Stop the rs3 import slop
#Livid Farm:
stone slate
stone slate
old recycled ezscape content instead of a new, fresh, properly tied in suggestion
rs3 without eoc isnt the goal
osrs is
modern basin
Reasons I dislike this post:
The content itself.
-As mentioned, even if it’s not “RS3,” that doesn’t make copying content good. In fact, the game started going significantly downhill LONG before RS3.
-Beyond just copying, we already have farming- and magic-training minigames and these are among the easiest skills in the game to train.
-Despite being a skilling minigame, it requires 90s in a combat stat to even properly engage with, and, by your description, sounds mandatory.
The rewards
-Broadly speaking, these combat upgrades don’t make sense to come from a skilling minigame.
-Venge other buff is way too strong and doesn’t make sense to come from a skilling minigame
-The altered Spellbook swap somehow seems completely broken and awful at the same time. Again, as entering statement, it shouldn’t come from a skilling minigame, but I’ll explain why it’s bad anyway. Specifically, it reads like it would bar you from using more than your one selected spell as it would override/replace your Spellbook swap spell, which is a downgrade as it is currently often used for things like Death Charge, Thralls, and other spells all for a single activity, or for using teleports on other books. That is to say, it would be worse for activities where you swap multiple spells. Furthermore, even just using it for e.g. a barrage spell somewhere like ToB Maiden room or Inferno, or even something like Fire Surge for Ice Demon, “putting on the same delay as Spellbook Swap” just means that it would either a.) stall your character entirely between attacks (spellbook swap delay is 4t), or b.) delay you before the attack comes out (extending your effective attack speed to 9t and making it wholly useless). In both of these cases it would be pretty unplayable to use. On top of all that, it sounds pretty tremendously awful to tether combat power into continually going to a skilling minigame to recharge. This is similar to the reason that elemental tomes are a joke and never worth using on ironmen.