#Adding Ally Nations from the Pacific Theatre?

121 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

chilly tundra
#

Malaysia, Thailand, Philippines, China, and Korea are some of the nations I have in mind. All of them unique in their card styles.

gloomy swallow
#

then you might as well add the netherlands belgium luxembourg under the benelux banner no?

#

more war action, its own uboat actions, desperate situations on all sides and much happening, both before and during occupation

#

id rather have a nation like romania or maybe hungary added in since they did more than people think

versed fiber
#

they already don't add cards for japan, don't think they care about the east anymore kappa

gloomy swallow
#

waiting for the day japan smoke or discard becomes more viable

tulip summit
#

I have a fanmade project with china being a main nation lol

tulip summit
#

Which means they are british cards

pine quest
#

add china already

#

jesus

tulip summit
#

some chinese ppl would be offended with the waving taiwanese flag

obtuse turret
#

?

#

its not a taiwanese flag

#

its the ROC flag

#

shouldnt be that big of an issue i think

#

its the flag of the old republic

tulip summit
#

Isn't taiwan the roc?

obtuse turret
#

yes and no

#

the government of taiwan is the ROC

#

taiwan is an island though

#

and then there are people who want taiwanese independence from both the ROC and PRC

#

the ROC existed long before the whole concept of taiwan or PRC vs ROC

#

its like russia and the soviet union

gloomy swallow
pseudo ridge
#

I think the chinese players/government would not be super happy with the ROC cards. I say to do it.

strong jewel
#

All 3 were independent, though occupied by Germany for most off the war

#

The Benelux has literally nothing to do with the Brits, so I don't even know how you came to that conclusion lol

gloomy swallow
strong jewel
#

Yeah, you had some divisions and such in exile, but the nations themselves were occupied

west pelican
#

A minor nation needs to have some amount of its own unique equipment and played a notable part in history

#

Of those listed China is the only that really works because they had so many units and contributed to tying down a large amount of Japanese forces

#

The others just don’t have anything that justifies them being a minor nation

tulip summit
#

Yeah thats the problem with it

#

Also in order to make a minor nation playable you need it to be somewhat important during ww2

#

As an example china was one of the nations that contributed to the downfall of japan

strong jewel
#

I mean, Belgium was super important

#

I don't wanna brag, but, we held on for the whole 18 days you know 😏

tulip summit
#

Can china be considered as a main nation?

#

Or at least main in the pacific?

grand musk
#

but still important

pine quest
#

china should have been added before poland

#

poland did jack shit during the war

obtuse turret
obtuse turret
obtuse turret
#

the chinese front was the same size if not bigger than the eastern front

#

it also lasted the longest

#

the chinese also had the biggest disadvantage of any major in the entire war

#

they got close to no support from the other majors besides the soviets which helped a lot

tulip summit
#

I consider it as main when it comes to the pacific front

pine quest
#

they got a little from the US

#

but thats it rlly

obtuse turret
#

then is britain a minor?

#

they didnt do much in the pacific

#

what about soviets

#

they did shit in africa

#

soviets are a minor

#

japan is too

#

never sent troops to europe

pine quest
#

the british did nothing other than die faster than the polish in europe

obtuse turret
#

what kind of logic is this?

obtuse turret
#

UK barely helped

#

same with france

#

germany only before 1938

#

soviets helped a lot and throughout the entire war

tulip summit
#

whereas nations like usa fought everywhere

obtuse turret
#

by that logic, heres a list of majors in WW2

#

UK france US

tulip summit
#

lmao

obtuse turret
#

none of the axis are even majors lmao

#

soviets didnt contribute to the war

#

china doesnt exist

#

italy doesnt exist

#

germany didnt exist

tulip summit
#

Then how do you identify if a nation is main or not?

obtuse turret
#

and US UK and france are only majors because they had colonies everywhere

obtuse turret
tulip summit
#

I see

obtuse turret
#

US UK USSR and China

tulip summit
#

if poland didn't exist, would that make a difference?

obtuse turret
#

even during WW2 they were called the big four

obtuse turret
#

its that these specific nations contributed the most

tulip summit
obtuse turret
#

for axis its italy germany japan

tulip summit
#

hungary?

obtuse turret
#

didnt contribute that much

tulip summit
#

how bout greece?

#

ally

obtuse turret
#

mainly just fought in their own country

#

and only a small portion of the war

tulip summit
#

what other nations can we squeeze into kards fanmade?

obtuse turret
#

mongolia

#

brazil and mexico maybe

tulip summit
#

I mean lkasr added phillipines

pine quest
#

another "nation" that did jack shit during the war

#

it did even less than the polish

obtuse turret
#

yugo did a lot

pine quest
#

i mean they did a bit

obtuse turret
#

mongolia was more useful than most others

pine quest
#

resistance would probably fit the yugos more than it would fit the french

obtuse turret
#

iirc

pine quest
#

the yugos practically liberated themselves

#

i mean if u add the philipines then u might as well add egypt and romania

obtuse turret
#

mongolia did about as much as poland

#

they fought both in asia and esstern front

#

were good soldiers too

pine quest
#

i know that they did fight in both fronts but i just cant help thinking of a bunch of mongol horse archers shooting arrows at germans

tulip summit
#

tho

pine quest
#

what is that suposed to mean

#

its part of the british empire

tulip summit
#

lol