#2025 Clancy Song Battle #7

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

fair badgerBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1755702000:R>

pliant wren
#

oh shit

hallow stream
#

first vote midwest

sudden bay
#

First

#

Fuck

pliant wren
#

nope

stoic lynx
#

midwest indigo is the best song on this album and i will forever say it

neon wing
#

OLDIES

lavish sigil
#

oldies

stoic lynx
#

it is the best made

#

and

#

best sounding

gloomy nebula
#

OLDIES STATION

stoic lynx
#

the best

vernal fulcrum
#

Goat station

idle crescent
#

TWO MINUTES 🔥

dreamy palm
#

Has to be oldies

dull saffron
#

PUSH ON THROUGH

woven hornet
#

NO FAIE

gloomy nebula
#

PUSH ON THROUGH

slate delta
#

This js so difficult

waxen sundial
#

i somehow cant choise bro what

earnest steppe
#

OLDIES

pearl cape
#

oldies station 100%

robust stump
#

Oldies pls pls

stoic lynx
#

fuck oldies, midwest is the better choice.

acoustic flicker
#

FUCK

woven hornet
#

GAHHHHH

hollow spire
#

oldies yay

pliant wren
#

WHATS YOUR ETA

dreamy palm
#

Both are peak but I think id cry over oldies

woven hornet
#

Oldies Station though

lavish sigil
#

breach_b 🇮 🇹 breach_c breach_h

sudden bay
#

I’m not voting this game is evil

pliant wren
idle crescent
#

I love both songs equally

dull saffron
acoustic flicker
#

i'm choosing oldies but won't be mad with midwest

true isle
#

as if it were even a question, OLDIES STATION, it's OUR SONG, it was FOR US

fair badgerBOT
delicate falcon
#

Oldies Station every day of the week

tacit harness
#

Oldies station goated

stuck loom
#

Sweepies Station

olive bison
#

Did y’all really have to kill Backslide like that

upbeat tangle
#

Oldies Sweep.

glossy birch
#

Oldies for life, love Midwest Indigo but not as much as I love Oldies, Oldies just means much more to me

ripe mortar
#

ez midwest

hallow stream
#

midsweep indigo

grim wedge
#

hey so midwest is bland for clancy so oldies takes this no question

frozen ivy
#

this is evil BUT MIDWEST IS AMAZING

knotty loom
#

YOUR FAVORITE SONG WAS ON THE OLDIES STATION 🗣️

fading pecan
#

oldies!

olive bison
merry pier
#

OLDIESSS

fathom crypt
#

ik midwest indigo is going to win but i'm going oldies station

vast estuary
#

oldies will sweep

kind ibex
#

OLDIES OLDIES OLDIES

limber atlas
#

whats your eta

formal jungle
#

MIDwest indigo

wintry tiger
#

I think I have to go oldies station

formal jungle
#

oldies sweep

grim wedge
#

KYLE WE CANT LET OLDIES LOSE

sudden night
#

NO.

low summit
#

Oldies Station, top 1 clancy

velvet girder
#

trafoamp indigo

true isle
#

OLDIES SWEEP! MANIFESTING

olive bison
#

Both songs ass Drum Show best song of all time /j

true marsh
#

midwest indigo my anthem grief

grim wedge
sweet marlin
#

Midwest Midwest Midwest

acoustic hazel
#

PLEASE OLDIES STATION SWEEP

knotty loom
hallow stream
#

Midwest Indigo oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh

robust stump
#

I really think Midwest Indigo is super underrated but against Oldies this is a no brainer for me

grim wedge
#

OLDIES SWEEPTION

ashen heron
#

you're in the crowd at her first dance recital

wintry tiger
#

How did backslide loose😔

rare rune
#

MIDWEST SWEEPIGO

crisp fossil
#

Ⓜ️ ℹ️ dwbreach_e 🇸 🇹 INDIGO

inner pumice
#

Clancy sb 7 songs vs their seeding(fanmade from the 2 previous clancy song battles):

#1: Navigating
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb
#3: Midwest Indigo
#4: Vignette
#5 Oldies Station
#6: Routines In The Night
#7: Next Semester
#8: Overcompensate
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

grim wedge
#

YOU DONT QUITE MIND HOW LONG READ LIGHTS ARE TAKING

median sleet
#

Oldies Station because it makes me cry

warped bay
#

Oldies station gotta win

crisp fossil
#

MIDSWEEP INDIGO

worn blaze
#

oldies ftw

ashen heron
#

YES GUYS YES

glossy birch
#

Push on through |-/

inner pumice
#

i go oldies here

pearl oasis
#

i love both so much 😭

velvet girder
#

midwest indigo is wow

hallow stream
#

midwest indigo takes the cake

grim wedge
#

guys its called MIDwest indigo for a reason

inner pumice
#

also this confirms the single version of the craving didnt make it to the 3rd clancy sb

hallow stream
#

I WANT LOVE AND SUNNY DAYS

grim wedge
#

bland asf for clancy

formal jungle
wintry tiger
#

Idk how people booed oldies station it’s so good

formal jungle
median sleet
#

Oldies station makes me feel seen and heard somehow

steady rapids
#

midwest indigo, but i also do like oldies

knotty loom
#

danni will personally give 100 dollars in corned beef to everyone who votes oldies

crisp fossil
steady rapids
#

i dont get the midwest indigo hate

hallow stream
#

we are all super depressed so midwest indigo should be a no brainer

formal jungle
robust stump
grim wedge
grim raven
#

midwest indigo means so much to me y’all are hurting me physically emote_disintegrate

maiden fractal
#

PUSH ON THROUGH

hallow stream
tardy dragon
#

Sweep station

median sleet
#

Midwest Indigo is good, but Oldies Station feels like someone has seen all the hard work and struggles I've been through since I discovered them with Car Radio and Ode to Sleep

worn blaze
#

if oldies loses i’m not pushing on thru 😭😭😭

grim wedge
#

yall what is ur argument against oldies

keen dust
#

i had to rep oldies. i mean i got "push on through" tattooed on my wrist that song is my lifeline

glossy birch
#

MAKE AN OATH AND MAKE MISTAKES, START A STREAK YOU'RE BOUND TO BREAK!!!

formal jungle
grim wedge
median sleet
#

I want a "push on through" tattoo

crisp fossil
median sleet
grim wedge
cerulean roost
#

oldies station obv

true marsh
#

“you’re in the crowd at her first dance recital”

sick swift
#

OLDIES STATION

wintry tiger
cerulean roost
#

push on through

#

its a contender for the best song on the album

grim wedge
#

only consistency

minor mica
#

oldies station made me cry in concert and i’ll never not love it for that

wintry tiger
#

I want a push on through |-/ tattoo

jade veldt
#

JUST PUSH ON THROUGH

grim wedge
#

in your periphery

hallow stream
#

Look I am the number one Oldies defender but it doesn't stand a chance against Midwest

inner pumice
#

a little fun fact: Oldies lost to Midwest Indigo the first time they ever went agasint each other

cosmic timber
#

Oldies sweep

grim wedge
median sleet
#

I wanna make more of these bracelets to give away

velvet girder
minor mica
formal jungle
jade veldt
#

I am sorry but Oldies has to win but I love Midwest

cerulean roost
#

fear of the past and

candid urchin
#

I sweae who is even voting midwest indigo in this match

wintry tiger
minor mica
jade veldt
grim wedge
worthy ermine
#

this is so hard

wintry tiger
grim wedge
#

FUTURE'S COMING FAST YOU GOT

hallow stream
#

😔 can i get an ice reaction just to see i'm not the only Midwest defender

median sleet
#

I was 19 when I discovered them and 30 when oldies station

true marsh
#

ugh im not ready for breach song battle MinoriSad

formal jungle
cerulean roost
#

the song isnt that bad but it might be one of the worst in the album for me

candid urchin
minor mica
neon blaze
#

midsweep indigo

broken ledge
#

PUSH ON THROUGH!

formal jungle
#

MIDwest indigo

worthy ermine
candid urchin
#

I'll be outta here what

grim raven
median sleet
#

I don't have kids (yet) but the "you're in the crowd at her first dance recital" had me ugly crying because I hope to be able to do that one day

neon blaze
#

MIDWEST INDIGO FOR THE WIN WTHHH

candid urchin
#

No hate but midwest over oldies is too much for me

median sleet
#

They are like...6 years older than me

grim wedge
#

oldies is peak top imo

remote blaze
#

sweep station

candid urchin
bitter hill
grim wedge
#

like drum show aint peak yet until recency bias fades so i can fairly rank it

bitter hill
#

What is this, 2 of my favorite songs

minor mica
bitter hill
#

Jocals for the win

grim wedge
#

i really love the song and its message

#

genuinely such a beautiful song

grim raven
ionic venture
#

push on through

minor mica
#

tyler’s scream cured something in my soul on drum show so it’s peak for me

formal jungle
grim wedge
#

but ive only listened to it <50 times to understand it

#

people dont talk about the earlier part of oldies enough

formal jungle
eternal onyx
#

oldies station is my favourite so id really likeit to win <3

candid urchin
#

But after you listen to enough songs and read enough books in general every message vecomes straight forward

eternal onyx
#

oldies station kept me alive, kept me clean, kept me going |-/

candid urchin
#

Or so I think

grim wedge
halcyon python
#

Midsweep indigo

candid urchin
formal jungle
candid urchin
#

Sorry just kinda felt the need to type that out i guess, didn't mean to sound rude

grim wedge
#

i have that skill issue though

native edge
#

Oldies station I feel like is just poetically written

grim wedge
#

peak tøp

native edge
#

Fr

halcyon python
#

hearing everyone talk only about the lyrics has convinced me it is the worse song

grim wedge
#

especially in their current era of progress

eternal onyx
halcyon python
#

ain’t no one talking about the instrumental cuz it’s boring ash

grim wedge
candid urchin
#

Imo lyrics should be what someone judges first not beat

native edge
#

I like the instrumental, its a very nostalgic sounding song. Like I'm getting a big hug

grim wedge
#

im sorry people dont want a huge ass bass blaring into the ears

candid urchin
#

Cuz a song with a good beat and lyrics that are horrible is just ew

formal jungle
#

it should be half half

halcyon python
native edge
#

If it's not ur vibe I get that but it doesn't mean it's objectively bad

candid urchin
grim wedge
halcyon python
#

I can zone out and ignore boring lyrics if the beat is good

#

Self titled is a 6/10

native edge
#

See that's ur preference, personally I really enjoy analyzing lyrics

formal jungle
grim wedge
#

thank god im dating someone who listens to lyrics

formal jungle
#

only the way tyler sings tho

halcyon python
#

I can appreciate lyrics it’s just not what i necessarily look for in music

native edge
#

That's fair

candid urchin
halcyon python
#

It’s cool if they’re good but if they’re not it’s whatever

formal jungle
#

i dont like it

candid urchin
#

Hmm

#

It's okay

grim wedge
#

idk i feel like you calling oldies instrumental boring makes me feel so off

#

cause like

#

tf did u expect from oldies station

halcyon python
#

it gets good towards the end ill give it that

candid urchin
#

Huh

grim wedge
#

its good the whole way round

candid urchin
#

Only there???

halcyon python
#

okay the instrumental isn’t bad by any means

#

its just not interesting

candid urchin
#

Maybe old jb made me appreciate chiller instrumentals more than I did before

grim wedge
#

even without the lyrics it FEELS like a self-reflection

grim wedge
#

and tyler really delivered the lyrics well with the instrumental

grim wedge
candid urchin
grim wedge
#

which true

formal jungle
#

you 2 share the same braincell

frank ferry
grim wedge
#

RYAN

#

NO

#

RYAN GTFO NOW

candid urchin
daring kiln
#

HOW TF DO I CHOOSE NOOOO

grim wedge
#

RYAN YOU MAKE ME SIIIIICK

formal jungle
candid urchin
frank ferry
#

can’t spell oldies station without MID 😂✌️

marble ether
#

midwest indigo

grim wedge
#

OLDIES PLEASE WIN

formal jungle
candid urchin
#

If oldies loses grief

daring kiln
grim wedge
#

LET A PEAK SONG BEAT A BLAND ONE

terse oar
#

COMO SE ATREVEEENNNN 😭😭😭😭😭

grim wedge
summer needle
#

no bc i cant choose😔

terse oar
#

LAS AMO A LAS DOSSSS PERO NO PUEDO DROPEAR A OLDIES, PERDÓN MIDWEST💔

halcyon python
#

calling Midwest bland is crazy

frank ferry
candid urchin
grim wedge
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

cause lowk

summer needle
grim wedge
#

those lyrics aint shit on oldies

candid urchin
frank ferry
vast estuary
grim wedge
#

the sound is fine but the delivery aint as peak

summer needle
halcyon python
candid urchin
#

Imo midwest is far from being either bland or mid HOWEVER when you put it next to a song like oldies it starts to fade

summer needle
#

i find both good tbh but oldies had more meaning to it for me

vast estuary
formal jungle
vast estuary
#

oh

grim wedge
#

it's still an 8/10 btw

#

but its bland during any other times of the year

grim wedge
candid urchin
candid urchin
elder cobalt
#

WHATS YOUR ETA

frank ferry
candid urchin
grim wedge
#

other than that the song feels hollow

frank ferry
#

Vote Midwest

formal jungle
vast estuary
vapid basin
#

i need to start setting an alarm for song battles i keep forgetting

candid urchin
#

Why do I have a feeling oldies will lose

vapid basin
#

anyways. now is my time to shine

frank ferry
vast estuary
restive narwhal
#

voting midwest indigo just to let it know its appreciated before oldies absolutely blows this one out of the water

candid urchin
vast estuary
#

yes

vapid basin
#

its my time to shine

frank ferry
vapid basin
#

oh wait i alr said that

restive narwhal
#

say it again youve earned it. you are #1

candid urchin
#

For one I know people go more for the beat than lyrics and with the hate it got on tour i think it stands a chance to lose against midwest

formal jungle
#

is there someone who is #1 oldies station lover?

sage fulcrum
#

if oldies loses I’m committing mass arson

formal jungle
#

to make a war

frank ferry
#

I’d vote Midwest for sound, and I’d vote oldies for lyrics

vapid basin
#

dont even try me when it comes to midwest indigo this song means the world to me

formal jungle
elder cobalt
#
  1. paladin strait
  2. overcompensate
  3. atrofd
  4. navigating
  5. lavish
  6. backslide
  7. routines in the night
  8. snap back
  9. vignette
  10. next semester
  11. midwest indigo
  12. oldies station
  13. the craving

(all are great this is just my order)

#

dont get me wrong i love oldies but

candid urchin
candid urchin
#

Blame is once again a wrong word

sage fulcrum
#

Oldies is the best song on Clancy, if yall let it lose to Midwest indigo I don’t even know what to say. that’s almost as bad as leave the city losing to jumpsuit

#

idc

formal jungle
restive narwhal
formal jungle
#

imo navigating is the best

frank ferry
grim wedge
vapid basin
#

i WILL cry if midwest indigo loses 💯

grim wedge
halcyon python
wintry tiger
rare wave
#

i actually can’t vote these are my joint second place

candid urchin
formal jungle
candid urchin
#

Or just to vibe with despite going against the fact thar I appreciate lyrics more than beats

grim wedge
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

its not bad ofc

#

but yk it's definitely the weakest

frank ferry
vapid basin
formal jungle
#

6/10

wintry tiger
frank ferry
#

acceptable

candid urchin
grim wedge
vapid basin
#

i’ll ride for my baby until the death

vapid basin
wintry tiger
#

I still can’t believe backslide lost

tranquil totem
#

oh..

unreal loom
#

Midwest Indigo

tranquil totem
#

Midwest

vapid basin
#

yeah i dont

candid urchin
grim wedge
#

i swear if midwest wins here the top fandom is absolutely cooked

frank ferry
wintry tiger
formal jungle
#

i mean

#

it kinda is already

floral topaz
#

gotta stay loyal to oldies

formal jungle
#

since not everyone hates fairly local

frank ferry
elder cobalt
#

the lavish video is literally what got me into top

formal jungle
candid urchin
# wintry tiger I was so confident

It was pretty obvious tho, overcompensate is better when it comes to production and lyrics. But, to be absolutely fair, I love backslide just because it descrives how I have been for years now

floral topaz
vital lichen
#

nahh putting these two together are diabolical

long kestrel
#

Guys js tell me which to vote for idfk

grim wedge
wintry tiger
long kestrel
grim wedge
floral topaz
#

oldies sweep for all the times the boys helped me growing up

fair badgerBOT
grim wedge
#

I did not boo them

candid urchin
candid urchin
grim wedge
#

the privileged fans who were at that concert did

candid urchin
candid urchin
formal jungle
#

fym booed off oldies station?

sage fulcrum
#

there might be a couple of things I’d switch around here, it’s a very had album to rank for the most part - but this is Clancy to me (I’m aware a lot of this opinion is very unpopular)

  1. Oldies Station 10/10
  2. Overcompensate 9.5/10
  3. Navigating 9/10
  4. Next Semester 9/10
  5. Snap Back 8.5/10
  6. Paladin Strait 8.5/10
  7. Vignette 8.5/10
  8. The Craving (Jenna’s Version) 8/10
  9. Midwest Indigo 8/10
  10. Backslide 8/10
  11. Routines In The Night 7/10
  12. At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb 7/10
  13. Lavish 6/10
formal jungle
sage light
#

Im not voting

fair badgerBOT
candid urchin
candid urchin
#

Fans wanted slowtown instead

sage fulcrum
summer needle
grim wedge
candid urchin
formal jungle
vapid basin
#

seeing oldies station live changed me

wintry tiger
#

I wish I heard oldies live

grim wedge
vapid basin
#

but i uh. i love midwest indigo too much

candid urchin
formal jungle
candid urchin
grim wedge
#

slowtown isnt even that good anyway

#

not compared to trench and beyond at least

vapid basin
wintry tiger
#

I think oldies is better than slowtown

candid urchin
grim wedge
candid urchin
sage fulcrum
# grim wedge ik but a lot of people dont like the song

I don’t mind it; the reasons I have it ranked so low are:

  1. the lyrics are really subpar for the band and I know they could have executed the writing much better
  2. it’s very badly placed on the album; if it was earlier in the project it wouldn’t be as egregious

I still like the song but it’s just weaker than much of the rest to me

formal jungle
grim wedge
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

its also the weakest song on sai

sage fulcrum
formal jungle
sage fulcrum
grim wedge
wintry tiger
#

Guys when I hear bounce man I think of some man who spoke to me in Tesco’s and now i can’t like the song

formal jungle
grim wedge
vapid basin
#

good day is worse than both bounce man and never take it be so fr

sage fulcrum
candid urchin
formal jungle
candid urchin
grim wedge
#

good day being worse than both bounce man and never take it deserves a public shaming

grim wedge
vapid basin
sage fulcrum
grim wedge
candid urchin
grim wedge
candid urchin
#

Vibes that match california girls anyway

sage fulcrum
limber atlas
#

i hope atrofd or navigating wins

candid urchin
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

i want oldies to make it far

sage fulcrum
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

and beat midwest easily

summer needle
#

good day makes me have a good day ngl

candid urchin
sharp gulch
#

I think atrofd has a chance to make it very far along with oldies

wintry tiger
#

I don’t want navigating to win

sage fulcrum
grim wedge
#

because yall i cannot explain the absolute fucking hell oldies got me through

formal jungle
sharp gulch
#

Like I expect routines, backslide, atrofd and oldies finals

grim wedge
#

oldies station is a 10/10 song

candid urchin
bold hatch
#

OLDIES

sage fulcrum
sharp gulch
grim wedge
formal jungle
candid urchin
unreal maple
#

Impossible choice grief

candid urchin
#

Expected

limber atlas
grim wedge
#

i really appreciate what backslide does

formal jungle
candid urchin
#

Snap back is bye bye already that makes me sad

vapid basin
#

i djdnt even vote last round

#

i couldnt

formal jungle
limber atlas
#

tbh for me i love backslide

brittle linden
#

i can’t choose nooo

formal jungle
#

snap back makes me float

wintry tiger
#

Didn’t Josh create the backslide mv

sage fulcrum
# grim wedge wow! backslide fucking died! 🥀

I love Backslide because I have a lot of nostalgia for last year; it was the last time I did a lot of things, the year I turned 18, etc - even though it’s only last year lol. Analytically backslide is just okay but for the memories it ranks highhh

sage fulcrum
limber atlas
candid urchin
vapid basin
#

doesnt mean its bad but ||snap back is bottom 2 on the album for me||

sage fulcrum
grim wedge
#

but idk overcompensate first listen was peak as someone who started listening to top about 6 months prior

molten steeple
#

first hard one off of clancy

summer needle
#

snap back is such a vibe for me

vapid basin
#

yall are acting like i said it was bad i LITERALLY SAID ITS NOT BAD

candid urchin
#

Y'all make me sad and second guess myself with some of these takes

sage fulcrum
frank ferry
grim wedge
#

snap back is top 3 clancy for me and ik thats a hot take so let me explain

sage fulcrum
#

overcompensate is their best intro

grim wedge
formal jungle
candid urchin
sage fulcrum
molten steeple
#

i have to say Midwest Indigo BECAUSE I'm moving to Ohio in two days it's only fair

vapid basin
#

i just like more energetic songs im sorry 😿

frank ferry
#

Jumpsuit is more peak

grim wedge
#

jumpsuit is carried by cool bass and amazing bridge

frank ferry
molten steeple
grim wedge
sage fulcrum
#

the only intro I have close to overcompensate is ode to sleep, but overcompensate is just executed better so it’s that little bit higher

candid urchin
wintry tiger
#

Hearing welcome back to trench gave me an adrenaline rush

candid urchin
#

Made me realize I gotta change some stuff

vapid basin
grim wedge
#

were you even conscious when you lived in ohio

frank ferry
#

I moved out at 19

grim wedge
#

still oldies peak

sharp gulch
molten steeple
#

moving to the midwest indigo for college so I gotta stick with her

wintry tiger
frank ferry
grim wedge
#

anyway snap back is top 3 clancy

#

speaking of clancy

#

drum show feels like a clancy recap if you think abt it

sage fulcrum
vapid basin
#

i think i like drum show guys

frank ferry
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

i cant believe it

frank ferry
#

true..

#

Damn you San Diego

sage fulcrum
#

whenever I think Midwest I think Midwest Choppers and then I remember Midwest Indigo

grim wedge
# sage fulcrum how so I’m curious

just with how its structured, finding comfort in distractions but realizing you gotta make an effort to make a change cause you're still avoiding your issues by distracting yourself, even if you enjoy the distraction

halcyon fern
#

It ain’t gonna be close (hopefully)

grim wedge
grim wedge
vapid basin
grim wedge
#

josh's snap back bro

halcyon fern
#

Oldies Station is so much better than MIDwest indigo

candid urchin
grim wedge
#

lock in chat lock in

vapid basin
#

if my baby goes down i’ll be fine i promise 🙏

frank ferry
#

I’ve been saying drum show is Josh’s car radio

formal jungle
halcyon fern
#

IMO, 3rd best song on the album vs the worst on the album

grim wedge
vapid basin
candid urchin
summer needle
halcyon fern
#

Not saying Midwest indigo is their worst song ever, but it doesn’t beat anything on Clancy

slim vigil
#

What’s your ETA

halcyon fern
#

Not really

formal jungle
halcyon fern
#

I’m surprised overcompensate beat backslide tbh

grim wedge
#

saying anything doesnt beat lavish on clancy is hugely freaky!!!

sage light
halcyon fern
#

I need to go thru and make a list of my personal favs from each album

formal jungle
#

even less

sage light
#

Make sure you pay attention 🙏

#

Through out the class

formal jungle
#

yes

#

oh wait

#

through had another h?

sage light
#

Yes 😭🙏

vapid basin
#

i forget a lot of yall start school hella early

#

ion got until september 4

slim vigil
#

Once again making this hard but I had to choose my favourite 😔

sage light
#

Thats why i said pay attention in english class

formal jungle
#

bro thats like the word that i always write wrong

grim wedge
tawny hollow
#

This one is hard broiooiooo 😭😭😭

grim wedge
#

so which one is ur fav

frank ferry
#

Midwest obv

grim wedge
slim vigil
#

Midwest Indigo was my first favourite from this album but now it’s probably Vignette

tawny hollow
#

This is the hardest test I've ever had and my dumbass graduated 💀

frank ferry
grim wedge
slim vigil
grim wedge
#

neotheater still gets glaze 6 years later

candid urchin
#

I made mine

slim vigil
#

I love Oldies Station though but you can only vote one grief

grim wedge
#

you're blocked.

candid urchin
#

Ouch

vapid basin
grim wedge
#

navigating is so overrated lowk

frank ferry
grim wedge
candid urchin
vapid basin
#

the bassline. the synths. it just fills me with so much happiness every time i listen i cant

frank ferry
# grim wedge ouch

you made them leave too I just saw when going back to check that message

pale ridge
#

Well

grim wedge
#

i still cant believe they said that lmao

#

it hurts bro

slim vigil
vapid basin
candid urchin
grim wedge
#

they didnt call me mean for being rude abt their neotheater obsession

slim vigil
vapid basin
#

afaik theres no scream in midwest 🐟

formal jungle
vapid basin
grim wedge
grim wedge
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

but its like if i were to pick dr. pepper (next semester) or pepsi (navigating)

grim wedge
#

thats an 85% score

vapid basin
frank ferry
slim vigil
summer needle
grim wedge
formal jungle
grim wedge
#

dr pepper cream soda is oldies station

#

so perfection

vapid basin
summer needle
#

😭😭

vapid basin
slim vigil
#

I forgot but was Lavish already in a poll

vapid basin
#

yeah it was against next semester iirc

#

it got slammed

slim vigil
#

grief (I like both songs)

formal jungle
candid urchin
slim vigil
#

Clancy being my second favourite album makes these song battles excruciating for me

hybrid sleet
#

i guess oldies station

keen mesa
#

navigating clears

#

both of these are perfectly valid

grim wedge
#

see this is what i mean

steady cape
#

my favorite song was on the oldies station

keen mesa
#

but ill vote midwest cus its my fave i love it

grim wedge
#

navigating gets too much love 🥀

grim wedge
keen mesa
#

navigating love is perfectly balanced 💯

steady cape
slim vigil
#

-# unrelated but deltarune mentioned (?)

grim wedge
steady cape
#

tv time

grim wedge
#

I LOVE YOU KRIS DELTARUNE

candid urchin
slim vigil
#

We love Kris Deltarune

grim wedge
keen mesa
#

but a song that SHOULD get more love is midwest indigo, guys vote midwest

slim vigil
keen mesa
solar oak
#

Oldies station

vast estuary
keen mesa
#

oldies hate is stupid af

#

its like hating a baby, how could you

leaden plover
#

I LOVE BOTH OF THESEEEEE grief

oak ether
#

WE MUST CARRY OLDIES TO THE FINISH

polar aspen
#

I love both, how am I supposed to choose?!

hexed oak
#

OLDIES STATION

idle pecan
#

I love both ! grief but Oldies feels like the right choice for me, it means so much NedHeart

hallow stream
sweet stump
#

Genuinely impossible

#

Oldies Station I think

#

Makes me cry

vapid jolt
#

PUSH ON THROUGH SWEEP

hallow stream
#

i feel like everyone's feeling guilty for the boos and trying to make it up on the behalf of those losers

#

oldies is absolutely a really good song

#

but midwest is >>

fair badgerBOT
sage fulcrum
outer cargo
#

uuuuhuhuhuh which do i pick

#

i relate to both 😭

#

i’m just not gonna vote atp 😭

visual kernel
upbeat karma
#

Oh fuck no ☹️

lilac mirage
#

This isn't a fair vote. I LOVE THEM BOTH

hallow stream
reef lintel
rare rune
#

midwest sweep

#

vote midwest

proud escarp
#

oldies

#

but this hurts

dry lily
#

this one is super hard

ionic venture
#

Your favorite song is -on the- OLDIES STATION

#

YOUR FAVORITE SONG IS OLDIES STATION

#

push on through vote oldies

hallow stream
#

are ALL you guys over like 28 😭
can't believe it thats why

void whale
#

You can be younger than 28 and enjoy oldies station 😭

lusty jetty
#

Oh what the fuck

dusty raptor
#

OLDIES SWEEPTION

#

Yall come on... Oldies Station is the crux of the whole damn album

thick stratus
#

Midwest

#

easily

glacial sinew
#

Oldies fs

rare rune
#

midwest midwest midwest

formal jungle
#

MIDwest indigo

lone dawn
#

if oldies doesnt win you guys really didnt deserve it on the tour

graceful moth
#

YOU CANT DO THIS TO ME

blissful bison
#

NOOOOO THESE R TIED FIRST PLACE AS MY FAV CLANCY SONG 💔💔💔

#

i have to vote oldies station… it’s too overhated

fair grail
#

i'm pissed. why do my two favorites have to go against each ither

#

oldies station was made for us and i love it dearly but also TWO MINUTES

craggy marlin
#

These song battles are really hard

#

It’s hard to choose between top songs

fair grail
#

the only thing i didn't really have trouble on was self titled

craggy marlin
#

That might be hardest

#

Actually idk I think all of it is pretty difficult lol I’ve never been able to pick and choose which top songs are better than the other

fair grail
#

seriously i'm ripping my hair out here

#

i can't bear to see either one lose

spice thorn
#

Cordell.

fair grail
#

hello cas

spice thorn
#

Hello

sage fulcrum
fair grail
fair grail
craggy marlin
spring ember
#

Well my #1 song already lost so let’s see if my #2 has a chance!

simple plaza
cunning veldt
#

OLDIES.

gloomy nebula
#

PUSH ON THROUGH

spring ember
#

MAKE AN OATH THEN MAKE MISTAKES 🗣️‼️

karmic horizon
#

“Your favorite song was on the Oldies Station…”

grim wedge
#

is it a hot take to say the shy away scream felt out of place in the livestream version

vocal sorrel
#

yes

grim wedge
fair grail
#

i think we just like it cause it sounds good generally

fair grail
#

it doesn't make much sense in the song though i will give you that

grim wedge
#

it just feels so weird to have it in shy away

fair grail
#

considering the instrumental is so pop-y i guess

#

idk

hexed oak
#

Yeah ik what you guys mean

fair grail
#

before anyone comes to burn me at the stake i love shy away

grim wedge
#

like from a lyrical standpoint, makes sense, he's breaking the cycle in half

#

but i feel maybe a key change couldve been cooler

#

a scream usually works as a form of drop before a big ending

#

car radio

#

for example

#

or even more recently

#

drum show

rapid ermine
rapid wasp
#

kill me now

#

this is unvotable which is a word i made up

#

i can't vote

sick fulcrum
#

go go go midwest indi-go

reef lintel
old junco
#

i love midwest indigo

#

but oldies station just means so much to me

reef lintel
#

Yeah, exactly

inner flower
#

im gonna admit this right now.. ive never listened to oldies station

#

BUT

#

i will

#

😔

vagrant rover
#

OLDIES SWEEEP

reef lintel
mystic sandal
#

I love both so it’s not easy… buuut im gonna edge out oldies station

inner flower
#

fr

#

fr like a second dad

#

WHATTT THAT SONG IS SO COOL

#

I LOVED THE MV

#

still love midwest thouhgh…..

lapis crag
#

i fear this is one i can’t vote in grief

quick cradle
#

midwest indigo for the win!

reef lintel
woeful knoll
#

Wait I can't choose

#

I love both of these so much grief

modern forum
#

gotta be midwest indigo for me

rapid gale
#

sending it on oldies station
the last verse just HITS DIFFERENT 🔥

errant kindle
#

oldies station got me out of the depths of hell in life

fair badgerBOT
errant kindle
#

oh yay :D

#

also, "you dont know how long red lights are taking, push on through." FAVROUTE LINE

bold hatch
#

GUYS PLEASE OLDIES NEEDS TO WIN

reef lintel
#

I agree with you's

astral heath
#

why tf yall made backslide lose

reef lintel
cunning elk
#

oldies, and it isnt close

wet lantern
#

oldies sweep

vast estuary
#

oldies is GOING to sweep

#

no chances it doesn't

grim wedge
#

i really hope oldies wins

grim wedge
#

don't know what ppl see in it

late rose
vast estuary
#

push on through

woeful knoll
compact plover
#

midwest

worthy seal
#

MIDSWEEP INDIGO

wispy moss
#

I love but I'm voting Midwest Indigo 😭

#

Oml I love the whole Clancy album sm

fallen vale
#

Please oldies station i need it to win for my sanity

upbeat karma
#

Guys I vote drum show

median sleet
#

oldie station must push on through

candid urchin
robust igloo
#

undeserved

#

midwest indigo goat

neon blaze
#

9 11 votes

ripe mortar
#

wtf

#

why so many oldies fans

fathom crypt
#

okay i was definitely expecting Midwest Indigo to win but i'm so glad that Oldies Station won 🫶

lusty jetty
#

I love oldies but it hurts to see my baby Midwest go

sharp gulch
candid urchin
#

YES

#

YES

#

OLDIES

ripe mortar
#

sorry

delicate falcon
#

I'm pretty sure Midwest won this same bracket last year, It's crazy how the consensus has changed

stoic lynx
#

NOOOO

delicate falcon
#

But I'm all for Oldies

stoic lynx
#

N+++

#

NOOOO

#

BOOOO

#

BOOOO

#

BOOOO

noble gyro
lusty jetty
#

Hey pause

#

Yall he made oldies for us

stoic lynx
#

NOOOO

#

NOT MIDWEST INDIGO

#

WHY

#

COME BACK

lusty jetty
#

Yes it’s sad to see Midwest indiGO (haha)

#

But oldies is love

lusty jetty
stoic lynx
#

don’t make FUN

#

of the best

sharp gulch
stoic lynx
#

THE BEST

#

clancy song

lusty jetty
#

Hey I love Midwest indigo

#

Oldies is just better

stoic lynx
lusty jetty
#

Noah calm down

stoic lynx
#

obviously like

sharp gulch
stoic lynx
#

people can have other opinions

lusty jetty
#

Midwest indigoat is amazing

stoic lynx
#

like in no way am i saying that people can’t have their own opinions

inner pumice
#

Clancy sb 7 results vs their seeding(fanmade from the 2 previous clancy song battles):

#1: Navigating
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb
#3: Midwest Indigo 💀
#4: Vignette
#5 Oldies Station 👑👑
#6: Routines In The Night
#7: Next Semester
#8: Overcompensate
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

stoic lynx
#

i have the right to be upset

inner pumice
#

IN A SUPRISING TWIST OLDIES STATION DEFEATS MIDWEST INDIGO IN COMFORTING FASHION

stoic lynx
balmy nymph
#

Always felt weird about Midwest Indigo getting #3 on the last Clancy battle (don't get me wrong though I like the song a lot and I voted for it)

halcyon python
#

yall are beyond saving

#

first paladin and now Midwest

lusty jetty
#

I hope ur okay bro

winged moon
#

that fact that midwest indigo did not win this one is criminal

vast estuary
#

it's not. oldies is VERY loved in the clique

tranquil totem
#

wait wtf

cosmic timber
#

oldies my beloved

obsidian vector
#

SMH

pale ridge
#

MY MIDWEST INDIGO

silver kernel
#

LOOK TYLER LOOK WE DO LOVE YOUR SONG

nocturne temple
#

Voting for Oldoes Station is awesome but JIM IS IN THE MIDWEST INDIGO MV YOU ABSOLUTE FOOLS!