lapis socket Feb 7, 2025, 9:56 PM

#

Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Please share your top 3-5 most critical issues or feedback topics for this week's testing in the thread below using the following format:

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)
2)
3)

To keep the thread organized, we kindly ask that you avoid back-and-forth discussions, and stick to the format above for your posts. We'll be closing the thread at <t:1739214000:f>

Important Note: While we greatly value your insights, please understand that we cannot guarantee all bugs or feedback topics will be addressed, or provide a specific timeframe for fixes.

Thank you for your continued support, feedback, and dedication to improving the Alpha Two experience! flamingphoenix

lapis socket Feb 7, 2025, 9:56 PM

#

lapis socket Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers! Please share your top 3-5 most critical ...

rustic light Feb 7, 2025, 9:56 PM

#

Most Important Bugs:

Fixed Resource Rarity & Timers - Resource nodes have a fixed rarity, and allow people to set up timers to come back to specific resource nodes if that node produces high rarity materials.

Most Important Feedback Topics:

Solo Progression Avenues - How are new players likely to progress if they are unable to find low level groups. This can cause the feeling of being softlocked. This issue might also become exacerbated when Rogue releases, and 50% of the low level players are all rogues.
Death Penalty On Tanks - With Tanks dying so often, there are long term economic implications for those who are playing Tanks. They will earn significantly less glint, and therefore gold during their playtime. Gold subsequently is used by almost every other system in the game.
Tank in general (grit changes feel like chinese water torture)

hollow socket Feb 7, 2025, 10:01 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans teleporting you to carphin
Guild wars getting stuck at 0-0 instead of showing actual score.
Being forced to leave groups to go attacker/defender on caravans.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The way resource respawning works continues to destroy the gameplay
Re-balance and re-enable guild/node war rewards. Whatever it takes to fix this so that guilds have reason to pvp each other.
Fix desert recipes like agave that don't have that ability to be processed.

sullen pond Feb 7, 2025, 10:01 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

You didn't fix the duplication bug. Please fix it
Invisible treese

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Do something about the chat moderation. People are so toxic ingame.

spring pilot Feb 7, 2025, 10:01 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Hunting Rarity does not work, this affects any profession outcomes that are in touch with any skin, bones, animal fat, weapon or armor molds or food
Unable to attack or defend caravan while you are in a party, you always have to fully disband party, choose attack/defend, and reinvite

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Guild - level one takes way too long. I do remember that the guild skilltree was ment to compete with smaller guilds vs bigger guilds, but atm its impossible to level up as a smaller guild because of the big invest that has to be done for a single player
Mitigation in PvP. Nerf Player VS Player DMG by a significant amount, test different values during different weeks. Armor values seem useless, penetration too powerful

normal crow Feb 7, 2025, 10:01 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The mounts getting locked into static animation.
when taking fall dmg, you are marked as in combat and cannot call your mount
The huntable spawns dont always disappear after hunting, resulting in a bug of them being visible, but not huntable.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I love treasure hunting, but have stacks of unusable curio coins taking up valuable slots. Increase stack size until there is use
the Hunting Pylons just dont make sense.. They last for 15 minutes, but most spawns are far outside this window. This means a pylon will cover 3 (max) spawns, usually 1.
I understand that scribe and alchemy are just shells of what they will be, but adding in more of their catalog will make those professions actually playable.

lapis socket Feb 7, 2025, 10:02 PM

#

let the feedback commence! elmoFire

quartz jetty Feb 7, 2025, 10:02 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mobs getting stuck, If a mob hasn't been damaged for x amount of time, reset/respawn it if it isn't responsive/at it's normal spawn.
Resources spawning in inaccessible locations.
Caravan bugs - despawning teleporting etc.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Nerf Enchanting for main stats (str/dex/int/wis), it's causing crazy power spikes from enchanting 10 gear because it's cheap and makes defensive stats irrelevant.
Fixed rarity gathering has GOT to go, no one enjoys camping a single node every 4 hours.
We still are barely getting to journeyman artisan skills, please make default for nodes apprentice and T1 buildings journeyman.

blissful python Feb 7, 2025, 10:02 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Wars and node wars are meaningless and there really isnt any reason to play anymore.

safe flower Feb 7, 2025, 10:02 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

gathering rarity on fixed spawns

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Bard rework rocks, feels so good!

hot lintel Feb 7, 2025, 10:02 PM

#

.

iron dome Feb 7, 2025, 10:02 PM

#

Top 3 Bugs:

Inventory bugs and storage ones, fixed with relogs
Summoning mounts is cancelled by any buffs or debuffs. For example bards melodies or clerics soothing glow
Logging out with a caravan beacon bugs it out and it is essentially lost

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravan attackers still need some risk. I suggested on reddit to make them buy an item to enable them to attack thats consumed upon attacking.
Zergs. Still the main problem. Will continue to be the problem. Will be the end of this game if allowed.
Ranger feels half baked compared to other classes, and Tank seems lost in terms of vision.

viscid sable Feb 7, 2025, 10:03 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)
2)
3)

wanton pasture Feb 7, 2025, 10:03 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

People exploiting the flag system to force flag other players
out of event healing is still present
world bosses bugging (or being bugged) in to terrain and buildings making loot unobtainable as they appear to have no structure collision
guilds/players purposely bugging caravans where they can't be flagged against as defender or attacker.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

can we get the items in recipes available. such as the janie anybones pinup. it's frustrating not having these items in the game but the recipes obtainable
voting for mayors need to be locked to accounts, not per character. this makes for a very unfair testing ground for those trying to legitimately test the systems asked of us
dynamic node spawns with proper use of rarity rating use would br great.
still awaiting the artisan skill trees. Really hoping they will be as good as we suspect them to be
guild war declare scrolls are still being expoilted by guilds already punished for their exploitation early on as a way to kill crafters for no risk due to there being no wind up time for the war to start. This is the sane for node wars. It's the same guilds every time

worn oyster Feb 7, 2025, 10:03 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Processing - Unable to use different types of materials during processing

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Coal feels too scarce at the moment

runic forum Feb 7, 2025, 10:03 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Items disappearing en masse from player storage, both randomly, but especially after a citizenship switch.
Broken mob spawns: mobs spawning as low levels, not respawning at all
Rapidly switching between tab-targeting and active targeting, can result in a weird bug which makes your character move in a different direction than provided by the player input

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Way too high influence of the base stats such as intelligence, strength, dex on player damage output
Static resource locations, respawn timers and quality basically broke any idea of "testing the economy".
You cannot join a caravan's attack and defence as a party/raid
The unnecessary, especially at this stage, "grindiness" of a lot of game systems adds to playtester burn out / retention issues

Lack of balance and broken group pvp content adds to playtester retention issue
Bard active damage abilities nerfed into the ground
Why items like node cloaks with specific stats such as physical or magical are locked behind a specific citizenship?
Switching citizenship and returning to the old node citizenship results in far higher tax burden. Terrible design.

fading igloo Feb 7, 2025, 10:04 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

No Damage Numbers when fighting sometimes
Lagging Mobs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Randomize the Resource-Rarity, it's getting camped and ruins all the fun from gathering
Guild-Storage would be cool
Separate LFG Chat and Global chat

dull glacier Feb 7, 2025, 10:04 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

caravan carph teleport is abysmal, I dont even understand why it happens.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravan system has a couple QOL changes that would make it much better, letting team leader flag for the whole party.
allow flagging on all caravans in an area.

broken hawk Feb 7, 2025, 10:04 PM

#

Mounts freezing animation breaks immersion
Marketplace search function should not display empty shops

bronze sapphire Feb 7, 2025, 10:04 PM

#

Only ever 1 feedback topic! Please add an inventory sorter, for the love of god!

crisp otter Feb 7, 2025, 10:04 PM

#

Pressing grit every 10 seconds is not fun

hushed wave Feb 7, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Most Important Feedback Topics:
Bard - Fortissimo - Underpowered for Pensive compared to something like menacing which gives the entire party an extra ~15% dmg (double)

whole badger Feb 7, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans still getting eaten by the server in certain server worker location when converting from raft.
Fixed rarity of materials makes me not want to gather anything at all ever because I never have a chance of getting anything good because I am not setting timers.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)Why is int and and strength the only important stats?

Can you please clarify coal? I hit over 200 rocks between today and yesterday of varying gathering levels (nov, app, JM) and have not gotten one since this patch. Were the drop rates heavily reduced? the amount of high rarity needed for steel is insane to the availability (similar to fat)

elfin sage Feb 7, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025
previously fixed bugs that reappeared!!

when typing you also do all actions of the bound keys which makes you unable to properly report bugs too...
if there are actually offensive or even in parts illegal names you should take more care moderating.
Bard songs stop playing randomly sometimes << if this is back in too like someone else posted here then that sounds even more like you reintroduced tons of bugs again that were fixed maybe while merging two versions or smth .-.

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

if you die desert, spawn riverlands, npcs hate and insta kill you upon spawn
riverland maps can give desert locations
npcs in desert stop attacking / freeze
in the desert below miraleth you can walk under the map and be invisible but still fight

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

i would appreciate being able to open the menu, report bugs, etc while SITTING ^^ its kinda annoying it doesnt work
there are a lot of map glitches recently again where you just stop walking, sink into the ground etc.
the desert crocodile role stun oneshots me which seems a bit annoying ^^
the aggro range is still really... fun... if you can ride away with speed buff for 2 minutes and still get chased... like i said in the past it could easily get reduced by 2/3 and would still be further than other games
go harder against griefers / people that dont respect bug reporting and stuff
rarities feel imbalanced currently e.g. its super rare to get legendary resources right but then the difference in gear is quite tiny so there feels like a disconnect

eternal fossil Feb 7, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan teleport bug
Caravan teleport bug
Caravan teleport bug. Tired of losing my caravans to a bug

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Solo Progression Avenues - How are new players likely to progress if they are unable to find low level groups. This can cause the feeling of being softlocked. This issue might also become exacerbated when Rogue releases, and 50% of the low level players are all rogues.
2)Death Penalty On Tanks - With Tanks dying so often, there are long term economic implications for those who are playing Tanks. They will earn significantly less glint, and therefore gold during their playtime. Gold subsequently is used by almost every other system in the game.
3)Tank in general (grit changes feel like chinese water torture)

inner holly Feb 7, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT
2)PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT
3)PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK for PVP is way too low and considering how at this time at least there are more instances of 1V1s compared to group PVPs, the balancing should reflect that.
Certain Nodes workers seems to be way worse in performance compared to other like the Carphin one. Please identify and improve these workers.
Hunting rarity calculations improvement

pseudo pilot Feb 7, 2025, 10:06 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fixed resource rarity & spawns - e.g. if a Willow spawns as legendary, it then respawns as legeandary every 4h until server restart. So people just camp it on a timer..
Unable to join caravan as attacker/ defender while in group/raid - you need to leave group - select attack/defend - then rejoin.
Mage Cone of Cold applies frozen effect with 1-2 seconds delay atm
Caravan driver protection does not work - easily can get killed before you can even dismount

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK too low across the board - especially Bard pvp damage is completely nuts atm
Lumberjacking needs more types of trees in t2/t3 - at the moment willow is a super blocker as all recipes require it (as there is no other t2 wood)
View distance in large scale PVP is way too low.

thin dagger Feb 7, 2025, 10:07 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

PLS fix Rarity

dusty fog Feb 7, 2025, 10:07 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)The Marketplace fix, where it automatically switches to materials if the items tab is empty, is unnecessary. If I’m looking for Recipes for example, idc about materials, if the shops empty of what I need let me move on. What’s worse, the next shop I move to will be on the materials tab, forcing me to click back to items. Undo this change please.
2)
3)

plush spruce Feb 7, 2025, 10:07 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rarity of nodes being fixed instead of randomly rolling depending on your resource quality (It causes each epic and legendary node to be contested by the big guilds and there to be nothing left for the other players.)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Stonemasonry is not in a great spot atm. As one of the processing skills that is utilized alot less then the others, the most/only important thing a stonemason can make are the weapon molds. Each processing profession has their specific gathering skill(s) that gather the materials for these professions. Lumber milling has lumber jacking, metalworking has mining, tanning has hunting, weaving has herbalism, etc. Stonemasonry doesn't just need mining, but also hunting/tanning for animal fat and herbalism and weaving for thread. The last two also need to be upgraded to journeyman to even be able to craft the journeyman level molds. Why does stonemasonry need 3 gathering professions + another processing profession to be able to make their signature items all on their own? And yes you can work together with other players or buy the items from others but that doesn't change the fact really that it is the odd one out of the group of processing professions that are currently available.
To my understanding, willow tree spawn locations are partially shared with briarwood trees. On Lotharia we have the problem currently of having max level nodes but none of the city's having journeyman lumberjacking. This causes weeping willow to be by far more needed then the other kinds of wood and there to be alot less available on the market. This is already causing the price of willow wood to sky rocket, there is a possibility for guilds to abuse this in the future. Would it be possible to change/add a few spawn locations for weeping willow?

dusk quarry Feb 7, 2025, 10:07 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Enchanted gear is too powerful.
PVP is way to fast
Takes way to long to kill enemies in PVE group areas for the amount of reward given.. grinding carph for 1 hour and seeing ZERO loot to roll on is just depressing

solar lance Feb 7, 2025, 10:07 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

People seen as pvp flagged when out of range in a party

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please give us feedback on what is to come for crafting,. world-building, and node philosophy as a whole
Fix gear crafting, high rare mats, and enchanting system

compact holly Feb 7, 2025, 10:07 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Lack of spin-up time for war-dec's being exploited by guilds to snatch mats from characters crafting/waiting in town.
View distance far too low for NPC's and PC's
Fishing derby still being used as a discount war-dec.

gusty jewel Feb 7, 2025, 10:07 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans become immune to damage for 1 minute when their driver respawns at an emberspring.
Guild war spin up times still don't work
The "Penetration" Stat does not stop when enemy mitigation reaches 0% and simply keeps going. Tested for both PvP and PvE enemies.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gathering nodes are static and in fixed timers. While probably not a bug and just a temporary system, this is my single biggest concern atm since it completely destroys the gathering professions as all the legendary nodes are controlled by a small number of people every time they spawn.
Stat power scaling is fundamentally flawed even after the "squish" from P1. The enchanting system shows this very well as with it you can reach these high mainstat numbers. Everything encourages gearing for offensive stats, since mitigation does not scale nearly enough to keep up with ability damage once people start getting 2-3 mainstat gear and enchanting these to +8 leading to the current one-shot pvp burst metas.
Example (Fighter): 1 Strength point increase gives you 1 more damage on your Blitz, however that same increase gives you 2.75 more damage with a Cataclysm. Making the big hitting abilities spiral out of control.

Great work otherwise 😊

kind stratus Feb 7, 2025, 10:08 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fixed rarities and respawn timers for gathering "nodes" shouldnt be a thing. Probably bugged/not implemented correctly atm?
Camouflage is not working properly.
Caravan carphin teleport is still in the game. quite annoying.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK in PvP is WAY too low. Oneshotting people is no fun. Dying to a oneshot, even less.
Defensive stats dont do enough/are worthless compared to offensive stats.
Guild levels take ages even in an active guild.
performance on bigger events like node wars could be better (EU)
healers feel useless with this TTK in PvP, especially after the nerf.
tank are a meme?

slender hollow Feb 7, 2025, 10:08 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)Getting teleported to Carph during Caravans
2)Not being able to swap weapon so you cant attack, only fix I know of is to relog
3)Caravan flagging being really buggy/annoying

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)Static spawns for nodes, people just get timers for legendaries and just sit on it all day
2)Better ways to farm glint, the best farms have been nerfed and it is a annoying process especially with stolen glint being useless
3)Medium armor is to hard to farm, its way harder to make medium armor than any other armor type.
4)Journeyman Scrolls are very annoying to get.
5)Coal is impossible to get at a high rarity, needing 20 legendary coal/steel for just one greatsword is way to much. The difference between getting a bow made compared to any weapon that uses a large amount of ingots is ridiculous.

raven smelt Feb 7, 2025, 10:08 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

resource nodes that are under ground and or not harvestable
Inventory lock / storage lock bug that requires you to log in and out to correct
mayor commision quests not updating the correct number once you complete one. So if it says 50/100 and you click complete commsions it should say 51/100

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

static resource spawns.... You have to add a random modifier on resource nodes
the ability to process a set number of resources
just overall bugs in caravans making them a pita to do cause of fear of lossing them to bugs

deep coyote Feb 7, 2025, 10:09 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Buff on caravana raider don't work and you are basicly oneshoted by anything.
Mobs should focus caravana not raider
When you crash on caravana you need to wait some time before you log in because it will be instant crash if you do so.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Party leader should be able to join caravana events as whole raid party. Disbanding and rebanding the party is anoying and destroy any ambush.
Re-think about enchanting system. lvl 10 gear should not be able to overlap set gears for 20lvl. It's funny that basic shit gear on +8 give you Time to kill around 2-3s.

upbeat pulsar Feb 7, 2025, 10:09 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rarities are too rare in professions
Bard songs stop playing randomly sometimes
Debuffs not showing up

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK in PvP has to get fixed
TTK makes healer feel useless
Performance for EU node wars has to get fixed
Tanks are worthless right now with this TTK
Defensive stats are… a meme (1 constitution = 10hp, mitigation stats do nothing to counter ttk, etc)
FIX FUCKING PVP TTK PLEASE 😭😭😭😭

brazen bolt Feb 7, 2025, 10:09 PM

#

Top Feedback:
I would like to see some rarity improvements, something similar to Last Oasis perhaps? Where rarities are represented as 0-500. A surveying telescope will let you pick out the higher rarity gatherables. Your Gathering scales with what Rarity of tools you have. Any Rarity other than 0 will give you a Rarity 1 item using a 0 rarity tool, then will you build your Rarity 1 tool, it scales quickly, and you start climbing the tree of higher and higher rarity.

real edge Feb 7, 2025, 10:09 PM

#

Haven't really played enough to have bug reports yet, only 30 hours or so

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Only progression is grinding mobs. I think a refined quest system would do wonders. I'm sure there's one planned.
It's only a test, and it takes AGES to grind out the levels you need to get max level. Current systems (I expect) are not end-game, so why not 2-3x xp gain to let people test every class/profession? I assume this will be wiped going into Alpha 2 step 3
No real ways to progress except grinding. Would be cool to see town progression count more toward player progression too. But not to the level New World had it where you could exploit the board to get max level if you just purchased everything on the AH.

vocal summit Feb 7, 2025, 10:09 PM

#

.

main pumice Feb 7, 2025, 10:10 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Resource availability
Duplication Bug
Resources not being able to be interacted with

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Guild XP system - please make this a background xp system where you gain it from whatever you do, just make the xp a quarter of the main tasks reward.
The enchanting system, scrap it just add more varieties of gear, from the people ive spoken too they either would like to see enchants be like a 1 time thing where you add an effect like element based damage or something or just see it completely removed because these stat increases are locking guilds out of the game when certain guilds attain these goals so fast and can slow the server.
please let me stow my weapon on my back please 🙂 ❤️

Thank you for a great testing experience, enjoying finding bugs and giving feed back on systems being offered

timber knot Feb 7, 2025, 10:10 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rarity Increase Scaling for Hunting makes crafting Leatherworking related items above Heroic impossible.
It is not clear how to obtain some crafting items from quests, such as the Janie Anybones Pinup.
Some Hunting Creatures provide their mount counterparts greater than 80% of the time. Bears for example provide their Trainable version far more often than the carcasses version making their craftables nearly meaningless.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Hunting system rework to allow for Leatherworking to be tested more thoroughly.
Further development of the Freehold system and more freeholds to promote their use more widely for testing purposes.
Guild storage and perhaps Guild Shops.

hexed delta Feb 7, 2025, 10:10 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Player PVP immunity extends to caravans
Player is able to reset a caravan while it is under attack
NPC vendors are taking more money than the cost of the goods

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resource nodes STILL have static timers and rarity... yada yada yada, we all heard it a thousand times. Still an issue.
Marks on the ranger feel... useless. With the long cooldown, short duration and travel time, they are not useful in PVE or a longer PVP against multiple targets.
Processing is still using a dropdown instead of a slider... Try crafting exactly 49 items. I dare you.
Rework of tank rendered the class useless

solid radish Feb 7, 2025, 10:11 PM

#

for the love of god and all that is holy make tanks feel like a tank, we shouldn't be killed easier than other classes by a large margin, our dps sucks make the one job we have meaningful
level 20 gear should not be weaker than any enchanted level 10 gear

empty flower Feb 7, 2025, 10:12 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Lighting issues
not being able to see party members on the map is incredibly annoying
having the whole group disband, then 1 by 1 choose to defend or attack a caravan just to regroup after

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Fixed rarity gathering is actively destroying the market
TTK has to be increased until the rogue comes out or a good equipped rogue will 1 shot everything
can we please swap to a non snowy season, atleast for a bit, even if the season system isn't working yet. the snow is actively causing pain to my eyes and since months that didn't change. that + the lighting issues in dungeons causes headaches after playing for an hour

grand cave Feb 7, 2025, 10:12 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1) Node wars switched back to the god spike/POI interaction gameplay loop
2) Would like to see node sieges turned on and available for testing
3) Would like to see guild wars functional 
    - Combat is restricted to War Area and point acquisition works as expected based on war type

olive tulip Feb 7, 2025, 10:13 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

out of conflict healing shout NOT EXIST. - you should not be able to heal people outside of caravan pvp, you should not be able to heal people outside of guild war, you should not be able to heal people outside of node war.
Constant crashes in large caravan trains.
Not being able to join caravan attack / defense while in a party - forcing players to re-organize a party as they get pvp flagged.
Voting not being restricted to per account. Politics are irrelevant when people with more time can just pump out alts.
Can't interact with the treasure map item to start the quest. Never used any before.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Static tier spawns for gatherable creates a horrible gameplay loop. You have to show up at server start to find good procs. Then you just sit on the timer for as long as possible, the optimal play becomes leaving every other activity to get back to your node when its valuable. Your whole gameplay session revolves around this.
Dropping guild should have harsher penalties. People are constantly dropping to dodge wars or to not be targeted in the open world. There is no point to the social / political aspect of the sandbox if it's so easy to circumvent.

hollow violet Feb 7, 2025, 10:13 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Out of Memory bug
Freeze
OUt of memory

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The wolrd need MORE lights, city are really SAD to see, there is no dynamics, only snow, we only see white, there is no torch in cities, this is flat graphics

karmic pumice Feb 7, 2025, 10:14 PM

#

Top 1 Most Important Feedback:
Don't listen to basically any of the feedback in here, i'm reading some really bad suggestions. Focus on bug fixes. Kthnx

mystic sky Feb 7, 2025, 10:14 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Not being able to see my own damage numbers.
People not rendering in and looking invisible despite not using a skill like camouflage
Bank to Materials bag not allowing to simply right click to move stuff in between them.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gathering rarity system. As it sits it seems there are multiple systems that govern rarity drop rate. The first most simplest system is that rarity of a dropped item or gatherable is tied to a simple 1/10 for uncommon 1/100 for rare 1/1000 for heroic etc. Then there is some sort of node system in which when a resource spawns it has some inherent rarity meaning that someone without any rarity rating may just randomly get legendary resources. Then there are static nodes and dynamic nodes. That is nodes that will spawn a particular resource no matter what and follow a spawn timer (static) and nodes that will respawn dynamically throughout an area. Basically what this boils down to is that some resources are locked to a very slim chance to ever get high rarity while others have a locked in rarity and can be camped on respawn if the timer is known. This allows people to put an alt on that known respawn and they can’t be competed against since that requires CCing them which isn’t supposed to be allowed.
I know that lawless zones are largely against Steven’s vision for the game but having rare resources spawn in a lawless zone has been really fun. With the advent of Daystriders my own guild has been setting up events to go run around the lawless zone and take these resources. It’s been fun and engaging and I’d like to see more content like it.
I think that the processing system should maintain having this non-mix match idea until at least the rest of the gathering system is fixed to allow us to observe how having access to higher rarity resources such as animal fat meshes with the system.

prisma oasis Feb 7, 2025, 10:14 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mount animations either stop completely or lag out
Duplication glitch. When game crashes and you relog instantly you duplicate your character
Flagging PVP in desert and flagging out again can get you stuck in pvp mode

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Unique monsters and ambience:
Many times in an MMO when you enter a new zone you have iconic music, iconic creatures and a different dynamic.
I understand that this is an Alpha and that more will be implemented but right now the world feels very copied and pasted.
There is no difference in mobs when you go from new aela to miraleth. they are all the same. and the mobs in desert are also the same three mobs.
hunting and husbandry:
Hunting has no vybe to is basically petting animals to death
Hunting rarity is basicaly 0 when you wanna aim above heroic rarity
Husbandry is TOO EXPENSIVE. a T1 animal shouldnt cost 55s. and the entire artisan in itself should not be a gold sink... its an artisan...you dont wanna run broke because you decided to lvl husbandry
Mounts dropped by bosses:
This might be a very very very hot take when it comes to mounts dropped from bosses. but right now the BIS slot mounts can be dropped by a boss and not by hunting them? what is the point of anyone ever lvling hunting when it comes to mounts if they can just simply kill the boss and get the mount through Mob drops.... mounts should either have increased drop chance for those who artisan husbandry or players with hunting should spawn bosses. like i hunted 30 wolves so an alpha wolf comes as retaliation... but to have 80 people spam a lion of which 2 have husbandry is insane...
Remove enchanting!!!
Enchanting is too overpowered. It shouldnt be the case where a lvl 10 with enchanted gear outdps, outheals me who has a full lvl 20 set.... there is no reason for anyone to go into dungeons or raids at this point if lvl 10 gear + enchants is BIS its ridiculous

dreamy cliff Feb 7, 2025, 10:15 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan teleport to the top right corner of the map. Even if they havent crossed a node border
Friendslist clear after serverrestart
mobs getting stuck in walls when farming in seph and other locations

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Weeping willow and braidwood shared spawn is bull****, cant understand that conzept. (Problem on Vyra)
A possibility to transfer items to alt characters would be much appreciated. There is currently a way where a friend is the middle person, so why not make it simpler. Makes it easier to craft and gather things

willow swan Feb 7, 2025, 10:15 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

N/a

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please make solo leveling a bit more accessible for all classes. Not efficient necessarily but accessible :c
Corruption System needs some work because the penalty is extremely steep

torpid cobalt Feb 7, 2025, 10:15 PM

#

Weekly Feedback 2/07/2025

Bug:

Allow the raid leader or party leader to sign up as defender / attacker on caravan for entire raid/party. Disbanding the raid / party for everyone to sign up is nuts.
Cleric being able to heal players in wars or caravans fights, outside of event, without flagging…
The change to market to switch to materials tab if there is no items, is the most annoying thing in history of all the marketplaces in games as now it stays permanently on materials when you browse items... Just make it overall that a player may choose if they are looking for material or for items for all the stalls...
Sometimes if you cross the zone border and continue riding no matter how far, if you dismount it will teleport you back...
Driving a caravan may teleport you to Carphin Tower Emberspring for some reason.
Caravans should not have spawn protection if you kill a driver.
Bard Songs stops from (de)summon mounts.
Abilities are bugging out across all classes, incl. sound effects, casting double (e.g. Scatter shot), camouflage not working as intended.
Lag spikes across the board on max spec PC while traveling through zones or farming or when night and day changes.
Drowning does not give XP penalty - Free teleport.

Feedback:

Please do not schedule maintenance on the EU Prime Time. Alternatively, please do share the timer in advance so we could plan better events.
People destroying their caravans to prevent you from destroying is plainly stupid design. Same for spawn protection for caravans if you kill the driver..
Too fast TTK in PvP - it’s a one-two shot fiesta.
Allow us to zoom out the camera more.
Current enchanting systems forces you to enchant items with lots of attributes. Overall gear progression is too simple.
Glint farm is abysmal, all grind spots were nerfed, there is no reasonable place to farm solo or in group for longer time.
Glint drop in party is a troll. Very inconsistent between members. In my eyes each time the glint is dropped, it should drop for each party member separately for them to pick up. Otherwise you discourage group glint farm.
Add some new, easy to add & fun content, some leaderboards, some extra features that will keep us engage in testing - Low effort - high value.
Change how the named mob respawn. Having 20 people swinging in same location during spawn window is, oh well...
Make the locations overall more fun with some zone progression in them to actually change with amounts of mobs slaughtered, e.g. more respawns, more elites, named mob may spawn after you do X, Y or Z.
Add more PvP zones that are actually worth visiting and taking the risk to farm, currently there are none. PvP zones could rotate across all mini zones and add extra loot chance / more glint / unique PvP loot to encourage all to come.

undone venture Feb 7, 2025, 10:16 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mob fixes. Glitched mobs in walls.
Drowning is a teleport
Server Worker transition in high pop zones.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Expand Zones/Node - So JM professions can be further tested
Expanded Recipes for the new resources.
Item based search function
Rarity and Resource Timers.

burnt pine Feb 7, 2025, 10:16 PM

#

tanks grit needs rework -- old system was fine but having to spam it is an awful experience. id rather see it removed altogether than use the current implementation
tanks chain pull -- would love to see it work
caravans -- if you find mine please lemme know. ditto for my first two material storage in winstead

grim stratus Feb 7, 2025, 10:17 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Please fix the ability to sign up as attacker/defender in a raid/party please
Please fix the ability to sign up as attacker/defender in a raid/party please
Please fix the ability to sign up as attacker/defender in a raid/party please

rigid vigil Feb 7, 2025, 10:17 PM

#

Weekly Feedback UX/UI edition (Mainly issues with the world map and chat filtering)

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Player markers are not shown on the Regional view. You can rapidly click the Party Member map legend in order to force display it on the Regional view which seems there is a UX/UI issue where some data is not retained properly for the player markers to be displayed on the Regional view.
Player markers are sometimes not showing at all even being close to the players. This seems to be more of an issue when in a raid which contains more than 8 people causing issues for having people gather up or finding out where the rest of the group is located.
When typing certain words the chat filter that is in place is to aggressive causing some things to not be allowed to type out at all. This includes an in-game item for the market board to never be allowed to be listed as Cocoon which can be quite disruptive for market board listings since that is what most people will possibly try to search.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Quest markers are not unified between Local and Regional view. This makes it quite hard when you have to figure out if this is a quest that is only available to view in Local only or in both. This is quite disruptive as a UX/UI aspect when it comes to interacting with the Quest systems.
POI markers disappear when in the region view making it harder to find where certain locations might be when referring to it in the game.
The chat filter it self is way to aggressive in all forms of words which points to it being a Regex match case without more input which is a bad way to do chat filtering. Look at some online services how they did chat filtering by ranking full on words at how bad they are just based on every combination of how their used in sentences. This I know can be quite time consuming to implement but in its current state does not allow for good chat communication.

Quite a lengthy one since I know this part of game/web design patterns with its terminology and what impacts it can have.

hollow bobcat Feb 7, 2025, 10:17 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Hunting Spawn Rarity- match to consistency with all other gatherables
Hunting tools, gear, and consumables- The numbers are inconsistent and do not match up. The JM hunting elixir is a great example of this where there is no change in rarity at all.
Moving from one server worker to another is still a major issue and causes disconnects and disruption

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Inconsistency of WIllow/Braidwood rarity spawn and quantity of spawn. This coupled with the hunting issue has caused an incredible bottle-neck that feels like should not exist to this extent.
Beast of Burden at JM level being strictly worse in terms of value feels really bad and makes the 400g+ required to get to JM AH feel more punishing as mounts get lower in demand and BoBs are just bad
A way to move mounts/BoBs back into the economy would be amazing. I think Steven mentioned potentially having limited lives and then the BoB or mount turning into a carcass and used in a new way. This would be amazing and would also potentially help with the massive issue we are seeing with the extreme rarity of carcasses from rare and beyond.

worn patio Feb 7, 2025, 10:18 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

mounts anim is not looping? or static? also sometimes de summoning it gets canceled despite not being in combat or taking dmg

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

As a Bard it would be nice to see the full list of buffs teammates have rather than the +2,+3,+4,etc icon. normally it will say what song is playing when you hover over it which is nice but it would be nice if there was more way to extend that view (if thats already in the game and I missed it my bad)
Visualizing when your mount is spawned on the summon icon would be nice I often forget if I spawned it or not and end up messing up de-spawning and spawning it by being impatient
Love the new stuff in the desert and bard updates good stuff!

pearl marsh Feb 7, 2025, 10:18 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

I do not like Carphin, please stop teleporting me there!!
Corpses don't stack in hunting bags... I dunno if this is a bug but it sure feels like one.
Underground enemies... I cannot kill them but being killed by ground otters is not fun!

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Node's spawn as set rarities, No, bad Ashes! This is so horrible! Also, I have heard people camping legendary spawning nodes, this sucks a lot! I have watched people set timers!!
Hunting doesn't ever look at my tools, clothes, buffs, foods, node buffs etc. I will just get common, always common.
Being attacked in a Carvan and being one shotted... This sucks. A freaking lot. What's the point of my caravan having good hp when I get killed, spawn across the map for whatever reason and by the time I get back, my caravan is dead.

weary flame Feb 7, 2025, 10:19 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Drowning as teleport. Please just remove the ability to go to your home spawn point for environmental deaths and this will solve it.
Bard songs stop you from summoning mounts even while out of combat.
Mounts don't show the flashing purple when it is wearing off of the player. (This caused some drama with someone going corrupt right before the last down time)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please re-work the static gathering nodes (LJ & Mining) to be based on Rarity rating alike to Hunting. (doubtful this could be done with great effect without a wipe to remove most epic/legendary crafted stuff already)
Would like to see more ways to get Guild XP seals (or set values of Guild XP) to better introduce smaller guilds to doing things aside from just caravans.
Rogue, T4 Nodes, and Desert Major POI seem to be a big priority for the community.

tired cargo Feb 7, 2025, 10:19 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan immunity for people who continue to launch at downtimes to try to spawn an event that can't be attacked when servers restart. Keep this from happening and ban repeat offenders.
Getting teleported to Carph during caravans sucks and has to stop being a thing, this has gone on far too long.
Collision bugs where exploiters drag mobs to a wall and get it to bug out by being slightly higher up...this has to stop and they need a ban.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gathering-You shouldn't be able to camp a legendary willow or whatever every 4 hours. Gathering has to change immediately, it's trash and nobody likes it. The entire economy and all gathering and guild relations revolve around sharing timers for mats and trying to get the hit when servers come up. Boring. Kills the game for gatherers, most I know have stopped playing.
Class identity- Mage as a Ranged DPS has no ability to maintain distance in a fight other than a move tied to our cc break. We are a ranged dps, everyone else has a kick, silence, and the ability to close the gap. This is a poor, inflexible design. CC break should be tied to Shield for mages, not blink, our only mobility. We need more flexibility, especially w the buffs to fighter, considering the number of kicks/stuns/silence etc bards and fighters have, which other classes also enjoy. We have little to no options compared to every other class, even ranger has a combo silence. Our incap is weak and slow cast. If we are going to be so inflexible, perhaps don't nerf our main combo and AoE dmg ability as a Range DPS that should function as a glass cannon...our class identity is much the weaker for it.
There needs to be some form of punishment/downside for attackers of caravan events. Everything already drives you to PvP. PvP is fun, sure, and caravans are high risk high reward for the person running it. They also function as an open world pvp event. Cool. It should still be high risk high reward for an attacker as well. Right now, it's all upside, with essentially zero downside to attacking any caravan. That has to change. I'm aware it will eventually, supposedly be a faction thing for nodes, but right now you could simply up the % durability loss for attackers. Something, anything to encourage people to run them and not simply attack, adding balance.

glacial venture Feb 7, 2025, 10:20 PM

#

Top 3 bugs
Mobs getting stuck
Laggy servers
No quest markers sometimes

Top feedback
The game has no sense of direction when your a new player
Quests are not satisfying leading to just massively grinding mobs adding more quests and story to the game would be a massive w
My main grip with the game is I login and have no sense of direction on what to do next
Also would be nice for you to add current level of what the mobs are to the map in the area those mobs reside

pearl falcon Feb 7, 2025, 10:20 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

hot keys for need or greed. while in action mode, needing to switch modes, sometimes mid fight, can be rather bothersome. also if you are the one that loots the item that goes to need or greed, the loot window doesn't close automatically, and even when you press esc it doesn't close.

undone venture Feb 7, 2025, 10:20 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Performance issues and framerate drops moving throughout the world since the patch on 1-30-25.
Node quarks not spawning in and falling through the world where they should be.
Cannot harvest resources because they spawn inside terrain and the interactable portion is unreachable.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics 1) Marketplace feels worse than before the most recent changes. I dislike how you have manually swap between gear and materials tabs and it "defaults" to materials. 2) Would love to see an in game LFG board of some type where I could list myself as available and for what content. This would also make it easier to find additional players. It does not need to be a WoW style group maker, just a notice board in game instead of using tools like Discord that takes you out of the game. 3) Chat system overhaul. It is very clunky managing global chat, party chat, and tells. This is nearly impossible to navigate effectively if you are looking for more people for a group and in the middle of combat. You almost have to have the entire group stop while you try to invite them.

trim fjord Feb 7, 2025, 10:21 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

not being able to pick up loot
inconsistent tax amounts
tears in the terrain

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Running dungeons is totally inefficient compared to farming legendary mats, with a timer and a spreadsheet. I didn't pay for a farming simulator
Can we please get freeholds fully functional so that getting legendary mats with timers and spreadsheets matter less
We're still waiting on the second wave of account actions that got announced weeks ago.

zenith patio Feb 7, 2025, 10:21 PM

#

ALL my storage dissapeared 2 weeks ago. Thats kind of critical.

earnest snow Feb 7, 2025, 10:22 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

trees in nodes are half way under ground

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Do something about the chat moderation. People are so toxic ingame.
attackers face 0 risk when attacking a caravan compared to the person running the caravan

scenic atlas Feb 7, 2025, 10:23 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

In-terrain nodes and creatures - whether they're underground, in the air, locked onto a pllar, etc..
Nodes respawning at same rarity is killing both the economy and the crafting.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The current trend of adding items, and recipes (though broken) to test things I understand. But on the players' side, new items with no use doesn't lead us to want to test anything. IE. acacia's look good, and can be harvested (at least they don't spawn underground so far like all the other trees), but they serve NO purpose. All these new items do is clutter up an already bursting inventory.
Node Tab - If you're not a citizen, you're able to see other node info. Once you become a citizen, you lose access to that info and get new info - why lose the old? Also, I'd suggest adding a tab to find out what crafting/bldgs are available at a node on the tab so people don't have to ask every two minutes.
I understand that carcass drops are the way rarity should be working, and I'm all for it. Please increase the quantity of animals available in the future though. The main reason I'm asking for this is for medium armor (tends to use a lot of hides) which currently unbalances the availability of certain gear [Though I'm guessing this will be addressed in the long term, I'm feedbacking based on current build as requested]

summer lichen Feb 7, 2025, 10:23 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bank storage does not give increased stacksize with specialized storage - general storage does not work well for the amoun of gatherables

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Rarity when hunting works differently than any other gathering profession and seems like it does not work well in the current economy - legendary should not be a once in a lifetime drop just rare enough so its possible but needs effort to aquire
Not enough possible buildings on the server to get everything in journeyman at least once - possibly fixed with freeholds providing buildings for processing and crafting - so freehold updates would be great
TTK in PvP is too low and a fight should not end in 1 combo
4)low rarity gatherables are not useful - vendors provide too many items making basic crafts more expensive than buying it from vendor

ember surge Feb 7, 2025, 10:25 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Resource nodes (all types) - need to be randomized based on the gear I am carrying and using (e.g. proper chance at rarities regardless of what node I harvest); tired of people camping legendary nodes and breaking the economy. Fixing this would significantly impact #2 below:
Players that choose to attack non-PVP flagged players (e.g. stun/sleep/cc to break resource gathering), should be immediately set to corrupted and incur the appropriate penalty. Too many L20+ are doing it to significantly lower players all the time, again - primarily because of #1 above.
Marketplace needs basic item search functionality along with sort by price. I feel most days I spend more time in the marketplace than I do playing the game. I know that's just a perception and not reality, but it really needs some love.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Node city taxes are BROKEN AF. I get that taxes should go up based on node population, but EVERYONE should be paying the exact same increased rate. Just because I joined the city weeks after the server was wiped, shouldn't mean I'm punished by hundreds of tax receipts, while I player that joined on day one is paying <10 receipts. Over time, as a node population grows, everyone's tax burden should be equal.
Please fix the friend/ignore Social functionality (e.g. /ignore playername in a chat window). This was working 2+ weeks ago, but has been broken since at least 31-Jan patch. My friend and ignore list is woefully out of date to what reality should be.
Guild progression costs are still way too high.

frosty violet Feb 7, 2025, 10:25 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

invisible enemies
gathering stats not working, unsure which ones exactly, but I know for a fact mining quantity is broken
bard song prevents mount summoning

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

please make named enemies respawn on a random timer (20-60 mins) and not on set intervals with small windows (58-59 mins). Having to sit at a spawn point all day just to get beat out by someone who knows the exact timer and camps the spawn is a pretty lame way to play a game and it’s demoralizing. An option to reduce this issue is to add the drop at a low chance to all enemies in the surrounding area. Or to make the named mob have 2-4 spawn points not within view distance of one another. That way people have to clear their way around the area rather than getting to sit in a corner until the mob spawns.
fix the gathering nodes so they don’t respawn as the same rarity. The economy is trash bc of this.
t4 nodes when???

alpine mesa Feb 7, 2025, 10:25 PM

#

Top 1 small adjustment: Add send items or coin to alts (only for self account)

woeful steeple Feb 7, 2025, 10:26 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Ranger Camouflage not activating ~99% of the time, and being targetable while in camo.
Player particles/effects playing when rendering/occluding into view. Not only does this spam audio and visual cues, I'm certain it bogs performance as well. It also immediately reveals the position of anyone in camo, if the camo worked.
Server not updating information and regularly causing UI issues, requiring players to log out almost every 20-30 minutes.
Mount locomotion animations breaking during travel is a particularly frustrating visual bug that I'd love to see fixed, since most of my time in game is spent walking back and forth across the map.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Using the flagging system is unintuitive. If a player is purple or red, players should be able to target and attack them without having to fiddle with whether they're forced flagged or not. A lot of combat doesn't actually take place because players can't tell that they're flagged to be able to attack. Please also consider allowing players to tab target to select flagged/corrupted players.
Please reduce Animal Husbandry costs and or the amount of animals processed in animal husbandry to level. Leveling animal husbandry is very soul crushing and an effort in insanity. Its wildly costly and it takes so many animal materials to get a level. Please lower the initial costs across the board and lower the amount of materials needed for levels, at least until it's properly implemented.
Extreme bottle neck in resources due to player population being too high. Either population needs to be reduced or resources need to be made more available.

earnest canopy Feb 7, 2025, 10:27 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Server Performance is poor - gatherables such as tree's don't despawn unless you relog / go to character screen. Render distance is also very poor - players and mobs just pop-in.
Right click to move items to the storage seem really buggy - sometimes it works but usually not. It's a pain when you have a lot of gatherables to transfer into the storage.
My character looks different every time I log in. I don't think I've seen my character look like how I designed it during character creation + my cape has a life of it's own.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Not enough demand in game economy, most items it's better to just vendor it. There's no incentive for most items to be bought / sold.
Not enough incentive to protect caravans, meaning there's less gold spread across the player base - which doesn't help with gold supply. There's too many poor people on the server, the wealthier players don't generate enough demand to keep the economy going.
If players don't generate enough demand for the economy to generate gold, perhaps the nodes can? It's fine for nodes to provide node specific currency - but the node currencies don't have much value right now.

lone prawn Feb 7, 2025, 10:27 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Blinding stadium lights in the night sky.
Dwarven moustaches becoming giant when riding certain mounts.
Some heals/beneficial casts can't be mouseover cast (like Mend).
Resource node spawn timers and rarities.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Common / uncommon materials should be able to be combined and upgraded via processing, so that they have some use.
People need to be able to differentiate friendly and enemy ground effects (like Divine Flare).

finite plank Feb 7, 2025, 10:28 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rarity for hunting is blatantly in favor of tailoring and armorsmithing, hunting quality barely exceeds rare on a blue moon of 1 in 100 huntables and they even need to go through the coin flip of carcass or mount when other gathering professions don't. Sometimes the mounts even feel closer to 80 20 in favor of mounts
Rarity for lumber/mining is not random but static on reset - While freehold is not exceeding Blue. Even at high quality root ball there's no difference from common rootball statistically.
Carcasses don't stack in hunting bag but mounts do.
Many mobs don't return drops equivalent to their level or stars if not don't respawn at all.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crowbaring is a toxic part of the game that needs changing. As it stands pirating or sore losers are all only crowbarring and wasting valuable cargo simply to deny others from getting them. This would be okay if the event doesn't dissapear almost as soon as crowbaring is available. So you either go complete corrupt or have a caravan ready to pick up loot. And even then you need to outnumber/cc the enemy so overwhelmingly its silly. There's no downside to crowbarring in the game other than player reputation. and yields nearly no rewards.
In my opinion here is one of several good solutions that may help.
Mainly: A cast bar that can be interrupted for crowbars. Preferably a minute or so per cargo maybe 30 seconds. This way people can stop others from playing the denial game and give the victors the ability to load cargo and make value in it as well as promote further PvP(instead of it just ending there)

The ideal solution would be a cast bar that turns you purple for crowbarring that can be canceled through cc.

solar viper Feb 7, 2025, 10:28 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1) being teleported to narnia, when crossing server boundaries while driving a caravan, most common teleport is to carphin tower emberspring
2) caravan delete button can be used when caravan is under attack, this destroys the caravan and cargo, preventing attackers from taking it
3) people and monsters and sinking into the ground during the combat after latest patch
4) some recipes are bugged, and are counting vendor materials as quality material preventing items to be crafted in legendary rarity (i.e.: sephillion ring)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1) time to kill in PVP is absurdly short, defensive stat is pretty much nonexistent, people need 1-2 shot to kill each other, small scale pvp from 1v1 to 8v8 takes about 10seconds before its over 
2) there is no risk to attack any caravan, and using crowbar just to ruin people's day, crowbar should be removed from the game, this is also abused a lot by "defending" players sign 1 or 2 people as attackers, just to crowbar boxes if defending side looses the caravan, to prevent attackers from being able to steal commodity cargo
3) ability to sign up the whole group/raid for the caravan event, instead of everyone being forced to leave the group to sign up, and then remake the raid 
4) hunting profession needs to be reworked, as it is terrible experience at the moment, there is not enough hunt-able monsters, high rarity of carcasses is rarer than being struck by lighting, bears hunting yields trainable bear 805 of the time and carcass only 20% of the time
5) agave seems to be yielding lower rarity more often then any other herbalism gatherable

wintry cypress Feb 7, 2025, 10:28 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

My character STILL cannot do maps!
My character STILL cannot do maps!
My character STILL cannot do maps!

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Fixed rarity gathering spawns are terrible for the game.
Completely impractical to craft high rarity leather gear.
There's no use for stolen glint now that you fixed glint laundering, are you sure you don't want that to be a feature for mayors?

cobalt plaza Feb 7, 2025, 10:28 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resource gathering rarity feels bad
bard nerfs feel bad
tank nerfs feel bad

rocky fractal Feb 7, 2025, 10:30 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

WAR DECs need to be disabled
WAR DECs allow people to be attacked anywhere since phase 1
WAR DECs...

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

why are war decs not disabled.
dopamine and other guilds on the Vyra server need their accounts actioned for exploiting war decs.
war decs are being used to exploit.

frail sinew Feb 7, 2025, 10:31 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Right click to bank not working very very often.
Quests like Burnt Ends and Vera Curse quests bugging out.
Quest item tab being unusable.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please fix rarity
Make storage better for ore
Make it easier to process the 30 different types of ore/gems/stone
JM Mining bags get too full really fast

rich path Feb 7, 2025, 10:31 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

action mode camera often unable to be controlled after opening map (only fixes with relog)
Rubberbanding
friends having issues with black screen not allowing them to login
typing in chat often triggers spells when in action mode

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

if youre gonna ban offensive words to men in the chat, ban ones that are offensive against women
people are still training mobs on others
the desert is getting so fun and cool!!!! Tysm!!!!!

barren hedge Feb 7, 2025, 10:32 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Glitchy Mobs resetting
Boundary disconnect bugs
INVISIBLE WEAPON/SHIELD

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Add PvP Brackets 20+ should not be able to attack level 10 & below
Add WEAPON SHEATHING, I want to sheath my weapon. The animation in game already exists, just enable it.
Remove passive healing from Walkers/Zombies

marsh vortex Feb 7, 2025, 10:33 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

fixed nodes for resource spawning
bards can get a permanent melody buff by going into a menu while channeling the melody as long as the channel finishes while in the menu
sometimes dying with a 1 stack of a common resource will upgrade its quality I’ve gotten heroic logs and herbs like this

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

guild progression should be guild wide not just a single person progressing it and the current exp value for level 1 feels like what it should be to reach max level with the current gain of about 100 xp per run even if it was 10k xp not to mention 4.5 or 5.7 million it would still take 100 runs to level up a single time
guilds need a bank or storage to streamline guild maintenance and in guild rewards

ripe wadi Feb 7, 2025, 10:33 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Most critical issues for me is:

1 - the UI resetting when ever a player joins or leaves the party
2 - The map needs Icons that we can see fully zoomed out.
3 -Please make the market place search hit on item types. Browsing the market is such a nightmare looking for upgrades when I click on a shop for Armor, and finding nothing but crafting items.

viscid loom Feb 7, 2025, 10:36 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The grit/courage changes on tanks feel so sad, previous system had a great flow to gameplay and now having to spam what was a passive stance and having values not equal to a single finisher really ruins the flow.
Bard damage is so completely gutted that playing in any group size under 4 feels horrible.
Fixed rarity resource spawns on huge timers is really killing any desire to search for higher rarity crafting or to craft higher rarity tools. Please don't leave this for an extended period.

tropic tulip Feb 7, 2025, 10:37 PM

#

Tank changes making tanks not at all fun or engaging to play. Having to spam grit every 8 sec to stay alive takes all agency out of the rest of tank game play. Especially bad in pvp where we were already too squishy. See forum posts for more explanation pls.
Caravans still omega broken. So many ways to lose a caravan it hurts my soul.
Hunting rarity broken and no way to get animal fat or skins above heroic.
Nodes being static respawns and not randomized is ruining the economy.
Being forced to leave groups to go attacker/defender on caravans.

lilac lotus Feb 7, 2025, 10:38 PM

#

Top 3 feedback

Fix resource gathering static node rarities ASAP
Push tier 4 cities to stop the bottleneck
Give us an update on tropic poi and node expansion

scenic cipher Feb 7, 2025, 10:46 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Players constantly underground, I believe this was caused when journeyman mounts came out and it seems to be the mounts that cause it, unsure.
I call them the Carphin Wormholes, Several spots when going to Desert in Caravans along river between Miraleth and AIthanar as well as in the desert between Aith and Azmaran where you can get teleported to carphin. Also just caravans bugging in general needs improvement still.
Maps still bugging, more so in desert many times the treasure mound is just , nowhere. rarely the mound can be found and not looted.
Players able to heal attackers and defeners in caravans without being attacker or defender themselves. This exploit is incredibly unfair. Players should either be unable to heal anyone or any caravan being defended/attacked or at least go flagged/purple if they do so without joining as attacker or defender.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Lawless zones are great and we need more of them and more rewards for being in them, such as increased rarity from gathering, grind spots fit for level 20-25 players that have increased mob density and/or increased glint drops.
Stolen glint should be usable or washable. Incentive for pvp is low currently, limited lawless zones and even looting a players glint feels worthless now. I thought this was a pvp game 😅
Time to kill in pvp is too fast, defensive scaling feels nonexistant. Everyone at max level is just getting oneshot/onecombod by anyone with 400-500 phys or magic power. 1v1 small scale and large scale pvp the fights feel too fast and people just die too easily in general.

restive iris Feb 7, 2025, 10:50 PM

#

Crafting lvl 20 gear is impossible rn. Would be nice to have lvl 4 nodes.
Melee is at a huge disadvantage to ranged.
Gathering mats is too formulaic.

stark flare Feb 7, 2025, 10:52 PM

#

My caravan floated down the river out bounds, I can't retrieve due to it being 96 meters away.

rugged lance Feb 7, 2025, 10:54 PM

#

Bugs
1). Emberspring buff extending to caravans
2). NPC's and players getting stuck underground
3). Numerous inventory bugs

Feedback
1). Sliders for crafting... easy to do get it done
2). TTK in pvp needs to be addressed.
3). Add a Caravan universal profession that can be leveled up as players complete them.
4). Adjust guild xp requirements further... pretty unobtainable atm.
5). Make grit a togglable resource drain skill or you'll see a bill from Dr. For carpel tunnel surgery... haha

onyx nova Feb 7, 2025, 10:54 PM

#

lapis socket Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers! Please share your top 3-5 most critical ...

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bugs
Visual Effects
NPC Bugs/Issues

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Character Skills and Progressions
Quests Tree Progressions and Rewards
Not Enough Content to Retain Tester Population

lyric dirge Feb 7, 2025, 10:55 PM

#

Bugs: Gathering rarity is borked and needs retuning.

Feedback:

Crafting material requirements need retuning. They're very aggressive for certain items, for example, all of the dang rubies you need for scribing.
The leveling experience is bland and not fun. Try to implement/fix more quests in the 8-25 range. Commissions should give out more XP than they do, the rewards are pretty bad. The world needs more events, this would help with the XP demand. Mostly, sitting in POI groups and grinding for hours to level is boring AF in 2025. If you want people to test new areas and high level systems, make it more engaging to level.
Caravan defenders need more incentives. Maybe they could get XP, glint, or node bucks? Why not create a commission for that?
Please make search better in the marketplace, or at least add the ability to search by category or add filters. The search being limited to a 50 character store description is limited and head scratching to say the least. World of Warcraft did this in 2004...

buoyant grail Feb 7, 2025, 10:59 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

mounts count toward guild war deaths
storage/inventory bugs
resourse nodes sometimes unretrievable
rubberband when you dismount to server worker edge

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

spontaneous guild wars can be used to attack players in town
players outside of wars can heal people inside giving unfair advantage
attacked caravans can deleted to prevent attackers from looting
confirmation for selecting promotion/demotion
getting higher teirs of food that used butter is difficult to obtain.

sick owl Feb 7, 2025, 11:01 PM

#

Bugs:

Desync issues that require relogs
Caravans- almost everything about them

Issues:

Storage
1a. No guild storage is becoming very problematic
1b. The way processed items stack into material bags makes little sense. If I can fit 80+ ore into this bag, why can I only fit 40 of the fragments.
Processing/crafting need a slider like donating to the node has. There's no difference in processing 1 or 250 of something so just use a slider. Clicking and crafting every single time is downright annoying 😑 even if I still have to stand and watch it craft, I would rather push the button once.
Hindered development due to lack of node progression and resources. Crafting gear is supposed to be on par if not better than farming it, yet access to the materials and resources needed (name mob drops, willow being non existent, and hunting rarity issues) lead to thr inability to get gear crafted at higher rarity. Not only this but due to the node bug in the start, there is not enough space to put out stations to allow us to craft everything at journeyman anyway.

arctic wyvern Feb 7, 2025, 11:03 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory and Storage Bugs, especially "right clicking" breaking
Static motion mounts and space mount abilities
Random teleportation especially during caravans (does feel reduced but still happening)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I know its Alpha and removal of staticnees of game may be in the pipeline but current mob, hunting resource spawns are being farmed in a way that's mechanical and not in keeping or have the feeling of "the hunt" its also ripe for abuse especially by bots.
Green and blue rarities for a lot of gatherables seem to have no real use, often seem a waste to craft with (few exceptions) and for same reason pointless to sell often just vendor trash especially if not used in work orders
There a lot of systems not being fleshed out due to size of world or bad actors (mainly with mayorship) so crafting is heavily impacted on some servers and exasperated by the above points, forcing many people to rely on item drops - seems to be in balancing expected game play.

cunning notch Feb 7, 2025, 11:04 PM

#

**Weekly Feedback - 02/07/2025
**
Top Issues:

Mobs resetting even when close to their spawn location.
Fixed resource spawn locations and rarity allow easy monopolization (bad).
Some resources spawning underground, making them inaccessible.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Shared storage pretty please with cherry in top
Randomize node spawn rarity/timers
Market interface needs serious search/listing improvements

warm cradle Feb 7, 2025, 11:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Upon death during a Caravan event, player gets 60 seconds of invulnerability. For unknown reason, this also applies to the caravan which makes it possible for a player to abuse the invulnerability, especially when the event is close to the Emberspring
Players sometimes appear to be partially or fully under the ground, so only their nameplate remains visible - extremely inconvenient when it comes to PvP. In most cases, happens with characters of Dwarf race.
All caravan related bugs, such as "Random teleportation to Carphin", "Random dismounting" etc.
Upon losing a fight for a caravan, some people destroy it themselves by talking to Caravan Master. Therefore, attackers get no reward for a successful caravan raid.
Players who did or did not participate in Caravan Event are able to instantly break the cargo caches using a crowbar without getting flagged or any repercussions whatsoever

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

In order to join a Caravan Event as Attacker/Defender, players are forced to leave the group or pass the Group Leader from one player to another.
Introduction of proper search filter to the marketplace - this will make economic gameplay loop and general trading much more convenient.
Gathering & Gathering Rarity - been mentioned a lot of times by many people. Static nodes lead to people camping them on timer instead of finding them while exploring/traveling. Current gathering rarity system doesn't make a lot of sense either.
Ranger Shortbow animation - Breaks immersion and it feels like I'm shooting AK-47, not a bow.
Ranger's Camouflage - Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't, totally unreliable
Make areas around World Bosses PvP zones

sour sapphire Feb 7, 2025, 11:08 PM

#

1 - Cleric's Flash Cure costing more than Divine Flare feels terrible. Double the mana was too much, reduce by 50% and it'll feel better. You could also revert the mana change and increase the length of time it takes to gain charges back. Have some kind of skill mechanic to help them recharge faster, like "reduce 1 Flash Cure charge by 25% for every finisher combo"

2 - Caravans still feel like crap.
-Allow successful attackers who have summoned their own caravan to arrange crates in their caravan that they have taken from a destroyed caravan.
-Still need a group que'ing for the party leader to either join Attack or Defender.
-Randomly teleporting the driver to Carphin needs to be fixed.
-Water Caravans dropping their cargo in the water seems very bugged and doesn't drop properly most of the time.
-Allow us to leave a caravan event and put us on a cooldown to rejoin another one for a period of time.
-Emberspring buff protecting the caravan is being abused heavily.

chrome geode Feb 7, 2025, 11:10 PM

#

THE most important bug IS the one when servers rolled back a couple weeks ago and I (and many others) lost the first two BANK TABS of storage in our home node. This was NOT from a loss of citizenship. Our small guild lost HUNDREDS of metal fragments as well as a LOT of other things.

vocal pier Feb 7, 2025, 11:13 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Killing the same mobs over and over again gets boring
Need to be able to trade glint (at LEAST between characters on your own account)
Guild bank needed

frozen maple Feb 7, 2025, 11:18 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

make any crafting, gathering or processing buffs be based on artisan level not character level.

candid estuary Feb 7, 2025, 11:21 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Great Job on addressing bugs. Maybe a bug reward for peep who find significant ones. 🙂
Lag in heavily populated areas. (Perhaps consider spacing mayor event areas out.)
Delay between map quests. Can't start another until time expires on first.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Trade Channel and/or LFG Channel (Like original eq) You can open what channels you like).
Tanks can use more - er personality. Tanks will be stuck on group grinding. Remember Monks, Shadow Knights gaming background).
Need a drop out button for people in the mayoral race who want to drop out.

agile acorn Feb 7, 2025, 11:22 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Still some ghosts gatherable, less but still existing
How i can get kill during loading?

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Performance as go down with the lasts patches. My configuration is on low end but i didn't have that much issue to play before. I have a lot of performance issue, loading take forever (on ssd). I don't known what going on but that's painful. 2. I'm unable to log on my main, without passing first by a reroll, i don't known why.

slate pagoda Feb 7, 2025, 11:24 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)resource Rarity in fixed locations, instead of actual rarity chance

2)resources in inventory/storage disappearing after hours of farming for gold to buy them

3)invisible resources

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)low level, leveling without just grinding will kill the game, there needs to be more options to level for solo/ smaller groups to level.

2)being able to have a raid leader Que the raid for a caravan attack or defend would be a great QoL change

3)multiple chat channels would be great

item linking in chat/whispers would help a lot of internal conversation

5)market place search function should be item based instead of shop name

shell marsh Feb 7, 2025, 11:25 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Player bug underground during pvp (visual desync bug), which makes it akward to fight them
Spells are bugged (f.ex. scattershot double cast or one cast eats two charges or camo that either keeps you visible, or makes you invisible but your bow is visible, sometimes shoes. Camo should also remove targets if you are targeted by someone)
Can summon/desummon mounts when bard soungs tick

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

There is very little to gain from going above heroic gear rarity. You just want heroic to get as many stat lines possible and then spam enchants to get most value.
Current pvp is one shot fiesta and bard damage is just unfair.
Market place needs some better way to search than shop title. There should be a way to look for items you want instead of going manually through hundereds of player shops
Mass pvp server performance leaves a ton of room to improve

past mauve Feb 7, 2025, 11:26 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)hunting is terrible. IE not having proper skinning
2)Making ALL animals have a chance to respawn as huntable when killed would go a long way to help
3)Testing placeholder systems feels pretty bad

humble falcon Feb 7, 2025, 11:27 PM

#

Most Important Bugs:

Nodes having a fixed rarity allowing alts to camp nodes with a phone timer. Surely the Gatherables always having a fixed rarity with little effect from items is a bug???
All off-hand items/weapons turn invisible after any animation or weapon swap
Mounts animations freeze when jumping up misaligned rocks or cliffs

Most Important Feedback Topics:

There's a huge discussion for the tank changes on reddit, so I hope you look to see what others are saying and take it into consideration
Why is the crafting/processing sizes not parallel to stack sizes? It should either be any amount or 5, 10, 15, 20, etc. The amounts make no sense and needing 25 is so aggravating
Guild Banks, a mail system, and work order system are starting to be more and more needed as the crafts increase in complexity. It's very difficult to get with others to complete orders with how much is needed.

sick sable Feb 7, 2025, 11:28 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Could you please make abilities on hotbars change based off the skill tree, for example if i have tremoring strike, and i respec to tremoring bellow please have it change on my hotbar to match.
im not enjoying the other melee classes and im desperate for rogue 🙂 that is all

lime anvil Feb 7, 2025, 11:30 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Some basic desert weaving recipes are missing, such as weaving agave thread and date palm weave.
Huntable targets spawning in rocks. A few Wyrmlings and at least one gryphon

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please, for the love of god, fix hunting rarity. It is depressing and disheartening in its current state....
It appears as though treasure maps were recently nerfed, perhaps too much.

rotund eagle Feb 7, 2025, 11:31 PM

#

World bosses not respawning properly and if killed often bug out without any loot dropping --> suggestion: let them occur 2 times a day at specific times to make it a contested event objective.
Survivability stats being pretty much useless in comparison to damage stats which makes the time to kill shorter every day due to gear getting better
War cooldowns not working - a guild who won or lost a war should not be able to declare another war against the same guild right after because this way guild wars tend to be even more unfair than they are anyways
Treasure Map Rewards are too low - heroic maps can give grey or green matrerial only etc.
Caravans still being VERY buggy which makes it a high risk to even start one even without counting in the risk of pvp contest

errant bluff Feb 7, 2025, 11:37 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Not really encountered any but ive not been actively playing that much

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The Crafting system increments needs binning, and replacing with a slider, being able to do things in just however many you need will be so much nicer.
Chat needs a LFG and Trade/Selling section.
Guild shared storage, right now its just trade materials around a shared guild storage would really come in handy just so we can organise (with perms in the guild roles) maybe at the cost of 1g in a node you can get a guild storage
Just guild content in general! Please more content !!!!!!

spare arch Feb 7, 2025, 11:51 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

My number 1 concern is the lack of randomness associated with node spawns.
Players are just camping the locations, meaning guild horde the legendary and sell at ultra high profits. This is an economy breaking characteristic of the game at the moment.
Lack of randomness on mob timers. I would suggest a +/- 20% on mob and resource node respawn timers. This forces people to keep moving, rather than hording and spawn camping. Variety is needed

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Toxicity is pretty ridiculously high. Including a lot of white knights giving false information that such and such act is actionable when it hasn't been. Shaming players just because they thought of something the others didn't. I think more information on what is an exploit and what isn't would be very helpful to the player base. I've seen situations where some guilds get reset for exploiting where to stand and not be attacked, yet other guilds are considered favorites of GM's and do the same actionable offense.

So a clear message that using terrain to inhibit NPC ability to touch players, leads to X result would give concrete understanding on what is an exploit, what isn't, and take away the ability of the white knights from just making shit up.
2)
3)

livid lark Feb 7, 2025, 11:54 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

FOV for super ultrawide is super bad. I'm missing like 1/3 of vertical image render because FOV bound to the wrong axis.
Monsters getting stuck in walls
The sound effect of the bell and dragon breathing from carphin stays with you even when you travel significant distance away.
playing with one character, then changing servers and playing with another will always result in a client crash about 30 minutes into playing the second character.
The game client is entirely capable of checking whether the cpu microcode for intel 13/14th gen i7/i9 CPUs is version 0x12b, which is the latest fixed firmware for the power issue. Please perform the check, and prevent the dialogue about the CPU's issues when it is unnecessary.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PvP is a hot, laggy, rubberbanding mess with ~30+ players
Spawning attackers and defenders on the same approachable embersprings during a node war is ridiculous. elevate/isolate separate embersprings to prevent causing a blender on the spawn point.
We really need a timer for node wars to start. Every time it's a large group of attackers who show up with no materials to lose, declaring instant war and sweeping through to kill people in storage, bench, and market menus for free materials. No risk, all reward.

restive mountain Feb 7, 2025, 11:55 PM

#

Servers + meshing. We just had a war and the game isn't playable at the moment. The view distance is much too low. People float around and warp in and out. It's just not testable at all. Even when noone is on-screen as a ranger playing from overseas on one of the US servers using scattershot makes you rubberband back and forth.

spark trellis Feb 8, 2025, 12:02 AM

#

Most Important Bugs:

Fixed Resource Rarity & Timers - Resource nodes have a fixed rarity, and allow people to set up timers to come back to specific resource nodes if that node produces high rarity materials.

Please allow all resources to be randomized. Randomized resources promotes adventuring and going out into the world. Maybe put a soft glow around trees that have higher tier material (Albion online has a good example of resources and tiers). This would allow people to fight for the resource if needed but won't have people setting timers and camping for the resource.

In the lawless zones, possibly increase the chances of materials spawning to be more rare to promote activity in the lawless areas to have the "risk vs reward" element in place

Most Important Feedback Topics:

Death Penalty On Tanks
-Have a skill/passive on exp/material dropped lost on death if recently healed by a party member. This would promote group play, but during solo play would still have the same death effects as the other classes
*Allow clerics resurrection to regain a percentage of lost exp

*Allow items to be linked in chat

*Allow a /r to reply and the ability to repeat last sentence by pressing up on chat menu

ocean ore Feb 8, 2025, 12:04 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

treasure maps are still bugged for some. can not activate them.
mobs having a green name and can not attack them

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Vender cost of potions enchanting scrolls and items of that manner are not worth crafting because it costs more to craft than to buy from the vendor
Tanks grit should not be a button mash skill it did need to be changed but the way it was done has made the class more frustrating
the economy while it is determined by the server pop and the rarity of crafting mats make this very difficult to craft. especially higher rarity hunting carcasses, coal and droppings.
The bottlenecks with crafting when needing the same rarity to craft components should not be a thing.

lyric panther Feb 8, 2025, 12:04 AM

#

======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Respawning mob sometimes broken, mob probably spawn somewhere inaccessible to player (under the map / in rock / walls). Probably a good thing to destroy them from time to time to make them respawn again (more than once a day when restart server)
Hunter satchel which are good with living animals but not with carcass
Fighters don't have any skills to use Echo from wands/book skill tree

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Static Ressource Spawns makes Gathering camp a Spot instead of running around
people and monsters sinking into the ground
Mobs glitching and stacking in Walls

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK on PVP is to low
Enchanting / Stat stacking is to powerful
Perhaps Caps for Stats like at lvl 20 you can only get 50 Int per Equipment
Marketplace is to basic, we need search for items and buy Orders

placid oracle Feb 8, 2025, 6:48 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Stability, crashes
Caravan reliability
Performance

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gearing at lower levels with crafting viable?
Hard to bring myself to test even for gathering citizenship taxes
Just more time to cook, it'll workout in the end

arctic mango Feb 8, 2025, 7:13 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

some mining are stuck
mount run bug

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Selling and buying a decent action house is a must! (search on item)

vapid talon Feb 8, 2025, 7:14 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

LFG and trade channel needed, plus not every channel can be turn off from General
ability to pin crafting recipes
option to increase starter bag (I know it can be swapped to craft bag, but those not universal)

rigid yarrow Feb 8, 2025, 7:36 AM

#

Bugs:

Hunting Rarity seems wildly different than mining or lumberjacking.
The market switching the materials automatically if no items are in the item tab is terrible. This was introduced last week and has made going through the marketplace even more painful than it already is.
Mounts getting stuck in static. Just really annoying

Feedback:

Time to Kill in PvP is absolutely busted. Tanks should not be two tapping a fighter. Auto attacks should chunk for 30-40% health a hit. Problem is a combination of enchanting scaling much harder with offensive skills than defensive ones and not having a PvP mitigation factor. The damage output works when fighting 60k hp mobs but not 4k hp players.
Please for the love of god allow for less static processing amounts. Let me select an amount between 1-250 or whatever you want the upper limit to be.
Not sure why the guild leveling is only tied to caravans and why a single level takes nearly 4000 gold in opportunity cost.

spare mango Feb 8, 2025, 7:51 AM

#

Bugs:

Broken mobs that will heal to full while not fighting back
Alt and other modifier keys being stuck on after Alt+Tab (I accidentally flagged, died without fighting back and felt sad)
Mount usability bugs.

Feedback Topics:

More content for solo players or small group/small guild play. I'd like to feel like I'm making progress even if I take a more casual approach w/ friends
Looting sucks. There is no enjoyment from going to a location and pressing a button. How much would it really hurt to have loot appear directly in the inventory after a kill? Obv not player corpses or mining from 40ft away
More incentives to help others without needing to group. Kill credit changes would be fantastic. Currently there is no reason for me to help kill mobs that are about to kill a player who overpulled. Kill credit seems all over the place and is hard to know if it's bugged or intended to be super strict. I used to heal others before I realized that it would pull aggro and I'd be forced to kill mobs for potentially no reward

modest sequoia Feb 8, 2025, 7:57 AM

#

Bugs:

Mobs seem to rubber band more than they used to
Roads need patching, these holes are ridiculous

Feedback Topics:

Do something about caravans, system is complately made for guild players...
Enchanting items at lvl 1-10 is way too expensive, no way low level players can afford enchanting their gear to +3
Armor to dps scaling is non existent, no idea why light armor gives a lot Magic Resist, while Heavy gives almost nothing

elfin furnace Feb 8, 2025, 7:59 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Not being able to use or switch weapons.
Code 32 on every startup.
Some places being littered with resources and some barren.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The time it takes for a solo player to become a citizen is too long.
(Why do I need to grind for 20 hours just to be a crafter/gatherer?)
The ability to hide weapons.(like in alpha 1) It looks silly when a dwarf is running with a sword in hand.
PLEASE reserve the flips for the Nikua, not the Dunir.

loud crypt Feb 8, 2025, 8:15 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Code 32
Code 33
Code 34

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

grit sucks
lasso sucks
code 32 33 34

heavy flare Feb 8, 2025, 8:26 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mend is not able to be used with hover healing.
Teleporting to Carphin while on a caravan.
Hunting rarity too low.
Mobs often get stuck in terrain and walls and will get bugged and unable to be interacted with or respawn.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PvP systems need much work. Guild War declarations on top of node wars should not be a thing. Node wars should take priority, and should cancel out guild wars. Why can the war declarer cancel the war whenever but the declaree has to wait to surrender? Also it is not fair for these guild war declarations and node war declarations to have no warning to the defenders. Any healers that participate in war should be tagged or their heals negated; currently they can sit outside any war and heal allies and enemies lol.
PvP balance is atrocious. Damage needs a special pvp damage reduction tag, time to kill is way too short and rewards zergs and glass cannons way too much. No counterplay is boring pvp.
Mainstats have too much weight on gear and with enchanting. Enchanting lvl 20 gear should be exponentially better than enchanting lvl 10 gear; the linear increase makes lvl 20 marginally better.
Static rarity material spawns need to go. Needs to be pure RNG. People are camping high tier rarity spawns with timers.
Unique mob spawn timers need to be much shorter. Again being spawn camped with timers.

quick heart Feb 8, 2025, 8:45 AM

#

Feedback:

Leveling: Leveling is extremely frustrating. It involves spending 15 minutes in chat to find a group, only to have a member leave right after joining. This results in further delays as a replacement is sought. Once the group finally starts killing mobs, they often wipe almost instantly due to various mishaps, including mob training, where other players intentionally or unintentionally lure mobs into your group, causing chaos. This leaves players back at square one, with a substantial XP debt and a strong desire to uninstall the game. Solo farming is even worse. Losing stuff when dying, and having xp dept and being teleported far away from the place you died is extremely stupid as well, we are in 2025, things like that should be kept for hardcore servers. anyone having a bit of self esteem will just play something else than have their time wasted because in all these time wasting loops. Idiots train on us and we can't even defend ourselves because you will get corrupted and die and lose all your shit and xp dept and you will have to run back while the person who trained on you is picking up your loot, TRIPPLE PUNISHED FOR SOMETHING THAT AIN'T EVEN MY MISTAKE OR BECAUSE SOME IDIOT WANTS SOME LOOT AND BEST WAY FOR HIM TO DO THAT IS TO TRAIN. YOU CREATED THIS PROBLEM.

Suggestions:

Implement a more efficient group-finding system.

Reduce XP penalties for group wipes.

Improve solo farming mechanics.

Address the issue of mob training to prevent griefing.

#

Hunting: The hunting experience is terrible. After clearing a whole location for a chance to get a huntable animal, other players can steal your huntable animal in front of your face because they have better mobility, i had bard follow me around and steal my staff while i was forced to kill all mobs to get huntable spawn, and the rarity is extremely low. Furthermore, the anti-PVP corruption mechanic prevents players from retaliating when others try to steal their spot.

Suggestions:

Revise the way huntable animals appear.

Address the anti-PVP corruption mechanic.

Increase the spawn rate of heroic animals.

#

Ranger: The top of the skill tree is nearly useless.

Air Strike rarely hits its target (99.9% failure rate).

Raining Death is weak compared to a single auto-attack, which does twice the damage.

Suggestions for Air Strike:

Implement a selection area similar to Vine Field, allowing players to choose where the damage is applied.

Reduce the cooldown by 10-15 seconds.

Remove the root/snare mechanic. (ain't working anyway)

Suggestions for Raining Death:

Increase the cast time to 5 seconds and reduce the cooldown to 30 seconds.

Allow players to select the area to cast the rain.

Lock player in place while casting, with the option to cancel early by pressing the skill again.

Hunts: Hunts are disappointing, especially the 10% crit damage bonus from the Tiger at low levels when players don't have crit chance. The Bear is more useful but not for non-tanks. Marks and armaments are also underwhelming due to their short duration and shared cooldowns.

Suggestions:

Make the crit damage bonus more relevant at low levels if you give this skill to players at low levels when player don't have any crit chance.

Improve the utility of other Hunts.

Revise the duration and cooldown for marks.

Make other Enhance Armament be useful, right now only bleed is viable and 99.9% of players will pick it because of synergy with other skills. So then what's the point of other two if we can't use them at the same time.

pure lily Feb 8, 2025, 8:57 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

performance. We are supposedly testing the economy but server performance causes frequent crashes and lost valuable loot.
frozen mount bug
mob train. The idea of getting griefed by trains or running a mile to shake one mob is frustrating to be sure.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Fix the static node rarity of items so everything is like hunting.
stop griefers from stunning people to prevent them from gathering resources. It’s not uncommon for higher levels to lock me and my friends out of harvesting.
marketplace. The item/material tab needs to stay whenever you change sellers. If I only want materials or items it slows me down considerably to have to swap tabs every new seller.

last quiver Feb 8, 2025, 9:03 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

For some reason, you can't view the journeyman recipes you learnt in your recipe book (when it comes to cooking atleast) but you can see the ones you automatically know.
Monsters keep getting stuck in Carphin.
You can't have 2 gathering tools. When I tried to make my second one it just disappeared.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Player made items should not be able to be bought at vendors. I'm a chef so where my annoyance lies is mainly the journeyman food. I was hoping the profession buffing foods would be my goldmine but you can buy every single one of them, for 47 copper... Just the gold sink cost of making the food, ignoring the cost of making all the ingredients, is 1 silver.
Baby cows should stack in your inventory. I honestly don't know why this was changed? It's annoying having to buy 8 at a time, and only being able to make 25 adult cows at a time because I have a filled up inventory.
The cost of listing items at your storefront combined with the expiration makes it very disheartening to sell a large volume of things there.
I was planning on having a very large variety of foods but now I'm just selling chicken, beef and scrambled eggs instead, which is boring.
You need to be able to have a longer description of your storefront. I wanna add that they can whisper me for buying larger variety of foods but due to the search function working off of keywords rather than what's for sale, my description is "food. Cooking roasted chicken, grilled beef and eggs" and thats all that fits.
Storefront search function needs to be fixed and improved. It really is miserable atm.

cursive obsidian Feb 8, 2025, 9:20 AM

#

Remove enchanting giving +1 base stats every level.

Make farming/hunting mobs give heroic+ mats as often as other gathering methods so crafting high tier 20+ gear is actually feasible.

Remove the massive diminishing returns formula from resist/mitigation scaling.

Buff con to give 50-100hp per point instead of 10.

wet hemlock Feb 8, 2025, 9:25 AM

#

Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Please share your top 3-5 most critical issues or feedback topics for this week's testing in the thread below using the following format:

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

I know how to trade glint and have put in a bug report and also reached out and heard nothing back
Unable to attack or defend caravan while you are in a party, you always have to fully disband party, choose attack/defend, and reinvite
out of event healing is still present

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Tank is unfun to play and needs to be reevaluated.
Re-balance and re-enable guild/node war rewards. Whatever it takes to fix this so that guilds have reason to pvp each other.
Mitigation in PvP. Nerf Player VS Player DMG by a significant amount, test different values during different weeks. Armor values seem useless, penetration too powerful

woeful delta Feb 8, 2025, 9:38 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

general caravan jankyness, especially when converting to raft
trees & resources having no collision/being untargetable
Mage blink passive for CC break still doesn't work

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

fix static gathering spawn locations/rarities...people can just keep returning to the same spot and get the same rarity...ruins economy & and is cheesy
find a way to better integrate enemy debuffs (relevant to/and caused by you) visually instead of having to constantly watch the little icons on the health bar...so tedious & awful especially in large groups with a dozen or more debuffs
continue to refine/balance the classes/combat (esp. mage!)
mitigation stats for PvP aren't keeping pace with damage stats.

suggestions:
debuff tracking/buff management needs a rework/re-evaluation to make it more visually intuitive. I would suggest that a portion of burn/shock/slow stacks that you cause are only useable by you and the amount you currently have on the target is indicated by a number on your spell that caused the affect (burn stacks caused by Fireball would have a number on the spell icon OR some small visual que on your character somehow; this would require a rework on debuffs somewhat i would imagine). You could also have the debuffs relevent/caused by you to be highlighted on the nameplate so you can keep track of it better. something needs to be done - straining your eyes to keep up with a shifting debuff box on an enemy feels bad and you often pay more attention to that than even the fight going on infront of you.
I also think the way all debuff stacks are shared makes everything so RNG in a group setting - i understand its to promote class/group synergy but there should be something that rewards a good rotation.

dim crow Feb 8, 2025, 9:50 AM

#

lapis socket Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers! Please share your top 3-5 most critical ...

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resources modes are static and end up being camped by players because it's on a timer.
Processing can't mix rarity.
Crafting needs huge balance to be useful

stiff comet Feb 8, 2025, 9:51 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Static resources spawns makes should not exist.
Memory leak
Healers healing outside of event (caravan / War)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Remove\remake enchanting giving +1 base stats every level. That working poorly now and will work poorly at 50 lvl.
TTK in PVP
Static rarity resource nodes of ore, wood and flowers are bad. They need to be dynamic to stop people from camping for high rarities and gathering being a nicer experience while making rarities of all kinds spread fairly.

stuck sable Feb 8, 2025, 10:15 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Enchanted items are very over tuned, TTK (time to kill) is so quick now that needing a cleric in pvp is starting to feel like a wasted space. (Yes its a bug because it too over tuned).
Caravans - when grouped up only the party leader can join the attack/defend event then they must pass the party leader down for another to join the event etc etc.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK is far to quick, without enchanted items it feels good, with enchantments it feels bad, tanks and clerics feel pretty useless in pvp.
Stop nerfing glint drops, in fact we need more mini farming spots, there are plenty of empty spaces around the map, mainly at the edges that need something added.
Quests, we need quests or much better rewards for the quests we have in game atm, board quests could give out more xp or/and more glint for example. 4) Flagging system is a bit flawed, just make more pvp zones/areas.

desert goblet Feb 8, 2025, 10:17 AM

#

Only 1 Feedback

would it be possible to add the map marker onto the small line that indicate the West-east-North-south on the minimap so we can get to our destination without having to open the map 3-4 time between the travel

round laurel Feb 8, 2025, 10:20 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

When my character dodges backwards, sometimes this action gets bugged. the character himself begins to perform constant dodges without my participation
Caravan bugs
Inventory bugs and storage ones, fixed with relogs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The spawning of all resources follows the same pattern, this is predictable and has already broken the economy.
My tank with 280+ constitution 35% protection from magic dies in 3-5 seconds from a mage or bard, and in general PVP now has a one-shot problem
It is impossible to obtain legendary resources from hunting, or the chance is close to zero
Please return the protective stand (Passive Grit)
I really miss the interactive chat

plush pendant Feb 8, 2025, 10:49 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Looting mob bugs seems to be back, or graphical. Only played a couple hours this week, and have seen the glow from mobs to collect loot but when interacting nothing happens

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Guidance from IS on what to test each week, otherwise its endless feedback on fixing caravans and fixing static rarity resource nodes.....
Tanks to get a similar mechanic to other classes (rangers/fighters), where they can have 1 active aura that works in different ways and can be used situationally e.g.
Grit - mitigation goes up for 30%, dmg goes down - solo buff
Iron Will - mitigation goes ups for group, but not tank - group buff for dungeons
Bait - aura for increasing threat - good for aoe farming areas
Brace - aura for increasing shield block rate - good for pvp against melee attacks?

fleet beacon Feb 8, 2025, 11:01 AM

#

Please share your top 3-5 most critical issues or feedback topics for this week's testing in the thread below using the following format:

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)I don't have hair
2)Trees spanws
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)
2)
3)

light ermine Feb 8, 2025, 11:13 AM

#

Three biggest issues:

The recent tank changes have made playing tanks unpleasant, and as a result, the population of tanks has plummeted.  This makes it really tedious trying to find one for groups, with hours spent doing menial pointless things like fishing while waiting for one to appear.  You’ve made a game centre around grouping which is theoretically fine, but not if you can’t get one.  Either make tanks fun to play, or increase the solo options in game.

Static spawning of rare resources (both timer and location) is a really poor mechanic, and makes the game wide open to botting, antisocial behaviour, and toxicity. This needs changing. Just make rarity random on each spawn. Scarcity of some materials (willow, metals) makes gathering and crafting tedious, rather than fun. It might not be so bad if freeholds were more readily available, but since they were bought up straight away by people who exploited at the start of the phase and therefore built up superior cash supplies, for most of us, it’s a distant pipedream. Some materials don’t even have rare versions! Add in a selling mechanism that is really difficult to use and you’re left with a pretty horrible crafting and economy system – for a game that likes to champion itself on the ‘crafter is king’ mantra, you’re making it really difficult to enjoy doing it.
Damage vs defence in pvp is way out of line. You need to significantly decrease damage dealt to other players in order to encourage more tactical pvp options. Tactical battles are always better than pewpew.

bold spear Feb 8, 2025, 12:18 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Remove cast time to summon mount, give us the option to let them follow us, allow us to use them in combat
Make caravan run faster
Give us level boosts or improve progression because grind is not fun

regal compass Feb 8, 2025, 12:24 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

1. inventory 
2. aggro behavior of mobs
3. mobs/resources are stucked

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

1. Please make a poll about removing the Death penalty 
2. Change PvP Flag system to PvP Zones with PvP always on
3. Give us testers a testingplan (what do you expect from the testers)
4. gathering materials are still too rare
5. too excessive crafting effort

sage ingot Feb 8, 2025, 12:32 PM

#

Bugs:

Mayor Quests seems buged! No possibility to store items in the box.
Mount freeze
so many mobs in the desert nods and almost none in the desert

Topics:
1.Respawn times are always the same! Spots are being camped! Change that and the respawn location!!
2. Please more options to level the guild!!
3. a reasonable search function in the player market

queen meteor Feb 8, 2025, 12:56 PM

#

No mail system to send materials to other guild members

white pulsar Feb 8, 2025, 1:38 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

caravans getting caravan protection after driver is killed
caravans despawning after converting from raft to ground near server worker borders
Hitboxes of leaves of desert tries blocks traveling on the desert and makes it a much less enjoyable experience

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

You should be able to join a caravan event while being in a party/raid. It makes no sense why this doesn't work currently. A party/raid leader potentially could have the option to join the event with the entire group
rarity on mining and lumberjacking nodes being fixed for a 24h timespan needs to change ASAP. The way node respawn + rarity works is heavily discouraging and allows monopolizing rare resources without contest.
AOE debuf clense on cleric and/or debuf protection. Cleansing some dots is just spamming a single button for 1.5 minute. This is not enjoyable gameplay.

orchid nacelle Feb 8, 2025, 1:41 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

engine crash/freeze

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Well I'm just giving up playing for now. I've been getting constant crashes the last few weeks.
They wouldn't have borthered me much if they wouldn't include the deaaath penalty from dying to a random crow next to me because the server kept my character in the game.
I've spend all my gold on getting Hunting gear so thata i can earn gold by hunting creatures instead so that I'm playing low risk low reward. well I've pettet countless creatures my hunting rank has increased to master by now and this week I got for the first time something valuable. an epic wolf carcas that should be worth around 50 Gold.
Well turns out you introduced a listing fee thats basedd on the price you want to set on top of the node tax rate for actually selling something.
I can't even afford to list the item on the market and even if I do it's questionable if it would sell within 3 days.
I want to earn something with my profession but so far i only spend a lot of gold on buff food and potions that seemed to have little to no effect and now I'm even priced out of the market by the listing fee.
I'm just so tired of making negative progress on every activity

trim garden Feb 8, 2025, 1:45 PM

#

Bugs
1)enemy players don't go red for stunning group healers resulting in unflagged party Player death. Recomnd: Any Flagging action on any party member, with resulting party death(s) within 90 seconds, causes Red Name/Corruption. This puts the onus on initiating attacker. #stop lowbie glint-farming!
2) In Dungeons können mops durch Wände gehen
3) Marketplace cannot be used in this way, please introduce a detailed search function
4)Weeping Willow,not to be found

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)Players who immobilize a Gather/Harvester should be marked with the corrupt status as it constitutes an attack
2)Please have a walk-in castle for every guild that you can set up, e.g. with crafting places (which you can also use) or beautify with a statue from Siegen

carmine shuttle Feb 8, 2025, 1:49 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Right mouse click to move items between iventory and storage sometimes stops working. If you have the items in the target location it works or not. Sometimes it will work fine if you don't have the items at the target location.
Archetyp: Cleric, Spell: Divine Flare - there are some problems with placing Divine Flare on uneven grounds like stairs (upper stairs in Church of the seven stars), uneven terrain like rounded and or uphill/downhill (tunnels and ramps inside Ursine Cave).
Bottles have a disco light effect. They switch between colour (green) and no colour (pink) in certain rhythem.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The desert looks beautiful ! Especially the dsert flowers, trees and the herbalism herbs fit perfectly into the surroundings.
The nre mounts look great. Including the variaties of outcomes (with or without sattle etc.)
Resources are targeted from much further than before, maybe the distance is a little bit too much ?

mossy token Feb 8, 2025, 1:56 PM

#

Top 3 most important Bugs:

Mobs are sometimes stuck in the environment textures and you can't target them and if you can they reset often before you can finish them off. Range mobs are deadly in these situations.
Right clicking in the storage space to load or unload items is very often bugged and can't be used unless you relog.
Mount graphics freezez often
Quest items are not in the quest items tab ?!

Top 3 Feedbacks :

Chat options , rightclicking on the name that shows you options to write to someone, or invite them to the party etc.
Buyorders on the marketplace please.
Map markers
Sorting bags by materials/sizes/etc

viral stirrup Feb 8, 2025, 1:57 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Monster desync (melee attacking and dealing damage from far away, most notably for me against Grem)
Monsters not reacting/being invulnerable, out of place and not possible to damage them
Tried the survey pylon for Herbalism in a poppy field, I think it did nothing except consume the item and let me roleplay as a lighthouse... Now continuing to just randomly collect what I find...

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

When a mount is summoned "add it to party" to show its HP bar, i want to know if i can ride through a mob horde or get dismounted and die
PvE ranged gameplay feels way better, I started solo as Tank, later on just used bow as it felt better, this should never be. After 9 levels i made a ranger and the leveling was way, way easier. Tanks should either have better sustain or be able to tank.
Chat whisper function: it feels very clunky. Maybe add a button [reply] or use a [shift]+[enter] to reply to last whisper. Cycling through last whisper contacts in a seperate whisper window with [arrow up] and [arrow down] to select would be helpful.
Save the last used resolution and monitor. I use two different monitors (4k, WQHD), each time i have to adapt resolution and it often bugs out if I try to play on 2nd monitor (WQHD) in fullscreen windowed.
I would like to have a stash space where I can transfer items between chars. I can trade it to someone who trades it back to me, but I can not transfer items/materials/... by my self.

real phoenix Feb 8, 2025, 2:29 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mages spells with area of effect his har to use somtimes due to the terrain
Mage blink has somehow gotten worse. Clipping and "sliding" after the blink causing some horror pulling extra mobs
Mage spells sometimes dosnt respond. example - firebolt firebolt "any area of effect spell" - dosnt start casting it. pressing it two more times start the casting of the spell.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Mages have been fucked over with the nerfs. Solocontent are even harder to survive now.

hollow gyro Feb 8, 2025, 2:29 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Game freezes and sever fps drops in windstead/lionhold/miraleth(on lotharia at least)
Gathering - timers, locked rarity in the resource node, gear progression, skill tree

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Viewing inventory has become very tedious once the height has been reduced. need at least 8 full scroll while motions in order to view whole inventory, this is very annoying to use. No option to reduce background rows for faster scrolling, impossible to work around without buying specific type of mouse.
Introduction of marketplace features/customizations - buy orders, search, filters etc. (I know its planned, but I'd like to see them sooner rather than later)

real phoenix Feb 8, 2025, 2:38 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mages spells with area effect dosnt work sometimes due to terrain
Sometimes at the end of the blink my mage slides for another 20 yards and kills me becuase i pull extra mobs.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Mage Arcane Circle only lasting 10 seconds removed all the fun from the class. Not beeing able to get a nice rotaion in during the burst window dose not feel as much fun as it used to do.
Mage nerf also made solo leveling very hard.
Make game playable in 5120x1440p

lime marsh Feb 8, 2025, 2:40 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Flying mounts should only work in your node unless you’re attacking another node. They should not work in lawless zones. Bypassing the game and being able to scout everything for your guild is overpowered especially when caravan hunting. Being able to just fly away, heal, and jump right back into a fight is broken.

vivid wave Feb 8, 2025, 2:42 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fighter skill whirlwind randomly stops casting when targeting an enemy sometimes

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

32x9 FOV fix, that is all I care about; game is unplayable at 5120 x 1440 with fov not adjusting to the resolution

zinc fox Feb 8, 2025, 2:51 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The Mage skill Aftershock is not working
Right mouse clicking to move items between inventory and storage sometimes stops working
Still some problems with caravans. Switching from rafts to land and vice versa is in some cases very buggy / strange.
When a player of a party has started a caravan, he cannot be a defender for the other party members caravans, if they are starting a caravan afterwards for themselves.
Visual settings: DLSS option is not saved and have to be set every time manually again.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Mage in general:
Make the skill set of the Mage more interesting, re-think all of his skills. There are too many cast time based skills with the effect, that the combat is feeling not fluid like for example with other damage dealer classes like Fighter or Ranger. Mage is feeling clunky in comparision to other classes.
Mage skills:

Improve the Arcane Missile skill, so that in high levels there is a benefit to use it at all.
Increase the damage of Ball Lightning after the recent nerf, at the moment the damage is way too low for a 20 second cooldown skill.
Decrease Magma Field cast time, it feels so boring at the moment.

You die too fast in PVP., please balance this out.
Defenders of caravans should get some rewards after the caravans successfully has reached a target location.
Add a simple function to use a /whisper command to a target player, like right clicking on a name of a players in the chat and then offer an option to "Whisper this player".
The high respawn timers for resources and rare mobs should be reduced or other concepts should be offered as alternatives ways for getting such resources. Make the crafting just more enjoyable !

topaz lodge Feb 8, 2025, 3:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Game feels lagging
Inventory / Bank still bugging

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

**Playability & MMO Aspect: **Crafting is almost impossible for solo players due to the need for many intermediate products. Forced interaction with other players disrupts the gameplay.
Item Transfers: No option to transfer items between own characters.
Professions: Effort is too high compared to the benefits.
Hunting Farming: Very frustrating, as certain animals (e.g., otters) are missing, and spots are camped 24/7 by players. On average, the quality is too low compared to the amount that can be farmed per hour.
Resource Farming & Spawn System: High-quality materials are hard to farm due to fixed spawn points and times, leading to extreme competition and instant depletion.

wintry hare Feb 8, 2025, 3:10 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

resource nodes should not have fixed spawn times and fixed quality. The whole current economy data is practically useless because of this and it forces players into strange behavior to not fall behind. There should be true randomness instead of camping nodes and extracting huge quantities of high quality materials and flooding the market.
random storage tabs suddenly being empty
caravan teleports and caravan disappearing at server worker borders
caravans should not be able to be destroyed manually or disappear when currently under attack

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

spawn grace period shouldn't extend to caravans, it is too often abused
please completely decouple artisan gear and buff items completely from adventurer stats and level requirements so that we can have true artisan characters that do not have to level their adventurer level to be fully functional and to also not force adventurers into specific professions for stat optimization
enchanting main stats up seems too strong
craftable items should not be sold by vendors for money in any quality, it heavily devalues some professions and negatively influences market prices
probably difficult to implement something to prevent that but in bigger fights where positioning matters more some guilds let single players join the other side of a caravan event to have a permanent scout that can't be attacked (or the other guild is forced to use the same tactic the other way around to kill the scout)

gritty ingot Feb 8, 2025, 3:17 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)Teleporting from inside caravan to Carphin.
2)Caravan being recoverable outside of the playable map.
3)Camouflage not working correctly on Ranger.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)SOLID WORK BEING PUT IN PLEASE KEEP UP THE HARD WORK
2)Made a pretty nice looking character with one of the races the other day, please continue to improve character customization.
3)It's unclear whether rootingballs are suppose to regrow or not. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't.

lean marlin Feb 8, 2025, 3:36 PM

#

1) Server Performance is atrocious, worse than it's ever been - crashing a dozen times per day + a few "blue screens of death".

Moving items to/from the storage seem really buggy - sometimes it works but usually not. It's a pain when you have a lot of gatherables to transfer into the storage.
Everything caravans.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

1., 2., & 3.) As a tester, we can't test or give feedback on anything without being able to reliably be in the game and stay connected.

twilit wind Feb 8, 2025, 3:49 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Right click to target self can´t be completely turned off. Can still right click yourself. I NEVER want to be able to press myself. I have accidentely left party several times. ANNOYING.
Invisible mobs.
Green (friendly) minotaurs.
Switching weapons makes it bugged sometimes so you can´t auto attack and switch weapon anymore.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Hard to know where to go to find X lvl mobs. Maybe once you have explored a place it gives a bit of info about that area. Maybe connected to the emberspring or something.

real narwhal Feb 8, 2025, 4:07 PM

#

Mitigation does not work. It definitely does not mitigate fraction of dmg, it looks like (not thoroughly tested) it mitigates flat amount in HP what it promises as percentage. This is critical bug because it is not balancing issue - it is issue of broken code which makes whole AoC the game of single offensive stat.
Right click moving stuff to bank does not work if it has to split stack on arrival, sometimes it does not work at all.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

World being infested by high-level resource nodes if there is nobody on server who can harvest them. Despawning these nodes during maintenance should fix it (mostly).
Enable joining a caravan event while being in a party.
Node respawn has to be randomized

rotund nacelle Feb 8, 2025, 4:32 PM

#

I know this is going to sound harsh but it seems only the mage and cleric are worth the time investment Sorry😕

rose igloo Feb 8, 2025, 4:36 PM

#

carphin caravan teleport bug
no force flag for party when queing attacker or defender
fix coal drop rate

vapid raptor Feb 8, 2025, 4:47 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Desert monsters and material nodes spawn much more frequent than in the riverlands.
Server cull distance during large player count fights.
Caravan bugs and client crashes.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Material nodes should not spawn on a fixed timer and should not be the same rarity when they respawn.
Enchanting gear should not give a +1 to all stats. Enchanted gear that has flat main stats on them is way to powerful compared to the weaker waterfall stats. Stats like armour or power rating should improve by percentages.
Items in the player market should stay in the market for a much longer time before they need to be relisted.

patent finch Feb 8, 2025, 5:00 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

whole party / raid can't sign up as attacker / defender at once
Game is too dark, too bright, too orange, too green. too hard to see stuff when the world keeps changing colors every hour. Or fog floods the world so I can't see mats.
gathering nodes suck. Stuck in trees, static rarity, not enough available on the map, etc.
look at this and tell me its ok level of brightness. i'll keep changing my monitors gama if i have to but its anoying

Sorry another feedback - The FPS is uncapped during the loading screen. imo should cap that at 30?

wide obsidian Feb 8, 2025, 5:43 PM

#

There needs to be a way to dispatch captured beasts to convert them to carcass. Bears for example are more rare than wolf and grem but for some reason 3/4 are tamed and captured beasts for animal husbandry instead of a carcass. There should be an option in farming or tanning to dispatch the creature and make it into a carcass. maybe this is planned or already in game and I don't know about it, if soo please do tell.

finite garden Feb 8, 2025, 5:59 PM

#

1: Weapon Talents:
a: it feels like there are certain talents that you take regardless (refreshing follow through is a good example) this removes actual choice because you just go for the same talent.
2: Weapon choice:
a: Long Bow vs Short bow: Long bow does not feel as competitive from a numbers standpoint vs shortbow. Between the procs and the attack speed, Longbow doesn't rate as a good option against shortbow.
b: Longbow range is not a large win factor when compared to the shortbow. 5m is not enough of a range increase.
3: Serverworkers
a: Is there a plan released on when dynamic server workers are set to release? The popular areas tend to suffer during primetime play and the work around seems to be just move away. But, if we are funneled to certain areas for leveling or resources, we just negate that work around.
4: Non flagged players susceptible to CC from flagged players.
a: This seems to just be more of a mild griefing when it comes to gathering.
5: Guild storage.
a: as crafting takes more and more of a place at the forefront, not being able to pool guild resources makes it harder to get things accomplished.

The game is coming along great! Love testing it. Addictive AF.

gray quail Feb 8, 2025, 6:31 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

auto-attack bugs seem be an infrequent issue (where it stops working and/or hotkeys stop working as well), but when they happen it can pretty much spell death (at least for low-level players like me riding a thin line with the mobs they are killing)
rubber banding back to a previous position when getting off horses (haven't seen this in the last week or so of play, so maybe it's been fixed...or maybe I've just been luckier 🙂 )
Not sure if this is a bug - when you're underlevelled and you talk to a vendor about raising a certification, the dialog just closes without any message. It needs a "Sorry" message to make me know that it isn't bugged, and ideally let me know at what level I can upgrade my certification.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting / Processing feels like a clunky and miserable experience that needs too much babysitting - lots of quality of life stuff like

being able to queue crafting requests
specify volumes that aren't a multiple of 5
being able to see what rarities are available to use without having the flick through all the processing rarity options
being notified when a ongoing piece of crafting / processing has completed without having to clock-watch

Paying 5 gold for the privilege of being able to store any items at a node is ludicrous amount for an early-game player who just wants to do interesting stuff - this just feels miserly, some amount of basic mat storage should be a given
Make the crafting stations in the early areas support proper crafting, not just the introductory quest mats - or have an option with NPCs so new players can find out where they can look for the proper equivalents out in the world. It took me so long to find any early on, and it drove me crazy.

I'm a noob player so my feedback is noob / new player related confusion 😄

vapid coyote Feb 8, 2025, 6:46 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mob leash range after aggro seems way to large. ( I'm looking at you Desert Scarabs -.- )
There is still a lot of invisible rocks etc in the Desert you can fall in to/ walk on
Ranged caster mobs shoot you through walls.
Maybe a bug? Dieing in a pvp zone and then ressing in a non pvp zone and still being flagged has got me killed in town on a few occasions. Would be nice if the flag dropped as soon as you spawned if you didn't actually flag yourself for pvp.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Low level crafting mats like copper etc need to respawn faster.
Still think crafting at lower levels needs a lvl xp reduction, like scale it down so novice to apprentice is quite fast then double the xp amount each artisan level or something (eg 100, 200, 400, 800, 1600 )
Mayor flying mounts should only work in their node/not in pvp zones

empty glade Feb 8, 2025, 7:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Teleporting to miraleth while doing carvans
mount rubberbanding after getting off went from sunhavrn to lionhold
right clicking to store items doesnt work reliably

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

guild perks need to be more impactful for some options it cost in glint around 470g for 1 lvl so total to get to lvl 5 might take 3k gold for 5% power is not worth it could just spend 100g per person and get that increase plus some
hunting animal shouldnt be rng pet it might kill the animal or get a mount then rng of either bob or mount. It sucks to get 5 boss mounts as bobs that are 1 speed faster than apprentice mounts
mining nodes and trees should not have static rarities like they do currently

spare arch Feb 8, 2025, 7:07 PM

#

I'm just happy to read so many people are upset at the economy breaking mechanic of static nodes. Seems like players understand how bad this is

static stream Feb 8, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fixed Rarity for Resource Nodes - This should be random so ppl don't have timers
Mount Animation freezing
Unable to see Party Members on the map unless you check and uncheck the Party Member option in the Legend

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Intrepid team is doing a great job, thank you
Add some/more apprentice and journeyman resource nodes to the dessert
Mix the type of gatherable for recipe, so either Sandstone or Slate to make a specific weapon mold (for example)

hidden parrot Feb 8, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory and storage remains a problem
Citizenship not locked per account

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Guild skill seems far from the concept shared initialy
Need a shared storage pls
What are exactly the mecanics implemented regarding freeholds ?
(Feeling that they are « locked » by few guilds)

frosty willow Feb 8, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

make the tank more attraktive again pls

sage walrus Feb 8, 2025, 7:15 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Total unrecoverable loss of caravans due to terrain glitches during conversion from raft>van or vice versa
Some nodes having issues with deleting buildings to build new stuff (miraleth on lyneth)
The bottom (purchasable) row of item storage in miraleth continues to be deleted for me, any items I stick into it are a total loss. Not sure what triggers it, but after some time of opening other storages, the items will disappear.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PLEASE make mitigation more impactful and increase TTK. TTK is insanely low and not in a fun way
Revert the tank changes, doesn't seem like anyone liked them
Change how gathering nodes rarity works. Camping legendary nodes isnt fun gameplay. Rarity should be rolled on gather and effected by modifiers provided by gear/consumes. Having predetermined nodes just feels like a really, really off design choice that doesnt lead to any fun gameplay. It's frustrating and only going to lead to people making multiple alts to park on nodes.

harsh oar Feb 8, 2025, 7:22 PM

#

My top 3 Issues for the week;

Market stall require player to pay 10% of the listing fee. If the items are listed for only 3 days, which means that if they are not sold within 15 days, you last half the value of the items by lisitng those 5-6 times.
Coal is way too scarce. Seems to pop around 1 in 100 or 200 rocks. Would prefer a separate deposit for it, just for the purpose of this testing, later can move the rock to other biome where it belongs
Befalen forge station seems do not work propperly to allow the crafts. For example, Dunzen Longbow is a carpentry recipe which can only be crafted by weapon smithing bench in the dungeon.

Feedback:

Mitigation feels like a joke with the amounts of mitigation penetration players and monsters can achieve. Caravan driver with over 95-96% mitigation can die in seconds. Fixing that should also help to make pvp more healthy as it would increase time to kill.
As of Desert Biome update, Weeping Willow and Braidwood seems to be much more rare.
Still cant use mix and match the materials in processing, this makes that less fun

autumn charm Feb 8, 2025, 7:23 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mobs being invulnerable and ignore everything.
While switching between melee/ranged weapon and toggling auto-attack in combat, sometimes you get stuck with the ranged weapon but it doesn't let you attack, it just does the "startup" animation for the ranged attacks but doesn't complete the attack. The only way to work around this is by using a melee ability which lets you auto attack as long as you stay in melee.
When you log out and then back in while in a party, it sometimes shows that you aren't in a party even though you are, and you can't interact with the party interface.
The "your cargo in this node disappears if you click on Lionhold in the cargo tab" bug.
items that gathering bags aren't targeted for get put in gathering bags instead of the sanctus resource bag even when both have room.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Processing artisan skills should have a slider for how much of a certain material one wants to process instead of a drop-down menu.
Caravans being stuck on very small ledges is VERY annoying.
Forsaken Blades Firestarters in Steel Bloom deal a little too much damage for their level imo.
Server Performance during Node Wars is quite bad atm.
a smaller, general purpose resource bag should be purchasable from vendors

undone lichen Feb 8, 2025, 7:24 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory and Storage. Regardless of how few or how many materials a person has, losing anything feels excessively draining and creates a lot of distrust in the community. Since there has been a problem with storage being wiped, now people are fearful of putting anything of value in other tabs because "it may wipe".
Echoing the previous statements about mobs being difficult and awkward AI.
Holding abilities with multiple charges can end up consuming multiple charges. For example, as a Ranger holding Scattershot, you can end up consuming both charges while only firing 1 of the 2.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Mining is excessively encumbersome with how many different materials and rarities there are. I recently got a JM pickaxe and ran x3 JM mining bags. I feel like I need another 2 bags. Instead, I think the gems (ruby/sapphire/emerald/etc... should just be 1x1. This would help to decrease the overall bag space needed, while still retaining all of its functionalities.
Redefine what archetypes mean and focus on their core features while allowing for branching features with dual archetypes. For example, the Ranger feels very bare bones ranger in a very good way. Then having something like Lightning arrow doesn't feel inline with what a ranger is, rather that feels like a ranger x mage kind of ability.
LFG TANK. LFG CLERIC. LFG TANK. LFG CLERIC. LFG TANK. LFG CLERIC. LFG TANK. LFG CLERIC. The amount of spam in global chat just trying to find either a tank or cleric pinpoints a problem in the game that tanks and clerics are a not an option but a requirement. However, people don't want to play these classes for a number of reasons. With the recent changes to tank, there are fewer tanks out there making it significantly harder to get a party formed, leading to less engagement. On the other side of that, I've witnessed an overall increasing demand for bards because there are so few clerics. In my experience, parties are running more bards to cover the need to NOT have a cleric in the party. Which speaks about yet another problem being that Bards are overloaded.
Change how resources spawn. People have pinpointed individual resources across the map as: "high valued" because they automatically spawn at higher rarities. Instead of making individual nodes have higher rarities, make the area/region/section spawn with better rarity.
survey pylons have no purpose in the game. They look like an enticing buff but there is no reason to use them considering they are so disgustingly weak, they cover a (relatively to valuable resources) small area where only 1-2 valuable resources are located, they're expensive, and it's not a fun mechanic to interact with. I've genuinely tried using them. The only thing survey pylons do is waste my gold.

wispy remnant Feb 8, 2025, 7:25 PM

#

Bugs:

Invisible Weapons
seeing Group members on map

Feedback Topics

new classes/ Gear Faster. I understand its a lot to be done for this but testing the combat PVE or PVP can change in a glimps IMO
Iteams are unbalanced to character strength and as resut of it TTK is way to high and buffs or nerves to the Archetypes will just layer problems on top since changes will be needed to be adjusted again.
PVP should have some kind of revenge system and a friendly duel system where u dont need to flag up for and not every one can join
Mobs getting pulled into farming groups to grief them should not be possible IMO

sage shadow Feb 8, 2025, 7:33 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)Resource Rarity and Resource Spawn is fixed currently for Mining/LumberJacking/Herbalism, this needs to change.
2) Shield disappearing while playing as tank.
3) Crashing Caravans on SW change areas, sometimes still being teleported to Carphin
4) Render distance and Networking issues related - but this would be mesh/server improvements as well as client side handling to be improved as well

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Grit on tank feels horrible, the internal CD is too short to use it properly, please increase to 20-30s instead of 10s.
PLEASE make mitigation more impactful and increase TTK. TTK is insanely low and not in a fun way
Give World Bosses an event area which works as the lawless zone due, World Boss are supposed to be disputed with the guilds, and therefore, PvP should be around for it.
Do not trigger events/world boss counters with the restart of the realm, use the time it was killed to have a CD (you can choose if such time would still count while the server is down/reset or not, as you did for the JM tables)
Citizenship MUST be locked per account

sleek frost Feb 8, 2025, 7:40 PM

#

Top 3-5 Important Bugs:

Resource rarity and spawn recycling
Mobs getting bugged so you can't pull them in various locations

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Tops:

Targeting through team/part/raid members. Targeting through Target should actually target the mobs that are being targeted by the target party member.
Need a quick way to respond to /whispers. (i.e. hitting 'w' to auto respond to last whisper or 'r' to "respond/reply")
Cycling through recent /whispers (i.e. tapping up arrow in chat to cycle through recent /whisper convos then able to respond to that character). Helps when you have multiple convos going.

torn nebula Feb 8, 2025, 7:43 PM

#

Inventory Management - Need a sorting button

untold raven Feb 8, 2025, 7:43 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

I cannot upgrade my caravan at all. New ones, used ones (after doing a caravan), different node, nada. No error as to why, no items will equip. I'm stuck with a basic caravan.
Several node simple quests are not completable. Lumber commissions particularly.
Lots of the UI for node (press N) doesn't work and has placeholder/error text.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

When a mayor is banned, there should be an immediate election. There are only a few nodes.
Desert still feels very placeholder.
Should be more incentive to not just group up and grind a safe spot. How about group up and beat dungeon bosses?
Crafting system - can we please be able to cancel something within a few seconds of starting and get our mats back? It sucks when you accidentally process 1 thing instead of 5 and now you don't have enough to start a batch of 5. Or can we just line up fewer than 5 (like 4) for the fuel cost and time of 5?

cunning token Feb 8, 2025, 7:44 PM

#

Feedback - 02/07/2025

Caravan defense. Have some sort or weaponry that is either manned or unmanned to help inidividuals run caravans and having some deterance for 2-3 people trying to destroy them alone.
Caravan bugs. Get rid of emberspring protection for caravans. It is being abused between Miraleth and Winstead because the embersprings are so close.
PVP. Increase TTK through general HP and mitigation buffs to armor (no nerfs).
PVE. Make mob exp grind less of a gather and AE and more of a control the adds situation, with longer lasting mez, sleep, etc. and the necessity of using them. Currently mez and sleep are just useless in PVE and there is no need for crowd control other than as an interrupt. (Also add other abilities that can be added like attack speed slow, charm, etc).

This can feed back into point 3 TTK being too quick, because with mitigation and hp buffs mobs can be buffed as well to be more deadly and have to be controlled instead of AEed.

Enchanting. Way too strong on specific items and useless on others. Any item with a stat (int, wis, str, con, dex, etc.) become too strong with enchanting compared to items that have straight phys or magic power, or other broader bonus stats. Not sure what the fix is, either buff what enchanting gives to the broad stats or nerf what it gives to the specific stats.
Guild Leveling. An EXP slider that allows people to allocate exp they get to themselves or to the guild. Would have to increase the exp requirements gradually for every point spent probably.

sleek dragon Feb 8, 2025, 7:45 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Resource rarity can not remain static for ppl to set timers and camp the rarest nodes.
Idk if it's a bug, but it has been only winter for weeks now.
Mobs get pulled through walls so there are places where you can not use half your kit because you will pull the other room through the wall.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Rolling on items should be somehow controlled. As a member of a not so active guild I mostly pug. It is frustrating and almost impossible to get a decent piece of gear when ppl need on whatever looks shiny, with reasons like: I have a ranger friend, I am a cleric but I need dex etc. Last night a rare physical longbow was needed by 3 mages because they were fiends of a fighter.
There has to be a way to get rid of ppl asking for tax to let you farm in peace. If you don't pay them they keep griefing by pulling the entire place on your tank. They are not flagged, so you can not kill them unless you get Corrupt. So you either pay, or not farm.
In my opinion solo leveling experience needs to be revisited. You can not always rely on finding a decent group of ppl to play with to have an enjoyable experience.
Performance issue in places la Carph. There are specific places where game always freezes for a few seconds or even crashes.
I just started a new Cleric, the kit feels very good so far. As a person who has healed for over 10y I am really missing the option to mouseover the frames without actually targeting the friendly. Also, as a healer I can argue that it is very useful for my frames to be consistent: difference between Raid Frames and Party Frame is very big(maybe enable an option to always use raid frame layout), add an order to members Tank>Heal>DPS or sth.
Message too long so I stop here 🙂

dusky ravine Feb 8, 2025, 7:50 PM

#

5 Most Important Feedback Topics (for me):

Resource respawning -- Needs to be random times and locations.
Cleric class needs a spirit/mana refresh/replenishment similar to the Bard but more direct/powerful. This could EASILY be implemented (if not now) then when secondary classes come out... Cleric/Cleric (High Priest) should have (needs to have) this one their skill tree.
Quest lines that may be accomplished solo and give decent XP. I realize group play is encouraged, however, we need this for progression outside of groups.
On the character selection screen -- ability to see the character progression bar would be a positive QoL issue.
Communal Restoration fails to work in a Raid config as it only affects members in your group -- please make this Raid wide.

quaint ember Feb 8, 2025, 7:51 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Node Buff persistence - Every time the server is brought down, we lose node buffs earned via mayoral commissions. This has resulted in many wasted commissions, and lack of being able to take advantage of the buffs.
Send To Warehouse - This feature has never worked, and would solve a lot of processing issues due to the current inventory system
Overall performance in large scale pvp suffers - Skill lag is insane during node war last night. I would cast Field of Vines and it would not appear where I originally clicked and would take 3-5 seconds to appear at all.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

During Node Wars/Large Scale PVP, current target indicators are very difficult to see in a sea of red names.
Hunting Rarity is insanely inefficient. Over 500 rarity seems to make little to no difference than no rarity on a sample size of 1000 gathers
Static rarity on gatherables (trees, mines, herbs) makes it a race to find the legendaries, and then setting an alarm every ~4 hours to camp it out. This makes rarity rating on every other gathering profession a moot point anyways.

lofty creek Feb 8, 2025, 7:52 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mob Aggro: Show a bar how much Aggro someone has
Ranger: Ranger AOE spell which can be used 2x buggs often and consumes 2 charges for 1. cast
PVP: Add 50-75% PvP Deff to everyone so the TTK isnt to high. Right now its nearly like in the wild west. Who shoots first wins the fight
Caravan: People have to tag first and have a countdown of 5sec (visible for everyone) so you have time to prepare

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Account Storage: Please add account storage. Its just annoying finding a stranger to give items to my alt.
Marketplace: Global Marketplace would be much better imo. Its annoying since there are to less people actively playing
Marketplace: Category atleast, to find stuff easier. It shouldnt show the lowest to highest price but atleast easier search instead of praying and hoping to find stuff
Guild: Guild storage would be a game changer too!
Guild: Guild quests, so you can level up your Guild with all members together (for example: Kill 1000 human, animals or what ever)

night fog Feb 8, 2025, 7:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)mounts locking up constantly
2)UI configuration changing spontaneously on log in
3)floating megalith in riverlands

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

please make an option to turn off tool tips for hot bar buttons
2)give Cleric another offensive ability for pvp sake
leash distance on desert mobs way too long

stone goblet Feb 8, 2025, 7:59 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Ranger abilities which cause you to move quickly, such as disengage, often cause characters to freeze and/or lag in midair, and fall well short of where their momentum should have carried them.
Camouflage does not always work, and will often leave your character completely visible (though their nameplate is hidden, and they have to be very close to be able to target)
Some of the waterways have gaps where the water texture shows on the surface, but it does not extend all the way to the floor of the river/pond/lake/etc... While I enjoy the underwater views without fear of drowning, it is still an important bug to report.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Thank you for fixing the bug that caused helm items to not show on my character.
I would appreciate more buildings with explorable (and possibly interactable) interiors in order to help facilitate roleplay activities.
Guild alliances with a shared chat would be very helpful, not just for the larger guilds, but also the smaller guilds which may seek to form a larger group by coming together and having a place in-game to coordinate.

sharp cape Feb 8, 2025, 8:02 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Hunting Rarity is completely broken or not working correctly.
Respawn protection allows the ability to attack a caravan and still keep the protection for a period allowing uncontested killing
Carphin teleport bug

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK is far too low and will only get worse as people progress.
Tank update makes the class feel absolute despair. Revert changes to Grit. Re-work Con as I feel it's the worst stats, it doesn't give enough HP and should possibly add mitigation as well. Allow a tank to build the classes main stat and have an effect. All tanks play like fighters currently as everyone gets 1-3 shot.
Healer nerfs also need to be reverted or improved on. With TTK this low, it makes healinga meme. Soon it will just be Bards, Mages and Rangers as the optimal group
Camoflauge is laughable
Tank pull needs to actually work. A giga pull where you can mass pull people on a large cooldown would also help make the class more relevant outside on leveling in PvE

sturdy lagoon Feb 8, 2025, 8:04 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Higher rarity availability of hunting materials due to Hunting nodes only spawning at common starting rarity (fat/hide especially)
Node Buffs being wiped on server restart - This is making it very difficult to maintain any node buffs on EU due to the timings of restarts/hotfix patches
Bear Carcasses are very hard to get due to the drop rate being 20% of hunting drops.
Mayor Herb/Lumber commissions are currently unable to be completed as you are unable to hand the materials at the mayor depot chest.
Tank grapple is very flaky.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

All materials required from hunting are significantly lower supply than all other material sources. Higher rarity resources especially.
Processing should work like crafting. Allowing us to mix rarities while processing would make overcoming some of the the supply shortfalls in the economy less bad (hunting mats).
Weeping Willow availibity is far too low. There are very few spawns, even less so when you remove the spawns inside the world mesh that are unharvestable. Willow is required for a huge amounts of the Artisan systems and is in very short supply especially in higher rarities.
Offensive stats (str/int) are scaling far better than defensive stats (con/resists) and player health. This is leading to TTK being way too low and will only continue to get worse as Player gear level slowly increases.
Tanks are not tanky enough in PVP. We have 0 damage but our defensives are also not great either. We should be tanky with lots of CC but currently in PVP we just get one shot the same as anyone else.
The game is based around a player crafted economy. There is FAR too much artisan crafted gear on vendors. This is hopefully just for testing, but it invalidates a lot of the main game loops when you can buy, artisan clothes, bags, enchanting scrolls, gear on vendors for very little gold.

swift juniper Feb 8, 2025, 8:07 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

LOS in healing changes targets vs. cancels cast, wasting a potentially longer CD
Caravan and server worker transitions leading to teleportation or just frozen game

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Rarity spawns and camping nodes.
Named mobs also just being sat constantly for drops. Possibly increasing spawn positions or randomize timer.
PVE heals are cake, maybe even stupid ez. PVP heals in the current meta is relatively poor with booty-blasting 1-2 shots. Defiant does it's job but possibly a bubble on the character vs a HoT that (stops death but they die anyways when death prevented). Think like bubble from WoW paladin. Debuff from it and possibly longer CD on defiant light. Make it stronger but more punishing if used incorrectly. Right now, it's just a nice HoT.
Hi. AoE purge/purify or instacast purify? Even have two specs from communal restoration (since it's party wide). One spec gives you HoT, one spec gives you a 3-tick(2sec ea') purify buff on all party members.
sliderrrrrrr for processing and mix-n-match rarities. This might allow for better 'quality rating' clothing to be beneficial
6)thx

pearl lotus Feb 8, 2025, 8:08 PM

#

Its not a bug (which is what should be focused on) but something REALLY FUCKING ANNOYING is why am I being aggro'd and my time wasted by mobs im 1-2 shotting? Shouldnt there be an intimidation factor towards lower mobs the higher lvl you get? This game is supposed to be HUGE in terms of size so this is already going to be time consuming but this aspect makes gathering or traveling VERY INEFFICIENT and VASTLY FRUSTRATING and ultimately a waste of time to an extent. This is an issue I would like to see fixed once more pressing matters have been focused on.

dapper citrus Feb 8, 2025, 8:09 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

need a clear delineation of where lawless/lawfull areas are. it is verrrry easy to accidentally stumble into lawless as it is not marked in the world or on the map. now that the automatic flagging takes an eon to drop off, it is very easy for players to accidentally put themselves into a position to be slaughtered whilst gathering, etc. also, i have a verrry fast mount, and sometimes the autoflag hasnt fallen off by the time i reach a town after leaving lawless--the sentries will of course kill people who are flagged :)) a warning as we approach a town might be helpful? and pls put something on the maps to show us where lawless starts and ends :))
bugs with wearing crafting clothing. currently the enhanced crafting clothing can have a negative effect on the crafts that we are making instead of having a buff effect. it reminds me of when healers were killing people we were trying to heal. the same thing is happening to our crafting projects.
there still arent any vendor clothes available for apprentice tailoring. please give us vendor clothes like all the other crafters have!! :))
like others have said, the bugged spawn points are super frustrating. trees/flowers/animals stuck in rocks, etc.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

intrepid
kicks
ass!!!!

solemn lion Feb 8, 2025, 8:09 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

my mining pylons werent working or didnt have noticeable effect
npcs and players getting caught in terrain. I was in the eastern node near oakenbain and theres a path I would take to get back to town to repair or vendor and climbing the rocks with the horse is horrendous. the geometry doesnt match whats actually on the screen. super jank. additionally, while i was mining, I would constantly ship my pants when a bear comes out of the mountain face or a minotaur appears from under the ground. scary.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I dont really pvp but I was killed for the first time by another player recently; they looted my glint and stuff. When I returned to kill them, they dropped nothing. Not sure if they traded it to their party members who didnt flag but it didnt make sense.
the stats in the character tab dont make a lot of sense to me; I was trying out the ranger and the long bow the other day and theres lots of penetration that I can get access to but I wasnt seeing much of a difference in my DPS. It would be nice to indicate if a mob/humanoid/etc is armored or do the frogs a have 'tough skin' or something that makes them susceptible to burn? idk having some buff indicator that gives a "armored" or "unarmoured" or "tough skin" tag so we can more easily identify mob weaknesses or strengths would be cool.
realm crashes or network lag is really annoying but i imagine that will get better with time. there also seems to be an issue when I alt tab sometimes it locks me out of making actions other than casting spells; I cant hit a menu or interact. I can just alt tab again to fix it but its weird nontheless

tight reef Feb 8, 2025, 8:09 PM

#

FEEDBACK:

In game communcation. If servers are coming down this should be announced in game. Someone logging in should be notified

fleet plover Feb 8, 2025, 8:09 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory issues and its management
Some characters seem to be burying themselves down into the ground when they run
Resource collection commissions

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Bard nerf feels so bad. I began dealing more DPS with my auto attacks than through skills
The low-level economy seems busted; copper turned from a scarce material to useless material for instance. Additionally, we lack a reoccurring need for other low-level resources, hence, new people entering the economy have a demand
As a JM miner and herbalist (soon with JM sickle), I'm drowning in resource qualities and their management and I'm lacking space for it

steel spear Feb 8, 2025, 8:12 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

ARTISAN TOOLS: add slots for previously used tools (1 per level such as Novice, Apprentice, et cetera) and retain the tool in an unequippable slot when you upgrade. When a person decides to demote their gathering skill, it could then revert to the appropriate tool for that level and not 'break' your artisan tool. It is unreasonable to upgrade from a high quality Apprentice tool to any journeyman and lose access to lower quality tools even after demoting. There should be a limit to a number of times you can regain access to a lower tool to prevent bouncing between the two masteries.

brazen cloak Feb 8, 2025, 8:16 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)Inventory bugs persist. items disappear, look to be duplicated at times, never show up when picked up/gaathered, etc. logging out fixes.
2)party bugs persist. from beiong able to see both raid/party interfaces at the same time, to not being able to do anything party related(chat, leave, convert to raid, etc)
3)gathering nodes conitinue to spawn inside rocks/terrain making them impossible to gather

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

resources need to be randomised, both for spawn points, to chance at rarity. the current system allows for too many timers, and spawn camping as certain nodes almost ALWAYS yield high rarity. every resource should have a chance to spawn everywhere in the world, and proc high rarity. this issue is currentyly hyper exacerbated due to the vast majority of players being forced into too small of an area.... super fun gameplay running around for hours and seeing none of the gatherables you are trying to find.
2)fix it so cc abilities do not work against non-flagged players!
hunting rarity is busted in that it does not exist. after thousands of gatherings, i have found 1 heroic carcass, and i have heard from other hunters that their experiences are the same. this hugelky negitelvy impacts crafting due to the inability to get high rarity hides/fat/bones/scales.

novel flint Feb 8, 2025, 8:22 PM

#

Most Important Bugs:

Fixed/predictable rarity on resource nodes. Huge problem for short and long-term integrity of testing environment.
Many scrolls just don't work (INT/DEX scrolls, Second Chance Enchantment scrolls, etc.). Would love to be able to test more Scribing but they simply don't do anything.

Most Important Feedback Topics:

As a lot of people start to reach end-game/level 25, there's far less actual PvP happening than expected. Almost no node wars happening, and open world PvP is largely limited to caravans with the current Flagging meta. (Caravans are so boring, personally hate that we have to do this to find PvP.) Would love to see more incentive (or less disincentives) for nodes to go to war and fight, etc. so we can test and enjoy more large scale stuff. When they only thing to do at endgame is fight other players and there aren't that many fights, you start to lose testers until the "next big thing" patches. This will keep people playing longer.
Consider putting bosses/resources on more random timers or base them on area activity so people can't simply camp things with logged out alts or have groups rolling from timer to timer and not interacting with the rest of the game/environment.
Defensive stats have diminishing returns while offensive stats do not, leading to a huge delta in Power vs. Defense/Mitigation. Give us more incentive to build interesting specs and experiment with mitigation/defense/evastion/etc. by having them not be bad!

dusk quarry Feb 8, 2025, 8:23 PM

#

Feedback - 02/07/2025

if we are expected to play for 50ish days 4-6hours a day to hit max level (50) the PVE experience will need a lot of work. If the grind stays in its current state of being boring and repetitive on release doing this for 200-300 hours for ONE character will kill the game.

halcyon drift Feb 8, 2025, 8:25 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Make cursor more visible and/or customizable
Make AOE abilities have more visible and/or customizable targeting circle
Would love the ability to have more chat features to @ people and invite folks from chat
It's a little annoying that if I'm currently set to a specific chat but use the / command for a different chat type that it switches to that new chat. For example if I'm currently set to "party chat" and I whisper someone, I don't want my chat to swap to whisper chat. Maybe make this a toggle feature?
Make it less likely to accidentally leave party when right clicking on myself. I have accidentally left group multiple times when trying to place AOE abilities.

topaz river Feb 8, 2025, 9:04 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Resource nodes aren't randomized
Self-explanatory, mineral and lumber resources need to not be predictable rarities to farm on spawn timers. This is well known, of course, but it's also the highest priority for me.
Headpieces remove hair
Cosmetic, I know. But It's so tiring to see every spellcaster go bald when they wear those bone helmets. Hair clipping through parts of these crown type helmets is totally fine, especially at this stage of the game. Totally preferrable to going bald.
Some enemies (notably the Scarab Hatchlings in the desert) pursue mounted players far beyond leash ranges.
I've seen these damned bugs skitter all the way to Lionhold in some cases, sometimes they disengage, othertimes they pursue endlessly until killed. I'm not sure why these monsters do it specifically, but I suspect it's due to their attack patterns having an ability right at the top of the chain.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The marketplace auto-switching to materials tab if no items are present.
This makes it incredibly tedious to scan through the marketplace for items, rather than materials. I'm constantly having to switch the tabs back on each store to check if they have both materials or items. I don't understand why this change was implemented, or why this wasn't also implemented for the reverse.
If I click on a store with no items, it throws me to the material tab. But if I click on a store with no materials, it just stays on the materials tab.
Just let me scroll through the stores on the tab that I want to view. Don't auto-switch me to a different one that I have no interest in looking at right now. Ugghhhh >:(
Dwarves look fantastic!
One of the best renditions I've seen in a game. They feel very grounded and heavy. They give great LotR vibes for their styling. Can't wait to see the islander dwarves!
AoEs can be hard to see
Low-graphic settings, or busy terrain can obscure important AoE abilities. They can be vital elements of a fight and should be easily visible.

sharp current Feb 8, 2025, 9:18 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

As a healer, raid frames are much easier to use to heal allies. However, any time someone leaves or joins the party the raid frames disappear. You have to go back into the HUD interface for them to reappear. This is incredibly frustrating and oftentimes happens mid combat, so it's even more difficult to navigate to the HUD interface.
Adjustments to hitting "F" to gather nodes numerous times before it actually registers. Sometimes it registers instantly, other times you have to move your character and adjust to make it work.
Your UI needs to stay if you make adjustments and log out. Raid frames reset locations every time you log out.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

There needs to be a better way to play solo. I know it's an MMORPG and grouping matters, but sometimes I have limited time to play and don't have time to find a group, get grouped up, then begin to farm. That can take too long (and sometimes playing solo is fun). And with fewer people at the lower levels, it's increasingly difficult to find players to group with. Either more soloable farm areas need to exist and/or commissions/quests need to be more rewarding. Unless I want to gather/craft, I feel like I need at least an hour or more to play if I want to log into the game.
Some QoL with crafting would be appreciated. It should take time and effort, that much should not change. However, why do I need to click on my fuel for every single craft? In the crafting UI, I'd like to see a number next to an item if I can craft a certain quantity of it. A sound queue when something completes would be ideal as well.
I know more music is coming, but having more than 1 soundtrack play would be fantastic. Also, there is no music in villages right now which is unfortunate. I know this is coming, but it's something I notice every time I play.

dark mango Feb 8, 2025, 9:25 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fix treasure map. for some reasons unbale to right click treasure map. and i think its something to do firs time i used and i didn't finish it. i delete q and its stuck in bedground. maybe?

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)
2)
3)

frigid shadow Feb 8, 2025, 9:32 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Let us craft a dynamic number; an input field to do any value from 1-250. This would significantly help storage issues and simply playability.

hidden veldt Feb 8, 2025, 10:49 PM

#

The random seed for gatherables (mining, trees, etc) does not get reset until the server reboots. If you mine something and it is legendary, you can start a timer for 2 hours and come back and mine it again to get legendary. This means if you log in a bit later in the day, everybody has all the high quality items timed and if you try to casually gather things as you explore you will only get low quality items. This is severely impacting the economy, the gear balance, and gathering. This needs to be fixed as soon as possible.
The larger guilds are exploiting the fact that if you use both a Guild War and a Node War at the same time, you can have some members that only some defenders can attack against. If Node A declared war on Node B, then has the mayor's guild declares a guild war on one of the defending guilds they can have attackers that most of the defenders cannot attack. This ends up with healers and supports being targeted by attackers that half the defenders physically cannot protect them from.

proper flint Feb 8, 2025, 10:56 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The random seed for gatherables (mining, trees, etc) does not get reset until the server reboots. If you mine something and it is legendary, you can start a timer for 2 hours and come back and mine it again to get legendary. This means if you log in a bit later in the day, everybody has all the high quality items timed and if you try to casually gather things as you explore you will only get low quality items. This is severely impacting the economy, the gear balance, and gathering. This needs to be fixed as soon as possible.
"Out of event" healers/supports for caravans and wars are killing the events and making where players feel their only options are exploit or lose. You should not be able to cast helpful spells (heals, buffs, etc) on someone unless you are also in the event.
The larger guilds are exploiting the fact that if you use both a Guild War and a Node War at the same time, you can have some members that only some defenders can attack against. If Node A declared war on Node B, then has the mayor's guild declares a guild war on one of the defending guilds they can have attackers can most of the defenders cannot attack. This ends up with healers and supports being targeted by attackers that half the defenders physically cannot protect them from.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The random seed for gatherables (mining, trees, etc) does not get reset until the server reboots. If you mine something and it is legendary, you can start a timer for 2 hours and come back and mine it again to get legendary. This means if you log in a bit later in the day, everybody has all the high quality items timed and if you try to casually gather things as you explore you will only get low quality items. This is severely impacting the economy, the gear balance, and gathering. This needs to be fixed as soon as possible.
The bard rework was very good. Bard feels a lot better to play.
Cleric heals feel too big. When my judgement crits I can heal for 6,700 which is enough to take any take in the game from 1% to 100%, and you can instant-cast it with Divine infusion. I think time-to-kill is way too fast, and healing is way too big; so HP amounts should stay the same but all healing and damage should be reduced by a fair bit.
Half of my inventory is 5 artisan shirts, 5 artisan pants, and a few artisan belts. Please let me equip multiple at once and only apply the relevant ones, or something.

rancid latch Feb 8, 2025, 11:24 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The random seed for gatherables (mining, trees, etc) does not get reset until the server reboots. If you mine something and it is legendary, you can start a timer for 2 hours and come back and mine it again to get legendary. This means if you log in a bit later in the day, everybody has all the high quality items timed and if you try to casually gather things as you explore you will only get low quality items. This is severely impacting the economy, the gear balance, and gathering. This needs to be fixed as soon as possible.
"Out of event" healers/supports for caravans and wars are killing the events and making where players feel their only options are exploit or lose. You should not be able to cast helpful spells (heals, buffs, etc) on someone unless you are also in the event.
As a healer, raid frames are much easier to use to heal allies. However, any time someone leaves or joins the party the raid frames disappear. You have to go back into the HUD interface for them to reappear. This is incredibly frustrating and oftentimes happens mid combat, so it's even more difficult to navigate to the HUD interface.

Feedback:

Resource nodes aren't randomized
Self-explanatory, mineral and lumber resources need to not be predictable rarities to farm on spawn timers. This is well known, of course, but it's also the highest priority for me.
Consider putting bosses/resources on more random timers or base them on area activity so people can't simply camp things with logged out alts or have groups rolling from timer to timer and not interacting with the rest of the game/environment.
Defensive stats have diminishing returns while offensive stats do not, leading to a huge delta in Power vs. Defense/Mitigation. Give us more incentive to build interesting specs and experiment with mitigation/defense/evastion/etc. by having them not be bad!

brittle pewter Feb 9, 2025, 12:17 AM

#

Top 3 most important bugs:

rarity rating on artisans tools are broken
higher rarity tools are pointless
camping nodes with specific rarity/spawn times

storm shell Feb 9, 2025, 1:06 AM

#

Important feedback

Please Make the best resources to farm be in pvp zones, it would be way more entertaining to fight for mounts or cool dungeons than getting trained or spamming f (as in the case for getting mounts) - by making things harder to get it gives players a reason to log on and compete

Please make a board where people can post for mercenary groups in game, would be a nice way to see what kinda content people are looking for help with

Make respawn rates for rare resources higher in PVP zones (maybe even increased rarirty) so more people are farming that area and adds content

tiny osprey Feb 9, 2025, 1:29 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mayoral quests unable to be completed
Character graphics very twitchy
It takes 1000 carcasses to go from Novice to Apprentice for tanning, hunting doesn't even come close to accommodating that it takes weeks to gain them and no rares above blue happening at all.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Again , a very real issue with toxic players in chat and really bad names for characters
For a social game it doesn't promote that at all anymore. People are more interested in killing others and taking their stuff or trying to threaten or talk down to others so that they can have the other persons spot for camping. I do think that people play games to be able to escape reality for a little awhile and there is way to much of "real life" nonsense going on the game. If you want a social game it might be a good idea to promote working together rather than it is ok to do "murder & mayhem".
Need a shared banking/guild banking to be able to exchange thins between characters easier. Also, Animal Husbandry amounts for training need to be lowered if you can't chose if you want to make a mount or beast of burden.

opal basin Feb 9, 2025, 1:34 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

carphin curse is still on, you can still get teleported to Carphin's emberspring if you run a caravan. chance is lower than before so definitely some bugs are being squished, keep at it
Freehold: no matter the quality planted you will still get all common output - we tested in different freeholds and all of them yielded common only resources no matter the input (tried both trees and flowers of different kind)
hunting rarity does not work which affect all the professions that needs it + makes hunting the least profitable out of all gathering professions.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

resources respawns being fixed makes a few put down a timer and just go and grab them. Some specific points in the map have resources that will always drop legendary which should not be the case
hunting: needs a rework on how you get the animals. Once you reach journeyman you have people camping the few mobs that have a chance to drop the rare animal. this should not be the case, only a hunter should be able to do so at the right level (possibly in the future by having a specific item only a hunter can craft). Also animals should be randomized in the map, people are just camping spots on timers while it should be random places in the map to avoid datamining. As a hunter i feel 0 rewards having achieved a journeyman
Remove the 50% chance for animal husbandry, this should not be the case for an animal husbandrist that reached journeyman; it feels amatourish at best. Make it instead the expert can choose the outcome - maybe increase the cost if the player is trying to craft a mount and lower it if it's for a bob?
pvp in general seems a waste of time unless you farmed your way to super end gear game. Would be nice to see some balancing done in the future around that, especially for caravan runs. On this note caravan runs should have more balancing:
-- defenders should get a reward for their efforts
-- attackers = defenders numbers

mental laurel Feb 9, 2025, 2:20 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Game client can crash right after launching.
Frequent in game screen freezes and poor performance, seems winter related. Started to happen after desert patch.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK is too fast.
Need more open world PvP objectives to fight over. Good call to arms content.
Game is amazing, thanks for all the hard work!

hidden meteor Feb 9, 2025, 2:34 AM

#

Most Important Bugs:

My weapon switches from ranged to melee when I didn't press the button. Still happens and is really annoying. I play a Ranger btw.

Most Important Feedback Topics:

Static Resource Rarity! The biggest issue facing the economy and also makes profession clothing/tools useless to an extent. Please make the resource node random and make it so the rarity is based off of your profession stats. Not pre-determined as it is right now.
Please reconsider the Guild Talent tree to not increase guild members from a talent point. Let guilds be the size they want to be from Day 1 but limit how many talent points they can use depending on how big the guild is. This is a big deal imo and should just let guild be the size they want to be.
Please look at consumables on vendors. Looking at Cooks and Alchemists here. The fact people are getting common food consumables and selling them in other node marketplaces seems wrong to me. My suggestion is to get rid of the profession consumables from vendors all together and make people go to the profession people instead.

sick prawn Feb 9, 2025, 3:23 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)mobs disappear into the sunset
2)mobs mesh with walls
3)w/e expoilts people have used to get best stuff and max level overnight i keep hearing about ban or fix them...

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)node war pvp should not have anyone not participating in the war allowed to heal people while out of combat. was in a new Aela war yesterday and they had a full 100 man it looked like on top of at least 20 dedicated healers not even apart of the war and couldnt be killed but where able to safely heal the attackers without issue...
2)as a mage with my shatter damage that cut in damage we got recently i feel was excessive. i get the thing for pvp being alot of damage, so why not have pvp calculated damage and pve calculated damage? its alot i know but cutting certain skills across the board just because its powerful in on doesnt maje sense to me :/
3)while i love the treasure maps and how much ore it gives its kinda killing the copper market from the ppl who activly farm and i feel like treasure chest maps should be more rare maybe not much, and ore should be halved and focus more on recipes for diffrent types of gear and various other types of ingrediants or recipes, i want it to feel like i found this magnificent thing and i got something good for the work. i just watch a YT video of a guy who bought 20 maps and made 20g, they where common.... which to use farmers dont seem right why make anything if i can just buy maps and get it with little effort?

harsh oar Feb 9, 2025, 3:42 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

"Tripped" abilities not correctly applying to a mob. I use trip as an interrupt. If I think the big powerful spell got interrupted but it turns out that actually it didn't work, I die. This could be me missing the attack? But if that's the case, I have no indication that I missed it.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The Grit change completely changed the vibes of tanking in a bad way. I am a huge tank fan, I've been playing a tank since 1999 Everquest launch. I play a tank in every game I play. I can't stand the Grit change. It's legitimately not fun.
a) Grit no longer being an aura. All other classes have indefinite buffs for self and group. Please let tanks have the same.
b) Mitigation is the fundamental difference between Tanks and non-Tanks. It should be a given that we simply have a mindset we can swap into before battle to harden ourselves, AKA: a toggled permanent self buff. Needing to press a skill every 10 seconds at the detriment of my other skills feels bad.
c) I felt less able to use my other active mitigation skills because I was constantly checking my buff counter, and chugging through courage to keep the stupid buff up. This does not feel good.
d) This doesn't make me feel more like a tank. I feel like a caster who needs to constantly keep myself buffed.
e) A 10s duration means I will have to press it every 10 seconds. My hands hurt.
f) We now no longer have innate threat gen? oof.
Tanks feel like they have no class identity. I don't ever feel like a "tank" unless I'm actively grouping. My survivability solo is terrible. I don't feel strong, I don't feel powerful, I don't feel like I can take more damage than other classes because I do so little damage that by the time I've killed a mob I've taken far more damage than a DPS would have.
Please change the class name away from Tank. I'm not always tanking. Other classes can "tank", but they're not Tanks. It's awkward.

scenic flax Feb 9, 2025, 4:20 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Disappearing inventory
Items delete from slot rather than inventory item (If I move an item to prompt delete, and swap another item into the spot, the new item gets deleted)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Rarity disparity between hunting and other gathering professions makes artisanship frustrating.
Guild leveling through glint as a primary source feels really bad.
Having no guild storage tools makes coordinating at a Logistics level extremely frustrating

faint elbow Feb 9, 2025, 4:37 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Chain Lightning skill doesn't proc SHOCK charges

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

"Ongoing" processing list (or something). What is ready to CLAIM at which NODE. I dont want to do my own spreadsheet for this 🥲
My friend list keeps getting "wiped" 😦

carmine chasm Feb 9, 2025, 5:22 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

make all gatherable resource spawns dynamic otherwise people will set timers and youll have problems with gathering / gold sellers camping static spawns on alts etc as they do already.
with wearing rarity clothing, rarity food buffs and tools it doesn't seem to work at all.
mitigation (physical and magical ) for fighter doesn't seem to work at all. Currently fighter and tank in group pvp are the first people targeted and killed. Fighters and tanks should have great survive-ability and feared and they should be at the front of the fight. they shouldn't have to stand in the back of the crowd and shoot with a bow just in order to stay alive. Fighter needs a skill to give full momentum similar to tanks have a skill the can use for full courage. the cooldowns for both skills should be on a 30 second timer. Fighters and tanks shouldnt be able to be killed in three shots from any class in pvp. both fighter and tank need more cc breaks and mobility skills. 4) need a guild bank desperately with tons of storage. currently we have to make alts, shuffle stuff around and its a pain in the ass. Expand storage for players as well. 5) Guild leader activity commissions that have guildies participate in oder to gain guild xp and glint for the guild. 6) Guild tools in game to see which guild persons has gathering or crafting skills. 8) this is an even number which is why ill stop here 9) The npc economy is screwing the player crafting. you can buy excavation kits cheaper than they can be made. Same with scrolls for scribes, cheaper to buy them from the vendor.

oblique robin Feb 9, 2025, 6:46 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)
2)
3)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)
2)
3)

fluid linden Feb 9, 2025, 7:48 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Invisible Mobs : either they are under the ground or straight up invisible, I've died a lot to that.
Mounts being stuck in a static position doesn't affect gameplay but its very annoying.
animations have been either doubling up or lagging ( Ranger scattershot )

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics: I have a lot more feedback than bugs.

Some mobs need there damage dialed back like the Grems, why is a level 10 nearly 4 tapping my level 20 mage in medium armor. And the Rot hounds, they attack way too fast and if 2 get on you, unless your a cleric you are essentially doomed.
Respawn rates on mobs in POI's need to be dialed back a lot, currently the meta is walk into Sephilion, Steel Bloom, Carphin, choose a spot and exp grind for hours. and its mainly possible due to how fast things respawn.
On the topic of Mobs and POI's Bosses need to be clearer that they are a boss, also make it more rewarding to actually kill a boss, the named semi boss or main boss i don't know, we killed her after 30 mins or less and all she dropped was a crafting recipe, I'm not saying drop Legendary tier armor I'm saying let her drop either a guaranteed armor or weapon ( any in the loot pool ) and or give us a ton of exp for doing it as its not rewarding killing any Boss or semi boss in a dungeon or Open world like Atticus the bear.
Classes need more skills ( which might be the subclasses? maybe? ) but at this moment in the testing period every class can take everyone of there abilities and roughly 7 passives at level 25, there's no real option to be for example a pure Fire Mage where all i do is burn and my ignite can stack higher than 25 or something. there needs to be more tough decisions in the skills.
speaking of skills and weapons, Bow is too strong, doesn't matter what class you are, a 2 handed bow will also be better than the other ranged items. I'll more than likely get so much hate for this but it needs to be said, everyone has a bow. even my mage after leveling the wand, a 2 handed bow was better stated. also the trees are very linear, I'm sure more is on its way but i would like a bit more forced direction like for wand let me be able to "enhance" my fire magic so my fire is stronger or my ice is stronger or allow all of my attacks to be beams combined or even allow for a "build up or charge " where i can shoot 1 big ball, its just all small stats that don't really have an effect, both swords 1 and 2 handed have the same tree. which doesn't seem right to me, i also feel like the skills tree should have like actual skills in the tree instead of stats ( for weapons ) Like for wand have a repel/ push back or have a volley similar to arcane missile ( i wouldn't add more than 3 - 5 for your main hand weapon )
This may be added later on I'm unsure, but we need more reasons to explore other POI's like Grave peak and the Stone pillars, there's no reason to go there at any point so a lot of content is just being missed ( again I'm assuming quests are going to fix this but at this current point its only the big 3 Seph, Bloom and Carphin )
I feel there should be a gold cap on a lot of items and crafted items, there's a lot of forced item meta prices going on and as much as its an open P v X game allowing someone to sell a mount for 50 gold or more is unreal.
my 8th and final as its a lot, Mounts should not have a set mount speed, every crafted mount should have a varying speed based on player skill and resources used to " help " the mount grow. otherwise end game its just going to be the same as it has in the test the maxed trainers are going to just find the hunting mounts train them and sell them and eventually everyone will have the " fastest mount in the game" and it would lose its charm. If it depended on skill ( a mini game ) and resources and still have the RNG it would be great to see a standard horse out run a Gryphon or a Raptor ( cap speed at 350% or something )

GG though

whole trout Feb 9, 2025, 8:16 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

NERF enchanting - it gives way too much power to the gear and this is impacting TTK heavily. My offered solution would be to make enchants only grant armor/magic resist, damage only on weapons, hp or mana regen on jewelry (and enchant should be euqal to about 1% increase on that item per enchant level), This way enchanting still has a meaning as fully enchanted person will definitely be stronger against non enchanted person, but it won't be 3x power difference. And it will push TTK to the opposite direction allowing better expression of skill and longer battles. This will also make level 20 gear useful as enchanted lvl 10 will not instantly outscale lvl20 grear.
Gathering node spawns MUST be fully random. Also please don't allow T1/T2 materials respawn as T3 which are impossible to gather as it creates scarcity of said nodes - if someone gathers Tin ore somewhere in the node, make that tin node respawn somewhere else within the node after random timer at random quality- this way overall amount of specific gathering nodes remains the same.
Keep up the good work! Playing since launch of A2 it's great to see the constant improvements and iterations to the systems. Thank you!

P.S. I know Cleric stuff is not that important... But it is important to me and seems like it should be easy fixes 😄

late coral Feb 9, 2025, 9:41 AM

#

Regarding Time To Kill PVP, instead of making changes to enchants and the like, just script in a new damage value system for PVP only to reduce damage by a given percentage and keep it separated from the PVE damage system. it will be a lot easier to balance and save work hours trying to balance that scale than to have to keep rebalancing all aspects of the game.

candid pollen Feb 9, 2025, 10:44 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

unfarmble nodes
pathing issues on npc

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Fix node rarety issues
implement a beter gathering-node place system
Very worried about 2nd class implementing meaning tank/clr for every class, keep the trinty.

pearl schooner Feb 9, 2025, 11:19 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Sometimes I damage mobs or players but there is a BIG delay between the damage and the reduction of the health bar (and it is not my internet connection, it happens regularly).
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The area of big events such as World Bosses (Firebrand, Tumok) should be a PvP zone. Right now it is impossible to have proper fights there. Not sure if I have good solutions but it could be like caravans (e.g. "Do you want to take part in the Firebrand event?"). So nobody is forced to PvP if they bypass.

quick heart Feb 9, 2025, 11:19 AM

#

Top Issue: Death Penalties Are Overly Punishing
The current death mechanics are excessively harsh, making the experience frustrating rather than challenging.

Every death results in multiple penalties, including:

XP Loss (XP Debt) – Progress is set back significantly, making leveling feel like an uphill battle.
Stat Dampening – A direct performance hit, making recovery even harder.
Resource Loss – Losing gathered materials or loot adds to the frustration.
Durability Damage – Forces additional time and money spent on repairs.
Time Wasted Running Back – The 1-minute loot protection timer is too short; by the time I return, someone who looted my items (often after mob-training me intentionally) is already unattackable due to anti-PVP mechanics.
This system does not respect the player’s time. I have been stuck at level 18 for weeks because the sheer punishment of dying makes me actively avoid leveling. Today, I spent 14 hours grinding from level 19 to 20, and it was one of the worst experiences I've had in 15 years of playing MMOs.

The leveling loop is miserable:

Endless downtime – Hours spent looking for groups, waiting for replacements, and searching for tanks (which are currently unplayable due to poor class design).
Group wipes due to minor mistakes – A single mistimed skill or mob train can set an entire party back massively.
Tanks suffer the most – Since tanks naturally take the most damage, they die 3x more often but receive no passive to reduce XP debt.

Proposed Fix:
Choose one primary penalty for death, not all of them.

Durability loss and running back are already punishing enough.
If resource loss is kept, remove XP debt.
If XP debt stays, remove stat dampening and resource loss.
Right now, every single system stacks against the player. This is not fun, not rewarding, and actively discourages engagement. Please reconsider how death penalties are handled.

pine sinew Feb 9, 2025, 1:04 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans teleporting you to carphin
UI issues, especially no being able to see debufs on the UI
Armor not having an armor class set bonus

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Poison / anti heal is not a fun mechanic and there is no counter play when it's being applied on every hit. Add diminishing returns
Intelligence and Strength are massively OP. Make them give 1 power rating.
Increase window for named mobs / gatherables to spawn 10/100x. Stop logging in on timers mechanics.
Remove food from vendors it kills the entire profesion. Or increase the prices 10/100x.
Make people who die in pvp respawn at home shrine and add big cd on changing home shrines.

dusty moat Feb 9, 2025, 1:45 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1)Caravan Has multiple bugs like teleporting the player as well as sinking in water.
2)Some enemy/mob spawns glitch them out where they can't be damaged / damage isn't kept on a enemy/mob when you are still in render distance and then runs back to it's stationary position
3)After a few deaths notices that the XP debt will not be taken away or used up when you get XP nor increases your level without a relog in some cases.
(Haven't found out what causes any of these for replication)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)Allow summoned mounts health and status bar be next to your character health automatically like the caravans have. As well as allow it to be repositioned with the HUD editor.
2)Have the professions be easier to know what professions chain into what through an in game NPC so people can know what professions are going to be more useful for them.
3)Allow more access to personal locations for guilds. Whether it be through an instanced location or a Node that is designed not to be run by players but an NPC for the sole purpose of base renting for guilds.

cold kindle Feb 9, 2025, 3:25 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

action camera mode improvement
movement physics. the ability to use skills or dodge accelaration makes for unbalanced and more ranged focused gameplay. most obvious example is mages blink.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

action camera mode improvement
random gatherable spawns
ttk adjustments: i think that for a pvx game the numbers for dmg and healing need to be balanced around pvp/8v8 and then those changes need to translate into pve ttk/balance. the early endgame of archeage was a good example for that imo.

weary sun Feb 9, 2025, 3:59 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

spawns need randomness and timers or you get gameplay that is a negative feedback loop (only sign on for one minute to harvest good tree or only join big pug raid because small guild group cannot obtain boss). Randomness and spawn activity meters (just copy paste the placeholder system for oathbearers for example, for bosses and harvestables)
enchanting change is a solution to a different problem than Ttk. Low ttk is occurring because of stat scaling imbalance. Specifically, offensive stats scale better than defensive stats. Mitigation is nearly impossible to get over 60%. Power scales indefinitely. That’s your problem. The enchanting system only interacts with that problem because people choose to enchant offense. Nerfing the impact of enchanting is a very bad idea because it is the only system keeping testers around and represents a future endgame system. Make defense scale equivalently to offense and move enchanting from flat change to percent change.
another contributor to how simple character build is: waterfall stats on gear. Int is such an easy chase because it gives you base power + pen + accuracy. I’d rather have all gear have more stat lines but not those six waterfall.

oblique coyote Feb 9, 2025, 4:44 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

War forced home town respawn. Players in dungeon groups are forced to run all the way from their hometown if they die when their node happens to be at war. Ruins group play. No warning of this.
NPC un-lootable bodies. You can view the body and see your Glint, but you're unable to loot. Hop on/off mount to fix or relog. Can't Hop on/off mount in tiny rooms.
Party UI Disappearing after relog. Toggle raid on/off to fix.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Grit as a Toggle was preferable to Grit as a maintained ability.
Did Courage give physical protection before as the meter filled? Believe that was better, rewarded more patient tank gameplay rather than spamming abilities. It trains players to hold onto abilities until necessary, or predicting the fight. Rather than emptying their resource and cd immediately to max dps.
Mana Maintenance and Refreshing Reflect. Mana seems to be in a good place. It's difficult to maintain for prolonged periods, but if you have Refreshing Reflect, then you're able to maintain almost constant up time. Rewards skilled gameplay, and doesn't require that much skill neither.
Tanks need better damage mitigation or self heals. They should be able to hold 3-4 enemies of their current level and cleave to win. Right now dps classes are able to burn down packs of targets and get good xp over time. Sit and heal etc. Tanks take forever, which is fair, but they should instead be able to cleave more targets so that they achieve similar solo xp farming to a dps single target farming. If a dps can solo 3 targets in x time, then a tank should be able to solo cleave 3 targets in relatively the same time. The difference is the tank would sit in the targets more or less and soak the damage instead of having to dance out and evade constantly.

knotty dagger Feb 9, 2025, 4:50 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

No indicator when using cleric chains (I never know if I clicked it or not) - a click state or a placement circle would be nice solutions.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Can we get some pre-login or post-login warnings about wars? Something that says Node X is at war against Node Y. It sure would be nice to get a heads up before logging into my death.
Grit should be a toggle and I don't even play a tank. Now it's more work for the healer if the tank forgets to click Grit. I don't need more work.
Droppings are needed for all low-level farming. Droppings should be harvestable. Why would a farmer kill? It seems out of character to make farmers have to go out and kill for their trade. Make a clickable on the ground. That's how droppings would be found logically in my opinion.

vapid coyote Feb 9, 2025, 4:56 PM

#

Bug just noticed. Tattoos are not removing from character models in character creator and are instead copying to other presets

somber laurel Feb 9, 2025, 5:09 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan crashes. I think I crashed 7 times today and others in our caravan crashed 2-4 times. It seems to happen more often if there are more caravans in a raid, which is too bad because it can be fun group content. Appreciate that you have ways to recover the caravans.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Can we get a Guild Commodity Vender in the Tropics please. Guild leveling events are great for teams to bond over. This could lead to more pvp and more content in general!
TTK - but sounds like this is about to be addressed - hopefully without impacting PvE too much and focused on PvP.

Appreciate all the hard work. The game is coming along quickly!

frigid orchid Feb 9, 2025, 7:16 PM

#

I only have one not sure if it’s a bug or intended.
-when casting intimidating aura on tank sometimes it causes a long period of animation where the tank moves extremely slow while holding his arms out in the animation and other times it’s fluid and doesn’t go into slow motion. Seems like I run into this more if I cast it from a sprint

gleaming field Feb 9, 2025, 7:46 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Treasure maps are still bugged for some people to a point where you can't even interact with the "restored treasure map" to start the quest.

lunar frigate Feb 10, 2025, 12:13 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 2/07/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Server worker boundaries: these cause a lot of desyncing and bugs
Ranger stealth not proccing and bow being visible
Mount gliding and losing animation

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Time to kill is too fast with high phys/magic power
Caravan defense is not rewarded
Make pvp flagging rewarded with better drop rates or xp

molten zinc Feb 10, 2025, 1:32 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fix anvil in forge, so ancient bows can be crafted
Miss my road buffs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1)
2)
3)

tranquil aurora Feb 10, 2025, 2:23 AM

#

Top 2Most Important Bugs:

1. Archetype Ranger: Ability Party Stride: When applying to other people, looking away and looking back at the people the animation AND SOUND is playing every time. this is louder than many other sounds and is so bad at times that people get mad at you if you use that ability
1. Crafting Scribe: you can not specify for wich area you want to craft the Treasure Maps, this feels strange, on top of that the Novice maps give higher tiered resources so Apprentice and Journeyman, this feels either like a Placeholder or a bug. Please clarify if it is a placeholder or bug publicly

#Weekly Feedback Request - 02/07/2025

Bug:

Feedback:

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Top 2Most Important Bugs:

Top 4 Most Important Feedback Topics: