#Remove C4 from medic or give it a weaker version of C4

1 messages Ā· Page 1 of 1 (latest)

untold aurora
#

Pretty please

toxic hinge
#

an average support player from reddit

lofty swan
#

I would say remove.all explosives gadets from medic. Is a better option

azure gyro
#

šŸ¤“

dry canyon
#

Remove C4 from all but Recon and Engineer

woeful shadow
#

I agree with this, remove all explosive gadgets and add more healing gadgets for medic, force them to do their works instead of rushing the entire enemy team with SMG and C4

vernal galleon
#

Keep a versatile explosive for buildings

dry canyon
#

Give Assault a breaching charge (good vs building, useless v armor)

vernal galleon
untold aurora
calm mirage
#

I would say, this is more feedback, and not a suggestion..

untold aurora
#

Tf do they want us to use it for then?

calm mirage
#

Ok, leave it then..

#

I mean, this shouldn't be used for balancing.. That's what feedback is for.. But I didn't set it up

wheat panther
#

How about breeching charge for Assault and Medic, C4 for Support, Engi and Recon

woeful shadow
#

Assault can keep the C4, give breaching charge to Medic

dry canyon
#

why does medic need breaching charge to heal people?

wheat panther
#

Tbh yeah, actually it will make the medic less of a "all around" role

vernal galleon
#

Main problem with medic having c4 was that medic was able to destroy vehicles

dry canyon
#

Along with using them like grenades

dry canyon
#

C4 fairies are my primary concern, but that could be resolved by changing how C4 or whatever handles

dry canyon
#

Yea, because currently they're being used for unintended purposes almost akin to griefing

#

Wanna know why server pop is garbage? Because playing against a bunch of C4 SMG medic sweats isn't fun

swift sluice
#

Give medic a hammer or a pickaxe instead of C4. You cant still reach dying people but you won’t be a better assault

dry canyon
#

I mean tbh, you can heal and revive through walls so the point is moot

swift sluice
#

TRUE

untold aurora
#

We have to advocate for C4 removal

#

It worked for the leveling system and it only took a month and a half

foggy wolf
untold aurora
foggy wolf
#

erm 60 people agree

spark needle
#

medic with c4 or c4 vest is annoying but also makes the class playing both life an death,
It can give it an take it,

also tf2- the pain is as rewarding as the healing) -psycho medic main XD

cursive flint
#

breach c4 would be good

untold aurora
#

YesBBcool

foggy wolf
#

aint gonna be removed sadly šŸ˜—

paper quartz
#

Remove C4
And add
Breach hammer
If its just for free moove un building

foggy wolf
#

😬

#

remove smoothBrain from suggestion forums

untold aurora
cyan lake
#

oh hell nah.

untold aurora
foggy wolf
#

aint unanimous so it aint gonna be removed HyperXD

foggy wolf
#

why would they take the fun factor out of the game šŸ˜”

untold aurora
#

Plus C4 is the jack of all trades gadget

foggy wolf
#

?

dry canyon
#

Fun for one class, completely invalidates most vehicles

untold aurora
#

C4= best gadget

foggy wolf
#

then why not use medic

#

or do you not enjoy it

untold aurora
#

Give medic a weaker C4 (C2) or remove C4 entirely

foggy wolf
#

cause it seems totally fine to me

untold aurora
#

C4 can blow large holes in walls, destroy vehicles quickly, and kill players quickly(depending on the area)

foggy wolf
#

why nerf medic

untold aurora
#

C4 should be restricted to assault, support and engineer

foggy wolf
#

you can just buff other classes

#

to make everyone happy

untold aurora
#

Oh this shit

untold aurora
#

Support was somewhat buffed(resupplying ammo)

foggy wolf
#

medic was already nerfed with the smg range reduction

untold aurora
#

They have plenty of other weapons at their disposal

#

Plus the best gadget

foggy wolf
#

okay... i still dont understand where you are coming from

untold aurora
#

It already has the best guns and the best class specific gadget

foggy wolf
#

i dont think youve really played the game enough to understand the potential of other classes

untold aurora
#

Giving it tank destroying capabilities is silly

foggy wolf
#

cause i can still get the same amount of kills and fun with others

tender tinsel
swift sluice
tender tinsel
#

Anyway, sound off, rest of people who want to see medic nerf

swift sluice
#

Also ā€œbuff other classesā€ only works to a point. Thats how you get power creep

untold aurora
#

Whenever someone mentions a medic nerf there’s always someone saying that

#

Since god forbid

swift sluice
#

Taking away one tool from medic that further lets it do what assault does but better will not break medic

foggy wolf
#

do you want medic to be nerfed because the class is op, or for the skilled players to have a harder time

tender tinsel
#

Infinite fast healing + unimpeded movement lets them be the indisputably best aggressive class

foggy wolf
#

i still see people go 1kd with medic

#

so from my pov i think its based on the players skill not the class

swift sluice
#

Obviously it is to a point

#

But how is one class being able to do most things better than another good

#

The only feasible way I could see to make medic not the only choice would be to give every clsss fast bandage and to remove bleed

#

Actually simply fast bandage would help

tender tinsel
#

Even then Medic can ignore chip damage infinitely so you can do stuff like leap off a building like it's nothing while any other class is going to have to use the whole bandage even if they took <40 damage, and they have a much more limited supply

spark needle
#

medic is kinda op, but not with the c4 sense, that med box along with the builda-bear forts an a rally near enemy teams main spawn is broken if the medic loiters to keep the rally secure an keep rebuilding damaged barriers whilst placing medic box's near the fire-fight, the worst example of this play-style is on frugis, namak, wakistan, an zalfibay to name a few.

#

but that's just my opinion, I dnt like playing that sweaty

inner cloud
#

Also c4 is broken across the board for all classes, not in the sense it’s overpowered just the sense that none of the devs can figure out how to make it work right omE

spark needle
# inner cloud I have never once seen someone do this

I know not much of the c4 I rarely touch it unlike the vest, vest is fun.

an plz tell me your joking?
I have seen multiple accounts of a single squad member doing this especially on bobs server,
Though granted it is usually a full squad dedicated to doing this bs

woeful shadow
tender tinsel
woeful shadow
#

So true!

inner cloud
foggy wolf
opal spoke
#

I think medic should have more explosive power. The more dead enemies the less fallen allies to revive a true healthcare profissional must focus on prevention before the treatment

swift sluice
#

Give medic every single gun

outer current
#

C4 on medics is just a BigMedicTM ploy to kill more people so medics can revive more people to get xp

spark needle
#

here we go green text adventure
*me: plays as medic with c4 vest.
*sees two distracted players.
*dies by c4 vest.
*revived by medic.
*other medic proceeds to do the same.
*medic dies.
*ignores medic.
*follows support for ammo box.
*dies cause support won't place ammo box.

modern lantern
#

engineer is 29/39 if I am thinking right

#

(could done the math wrong,so feel free to bonk me on the head)

modest rain
#

Explosives only for support. Engineer builds, support makes traps. Or vice versa

silk siren
#

This suggestion wont happen. To begin with you're dying to medics with c4 mostly because they're vet players. If this is removed you're still going to get the same players c4'ing you in the same places cause the player will just swap to a class with it and kill you. Perhaps Op you can change your playstyle to counter the medic tossing c4 over the waki bridge barriers and killing your entire frontline.

silk siren
#

If you can work around the issue easily with playstyle and some clever thinking than it comes off differently. If you want to learn how to counter this type of player than you are free to dm me.

untold aurora
#

I made it because it’s bullshit for medic to keep getting all the best stuff

#

It’s a support class and yet it can blow up tanks

#

It’s a support class and yet it’s the best assault class

silk siren
#

Ima wait to see if Cleo has anything to add before i comment

odd quail
inner cloud
#

Steve

#

Stop

#

It’s not worth it

odd quail
silk siren
# untold aurora I made it because it’s bullshit for medic to keep getting all the best stuff

Firstly. Medic doesn't "Keep getting all the best stuff" Medic has only been nerfed/indirectly nerfed since launch, and has not gotten any addition features since then iirc. (If you can provide evidence that says otherwise then ill retract that statement)

Secondly, tanks in general are under powered. This is not the medics fault. C4 should only 100-0 tank hp if its placed properly at the rear. OR C4 vehicle damage to the tank should be nerfed to make it so a medic has to equip a backpack to grant additional c4 in order to blow up the tank.

Thirdly, AR gunplay for assault is MUCH better than on medic. This is why you see the best medics touching only 2 or maybe 3 ar's.

In conclusion medic is right where it needs to be. The other classes need more QOL updates to polarize their uniqueness.

inner cloud
#

Jesus fuck

#

Steve wrote a whole fucking Aesop fable

odd quail
#

tldr.

silk siren
#

Dont read, than dont post buddy.

untold aurora
inner cloud
#

TLDR Revert game to playtest patch

untold aurora
untold aurora
silk siren
#

Its been nerfed, many times.

untold aurora
#

And only one

odd quail
foggy wolf
#

Just stop it tbh c4 isn’t going away from medic šŸ’€

untold aurora
#

It should be restricted to the classes it makes sense for

#

Why would the team healer need to blow up vehicles

foggy wolf
#

Who tf even heals others with medic

untold aurora
foggy wolf
#

Why would u heal and revive others that’s so boring lol

untold aurora
#

Because it’s medic?

silk siren
#

@untold aurora c4 count nerf, smg nerf, bandage rework (very indirect but just keeps the other classes better)

foggy wolf
#

Brother has been with medics fr šŸ’€

#

No one heals with medic cause it’s boring

untold aurora
modern lantern
#

otherwise I don't recall many/any nerfs on medic directly beside the removal of a single C4

inner cloud
#

Nobody heals with medic when I can respawn 2x faster than it takes to heal back to full hp

silk siren
#

Very true HG, medic bandages do heal while the other classes do not if i remember correctly. They should heal at all classes imo if true.

modern lantern
#

Bandages heal everyone when used

#

40 HP

foggy wolf
#

Why u typing paragraphs Steve 😭

inner cloud
#

You use bandages

#

lol

silk siren
#

40hp from bleed?

modern lantern
#

to clarify the medic's self bandage requires a bleed but heals 40 HP like everyone else's

inner cloud
#

Never bandaged so didn’t know

silk siren
#

Brain had the idea that only medic could stop bleed + heal 40hp, idk where i got that from tbh

silk siren
modern lantern
#

But to clarify medic has 3 ways to heal, two of which can be used at a time based on conditions

inner cloud
#

šŸ¤“ alright fucking EMS we don’t need the explanation

#

c4 thread btw

foggy wolf
#

Arguing on something that’s not gonna happen crazyyyy

modern lantern
#
  1. the medkit in hands
  2. medkit on ground (can be comboed together while healing in hands or reloading)
  3. bandages while bleeding (40 HP)
untold aurora
#

Atleast give it a weaker version of C4šŸ˜”

#

C2

silk siren
#

100% not even close to happening

silk siren
#

Just lose the idea man

foggy wolf
#

Needa kill some people with c4

untold aurora
#

Why are you people so against removing C4 from medicšŸ˜”

modern lantern
#

Otherwise I feel reducing the explosive power from Medic wouldn't be a terrible idea

foggy wolf
#

Because you would ruin the game ofc

silk siren
#

its already capped at 4 people per, you wanna go back to when i could toss one and get a 16x?

modern lantern
#

they are one of the fastest classes with more than enough to kill a tank from the front or such

untold aurora
odd quail
untold aurora
#

It’s not like 3 other classes have C4

modern lantern
#

mix in the fastest & infinite self healing, faster bandage speeds & so on

foggy wolf
#

The alr ruined the game lol

#

And the player count reflects that

modern lantern
#

alr?

untold aurora
#

Yeah what is that

silk siren
modern lantern
#

Steve, I feel it could be a very different reason

silk siren
#

Well they have to elaborate

untold aurora
#

I said it wasn’t and I said why I think that

foggy wolf
#

I think you are just a baller

modern lantern
#

But I do see a arguement for medic is too good at everything beside ranged AT while not having many issues beside at like dmr+ range

foggy wolf
#

Downfall of bbr began when the nerfed the vector

untold aurora
#

Fuck sake

foggy wolf
#

Why u mad monkey?

#

😔😔😔😔

modern lantern
#

That got to be a joke Keiof

foggy wolf
#

Why

odd quail
modern lantern
#

Fair

foggy wolf
#

I am just an adderall dosing vector abuser

#

What’s wrong with that

silk siren
#

Keiof either got adhd or is a drug addict

foggy wolf
silk siren
untold aurora
#

I was proposing removal of c4 or a weaker c4(c2)

#

The c2 would obviously do less damage to stuff

foggy wolf
#

Remove c4 from mediccc funnymonkey

swift sluice
#

Their playstyle WILL be hampered

silk siren
#

Holding spacebar and swapping classes doesn't scare these type of players using c4

swift sluice
#

Medic plays assault better than Assault does. How is this not a problem

modern lantern
#

medic's self heal is a big outlier

#

they also share several gadgets with assault

silk siren
# untold aurora The c2 would obviously do less damage to stuff

So you're saying yes. Gotcha. It wont happen. You're asking for a whole new item to be created, be a weaker version of something that's already streamlined into the game across all classes. All for a class that you personally feel is too oppressive, when I told you before, you can easily counter.

silk siren
untold aurora
#

They have better assault capabilities than assault

untold aurora
inner cloud
silk siren
#

might as well rename it to "Default"

#

Does things well, but nothing great other than aiming, shooting, reloading

inner cloud
#

^

#

steve preachin rn

#

sunday service is in session

silk siren
#

Just doing my service so whenever I create suggestions I get X bombed

swift sluice
#

And PERFECT for a run and gun ā€œassaultā€ playstyle

silk siren
#

I find the gun overlap kinda weird to begin with. Assault already has access to a plethora of guns, though they add dmrs over smgs?

inner cloud
#

real shit

odd quail
swift sluice
#

And it’s not strong on medic?

odd quail
swift sluice
#

It sure enables a certain playstyle

odd quail
swift sluice
#

It just so happens that the playstyle SMG’s enable for medic is pretty much exactly what assault is supposed to be

untold aurora
#

Run and gun

woven swan
#

The thing is that Medic and Engineer are the only classes with SMG access, and both of them have horrendously annoying things going on with the pair of them. Engineer gets access to RPG spam which a lot of people aren’t terribly happy with, and Medic gets access to faster self healing, and most Engineer players either play their role and hang around vehicles or make destroying them the priority.

Unless you do something akin to restructuring what class gets access to what weapons — which would involve some addition changes to class specific shit like the faster speeds of the Assualt class — it’s just not happening in a way that’s satisfying for the majority.

dry canyon
#

Having 6 RPGs is a little crazy, the fact that it takes all 6 to take out a tank too is also crazy. Just means they get used for other, more sweaty purposes

unreal scarab
#

removing c4 from medic is just going to take fun away from a large group of players. there are better ways to balance classes

untold aurora
#

And more of it

tender tinsel
#

Just because people go for the obviously superior choice in terms of power doesn't mean they wouldn't actually prefer playing something except then they're just handicapping themselves for no good reason

tender tinsel
unreal scarab
#

medics advantage mostly comes from healing not c4

tender tinsel
#

Yeah we all know that which is why we remove the superfluous extra power it has instead of gutting what makes the class actually special

swift sluice
#

^

#

Medic doesn’t need C4. Medic doesn’t need to promote the exact same playstyle as assault except better because it’s more sustainable

jovial rampart
#

Ye medic shouldnt even have Guns they are healers

inner cloud
#

honestly we should just remove medic

#

everyone has bandages anways

modern lantern
untold aurora
#

So 4 others

modern lantern
#

That sounds bad, very out of context

#

hmm, I am unsure how to phrase it better

woven swan
#

Every class does afaik. The only one I’m unsure about is Recon but I think I’ve seen it there as well

modern lantern
woven swan
spark needle
#

c4 vest is better, I can run up to a tank an kill it ez

modern lantern
#

best guess he assumed I just when prone oustide & only noticed I jumped in once the turret rotated to face him (he chose to attempt getting close enough I lacked depression but chose to throw it when I could still aim at him)

woven swan
#

It could have been an assault but I’m starting to notice a lot of people don’t use DMRs on Assault

woven swan
#

Say less

modern lantern
#

hmm

#

Camo Hat?

spark needle
#

cause ppl dnt want to start a sniper fight half the time
Plus pdw/AR or go touch grass
Or so I'm told

woven swan
modern lantern
#

Yes

unreal scarab
#

c4 vehicle damage def should be nerfed a bit

unreal scarab
swift sluice
unreal scarab
#

i think assault should get same smgs and armor as medic plus a syringe or something to encourage that playstyle

swift sluice
#

Yes, absolutely. Assault needs SMGs and medic does not

unreal scarab
#

but taking away c4 from medic is just making the game less fun and not actually changing much

woeful shadow
#

Those who don't want C4 removed from medic only have 1 reason
"it would make the game less fun šŸ¤“"
Go heal your teammates, you shouldn't be capable of destroying tanks

#

Leave that to assault and your engineer

dry canyon
#

Go heal your engineer so they can destroy the tank

foggy wolf
#

nah i dont like healing others

swift sluice
#

Then don’t play medic

#

Honestly now that bandages heal you I think removing medic’s self heal unless he puts the medic pack down should be seriously considered

#

exactly how Support’s Ammo box works

#

Medic would still have a ton of survivability since it has much more bandages than any other class but it wouldn’t be able to easily heal all damage on the fly

modern lantern
#

at least with the current bandaging passive

modern lantern
#

on topic of the medkit it can be picked up unlike support's ammo boxes which would help

unreal scarab
swift sluice
#

If that happens I’d like to see higher rocket damage to tanks

#

Maybe not HEAT but certainly tandem

past lagoon
#

people talking about medics being able to kill tanks, But last time i checked tanks can kill medics. if you find yourself dying a lot to c4's in tanks then you need to work on your awareness and positions.

modern lantern
swift sluice
past lagoon
swift sluice
#

See, on some maps it’s easier cause of cover

unreal scarab
#

yeah, making it take 6 c4 or reducing throw rate would help

#

but if a tank is completely oblivious any class should be able to threaten it

past lagoon
#

we should also remove heavy armor from support, remove 1 hit rpg, remove supply for assualt, and remove insta kill from 1000 meter on recon just to make everyone enjoy the game less

spark needle
#

while we're at it remove glint

modern lantern
#

Anyhow, why should we do that Kevsky?

woeful shadow
#

Just admit you like running medic with C4

honest marsh
untold aurora
spark needle
tender tinsel
unreal scarab
#

crazy how everyone missed the sarcasm

untold aurora
#

šŸ˜”

mystic ermine
inner cloud
#

You think mw2 got movement

#

Im going back to geometry dash tbh

timid spoke
#

Remove mokey BBHuh

untold aurora
untold aurora
#

šŸ˜”

jovial rampart
foggy wolf
keen anvil
#

What about breaching charge? It destroys wall + flashbangs people behind the wall but deals no damage

swift sluice
#

why the bold and italics

dull urchin
#

oki mentioned that removing c4 from medic would be a big change to how the game plays but that's kind of the point. Super speedy medic tossing his c4s and getting 20 kills in half a second is ridiculous

keen anvil
timid spoke
#

have you tried light engineer ?

#

its faster and has 3 rpgs

swift sluice
tender tinsel
dull urchin
#

Yes

manic canyon
#

no

wheat scaffold
#

Apologies if suggested. What about larger explosion radius but remove damage to players/vehicles? Make it a building c4? Still keeps one of the main purposes Oki has discussed before, which is being able to destroy buildings but also removes the very powerful tool from one of the most used classes for aggressive playstyles.

tender tinsel
wheat scaffold
#

Medics having c4 means that they will always be the top choice for the aggressive playstyle people, since they can get kills quickly (with the gun selections) + self heal + mass group kill with c4/vehicles, they are the jack of all trades. This means people may actually consider assault over medic since assault would still keep c4 that damages people/vehicles.

tender tinsel
#

Agreed

timid spoke
wheat scaffold
dull urchin
timid spoke
wheat scaffold
tender tinsel
spark needle
#

but what about c4 vest?

tender tinsel
spark needle
spark needle
#

a c4 vest can 48-50hp(even kill) damage a tank after its been hit twice by rpg, where as vehicles are really easy to this tactic

tender tinsel
spark needle
#

agreed

dull urchin
wheat scaffold
dull urchin
#

I'll get on and double check but I'm pretty sure it's just assault and recon that get melee weapons

#

Which recon is an odd choice imo but whatever

spark needle
dull urchin
#

Well yeah obviously if you want to poke out one little hole to snipe through

#

It makes sense that way

blissful yew
#

Good strat

dull urchin
#

I'm just too big of a grappling hook enjoyer on both of those classes

spark needle
#

if u see a sniper not using a fish-eye trick then their just playing for parkour

dull urchin
#

Yeah it's just assault and recon. Had to double check because the removal of leader class still messes with me

spark needle
#

it will be re added I'm sure with milsim mode

untold aurora
#

šŸ˜”

flat pumice
#

That would be a good nerf. šŸ‘ Medic needs a downside.

bright coral
#

If anything; C4 should be limited on medic to counts 1 at the very least –for "speed builds", 2 as base, and 3 on equipment that modifies the base gadget count to higher than 2.

silk siren
#

Should be the opposite, add more c4 to medic and fix all the bugs with it while oki's at it. Medic right now is a weak class

jovial rampart
#

Compared to assault and support medic is going to be weaker for sure

modern lantern
woeful shadow
#

He's trolling

silk siren
# modern lantern gotta ask, how is medic weak?

Not fast enough to move speed, Engie is faster, not enough weapons (pdws are getting deleted from the class along with mp7 & pp2000), 0 long range weapons, armor limited, heal box is slower than bandages.

woeful shadow
#

L