Did you set a binding for your root bone?
#Is this a bug, or am I doing something wrong?
plain dagger
Get rid of the rightItem bone. Right click root, Edit Binding, and select Main Hand
keen grove
What does it look like now? @snow sleet
keen grove
And you're sure you don't have any other animation applied at the same time, on your attachable?
Can you try by keeping the scale at 1? And send screenshots of it in BB, and in Minecraft
seems like it works yeah? your Minecraft skin has slim arms so it looks like it's a bit more on the outer edge of the arm, but it's in the same position
I'm not sure if the scale keyframe was messing up the position though, can you try again with a bigger scale value like 4, and positioning the weapon in the inner corner of the hand, to see if there is a difference?
but maybe it was just that, I can't quite tell from your first screenshots
yeah, something is different in the order they are applied or something
like, between Blockbench and Minecraft, Minecraft scales the position offset with the scale keyframe, while Blockbench does not, something like that
I think add another group to your model, nest the geometry inside of it, and use that group to scale the weapon,. But keep rotation and position adjustments on the parent bone
That may work around that
Keeping the geometry near the origin is also a good idea in general, and you might wanna position like that to simplify how much your have to adjust it
You'd have to adjust it again for first person of course
hopefully the workaround works, but yeah no problem, happy to help
Oh, also keep the pivot point of this child bone close to the center of the weapon
plain dagger
Scaling and rotation isn't an issue, you just need to make sure your root bone has the correct binding. It should also give you are warning if the binding is not yet, although that only works if it detects that the model belongs to an attachable file.
Can you send a File > Export > Share?
yeah
Works for me
keen grove
even scaled up?
with or without the additional child bone?
weird, I don't see what was changing the offset before then. You didn't modify the player geometry or add any model, or animation on the player entity file?
plain dagger
I recommend setting it from Local to Global in the top toolbar
keen grove
plain dagger
MC Bedrock doesn't have UV rotation so texture extrusion is recommended in the upright orientation instead of flat.
keen grove
!close