#šŸ¤”ļ½œtheories

1 messages Ā· Page 66 of 1

cold siren
#

Do you really want to discuss that?

#

There are some things that should be the base, not topic to discussions

shy pecan
#

No, but not because it's not interesting. It's because I'm a gamer, not a geologist.

cold siren
#

It would develope the theories better, instead of doubting what people already discussed

#

If everytime someone came up with a different theory we discuss it, we would be stuck forever in the beggining

shy pecan
#

And let's face it, the Samsara Wheel theory isn't water tight.

tawdry fulcrum
#

but not everyone know that base. and if this person show us their theory don't just say them, they are wrong. Told them this base

cold siren
#

But thats why you research first!

tawdry fulcrum
#

maybe you can learn something from them, too

#

it is allway possible, that you just oversee something

cold siren
#

Thats why you study physics to discuss physics, study geology to discuss geology and should study the game before you discuss the game!

shy pecan
#

But I don't mind being at the beginning with people. I love hearing them excitedly tell me what they think is going on.

tawdry fulcrum
#

^

shy pecan
#

Thing is those are all professions. This is a hobby.

cold siren
#

Yeah, I'm more like, if you have a theory and have proof that disproves the other theories, then we can discuss new theories

tawdry fulcrum
#

not everyone spent days in one game to see every pixel

cold siren
#

But some people do! And we should learn from them

#

Not want to disprove them with make believe theories

tawdry fulcrum
#

but we don't know about that other theory, why we cant discuss then?

shy pecan
#

So...we can't create make believe theories about a make believe place?

tawdry fulcrum
#

so you only can discuss theories, if you spent days in analyzing the games?

shy pecan
#

And here's another thing, what if the dev's made a mistake somewhere? What if they added or omitted a detail they thought was inconsequential that we notice and dwell over?

cold siren
#

No, you dont need to spend days analyzing other things, but people who already did have better answers than you and you can learn from them reading texts that takes little to no time compared to the time they spent

tawdry fulcrum
#

but if you don't know about that texts you can't lern from them

cold siren
#

So read them!

tawdry fulcrum
#

but until now i didn't know there were texts about it

shy pecan
#

Funny you should mention the previous texts because that's also where you can see me and another person talking about the Buddhist themes of the game like two weeks ago.

tawdry fulcrum
#

so all my theories are crap, because i didn't know this texts?

cold siren
#

Argumentum ad novitatem

tawdry fulcrum
#

you can't assume everyone knows all the texts

#

and even if those texts have to be correct

cold siren
#

Everything discussed are fallacies that you want to be true for the sake of your ego

#

You just want to be special for your theory, even if its false

tawdry fulcrum
#

wow, thats rude

cold siren
#

And I'm not really in the mood to continue to explain why they are fallacies and thats also why I stopped talking here

#

Rude, but true

shy pecan
#

Um...you're still talking

cold siren
#

#flatearthisreal

tawdry fulcrum
#

i can accept, that my theories are wrong, if you prove, that they are wrong

#

but you don't do that

#

the only thing you said is, that they are wrong

#

no reasons why, no prove

#

you only said something like "a other theory says a other thing"

shy pecan
#

@cold siren Okay, I've been giving you a lot of pushback. I have an idea. Would you like to talk about what you'd like to know about the story? Do you have any burning questions that haven't yet been answered by the games?

tawdry fulcrum
#

how schould i believe you, if you didn't say why i should believe you?

shy pecan
#

Not that I could actually answer them for you.

vague imp
#

The main problem is that many theories are built by players (usually children) who have not been very attentive to the games, but want to build a their own theorys. This discussion is meaningless for those who know the Rusty Lake Universe well. The best ideas are born in solitude.

#

"fallacy that you want to be true for the sake of your ego" - that can be said about any theory imo

#

lets just

#

be polite to each other

tawdry fulcrum
#

^please

shy pecan
#

huffs Okay, mom.

#

jk

#

So, one thing that has been on my mind lately is to what extent did Dale deal with his past?

#

Like, does he have a timeline where he's orphaned at the age of 9, revisits that pivotal moment, and suddenly had a completely different childhood?

dim edge
#

Thanks Radium, think polite is right way to go for discussions on this channel and server 😃 if someone (new or long time fan) have new theories or questions about old, more established theories, then please just provide links and more info.

placid tulip
#

Then the inspiration decreased over time 😢
No new theory since that time...

#

wait, perhaps the 2 rabbits used to be partners, then the brown killed the white one, who is the main performer
....
nah

shy pecan
#

Well that's kinda interesting in that it asks why there is a white rabbit in a black cloak outside of the window while you could see the brown rabbit alive. I do however have some problems with the evidence here like saying he's not a ninja. After all, it is very possible that corrupted souls are not confined to follow the corporeal restrictions of time and space.

round hare
#

Hey @cold siren could you please link me to some of the theories you were referring to? (beyond the reddit stuff I already saw that)

vague imp
#

Can developers explain who is Jimmy Vandermeer (from Rusty Lake: Roots)? Perhaps he is Dale’s son.

round hare
#

Wait who's that

#

I don't remember him from Roots

vague imp
#

I don't remember seeing that either :ooo

#

He was not in the game. This image from game files.

round hare
#

Oh

vague imp
#

What's game files?

vague imp
#

could also be a nephw?

#

nephew*

#

or something..

#

but it could be a hint like for a future game, just a file placed ingame for a hint i mean ya know?

fresh badger
#

omaiga

#

this excites me

gritty arrow
#

Wait so is Jimmy like a secret level in roots?

rough nymph
#

Whoops, gotta remember to check game files now

shy pecan
#

Which game file is it?

digital fulcrum
#

Nothing excited in the actual generation, frame(Shape), name(text), date(text).

#

In terms of code I can't find anything juicy except that sometimes buttons are referred as Buttons and sometimes as Knoppen (which is Buttons in Dutch, yipee).

shy pecan
#

Hehehe, WOW! Now I'm more impressed with the length you had to go to to find this. Way to go.

#

searches facebook for a Jimmy Vandermeer

vague imp
#

woaah

#

@ancient dagger

tawdry fulcrum
#

Maybe they yust forgott it in there and it’s not a hint for a future game?

fresh badger
#

but still, who is this jimmy?

#

if they put it there, he surely must be someone relevant

tawdry fulcrum
#

maybe they planned calling a charakter Jimmy but then they decided to pick another name

#

a name of a charakter, who is in the game

fresh badger
#

hmmm maybe maybe

#

perhaps

vague imp
#

There was no Vandermeers in the game. Most likely, it's an Easter egg, like the date of Dale Vandermeer's birth.

digital fulcrum
#

Let me add fuel to fire.

#

The sprite name, introMC is not the first instance.

#

As you can see, it's all the intro messages compressed into one sprite, with each frame being more or less unique(Days 1-4, 2-5 share a frame).

vague imp
#

The matter is that the background from RLH is used. Unnecessary files from old games are often found there.

vague imp
#

the rusty lake crew arent the kind to just completely leave in a file with the wrong characters name are they?

vague imp
#

Lol. I just thought that we, discussing this here, will achieve that the developers will clear the new game from needless files. It will be bad.

vague imp
#

šŸ’©

carmine patio
#

sudden realization those are legs

strong finch
#

wait a minute, is it just me or that eye next to that building has an eye?

rough nymph
#

The tree? It may just be a treehole, but you never know

carmine patio
#

no that's an eye

vague imp
#

Om

#

Spooky

#

SšŸ…± ooky

round hare
#

Spoopy

shadow stump
#

I'm coming back on a theory I had with some other people about the location of Rusty lake. To make it short, the lake would have been somewhere in UK because of the uniform Leonard was wearing in WW1 in "roots". It was a British uniform. Also, still in roots, you could find a newspaper called "daily herald", which was a real UK newspaper that published during WW1. It's basically it.

thin elk
#

Yeah, but Vanderboom doesn't seem like an english name. considering it's a mush of three dutch words

shadow stump
#

Here is what I bring new: First, there's a real lake called "Rusty lake" in Ontario, Canada (thx google map). Canadian soldiers had the same uniform than UK soldiers. Also, during WW1, in Canada, another newspaper was called daily herald that first published in Saskatchewan but the company was bought around 1908-1909 by a man living in Ontario. I think rusty lake might be in Canada.

#

@thin elk There was some immigration before WW1 in Canada. Maybe the Vanderboom are immigrants.

thin elk
#

That does make sense, although an immigrant family having a house on their own doesn't really make sense to me

shadow stump
#

Yeah... maybe. But if you look at the lake on google maps, it looks to be in the middle of nowhere. If an immigrant family would like to have his own house, it would probably be the best place.

shadow stump
#

Just to make it clear, the canadian "Daily Herald" was call "Prince Albert daily herald"

placid tulip
#

Holy bird shit!

#

I just hope the devs would come here and be like:
Ooh, that's good stuff you got there, we shall take it šŸ˜… šŸ˜‚

honest magnet
#

but anyway I am currently going off the theory that this is the island the hotel was built on

#

so if that is an elevator then that kinda ties things together

swift kindle
#

i also think it's the same island

#

kinda

#

also tristan what's your theory? šŸ‘€

shy pecan
#

It's in the right place for it.

#

Okay, jeez, so this is in no way trying to steal the series away from the other religious themes, but the idea of there being plagues, especially biblical plagues, reminds me of bible themes.

#

Where in Exodus, the book with the plagues in it, also features animal sacrifice for redemption which was actually just pointing ahead to the time when the real lamb of God would be sacrificed.

#

That's the biblical story. You don't have to believe it.

#

So seeing the people with the masks on makes me think they are sacrifices to appease the lake, make the plagues go away, but ultimately pointing forward to when another sacrifice would have to be made.

#

Death that would cease the hostility between the lake and its inhabitents

#

And mister owl is the lake's prophet

#

That's all

honest magnet
#

interesting

#

I never thought about it like that

shy pecan
#

In RL Hotel mister owl says he has his reasons for having them stay. I think it's very likely we'll find out about those reasons in Paradise.

distant mirage
#

that's not bad, i like it

#

it does sound like the kind of thing they pick up and do

shy pecan
#

Thanks

#

Don't let that stop you from thinking of other theories

distant mirage
#

i'm pretty much just chilling until it comes out

#

when i play, my wee wrinkled brain will be buzzing with interpretations and suppositions and omgs

shy pecan
#

Hmmm, maybe there should be a seperate chat for paradise for a while, for avoiding spoilers while still allowing people who have played the game to talk about it.

#

I mean, after it comes out

swift kindle
#

yeah that would be nice šŸ‘€
maybe try posting it in "suggestions"? šŸ‘€

shy pecan
#

Oh yeah. See, you're smart.

swift kindle
#

actually i'm really not xD

distant mirage
#

i'm kind of surprised there isn't a pin on this channel saying something like, this channel may have spoilers about new content

vague imp
#

oh shit

#

I never really made the connection to religion beyond the most obvious stuff but fuck

#

If that's the thread it's going in then it really might be the lakes origin story, like maybe someone got killed in the lake and since there's no way to separate the good& bad memories the lake is malfunctioning because of all the bad memories in it

#

you might have to continue sacrificing people for the brief respite that the good memories provide and then the cycle would start over again with the bad memories from the person you sacrificed

distant mirage
#

"paradise" is a pretty strongly religious term

#

e.g. dante's paradiso

#

milton's paradise lost, etc.

vague imp
#

yea I got like that stuff& the basic eden/sin stuff but damn

shy pecan
#

Having to continually sacrifice people suggests a cycle and would fit in with the Samsara wheel. Doing it to maintain balance, and correct me if I'm wrong, is more Taoist?

#

Not that labels matter I guess. It's an entirely different universe where all of these things could be the truth.

vague imp
#

wheels have been a hugely reoccurring theme in general plus the whole theme of death and rebirth that's been used repeatedly, that's definitely a good point

shadow stump
#

I m pretty sure that everybody knew that, but just in case

#

Someone has an idea

#

*?

rancid niche
#

They got reincarnated didn't they?

#

The one old guy

#

Or am I mixing things up?

shadow stump
#

Yes, he did, but how did she knew at that moment?

rancid niche
#

Cause she was posessed by the spirit right

shadow stump
#

Wasn’t the spirit just talking to her through the ouija board?

rancid niche
#

No she had this really weird raspy voice

#

At least that's how I interpreted it

distant mirage
#

i think the basic concept is "rose is weird and therefore knows stuff through weird ways"

#

i didn't think she was possessed, more like just psychic herself

shadow stump
#

I still think that there s another meaning to what she says, because if you want her to say that, it s through an easter egg

distant mirage
#

what other meaning?

shadow stump
#

I don’t know, maybe Rose is more than Albert’s daughter?

distant mirage
#

what more would she be?

#

that's already pretty weird, just considering how bizarre albert is and how weird her conception was

shadow stump
#

Yeah...
But still, wouldn’t it be weird if an easter egg had no other use than making her say something that has no importance?

distant mirage
#

the world of gaming is pretty full of easter eggs that are just little extra fun things

#

and it does confirm that she knows the whole arc she's involved in, with the tree and resurrecting her great-grandfather, and that she even knows that her daughter is at the center of that

#

which is not nothing

shadow stump
#

Good point

shy pecan
#

Rose is interesting. At a young age she made that prediction. Do you suppose she somehow had knowledge of the future?

shadow stump
#

That’s something like that I was thinking. Or maybe it’s not her first life? Maybe she had past life(s)?

round hare
#

Ooh

#

I thought it was because she was somehow psychic/a medium

#

But that could also be true

strong finch
#

Rose is Albert's daughter

#

But he used Ida's egg, and Ida used tarot cards to somehow predict the future

shy pecan
#

Ooh, that's a great point.

#

I never thought about Laura being a direct descendent of Ida before.

exotic rock
#

SPOILER
Wait... did the guy just turned into Mr Owl? Or am I misunderstaning something?

vague imp
#

Cave?

twin drift
#

Paradise

little garnet
#

@exotic rock Yeah it seems that Paradise is the origin story of Mr. Owl

twin drift
#

But doesn't someone become Mr. owl in the cave after drinking the elixir?

#

Or am I thinking of Roots

#

Might be thinking of roots.

little garnet
#

In the cave, that's just Mr. Owl transforming into his owl form, they can transform back and forth

#

And in Roots, that's Aldous transforming into his crow form

strong finch
#

Mr Owl exists before the beginning of Roots

exotic rock
#

@little garnet Thanks! ^^

clever ridge
#

i honestly don't remember all the characters appeared in this game, maybe i should re-play all games againšŸ˜‚

fossil socket
#

Is it just me or do I have the feeling Dale is a descendant of the Eilander family?

round hare
#

I was thinking the same thing

#

But I can’t say why

fossil socket
#

I mean, Paradise is the same island as the hotel, right?

#

So, I assume that either Laura or Dale is a descendant of the Eilander family

#

Knowing this franchise, there are ties somewhere between the premium games

round hare
#

Yes it is the same island

#

For sure

torn seal
#

I was thinking that the connection was that hotel is the same island? And @fossil socket Laura is the baby in the end of roots i thought? She's one of the vanderbooms.

fossil socket
#

Yes.

round hare
#

But aside from investigating her death, what does Dale have to do with anything?

#

There must be some kind of connection

fossil socket
#

Indeed. If you look at his birthday, Mr Rabbit didn't go there for no reason. Dale has a connection to the lake, somehow

round hare
#

Mr. Owl called him the chosen one in previous games

#

So the lake chose Dale the same way it chose Jakob in paradise

#

The question is why Dale

fossil socket
#

Indeed

twin drift
#

I thought maybe Dale is baby William all grown up?

#

Do we know what Rose did with the baby?

vague imp
#

Isn't the baby Laura Vanderboom :o

twin drift
#

I thought the baby was William re-born?

vague imp
#

Yup reborn as Laura I think

twin drift
#

I mean... Wouldn't the baby be a boy though?

vague imp
#

Nope XD

twin drift
#

Yeah I read the timeline you're right.

#

Weird

shy pecan
#

It makes you wonder if that qualifies as being trans or if souls are without gender.

twin drift
#

Given the era (sadly) I doubt William would uave been openly trans, i guess souls don't have gender, it is noteable that no matter whose corrupted soul it is the soul is androgenous.

twin drift
#

Okay so actually I've noted another thing that appears to be a gender switch, Harvey, the wiki says Harvey is a girl but anthropomorphic Harvey looks like a male.
Also I'm wondering if not all the animals are human>animal but some are animal>human, as far as we know no one else has turned completely in to their animal Harvey is the only one who is ever actually a parrot and we know from roots animals can take the elixr and become immortal, so I wonder is Harvey is actually a parrot (maybe also would explain why they're not called Mister/Mrs Parrot)

round hare
#

Harvey is transgender

#

And it’s true, we haven’t seen Harvey’s human form yet, so maybe he started out as a parrot

#

I really want an origin story for Harvey

twin drift
#

This is from the wiki

round hare
#

Yeeee

#

Harvey is male presenting and has a male name

#

But lays eggs in Seasons

twin drift
#

Harvey is a unisex name

round hare
#

Is it?

twin drift
#

I believe so?

round hare
#

Oh I didn’t know that

#

Ok everything I looked up says it’s unisex but slightly leaning toward male

twin drift
#

Yeah same, I love it as a girls name though!

#

Sounds like the main character of an adventure story.

#

Either way though I hope Harvey get more development, would be cool if they were trans.

round hare
#

Harvey making a cameo for 5 seconds in Paradise healed me

twin drift
#

Yeah, given how long Harvey appears to have lived I'd say they're immortal.

round hare
#

But that means even Caroline/Jakob weren’t the first to make the elixir

#

How did Harvey get it

#

I need to knowwww

twin drift
#

Well Harvey wasn't necessarily immortal in Paradise.

round hare
#

Oh yeah

twin drift
#

Could have got it the same way the dog got it.

round hare
#

Someone had to make it though šŸ¤”

#

Someone who instantly died

twin drift
#

Yeah, is that a rule that two people always have to take the elixr and one of them dies?

round hare
#

Yes that’s why it’s called the elixir of life AND death

twin drift
#

Idk why he took the elixr once he saw the Dog wasn't dead lmao XD

round hare
#

James didn’t know

#

Poor, poor James

twin drift
#

Fair

#

I feel like William was tricked also

round hare
#

I’m still confused as to why William reincarnated as Laura

#

Was he trying to get a second shot at making the elixir?

strong finch
#

idk

#

maybe he thought he had died unfairly?

twin drift
#

It was Aldous who arranged for him to be ressurected though, I felt like William was just doing what he was told.

round hare
#

Did Laura ever interact with Mr. Crow though

twin drift
#

Over the phone

round hare
#

Ohhh

twin drift
#

I think

round hare
#

Yeah you’re right

twin drift
#

It's inplied she did.

round hare
#

ā€œAll that you touch you changeā€
ā€œNew phone who disā€

strong finch
#

šŸ“ž

vague imp
#

I've replayed the series like 3 times and I still have the most basic idea in the world of what's going on

#

the story from what I can tell (including rusty lake paradise)

The lake has been around for a while, at least over a hundred years going by the dates in cube escape. it requires sacrifices or else it unleashes plagues on paradise/rusty lake hotel. It also seems to influence people into discovering the elixir but the current elixer must be repeatedly drunk so it isn't the 'true' elixir Mr crow and Mr owl are looking for.

the eilanders had all been given the elixir and their lake mandated fursonas but Mr owl hired Harvey from...somewhere and got them all to eat each other and turned them into corrupted souls, who then broke out nd forced Harvey to become an immortal parrot.

twin drift
#

I don't see how all the Eilanders could have been given the Elixr since for each person who gains immortality someone else dies.

vague imp
#

the Vanderbooms have spent 4 generations trying to ressurect a crusty old dude they've never met and then succeeded in creating a vessel (laura) who was then...killed by said crusty old dude and had her memories fed to the lake??

#

I don't think it's an equal exchange because the dog and Mr crow gained immortality and only William was corrupted, it does seem like some kind of chance though

#

but dale came to investigate and he was captured and given to the lake with the lake or Mr. owl changing his bad memories to good ones so he doesnt become corrupted

twin drift
#

No William died for Aldous to get immortality and the first guy in Roots who I forget the name of gave the Elixr to the dog to test its saftey then drank it himself not knowing about the equal exchabge.

vague imp
#

and now Mr crow created the gold cube which is probably part of the final elixer

#

oh yeah you're right

#

wait then the eilanders got their immortality directly from the lake?

#

because they were all in immortal forms for a while

round hare
#

elixir = fursona juice is exactly what I was thinking šŸ˜‚

twin drift
#

I don't think the people in hotel are the Eilanders, the way the Eilanders wore the masks made it sewm more symbolic and worshipful.

#

They're personalities don't really match up save Mister Boar.

vague imp
#

if u want immortality u gotta pay the price (living in a fursuit forever)

#

im confused then because they did all seem to have drunk the elixer before they came to rusty lake

#

could they be the Vanderbooms somehow?

twin drift
#

The guests at Hotel certainly did but they're not the Eilanders. We've seen Miss Partridge in hwr human form even it's not the sister.

#

In theatre I beleive.

vague imp
#

dang

#

well I'm back to knowing nothing have a nice day

distant mirage
#

why the corrupted soul, who afaik is william, kills laura, who afaik is also william, reincarnated, is the biggest wtf in the story for me

twin drift
#

How do we know the corrupted soul is William?

distant mirage
#

somewhere, we found out that the elixir that made aldous into mr crow killed william and made him into the corrupted soul -- maybe roots or the cave, i think

twin drift
#

I remember Ailliam dying I don't remember him being corrupted though.

distant mirage
#

most the other things i don't understand i'm pretty cool with, because they mostly come down to details about how the elixir works or backstory things like where harvey initially came from, and although i'd like to fill in those blanks, they don't just totally stump me

#

i'd have to replay to find the place where that's indicated, but i'm 95% sure i'm right about it

round hare
#

I agree, I don’t get why Laura is killed

#

And William does get corrupted in Roots I believe

twin drift
#

Okay I read the wiki, I didn't realise in roots you plau as the corrupted soul but the wiki ends it at hin being reborn as Laura, William isn't the soul that killed Laura.

round hare
#

But doesn’t Laura go back in time to kill herself or something

distant mirage
#

he's both, that's what i find mystifying

round hare
#

Idk actually what’s going on at any point

twin drift
#

The wiki says nothing about him being both or killing Laura.

distant mirage
#

i actually don't even mind him being both the corrupted soul and laura -- even that, i can go, all right, this is the world

twin drift
#

There's no evidence the soup that killed Laura is William, that I've seen.

#

*soul

distant mirage
#

the corrupted soul kills laura in seasons, that's definite, and i think we're supposed to take the one humanoid/non-animallish corrupted soul as the same entity throughout the games

twin drift
#

I disagree, unless wehave some major time travel shenanigans I think it's a different person.

distant mirage
#

wait, why would there need to be time travel?

round hare
#

Seasons does involve time travel though??

twin drift
#

Yeah the entire plot of Seasons is time travel shenanigans as is Birthday. But I think people can only travel back to past memories.

distant mirage
#

but why would william being both the corrupted soul and laura necessitate time travel?

#

unless i'm missing something, that's the kind of thing i'm happy to just hand-wave off as "yes, because weirdness"

#

incomprehensible character decisions/motivations trip me up a lot more

twin drift
#

Cos if he's both that's requiring him to be in two places at once, Laura has his soul she is him ressurected, so unless there was timetravel how would his also corrupted soul be there? This seem like to big a plot point to wave off with weirdness. Arming a bear trap with worm and having it catch a fish in the middle of the garden is weirdness, this is the plot.

distant mirage
#

yeah none of that bothers me

#

as soon as we have an elixir that always kills one person and makes another person immortal (dogs are people too), i'm pretty ok with any bending of metaphysics

#

and time travel generally -- if i can get on board with that, there's not much as far as constructing a magical reality that will really bug me

#

stuff i'd like to know because it's interesting, but not stuff that feels incomprehensible

#

i watched the movie Looper with a couple friends a while back, and one of them immediately launched into an enthusiastic conversation with me about how awesome it was, and the other was like, "but -- if he shot himself, he couldn't be there to shoot himself"

#

looking too closely at that side of logic in time travel stories, or clearly weird, twin-peaks-inflected stories, time travel or not, can just ruin them for you

#

and i like rustly lake, so to keep liking it, i'm more than willing to let it set up any weird rules of reality it wants

twin drift
#

Nah it makes sense for him to still exist if he shot himself since it would just create an alternate timeline, he's from the timeline where he didn't get shot so he's all G. I haven't seen the movie but that makes sense from what you said.

distant mirage
#

the plot hangs on it being one timeline, unfortunately

#

and it's really good, see it, definitely one of my favorite sci-fi movies of all time

#

although maybe wait a few months now that i gave away the big ending moment

twin drift
#

Besides that seems like a hole I'd be willing to look over. The same person being in two places at once for no reason other than to drive the story isn't, plus I don't feel like the creators of Rusty Lake would do something as sloppy as that.

distant mirage
#

i don't know that there's anything sloppy about it

#

it's just something they haven't yet explained

twin drift
#

Exactly

distant mirage
#

if it never gets explained, that would probably be a mistake, but i'm operating on the notion that there's something there

twin drift
#

That's what I've been saying.

gentle parcel
#

We know very little about Laura. The deciding question is to what extent was she aware of her past life as William?

#

Also, who killed her? Was she a sacrifice to the lake or did someone have unfinished business with her or William or was it both?

twin drift
#

All we know is a corrupted soul killed her.

gentle parcel
#

Yes, but whose is the question

gentle parcel
#

Speaking of who kills whom and why, if the Eilanders from Paradise really are the hotel guests (and that's a pretty big if), that gives Mr Owl a pretty decent motive for wanting them dead

#

After all, they killed his mother and him

twin drift
#

We've seen the woman beleived to be Ms Pheasant in Theatre, and it's not the sister from Paradise. Furthermore there are character profiles for all the guests in Hotel and they are all born at least 50 years after Paradise.

gentle parcel
#

Well, we've seen the actress portraying her. I'm still not too sure what to make of Theatre. And we all know time has little meaning in this series.

#

I'm not saying they are the hotel guests, but it's something to consider. This constellation can't have been coincidental.

#

Maybe the hotel guests are the Eilanders reborn.

shy pecan
#

Yeah, I have trouble with the corrupted soul with what it is and how it killed Laura.

#

It might be that there are two entities in her body. The devs are fans of Twin Peaks, and there's a character like that in it.

#

Though I'm generally not thrilled to have to reverence outside media.

gentle parcel
#

Without being familiar with Twin Peaks, I had the same impression about Laura

#

It'd make sense too, because she's William reborn, but she's also very much her own person

humble wagon
#

Damn now i wanna watch Twin Peaks

shy pecan
#

I wish there was something like the diary of Laura Vanderboom.

round hare
#

Haha I literally just got to that part in Twin Peaks last night

#

The diary, I mean

mystic star
#

Anywhere i can watch this?

#

Hmm I see, on netflix just not in my country

twin drift
#

I thought Twin Peaks was a game?

distant mirage
#

it was a tv series, orginally in 1990-91, revived last year

mystic star
#

It is on another streaming service, yikes don't wanna subscribe to a third one xD

gentle parcel
#

Just stream it illegally

#

Come to the dark side

strong finch
#

we have cookies

thin elk
#

COOKIES

#

Steals the cookies and then runs away

mystic star
#

So now there are no cookies😬

fresh badger
#

yes but do you have coffee

twin drift
#

I don't think he meant the edible kind of cookies

mystic star
#

Sad

strong finch
#

Are you saying my cookies aren't quality ones?

twin drift
#

I assumed you meant internet cookies that get put on your computer when you downlaod stuff to monitor your browsing habits.

mystic star
#

But how do you suppose that lures people to the dark side

strong finch
#

They are tasty

mystic star
#

That just gives me a general google search x)

distant mirage
#

It should be an images search for images, e.g. t-shirts, posters, etc., with the phrase

mystic star
#

Oh I thought I was looking at one about computer cookies yeah I know about this one

distant mirage
#

Yeah, the link was really for people who didn't recognize the line, not for people who do ;)

mystic star
#

Yeah, and the dark side got me a long time ago already šŸ˜„

vague imp
#

wowowow, that end was soo fast, so i think im gonna read this whole chat

round hare
#

Why would you subject yourself to that

vague imp
#

okay, thats too much

round hare
#

šŸ˜‚

vague imp
#

so the island is hotel

#

the player, what happens to him?

#

he bruns

#

burns*

#

is he dead?

round hare
#

No

humble wagon
#

He gets reincarnated as Mr. Owl

#

I think

vague imp
#

okay

round hare
#

He accidentally makes the elixir

#

The last ingredient was a cube

vague imp
#

is laura an animal?

distant mirage
#

transformed into mr owl, i think -- he's not reborn, like william is

#

it's more like the transofrmation of aldous into mr crow

humble wagon
#

Yeah that's more accurate

round hare
#

Laura’s just human

vague imp
#

so your family are the hotel guests

humble wagon
#

No she is just William's reincarnation

round hare
#

Possibly, it was unclear

distant mirage
#

they're two sets of people, at two different times

#

same place, the island

humble wagon
#

Aaa maybe. We actually don't know there isn't any info about that

distant mirage
#

same set of animal associations

#

but we don't know exactly what the significance of that is

vague imp
#

they had these masks so they are the animals probably

#

or a refference

#

who is mr crow

round hare
#

Aldous Vanderboom

vague imp
#

oh yeah

#

and harvey?

round hare
#

We don’t know

distant mirage
#

harvey is a MYSTERY

vague imp
#

lol

#

next game is cube escape, right?

round hare
#

Yee

humble wagon
#

Yep

vague imp
#

i love rusty lake

#

uhm

#

i rly wanna know what the story is

#

btw gtg now

#

bye

#

one more question

#

Whats the scariest part in all the games

#

cube and premium

distant mirage
#

for me, the timed thing at the end of harvey's box where you have to. . . what is it, use fireflies on a corrupted soul, i think?

round hare
#

imo Mr. Rabbit jumpscare in the window in Birthday

vague imp
#

Mine in hotel, when you are at the rabbit, outside there is the black rabbit ghost thing

round hare
#

YES that was creepy roo

#

Too

vague imp
#

gtg

humble wagon
#

For me was that fucking corrupted soul going after you

shy pecan
#

Scariest for me was in seasons when you're looking at the moon and see Laura's throat being slashed. I still dread it when I play that one.

honest magnet
#

for me it's either being chased by the deer man at the end of Cse 23 or going up from the basement in The Mill and seeing all the damage the corrupted soul has done

vague imp
#

the deer spirit in case 23 is absolutely the scariest god

vague imp
#

Guys, first of all : SPOILER ALERT

#

At the end of Paradise you can get a secret Owl mask, you can give it to your mother, it's an achievement, does this means that your mother is Mr. Owl?

#

Can this be true or am i just stupid

azure sluice
#

I think its one of his Reincarnation

vague imp
#

Yeah

azure sluice
#

But he supposed to live forever. So maybe its before the elixr .

vague imp
#

Possible

distant mirage
#

The mother's memories show that she sent you away to keep you safe so the rest of the family wouldn't sacrifice you; instead, they sacrifice her

#

You then return to the island, and in bringing her memories together, you create the elixir

#

Your family sacrifices you, but instead of just being sacrificed, you turn into Mr Owl

vague imp
#

wow

#

Since you are a mod, is Rusty Lake telling you things about the story?

distant mirage
#

No

vague imp
#

kk, is it on the wiki?

distant mirage
#

I don't know

vague imp
#

kk

distant mirage
#

I just figured that out from playing the game

vague imp
#

k

#

cool

strong finch
#

Was Jakob's mother reborn, too?

distant mirage
#

My thought is no -- she seems to become a corrupted soul, based on her appearances on the island

#

I don't know of any later characters that seem to resemble her in any way, but you never know

#

Maybe she's Harvey <3

strong finch
#

Hm, but Harvey already appears before Jakob dies

#

Also, is Jakob the voice that says "The x Plague, x?

#

Dang

distant mirage
#

Oh, she does, you're right, the mom can't be Harvey

#

I'm joking about that, anyway, although it would have been cute

strong finch
#

Yeah

distant mirage
#

I think he is... in which case, the game itself is his memories?

#

So meta

strong finch
#

But if Jakob's the man who says "The X Plague, X", his voice seems to transform into Mr. Owl's voice the more you progress into the game

distant mirage
#

I didn't notice a change in voice

#

I thought the plague announcements were voiced by the same actor as Mr Owl, I just hadn't thought about the ramifications

#

The accent might be different, not sure

white beacon
#

I think all of the voices are the same actor

#

so not sure that tells us much

twin drift
#

Yeah I got the impression they have a man and a woman who do all the human voices.

white beacon
#

no i don't think there's a woman

#

think it's jst bob rafferty

#

*just

#

the eilander women definitely sounded like they were voiced by men

shy pecan
#

Yeah, like Monty Python.

dim edge
#

Yes it was all Bob Rafferty, except for the Corrupted Soul (Maarten did this).

strong finch
#

The corrupted souls have some sort of French accent

#

I guess we now know where people go when they die

round hare
#

šŸ˜‚

humble wagon
#

Do y'all have a favourite music track in Rusty Lake? I think my favourite would be "Vanderboom Family Time"

shy pecan
#

My favorite is from theater. The slow horns and piano.

strong finch
#

Mine is the Main Roots Theme

shadow stump
#

I was thinking about that:
When a human become a human animal (as mister crow did), do you think the human chooses what animal he becomes or it s random?

rotund wing
#

i like to think that they dont really ā€œchooseā€ their animal, their personality determines what animal they become

shadow stump
#

I just noticed that there’s a crow on mister crow’s family emblem. Maybe it’s related by a way or another?

rotund wing
#

possibly? maybe its more of ā€œwhich animal is related to you moreā€ based on either family emblems/symbols or personality, or both ?

shadow stump
#

Maybe

#

It’s just that i feel like mister crow already knew that he would become a crow, which would explain why there’s a crow on the emblem

#

Still, I prefer the idea that the animal you become is determined by your personality

round hare
#

The elixir is fursona juice

rotund wing
#

funny you mention that

round hare
#

Oh

copper hawk
#

Hello.
Even though I just arrived, I wanted to share with you some... Uh...
It's not really a theory because I have the answer...
And not a discovery because of the answer...
Well I'll just start...
I am a big fan of Rusty Lake and I was thinking
"This place is just too damn cool I hope it exists in real life."
So I made my researches.
You'd be surprised that there are 3 or 4 "Rusty Lake" lakes ins the world x)
But the one that caught my attention is Rusty Lake, Leaf Rapids, Manitoba, Canada.
You see, upon closer inspection, I found a place on that lake that has a similar map to what we see in the games.

#

If you rotate the map by 180°, it's exactly the same

#

You even have "mountains" and hills in the same spots

carmine patio
#

That's neat

copper hawk
#

BUT THAT'S NOT ALL

#

The lake is near a little city named Leaf Rapids

#

This city is I think the village of little 9 yo Dale, and Laura (we know it's the same town because of the white flowered tree that we see in both Birthday and Case 23)

#

The layout of houses is similar to what we see in Birthday

#

As hinted by the drawing of little Dale, some houses have randomly black roofs

#

and an interesting little detail :

#

on the same drawing, the houses are... blue...

#

bu Laura's house is white

#

a childish choice ?

#

I don't think so

#

for the houses in Leaf Rapids are painted in a white coloured paint...

#

supposed to become blue with pollution

#

witch never happened because there is no pollution .-.

thin elk
#

So what you're saying is there's a whole town in Canada all of us needs to visit? :D

copper hawk
#

SADLY

#

I showed my discoveries to Rusty Lake...

#

And...

#

Um...

#

It's disappointing, to say the least...

carmine patio
#

what if that's what they want you to think lol

thin elk
#

Still more reasons to visit Canada.

copper hawk
#

Yeah, it's too coincidental to not be real

thin elk
#

Canada is a good country, hope I can get there someday

copper hawk
#

Btw, Leaf Rapids is now a ghost town

thin elk
#

Is it populated by animal-headed people?

#

Wait, nvm

#

I read that wrong

copper hawk
#

It's a little village that built itself in a anarchic manner in months because of mine exploitations, but they quickly emptied the place .-.

#

(mines ? A Cave perhaps ?)

thin elk
#

Someone needs to start a mental resort in there :D

copper hawk
#

They sure should x)

#

This is my biggest theory so far x)

#

and the more fleshed out

#

Now I have a question I hope you can answer...

#

WHY VAN GOGH ?!?

#

Why is he in EVERY

#

SINGLE GAME

#

Even in Paradise !

thin elk
#

Good question

copper hawk
#

Why does Arles exists ? Why is there a representation of Van Gogh in every game that came after it ? It just seems out of place, and yet I feel like there is a deeper meaning, something that wraps up the hole story and put the pieces together...

#

And yes, it's so weird that even in the Rusty Lake universe, it doesn't make any sense. It's that intense of a question XD

thin elk
#

My best bet is that he might be somehow connected to the whole story, whether it being through him becoming Bob in a new life or something like that

copper hawk
#

Bob... Uh... Bob...
Oh yeah, Bob, Laura's boyfriend, right ?

thin elk
#

Correct

copper hawk
#

He's just so ignored in the story .-.

#

yet he is the center of Theatre

#

Btw, Laura getting killed... Well ! So much of a successful reincarnation, right ?
It sure was worth slaughtering your descendents, William...

thin elk
#

Eh, they would die anyway, lel

#

I mean, c'mon, doesn't everyone die? Might as well get reborn while he's at it

copper hawk
#

Btw, I'm just thinking about the signification of the 10 sacrifices right now

#

(I have a huge time line with every event in every game were I can have a sense of datation, so I don't have to search too long)

#

The tongue of someone that drank the elixir
The tears of a loving mother
The eyes of the couple that saw the future
The teeth of... idk, he just needed teeth .-.
The amputated foot of a war hero
The brain of a psycho
The hair of someone that got abused
The blood of the future mother
And finally, the victim's heart

thin elk
#

Thong? I'm fairly certain you mean tongue

copper hawk
#

Yeah, english is not my native language...

thin elk
#

It's fine.

#

Neither is mine

#

It's just that thong is a very different thing than tongue :D

copper hawk
#

huh .-.

#

OH

#

OH YEAH

#

Oh ok XD

#

My bad x)

thin elk
#

Happens to the best of us c:

copper hawk
#

The teeth, though...

#

I don't know how it's a relevant sacrifice .-.

thin elk
#

Which one sacrificed teeth tho?

copper hawk
#

Mary

#

Jame's wife

thin elk
#

Hm

copper hawk
#

The one that gave birth to Emma, Samuel and Albert

#

I mean, it's not like she eats a lot...

#

We hardly even see her .-.

#

Btw, wtf is it with weird births, in the game ?
Albert drinks wine as a baby ?
Emma gets impregnanted by flowers ?
ALBERT RIPS IDA IN HALF TO COLLECT HER EGGS AND IMPREGNANT THEM IN VITRO WITH HIS SPERM IN A WEIRD MACHINERY ?!?

#

Even the rebirth of William makes more sense that the one of Rose .-.

thin elk
#

Someone needs to have the birds and the bees fish talk xD

copper hawk
#

x)

#

Rusty Lake, wtf is wrong with you ?

thin elk
#

Just about everything, and we love it

copper hawk
#

That's... Very correct x)

#

Oh, and since I have that huge timeline, it's interesting to see that Arles takes place in 1888
Just between Masks (spring 1885) and The Clock (spring 1889)

#

So... Van Gogh is clearly not a Vanderboom...

#

At least not in the branch of the family we see

#

but he is about Emma, Samuel and Albert's age

#

Maybe a bit older

#

I even have the precise date of Arles

#

23 dec 1888

#

the day he cut his ear

thin elk
#

Uhm, you can track down when the three were born, and compare it to actual birthday of Van Gogh

copper hawk
#

he was 35

#

Childbirth was in...

#

1867

#

so they are about 21 during Arles

#

yeah...

#

Considering that Van Gogh is german, like the Vanderboom and Vandermeer, that Arles is in France and Rusty Lake most likely in Canada...

#

Oh, it's a mess

#

Oh, and Canada was invaded by France in 1534, so it holds up

#

even considering Paradise (1796)

thin elk
#

Van Gogh isn't german, he's dutch

copper hawk
#

He is...

#

Oh yeah ?

#

Oh well

thin elk
#

So are the Vanderboom and Vandermeer

copper hawk
#

But...

#

Oh .-.

#

Ok

#

Still a big mess

thin elk
#

Well, we know that Van Gogh actually visited Arles

#

And Rusty Lake really doesn't have to be in Canada

copper hawk
#

Yeah, he pretty much painted every sunflowers, his chamber and his chopped off ear self portrait in Arles

thin elk
#

Exactly

copper hawk
#

And honestly, the only other "Rutsy Lake"s are not that likely to be the ones from the games .-.

#

Except if it's really just a big coincidence and they just imagined all of it

thin elk
#

Rusty Lake itself, judging by the last names of residents, is more likely to be in Netherlands

copper hawk
#

or if they took the Rusty Lake in Canada and put it who knows where

thin elk
#

That's probably what happened

#

I mean, c'mon, Rusty Lake uses hebrew as a part of their puzzles

copper hawk
#

Wut ?

#

Where ?

#

Never seen it .-.

#

Are you sure you're not talking about hindi ?

thin elk
#

Crap, sorry, I mixed the two together

copper hawk
#

x)

thin elk
#

Yes, Hindi

copper hawk
#

There even is a word in... Lao... Laotien ?... La..... How is it called ? .-.

thin elk
#

Idk

#

There's a lot of stuff

copper hawk
#

Laotian

#

It's Laotian

#

On the box in Birthday, there are two word, one in Hindi and one in Laotian

#

(They both mean ghost)

#

or something like that

#

ą¤Ŗą„ą¤°ą„‡ą¤¤ (pret) means "soul"
and ą»€ąŗœąŗ” (phed) means "spirit which is unable to be reborn"

#

btw, I found out that someone actually translated every word in the games AFTER I did it myself, so... yeah

#

I had to search the language, how to wright it and what it meant XD

#

I love to suffer, apparently

#

ą¤¦ą„‡ą¤µ (dava) God (the cubes)
ą¤®ą¤¾ą¤Øą„ą¤· (maanush) Human
ą¤…ą¤øą„ą¤° (asur) Asura, surnatural being (angel/demon) (the human-animals hybrids)
ą¤¤ą¤æą¤°ą„ą¤Æą¤—ą„ą¤Æą„‹ą¤Øą¤æ (tiryagyoni) Tiryagyoni, name of the buddhist animal’s state
नरक (narak) Hell (blood forest)
ą¤Ŗą„ą¤°ą„‡ą¤¤ (pret) Ghost (souls)
ą»€ąŗœąŗ” (phed) Spirit unable to reborn

#

in fact those six things ARE the buddhist 6 states of life

#

Paradise, humans, animals, souls, Asuras and hell

#

And the Lake... represents the 6 of them all at once

#

(Yes, the Lake is part sentient)

#

(Or at least the spirit of the Lake, or a being that lives in it)

#

(Yes, I did A LOT of research)

stray token
#

You sure did

#

But it's pretty refreshing :)

copper hawk
#

Oh, I'm doing a bit of research right now about the story of the elixir of life in alchemy

#

most of them are based on mercury, arsenic, and other highly toxic materials...
So yeah, If they really did find it in Rusty Lake, it's no wonder why William and James died...

#

And interestingly enough, India did a lot of alchemy too

#

And some fundamental alchemy principles comes from buddhist texts...

#

That's REALLY interesting

copper hawk
#

Considering the other great principle of Rutsy Lake mythology is buddhist...

#

Now, how do we link all this...
To the 10 plagues of Egypt in Paradise ?...

#

x)

thin elk
#

Good question

#

Especially since there's only seven

copper hawk
#

?

#

Why do you say that ?

#

oh

#

No, there are 10

thin elk
#

There's only seven original plagues

copper hawk
#

What ?

#

What are you saying ? XD

thin elk
#

Seven Plagues of Egypt

copper hawk
#

no, there are 10 in the Bible x)

thin elk
#

Wut

#

I always thought there were seven O:

copper hawk
#

1 water becomes blood
2 frogs come from the sky
3 dust becomes mosquitos
4 flies from the nearby countries just hang around in just one of them
5 the death of the cows and other domestic animals
6 sickness
7 hail storms
8 grass hoppers
9 darkness
10 death of the first borns

hallow geode
#

Hail which becomes fire for some reasons

copper hawk
#

?!?

#

Wut ?

hallow geode
#

Yes

copper hawk
#

Oh yeah

#

You're right XD

hallow geode
#

Thunderstorm and firehail

#

Fuck the logic it's the bible

copper hawk
#

Solid oxygen is really easily flammable, i think it's because of that

#

Theoretically it's possible

#

You just have to get some serious pressure and low temperature up there

hallow geode
#

Tfw god has a PhD in chemistry

copper hawk
#

He INVENTED chemestry

hallow geode
#

But who invented god

copper hawk
#

god

#

x)

hallow geode
#

šŸ‘€

copper hawk
#

Hey, in buddhism, humans invented themselves, so...

#

that's not the point

#

also

#

how did the soul of Caroline curse the island ?.......

#

THE MORE YOU ANSWER QUESTIONS, THE LESS IT MAKES SENSE
That's why I love those games

round hare
#

Where was Van Gogh in rusty lake paradise? :0

thin elk
#

I don't think it was Caroline who cursed the island, but rather her presence was protecting the island from whatever the hell the lake is

copper hawk
#

When Elizabeth cuts Gerald's ear

hallow geode
#

Or the elixir was the curse

round hare
#

OH

#

I never noticed that omg

thin elk
#

And when Caroline died, her presence was no longer there

#

Which meant that Lake can wreck stuff up

copper hawk
#

She gives him a hair cut...
And... She's blind...
So yeah...
And Rusty Lake don't make jokes
Everything has a signification...
And this ear cutting doesn't mean anything...
Except if you consider that since it takes place literally 57 years before Van Gogh was even born and that they ALWAYS put a reference to Van Gogh, so obviously they can't put a painting...

thin elk
#

Why would you even let your blind niece give you a haircut?

copper hawk
#

Do you really think that this pig is clever enough to think about that ?...

hallow geode
#

What if he was Vincent van derboom

copper hawk
#

I thought about it

hallow geode
#

Or idk the elixir seems to give you a different form ( mr owl / aldous vanderboom)

copper hawk
#

but he can't be from the same branch of the Vanderboom we see in Roots
During Arles, he is 35, ans the 3 siblings are 21
So he can't be Jame's son

hallow geode
#

So maybe he's an heir of idk

#

Rose ? Frank ?

copper hawk
#

No, Emma, Samuel and Albert

hallow geode
#

Oh

#

Forgot the date

#

Of roota

#

Roots

copper hawk
#

So

#

Maybe he is another descendant of William and... Crow... I always forget his real name...

#

But a third one

#

(yes, a third one, I think the Vandermeer are the descendant of..... Crow...)

#

Aldous

#

That's his name

hallow geode
#

What if van Gogh

#

Is the dog

copper hawk
#

uh .-.

hallow geode
#

Aldous is owl

copper hawk
#

Owl is Jakob Eilander

#

Crow is Aldous Vanderboom

#

Van Gogh is born in 1853, the dog becomes immortal in 1870, Arles takes place in 1888, and we find the dog again in The Cave in 1972

hallow geode
#

šŸ¤”

copper hawk
#

So it's... unlikely .-.

hybrid elm
#

Aldous is crow yeah!
Also I always had a HC that the Vandermeer are defendant of a third sibling tbh
(Also y'all rmemebir dates and making connections I just now realized there was a Van Gogh reference in paradise.dllglsƱld)

copper hawk
#

I don't remember them

hallow geode
#

Maybe there is a lake in a van Gogh painting

hybrid elm
#

Van Gogh is Harvey (?

Also maybe?

copper hawk
#

I just made a time line precise to the month from 1796 to 1972 with EVERY ELEMENTS OF EVERY GAME YET

#

Except Samsara room

hybrid elm
#

That's amazing!!!!! I should do the same becsye my memory is....bad LMFAO

copper hawk
#

But I guess it's in the 1970's

hybrid elm
#

I thought samsara was not a part of the Cube Escape/RL series????
But I think it was in the 70's yeah

copper hawk
#

I'm planning to put on this timeline every important character, in what game they appear, and in witch of the 6 states of life they are

#

For now, I did the life of every Eilander

#

It's not part of the series per say...
But clearly, it's in the same universe

hallow geode
#

Tfw I follow a let's play of those games

#

And the yt is at roots

hybrid elm
#

Oh yeah it's definetly part of the series tho I never took it as like a part of it???? I rmeemebbe totally loving it tho, I ssjould replay it

copper hawk
#

I just played them all

#

ALL OF THEM

hybrid elm
#

Same

#

Same

copper hawk
#

I even got the Hotel / Birthday lore easter egg

hybrid elm
#

When paradise came out I played them all in a row in a day or two....
I haven't been the same since then (? Lmao

#

SamE!

hallow geode
#

What is it

copper hawk
#

if you finish hotel 100%

#

you have a code

#

a date, in fact

hybrid elm
#

And you can use it in Birthday

copper hawk
#

the date when Hotel takes place

hallow geode
#

Oh yeah like the Easter egg between seasons and the one

#

Cabin

#

IIRC

copper hawk
#

if you put it in the snow globe of the Hotel in Birthday

#

you get a new cinematic, that is what happens right after hotel

hallow geode
#

What happened to dale

copper hawk
#

Dale... Uh

#

No news of him since The Cave

hybrid elm
#

I should replay birthday because I don't rmemmeb that ciinematic

#

sorry I'm on mobile and I Can't Type Without Typosā„¢

copper hawk
#

What happens in it is, the souls of the Asuras (hybrids) escape, try to kill Owl and Harvey, but Harvey changes himself in a simple bird, (witch is permanent) and fly off not to get himself killed, while owl GTFO with Crow on a boat, and the souls just go to the bottom of the Lake

hallow geode
#

Permanent ?

copper hawk
#

I think Bat did the same as Harvey, since we see him as a simple bat in The Cave

hallow geode
#

That's why Harvey is "human" only in hotel

#

And not the other game?

hybrid elm
#

Ohhhh yqh I wasn't sure if that was shown in birthday or Hotel, thanks!!!

And yup

copper hawk
#

I mean, I think it's permanent, otherwise, he could've just become an Asura again and rip the box open with his height...

hallow geode
#

Who is Harvey

#

Who WAS Harvey ?

copper hawk
#

I think Harvey was born like this

hallow geode
#

Like the guests in Hotel?

copper hawk
#

The guests are the Eilander family

hybrid elm
#

Harvey is the MC in Hotel, I think

#

Like, who you play as

hallow geode
#

Yeah

#

He is

#

Why do you kill the guests tho

hybrid elm
#

Also I think Mr Rabbit isn't a Eilander

#

Since he doesn't match the guys rabbit mask AND there is two rabbits in the game

#

A white one and Mr Rabbit (that's a brown rabbit)

hallow geode
#

Mr rabbit wasn't the rabbit who killed the family of dale ?

hybrid elm
#

Yeah but again this colors..don't match? The one who killed SDales family is a white rsbbbut too

hallow geode
#

He dyed his hair

#

Lul

hybrid elm
#

Ldlflslflld

#

Aestheticā„¢ (?

round hare
#

They can be the same if he’s a snowshoe hare

#

Their fur turns white in winter

#

Birthday takes place in winter

hybrid elm
#

also when you check the "tanks" in Mr Owls room, the siluete matches the rabbit that appears in Mr Rabbits window more than Mr Rabbits siluete...if I Remember well??

#

TouchƩ

copper hawk
#

The guests are the Eilander family, that got killed by Caroline's curse, but brought back to life by the lake and turned into Asuras, just like Jakob become Owl.
But after their transformation they became different :
Nicholas was a religious fanatic, and became a scientist
David was down to earth and became a magician
Elizabeth was blind and so she didn't care about her appearance, she became an actress
The grandmother (I don't recall her name) was against all type of technology, she became an electrician searcher...
Only Gerald didn't change... He's still a big fat pig...

hallow geode
#

Eat shit gerald

hybrid elm
#

Geralt stayed true to his nature...

#

The only one who is not Fakeā„¢ (?

copper hawk
#

No, they're all real

#

but their rebirth just made them different

hybrid elm
#

No yeah I'm joking!! Like, he ain't Fakeā„¢ becsye he remained a pig while the rest "changed" lgldla sorry I joke too mucch

copper hawk
#

Gerald have more heart than he has brain...
And he doesn't have a heart .-. (figuratively and literally)
So changing personality ?!? No way

round hare
#

So did Mr. Owl spend a ton of money making an entire hotel just so he could get revenge on his family in a fashionable way

copper hawk
#

Yup

hybrid elm
#

Yeah

round hare
#

I love Mr. Owl

hybrid elm
#

Iconicā„¢

copper hawk
#

Btw, if you finish Paradise 100%

#

You see owl in transparency, Paradise becomes the Hotel, and he says
"Our time has come, Paradise will rise again"

hybrid elm
#

YEAH!

copper hawk
#

He

#

literally

#

just invited his family

#

to their former island

#

to kill them

#

and make them eat one another

hybrid elm
#

"Hello come to my hotel that's totally not your past lifes home so I can totally not kill you"

round hare
#

Does he just like...close down the hotel afterward??

copper hawk
#

for vengeance to what they did to him and his mother

hybrid elm
#

"Yum Yum. Delicious dinner"

#

Yeah, I mean...
A tad extreme but understandable...

round hare
#

Do you think the Eilanders all took the elixir? Because they have animal forms, also they don’t seem very afraid of death during paradise

#

They seem resistant to death actually

copper hawk
#

@round hare
The reason why we can't go to the basement in hotel is because it's like in the Cabin... It's directly connected to the room in The Cave

hybrid elm
#

Yeah they all kinda...were technically dead at some point

copper hawk
#

So he closes the hotel to visitors

#

but he keeps it as a lair

round hare
#

Villain goals

hybrid elm
#

Also idk if they took the elixir per se but I guess their aparent inmortsily has smth to do with the whole "gotta sacrifice first born for...reasons...."

copper hawk
#

There is a reason

#

the prophecy

#

Owl VS Deer

#

One is the destroyer, the other one is the saviour

hybrid elm
#

TouchƩ! Im a dummie with no memory and that takes forever to make and rmmebred connections

copper hawk
#

they don't know witch one

#

but they think the Owl is the saviour

#

But I think it's the Deer

#

For one thing

#

A detail that appears in Paradise...

#

and is never used as a clue or a jumpscare

#

"The Owls are not what they seem"

round hare
#

Twin Peaks reference

copper hawk
#

x)

#

Plus, the thing is

#

Nicholas made sacrifices to save his family

#

Jakob and Carolin were selfish and vengeful

hybrid elm
#

Yup!

copper hawk
#

so...

#

I don't think Owl is a good "saviour"

round hare
#

Smh Mr. Owl did nothing wrong in his life ever

hybrid elm
#

Tho Nicholas isn't good at all, he (or his soul) might be the saviour...

#

Dlkglsslfllslq

copper hawk
#

Nicholas isn't good

#

but Mr.Deer is

hybrid elm
#

TouchƩ!!

#

Mr. Crow is the savior I don't care anymore (?

copper hawk
#

remember, their personality totally flipped

hybrid elm
#

Jk jk

#

Yeah exactly!

copper hawk
#

same for Jakob, he is calm and kind

#

but Owl is a dick

round hare
#

Anyone have predictions for what’s going to happen in paradox

#

Assuming it takes place after the cave

#

I feel like the title refers to the paradox of Laura’s own corrupted soul(?) killing her in seasons

hybrid elm
#

I....honestly have no idea of what could happen

copper hawk
#

I don't like predictions, after, either you're not impressed because you knew
or you're disappointed because it's not as good as you thought....

hybrid elm
#

Ohhhh yeahz also Laura seems to be a character in it? (Or did I read wrong?)

round hare
#

True

hybrid elm
#

Yeah true

round hare
#

Yeah she is

#

We know that Dale, Laura, Harvey, and Mr. Crow will be in it

copper hawk
#

Obviously

#

it's either before Seasons

#

or after The Cave

hybrid elm
#

Is not a RL game without Harvey tbh

round hare
#

Harvey is the most mysterious character imo

hybrid elm
#

Yup, I would think it's after The Cave but witj RL you can't never know

#

Harvey is the real saviour (?

copper hawk
#

Harvey is one of the main reasons why I think the Vanderboom and Vandermeer are the same family

round hare
#

Why?

copper hawk
#

Roots
december 18, 1930

#

If you clic 5 times on a window

hybrid elm
#

You see Dale

#

Im replaying to get the achievement

copper hawk
#

Harvey appears and it's written on the window that Dale was born today

hybrid elm
#

Yupyup

copper hawk
#

But why say this, about a Vandermeer, in a game about the Vaderboom

#

and how does Harvey know about Dale

round hare
#

They’re definitely connected

copper hawk
#

if the two families don't at least know each other ?

#

Plus, Dale's grandpa is... I mean, clearly... It's Aldous...

hybrid elm
#

I don't think its albous but he is clearly similar

#

Maybe another sibling of Aldous and william?

#

Or a cousin?

copper hawk
#

Just think about it...
If it really is Aldous...

#

then he had a daughter

#

that married a Vandermeer

#

and she gave birth to Dale

hybrid elm
#

!!!!

copper hawk
#

And we know that Aldous is pretty much immortal

hybrid elm
#

I gotta replay birthday to see if he is THAT similar to Aldous

copper hawk
#

so it's not a stretch on the timeline

#

no

#

he is not similar to Aldous

#

he is similar

#

to the mask of Mr.Crow

hybrid elm
#

Also Mr Owl and Me Crow can turn back to their Human versions. Both did it in theatre

copper hawk
#

in Case 23

hybrid elm
#

Oh...OH

#

Too many games (?

copper hawk
#

At that time, he had enough elixir to stay an Asura

#

in Cave, he just ran out

#

(and in the mill, since we have a picture of the couple)

#

I also saw an interesting theory about Seasons

#

it is that the events of Seasons are just the memories of Laura, during the time when her body is corrupted in Mill

#

And she have to make peace with them

#

to let them go

hybrid elm
#

Ohhh gotta replay both case 23 and The Mill to see it again!

copper hawk
#

And i think that it's more likely than mine that was like "she was corrupted and so she killed herself, and her soul came back in time to kill the corruption, and her soul had a samsara to paradise"

hallow geode
#

Why would Jakob kill his family ?

hybrid elm
#

Also that was my HC of it tbh

copper hawk
#

I mean

#

if she's just reliving memories

#

the fact that she has a samsara at the end of the game is logical

#

(samsara : change of state of life)

hybrid elm
#

When I played The Mill it kinda made way more sense of it being she reviving her memories

#

Also, Liss, he did it for vengeance. They killed him and his mother.
Or at least that's the most logic motive

copper hawk
#

(I'll not explain the 6 states of life again, just search for "hell" in the Ctrl+F)

hybrid elm
#

Maybe he did it for another reason but killing them and feeding them to each other seems...pure revenge

hallow geode
#

He isn't the son of Caroline?

#

It's the elixir who killed her

copper hawk
#

no

#

she was sacrificed by the family

#

the elixir only appears in roots

round hare
#

She was trying to make the elixir

#

In paradise

hybrid elm
#

Yup, but I think she is trying to make the elixir too?

copper hawk
#

like... 64 years later...

#

no, she's trying to make sense of the prophecy

#

She's trying to know who is the saviour, between the Owl and the Deer, and who is the saviour in her family

#

To see if there is a way to save her child

#

and if the fact that she sacrifices herself will be enough

#

but she didn't find out, so she tried anyway

hybrid elm
#

Touché​!

#

Yeah, and as it didn't work they later sacrificed Jakob too

copper hawk
#

yup

#

Idk, maybe they didn't know it worked with Jakob, so they all sacrificed each other ?

hallow geode
#

Why was Jakob reborn

#

But not Caroline?

copper hawk
#

Because...

#

Because Caroline cursed the island, so the Lake wasn't as kind to revive her as it was with the rest of the family

hybrid elm
#

Maybe? And that's why they all became (you called them asuras?)
Or maybe that was the effect of the sacrifice itself

#

Yup

hallow geode
#

Wasn't her fault

#

?

copper hawk
#

she purposefully cursed the island with the 10 plagues of Egypt to purge her family and kill them all

hallow geode
#

🤷

#

Why kill Jakob?

hybrid elm
#

Iconicā„¢

hallow geode
#

She could put only 9 plagues ( i assume he died because he was Caroline firstborn)

hybrid elm
#

And becsye he was the first born?

copper hawk
#

Jakob was brought by the rest of the family because of the curse

hybrid elm
#

Yup

copper hawk
#

and she didn't kill him
The family did

hybrid elm
#

And Jakob was also the one that was gonna get sacrificed originally cause of the profecy

copper hawk
#

they were the 10th plague

hybrid elm
#

Mmhm, it wasn't her but the family itself.

copper hawk
#

they were so horrifying

hybrid elm
#

Jakob, watching his family set the thing on fire: should have left them with the frogs...(?

copper hawk
#

that if they survived the 9 first

#

she wanted them to become the plague

hybrid elm
#

Exactly

#

That's...wow

copper hawk
#

The day I get my Mr.Crow 24x36 poster, I use it as a huge Rusty Lake conspiracy board (with blue-tack... I wont pierce this beauty)

hybrid elm
#

Lsfkkdlsla

#

Do it

copper hawk
#

x)

#

Oh, did I mention that I was so into my researches about IRL Rusty Lake that I found out the house of little Dale ? XD

hybrid elm
#

Kdggks you did!!! I was backreading that a bit ago alfksla

copper hawk
#

Based on what we see in birthday

hybrid elm
#

That's a lot of research tbh!

copper hawk
#

This is Leaf Rapids

#

Based on what we can see in Birthday

#

if this is the village where he was

#

This is his house