unborn ginkgo Jan 20, 2025, 6:45 PM

#

Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Please share your top 3-5 most critical issues or feedback topics in the thread below using the following format:

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

To keep the thread organized, we kindly ask that you avoid back-and-forth discussions, and stick to the format above for your posts. We'll be closing the thread at <t:1737482400:F>

Important Note: While we greatly value your insights, please understand that we cannot guarantee all bugs or feedback topics will be addressed, or provide a specific timeframe for fixes.

Thank you for your continued support, feedback, and dedication to improving the Alpha Two experience! flamingphoenix

unborn ginkgo Jan 20, 2025, 6:45 PM

#

unborn ginkgo Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers! ```Please share your top 3-5 most critic...

sonic kite Jan 20, 2025, 6:49 PM

#

first

rancid jolt Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

Second

ashen lion Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

third

deep cypress Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans being immune once rider rezzes
Bards are bugged, they are broken in all PVP aspects, please fix
Gatherables - A lot of gatherables (Willows in particular) are not gatherable please fix these locations

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Would like a small change to the flagging system for attacker/defender. Please let it be done for an entire raid group/party so that we don't have to constantly drop party to attack or defend. Still love the Caravan events, not sure I like them ending with people crowbarring the content. This is a great event to keep going, maybe remove crowbar or make it like a 1 minute cast that can be interrupted and flags you for pvp?
Not a huge fan of the lightning ball change, it completely makes the skill a waste of time in PVE and PVP. Maybe another adjustment is what is needed here.
Hunting rarity is still a crapshoot, I'd love to see some changes made to that. It's a big bottleneck for servers and guilds.

meager rain Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bard's one shot with wand finisher
Caravan Invulnerability on driver respawn
Ability to crowbar and heal out of the caravan event
Invisible/ friendly enemy npcs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravan event clarity; Names of whoever's caravan it is in the event pop up, having to walk on top of the caravan to select attacker and drop party, etc.
PVP on caravans in the water feel super bad/ hitboxes feel weird for the caravan and movement abilities bug out or don't work
Majority of caravans ran are only in groups of 40+ making it risk free and boring, should give you less gold when you defend/ are with multiple caravans or smth like that
======================

rare spire Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans: Being able to kill the driver is a terrible change, getting sent back to carfin while driving (happens a LOT), rng caravan's just being undeployable.
Raids bricking, randomly you just stop having the ability to invite to raid, frames don't update and you're constantly having to reform raids during Guild wars and events.
Target markers not always updating, STILL cannot mark map and have others in party/raid see the mark. Constantly having to hit the filter or scroll in to see where my raid is on the map is also just so annoying lol

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

FIGHTER IS USELESS IN MEDIUM TO LARGE SCALE PVP: Right now HP doesn't scale enough on fighter and mages are just always getting buffed. Tanks with fighter gear are doing more dmg than fighters, have 10x more up time & mitigation along with more kill potential. Your TANK is a better fighter and mage is the only class that gets any sort of attention. This is already turning into a KR MMO where melee is just never viable because EVERYONE else can do way more dmg while never having to be in someone's face.
#alpha-two-vyra-us message this is your tank change history.... your tanks abilities (chain pull) has NEVER worked since pre-a2 yet the only updates you've given is "visual effects updated!" We don't need visual changes on abilities when the abilities themselves never work....
Its 2025, I should not have to spam /invite <name> 42 TIMES TO FILL MY RAID HOLY REEEEEEEEEEEEEE PLEASE add a "Invite guild to raid" button like in AA, let people right click names in chat or right click party leads to "request invite".

rapid zinc Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan event bug where you cannot select attack/defend on an active caravan.
Having to drop party/raid to accept a caravan event. This is a massive pain in the ass.
Guild War type bug -- Make Guild Wars require the correct type of scroll for the event desired.
Out of event healing/buffs - This is being abused very heavily.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Server performance needs to be better - Carphin/Steel Bloom is still a shit show. Tick rates in busy locations are unacceptable and enemies move erratically client side due to latency. Same root cause likely for caravan teleportations and other wonky behavior.
Static resource spawning has to go. This is preventing a meaningful test environment for the economy - and this meta of camping high tier resource nodes is very off-putting.
Make attacking a caravan more risky, currently it's pure profit with nearly 0 risk. I'm starting to convert to the "make people flag/go corrupt" camp.
Reduce the corruption penalties or make an iterim step where you can murder a player every now and then without going red. Maybe force combatant for a long time(hour+) with multiple murders in a time window causing you to go red?
Improve the artisan situation. apprentice should be baseline in nodes (lvl 10 for citizenship anyway!), first building should be journeyman. This will largely fix the massive gap in artisan <-> character progression.

mortal valley Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Healing out of event. Healers are abusing this so much
2.Tank Protection ability force flagging people trying to corruption baiting people
3.Caravans flagging, caravan Tping to carphin still a thing. Caravan system really needs some love
4.Hunting has problems with rarity

brittle drum Jan 20, 2025, 6:52 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans Teleporting you to the other side of the map.
The amount of crashes during big fights even at 20v20 is asinine
Crafting Rarity increase for 5% from a node buff does not work/ not added to the crafting equation
Out of caravan raid healing should auto flag that healer as a defender
Having to drop a 50 man raid to pick up attacker/or defender on a caravan to get back into a raid
Tank placing buff on something else while not flagged and that thing getting killed corrupting the player attacking.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Static Timers on resource nodes
World Bosses Camped at static locations for server resets and better dropping for groups that aren't the main zerge that logs out there
3.a. Crafting after the multiplicative to additive change needs rework. A legendary Novice items should at least = a rare or heroic low roll apprentice.
3.b. An apprentice legendary should = a Journeyman rare or heroic low roll item. The stat squish from P1 was needed, just not in the way it was implemented.
Crafting a novice weapon at uncommon rarity sells to vendor for 64c when the craft is 60c. An apprentice weapon crafts at 12s but uncommon sells for 3ish silver to vendor. Even rare apprentice crafts sell for roughly 5s back to a vendor making it impossible to do large batch crafts to level the skill reliably
======================

Remember to leave thread in the right hand corner once completed

heavy bronze Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

.

manic geode Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

.

tulip obsidian Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rubberbanding
Inventory doesn't update. You have to log out and in for it to update
Hunting pylon shows mining nodes instead of doing anything with hunting

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

When you gather a 'new' legendary tree you have to wait exactly 4 hours for it to pop back up in the exact same place and rarity. you can repeat this process for 24 hours until the tree is depleted. This makes the gameplay that you have to scout for rare trees at night so you can camp them during the day. This results in normal players not finding any rare trees at all. This applies for mining and herbing professions as well but with different times. A fix could be that a tree is depleted after 1 time of chopping the tree down or that if it respawns in a different location
Flying mounts are too OP for gathering and scouting, in the wiki it says flying mounts can only be mounted at royal stables. Since we don't have royal stables a good fix for now is that royal mounts can only be mounted at the home node.
Let us make carcasses from huntable mobs / mounts. Bears/wolves/otters become useless after a month. make them have a purpose.
======================

hushed ruin Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Harvesting artisan gear rarity increase not working
Guild wars being exploitable with no cooldown
Inventory desyncing

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resource nodes rarity being set on server spin up instead of being randomized when the node is harvested
World bosses spawning on server restart instead of having a window in which they can spawn
Items and materials not being searchable on the market
======================

alpine crescent Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory not updating - requiring 15 second logout.
Position desyncing while mounted. Dismounting sends you back to where the server thinks you should be.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

War declarations - Currently feels like it is being used to instantly kill smaller groups and avoid corruption. A delay before the war starts would be most helpful.
Gathering - Communication about the current status of how things are working might help testers provide better feedback. A lot of complaints seem to be due to misinformation. (Example: Iron nodes blocking copper)
Economy - Gold/Items are constantly entering the economy but there is very little leaving. Inflation and new players feeling "left behind" might drive away some potential long term testers.
======================

wise turret Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Most Important Bugs:

Steelboom Performance -Anecdotally, I notice hardly any groups grind here as opposed to RoS (for levels below 20), due to the performance issues that this PoI has.
Fixed Resource Rarity & Timers - Resource nodes have a fixed rarity, and allow people to set up timers to come back to specific resource nodes if that node produces high rarity materials.

Most Important Feedback Topics:

Solo Progression Avenues - How are new players likely to progress if they are unable to find low level groups. This can cause the feeling of being softlocked. This issue might also become exacerbated when Rogue releases, and 50% of the low level players are all rogues.
Death Penalty On Tanks - With Tanks dying so often, there are long term economic implications for those who are playing Tanks. They will earn significantly less glint, and therefore gold during their playtime.

hallow cargo Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Dwarf Jumping is the WORST BACKFLIP BARREL ROLL

pale sentinel Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Fix out of caravan healing. :^)

soft shale Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Healing from outside of Caravan Events, Node and Guild Wars.
Journal Not Saving Tracked / Untracked after logout
Lighting issues in-door areas (Forge and Carphin)
Party Markers in Mini-map and world Map not updating.
Rarity Gear, Artisan Gear, Tools. Actually do something and work as intended. Static Node Spawns suck

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Having to leave group to chose attacker/defender (let party leader choose) and give menu option to not allow party/raid to opt you in.
Fixed Static Rarity spawning.

======================

exotic leaf Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

give me rogue

weak tulip Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Error code 32, 33, 34
Raidframes need to start showing debuffs and more healer QoL
Updating later

winter geyser Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Node rarity being static for 24 hours without a way to discover already gathered node location funnels wealth into specific people. This needs to be addressed. Node rarity should not be static for 24 hours, this is throwing off the economy terribly.
Raidframes need serious work. They do not show out of range correctly. It would be nice to show when someone is being targetted. Showing buff/debuff icons you can interact with would also be nice, but range is super important.
Buffing/Healing/Supporting outside of sanctioned PvP Events.
Inventory de-sync issues
Bosses need to be on variable timers so they are more difficult to iron down farming routes. This includes world bosses like Tumok/Firebrand.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Node rarity should be toned down, but Artisan stats should be tuned up. Right now gathering feelsl like a casino and your artisan level means very little.
Tree spawns need similar tuning to mining nodes.
Hunting rarity is gatekeeping 50% of the crafting game and making it hard to give proper balance feedback on gear. In general, I feel like fleshing out what you have more instead of adding newer content like Class Archetypes is the right direction. Get Nodes more fleshed out, flesh out gathering/crafting for Novice-Jman, flesh out the PvP systems more, Freeholds, etc. Then once you have a strong base, expand out.

hallow cargo Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

FIX DWARF FLIPPING

tiny hill Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

.

ornate rose Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory issues with items not visually moving, items not appearing right away when collected, etc.
Caravan stability and clarity
Out of event healing/buffing (i.e. caravan events)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Have the caravan event popup show the caravan owner's name to better differentiate between caravans events.
Make gathering nodes truly random every time instead of the same thing spawning in constant intervals. Improve hunting rarity so truly top level gear is obtainable in the future.
Add arachnophobia mode
Change rarity gathering stat so it has more impact on the gameplay experience. Currently, it feels useless.
Adjust freeholds so that individuals can't buy and sit on them without ever using them.

meager rain Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

@deep cypress

rigid totem Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Enveus/Polar healing out of party/event
Enveus/Polar rezzing out of party/event
Enveus/Polar corruption baiting with tank protect out of party/event

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Node rarity and timer shouldn't be static
Caravan events attacker/defender should be selectable while in party or the party lead can set everyone
Tank grapple should work
======================

rain galleon Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

.

languid igloo Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025

Clerics/All Buffs, giving heals/resurrection/buffs, out of raid/party for all pvp events
Clerics/All Buffs, giving heals/resurrection/buffs, out of raid/party for all pvp events
Clerics/All Buffs, giving heals/resurrection/buffs, out of raid/party for all pvp events
Riding my mount for 10 minutes, getting off it and being teliported back to 10 mins ago

lavish sandal Jan 20, 2025, 6:53 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Buffing and healing out of party or event
2.Buffing and healing out of party or event
3.Buffing and healing out of party or event

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.Buffing and healing out of party or event
2.Buffing and healing out of party or event
3.I want Rogue

silent fox Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans glitching / vanishing etc
Resource nodes you can't interact with due to terrain / desync. Those "invincible" weeping willows that you can still chop on, but nothing happens are the worst :C
Inventory / storage bugs drag and dropping massive amounts of loot, especially when it doesn't stack the same way is .... bad.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Affecting (caravan) PvP without being flagged / joining defence or offence

======================

wicked mauve Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory/Stash Bug
Mount Translation/Teleport Bug
Caravans

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Ban the exploiters
Improve node code
Hang out with the dogs

wide orchid Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory desync is still an issue and can get daunting having to relog so often
Similarly, The caravans are still teleporting people -- between this and #1, they both feel like server boundary issues
Rarity across hunting and other gathering items seems like it is not working as intended?
Inability to leave a caravan event

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Being able to heal someone without being a part of the event should not be allowed. Too often people are leaving healers out of caravan events and you cannot attack them without flagging up.
I genuinely cannot tell if the rarity has been nerfed to all oblivion or if it is just not working correctly. It would be awesome to get more transparency around this. It feels too difficult compared to other gathering professions to get higher rarity carcasses. Additionally, because of how little anyone is getting higher rarity items with gathering, the sentiment I often hear is that people should ignore the rarity or upgrading it and just get the base of whatever tool since rarity doesn't work,
I think that the zoi for the event should be tied to where the caravan is. People are leaving caravans up (not turning them in) just to be able to freely attack others in towns; I.e. having a caravan in halcyon and then attacking someone in new aela with no way for someone to leave the event and for the person abusing it to have no consequences

zinc siren Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans disappearing randomly

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

stark narwhal Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fix Caravan bug where you get teleported to Carphin randomly
Randomly flagging up on rangers and tanks when you attack them without being flagged up
Fix cows and chickens planting on freeholds

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please add animal corpse rarities
Please add coal
Improve freehold functionality
Make cooking cheaper
======================

small charm Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

1: Caravan-bugs.
2: Moving items from inventory into storage, not showing correct visual of where material/items are.
3: Copper, Zinc being extremely hard to come by. Probably other resourses too. and the need to have so much of it to get weaponsmithing/armorsmithing to lvl 10 when the ressourses is so scarce.
4: Boss respawns tweak.

vague crater Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory glitching - needing to mount or relog
Set Rarity for certain spawns of Resources
Items being lost in trades during lagspike or DC

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Need more ways to level up
Fairer XP to Gatherers/Crafters
Doing a great job!

fervent canyon Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

automatically unmount when entering a town area
being able to hide mount but still have the speed bonus applied
skeletons should follow at least basic anatomic knowledge and should not be able to "rib toss" more ribs out of themselves than possible (that would be not more than 24, if you count them as pairs...)

glad wave Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory looting issues, looting most of everything and not ALL of it
Corpse materials not dropping from EVERY mob that can be hunted (Otters)
Fix Caravan bug where you get teleported to Carphin randomly

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Bard DPS 1v1 dps output - Bard oneshot should NOT be a thing
Rarity of nodes always being in the same spot - Leggy tin ore always spawns in Z spot on map - Leads to less organic gathering
Filters for finding objects at Market
More roles for Guild Leadership (Officers who can wardec)
======================

reef stump Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Firebrand resetting after flying out of its own range and bugging on terrain mid fight
Visual distance showing incorrect trees either there or not there
Node wars/Guild wars not having the "formation period" and people without warning are getting killed the moment the war is triggered.
Still often not seeing players/caravans load in until they are practically on top of me with cinematic view distance on. Making PVP less enjoyable as a scout.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Continued improvement on higher/lower tier nodes needed. Cities unable to advance due to extremely hard to find resources needed for comps.
Enjoying the direction on guilds hopefully expanding or smaller specialized guilds.
Want to see more info on deep sea fishing and naval ships. Will it have a new artisan skill or fall under carpentry? or have a carpentry specialization?

knotty fern Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bugged Resource Nodes
Inventory Issue making it so you have to relog
Friends list bug

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resource Spawns / Locations and timing
Improve guild capabilites within a node
Improved XP from Gathering / Commisions of a node

willow bobcat Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

storage and inventory issues with inventory not updating and bricking my game. had to restart and repair
getting stuck in a mount while dismounting
small hitbox from weeping willow
constant freezes that leads to crashes. then 32 33 34 error into an empty character screen
being rolled back position wise when dismounting mount or caravan, and crashing

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

qol changes in crafting in general
buff ranger so we can hold our ground better on small scale pvp and 1v1s. add a defensive skill
changing caravan flag when accidentally choosing the wrong side, either leave and join again as the other side
either let party lead choose side in caravan pvp or let us choose side while in party/raid
dont count down force pvp flag when in combat to prevent corruption baiting
======================

tough olive Jan 20, 2025, 6:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Issues - not updating - having to mount/dismount or relog to show updates

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Lack of information available regarding how various mechanics work, should work, or will work in the future on the economic/crafting side of things.
Are the artisan tools/equipment rating factors working as intended?
Is the current hunting rarity working as intended? It is extremely rare to get a quality carcass/animal above rare. If so, does this mean the rarity ratings for mining/logging are wrong and too high at the moment?
======================

solid anvil Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Loss of all inventory in extra bank tab when citizenship is lost and then regained. I paid taxes 2 or 3 times and when I came back I had lost citizenship to Miraleth, as had others. And when we regained citizenship that tab came back empty.
There has been a weird bug where either Caravans don't have an event, or the Caravan becomes untargetable or indestructable once the caravan driver dies.
The weird teleport to Carphin still happens when you cross nodes with caravans. Supposedly it happens while mounted, but I've only seen it with caravans.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Most things seem alright, there are some balancing concerns, some of this would be taken care of by a slightly larger map.
All war initiations should have a 15 to 30 warning before they go live. Without the ability to build defenses, or have over powered guards, there is no way that defensive players can win a fight from a surprise position. There is no defender's advantage. And most guilds use this as an opportunity to simply grief an entire node, and tend to choose timings when they know the majority of pvpers of another guild/node are offline. This would also probably help with the "assassination" wars of some of the crafting guilds; or at least reduce the effects.
My name is FoxVulpes in game on Vyra, I deserve a Fox mount. >.> All things considered, you all still have a pretty good skeleton of a game, I enjoy playing it. There are some kinks, but I am very interested in seeing the final results at some point.

craggy lagoon Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

======================

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bug issue (need to relog or mount up to quick fix actually)
Hunter satchel which are good with living animals but not with carcass
Mobs stop to fight after some time (ashen warriors)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Filters for finding objects at sales
keep the tropics as an open pvp zone, but add some rare ressources spawn point in it to encourage pvp (like t2-t3 trees, mining, etc...), great to see some zone like this in the final game too (like abyss in DAOC, with a high reward / high risk system)
give guilds more role than recruit and guild master, and add some feature like a guild chest to share some ressources with guild mates.
======================

hardy jungle Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.
Title: Critical Shortbow Arrowstorm bug
Type: Archetype
Text: Arrowstorm passive from the shotbow tree should damage for 5% from your damage per projectile. In general way with auto attacks it is works as expected. BUT when you have arrowstorm bug and you use Barrage. Each arrowstorm projectile use damage formula from Barrage (15% projectile). It is critical because arrowsrom does x3 damage from normal. And this broken mechanic used to oneshot peoples. Video starts from 12s: https://youtu.be/KwH9pCo2n7E?t=12

Critical Boss Respawn \ NPC
Please FIX\DISABLE boss respawn after restart. You should disable this or Add 30-60 min after restart. Because depends on the patch download speed peoples can't regroup in time. Also better to increase HP poll for x10 or dynamically depends on how many peoples in fight. Because raid in 60-80 people kill boss in 1 min.

YouTube

_nda_

2025 01 17 00 32 21

▶ Play video

muted nexus Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Lvl 25 Griefers (specifically in places like HH)
We need diminishing CC in pvp
Better mob density but lower xp, slighly weeker, but more "packs".
======================

timber path Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Loot bugs where you have to relog or get on your mount to reset
Inventory to bank transfer bugs
"Escape" cancels bard melody

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Flying mounts are OP
Crafted stuff lags far behind leveling. By the time the stations are up to craft gear, most players will be long past that tier of gear.
Massive zergs imbalance the server
Willow is needed for everything
======================

proper granite Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bug
2.Map transition
rarity of hunting resource

odd gazelle Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans, I have lost so much gold to these...
Hunter gatherable rarity
Fixed rarity spawns

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please address that spawns are fixed rarity right now, it breaks gathering completely. Particularly since there's a drastic imbalance in the total amount of overall wood you require.

analog condor Jan 20, 2025, 6:55 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.node traversal stuttering bug
2.party loot issues / glint distribution requiring restart to loot
3.needing to loot after roll ( someone has already gone to the trouble to loot so why does it need to happen again )

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

fossil mason Jan 20, 2025, 6:58 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Please make it possible for us to remove the items from the quest item inventory.
Please fix the lootbug you have to restart the whole game too often to be able to loot again
the different roles, for example ‘Scroll of Adventuring’, do not work properly.

======================

potent shale Jan 20, 2025, 6:58 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Desync crossing server boundries causing potential rollback to desync point when dismounting
Bard damage stacking with resonant weapon to >9000 oneshotting any other PC

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Corpse rarity is too low compared to other gathering professions. Heroic+ drops are about 1 in 1000, even with good rarity gear
Bear corpses are too low compared to tameables when hunting (1:5ish ratio)
Everything requires bluebell or willow, the chokepoints are too choky.
======================

olive shale Jan 20, 2025, 6:58 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans just disappearing for various reasons
Not exactly a bug... but just general server performance in places like Carphin. Both me and mobs will be rubberbanding all over the place.
Hopping on my mount, travelling a long distance, hopping off my mount... and I'm tele'd bac to where I first hopped onto my mount.
Some quest objectives refuse to progress.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please let us trade Commodities with each other.
Gathering node rarities being static seems to go against the intended design.
Render distance is awful.
Corruption sucks.
Action Cam in general gets less fun the bigger the pvp fight... targeting is a huge hassle to deal with in action cam.

brisk socket Jan 20, 2025, 6:58 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Constant crashing around Joeva and water. It seems like if the servers are up for too long, crashes and lag tend to make farming mobs near impossible because of lag and/or crashes
Some enemies will hit you from yards away. Like the bears maul attack, I can be several yards away and still get hit by it.
Random Crow attacks. IDK how to report this but even once in awhile, I'll be out and about, fishing or gather and a Crow will just randomly appear. 9/10 it's below my level but it's annoying

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravans with attackers and defenders. I still believe that attackers of caravans don't get punished enough for attacking caravans as if they were in PvP. There should be a way that when attacking a caravan, you are pubished. IE, guards will attack you, NPCs will not talk to you...something. Maybe a bandit system
I still believe that there should be by products of animal handling of getting droppings.
INCREASE THE DROP RATE OF MAGIC GEAR! I will farm for hours in HH or outside of Carphin and out of like 20 pieces of gear drops, like 1...maybe 2 are magical gear but all uncommon quality.
======================

left garden Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Monster spawn locations clipping out of map and "disabling" that spawn point
Friends list inaccurate
3.Western larch adult timer seemingly off
Death and fighter's berserk sometimes exponentially increases phys damage after respawning, allowing player to deal 8-12k damage with deadly finishr but take large constant DoT

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

displaying statuses/damage numbers disappear at random. maybe make it an option?
allow user to see all buffs applied to character
allow to see stat changes from buffs vs base in character details menu
======================

noble flax Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

being in a caravan and teleporting to carphin randomly

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

the flagging system for pvp, (having the option to unflag DURING pvp is bitchmade and corruption baiting)
havesting system as is isnt great, 'this tree' always spawns as x qualty until a restart when the world is reseeded, is HORRIBLE
fish isnt used enough. more recipes plz
======================

green gulch Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

Resource respawns being more random.
Caravan bugs
Moving items in inventory

edgy gate Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.some heavy forge-gear has bad textrures

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

we need coal as a resource
armoursmithing quality rating seemingly doesn't work or too low
caravan banditry is low effort high reward
======================

surreal night Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Stuck Spots
Mob pathing can be irregular / speed included
3.Cleric spell Judgement target priority heal vs dmg with 2 window setting turned on

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Classes feel linear - Cleric / Tank imparticular - early dev state ?
Quest's need a lot of improvement , POI should be removed after completion,
Nodes have the same feel - too much simmerty and feels repetative
======================

floral otter Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Discordant note pulls everything in the world when you it should just bounce between things I'm already fighting. and not whatever group is trying to train mobs on us.
Getting stuck in combat with bard song interrupting actions.
Escape still cancels bard songs.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Remove flying mounts. These are not balanced and have no place in this game.
If Flying mounts must exist they should not be usable in open world dungeons or POI's or outside of their own cities.
Flying mounts should not be able to fly infinitely. .
======================

west wigeon Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Able to heal/buff/resurrect out of event & party (Cleric Heals, Resurrects, Tank Protects, etc.)
2. Hunting Rarity non-existent
3. Caravan Event able to be ended so that caravan is unkillable/targetable

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. Out of Event and Party Healing needs to be fixed. 
2. Corruption is over punishing.
3. Gear scaling is too strong. 
======================

thin steppe Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Improvements to the leveling experience. I know its not super crucial, but standing in one spot at a POI and grinding for hours is not engaging at all, thus I imagine it limits the number of testers that will reach 25 to test features that require a higher level.
Caravans seem hardly worth it. Risk lots and lots of money to very likely get nothing.
Crafting and gathering just feel kind of...Meh. Huge time sink, barely any exp so you are delaying your leveling substantially, and hardly any money in it.
======================

worn zodiac Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Render distance in pvp
Wars not giving rewards (especially node wars)
Fixed timers for resources / boss spawns on realm restart

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PvP-Flag timer should reset when taking damage so you don't turn green in combat
Corruption is so overtuned it is not worth to get corrupted at all
rare Resources / named drops should be contestable with PvP or moved to PvP areas. Being able to CC "Green" players should stay in the game to not have "free" gatherables

granite salmon Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Server stability in pvp. We have been patient and are all aware this is an alpha. However we cannot move forward with incoming system testing for sieges or raid vs raid when simply getting 40 players fighting in the same server worker brings network performance to a complete halt.
Caravans disappearing, stored cargo disappearing etc. This is a core gameplay loop and really all we have atm but it’s a daily bug that someone in your group will lose 20-50g in the caravan master lottery.
(Will edit later)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please remove the gear drop from level 1 corruption status as in this small environment it provides protections for players to grief you with no recourse other than risking your gear or logging out and letting them win
Increase base guild capacity to 100. This is an MMORPG and the MMO portion is being stifled in an incredibly clunky way that also leads to 5 guilds declaring or NOT declaring on you while helping each other.
Please extend the combatant state if you are currently being attacked to end the rat and cat gameplay loop of losing a fight and then running indefinitely or running into a pvp fight to bait corruption as it’s dropping.

3x the damage of Fighter's Whirlwind ability in PvP; or replace/add a talent to scale the damage as more targets are in your whirlwind. This should be your main zergbuster to split stacks up and instead it deals 90 damage with a legendary world boss weapon. The risk of playing melee in the current state of the game is simply too high to ever press this ability in a PvP encounter. This sucks with how iconic it is for the class in MMORPGs.

Thanks for all the hard work the team is doing 🙂

robust root Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

525 error bug preventing players from logging in
Crocodile Speed is too fast, making JM AH useless
Hunting rarity is bugged, making heroic+ carcasses nearly unobtainable

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

pastel forge Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

Bugs:
1 - around inventory.
2 - switching between tab and action sometimes blocks the character looking and moving only on direction.
Feedback:
1 - Time to kill is to low, its due to the all-in dmg stats meta, having constit or mentality is not a good idea, and evasion stats neither can make a build.Everyone is just going full strength or full intelligence and bursting everyone.

timber gyro Jan 20, 2025, 6:59 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Implementation of Rogue
Expansion of all class skill trees (new actives/passives -- build variety)
More Horizontal gear progression (again furthering build variety)
======================

runic fog Jan 20, 2025, 7:00 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

This game memory leaks hard
Unable to loot after playing for so long causing us to have to relog to loot each time we want to loot

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

More communication from the devs on what they want us to test
More communication on what feedback is being received/rejected
PI clearly has a wealth of information the rest of us don't have and it's clear that information is being exploited in the Alpha, please communicate with us how you plan on combating this
======================

stoic igloo Jan 20, 2025, 7:00 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Trees sometimes lack visuals when chopped down
Trees often appear unchoppable without explanation
While chopping, tree indicator of coppedness disappears when camera is moved.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Raid frames don't show important debuffs like heal immunity from Carphin thaumaturgists
A way to cancel casts without escape menu appearing or dodging is needed. Even if the cast counts as something that 'esc' can cancel by itself, a second press brings up the menu etc.
Love your faces, keep it up.
======================

outer totem Jan 20, 2025, 7:00 PM

#

Please let me sort my inventory 🙏🏻😩

sacred marsh Jan 20, 2025, 7:00 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

inventory sync - inability to see inventory correctly
Resource availability - the bottleneck on crafting seems excessive with such limited resources
Rubber banding

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resource rarity
Due to the nature and limited game space as we get to the current max level the congestion of loot and exp spots
The drastically increased risk vs reward on running cargo.
======================

slim quail Jan 20, 2025, 7:00 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Promotion/Demotion of artisan skills
Quests non-functioning for the most part
Draw distance diminished depending on population

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The development team spent a lot of time and effort rebuilding MMO PvP flagging systems and now there is Alt+F to flag, going purple, being corrupted, building up blight, etc; but those systems are very rarely used. Almost all PvP (at least on my server) is guild war, node war, or caravan PvP. It feels like this game is different PvP games that went through a merger and doesn't know its identity. I would suggest removing one (either the open world with corruption or sanctioned events) system and focusing on making one robust system, rather than two competing ones.
I am a level 23 cleric and I feel like there is nothing left on the talent that I even want. Lower levels it felt like there were multiple "builds" some people going hard into devlierance and judgment and cast heals, other people going for Soothing Glow + Defiant Light for a more HoT based build. But near the level cap, there are 25 skill points and I think 28 options so every cleric just has every skill. It is my understanding that other classes has this issue too.
3.Some artisanships, like Stonemasonry, feel extremely easily to level while others, like Metalworking, feel far more expensive and annoying to level.
======================

unique sentinel Jan 20, 2025, 7:02 PM

#

Bugs:

Some of the Guild War Events are bugged.
Node War Events are bugged. The phases are not shown propperly.

Feedback:

Give Guild Wars and Node Wars a propper Timing (coolup timer) so players can somewhat prepare even if it is only 5 - 15 minutes.

As always you are doing a great job, the systems are clearly in alpha so keep it up and fix it bit by bit 🙂

tardy ridge Jan 20, 2025, 7:03 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Material inventory occasionally freezes and cannot be used

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Clearer pathways to artisan levelling
Get rid of exploiters
Collecting metals for any processing/crafting artisan skills feels very unsatisfying due to rarity/spawn method. Perhaps randomized respawn material or more common respawn or varying respawn time ( random within range of 1 - 2 hours ) so someone can't camp all the copper
======================

Love the direction of the game, just wish it felt more worthwhile to go into artisan builds instead of scraping copper off of hundreds of granite rocks I want to mine actual copper rocks

snow abyss Jan 20, 2025, 7:03 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

healing / buffing players in events while out of events
caravans getting deleted while converting from land to water / vice versa
if someone goes flagged they should not be able to lose combatant while being attacked (aka corruption baiting)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

if someone is flagged a flagged player should not be able to go corrupt on them if they don't get a chance to attack back.
people should not be able to instantly go out of combatant when going in and out of lawless (another form of corruption baiting)
Please don't have world bosses respawn instantly on server resets.
======================

fallow skiff Jan 20, 2025, 7:03 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug making it so that moving items/transferring between storage causes "ghost items" and unusable inventory space until mounting/reloggin.
Caravan event forced participation after caravan is turned in (people are still flagged on each other)
Unharvestable nodes,

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gathering sucks right now. Rarity isn't working as intended, nodes will respawn as the same rarity for 24 hours allowing someone to camp the node on a fixed respawn and farm legendary materials all day.
4 Weeks into the game, journeyman crafting is not available ( may not be a bad thing for long term progression, but for testing it sucks). Most of us are level 20+ already. We can not test the level 20 crafts because there are no buildings for it. Additionally, the servers currently don't have enough building slots to even make a journeyman building for all crafting professions.
Caravan pvp is a struggle for everyone to get on the same team. Currently, only the party leader can flag attack/defend. Additionally the distance you have to be to flag on caravans is extremely close meaning that your attacking group can get picked off one by one while you run up, drop group and flag and then have to regroup.
======================

dark otter Jan 20, 2025, 7:03 PM

#

Top 3 bugs:

Please fix chat systems, getting rap* threats and not being able to block people sucks. Seeing people laugh about it in chat is also dumb.
Please fix the inventory bugs. They've been here since the beginning with no fix.
Please address the rarity issues in hunting. It's very frustrating to compete with so many players for 1-3 spawn locations as it is, and rarity being broken is exceptionally frustrating with how much competition for so few spawns.

Feedback

Please consider implementing better chat functionality. The chat system is frustrating, you have to put up with constant toxicity, sex talk, degrading speech from the same people, with limited bans available, no LFG channel, no trade channels, etc. you can't clean up your chat at all.
Please consider putting more spawns in for willows and some hunts, there is too much competition for freeholds, willows, etc. not enough players get to experience or test freeholds, which is exceptionally unfun in an MMO. Not having enough resources for so many players on top of that, is also not fun. Please consider instanced freeholds, as they're extremely expensive anyways to keep up which limits players heavily as is. Or consider putting far more spawns in.
Please consider limiting guilds. Currently on lyneth, the federation and their supporters are extremely toxic and disgusting in chat nonstop, and their beef is with pirates which are massive also. So when federation and their supporters are on, chat gets clogged with nonstop hateful rhetoric, slurs, sometimes rapey comments and brothel comments and sexually degrading comments, and it's frustrating and tiring to have to put up with their toxic antics when you want to see what people are selling. Please consider limiting giant guilds in their size, ability to buy up all freeholds in an area, and in one guilds and their supporters case, their toxic kind of behavior in chat, especially if we're all gonna be squished together like sardines.

versed scaffold Jan 20, 2025, 7:03 PM

#

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans getting deleted when you convert from boat to ground
Caravan tp where you get warped to Carphin and lose your entire cargo
Tank grapple doesn't work
Memory leaks

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Healing out of party/caravan event without being forced into the event makes any form of caravan testing impossible since you cant kill the enemy clerics. Its being heavily abused atm
Gear is way too strong in the game, needs another rebalance/nerf. People getting one shot makes pvp testing very difficult
If you flag up for pvp you shouldnt be able to unflag for x amount of minutes to prevent corruption baiting, make it a visible buff when they attempt to unflag and show the timer of how long they have to unflag

scarlet valve Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

top bugs:
1: inventory bugs
2: crafting rarity
3: crafting xp scrolls
4: hunting rarity
5: memory leak

feedback:
1: please add refining to gathering bag inventory stack size increase, and add a prioritization to materials so they go into their respective bags > Sanctus bag > THEN other profession bags.
2: please free up freeholds that haven't been used so people can actually test them.
3: please consider some form of instanced freeholds till the system is fully implemented so we can get better testing and to stabilize markets
4: Please give clarity on if we will get new character slots for new classes when they're released or if we will have to delete characters. (this can massively effect economies with mass amounts of players starting over on professions.)
5 please give us a way to split LFG/trades to new clear up global and make finding groups / trading a LOT easier.

drowsy sand Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

CARAVANS. Caravans are such a fundamental part of the game's core loop and currently i've lost 6 in total to various bugs all related to them vanishing and being un-summonable. I've reported it several times but one of the causes of this is converting the caravan from/to raft on a server border will delete the caravan and it cannot be fixed.
Inventory Bugs - Anyone who uses their inventory a lot has to relog numerous times per day to ensure that items are transferring correctly, to be able to trade, to be able to put items in storage, to interact correctly with crafting benches etc.
Mining resources having fixed rarity for a set amount of respawns. The meta of finding a high rarity node and having to camp it every few hours for the whole day is terrible and exploity.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

FIGHTER - Needs a large balance and utility pass. Fighters do not do enough damage, they do not contribute enough utility, and they are not durable enough. Currently fighter is by far the weakest class in large scale pvp. I personally have over 500 hours playing Fighter and have re-rolled to a dps Tank because tank can at least offer something to the fight AND can do as much damage as a fighter.
Caravan pvp is a struggle for everyone to get on the same team. Currently, only the party leader can flag attack/defend. Additionally the distance you have to be to flag on caravans is extremely close meaning that your attacking group can get picked off one by one while you run up, drop group and flag and then have to regroup. Having to leave your party, flag up as attacker, and then re-form your party is terrible.
Change world boss respawn timers to be server-restart independent. Every large guild runs to tumok spawn just to wait for restart and whoever logs in first usually gets the kill.

harsh ore Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fixed resource respawn timers with same quality - resources respawn on fixed timer with the SAME rarity they were originally spawned as. Legendaries included. People are metagaming it and making thousands of gold. People camping known spots on server restart
Processing job materials lost when building is upgraded (e.g. to journeyman)
Materials not visible in inventory after looting / cannot loot items (randomly happens, needs a relog to fix)
After caravan is delivered / the attacked / defender status remains on characters. Can't go AFK / carry resources without someone possibly attacking you with no repercusions

brazen fox Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Lag in entering Nodes ( sometimes locks up system requiring restart)
Lack of continuity in Crafting tools (hunting bows and rarity variant)

======================

pine topaz Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Dissapearing weapons / swords/ shields, books, etc
Generally most mobs are bugged in a way. They either stop fighting, they dont take any dmg at all, they run, etc.
Map feels super empty, and you just run around with no idea on what to do. I mean generally, i rather have the bugs fixed first and only then you move to fill in the map, but its super dissapointing/feels like game will never be done.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Filters for finding objects at sales
keep the tropics as an open pvp zone, but add some rare ressources spawn point in it to encourage pvp (like t2-t3 trees, mining, etc...), great to see some zone like this in the final game too (like abyss in Aion), fraction pvp zone ,etc.
I know its an alpha , but no cut scenes, nothing, feels very strange and i doubt new players will get that MMO vibe out of it... and i believe the story of Vera can be told in a much more beautiful way ....

inner brook Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug i like to stop having to restart to have a working inventory
Tree's that don't spawn in a state/location you can harvest them.
hunting and rarity the fact its impossible to find high quality hides.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

resource distribution special weeping willow with the current server pop it takes for ever to find one.
Give hunting the option to harvest a carcass of a death animal you did kill and have the huntable's only give live one's
Develop the desert and tropics more add POI's and resources to have the population spread over a larger area.

sterile egret Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans Issues (bad performance with 5+ caravans on screen / crashing the game, vanishing, teleporting you to carphin, healers healing caravans without being defenders,etc)
Speed desync issue (seem to be a speedhacking protection but you desync everytime you go a little bit faster or use a disengage ability)
Mining resources having fixed rarity for a set amount of respawns
Getting corruption on a legit kill (caravans, wars, fake purple players)
World bosses respawning with server restarts/crashes
Weapon procs stacking (it was fixed but you can still stack weapon procs by resetting your weapon skill tree)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Corruption (overpunishing causing more griefing than preventing (karma bombing and mob training), going from purple to green mid combat, flagging options on menu and not on HUD (more flagging options) and more. see all at: https://forums.ashesofcreation.com/discussion/comment/491743/#Comment_491743
The irrelevancy of the debuff system (wounds, weakened, shaken) due to the small pvp TTK (making group pvp coordination all about doing damage). Expanded: https://forums.ashesofcreation.com/discussion/63918/current-pvp-ttk-design-is-bad-for-the-game
Action cam polish (more nuanced target system and ability to lock the target in the center of the crosshair, ability to access menus in action cam, better mount action camera usage)
PvE encounter design (less static and more mobile, more constant pressure less insta kills). Expanded: https://forums.ashesofcreation.com/discussion/63848/feedback-on-pve-encounter-design
Gear progression and power creep. Expanded: https://forums.ashesofcreation.com/discussion/64606/gear-progression-and-power-creep
======================

cursive wagon Jan 20, 2025, 7:04 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rarity for Hunting is vastly worse than other forms of gathering
stability in the forest in north Sunhaven is atrocious with mob behaviour being very unpredictable and crashing being frequent.
excess resources being destroyed when trading with someone who doesn't have space for all the materials.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

attacking a caravan seems to have way too little risk. as it stands there isn't really any reason not to do it.
time to kill seems to be too fast in pvp. allowing very little time to respond for the defending side if attackers just pounce.
mob passing is currently a way to grief without suffering corruption and needs to be curbed in some way.

queen current Jan 20, 2025, 7:05 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rubberbanding

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

When you gather a 'new' legendary tree you have to wait exactly 4 hours for it to pop back up in the exact same place. you can repeat this process for 24 hours until the tree is depleted. This makes the gameplay that you have to scout for rare trees at night so you can camp them during the day. This results in normal players not finding any rare trees at all. This applies for mining and herbing professions as well but with different times. A fix could be that a tree is depleted after 1 time of chopping the tree down or that if it respawns in a different location
Flying mounts are too OP for gathering and scouting, in the wiki it says flying mounts can only be mounted at royal stables. Since we don't have royal stables a good fix for now is that royal mounts can only be mounted at the home node.
Let us make carcasses from huntable mobs / mounts. Bears/wolves/otters become useless after a month. make them have a purpose.
======================

dusk patio Jan 20, 2025, 7:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

caravan related, especially the possibility to flag yourself as defender and attacker and therefor avoiding being able to attacked yourself
finisher stacking isnt fixed its just bandaided and you can still do it, it just wont stay after relogging
material storage hud not showing the right materials if you store or sell some only fixable with logout

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

LET RAID/PARTY LEAD FLAG THE WHOLE RAID/PARTY TO ATTACK OR DEFEND CARAVANS
stability during node wars/bigger fights has to improve as its just a power point most of the time
fixed recource raretiy until reset seems weird

mental kite Jan 20, 2025, 7:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Teleporting to Carph when summoning/mounting your caravan
Training mobs should not be a thing... well until they kill their target, they should stay focused on the target
crashes, crashes, crashes.... all the freezes

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Mounts seem to have a Meta and need more diversity, i.e. the raptor can jump super high, we need certain mounts who are better in the water, climbing, accelerating, normal speed, etc
classes seem to have a meta build and need more diversity to make them differerent from others in the same class
Desert needs for everything to make it unique like tropics

sly fjord Jan 20, 2025, 7:05 PM

#

Bard damage stacking with resonant weapon
Weapon finishers and skill tree Between melee and ranged Weapons.
Healing People Doing event Without participating.

From Sense Lorthoria Eu

timid edge Jan 20, 2025, 7:05 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Having to drop party to join caravans
Having to relog when inventory stops updating (when xfering to/from storage)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Predictable gatherable respawn timer means high rarity nodes are camped on cooldown and almost impossible to find organically
Right clicking names in chat to invite etc.
Could use a "Last online" column in the guild member list. So we could purge inactive members and make room for new ones.

wheat tundra Jan 20, 2025, 7:06 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug , needing to relog or mount up
Rubber banding , Teleport back when dismounting
Mob training

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

If 1 member of a party PvP flag then the rest of the party should be PvP flag to avoid corruption baiting
Marketplace needs better search function, like be able to search for types of items like resources
War declaration / Node war declaration needs a longer prep time and noticeable notice both when activated and on log in.

untold seal Jan 20, 2025, 7:06 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Specialized node storage not working
Mages being able to apply another element to another mage

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Get rid of the processing batch sizes and let us process all at once in any available amount
There should not be fixed locations for fathers or rarities, because the rarity bonus looks like to be pointless
Add better explanation for the gathering tool bonuses. Most people assume that the speed modifier is not working, because they think that it is a constant speed increase like, f.e in Minecraft. Although it seems to be more like a crot chance that, where you sometime clear multiple ticks at a time.
Addition to 3, add a better visual indicator that a gathering crit occured
======================

forest siren Jan 20, 2025, 7:06 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bug requiring relogs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Barely any punishments for bug abusers and exploiters, the numbers were pathetic and should've had at least another zero on each of those reported. The player base isn't going to stick around for a game where people aren't playing it as intended. You've clearly stated what is considered an exploit and most of the biggest guilds have blatantly ignored that and have continued happily exploiting, with numerous videos and screenshots showcasing it. GMSteven going for walks through POIs on occasions and discovering the odd person red handed is not going to be enough to keep this a healthy and worthwhile testing environment.

======================

unique plinth Jan 20, 2025, 7:06 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

caravans becoming invulnerable/resetting when driver is in loading screen
player markers visible on map only for a brief second after enabling/disabling player markers in map options. they should be permanently visible
player markers can randomly stop showing for some party members
world boss bugging out on terrain, firebrand fly-over attack lands in places completely different to where firebrand is flying visually

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

no delay in flagging for participation for caravan attackers puts defenders at a disadvantage. repositioning, denial of access is substantially hard when unflagged attackers can come as close as they please and then quickly flag
players not flagged for caravan events can assist with the event without actually participating making counter play hard if not impossible
no visual indicator for when caravan event participants are going to unflag makes it very easy to go corrupted
======================

proven thorn Jan 20, 2025, 7:06 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan is key to the current gameplay events, it needs to be fixed as early as possible
Everything related to storage/inventory : right click sometimes doesn't work, sometimes the item is duplicated and require a relog,
Yeahh you did a great job I don't see a "3rd most important bug" ! So maybe fix some player animation/bug that require relog ?

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

server server server ! ! ! Node & massive PvP is key to the game, fixing the 100v100 node war without lag would be the best improvment to the game : Let us play the game as it should be, not a powerpoint simulation !
There is no point in defending a caravan, just push with other zerg and get a reward. This need to be adressed asap or the world will be empty soon
3.Profession are 1000x slower than player development. The "best way" to be strong is to get low lvl item (10+) and enchant them. It's a bad game design on this point that need to be adressed

junior swallow Jan 20, 2025, 7:06 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The inventory bugs!!!!!!!
Resources not being able to be harvested ( trees in the side of cliffs, resources able to go through the motions of being gathered but after the cast bar is complete nothing happens.)
Random crashes.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Game and system crashes.
The inconsistency of mob behavior (mobs being in you as opposed to them being in front of you, causing you to miss attacks.)
Random mobs appearing out of thin air.

slim quail Jan 20, 2025, 7:06 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.mobs resetting health suddenly during combat
2. fishing commission mayoral doesnt count fishes caught
3.Server worker boundary issues. snapbacks, copies

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans constantly bugging
Boss exploiting and bugging and inconsistent respawn timers (respawning on server restarts, etc)
Many artisan stats seem to not be working correctly or at all. Need some clarification as to whether what we currently have access to is too little to make a difference or if it's simply bugged
Meshes constantly bugging and rollbacking players

Despite how some of how that may have sounded, I'm thoroughly enjoying the game. It's just a few tweaks to make crafting a better space.

misty cradle Jan 20, 2025, 7:11 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The mounting (inventory closing?) sound that plays every time you change server boundary (which I did not know this was the reason) was the main reason I decided not to play as I personally find it grating and irritating when it plays.

calm lava Jan 20, 2025, 7:12 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan warps
Invisible enemies
Corruption bug (seeing uncorrupted players as corrupted)
Bard - Resonant weapon bug
Inventory and caravan bugs like items disappearing during trade or inability to equip caravan elements

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting and economy features are missing like crafting multiple copies of an item at once and guild bank
Desert, not only is there no PvE but resources cant be harvested and the nodes there just cant develop
Enchanting is OP, it needs immediate nerf, lvl 0 enchanted gear is way better than lvl 20 gear
Availibility of resources, for example: there are about 90 raptors(tops!) able to spawn for the entire 24h while whole server needs clothes made out of those
======================

near current Jan 20, 2025, 7:12 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory is still not fixed
Cannot see my shield
Treasure map quest vanishing when logging out
Winter textures buggy
Mob behavior sometimes erratic

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Slate molds too complex to build
Some resources are way too rare (willow for instance)
Many mobs seem to loot nothing - may be not tuned yet.

low kiln Jan 20, 2025, 7:12 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

GREM
GREM
GREM
GREM
GREM

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Willow balance (required amount vs availability and bugged trees)
Willow balance (required amount vs availability and bugged trees)
Willow balance (required amount vs availability and bugged trees)
Willow balance (required amount vs availability and bugged trees)
Willow balance (required amount vs availability and bugged trees)
======================

short crater Jan 20, 2025, 7:12 PM

#

=====================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

we need a better /bug, a feature where we can see our past reports and add additional info/screenshots to it. some bugs need more than one screenshot to properly describe them. or even a video
tank need some love

======================

teal ore Jan 20, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Gatherables still underground and rarities persisting on every spawn.
Caravans still disappearing, unmounting at random spots.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please implement more Freeholds. This is not allowing for people to test that system. Have a tax or something that needs to be paid frequently and if not paid freehold is up for grabs again.
Clean UIs
======================

autumn pewter Jan 20, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3 Most Important Bugs:

Some areas are too laggy (Steelbloom, Carphin,...)
Skills being canceled for no reason (Bard's dances, Tank's Reflect,...)
Node Wars event not popping up properly on Lotharia (need prime time event please)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravans may need a low profit protected route to give newer players an entry into the system. Right now it has to be bad for them.
2.You should need to be a citizen of a node for the 32 hours before voting just like how you have to wait 32 hours to re-citizen. It has to feel jarring just watching 100 people show up into a dead town to vote, and then immediately leave the node. It also allows them to dodge taxes on the large towns.

oblique marten Jan 20, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

Render distance in big fights. Makes it tough to engage in large scale pvp when you don't know what you're fighting.
Non interactive caravans, making them essentially Invincible in pvp. They also randomly go Invincible when the rider dies and respawns
Steel bloom performance. Even with nobody there, there's invisible ads that one shot you, my allies disappear etc.

solemn crown Jan 20, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory and storage bugs, particularly ones that seemingly block inventory space or make items invisible until relogging, not having the one click transfers between storage and inventory spontaneously stop working would be good.
Rubber-banding, particularly being teleported back to a previous location after dismounting.
Gatherables not disappearing when harvested. e.g. trees not falling, rocks not shattering, herbs appearing untouched. Both when end up able to be walked through and cannot be interacted with and when they appear interactable but the interaction fails.
Hitting invisible walls when walking, or riding a mount can be annoying. while being able to walk though or accidently climb into terrain is a problem.
Characters suddenly dropping from friends list, party arrows on maps disappearing, characters not appearing to be in party despite appearing to be in their menu.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Movement/terrain bugs along with invisible creeps are awful.
The terrain, landmarks, and features are beautiful.
The rarity tuning is slightly too harsh, particularly for low level crafting items e.g. those provided at novice hunter.
The difficulty of obtaining items for crafting gear is far outweighed by the ease of obtaining items that are comparable or better through combat.
The idea suggested that storage places could be destroyed arbitrarily without a means to access a secure storage location sounds like a mechanism for extreme griefing.

latent wagon Jan 20, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Your inventory will randomly bug out and cause it so you can't right-click to move things into and out of storage. It can happen multiple times while moving things in and out of your storage and is a huge pain point.
In my experience, Mining Quantity does not affect the actual quantity recovered from the mining node. It is always 2 for small and 5 for big
Mounts freezing in animation/your character going bald when transferring to a different SW

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

As a processor, there must be a way to bulk process items of different rarity. I have a ton of different rarity ore that I am waiting to process until it gets to 50 because otherwise, it is way too tedious to do hundreds of 1 or 5-minute jobs
Mining is currently a race for people to find where the current epic or legendary node spawns are and then camp them on a timer. It is very annoying since the only counter-play is to somehow magically also know where the spawn is AND when it was last mined in order to be there and contest it. It also makes me question whether Mining Rarity on gear even matters.
There needs to be more options for processers to contribute to the node. When the node needs copper ore, I am stuck deciding between helping the node or progressing my character. I think a good solution would be that if your node needs a processable item, you can also donate any processed versions of that item to contribute. (IE If a node needs copper, you can donate ore, fragments, or bars). This means I could contribute to the node's improvement without feeling like I am losing out on character progression
======================

glacial flax Jan 20, 2025, 7:13 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.rubberbanding while traveling / teleporting when dismounting / lag spikes in town
2. continued issues with inventory / not being to loot
3. unable to lower taxes through town quests/mayoral commissions

heavy mason Jan 20, 2025, 7:14 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bard Song issues with songs turning off when hitting the ESC key.
Bard Song stopping mount summons
Caravans disappearing and the recall button not working.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Groups should be able to join caravans as a party rather than needing to drop to join

======================

winged wigeon Jan 20, 2025, 7:14 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mob train/leashing AI is still kind of weird.
Loot bug where you stop being able to take items from corpses to your inventory (requires relog).
Loot bug where enemies simply stop dropping loot for your character (requires relog).

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PVP flag on looting player corpses is way too short, and typically expires faster than it takes a player to run back to where they died. I'd recommend extending this to 10-15 minutes as there's really nothing that disincentives robbing people right now.
UI enhancements for party and raid frames, so that we can track the buffs that we add to players (cleric/mage weapon blessings) or more quickly identify debuffs that can be dispelled.
======================

meager widget Jan 20, 2025, 7:14 PM

#

Invisible mobs on map which can attack you. (seems like it happens more in Sunhaven "shardling beach", near Azmaran border)

sterile socket Jan 20, 2025, 7:14 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug where you may gather something and it doesn't show up until you relog, or being unable to loot items.
Being teleported to carphin while running a caravan.
Heals not critting, ever.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Having to pick up loot after winning need/greed. The action of looting has already happened. I understand the goal is to incentivize pvp for drops, but the extra time from winning roll to pick up the item is 5 seconds at most, the system doesn't fulfill that intended role and only serves to waste time/annoy players. The potential gain of enjoyment is heavily outweighed by the annoyance and makes the game less fun.
Please let us select an exact amount of items to process, as well as use materials of different rarities in processing like we can do with crafting.
Ability to search by item in marketplace, not by store.
LFG channel or function like group finder in WOW. General chat is a dumpster fire.
Currently, you can only craft apprentice and up items in specific nodes which deincentivizes guilds/friends from making a node a common home. I believe making it to where all nodes can utilize crafting stations of all levels, but have the node upgrade buildings provide large buffs to specific artisan paths. For example, you can tame animals anywhere, but a node with the building upgrade can be 50% cheaper and or have a time reduction. This solution gives players a choice and feels more impactful as a "dedicated" node towards a specific profession.
Add more events. New Aela, and the western side of the map in general seemingly has no events, while areas around miraleth are chock full of them. Having random events, like say caravan ambush, pop up around the map would make the game feel more alive and fun.
======================

desert nymph Jan 20, 2025, 7:14 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug (not correctly displaying unless I get on/off mount or log out/in)
Getting stuck while on a mount and you can't dismount to use the unstuck option.
Friends list

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Would be nice if the corruption penalty for looting (or for stunning/mesmerizing you while to get the item you were harvesting). The 60 seconds that it lasts now isn't enough time to feel bad for what you did, nor does it give the victim enough time to get help/reinforcements.
Items (including mounts) need to deteriorate to keep trade skills viable. If I can keep my item/mount forever, why would I ever need to buy another - thus killing the trade skill
If you get resurrected, the loss penalty should be zero (or a lot less). Also, it would be nice to be able to resurrect people after release. Drive by surprise resurrections that save the run back are glorious!
======================

split sedge Jan 20, 2025, 7:15 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Storage bug, that you need to log off for
Not being able to pick up loot, until you need to relog
Curses Flamestorkers teleporting into the walls

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

People having spreadsheets and timers to go and get 'legendary willows' etc should absolutely not be possible. nothing of any actual gameplay comes even close to generating this much gold.
2.chopping for dozens of hours knowing that 99% of what you get will be useless is unfun game design.
being practically forced to get crafted gear to be in anyway competitive is of putting.

languid pelican Jan 20, 2025, 7:15 PM

#

latent wagon ====================== Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025 Alpha Two Phase II Feedback ...

This is not entirely tue. I have gotten 3 from a small or 6 from a large before. It is incredibly rare though

white sphinx Jan 20, 2025, 7:15 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

inventory glitching making items look like they disappear
being able to heal while not flagged for caravans
Willows (and other trees glitched into the ground
when you flag for a caravan, that designation does not fall off when the caravan is completed so people can stay flagged and potentially get pvped long after that caravan drops
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Coal is not one of the biproducts of journeyman mining yet so once we get journeyman metalworking there will be a lot that cannot be crafted because we cant make the coke
Raptor mount should be one of the faster mounts. especially faster than gator and the runic and obsidian steeds
would love a named mob that drops a named Great spellsword and 1h spellsword.

silk wharf Jan 20, 2025, 7:16 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Cannot change caravan parts unless higher rarity ex cant put common on a caravan
Ranger scattershot's second charge rarely works
Having to relog to be able to pick up loot

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Being able to access other nodes marketplace from one node. it is too hard to constantly run between nodes to find certain things
It is impossible to find rare materials as a casual player and people camping rare spawns are charging a crazy amount of gold for them.
Only use for one tank in group making it hard to find a group that wants a tank.
======================

tall hollow Jan 20, 2025, 7:16 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug. This should be top priority when it comes to bugs, as it makes doing literally anything tedious at times. Having to close the game/launcher and re-authenticate to fix it is extremely annoying
Invisible/green mobs
Rubber-banding
Maps are still spawning the treasure in bad locations, or seemingly not spawning at all

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

While it was nice to see some strong account actions taken for the exploiters, we're still in the dark as far as what actions were taken for the majority of accounts in question. How many levels did these players lose? How much gold/how many assets were taken away from these players? Transparency is important, so we as a community feel that the issue has been properly addressed. Furthermore - it would be nice to have a wall of shame, or something similar, so we as a community can help to monitor the offenders. Character names being made public would simply add to their punishment. Also, as it stands, people feel that PI members get preferential treatment - which shouldn't be the case simply because they had more money to donate to the game. We've all paid to see this project get off of the ground, and should all be treated equally when it comes to breaking the rules/punishment
Market stalls could really use filters/the ability to make buy orders ASAP. That would go a long way in moving the economy along, and help players address material shortages.
Resource nodes being static, and some being super rate, letting players monopolize those materials. Also, with population density way higher than it should be, it's extremely frustrating to go gathering just to see nothing but fields of stone. Even semi-hardcore players have a very hard time finding good resources due to the way resources currently spawn.
Wars need some kind of build up period ASAP
======================

potent peak Jan 20, 2025, 7:17 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Guild wars with no cooldown.
Caravan runs crashing in wind and sea
Treasure maps quests not completing. Causing the next one not to spawn until logged out for 15 seconds.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The treasure maps are a really good bare bones system. Can’t wait to see it when it is fully setup with rarity and crafting levels.
Tree rarity feels very low when compared to mining and herbalism. I filled 3 (2 of them blue baskets) apprentice mining bags full of oak and only got a few uncommon while the rest was common. I only cut adult trees.
Love the openness of Steven and what you all are doing and when things will be implemented.

violet ice Jan 20, 2025, 7:17 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Please fix the chat channels to be more user friendly and fix chat filters to remove offensive words. For example, I cannot type the word "simple" but I have seen the word "b___h" and "c__k" typed in the citizen/global chat. Hmmmm....
Please bring back the missing Freeholds. I know of two of them myself. They are already so scarce.
Fix the desert nodes so their trees can be harvested. Even many of the trees we can harvest in the Riverlands cannot be harvested there.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Fix the bug that strips all buff off of drivers and that enables drivers of caravans to be easily targeted and killed while they can take no defensive actions. As it stands right now, the system forces you to play my class with no spells, no weapons, no buffs and the ability to walk at an RP pace in game. Because of the most recent change removing the caravan protections for the driver, that is what is happening with our caravan drivers now.
Provide in game reward for DEFENDERS of caravans (like glint or exp). This could be one set amount only for those who participate from beginning to end or it could be on a graduating scale depending upon the distance the defender was near the caravan and distance traveled from node to node, etc).
Add in a “safety” timer for those who are killed and respawn at an emberspring so they cannot be killed within seconds of spawning there by someone camping the emberspring area.

Thank you for all of the amazing stuff you are doing! Also, you might want to make these posts un-editable…I think the results of that would be enlightening.

waxen python Jan 20, 2025, 7:17 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

I don't recall any game-breaking bugs besides the usual rubber-banding and mobs being invulnerable and hitting me for some reason, but here are my top 3 feedback points:

Some artisanship professions are super-imbalanced, for example, scribing. Not only is it very expensive to level due to everything requiring 5 rubies, but the raw silver cost of crafting an enchanting scroll is higher than just buying the enchanting scroll itself. These artisanship classes could do with some love. Scaling has also been discussed, but it's much easier to level than it is to level artisanship.
This was discussed during PirateSoftware's interview with Steven, but please do NOT make mounts die permanently. I really, really urge you guys to reconsider. This is a slippery slope of making a lot of players very upset, and it removes the ability to become "attached" to a mount, which is an integral part of any successful low or high fantasy world. Instead, I would urge you folks to look into using mounts to breed and pass on genetics, which would "consume" the mount, or in other words, make the mount unusable as a mount, with limited breeding charges.

This would create an infinite sink, if done well with a healthy dose of randomness, where wealthier players could heavily optimize mounts, and require many, many mounts to do so. This would also have the benefit of being an elastic system, where demand can scale with supply as mount breeders will always be attempting to breed the perfect mount.

Although some might argue that having a mount die makes players more attached to the mount, and its protection, the fact of the matter is that mounts are not entirely predictable. Having them die will result in a lot of undue frustration, salt, toxicity and even potential game-quitting. There is such a thing as "too hardcore." Be wary not to alienate your playerbase.

There doesn't seem to be much reward in it for players to defend a caravan. As it stands, since there are no criminal repercussions for attacking a caravan, it's always optimal to attack lower-level player caravans. This, while fun, is partly immersion breaking and frustrating for newer players who, over time, will get entirely priced out of running caravans. It could be beneficial to have more balance between attacking and defending a caravan-- towns would surely benefit from having more trade deliveries, so it makes sense for them to reward defenders.

I know the original goal was to have people pay other players to defend caravans, but lower level players are unable to do so for obvious reasons. In brief, it would be nice to have more risk/reward balance.

charred ocean Jan 20, 2025, 7:17 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravan Beacon can be placed in closed areas
Caravans mounted in closed areas can not dismount
Caravans placed in closed areas can only be recovered in that area and character gets blocked from running caravans
Randomly teleporting to Carth while caravanning
Randomly teleporting with caravan back to where you were travelling from

misty quarry Jan 20, 2025, 7:17 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rubberbanding/Lag issues (dismount and teleport back to where you were, mobs in combat not registering hits or aggro, etc)
Resource nodes not despawning when extracted
Crash to desktop when idling a few minutes (still happening, not sure how to reproduce reliably)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Love the level of effort and care that appears to be going into the game and various systems.
Economies are starting to feel more interesting as folks level up their artisan skills
Solo play is still feasible and feels mostly good, acknowledging it's not the ideal intended vision but it's still viable
======================

versed prairie Jan 20, 2025, 7:18 PM

#

Top important bugs :

1- /!\ Caravans poofing into nothingness. Nothing makes me feel like closing the game than a 3 node 90mn caravan run, then it poofing in the sea 5mn away from the target node for no reason making me lose the caravan parts and BoBs investment + the glint..

2- minor compared to the first one, but sometimes, the floating damage and heal numbers stop displaying for random reasons

3- Mobs teleporting into walls, and hitting from out of line of sight

Improvement feedback :

1- More game organic pvp events. We need more events that encourage players to pvp each other, be it chests or some POIs spawning valuable loot and having a forced pvp zone around it etc.. to lessen the need of bloodthirsty people to just gank fest, and provide fun activities to channel this competitiveness

2- A better marketplace search functionality

3- Pleaaaase a guild bank/storage with logs of who puts / takes from it, and some king of permissions (like for withdrawing high rarity items etc..)

sharp raven Jan 20, 2025, 7:18 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Hunting spawners always have common rarity, close to impossible to get rare and above carcasses
Inventory and storage often get out of sync, it is supper annoying to relog just to have them synced

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Attacking caravans is pure reward with no risk, some risk is needed
Lower level crafting is useless, drops are to good in comparison
======================

plain wharf Jan 20, 2025, 7:18 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Invisible mobs attacking you, even while mounted and running away they are able to hit you.
Loot bag has issues every time I use it. We have to get on and off horse or relog to fix loot.
Stuck on mount, can't dismount and have to relog.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Guild bank please! I'll suck your sausages for a guild bank, it takes a long time when waiting to trade with specialist and you run out of storage holding it.
I want more control over the keybindings e.g I can't rebind the switch weapon key, I don't like where it's at.
More map Information, the map is lacking when it comes to quest locations especially. 4. You guys are awesome, thanks for making an amazing game. ======================

solid swift Jan 20, 2025, 7:18 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

To Craft some of the weapons/gear you need to camp the same Named boss over and over for hours, this is tedious and boring (Forsaken Blade fragment)
I have tried to do Pve things such as Farming Willows or other resources but it is so boring, the only way to do it is find a rare Willow Spawn or Node and Farm it every 2 hours when it spawns again, People have marks and timers for these things so they always farm the same nodes

lime zephyr Jan 20, 2025, 7:19 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Hit detection seems very buggy. Mobs and players seem to be able to melee you etc from 20 feet away.
Caravans Attack/Defend pop ups, conversion to different travel forms and party interaction with Caravan events are all very janky/buggy
Lag in popular areas such as dungeons/towns.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Artisan is way to much of a grind at basic level. It should be more of an inverted pyramid than a sheer cliff. Totally get that higher tiers should take a lot of time but apprentice/novice takes far to long to be useful.
COPPER/FLAX etc T1 nodes are incredibly scarce. Something should be done to either change their spawn rates/conditions or have them spawn a lot around low level areas such as the divine gate to aid with players initial artisan progression.
I'm sure this is on the way but a properly fleshed out market system where you can search for items and not just hope they mention those items in their shop intro 🙂
======================

kindred kite Jan 20, 2025, 7:19 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bug, having to constantly relog and not actually truly know where and what is in your inventory is awful.
Render Distance, leaves large scale pvp and engages in the air
Unharvestable resources spawning under the map.. Mainly Willow loves to spawn under and i suspect a TON more, need these placements fixed.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting in general, a lot of items requiring almost every specialty seems a big stretch.
Resource spawning
NPC Training

hardy idol Jan 20, 2025, 7:20 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan system bugs; disappearing, cannot switch caravans, losing cargos, stuck in PvP until server reset when you attack them, caravans position desync.. list goes on. This being one of the main late game activity right now along with world bosses, i would consider it top priority
Static spawns rarity and fixed timers. Timers for gatherables should be variable, so it cannot be camped. Also rarity gathered should not be static, it should change every single harvest
party/raid sync. Losing player position, not seeing party members in tropics, etc.
Travel position desync, when running on your mount, it happens frequently that you get desync, teleporting you way back when you dismount

silk mantle Jan 20, 2025, 7:20 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

inventory, storage and trading bugs
invisible enemies at various spots
Chat settings are not customizable, or at least not saved

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Carcasses stacking up to maximal 20 seems very off. Hunters would have a better time farming with according carcass stacks
Finding t2 nodes (and still same for copper&zinc) for most professions is really cumbersome for the amount needed to reach a somewhat feasible point in crafting jobs.
Memory leak is a big topic for us when approaching group content. We introduced tactical restarts to mitigate lag
======================

hexed crystal Jan 20, 2025, 7:20 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Performance, mem leak.
FPS loss when turning camera after a few hours of gameplay.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Calculating required crafting resources is nigh impossible without having more materials than required and then shuffling them about to make desired quality on a budget.

======================

lone linden Jan 20, 2025, 7:20 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

When caravaning or just traveling long distances on mount, eventually entities will stop loading in, if you dismount you will be teleported back to a previous location. Maybe not being handed off to another server properly?
Error 30, 32, 33, 34 on main menu
Mobs are sometimes able to attack players, while also being invisible to said player

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Mounts should die permanently (except starting horse) or last a limited duration, husbandry is way too much investment for having no sink
Mounts should be more similar in speed in general so there is more variety in what players are using. Currently nearly everyone just has the meta mount, which is boring visually. Maybe mounts should all have similar base speed and rarity increases it. Higher rarity then should be what is capped by your husbandry level, so novice can only train common, apprentice can train uncommon, etc.
Add separate classification for amphibious mounts that are not quite the best at either land or water, but decent at both.
Game needs more otters
======================

shy moon Jan 20, 2025, 7:21 PM

#

Critical Feedback:

New Player experience and a stronger focus on correcting early level quest bugs.

Granted the game is in an Alpha State and havign tests more than a few i understand that the goals and focus are likely elsewhere. However I think a large portion of the critical feedback the game and devs are getting is stemming form people who purchase or watch the game struggle in early levels due to a disconnect in expectations to what is being offered gameplay wise.

I expected when i downloaded to be able to quest as a way to build my level up. This does not feel entirely feasible due to how many broken quests exist. I will often spend 20-30 minute pursuing a quest to arrive at the final part only to find there are no NPCs or location to turn it in. A lot of time feels wasted.

I paid the 100 dollar price tag because i believe in the games future, but when there is a lot of hype and advertising around a game like this, there are some expectations that need to be met for those who arent extremely invested in the future of a project. Otherwise they will leave bad reviews and claim the devs are scamming them for such a price tag (even if the price was never lying about what it was offering.) People will always misinterpret things or not read or research before making reviews. And i feel a stronger focus on fixing the early questing would relieve some of that negativity.

sharp swallow Jan 20, 2025, 7:21 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Only bug I can currently think of out of game is when fighting a mob, they will sometimes run away from you to get back in their main spot which gives them back all their health and then runs back to you to continue fighting. It can be very difficult to kill something that can endlessly do this.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Rarity of huntable animals--It is extremely hard to get good rarity on huntable animals and you don't feel relief on this even with the hunting shirt/pants/scrolls/etc...I would argue that it needs to be more accessible for us to get rare and above hunting animals
I would like to see a decrease in cost of animal husbandry training OR an option to pick between a BOB or a mount--it's debilitating to the player to spend so much and not even get what was sought after.
Make more huntable animals spawn over the riverlands please!! It is extremely hard to find obsidian stallions, runic steeds, armored bears, and raptors with their small spawn locations and their long spawn times.

rotund adder Jan 20, 2025, 7:21 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Journeyman enchants scrolls missing from journeyman scribe vendor
People outside of events healing people within pvp events without needing to flag. No way that's not a bug.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Let us mix and match processing like we can with crafting rarity. Animal fat being the biggest hurdle is infuriating for making quality crafts. "Crafters make the best shit" can't stand true if they're gated by low rarity materials.

violet pebble Jan 20, 2025, 7:21 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Training of monsters seems to still be an issue.. but getting better
Graphical issues with character, weapon/shield, cloak disappearing
Continue graphical issues, lag, sound bugs, graphical issues in Forge and with change of day/night, flashbang issues, mouse icon disappearing.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The availability of resources for crafting is limited. For example for leatherworking, tanning of leathers takes Willow.. which is just too rare. The crafting system and resources needs some balancing. I would suggest hiring an economist to better structure the economic system of Verra with regards to resources, inflation, etc.
Global chat needs to be revamped, and a trading channel or window should be added. Also looking for group window should be added. Just too much spam.
Not all of us have young eyes and various graphical improvements to item quantities in stacks need to be made. Hard to tell. Also would like to see a better indication of if I am in combat or not.

hallow bronze Jan 20, 2025, 7:22 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Constantly having to relog as can't gather mining nodes
Players can still train mobs onto unsuspecting groups
Recently had more and more mobs attacking that some party members can see and others can't
Right clicking to move items from your inventory is constantly breaking

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Marketplace needs a proper filtering system or at least items searchable and not just shop descriptions
Crafting and levelling are nowhere near balanced. Unless being funnelled by a large guild it feels like it takes so much longer to level a trade that by the time you can make level 10 gear for example people are already level 20. The saving grace for this at the moment is people using level 10 gear and enchanting it.
I recently started an alt and hadn't realised just how many 20+ players grief the low level POI's by training mobs onto players for easy glint that the players have no chance to defend themselves from.
Hunting needs an overhaul. The rarity of drops in hunting is very unbalanced causing a major bottleneck in the resources. This combined with the limited spawns of some creatures allow them to be spawn camped means that materials like raptor hide are very limited when a core component of many 10+ crafts.
======================

velvet compass Jan 20, 2025, 7:22 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bugs ... so many relogs bc the inv keeps bugging out
2.Teleportation bugs ... got teleported across the whole map after unmounting, or got teleported across while driving a caravan and so on ...
friendlist bug (not able to see a friend request)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Lumberjacking Grandmaster is useless, and all the tool stats are not working as intended, rarity,speed,
Tree spawns and rarity system ... as a lumberjack i have to ride through the whole world to get to specific locations to get quality wood ...
3.The map is just a pain, zoom lvls, readability of the map, visability of grp members

sudden plover Jan 20, 2025, 7:22 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

freeze crashes / cant tab out, need to task manager kill task / task manager kill client
inventory/storage bugs
caravan bugs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

development roadmap mapped out with % complete for systems
when showcasing a system going forward, explaining what systems still need stood up / doing this for any previous showcase
mount life cycle - durability/lives etc
======================

misty coral Jan 20, 2025, 7:22 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Please do a pass on controls. Action mode and other things getting out of sync really destroy the experience.
Please have more things remember state. Last logged in character, last state of storage when it was open etc.
Stop resetting my tracked quests every time I log in.
Filter in the marketplace.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Create a per Realm Message of the Day/Week dialog and get focus on a feature per realm. This will slow deluge of bug reports all the time.
Take a break on features and do an extreme bug bash on QoL defects for a week a month. You need to keep the new/softcore players engaged and not annoy them every time they try something. People want all the cool features coming but will stay engaged if the basics work. There is enough here for a short break if your teams structure\skillset allows it.
I do like the daily patches. It gives a feeling of progress. I tend to get one small thing I have noticed every other day or so but as I said above, you need to reduce all the noise you have incoming from the small stuff.
======================

fluid plaza Jan 20, 2025, 7:22 PM

#

1-Inv adds,
2-matts/node respawn is broken- most Ash trees are in the ground

bitter bough Jan 20, 2025, 7:22 PM

#

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Quests for Targeted NPC kills not spawning NPC
Constant Rubberbanding
Getting kited in respawn areas with death shield

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

A sense of direction for players. Wide as the ocean and deep as a puddle right now.
Exp farms should not be the primary way to play the game
The water physics just need to go. It looks like flubber. Dial it down to a 3 from the 10 in UE5 water physics

pulsar thicket Jan 20, 2025, 7:23 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Guild Wars - Fishing Derby - Being used to hunt players down
Having to Drop Party/Raid to join Caravan Events
Being Stuck in a caravan event when a caravan dies until server restart

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting Quality on Crafting Shirts doesn't feel very impactful after the Phase 1 changes
No Rarity system for Hunting makes hunting feel bad
Allow us to Queue crafting queues of any size please!
======================

hollow estuary Jan 20, 2025, 7:23 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mobs getting stuck in walls/terrain, and therefore being permanently inaccessable until server reset.
Materials inventory STILL gets glitched and nonresponsive after a while, until relog.
Fire Elementals build up around Highwayman Hills after being summoned, and they don't leash back to anywhere, so they just sit around everywhere, including what should be safe areas.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The Market needs some kind of buy orders. I will regularly return to town with a smattering of different mats, but only 1-10 of them. Not worth the sell slot.
And you can't list everything you're selling in the description, because it's short (but I assume there's good reasons for that).

hardy idol Jan 20, 2025, 7:23 PM

#

Top 3-5 most important bugs:

Item and inventory tracking sometimes stops during high population zones. Example - you move items into your bank, the UI doesn't display that they moved, but when you relog, they are moved.
Sometimes when swapping between node borders while fighting mobs, they will become invisible but still attack you.
You can still see quest objective items and markers when you are not on the quest, or have finished the quest.
Quest items are not deleted on quest delivery.
Treasure quests do not complete when picking up treasures.

deft sphinx Jan 20, 2025, 7:24 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

caravan teleport driver to carph
invintory bugs
loot bug

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

more resource nodes for flax, copper, ect
either make the ammount of exp required for crafting lvls less or give more per craft.
maybe have defenders get glint for caravan duty?
======================

grizzled flower Jan 20, 2025, 7:24 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory de-sync
mobs inside terrain that you can't hit but can hit you with ranged attacks
Can't finish or advance quests. ##1 2nd sword outpost, none of those quests update. ##2 Echoes of Betrayal, a seal cannot be reached, it is beyond an invisible wall. A mob for "Horns of Betrayal" event also spawns beyond there. Linked is a screenshot from the AshesCodex Map showing the seal coordinates. Certain class can sometimes damage these out-of-bound mobs (ranger thorn skill?). ##3 "Set to Motion" rewards the player with "hourglass ankh" which has no sell value, and does not initiate a quest when double-clicked. With limited space for "Items", a tab which is shared with ALL warehouse storage, please stop rewarding us with absolute trash. If it is intended for a future questline, please include at least some text about this in the item's description (like what are all those skulls for? {Brayox, Varsool, Gruun, etc.})

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Make crafting quantity a slider instead of preset numbers on a dropdown list. Crafting time and fuel costs already adjust for quantity selected, so the calculations already exist and could be applied exponentially with a slider
Please tag quest items in some way so that they go to the Quest Tab in the Inventory window automatically and remain there until a quest completes. I understand the items that drop that can be clicked on to initiate a quest should still go the the Items Tab.

distant hollow Jan 20, 2025, 7:24 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Running along and getting stuck going through a world border. Having to stop for a few seconds before being able to walk again. Especially frustrating when pvping.
Quality on harvesting tools seeming to not be working, and pointless.
Inventory and storage not working, when transferring items they get stuck and need a relog to see.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Spawn times on names mobs, right now there’s just at least 4-5 people standing around killing these bosses on a repeat timer. Feels bad.
Render range, especially for pvp.
Disable healing a caravan when flagged as an attacker. As a real attacker you can’t kill someone who is flagged as an attacker and healing it.
======================

bleak flare Jan 20, 2025, 7:25 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Stability in towns. Seems to have gotten a little worse. Not by much. Maybe disable mounts in towns? Would help with the amount of entities.
Treasure Maps disappearing if you log out for a certain amount of time. And Treasure map quest not deleting itself after you complete the map.
Not harvestable nodes. You see them in the world and are not able to harvest that material no matter how many times you interact with them.
Rubber banding. Has gotten a little worse over the last week.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please make it more viable for Crafters and Gatherers to level. I know that this is planned in the future but buffing the XP on that now would be a very nice quality of life.
Guild features please. More stuff in the UI, Guild Bank, and other QOL. Will make the game feel better. (Probably Planned for the future but having it sooner than later would be ideal.)
Having more Marketplace search options would be nice. If people do not put the right word in there descriptions no one can fine there items. Especially when there are now 150 pages in some nodes. Will also help reduce lag in town if people can find what they are looking for faster.
======================

Keep up the updates. Every week it gets better and better aocphoenix

little steeple Jan 20, 2025, 7:25 PM

#

Bugs

Inventory desync (Relog needed each time.)
Landscape desync (You harvest a resource, but its still there, until you relog)

Feedback

Having crafting limited at 5 professions is too limiting. Crafting should not be considered a side thing to PvX. Optimally you would create a crafting class, that had only fairly basic PvX skills, but full access to crafting. Current design forces crafters to play multiple characters and/or multiboxing.
NPC leash length is far too long.
Do not have timed respawn of resources in the same place. Being able to set the clock to when you can pickup resources create an illusion of scarcity as a core group of players exploit this mechanic. Or rather at the end of the timer it should always respawn in a new location. No same spot respawn.

hardy idol Jan 20, 2025, 7:25 PM

#

Top 3-5 most important feedback.

It is not overly obvious for a new player what areas and parts of the map you should be leveling in.
Most people have leveled up most of the way by now, so lower level areas see less play, and are harder to get groups for. There should be some kind of way to encourage playability of lower level areas aside from alts.
There currently does not seem to be an obvious reason to become a citizen of a node, at least from a new players perspective. There needs to be a system that further explains and utilizes the node system benefits.

knotty pecan Jan 20, 2025, 7:25 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Unharvestable nodes
Have yet to see anything over rare in hunting and alls i do is gather.
inventory bug fix this please rn.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

More willow. More ore. idk seems very unbalanced. Lots of people live to craft in games. And prices on the market are complete ass.
Need better pvp system.
Faster resource respawns as well.
Release the summoner.
Reduce costs on crafting, 20 copper for a t1 sword is pretty wild and very demanding. Maybe cut resource costs to craft in half in general for some items.
======================

split dragon Jan 20, 2025, 7:25 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Unable to loot or move items in inventory/storage
Losing raid/party frames when you d/c or have to relog, usually due to inventory issue (#1)
All of the other stuff also caused by #1...

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gatherables nodes need to be more random (each node spawn should have a chance of what spawns, not always granite here, always basalt here, etc.)
Gatherable node spawn times need to be more random (+/- 10 mins, if not more) to prevent one person timing them and taking all important spawns
Gatherable rarities need to be stackable in some way - tired of having 3-5 of every rarity and wasting 95% of my huge bags because I have 5 different rarities of each gatherable
======================

twin talon Jan 20, 2025, 7:26 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

525 error Affecting friends and demotivating them from playing. (Specifically a friend named Stonefather)
Caravan Driver Teleporting to Carphin bugs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Keep going on Caravan improvements
I look forward to guild improvements that are potentially coming the 31st
Please fix that 525 error as soon as you can so friends can come back to enjoying testing this lovely alpha
======================

vapid nest Jan 20, 2025, 7:26 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Over the last 48 hours I've had multiple instances of a bug when jumping around the open world where my characters gets stuck in a state where movement speed is nearly doubled, which lasts as long as I keep moving forward and until I fall any distance.
Ranger's "Camouflage" ability sometimes renders the avatar transparent with the weapon still visible (which is cool) and sometimes just hides the player's nameplate without any visual changes to the avatar. Whichever one is correct, it would be nice to have consistency.
Huge swathes of Oak and Ash and Larch trees in the forest at the northern reaches of the Riverlands remain non-interactable.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Griefing and exploiting has slowed down considerably on Lotharia since the clean-up, many thanks!
Node wars need a ramping-up period. Some folks have become insufferable with rolling up on a node, starting a node war and killing all the idle citizens crafting/processing etc, then riding off with their spoils or camping the node's emberspring.
Caravans need to be either more beneficial to Defenders or riskier to attackers. Offer experience to defenders or allow the caravan master to allocate silver/gold to be paid on arrival from the sale of the commodities; Send an announcement to the originating ZOI citizens or mark the attackers on the map when a caravan comes under attack.
Please offer the option to combine caravans created by members of the same party/raid into one attack/defense event. Imposing distance limitations from the lead caravan (first one placed) would discourage exploiting this feature.
======================

rough wyvern Jan 20, 2025, 7:26 PM

#

======================
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory desync, causing items to not be visually moved
Dismounting and rubberbanding back across the map
Caravan invuln on driver respawn
Gatherables spawning in rocks and under terrain
World bosses not respawning/ spawning under the map

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Desert needs some PoI's aand more gatherables to incentivize players to play in them across more scenarios.
General stability seems to be decreasing rather than increasing since phase 2 start.
Rogue please?
======================

midnight bloom Jan 20, 2025, 7:26 PM

#

Top Bugs:

Mobs are responding (or not) weirdly.
Trees/Minerals are not disappearing when harvested. Thankfully the trees usually change color.

Feedback Topics:

Chat - Aside from the previously mentioned usability features such as right-clicking, and up-arrow, I'd like to see more standard channels. One for LFG, one for Recruitment, and one for whatever region you are in (maybe call it Local).
Kind of like there are markings when you are in a party, make a LFG marking visible to all that you could apply to yourself, which makes your class and level show above your head or something like that. Also, place a small bench or pavilion or something near the dungeon entrances for people who are looking for groups to wait (like a bus stop).
Bug report feedback score. I've submitted somewhere between thirty and forty bug reports. It would be nice to get a count of how many have been submitted and if possible, how useful they were. Maybe even a zero to three star rating system for whoever analyzes the report to click. Not trying to add to their work, but it would add to our satisfaction and maybe help us submit better ones if we knew we were submitting poor or useless reports.
Some kind of Leaderboard. Top 10/100 lists for each server showing who has the most XP in each skill, weapon, most kills of a particular mob, etc... Top characters and top guilds, maybe with a monthly reward or something. Most completed missions for each node. I'm sure you have the data, being able to see it would be cool.

Thank you for this and everything!

neon stone Jan 20, 2025, 7:27 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Enemies engaged in combat don't appear to move, but they do damage even from afar as if they are invisible
Mount moves but feet freeze
Enemy indicators inside of rocks and hills

craggy talon Jan 20, 2025, 7:27 PM

#

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Teleporting to Carph during Caravan. Various other carvan bugs that are known and reported.
Mobs glitching. Into walls, floors, etc., Being invisible but still doing damage. Being green and non-attackable but still doing damage to you.
Inventory and loot glitches that never end and require constant relogs to resolve.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The rarity on hunting is far too low an a major bottleneck to making good gear.
PVP TTK is far too fast, pvp needs to be re-thought for a balanced system. A small group can destroy a Caravan so fast there isnt much to do but sit back and watch if your defense wasnt already standing next to you.
Crafting needs work. no custom amounts, no mix and matching rarities in some cases. This combined with lack of storage grouping (just tier 1 lumberjacking takes 28 slots at 1 x 3 if you had just a single tree of each rarity, this was not thought out) means we are stuck either storing a ton of non craft amounts like 4, 9, 24, etc, or we have to sit there for long periods of time doing singles. At the very LEAST change it from 5, 10, 25, 50 to match stacks, like 5, 10, 20, 40, etc. Whomever thought the 25 and 50 was a good plan when all the stacks are in 20's needs to be slapped.

======================

twin citrus Jan 20, 2025, 7:27 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Any caravan related bug as there are too many
Rubber banding is a major issue which causes unnecessary deaths
Storage causes for an insane amount of crashes and glitches

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please have a deeper insight into freeholds. Freeholds. Freeholds can be obtained only by the rich and powerfull. Once you have it only YOU can use the buildings there this causes an insane gap between the realm and freehold owners where gatekeeping is inevitable…. Example solution:

make it so people can use freehold buildings in towns aswell but give those in town a limit use and CD and give freehold users unlimitted acces

Animal Husbandry & Hunting needs more love. Right now these 2 skills feel neglected.

we have barely any rarity when hunting
The rarity that drops on mounts is only usefull 50% of the time (as a beast of burden)
The amount of animals we can collect is basically 10 in total as a journeyman (apprentice and novice animals excluded)
The price of a husbandry animal is very expensive its like 55s for a t1 animal this causes an big advantage over those who picked husbandry and those who dont. People should not be going broke because they chose the wrong artisan system

3 Pvp ranking system

I think it will be good to have a pvp ranking system. A pvp ranking system will go as followed:

Rank 1 - 2 (gain 200 points)
Rank 2 - 3 (gain 400 points)
Rank 3 - 4 (gain 700 points)

If you kill people 2 lvls below or above you you gain points (based on if they are below or above you)

If you kill someone more then 2 lvls above or below you you decrease in rank (this instantly stops low lvl killing) but you get more organic pvp then opt in pvp like a caravan. Because right now there is no risk in running around as people do not attack out of random

4.Nerf the bard. Bards shouldnt be able to outrun a mount.

grave forge Jan 20, 2025, 7:27 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Friend List not working
2.Lotting sometime not working
3.fix the rarity in ghatering nodes, ppl started to camp every legendary piece of it

===================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II

Inventory not synchronised.
Helping solo players to level up with exp zones that may be less interesting for group exp, but which could allow others with less time to still be able to exp without spending hours on it.
Prioritize corrections and performance.

strong portal Jan 20, 2025, 7:31 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mob Training
Position desyncing while mounted. Dismounting sends you back to where the server thinks you should be.
Crashes, memory leaks

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Filters for finding objects at sales
Chat channels to reduce clutter in global
Expansion of all class skill trees (new actives/passives -- build variety)
======================

celest hemlock Jan 20, 2025, 7:31 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory will sometime freeze up and will need to relog. Can't move items.
Friends list not working
resource nodes not rendering in, not lootable

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Struggling to understand what is going on what I should be doing to level make money. How to improve gear/make money. Some of these I have figured out but it is a slow process
Similar lack of information on how to get better/rarer resources
Marketplace very difficult to comb through

dim dock Jan 20, 2025, 7:32 PM

#

JUST GOR 1 feedback 🫡
NO: 1-as a healer the mouse hover for group healing is great under the group HUD system.
under Raid HUD system it is better cuz the visual make it more obvious and there is a even more advantage with having myself in that HUD
Sugjestion: First having the choice of how my Group HUD visualy be like raid
Second: adding myself to the group HUD cluster so my eyes need to travel less
thx for your time have a great day 🥹 ❤️

deep swan Jan 20, 2025, 7:32 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans being immune once rider rezzes
People LOS mobs in oaken to where they cannot be attacked but can attack mobs
Gatherables - A lot of gatherables (Willows in particular) are not gatherable please fix these locations

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Would like a small change to the flagging system for attacker/defender. Please let it be done for an entire raid group/party so that we don't have to constantly drop party to attack or defend.
XP for rarities in crafting should not be the same as well as types of items for example a crate should not be the same experience as a caravan in carpentry especially since it cost double the resources to make.
Build diversity all archetypes feel very cookie cutter. No build diversity. Maybe add magic abilities to physical classes and vice versa to allow for stamina bard or magical ranger

orchid hornet Jan 20, 2025, 7:32 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bugs. When moving items, they don't move or don't show up.
Looting items. Quite often you'd need to log out and log back in to loot an item. The "just updated with DB with attacking something" doesn't work often enough.
Other players in group sometimes don't show up. Sometimes where a player is, they don't show up on screen or on mini-map.
Cloaks. Please fix cloaks. They often bug out.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Marketplace Idea. Allow us to look at items and purchase items from other nodes. Still require to go to node to pick it up though.
Marketplace Idea. Create a better filter for items. Don't rely on the players to update a note.
Treasure Maps. Common and Uncommon should be easier to find and not in "dangerous" places. Rare and above should be difficult and potentially in difficult places.
======================

kindred dagger Jan 20, 2025, 7:33 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Ranger: Concentrated Scattershot skill is still buggy and still misses alot.

bitter shore Jan 20, 2025, 7:33 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The inventory bug. This is the only bug that makes me want to rage quit. If I move or delete something, the item doesn't move until I jump on my mount. So I'm stuck jumping on and off my mount just to move items from inventory and storage. I lost 30 rare bluebells from a treasure chest because my mount had died. I had made room in my inventory, but this bug wouldn't recognize those spaces were now empty.
Have done dozens of treasure maps and in several I could not find the mound. Trust me, I looked everywhere. I did find mounds in my area, but was told I didn't have permission to interact with it. I have bug reported this multiple times.
Trees are still underground and can't be chopped down. Or I do chop them down, am given the inventory is full error, I delete and item, but now the button to get the item is at the base of the tree underground and I can't click on it.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The player merchant vendor really really needs work. Searching on keywords in the title makes me click through lots of vendors who aren't even selling that item.
Attacking caravans is zero risk, all reward. If you are going to punish players for griefing other players, then they should be punished for griefing caravans.
Love the treasure map system. Make more solo content like this.
======================

sullen abyss Jan 20, 2025, 7:34 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Having to drop group to sign up for caravan events
You can heal outside of Caravan events
Trees spawning terrain and cannot be chopped
Groups getting into a bugged state where you cannot drop the group

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Node Requisitions and Taxes - It would be nice if we paid our taxes with node requisition tickets versus glint. That would make sure people had to contribute to their node in order to stay a citizen.
Groups: Map markers for groups/raids
Guild: It would be nice to see people's level in the guild window. It would also be nice if the Last Online was accurate.
Would be nice somewhere on the node window to show what building is currently being worked on in a node.

deep sphinx Jan 20, 2025, 7:34 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Inventory bugs, whether it be being unable to pick up glint from a dead mob, having to re-log to even register a change in the material inventory when finishing mining an ore deposit, etc.
2.Render distance when fighting wars/doing caravans, etc. a major part of it in my opinion is the fact that you have to be practically right next to the caravan for it to even load, or be in the middle of a big fight when doing node wars to actually see the fight
3.Having to reset the raid/ui whenever someone in the party relogs and not being able to see the party list. another part of it would be not being able to see raid members on the map when your in a raid group
4.Mount animations constantly messing up or being stuck in the middle of an animation. for example when jumping while going up some sort of slope while on a mount, the mount gets stuck in a jumping animation

A better filtering system for the marketplace. One that compares the prices of the item(s) you are shopping for.

frozen plank Jan 20, 2025, 9:03 PM

#

====================== Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025 Alpha Two Phase II Feedback Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Since the last update at 01/16/2025 the game is very laggy in towns and on the road (especially while auto run is active and a tap like the map or journal is open)
The Quest for farming 20 Tin has a spelling mistake. It says in the description „Tin Copper“ where it should say „Mine Copper“
In several areas like Steel Bloom or Carphin there is an eerie background noice that doesnt go away even when you leave the area again. I currently have to relog if i want to get rid oft hat background noice.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The Item inventory should be either splitt like the material inventory for every city or given more room. The current item inventory space is to small for all the items and questitem you get by either farming or crafting or questing.
The Western Larch trees are to often only in an adolecent state where they only give 2-3 wood when choped. In comparencen to the other tree types they are almost allways in the adolecent state. Either increase the growing speed of these trees or reduce the need for this tree type in recipes if it is the problem that this tree type is overfarmt
The background noice (voices) in the cities is very inconsitant. There are places where it is audible and then it is gone 2 meters away. Let it be constant in the cities and when you enter the city let the background noice increase in volume slowly. The current noice starts to loud.
======================

undone bridge Jan 20, 2025, 9:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Sometimes clerics get no Divine Power (solution relog)
Cannot loot mobs or only partially
Cannot see party members on map / see former party members on map

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

It would be good if the chat functions could be expanded

Click on player names in chat to invite and whisper.
"Recruit group" function that you can click on to apply to a group.
Ability for each group member to arrange players individually in the group window

rancid pilot Jan 20, 2025, 9:05 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mobs hitting you from very far away. Makes dodging/trying to run pointless.
Inventory bugs where items disappear.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gatherable nodes' tendency to respawn as higher level gatherables (e.g. cannot get novice/apprentice tools or level up metalworking due to lack of copper/zinc)
Node wars/guild wars: lack of wind-up time is problematic, lack of punishments for losing/surrendering means there is no real risk of declaring a node war. There should be an option to reject surrender and to recruit allies into the war.
Mob training should flag you for PvP.
Why do you need to pay taxes on tax receipts? It's going towards the same thing except the amount it costs is different from what it displays.
======================

wheat fulcrum Jan 20, 2025, 9:06 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans, Caravans, Caravans! Rafts sink to the bottom of the lake near Carphin. Rafts turn into carts randomly while sailing. Caravans bug out when they touch each other. Rafts bug out when they touch each other. Caravans and rafts bug out when spawning on and/or near each other. Cargo will disappear upon turning it in until you log in and out.
Nodes. There are a lot of bugs when traveling across nodes/server workers. Such as dismounting, only to be teleported all the way back at the server worker you glitched at. Sometimes, invisible walls appear that prevent you from traveling across nodes until you dismount, and remount your mount.
Action Mode and tab mode. Swapping between them makes the mouse/pointer freak out. Making the movements between the two modes intermingle. Such as mouse appearing on screen, but moving the point of view of character without pushing any additional buttons. Typically happens when in action mode and opening/closing the map, inventory and/or storage in cities.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I have been experiencing much less disconnects/crashes, which has been great!
Happy to see action being taken against 'less-than-desirable-players'. I'd love a wall of shame like Runescape has.
N/A
======================

sharp condor Jan 20, 2025, 9:08 PM

#

unborn ginkgo Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers! ```Please share your top 3-5 most critic...

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fix the Inventory bugs
Fix looting bug - sometimes can no longer loot and have to log to fix
Fix floating assets - floating dead wolfs and other such items - Tree sunk into ground making them non harvestable

glass pecan Jan 20, 2025, 9:11 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Parties and party exp breaking, requiring the group to hard relog to get out of the party and regroup.
Server workers around steelbloom need help.
Caravan bugs. all of them.
Friends list bugs. Sucks to make friends and never be able to see if they’re online after logging out and back in.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Echoing the need for solo progression avenues. It is already starting to show for low level groups, and it will get worse for rogues.
Rangers need adjustments to be brought more in line with mages. Current party utility is not enough to outweigh the lower damage output compared to mages even post-nerf.
Esc no longer cancelling bard melody.

naive lynx Jan 20, 2025, 9:12 PM

#

Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Please share your top 3-5 most critical issues or feedback topics in the thread below using the following format:

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Missing hair xD
Animation for mounting is not consistent

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Weapons can be sheathed
Mounting has a climbing animation
Would nice to have more weather effects
======================

To keep the thread organized, we kindly ask that you avoid back-and-forth discussions, and stick to the format above for your posts. We'll be closing the thread at <t:1737482400:F>

Important Note: While we greatly value your insights, please understand that we cannot guarantee all bugs or feedback topics will be addressed, or provide a specific timeframe for fixes.

Thank you for your continued support, feedback, and dedication to improving the Alpha Two experience! :flamingphoenix:

sleek plank Jan 20, 2025, 9:13 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

No Signal Crashes - Screens go into sleep mode/no display/black during play and requires a hard restart of the PC.
Inventory Desync - Issues with inventory updating/refreshing position and counts.
Green Mobs/Invisible Mobs/Mob Spawn Desync - All of these make mob interaction a pain in POIs or while out adventuring.
Settings not sticking after relog - Have to constantly change my settings every time I log in.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gathering // Crafting leveling is far too harsh IMO. Takes a lot of commitment but doesn't currently have the payoff to attempt. The costs outweigh the gains by a large margin.
We need more leveling avenues other than farm a spot for hours.
LFG/Trade channel please 🙂

celest jewel Jan 20, 2025, 9:13 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

inventory/looting desync
Healing from outside of Caravan Events
unharvestable gathering resources

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

There is no reason/reward to defend someone elses caravan other then being friendly, and if i have anything in my bags i will not go gear the event.
player corruption system is not working. right now if a player gets corrupted. they logout, wait for their friends to come and then their friends kill them loot them until corruption is gone, not fun.
horrid marketplace functionality, can only search for player made tags, most stores have no tags. i want items, and not to spend an hour searching the market.

final wing Jan 20, 2025, 9:13 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug, its annoying as hell because theres hunting spot you cant summon a horse to partially unbug the inventory and allow to loot the drop. Managing a bank... its worse.
Frozen mobs or mobs that go underground/invi but still keep hitting you while you cant fight back.
Constantly frozen nodes that cant gather and lots of spawn under the ground

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Need a seriously rework on willow spawn quantity, plus lumberjack rarity its insane amazingly bad compared with mining.
Lack of parcel system (where you can mail stuff to yourself or another player) and your market sell slots should increase based on you citizenship level at least in the city you pledged (normal 20 market slots, lv. 2 lets say 30 market slots, lv.3 lets say market 40-50 slots. Make the citizenship have a good purpose and benefit) and add an option based on citizenship level to upgrade our backpack(not saying inventory...) (lv2 can buy 1 extra bag, lv 3 can buy 2 extra bags).
Terrible latency around all server, the fps and ping from client its just a joke aside... it shows like 50ms but in reality its over 500ms considering the skill cast delays from instant stuff.
======================

hushed linden Jan 20, 2025, 9:15 PM

#

The inventory bug in all its variants. That thing is brutal. 2. I'm told Winstend's journeyman lumbermill is bugged, foll like a month now. Some people got their journeyman rank and ax before the bug though. Giving them a big advantage over who are stuck at lower level of lumberjack. 3. Cosmetic bug. Many trees don't fall down or the base is so far below the ground level they can't fall down. FEEDBACK 1. I'm concerned about allowing free holds to grow difficult to get resources. Weeping willow or flax for example. What gives it it's value is the rarity. Freeholds will always be able to out compete a wild harvester, making harvesting these resources pointless. perhaps having free holds grow stuff that has to be purchases, like cotton or lettuce. 2. Right now the best way to get anything in the games is to group up and grind. The people who did this got to max level first, got all the freeholds, got the best gear, ect. They have all the advantages. Making all other ways of playing the games singificantly less affective.

nimble hinge Jan 20, 2025, 9:15 PM

#

.

small sorrel Jan 20, 2025, 9:18 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

World Desyncing (Hafting to mount and unmount and teleporting whereever it started)
Bards One shot Wand Finisher
Caravan's in general, multiple bugs. Desync, selecting role, bugs that allow healing

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Need to get dynamic resources.
2.Hunting spawn rate and rarity
Tick/Frames
======================

turbid nacelle Jan 20, 2025, 9:19 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bank bugs continue to be a major issue. Moving items doesn't appear on your screen then when you get on your mount, they update. This happens at various times and is difficult to resolve.
Group/Party issues. Some party members don't show up. Party has to toggle to raid to clear some up. Some players are unable to be healed without relogging to desktop to clear the issue as logging out to the character list isn't enough.
Invisible mobs at times has been a huge issue and was seen in Steelbloom. Some party members could attack them but others couldn't see them even though they were taking damage from their attacks. It appears to be a disconnect between the server location and the client location.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Visual Distance is a huge issue. We should be able to see players coming in to our screens yet they are still loading after standing next to me for a while and some of them were attacking.
Given the volume of resources in the game and the rarity, the storage in game is woefully small. To be useful, you will need to have storage at least 2 times this size and with guilds, you will need 10 times the size of a player's storage, minimum. That is just for resources to 25! If you double it with resources up to level 50, that would mean our banks just can't stand the sizes. Recommend changing everything to 1 square if you are going to continue with this system.
Freeholds are economically broken. The volume of resources available to those with a freehold versus those without is not something the game can withstand. There are resources in freeholds that cannot be farmed in cities, such as growing willow and those should be allowed. The volumes can be smaller in cities but you should be able to do anything in cities that you can in freeholds.

sharp condor Jan 20, 2025, 9:19 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Fix the Inventory bugs
Fix looting bug - sometimes can no longer loot and have to log to fix
Fix floating assets - floating dead wolfs and other such items - Tree sunk into ground making them non harvestable

Top 3 Feedback

Artisan skills at lower level have no value to the community - Besides gathering and processing, which you can sell to crafters - the crafters have no one to sell too as you can simple purchase the items from the node vendor - Crafted items sell back to the vendor NPCs for absolutly no money, you cannot even break even but actually have a significant loss. I know cost should be a part of the equation but with no viable options to do anything with the items you are creating then why creat them. Just seems like you should just be a gatherer and sell raw products.
Caravan need a better risk reward balance - right ow all risk is on the caravan owner. There is no risk to the Caravan attackers. There needs to be a way to balance it so that everyone can pertake in this event type but as it stands right now only capted level and large guilds can run caravans consistently. It is another system that will be only for the Large Guilds.
Flying mounts for omly Node Mayors needs to be altered - Make it so the Maypr Mounts can participate in battles - but give the rest of us a chance at flying mounts that we can travel on - just make them extremly rare - Maybe they can only be made after defeating a boss dragon that you can then use her nest to hunt a lesser wyrm.

crystal brook Jan 20, 2025, 9:22 PM

#

Bugs 1) caravan flagging system forcing people to drop group and reform on every single event
Bugs2) caravan flagging system forcing people to drop group and reform on every single event
Bugs 3) inventory not updating visually when using storage

Feedback 1) caravan flagging system forcing people to drop group and reform on every single event
Feeedback 2) caravan flagging system forcing people to drop group and reform on every single event
Feedback 3) caravan flagging system forcing people to drop group and reform on every single event

rustic linden Jan 20, 2025, 9:25 PM

#

I want the full artisan loop. Want to have more resources and want tropics and dessert to get their resources.

tidal frigate Jan 20, 2025, 9:25 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Tax Calculation Bug: Taxes incorrectly calculate owed amounts when leveling up. Initially, taxes are original_value. After leveling, the system should deduct only the difference, but it checks for original_value + difference. This forces players to have excess resources available, and upon payment, the system refunds original_value.
NPC Desynchronization: Certain NPCs appear invulnerable or invisible while attacking, making it difficult to predict pulls or defend against invisible threats.
Boss Reset Bug: Some boss NPCs prematurely reset to spawn points, fully healing themselves, making them undefeatable at intended levels.
Mount Desynchronization: Players are teleported back to previous locations after riding mounts, sometimes losing up to 30 minutes of progress.
Gatherable Desynchronization: Gatherables often show as interactable when they aren't, leading to wasted time or erroneous errors, such as "permission issue"

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Excessive Taxes: Taxes are overly punishing, especially for lower-level players. Joining Halcyon requires ~500 tax receipts weekly (~1g9s80c in glint, taking ~6 hours to farm). This is unrealistic for new players, those focused on professions, or players trying multiple classes. The setup feels overly restrictive in the current node system.
Lionhold Skeleton Farm: The skeleton area outside Lionhold is too difficult for low-level players. Skeletons are hard to see at night, and it's easy to accidentally pull large groups, making traversal dangerous even at level 10+.
Sparse Hunting Opportunities: Hunting lacks balance compared to other gathering skills. Corpses are too scarce, and there’s no alternative way to harvest animals for non-mount purposes, limiting progression options.
======================

sweet linden Jan 20, 2025, 9:25 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory/Bank bugs where I dont' see loot going into inventory, cannot loot things, or cannot put things into inventory properly
Can't read text in inventory for stackable items it's too small. Fix the UI for sight impaired people.
Mobs randomly fleeing then popping back on top of you. Mobs being trained by someone else then veering off to attack you just b/c you're in proximity.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Treasure maps need to be easier to find the dig sites when in the circle(s). Scouring for a clump of dirt often obscured by similar clump of dirt is UNFUN. Spent an hour for one circle before finding it. This is not a fun experience.
Crafting needs to be made fun. Right now it's agonizing over finding the component and/or right kind (common vs uncommon vs rare etc.) There's 0 clue in game that above novice processing and crafting becomes so much more resource intensive.
Stop favoring mega zergs and people who clearly can play this as a full time job. Let those who want to craft/process/gather actually do that without some arbitrary, no you cannot master it all, design decision. If I want to do it all let me even if it's slow -- that's the trade-off time involved.
======================

runic moth Jan 20, 2025, 9:26 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Armor and Magic Resist are NOT working! My naked Character got around 100 Armor..how?
Inventory/Storage bugs..after how many fixes will it finally work?
Caravan bugs, way to squishy cause of armor/resists are not ingame? Mitigation in caravan isn't working too?

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PLS fix Mob aggro behavior..it's so annoying, worst of all MMO I played so far..and I started with DAoC...
Change gatherable rarity system..now you just can spawn camp a good ressource..why not make it random?
Like Common 70% chance, Uncommon 10%..Rare 7%...Heroic..5%...Epic...3%....Leg 1%..and you can increase/decrease it in favor of gear stats
Oculars are way to OP, maybe cause Armor and Magic Resist aren't working?
======================

pliant fulcrum Jan 20, 2025, 9:28 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan Issues (Dissapearing Caravans on Server Border/Teleporting to Carphin from Caravan)
Dismount teleportation to previous position
Mining nodes not being mineable in some sections of the map
Material/storage bug. Need to mount/dismount to refresh.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Make marketplace searchable by item. If I search bluebell it should bring up any listings with bluebell in it.
Nerf bard, to stupid crazy shock stack rotation. They have silence/cc/big damage, movement and utility. Way to overpowered, especially for pvp
Make other matts like moonbell that aren't used in alot of recipes more useful
Hunter rarity is way to low, getting high rarity animal fat, bones, and hides is way to difficult atm
Make journeyman enchanting scrolls more easy to access

solar geode Jan 20, 2025, 9:31 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

CARAVANS GETTING DELETED - I had my 20g caravan in Azmaran get deleted because I bought a second caravan in Miralith and left it out to defend the town during a potential node war. when the recently bought caravan got destroyed it also deleted my other one in Azmaran. Deleting 10s of gold worth of investments into caravans and hours of time grinding is devistating to anyone and needs to be addressed first I feel
Inventory stops showing where items are placed or moved too when going to storage and back or moving items between inventories
unable to pick up glint and having to relogg for it to be fixed or sometimes fully close launcher

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Allow for a nod war the mayor to select who can and cannot particpate from their citizens (with a minimum requirement to meet) to bypass win trading or having allies of the attacker become citizens prior to attack to win trade or feed kills.
Please let us craft any amount of an item rather then these fixed rates of 5,10,25,and 50. its painful having 49 of something and needing to spend way more then needed time at a station. just make it any amount can be crafted with the 1:1 min ratio you guys have.
Allow glint to be able to be free for all as well if a party opts to do so. been times where I wanna help a friend glint farm and have to drop party to ensure they get it rather then just being able to free for all and leave to them to collect
======================

pallid furnace Jan 20, 2025, 9:32 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Constant disconnections: It's hard to pinpoint the cause, but it frequently happens in caravans. Recently, it occurred when I summoned a caravan near the NA entrance. After needing to relog, my screen froze every time I loaded into the game. I had to use the repair option on the launcher to fix it.
Rubberbanding: I'll be running to one location and suddenly get teleported back—sometimes really far back—forcing me to spend a few minutes catching up to where I thought I was.
Mob aggro range and leashing: Training mobs is still an issue.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravan interaction confirmation: When attacking or defending a caravan, a confirmation ("Are you sure?") option would be helpful. I've accidentally clicked the wrong option, and since it's permanent, it's frustrating when mistakes happen.
Caravan target clarity: When attacking or defending a caravan, it would be nice if the pop-up displayed the names of the people you're trying to attack or defend. Sometimes, it's hard to ensure you're targeting the right one, especially when a friend's caravan is nearby.
Node citizenship benefits: There should be more incentives to be a citizen of a node. Currently, I don’t see much reason to pay taxes because I can simply re-enroll after it expires a few hours later. While some inventory might be unavailable during that time, I can still use that extra glint for caravans, so there isn’t much of a downside.
Traveling in this game makes me prefer to log off sometimes than run accross the map for the 10th time. I understand wanting to go for some sort of realism but we desperately need some automated forms of travel. I'd be a fan of a Black desert online system where you put a ping on the map and auto run there, but literally anything. Running from NA to Miraleth and back.. please save me from this, it's not fun.

fathom root Jan 20, 2025, 9:34 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Various Caravan features not working properly
A variety of quests not working properly/at all, in addition to certain Quest Items dropping despite the quest not being active on a given character
Vision Range being dependent on latency. I refuse to believe this is a desired feature.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Not much feedback to give, aside from the current %-chance to acquire ore from rocks being too low.
Waiting on more quests
Some enemy NPC damage values are absurd. Mostly caster-types.
======================

regal narwhal Jan 20, 2025, 9:35 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Looting / Inventory lag issues.
Mob training
Rubberbanding
"Ghost" mobs that don't register hits but can still attack you.
Treasure Maps not properly spawning dirt patches.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Lumberjacking is inaccurate and for a medieval setting it is completely off the mark. Medieval Europe generally practiced forestry management.
It would be nice if quests involving named mobs were cleaned up a bit. Either remove the quests you don't want being done, or fix the spawn rates so you're not wandering around for an hour for a mob that refuses to spawn.
It would be nice if group content oriented locations- think field dungeons, etc- had some kind of water cooler type object / location where people can meet up and form groups with some sort of LFD style tool (but not one that does the work for you.)
It would be nice if the game would throw some kind of error when it freezes and locks up. To date I've had a UE crash report generate exactly once.
The market board really needs to be cleaned up a bit.

stone bone Jan 20, 2025, 9:35 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Cuser/tab target issue
2.mounts / cuser issue
3.freeze/crash from zone to zone

heady hollow Jan 20, 2025, 9:35 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan being unusable if you crash/DC after pressing launch but before placing the object. (Waiting for restarts or deleting your caravan aren't great options esp without automatic restarts)
Combat deysnc causing things like Grapple to just not do anything
Gathering nodes being static locations/timers. If you're not someone meticulously tracking a dozen timers for Epic/Legendary resources you end up just never getting any.
Node wars have zero warning time the attacker advantage is absolutely massive especially when you have a very active node they will get 100 of the 800 kills in the first minutes before your side can even get a group formed.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting is a bit over the top I can only imagine how insane crafting at level 50 could be. We have materials just randomly forced in where they simply don't make any sense. For example why does Slate Mortar cost Bluebell Thread? We already have to go through several crafters between multiple cities to make one item needing all this to make a basic Bronze Weapon is insane.
Treasure maps are a novelty but get old very quickly due to some being painfully annoying to find after travelling across multiple zones I've had maps I spent 20+ minutes looking and just opted to abandon it after combing the entire zone multiple times.
Converting glint to gold should have more routes than direct vendoring or caravan runs. Maybe a crowbar that gives 100% resources from cracking open a caravan you've killed but it costs an amount of glint to purchase or use it in crafting to bump up results rarity.
Node War point system should be reworked to account for level discrepancy. I'd suggest something like changing the score cap to 10000 and making it so a level 15 or below killing only gives 1-3 points but a level 25 would give 10.

slim cedar Jan 20, 2025, 9:35 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug where you move items but they don't change location into a back or inventory until after you jump on your mount.
Processing multiple goods in one recipe all have to be the same rarity or it cant be crafted an example of this is the slate mortar needed rare animal fat, and rare slate sand otherwise it cant be crafted.
Hunting rarity bug for the potential mounts and carcasses is skewed to hardly drop a rarity higher then common.
Glint bug where you cant pick up lootable glint after killing a mob. Forces you to log out to loot the mobs glint but then causes the next bug below.
Logout bug - Hard crash with no crash notes when logging out and back in in quick succession. Usually takes 5minutes or less for the crash to occur once you log out and back in.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Tank's need love too especially when it comes to mitigating magic damage. Grit only mitigates physical damage and the silent nerf to iron aura to 2% is practically useless for a tank and party application. A suggestion would possibly be a toggled ability in lieu of iron aura to either only focus tank mitigation for magic damage and the other selection would be a hp shield that would refresh after 10 seconds or so for 5% of the tanks overall HP for the group within 35m.
Searchable by item and rarity in marketplace.
Introduce into the drop table some gathering, processing or crafting shirts/pants/belts into the open world and possibly with some of the harvestable items. Some place other then just raid bosses in the forge.
Take another look at bards please. I witnessed a level 12 bard train 3-4 spiders at level 19-20 and kill them all. Some kiting was involved but he sat there for a couple of seconds and barely took any damage.

humble remnant Jan 20, 2025, 9:36 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Lighting Issues - Extremely dark in a lot of shadowed areas, especially at night.
Graphical Issues - Facial hair stretching across the face into the sky, off hand not showing,
Extreme lag spikes from launcher whilst updating, or in carphin & approaching nodes

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Community needing clarification on whether some behaviours are griefing or not e.g. mob training, harassing low level players to farm glint from their corpses etc.
Lighting is extremely dark - I cannot fathom going into the underdark in later phases with this being the case. The entire sever when pitch black the other night, global chat assumed it was an eclipse or something. Even by adjusting Global Ilumination, it is so difficult to see the detail of anything that has shadows.
Lighting of skills e.g. Cleric abilities need to have an effect on the lighting, currently it looks like a big bright circle in pitch black darkness in dim lit areas.
======================

twin badge Jan 20, 2025, 9:36 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

I have not played phase 2 at all so I can only say that the constant storage and inventory bugs are one of the biggest reasons I'm not playing right now.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Alt trading. I personally dont want to have to ask my friends to help me transfer goods between my characters. In phase 1 it was excruciating to farm hunting on my cleric so I made a mage but needing a friend to trade materials was too tedious.
Flying mounts destabilize the economy. Please reduce the impact that flying mounts have when it comes to gathering resources. My suggestion would be requiring empty material bag slots (1-3) to mount the flyer.
Hunting should always give a live creature. From there you can butcher it or domesticate it. This gives players the choice of how to use the animal and allows you guys to add more detriments such as death or other consumable elements to mounts as per the recent piratesoftware interview.
Gathering materials should be allowed for any tier, but has an increased rate of failure and loss of materials based on the difference between your skill and the skill required to gather a material normally.
This means that nodes will constantly be open to gathering and there will be a large amount of materials sunk by lower level gatherers in exchange for experience and the increased spawn cycling of wanted Lower tier materials.
Remove slows and roots from the immunity to cc that greens get. This will help solve the training of mobs, giving players tools to force greens to contend with these trains. If they cannot outrun the mobs they will need to run away quickly or the enemy team will damage them enough so that the mobs finish them off. Training can still be done, but now players can actually deal with trainers without needing to go red or leave the area.

jagged bough Jan 20, 2025, 9:36 PM

#

Bugs:

Caravan bugs - being kicked off caravan, teleported to Carphin, unable to summon, etc. They are bad.
Exp and loot bugs - still have to log out many times to reset so I can pick up loot and get exp
Inventory and storage bugs - when at storage, items don't transfer to/from inventory smoothly; often have to log out and back in to reset

Topics:

Ungatherable willows - willows are too rare but half the time when you find them they are not gatherable. They should also not share spawn timers/locations with braidwood or other wood that cannot be gathered by the same level gatherer
Tank name - tank is a role; should not be an archetype. Calling tank a tank is the equivalent of a mage archetype being called magic dps instead of mage, or like ranger being called physical ranged dps instead of ranger.
Take rare materials and bosses off timers so they cannot be spawn-camped; bosses should spawn more often than just at server reset

wary jasper Jan 20, 2025, 9:36 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory systems constantly breaking, forced to mount / dismount to temporarily fix until it gets so bad I have to relog.
Rubber banding as you travel across the map.
Corruption baiting. When attacking a corrupted player with his mount submerged in the river you go corrupt for killing his mount and then he uses the stacked weapon exploit (supposedly fixed ) to kill you.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

For the sake of my sanity please get rid of the set quantities at crafting stations. I should be able to set any quantity to the max I have available in my bag. This should be a simple right click or slider.
As it stands there is no downside for an Attacker of a caravan. There should be a reputation score on a moving scale that drops when you attack a caravan. This score should be specific to each node, region and perhaps guild. An example of this system is at X you can not trade in a node, at Y you are KoS in a node/region. This should be a clear scale much like blight.
Guild warehouses/banks are supposed to be on the way. Basic controls must include tabs that limit what may be deposited by item and rarity. Controls must also limit who may withdraw what.
======================

knotty hedge Jan 20, 2025, 9:37 PM

#

rubberbanding

queen widget Jan 20, 2025, 9:38 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Log in is exceptionally slow for myself and my partner. It can at times take upto 30 minutes to log into the game. Its to the point where my partner cant be bothered trying to play and test
NPCs are often located around the world bugged in frozen states or unable to be attacked. I report this when i find them but i feel its to often.
Treasure chest maps quest dont complete on locating treasure chest

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Attempting to locate some of the items required for crafting are difficult esspecially of different quaility. perhaps there could be a processing ability to scale up. example being 10 common to make an uncommon...15 uncommon to make a rare 20 rare to make an heroic and so on...that way the cost of scalling up is extreme but you dont have to waste all the other items you farm
More active quests. I personally love doing quests and hate grinding. Most of my friends are like that. I get its all place holder but maybe a few more would make it more enjoyable
Fast travel. I dont expect this to be over the top like wow. but we shhould be able to hop on a bird or something from each major city to fly to the next major city. I dont have the time to constantly run in circles around the world between work life and kids

vernal wyvern Jan 20, 2025, 9:38 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Terrain and map inconsistency. Majority of the map either has randomly elevated levels, your camera can seen underneath the world in areas. Texture is nonexistent/discolored/smudged.
Inventory and UI. The relationship between inventory and picking up items/receiving items/manipulating items/storage, etc. is extremely bad. UI is constantly changing from the journal saying random text to skills popping up from caravan or horse ride without any input at all. There is no flow of development between the different variations of customization and application (meaning; if I want to drag a log with a horizational 3 like space profile to another spot. If i do not click on the top most spot it will not drag, or the smoothness of dragging doesn't exist).
Vast emptiness. There is plenty of room to have a load of content between travels, HOWEVER. After level 5 (when most working quests are done) it turns into an exp grind fest in a beautifully empty world. There are random farm homes with nothing to them and plenty of space that could be used for some sort of event, quests, resources, pvp or something.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Clean up the UI and make the manual attack mode easier to target enemies (this is vital for tanks)
Develop content to utilize the space that's not being used in this game.
Fix the terrain. This game is too beautiful to be half finished. It has potential to be one of the greatest if you actually fix these problems and many the others are saying.

small yew Jan 20, 2025, 9:38 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Enchant scrolls need to be reworked a little to avoid round to even when applying to base stat (STR, DEX, CON...). Atm, it leads to overenchant apprentice stuff becoming the meta.
Crafting level are too long compared to the adventuring exp. Moreover, the loot percentage for complete items are too high leading to useless crafting for uncommon/rare item. To me, loot full items must be a thing, but it need to be lowered and material loot for craft must be increased. Same for recipes.
Hunting rarity seems strange compared to other profession.
At the moment, it seems it's better to looking for diverse part from named with specific stat (Like INT, STR) than using an armor set. Seems other base stat need balancing to compete.
Bard is overpowered because of wand finisher combine to shock stacks. To me, there is some change to do with shock stack. At the moment, shock is consumed by hit, maybe consume it by damage ? Moreover, it will allow to play with slower weapon instead of looking for only fast weapon.

blissful stump Jan 20, 2025, 9:38 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Various Caravan features not working properly
Clipping when on caravans and riding a horse is ridiculous
latency, rubber banding, chat not responding

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Movement and combat is aces
I'd love a polish to the desert and jungle and other areas
Plz filters on marketplace
======================

steep lava Jan 20, 2025, 9:38 PM

#

Grinding is fun but fighting over spawns to level isn't fun

storm cobalt Jan 20, 2025, 9:42 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan bug that teleports player to another city
Caravan bug that caravan disapears when converting
3.Inventory for certain mateirals does not work. have to use general to have a larger inventory

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Have a countdown to select defend or attack for a caravan. force players to deceide instead of harassing
Be able to loot party and/or guild members without being corrupted
upon death should be 25 percent loss not 50 and all 25 should be recoverable by all players

scenic geyser Jan 20, 2025, 9:42 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory/storage not reading actions of moving inventory items or picking up items while adventuring. Have to relog, and that does not always solve
Rubberbanding
Crashing during important events like caravans or when too many people are in one area

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gatherable spawn timers/locations are predictable.
The importance of mayors coordinating for node buildings, perhaps there could be a tutorial?
3.. Caravan defense and quest rewards, could those be more appealing?
======================

noble trail Jan 20, 2025, 9:43 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mob Behaviour when server is under load. Mobs stop being responsive, aggroing, game feels laggy.
Caravans. Lots of things concerning caravans. If you use a caravan beacon and don't end up finishing the summon it buggs your character out, you have to run to the town where teh caravan is to summon it. Wont let you launch any other caravans. PvP around caravans: when attacking a caravan another player joined the attackign side. When I summoned my own with a beacon that player chose to attack me, but because we were on the same team attacking the previous caravan he was able to attack me, but I couldnt attack him.
Legendary static nodes - people are camping these and getting a lot out of it.
Inventory bugs that require several log out/log in to fix.
Bugged out nodes that show they are there but dont yield anything.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Make legendary nodes random spawns and not static, make node respawn windows have some fluctuation and not be exactly a set amount of time.
Add more gatherables to lawless zones, and make those have higher rarity - this increases risk vs reward.
Performance continues to be an issue, lots of performance issues when a server has been up for a while - this impacts gameplay the most.
Clerics and Bards need to be tuned for pvp - Clerics are very very hard to kill and Bards can one shot you with their stacks.
Keep up the great work.
======================

glacial berry Jan 20, 2025, 9:43 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Mob Behaviour when server is under load. Mobs stop being responsive, aggroing, game feels laggy.
Caravans. Lots of things concerning caravans. If you use a caravan beacon and don't end up finishing the summon it buggs your character out, you have to run to the town where teh caravan is to summon it. Wont let you launch any other caravans. PvP around caravans: when attacking a caravan another player joined the attackign side. When I summoned my own with a beacon that player chose to attack me, but because we were on the same team attacking the previous caravan he was able to attack me, but I couldnt attack him.
Legendary static nodes - people are camping these and getting a lot out of it.

Edit - minor thing, but also having the last played character be the default on the login screen would be nice. Instead of whichever character is at the bottom of the list.

lunar parrot Jan 20, 2025, 9:50 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Toggle abilities are deactivating by themselves (on tank)
Characters teleporting after dismounts and other normal actions
Item transfer from inventory to storage does not always work when right clicking.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Give us back multiple servers in EU. Not everyone wants to play on competitive server (with toxic, bullying, exploiting sweaty murderhobos - let them have their own "competitive" server)
The ban wave for exploiters who built their server advantage on exploiting was too small. Willfull blindness to this will cause players to lose interest in the project. Hopefully you improve this in wave3.
Caravans are imbalanced in terms of having no risk for the attacker. There is no incentive to help defend caravans too.
This was supposed to be a phase for testing economy. Not all life skills are properly implemented though - cooking for example.
Please implement mail system and guild warehouses. Moving materials between characters is a nightmare.
You should remove consumables like food/enchanting scrolls/elixirs from shops. Why would anyone create their own food if better and cheaper food is available in vendor shop?
Please add "search" option for specific items on player market.

civic thistle Jan 20, 2025, 9:50 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bugs requiring relog frequently
Static resource spawns, make all spawns random at random times please!
Gatherables spawning partly underground or in other places that they can't be harvested.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

XP Debt is an utterly stupid and outdated concept. If you want it in the game then make it apply to PvP deaths as well as PvE deaths and we'll see how much the player base likes it.
Beyond XP debt, the amount of materials you drop in death is too much for no good reason.
Allow processing/a sliding amount of gatherables/components ratehr than 1,5,10... and stop making me select the rarity I want to process. The costs to process seem to be the same regardless of rarity, so let me just click a button to process all of that item in my pack, regardless of rarity.
The city gates should close upon a Node War commencing and only citizens can get inside during war. Having the gates open and a horde of hostile players coming into town to murder unsuspecting citizens who didn't vote for any node war is daunting to newer players who only wanted an extra bag slot. For now have node wars outside the city with closed gates so those citizens who WANT to participate can without the Node War affecting the game play of newer leveling players. And add on screen countdowns for citizens when a Node War is going on, not just counters in global which someone may not be reading.

frank rover Jan 20, 2025, 9:52 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

buffs displayed but not active (city artisan buffs for exemple)
Building getting upgraded, destroying everything inside (lost 50+25 green copper because the forge upgraded from apprentice to journeyman)
Quest keep reseting when launching game, losing track

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Being able to press escape to close bag or menu without canceling stances or bard melody
Being able to place the amount we want while crafting having 49/50 is very annoying
(I know those are hard to change cause hard coded)
Loot system, being able to wait and then loot, avoiding rolls is dumb.
Shared glint amongst everyone when glint drops…
Rarity drop, having mining or tree spots dropping better rarity is the stupidest thing on earth (sorry)
Should be random !
Maybe adding caves with rare veins defended by elementals or tree monsters defending a rare spot of trees would be a better solution

Thank you

dense knoll Jan 20, 2025, 9:52 PM

#

feedback -
1 - oce / australia servers please ( at least for the alpha 3 in may ? )
2 - bards seem OP
3 - games years away from release, can we ditch tab target / hybrid and go full action attack ?

vague oracle Jan 20, 2025, 9:53 PM

#

unborn ginkgo Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers! ```Please share your top 3-5 most critic...

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bugs
Being dropped from the server and having to login again
In-game Graphics Issues
Not Enough Resources to Gather to help Gear

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

In-Game Bugs/Issues
Character Progression
Quest feedback and Recommendations

forest depot Jan 20, 2025, 9:53 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory and looting issues have to relog constantly to fix and if you dont wait long enough its still broken.
Monsters teleporting up floors and not leashing properly.
Croc mounts are wa to fast, needs to be adjusted to match other types of mounts.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Ability to process random amount of things for example I dont have 5 logs but I have 4 let me process max of 4?
Guilds are pretty massive kinda bad if you dont want to be in a zerg you only see three guilds running caravans because they have hundreds of people.

upper mauve Jan 20, 2025, 9:54 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Storage/Looting/Inventory Issues: Most of the time, there are issues with looting from bodies such as not being able to pickup the item in the mobs inventory, to it staying there and in your bag. Then going to the Storage, you can’t right click to add items or actually even move the items over without having to relog each time.
Griefers Training Mobs/Hostiles: This is still happening all over the place. They will drag these mobs onto others then loot the corpses of those they killed via mobs. If this can’t be fixed, then these people should be flagged as murderers.
Desync of resources and other areas: Often I run across resources and see them, but when I go to gather them, they aren’t there. I relog and see that there is nothing there to harvest. Many people are thinking they aren’t just harvestable, but in fact, the graphic is there, but it is a shadow of what was.
UI Party/Friends Lists: If you log or lose connection but you haven’t ungrouped, then you look like you are not in a party when you come back and have to be kicked from the party to readd you. I also find that the friends/guild list tends to fluctuate similarly. If you log on, you may not see anyone on (including in Guild) but when log out and back on, they are showing again.
Mounts freezing at different times: It seems that many times the mount you are on will seem to get stuck or freeze when they transition from one level to another on the terrain. You will have to dismount and unsummon, then resummon to fix.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Marketplace: Great concept, but currently it is cumbersome. The search is horrible, doesn’t find all types of what you put in. You can’t even type out exactly for what you are looking for and it find it. We need a way to actually select filters, not only for type, but rarity’s to add to the search.
Chat System: Need to add a Looking for Group and a Trade Section. These sections need to be completely removed from the General Chat.
Guild: We need the ability to change our members from recruits, to officers, and perhaps a another for members that passed their recruitment stage. In addition we seriously need a guild bank that members can add too, and GM and any assigned member(s) can distribute from. It would be nice to have a guild log as well so we can see who is donating the items and who is withdrawing.
4: Freeholds: It seems several gathered the money (hopefully not during the duping) and purchased freeholds. However going by there, you are seeing nothing being utilized. There needs to be some sort of decay timer, that exists, for those not utilizing them. For them to sit there not being tested or utilized is a bit daunting. We are suppose to be testing, unless they are testing for abandonment, seems a waste.
Caravans: There are a lot of issues with Caravans. That is saying it lightly I know. Some are converting from wheeled to raft, you can often times lose them. There is or hasn’t been any payout from the system that I am aware of for defenders, unless whoever is asking for the help pays them. Then there is the issue of finally, miraculously making it to your destination. You lose the supplies at the finish line to bugs or, my favorite, getting there and to the commodities vendor and not being able to sell them to him. I given up on caravans until it is fixed. Which for me is terribly inconvenient for to continue testing animal husbandry, it costs money. So yes, please fix Caravans, from defending/attacking, to bugs on converting, and finally to acquisition of your supplies and selling. Thanks.
======================

runic socket Jan 20, 2025, 9:56 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory not updating - moving or deleting an item does not apply or show until after logging out and back in. New items cannot be added to the free space created until doing the logout/login.
NPC aggro and leashing - aggro and leashing operate in frustrating ways resulting in other players unintentionally and intentionally dumping pursuing NPCs onto other players or mounts. NPCs leash, heal to full, then return to player at full health (likely due to DOT effects)
Mounts frequently come to a dead stop as they hang up on server region zone lines. NPCs seem unaffected by this.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Artisan system: Gathering should be removed from artisan progression limit entirely or allow 4 gathering skills and 3 processing skills as the limit. More players able to have more gathering skills will maintain a steady supply of materials available within guild/node groups and on the market. Too much rarity only ensures player frustration.
Rangers seriously need a small self-heal or vampyric damage returned as health ability. It seems to be the only class that significantly struggles with multiple equal level opponents.
Gathering nodes need a randomization added to their spawn timers. Current system allow monopolization of resources by players with unlimited free time. This will also be highly exploited by for profit game farmers.

sleek haven Jan 20, 2025, 9:57 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Training Mobs onto other groups is far to easy of a thing to do
Mobs getting stuck in walls (Mostly Mages @ Carph)
Shield won't stay visible on character

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I think when a player runs a pack of mobs onto a group they should run back to their spawn location first or at least need a considerable amount of threat before they focus new group
More Guild UI functions, Guild banners & logos
More drama

wide magnet Jan 20, 2025, 9:59 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

My character has a recurring graphical error, looks like a stick coming out of my back on Dunir male dwarf all the time (ambitious academics pants uncommon)
New Aela warehouse spacing bugged. Swapping items around fixes it.
Mount freezing in motion.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Grouping / Chat systems functions to help find people to group or trade with outside guilds.
Solo player experience. There are a few areas on the map to solo farm by farming multiple mobs at once. Should this be the only way to level solo? If so there needs to be more areas to do this in, as they quickly become saturated. Can I suggest artisan crafting has a larger impact to xp gain?
Need more higher tier nodes to gather from. You can reduce the impact to the economy by reducing the chance of higher rarity to be more in line with T1s. If you don't do this, people need to search for HOURS to find a handful of nodes to gather from. It's much more fun (imo) to have a constant supply (think ash tree farming) but the chance at high tiers is lower.

midnight grove Jan 20, 2025, 10:00 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Bard Resonance stacks / blowing up 40 shocked stacks with wand. 40 stacks of shocked is absolutely ridiculous 5 auto with a finisher can do 3k-4k damage, this can only happen on bard because of resonance stacks and the interaction with wand and shocked stacks. Other classes applying 10 stacked of shocked is very strong, who ever thought 40 stacks of shocked was ok to be in the game is off their rocker.
2. Caravans still have a lot of bugs
3. Using tank protect to flag players purple in a caravan event exploiting
4. Healing out of event, stop letting players heal out of event turn the ability to heal out of event off or start handing out more suspensions, a lot of the same people are doing it over and over purposely and it is exploiting.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Gear scale is still too wide the bottom of the barrel compared to top end gear needs to be adjusted, if it’s nerfed PLEASE, do not nerf the armor values and the mobs do need lower hp. Currently it feels like if I want to compete with top end guilds / players I have to get full crafted/enchanted gear, I can get a lot of gear and compete but the sad fact is then when I run into random Timmy just trying to have fun in some caravan PvP for example the Timmy has no gear and gets 2-3 shot, I want the overall scale to be smaller so gear doesn’t feel like the biggest factor when it comes to running into random PvP. I want good fight but then some of the Timmy’s I run into randomly just get deleted too fast, it’s bad for the game the gear scaling needs to be smaller overall.
Caravan join event as party PLEASE
People are still super toxic and say ridiculous off the wall things in global chat with no consequences, impersonating people is become a very common thing and it’s just super weird, it’s targeted harassment and you guys don’t moderate chat the best.
Put the world bosses on consistent 4-8 hour timers, let everyone have a chance at world bosses, before servers were being reset in the middle of NA night time now they are just doing it randomly or when they have patches so there is no consistency with bosses, the only world boss of the day should not spawn at 2am on an NA server please just let the bosses spawn more frequently and consistently so everyone has a chance to fight for them.
======================

unique smelt Jan 20, 2025, 10:02 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Freeholds need instanced quicker if testing is wanted on farming etc. pointless trying farming without it
Too many un-gatherable resources in world
Cannot ID guild owned assets like Caravans, Corpses on ground, Marketplaces
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Tax receipts rework pay with glint ? sold in 20 units takes too much space and auto pay from bank option , cannot prepay what if I am AFK IRL ?
Storage Clerk crates and probably Marketplace Stalls need item limits brought into line with Material bags 20 is too low when my bag I carry can hold far larger stacks
Further balancing of Artisans Low level seems almost redundant , Rarity Lowest and highest seems to be sought low for levelling, high for crafting items. Noone seems to buy anything in between. I do Love that any one person cannot max all Artisans and causes reliability of others and a detailed plan of what you want to be.
Fishing check to stop AFK not being forced to move as fishing in other games is annoying to find spots, it should be casual but not without limit. Other fishing needs, perhaps rotten fish being used as fertilizer as an alternative to droppings ? Treasure maps/chests. 5. Player equipment/assets needs a better sync if player economy is going to work, permanent Mounts and equipment although nice just reduce the requirement to have processing/crafting. Economy and Trading can only really work if there is a need for me to buy/renew my things , Right now mounts sell for far less than they cost to train. I have heard ideas of lifecycles of 30 days but even this seems too long to me. ======================

north sundial Jan 20, 2025, 10:04 PM

#

Top Bugs : 1, the need to relog to fix loot drops or exp regularly... 2. Mounts breaking and stopping animations..3. caravan exploits. ......::: Top feedback. Please find a solution to some of the resource bottle necks.. like Willow. its all and well to use a resource to make wheat but perhaps Oak would be a better choice. ... 2 . Thinks worked so much better when the rider of a carravan was protected within the van. ..3. Super remote locations should have nice resources to.. places that require a bit of puzzle jumping to gain access to. Or perhaps chest to find. Also please seed more resources into the new lands.

royal pagoda Jan 20, 2025, 10:04 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

One-sided PVP flagging allowing someone to disrupt/grief (and steal) gathering nodes with the target not flagged/corrupted (while outside the lawless areas).
NPC pathing, particularly on stairs, sometimes causing issues (saw this at roof of Church of the Seven Stars in particular).
Happy little event exploits as others have discussed.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting recipes that require less commonly spawning materials (metals, gems, willows) should be adjusted downward in quantity to allow smoother progression (FOR NOW) due to scarcity of some materials. Scribing, for example, requires rubies only, and no other inks despite those being produced at Novice too. To better test crafting, we have to be able to craft, even though it does pose a threat to item economy (again, FOR NOW). See also weapon & armor smithing recipes.
UI QoL - whose caravan event am I joining? Would make the attacker/defender AND IGNORE buttons all "push and hold to do this" (ignore button would lose the confirmation dialog and just be a push to hold).
I would love to be able to have my chat window settings save so I can filter my windows. ;.;

north acorn Jan 20, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Gathering nodes remaining in the world after harvesting them, still interactable.
Invisible enemies being able to attack you.
Higher tier gathering nodes pushing out lower tier ones.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The current marketboard system is awful to search through, since it only searches store names.
There's a strong bias in crafting/processing towards either having the best quality (for use) or the worst quality (for leveling). There needs to be some incentive to use "middle" quality resources, perhaps increased experience from processing/crafting.
Enemy leashing lasts forever. I'm not sure if this a bug or not, but it feels bad.
======================

grave tundra Jan 20, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory doesn't update and you have to relog
Items being lost in trades
Why am i bald?

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Flying mounts
Marketplace
Guildbank
======================

tropic nexus Jan 20, 2025, 10:05 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Desync Desync Desync. Running on a horse for 3-5 minutes just to get off and teleport to where you started is tough.
UI bugs on party frames. Tough to heal when the X on your party showing they can't be healed refuses to appear.
I've had people bug out driving a caravan, the caravan becomes untargetable or disappears entirely, and then I was stuck for hours pvp flagged against the defenders.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Players who don't flag for Caravan pvp should not be able to resurrect those fighting. Easy fix, if you die in pvp, there should be a 5 minute timer, and anyone rezzing you should go purple if they choose to rez.
Players who try to ninja the loot from a destroyed caravan should be immediately flagged and killable by both the attackers and defenders.
Choosing attacker/defender when there are multiple grouped caravans is a guessing game. UI should reflect the information on who owns the caravan.

tardy pond Jan 20, 2025, 10:08 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Critical Boss Respawn.
Arrowstorm passive from the shotbow tree should damage for 5% from your damage per projectile. In general way with auto attacks it works as expected. BUT when you have arrowstorm bug and you use Barrage, each arrowstorm projectile use damage formula from Barrage (15% projectile). It is critical because arrowsrom does x3 damage from normal. And this broken mechanic is used to oneshot people. Video starts from 12s: https://youtu.be/KwH9pCo2n7E?t=12
Critical Boss Respawn
Please FIX\DISABLE boss respawn after restart. You should disable this or add 30-60 min after restart. Because depending on the patch download speed people can't regroup in time. Also better to increase HP poll for x10 or dynamically depends on how many peoples in fight. Because a raid in 60-80 people kills a boss in 1 min.
Seeds rarity for freeholds doesn't work. You can plant a legendary one and get a common willow.
Caravans! Sometimes you can heal without joining attackers/defenders. That is a serious problem that breaks the event!

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Server degradation during mass PvP. Not seeing the battlefield is a serious problem. Please speed up with the server mashing tech.
Need a storage for the clan/party! It is a nightmare to organize resource movement between party members
Caravans! You have to leave the party to register as Attackers/Defenders and then rejoin the raid. This is PAINFUL! Please add an option to invite everyone in the guild! Inviting 30+ people is madness
======================

YouTube

_nda_

2025 01 17 00 32 21

▶ Play video

timid isle Jan 20, 2025, 10:10 PM

#

Bugs

Desync is a large problem at the moment. Teleporting back and losing 5-10 minutes of travel time sucks.
Ui and Graphical bugs such as with the party frames as well as tank shields vanishing
Still persistent glitches such as hair vanishing from your character when you cross certain areas.
Memory Leak causing you to have to reboot every few hours and also Ashes negatively clashing with programs such as OBS when you attempt to run them at the same time.

dull crow Jan 20, 2025, 10:11 PM

#

Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Please share your top 3-5 most critical issues or feedback topics in the thread below using the following format:

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.visual bug, tank has shield equipped but disappears as soon as engaged in combat.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Roads giving a x% movement speed buff if following.
======================

hexed umbra Jan 20, 2025, 10:12 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mount bug sometimes when you dismount it teleport you back
Bags not updating their content
Invisible mobs
Quest tracking and rendering on map
Some stats on item when they have supérior rarity (artisan mostly)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Show important buff / debuff on raid frames
Hunting rarity
Caravan stability
Low tier ressources rarity (copper, zinc ...)

hidden galleon Jan 20, 2025, 10:12 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Inventory bugs
Desync/Ghost players/Cull distance volume and some shit like that in pvp
Attack/defend a caravan as a group with a simple confirmation for all without disbanding the group or passing the lead to each members...
All other existing bugs relating to caravans...

pallid knoll Jan 20, 2025, 10:13 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mob pathing
Gatherable rarity procs are not the same across all gathering types (mining rarity procs happen a lot more than hunting procs)
Inventory bugging out requireing you to restart to see what gatherables you have collected, or which items you have put into your storage

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

MarketPlace searchability needs improvement
The introduction of gatherables needs to coincide with the introduction of craftables (recipes) or else the economy will struggle.
3.randomization of gatherable spawn rates/rarities

shadow flare Jan 20, 2025, 10:14 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Guild War Declaration abuse. Ban the exploiters. Permanently.
Rubberbanding and teleporting across the map when umounting
Static rarity. It ruins the market

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Class Balance. Bards are by far the strongest.
More severe punishment for people actively abusing exploits
Crafting. Almost everything needs weeping willow and tanned raptor hide. It's not balanced

loud relic Jan 20, 2025, 10:15 PM

#

flagging whole group as raid or party
flower rarity and alchemy cost

topaz snow Jan 20, 2025, 10:16 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bard unable to rest with song active
Rubberbanding back to a previous location while traveling
Unable to loot all treasure chest items from maps

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please provide specific things you would like to have the community test - to improve alpha engagement
Bug-bounties or other bug finding events with rewards would be a great way to drive engagement and gather bugs
Keep up the great work!

crimson valley Jan 20, 2025, 10:17 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Glint pickup randomly being disabled
2.when entering new nodes or city zones on map getting regularly stuck on am invisible wall (lyneth server)
Since most recent update sometime mobs will "despawn" for me individually I can't see nor damage them even with aoe can be very lethal especially as a solo player

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

When selecting a chat type to view automatically set that as the chat I type to
2.mounts feel terrible to jump with making off road travel either frustrating or slow due to having to get off despawn resummon
Whirlwind gets canceled by auto attack if you have it on and use it in the middle of an auto combo if this isn't intended for skill expression is extremely frustrating
======================

Lastly thanks for all your work and wonderful game much love to the team

hybrid dawn Jan 20, 2025, 10:20 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

NPC terrain collision. NPCs clipping through walls and the ground when trying to LOS behind terrain is painful.
Spells and abilities clipping through walls. Ex. 4th floor Carphin, using Consecrating Wave toward the center of the tower will damage and pull mobs on the other side of the wall.
Carphin Teleporter bug. Attempting to use the Carphin 4th floor teleporter and having to relog feels bad.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Market place interaction is awful. I know a revamp is planned for later, but adding another text field that is uneditable and only populates from the item names and qualities would go a long way to fix the current pain. Ex. Instead of having to call your Market stall: "Legendary Copper" have a separate tag field populate with "Legendary Copper" when that item is for sale.
Avoid naming items by a single common phrase. Ex. Instead of "Copper" call it "Copper Ore" This makes searching much easier.
Players use the Unstuck button as a Hearthstone. I know a cooldown was added, but if the intent is for it to be a Hearthstone, then just rename it something like "Recall" and formalize it. If the intent is to not have a Hearthstone, then treat it like a death without recovering items, i.e. Exp debt + lose 1/2 of carried materials. Alternatively, have it send the user to the closest Embershrine instead of their Home Embershrine.

pure vapor Jan 20, 2025, 10:21 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top Most Important Feedback Topic:

Align crafting batch sizes with storage stack sizes (5,10,15,20,40)
Make crafting batch sizes dynamic. If I have 12 items, let me craft 12 items
Rework the Marketplace. We should to be able to search for specific items you have in database
Introduce notifications when crafting jobs are finished. Either in a dedicated chat channel or smth similar

amber stag Jan 20, 2025, 10:26 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

invisible mobs
Inventory bug
I haven't really encountered anything breaking yet.. though have mostly only done combat because (see below)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Entry level resources too rare, apprentice should be maybe a lower level, 7 or 5?
Debuffs on the party frames are GREAT, however tracking debuffs on yourself needs its own UI widget to separate from the buffs.

======================

errant mauve Jan 20, 2025, 10:26 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
🐎 1. Mount Animations.
🗜️ 2. Stuck Mounts.
👩‍🏫 3. Mob Training.

2.rubberbanding is getting noticably worse. Any alleviation of this would be very welcome!

regal otter Jan 21, 2025, 3:57 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory not functioning, unable to loot items, move items in bags or storage without relogging or mounting and remounting
Caravans just disappearing if you disconnect or on shaky SW crossing
Desynching while traveling then getting ported back to a point in your travel route.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

If permanent durability becomes a thing then allow the owner of the item to be able to take it to an artisan of that type to have the permanent durability to be reset by using some of the original crafting materials.
Allow processing to select the quantity of items to process in any amount up to a max to be determined.

tough fossil Jan 21, 2025, 4:00 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

pvp mode sometine you see pvp in pvp but there are not so you are curupted when kill then
roll back when you go back a mount
3.Hunting has problems with rarity

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

pls give us more wipping willow its only guild with free hold can have them
hunting rarity is a huge probleme for everyone
pls nerf currupted effect

spice trench Jan 21, 2025, 4:00 AM

#

bugs : 1 players exploiting of npc for exp and or profit of glint.. 2: pathing or mobs or npc by agro.. ie players running thru areas and jumping over you to get agro on you and you group. this is intentional and is destroying proper gameplay for pve players. The same problem was left uncorrected in New World Beta and the player base decreased and the game was no longer attractive. 3- high lvl player griefing and group griefing for profit, high lvl players such as shroomsforvets and ethani from a rouge guild name nuerotic savages on vyra server go into lower lvl areas, demand payment for protection from agro trains. when you dont pay they say enjoy your death exp of 100k . they run thru the area not getting injured or even hit while attracting 5 to 7 npc mobs and running them thru your group.. thus killing you and your group. after you die they steal your loot. they come back later demand money again or else. if you attack them they let you kill them because you are now corrupt and then the high lvl characters kill you and loot you and your gear. this is ruining the game play, it is destroying the quality of the game for thos of us that want to enjoy the game at all lvls. Along with pvp we want to learn and enjoy it but what is enjoyable about fighting for 5 hours to get enough exp for a lvl and som asshat thats bored because he was able to reach 25 is now running around harrasing your player base.

rich marten Jan 21, 2025, 4:00 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

inventory lag and needing to relog to receive items from crafting and or looting
falling through the earth when logging in and the earth being missing after it puts you at the emberspring
mobs getting stuck in terrain

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

sitting in one spot of a dungeon to kill the same packs of mobs is extremely boring. giving us a 1 instance per day lockout would go a long way in the entertainment of the game.
crafting is very tedious. it takes no less than 12 minutes to craft an apprentice level belt not including gathering time. this feels like a chore and or job. this is not fun
i love the combat system and it would be great to have an instance with an actual boss that we can do as part of our 8 man parties. the world bosses have already turned into "who can dps the hardest" and is very boring and or not interesting.
======================

lilac ruin Jan 21, 2025, 4:03 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Training mobs to grief other parties

2.Trees and other gatherables being halfway in the ground or farther(like the trees surrounding Winstead that are almost completely in the ground)

when mining you get the xp for the node you mine but you dont get the ore/rock/gem in your inventory until you log out and log back in. this has been something that is happening to myself and other more and more often.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

1.Make spawns for things like willow random locations. tired of seeing people log in on a tree timer chop willow or farm a boss then log out. it makes for a horrible experience for other testers in progression and game play

Griefers and Exploiters deserve harsher punishments (we all know the numbers dropped by steven werent even half the amount of people exploiting douping or being generally shit)

3.We need mats in game that match the level we are able to get to in professions. I.E we need animal fat to make slate molds for things like JM Mining, Lumberjacking, but epic and legendary are almost completely non existent. it would be beneficial for everyone if we were able to obtain mats like these(some people say they arent even in game yet)

======================

idle kelp Jan 21, 2025, 4:05 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory desync is still an issue and can get daunting having to relog so often
Similarly, The caravans are still teleporting people
Rarity across hunting and other gathering items seems like it is not working as intended?
caravan get stuck in inventory cause i cant deploy it in its original node - so no further caravan deploying is possible cause i have one in my inventory rdy for deploying ?!

static bridge Jan 21, 2025, 4:10 AM

#

Raptors being one of the largest bottlenecks and having so few spot points is a pretty big pain point.

tall jungle Jan 21, 2025, 4:12 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

certain enemies phase through tank while shielding( mostly tank arch-type mobs)
Having your mount get stuck while running into a jumping animation
inventory un-syncing and not updating

3.Processing is quite unintuitive currently, processing 4 or 5 different items through different professions will probably be a good thing for the economy in the long run, however while the market is currently hard to search for, and processing can only happen in specific steps and not with a slider to set the amount really takes a lot of unneccesary time. This all adds with the Inventory UI being not great. Finding some combination of changes that makes a few of these steps a little easier would be greatly appreciated

stoic bramble Jan 21, 2025, 4:18 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Ban all the exploiters
Fix the resource node spawns around the map so as they are completley random and not fixed at server resets
Fix the croc mount's land speed ASAP

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resource node system needs to be 100% random.
Fix things you say that you are fixing, and if not fixed state that it's not fixed but work in progress.
Market place should be allowed to search any market place, but on purchase have to ride to that node to collect your goods.

fathom mulch Jan 21, 2025, 4:22 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Graphics setting optimization pass to help prevent crashes.
Fixing the loot bug preventing you from looting mobs. (Currently have to log to loot probably 40% of the time when the bug occurs)
Caravan flagging bugs. Half the time you have to drop party to flag. Or if you flag incorrectly there is no way to drop and reflag. And flagging remains for far too long after. (Sometimes you’re shown as flagged and never even flagged on the caravan)
Completing the mayoral commissions which take resources from you should allow you to add the resources to the quest for completion. Not just blindly take all of your rare weeping willow. (Yeah, I got burned) 😖

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The graphics optimization feels important because I worry about the health of my pc components and the memory leaks and maxed cpu/gpu usage spikes feel scary.
People are still getting attacked in towns. New tactic I’ve seen is one person going corrupt killing and training the guards away while their guild members loot all the bodies and run.
alternative, and viable, leveling. Primarily the topic of gaining primary levels through artisanship work. (Swinging a pickaxe is just as tough as swinging a mace)
======================

vagrant trail Jan 21, 2025, 4:28 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Traveling really far on a mount only to be teleported almost back to the beginning of your journey when you arrive at your destination and dismount.
invisible enemies that one person in your party can see and fight but you can not since on your client the mob is still in its starting position. This makes it extremely difficult in situations.
3.Gathering nodes remaining visible after being harvested so you interact and nothing happens.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.Please allow gathering tools to be replaceable at the very least so if you upgrade rarity or downgrade tier you are not completely out of already difficult to obtain materials. I understand not being able to remove them completely but at least having the ability to swap and regain the previous tool would be very helpful.
2.An addition of another lumberjacking apprentice and journeyman recource. This would vastly help alleviate the use of willow in every recipe if there were more types of the same level. Or at the very least change recipes to implement some lumber from the novice tier when an apprentice or higher tier is already being added. Everything calls for willow its too heavy handed when novice tier has 4 wood types spread out among recipes.
3. Please add focus target for healing or other purposes. it is hard to see what an enemy is casting or to retarget an enemy in some cases where if there was a focus target it would help manage party health and damage output or at least an enemy list with all the enemies that your party currently has aggro on. This being different than the current dual target system that for moves with dual purpose will chose to do damage over heal. Another fix way to address this would be to simply allow multipurpose moves some way to differentiate when using dual targeting.
4. Salvaging for crafting to even have a chance to obtain some recourses back would be nice.

lunar harbor Jan 21, 2025, 4:34 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Rangers go through mana way to fast
As a gatherer it is hard to get glint to pay taxes. would be nice if there was another way to pay for taxes than glint.
Having a bow that only rangers can use. Right now when a bow drops there is 3-5 people rolling for it and usaully the ranger that needs it doesn't get it.

fresh gate Jan 21, 2025, 4:37 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Loot bugs are still happening pretty frequently - gathering or looting and things not showing up until a relog, or being unlootable until relog.
Mounts bugging out and taking off without you after dismount, still freezing in place while riding them. A simple recalling of the mount fixes the issue.. still strange though.
NPC movement and pathing. This is pretty bad. I was in town today in Miraleth and all the villagers were walking in place, completely in sync. Enemy agro radius seems either insanely far or non-existant, no matter the level gap between you and the mob. Enemies follow you for quite a while when running even while mounted. I have noticed recently that some mobs are becoming more mobile while out of combat, which is definitely making the game feel more 'alive'! That feels good!

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

On the world map, it would be nice to have party members be marked a little clearer. Maybe have the markers be slightly enlarged each time you zoom further out? It's extremely hard to find other party members if they aren't very close.
The adaptive world as it is changing through the seasons is amazing. Every time I log in, there is more snow. Looks like winter already! Maybe scale back the progression a smidge, we still have 9 days of Fall left! I am worried about winter haha! The game is beautiful, I continue to be amazed every time I log in.
Being able to cycle through the character screen with the up and down arrows and log in with enter would be an amazing update

muted stag Jan 21, 2025, 4:45 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Gathering resources are not random!
Inventory sync/servers sync
Fix gathering resources in freehold

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please make Wednesday and Thursday offline days instead of Thursday and Wednesday!

wheat bloom Jan 21, 2025, 4:48 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Items not moving between inventories cleanly.
NPC's getting stuck and unattackable. Tracking and movement of them fixed.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Come up with better shop, player market design. I don't think searching by item type will convey a proper economic platform for city life. For example a search "Ruby" that shows all Ruby's in all shops and there prices on one return page. The idea if you spend time looking for a deal has appeal. But the current sort and searching is to burdensome. Longer description perhaps. Item type filters that only return shops that actually have that type actively listed for sale. Please do not flatten the economy by creating a true search all shops by item name market place.
Requisitions for node development are difficult for individuals to participate in. They are typically 2 items of opposing or differing enough crafting professions that typically 1 player will not be advanced in both. A contribution system that allows single item type contributions to the final product seems logical. Why would a town reject my stone because I didn't have the wood as well to make a final product. Partial reward for partial contribution?
Collision detection with terrain edges mounts seem overly sensitive.

half hazel Jan 21, 2025, 5:07 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Healers being able to rez and heal outside of events like caravans, they don’t flag attacker or defender and heal people in the event and we can’t attack them
riding in caravan and getting somehow teleported to Carphin
Caravans cause extreme lag and crashes when you have a few on your screen
Caravans simply disappearing and unrecoverable
The recover caravan doesn’t recover says it destroys it ???
People can still log out and caravan disappears after a short amount of time

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please fix caravan systems
please ban exploiting abusers, especially repeat offenders
reduce respawns on materials and named bosses waiting 2 to 4 hours with little space and tons of players for willow or tin and 20 to 40 mins to farm a craft item from a named mob to many players on such a tiny map
======================

fallow star Jan 21, 2025, 5:08 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

chain lightning does not apply any stacks of shocked if the target has volatile, like it should
The Gathering bag bugs are still quite anoying where they become desynced? And stop visually updating. game thinks it might be full and showing as full when you remove an item ect.
Bronze hoop earring doesnt show up in crafting menu for the app bench. i cant make it even though i know the recipe
Gatherable rarities need to be more random. we can find where all the legendries are and just set a timer for them

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Players outlevel crafting far too quickly. we get level 20s+ out there before even apprentice stations are up and before people can even craft themselves enough novice gear to fill out missing slots.
Item deconstruction is needed for small crafting exp and recycling of materials. please
It should be a higher priority on your list to fix being able to CC or stun an unflagged player perhaps.

cold jasper Jan 21, 2025, 5:09 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Party System not holding state after relog
Loot system bugging out where you can not loot and you need to relog
Bank bags for specific materals not allowing for higher stacks then 20.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Highwaymen Hill High level players training mobs and wiping multiple partys need to be address
Pyromancers in Highwaymen Hill needs to be toned down a bit
Copper/Zinc is to rare and is a major stopper for a lot of early progression

grand quarry Jan 21, 2025, 5:19 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravan Drivers being targetable - this will not allow newer players to begin caravans and even certain classes that can't win 1v1s will diminish the number of caravans out in the world, reducing content. It also means people won't have as much time to respond to a caravan to help it (or to gather to attack it if it escalates) because it will stop moving with the death and running back of the driver. We helped someone defend his caravan tonight and he didn't even come back to it after dying so much, he just logged out of the game, possibly to never return even after we saved him from the attackers, whispering that he was done and didn't care anymore...

======================

digital kettle Jan 21, 2025, 5:20 AM

#

Weekly Feedback- Critical: Please Read

1. Lack of In-Game Organizational Systems
Currently, there is a noticeable gap in systems designed to facilitate player organization. Introducing an ease-of-access system for managing alliances, factions, guilds, and vassals would be immensely beneficial. Features like in-game contracts, scheduling tools for events, and robust tooltips would greatly enhance coordination. Social and organizational tools are essential for building a thriving community and ensuring long-term player engagement. Without these systems, servers risk becoming stagnant within months, potentially jeopardizing the game's longevity.

2. Critical Healing Mechanic
To my knowledge, critical healing is not currently implemented in the game. Adding this mechanic would significantly impact gameplay for healing-focused classes, particularly the Cleric. If this feature already exists and I have overlooked it, I would appreciate clarification. However, if absent, I strongly recommend its inclusion as it would enhance the depth and effectiveness of the healing role.

3. Expanded PvP Game Modes
While the current alpha provides foundational PvP content such as node wars and conflicts, I believe additional PvP modes are necessary for the game's success. Incorporating features like arenas, open-field skirmishes, or special PvP events would help sustain and grow the PvP community. Expanding these options would ensure that PvP remains engaging and dynamic as the game evolves.

Thank you for your hard work and dedication to creating an incredible gaming experience. I appreciate the opportunity to provide feedback and look forward to seeing how the game continues to develop.

gentle drift Jan 21, 2025, 5:22 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

UI Hard Target and soft target aiming tool: As a healer, I will have the tank on hard target and his target as soft target. This UI stop working from time to time, if it isn't caught in time. The whole party whips because the tank go down from no heals because i am healing my self with no target.
The inventory bug, I know it seem small but I really like a right click option to quickly transfer item from one column to another.
Caravan are still bugging out at zone progression. zone or node or little tile I cross will send me across map to span while the caravan disappear until I get on the right tile/zone/node
NPC show up as allies, flag player. Not having them not be there but attack like they are there need to be top on the list. dieing from a npc you can not target or even know was there is a issue.
the party bug issue when you log out and back in, and the bug that make your weapons disappear when you claim a hunt animal.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Amazing you all have done so far. love to see your work.

unique pier Jan 21, 2025, 5:24 AM

#

Weekly Feedback 1/21/2025:

Inventory bug is still a thing. Either having to mount/dismount or relog completely it takes up a ton of extra time that would be nice spent elsewhere. This goes along with looting corpses as well. Sometimes need to mount/dismount or relog to loot glint.
PVP time to kill - numbers need adjusting in pvp. Skill is irrelevent in medium-large scale battles. It only takes 2 or sometimes even 1 geared mage to kill someone in under 5 seconds.
Gathering system - Do not like the way the gathering system currently works. Allows for camping of a high quality spawn on cooldown and feels like there is no point in gathering rarity. Better system would be the mining vein or the tree to randomly roll quality upon being mined or chopped.

timber dew Jan 21, 2025, 5:25 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Server workers either making your caravan go poof or teleporting you back to Carphin.
Inventory/ Storage not registering until a mount up.
Since holidays and the team came back and patched the game, stability and rubber banding has been worse. Whatever the patches did it hasn't been enjoyable registering 10 minutes travel backwards.

Thanks Y'all having a blast! Keep up the good work!

restive bobcat Jan 21, 2025, 6:12 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Carvan TP, Healing out of event and the ability to Snipe Drivers outof caravans. Its allready basically impossible to drive a caravan without at least another 8 people.
2. Inventory Not working as intended
3. Treasure Molds sometimes dont spawn

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Static Spawn locations with fixed rarity basically incentives Node camping with twinks and it funnels a lot of rare resources into a small amount of people.
I brought Weaponsmithing with a lot of effort to apprentice and now its basically useless bc higher quality slate weapon molds are so expensive bc of the low rarity of animal fat, its more or less worthless to skill further/Build weapons for Others. Even when making common weapons to skill its always at a loss.
Treasure Maps: There should be a more "fun" way to find the treasure mold. Right now its just running in circles in the area hoping to find the mold, even tough it sometimes wont even spawn or u find the mold of someone else. And it should not be necessary to turn down ur graphics to even find them reliable. Maybe something with getting in the area, finding something easy to find that guides u in the right direction ? 4. Combat feels very different if u do PvE vs PvP. Mobs are pretty ok were they are now, if u fight something higher lvl or with stars u really should avoid their ability's and focus on the fight. In PvP on the other hand is just "who oneshots first". The defensive stats are not "felt" in anyway in most combat situations in PvP, especially with better gear. a Possible Solution could be to Up the defensive stats or make them more effective and up the dmg of the NPCs to keep their strength. But in PvP it would allow a real dance between opponents. Ofc if u are far outnumbered u still wont stand a chance, but it shouldn't be in 1v1 that if someone attacks first he always wins. At least in my opinion.
======================

covert herald Jan 21, 2025, 6:15 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug is still happening
Mount Freezes
Mount keeps getting stuck on even small slopes fix his jump over slopes

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

people who attacked players or steal your things are flag way too short , extend their PVP flag to last longer because they keep getting away with a murder !
Improve economy and some trade crafts , for example taming becomes redundant way too fast , everyone gets a mount so you can't sell them to anyone, there is no demand for tier 1 .. and vendor only gives you 6 copper for a mount you invested like 65 silver ... as result new player can never level it unless in a huge guild to help them with taming cost ... makes no sense!
make mounts stats better for more valuable rarity, at this point its all same !
======================

To keep the thread organized, we kindly ask that you avoid back-and-forth discussions, and stick to the format above for your posts. We'll be closing the thread at <t:1737482400:F>

Important Note: While we greatly value your insights, please understand that we cannot guarantee all bugs or feedback topics will be addressed, or provide a specific timeframe for fixes.

Thank you for your continued support, feedback, and dedication to improving the Alpha Two experience! :flamingphoenix:

rain palm Jan 21, 2025, 6:15 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory desync causing item loss
Location desync causing you to warp backward very far after traveling on a mount
Mobs becoming stuck in geometry or weird locations and they become uninteractable after players run away to leash them, in Carphin especially this ends up removing many available mobs to kill and causes issues with an already busy xp area.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Loot system in general has some major design flaws. If a player waits to loot an item until its "open loot" to anyone, it is not shown in the loot log when someone loots an item and players are actively exploiting this to avoid rolling for items. People with more active roles in a group (like pulling mobs into a camp) are often losing all of their loot opportunities to less active players just scooping up others glint piles and there is no way to see who is doing it. Same goes for loot that should be rolled on.

thick lake Jan 21, 2025, 6:17 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Inventory bug. Loot something and it doesn't show. Or can't loot things. etc.
2.Invisible Mobs attacking.
3.Mob trains still go after others just standing doing nothing.

surreal timber Jan 21, 2025, 6:20 AM

#

Top 3-5 most important bugs

put in a level limit between players in non pvp or caravan. 3 level limit above or below allows us some chance to fight back. tired of getting ganked by level 20+ when im 10 level below them i have zero chance of fighting back.
Ranger abilities like snipe, scatter shot ect are going over the target and not even hitting the NPC. at all when I am NOT on level ground. the shot goes into the ground, or just fanishes after I fire with NO miss announcement. the same for the ring of vines, it doenst work when the ground is not level.
BAG BUG. i cant move items, transfer to or from the bank ect. I have to log out and run a repair. I usually have to do this at least 1 time an hour or more when I am farming for materieal it is super annoying.
Market place. I can NOT do an effective search for items by name. I enter bow and it only comes up with a few pages where people have listed bows in there description. the AH should search all items listed in the marketplace and give me every vender tha has any type of bow, item, material, armor ect by name.

near galleon Jan 21, 2025, 6:21 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Camouflage still does not work properly
Creating a character with the bald preset, while still setting all the hair length sliders to max apparently stops helm items from appearing on your character.
Ranger abilities that make you move quickly still sometimes freeze you in the middle of the animation, and you just fall to the ground, or start rubber-banding.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I would like to see more open buildings to explore, and do RP in.
Please add a LFG chat channel, as well as a Trade channel to help cut down the traffic in Global chat.
Please add the ability for guilds to set tags on individuals and other guilds, like a red [KoS] tag that shows up next to a person's name or their guild name, and that only members of the tagging guild can see. There could be other tags like a green [ALLY] tag, and a yellow [RoE] tag. Maybe even allow us to set custom tags and colors, with a 4-6 character limit so it doesn't clutter up the UI. That would make it easier for guild members to identify a friend or foe more quickly, and add another layer to guild gameplay.
======================

stone tide Jan 21, 2025, 6:21 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory/loot bug that force you to relog
Having to manually delete the Treasure Map quest after finding treasure before starting a new Treasure Hunt.
Crocodile mount too fast, FIX ASAP

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Some kind of find group filter(UI?) other than using Global chat.
Better filters for finding objects on the market
Flying mounts are too OP, should they really be mountable from anywhere?
Racial Traits needed for immersion
======================

fluid plover Jan 21, 2025, 6:21 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Node passives buffs not benefitting citizens more:
Node buffs like school of construction or bandit pacification will grant a 100% and 50% processing buff xp. Becoming a citizen increases this more by another 50% each. So instead of 150% xp buff, you can get 250% xp. This increase had no effect. Also smeling xp scroll had no effect. The xp my character was getting at 150%, was the same after becoming a citizen for 250%, and was the same after popping an xp scroll for 250% +. I tried smelting and collecting. Smelting then popping scroll and collecting. Already having scroll popped before smelting and then collecting. All scenarios gave the same xp.
Inventory Lag:
Doesn't display movement of items within inventory. Temp fix with mount/unmounting or log/unlogging.
Gathering Nodes not disappearing:
Gathering nodes are interactable but don't finish looting, seems the node was gathered by someone earlier but didn't disappear.
Animal carcasses not dropping up to legendary:
This limits us from getting legendary animal fat. Which limits us from crafting legendary slate molds.
Terrain:
Water edges extend or cut off. Doesn't cause me to get stuck, nor cause any real grief.

Keep up the great work intrepid!!!

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting is too difficult, and player economy is too large and greedy. Relies on Caravans too much, and rewards market sniping.
Suggestion: Node currency or gold can be used to buy common rarity of resources. Have daily limit to how much resources can be bought.
Crafting can mix rarities for crafting weapons and tools. This is good.
You can't mix rarities for crafting molds, this is bad. Even more since animal fat is capped at rare.
Cleric divine flare and wave attack won't dispel the streamweaver water shields.

Keep up the great work intrepid!!!

steady quest Jan 21, 2025, 6:21 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Inventory not updating. Need to mount for it to update
2. Treasure map quests won't finish properly when chest looted. Need to Abandon quest manually
3. Can't join Caravan event if in Party/Raid. Need to leave party and then join event
4. Apprentice scribe scrolls cost 10 silver + tax/materials to make. However scribe vendor just sells these same scrolls cheaper. Makes Scribes useless.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. Ability to put freesize stack to processing and taking it out. Now it is much downtime to just stand in processing bench and wait individual processings to finish. If you put large processing directly from gathering bags to processing you can't take them out since the processed items don't fit anymore to your bags.
2. Checking recipes for needed material. Some processed materials are not needed by any recipe (white ink/Yellow ink) Also Red/Green Ink is needed a lot by Scribing and the materials for that are very rare. (Ruby/Emeralds)
3. More General XP for crafters/gatherers. In my opinion crafting should be more xp rewarding. Would be alternative way to level character.

jaunty osprey Jan 21, 2025, 6:22 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Monster spawns are messed up, they are spawning under the ground and inside of walls all over the place it's a disaster.
Tree spawns are also messed up, a lot of them are spawning inside the ground and almost all of the willows are not harvestabl.
Cannot heal anyone other than yourself while in the desert PVP zone. AOE heals are not working on other characters and targeted heals heal the caster no matter the target selected.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I feel that the PVP in the game is not in a healthy state. Interaction between a lot of players is becoming kind of toxic (To use an overused term). I have a number of ideas that culminate into a single large idea of how to address this problem but it's very much a long form discussion. Please feel free to have anyone on the team DM me if you would like to hear my thoughts on the subject.
I feel that it is more difficult than it should be for higher level characters to acquire large quantities of droppings. Droppings are necessary to level Farming because everything uses droppings and I'm having trouble getting my hands on them now that I outleveled some of the mobs that I was farming. Perhaps some kind of flower derived mulch could be used in place of droppings?

======================

jaunty hearth Jan 21, 2025, 6:23 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The raid frames showing up when you edit UI or missing party frames and having to convert to raid and back multiple times in a single group is a very big quality of life improvement that could be made.
The invisible mobs attacking you or not being able to be attacked is pretty bad.
There is some pretty bad lag at certain spots in Carphin, these can get you killed if you lag at the wrong time. It's almost like some big textures are loading or something but I freeze up in two different spots constantly.
Mount desync is really bad because you don't find out until you get to your destination.
5.Being able to heal without being part of a caravan feedback is true, this has to be addressed asap.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

There is a person who literally sits in Carphin all day and trains mobs on people and then loots the corpses of parties hes wiped. He will stun a random person then jump off the fourth floor. Hes a lvl 25 fighter so there is no counter play as he has a ton of mobility and can literally sit there and grief all day while streaming. This kind of behavior is not what I assume is wanted in this game but if nothing is done then this behavior has all of the reward with very little of the risk. Sure he may sully his name but who is going to flag up and go corrupt to risk all their gear to stop him and there is no counter play to the interaction because hes not trying to farm hes just trying to grief and is profiting off of it. Griefing during alpha needs to stop, it should be in alpha or release IMO, its not PVP.
PVP Flag timer should be extended and the more often you flag and drop it in an hour or 30 minutes, the longer it should stay. The current system is not terrible but I think adding some duration based on frequency is important (don't count walking in and out of desert)
Keep the good updates coming, you guys are doing great

solemn wedge Jan 21, 2025, 6:23 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory/stash bug - having to mount/unmount all the time to fix it for a time
Willow Trees stuck in rocks
bugged mobs in tropics
having to degroup/tag/regroup when defending or attacking caravans

GAME IS SPIKING CPU USAGE RANDOMLY, CAUSING IT TO FREEZE, FORCING ALT+F4 AND LOGGING BACK IN TO YOUR DEATH DUE TO MOBS

lapis pewter Jan 21, 2025, 6:27 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The Mining/Lumber/Mining/Herbing/Fishing Storage tabs (In the town storage) for gathering still isn't working as intended for gatherables. Have to use General Storage for everything. Please fix.
Dragging items that disappear from bags or just materials disappearing and having to get on a mount to show the visual that its there.
Dead or Unharvestable nodes for gathering.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Rarity for gathering nodes. I think having static rarity on gathering nodes is terrible and causing gameplay from players that isn't fun or intended at all. Come back in two hours again for the same rarity shouldn't be a thing. Also, please gate rarity per certification. I.E. Novice can only get common, uncommon & small chance for rare. Apprentice now has a small chance to get heroic. Journeyman now has a chance to get epic, so on and so forth. I believe a change of this magnitude would require a wipe but I truly think its best imo sometime in phase III.
Adding a 5-10 minute timer to de-flag yourself as a combatant. Right now, people can turn off being a combatant too easily and that decision should have weight. If you want a grind spot and you flag up and win, the other group should have time to get back and try again instead of PvE griefing.
Make any support (Cleric or Bard) class that isn't in any event unable to participate unless they choose to become an attacker or defender. If I'm trying to heal someone in a caravan run and I'm not an attacker or defender and I try to heal someone, have a dialog box pop up and say the person you are trying to heal is in an event. Would you like to enter as Attacker or Defender? That would be such a godsend to many groups.

earnest harbor Jan 21, 2025, 6:27 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bugs. Items disappearing, unable to move items within inventory. Relogging typically fixes it, but it happens frequently
Frequent game crashes
Visual terrain textures look blocky when rendering and updating between seasons

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Automatic travel betwen nodes (Not fast travel, but also not having to manually steer when running between towns. Maybe an auto path on roads option)
Node upgrades beyond lvl3
More nodes/larger map to prevent zerging
======================

wide shuttle Jan 21, 2025, 6:27 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Being teleported back a long distance after dismounting sometimes.
All the quest bugs/quest npcs being uninteractable or just dont spawn
Skill specific bugs within archetypes - such as on my bard, the fire ground saga doesn't appear for me as it does for other bards and doesn't do any dmg. On my ranger, when I hold down the keybind for scattershot to charge it up all the way, it occasionally stops halfway through without my doing

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
4. Many mobs are bugged/all the mobs at oaken then just roll around and spaz out, many mobs in other places bug out often too

obtuse gorge Jan 21, 2025, 6:29 AM

#

unborn ginkgo Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers! ```Please share your top 3-5 most critic...

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Still getting bag bugs. Not as often, but it's still happening.
Unchoppable willows get me weeping.
Let bodies persist longer. Fighting one's way back after a bad wipe takes time. Same with lootable bodies. I don't want my loot vanishing while we finish killing a nasty pull.
Had more frequent position desyncing in the last week. Several times arrived at node towns only to fall through the world back to a previous point.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PLEASE make the quantity of items to process scrollable up to 250. BIG QoL item
When I roll on an item, let me auto-pick it up. Don't make me go back to the body once the rolls conclude.
Right now, caravans are unbalanced. There's little risk to attacking... worst case you run away. At least make attacking take an item, like you can't attack unless you have a crowbar... Also, defenders get no reward. Seems like that is unbalanced with (again) no real risk to attacking.
It would be helpful to be able to mix quantities when processing, especially because sometimes you get a one level rarer item from the first step and then you don't have enough for the next.
======================

bold umbra Jan 21, 2025, 6:29 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Still getting inventory bug/glitch
Invincible/non-responsive NPCs abuse/exploitation
Gatherables spawning below ground

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I don't think that people who knowingly exploit should be allowed to continue ruining the testing environment. I don't think that the punishments handed out were effective as a deterrent, and I have seen many of the same names that I have seen knowingly exploiting caravans/guild wars still in chat.
Artisan experience needs to be adjusted. I have more or less soloed 1-20, off of doing quests, etc, and a good portion of that has been 37xp at a time off of logging and mining. I don't understand why the xp gain doesn't scale with the level - I would be happy if it was even 1 extra xp per artisan level, just give us something?
PLEASE do something about chat. I understand this isn't a priority for you, but not even being able to have the changes to tabs save, compounded with having to relog multiple times a session for whatever reason, makes this is exceptionally frustrating. I have seen many questions/requests for help/etc go unanswered in /global because chat spams too fast with LFG/trade requests. We absolutely need a separate LFG chat at the very least, even if it's just during the testing phases and gets pulled out later.

covert herald Jan 21, 2025, 6:30 AM

#

lapis pewter Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025 Alpha Two Phase II Feedback **Top 3-5 Most Importa...

amen to that extend PVP timer , why not even make it a wanted quest , for a such people to be hunted for money in game that would be fun , and made it more realistic... thats how it was done in old times there was a WANTED PERSON REWARD!

clear nova Jan 21, 2025, 6:30 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

All Item/ Material bugs. Needing to relog to loot. Needing to mount/dismount to see items transferring positions.
Mob Threat. Frequently mobs "stick" to players despite Taunting / using abilities.
Mob Pathing / glitching. Example Hounds rubber banding / teleporting and 1 shoting people.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Tank Abilities Tune. Increase Defense Aura. Intercept should provide a larger Shield than Bard AoE Shield.
Bank Stack size should be larger than 20
When I roll on an item, let me auto-pick it up. Don't make me go back to the body once the rolls conclude.
Make Tank Skill [Grapple] NOT RESISTABLE. 20 Second CD seems fair to be guarantee hit.

covert herald Jan 21, 2025, 6:32 AM

#

Make Defenders of Caravan get some reward for investing their time , make it matter , it's only logical !
Make Defenders of Caravan get some reward for investing their time , make it matter it's only logical !
Make Defenders of Caravan get some reward for investing their time ,make it matter it's only logical !

uneven loom Jan 21, 2025, 6:32 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Monster Desync. Many times you will attempt to engage with a mob that does not take damage or fight back. Can sometimes have a majority of an area out of sync with your client.
The bug that doesn't update your position when riding a mount. Rubber bands you back to your starting position and requires a relog to fix.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

If not locked onto a target, automatically target the closest mob that is attacking you. (as a configuration toggle)
Return mobs to their spawn radius before allowing them to re-aggro players.
Disable aggro based on level difference.
Address claim mechanics for NMs specifically so that a higher level player cannot "steal your mob" by shrekking it while you're fighting.
======================

viral kindle Jan 21, 2025, 6:35 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

fix personal inventory so you dont have to log out then back in to get it to update
fix town storage so that when a specific storage is selcteb, eg timber, it stacks more than 20 in each stack, otherwise they are pointless
fix spawn times for heroic and above resources and increase the amount of will and braidwood so that there is a higher chance of someone else being able to find a tree instead of covering the whole map for 2 or 3 trees

sacred scarab Jan 21, 2025, 6:35 AM

#

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

city storage inventory bug
party's disappearing and in raid bug
3.caravans falling outside of map and deleting
not able to heal party members in the desert pvp zone unless manually flaged bug.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please add a guild bank or storage it is hard to pull resources as a guild or to keep it separate from your own character
add a last online so you know who is playing and who hasn't been on in weeks.
Add a have learned to recipe blueprints so i don't keep buying and trading ones i already have.
Please add a lfg tab so global can stay organized with discussion and trades. added with this please keep personal made chats for resetting every time you log in.
======================

pseudo ermine Jan 21, 2025, 6:39 AM

#

Fix the possibility to grief where ppl can train mobs / possibility to report IG
Focus on Server dynamic griding : to increase calling distance
Time to kill is too short in pvp
Balance the meta where distance dps is meta
Make crafting more interesting than looting from mob

red widget Jan 21, 2025, 6:40 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The bank issues almost feel worse. They’re extremely frustrating
Items in a work station when it upgrades poof into oblivion
When trade times out or lags both people lose their items
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
the grief trains are almost unbearable and have caused most people I know to quit
We really need a guild bank system with the hundreds of things we have to gather and share
3.the chat system gets lame. A simple LFG or TRADE tab would make life so much easier. And being able to tap to message people or link items. All these things should really be implemented
======================

To keep the thread organized, we kindly ask that you avoid back-and-forth discussions, and stick to the format above for your posts. We'll be closing the thread at <t:1737482400:F>

Important Note: While we greatly value your insights, please understand that we cannot guarantee all bugs or feedback topics will be addressed, or provide a specific timeframe for fixes.

Thank you for your continued support, feedback, and dedication to improving the Alpha Two experience! :flamingphoenix:

tiny void Jan 21, 2025, 6:40 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Recipe inaccuracies (Butcher Wolf labeled as Butcher Bear, Bloodied bone ring recipe item granting sephillion shard ring recipe)
Memory Leaks
Hunting Skinwalkers do not drop Skinwalker Carcass
Dismounting-teleporting
Looting bugging

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

auto pickup on rolled items
Outside players influencing caravans

wide nacelle Jan 21, 2025, 6:42 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Shadow disconnect when it looks like your connoted but your not
Mobs leashing in place doing full heal
Ranger camouflaged skill does not work

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I would like rangers to be able to act has skirmishers with a few melee powers
I would like the Free holds to each look different
I would like the nodes to be larger and look more different
======================

serene hornet Jan 21, 2025, 6:43 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

1.Trade item not working
2.Cant invite offline players in the guild and cant set up officers in the guild so they can invite players to help the guild grow
3.Rubberbanding its so bad also Memory leaks like crazy

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Leveling in this game its just so bad.Fell like im playing again WoW from 2004 and I dont think so the new gamers generation its ready for this.
Need better solution to find the group to lvl or to do dungeon
3.Crafting system need complete rework since its old style taking 4ever and boring.

wind steeple Jan 21, 2025, 6:43 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Saga (Bard Skill) with 3 red buffs isn't doing any damage to enemy NPCs
gathered ressources are sometimes still displayed (mostly trees and herbs)
mount animation (bear) seems to freeze at random

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

class skill trees lack variety of choice starting between lvl 15 and 20
pls dont lower the exp needed to level (adventuring class as well as crafting). Since it takes a real (long) time it feels ever more rewarding to reach milestones

steady spruce Jan 21, 2025, 6:44 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bugs where things won't move between personal inventory and storage or vise versa
Mobs still going underground or just being glitched where they stand
Some gatherable resources let you get through the process but then nothing happens and you can't get the resource from the node

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

No Rogue archetype yet

3.Very easy to get stuck leveling and not move forward without a group, need more variety in ways of getting decent XP then group grinding

quaint rune Jan 21, 2025, 6:44 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Invisible monsters
Caravan reliability
CC against non-flagged players

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Desyncs, inventory bugging out
Server/client performance when loads of people/caravans in view
Social stuff, communication with other players, linking items into chat,
Right click to invite from chat window, etc
======================

fierce vale Jan 21, 2025, 6:46 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Stabbers in the tropics have bluetooth attacks when you get too far away and can 2 shot a whole party while 100m away.
Inventory bug glitch with trading items to storage and picking up loot
Gatherables spawning below ground
Treasure mounds need a bit of a tune, almost impossible to see it in some circumstances, but when turning graphic settings to low you can spot it easily. Not telling you how to build your game, but maybe a visual indicator above the mound like the glowing effect on the parcels along the road (even if feint)
Treasure map quests won't finish properly when chest looted. Need to Abandon quest manually

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

When you have bought 3 stash tabs in a city as a citizen, if you renounce your citenzinship, those become unavailable, it would be cool to still have access to them for moving during the 36 hour citizen cooldown.
The market place is pretty fundamental at the moment, specifically for materials, could we maybe get a filter even if its just by item name and rarity even if nothing else.
It would be easier to test processing progression systems if we could select a custom amount for processing
Guild storage forthings like recipes and materials would be great
It would be nice to increase the global loot timer. When fighting large amounts of mobs which can take time, the loot that is dropped tends to go global before finishing the mob, and it causes people to want to roll into the mob to pick up their loot before it goes global.

hard tusk Jan 21, 2025, 6:49 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Looting / inventory not working properly: Needing to relog a bunch when looting mobs or moving items around inventory due to it not working.
Invisible / Friendly enemy mob: Fighting a mob and it dissapears part way through fighting or hits me when it is running the opposite direction. Enemy mob appears as friendly and it can attack me, but I cannot attack it back.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PvP Flagging: I feel like if you are actively in combat you should not be able to instantly unflag for PvP and there should be a timer that starts when out of combat and when leaving a lawless zone.
Corruption Warning: It would be good to let the user know somewhere in the HUD/Nameplates if you are potentially going to go corrupt from killing a player based on who you are targetting.
Render distance is way too close, enemies just appear out of no where. Dynamic Gridding please! 🙂

spare basalt Jan 21, 2025, 6:52 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Teleporting to carphin Tower mid caravan run.
Out of party healing (still)
Killing crafters or merchant players in nodes with cheap gear to steal their items (intended?)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Hunter is bricked.
Rarity for every other resource spawning in the same location at set times is a joke.
world Bosses spawning at set times, in the same place.. also a joke
devs/Team letting people get away with serious exploits for weeks before dealing with it is a let down and ruins server health.
Cya bye

timber venture Jan 21, 2025, 6:55 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The many obvious and well reported bugs being constantly abused by large guilds. Specifically caravan immunities and flagging problems
Having to drop group to flag for caravan with the fastest invite method being typing is ... less than convenient for mid battle.
Corruption baiting and mob training through different forms results in an environment in a pvx game where it is more punishing to kill a harassing player than it is to be the harassing player. These issues need to be resolved.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The driver being vulnerable on caravans does not feel like a good idea. There was counter play in maneuverability of the caravan, whether to retreat to allies regroup or provide up to date data to incoming allies. Currently being 1 shot and having to fight back to your caravan only to be one shot again feels terrible. Small groups are completely invalidated against large groups. You would need multiple Defenders and you're already risking the value of the single load (cost of 2x6 or 3x7 caravan = price of sale from 1 trip) so you need multiple trips to profit but add in paying Defenders.. maybe it's exaggerated in how bad it feels by caravans being a primary source of gold due to the economic systems not being even half implemented.
With crafting being the endgame bis items the full artisan suite needs to be developed ASAP. The current system from my understanding is extremely placeholder but it is not good. Needing 11 willow logs to make a shirt is absurd. The cost of buying a vendor apprentice health potion vs the cost of supplies to make it are extremely unbalanced.
Server stability and rubberbanding, memory leak etc. The game feels extremely bad in high density areas if the server is not reset daily. Frequently being teleported back across server workers. Mobs not acting correctly. Stuttering and freezing. Render distance especially during high risk pvp experiences.
==========

gleaming thistle Jan 21, 2025, 6:56 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan pvp bugs

healers being able to heal outside of event
player emberspring invulnerability carrying over to caravan

Feedback Topics:

Caravan pvp is the most consistent end game content. Impossible to fight big guilds over them as every guild is aware of the bugs and uses them. Makes it very unfun.
Server health - desync getting worse and worse, teleporting back across the map after coming off Mount. Large scale pvp just bricking the area

atomic tendon Jan 21, 2025, 6:57 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bug where you can't see the items unless you mount/dismount or relog
Trees in the ground
Invisible mob attacks
When going across different server (area?) workers quests you've hid pop up as visible + sound when they do
^^ sometimes de-synced when dismounting

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Carcasses to stack higher than 20 in hunter bags
Link items in chat
Make communication easier where you can right click names in chat or something
(Probably just me but) Make it easier to see the maturity(?) of metals and stones (don't want to accidentally mine things not ready)(if scarcity and depletion is going to work like over-deforestation)

long barn Jan 21, 2025, 6:58 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan flagging. Anyone can heal outside the caravan event without being flagged.
Passing over enough nodes eventually causes your game to lose performance, lessing to sever FPS drops.
Mob training is still a thing that needs to be resolved.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

World Bosses are hard-camped by zergs at all hours of the day. Making it impossible to participate for loot. Server resets also cause the boss to spawn, exacerbating the issue.
Weeping Willow spawn rates and frequency are painfully low. Once Journeyman lumber is out, likely the same will happen with Briarwood.
Carphin still needs a lot of texture and environmental fixes. Still appears to be a cluttered mess with bugged AI in several areas.
======================

lyric cargo Jan 21, 2025, 7:01 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan Event (Healing, Crowbaring instantcast, by defenders, losing event popup on server restart)
Caravan Event: Party leader should flag for whole party.
Inventory bugs

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravan: Remove crowbar from the game. // player name on event.
Defensive stats on gear / Health of players needs a buff.
Caravan: Attackers should fight for the loot if not in same party.
Level 5 alts shouldnt be able to spawn camp a resource (apprentice level 10 Willow) same for level 20 resources. - In addition to the profession skill you should need a player skill also. I dont think alts should be mandatory the way they are right now.
Gathering rarity nodes. To work better with gear/tools. No static rarer nodes. Make it like hunting.
======================

eager kraken Jan 21, 2025, 7:03 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs: (to me <3 )

Rubberbanding while crossing between servers on a Mount.
Inaccessible gatherables- an example being trees that are sunk into the ground
Ranger's Charged-Scattershot consuming both charges fairly consistently
Ranger's Camouflage not properly veiling your character. Most of the time you'll have certain portions of your character visible, i.e. Helmet or Legs.
Invincible Caravan Bug, unsure of the exact cause but have encountered it a few times.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Expansion on current/future Economic features. Player Marketplaces could use some love, but overall love that we have to advertise them ourselves. Hoping for filtering/sorting options when Auction Houses come.
Allowing Processors to specify their own quantity of items, as opposed to set options.
Consistency in PvP implementations, specifically to allow players to police their zones. Safe Zones should only be implemented sparingly, such as storage areas in Non-Wilderness zones. Wouldn't be opposed to changes to the current flagging system
Consistency in defining what 'griefing' and 'exploiting' is, and what is required for someone to review. Being reported for stock-standard PvP sucks, and reporting someone for Macro'ing/Bug Exploiting seems to be inconsistent at best. i.e. a certain guild abusing raft caravans to transport beyond the world border (thankfully patched now, but was exploited HEAVILY)
Improvements to Hunting- high-rarity fat right now is genuine gold due to inconsistent implementation of gathering rarity w/ Huntable creatures.

charred solstice Jan 21, 2025, 7:11 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Random Teleports to Embersprings
PvP Flag runs out when in Combat
Bard Instakills with 3 Autoattacks while beeing untouchable with all utility they got Supporter shouldnt be best class in timetokill
Combatlogging: Players who are Corrupted or Flagged can logout instant and Playermodel disapears immediately, to avoid their death or wait for friends to arrive

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Bankslot are far to less... im using 3 1/2 towns atm with all available bankslots to purchase and still its not enough
Allowing Processors to specify their own quantity of items, as opposed to set options.
The AggroSystem is so bad that u even grief players when u dont want to do it.... Maybe implement "Safespots" to reset Mob aggro or Rework Aggro System
Mayor Mounts to OP

chilly moon Jan 21, 2025, 7:16 AM

#

Caravan is bugged I cant turn only can go forward or backwards and most of the time I go forwards it sends me backwards anyways

visual breach Jan 21, 2025, 7:19 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory bugging out, i.e not updating when harvesting, looting, processing/crafting.
Quests not able to complete if they are started before a patch, thus needing to redo those steps after server has been patched to get it going again.
Not that important, but surveing pylons for fishing are broken. Maybe because there are technicly no "nodes" for it to interact with. Also ,it is a bit weird that on some it says you can repair them, however they dissapear after use, thus they are not repairable?

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The ranger archetype feels a bit weirdly designed. Most of your abilitie have long cast times. This doesnt feel very good when playing, it is more like playing a spellcaster with a bow, given that you kinda plant your feet every time you want to use an ability. The regeneration seems like a joke, at least make it also give some mana back. Hunts are somewhat okey however marks seems pretty useless due to their low uptime. Would like to see some kinda distinction betwee short bow, long bow and books, or at least some synergies with the rangers abilites. The knockback on scattershot is for the most part wonky, and it might have a better spot if paired with snipe.
Augments in the skill section are mostly ok for their respective abilites.
Tank feels like it has way to little dmg doing solo stuff. Also beeing locked into animation/casting and not being able to popp defensive or potions does not feel very good. Beeing able to react to something in te environment, and then having the game tell you, no cannot do that, does not feel good. Blocking manually seems a bit to slow, might be the animation again, and oh yeah, make shields visible again on female Vek please.
Maybe caravans should, for the moment, have a buff that helps defenders? Feels like running a caravan has way to high of a risk vs attacking one.

======================

fervent condor Jan 21, 2025, 7:21 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan bug that makes you teleport to Carphin leaving your caravan abandoned.
Firebrand very easy to bug and guilds take advantage of it.
Looting bug that prevents you from picking up items and you have to relog so often.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

World Bosses should have random spawns and not always appear at reset. This makes it easier for the zergs to control them and for no one to do so. They should also have a more random route or be able to appear in several places.
Maybe quests and lore should start to have some importance for testing and have some secondary content to do.
I know you are working on it but the auction is awful.
======================

Thanks you!

scarlet harness Jan 21, 2025, 7:31 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Frequent client crashes has been introduced with the latest two patches. Previously I had a crash once every 2-3 days, now we are talking several times a day. This seems to be even more frequent in contested areas such as Remnants of Sephillion and Carphin.
Mob pathing in floor two in carphin seems completely broken.
Many nodes still do not yield resources when you harvest them.
Rarity of resources can still be calculated. I gave a relatively long feedback off this on reddit
https://www.reddit.com/r/AshesofCreation/comments/1hytd1q/gathering_system_feedback/
Basically as the rarity of the node can be predicted people spawn them over and over again. Much more randomness needs to be introduced. This could be a bug, or it could be a current feature. I place it under bug as it seems like a mistake. Many gathers have quit the current testing phase over this as it is hard to compete with the excel warriors.
mob pathing in general seems somewhat difficult and griefing with pulling mobs into people have increased substantially after the last few patches.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The building sequence on the nodes makes it quite difficult to progress and as it was mentioned on the stream the other day it does create a kind of "swamp" where no one really can progress.
With the current gold making system where only the dominating guilds can even dream about running caravans many of the guilds currently run dry. This is even more problematic as many of the dominating guilds also run nodes so they got flying mounts to scout with for easier targets. ( market place has helped quite a bit)
Almost no availability of high rarity carcasses makes crafting super difficult
Many level 10 crafts are so expensive to craft it could take a full month gathering for them in a normal pace.
Leveling solo needs to improve.

======================

From the AshesofCreation community on Reddit: Gathering System Feed...

Explore this post and more from the AshesofCreation community

hard jacinth Jan 21, 2025, 7:31 AM

#

Important Bugs:

Having to summon and mount OR relog to fix non responsive inventory
Lots of trees around nodes are halfway in the ground

Important Feedback Topics:

Character level outpaces artisan level and node buildings and creates a weird item lag problem
Bard overpowered
Hunting doesn't seem to ever give higher rarity carcass ~ making crafting difficult
Better rewards for completing node buy orders - after you get the node cloak, no one seems to care about it anymore
Some gathering nodes (willow) seem to have a pretty static spawn. We all know the spawns/timers now and it feels gameable in a negative way.

scarlet shell Jan 21, 2025, 7:31 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravan crashing. While I have not experienced it personally, I hear about this often. As a solo player who does not do caravans but relies on those make money doing so. Since the griping of caravans has increased I have made noticeably fewer sales. Could be unrelated but just in case.
Looting/inventory bug. Unable to loot mobs or transfer items from inventory. Having to relog for 15seconds to fix frequently is annoying.
Invis enemies killing you.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I made it halfway to grandmaster hunting before I could acquire the mats to make apprentice hunting pants. I finally got 2 rare raptor and legendary everything else. The resulting pants were maybe 6 rarity points higher than the vendor trash Journeyman pants. Infuriating is the only way to describe my feelings. Those does not even consider the time spent which was horrendous. I expected to carry this for quite some time. Instead I gave it to my apprentice hunter friend. Crafters certainly don’t feel like they make the best gear if one tier up vendor trash is better.
The above aside, hunting is the only gathering profession I truly like. I have only seen one epic carcass and heard of one other. They actually feel great to get. Whereas the wow factor is lost with other gathering professions. I get a legendary bluebell/copper/etc, it’s awesome. Heroic carcass gets the same affect though. I wish all gathering professions were like hunting.
Griefing. This is a broad category but higher levels stunning you mid harvest. Higher levels killing your caravan. People in group stealing your loot. Higher levels doing more damage to steal your mobs. Im unsure of the solution but I play 95% solo because of these things.
======================

willow isle Jan 21, 2025, 7:41 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Items in storage or on your character not correctly transferring between the two, and having to either get on a mount or relog into the game to fix the issue for a limited amount of time.
Enemies like Firebrand resetting constantly and getting stuck (bugged) or teleporting around in-game. Not being able to loot these enemies because they're bugging and having to destroy all the items and materials so as not to be exploiting the game, after working for 30+ minutes to beat them is annoying.
Gatherables in the world not being able to be harvested (such as the entire forest area to the east of Halcyon on Lynneth server), or gatherables allowing you to go through the harvesting motions and then not being destroyed and not going into your inventory (mostly with ore and gem nodes).
Thaumaturge enemies despawning or disappearing or teleporting at random levels of HP after being Corrupt Sacrificed from Sighted Fanatics.
Enemies bugging out and teleporting through walls, launching magical attacks through walls, teleporting to your location to attack, and being able to walk through solid objects like freehold fences or getting stuck inside them.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Currently the PVP feels bad. It is unenjoyable to be 1 of 2 players online in a guild and being declared war upon to have to fight high-end PVP guilds who randomly target your guild not even knowing how many players you have online, and then being unable to do anything outside the war across the entire map because you are flagged even when you are not directly in the PVP zones indicated on the maps. Also, having the PVP zones dip inside towns when it is not a Node vs Node war, such as the fishing derby war extending inside Halcyon proper, is a negative gameplay experience when you are one of the only players online, you have no guild leader online to end the war, and you are the only points the opposing guild can earn to stop the war.
Caravans are currently unenjoyable to run when commodities can just disappear, caravans bug out, attackers and mobs can target you in the caravan and kill you instead of the caravan itself, players can queue up as both attackers and defenders of caravans and confuse the system by suddenly not allowing you to attack some people in a guild because they are now on your side as attackers or on your side as defenders and then use that opportunity to try and get you corrupted in the fighting. Just generally having exploits or issues with caravans makes them incredibly unenjoyable and I have stopped attempting to run them at all when I stand to run into so many possible issues, but they are a massive way to start earning the money needed to actually level up processing skills, so unless you can do these without having other people work exploits against you or having the game bug out, you end up losing too much for this part of the game to be worth doing, and your progression stagnates a lot outside of doing anything other than leveling (which ends eventually), and gear grinding. Caravans should be a risk, but currently the amount of issues are so heavily stacked in the favor of people attacking the caravans that it frequently is not worth doing these at all.
Exploits in wars are incredibly frustrating. Having a guild be able to declare war, and having their healers in another guild so they can heal their members who are in the war without worrying about their healers and support being attacked is wild. Not having the ability to end wars unless the leader of a guild is online and not having an implemented structure to the guilds (e.g. having officers and other rankings with a guild who can also be online and end a war) significantly disrupts gameplay and ends up getting me to log off and do something else with my time.
======================

halcyon plaza Jan 21, 2025, 7:42 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory not updating, deleting items, not being able to loot items, and similar.
Mobs spawning inside walls, spawning as friendly instead of enemies, mobs being dragged away from spawn points and getting caught on terrain in inaccessible areas so they block spawns,
Harvestable resources being uninteractable.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Blocking stamina drain needs to be reworked or there needs to be some form of stamina gain added to the game in terms of regen or total stamina.
Pyromancer/Firestarter damage is obscenely overtuned to a degree that whoever put it to what it currently is needs to be pulled aside and talked to. It is entirely possible for them to output 2k+ damage PER SPELL on a level 17 mob, in an AoE, and even if interrupted they will immediately cast the same spell. They are frequently encountered in packs of 2-4, alongside other mobs with high damage. This goes far beyond hardcore. I will go so far as to say that if Steven wants them to remain as they are, then I challenge him to show himself and a group of normal players in appropriate gear for level 17 taking on Citadel of the Steel Bloom WITHOUT GOD MODE or any other form of damage immunity and remain within the dungeon for one hour with zero deaths.
Harvestable resources are both excessively scarce, and the fact that all herb/mining/wood harvestables are STATIC RARITY once harvested with STATIC, KNOWN SPAWN TIMERS means that large guilds are marking down legendary spawns and timer-camping them. It does not feel good as it currently stands.

dapper tartan Jan 21, 2025, 7:47 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Shield Disappearing Bug:
- Description: Shields disappear when switching weapons or after being equipped for an extended period.
- Impact: This significantly disrupts tank gameplay, rendering the class less effective during combat because your not sure if your shield is working.
Tag Stealing and PvP Flagging:
- Description: Players are able to steal tagged mobs without consequence.
- Suggestion: Implement a Purple Flag system where offenders who attack tagged mobs are flagged for PvP. This would deter disruptive behavior and promote fair play.
Durability and Longevity Systems Missing:
- Description: Gear, weapons, and mounts lack a finite durability or lifespan system.
- Impact: Without these mechanics, the economy risks stagnation, and crafting professions lose long-term relevance.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Durability and Mount Lifespan Mechanics:
- Description: Introduce a finite durability system for gear and weapons, with a limited number of repairs before items become irreparable but salvageable for materials.
  - Gear and Weapons: Set a maximum number of durability points and repair cycles (e.g., 300 durability, 20 repairs).
  - Mount Lifespan: Mounts should have a limited number of lives (e.g., 5/5). Once expired, they leave behind a carcass that can be butchered for materials useful in crafting professions.
- Why This Matters: These systems would ensure a dynamic and evolving economy where crafting professions remain integral, and market stagnation is avoided. Broken gear and expired mounts would retain value, contributing to a balanced game economy.
Armor Skill Trees and New Classification:
- Description: Expand armor classifications with distinct progression trees, offering diverse playstyles and trade-offs:
  - Light: Focused on evasion and magical conductivity, enhancing magic-based damage. Talent trees can optionally improve agility for those seeking a hybrid playstyle. Best suited for mages, healers, and agile fighters.
  - Medium: A balanced option for rogues, hunters, and hybrid fighters, offering mobility, moderate defense, and a small increase to magical capabilities through a specialized talent tree.
  - Heavy: Optimized for tanks and melee warriors, offering high physical and magical damage mitigation with limited mobility. Heavy armor has minimal magical conductivity, making it less effective for magic users.
  - Titan: A new proposed class focused on extreme physical and magical damage mitigation, sacrificing magic conductivity entirely. This armor provides unmatched resilience but reduces magic damage effectiveness.
- Additional Mechanics:
  - All armor skill tree classes except Light have optional talent trees for a small magical increase, allowing players to customize their builds within limited talent points.
  - Players must strategically allocate their limited armor tree points, encouraging unique and diverse build styles.
- Why This Matters: Introducing distinct armor progression trees adds strategic depth, supports varied playstyles, and emphasizes meaningful choices. This ensures players can tailor their builds while balancing trade-offs between defense, mobility, and magical capabilities.
Tomahawk Skill Adjustment for Tanks:
- Description: The tomahawk skill feels out of place for the tank archetype. Tanks traditionally focus on defense and crowd control rather than ranged attacks.
- Suggestion: Replace this ability with one better suited to the tank's role, such as an enhanced taunt or area-control skill.
  ======================

tidal coral Jan 21, 2025, 7:49 AM

#

Draw distance for PvP in general is bad and needs a bit of a boost so enemy players render in a bit faster at a greater distance
Many caravan related bugs and the entire system needs some love. Giving party group lead an option to flag entire group for attack/defence would be number one priority and not allowing out of party healers to heal combatants would be number two. Caravans are awesome content btw.
Server reset schedule and randomisation of Firebrand spawn
Resource node respawns need to be properly randomised instead of being set on same rarity 2hr cycles
Expansion of more gatherable resources to the new desert areas

untold tinsel Jan 21, 2025, 7:58 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Rubberband back to the server where you originaly got onto your mount.
Archer Stealth ability should (as described in the skill) make me untargetable, but when i was gathering herbs i got agro'd by mobs (i was underlevel'd for the area). Either the skill description has to be edited or this is a "visibility bug" where mobs can still see through your stealth.
Not being able to pick up glint from killed mobs after a while; Gives the message "got the wrong weapon for that"

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Increase respawn rate for quest specific mobs. (sometimes you wait for a few minutes for the mob to spawn, just to have someone kill it away from you, and then have to wait again)
Keep improving the servermeshing, there are quite the lagspikes when you transition from one server to another.

upbeat furnace Jan 21, 2025, 7:59 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Getting teleported to emberspring while running caravans and then being unable to see your caravan after running back to it after the teleport
Invincible caravan: There are players consistently abusing this and some trying to sell the info on how to replicate it.
Invincible Caravan driver
having to break group to flag as caravan attacker or defender
Mob training and aggro: one person can make an entire zone unusable for entire groups since killing them isn't a realistic option.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Caravan loot: If you successfully destroy a caravan, anyone can flag as an attacker with you, causing them to become unstoppable since they are on your "team", which they can abuse to grief the loot by instantly crowbaring it
Caravan loot: As mentioned above, caravan loot is highly griefable, even by people passing by not involved in the event. Caravan loot should only be interactable and available to be picked up by the attackers until a certain amount of time has passed, after which it becomes available to the public.
Caravan loot: remove crowbars from the game. And if they stay, crowbaring should have a VERY long cast time rather than being instant.
Caravan PVP: attackers should not all be on the same team, rather group/raid based
There are only downsides to being in a guild: with the lack of guild progression, being guildless you are immune to being war scrolled, you can kill your friends that turned red and you don't often suffer the consequences of your guildmates actions. Competitive players are often seen guildless for those reasons and only wear their guild name momentarily while using a war scroll against others.

median rune Jan 21, 2025, 8:00 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs
Inventory Management: The inventory doesn't update properly in some cases; players need to relog or mount/dismount to see the changes.
Caravan Role Assignment: Players must either be without a party or the party leader to assign themselves as a defender/attacker of a caravan.
Rarity Stats: Rarity stats are broken. It might be better if all node resources start as common and become rarer depending on the gear’s rarity. Currently, it feels odd that players without rarity gear can gather legendary resources.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics
Time to Kill: The time to kill (TTK) is too low for players with high-level gear.
Convoy Caravans: Allow multiple caravans to participate in a single convoy event to encourage more interaction and cooperation.
Material Sink: Introduce mechanics to reduce material overflow and stimulate the economy, such as crafting-based gear repairs. To prevent frustration, a "User Repair Shop" could be added to stalls, avoiding the need to carry excessive materials in inventory.
Caravan on map: Add a way for players to track the location of their caravan on the map.

umbral yarrow Jan 21, 2025, 8:01 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Loot bug. Quite often you just lose the ability to pick up loot and gathered materials. Only fix is to restart the game. This also happens when moving materials from bags to storage sometimes.
Treasure map rewards. Sometimes you can't loot the items in the treasure chest.
Shileds aren't showing.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

A way to stop or report people from griefing by pulling mobs on other groups or players. It's ruining the experiance of open dungeons.
More metal ores to be mined. The scarcity is too harsh right now.
Ability to see guild names in chat and on marketplaces so I can avoid buying from guilds I don't want to fund.
======================

drowsy charm Jan 21, 2025, 8:07 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/21/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Crashing when crossing server worker while doing caravans
Carphem teleporting when running caravans
If the driver of a caravan dies and spawns at ember spring, during the 30 sec safe cooldown caravans cannot be targeted

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

World bosses need to be more consistent instead of players depending on server resets
Cooking right now is useless as the benefits from crafted food is not that much better then the vendor food and the price for the vendor food is significantly cheaper so it is not cost effective to craft food as it requires more money, mats, and freeholds do not even work properly
Not all artisan skills are useful, Fishing needs to be revamped and implemented into the system so their is a a wider range of skills players can utelize and input into the economy

grave palm Jan 21, 2025, 8:08 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans crashes/unreliable - Happens alot when more than 2-3 caravans are close a.o caravans disappearing when summoning [caravans are coinflip wasting time and recources for it to just vanish/not work at all]
Inventory bugged
Party leader should flag entire party for caravan PvP
Teleporting after dismounting
Memory leaks

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Tagging NPCs/Contesting spots is cringe and boring [Corruption is to punishing]
Remove marketplace
You should be able to upgrade materials [20 common wood makes 1 uncommon wood] for example
Bards and clerics are too strong
Stuns are too long, no way to cleanse it as a mage [ranger stun ability is too far - Fighters stun into oneshot]
Change legendary color to red

lofty bobcat Jan 21, 2025, 8:14 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Off-hand equipment (shield) disappearing sporadically. Noticeable when opening menus, swapping weapons, sometimes casting.
Invincible/map bugged mobs. Change spawn location, fix clippings etc.
Flagging pvp for picking up friends loot. There needs to be a way if an ally/friend dies we can safely retrieve their items and not be flagged for pvp.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting feels exceptionally and undeniably bad. The term "fuel" makes little to no sense, the system is unintuitive, and is extremely overly complicated. I understand the idea of needing other players, but the amount of resources required vs the amount of resource nodes are insanely unbalanced. Nodes should be able to be marked on your map once found or some similar fashion/function
Tldr - make crafting fun, make gathering plausible.
The Tank class needs some love and work. A tank should be focused on taking hits, mitigation, and have interrupts. It feels like a weird fighter not an impregnable fortress.
More mob camps. Even with the limited amount of players currently, the "good" camps are always over camped. Higher numbers of mobs, and mob diversity would truly help.
To reduce griefing, force high level players to not be able to interact with level 1-5 mobs, or grant them zero drops etc. took over an hour to kill some ravens for an introductory quest...
In the absence of fast travel...there should at least be a return to town/home point function even if it costs a few gold.
Telegraphing for your own actions, conal AOE, LOS, etc. something to help amidst the chaos of a cluttered battlefield to see which allies we can target.
======================

wraith trail Jan 21, 2025, 8:15 AM

#

NM_Bell IF YOU ARE READING THIS. PLEASE LEAVE THE THREAD** ONCE YOU HAVE POSTED YOUR FEEDBACK**. NM_Bell

RIGHT CLICK THE THREAD ON THE LEFT MENU BAR
HIT "LEAVE THREAD"

PLEASE DO THIS TO ALLOW OTHERS TO POST FEEDBACK. (Due to Discord Limitations of Threads).

THANK YOU FOR READING THIS.

mental elm Jan 21, 2025, 8:16 AM

#

Most Important Bugs:
1.Caravan drivers getting teleported to Carphin
2.No high quality in hunting materials
3.Gear for artisan does not affect gathering rarity chance
4. Inventory bug: You cant put things in bank or u cant see things added to bags
5. Node buffs are gone after server reset

Most Important Feedback Topics:
0. You are amazing, keep the good work. Take your time, we will wait.

Current rarity rate of resource gathering feels bad. Fixed respown times for resources feels terrible, it destroys entire artisan system - its outdated idea that promotes behavior close to exploiting and demotes hard working gatherers
Running a caravan is a big risk (You can loose cargo and caravan and time). Attacking a caravan also should be a risk (currently its only time). Current risk-reward part of the system does not feel good.
Inflation feels bad. There should be some more gold sink, maybe new items to buy with gold.
Item saturation feels bad. All items should be destructible/decaying in some way.
Not being able to mix rarities of resources in proccesing feels terrible. Not being able to craft multiple items during leveling feels bad.

hexed palm Jan 21, 2025, 8:18 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Enchantment System completely broken. It is either bugged or not thought trough at all.
=> Why: +1 => every stat on item gets +1 => for lvl0 item with 50 power rating and 1 int this means 51 power rating (+2%) and 2 int (+ 100%).
Compare this to lvl20+1 item: 200+1 power rating (+0,5%) and 4+1 int (+25%).
=> Currently ppl grab **lvl10 stuff **and make them **+10 **=> we are back to 1 shot meta with 200++ int/str
Quick Fix: delete enchantment from the game until its overhauled
2. -
3. -

Thank you for all your hard work on the game so far and for taking our feedback on board. The addition of the chance ore drop to stone gathering has been greatly appreciated ❤️

atomic vapor Jan 21, 2025, 8:42 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Increased gathering speed from gear does not work
Increased gathering rarity seems to be working only on novice nodes, if any
It seems, that only one tressure map per server restart generates loot

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Fixed time, place and rarity respawns of gatherables completely eliminates casual players from getting any good materials, as hardcore players keep them on timers.
Current one-combo burst pvp meta is not letting people to show their pvp skills, players should have more HP or defenses
At least now over enchanted 10lvl (to around+6-8) gear is way better than best lvl 20+0 gear, maybe defenses should be bigger on lvl 20 gear
======================

full mica Jan 21, 2025, 8:50 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.the fact that rarity and spawn time for resources is trackable needs a temporary fix to give +/- 10 to the spawn time and a rarity reroll every time it spawns.
2. the server worker change over sometimes failing on a mount and being sent back to the previous server worker. I run every wheere for now
3.inventory bugs especially when tabbing away from the game are pretty severe so if I'm playing basically can't tab out

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.better bag slots for more rarities or stacking of different rarities of a resource
2.countdown to wars added to prevent abuse
3.temperory higher spawns of certain materials like happened for copper while the server size is limited

gentle canopy Jan 21, 2025, 9:13 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Desync of mob client/server location, mobs teleporting
I have to sit through loading screens and errors 32, 33, and 34 before my character loads, each time I start the game. The issue has persisted since phase 1
Each time it takes around 5 minutes to be able to choose character and play. I have a good connection and ping
Gatherables, especially animals sometimes have to be approached at a very specific angle to be able to gather them.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Please add a custom number of crafted / processed items instead of the hardcoded options
Animal husbandry stations can only have one animal per queue and training costs waaaaay too much gold for how demand works for mounts / beasts of burden
There is no easy way to find out which node has an apprentice station, have to ask in chat or go to each node and look yourself
======================

Keep up the great work guys!

inner bison Jan 21, 2025, 9:21 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Had an Oculus mob leash on me across the entire map. Was able to log out and when i logged back in still leashed to me and killed me. Leashing range on a lot of mobs are kind of crazy.
Still a lot of inventory bugs. Items not showing that you looted or removed. Have to relog in order for the update to show. Sometimes this caused a game crash after logging back in.
Bugged mobs when attacking health doesn't drop but they are attacking you and chasing you, but they are invisible and none of your hits connect.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Finding very specific resources is way to time consuming and can be impossible to find. Sometimes when you do find them, you cannot even harvest them. Right now Zinc and Copper are harder to find than Iron. Basalt and Granite is everywhere. I feel like all tier 1 resources should have a fairly equal distribution between all the resources. Maybe even put resources to update on so many server ticks so when everyone skips all the basalt and granite it still can update to a copper or zinc node.
Joining the game late seems very very punishing as a new player. Tax reciept for players joining late is punishing (should be the same for everyone or tie it to a town contribution leaderboard). No need for lower level resources so artisan skills are worthless if you are late.
The Market Place is a mess to look through. I like that each node has its own, but would be a lot better to be able to place buy and sell orders in a single ui instead of having to go through 12 pages of shops that tag the item you are looking for, but dont even have any of it at the time. (Something like New World or even Albion)
World can feel empty sometimes and finding appropriate mobs to grind can be tough and time consuming and having random elites littered in the non specific areas feels off. Keep Elites group oriented and location specific.

smoky stag Jan 21, 2025, 9:24 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Overall server performance combined with the consistent desync between player to server causing an array of bugs including but not limited to inventory/storage issues, movement & rubber-banding issues and issues pertaining to PvP between as little as 1v1s all the way to large format 40v40+ PvP
Permanent solutions to the constant and assorted bugs pertaining to caravans and the abusable nature of Attacker vs Defender. Defending teams having a friendly player choose Attacker on a caravan only to then heal the caravan without consequence, the immunity being granted from Emberspring protection applying to a caravan driver's caravan upon their resurrection. Including fixes to the bugs based around simply running a caravan, for example; caravan launching crashes, caravans suddenly disappearing and deleting themselves, missing cargo, commodity sales issues at destinations etc.
Variety of rarity, quantity increases on certain professions doing nothing, for example; Hunting Rarity Increase seem to visually give the player the status increase in their Artisan Stats however after myself and numerous guild mates can attest to, we simply aren't gaining those effects. Thousands of hunts with some players have 400+ rarity increase and seeing no heroic, no epic, no legendary carcasses is frustrating. Whether this is intentional due to some systems not being stood up completely yet or a bug its frustrating at the least to be unaware whether this is the case or they are bugged. Resources and time can be put into other forms of gameplay & testing if they aren't ready. We can mine heroic, epic & legendary ores, stones, gems, trees, herbs all day but carcasses, cocoons etc are essentially impossible at the moment.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Improved Server performance I think being the most important feature at the moment due to it first and foremost. Allows real, verifiable and trustworthy data to be collected. How are we to know what is bugged if the server has hiccups and bumps, it makes it harder to determine bugs.
The item stat nerf in phase one was necessary but may not have been enough. Currently in PvP its possible to just be killed in a few seconds through all defensive and 60%+ Mitigation to Physical and Magical attacks. Right now the Defensive stats don't seem to grant the amount of negation necessary to warrant ever building that way. And that for the most part is with players in level 10 gear enchanted to around 7. It will only get worse with level 20 gear enchanted once the necessary node buildings have been completed. Getting a head of this now will save many players the pain of dealing with this problem before it gets worse.
A greater interference from Intrepid Studios upon the player base. We have guilds being named IllIlIIIlIl and the like. When dealing with guild wars, its near impossible to know which guild you actually want to go to war with. Its little details like this spread throughout the whole testing environment that make it harder for testers to give you reliable feedback and an enjoyable enough experience to keep players around. Many guilds are already seeing player retention loss and I fear it will just get worse if issues like this one above aren't addressed.
Many gatherables around the world are simply ungatherable. Trees half-sunk in the ground and clipped into mountain sides making them wasted, especially weeping willows for some reason. Areas of the map where gatherables become stuck and won't allow you to receive the materials etc.
The storage clerk system is a great design and the limited tabs makes the player need to decide what they will store, and what they will not. However the ability to choose what materials will be stored and allow for greater stacks has not worked since its implementation, this causes clogging of useless items on markets too.
======================

thorn mesa Jan 21, 2025, 9:27 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Client crashes & UI bugs
Caravans bugs
Can't join a caravans event as party/raid

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

TTK is too low, this is must be one of the priority.
CARAVANS : In order to slow down the zerging, we shouldn't be able to join more than 1 event of caravans at the same time especially in defense. A train of 20 caravans is unstoppable and do a lot of money.
Too many kind of rarity, it's ok but we need more storage and better UI.
Buildings to craft level 20 items is not up after a month, many people are 25 after 2 or 3 weeks.
As guilds wars, we should use scroll to declare war on a territory, exemple : we want Carphin to be ours, let's make a scroll and put a flag on the ground on the spot and say to everyone, this is a pvp zone for 1h !

gusty dew Jan 21, 2025, 9:34 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Magic Damage Balance:
Magic damage is significantly overtuned relative to defense stats. Fighting against classes with magic damage exceeding 350-400 becomes a race to see who can one-shot the other first. Unsurprisingly, Mages and Bards excel at this. The PvP aspect of the late game feels entirely dull and unbalanced because of this, killing any desire to continue playing the game in its current state.
Bard Class is Overpowered:

Absurd Mobility: The combination of Flourish, dodges, and infinite stacking of 20% movement speed makes the Bard absurdly mobile, effectively rendering it impossible for other classes to kill a Bard unless the Bard allows it.
Excessive Crowd Control (CC): A chain of stuns, silences, and marionette — why does a single class have access to all of these?
Overtuned Buffs: The power of Bard buffs is overly strong, especially the Alacrity buff granting 30% attack speed. Given how auto-attacks scale with high spell power, this turns Bards into a class focused on one-shotting opponents through auto-attacks.
Excessive Damage Output: Should I mention that a Bard with 400+ spell power can deal around 5,000 damage using Dark Lullaby? This is completely absurd. A class designated as a support should have its damage significantly reduced across all offensive spells.

Summary: Bards combine mount-level mobility, effective healing, excessive CC, and high damage. Does this class secretly have Game Master privileges?
The existence of all these features in a single class severely diminishes the experience of playing other classes.

Finisher Control Feels Poor:
Controlling finishers on most weapon types feels clunky, especially when fighting large groups of monsters. It would be fantastic to have a separate visual indicator to track the progress of finisher activation stages.

dreamy egret Jan 21, 2025, 9:39 AM

#

Top 3 Bugs:
1.Caravan issues. Everything from them sinking, unable to attack or defend, pulling driver out of caravan to kill them, teleporting the driver to carphin, healing players on one side of a caravan fight or another without be classified as an attacker or defender, to a host of other issues.

2.Inventory bugs, from items not appearing in your bags to not being able to move them to thinking you moved them etc, relogging 3 to 5 times to do inventory management is an issue.

3.Looting monster bug where you have to log out and log back in order to get your loot.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Crafting - There is a lot to unpack here and I know there is a lot of artisan things coming. That said I feel like there is a issue that will become clear when people are able to level from 1 to 50. From level 1 to 10 crafting is fine it is not hard to make someone armor or a weapon that they can use right away. Once a player gets to level 10 and keeps leveling they get drops instead of coming to the crafters, mostly due to 3 issues. 1) node progression to alow the crafters to make things that can help a level 10 to 20 player takes a long time in comparison to the players ability to level. 2) The amount of time and needed rescores for the crafter to up their skill to apprentice in comparison to normal leveling. 3) the complexity of the recipes increases 3 to 5 times just to make level 10 gear. Currently in the test people are now making more level 10 gear to use with enchantments making them better than the drop level 20 gear. However if you look at how long that has taken vs the character levels you will see a issue that will just get worse when people can level to 50. Almost no one will ever craft any gear to be used between level 10 and 39, thus making it just a huge time and rescores sink with no empowerment of the craters. I want to make things and see people use the things I make to help them level and fight, not just sell back to a vendor.

thick grove Jan 21, 2025, 9:51 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

light bugs in forge/carphin
driver of caravan being randomly teleported to carphin
croc randomly murdering you while driving on it
spots where mobs can't deal damage to you but you can to them
lack of coal

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

window/ variance of named mob respawn timer needs to be increased greatly to stop people from logging in every 36 min
flying mounts are too opressive for caravan riders. Remove from game till proper royals stables functionalities added
there isn't enough nodes to test all functionalities. boost default gatherable stations to journeyman so we can test artisan system fully
remove food/scrolls from vendors. Prices are too cheap which kills a lot of professions as people can buy cheaper then artisans can produce
Add basic item name search for marketstalls. That's a low hanging fruit that will save thousands of tester hours.
======================

chilly minnow Jan 21, 2025, 9:53 AM

#

======================
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Fix the static spawns on Mining/Herb/Logging
Inventory/Bag/Storage Visual Bug
Desync when riding mount and getting off sends me back to previous location ( doesnt happen as often after patch but still happens )

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

More Raptor/swiftclaw spawns in different locations maybe. Maybe griffon too havent really seen the need for them but I see them used in a lot of recipes
Coal and other resources needed for Journeyman to be implemented
Small thing = More reasons to defend caravan, as attacking benefits way more to random encounters
======================

polar bolt Jan 21, 2025, 10:06 AM

#

======================

🧵 ** Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025** 🧵
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Raid Frames: Debuffs are not being shown / Range needs to be adjusted correctly
Friendlist/Guildlist: Lists do not show guild members/friends properly.
Equipment: Shields are not being displayed. Shield vanishes when you roll, climb etc..
Mount Glitching: a. Mount's legs often getting frozen, b. Sometimes you get teleported back like 5 mins ago.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

🔥 Chat systems: Trade / LFG / Whisper/ Invite/ link items-proffesions
🔥 Marketplaces: Need filters
Guildlist: Need more filtering (archetypes/level/location)
Quests: Needs serious rework. Not appealing to the eye.
Buffs: Need rework in the way that they are being displayed. Too many buffs are hard to understand/detect. Put the node-buffs in a separate buff “box”.

======================

sinful sand Jan 21, 2025, 10:09 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

inventory issues - constantly desynchronising, creating the need to remount or relog your charakter with no guarantee to long term fix it. also items stuck in the quest item section of the inventory.
apprentice enchanting scrolls usable by novices. -> enchanted lvl 10 gear making a joke of gear-, crafting-system and game balance.
resource nodes that are ungatherable or phantoms (not harvestable trees vanished after relog) increased with last updates.
mount animation glitches are persisting
spawn mesh hight is off in too many places

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

server performance took a hit with the last patches (rubber banding, phantom nodes, input delays)
the reward for running carawans is too low, the events are still being exploited in their current state.
more GM presence and immediate actions please
**weeping willow **as crafting component, especially in its current quantities needed for "everything", is a too strong bottleneck.
please fix Ardant Voyager speed - this has been "exploited" for weeks now.

strong sundial Jan 21, 2025, 10:09 AM

#

I've yet to progress to level 10, but I have some feedback regarding what I've experienced thus far, which is as follows:

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

I've found that some of the most rewarding commissions I've taken are bugged or on an extremely long spawn times. Particularly the Quick Teddie, Captain Roderick Bloodbane and The Fang of the Road commissions.
The Zephyr Winds quest that starts from a scroll found as a drop from some mobs (Our Family Fights!) seems also broken, as the Zephyr Winds camp doesn't have the leader or any kind of NPC there as far as I could tell.
Some commissions or quests seem to mislead in regards to map tracking, like the goblin Blood Rune quest or the green crystal one.
The shields seem to be bugged as I have one equipped yes, but after some time the model just disappears.
It seems that quest items clutter the regular inventory spaces instead of going into the quest item tab.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I would like to see the ashes of ones corpse linger for a minute or few longer to give a bit longer for us to recover our drops when we perish.
I would love to see gathering nodes be a bit more static in their locations and rarity.
Would love to see more ways of leveling while low level, as most of the most rewarding commissions and quests seem to be bugged and I've failed to find groups often when I've tried to level by killing mobs.
Would love to see a way to add map markers on an quest area (the rings that show up when I need to kill a boss or some mobs in a particular area).
You're all doing a very good job so far! Keep it up!

tiny prawn Jan 21, 2025, 10:12 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

The most common bug is an error in displaying items in the inventory, please fix it
A player who fights in pvp can be healed and not receive a flag, this is not good
The aggro of mobs sometimes doesn’t drop, and the mob runs after you half the map

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The spawning of all resources occurs strictly in time, in the same quality and quantity, this kills the economy, please make the system unpredictable.
The damage in PVP is too strong (Bard, Mage), it kills the tactics and comes down to the zerg.
Add interactive chat! This is sooooo necessary 🙂
=====================

ashen heart Jan 21, 2025, 10:14 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs

Client Crashes too frequently - did not see this in Phase 1.
Memory leaks (seen memory requirements grow by 1Gb every other second in Task Manager when triggered!)
Desync issues forcing logout to collect loot/reorganise inventory

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Weeping Willow being rare and required by just about every craft in some form or another is ridiculous. Scarcity is one thing but when combined with timed resource spawns can lock crafters out of there profession for an entire tier...
Server performance still an issue (let's hope dynamic meshing is in place soon!)
Armour/Magic Resistance seems to mitigate a lot less than it should.

ember stump Jan 21, 2025, 10:16 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Random Teleportation to Crphin when running Caravans, seems to affect some people more than others
Reduction in random crashes
Warehouse functionality especilaly righ clicking breaking

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

When right clickin items into storage seemt o place new item in the lowest storage bag, this would be more effiecient if it was the top one as this one is unaffected by citizenship
Would love some quality of life improvements such as right clicking chat for whispoers
Not sure if this is a bug, exploit or as intended but Fishing and Lumberjacking guild wards wara are alsmost constantly being declared and the chatter is its being used as away to attack guilds without the expense of a guild war.
======================

hollow oasis Jan 21, 2025, 10:36 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory - It is inconceivable that the inventory is still broken. Probably the most commonly used game system there is, and its still broken this far in to testing. The amount of disruption this causes hampers testing - unless your intention is to test continually logging in and out as a by-product of this bug.
Caravans - There are way too many bugs with caravans. Disappearing when converting to raft/land, spawning without event, not dropping crates when destroyed, teleporting you to Carphin for no reason, unsellable cargo, disappearing cargo, crashing if too many caravans in area, flagging system breaking and causing corruption, rider being killed off caravan despite having rider protection buff, unflagged healing. There are probably more but this is what I have encountered, and continue to encounter.
Mob AI - Despite the ban wave I still see continual abuse of game mechanics with mob pathing to avoid being hit or pulling on to others. Whether its jumping over a Freehold fence to make a mob run to either side, standing in a safe spot to avoid attacks, purposely pulling mobs in to other groups AoE. There needs to be enforcement for these actions. Unfortunately PvP it out of the question because corruption is over-turned and prevents social justice with its current form.

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Static Resources - The current system it atrocious. Once you know the system, and just how basic it is, gathering descends in to a matter of stopwatch and spreadsheet. Resources of high rarity are being gatekept by those who find them first, as they know the rarity level and the respawn time and farm them non-stop. A basic solution with the current system would be to randomise the spawn time to at least give a slim chance of finding resources, as it would disrupt the gathering routes and prevent clock watching.
Desert Nodes - The desert nodes are at a severe disadvantage and lagging behind in progression due to lack of POI, resources, and other reasons to be in the Desert. This lack of progress means certain artisan skills are missing, and will be for seemingly months, due to the speed of progression of the nodes. Even if the desert nodes somehow manage to complete their buildings they will struggle with the upkeep due to lack of player footfall generating income.
Respawn Timers - The more times you die in quick succession the longer it should take for the release/revive option to be active, or some sort of 'rez sickness' beyond the currently inconsequential stat dampening. PvP battles can descend in to a war of attrition, or who's gear breaks first. Take for example a Caravan, the closer it gets to town the quicker bodies are thrown at the battle in quick succession; there should be some form of penalty/delay for continually dying during attacking or defending.

languid gulch Jan 21, 2025, 10:40 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Invisible/ friendly enemy npcs
Harvesting artisan gear rarity increase not working
Inventory desyncing

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Character XP gains from artisan skills. Ridiculous I can put in just as many hours testing a different part of the game and severely lag behind in level compared to someone that just aimlessly kills the same mop over and over again.
Marketplace needs a better search option, trying to find what your looking for currently is a total PITA
Rarity on "hunted" mobs. Have farmed well over 100 frogs with only 1 rare and this is at 250+ hunting rarity

nimble crane Jan 21, 2025, 10:42 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bug
Teleporting / traveling back to zones
stuck in Place ( for sec.)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Armor does not effect on Character
DMG Scale is too high ( 1 Hit Fights )
Market place needs love
======================

covert halo Jan 21, 2025, 10:48 AM

#

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Terrain stopping movement (either invisible items or minor items stopping you dead, when mounted or driving a caravan).
Invisible and under terrain enemies
Storage bugs from either moving into or out of storage, sometimes climbing on mount and off again fixes, 98% of the time it needs a relog. Any manipulation of glint is the most common trigger for this. This includes the plethora of caravan storage bugs either, epic or rare items appearing to not be in a caravan to caravan bugs out to commodity cargo actually disappearing.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Rubber-banding between or in server workers
invulnerable enemies NPC's
Give the marketplace some real love, especially search filtering.

torn trench Jan 21, 2025, 11:00 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mobs teleporting and running away, not being killable, invisible mobs hitting you
HUD resetting on its own after customizing
Weird hotkey issue where if I use hotkey Shift + S but I try to rebind S to walking backwards, it doesn't work. The fix is I have to reset all my keybinds. Also noticed that randomly action combat mode will break & I am unable to auto attack. I would hit z to enter tab target and z to go back to action combat mode but then combat mode acts like tab target mode.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Allow us to use scroll wheel up, scroll wheel down, shift + scroll wheel etc as hotkey options.
Game is not new player friendly at all. I spent countless hours running around trying to figure out what to do in the game. I spent probably over 24 hours in game time just getting to level 7 because of this. The crafting skills are especially bad with this & I have no idea what they even are or how to start them. Finding groups is extremely difficult because everyone is nerd no lifers already at max level.
Make the game less grindy or at least provide better pathing for where to go. The game has appalling user interface in regards to the map and icons on the map, with both the minimap and the world map. Make things stand out more, make them more obvious, or at least easier to notice and understand.
Figure out the PVP system. Granted I havent dedicated lots of hours playing but it seems to me like the current system discourages and disincentivizes PVP in the open world because its so punishing. Basically this means the only ones that will PVP are big clans or a big group of people versus a small group of people or 1 person that the bigger group will obviously win against. It feels like the PVP in this game is just pointless, but maybe I'm just too low level and inexperienced that I'm missing the points of where PVP actually matter.
Fix the sprint. Allow an option to either toggle or hold sprint

rich hazel Jan 21, 2025, 11:13 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory desync
The caravans are still teleporting people -- I think is server boundary issues
Rarity across hunting and other gathering items seems like it is not working as intended? What is the probability to get legendary compare to the other profession?

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Being able to heal someone without being a part of the event should not be allowed. Too often people are leaving healers out of caravan events and you cannot attack them without flagging up.
I genuinely cannot tell if the rarity has been nerfed to all oblivion or if it is just not working correctly. It would be awesome to get more transparency around this. It feels too difficult compared to other gathering professions to get higher rarity carcasses. Additionally, because of how little anyone is getting higher rarity items with gathering, the sentiment I often hear is that people should ignore the rarity or upgrading it and just get the base of whatever tool since rarity doesn't work,
Create a working market filter for item

whole crane Jan 21, 2025, 11:18 AM

#

Bugs :

1 - Caravan event tagging not working while grouped
2 - Group members markers on the map getting out of replication or not showing at all (having ton spam click the filter to have them blink)
3 - the group ui not showing and having to toggle raid/group or move someone to get it refreshed is annoying and happens a lot

Feedbacks :

1 - Not having a way to decide if a spell should target the offensive or defensive target is a bit frustrating
2 - Having an option to make the raid frame grow from bottom right to top-left instead of to opposite it currently is.
3 - i found it hard to know if a target has a particular debuff
(also in raid frame same issue with friend debuff often not showing)
4 - an option to show raid frame even when in group mode pleaaase
6 - i absolutely loved it during preA2 when Cleric's wings were able to "fly" vertically, please consider restoring this behavior ❤️

terse comet Jan 21, 2025, 11:19 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/21/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 most important bugs:
1-) The caravan system still needs some work, so far I lost 3 full caravans. Once you launched it and log out, you can't deploy on any node.
2-) In some of the dungeons glints and items cannot be looted. We have to relog to loot again and the inventory error still exist
3-) We have an optimization problem in Carphin and also inside the nodes (I think the structure roof etc.). This is killing the CPU. Also there is some render distance issue when it comes to medium sized pvp.
The most important 3-5 feedback issues:
1-) The locations of collectible materials are not random, even their rarity is not random, so mostly all good materials are collected by certain players, because they know the exact location. This will hopefully change in the future because people are stunting each other and stealing materials. And this creates a really toxic habitat. Because this is something other than PVP.
2-) Griefing is a big problem. If it is intended as it is now, it should change. Basically mob behavior has to change, for example they follow you to the grave, that's too much. And the agro mechanics need to change a bit, for example we can be the target of someone else's mob even though we didn't hit it. 3-)The rarity bonuses in crafting items are not working at all . I was following the project since the beginning and I admire your work and effort thank you for it.

stark lava Jan 21, 2025, 11:32 AM

#

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Most Important Bugs:

inventory desync is one of the annoying ones and been in game for so long
in some pvp cases when players Alt + f4 their body becomes immune to dmg and ur attacks / abilities doesn't dmg them at all i dont know how they do that.
rubber banding still happens
Hunting rarity needs some love its rough to hunt 1000 of animal and maybe get one epic or rare quality.
if you kill a person next to emberspring and their caravan is close by their caravan will become immune to damage too so they can buy time there just dying and wait for their team to arrive or dont move at all till attackers give up!!!

Most Important Feedback Topics:

gathering rarity doesn't mean anything if u know legendary materials location also gathering speed still does not work
Make hunting to be actual hunting for example if someone wants otter carcass they need to go hunt and kill an otter and they should be apprentice hunting already with a app bow so they can have the carcass as drop, this means if an animal is novice or app or journeyman your hunting should be in that same level first so when you go kill them they will drop carcass for you or a chance to drop carcass and if we want to get the mount you can feed them or pet them or set a trap to catch them alive.
add the name of person in caravan UI so when there are multi caravans we know which is which and choose defend or attack without making a mistake cuz once you choose a side you cant change it anymore.
a simple way to fix corruption baiting instead of going a mile to add more coding and... to just make name plate start blinking before they get out of flagged is when you are flagged for pvp you cant get unflagged as long as you are taking dmg so if you take dmg it will just simply restart your timer which is supposed to take u out of pvp. so if you flagged and you are taking dmg every second or so u cant unflag unless u dont take dmg for like 1/2 min.

stray dagger Jan 21, 2025, 11:32 AM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Gatherable Nodes being static (primarily related to Mining), doesn't matter tool rarity, gatherer shirt/shiv/tool, the rarity and quantity is always the same and the respawn time is fixed, so after every maintenance or restart, just keep farming the same to get high rarity materials
Caravas are immune during EmberSpring protection time, I don't believe this is intended, also the Mesh change areas for caravans are causing huge issues for many players
Being able to Heal or act in an event without opt-in to join the same, Clerics and Bards are able to give support to players without joining a Caravan event
Inventory issues, gathering materials and them not showing on the inventory, needing to relog to show what you have on your inventory

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Let us make carcasses from huntable mobs / mounts. Bears/wolves/otters become useless after a month. make them have a purpose.
World bosses spawning on server restart instead of having a window in which they can spawn
Server performance needs to be improved, we are still having meshs comming down during prime time.
Improve freehold capabilities and Family/Marriage system for it
Make so raid/party leader has the ability to opt-in on Caravan events for ALL players inside the group.

steep heath Jan 21, 2025, 11:35 AM

#

Top 3 Most Important Bugs:
Server Worker Transition (Inventory loot bugs, performance issues)
Caravans (lot of unintended behavior here)
Untouchable Gathering locations (Trees in rocks etc)

Top 3 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Love what you are doing with the game, keep up the good work!
Sorting of the Marketplace by item and not by keywords. Option to remove sellers who has no items/goods for sale.
Resource spawns are shared, however its not a good idea to spawn more high lvl deposits of a specific type, if the tool to harvest them can't be made in the world.

rough garden Jan 21, 2025, 11:36 AM

#

chat size

whole hull Jan 21, 2025, 11:38 AM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Servers are still horrible, a lot of work has to be done to get things smoother. A LOT of times I get stuck moving between one server and another, it is very annoying.
Hunting animals respawning mid air or at unreachable locations.
Caravans are 100% bugged, when I attacked another player's caravan and destroyed it, the loot spawned mid air and we couldnt loot it, wasting everyone's time.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

PLEASE put some time in mobs mechanics. Ranged mobs are casting spells / attacking through walls, Line of Sight almost never works. Also pathing is horrible right now, when mobs cant walk to you they'll get stuck and suddenly teleport to your side.
Treasure hunting feels very boring after you do it for the first time, we need more variables and different mechanics on it.
Loot drops should be better distributed between zones and mobs.
Please add some basic filters to the marketplace. If we could filter by weapon / armor, type of resource - it would make marketplace so much better with little development.

patent haven Jan 21, 2025, 11:41 AM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Channel settings are not saved. When I relog back in, I have to go and set the options for all the channel tabs again from where I had them. This is VERY frustrating.
Many quests (such as Delivery: Eye of the needle) are not able to be completed. There is no one at the tailors house to deliver the package to (perhaps it's a level thing? I was level 7 at the time).
No quest markers on the mini-map. If I am following a quest, a compass direction of where it is would be great to have.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Stealing. There is no real punishment from stealing and a party member can't stop people from stealing their friends loot. Perhaps put an area around the loot so that if a party member of the person who died is in it, only the party member can pick it back up? At the very least, allow party members to fight the person stealing it without a penalty.
I cut the oak. I mill the oak. I can make a cart. I repair my tools and spent around 20 mins. doing all this. My profit? 20 copper. It seems that it should be higher as you have a homeless guy in Lions hold asking for a gold for help. I guess what I am saying is that I feel if I'm doing the entire spread of tasks, I should make more than 20 copper.
Caravans should give something to defenders. XP and perhaps gold. I've spent a good 45 mins. with a caravan and all I got from the person who I was guarding was 2 silver. I understand that this is a player decision, but what I'd like to suggest is that before the caravan takes off, you set a total amount (either to be split by all defenders or by person {and some kind of limiter on the number of people allowed to defend officially}. This can also be 0 money) and pay that before the caravan leaves. Those who are offered to join the caravan see how much they will be paid and can make the decision to defend it or not and if it arrives and they are within a certain reasonable distance, then they get paid.

======================

indigo plume Jan 21, 2025, 11:47 AM

#

📎 message.txt

fleet totem Jan 21, 2025, 11:50 AM

#

====
01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Dismounting desync on your position (aka teleporting you to a different area after you dismount)
2. Invisible enemies. Invisible enemies that cannot be found, targeted, or killed.
| This may be caused by attacking a 'locked/broken' mob that doesn't move, but soon you get attacked by an invisible mob |
3. The Cleric spell Chains of Restraint does not have an indicator of where it will be placed on the floor, nor does it have an indicator (hotbar icon change/sound/etc) that it is even active to be placed on the floor.
| This makes it difficult to cast and it's possible to accidentally lock yourself out of your other healing spells unaware. |
4. Friends list not saving or showing friends properly.
5. You can heal caravans, attackers, or defenders, while not being an active participant yourself. I recommend locking out caravan players and caravan cart from heals from non-caravan players.

.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. The rarity of a hunted mount should matter for its attributes, such as HP, max speed, etc. This should apply to both Mounts and BoB's.
2. At the moment, Apprentice tier crafting artisan tools and especially clothing are heavily gatekept behind a very few select resources (such as Weeping Willow, Raptor Hides), which do not spawn properly in multiple locations/sites for actual harvesting. Please consider adding greater variation of materials for the compositions of the different processed items needed for clothing and tools. This might mean expanding the pool of available resources, such as more types of Apprentice tier woods or hides to use. For instance, Willow should not need to be in (almost) every single processed item to make (almost) every single crafted artisan item, and Raptors should spawn in more than a single condensed location and should also not be needed for every single crafted artisan clothing. Variety is key.
3. It is impossible for every single artisan profession to reach above apprentice level (there are not enough nodes for the buildings). Being able to ensure that every profession can be followed through to its end is important. This may mean that outside of major towns there are smaller Outposts that could be dedicated to a single profession, similar to Briarfarms for the novice stations. Allowing for these kinds of outposts to also be upgraded to higher tier stations would be one possible way to address the issue, as would simply adding more towns or more nodes to towns.
4. Too many crafting recipes use identical recipe formats. As with artisan items, variety in this would be greatly valued.
5. Quest reward values, such as XP, are essentially insignificant. This should be improved, so that quests can be somewhat viable for progression.

steady mist Jan 21, 2025, 1:31 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Huntables: Carcasses quality (rarity) lacking, bottlenecking crafts.
Caravan: Teleporting to Carphin emberspring.
Inventory: Items being moved between inventory and storage but no visual feedback provided, this also happens with caravan cargo after arrival.
Invisible enemy NPCs: Some NPCs are showing to some players but not to others. Some NPCs are showing but standing still not taking damage while other players see them correctly moving and taking damage.
Events missing: The “Spider Hill” event for example, seems to just not spawn anymore. It seems impossible to get Arboreal Cocoons at this point.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Marketplace:
The bare minimum would be a search for item name, more filters (quality, stats etc) would be nice to have.
Caravan/ economy balancing:
Problem: Right now the attackers basically carry no risks, while the caravan driver not just invested his glint in the commodities but also the caravan pieces. This leads to pirate/pvp guilds snowballing hard and controlling the economy.
Proposed quick solution: Get rid of caravan request beacons - this will require attackers to escort an empty caravan with them if they want to loot the full commodities.
Cursor customization:
Possibility to increase cursor size and change cursor color (maybe also style <3)

bright schooner Jan 21, 2025, 1:35 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bug when switching weapons that disables auto attacking and prevents weapon swapping. The attack animation continues at a faster rate but does no damage.
Some mobs can be attacked but do not move from their original position. You will then begin to get damage markers on yourself as they are attacking back, but you cannot react to anything they are doing.
The flashbang. Entering certain areas causes a flashbang effect where the entire screen gets extremely bright. Current workaround is to play with global illumination.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

MEMORY LEAK!!! The game is constantly peaking to 20+GB of memory usage where it crashes.
Game still needs more T1 metal resources on the map. Resources should be zone controlled: Lower level areas have more T1 resources and vice versa as the mob levels increase in other zones.
Some starter quests are still missing zone markers that make it difficult to find the mobs you need to kill. On the characters I have made I've just been skipping these quests.
======================

errant ingot Jan 21, 2025, 1:36 PM

#

Weekly feedback - 1/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Too 3-5 most important bugs:

inventory desync not being able to pick up or move items is very frustrating.
Gathering scroll working on all professions -logging getting none.
Gathering tools stats applying correctly.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

The gathering rarity rating seems not to be working. Many of us wasted A LOT of time crafting a rarity gathering tool to increase that stat but what we saw is our effort was useless. This should be checked because, as you said many times, the best gear in the game is the one you craft. We also need to test if the gear in the game is balanced, but we cannot progress in this way.
Durability loss on PvP should be reduced by far. In an event where we want to test a lot of things and improve our skills, we cannot loose 2g or more repairing items...
Change the way a player joins a caravan event because if it's in party he can't unless he's the leader. Also you need to make the party again after all the players have accepted the event. Healing outside the event should not be allowed, but that seems hard to solve right now.
Add a range of time for spawning all nameds and bosses: its respawn time +-20% would be nice.
Visual distance of players when several players are near is reduced significantly. I guess this is part of the server's optimization routine, but doesn't feels great when a lot of players starts popping in your field of view so close to you.
Thanks for your effort! 😄

hexed solar Jan 21, 2025, 2:02 PM

#

3-5 Feedback

Hunting. I know that the current system is not what is intended in the slightest, but it is all I have to go on for Feedback. The spawn system is two rigid and allows for serious spawn camping which monopolized all of the early tier one spawns and now tier 2. I had made a new character to try out the Tank and had a hard time leveling to 3 in the safe area because several high level players were camped in the timid grem and timid spider area killing everything that spawned. To me that is kind of a problem because for early level the killing fields alone is too dangerous, so you need a spot to learn the move sets without aggroing the entire universe, especially as a tank. Last night, at like midnight was the first time I was able to get a mount trainable tier 2 hunting gatherable. I got lucky enough to walk up right as it spawned. Usually each of these areas has max level players just hanging out to wait. I am almost hunting level 20, if that puts it into perspective. I understand that there is a need to maintain rarity and I have been informed that random spawns is very hard to actually accomplish, but the current system is really not good. In addition, why do the silk worm larvae move? As a concept it's cool, but it always cancels out my gathering so that sucks.
Herbalism vs Farming
Now, this next issue may be due to the limited supply of crafting items currently available. I have reached Journeyman Herbalism, though no sickle because I am on Vyra. It has been my observation playing with someone who had apprentice mining and now journeyman mining, that herbalism spawns are really low and few and far between. So the actual plants are hard to find, but then you can just make any of those plants with farming, and many more. So what is unique about herbalism? My hope is that there will be mats that can only be gathered, otherwise herbalism seems kind of redundant. Farming has a much more controllable outcome and you can get huge quantities

#

Debuff markers. I play a cleric, and therefore always have a party member targeted so that I can easily heal them. With all of the buffs that player can get, class, node, etc. Seeing debuffs can get very difficult. This comes in particular importance with the zombie curse debuff which changes healing to damage. I need a way to more quickly ascertain when someone needs a purify versus a heal. Burning is pretty easy to spot, but the bleed, wounded, curse all kind of look similar. Maybe like a red box over the person's bar on my screen?
Node war. I saw in Steven's latest interview som of the ideas that you guys were working on to deal with Emberspring spawning and camping. The root of the issue though, is that you have a designated location where people know where players are going to be. One day those embersprings won't be in the middle of nowhere so this problem won't be so exacerbated, but at low tier nodes it's a problem. My humble suggestion, is that the Embersprings have Citizen only secret passages that lead to two separate spots within the territory (maybe a node can spec into more idk) that way you split the forces that are waiting for vulnerable citizens. It would also provide a way for low level citizens to retreat from the battleground as safely as possible

low gale Jan 21, 2025, 2:07 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Inventory glitching - needing to mount or relog
2.Bugged Resource nodes. Often harvesting a node does not visually destroy it so it looks like it is still there, but it isn't. This happens A LOT.
3.Node rarity being static for 24 hours.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.Tank "charges" never reach the target. It happens more often than not that my charges get rubberbanded or maybe blocked by inclination? If the ability lights up and I click it, I should reach the target unless blocked by a tank wall. These abilities feel bad, and I think they used to work better before the XMAS break.
2.Make Resource components searchable in the recipe book. Very hard to get a sense of what is needed for what to understand if I should keep resources for a skill trade I want to do or sell it.
3.Chat window. I should be able to right click names to invite to party or to reply to messages. Hitting "enter" before typing is not intuitive or in line with older MMOs that I remember... typically hitting "/" will automatically put you in chat so you can enter a command, this would at least be an easy change by default
4.Marketplace should be searchable by exact item name, not just one word inserted in the title of the store.

final fjord Jan 21, 2025, 2:10 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Memory leaks. My God, they are bad!
Bank issues with not showing items are transferred between bank and player is still a major issue, having to constantly relog to fix it.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Server needs to be restarted each day to reset screwy spawns where the mobs are bugged or having mobs spawn that should not be there...
The static spawns for resources is horrible IMHO. Aren't they supposed to be constantly changing locations and what they are dropping?
I really think that manufactured items need a bit of price adjustment. For example, inks need to have their resale prices increased. The water costs more than the ink is worth. Usually, the final product is worth more than the ingredients, even to an NPC vendor. Not looking to get rich but everything should probably get some sort of adjustment.

grim narwhal Jan 21, 2025, 2:13 PM

#

Weekly feedback - 1/21/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 most important bugs:

Random teleporting to the past.
People being able to target caravan drivers and attack them directly and at certain angles do full aoe damage.
Inventory, needing to remount to update the inventory.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Crafting mostly useless. Just buy from vendors or mob drops. Fire whoever put gear on vendors (j/k)
Improve the marketplace with the ability to search and sort. This will help the economy a lot.
Too many players for how much map is available. Need more playing area. If a willow tree spawns then there can be 3-5 players racing to it. spreading players out on more map would help out a lot.
======================

jaunty gull Jan 21, 2025, 2:20 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Server Performance issues is the highest issue. It affects the overall state of the gameplay with npcs or players. Group content in major points of interest doesn't feel as satisfying and ultimately may be detrimental to time sink due to server performance (i.e. mobs don't respond, mobs are stuck in wall, mobs blink out, etc). I know it's on the high priority focus already but for a personal Likert scale, this is a big one

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

You all are doing a fantastic job. This is an amazing Alpha II roll out and I am hooked. I'd say one of the things that is tricky is the game play is created mostly towards group play, with some focus on soloing, which makes sense and matches the vision I've heard. Not opposed/objecting. For the solo player, the game becomes difficult to get into the best gear or top loot rarity. Only feedback would be to consider options that allow for an adventurer in the massive world to find a random roaming/spawning mob that is a feat to solo, but is feasible with some rewarding loot. The rarity being that the spawn location isn't camped and even if group content was doing it, it be scarce enough that no one could exploit it. Just a thought
I've heard this mentioned I believe as a focus, but the scaling of tiering up crafting and level disparity really makes crafting a secondary priority to leveling. This gets compounded when the specific crafting spawn spots for certain areas are able to be camped, but are needed (i.e. raptors etc). This does provide some competition of a sandbox where "how will the players respond?" "What social/behavioral constructs will be done" As this behaviors mirrors society, war will break out over scarcity of resources -- makes sense/expected. However it forces out smaller groups/solos from any competitive chances with such minimal static scarcity. Random spawn spots would be more rewarding for the adventuring element and purposeful crafting time sink.

rugged basin Jan 21, 2025, 2:22 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Tower of Carphin teleport to 4th floor acts more like a relog bug than anything cool, please fix. Maybe make the key actually required?
2.Tower of Carphin 5th floor Oculars - glitch out and get stuck behind walls, hard to find and fix regen, they randomly reheal to 100% over and over on the same ocular. I still like the idea of having like 30 behaviour states on these oculars and make some of them really funky. Some of the glitchy behaviour is alot of fun to manage! So don't make them too predictable please.
Tower of Carphin 5th floor boss is bugged, but considering how mean the oculars are, i don't feel bad for killing it.
Caravans bug out and disappear and all loot is lost, drivers can be attacked, stuff like that.
Game keeps crashing randomly.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

I know there has been a lot of talk about taming monster teleports etc. to make this game easier for players... shrug. **Don't make the monsters too predictable.**Keep teleport IMO. Prefer gameplay over "immersion". Teleporting monsters is way more fun to deal with.
On a similar topic, people complain about "griefing" alot, but using the monsters against enemy teams is the most fun gameplay designs ive experienced in a long time. If anything, this idea should be expanded on, not run away from. If they don't like it, they can go pick flowers for gear instead.
Would like to see and expanded buffs list. Half the time i cant tell what buffs I have up because the nameplate is overfull +7 buffs.
Party forming and chat features like a modern game would be nice to have. My friends list keeps getting wiped. Would also be nice to have an enemies list 😄

novel brook Jan 21, 2025, 2:26 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

More of an optimisation issue, loading characters into heavily populated areas, alot of the time. Improve or add a workaround to improve loading of assets and textures. Often I have to log out and back in to fix any issues - for example character models not loading (i.e. just see floating weapons).
Randomly not receiving general experience when gathering. Appears to be hit and miss, sometimes I get it while lumberjacking, othertimes I just dont get and the lumberjacking exp only.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Limited areas for experience and gearing opportunities. Whether its based on lack of knowledge or lack of content, 99% of players end up going 10-15 at Highwaymen Hills, 15-20 at Sephillion, then 20+ to Carphin. Positives are that always easier to find players to group with, but negatives areas get crowded, etc. Also all the loot that seems to drop is heavy armor
Lack of variation of 'metals' and 'gems' to mine and Wood. Everywhere I go I always see Granite, Basalt, Oak and Ash. Alternatively, put these in a mine content area, where there are lots of spawn points of copper, iron, tin etc but make it where there are also mobs. Copper can be in a 1-10 first floor, iron/tin on a 10-20 floor and much rarer metals and gems on a 3rd floor where its 20-30 mob areas. Flil it with undead dwarfs or something due to Warhelm Curse. Not hard to be imaginative about it. 🙂
Stealing from [Axiom] Sonic: Death Penalty On Tanks - With Tanks dying so often, there are long term economic implications for those who are playing Tanks. They will earn significantly less glint, and therefore gold during their playtime.

granite merlin Jan 21, 2025, 2:49 PM

#

Rendering Distance Limitations: Current rendering distance is too short, impacting gameplay visibility and experience.

Resource and Boss Spawn Mechanics: Resource and boss spawn timers need more randomness to prevent predictable camping, especially on server restarts. Spawns should have randomized locations and timers post-restart.

Performance Issues: Persistent visual stuttering, rubber-banding, and memory leaks require optimization and cleanup of game code.

Loot and Inventory Bugs: Players experience issues picking up loot and managing inventory or bank items, such as being forced to re-log or manually dragging items due to right-click functionality failures.

Party System Defects: Party UI often disappears upon re-logging, requiring cumbersome workarounds by party leaders or members to restore functionality.

median aspen Jan 21, 2025, 2:51 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

When dismounting sometimes the mount will get stuck in a run pose, start sliding down a hill after dismount, or worst teleport you back to a point on your route in another node.
Mobs stuck in walls
Mobs not leashing back to their original spawn point after breaking agro

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

LFG window with auto invite and character lvl would be very helpful!!
would love to see more huntable apprentice lvl creatures/faster spawn times for apprentice and journeyman tameables
a buy order window for individual crafters would be nice to connect gatherers and other crafters

surreal pollen Jan 21, 2025, 2:55 PM

#

Top 3-5 most important bugs:

trading 21+ sized stacks if your sanctus bag is full doesnt work consistently even when your other bags are completely empty
any kind of war spam - needs warm up and cool down
caravans disappearing, bricking, becoming undeployable
right clicking to move items from bags to storage at the storage manager doesnt always work

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

inland drum Jan 21, 2025, 5:23 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans disappearing, getting stuck, and being undeployable. I've lost more caravans for bugs than for players attacking it
Random rollback (when you get teleported to the past)
Server are too unstable when crowdy

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

World Bosses need some love! it feels more like a PvE event than PvX. Groups prefer a DPS dispute over fighting each other. They are forming a single raid with members of 5 different guilds so that you can't declare a guild war to claim the boss for yourself. Some players even prefer dropping their guild tag for that same reason. It would be great if the World Boss area become a PVP Zone where each raid is an attacker team. The Boss is also dying too quickly that you barely have time to arrive there.
PVP needs a stronger incentive for increasing its engagement. Right now when a Node Territory War is declared, players just leave the node territory for not engaging in it. They abandon their city unprotected because there is no consequences for losing the war. It ends 800x0 with only one side engaging in it. Same thing happens to Guild Wars, you see a guild raid grouping up, you declare a war thinking you're gonna have a fun PVP match and they just disappear from the game completely. Suddenly you can't find them anywhere and the guild war ends 15x0 when the time is over.
Guilds could have some kind of level system that gives benefits both in PVE and PVP. Something like craft bonus, or 1% stat increase, or even active skills. It's sad to see some major guilds playing without their tag to avoid the consequences of their political actions. They are spreading in 10 different alt guilds with random names to avoid guild wars, they are leaving their guild to avoid getting their caravans attacked. It would be good if there was some gameplay loss for not carrying your guild label.

quasi ivy Jan 21, 2025, 5:25 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Bard is to overpowered
Game freezes and memory usage goes to 20gb+
Inventory bug (not being able to see the loot in inventory, or not being able to right click items out or into storage)

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

You should not be able to right click your own character to mark or leave party. Let it be done only by clicking your player frame
Can we get a shared storage between characters
Buff Fighter damage or mitigation
======================

twin wadi Jan 21, 2025, 5:26 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory not updating require mounting or logging out for 15s
Not being able to loot items
Broken/bugged mob spawns and mobs getting stuck in geometry

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Randomize and shorten node spawns.
rework the market system and add a trade chat
add the ability to condense materials to increase the rarity. ie turn 10 common logs into 1 uncommon.

lost widget Jan 21, 2025, 5:28 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory/Bags and Storage out of sync
Map and group display, making group PvP a nightmare
Hunting rarity totally bugged (and spread of hunting resources)
Fishing and Lumberjacking events Wardec exploits

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Auction House search and display
Server Workers transfers and PvP at borders
Esc key should NOT stop melodies ! That is really annoying
Almost no benefit from being in a guild (except Wardecs)
Leashed mobs at SW borders get stucked until server reboot

indigo nest Jan 21, 2025, 5:29 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Dead body timers. They are not long enough. This is causing reckless and suicidal behavior when trying to retrieve them. When I'm in a group, I often find that everyone just abandons their bodies all-together....the risk of compounding losses is just too great. We already have to worry about the bodies being looted...why do we have to fear the timer, too?
Dead bodies being overwritten. If you die while trying to retrieve your body, then the former body is deleted along with the loot. I think this is a very punishing system. I would encourage consideration of allowing one to loot their past 2 bodies. This, with an extended timer duration would give players a chance at regaining some of their loot.
Flagging PVP. Why can't we just simply press the button once to toggle for PVP? Why do we have to hold the button? The default is ALT...and if I release ALT while attacking someone who is purple then I can no longer attack them. Sometimes I release ALT by accident and I waste a bunch of my skills. This is incredibly annoying and can be improved upon imho.
======================

wind swift Jan 21, 2025, 5:33 PM

#

Top Important Bugs

Inventory issues persist. From disappearing items, not being able to move items, to not being able to loot
Gatherables, specifically willow trees, spawning inside rocks and being unobtainable
Caravans still being a buggy mess where you can get teleported across the world to an emberstone and your caravan isn't wirth you. To glitches during converting to or from a raft.

Top Important Feed Back

Caravans should not be slowed down when damaged by monsters or players, and should be 100% immune to all cc. They are stupidly slow as it is.
Caravans are pathetically too easy to destroy with just 1 or 2 people, even with the braidwood armor. Make caravans take 80-95% reduced damage, or make it so you don't lose your caravan and bob when it gets blown up.
Make it possible to rename caravans so its easier to manage when you have multiple.
There needs to be a reward of some kind for people to defend a caravan, as right now there is nothing and no reason to help anyone.
Those attacking caravans should be given corruption when the caravan explodes as currently there is ZERO deterrent or repercussion or penalty to offset the huge losses the caravan driver faces. Too skewed to the benefit of the attacker.

slender glade Jan 21, 2025, 5:34 PM

#

Top Most Important Bugs:

The lighting issues in the Forge (and likely Carphin still) where night/day and death causes either flash bangs or darkness.
As a bard, the melody sticking you in combat forever is frustrating (for mounting and trading)
Rubber band issues with running

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Resource nodes should be more random in location and rarity. People set timers for high rarity nodes, named mobs, and world bosses because the spawn times/locations are so static and predictable. This is very uninspired and boring.
Draw distance is way too low for pvp (and even pve sometimes)
Bards have amazing CC, damage, and heals. Balancing needed as this is one of the best 1v1 AND group classes. Resonate Weapon 1 shots people in pvp and this is a support class?

signal bobcat Jan 21, 2025, 5:50 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Still a lot of issues with parties/social service. It requires constant refreshing/toggling to raid then back to party frames. Often updates to the party stop working where the names become faded or shows 0/0 for the user. Crashing puts your client into a bad state upon logging back in where your party UI does not sync to the server. It thinks you're solo, but party chat still works.
Ranger scatter shot fires twice while holding/being charged so that you no longer have a second shot. Or in other words, you could have 2 shots available, you do your charge shot and it uses both shots on 1 shot so now you're not able to use it again. Dmg numbers show for both so it seems what is happening is the initial charge fires at full strength then the secondary cd is being triggered but not at full strength as it is always weaker.
A lot of random crashing/freezing. It hasn't been established what to do about this.. do we send in logs? There are no errors codes, the game just freezes where you have to force close, or it will randomly crash and go to desktop prompting an unreal error report.
Rarity seems bugged for wood/hunting

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Ranged classes are inherently at a disadvantage with current pvp mechanism. I like the pvp mechanism as I come from L2 and Archeage. But the whole point of a ranged class is not to be hit/caught etc. Currently you have to wait until someone hits you in order to fully unleash on them otherwise you go fully corrupt. If I initiate as a ranger, I now have to wait for them to catch me, hit me in order to flag, just to then try and escape so I can actually fight. That's pretty poor game play mechanics. It benefits melee classes by default. Unfortunately, I don't know how you solve this. It means that the only time ranged classes can pvp is if the other person initiates first and that defeats the purpose of being ranged. If there is no way to solve this via the pvp mechanics, then the class kits need to be severely updated to account for reactionary game play.
Risk needs to be introduced for Caravan attackers. Currently, all the risk goes to the defenders and person transferring the goods. Please introduce the concept of mules with packs like in Archeage. I don't want to be forced into group content always ie caravan trips. Allow for solo travel packs with a small bump in trade amounts compared to vendor and enable caravan pvp mechanics if needed.
Processing queue slots should start asynchronously, not sequentially. The crafting implementation needs an overhaul and should be a focus given how much it is used currently in the Alpha. Missing 1 item to make it 24/25 where you can't craft because of that is really annoying. Also, we should be able to craft more than 1 item per click. Crafting 100 small ash crates gets old quick with that many clicks and tempts someone to automate it anyways.
PVP/Classes needs some initial balancing. Bards/fighters are way overpowered
Item storage in warehouses needs some increasing. Compared to personal inventory and other bags, it is really low. That or lower the entry fee for the first upgrades. It should not be 5 gold
======================

analog scarab Jan 21, 2025, 5:52 PM

#

Bugs

Hunting rarity needs to be fixed. It’s crazy that I’ve picked up plenty of high rarity copper at lvl 5 mining with the starter pickaxe, but I’m lvl 26 hunting with an epic apprentice bow, and the best I’ve ever gotten is 1 rare otter carcass
Invisible mobs. I’ll hit a mob and it doesn’t move or react, so I move on, but then I’m suddenly taking damage from something that I can’t see or defend against so I just have to run away until the damage numbers stop
Invisible items in inventory. I try to move something from my bag to storage and it disappears, so I either need to get on my mount or eventually just relog in order to see it again
Attack distance for mobs. I’m constantly taking damage from mobs that haven’t reached me yet, but yet I also can’t fight back because they aren’t close enough

=================

Feedback

Inventory storage slots needs to be increased if it has to be shared with all of the nodes
Someone who isn’t part of caravan PvP should not be able to heal someone who is participating in the caravan PvP
Caravan attackers need more risk
Stop removing my cursor from the chat box every time I make a comment. Once I start using chat, keep me in there until I choose to tab out of it
Marketplace UI needs improvement. Searching is clunky and tedious and letter count for stall bios needs to be increased

brisk pagoda Jan 21, 2025, 5:54 PM

#

Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory issues still. This is a massive annoyance and sometimes hindrance to gameplay.
Terrain issues causing mobs to get stuck and gathering nodes to spawn in locations that are impossible to harvest.
Some video settings not working (resolution) & lighting causing graphical issues.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Great job addressing many of the top concerns from last week's feedback thread! It's reassuring to know that this exercise counts.
Caravans need some balancing around the PVP aspect. There needs to be some better incentive to defend.
Weeping Willow is used in FAR too many recipes at both the apprentice and journeyman level. Almost everything requires willow at some point and it's a frustrating choke point.
======================

echo wadi Jan 21, 2025, 5:58 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bug
Game crashes since one week
Caravans / The coachman should not be targetable

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

[Crafting] needs to be reworked in the intermediate levels. Given the difficulty of creating items beyond rare quality in the intermediate levels, there is no point in doing so. It's better to wait until you've reached the final level before starting to craft heroic, epic or legendary items. These items could be upgradable to keep them interesting to make.
The risk of losing everything (storage, house, etc.) following defeat in a [node siege] will drive many players away. The penalty for defeat is completely disproportionate.

hollow estuary Jan 21, 2025, 6:01 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Caravans being immune once rider rezzes
Bards are bugged, they are broken in all PVP aspects, please fix. It makes no sense a bard 100-0 faster a dps than the dps does it to him+ all the insane party buffs
Gatherables - A lot of gatherables (Willows in particular) are not gatherable please fix these locations

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Would like a small change to the flagging system for attacker/defender. Please let it be done for an entire raid group/party so that we don't have to constantly drop party to attack or defend. Still love the Caravan events, not sure I like them ending with people crowbarring the content. This is a great event to keep going, maybe remove crowbar or make it like a 1 minute cast that can be interrupted and flags you for pvp?
Time to kill is to fast and renders classes like warrior weak af when they’re designed to have sustain and durability (bruiser style) when they get 1 shot by everysingle class including supports like bards and clerics
Mele classes in pvp underperform at a huge rate due to hypermobility, it’s borderline impossible to stick to a target + required the same ammount of hits a mele weapon than a ranged weapon for finishers etc with less attackspeed and 0 range. Mele underperforming is obvious if u check top pvp guilds compositions

unborn ginkgo Jan 21, 2025, 6:06 PM

#

Hey friends! Finish those thoughts, and I'll be closing down this thread momentarily.

Future threads will be open up for most of the duration of testing, so you'll have more time to share those thoughts 🙂

visual thicket Jan 21, 2025, 6:08 PM

#

Most of my reports ingame this week were stuck npc not targetable but target you. In walls/terrain. Got attacked a few times trying to report from the location and had to run. Shaman I believe throwing spells from inside a hill. Second most I logged was gathered items not dissolved after. Staying visible but can't be collected again so you don't know till you actually stop to try and harvest it.

tight dawn Jan 21, 2025, 6:10 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Cleric healing doesn't crit. Or, more accurately, the crit % feels like it's stuck at 0.0000001%. I can go hours and not see a single crit on my HoTs or direct healing. Then, seemingly randomly, it occurs. I have 5 clerics, different races, different gear, and healing crit ranges from 15%-20% at max divine power. I've reported this in game but it never seems to get any attention.
Targetting gets stuck on a mob while using Action Mode. Understand, I am NOT referencing an accidental target lock onto a mob. I mean the game locks my target to something or won't target something. I have both my lock target and clear target keybinds set. Clearing target does nothing. I have to hit Esc to drop all target to "reset" it.
High Server Latency causes Cleric heals not to register. This is primarily an issue with Deliverance. I usually have both passives for it. Not sure if that matters.
Skill queing is broken or registers slightly too quickly. In the heat of a battle with high latency, I can often double HoT someone by accident. Maybe I'm in heat of the moment and it's user error but it feels like it double registers my input.
Debuffs do NOT always show on party frames. It's frustrating to waste heals on someone that is heal debuffed. This happens the most with the zombie heal denial one.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

Essence infusion is trash. I can manage mana just fine without a bard by the time I level up my weapon. At starting levels, it has very low value as well compared to Divine Infusion. DI saves lives and can allow you to insta rez to restabilize from a wipe scenario. EI is just soft padding for a Cleric that plays poorely. You don't ever want to spend Divine Power unless it's in a high stress situation. EI never feels worthwhile. Please, give it a different functionality. Personally, I would like to see it provide shields to my healing target(s) or a minor HoT. If DI is for saving parties reactively, EI should be the proactive option.
Communal Restoration needs to affect allies in a raid, up to 8-10. This skill feels bad in large scale PvP since it only affects party members. It's not realistic to stay stacked that way and this skill is hardly that impactful in comparison to the high burst damage currently present.
Cleric feels too basic. I'm a hardcore healer from many games and right now AoC's implementation feels lacking. Most of my buttons have very little interactions and I feel like I provide very little utility to support my group. No AoE cleanse and almost no proactive way to prepare for incoming damage. I'm just a reactive heal bot with different flavors of healing lost hp. Maybe this is a level 25 problem but I really would like to see some major utility cds added to fix the void. Similar to how Tank's top section is Rally, Intervene, etc.
CC break skills should make you immune to all follow up CCs or provide 50% dr for x seconds. CC, in large scale, is an issue.
Fighter and Tank have a melee problem in large scale. The game's PvP heavily favors range because burst damage and CC are obscene. For example, I have 40% physical mitigation on my Cleric and was still hit for 2.2k+ from a single Ranger. I only have about 4khp. Melee need defensive "walls". It's how theey stand their ground and uphold a frontline. That's a term meaning high % mitigation cds to predict incoming damage. Typically, cds like this last 5-8 secs. Alternatively, stick to the game's team reliance focus and allow Tanks to provide some group % mitigation via skills like Rally or Aegis, so Fighters and Tanks can work together. Iront aura could also use a buff to 5%, at least. At 2% and at such a small range, it has almost no value.
======================

unborn ginkgo Jan 21, 2025, 6:11 PM

#

Thanks for those last minute submissions! I'll be closing this thread now 🙂

rose ore Jan 21, 2025, 6:26 PM

#

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Mounts and caravans teleporting you back to where you mounted up originally when you dismount.
Pressing Esc removes Bard Melody
Inventory Bugs where transferring items to storage does not visibly work or harvesting items wont show as looted without relog.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Improvements to the tank role and giving it a different name as "Tank" sounds placeholder.
Improvements to searching for specific items in marketplaces instead of keywords for shops who are sold out of the thing they were mainly selling.
LFG chat or board.
Item linking in chat and right click persons name to whisper, invite to party, add friend Etc. (snuck it in)

kindred schooner Jan 21, 2025, 6:43 PM

#

======================
Weekly Feedback - 01/20/2025
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:

Inventory Bugs (Moving items working but not being updated. Have to mount/dismount/relog to refresh. Can't right click items to transfer between warehouse/bags. sometimes it will combine glint instead of moving to warehouse)
Mobs being Green for some players causing them not to be able to affect the targets (requires player to re-render mob for fix)
Mobs appearing to be stuck/stationary on some people's screens, but the mob is actually moving and participating in combat.
Mob's going through terrain/walls. (Things like the thaumaturge in Carphin always backing up to get away from melee will back away into a wall where they can't be targeted by spells. They can also back pedal through a tank wall)
Mobs will sometimes climb trees when trying to path to you and will cause them to get stuck on that tree forever. Might get lucky with a tank taunt/chain pull to get them down, but most will just get stuck on there. See Tropics with Kumots and Iguanas.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:

There are people actively abusing exploits, gloating about it and not getting punished. Tanks are were purposefully getting to 99% damage reduction and then griefing people because they were basically unkillable. Guilds would get tanks this high and then declare war on another guild and abuse this bug to gain a high advantage. After recent round of punishment, they were untouched.
Gatherables being static rarity ever X-hours. feels like +rarity means little to nothing.
Pylons seem to add no value
Hunter Rarity feels bad - thousands of huntables and only gotten blue. Received more legendary Zinc than I have rare huntables
Better information UI for node buildings/upgrades. Too many players have no idea how mayors/buildings/upgrades work unless they are a mayor.
======================

#Weekly Feedback Request - 01/20/2025

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.Marketplace search needs love
2.a way to transfer items between characters on same account
3. /r to reply to whispers

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

Thanks for all the hard work the team is doing 🙂

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.A visible point system of artisan skill tree to show availibility of
2.
3.

Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3. Too new to know

Game is amazing, keep up the good work!

======================

Alpha Two Phase II Feedback

Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs: