#Whos your most requested character to be in smash that isnt already listed here
598 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
this poll sucks
mongus
That isn’t already listed here
I agree
why the fuck is shantae so high
lol
Freddy fivebear
Be so for real
Whos your most requested character to be in smash that isnt already listed here
Trybel im gonna be real idgaf about bandana dee
respectfull i dont know over half the characters there
Wr do not need bandana dee
Kirby got enough shit as is
also yeah we do not need bandana dee
James bond
Anyways add Commando RoR2
Or a mini version of master hand
Yes we do
All bandana Dee haters should perish
kirby is very underrepresented h
im glad that with the mario rpg remake, people realize that geno is really not that important a character
i have a hard time believing heavy made it in eu but not america
like seriously
heavy tf2
Magalor
why are we lying
The fact that jibanyan got more votes in the EU than he did in Japan is crazy
It has 3 reps
or magalor
POKEMON HAS 9
it's way bigger
Its not really a franchise that brings home the bacon for nintendo
Not 3 times bigger
pokemon is the biggest media franchise
?
Pokemon is the highest grossing franchise of all time
Wait pokemon has 9?
Kirby has an appropriate amount of characters for the nature of the franchise
What are they
It just doesn't have many memorable characters
The only over represented franchise in terms of fighters to sales/importance to Nintendo is your pal fire Emblem
just look up a list
Yeah
Anyways add Jonesy from fortnite
cope
Dark Samus does not count has metroid having 4 reps be so ffr
Half of metroid roster is one person lmao
Its significantly over three times bigger
Kirby hasnt made more than 10B total gross
based
Pokemon has made 90 B
I think 9 is a bit much tbh
?????
Counterpoint kirby is awesome
Yo ass is the one coping about mid ass Kirba Goomba who wears a bandana not being added
It's not
Surely you can cut like 2 of them
trybel you dont have to argue "representation" or whatever
Add Chad from jingi storm
No i agree, you can
i don't
But it isnt an argument for another kirby rep
Bandana Dee would be like the only character in smash to use a spear
that's why im leaving the arguemtn to cool down
Esp for fucking BANDANA DEE
Yeah
instead of like
there definitely is
fire emblem is overrepresneted thats it
Mark
Like 7 is a good number
Or megalor
dont some of byleths attacks use one
Also sev if the roster was decided purely based on money you might as well just call it Pokemon vs Mario characters
Anyway my answer to the question is Maxwell from Scribblenauts.
yeah thatd be nice
only character in fighting game history to have tech revolving hitting the griddy. need i say more?
That’s a little bit different from a full moveset
Add another fe sword character I think the game needs it
i suppose
Add spamtong spanto
They already added dark pit wdym
I love edging
Oh yeah this a godo one
LMAO
they should add goldeen and magikarp to represent the current state of mainline pokemon tbh
add the knight from hollow knight
I mean
Kirby already has 3 reps though
Shantae has... a world of light spirit
flop
or grimm
No fuck edge add rocket launcher bowser
💤 take
He's completely separate from normal bowser
us
couldn't care less!
Shut
anyway they should add my main man Prince Fluff before Bandana Dee anyway
Unironically, Meta Knight can be replaced by Bandana Dee.
If people want to restrict kirby to 3.
Edge would be way cooler
Hell nah
Anyway bandana dee wouldn't even be the best kirby rep they could add
Magalor or Marx would be so much better
Worst take in this thread
fr
Counterpoint bazooka bowser
FUCK jibanyan’s already there, uhhhh, usapyon
Meta Knight if being important to modern kirby. 🥱
Hollow knight lame and bad
GOLISOPOD!! CUT SHIT LIKE GRENINJA OUT IF U NEED TO
No more swordfighters
add both tbh
all three
they should do three mage sisters as a pokemon trainer situation
kirby deserves it
Nah kirby doesn't need 6 reps
kirby with 6 reps would be fucking awesome
I love the series but it is not 6 reps worthy
and who are you to decide lmao
Marx is lame though magalor better
golisopod is based it carried by run and bun e4 run
Id alson be like to state retroactively that trybel counted pokemon trainer as 3 chars
It is.
because they are when gameplay is considered
Plus rtdl got remade a few months ago so mag is fresh on the mind
I left to take. Shower bht meant to say that earlier
It's three reps
And it's a lame 3
Bandana Dee was in there too 
I am telling you we need Prince Fluff
Kirby's epic yarn is unique. It offers unique gameplay opportunities.
Marx and Magalor are cool, but they are also just from normal mainline games. We need to get quirkier
Kanto starters are so overdone
Epic embed fail
YOU DID NOT JUST CALL PT LAME
Dosent the pokeball have a ton of pokemon you can get from it?
This is true also
Pokemon trainer is the most hype pokemon fighter in smash tbh
Ip grabber
Prince Fluff was removed in Kirby Epic Yarn.
Shouldn't we count all those as well if we count pokemon trainer as 3 separate characters
Lmao
oh sorry we arent getting maractus in smash bruh
Stanley from the Stanley parable
I wish pt had three starters from 3 different gens
Or like if it was Cynthia with gar/spirit/toge
Anyway if we were to get rid of 2 pokemon reps I would get rid of pichu and incineroar (sadly)
Pichu is cheating
Kill gren before incin
no no greninja goes before incineroar
?
Nobody asked for this guy brah
golisopod is just better than pt combined 🫡
Greninja never goes because it's the most popular pokemon as of 2020
Pichu is a scam of a slot
Pichu is a glorified echo fighter
Saying he takes a slot is akin to saying lucina takes a slot
Yeah but he counts as a rep so he goes
waluigi
he was literally introduced in epic yarn what are you on about
Next add raichu and they heal themselves
That’s how echos work yeah
You know
Nintendo themselves genuinely do not care when it comes to cutting characters
Like
I see everybody go
“Oh theyre gonna cut so many characters”
No
Theyre gonna cut the characters they cant financially justify the rights to
Id be down for priince fluff
That's cause it's a transform character dumbass
Theyre not gonna cut chatacters off of roster size
Thats appealing to like
0.03% of the fanbase
While keeping someones favourite main appeals to 100% of the fanbasw
Piranha plant cannot be cut he's too funny
Yeah aiinit nobody beiing sold on "We removed these characters!"
Piranha Plant is hella sick
I actually do main Piranha plant and it's the funniest thing ever (I also always lose)
Every single nintendo character will return for smash six.
Ptooie is a really good edgeguard though
That is my prediction
Extra Epic Yarn
Except maybe like
he was still there
just not playable
Toon link/young link
Let's get Peter griffin for smash 6
because no multiplayer
angry bird
They could have made him a swappable character. With how much random junk they added.
why is a pyuo pyuo character here
Anyway of the pokemon here's my opinions on who could be cut or not:
Pikachu: lol
Jigglypuff: From a pokemon stand point this should be cut, but from a smash standpoint Jigglypuff is one of the original 12 which makes me not what to cut her.
Mewtwo: I could see mewtwo being cut seeing as he already had been cut at one time, but I would rather see him stick around
Pichu: lol (for the opposite reason as pika)
Pokemon trainer: I hope this one never gets cut again because it's such a cool character. But I could see them pulling a smash 4 and cutting squirtle and ivysaur and making charizard a solo character again
Lucario: too popular to be cut imo
Greninja: Same thing as Lucario
Incineroar: Definitely could be cut now that gen 7 is over. I don't see really any reason to keep him other than the fact that his moveset is awesome
I wonder where all the “nobody has any personal attachment to Piranha Plant, such a shitty addition, you would all play as a walking dildo if you could” people went after Plant came out with the sickest fucking moveset of all time
cut incin
replace it with golisopod (cooler gen 7 rep)
Pichu might get cut
Nobody else will
What reason does nintendo have to cut characters they own
Saves development time and costs
Pichu is a Pikachu echo though lol
Its been 6 years since smash 5
No its not
Smash Is one of their highest grossing franchises
Jigglypuff rest is too iconic, can't be cut
Its not a franchise theyre gonna “cut costs” on
honestly not sure about Lucario
what does he even bring to the table?
Aura
Gamefreak has been trying to sell him as “your favourite” since gen 4
Hes gotten multiple movies and was ashs ace in the generation he won
I dont even think hes popular off of people like him i think its just an exposure thing
meh
just not very fond of the guy
furries
Seriously though greninja was #1 and lucario was #2 on the 2020 official pokemon popularity poll
Neither will ever get cut
Brah thats because theyre in smash
Porgs for me
i hope incin stays he's way cooler than greninja or lucario
Smash is only part of the popularity of those 2
And even then who cares where their popularity came from, the fact is they will never be cut ever because they now have that popularity
Already iin
real chicken or the egg situation, isn't it?
It’s kinda scary how many people are concerned with adding or cutting characters based off of how much of a cash cow their respective franchise is, instead of how unique they’d be among the cast of existing characters
i want to see a traditional 2d fighting game with smash roster
Isn’t that just Mugen
was Lucario originally popular on its own? Or did it just get popular due to getting a movie then getting into smash then getting a mega evo as a gym leader ace with a focus in the anime etc etc etc
yeah mugen is a thing but mugen is a mess
Via exposure
True…
Gamefreak gave the guy everything and more
That's because we aren't saying why we personally would want to cut/not cut a character, and instead are trying to see through the eyes of Nintendo and guess which characters they would want to cut/not cut. And cutting characters usually comes down to how popular/not popular they are
and nintendo wouldnt have a reason to do so
They added Ice Climbers in Brawl and Duck Hunt in 4 their asses do not give a fuck who is and isn’t popular
Thats what im sayin
Like if it were up to me, my ass would cut sonic because I fucking hate that character in smash. But you know they are never going to cut sonic
ice climbers was in melee btw
not trying to detract your point
yeah i dont think anybody pulled that argument here, basing it on their enjoyment of the character's gameplay
Ice climbers were added in melee
And also then cut in smash 4
They were cut in smash 4 due to hardware limitations
I heard that that had to do with some shit involving the dual release on 3DS but I have no source for that so take it with a grain of salt
But anyway if you look at the trend of cut character they were either shitty semi clones of franchises that had tons of reps (pichu, young link, doctor mario, etc), third party characters that they couldn't maintain the rights to (Snake), or hardware issues (Ice climbers, pokemon trainer)
hardware limitations?
whug?
bruh
3ds didnt like ice climbers with 8 players
And wii u suffered for its sins
its also why rex isnt in smash ultimate
…
The 3ds couldn't handle icies, pokemon trainer, sheik/zelda, and samus/zss so they either cut the characters or split them into two instead of keeping them as a transformation character
who is rex
Who tf is rex
rex xenoblade 2
?
since pyra/mythra
the fuck is a xenoblade
yes it is a hardware limitation thats what im saying
maybe just don't release the console game on the mobile platform idk what to tell ya
?????????
im comparing it to ice climbers on 3ds
theyd need to have both him and either pyra or mythra on the screen and they said the models were much more demanding than the ice climbers
since its a duo situation
I know Mario already has so much rep but
where's the Paper Mario rep?
I don't think paper mario really needs a rep
since now more people can see that geno is lamer than they were told
Eh
Heres the thin
Mario is gonna get a rep next game anyway
Geno fans 
Cos its fucjin mario
I want to be able to turn into a paper airplane
I wanna kerfucking flip
Dr mariio
Captain toad
toad
captain toad !
Waluigi
Fawful
Professor egad
fuck captain toad
Can we just replace dr mario with paper mario already
yeah thats why its funny
they should add bowser,
Piranha plant:
Favorite twitch clip of all time is FatGuy703 telling people that asking for Geno in Smash is like asking for Bobbery, specifically and only Bobbery, as a character
Maybe they can atone for their sins with little mac
yeah piranha plant is peak
the entire gimmick of captain toad is that he can't jump
Who tf is bobbery
haven't there actually been some jumping piranha plants in the games though?
if they added a koopa in i think thats fine
we have definitely seen piranha plants jumping
The partner from TTYD
what was the video? What happened?
This would automatically make him cool as fuck
Doont think any more mario reps other than maybe waluigi needed tbh
King bob omb:
i hate waluigi never let him in
waluigi is not getting in
Anyway
Wapeach 🙃
I want waluigi in but like
Specifically as a mario spinoff rep
All his moves relate to like mario kart mario party mario tennis whatnot
yeah that makes sense
Among us
Me after knocking King Bob-Omb off the stage (he automatically recovers back on and tells me that it’s unhonorable) 
I want King Bob Omb now
It would
Honestly the main thing I want from the next smash is to rework Ganondorf to be like his totk incarnation and to not be a shitty falcon semi clone anymore
Because God does he need it.
As far as reps i think are lilely uh
300 bucks theres gonna be a monster hunter rep in smash 6
Gonna be popping off when they reveal Excitable A-Lister
If they call you “The Monster Hunter” that shit is gonna be so fucking funny
mr helldiver
I swore I read something about how the monster hunter creator didn't want a monster hunter character in the game because it would most likely be a hunter and he thought that would take the focus off the monsters or something.
But I can't find it on Google so maybe I'm just tripping
Monster Hunter is already cool as hell but I’m not sure how well it’ll translate to smash
Could be a 18 fighters in one thing where you can pick between different weapons
Add a monster then
yeah ive only seen like one case of a monster hunter hunter
with mvci
Like
mii fighters!
Nah rathalos would not work
Okay but Rathalos being huge is kinda the point
All monsters being big as fuck actually
there aren't any like monster hunter npc people that could be the smash character?
There are some smaller ones though
This guy said ridley wouldnt work
https://www.playstation.com/en-us/games/marvel-vs-capcom-infinite-ps4/
A monster hunter from Val Habar, the nomadic desert town that fused with Wakanda. Monster hunters are experts at tracking and taking down monsters using weapons and armor forged from monster scales and claws. Hunters typically go by their given name, but this legendary hunte...
Rathalos is even bigger and less humanoid than ridley
A lot of them don’t actually fight or hunt the monsters
-duck hunt
ivysaur !
Actually yeah playing a monster would be way cooler than playing a hunter
Krool is like half quadrapedal
duck hunt dog is partly anthropromorphic anyway
guy could probably stand up if he wanted to
it does when it laughs at you
Be fucking for real
His dash is him running on all fours
Doof
but he stands and punches and throws and shoots stuff
Hence the half
half is meaningless
Yeah and EVERYTHING ELSE is on 2 legs
Running does not constitute “half”
inkling is a no legged rep !
Charizard is a No-Legged fighter (flies in running animation)
I thought krool was some monster hunter creature you were suggesting, not K. Rool, the kerfucking lizard man with a cannon
If quadrapedal is using 4 legs to walk and run, and krool uses 4 legs to run and 2 legs to walk
He is half quadrapedal by definition
Fox is a 3 legged fighter
get real
(Puts his hand on the ground to side B)
Rob is a 1 legged fighter
Doof you are gonna look back on this conversation in 2 years and be so fucking embarrassed
Quit now while you can
Nuh uh
FOR WALKING AS WELL
doof
I will concede defeat
Bowser Jr and Koopalings aren't really using their legs
rosalina is a 0 legged fighter (she floats)
sure, K Rool can enter a crawl
but he very obviously leans more on the side of anthropromorphic than not
the guy mainly fights you with a cannon in Donkey Kong Country 2 (Might be naming the wrong game but whatever)
What if the Monster Hunter rep was Poogie
they should have a cat
The felynes do actually fight monsters and shit
Unironically komala would be fire
Look at the damn dk 64 fight
He wears BOXING GLOVES
DO YOU WEAR BOXING GLOVES ON YOUR FEET?
Crawl once and suddenly you’re a quadruped
sorry but
no
Komala does not have enough going on
*half quadraped smh
Doof you are gonna regret this conversation later
I'm not
actually a half quadraped would be a centaur
are infants quadrapeds
If not we will hammer it into you until you do
I don't see why I would regret this conversation
Cause it’s stupid that’s why
the guy mainly fights standing up
He acts like a person
He does most of his actions, standing up
He does not count as a quadraped because he... checks notes crawls into a sprint, something literally anyone can do
Did you like actually think I was being serious?
Ffs I'm not that stupid. I don't actually believe krool is a quadraped
💀
then you shouldve stopped from the beginning
masterful bait
Shrodinger’s Half-Quadruped
Now donkey Kong on the other hand...
This is what Smash discussion does to your brain
we should have a centaur in smash
alas, there are no centaur game characters
Characters in FE can ride a horse when they get promoted enough times iirc
motaro mortal kombat
That’s close enough
yeah sure that works
To be fr, Donkey Kong is also a quadrapedal rep
- anyways

Horse ridder character getting punched a million times yet somehow never falling off the horse
what the. why did the year do that
ANYWAYS
Sol Badguy
yeah im surprised nobody else said it
Also its beating a dead horse but kirbys rep is fine
any traditional fighting game character really
3 is a good amount
Apes are literally bipeds I am going to fill your house with platypus eggs
but kong is a monkey so dk is a monkey
cap
Literally if you watch a Gorilla move it almost always walks on all 4s
Also yeah DK do be locomoting on those knuckles doe
why are u guys so invested on this
scorpion 🙏
after some reinvestigating into my research it appears I misread some things
Like dk starts off on all fours, he idles on all fours, he walks and runs on all fours. His ass is quadrapedal
counterpoint: nuh uh
also shantae has no reps and kirby has 3 and shantae seven sirens has just come out so it prob has a decent amount of talk to back it up
shantae is on the list
actually they should add zero from drakengard 3 that would be funny
nah add maxwell
like obviously go with nier automata but still
Maxwell could be one of the alts
maxwell as a character could have a vastly different moveset though
His smash attack can use a Dark Sword instead of a spear for flavor
Wigfrid alt becomes meta because her hitsounds destroys your opponent's ears when they combo you
Eater of worlds
tbh, it is fair when the modern representation kinda sucks hard
yeah the final smash is about it
Pretty sure Mask Dedede and Kirby's Ultrasword are the only modern representation in their moveset.
Bandana Dee would be a cool way to rep the newer games without somewhat arbitrarily changing the existing movesets just to have more timely references
Yeah, if Bandana Dee comes in, I expect copy abilities to actually get referenced in his moveset.
BD doesn't use copies though
No, but all the other Dee's do. Like, there is sorta a reason why some people pair parasol /Beam with Bandana Dee.
(even though Beam is a Doo ability)
Spear is kinda a like the the base
Though, Bandana having a janky as hell element gimick from SA, would be really funny in my humble opinion.
And I'm dumb, parasol is an actual weapon he uses.
In Smash Flash 2 they let him use the Beam Wand in some moves
Maybe take that Pogo move Staff has in SA since Spear and Staff are pretty similar
Would be funny
A Clay Alt because he was the co-op helper in Rainbow Curse would be sick
Kinda like the Woolly/Crafted World Alt Yoshi has
alt that would be so sick it justifies Bandana Dee’s inclusion alone
Puyo Puyo is a lot more popular over at Japan, so I'm not exactly surprised, but it is still kind of funny to see.
Whos the pyuo pyuo character
Arle
Ok
its peak
i watch starwarrior play it
Steve
Not only did you answer a character thats already in game
Not only did you ignore the fucking question and pick a character on the list
You had to fucking ping me while doing it
Dont ping me when replying to qotds
Years later of discords existence and people still get angry about a meaningless pixel
I dont care about being pinged normally
Steve was the only good option anyway
Just dont ping me when replying to these
🆗
Nah just people don't care enough about Mortal combat 
smash playerbase and mk playerbase isnt very shared
ngl I kinda want Mountain from Arknights (or equivalent, I just used this guy as an example) in there, just so that there's a realistic-looking furry character alongside the other furry bait characters, because I think it'd be very funny
Heavy TF2
so true
Europe, 7th
🔥
CJ from gta san andreas
You'r cooking
v1 from ultrakill
Amogus
Lets add, alear
We need more anime sqordfighters
Dont ping me when replying to qotds
I know it's the least appropriate thing to put in Smash ever, but
Homelander.
it wouldnt fit him in the slightest and thats exactly why
hello non
hey rq
can I get unverified
I wanted to say something funny in #verification-request but yall verified me immediately like
ah im kiddin anyway its good to be back
❌
He's not a video game character
"whos your most requested character"
not most requested video game character
silly
Yes but it's smash, non video game characters don't get in
ok...................
most requested character...........
not that I actually think he's gonna get in............
You must be realistic in your hypotheticals
:(
Hell be a videogame character when he gets into mk1
That doesn't count. He will be a character put into a video game not a video game character
Nuh uh
what.
who cares
I said what I said
MK1 is a fake videogame anyways
just have fun with the question
I want Abraham Lincoln, Elija Wood and Ice-T
Green Shadow from the hit mobile card game Plants vs Zombies Heroes
justini moderator of the plants vs zombies heroes discord server
