#Simplify Melee Weapon Appearance scrolls.

34 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

chrome ocean
#

Problem 1: There are so many cool appearance scrolls you simply can't use for combat because they're all for 1h/2h blunt weapon.
Problem 2: 1H Axes are currently meta for SG. There are exactly two appearance scrolls for 1H axe.

Solution: Reduce the catagories from:
1h axe 1h blunt 1h sword, 2h axe 2h blunt 2h sword
To: 1h Close Combat weapon, 2h Close Combat weapon.

The appearance scrolls will overwrite the melee animations in cases where a skin uses a default animation for its old required type.

feral kelp
#

Agreed

brisk wedge
#

Had a brain blast and thought back to this feedback. If scrolls were simplified, then 2h axes could have the 2h sword app scrolls applied to them.

I'd be so happy to have that!!! that way an elf like me could still have the ultra cool 2h sword apps even when we don't have 2h swords to put them on.

I AM ON MY KNEES, NEXON!!!

prime timber
#

I never understood why they lock many of these scrolls to specific 1h or 2h weapons when they easily could work for anything that uses the same number of hands in the animation.

For example, we do have some that are like the appearance of a scythe like Guardian Scythe, that is only for staff, but that I think would look proper on any 2h weapon.

brisk wedge
#

Bumping :3

north tapir
#

Agreed. Just because it says it's an axe or sword shouldn't prevent it from living its best life. Games should be fun, it doesn't have to make sense.

reef sky
#

Why can’t we have the appearance scrolls just bundle up as 1h items and 2h items
I want to use a tech chic handheld console appearance scroll(1h blunt) on my Celtic royal battle axe(1h axe)
Or even the tech chic smart scooter(2h tool) on my ruin staff(2h staff) when I heal as a HS just scooting around the battlefield for fun and casting healing along the way
Or at least something along the lines of that; surely it’d give more value to the lesser wanted minority of 1 handed blunt weapon appearance scrolls

brisk wedge
brisk wedge
#

Bumping again- :0
I wanna see this get a Mabinogi symbol-

cosmic rose
#

yeah i dont get why so many of the funnier ones are restricted to blunt overall, but axes get almost nothing? i have swords in the game that use non-sword animations aswell, also the appearance would already dictate the animations so i really wonder why things are catagorised this way. 1h vs 2h i can understand.. but msot of the other ones feel very odd.

last badger
#

we had swords with blunt animations before we even had appearance scrolls so theres really no excuse

lyric jolt
#

There's even that sniper rifle appearance scroll that's for 2h blunt (for some reason), so it's really strange to not have more flexibility in our 1h/2h options.

And as others said; 1h axe only has two appearance scrolls; The Bipennis and the Soldiers Field Axe.

brisk wedge
#

Please.

Bumping this again!

Please make this happen.

chrome ocean
#

What would be the process to actually getting this kind of feedback implanted? Does KR have to decide they want it in the game and add it to their branch, or can NA do NA exclusive changes?

brisk wedge
chrome ocean
#

:(

brisk wedge
#

:(

brisk wedge
#

Bumping this again. We got 63 thumbs up on it, can we please get a mabi???

reef sky
chrome ocean
brisk wedge
timid elm
gray acorn
#

Thank you for your patience while we got to this 🙏 I think this is a change EVERYONE would love

chrome ocean
#

omg thank you for noticing me senpai

brisk wedge
timid elm
#

Sitting on a 2h blunt weapon fan appearance stuck on a celtic because 2h blunts don't exist in pers or nb. yes please!

reef sky
high ore
#

I just wish any weapon could transmog into another. If we wanted a super strong bokken, or a sickle, or dirk to replace a super strong sword, like why not? I wonder how hard that would be to implement.

timid elm
# high ore I just wish any weapon could transmog into another. If we wanted a super strong ...

they already have an item from the past that sacrificed a weapon to make it into an appearance scroll. It was from the Fate crossover. They really should bring that back updated for actual use on in game weapons.

If it could use any gach, crafted, dropped, or NPC purchased weapon what's the harm in that? I'd like my revanant guard cylinder appearance back...

*Adding to what leafy says below, That syringe woulda been a great option for a healing wand appearance if you'd made it smaller and given it an idle pose holding it like a nurse about to give a shot.

unkempt stag
#

Gotta mention here too, please stop making scrolls exclusive race wise or provide a work around.
For example the syringe Lance scroll from recent battle pass, Lance only,should have had a 2 handed sword/axe as option to. Or please release something that like the secret forest sword,elves can equip but counts as a Lance for app scrolls. Same with a lot of bow scrolls for giants, please make them usable on atlatls or even a blunt weapon,like the sniper ones mentioned above were

safe hornet
chrome ocean
#

Any update on this?

tardy leaf
#

Yeah I wanna dig this one back up. I'm wanting to build out a gear set for SG, and there's just barely any 1h axe scrolls, and I REALLY like my 1h sword scroll that makes it look like a rapier (I have a red mage outfit). I sure would love to be able to put my rapier scroll on an axe...