hunter - Rank 2 😭😭😭
Does anybody know the FASTEST way to rank up that role quickly? So i can have everything maxed
twilit hemlock
People dislike cripps because of the bug where he would pack up your camp randomly and you were unable to place it down again
pliant owl
ohh makes sense
don't blame cripps for the stupid bugs though, my man can't help it :((
mint wraith
Oh... now I understand why they disliked him. Thankfully that seems to have been fixed. So... anyway...
Naturalist is kinda... ssssst... how do I say... boring...
mint wraith
I heard about the trinkets, which boost your stats. But...
Arent they, like, basically just discount ability cards?
pliant owl
i hope not
mint wraith
I havent.
marsh dirge
Yh
pliant owl
yeah i haven't either
marsh dirge
Take it from someone whos arready distinguished, its fun
Its a bit bad that u have to get to rank 5
But
Rockstar is rockstar
pliant owl
yeah lol
twilit hemlock
I like how if you redo the same legendary animal mission its different
ocean cargo
buoyant panther
How do I upgrade my gun belt to hold more guns?
marsh dirge
this game is such fucking bullshit! I shoot someone 5 times with a rifle and they don't die but I die from a single shot every time!
twilit hemlock
you need to buy an off hand holster
buoyant panther
OK thx
flat quest
Indeed
pulsar arch
etc
marsh dirge
No it's pure bullshit
flat quest
You can outgun somebody and they can still win if they hide quickly and heal.
pulsar arch
an opinion
marsh dirge
I have the best rifle and ability cards
flat quest
I Play on defensive and get good at that. Wait for them to shoot first. Boom. Sad times all around.
flat quest
Whats your rifle
buoyant panther
Dang gotta be rank 25 to buy one
flat quest
I didnt keep up with balancing updates. Im unsure how the guns work now. Like i said i just outvun everybody in free aim.
Mfs suck at free aim so hard
marsh dirge
I think I'm in free aim
flat quest
Oh no bud
marsh dirge
still they seem to hit all the shots headshot or I just die instantly anyways
flat quest
Thats why
You need to play on defensive and not shoot first
Oh wait
Are you on pc
marsh dirge
yes
flat quest
They have free aim lobbies
If you change your settings in story mode first. So everybody has to free aim (i think)
flat quest
Could be ability cards. Slippery bastard
Im unsure which ones are the best on pc
Free aim changes quite a bit.
flat quest
Its not well done. Youre probably gwtting PIBd
marsh dirge
what's that
flat quest
That deadeye mode where you can put x's on stuff you aim at
marsh dirge
oh
flat quest
Just have to swipe the cursor across somebodies head and have deadeye
marsh dirge
yeah that's also bs
marsh dirge
and whenever I try to use it it never puts a cross on them
I have to be like still on them
buoyant panther
Is there a holster available at a lower level maybe from the General Store?
If not that's only seven more levels that's not too bad
marsh dirge
how does twitch prime work?
I joined a random posse before and got rewards for twitch prime
slim pagoda
rockstar made a mistake and gifted the twitch prime rewards to pretty much everyone on the PC
slim pagoda
good for us
slim pagoda
i don't think they were too happy about that hehee
marsh dirge
well it's their fault anyways lol
slim pagoda
i dont think console players got it
slim pagoda
a new patch might be coming in the next few weeks
to fix more issues
i contacted rockstar about a bug, and they said they were working on a patch so
flat quest
A fix for more to do?!
marsh dirge
I hope they start updating the game with new stuff more often now
flat quest
Jkjk
slim pagoda
nah, they won't update the game with new content more often
marsh dirge
bruh
flat quest
I thought i saw they were doing dripfeed now?
slim pagoda
the updates were always in july and december
modest crown
random explosions from people are back, this was fast.
tossed up in the air and was burnt to death
marsh dirge
why tho
modest crown
marsh dirge
rip
flat quest
Can u also push for free aim servers on console pls thx
slim pagoda
the last time that happened to me was 4 months ago
flat quest
They like u guys
twilit hemlock
i mean there are leaks of items in another outlaw pass for halloween so i guess we will get another update there
slim pagoda
there are not many cheaters in this game
modest crown
it just happened to me 5 mins ago lmao
slim pagoda
and i hope private sessions never come tho
modest crown
you can turn off aim assist on consoles no?
marsh dirge
it would be cool if they made a scary update on halloween
modest crown
flat quest
Yes you can turn it off
marsh dirge
this game can be scary with its atmosphere
flat quest
Everybody else has it though
slim pagoda
yea, they will make some sort of halloween event
maybe even a small update with some clothing and masks
marsh dirge
I hope
modest crown
idk Doug, literally got burnt to death 5 mins ago
rag-dolled in the air
like "okay..."
flat quest
To explain more. I have to let people shoot me first in defensive mode to force them to free aim. Ick
slim pagoda
i hate the defensive mode system tho
flat quest
Its the only way free aim works on console