#Roller Shutter smart Switch

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

steady sandal
#

Roller shutter switches

Ich habe das hier gerade auf AliExpress gefunden:
ZigBee Rollladen Jalousien Schalter Relais Modul Tuya Smart Life Prozent Fortschritt Timer Steuerung Google Assistant Alexa
https://a.aliexpress.com/_Ey1HoPW
Is this good?

Screenshot_20260221_180756_com_alibaba_aliexpresshd_ProductDetailActivity.jpg
cobalt scaffoldBOT
#
Rule 3

@steady sandal No typing in any other language than English; we cannot moderate different languages.

wind cloak
#

And as it is Tuya, no - it likely isn't good.

lavish heath
#

already explained that a month and a half ago 😉

steady sandal
#

To me?

#

So better use shelly?

gleaming whale
#

Better to hire a person to push the button when you yell at them than use tuya

steady sandal
#

Why is that so bad?

gleaming whale
#

It's not really that bad. Sometimes. It kind of almost works some of the time, but as a rule tuya devices are the dumbest smart devices you can get

wind cloak
#

Tuya WiFi = bad.
Tuya Zigbee = often lower quality, but still better than Tuya WiFi.
There might be some decent Tuya Zigbee devices, but it is more often a miss than a hit.

gleaming whale
#

Yeah, their zigbee devices can work fine, but even then I've seen issues part to part

wind cloak
#

Some are spamming the Zigbee network to death, some are breaking early (or start to burn),...

wind cloak
steady sandal
wind cloak
#

Eltako Matter for example.

#

The ESB64NP-IPM should be the one for shades.

#

Those are Matter over WiFi though. The newest Shelly ones can be set to WiFi or Zigbee.

#

Aqara also seems to have a T2 shade module.

gleaming whale
#

Sonoff MINI-ZBRBS for zigbee and the MINI-RBS for WiFi

steady sandal
steady sandal
gleaming whale
gleaming whale
steady sandal
#

But I would like to start the calibration without having to disassemble it

gleaming whale
steady sandal
#

Where did you find that?

#

Can I use the shelly 2pm Gen 4 also for lights, and 2 different lights? Cause it says that it is a dual input channel switch

#

Can I also connect a motor and a light on one?

steady sandal
#

Is 1 ampere enough?

steady sandal
#

As far as I found out they do not have automated calibration

lavish heath
#

have shelly, go shelly again.

lavish heath
#

saving a few bucks on a buy is not always a good thing. Shelly's proven it's (build) quality and reliability. Other brands you would have to add an app or something to work, so there would be no profit at all.

lavish heath
lavish heath
lavish heath
steady sandal
#

that would not be a problem

lavish heath
steady sandal
#

Is sonoff that bad?

gleaming whale
#

But yeah just buy a shelly. They're rock solid if you have good WiFi
If you really want to use zigbee - then imo sonoff is one of the better ones you can get

steady sandal
#

I want to use zigbee not wifi tough

#

So sonoff is better then shellys in zigbee?

gleaming whale
#

If for some reason you don't like either of them, list out your actual requirements for the control rather than just coming up with new issues or asking for another option every time someone suggests something

steady sandal
#

I had to put the zigbee commander directly in front of the shellys to get them to join

steady sandal
wind cloak
#

Shelly 2PM Gen 4 can be set to Zigbee communication.

steady sandal
#

I know that. But they are expensive

gleaming whale
#

OK, so what is your budget?

wind cloak
#

When using mains power, cheap may in some cases also mean dangerous.

steady sandal
gleaming whale
#

And the shelly is about 35 iirc?

steady sandal
#

yep

#

I bought 2 of them for 58 euros

#

so more like 29

gleaming whale
#

Sounds like a good deal

#

What's the ask in terms of features - both control, and usability?

wind cloak
#

And what loads are they expected to handle?

steady sandal
#

For me it just has to work as expected

steady sandal
#

Must be around 1 ampere of usage

#

Or what do you mean by loads?

gleaming whale
#

What else?

steady sandal
#

has to work with zigbeetomqtt

#

and it should handle firmware updates via homeassistant

gleaming whale
steady sandal
#

but there are aliexpress ones

wind cloak
#

It is a compatibility list, not a quality list.

gleaming whale
#

Those are literally all the ones that work with z2m. It doesn't mean they're good.

#

But it's a starting point. Go through and find the ones that meet the rest of your needs

steady sandal
#

These two

#

Which one better for ZigBee?

#

Sonoff or shelly?

lavish heath
#

Heading out 😉

steady sandal
#

What?

#

On the way out?

lavish heath
#

yeah 😉 i gave all the advice i could give, no more to say or type

#

cause we're running in circles

gleaming whale
#

Of the two I would trust sonoff more for zigbee. They have been doing it for much longer than shelly.
I would probably buy the shelly though as it's better overall

steady sandal
steady sandal
steady sandal
#

So

#

I do think i will have to try both and see which one is better

gleaming whale
#

Just pick one. They will both work. Buying one of each to try will just be more expensive overall as you probably won't be able to return the one you don't want, even ignoring shipping costs.

steady sandal
#

sonoff is way cheaper