[Please delete]

[analog oasis]

the knight's sword req doesn't seem very new player friendly, i get that its an easy quest, but you'd want to be able to jump into crafting without too much of a smithing reliance especially if the goal is to lower the requirement of making some jewellery from 20

for that same reason, having a smithing requirement as high as elder rune to make alchemical onyx things doesn't sit well with me either.

point of clarification: the brooch is what requires elder rune, making an eof does not, i don't think you can use it as a baseline when the only two items that use the gem aren't even consistent with eachother in what items they require

if something like this was going to happen, i'd probably want to see zinc ore introduced around burthorpe so new players can make brass

and on a similar note, a high level ore exclusively for crafting would also be pretty nice, something titanium-adjacent if not titanium itself or ome runescapey fantasy version of it (don't make me say gielinorium)

[tepid zinc]

Crafting is a mess. Props to making it look better.

No to the Knight's Sword.
I would use clay instead as that's only a lv1 Mining req.