#rdo-chat

1 messages Ā· Page 495 of 1

glad frigate
#

Is it hard to find animals to hunt now?

atomic hare
#

yes on ps4

glad frigate
#

😭

atomic hare
#

@fallen light maybe try legendary bounties

glad frigate
#

I tried loading into new session to fix it and it’s infinite loading screen

atomic hare
#

can't load into new sessions any more

#

always close the game and restart

#

otherwise you get that wonderful spinning wheel until the end of time

glad frigate
#

Why isn’t this fixed lmao

indigo tangle
#

Cause SANDALS

surreal coral
#

I only got this game recently and I'm already asking that a lot

#

Dont even get me started on the money glitch, then there's the trader role crashes, and my camp that hates to be pitched. Oh and then there's the random disconnecting too

#

The one problem I've seen a lot of people have that i personally haven't is a lack of animal spawns

wild imp
#

well i guess it's somehow related with how much player are in your session

#

i never had that animal spawn issue too

#

and i have a bad nat status, i'm always in lobbys under 20 people

bleak creek
#

The disconnection thing has gotten alot aggressive after thr moonshine update

marsh dirge
#

gonna see if I can use my 'free stuff from the Catalogue' coupon on a Missouri Fox Trotter

#

if it works, that's $950 I can put toward maxing abilities

wild imp
#

do you mean the two from the outlaw pass?

upper jay
#

there’s a horse discount coupon

wild imp
#

i can't remember there was one

upper jay
#

well i can

indigo tangle
#

@wild imp are you on pc?

upper jay
#

there was one

wild imp
#

yea i'm on pc

upper jay
#

that’s irrelevant

indigo tangle
#

The animal spawns issue is mostly on consoles afaik

wild imp
#

must have used it already i guess

upper jay
#

outlaw pass 2 is on pc- oh entirely different conversation

indigo tangle
#

Yeah i was referring to the other convo haha

#

Is the kladruber free after all?

marsh dirge
#

is there any reason why

#

the moonshiner's shack is just 18 gold now?

#

couldn't find anything regarding this in the newswire

#

just wanna know if this is temporary

#

in which case i better get some gold quick lol

#

is outlaw pass 2 not out for console? @upper jay

wild imp
#

@marsh dirge dunno someone said the outlaw pass is also reduced, but i guess it's temporary

indigo tangle
#

Yeah discounts

upper jay
#

reading comprehension @marsh dirge

devout cliff
#

You hoes not reading the newswire susredeyes

#

`Those yet to cut their teeth in the moonshining business can take 25% off the cost of all Moonshiner Shack Properties and Property Relocations; meanwhile, Traders can take 40% off Novice and Promising Trader Role Items, such as the Stew Pot and Medium Delivery Wagon.

Players who verified their Social Club email address and set up two-step verification on their accounts will receive discounts on the Outlaw Pass, Role Items for the Bounty Hunter, Trader and Collector Roles, and a free Kladruber Horse of their choice.`

upper jay
#

you should probably mention whoever was a part of that conversation lilith

#

i think that was a while ago? i’d have to scroll up

marsh dirge
#

I read it

#

thanks

devout cliff
#

Not even 10 minutes ago

upper jay
#

lmao that reaction, don’t hate me because you can’t read properly @marsh dirge

#

and yea they’re here anyways so it don’t matter ig

marsh dirge
#

I asked a question that I don't know the answer to*

#

no need to be toxic

upper jay
#

wha..- says the one who responded with a reaction that said ā€œok (offensive word for differently abled)ā€

#

all i basically said was to re-read it because i didn’t say outlaw pass 2 wasn’t out for console

marsh dirge
#

ok

#

I honestly didn't know if R* was still doing the staggered releases or if all 3 platforms caught up with Moonshiners

#

haha

upper jay
#

oh, well i’d assume in any case PS4 would take priority

#

unless we’re talking about the m1899 pistol

lean plover
#

Any xbox players able to help me out with leveling up, making money and gold?

upper jay
#

from there you can get the roles for xbox trader,moonshiner,bounty hunter, or collector, as well as a lfg chat

lean plover
#

@upper jay thanks

marsh dirge
#

@upper jay Xbox trader?

#

oh nvm

indigo tangle
#

@marsh dirge u tha mvp

stone hull
#

Infinite loadings are killing me -_-

upper dagger
#

Yeah they’re pretty annoying

#

SSD helps a lot if you are on PC

stone hull
#

I have a pretty good PC. i7 9700k, 2080 and everything on SSD of course (I don't even have old school disk)

#

I don't think the issue comes from my side

versed roost
#

its a server issue for sure

stone hull
#

it's always the same problem, it's when I launch a moonshinber delivery

versed roost
#

not on our end i'm afraid

#

I haven't experienced many infinite loadings recently tho (ps4)

dense osprey
#

Can someone give me a good dead eye pvp build?

cerulean wharf
#

Depends on which Dead Eye card you use the most. thonkhaw

dense osprey
#

pib

cerulean wharf
#

Offensive PIB:

  • Winning Streak/Sharpshooter
  • Peak Condition
  • Never Without One

General Purpose PIB:

  • Winning Streak
  • Strange Medicine
  • Never Without One

Defensive PIB:

  • Fool Me Once
  • Iron Lung/Unblinking Eye
  • Never Without One
marsh dirge
#

Which is better for gold: bounty hunter or free roam missions?

cerulean wharf
#

Bounty Hunter

marsh dirge
#

Do you have a list of all the builds or something Maze? Lmao

#

Ah okay thank you

cerulean wharf
#

Yes and NP šŸ‘Œ

marsh dirge
#

Oh damn, really?

cerulean wharf
#

I said "yes"! thonkhaw lulhaw

dense osprey
#

thanks

cerulean wharf
#

NP šŸ‘Œ

marsh dirge
#

How many builds are there on the list? Three for each dead eye ability?

cerulean wharf
#

I have the following per Dead Eye ability:

  • For PvP: 3 for each
  • For PvE: 4 for each
  • For hunting & fishing: 2 for each
  • For maximum trolling: 1 for each
marsh dirge
#

Damn

#

Probably a lot to ask, but could I get this list?

cerulean wharf
#

You

#

WHAT???

marsh dirge
#

I value your advice

cerulean wharf
#

OK. Prepare for a barrage of private DMs in the near future. I'm not posting it all here.

devout cliff
#

Your values are pretty low lulhaw

cerulean wharf
#

For you, yeah, but not for @ Perunastra

narrow glacier
#

so aggressive. who hurt you Lil?

cerulean wharf
#

Me and my facts

devout cliff
#

Just tired of bad advice and opinions being put as "facts" here

narrow glacier
#

then what's your advice? thonkhaw

indigo tangle
#

Can i get a lot of pelts on horse. Then drop em on the floor and wait for my wagon? Or they disappear? Cause lately everything disappears

cerulean wharf
#

More like giving accurate information to people who need help, but kek.

marsh dirge
#

šŸ‘€

#

If this is war I’m taking the side of the level 300+

#

Fear me and my 122 levels of madness

cerulean wharf
#

I'm Rank 541, not 300

narrow glacier
#

Opinions are subjective at best, so the same goes for advice and "facts" about a random simulated environment

marsh dirge
#

;-;

#

how to fix horse stuck bug?

#

541?!

devout cliff
#

No life yo

marsh dirge
#

Fuck me, what’s your hours played?

narrow glacier
#

@marsh dirge make your horse flee then call it back

marsh dirge
#

didn't work

narrow glacier
#

reload your freeroam session?

marsh dirge
#

could you donate some levels to me lol

devout cliff
#

Just no life the game

#

ez

#

Cancel all social, family, relationships, work and bam

marsh dirge
#

Collector all the way

narrow glacier
#

salt? what salt? i don't see any salt anywhere...

marsh dirge
#

I wish I could do that lmao

devout cliff
marsh dirge
#

Na

devout cliff
#

Just like how Arabians are bad and waste of money and/or gold lulhaw

cerulean wharf
#

I can understand opinions and advice as subjective, but facts are actually objective.

devout cliff
#

People get real salty on that fact

cerulean wharf
#

Like you

narrow glacier
#

thats why facts were in quotes

marsh dirge
#

my starter horse annoys the shit out of me

devout cliff
#

Yes, because I'm the one that likes the ponies so much lmao

#

ight

marsh dirge
#

In defence of the ponies

devout cliff
#

Role horses >

#

Well actually

#

Turko and Fox Trotter > Role horses

marsh dirge
#

My morgan served me well in pvp

narrow glacier
#

MFT = Criollo

#

change my mind

marsh dirge
#

I had it set to preferred horse for some reason and the slow speed actually helped, who would have thought?

devout cliff
#

Tbf, I'd take a Morgan over an arabian any day

#

Donkey's though

#

Top tier

knotty arrow
#

I like my arabian : /

devout cliff
#

🤮

indigo tangle
marsh dirge
#

I wanna get a shire horse at some point

#

They’re slow af but nice and chonk

devout cliff
#

I have two Arabians and they're the last resort of just running away and hoping a grasshopping doesn't come by and makes it buck me

indigo tangle
#

@marsh dirge hungarians are top tier

marsh dirge
#

I have a fox trotter already

#

I’d buy every horse in the game if there were enough stable slots

knotty arrow
#

The arabian seems to hit a lot less trees and rocks than my thoroughbred and american standard. It seems like it doesn't try to correct my steering as much as others.

indigo tangle
#

Hungarian wont disappoint

#

Half bred half incredible

marsh dirge
#

What are the black and white klads like? Wondering if it’s worth claiming that horse or not

devout cliff
#

Quit your half breeding lulhaw

#

It'd be worth as a starter

knotty arrow
#

Black Kladruber is a nice looking horse but its stats make me sad

marsh dirge
#

Ah shame

cerulean wharf
#

I've already said this plenty of times: Black Arabians are currently the best horses in RDO overall due to their high stats.

That's it. I'm not gonna get involved any further this time.

indigo tangle
#

As soon as rancher role comes im making the hungarian fullbred

marsh dirge
#

Is there a horse with maxed out stats?

#

In terms of speed and acceleration

devout cliff
#

sigh more lies being spread as facts

#

Yeah

#

Rank 20 Klad

#

Wait

#

wrong thing lmao

#

no there isn't

marsh dirge
#

So far I haven’t had a bad enough handling stat on a horse for me to care about it

devout cliff
#

but speed and accel don't really matter when most horses are in the same range nowadays

#

Total salt

marsh dirge
#

True enough I suppose

knotty arrow
#

Different opinions on what your favorite horse is aside, I think the main thing is that it's not snowing anymore. Hallelujah

marsh dirge
#

I went for fox trotter for the stamina stat

#

Apparently though there’s a horse with max stamina and max health of a similar speed

indigo tangle
#

At the end of the day the hungarian is objectively better but yeah no snow

devout cliff
#

It's more the least skittishness and and best stamina would be what you want for online

#

Rank 20 Klad has max stamina and max health

marsh dirge
#

I second that, snow was pretty but irritating

knotty arrow
#

So, max klad, halfbred and black arabian are all top tier is what i'm hearing

marsh dirge
#

Seems so

devout cliff
#

Max Klad and halfbred

#

yes

indigo tangle
#

Halfbred yes

marsh dirge
#

I can’t imagine there’s much of an improvement on my fox trotter though so for now I don’t mind sticking with what I have

knotty arrow
#

Have any of ya'll gotten out of the glitched bounty hunter license xp issue?

marsh dirge
#

Once I have the cash to splash I’ll go for it

knotty arrow
#

I got a free license from that frontier pursuits promotion but I can't progress in the role because it's bugged. Any of ya'll run into that or know a friend who had it?

devout cliff
#

Fox Trotter is pretty brave and has good stamina so that's a pretty good horse to stick with

marsh dirge
#

Maze how much money do you have now?

#

And more importantly, are you gonna be a millionaire by the end of this year?

#

this horse bug is worse now than it's ever been for me

devout cliff
#

Yeah it's pretty bad. Go into a stable, even if you have to steal another horse and walk in then exit

#

That's how I've fixed that issue for me

marsh dirge
#

What’s the bug?

#

Is there any particular state that is best for bounty hunting?

devout cliff
#

Horse not moving, it's been around since frontier came out but got even worse with moonshiners
West Elizabeth maybe?

indigo tangle
#

In the west. Less trees

gleaming umbra
#

usually smacking the horse helps, for me at least.

marsh dirge
#

So New Austin/West Elizabeth?

#

I found West Elizabeth often took me north a lot

#

New Austin is alright though

devout cliff
#

New Austin is very hilly and mountainy but very open

proper granite
#

hey guys. with the wheeler and rawson Club award you got cupons for free and one with a questionmark on it. it Says you get one random item. But when i wanna redeem it, it just opens the catalogue and nothing happens. what can i do?

devout cliff
#

It'll be an unlock later in a few months

proper granite
#

oh

devout cliff
#

It was like that in the first outlaw pass

proper granite
#

nice ^^

marsh dirge
#

What did we get from the previous mystery tokens?

devout cliff
#

Got a free coat and vest with all it's colours

marsh dirge
#

I think I remember redeeming them for something but can’t remember what

proper granite
#

do you know a date?

marsh dirge
#

Ah what was it called?

devout cliff
#

I'm looking

marsh dirge
#

Nah but it’ll definitely be after March 31st

devout cliff
#

Clairborn Coat

proper granite
#

awesome

#

<333

marsh dirge
#

Most likely sometime in June or July

devout cliff
#

Churchwell Vest

marsh dirge
#

I’ll take a look at that, not sure if I ever tried them on lmao

#

Thanks Lilith

cerulean wharf
#

@marsh dirge To answer your question: I currently have about $350K and, theoretically speaking, I could be a millionaire within 161 days if I collect everything every day (for the next 161 days).

narrow glacier
#

here comes lillith to step on your cubes in high heels...

marsh dirge
#

Hahaha

cerulean wharf
#

More like my high horse, but kek

devout cliff
#

Who's lillith though

marsh dirge
#

Is it still a good idea to wait for the last 30 seconds for bounties? Farming gold

devout cliff
#

Nah, 9 minute timer is max payout

marsh dirge
#

Jonk’s bitch I hear

#

For gold?

#

OoOoOoOoooo

#

Damn son

devout cliff
#

Gross, gingers

marsh dirge
#

I take that personally

#

Us soulless need to stick together

devout cliff
#

meanwhile, I got the Chucky pfp

marsh dirge
#

@sage quiver you pull bitches?

sage quiver
#

Whut?

devout cliff
#

He only pulls himself

sage quiver
#

Unnecessary

marsh dirge
#

Oh jonk is a dude?

sage quiver
#

Tf

marsh dirge
#

Well that backfired

devout cliff
#

LOL

#

I like how he didn't deny pulling at himself

marsh dirge
#

Imma be honest I picked a random staff member and hoped for the best

devout cliff
#

I mean, the true couple is Jonk and Ash so

marsh dirge
#

OTP

sage quiver
#

I dislike how I am being used to insult eachother

humble helm
#

are all missions the same as bounties the longer you wait the more rewards you get?

marsh dirge
#

More like she’s jealous

#

Uhhh

#

Stranger missions are

#

Story missions yeah you’ll get better rewards too, but not really worth it to me tbh

#

I just got .24 gold from turning in a medium double target bounty

#

$32 though

#

Yeah bh pays pretty good gold

devout cliff
#

golf

sage quiver
marsh dirge
#

Shh

#

You didn’t even see it

#

Ah yes, I do this for the plastic balls of death

devout cliff
#

golf

marsh dirge
#

Isn’t there supposed to be a discount on the pass atm?

devout cliff
#

If you have your social club linked

#

yeah

marsh dirge
#

I’m a broke bitch with only 3 gold so any savings at all are welcome

#

Guessing it’ll take a few days to go through

devout cliff
#

Dailiesssss

marsh dirge
#

Pffft

#

I don’t even do my dailies

devout cliff
#

Mmmmhm

sage quiver
#

I'm on day 34

marsh dirge
#

I’ve done most of my dailies today

#

Building my streak back up

#

Existence is pain

indigo tangle
#

Where the heck are my sandals?

marsh dirge
#

On your feet

indigo tangle
#

I feel scammed

#

No sandals and no free kladruber

#

Who needs that big nose mofo anyway, got an hungarian

marsh dirge
#

Check your benefits page thingy

indigo tangle
#

Nothing there

marsh dirge
#

Not sure about the sandals but I received the klad cupon

#

Oh damn

indigo tangle
#

Maybe it takes a while?

marsh dirge
#

R* support is your best bet then

#

Maybe

#

You’re on PC and I’m on Xbox so there might be a delay

indigo tangle
#

NVM found the sandals

marsh dirge
#

The specialist discount page hasn’t updated for me yet

#

Guessing that’s a bug

indigo tangle
#

Nah i think they take a lil bit

#

Last time they gave role xp coupons and took like a day

short cedar
#

What's with all the arabian hate? šŸ™‚

atomic hare
#

oh cool, i got a resupply mission to hunt a deer

#

nice waste of 15 minutes

indigo tangle
#

You literally dont see any animals?

#

Empty world?

atomic hare
#

welcome to full lobbies on ps4

#

I did just shoot a songbird though

indigo tangle
barren lindenBOT
#

You can now ping respective channels when Looking for players.
If you're looking for a group please checkout #role-request and select which system you play on. From there you can check out the how to channels to see how you can find players easier.

steady matrix
#

Love the drug rugs in the patch

upper jay
#

why would you put sharpshooter in a PiB builds lmfao

cerulean wharf
#

Because...sniper rifles.

#

And just in case you get caught off guard, you use PIB to fight off anyone who gets close to your sniping position.

upper jay
#

you can mark targets while scoped in?

cerulean wharf
#

No.

upper jay
#

so like.. what’s the point

cerulean wharf
#

PIB is for defense, not with a scoped weapon.

upper jay
#

if they’re close enough for you to not use a sniper, then you’re just like.. bad if you need PiB

#

i’d understand if it was pre-slippery bastard buff but now PiB isn’t useful that much for taking out people using SB

#

unless you carry a bow with you

cerulean wharf
#

That's more of a personal problem.
However, as I said, if someone gets too close, you use PIB as a last ditch effort to ward off attackers from your sniping spot.

upper jay
#

yea nah, i still wouldn’t use sharpshooter if i were running PiB

heady river
#

If they get that close maybe you're not as good a sniper as you think šŸ¤”

upper jay
#

^^^^^

#

perfect response

cerulean wharf
#

Or you're being rushed by waves of incoming enemies.

upper jay
#

anyways i wouldn’t use winning streak either because if you’re using PiB why would you not aim for the head?

heady river
#

It's really not hard to 1vX with a sniper though.

cerulean wharf
#

Simple: PIB works with non-scoped weapons

upper jay
#

that doesn’t answer my question

#

winning streak only adds damage after the first shot, but with PiB i’d assume you’d be trying to mark the head

cerulean wharf
#

Bodyshots are easier to hit than headshots, but they don't guarantee 1 hit kills

upper jay
#

and even if they’re using never without one i’d assume you’d be a decent player and aim for the head again

#

then you’re dead

#

if you really want to take like 2-3 shots even more if you’re using semi autos or mausers, you’re just dead

#

the other person will kill you faster

heady river
#

How's about an unpopular opinion

#

Focus Fire and Winning Streak is a sexual combo.

upper jay
#

i was about to say that

cerulean wharf
#

That would be the case most of the time, unless the sniper is using explosive ammo.

upper jay
#

winning streak seems like a card for focus fire

#

if you want to run dual semis or mausers and just hip fire

heady river
#

Every card is a card for Focus Fire

#

Unless you're melee.

upper jay
#

quickly turn on deadeye for focus fire and spam hip fire with winning streak

#

absolutely melts

lunar ginkgo
#

Guys.

upper jay
#

add that with gunslinger’s and make peak condition

lunar ginkgo
#

Guys please.

#

I need help.

heady river
#

I like it because it makes my bullets do the big shooty.

lunar ginkgo
#

My friend just got Lumbago idk what to do.

#

He doesn't want to do any work.

#

It sucks.

upper jay
#

i put in a vote kick

#

can we request that

lunar ginkgo
#

Oh.

upper jay
#

i’m joking

lunar ginkgo
#

Sorry was that for me?

upper jay
#

yes

lunar ginkgo
#

Oh thank god.

#

...

#

So is anyone going to help me with my Lumbago situation?

upper jay
#

no

lunar ginkgo
#

It's a slow and painful death.

heady river
#

The Lumbago meme is old and played out.

#

Tell him to see a chiropractor though.

lunar ginkgo
#

You know what else is old and played out?

#

...

upper jay
#

head over to #550659240633827329 , if you’re in this channel i’m assuming you want friends to play online with

lunar ginkgo
#

Red Dead Redemption 2.

upper jay
#

and you can get a role for your platform and roles

#

i mean you joined like 2 minutes ago

#

a rdr2 server

#

so i think it’s still being played.. in

heady river
#

Eh. It is as it does.

#

Anyway

#

Focus Fire

#

It's my favorite dead eye card.

upper jay
#

i use focus fire in my sniper build

lunar ginkgo
#

Focus Fire is amazing.

heady river
#

Same here.

upper jay
#

really helps one shot a lot of players

#

even with a carcano

heady river
#

FF, Sharp, Peak, Landon's

upper jay
#

same

lunar ginkgo
#

Do you guys use auto aim?

upper jay
#

except i have landon’s first

#

i think..

lunar ginkgo
#

Not with the Carcano.

upper jay
#

i have peak in my third slot

heady river
#

Order doesn't really matter lmao.

upper jay
#

shhh

#

i’m am r/notlikeothergirls

#

not just because the fact that i’m not a girl but just because

heady river
#

I'm a skeleton.

upper jay
lunar ginkgo
#

Uncle fits in that.

upper jay
#

damn

#

what about 6

lunar ginkgo
#

Can you not!?

#

MY EYES!

upper jay
#

toot toot

heady river
#

Rapid skeledance

lunar ginkgo
#

Favorite character in RDR2?

upper jay
#

i don’t have a skeleton doot emote so rip

#

definitely micah

lunar ginkgo
#

Vote to kick.

upper jay
#

micah is the best character

lunar ginkgo
#

--Vote to kick--

short cedar
#

I -hate- Micah.

heady river
upper jay
#

in fact, he’s such an amazing character, so well thought out, so well crafted, every part of his character is so amazing

#

that he’s a character that managed to make everyone hate him

lunar ginkgo
#

You guys ever seen that kek or cringe video of RDR2?

heady river
#

About five times now.

lunar ginkgo
#

It's beautiful.

#

''Well Dutch, what do ya think? Pretty kek right?''

#

COUGH COUGH IT'S MAKING ME CRINGE DUTCH DYING

upper jay
#

i just saw it

#

and

#

no

lunar ginkgo
#

Kek or cringe?

#

Would you rate it a kek?

upper jay
#

oh wow, tac finally got a role, i’m proud

#

go away

lunar ginkgo
#

I'm sorry.

upper jay
#

i can’t tell if you’re joking or actually serious

lunar ginkgo
#

Joking.

upper jay
#

i’d provide you a handy book on how to internet but i have no such book in hand

heady river
#

Honestly, does it make a difference either way?

#

Every ironic statement has a bit of seriousness behind it nowadays.

upper jay
#

is that a serious statement

heady river
#

No, it's an ironic one.

upper jay
#

are you sure about that

heady river
#

Certainly.

lunar ginkgo
upper jay
#

i think you mean

#

Kertainly

heady river
#

Suretainly.

lunar ginkgo
#

Kek.

upper jay
#

he’s speaking the language of the gods

lunar ginkgo
#

No.

#

Go away.

upper jay
#

do you are have stupid

heady river
#

Yes.

lunar ginkgo
#

Now he's speaking the language of the gods.

upper jay
#

i don’t like it when people end their sentences in period over text

#

it’s unsettling

lunar ginkgo
#

Okay.

heady river
#

Alright!

lunar ginkgo
#

.

#

Why is it unsettling**?**

upper jay
#

no i mean ! is fine and stuff because when people use ! it has an emotion i’m aware of which is either anger or like excitement

#

? is like asking a question obviously

#

. however, . can mean a lot of things

lunar ginkgo
#

Kind of like when you told me to go away.

#

With.

#

A.

#

.

upper jay
#

yea sure

lunar ginkgo
#

But since I'd rather want you on the friendly side, I'll just end my sentences with the periods.

#

Oh sorry

upper jay
#

we can’t be friends

#

you play on xgay doge

lunar ginkgo
#

Okay

upper jay
#

i mean i have one to but i don’t play rdr2 on it so i didn’t pick out the role

#

but you, yea you do that

lunar ginkgo
#

In which case

#

I wish you luck in your future endeavours

#

In RDR2 I mean

upper jay
#

i’m gonna jump on an airplane- oh

heady river
#

I play RDR2 on the Switch.

upper jay
#

rdr2 on VR would be fun

lunar ginkgo
#

OOoh.

heady river
#

So would Dying Light.

upper jay
#

eh

lunar ginkgo
#

Dead Eye would be awesome in VR.

upper jay
#

that would require much more movement

heady river
#

I want motion sickness.

upper jay
#

and - yea

#

head turning , lots of motion sickness

#

i wanna play killing floor 2 on VR

heady river
#

I mean, they do have that VR one..

lunar ginkgo
#

Killing Floor 2 is good but on VR?

#

Meh.

upper jay
#

which is why i said i want to play it on VR

lunar ginkgo
#

Just play SuperHot

#

In VR

upper jay
#

i’ll watch superbad

#

in VR

lunar ginkgo
#

Why is it bad in your opinion?

#

I think it's amazing.

upper jay
#

..

lunar ginkgo
#

Pretty hypocritical of you to do what you hate but okay.

upper jay
#

i’m assuming you were born after 2006

lunar ginkgo
#

No.

upper jay
#

it’s a movie

#

superbad

lunar ginkgo
#

...

upper jay
#

i said i’ll watch superbad on VR

#

watch

lunar ginkgo
#

Oh.

upper jay
#

yes

lunar ginkgo
#

I didn't realize it was a movie.

#

I'm sorry.

#

Have a cookie.

upper jay
#

it’s a comedy

lunar ginkgo
#

šŸŖ

#

Here.

#

You deserve it.

#

I'll be off now. See you around!

halcyon siren
surreal coral
pulsar arch
#

i miss you, hosea

storm fern
#

šŸ˜”

upper jay
#

how you gonna say that your apartment allows dogs and then say there’s a 35lb weight limit

#

like bruh that’s ain’t a dog, it’s a kickball

frank knoll
#

anyone know why sometimes my horse will automatically walk to the hitching post in camp, and other times she doesn't? I can't seem to figure out what triggers it, or what prevents it from triggering...

storm fern
#

idk

frank knoll
#

figured it out. need to be close to your tent (not just anywhere in camp) when you dismount

storm fern
#

good

#

I'm glad you did

warm sapphire
#

I can finally do race seriessss yay

indigo tangle
#

You mean... horseback deathmatch?

errant forge
#

Mhmm

boreal fog
#

anyone not get the rewards after setting up 2 factor authentication?

warm sapphire
#

I haven't been able to play the race series on pc since the christmas event took place xd

plush drum
#

šŸ‘€

pulsar arch
#

@boreal fog can take up to 72 hours

jaunty terrace
#

Hi

pulsar arch
#

check if you've got a klad for free in the stables

jaunty terrace
#

Ok

#

I’ll try

pulsar arch
#

haha

#

that's only if yu have enabled 2fa

jaunty terrace
#

I do

pulsar arch
#

that's a good boah

jaunty terrace
#

Ikr

#

Wats ur IP address

pulsar arch
#

32

jaunty terrace
#

Wats ur IP address

frank knoll
#

127.0.0.1

pulsar arch
#

32.0.0.1

jaunty terrace
#

Thanks

marsh dirge
#

How do I call the hunter wagon?

#

Anyone know?

frank knoll
#

online menu > stables

#

left on D pad

marsh dirge
#

Yeah I just remembered that menu, thanks though!

indigo tangle
#

@boreal fog not me

errant forge
junior rock
#

Dailies reset at 1am for us EST folk, right?

indigo tangle
#

Hmmm

plush drum
#

Yup

indigo tangle
#

Yeah

errant forge
indigo tangle
#

Oh my gosh im on a 5 ppl lobby

errant forge
#

Disconnected

indigo tangle
#

Wdym

errant forge
#

In 3

plush drum
#

I had a 2 person lobby a minute ago. No camp tho

errant forge
#

2

indigo tangle
#

No

errant forge
#

1

indigo tangle
#

No

#

No

#

Nooooo

errant forge
#

2001006

indigo tangle
#

My delivery boutta be ready

#

Imma go solo

errant forge
#

wagon explodes

#

Full delivery?

indigo tangle
#

Yeah

errant forge
#

Aii don't do distant

indigo tangle
#

Everyones invited

errant forge
#

Not worth it

indigo tangle
#

Never done distant

errant forge
#

Good

indigo tangle
#

Im too much of a pussy

#

And always play alone

errant forge
#

I've never been attacked by players on my distants

indigo tangle
#

Well actually i invite newbies to my posse when i got moonshine or wagon rdy

errant forge
#

Even though I'm solo

#

But ever since my wagon randomly broke down when i wasn't even a quarter of the way in

#

I decided

marsh dirge
#

Does anybody legitimately go to Ambarino

errant forge
#

Never again

#

Hold up

#

Ah ok

#

Thought you meant hannover

marsh dirge
#

Ha yeah

errant forge
#

Since they're only the grizzlies

#

Not really

marsh dirge
#

Yeah thought so

#

I've never had an enjoyable time there

errant forge
#

Snow is annoying

#

Grizzlies east paths are annoying

frank knoll
#

I had my camp in Ambarino today for the first time, delivery wagon was destroyed trying to get across the river.. never again lol

plush drum
#

Hunted from Cattail all the way up the Adlers ranch a few weeks ago

errant forge
#

Oof

#

There's just not enough shit there for people to care about unfortunately

#

I wish Colter was a legit town

frank knoll
#

the springs were cool

errant forge
#

That could make it worth going up there once in a while

indigo tangle
#

I think there should be exclusive animals

#

Plus big animals actually be valuable

errant forge
#

Yeah but it only lends legitimacy to grizzlies east

#

West has literally nothing

upper jay
#

colter is nice

indigo tangle
#

Damn feels so wrong to ride a morgsn

errant forge
#

When Arthur rides a Morgan, is it incest

indigo tangle
strong niche
silk bobcat
#

How do I join the new free aim series they advertised today?

devout cliff
#

Start, online, scroll down to Series Playlist and it should be the first one

#

Or open the player menu, quick join and featured series

silk bobcat
#

Ahh

#

Dunno if they updated it yet for pc, and I tried that one multiple times today. Dead lobbies (PC) lol

#

thanks for the response though šŸ˜„

barren lindenBOT
#

You can now ping respective channels when Looking for players.
If you're looking for a group please checkout #role-request and select which system you play on. From there you can check out the how to channels to see how you can find players easier.

indigo tangle
#

shut up

marsh dirge
#

Anyone know what those "Mystery Rewards" are for? I mean beyond what it obviously states.

#

Any speculation what we'll get, if I'm supposed to use them now (and how) so it unlocks when the mystery reveals itself

#

Or if, when the mystery is revealed, they'll turn into "black coat coupon"

fallow wing
#

From what I gather, it is an item that will be released in the future and we will find out what it is then.

I had to have it explained to me as I thought it meant 'random reward' from the store.

burnt charm
#

anyone wanna play?

surreal frigate
#

eu ?

marsh dirge
#

Why does location matter? Lol

surreal frigate
#

ping

marsh dirge
#

It's RDO, not CSGO

burnt charm
#

AHAHAHHA

#

True

surreal frigate
#

lagg sucks ^^

burnt charm
#

I play in asia

#

But placed in a session full of americans

#

With no lag

marsh dirge
#

^

#

Although not Asian

#

300 ping doesn't matter unless you're playing a game like Starcraft, CSGO or a Moba. GTA and RDO already feel sloppy by gameplay, it's like playing in water compared to the snappiness of the aformentioned. The game's 300 ping by design

#

Mystery rewards are R*’s way of saying, ā€œwe have no idea what to put here, so here’s a participation medal we promise it means somethingā€

surreal frigate
#

for me it isnt as sloppy idk. i play even first person cause i hate 3rd person games

pulsar arch
#

the mystery reward for the first outlaw pass were every colour variant of both a vest and coat

#

so, probably something similar for the 2nd

errant forge
marsh dirge
#

Alright, thanks.

Another question. Is there a way to "overwrite" a saved outfit?

For example I've got an outfit, I want to change the belt buckle when I click save outfit it prompts me to type in a new name and starts with "Outfit Three" obviously taking up a new slot on the list.

surreal frigate
#

ye

#

just load that outfit, change something, save and delete the old save

marsh dirge
#

That's not overwriting, that saving and deleting

#

So yes but not directly

#

What I've been doing

#

I do it all the time, it’s the only method as of yet

surreal frigate
#

there aint another way im pretty sure

errant forge
#

There's no way to edit an outfit

marsh dirge
#

It’s stupid but it’s R*

#

It's just annoying because I have say, "Vest" and then "Vest cold" and then "Overalls" and "Overalls Cold" I like ti keep it in order.

abstract atlas
#

Uh hello! I have a question about red dead online- is this the right place to ask about it-?

errant forge
#

Yes

#

Technically

marsh dirge
#

ā€˜Technically’ lmao

#

The answer is yes

#

How can we assist you, polite internet stranger?

errant forge
#

I mean

#

But noone cares

#

We're always happy to help

marsh dirge
#

Yeah but it usually leads to casual conversation that isn’t support related

errant forge
#

Mhmm

marsh dirge
#

Plus it keeps the chat alive during the quiet hours

abstract atlas
#

Ah! Okay!
I'm sorta new to red dead online,
And I wanted to know how it worked! I mainly play single player,
What I mean by that is,
What are the people like-? And what types of rooms are there-?
Can I have a private room- or-?
I wanna get used to online before I actually play with people-

errant forge
#

People are assholes around America

#

Friendly around asia

abstract atlas
#

True!

marsh dirge
#

There are no private lobbies, no

errant forge
#

No private room

abstract atlas
#

Darn-

errant forge
#

And you'll mostly be alone

marsh dirge
#

Defensive mode will help you ward off most of the griefing

#

Why do you use hyphens like that.

abstract atlas
#

There's private rooms in the first game :(
Kinda sad that there isnt one in this game!

errant forge
#

Since people don't appear on map till they're close by

marsh dirge
#

I recommend getting a posse and playing it cool around players

abstract atlas
#

Oh-?

errant forge
#

Yeah and in gta too

#

So weird we don't have them

#

@abstract atlasalso when you pass by a player whistle constantly

marsh dirge
#

Low player count after the launch flop

abstract atlas
#

Why-?

errant forge
#

It's the sign that you're a friendly player and not a griefer

abstract atlas
#

Oh-?

#

Okay!

marsh dirge
#

Again, those random hyphens, why do you use them like that?

#

That’s a thing?

#

Imma whistle now

#

Spread the word bois

errant forge
#

Phee

#

That's been a thing since rdr online griefers were a thing

marsh dirge
#

Just asking- a question- and being- ignored- rude-?

#

Probably habit

abstract atlas
#

Oh- sorry! I tend to use them a lot-

marsh dirge
#

Meme it man

errant forge
#

....-

marsh dirge
#

But why---?

#

It makes zero grammatical sense.

#

So I'm very- confused.

#

#metoo

#

@abstract atlas If you need help on Xbox, my gamertag is my username. My timezone is GMT and I’m usually online in the afternoons and evenings. Hit me up if you need any help.

errant forge
marsh dirge
#

Never heard of the whistle thing myself and if it's a thing surely griefers will just do it, then walk up to you and shotgun you in the face.

indigo tangle
#

Omar?

sage quiver
#

That's not how you do it, you shotgun them in the back.. sigh

indigo tangle
#

Shit i now got omars whistle stuck in my head

marsh dirge
#

Do you require a shotgun to the face, sir?

errant forge
#

@indigo tangleWHY DID YOU SAY THAT NAME?

junior rock
#

What's the best way to level the outlaw pass? I'll probably have enough gold by the 10th and I want to make sure I can still get everything

marsh dirge
#

Collector

#

Sets boost your xp like crazy

junior rock
#

Sweet

#

You think I'll be able to complete it by March?

marsh dirge
#

Oh yeah no problem at all

#

If you did just one coin set a day, I bet you could do it in a month tops

#

Maybe less

junior rock
#

Sweet. From now on, I'll keep a cushion of 40 gold after I get it all back

marsh dirge
#

That’s assuming you get absolutely no xp from anywhere else which is unlikely

#

Yeah same

junior rock
#

Probably a smart thing to do, but I joined on Steam release

marsh dirge
#

I’m grinding to buy the pass

#

Xbox player but I’m broke lmao

junior rock
#

I should have 40 gold by the 10th

marsh dirge
#

I’m on like 6 gold

junior rock
#

I've been doing every daily that's not pvp or bar related

marsh dirge
#

Gonna be a while

#

Try bounty hunting

#

Easy gold if you have the time

junior rock
#

I have nothing but time. I just try to do all my dailies because 0.5 for some weird task I should probably be doing anyways is too good to pass up

#

I'm in a bad spot where I have more gold than money right now

marsh dirge
#

I gotta get my streak back up

#

I don’t even have 7 days yet

#

I always need cash haha

#

To me gold is more important

junior rock
#

Yeah, streaks are really the deciding factor for gold

marsh dirge
#

Seems like everything I want costs gold and lots of it too

junior rock
#

I want to get that limited corset as well, but outlaw pass is first

marsh dirge
#

That’s been my problem

#

Snatching up limited stuff

junior rock
#

I mean it'll come back, but I don't know how patient Rockstar is

#

I don't like the corset that much, but I know I will when I can afford clothes that complement it

#

I'm kind of just dressed like an industrial revolution chimneysweep right now, and I have no qualms, but fashion is endgame in any online game

humble helm
#

lol someone was hacking night hand day cycle I think kept blinding me witht he change

marsh dirge
#

do boot spurs improve horse handling

jaunty terrace
#

Hi

winged ember
#

Outlaw pass wasn't as good as the first one in my opinion but it was still pretty nice

viral mason
#

its still expensive tho

#

thats a good thing

#

dont give nice things away for free

stone hull
#

is there a link where we can see what was in the first pass ? I started the game with pass 2, and would like to know what I missed

lofty ridge
#

Will you get all rewards afterwards?

winged ember
#

What do you mean @lofty ridge

viral mason
#

the first pass had beter rewards

lofty ridge
#

If you buy the pass after you already played and leveled?

winged ember
#

Yeah

#

At least until the tier you finish at

#

Like let's say you got to 50 on the free, if you then bought it, you would receive all the premium shit up until 50

#

Outlaw pass 2 is worth it just for Arthur's outfit and the husky alone uwu

viral mason
#

yes

#

husky meat

#

arthurs outfit is nice

#

but id rather get a cool gun

fiery canopy
#

It dont feel right wearin the hat, I feel like I dont deserve it xD

barren lindenBOT
#

You can now ping respective channels when Looking for players.
If you're looking for a group please checkout #role-request and select which system you play on. From there you can check out the how to channels to see how you can find players easier.

pulsar epoch
#

You get all 40 gold back from the outlaw pass

#

In a week i got the 40 gold back easy

long rune
#

So how do i earn my 40 gold bars back?

pulsar epoch
#

Yes man

#

Basically they gave this for free

atomic hare
#

just level it and you get 5 gold reward tickets you have to claim from time to time

#

eventually you'll get all 40 back

long rune
#

i bought it and was instantly put to rank 100

lofty ridge
#

It isnt for free if you pay with real money....

long rune
#

so like ... how do i level it if im max level?

atomic hare
#

it's already leveled

#

check your benefits page

#

claim the gold

pulsar epoch
#

@lofty ridge ypu don't need to pay with real money man

lofty ridge
#

I know

pulsar epoch
#

I have 1 month in the game

lofty ridge
#

You just need to grind everyday your dailies

pulsar epoch
#

I have all roles and outlaw pass

lofty ridge
#

y

pulsar epoch
#

And 200 gold bars and 13k dolars

#

Without any real money involved

#

Play daily quest

#

Hit the streak

#

Play some stranger missions

winged ember
long rune
#

wow its that easy to get it all back lol

#

so like i had grinded 100 gold bars and vowed to buy the pass once i hit 100 .. funny thing i am club reward rank 100 already

#

free shit wooo

errant forge
#

Yes RDO is spectacularly easy

opaque cairn
#

I have almost 20k and i dont now what to buy xD

errant forge
#

Pamphlets

upper dagger
#

oh wow, i didnt know that bolas are single use

errant forge
#

No they aren't

#

You can pick em back up @upper dagger

upper dagger
#

i tried bolas on a random guy

#

then I couldnt get them back up

errant forge
#

If you hogtie him you get it back

upper dagger
#

i did

#

bolas didnt come back

errant forge
#

Probably a bug then

upper dagger
#

😦

errant forge
#

It's supposed to come back

#

Rockstar scammed you outta 30$ rip

long rune
#

if you miss they will appear on the floor to pick up .. if they break free i think you loose them

errant forge
#

Yep

#

I wonder what happens if you kill a bolaed guy

#

If we lose it or not

plush drum
#

3 days in a row someone's killed me when I'm in defensive mode

rotund sky
#

There's so many fucking bugs

#

God

#

Black screen when switching in online mode

#

Dailies not registering as done

#

When will they fix all this shit

errant forge
#

When they do

atomic hare
#

What dailies aren't registering today?

errant forge
#

Stew maybe

atomic hare
#

No stew one today

#

I hate that it's bugged, though, that's an easy .5 gold

#

Resupply missions too now

#

$$$ bounty is bugged, but in a good way

#

It autocompletes when accepted

upper jay
#

they fixed the bolas daily

#

not sure how long ago but before you couldn’t get it by throwing the bolas you had to tackle them with the bolas equipped which defeated the purpose of having bolas

hidden steppe
#

worked for me if they were on a horse

#

I hadn't tried it on the ground, didn't know that was a bug lol

blissful sundial
#

yo does cripps keep making trader stuff while I play poker ?

gritty oar
#

yes

#

he keep making stuff if you're online with a camp

blissful sundial
#

awesome I stringed some fools for 60 bucks last night gonna have another go lol

#

I know its only 60 to rich ppl

#

its stil fun

#

šŸ™‚

#

caus some ppl go full bet with a pair of 5 s

indigo tangle
#

@errant forge wuut?

hidden steppe
#

card table

marsh dirge
#

What is going on with Cripps, never sets up my camp!!

bleak creek
#

Jesus all mighty why can't i access moonshine Missons or bounties or even stranger missions!

gritty oar
#

@marsh dirge sometimes changing sessions fixes the problem

marsh dirge
#

Makes sense but sucks when I’m trying to replenish my goods for trading... @gritty oar

jolly leaf
#

Is the navy revolver the best revolver now?

gritty oar
#

@marsh dirge ik right.. or when you launch the game choose camp instead of free roam, usually works for me

errant forge
marsh dirge
#

That sometimes works other times it drops me where my camp used to be..

errant forge
#

One workaround I've found is pitching in the state nearest to you and it pitched camp on the border

#

So works out well

marsh dirge
#

I'll have to try that. Thanks @errant forge

errant forge
#

For example if you want an emerald ranch camp and it doesn't work

#

Pitch roanoke

#

It's basically the same but on the border

heady pivot
#

need to do my dailies but im sitting here on ps now playing ratchet and clank thonkhaw

marsh dirge
#

trying to load into Appearance change & endless load screen

#

I don't understand

#

how do I change my Appearance now that the devs insist on being lazy

upper dagger
#

go in a shooting series

#

leave

#

then try again

#

should work

marsh dirge
#

tyvm

versed roost
#

Gosh i just met a level 580 on ps4

#

Oof

heady river
#

Maybe he just really likes the game.

marsh dirge
#

Haha šŸ˜‚ @heady river

cerulean wharf
#

There are Rank 700s, 800s, and even a few Rank 900s on PS4. I saw a Rank 892 player last week when I was minding my own business in Free Roam.

However, no matter what anyone says, Rank does NOT mean skill. It simply means how much time you spent playing RDO.

marsh dirge
#

why is it impossible for me to join back into rdo if I go out of a server and then try to join a new one

#

it just keeps loading forever

cerulean wharf
#

Because the game is buggy af.

marsh dirge
#

):

#

I can't change my appearance

#

which means I can't use that 'free' coupon

upper dagger
#

going into a series doesnt work ?

marsh dirge
#

here's hoping they fix this shit before the outlaw pass runs out in March

#

No sir / ma'am

#

this sucks

indigo tangle
#

Daily reminder that the hungarian halfbred deserves a spot in the superior category

marsh dirge
#

we should be able to buy Donkeys to ride

#

it would be funny if there was a mission for the 500th Moonshiner delivery where we unlock it

#

through a series of unfortunate events

frank knoll
#

there should be more perfect animals in the world if there are going to be so few animals to begin with, hunting is such a chore

marsh dirge
#

they had a 'mission' in free roam in GTA where after X number of Bunker resupplies (I think?) you encounter a ufo

errant forge
#

Today I accidentally got in a solo lobby and stayed there somehow

#

For the entirety of the time I was playing

#

About an hour

#

It was fookin animal heaven

marsh dirge
#

What do you mean halfbreads suck

errant forge
#

Faxx

#

@indigo tangle

indigo tangle
marsh dirge
#

They are slow

indigo tangle
#

This guy

errant forge
#

They are slow aren't they

long rune
#

@jolly leaf Navy is like the cannon on the revolvers , very accurate and deadly but slow rate of fire and even slower reloading rate

marsh dirge
#

Super slow

indigo tangle
#

Thinks because the feet move faster the horse is faster

errant forge
#

Slow to turn as well

indigo tangle
#

@marsh dirge what horse do you have?

marsh dirge
#

Yeah

indigo tangle
#

Yeah norfolk are slow to turn aswell amirite?

errant forge
#

Yeah

#

Arabians best

marsh dirge
#

Shoot i cant rember but i think its one of the moonshiner horses

errant forge
#

Norfolks lol

indigo tangle
#

Lmao

#

This guy

marsh dirge
#

Yeah i bought it not to long ago

errant forge
#

Still halfbreds are slow

#

Norfolks have the best acceleration yeet

indigo tangle
#

Yeah about 3% slower

errant forge
#

Acceleration matters

#

Especially since we mostly offroad in this game

indigo tangle
#

Anyway best horse =/= fastest horse

errant forge
#

Yes

#

Best horse=superior horse

#

Which is

marsh dirge
#

Offroad dont matter they still will go the same speed

errant forge
#

drumroll

#

The Arabian!

marsh dirge
#

Yeah i have one of those As well

indigo tangle
#

They put em in superior category so all the dummies buy it

#

Baited by rockstar

errant forge
#

They put them in a class of their own so dummies can understand it's the best

marsh dirge
#

Superior name dont matter

errant forge
#

Lmao

marsh dirge
#

Its the speed

errant forge
#

Reverse rockstar logic

#

Handling most important stat

indigo tangle
#

So you just use your horses for racing ok

marsh dirge
#

No i use it to travel arround the map FAST

indigo tangle
#

Thats still incorrect thoroughbreds should be faster only thing better from an arabian is stamina

errant forge
#

And health

indigo tangle
#

But r* suck

errant forge
#

And handling

indigo tangle
#

No i mean in the real world

errant forge
#

And hitbox

#

Arabians are fastest IRL I think

indigo tangle
#

They have better stamina

errant forge
#

That's why they're so prestigious

indigo tangle
#

They look like inbred dogs when they're young

#

Have a look at their face

errant forge
#

Arabians are majestic

#

They are truly stallions

indigo tangle
#

Look i was right

errant forge
#

It looks adorable

#

Dafuq you on

indigo tangle
#

Thoroughbreds are considered the fastest horses in the world and dominate the horse racing industry, while Arabian horses are known to be intelligent and excel in endurance riding.Apr 18, 2016

errant forge
#

Thoroughbreds are fastest yes

indigo tangle
#

You said arabians were

errant forge
#

I said I thought they were

indigo tangle
#

They also look better

errant forge
#

Thoroughbreds are beautiful not gonna lie

indigo tangle
#

I cant remember if thoroughbred decend from the arabian or some other breed from that region

errant forge
#

But honestly when your standard is a half-bred everything probably looks nice to you

#

Half-bred is just a fancy word for inbred

indigo tangle
#

Just because rockstar didnt give them nice coats doesnt mean they're ugly

errant forge
#

Bad coats

#

Bad stats

#

Giant size

#

Giant hitbox

#

I'd rather have a plain coat shire

#

Shirechanka

indigo tangle
#

Good hidden stats

dire pebble
#

Hey I’m new, looking for people on ps4 that I can help with some large trader sales to earn some cash if possible

errant forge
#

Get the PS4 role in role request

#

And ask in the lfg channels

#

That's where peeps hang for work

indigo tangle
#

idk why hungarians dont have black coat

#

i think that's a pretty common coat for them,

errant forge
#

They're racist too

dire pebble
#

Aight cheers

errant forge
#

Wow

versed roost
#

@cerulean wharf I know that level =/= skill but the time investment to reach 600+ levels is impressive.

errant forge
#

You're just bringing down the Hungarian's rep

versed roost
#

on the other hand.. I see people 60+ who don't use ability cards lol.

indigo tangle
#

you don't get it

errant forge
indigo tangle
#

they have black coat irl but r* are horse racists

errant forge
#

Maybe the Hungarian inbreds disagreed

#

With the use of black coat for their family of horses

#

Ok

#

Why would I buy a Hungarian and not a Shire