#whats the difference between 完了(wanliao)and 完了(wanle)

5 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

vital salmon
#

Do they differ slightly or is it just different pronunciations, cuz the example sentences pleco gives are identical.

tight parrot
#

No difference.
了(liao) means end, so does 完. So 完了(liao) still means end.
I only heard this in some Peking operas. I think it is a way to stretch the sound because了(le) is too short to sing.

uncut patrol
#

wanliao is a somewhat formal intransitive verb meaning to finish/end
wanle is a transitive/intransitive verb phrase meaning "to have finished"

since the le particle can be omitted a lot of the time without altering the meaning, and wan/wanliao mean the same thing, there's often little difference

#

in singing, le is usually pronounced liao, in which case both uses are pronounced the same

#

(because le historically developed as a reduced version of liao, and music preserves the nondistinction for melodic reasons)