terrible ideas

[plush hemlock]

New Challenge : Frail companion

The hero descend the dungeon depth... together with someone incompetent.

The new npc that follows hero would be simply called magic less scholar. He descent the depth of dungeon for some reason that would revealed sometime after depth 3.

If he dies during the run, the run fails.

[dry canopy]

Man. An escort mission in a roguelike

[teal moss]

adom has one early on where you escort a puppy (no joke lol)

[granite sundial]

Nah, warp debuff you with a chance to buff you at very low chance, you should add opposite affect like Warp, it will buff your hero

[azure garnet]

but isn't that a trap that gives you almost no reward?

[wintry tendon]

Disarmed Status:

A debuff that disallows attacking or using thrown items (not wands)

"Isn't that just -100% accuracy?" Maybe, but accuracy modifiers are completely ignored and you cannot even attempt to attack during this debuff. That capability is completely removed when you are disarmed

[dry canopy]

You get to do a good act, that's the reward

[teal moss]

Wow, really? smh. I tried to give that game a honest try years ago but it's just... so bad, and "anti-player" as hell

NeoSlav typing a 200+ words shitpost
kermit_typewriter.gif

[grizzled flame]

New floor status effects:
Every chapter now gives a global status effect to go along with thwir theme and spice things up

Sewers: Beginner's Luck. You feel confident! 10% chance to negate all of a hit's dmg against you, and your satiety drops 15% more slowly. Higher chance to roll avg on wep and armor rolls

Prisons: Warden's Watch. The prison's chief has his unerring eye on you, unnerving you to the core. Every 25 turns or so, random enemies on the floor will become alerted to your presence for 2 turns (20% of enemies currently alive). Enemy armor becomes twice as effectice against your damage, and wands have a 10% chance to miscast.

Caves: Nature's Onslaught. The earth itself seems to be against you. Enemies that step on grass get a 25% dmg boost for 10 turns, while grass itself spawns on random tiles at a rate of 1 every 15 turns. Every 3 grass spawned will also spawn a random harmful plant on thr floor: enemies that step on them get the associated warden's effect. If the hero steps on grass, they move 20% slower for 8 turns.

Metro: Necromantic Aura. It's hard to keep going when the place itself wants you dead... Enemies have a 20% chance to respawn when killed (max of once per enemy). The hero gains the doomed debuff for 5 turns after killing anything. Healing sources become 33% less effective.

Halls: Madness Incarnate. Every second spent here loosens your grip on reality more and more. This debuff has stacks that build up with turns spent. 1 every 50 turns or so. They reset after going down a floor, but u vant go up and then down again to keep resetting.
1 stacks: You start hallucinating various items. When these fakes try tk be picked up, theyll fade into nothingness and deal 2 times ur stacks in dmg
2 stack: You begin hallucimating enemies. These fakes act like normal enemies and can be damaged, but they cant dmg u. When they try to dmg u, they dmg ur mind instead and disappear (7% times stacks chance to forget an ID-ed consumablr.)
3 stacks: You begin seeing copies of yourself, whivh attack and damage you with your own gear. Their dmg is cappef at 10% of ur max hp, they have 0 armor and DR

Cant come up witb more stack effects

[honest gull]

boneless
everything is a slime

[plush hemlock]

Add an effect of unwearing hero armor instead of simply tolerating the succubus presence, whenever getting charmed by them.

(They were supposed to make you horny, not obedient)

Punish early player decision of upgrading their first weapon, by destroying it after killing goo

(Their body supposed to be corrosive after all. Nothing could break your weapon faster than plunging it into walking acid)

Digging tombstone requires shovel now.
Merchant sells overpriced portable shovel

[gritty nova]

4 stacks: You're beginning to go insane. Every so often (5% per turn) you feel a powerful sense to scream, which alerts all enemies, and takes (stacks) turns.
5 stacks: You're starting to lose your ability to think. You occasionally wander the map, not knowing where you are and how you got there. (Triggers teleportation effect every 150 turns)
6 stacks: The walls seem to....... move.................... (Each turn, you have a 33% chance to move in a random direction, as well as your movement speed being reduced by 33%)
7 stacks: You've lost it. Run... Run... RUN..... RUNNNN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-All previous debuffs are removed
-You are teleported to a random floor of Demon Halls in a random spot. If the room is locked when this effect is triggered, you instantly die from losing your mind
-You are unable to do any actions other than run and melee attack
-You are afflicted with permanent blindness
-You are unable to remember the map layout
-All enemies are constantly alerted to your position
-Accuracy and evasion are reduced by 50%

[grizzled flame]

make it only tp u to another spot in the same floor, and being inside a locked room doesnt insta kill u (it just unlocks the room for u) and hell yeah

[runic granite]

This is, in fact, a terrible idea.

[dusk sky]

i agree

[tardy ingot]

lmfao

[runic granite]

I love how it declares it.

[mental mortar]

Ok that's actually a good terrible idea

[granite sundial]

That is vannila monk but Armor

[runic granite]

Succubi become the anti warrior

[tardy ingot]

if succubi werent annoying enough

[verbal topaz]

That gives me bobylev vibes

[dry canopy]

So nethack foocubi

[teal moss]

It's almost as if everyone is taking sneaky potshots at other roguelikes lol

[marble tundra]

Shop keeper selling made in China items instead of the original. These items are much cheaper, but are less efficient. There are exceptions (hourglass sands, artifacts, stone thing, small rations, revival thing, darts, and bags) as they are unique and unobtainable elsewhere. For armours and weapons, they basically have the Fragile curse, but… it can still be cursed by fragile thereby making it possible to be significantly weaker. A good example of the comparison of the downgrade and the original is the normal rations to the small rations.

When bought, they’ll have the adjective “Cheap”

[stone marsh]

yep

[azure garnet]

it is not a secret than most of classical roguelikes are made by bored coders with no education in game design

[marble tundra]

E.g. Cheap Chainmail—lower blocking power, Cheap Turqoise Potion—less duration and/or stat increase, Cheap Identify Scroll—either show curse status or delays its effect by 100 turns.

[wintry tendon]

Wearing metal armaments increases shock damage you receive. Wearing chainmail decreases shock damage you can receive.

[granite sundial]

J

[wintry tendon]

J

[marble tundra]

Thirst mechanic: starve but u relieve it by drinking 4 dew

Potions also relieve as much as 2 dew

[feral fractal]

water tiles can relieve as much as 1 dew but with a chance of poison

[granite sundial]

Well in Chasm room is filled with Normal water

[languid drum]

Lol. Summoning pd is actually nice

[dusk sky]

yes enough of this boby slander already

[upbeat kestrel]

Have ads pop up every loading screen

And those super cringe ones

Selectly picked from the bad pile

Yes

Even rarely an extra scroll of wipeout

Being the only way to get it

Every 100 ads

[tardy ingot]

paid pixel dungeon

a pd version where you have to use real money to bu things in shops

[dusk sky]

both ad and microtransaction ideas were posted like 50 times each already

[teal moss]

Welcome to Discord ideas/suggestions channels ¯_(ツ)_/¯

[ebon ingot]

Ok hear me out

How about a champion that has every other champion effect combined

It would make for a very fun and creative encounter

[grizzled flame]

New champion: @÷31a! (Glitched)

These champions have a 25% chance to "glitch" either the hero or their inventory when hitting them. +2 attack range, and if one shot from full hp, will survive with 1 hp.
If the herois glitched, any of these effects can occur:
Their level is randomized with a range of [X-8, X+2], with x being the actual lvl (this can remove talent points invested
Their talents are glitched, rerolling the points invested in all tiers
A talent is glitched, metamorphing it (u dont get to choose between 3)
Their hp is glitched, rerolling it by a range of [-50%, +10%] of its max amount
Their acc and eva are glitched, rerolling them within a range of [1, current]

Worth noting: all these glitched effects are based off of ur actual stat. If u roll and get a -50% to ur max hp, (100 hp ---> 50 hp), then hit the effect again and get a -25% instead, ur hp will go back up to 75.

When ur inventory is glitched:
2-6 consumables are recycled
1-4 unequipped items are transmogrified
1-5 equipped items are rerolled
A random bag is removed for a floor
Your gold is rerolled within a range of [-75%, +20%] of its actual amount.
Your alchemical energy is rerolled within a range of [-50%, +10%] of its actual amount
Ypur gold and alch energy amounts are switched
Your upgrade levels are rerolled (adds up the upg lvls of all ur ID-ed items both equipped and unequipped then distributes them randomly)
Your entire inventory is transmuted

And yes i spend too much effort in my shitposts

[plush hemlock]

New Challenge: Rival

Add another mob that acts as speedrunner hero.

It doesn't attack you, instead stealing the strength potion or scroll of upgrade whenever stumbled on it.

You can kill them ofcourse, to recover their loots, but they would always respawn.

Based on your action on these rival, they may or may not side with yog in final battle

New Challenge: Nemesis

Add another mob that acts as malicious speedrunner hero.

It sometimes attack you whenever you below 50% health. And it loots everything they see, often discarding items of low quality when their bag is full.

They also could buy bag from merchant, unlike normal rival. This hinder you to buy bag, so try to reach shop fast.

Good luck on killing them, they always uses their upgrade scroll or strength potion, unlike normal rival that saves these up for later. They didn't respawn though.

They always sides with yog whenever survives the whole run.

[grizzled flame]

New challenge: Karmic Cycle
What goes around, comes around.

You permanently have the Karma status effect on you, which has a counter starting at 0. Doing "good/pacifistic" actions (taking dmg from enemies without striking back, buying from the shop, completing an npc quest, leaving a floor with enemies still asleep, healing allies and enemies, etc) increases the counter, while "evil/violent" actions (attacking enemies, burning grass and doors, stealing from.shop, scaring away the shopkeep, leaving a chapter without completing an npc's quest, opening graves and bone piles, etc) lowers the counter.

When below 0: the hero takes extra % dmg from all sources, debuff durations are extended, buff durations are lowered, wraiths begin randomly spawning, and evil actions lower the counter more. The severity of these effects scales with how far the counter is in the negativez (ex. Wraiths spawn faster based on how low ur counter is)

When above 0: incoming dmg is lowered by a % from all sources (softcaps quickly tho at like, say, 25%), debuffs last less, buffs last longer, and good actions increase the counter more. These effects' severities scale with how much the counter is above 0

[plush hemlock]

New? Challenge: Plants wonderland

Every inch of dungeon that doesn't occupied by water or traps or something special, would be shrouded by thick grass.

Dew chance to appear reduced greatly, but would gives double amount in single dewdrop.

As per rule, the grass could be ignited. Be sure to stand on water to avoid the fires.

Mobs would have something changed in their behavior, like could hear rustling in grasses, moving around the grasses without destroying them.

Stepping off water leave wet footprints. Mobs could follow them to locate you.

Stepping of charred tile (burned grass) leaves ashen footprints, effect the same as wet footprints but faster to vanish.

[neon spindle]

When you desend enemies are waiting at the next depth

[glacial sandal]

Exists

Possibly my most repeated word in this whole server

Followed by "already"

followed by "mods"

[neon spindle]

Mod already exists

[granite sundial]

When you bleeding, blood from your bleed can make your chalice upgraded

[dusk sky]

that's not a terrible idea

[teal moss]

Won't it make the chalice pretty easy to upgrade? (Non-rhetorical question)

[dusk sky]

it could gradually upgrade with each hp lost to bleeding

or reduce the damage taken for next prick

[granite sundial]

Make anti magic useless, because anti magic scroll is made of magic, so when you read it, nothing happened

[dry canopy]

Huh

[shy mica]

the word "the" has been said 211k times

neo has 171k messages

so if he posts 40k more times he would have posted more messages than there are messages with the word "the"

[grizzled flame]

U have to take into account that my msgs may contain the word the

Which would tilt the number of msgs i have to send severely

Therefore i can no longer say said word

No more t. HE

[azure garnet]

Congratulations for defining an arbitrary task for yourself that will make you look extremely weird

[grizzled flame]

Anyways new idea:

RNG Manipulator
This nifty little device can turn the odds on your favor, for a price...

New alchemical recipe, u can sacrifice items or gold or hp to it in exchange for giving you better rng drops for next floor (its magnitude is dependent on how many things you sacrificed to it, nd their quality.)

[grizzled flame]

Isnt this what a conduit is already in roguelikes

[azure garnet]

Not eating any food is not as arbitrary as avoiding word "the"

[grizzled flame]

It is quite arbitraru

"Mmh yes i will now avoid using multiple of these mechanics and items for no reason or unless very certain circumstances occur"

It is just as weied

Weird

[shy mica]

very stupid challenge
Halls of Madness
Whenever you are in a room, every other room in the dungeon will warp, get inverted, generate corridors to anywhere, generate more traps, reactivate traps and merge with other rooms
the amount of loot in a room stays the same, and some roomsare ignored

[grizzled flame]

Example: face challenge

[shy mica]

if you want extra pain the warping radius is your fov and not just the room

[dusk sky]

make it so on the first of april all the rng calls return the lowest possible value

[feral fractal]

Actually brilliant

[dusk sky]

the fact every floor will fail to generate makes it even funnier

[plush hemlock]

Mob variant : Hoarder rat.

This rat wear small pouch behind it's back, and spawned awake. They loots small items such as stone or seeds, even dew.

Generally doesn't like fighting, they would run if the hero see them. But if being chased, would screech like alarm trap.

Kill it to loot their pouch contents

[grizzled flame]

New enemy: gnoll cannibal
Normal movement speed and what not, stats on par with brutes, when getting hit by it, theres a chance u start bleeding and get crippled. This mob can kill other mobs in its way to get to u: for each mob killed and "eaten", it regains hp and gets a boost to its dmg and max hp

[plush hemlock]

Mob variant: Captain guard.

This guard wear a shield, unlike ordinary guard. Instead of pulling hero, they would jump, pushing hero several tiles back alongside stunning them for 1 turn.

Always spawn awake, wandering the level, forcing any sleeping prison guard awake to follow it.

[dusk sky]

give skeletons more armor

[plush hemlock]

Mob variant: Spectral bat.

These bats likes to eat magic charge, or magic in general.

Instead of sucking hero hp like their cousin, they would steal any charge of hero wands or alchemical energy.

Could probably also eat any enchantment in hero equipments.

[shy mica]

when chalice

crazy thieves should be able to use their rings/artifacts

and if its chalice they prick to deal 81 damage

[grizzled flame]

New mob variant: Egg-Dweza
Yog with an egg sprite

[plush hemlock]

Mob variant: Dwarf Cyborg

Some of dwarves are so bold in experimenting their finds...

These mobs spawned hibernated behind locked doors, inside a special room called laboratory. If hero interact with any machinery present inside, it would wake up

Has variety of ability that could be found in other mobs, such as pulling hero, throwing hero's weapon away, or simple disintegrating bolts, maybe more?

[shy mica]

rapper demon

rare variant of ripper demon

[plush hemlock]

Mob variant: Incubus

Unlike the opposite gender counterpart, these mobs lulls hero into sleep, and leaves after doing their job. Damage receives when asleep is doubled.

[shy mica]

uhh

i

[tall matrix]

HAD AN REVOLUTIONARY IDEIA

MAKE THIS HAVE A RANDOM CHANCE TO PLAY WHEN SELLECTING HUNTRESS!

😄

[livid summit]

Glad I never had to see that shit before 🤔

[tardy ingot]

his ideia was so good that Ifrit removed him

[grizzled flame]

make what thing

[tardy ingot]

there was a youtube link

[marble tundra]

Challenge: Dungeon’s Alias
Entering a room for the n’th time will rearrange the rooms of the floor (with the same items and enemies in them).

[shy mica]

explain

[tardy ingot]

ask Meth for the link

[plush hemlock]

New trap : Piranha trap

These traps spawned exclusively in water, though mostly occur in room filled with water tile.

When stepped, a number of piranhas would be freed from hidden drain close to the trap.

[tardy ingot]

would be cool if geyser traps spawned piranhas

they would be dangerous

[plush hemlock]

That would be cool, better than current geyser trap

[tardy ingot]

yeah

[granite sundial]

What

What

[plush hemlock]

New trap : Slippery trap

These traps spawned exclusively on platforms that connect between rooms in chasms floor.

Stepping on them forces hero to slide several tiles to where they tapped, taking only one turn. It could be dangerous if it was spawned in corner....

[neon spindle]

Idea: unstable trap
This trap can activate any type of trap

[verbal topaz]

What the fuc

Idea: give skeleton an explosion range to everything they can see

Idea: give guards infinite use of chains

Idea: give crabs 50% more attack speed

[tardy ingot]

ide: necromancers can give their skeletons adrenaline even if they arent at full hp

idea: DMs100 will run away instead of fighting on melee

[verbal topaz]

Idea: give evil eyes the ability to perfore walls with the deathgaze just like disintegration wand

[tardy ingot]

idea: theifs will get infinite haste after stealing something

[verbal topaz]

Idea: scorpions give you knockback when you get hit by them

[neon spindle]

Idea: King of Dwarves gets infinite sheilding

[verbal topaz]

Idea: spinners will give you corrosion instead of poison

Or both

I am currently bringing shattered enemies from annoying to pure annoyingness

[tardy ingot]

idea: shamans now enrage after dying, pushing you with melee attacks and blinding with their magic bolts

[verbal topaz]

Idea: rippers always try landing on you so you always get hit

[verbal topaz]

This is a good idea, not a terrible one

[neon spindle]

Spawner have 10000000 health

[azure garnet]

honestly half of those ideas could be adapted into Shutter PD

[verbal topaz]

Spawners behave like chickens in the abyss, with 20 hits

Ghouls are immune to all aoe damge

And they die only if all ghouls in the level are dead

[verbal topaz]

I mean, those are not only terrible but also make shattered pure hell

[tardy ingot]

ghouls enrage after reviving

[verbal topaz]

Imagine 9 chall when you meet skeletons and you get a 9 damage when you kill them

[dusk sky]

warlocks have scorpio ai and can teleport away

[verbal topaz]

Pure hell

[neon spindle]

All rats deals heavy bleeding

[verbal topaz]

Ifrit try reading my ideas here and rate them 1 to 10

[dusk sky]

1 to all of them

good job

[verbal topaz]

From here

[tardy ingot]

warlocks will heal when attacking

[verbal topaz]

Thank you

[neon spindle]

[verbal topaz]

@granite sundial

[tardy ingot]

[tardy ingot]

rogue

[verbal topaz]

He be cloaking

Amazing

[neon spindle]

The cloak ran out of charges

[tardy ingot]

indeed

[tardy ingot]

lmfao

[verbal topaz]

😦

[dusk sky]

he had an ankh!

[neon spindle]

Blessed?

[dusk sky]

lmao dumbass preserved weapon and armor

[plush hemlock]

New map : Maze Trap

Spawn exclusively in maze room, now maze room had two doors connected to it.

When hero enters, lock the door where they entered, spawn a Maze guardian (maybe new mini boss?) inside the maze.

[granite sundial]

Ok

[granite sundial]

Imp quest to deactivate all golem, go to the Power room that is hidden locked room behind bookshelf in floor 20, you can get the key when defeating DK, inside the room you can active or deactivate all golem and DM, also you can use a ritual to spawn ally elemental, or destroying all elemental in metropolis.

[maiden lily]

Do it.

[plush hemlock]

New mobs : Rat Nest.

Similar to demon spawner, instead they spawn normal rats.

Destroying all of them in every sewer floor incite the wrath of ratking. Forcing hero to fight goo alongside enraged rat monarch.

New mobs : Skelegion

Similar to demon spawner, instead they spawn normal skeletons.

Destroying all of them in every prison floor incite the wrath of Undead king. Forcing hero to fight hidden boss alongside Tengu.

New mobs : Gnoll Fortress

Similar but different than demon spawner, player couldn't destroy it by simple hitting or shotting. Spawn every variants of gnolls.

Destroying all of them in every caves floor incite the wrath of Gnoll elites. Forcing hero to fight hidden mini bosses alongside DM300

[feral fractal]

Cant work cause rat king is stronger than yog

:troll:

[maiden lily]

Skeleton spawner

[plush hemlock]

Eh, it's not like the player have to kill ratking too to proceed the next floor

[feral fractal]

Great point

[azure garnet]

have you ever looked at rat king boss?

[plush hemlock]

New mobs : Golem Fabricator

Similar to Gnoll Fortress, but now player couldn't rely on elements such as flame or ice. Because Dwarf invention is the best in the world!

Spawn the best version of golem, but a lot slower than the rest of spawners variant.

Destroying all of them in every metropolist avoid the hero from having difficult battle, from fighting Dwarf king alongside army of golems.

New mobs : Infernal rats nest

Similar to rat nest, but spawn new variant of rats that could shoot fireblast.

Destroying it in 21 floor prevent rats from appearing in yog fight.

New mobs : Demonic Skelegion

Similar to Skelegion, but spawn ranged variant of skeleton that could use crossbows, tipped with various different seeds. Mainly flame though.

Destroying it in 22 floor prevent skeletons from appearing in yog fight.

[dusk sky]

make it so with champions on all mobs spawn as champions (to reduce rng)

[plush hemlock]

New mobs Hellish Fortress.

Similar to Gnoll Fortress, but instead spawned guards and thieves variant. Doomed Paladins and Cursed Assassins.
Paladins could reflect any

magic casted at them and assassins spawned invisible and could backstab you.

Destroying it in 23 floor prevent these new variants from appearing in yog fight.

[mystic shell]

Buff corrosion

Every 3 hits of corrosion will degrade all equipment by 1 level

Buff poison

Every 3 hits of poison will make one of your potions become unstable

Buff blazing

Blazing burns your hands so much you can only output attack damage at 50% power

[plush hemlock]

The last normal floor would be for ripper demon spawner only, though it could spawn flying ripper demon variants.

Yes, they don't have to leap to kill you. They swooped and incapacitated you from fighting back until dropped.

[neon spindle]

Idea: brute spawner

The spawner gets enraged upon 0 hp, starts spawning brutes every turn

[mystic shell]

Nerf potions

You got used to effects of potions. Every succeeding potion drunk only gives 95% effectiveness compared to previous potion.

E.g healing potion gives less %healing if it's your 10th pot of the run vs your 1st healing pot. Turn based pots will give less turns.

Nerf plants

The plants are one with you. Every plant you step on has 10% chance to curse your armor with overgrowth, removing any existing enchant

[azure garnet]

[mystic shell]

Hohoho

[grizzled flame]

buff sniper

[neon spindle]

Use weapons with higher strength has a chance to inflict bleeding as the weapon is too heavy to use

[grizzled flame]

swinging a weapon 75 times makes ur arm muscles tired, reducing ur strength to 10

[mystic shell]

Nerf wands

The mystical energies course through you, slowly turning you into something... different.

Each wand cast has 10% chance to give you an "elemental" counter.
Each counter gives you 1% additional magic damage to enemies (and also to yourself) as well as +0.5% evasion.

At 10 counters your fingers turn into an elemental and you are unable to equip rings

At 15 counters your arms turn elemental and you cannot use weapons

At 20 counters your body is elemental and you cannot use armor.

[grizzled flame]

u can only reverse this debuff by resting for a total of 10 turns

aka press the wait button to make the debuff duration go down by 1

[grizzled flame]

this is literally just a buff to wands save for the no rings part

lol

[mystic shell]

First 9 levels it's a double edged power yea

But it opens up challenge ideas in the future where beat yog as a full elemental is in play. No weapons, armor, or rings. Artifact is ok.

[azure garnet]

double edged
only energy benefits wands

if you use wands

then you gonna use wands

[mystic shell]

But no armor and rings tho

[azure garnet]

truly terrible idea, accomplishes nothing but buffs broken items

[mystic shell]

And also no weapons for times when you dont have charge, so battlemage isnt much of an option anymore (?)

[azure garnet]

👍

[mystic shell]

Pls downvote if you think it is terrible... thanks 😁

[grizzled flame]

"doubled edged"

its literally just a buff to wand users

the only bad part is rings gtting removed

everything else is a non issue and a straight buff to wand users so

lol

[mystic shell]

We can make it every 5, 10, 20, 25 counters then

[azure garnet]

if you want it to be nerf

[grizzled flame]

freerunner already doesnt have issues with charges

[azure garnet]

then it shouldn't give buffs

[grizzled flame]

throwables

what trsh said

[mystic shell]

Hmmmmmmm

[grizzled flame]

wand users do not care bout not being able to use weapons or armor

at all

so those drawbacks dont rly exist

[mystic shell]

How about spontaneous internal combustion every now and then?

Cause the energies fluctuate within you chaotically

Kinda like hunger, but more energy overflow smth

[plush hemlock]

Make it so at 40 counter, you can't wear your backpack.

[azure garnet]

if it doesn't kill, then it will just make player stronger

also

[grizzled flame]

new idea:

[azure garnet]

if it is just 5% chance

[grizzled flame]

fireblast now gets exponential scaling based on its upgrade level

[azure garnet]

what is probability than you will reach full power of downsides before you beat yog?

[mystic shell]

Then..... 10%.... and make it 5, 10, 15 and 20?

[grizzled flame]

wands have a 1% chance to break when used, going up by 1% every time u zap one and it deosnt break

[mystic shell]

The buff also acts against youause evil eyes might blast you with stronger damage

[grizzled flame]

when they break, u can still use them but all their effects will be cursed

[azure garnet]

that's how electrical explosive from summoning works

[grizzled flame]

using an upgrade scroll on a broken wand instantly repairs it and also upgrades it

[azure garnet]

except it is right now broken

[grizzled flame]

no more wand dumping

oh oos

[azure garnet]

I modified some numbers by accident

and it deals 0 damage

[azure garnet]

wait

so you can't upgrade wands normally?

[grizzled flame]

u can upgrade them

using a SoU to repair a broken wand still upgrades it

u just dont want to be left without SoUs bcuz then ur wand can break and u cant do shit

:p

[azure garnet]

well

if your wand deals more damage then you need to zap less frequently

[grizzled flame]

altho ngl making it so repairing a wand with an SoU doesnt upgrade the wand would aslso be very funny

also*

[azure garnet]

leaving less chance to break

[grizzled flame]

• clueless, as he zaps it once and it breaks

realistically u are gonna zap most wands at least once per enemy

so 1% then 2% then 3% then yara yara

[azure garnet]

if you really want it to be terrible idea

[grizzled flame]

take into account how many enemeis ull find in one floor

[azure garnet]

then only broken wands should be upgradeable

for misery

[grizzled flame]

fine then 10% with an increase of 2% per failed breakage

[azure garnet]

so you have to actually wear your wands down in order for them to be strong

[grizzled flame]

nah nah hear me out

new challenge: Wand Game

[azure garnet]

so like squid game

you can only zap wands when it is green light

if you do it when the light is red

you die instantly

[grizzled flame]

• every time u zap a wand, there's a 10% chance for it to transmute into another random type fo wand. Every 2 kills with a wand is a guaranteed transmute

• every time u swing ur weapon, theres a 10% chance for it to transmute to another of the same tier. Every 2 kills with it is a guaranteed transmute

• every throwable u throw has a 10% chance to transmute to anotehr of the same tier. Every 2 kills with it is a guaranteed transmute

rename it to Gun Game

[azure garnet]

honestly

I could use this

for rework of Entropy Drive

[grizzled flame]

lol

have fun with that

if u want even more chaos make the transmutes for weapon and throwable be within all tiers u can equip

example: a flail can only transmute into a t4, t3, or t2 (exclude t1 bcuz too mean)

[mystic shell]

Interesting...

Will enchants go along with transmute?

How about throwable durability tho? Say 2/5 durability transmuting to something with ?/15

Or even 1/5... will it disappear and not transmute if it's at its last durab?

[mystic shell]

Or maybe you can transmute between (-1,1), so either one up, same or one down

[grizzled flame]

Enchant gets rerolled every 3 procs of it

[grizzled flame]

% is passed ov3r

[mystic shell]

Some enchants are perma turned on tho, like Flow

So three water tiles and then reenchant? 😅

[grizzled flame]

Yes

[dusk sky]

lol the elemental thing is a class perk of one of cvpd heroes

[gritty nova]

Class specific challenges
Warrior: scale and plate armor are removed
Mage: mage's staff has its charges increased by 3, but you can no longer obtain wands, and wandmaker is gone
Rogue: Cloak of shadows charges 5x as slow, wands use your accuracy stat and your accuracy is reduced by 50%
Huntress: ||Quickslot is removed||

[dusk sky]

rogue one is too easy

[grizzled flame]

QUICKSLOT REMOVE NO

NO NO NO FUCK NO

also buddy

reducing non-melee accuracy by 50% doesnt do much when wands dont use acc

[gritty nova]

There we go!

[grizzled flame]

pog

[gritty nova]

Huntress one is the hardest one probably

you'd go mentally insane by demon halls and throw half your runs

[dusk sky]

just go warden lol

[grizzled flame]

it isnt hardest

its just the mot tedious

[grizzled flame]

warden button is also remove

not a part of the challenge, just a QoL change for huntress

u can no longer accidentally pick warden when sniper is the proper choice

[mystic shell]

Mage really becomes weak wandrunner

[grizzled flame]

mage was already weak wandrunner

ech

[dusk sky]

except there's no "runner" and you can only play warlock

since battlemage ability is completely useless with only 1 wand

[gritty nova]

nah

[mystic shell]

Warrior one doesnt seem too hard. Maybe limit both weapons and armor to tier 3?

[gritty nova]

the strat for mage challenge is transmutation scroll rng

[grizzled flame]

cry harder

[dusk sky]

ah so transmutation works

then those extra charges are super useful

[grizzled flame]

for warrior: all enemies have a 75% chance to be replaced by that chapter's ranged enemy

[mystic shell]

Hohoho

[grizzled flame]

scorpion dmg is also magical now

[dusk sky]

the biggest challenge is convincing yourself to play warrior

[grizzled flame]

^

wait

warrior challenge: u can only play zerker

[mystic shell]

Then what would be a good chall for the huntress?

[grizzled flame]

mage challenge: u can only play battlemage with transfusion

[mystic shell]

Instead of removing quicklsots

[grizzled flame]

rogue challenge: playing rogue in the first place

[gritty nova]

hmmm

[dusk sky]

the bow gets a durability limit

[gritty nova]

a serious challenge for huntress is your accuracy is reduced for each tile in between you and your target

[grizzled flame]

huntress challenge: no quickslots whatsoever so u cant quickslot seeds throwables or anything, and u have to manually click on ur weapon to atk

[dusk sky]

like other throwables

[mystic shell]

This might work

[azure garnet]

scale and plate armor are removed
have you heard about +22 leather armor?

[gritty nova]

how much does that even block

[mystic shell]

Warrior chall.

Warrior is a proud warrior. Warrior refuses to equip anything below tier 4. Warrior starts sewers with sword and armor unequipped because it is beneath him to use flimsy equip.

[azure garnet]

22-48

22-70 if defense-augmented

[mystic shell]

Basically survive no weapon /armor till you get str pots and +3 tier 4 stuff

[azure garnet]

it may not seem that much

[gritty nova]

I want to say that's good but at the same time that's so bad lmao

[azure garnet]

but the average of 22-48 is 35

and average of scorpio... is also 35 (30-40)

[gritty nova]

it's like

good for normal standards

[azure garnet]

you take no damage from scorpio because of huge min value

[gritty nova]

it's just for +20 standards it's... as expected

[azure garnet]

yes, I know it is very small

but because min damage is high

[gritty nova]

min damage is insane

[azure garnet]

you can just spam slam as gladiator

[gritty nova]

yep

man this makes me wanna try like +22 plate

with sai/gauntlets

and then just

[dusk sky]

thorns

[azure garnet]

my point was than scale and plate being absent doesn't prevent warrior from dumping leather and mail

and still be immortal and unstoppable

[plush hemlock]

Warrior secret challenge : Training journey.

To fulfil the challenge, never use any strength potion or upgrade scroll.

Any unupgraded weapon with higher strength level would increase your strength gradually as you train with them. For every 30 successful kill with it, increase 1 strength. Until reaching their strength requirement and you have to move on to the higher tier weapon.

Reward for winning challenge : badge of experienced warrior, and change of starting weapon: Pristine shortsword

Rogue secret challenge: Unsighted

To fulfil the challenge, you must never be seen by any common mobs outside boss arena.

Potion of invisibility would last shorter, cloak of shadows rate of charging would be longer. But ambush attack would guarantee kill, as long as enemy haven't see you.

Reward for winning challenge: badge of experienced rogue, and bonus starting artifact : Hidden blade

[gritty nova]

looks fun, but a bit easy

[mystic shell]

Trickier for multi mobs like flies / ghouls / spawner nests

Altho rogue does have the keep enemies sleeping talent so that makes it easier

[tall matrix]

It was a video of the simp stereotype

Bassically awooga bark bark when sellecting huntress

[shy mica]

if the demon spawner dies to fire it ill drop a rare food item called "Meatball"
it takes 30 turns to eat and gives you every negative debuff in the game

[plush hemlock]

Mage secret challenge: Mine's stronger than your's

To fulfil the challenge, you can only use your wands/staff charge on magical mobs.

If the challenge is still in progress, your wand/staff gain extra damage whenever fully charged.

Reward for winning challenge: badge of experienced mage, and bonus starting artifact: Mage hat

[azure garnet]

wdym magical

[teal moss]

Hmm. Yeah. Magical is kinda vague
Maybe he meant magicians

Let's hear him out

[plush hemlock]

Huntress secret challenge: Distance doesn't matter

To fulfil this challenge, kill enemy 20 tiles away from you using spirit bow 100x

If this challenge still in progress, your spirit bow gain free projecting enchantment.

Reward for winning challenge: badge of experienced huntress, free projecting enchantment in your spirit bow.

[azure garnet]

20 tiles away
there are literally no rooms this big in default shattered

[shy mica]

floor 26

i think

so you have to dure infuse a lot of summon traps

like

a shit ton

[dry canopy]

By that time the game is over

[plush hemlock]

Should've explained that magical part, hehe.

Magical mobs are those that mainly cast spells than physically hitting/shooting. Such as Gnoll shaman, dwarf warlock, that hooded guy in prison who summon skeletons, etc. Oh and elementals too

[shy mica]

the eye

the other eye

technically the ?

[plush hemlock]

Yeah evil eyes too

[dry canopy]

Or magical abilities

[plush hemlock]

Does the huntress challenge's distance impossible to achieve? Maybe i should lower it to 15

[shy mica]

to put in perspective

the dk arena is 11 tiles wide

so for 30 tiles you need to kill an enemy from 3 dk arenas away

100 times

wait no 20

thats still a lot

[plush hemlock]

Idk...i was thinking that this challenge would be feasible with projecting enchantment. Maybe the arrows could bypass walls, and hitting enemies far in other rooms.

You only had to detect them with mind vision first.

[azure garnet]

projecting only bypasses walls that are 4 tiles away man

[shy mica]

yea

proj bow hits anything thats 4 tiles away

[plush hemlock]

Ah shot, should also make appropriate enchantment first before attempting this.

[languid drum]

Text like this

[grizzled flame]

U do know projecting is worthless for this right?

[granite sundial]

Challenge Wraith

Everytime you kill a mob, a wraith will spawn and they always follow where you go

A DM will not spawn a wraith.

Boss have low chance to become wraith (Goo, Tengu, DK) with stronger power than normal wraith and have it's own unique attack

When a Mob that is not boss die in boss level, they will not become wraith but will spawn on next floor or will heal the boss if the boss still alive

[mystic shell]

Is that wraith friendly or enemy?

I'm guessing enemy since they will heal boss if boss still alive

That feels like it's part of a talent of mage

[earnest moat]

Huntress challenge : bow gives haste to ennemies

[plush hemlock]

Reworked huntress secret challenge: Unobstructed

To fulfil this challenge, shot enemies without seeing them first (eg. behind grass) x50.

If this challenge still in progress, your hearing heightened (inspecting a tile with hidden sleeping enemy would play sleeping enemy sfx)

Reward for winning challenge: badge of experienced huntress, able to see enemy hidden in grasses.

[wintry tendon]

Giant enemies now have sprites that are as large as 3x3 tiles

[mystic shell]

The 3x3 would find it difficult to enter narrow passageways tho...

Rka crowd diversity challenge gives you mobs like this

Maybe they could be 3x3 size, or just really big, but make it so they only occupy 1 tile so that they can still chase you through hallways 😁

[verbal topaz]

But giant champs can't

[mystic shell]

Which is why this is a terrible idea

😁

‐-------------------
Slippery floor

Walking on water tiles slows down move speed by 10%
gives a 10% chance to slip and gain 1 cripple
and 1-3 items will fall out of your bag

If you walk on water too long, you get the waterlogged feet debuff which is a long lasting (100 turn?) Debuff that gives 20% slower movespeed.

While water logged and still in water, Theres also a 10% chance for metal equipment to get rusty. Rusty equip will have a permanent debuff of -1 level, which can only be removed if use SoU or reforge

‐-------------------
Damp scrolls

Scrolls that are placed directly on top of a water tile will be unusable after being picked up. The scroll color will be grey instead of white to indicate it is a "damp" scroll.

Damp scrolls can be converted to normal scrolls by placing it beside a burning tile (not on top of)

[verbal topaz]

I mean, slippery floor seems the tcpd one but like opposit

[mystic shell]

Well yeah TCPD seems more like sliding floor, or ice skating rink

Or maybe this one would be better worded as... Wet world.... or Marshland...

I just think it would be funny to be running away from a gnoll and then getting ready to blast him with wand blast or smth... but after stepping on a water tole you slip, drop your wand beside you, and get crippled 1 turn, allowing gnoll to catch up and you cant zap in time anymore

Nyahahaha

[wintry tendon]

Delete and sue every mod of shpd. And ultimately, sue shpd itself as it isn't original pd

Make tengu british

Blazing champions move 25% slower on water and take 25% more damage. Cannot proc burning effect while on water

Yog is now 20% more racist

Challenge: enemies cannot die for the first 5 turns after receiving damage for the first time

[teal moss]

Ouch. What a really terrible idea lol

[tardy ingot]

idea: deathgazes without a cooldown

[maiden lily]

[neon spindle]

Vanilla evil eyes:

[red oak]

iirc there was a mod existed that a mob's deathgaze has no cooldown, from 11f~15f iirc?

[tardy ingot]

you are talking about #🐹yet-another pd's evil eyes, they spawn on the caves but have changed stats because of this of course

they are like vanilla's, without a cooldown

vanilla evil eyes though, dealt less damage with their gaze because it didnt have a cooldown

[red oak]

Anyway, I love current evil eye's deathgaze cooldown, because it provides strategy to avoid it. At least it's better than no way to avoid.

[tardy ingot]

i think that 2 turns to avoid it is too much

but 1 isnt enough

thats why it should be 0

[red oak]

then let's add the evil ability to deathgaze. When you take hit from deathgaze, one poh is always destroyed. Now 2 turns, is not too much because the reason to avoid is more important

[grizzled flame]

deathgaze now applies a funky debuff to you: Psionic Mark

• All enemies gain mind vision of you for its duration.
• Evasion is set to 0

[red oak]

Found a perfect solution for deciding cooldown turns. 2 if eye has full HP, 1 if eye has not full HP(angered)

[tardy ingot]

it wont do too much because i play without healing pots

[tardy ingot]

funny mark

[grizzled flame]

funny mark

[tardy ingot]

ok now we turn it in a bad idea: they enrage at full hp

[red oak]

lol

[dry canopy]

Rename them beholders so pd can get sued to death by wizards of the coast

[red oak]

New weapon idea but probably discriminatory: puritybane. 4-tier weapon.
Deals 20% more damage compared to average longsword if you have never consumed any ankh for a run, but deals 10% less damage in contrast if you have consumed any ankh.

Also new idea: anti-cure sword(sorry for the uncharacteristic name) 5-tier

Deals 25% more damage compared to average greatsword but while holding this weapon, if you drink all types of healing potions, you instead INSTANTLY DIE.

What a terrible idea.

[azure garnet]

Honestly, first one's downside doesn't sound meaningful

It kind of just rewards you for surviving without ankhs

Which doesn't take much of a skill

Second one is more impactful, but also kind of extreme

Pharma only essentially triggers poison dart trap under you

Not murders your character

[grizzled flame]

new artifact: Mirror Shard (+0)--> Shattered Mirror (+3)--> Cracked Mirror (+7)--> Perfect Mirror (+10)

While it may look like just a regular piece of reflective glass at first, taking a closer look at it reveals something rather unsettling: your own image is permanently affixed on it even as you tilt the mirror around, and you start feeling frailer by the second.

Universal effects: Weapon/wand/throwable minimum damage is increased by 7%/15%/24%/33% of its damage range. Accuracy is increased by 10%/15%/25%/40%. Evasion is decreased by 15%/25%/40%/50%

Effects at +3:
10%/20%/30% for attacks to "crit", causing different effects based on the attack.
Weapon: 1.5x the damage roll, applies bleeding for 30% of the damage rolled.
Wand: Roll for damage a second time and use the highest of the rolls, no wand charge is used.
Throwable: No durability is used, and it cripples + blinds for 3 turns.
Incoming damage is increased by 15%/25%/40%

Effects at +7:
All attacks ignore enemy armor and enemy dmg reduction (such as giant champs or demon spawners).
All attacks can now apply random debuffs from this list with a 15%/25% chance:
Bleeding (30% of the damage dealt), poisoned (20% of the damage dealt), corrosion (10% of the dmg dealt, 3 turns), vertigo (5 turns), charmed (5 turns), amok (6 turns), paralyzed (2 turns), rooted (4 turns), corrupted/doomed (special: has 1/10th the weight of the other debuffs in the pool, increases to 1/5th at +10).
All damage reduction effects (armor, tenacity, challenge scroll, etc) have their effectiveness divided by 10.

Effects at +10:
Attack speed is multiplied by 1.25x for all attacks (including wands).
Crits take 0 turns.
Drinking a healing potion/shielding potion/healing well/sungrass seed breaks the mirror, resetting it to +0 and inflicting bleeding on the player equal to 33% of their max hp.

Upgrading: Feed it healing items to repair the mirror. Healing potions are worth the most obviously. Takes quite a hefty amount of healing items to level it up though

yes this is glass cannon the artifact

yes it is too long

idc

hence why its a terrible idea

[runic granite]

Unequip it

whoops I just sidestepped all of the drawbacks

[dusk sky]

as a bonus it reflects evil eye beams

[tardy ingot]

atracts*

[dusk sky]

sure

[tardy ingot]

😃

[dusk sky]

oh wow

[runic granite]

Heh

[neon spindle]

Idea if you open the chests from rat king room he will ratmogriflies you

[dusk sky]

brilliant

[hardy ocean]

the strange thing is that the rat king doesn't tell you anything when all his gold is stolen xd

[shy mica]

all that money was for feeding his rat kingdom

and you stole it to buy drugs from a shady guy in a prison

[dusk sky]

you're using wrong reactions

[grizzled flame]

unqeuipping it also breaks it

at any lvl

easy

[mystic shell]

So basically use it but dont let it get to level 10

Also bow

Oof no wand charge used.... spam regrowth/chilling/mm

No durab used.... spam shurikens

I feel like you can cheese it by just bring it u to level 7.

However if you make it that it levels automatically by using healing items, it would be more dangerous. Like any healing item = +1 level.

So as long as you use less than 10 healing items in the game, you're good. Use more than that and it cracks and world of hurt

One might be tempted to level it up fast early game, but then you risk it cracking late game if you need to heal.. so better to pace its level up and only dump level 7 if near yog or smth

[grizzled flame]

probably

[grizzled flame]

its a chance

[mystic shell]

Ah.. yeha that's better

[grizzled flame]

id probably just hae the +10 draback be applied since the start

[grizzled flame]

the idea is u dont use any at all :p

[mystic shell]

Oof

Hmmm

So food is ur friend here

[grizzled flame]

near yog

so the same issue as amror abilities huh

aka worthless

[mystic shell]

And potion of cleansing maybe

Putting the level 10 debuff neat the start might be useful

All you need is one accident.... and say bye bye mirror

Will reviving from unblessed ankh keep it alive?

I'd be interested to see an artifact like this in game, even if the +10debuff happens at base level

Its gonna be kinda like Pharma x Barren land x No well of health

Not so bad cause food is your friend

[grizzled flame]

u can use ankhs yeah

[mystic shell]

Nice.. now to hope a dev sees this and implements in their mod 😅

[grizzled flame]

lol

no one will ets be real here

[dry canopy]

Leaping attack sets you on fire because his mixtape is so hot

[wintry tendon]

Ancient wendigo: a rare mob that appears at the floor you died last run and equips your weapons and armor you had when you died (which will not drop when killed)

Challenge: whoopsies -
Special effects have 50% chance not to trigger.

Includes enchantment rolls, plant effects, scrolls and potions (will simply be wasted) and last but not least, ankhs

[grizzled flame]

what does that have to do with a wendigo tho

[dusk sky]

nothing

to make it extra terrible

[grizzled flame]

bruh why u gonna waste the coolest monster out there

[dusk sky]

.

[grizzled flame]

but

but dude

😔

[dusk sky]

leave it a if it's that terrible

[earnest moat]

Vanilla-flavored dungeon
-No more grass outside of garden rooms
-No more water in every floor but 5, wich is full
-No more doors outside of boss floors

[dusk sky]

all food lines are changed to "this food tasted like vanilla"

[brittle skiff]

Losing a round locks your character slot for that class for 24 hours unless you pay for premium energy to recover it

[plush hemlock]

Dying removes that hero permanently from being used again.

If all hero were dead, start by using sane mobs (sane thief, sane guard, sane gnoll trickster, exiled dwarf warlock)

[red oak]

FYI: one of touhou pixel dungeon's item, three star ticket, was a reference of gacha game "BanG dream! girls band party!" That item does this - 90% chance to get a potion of strength, 10% chance to get a sou when use. In gbp, three star ticket does 90% chance to get a 3-star character, and 10% chance to get a 4-star character. Before this thread was opened, That was really bad but funny idea.

4th wall break idea - for mobile version only.
Turn on GPS system on your phone makes enemies always chase you.(think mark debuff) Can be used strategically to chase and kill enemies easier...

[dusk sky]

pixel dungeon nuzlocke

[ebon ingot]

Crabs should have demonic typing

[tardy ingot]

hey if fetid rats are demonics

why not crabs

[ebon ingot]

I mean it makes sense

Snakes should also be treated as minibosses

Obviously

[shy mica]

the cleric's class armor is a maid outfit

i willnow leave the thread

[tardy ingot]

good idea

[teal moss]

Not

[shy mica]

back

[teal moss]

Someone smack him. What a very terrible idea

[shy mica]

i see one person that likes it and one that doesnt

perfectly balanced

[granite sundial]

Dead corrupted enemy will posses other enemy in sight

[teal moss]

What does that do?

[shy mica]

a corruption bolt

so if the enemy is weak enuff it gets corrupted

[tardy ingot]

shadow bolt from warlocks?!?!?

[wintry tendon]

Add paths of good or evil

Such as helping wandmaker or killing him etc etc

Letting tengu flee

Infernax style

[verbal topaz]

deadriorr

[dusk sky]

a multi tier badge for dying or winning in an exact amount of turns starting with 5
end the game in 5 turns, end the game in 6 turns, end the game in 7 turns…
up to 15000

[grizzled flame]

YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES

[shy mica]

now 2 are for and 1 is against

isnt democracy beautiful

[verbal topaz]

Hey!

This is a thread only for bad ideas

[shy mica]

ah okok

[verbal topaz]

The good ides should go in Ideas megathreas

[teal moss]

3 vs 1
I hate democracy >:(

[wintry tendon]

Maid outfit cringe

[verbal topaz]

Megathread

[wintry tendon]

Make them wear the absolute baller pope outfit

[verbal topaz]

You cringe

[shy mica]

i have a compromise

[wintry tendon]

No u

[shy mica]

maid pope

[verbal topaz]

Aaaaaaa

[shy mica]

now everyones happy

[wintry tendon]

Idea: any character resembling a maid will die in a horrible death, a death with the likes of final destination. Or saw

[verbal topaz]

Wow we are both so mature

[wintry tendon]

Add crack cocaine and black tar heroin to alchemy

Breaking bad mod

[verbal topaz]

Please play tohou pd

[shy mica]

gives adrenaline

[shy mica]

theres coke???!???

[wintry tendon]

An*me 🤮🤮

[shy mica]

...

bruh

its not even an anime

[wintry tendon]

Still same ish

[shy mica]

i think

its a bullet hell

which is the best kind of action game

[wintry tendon]

Jrpg inspired sprites. Looks more like anime unlike final fantasy style

[verbal topaz]

I mean

[azure garnet]

fun fact: there was once an attempt to elect female pope

[verbal topaz]

Can we consider undertale as bullet hell

[shy mica]

no

theres not eough bllets

[wintry tendon]

But catholic Church decided female = cringe

[shy mica]

bruh me english

[azure garnet]

it didn't really work out

[teal moss]

Oh man this thread went completely off the rails lol

[azure garnet]

🔪

[dusk sky]

✅ bullet
❔ hell

[verbal topaz]

The flowey battle is a bullet hell

[wintry tendon]

The real bullet hell is playing counter strike on 1:1 aspect ratio with sensitivity set at 400

[shy mica]

this thread went from maids to drugs to touhou

[verbal topaz]

See?

Pure terrible ideas

[shy mica]

10/10 experience reminds me of pd matchmaking

[wintry tendon]

Pixel dungeon mmorpg when

[verbal topaz]

Yes please

But evan will kill you

[shy mica]

the first letter of MMORPG means "massive"

[verbal topaz]

If you suggest it

[shy mica]

[wintry tendon]

DotA 2 2 if you will

[verbal topaz]

I love mmorpgs

[dusk sky]

i don't

[shy mica]

begone

[wintry tendon]

There could be some Easter eggs hidden as well idk

[verbal topaz]

Skyblock, elder scrolls, wynncraft are my personal favourites

[shy mica]

wynn?

[verbal topaz]

Imagine tryna kick me

[shy mica]

oh hey another wynn player

[dusk sky]

sorry it's funny every time

[shy mica]

its funnier with neo

[wintry tendon]

Chardon de rat becomes a Easter egg. Like lusty argonian maid from elder scrolls

[verbal topaz]

Started 2 weeks ago, alr in love with it

[shy mica]

ah

quick tip

have th emusic on

[verbal topaz]

I dunno why skyblock has more players tho

[shy mica]

dont play more than 100 hours

[verbal topaz]

Too late

I have 400

[wintry tendon]

Unrelated: why does Terraria calamity community bully music makers

[shy mica]

istfg it gets worse every subsequent time

[dusk sky]

removing someone from a thread does literally nothing but the system message adds a dramatic effect

[wintry tendon]

Also they hate whips

[shy mica]

poor dokuro

[azure garnet]

because terraria community doesn't understand than things take time

[shy mica]

500 in 2 years

i remember doku posting a vid explaining what they had to do b4 the calamitas themes

[wintry tendon]

Once saw a video by shyguymask where he was literally banned for arguing vanilla whips made sense and said summoner whip is a viable class

[dusk sky]

join terraria discord they'll bully you as well

it's hell

with no bullet

[wintry tendon]

For a community of tryhards they really go off the rails lmao

[verbal topaz]

400 in 6 mo

[shy mica]

br

[azure garnet]

shyguy can go fuck themselves as well

[shy mica]

still no mythics 😔

[verbal topaz]

Bruh

[shy mica]

lets talk bout wynn in #casual

[wintry tendon]

Did he do something. I just watch his gameplay

[azure garnet]

he attempted to argue with the wall and constructed a biased text wal

[wintry tendon]

Also PvZ meta videos were great

[dusk sky]

actually it's because terraria is very very popular so the loud minority of annoying people is just more visible

[wintry tendon]

I think a few months ago (or a year?) I heard shit about the calamity dev going off the rails

Some small drama

Something about hating qol

And saying it's "cheating"

Vein miner and all

[azure garnet]

there is always drama because most of terraria mod devs are not prepared to handle popularity they face and catch starstruck disease

and go mentally unstable

[dusk sky]

as if mining is in any way important in terraria

[azure garnet]

some of them are straight up egoistical

[dusk sky]

you walk through caves for like 30 minutes and you have everything you need from underground

[azure garnet]

veinminer is cheating since it fixes what doesn't need to be fixed 🔪

[wintry tendon]

It's one of the most time consuming and yet, most important aspect that only becomes easier lategame (when you need it least) so it's kinda ironic.

Most time consuming would be drop farming and fishing ig

[dusk sky]

also who cares about cheating in a game where you can join a server with all items and just bring them to your world 100% legally

[wintry tendon]

I still don't know if saving time can be considered "cheating".

Especially for those games that takes time to grind and if you found a thing that can speed things up, but change nothing else, is it really cheating?

[dusk sky]

fixing something in a game that's completely broken

[wintry tendon]

Reminds me of a post where a dude cheating and got the zenith off the get-go but did not enjoy playing anymore because they took away a core gameplay mechanic lmao

[shy mica]

its almost like removing the challenge and getting your objective super easily removes alll the fun

[azure garnet]

like I would argue than veinmining in minecraft is excusable because you can't increase your efficiency in mining past certain point

so mining several blocks at once was the direction mods took

however

in echraria you have dynamite and bombs

also pickaxe's stats actually matter

you have the ways to make your mining faster via vanilla means

[dusk sky]

which makes picking out iron ore one piece at a time better in what way?

by the time you get those endgame pickaxes you don't even need to mine anything

just swing those 3 useable weapons at bosses or something

[azure garnet]

there is noticeable difference between early game pickaxes already

[azure garnet]

I hate than community at large hyperfocuses on arguably weakest aspect of the game and forgets about everything else

[dusk sky]

nah i'm just personally biased

[azure garnet]

I am for real

many discussions online and videos boil down to rushing bosses and ignoring anything else like it doesn't matter

the main apotheosis being calamity's design philosophy and its community

[dusk sky]

i don't see what else is there to do other than building and fighting bosses

fishing? noooooooope

cool weapons are cool but many of them are just too weak because they're just oh so obsessed with balance in a sandbox game

in addition to tiny drop chances that make it so you have to scour through the wiki for hours to learn of half the content's existence

[brittle skiff]

Make it where your character can be paralyzed by the Neverending realization that even if they get the amulet the long days they spent in the dungeon still only amount to a tiny speck of time compared to the grand scheme of things.

[wintry tendon]

Ballista trap: when activated, will spring up like a sentry, takes 3 turns to fire. If you are in its line of sight, will damage you and push you back. Will pin you to a wall if you are close to it and stun you for 5 turns. Damage is 2.5x worn dart trap

[tall matrix]

Darkest pd ballista flashback

[granite sundial]

Change succubus to amogus when Playing huntress

[plush hemlock]

New levels : Drowned ruins.

Alternative of prison after sewers, this depth uses similar tileset as prison, but with more molds and blue hue, indicating the levels is underwater.

The hero could buy a diving gear from merman merchant on floor 6, and supplies of oxygen bubbles. These new items could also be harvested from air pocket found around the levels.

Water tiles removed, vision significantly reduced compared to normal prison lighting. Grasses changed into corals, which couldn't be destroyed but could be used to hide.

Mobs would mostly aquatics. Piranhas would be common here, but with reduced health points. Drowneds, Electric eels, Water elementals, Snapper turtles.

Npc quest would be only found on the last normal floor in this level, the npc : Distressed hero. Uses almost same rogue sprite except using blue rogue garb.

The distressed hero ask you to help him escape the level, either by going back to 5 floors or by helping him fighting the Hydra (this levels boss).

If you succeed the npc would gave you one of his artifact: cloak of depth, or horn of flooding. This quest also unlock subclass exclusive for rogue : Depth strider. An elusive stalker of depth.

Enchained Hydra boss fight requires you to slain 3 hydra heads in short succession. Fail to do this, the head would healed to full hp.

[red oak]

Use a blazing weapon successfully prevent healing to full. Because dcss hydra reference

[plush hemlock]

But the general blazing damage would reduced by half. Because you know, it's underwater.

What is blazingly hot would only feel warm

[dry canopy]

You mean mythology reference

[granite sundial]

Potion and scroll funnhahdjd

[wintry tendon]

Add option to upload custom music

[dusk sky]

allow everyone to commit to shattered on github

[wintry tendon]

Ring of Duplication: When taking direct enemy damage (non-trap/environment hazard like poisons), you have a chance to go invisible for 1 turn and summon an illusion that takes 200% damage and deals 25% of your damage. Invisibility fades as soon as you move or attack/use items (to counteract haste effects).

Chance increases with levels and also with lower HP

[plush hemlock]

Darker prisons.

Add more cells like room, with cages, stray chains, torture racks, and execution block.

Add new mobs too : torturer (will pull and bleed you), starved thief (stole ration/meats. Run faster than thief too), and Sadistic guard (which hunt random thieves when not targeting you. Pull, stun, and bleed you)

Tengu uses starved thieves in his first phase, hypnotized them to cannibalize you. (Add bleed in their physical hit, disable stealing ability)

The traps would spawn in his second place, alongside his barrages of projectiles. He could also pull himself away if you move close, using stray chains he stole from some guard.

[dusk sky]

this is the terrible ideas thread for shitposting stop sending detailed ideas here

#1017621268448673824

[plush hemlock]

It was terrible tho, terrible to develop

[tardy ingot]

adding more annoying prision enemies is a terrible idea

[wintry tendon]

Warden now charge up their chain pull like evil eyes, and can pull enemies if they obstruct the warden

[tardy ingot]

warden now can use their chains at any range and can use them like the hero

[echo heath]

If you drink too much potion you die by potion overdose

[shy mica]

guards are aggressive towards thieves, and so are dm100s
spinners are kept as pets by gnolls
if for some reason you see a succubus and a warlock near each other you take psionic damage
evil eyes attack 8 times a turn, 1 for each tentacle and 1 for their gnarly toothy maw

this also includes the deathgaze

it fires 8 times

[grizzled flame]

Female versions of each mob

[dusk sky]

awful!

great job

[grizzled flame]

Idea: remove other mod channels and just keep shattered's

Not like anyone else plays other mods

[teal moss]

Remove #pd-general while you're at it cos it's pointless at that point 😔

[wintry tendon]

Remove any PD mod that doesn't have minimum 15% of shattered's concurrent player count

Add pipe bomb recipe to Alchemy

As in, literal real life pipe bomb recipe

[grizzled flame]

New item: rat ears
You can wear them to look cute

[verbal topaz]

Sounds like coders

[azure garnet]

Nah you can be perfectly calm as programmer

Just don't take too much responsibility

[dry canopy]

Just like og rogue lol

[tall matrix]

" this machine does what i tell it to do, but not what i want it to!"

[knotty crow]

bro

[wintry tendon]

Comically Large Spoon: T6 item that requires 22 strength to use.

Lets you eat a spoonful of ice cream

[plush hemlock]

Shattered amulet of yendor.

You only find the amulet chain after beating yog, on the amulet pedestal.

Find the scattered shard on levels above. Make it ascending more exciting

[grizzled flame]

honestly

not even a bad idea

[dusk sky]

don't post normal ideas here

[wintry tendon]

Make warrior W I D E R

[wintry tendon]

Boi what da hell boi

[granite sundial]

Change ghost to Sewer Guard instead, he need your help to kill the miniboss enemy (fetid rat, gnoll trickster, giant crab), he will give you a 2 weapon choice

Ghost will spawn in random region that is not sewer

The ghost miniboss is

Guard captain
Tengu Minion

Queen spinner
Vampire brutes

Dwarf necromancer
Mining Golem

Elder eye
Skesjsuusu

[plush hemlock]

Permanent damage.

Every hits taken reduce health points by 1 hp.

Piranhas attack you once before dying if you pull it with chains

[dry canopy]

Gender swapped sprites for the player character

[neon spindle]

Sucubbus spawn as male gender

[feral fractal]

Spd gay edition

[neon spindle]

The shop prices are not inclusive of gst (to get the item you must pay with gst)

[granite sundial]

Incubus spawn when you play huntress

[plush hemlock]

NFT pd

[grizzled flame]

Its the 173th time someone suggest this here

New rare enemy variant: gnoll wizard (has a pointy hat)
He shoots a +7 fireblast at u instead of the usual shaman bolts. This attack can be used infinitely when at range

Replace the pasty with a taco during 5 de Mayo

[grizzled flame]

Do not call me out like that

💀

Now idk if thats allowwd

Allowed

[teal moss]

Now these are really horrible and facepalm-y ideas
Downvote

[dry canopy]

Oh that's actually amazing

Ayo bruh

[dusk sky]

(it isn't)

not even as a joke

[grizzled flame]

There it goes

[dry canopy]

F

[shy mica]

what

what was that

[ebon ingot]

Some really terrible ideas

[shy mica]

more details are needed

[ebon ingot]

[shy mica]

it cant be that terrible

can it

[dusk sky]

it was called "racism pixel dungeon" i think that's enough of an explanation

[shy mica]

[wintry tendon]

Harem pixel dungeon

With new biome: succubus lair

[grizzled flame]

Haram pixel dungeon

The only change is theres no more succubi

[sharp parcel]

Spawn champions in every open tile on the depth entrance of the first floor

(the room)

[granite sundial]

Don't lie

[granite sundial]

No more scroll

[teal moss]

lol why tho

[granite sundial]

Because is fake

Reading scroll will do nothing

Real life pd then

Scroll do nothing
Some item (cloak of shadow, mage staff, spirit bow) doesn't exist

Instead the unique item from hero start is changed maybe?

[shy mica]

huntress has an actual bow

mage has bombs and napalm

rogue has blinding darts/pocket sand

warrior's seal gives you a small reputation bonus

so cheaper prices

[granite sundial]

Scroll of upgrade changed to upgrade tool

[shy mica]

repairs your item

it also has a chance to make it better

but how

cloth armor gets leather plating added?

for armor it adds plaques of the newt tier to it

plate gets plates of stone

after enough upgrades it turns into armor of next tier

[granite sundial]

Enchant your item improve the quality

[shy mica]

maybe it coats it in a specific substance?

[granite sundial]

Yes

[shy mica]

chilling has paralyzing coating

burning coating

[granite sundial]

Handmade Huntress rifle

[shy mica]

gun

cossbows pierce after killing

crossbows*

gases spread fire

YAPD called

[gritty nova]

the game runs live instead of being turn based

[shy mica]

taking damage bleeds you

[granite sundial]

Rogue have a start throwable weapon, he always hit 100% on enemy eyes, blind it permanently

[shy mica]

enemies deal bonus damage based on accuracy

[sharp parcel]

Bloodbag challenge

[shy mica]

bcuz they hit the weak spot

[granite sundial]

What about dwarfen

[shy mica]

the damage boost is exponential

elementals are

what would eles be

[granite sundial]

Drone

[hollow verge]

wa O.o

[granite sundial]

Blinding drone, Flame drone, Frost drone

[shy mica]

chaos drone

wands become vials

[granite sundial]

Then how the dwarf become corrupted?

[shy mica]

money

yog is the representation of corporate greed

aka some very highly esteemed dwarf

who takes coin showers and wipes their ass with gold plates

[granite sundial]

Tengu mask is Changed to the tome of mastery like in vannila

[hollow verge]

new challenge is: you can't drink potion of stregth and heath.

[shy mica]

you still get the mask

[granite sundial]

But it's blocking

Damage

[shy mica]

you can equip it to ger more reputation

but less accuracy

[granite sundial]

And -1 vision

[shy mica]

bit harsh

dwarven crown massively increases reputation

but dwarves ae enraged

you can sell it for a shitton of gold

[granite sundial]

What reputation

[shy mica]

better prices

npcs give you better rewards

some smarter enemies give up instead of fighting

paralysis freezes you entirely

including your vitals

so

[feral fractal]

death

[granite sundial]

Gas mask

[teal moss]

I think some loonies actually do that as a personal challenge lol

[shy mica]

heavily decreases accuracy

but reduces/cancels airborne effects

some enemies can break the mask if they are accurate enough

but that strike wont deal damage

what would halls looklike

[granite sundial]

You gain a weapon experience, if you kill more and more enemy with that weapon, you will level up weapon mastery, making you can attack faster/ more accurate attack

[shy mica]

it also reduces the str requirement

[dusk sky]

make spirit bow have 0 damage with 0/0 scaling but also 0 strength requirement

[granite sundial]

Why

You create this thread, you are not allowed to ideas

[shy mica]

they are tho

[teal moss]

owned

[shy mica]

he is gone

https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/807178579506626650/975370965884215306/crab.gif

[granite sundial]

Cry about it

[shy mica]

he hath returneth

[granite sundial]

Wait

[dusk sky]

yeah it does nothing

[granite sundial]

Noo pls Don ban me aygchfc😭

[dusk sky]

okay

[granite sundial]

Who is aygchfc anyway

Wait

There's is no way

[dry canopy]

Hmm

[teal moss]

"Occasionally summon demon after killing mobs"
Holy crap a better warlock from floor 1. Awesome
(Unless the demon is hostile then uh, un-awesome)

[dusk sky]

please stop with the controversial stuff

[tardy ingot]

great idea

[wintry tendon]

Add portal gun

Mage Armor ability but cooler

[shy mica]

because life leech

succubi deal magic damage if you are charmed

disintegration inflicts bleed because

theres a fucking hole in your insides

that thing can blast open barricades

[earnest moat]

this food didn't taste

[verbal topaz]

Ok what about this: if you eat too much food you get diabetes, that makes you fat and slower

Or what about this: no more str pots, instead there is a gym each 3 floors, where you can train for getting more strength

There is also the chance you get the "wand of hot single in your area", giving you an ally that charms enemies, like succubus

Ok what if rogue has an artifact called hair, that grows him hair when it's at 100% chance

[verbal topaz]

Charge

Easy but beautiful idea: in city there is a dwarf warlock strip club

You can also get there the wand of hot singles

[tardy ingot]

great idea

[teal moss]

No. It's a bad idea
Stop disagreeing with me >:/

[maiden lily]

Idea: when you die, you have to buy the whole game again

[red oak]

lmao

[tardy ingot]

idea: when you die, you die irl too

[granite sundial]

Everytime you touch grass, you lose str

[dry canopy]

Life is the og RL

[wintry tendon]

Add option to cover yourself in oil

[teal moss]

I wonder what that would do
(other than obviously make you take extra fire damage)

[wintry tendon]

Wait for it to rain

Step 3: Fly

[teal moss]

smh. yeah I've seen the meme
Free levitation potion I guess

[red oak]

New weapon idea, Toyama Kasumi's random star: You start to play Kisuna Music music, triggers an alarm trap, but hearable enemies take -10% damage continuously per each turn when you face an enemy.

[tardy ingot]

potion of sex

changes your character's gender

[red oak]

terraria?

[tardy ingot]

i was referencing to terraria

hmmm

what if shopkeepers sold red potions from terraria

[red oak]

Perhaps someone makes terraria pd?

as terraria has lots of contents.

[teal moss]

TIL Terraria has a miraculous sex-change potion 😐

[tardy ingot]

wouldnt be a terrible idea

imagine yog as moonlord

[maiden lily]

Yoglord

[tardy ingot]

or the DM300 as the golem

[wintry tendon]

You can craft explosive shurikens if you craft shuriken + scroll of retribution + stone of blast.

Deals usual thrown weapon X3 damage to enemies in a 3x3 area and 1x damage to enemies in a 5x5 area. Also knocks back enemies closest to the blast much like a wand of blastwave

[teal moss]

Doesn't sound that terrible of an idea 🤔

[wintry tendon]

With several upgrades it starts dealing massive amounts of damage (and also takes zero turns to use) and doesn't break. Also can situationally stun enemies.

Maybe not too broken but still, a nifty tool

[tardy ingot]

give the runic blade this effect

😃

[red oak]

New terrible idea: cursed sword from dead cells
While holding this, you always get mind vision passively.
All types of damaging traps are visible.
When you try to attack, you backstep by 1 tile so you avoid enemy's melee attack turn basically.
Once you hit an enemy, that enemy is instantly killed.
When you take any damage,(even with hunger damage!) You instantly die.

Ankh, 100% dmg reduction(from talent) are ignored. Even 0 damage will kill you.

On boss floors, these effects are all disabled and works as a normal melee weapon.(also temporarily disables instakill)

Mistyping fix: backstab->backstep

[granite sundial]

Imbue mage staff with the returning spell and teleport scroll will make Lloyd beacon

Ideas

You can now imbue your staff with Scroll

Recharging imbue staff will make your staff charge faster

Retribution imbue staff will do a lot of damage to 10x10 area, the staff charge will reduced by 2, also you will blind and your wand damage will reduced by 33%

Teleport imbue staff will teleport your enemy when you zap with your staff, when enemy killed when you zap and drop item the item will in your backpack

Terror imbue staff will frightened your enemy when you zap with it for 2 turns

Remove curse imbue staff will damage a demonic or undead enemy when you zap with it

Rage imbue staff amok the enemy

Ye

[wintry tendon]

Remove ring of haste.

Add a boots accesories slot

Different types of boots throughout the dungeon can now be found which gives different bonuses relating to movement;
The simplest one being a flat speed increase,
Others including "rushing" - attacking after moving in a line dealing extra damage,
"Side stepping" - which gives a chance to evade attacks and automatically moving one time to the sides etc etc

[grizzled flame]

The flat bspeed increase seems like the strongest by a good margin

Also its not good to make extra movement sources even more common and givr them their dedivated slot

But then again this is terrible ideas so

[shy mica]

you can randomly find miniboss rooms in the dungeon, marked by a differentkinda door
entering the room (it cant be entered/exited using TPs) will lock the door and fore you to either fight a champion mob/rare enemy in a preset arena
killing the opponent will give you a guaranteed mob drop from that enemy, and will also spawn 2-4 normal chests in that room

corrupting/charming it will open up the room but not give the chests

you gain a badge if you defeat the enemy with duelist

[grizzled flame]

Eating too often makes u fat
If ur fat u move and attack slower
Starve for a while to unbecome fat

[granite sundial]

Well fed?

[grizzled flame]

Starving for too long makes u emaciated
If ur emaciated u deal much less dmg and get ur str set to 10
Eat often for a while to unbecome emaciated

[shy mica]

pick your poison

[grizzled flame]

Balance is what uneed

[shy mica]

always hungry

itll make small rations actually good

[grizzled flame]

New idea for a PD
Shredded Pixel Dungeon
New gym mechanics for u to naturally increase ur str
Enemy sprites become progressively more buff as u descend (DK is bodybuilder levels of buff)
Whenerver thr hero or enemy attackz, they now do a random jojo pose
Pots of str are removed (no steroids >:( )

[granite sundial]

All hero now can leap for 2 tiles, after leaping you will get 20 turn exhaustion that make your walk 20% slower

[grizzled flame]

Chance to insta die from rat bites due to sepsis

[shy mica]

snakes can choke you to death but gain less evasion while choking

[granite sundial]

Prison guard drop human meat

[grizzled flame]

Prison guard dating simulator

[shy mica]

ifrit isnt here to kick you now

[granite sundial]

Who

[grizzled flame]

New fishing minigamez

A bejeweled-style gamemode where u match and combine tiles to defeat enemies and progress

Succubi now wink at u when they charm u

[granite sundial]

Eating human meat permanently poison you, the affect only gone when you drink PoHealing

[shy mica]

https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/791129308495216691/1015607226305622096/mob_succubus.gif

like this?

[grizzled flame]

New mechanic: healing potion addiction

[grizzled flame]

Yes yapd is so fucking based

[shy mica]

im becoming more based by the second playing YAPD

[grizzled flame]

Potion healing addiction:
Each hp pot u consume in a run lowers the effectiveness of the next hp pot u drink by 33%

Completing a chapter reduces this effect by the equivalent of one hp pkt

[shy mica]

it gets less effective for every turn without drinking a potion

[granite sundial]

Gladiator combo move is depends on weapon

[grizzled flame]

Drinking 4 makes u officially addicted: new status effect that counts down from 100 turns. If u dont drink another hp pot before it reaches 0, u take 25% of ur max hp in dmg

[azure garnet]

here is my terrible idea

rings are removed