pulsar oriole
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
======================
wanton eagle
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
pallid shoal
Feedback:
robust iris
Hi here,
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
obtuse shadow
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
odd solstice
Thank you for all you have done to make a fantastic game! You are all very appreciated ❤️ I love so many concepts of the game and am looking forward to seeing the progress.
tranquil thistle
Top 3-5 most important bugs:
Top 3-5 most important feedback topics:
void mason
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Mobs' leashing and AI issues being trained onto bystanders. Or Mobs like grems being able to consistently attack from way far away. Mob aggro ranges are also inconsistent even between the same named mob.
2. Caravan system needs revamp. Incentives for defenders, and recoupability, as well as just polishing out the bugs of disconnects, wierd teleportations, etc.
3. Different invisible terrain walls for the same height stones but in different areas very inconsistent, and mounts don't traverse particularly well, or on foot. You know, those mobs may also have trouble with those walls and could be the reason they get stuck a lot after being trained far away.
4. Quests need some vigorous polish, from lack of information and immersive-ness, to poi points to inventory quest items not actually going into the correct Quest Items tab or items being properly removed upon completion, this effecting side quests and the radial ones from the various boards of nodes.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. We may need to define the line of what is acceptable behavior for pvp and what would constitute griefing. Because it certainly gets old with enough your mom jokes or just shittalking thank god for the ignore button, but then deliberately gaming the system on low-level players because you're bored? Better accountibility needed. In addition, you find exploits and report. Then you DO NOT USE THEM, REPEATEDLY. Ban those that knowingly do.
2. QoL things for many UI features. From enabling a better search and filtration for the marketplace, better chat/social filters, maybe even making guild's membership a slightly bit larger in capacity. And adding some more features to the UI editing hud to address the bajillion buffs/debuffs a person can get within a node and fighting.
3. Gathering spots that spawn higher tier levels could refresh into whatever else it shares on its table randomly after so long so that they can be gatherable again, preventing some painful chokepoints for gathering and crafting and potentially removing static rarities so a single node isn't camped endlessly.
4. Remember to love the casuals, solo, and RP players please. Thank you. ❤️
lunar siren
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sudden rain
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
stoic saffron
Bugs:
Feedback:
whole sleet
Top 5 Bugs:
Top 5 Feedback Topics:
soft tiger
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Thank you for listening to us ❤️
ivory zealot
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
worn ledge
Bugs:
Feedback:
south jasper
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Cannot do Treasure hunts still, (Right clicking map does nothing)
2. Caravans disappearing
3. Inventory bugging out which includes, Unable to right click from personal to storage, Dragging from personal to storage doesn't do anything, Right clicking from personal and it shows in your personal and in your bank storage at the same time. (Relogging fixes this but it breaks wayyy to often)
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Communication - discussed on asmongold v narc v stevens stream the best and after reviewing it understand Stevens side better. Just wondering if you can confirm is the Wiki something Intrepid updates or is it a fan made wiki that is updated by data miners and ashes geeks? Because the phase 2 list of what was to come on the wiki sparked a lot of joy for some people but I know the livestream didn't nearly everything on the wiki. So just curious so I know which source to rely on.
For future reference,** I do not think releasing a phase or beta, alpha anything directly before a holiday break is a good idea.** I think you kind of left the team with a massive storm to deal with as players were unhappy with all the issues occuring over break. Personally I get it, everyone has lives, holidays, families. But you or whomever decided to put the phase 2 on December 20th, and then extend it to January 6th kind of made that excuse have less impact as this phase could have started on the 6th instead with the whole team back from break ready to be on standby. Leaving a brand new phase and in alpha state no less alone for 2 weeks not very forward thinking. Everyone no lifed the HELL out of ashes over break and found lots of bugs, exploited them, and well some found in their minds a lack of content. (Not me doe but ya know)
**Everyone, and I mean a large portion of your community is waiting to see what the team does about all these exploiters. **There have been multiple videos sent over break expecially in the Vyra channel about guilds like Polar abusing the war bug. I do hope that you do not just give these players a slap on the wrist as it would not coincide with what how Titans ring was handled. Please be thorough and please do your best to get rid of exploiters. A lot of them are just laughing off the exploit.
4.** I love Steven streaming and flying around seeing what testers are up to on stream. More of this please! **
covert osprey
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Inventory lock have to log out to fix
2.Group lock have to log out to fix
3.No xp have to log out to fix
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
weary jacinth
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
random leaf
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
midnight briar
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top Most Important Bug :
Top Most omportant Feedback :
Thanks for the work
opaque gale
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wet spire
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sick shell
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
dull cape
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback @slate mica
I would like to present to you video of botters (would prefer to send you these directly if possible) at a broken ashes warrior spawn. the names so far are UIU, BiuBiuBiu, DZT, LuckQueen (Part of guild: Bussies) and girl.
I have submitted a ticket and have been adding to the email chain for the ticket.
A friend and I were aimlessly running through Winstead near steelbloom and found a very suspicious group of people exploiting an Ashes Warrior spawn near steelboom (The island north east of steelbloom) . After trying to communicate they would run and unstuck to try and get away. We noticed they depot at Winstead vendor and sell all that they collect from here. Today we came back to find them again and started to kill the botters and try to break them off of the spawn with some success. One of the botters replied to my friend asking them if they are botting and they replied with "Mind your business."
Please fix this asap. Its a pebble in the mountain of things yall have going on, Thanks for what yall do.
fringe wing
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
valid mountain
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wild hill
Alpha two phase II Feedback
Love the Alpha, love the team and love Steven - keep up the great work😌
mystic sonnet
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top Bugs:
Fix Inventory - Items either not showing up when you pick them up or move them around. Current work around is to log out and log back in.
Fix Bard Melody will always end if I close Inventory, Options, etc wit "ESC" - its so annoying
Fix Caravan System, lost caravans,, lost cargo in cargo storage, port during driving a caravan to another city
ripe plover
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback - (Thank for asking!) a Bards perspective.
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
formal blaze
Top 3 bugs to be fixed
2・Treasure maps cannot be used.
3・Bug in which movement of material items is not reflected.
ーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーー
In-game elements that need improvement (may be bugs)
1・Mob train and PK with holes in the rules
I would like to know what the ruling would be on the act of pulling a large number of mobs and egging them on in order to keep others from farming.
Also, targeting a PT in the middle of a battle with a mob and stunning them so that the mob can finish them off is still the same as killing an unflagged opponent, but it only results in a purple name and has no disadvantages.
I'd also like to know the ruling on this action.
2・About the irreversible debuff given by zombie mobs.
The description says that they can't heal, but if you try to heal them with a cleric's skill during the debuff, you'll take damage.
Also, if the heal kills the opponent, the cleric who has not been flagged will be red-named.
regal perch
Treasure Maps
Mob AI Exploiting
upper karma
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Important Bugs:
Important Feedback Topics:
Would like to see large resource gathering operations as a group using caravans (will promote more PvP).
Imagining something along these lines :
Resource pylons temporarily claim an area for a limited time.
Resource pylons temporarily increases respawn rate of resources in an area for a limited time.
Resource pylons cannot overlap with other claimed area.
Resource pylons should apply a cooldown to all participating members to prevent players from controlling a spot indefinitely.
Players not in the group that gather in the claimed area become flagged.
Large quantities of collected resources can be placed in a caravan and driven back to town.
Please put more effort in making questing more viable. Grinding Dungeons and Points of Interest to level should have limits or diminishing returns so it gives other groups an opportunity to rotate in. Maybe make a mob grinding pylon that "claims" an area for X minutes using similar rules mentioned above for group gathering pylons.
======================
cold ridge
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
void dirge
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
rigid ice
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
fluid horizon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wraith vigil
Bugs:
open linden
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
elfin jay
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sweet wigeon
I thought of one more feedback but I did not have enough letters to write it in my first initial text….
Feedback
zealous pebble
Can we please have a game with stealing? Somebody please answer how come a game can be All pvp. You can murder but you can't steal? Rogues, when they do make it into the game, needs stealing!
radiant urchin
Caravans: My caravan in Sunhaven with all cargo crates inside it, completly vanished over night. Sunhaven crates in Winstead Node cargo completly vanished...I bought crates in New Aela, lost the glint, never got the crates in the New Aela cargo for my caravan. Various caravan bugs like spawning in front of Carphin!
Zombie negativ healing bug! Killed so many ppl till now, first time got corrupted cause of it and lost much stuff after I got killed -.-
Inventory/Storage bugs! Unable to loot or to move/vanishing stuff in inventories.
Overall bad performance around player concentration zones, like up to 3sec skill delays from the server side.
Treasure maps cannot be lootet or used, cause he is permanently kneeling or something else.
Nerve Oculars? Nobody likes them..way to overpowered!
I couldn't heal or rezz ppl outside my grp, is that intended now?
You didn't fix the zombie bug where they endlessly run away after mage chill/freeze/shatter..did many reports in phase 1
Debuffs not showing in grp, have to constantly switch grp/raid to fix it
Make custom crafting amounts, PLS
ashen siren
1.) Caravan disappearing bug & Caravan Alt+F4 Exploit
2.) Randomly getting teleported to Carphin Tower Emberspring when changing Server Worker
3.) Flagging sometimes incorrectly displays people as purple aka PvP flagged even tough they are not
4.) Launcher is bricked and every time you want to relog you have to do a full restart and force close the launcher or the game will break in all sort of funny ways.
5.) fix rarity for hunting
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.) Fix Caravan bugs and Exploits
2.) World bosses should have a fixed spawn time independent from server crashes and restarts, it should be during prime time and not at 02:00 like its on EU server atm.
3. Negative progression and RNG with enchanting sucks extremely. If you want to make enchanting expensive then make it more expensive but remove gear loss and downgrade chance. Failure chance, downgrade chance and item break chance feel like you are playing some shitty pay2win trash game.
neat belfry
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
dim plume
Bugs
Feedback
When you have 20+ something quests on you, and a step of that quest is done or the quest is completed, you cant see in the quest log what quest just has been updated.
I would love it to be more visual in the quest log, what quest that recently got updated and also i would like quests to be more visual on the map. Now i have to zoom in and go around the map to find a little yellow circle melting in to the background of the map... And the "show on map" dosnt work on a lot of quests.
steep phoenix
Mine was kinda long sorry
woven jacinth
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
past bobcat
Bugs:
1 - All caravan feature bugs(only real pvp system in game)
2 - Inventory and storage bugs
3 - camera locks problem between action/tab mode
4 - nameplate colors and classes colors cant be changed
stone stirrup
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
true pebble
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Connecting to the server led to the game stop working or not loading, which meant having to always reload (either with the launcher or task manager) at least 3 times before it loaded the server correctly. Even then, sometimes most functions were not ready, so that a soft log out and log in 1-2 was required. This was not the case in Phase I.
Some mobs appeared with no health or mana, with a green name tag. This meant there was no way to kill them. They still became aggro if you got too close or attacked them, meaning you were faced with invincible mobs. Depending on the level they were, this could be lethal.
Having another bag in your inventory (not equipped in your materials tab) made the primary bag bug out. Materials that were placed in the bag would not appear. Materials collected in the world which were automatically placed in the bag would not appear, nor would you get a message in chat that you received the materials. Any materials already in the bag which were placed in storage or another bag would still appear in that bag. Everything would fix itself with a logout/login, but it leads to a lot of confusion.
Some commissions are bugged and cannot be turned in, in my experience it was a mayoral commission of collecting 25 lumber.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Some mobs like the wolf are too fast, even if running away on your mount, meaning they will keep hitting you even if you are only running away, especially if it was a coincidental pull as you were travelling along. At higher levels this can be deadly.
If there is a marketplace, there should be some sort of market price system. Right now it's a lawless land of pricing things as you will, with no point of reference. Also, have the search function search for the items themselves, not the name of the storefront or description. As it is, you are forced to name what you have listed in your storefront description if you want someone to find it.
Please change the colors of the different chat modes. Citizen and Say should not be the same color.
Better mob placement. There is little sense to having an area with lvl 10 mobs, and suddenly one lvl 18 standing right at a crossroad. In general, roads should be safe to use (exceptions are intentional placement like the roadblock from maurauders between Halcyon and Winstead, since there's even a physical roadblock). Random high level (usually even starred) mobs popping up on the road seems unfair and in general annoying.
wraith oxide
terrain errors mainly, spasmatic or mass respawns
boreal elbow
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
getting corrupted for killing a thieve who is flagged. (please add a combat log to flagged players)
getting griefed by other players in open world dungeons, either add save points where u can jump onto tob e save or fix aggro system
inventory bugs which force u to relog every minute to either loot or organize your inventory
======================
frail steppe
======================
Most Important Bugs:
Most Important Feedback Topics:
griefers
players training mobs into other groups, or pulling high level mobs at town storage where low level characters die. guards are useless. not enough being done to address these players
caravans:
ui not saying who is the owner and guild they are from, being confusing when multiple are on screen. range of event being very short, need to walk up to it to sign up. attackers have no risk at all while owners risk it all.
citadel sets:
one small room with lvl 19-20 mobs to farm sets is awful, with the other room not being accessible anymore with mounting/dismounting bug. some pieces (medium set) much harder to find than the other 2
rarity for different professions
finding even a rare animal/carcass as hunter is almost impossible. same with lumberjacking and herbalism i think. mining instead can find a lot variety in rarity even with just a low grade pickaxe.
nodes growth
always the same 2-3 nodes growing fast while the others always lag behind because they have no low-level grind spots. once the vassal system come in place i wish every node had a fair chance to level up before the others do. all servers will look the same
storage space ridicolously low, for items and for materials.
======================
topaz parcel
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
obtuse yacht
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tardy peak
Bugs:
Feedback:
short crescent
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
pearl surge
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravans disappearing.
Caravan attack / defense doesnt work on party, need to disband the party / raid. Everyone must flag and we must reinvite people.
Weapon skill bug. Even if you change weapons, unequipped weapon skill tree still applies.
Feedback:
Enchanting level 10 gear is currently too op. For example Bone Ring uncommon has 1 int. On every successful enchantment item's power increases by %100.
When you reach 180 - 200 main stat regardless of armor type , pvp becomes too bursty. Everyone one shotting eachother.
fallen coral
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
worn copper
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
pastel shadow
Bugs:
FEEDBACK:
runic moth
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
- Teleporting to Carphin while traveling with caravan across the ServerWorker,
- Disappearing commodities from caravan,
- Commodities selling value = 0 for Desert commodities,
- Unable to "Group join" to caravan event - you need to disband the group and join separately,
- Infinite caravan event - most of the time you stay flagged for caravan event even when caravan is finished.
- In event PVP game should prevent Healers from being able to help without joining the events - it results with not being able to target them without additional PVP flagging,
- You can disable PVP flag and it have ~15 sec until it's off. The time should be refreshed when you are hit by enemy, as currently the flag can disappear during the fight corrupting you.
- Enemies are stuck in floor, walls, underground which cause some spots to be broken/unplayable or too easy, being able to pull mobs out from their default place,
-Mobs aggro as it's easily changed it allows to fight for mobs, but on the other hand it allso allow to grief the spot to pull group of mobs into other party to wipe them,- It's not a bug, but WorldBoss and named mobs spawned on server restart results with spot camping on restart time to get the first kills.
- Eq is often bugged so we cannot see that we moved items. They are moved, but UI is not refreshed,
- Right click to move to and from Storage is not working most of the time,
- You cannot pick up Glint from time to time and have to relog or mount often in the middle of the fight.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
stiff dragon
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
glacial fossil
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback - POLAR GM
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
shell island
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
placid niche
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Resources like ores respawn too slowly, and having them on a fixed timer makes them too easy to monopolize by the same players.
Level 10 crafting requires a significant investment for items that are barely better than those available on the market.
molten lance
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mighty talon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
upper isle
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hushed mortar
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
meager wraith
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hushed root
It's way to easy to aggro mobs on somebody else.
Basic loot (glint, emblems) should be distributed fairly to party members as soon as one party member loots the body.
Cathartic melody sfx is way to loud!
Game should remember selected weapon between sessions.
Illumination in Befallen Forge
verbal cairn
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
manic tartan
=======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Important Bugs:
Inventory and storage. This bug adds so much friction to testing. Constantly having to re-log, just to be able to pick up glint, gather nodes or interacting with storage, is extremely frustrating.
Caravans randomly disappearing
Shields turning invisible. Because it makes me feel lobsided and I don't have anything better to put here 😂
teal junco
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
median grotto
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
outer cloak
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. inventory
2. caravans
3. getting corruption lvl 1 for healing someone who actually died by mobs
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. excessive crafting effort makes the whole system useless
2. gathering materials are too rare (copper, zinc...)
3. map improvement needed (party member visibility)
4. Best alpha played so long, well done and good job !!!
======================
regal stratus
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Weapon tree effect stacking: leveling up weapons give the ability for people to equip one of the weapons leveled up and still get all the damage procs from the different weapons = huge damages that are not supposed to be there, i saw bards proccing finishers for 8000+ damages (people are actively abusing it at current time)
Carphin curse: while riding a caravan you have a chance to get randomly teleported at Carphin's Emberspring; your caravan will still be in the place it was before this happens = you will need to run back to your caravan which will be left exposed to attackers. Happened 2 times in a row in the same caravan run one time, usually it happens 1 time per run
Storage bug: there is no duping happening on this bug but what happens is that i will try to store some resources in town and I can see they are put in the storage but they do not disappear from my inventory. When closing the inventory and storage of town and reopen them they correctly disappear from my inventory and the right quantity is added in storage
Freehold: weeping willow, eastern hemlock and western larch all give oak wood once I chop them down and no matter the rarity of the tree it's always common (that applies to the other woods as well)
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.2: Hunting: make hunting actually count, once you reach journeyman hunting you are faced with the best mount and the only acquatic/land mount being farmed by zergs that are killing the mobs that drop them. You are completely powerless against that and all the work you put into it does not count. I know lots of hunting and AH is placeholdery but I would love to see actual player skill being involved while hunting VS just anybody can come and get an animal
Exploiters: imho resetting characters to level 1 is completely useless because 1) the exploiters since the announcement of potential punishment have been creating alts 2) they are laundrying the money and the gear in the marketplace to retrieve them back thanks to other people they know that are buying them to keep them safe and trade them back once the punishment will go live. They need to be banned from at least the alpha, they do not contribute to the game as they are never reporting bugs and actively grief other players - making actual testers quit the game. You have a high retention rate since phase 1, but how much of that 20ish percent that left were really good testers that got exploited over and over and decided it was not worth it anymore?
We absolutely need active GM presence in Europe, is something that was told we will have for each server and at the moment there is none in EU. We have so many cases of exploiting, griefing and botting that a GM presence could solve easily. Seeing Steven getting into EU and having active exploiters being all nice and kind to him to have their 10 minutes of fame was distasteful.
Add one more server on EU, let people choose to be part of a specific type of environment instead of being stuck in one server. We are currently stuck in a server dominated by zerg guilds that want to PvP all day - which is fine, but let other people create a different type of gameplay instead of forcing them to just deal with 50 people hunting you down for daring gathering 1 animal. Just yesterday I saw a group of low level players being ganked by level 25 zergs - this is not PvP, is being a coward. #FreeArioch
winged bluff
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
-4. Current state of crafting and processing costs,utility, marketability up to lvl 10, aside from NPC vendors
-5. Marketplace features, improvements, level of node
======================
Thank you for reading! 
wary lion
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
subtle thunder
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
small fjord
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
narrow linden
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
dull meadow
Most "annoying" bugs from my perspective:
2.Weapon trees always being active
4.Various crafting/gathering bugs
shell heart
white estuary
Gathering related feedback
Respawn timers for resources need a randomizer (+/- 10-15%) to prevent players harvesting on the clock. Currently dedicated players can completely 'own' the rarer resources in an area without more casual playstyles having a chance to make an impact.
T3 resources 'blocking' lower tier respawns while the server progression is not far enough along. Assuming the (very slow) natural reshuffle of some T3 nodes I observed is intentional and not some bug I am ok with the way it looks now.
Freeholds potentially trivializing resource bottlenecks. Freeholds filled to the brim with planted weeping willows. 'Nuff said.
storm vector
Important to continue working on General Networking improvements (dynamic griding etc)
Treasure maps not working (cannot accept quest)
Freeholds and mass Weeping Willows
Great job so far with the game
vivid rune
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
warm lion
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
- tin ingot (metalsmithing)
- tin fragments (metalsmithing)
- tin (mining)
- tanned otter hide (tanning)
- otter hide (tanning)
- otter carcass (hunting)
- weeping willow woodchips (lumbermilling)
- weeping willow (lumberjacking)
- slate armor mold (stonemasonry)
- slate clay (stonemasonry)
- slate fragments (stonemasonry)
- slate (mining)
- animal fat (tanning)
- any carcass (hunting)
- slate mortar (stonemasonry)
- slate sand (stonemasonry)
- slate (mining)
- bluebell thread (weaving)
- giant bluebell (herbalism)
- slate fragments (stonemasonry)
- slate (mining)
- weeping willow board (lumbermilling)
- weeping willow timber (lumbermilling)
- willow logs (lumberjacking)
I can understand wanting artisan professions being dependent on others but this seems excessive, especially when you could potentially have to make hundreds of these items to level up to journeyman. I would recommend simplifying the basic recipes then have more complex recipes that create better items in that tier.
mystic ibex
Top 3
Visual no shield bug
Dropping through the world . Random locations
Quest markers not showing on map
Caravan system
Adding the dual archetype system
Chat log functionality, qol features like right click on names etc
worldly panther
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
If number 3 point is not an option, then let us also have an option to auto in materials for crafting, similar to how processing works
Player shops need major improvement, want to be able to search by item rather than look through each person's individual store, reaaaaaaally time consuming
acoustic surge
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
twilit ruin
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
The action camera needs some love - mouse movement bugs many times (need to switch back no normal mode), sometimes you point to a mob and target another next to it.
inventory/storage bug.
node buffs multiply and you cant see your own buffs.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Some resources are way too rare (hello copper, grem)
the animation from hunting tamed animals i think its not immersive at all.
The fuel system it doesnt make sense (exemple: put wood to train a mount) why not put some flowers, or some farm plants so they can eat while training.
dying to pve and drop loot so some guy can come and steal it. i think one of the 2 should be taken into consideration : 1 - we drop stuff when killed (pvp, pve) but there is a timer like 5min, so we can get it back. 2 - we dont drop stuff in pve , only in pvp. i say this because of that those players that aggro high lvl moobs to you and your party when farming in some POI's and we all die and they loot everything.
======================
thank you for the game, so far its been great!
charred solar
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
uncut harbor
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
jolly vector
Top 3 - 5 Most Important Bugs:
Various bugs related to caravans
Such as them disappearing, people getting yeeted and teleported around the map and commodities that sell for 0 gold
Many many bugs related to buffs/debuffs
Such as various weapon skill tree issues - for many people theres a bug that allows them to use all/many enhancements and buffs from all the weapons they have leveled up, but for me personally i can only reliably use a weapon skill tree from only one weapon (the one im currently holding in my hand). I'm using a longbow and mace+focus.
Monster/other NPC ai issues with pathing, return points after gettin aggro'ed and some other mob behaviour that could actually be tied to servers themselves. As some other people here already mentioned there might be a bug that causes monsters to drop less gear, some time after the server reset.
Inventory
Issues with moving items, UI not updating, right click to move often isnt working properly, issues with picking up glint
Classes/skills
There is a lot of minor bugs related to archetype skills like the CC breaks not working properly but other people here have much more to say about it
Top 3 - 5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
I think as of right now the desert needs at least 2 points of interest that would lvl up with the node levels. There was very few places you could actually use as a low level grind spot. On lotharia server those 3 desert nodes leveled up wayyyy too slowly, in comparison to other nodes. for players to be able to reliably test how the addition of those 3 new nodes affect the economy in comparison to phase 1.
Devs should take a look at the entire mechanic related to guild wars, because i see relatively many guilds declaring wars on other guilds, that end with a huge disparity in score. I myself havent personally been a witness to it but many people claim that some guilds are exploiting and bugging the guild wars to gain gold and xp scrolls from them. I have heard that the cooldown on a war declaration is 24hrs now, but on Lotharia we have a certain guild that went to war more than once the same evening.
Classes need some minor fixes and balance. I know this is not the focus of this phase, but i dont believe you can reliably test the node wars, guild wars and even the economy when the current mass pvp "meta" is to have as many healers, bards and mages as possible. I see bards doing constant over 1k hits from auto-attacks, feels kinda bad.
In action combat mode TAB, or a brand new button, should target the NPC closest to the aim triangle. I also suggest to get the "target of defensive target" mechanic to work - it'll make all group content a much better experience. I think that there should be an invisible square around the action combat target triangle that decides whether tab will switch target to the one nearest your mouse coursor/the triangle, or will just scroll through all the targets like it works right now (i'll make a forum thread)
cinder violet
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
outer glade
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
molten plinth
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
frail mural
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
That is all for me.
delicate gale
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1 - Caravan's issues - being warped, constant disconnects happening, caravan's falling into the bed sea/river, going below the ground for unknown reasons.
2 - Non-equipped weapon tree being used wanting or not
3 - Flagged status not displaying properly, people are temporarily flagging themselves to bait other's into the corrupt state, after the combat has started, combatent status should not be removed.
4 - Rubber bending during walking/moving during the war - many players were not able to properly play node wars due to being moved back and forth multiple times, making it unplayable for many, this was felt over the mounts or even if the player was on foot.
5 - Boss are bugging on walls, road or other places, intended or not, this kept happening with both Tumok and Firebrand. Spawn's should not start as soon as the server/mesh comes up.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1 - Render distance is awful when there are multiple people, you can easily start to render closer than max attack distance. While in combat, it shows players "showing up from nowhere" right in front of you.
2 - Corruption, as is, currently breaks PvP and promotes griefing as if that is pvp instead.
3- The chat system can really use some love
4 - Improve the Mob AI's so they return to their correct placement if they stay away from that spot for too long - some players are bugging/stucking mobs in the walls/waters in order to skip and not deal with them, or just so other's can't farm such mobs.
wispy heart
Apparently this is too long so... Here we go.
Edit: Add 1 more to the bugs: All known weapon skill trees are being used instead of just the active one.
visual garnet
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
junior ibex
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Every 2 or even 3 months would be great
cedar fern
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Bugs
Feedback
still plover
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravan bugs
Caravan bugs
Caravan bugs
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Caravan bugs
Caravan bugs
Caravan bugs
earnest arch
Most Important Bugs:
Most Important Feedback Topics:
scenic knot
Top 3 - 5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Horse/Mount Animation Glitch:
After a few minutes of use, mounts stop moving properly and begin to slide motionlessly. This significantly impacts immersion and gameplay.
2. Carphin Mob and Button Issues:
Mobs becoming stuck in the floor or in the wall is a frustrating and immersion-breaking issue.
The button to the third floor often fails to work, requiring players to relog to proceed.
3. Item Flare Timing Bug:
Item flares sometimes appear long after the drop, allowing other players to loot items without rolling, causing unfair advantages and frustration.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. XP Progression Is Too Fast:
The experience gain rate needs adjustment, particularly for levels 20+. Consider significantly increasing the XP required for level progression (e.g., x5 for each level).
Reaching level 25 from 24 should demand approximately 12 million XP. Currently, players can grind 24->25 in 3 hours (Tropics xp party), which undermines the sense of achievement.
Progression to max level should take 500-1000 hours of dedicated play. This ensures that reaching max level feels like a rewarding and significant accomplishment.
2. Standardize Death Penalty at 1%:
The death penalty should consistently be 1% of total XP across all levels. This standardization ensures fairness.
3. Revise Item Durability Decay on Death:
Remove durability decay on death and instead introduce a mechanic where mobs can use a skill to break (render unusable) a piece of armor and/or weapon.
Add an NPC capable of repairing broken items for a fee, creating a new in-game economy element.
Introduce a unique class or racial skill (e.g., Dwarves) that allows players to repair broken items using specific materials (e.g., 1x Steel).
nimble python
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
idle brook
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wicked quarry
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Not being able to join caravan pvp as a group/raid
2.NPC ai and griefers making trains
3.All weapon bonuses stack
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.Multiple weapon triggers activating on active weapon is it intended? It is gamebreaking so it should be looked at
2.Guild storage
3.Tank taking no damage when standind specific places (makes leveling and gear farming easy)
sharp tree
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
swift garnet
If you have already posted feedback in the feedback thread please right click the thread and choose "leave thread" to open it up to more players to leave feedback please! 
CM's will work on a solution in the morning, it appears to be hitting limit to how many can be in the thread as active at once... you all are amazing so much Feedback!! ❤️ ❤️
naive thicket
Bugs:
Feedback:
thick tree
inland spoke
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
• 1. Caravans being lost at server-worker boundaries. Really stunts the desire to run them.
•2. Combatant flags being able to disappear mid-PvP. Currently, it is somehow possible to become flagged as a combatant, be actively in combat with another player, and suddenly lose that combatant status. Beyond just causing people to accidentally become corrupted despite fighting someone who was flagged as a proper combatant (purple name with crossed swords), this bug is being abused by a number of groups and individuals to bait others into becoming corrupted.
•3. The Mage’s Unyielding Blink ability upgrade not making Blink break CC. It is endlessly infuriating and frustrating when most (possibly all?) other classes can break out of your one and only form of non-incap CC (Freeze) while your own CC-break ability is entirely useless.
•4. The friend’s list being mostly (if not entirely) cleared whenever you log out. It’s just super annoying.
•5. Heal cuts causing heals to damage you instead of just stopping you from being healed. Enemies that could cut healing were already annoying to deal with, but now not only do you have to actively worry about accidentally killing your ally, but you can actually become corrupted if you use a heal on someone outside your party on accident and it kills them.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
•1. Having mining gatherables be static (both in terms of resource type and rarity) on an exact two-hour respawn is a really feels-bad system. People simply monopolize gatherables that give high quality and valuable mining materials by coming back and farming them as soon as they respawn.
•2. Clerics (and heals in general) are currently way too strong in PvP. In a 1v1, most classes are more likely to run out of mana than kill any competent Cleric.
•3. I feel like Tax Receipts should be purchasable with the citizen/reputation currency that you get from completing buy orders.
•4. Small QOL thing, but please add the ability to click “back” in the marketplace interface to instantly flip to the last page of storefronts.
granite thicket
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
shut idol
BUGS:
Inventory bugs. Where the newly obtained items stop showing in inventory and you need to keep mounting/dismounting to make them appear or relog;
Some resource nodes are unobtainable. You press F, wait for resource to be gathered and then it just stays there;
Invincible mobs. Some mobs spawn invincible and don't react to getting hit in any way;
Performance and memory leaks. I've had a case of bad memory leak the other day where the game just took all of my RAM (I have 32gb ddr5) and froze. Had to alt+f4 it for good;
Taxes are not always get accepted. I've paid my taxes the other day, the status changed to "Paid". Then relogged the other day to see that the status is "Due" again;
Some mobs spawn in textures/trees/underground and as a result either cannot be targeted or cannot move properly. Specifically suck when this happens with named mobs;
Quests. Some quest chains end up with NPC just not having a dialogue option to finish the quest;
SUGGESTIONS:
Improve chat. Add capability to right click player's name in chat to automatically /whisper to him. Add capability to link items from inventory to chat. Add Trade/LFG channels;
Marketplaces. Make it possible to sort all items in the marketplace by name, lvl, type, price, etc.
PvP/Corruption. So, I was sharing a farming spot with some other dude and at some point a huntable grem has appeared. I was first to get to it and start "hunting" which pissed the other dude off and he flagged and started attacking me. I responded, flagged up and started fighting back but he somehow managed to deflag himsel, so it made system to believe that I was the one starting the fight. So, after I've killed him I got corrupted and became red. The next lvl 25 ranger passing by saw me and one-shotted my ass. So, I didn't get anything out of this pvp interaction, lost a lot of materials and 2 equipped gear pieces on top of XP dept. Gave myself a word never to flag in this game ever again.
limpid charm
Most Important Bugs:
Most Important Feedback Topics:
raw thorn
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
remote umbra
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
📣 ... keep up the good work for 2025 !
still lintel
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The next wave of punishments needs to be big, aggressive and lasting to send a message to all the bad actors. A simple slap on the wrist is going to achieve nothing.
If you are a healer in a group and some members of that group join in attacking a caravan but you do not, you should not be able to heal your group mate without being flagged. This is exploited and means the caravan defenders must flag and go red to kill the healer.
Resource rarity - The benefits of having higher rarity artisan gear don't feel very impactful so some tweaking could definitely be done here. A high rarity lumberjacking axe should more regularly yield higher quality wood. Tools and luck should determine the rarity, not the spawn location. Currently people just spawn camp/run a route of the various locations. This doesn't feel organic and feels too "gamey". You could do much better by really tying the rarity and land management systems along with the artisan gear together that would feel fun, engaging and organic.
The difference in adventurer level grind and profession level grind are out of sync. Currently it is far too easy to get to 25 adventure level before you get to apprentice or higher in many professions. This combined with the time it takes to get a node levelled and with the correct building means by the time you can create level 10 gear, many players have already out-levelled what you can make. And that was with Steven bumping the nodes.
fallow cobalt
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
olive quarry
keen thorn
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sly lichen
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback** Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:**
Happy new year and thank you for your hard work and dedication, much appreciated!
======================
glossy holly
Bugs and feedback
Fix monster aggro, most frustrating part of playing mostly solo is having a horde of monster aggro you from another player (and doing it to other players unintentionally)
Better UI visibility, quantity in stacks in inventory is hard to see, more option for resizing the ui, keeping font size separate from the ui element for better readability, better scroll in inventory or change shape in the inventory ui
Thanks for all the hard work and keep it up!
coral steppe
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravan Bugs:
Map Failures:
Inventory Bugs:
Gear Loading Issues:
Node Server Crashes in PvP:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Caravan Functionality:
PvP and Server Stability:
Party Creation System:
silent rose
viscid oriole
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Most Important Bugs:
1.caravans vanishing when changing SW / resummon caravans can be in ground and not mountable.
2.weapon bounces stacking = unintended dmg numbers.
3.Inventory delay to update when moving stuff.
4.so many game freezes or crashes compared to phase 1 which i had 3/4 crash during the whole test
5.Freehold trees not giving the correct wood when chopping them.
6.Mob training.
7.corruption bating when player shown as flagged but its not.
8.party / raid UI being bugged again that needs relog or convert to raid/party to fix, in some cases nothing works everyone need to relog.
9.Cant Loot Glint on some cases last happened to me was today.
nodes buff vanishing after server restart(rarely), also nodes buff stacking visually when changing SW.
last but not least tressure MAPS.
Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.use the BAN hammer on exploiters, cheaters.
2.add market search filters faster if possible.
3.Add more harvestable in desert like wood, more ore and etc so it would make sense going there to be citizen to help nodes lvl up.
viral plaza
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
(1) Caravans - Caravans bugging and completely disappearing sometimes upon converting to a raft or vice versa.
(2) Inventory and looting - Inventory, especially storage bugging and not showing visually any movement from bags to storage or storage to bags and only being applied after a relog but this adds up in time consumed relogging. There is also a bug with inventory looting sometimes specifically related to picking up glint, you are able to loot a corpse of a mob and grab everything except for the glint until a relog is done but the relog needs to be done for every loot occurence.
(3) Monster aggro - Monsters and other enemies aggro changing to people nearby who have no interacted with the mob at all or if they have accidentally hit them with an aoe as it ran through it. The aggro should only change if they interact with them and have done more damage or generated mroe threat directly than the person who pulled said mob.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
(1) Griefers and exploiters - There needs to be clear and concise communication about what is and isnt abusing and that action should be taken against the worst culprits beyond jsut a character wipe. I think if intrepid don't take a harsh stand against that sort of behavious it will just encourage them to continue and ruin everyone's experience and any sort of balance data you guys might get.
(2) PVP - Currently pvp feels very poor, level 25's shouldn't be able to flag and kill level 5's in my opinion, also even people of a similar level have almost no reason to flag and fight back along with corruption being extremely harsh for a first offence of killing giving any attackers no reason to continue attacking for fear or corrupting and losing tonnes of gear.
Caravans should have it so any citizen of the same node cannot be an attacker of said caravan, to encourage people to work towards assisting them outside of their own guilds. Also people attacking a caravan should have a certain amount of "lives" before they cannot continue to attack as it should be counted as a failed attempt. People buffing and healing people who are flagged while not also being flagged themselves should not be possible and a healer only flagging during a pvp event right as they need to heal instead of joining the fight with the rest of their side or party needs work as well.
stark halo
bugs:
feedback topics:
HOWEVER I AM HAVING SHIT TONS OF FUN ! TY!
jade dagger
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Most of my other complaints/annoyances are balance/optimization/current phase-related and will (hopefully) sort themselves out over time or design decisions (e.g., overpopulation to encourage contention, solo play of any kind at any level is very hard and profoundly unsatisfying).
dusk dove
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
cobalt sky
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Cooking feels a little lost at the moment. Food Buffs don’t feel significant enough to give people an incentive to want to buy them. It also doesn’t help that most of the common cooked food can take roughly 5 silver to make in total costs, when people can just buy relatively decent food for less than 30 copper from the vendors. I am all for affordable food that everyone has access to, but player cooked food just doesn't seem worth it at the moment. Personally, I would like to see cooking be similar to tool crafting: Being able to mix ingredients of different rarities, yields foods with different buff ratings. That way if you're not in a position to obtain a high rarity ingredient, you can still use what you DO have and make something out of it.
I'm sure other people have talked about this, but artisan tool buffs don’t seem to do anything other than allow you to gather higher tiered items. For fishing, I crafted a rare apprentice fishing rod. But I noticed I was only fishing faster when I was wearing the fisherman shirt and skivvies (Which seem to help a lot). But if I forgot to put them on, I realized I was fishing just as slow as when I was using a crude rod. I'm noticing somthing similar with herbalism and rarity. Anyway, not a complaint, just something I think is worth looking into. It seems that the clothing is applying the buffs but the tools might not be.
Not the biggest issue, but I tend to a lot and it sounds like a lot of other people do too. I'm not sure if that is a game issue or network issue. But that would be nice to get looked into.
======================
dull ginkgo
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tidal yew
Alpha 2 Feedback
Most important bugs:
Inventory issues: the inventory for materials bugs out sometimes, where it does not seem to update new materials coming in or going out. Workaround i found is mounting and dismounting.
Group bug: Sometimes upon relogging, the grouo disappears in the Hud and you also cannot leave the grp.
Blackout on the Minimap: sometimes the minimap is only partially displayed anf the rest is blacked out in latge recktangles.
Several visual issues: mount freezes; Shield disappears after first cast; Hair is a mess etc.
Gathering issues: mining nodes/trees are not "breaking" or giving rescources
lethal gulch
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Inventory/Storage/Looting
2.Buff bar overfilled
3.Sync Problem with Players and Mobs
4.First-Person zoom is too close at the furthest distance on ultra wide monitor (5120x1440)
5.Ram is flooded from time to time and the game hangs or crashes
valid plaza
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Hunting Rarity - While the overall difficulty of acquiring items seem decent so far, having a single profession bottleneck entire Gear types (Medium armor and Apprentice weapons) because of barely any rarity drops above Rare seems pretty bad.
Keybinds - Please allow more flexible keybinds for Action Bar abilities such as Mousewheel up/down, PageUp/Down
Caravan UI is incredibly annoying for PvP - Meta is shifting towards massive caravan trains. I would love to see a "convoy" style party that caravans can form in order to move together and make this easier on defenders and attackers. Or simply the ability to hide the caravan alignment UI completely.
Mounts are too persistent - Having mounts die permanently in PvP will put a lot more focus on long term attrition based fights especially in Guild vs Guild, while also keeping the Animal Husbandry economy alive and allowing player made monopoly economics.
You guys are killing it. Amazing job keep it up 
Two Hand maces when? 🙂
grim copper
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Loving the game, keep up the good work ❤️
true elbow
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
frosty agate
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
arctic gorge
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
cunning ember
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sweet pawn
Top Bugs:
Top feedback.
warm grail
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
peak hare
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Randomly quit being able to loot or mount horse.
2. When server is busy often not able to interact with storage or other npc's in town. At the same time audio bugs occur and relogging is required
3. Cleric auto attack does not always work consistently and if you are using a shield it does not always appear equipped. This seems to be more common in early levels. Self buffs drop off for no apparent reasons.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. Hunting is very hard to level up as there are not a lot of novice mobs available. This leads to everyone being at the gremlins near Lionhold to farm poop and hunt gremlin. There should either be more of these mobs or they should be more spread out.
2. Mob aggro is too easy to drop onto people. Sometimes it is someone deliberately training to kill people but sometimes it is just a person riding by on a horse with mobs following. The mobs need to stay on the original aggro target until they leash and once leashed they need to walk back to there original spawn area without aggro. FFXI learned this around 2005 and it stops MPK and is a big quality of life improvement.
3. I don't know how you do it but toxicity needs to be addressed. Not everyone enjoys "PVP banter" and the racist and sexist insults that are thrown around constantly. Currently the in game culture seems to encourage exploiting, griefing and other bad behavior. This will lead to lot of people quitting as soon as they see that.
======================
round hinge
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3 -5 Feedback Topics
neon niche
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
slow basalt
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs
Top 3 -5 Most Important Feedback:
tulip stratus
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Rubber Banding. when you're walking along and suddenly get stuck on nothing and teleport back again and again, only way to fix it is to stand still/demount/block. wasts loads of time
3.Action combat mode constantly gets stuck, you can access your inventory sometimes and you get the reticule for action combat when the inventory is closed and you get stuck with your cursor despite toggling action combat.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Item deletion upon death should be removed. make it dropping items on death, we already get punished by XP debt and having to come collect our loot, risking people stealing it and having to fight your way back to it. but if you have trouble coming back to get your stuff you die over and over. resulting in losing everything from possible hours of grinding. its just needlessly punishing. specialy for glint. I'd suggest make it 50% drop and 0% deletion unless corrupted, that way if you dont make it back in time you lose it but you at least have a chance to get your loot back.
Node wars should be OPT-in (or at LEAST for lv19 and below, the power difference in gear is just too great)
Something needs to be done about zergs dominating the servers, they ruin the experience for other players who don't lead 200+ member guilds, they speed to max level then just wreck everyone they come across.
I feel like the gear boundaries are too forced, like lvl 10 then lvl 20 is too harsh, i understand why but why not limit them behind difficulty and not level? as it stands the power difference between a lvl 9 and a lvl 10 is incredible and thats even worse for lvl 19 to lvl 20, nobody can compete so everyone is forced to just grind levels as opposed to finding cool gear. it makes sense for artisans but combat gear it doesnt.
I believe Hunting nodes should be variable. I don't mean respawn times, i mean like cobber nodes. where if you catch a pallas cat, camping that same spot for hours wont nessicarily net you another cat, you have to venture around and look for them. theyre living animals after all. right now its just sit in the same spot and wait. hunting gets way too easy to level aswell since some things have a 2 min respawn time and group up together. it requires no effort.
Caravans are just not worth it. in any measure. i understand that their gain is directly related to the size of the caravan and the distance travelled, but nobody can manager to get a group together to defend the caravan, specially for long distances. and even then there's no reward, you end up squandering 90% if not all of your earnings from the caravan just to pay for 'guards', i suggest making an ingame quest that gives defenders rewards upon caravan completion, or at least a quest you can repeat for this. Attackers can loot the caravan and get the loot from defenders bodies so they're incentivised but defenders get nothing.
======================
wispy kelp
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
safe coyote
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1 - Zombie putting a healing debuff that is actually making heal damaging, it's killing people and can also lead to getting corrupted while you just tried to help someone
2 - Treasure maps, if I right click on it, nothing is happening anymore, was working at the beginning
3 - Inventory not working properly, not refreshing what we have or making things impossible to move
4 - pvp flagging sometimes will disappear while you already attacked the person, that can lead into corruption, pvp flagged should remain while in combat and should take a 20-30 seconds out of combat to actually reset
5 - Group interface not showing when people are disconnecting/reconnecting or relogging
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1 - Change the search feature of the marketplace to also allow for search on the name of the item, that would already be enough to make a huge improvement of it, and have a more accurate economy
2 - Improve the chat, reply & whisper
3 - Buff bar, we need to see them all
4 - you are all doing a fantastic job, keep it up !
5 - Make the node tickets still relevant after you get a few items so that there's still an incentive to complete the buy orders
obtuse wave
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
quaint mortar
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs + feedback for each:
1. Mining nodes need to be "locked" to same tier of mining capabilities (Many times have seen a copper node respawn as iron, becoming un-mineable due to scarcity of miners of that tier). Possibly lock "types" (basalt/granite on same node, zinc/copper on same node, etc), while adding in area(s) for gemstones as well. (Possibly later add in some micro-dungeon "mines" that the entry-way is the low tier of rock or metal or gems, with little / low level mob guards, while going deeper gets harder due to mob's levels, and as you go, tier goes up as well, requiring a party to escort miners in for good tiers of metal/stone/gems.
*2. *Bard's constant songs (IE: health gain on hit, party mana gain, movespeed, etc) currently stop applying if you hit escape in any way. If you use escape to close a window, or de-select a target, the song you are actively playing will stop playing. (Cards for the constant songs possibly need info on them to inform that only one constant played song can be played by the bard, IE: Rangers have card info for "only one hunt can be active at a time")
3. Recipe learning cards have no way of identifying if your character already has learned the recipe already... Please, add a little tag on the cards somewhere that states "Known" or "Un-Known", or like "Learned" on the card only once it's learned, or some other method of saying that the player has learned the recipe on that character. I've accidentally bought a recipe from a vendor and not realized I'd gotten it as a drop and already learned it, then of course, lost money due to no "grace period" of sell back to vendor on purchased things.
4 Please add a capability for mouse-over macros or spellcasting, would be great for raid healing / casting of buffs on raid/party members
======================
rustic kraken
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hardy narwhal
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tropic kite
Anti-Heal turns heals into damage
The vomit of zombies and thaumaturges turns heals into damage. This can cause healers getting corrupted.
Group and Raid Ui showing debuffs
The group ui and raid ui is really inconsitant in showing any debuffs/buffs of the players. There are a lot of buffs which are not related to combat which are shown first instead of combat relevant buffs.
Group and Raid leaders can't start events for the whole group/raid
If for example a raid wants to attack a caravan it is kinda hard to reorganize everything, it would be easier if the leader could pull everyone into the event.
combatants don't stay combatant while getting damaged by other players
If someone loots a body and becomes a combatant, he opted into potential pvp. If now another player attacks that person, even if the don't fight back they should stay combatant. causes accidental corruption.
Caravans
Caravans still need some love, there are some bugs preventing players from propperly run them, but also for attackers and defenders there are some aspects which would make a lot of difference in the QoL perspective. The reward for raiding or defending a caravan successfully is currently a bit lackluster, but rewards are a secondary thing
Guild Wars
Here is a lot of potential for QoL features. e.g. timers for a start, cooldown timers, also features to discourage griefing like hinderance of multiple challanges and all.
Corruption
There is currently no real reason for open world pvp, it is easier to get killed without fighting and afterwards killing the corrupted player to get their gear and loot. There are multiple ways to bait people into being a combatant (through healing (the healer needs to set the option to heal combatants without being flagged) or ranger thorns) as well as getting corrupted.
You are doing great work thx
waxen charm
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Quests – Please add in quests and make them rewarding. Grinding mobs is not for everyone. It is tedious, mostly unrewarding, and is not fun in any way.
Processing – I would like to be able to process any amount of materials. The drop down is limited and frustrating. I should be able to type in the amount I want to process, or have a slider or something.
Farming – Baby cows take up one space each in my Items tab. Adult cows can stack to 20 in my materials tab. How does that make sense? I feel like the baby cows should also show up in my materials tab and stack. 1 cow = 1 milk = 1 butter. Shouldn’t an adult cow be able to give you more than 1 milk? Or instead of consuming the cow, I should be able to feed the cow and milk it once per day or something?
Gathering – Resources are too scarce even at the lowest levels.
Animal Husbandry – Why is this so expensive? 80G to get to apprentice? At that cost you should be able to choose if you want a mount or a Beast of Burden. Will this be a part of a skill tree? Also, this seems to be the only processing skill that you cannot self-sustain while leveling.
Crafting – Please make it worth our while to even attempt to level up. It seems at this time, drops from mobs is better than crafted. Especially since it takes so long to even get apprentice buildings, much less journeyman buildings, and everyone rushes to 20+ crafters aren’t able to even make gear for them. We can only grind the least expensive recipe, while hoping to not go broke, in the hopes that when journeyman buildings are available people will even want or need to buy our goods.
lost pier
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Monster AI. Their targeting, mobs training after a single player, how they respond to interacting with them feels inconsistent, and being targeted by ranged abilities without LoS are the key issues I've had.
**Caravan system. ** Caravans started in desert nodes do not get any gold when selling to any node outside the desert.
3.Friends List and other Social Tools From day one of A2 I have not had a working friends list. I am on my own friends list and the people who show up on it changes constantly.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hollow laurel
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
iron jacinth
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.all inventory/storage linked bugs, they happen a lot
2.Rare ressources shortages (weeping willow bugged or too rare even if mandatory for crafting)
3.Treasure maps bugged, increasing some rare ressources shortages
4.friends list bugged
5.Caravan events bugged (pvp flag not resetting, caravan crashing, defender not being able to attack attackers....)
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.Griefing / Mob training is a bit annoying
2.more quests
3.improve new player tutorial
4.buff bar is just unreadable
clear wagon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Including inventory, chat, experience gain issues. This seems to subside the longest when switching characters, and then switching back. Many think its happening server-wide, but I have seen it to be happening at the individual level.
Delivering a caravan only to have it be deleted along with the cargo and all other caravans you own. Along with this bug, comes the being stuck perpetually in the defender/attacker status until server restart, which leads to being a free kill many hours later sitting afk in town.
Apart from immediately after a server restart, many hunting grounds become empty due to mobs spawning under the ground (I assume). Prime examples are the circles for most of Winstead's mayoral commission targets such as Wolves/Grems and Bears/Ravens.
Often when gathering, I come across nodes that either won't break and provide resources or the base of which has spawned inside of a rock or under other mesh, making that node useless and unavailable for all players.
Apart from the fact that you can be trained simply by being in the path of mobs chasing others, even when standing still and doing nothing, mob threat in general does not seem to be working in a manner that makes sense to someone who has main tanked in other MMO's for years.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
At least for the alpha, we should have one centralized, sticky topic about know bugs/exploits, with a warning that doing these things will result in punishment X, Y or Z based on offense/severity.
For the most part, it is adults that are participating in this Alpha, and for most this is not their first MMO. We know what exploiting is and there is no excuse for repeated abuse of exploits, alpha or not. I would love to see more severe action taken against repeat offenders.
A ticket option in the "Esc" menu similar to what World of Warcraft had at one point where we can submit a ticket in attempt to get an online GM to come investigate a bug/exploit first hand would be tremendous (if we in fact have online GM's).
We all know Steven played and loved Lineage 2, so he knows what this is. I don't care if you make them uber-expensive, purchasable for only node-currency, linked only to return you to the ember spring of your node-of-citizenship, etc.
Almost every party is multiple-mob non-stop pulling. This leads to a severe inability to see/obtain your glint loot from mobs without constantly walking up to the pile being fought and spamming "F". In-part due to the visual effects cluster-eff and the timer before the loot becomes available for those other than yourself. This results in tanks/melee obtaining a large portion of glint drops that was originally dropped for your ranged dps or healer characters.
When inside villages, the amount of mounts standing around not being used for extended periods of time is staggering. This has to be an undue performance drain as well. Please add a 60 second mount despawn timer or something when the mount is not in use, at least when in town.
======================
copper gulch
Alpha Two Phase II Feeback
Top 5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Inventory and Storage bugging when transferring or moving items.
2. Rush/Charging skills of mobs need to be fixed so they're rushing towards you and not off in some random direction so that dodge/guard can be predicted.
3. Memory leaks. I get I'm playing at 3440x1440, but I have seen 31/32GB system memory, 50GB+ of virtual memory and 22/24GB VRAM used after about 6-8 hours with stutters and half the frame rate I get during the first 4-6 hours of playing. This doesn't happen every time, but I have had to restart more than 5-6 times to fix this.
4. Party UI/sidebar/frame has to be refreshed all the time it seems like.
5. Friends list needs some serious attention. It seems to constantly delete/reset for me. That will be a big issue for a game that seems group oriented.
Top Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. Effective limitations on Zerg guilds/alliances.
2. Longer flag durations, especially in a case where you're being attacked by someone you were flagged for looting.
3. Mob AI, specifically hate/aggro should be set up in a way where you can't just dump them on a group of people by running through them, but your group should still be able to pull them if they are intentionally trying to.
4.Please allow us to use custom values for processing and crafting. If I want to make 2 of something, I should be able to select 2, not make one and wait to start the next or be forced to craft one item at a time if I have the resources nessecary to make 47.
leaden mica
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
fast vapor
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
blissful shell
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
kind dirge
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
https://forums.ashesofcreation.com/discussion/65141/repeated-griefing/p1?new=1
======================
sweet mist
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
MOB LEASHING - Mobs across the world (especially Carphin tower) are often broken. After someone runs from an enemy NPC (or trains it on another group), they do not always leash properly and often get stuck and end up far from their intended spawn location.
MAGE SKILL INTERACTIONS - Interactions between mage abilities are very inconsistent/do not work. For example: Aftershock does not work. Unyielding blink does not work. Chain lightning does not apply Shocked status effect to "Volatile" enemies.
SERVER WORKERS - There are still issues regarding server worker handoffs. Really strange things happen when moving or doing combat across server worker boundaries.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
NODE MARKETPLACE MANAGER - It's very difficult to sort and filter for specific items and types of items in the Node marketplaces. Consider adding more sort and filter functions for items and the various item types. Also if too many people are around him, NPC is impossible to reach.
PLAYER DRAW DISTANCE - When many players are in the vicinity, the distance at which players load in to visible range (Draw distance) is too low. Big issue for large scale PvP.
**LIGHTING **- Lighting needs a lot of work. The game scenery looks fantastic, but the character models appear very dark and hard to see even during the day (on Epic quality).
EXPLOITER PUNISHMENT - Exploiters should receive harsher punishment. It's unfair to the majority of testers to be in an environment with testers that are abusing systems for clout or some sense of personal gain/achievement.
======================
mossy harbor
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
timber notch
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hot quail
the amount of mountsd out in town around the areas players need like storage. it would be nice to see if people can put them away or mayeb not be able to usee m,ounts in the towns.
blissful rose
Top 3-5 most important bugs
onyx marten
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
deft swan
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
halcyon kayak
Hi folks. My feedback
getting loot that has the most damage is not good. It needs to be done the other way around. Even if the first hit has 10% it is often unfair to tanks and healers.
the action combat should be free. Leave out this hard lock. I want to heal and do damage that I target.
night anvil
**Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
void slate
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tribal oracle
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Inventory not updating. Need to mount for it to update
2. Treasure map quests won't finish properly when chest looted. Need to Abandon quest manually
3. Can't join Caravan event if in Party/Raid. Need to leave party and then join event
4. Node buffs are not updating correctly. They tend to stay in buffs bar even though buff is not active anymore.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. Ability to put freesize stack to processing and taking it out. Now it is much downtime to just stand in processing bench and wait individual processings to finish. If you put large processing directly from gathering bags to processing you can't take them out since the processed items don't fit anymore to your bags.
2. Checking recipes for needed material. Some processed materials are not needed by any recipe (white ink/Yellow ink) Also Red/Green Ink is needed a lot by Scribing and the materials for that are very rare. (Ruby/Emeralds)
3. More General XP for crafters/gatherers. In my opinion crafting should be more xp rewarding. Would be alternative way to level character.
sick oracle
Top 3 Bugs:
-- 1. Inventory and storage bugs. These happen frequently having to constantly relog breaks immersion and messes up harvesting
--2. Maps. Getting locked out of maps is common and also helps create resource bottlenecks
--3. Mobs glitching into walls and/or resetting in ways that break respawns. For example...missing Dread Praetorian spawns in Halls of Adjudication because they are behind walls, or the warden teleporting upstairs/into wall. Another example is Forgemaster in Befallen reset its healthbar 3 times in one fight last night because the NPC couldnt properly path up stairs and kept slipping through terrain.
Top 3 feedback:
--1. Players should not be able to sleep unflagged players at any point, but especially while fighting mobs.
--2. The reward curve of crafting is skewed so far everyone literally just farms equipment from dungeons to level 25. By the time crafters can make useful items most people are farming the next tier, and the extremely rare materials and recipes make it too difficult to craft yellow/purple/orange items to compete with blue drops. So not only do crafters stop leveling because harvesting/crafting exp is so low, but this feeds into a loop where they are slip farther and farther behind economically and in combat power and become easy victims to players who just grind to max level right away.
--3. I hope to Bellsong that the crafting system is placeholder for something engaging. PS Not having manual count inputs when processing/refining with such limited bag space is laughable. Having to stand around and do 5 - 1 - 1 - 1 - 1 for 9 or worse 10-5-1-1-1 is infuriating.
I love this game so much, despite hating PVP. Keep up the good work. Let people find niches and don't forget the bottom of the pyramid. If small guilds get squeezed out of meaningful node interactions and game progression, it will die.
wheat carbon
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mild vortex
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Treasure maps are great once you know what you are looking for, however, the fact that playing on high graphics hinders you doesn't feel right. The diggable mound should be just as visible on all graphic settings. Treasure should also not spawn in locations where you require a flying mount to get there.
Processing rarity rating (for example on a lumber miller's shirt) is now more of a hinderance than a bonus. After crafting 250 Ash timber, I get 4 uncommon pieces; this both requires me to store/sell the uncommon wood and forces me to craft 4 more common timber just so I can run another 250 batch. While this is nice at the end of a crafting chain, it is definitely not in the middle of the chain. This would be eliminated by the option to choose the exact amount for a job with a slider (1 - 250 range is fine).
steel wadi
Top 3-4 Most Important Feedback Topics: Tank Skills
Were [Tomahawk] is give us options to modify a few skills like Javelin Toss. For example: Add a second charge to Javelin Toss or Introduce a debuff applying armor reduction for Javelin. Or Pick the new skill [Tomahawk] but don't make [Tomahawk] the only option lot's of people don't use/like it. More branch talents that give options, As a example one that gives Taunt a buff that will mark the target, increases allies’ melee damage by 2% to the marked target.Alternatively, provide a second charge of Reflect via talents to improve versatility in high-threat scenarios.```
4. **Reworking Vengeance Skill**:
```Current Version: Deals 90% physical damage to a target, with reduced AOE damage, generating Temporary Health per stack.
Empower other abilities by consuming Vengeance stacks:
Example: Javelin Toss applies Taunt to nearby enemies if 10 Vengeance stacks are consumed.
Example: Self-heal improves significantly when consuming Vengeance stacks, scaling with the number of stacks.
or [Vengeance] can be used consuming your stacks that unleash a powerful [Vengeful Strike] this could deal burst damage proportional to Max HP and restoring health at a % of max HP scaling with the number of stacks the player has.```Top 3-6 Most Important Bugs:
Leashing Mobs and Griefing: Introduce a Purple Flag system where players intentionally leashing mobs to grief others are flagged for PvP, allowing the offended players to address the issue directly.
Stealing Experience: Implement a mechanic where tagging a mob already engaged by another group triggers a Purple Flag. This discourages disruptive behavior like XP stealing while maintaining fairness.
Shields Vanishing: Shields disappear or are unequipped when switching between primary and secondary weapons. This is a major issue for tank gameplay.
Mob AI Resetting: Mobs, such as the 3-star Infested Zombies near Miraleth, often bug out by running away, resetting, or vanishing entirely without respawning.
Loot Interaction Bug: Dropping items to make inventory space while gathering sometimes causes loot to become permanently inaccessible.
Treasure Maps and Quest Improvements:Treasure Maps: Fix treasure maps so they can be fully utilized across the Riverlands and parts of the desert. Questing Fixes: Address bugs in quests around Lionshold and add more robust questing options throughout the Riverlands, as this is a key leveling zone and should feature more quest diversity and stability.
shy current
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sonic yew
Havent played a ton yet so this will probably be minor and get lost in the fray. The bag bugs are getting annoying. Having to mount/unmount to be able to pick up items or refresh my bags is tedious.
silent badger
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
safe cape
Bugs
1-when gathering mats from mining, lumber cutting, etc receive exp but not receiving mats requiring relog.
2-gaining exp from mobs while grinding just stops being rewarded requiring relog
3-some gatherables across vera being stuck inside of rocks or spawning slightly below ground level
4-mini map when zoomed in will turn black and requires zoom out then back in to fix
Recommendations
1-change the way buffs are displayed under character name as to allow player to view all current buffs
2-when finished with combat bard remains in combat until songs are turned off
3-make it where my tanks def aura does not turn off randomly over time it should stay on till I die or turn it off
crude moss
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
slow sleet
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
visual compass
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
undone lance
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
0. You are amazing, keep the good work. Take your time, we will wait.
quick spindle
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
thorn finch
Important Bugs
Cargo and Inventory bugs - I've had multiple glint commodities just disappear out of cargo, never to be seen again.
Mage weapon imbuements randomly stop working - Fire, Lightning, and Ice imbuements will randomly stop working until a Logout reset.
Mob AI - Most common with Ashen Flame enemies, they will occasionally bug out and stand still, not attacking. Then they won't drop resources or exp.
Terrain interaction with resource nodes - I've seen multiple areas where resource nodes are up to 90% burried, so that they are extremely difficult to collect. The opposite happens for some hunting spawns, where they spawn way too high up.
Feedback Topics
Novice Resource Rarity - Things like copper, zinc, flax, etc. Need more spawns than jouneryman resources.
The level up notification for Hunting is all lowercase.
Guild Size - While zergs will be an inevitable problem, guild size should be at Least 100 imo. That seems pretty standardized in most MMOs I've played.
abstract geode
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory bug - both looting corpses and moving items between inventory and storage are very frequently fubar. Mounting/dismounting sometimes helps and sometimes doesn't. Having to leave loot in corpses because you can't pick it up (or alternatively, having the group stop play every five minutes for someone to relog) is a pretty fundamental issue.
Mob aggro - the way it's currently working enables toxic behaviour. If someone pulls a mob, they should maintain their position at the top of the hate list unless someone else takes an action that moves them higher, not because they were simply in the same vicinity.
Caravan bugs - They seem to be plenty, and for a key part of the game economy, it does need high priority fixes.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Resource Scarcity - it's clear from the last few weeks that with populated servers, the resource spawn rates are not working in a way that's consistent with building a positive, thriving community. Spawns need to be more random, and need to be more reflective of the resources that people actually need to progress. At the moment, it's too easy to create monopolies, which leads to toxic behaviour.
Caravan risk vs reward. Currently, all of the risk is taken by the caravan creators, with no risk taken by the attackers. This becomes terrible when you have one or two dominant guilds. I'd like to see this become much more balanced - perhaps attackers have to create an 'ambush kit' that requires resources and has to be placed on the route with say a 1 min setup time, so that both parties have to take some risk.
Farming/Cooking reward vs resource vs time - this is way out of wack just at the moment, with such huge amounts of resource required for seeds, water, ingredients, animals, etc as well as the actual crafting, and the number of crafts needed to level up. Rearing a cow from calf to adult should give me significantly more than 1 milk!
wintry crag
Top 2 Most Important Bugs:
1. Random invisible water that can drown you.
2. Having Camera Movement Unlocked will make you face random directions after jumping at times or using abilities making you take direct damage from behind at times, especially as a tank.
Top 2 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. The state of gathering and processing. Crafting over all, is literally like watching paint drying (and in live, you'll be paying to watch paint dry). If the current implementation is a sign of what the goal is in the future, I won't ever engage with it. If I had to put it into view. Just like how combat was horrible and needed a rework in alpha 1. The crafting is at the same level, if not worse. The hope of those I've talked about is that crafting would feel as engaging as combat would be. I guess stimulating that is. I'd personally make client side mini-games for each tier of crafting station, each tier of station has different tools that makes crafting easier and you can make better gear with, then include personal tools as well. After successfully combining once, you can bulk make things with "chance to make worse or same" quality gear, but you can only make better things using the mini-games and tools allowed by the tier of crafting station and the material used.
2. Trees and Flowers spawning in open world and field makes sense. Mining nodes popping up everywhere though? That's some terrible outdated MMO logic. I think there should be locals for certain things, but what it should be is ruined mines or caves around nodes. And depending on the node environment, the mayor should be able to choose to "develop" an old ruined mine, or destroy the local fauna and wild-life to develop a mine. Meaningful choices. Mountain regions wont have much wild life, make more mines. Forest regions have wild life and lots of forests, maybe not make a mine and destroy a healthy forest.
civic raven
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
barren ermine
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
crude heath
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mild palm
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
native locust
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
thin laurel
Top 5 bugs:
Top 5 most important feedback topics:
Permaban/yeet all of the exploiters and their alts/alt accounts (At the very least the ones who have prior warnings for something), character wipes mean nothing and a number have already moved their stuff to alt accounts. Don't let this turn into a last ride mentality / exploit early & exploit often culture.
Damage is way too high / TTK is absurdly low and massively denegrates pvp, we're not supposed to be playing T&L 2. This is not the ttk that we were sold on - even for a WIP, it's so out of tune that it denegrates the rest of the testing in addition to drastically reducing the quality of enterainment..
Adjust Corruption: The penalties for going red are absurdly overtuned atm and creates an absolutely silly amount of problems. We need the corruption system to properly come online/start functioning as intended. At the very least, remove the gear drop portion of it caused by low stages of corruption.
More mob density / locations with high mob density + a larger range of options for grinding: currently, even when spawns are working properly, the mob density is extremely low outside of a handful of locations per level range and it just doesn't feel good. Further on this, there should be a wider range of locations centered around grinding with less than 8 people but more than 1 person 
Archetype design: Tank needs a lot of love, its kit doesn't fit the nature of the game at all and it is also savagely punished far more than any other class by the various systems of the game. Cleric needs an expansion of playstyles, Ranger relies on a single ability to remain relevant relative to the overtuned Mage, which has a design that is antithetical to high quality large scale pvp.
marble depot
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
supple reef
something I forgot to mention is the guild cap being 50... whats the point of having a cap when people make 50 guilds of 50... if there is a guild cap it should be a guild cap not just a completely irrelevant number it seems like Steven encourages people like Thor to just ignore the guild cap of 50 and they can have as many people as they want
thorny raptor
=======================
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
faint valve
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
wind musk
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Invisible walls - Character gets "stuck" in the same place in "eternal rollback"
Critical Healing - Healings are not critting
Stats Dampening - The penalty is remaining even after recovering the XP debt, requiring the game to be closed completely and opened again to perhaps resolve the status loss.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Rework/Improvements to the City Store - We urgently need efficient filters in the stores. There are over 100 pages per city, that take a long time to find an item of interest. It would be more interesting to classify items based on their type (material, head, gloves, pants/legs, shoulders/pauldrons, etc.). I don't understand the real point of classifying the store by character. In addition to displaying the name of the player who is selling, it generates a huge amount of rework, because a player opens a store and always needs to update the store name so that their items can be found. If they have had an item in the store for a long time and add a new item to their store, it stays in the same position, making it difficult to find.
Improvements to the UI for buffs and debuffs - At this point, it is possible to make many criticisms. The unnecessary accumulation of "buffs" from nodes is horrible, completely hindering the management and vision of buffs applied to players. It is very difficult to know whether an ally has a specific buff or not, since the visualization does not help, not to mention that after a certain limit they accumulate in "+". The visualization of debuffs also needs improvement, both so that clerics and bards can work more efficiently and so that those suffering from the debuff can identify them in a better way. My suggestion is that 3 separate status bars be created. Bar 1: Buffs from spells, food and status, Bar 2: Buffs from nodes and events, Bar 3: Debuffs in general. The idea is that these bars are separate in themselves and through the settings it is possible to adjust their scale and position on the screen based on each player's preference.
Corrupted System (PK) - The core structure of the game revolves around conflicts and disputes between players. However, the corruption system (PK) is extremely punitive for those who engage in it. While I understand concerns about griefing and anti-competitive behavior, this system discourages PvP within the game, particularly competitiveness. I dare say that this system strongly incentivizes a terrible practice where players lure multiple monsters toward an enemy party to get them killed.
I acknowledge that balancing such a system is challenging, and I agree that the punishment for becoming corrupted (PK) should be severe. However, isn’t dropping your own items already a significant risk? Some games with similar systems manage to explore this mechanic effectively, which could serve as inspiration for Ashes.
For instance, it would be interesting if each player had a counter allowing them to kill a limited number of players per day without becoming corrupted (PK). I’m not sure about the ideal number—perhaps 1, 2, or 3—but this would enable players to strategically use this limit to contest spaces without facing overly harsh punishments.
Currently, when you flag (become a combatant) against another player, they can simply ignore you and continue doing what they were doing, which doesn’t make much sense. To give context and rationale to this suggestion, we could consider that a player only becomes corrupted after repeatedly committing the same act of murder (using the daily kill counter).
A player who exceeds this limit would then be considered corrupted (PK) in the eyes of the world, making their bounty substantial (e.g., increased item drop rate for PKs and greater visibility on the minimap).
empty halo
Bugs:
still plaza
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
prisma coyote
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Players who loot other players should not lose the PvP flagg if in combat with another player even if they do not retaliate. Forcing the attacker to become corrupted even if they attacked someone who looted their corpse while the looter was initianly PvP flagged.
Abilities going thru walls, roofs and floors, damaging mobs risking wipes and/or damage to other players if PvP flagged.
NPC's not returning to their spawn location/area if their leash has ended due to various reason like running away to avoid dying, making them bugged and unable to re spawn if you cannot find where the mob is stuck and kill it, but even then that wont help to reset the spawn.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
A option in the settings to lower the graphical effects of allies spells and abilities, as a Melee player the over stimulation of effects makes it hard to spot hostile effects on the floor or find the right timing to block or dodge an attack based of the animation of en enemy.
A change in color for either Heroic or Legendary to a more contrasted color like red, as the color difference can be hard for some to spot at a glance and even harder for those who have problems with color gradients.
An opt-in system for something like a mentorship program as a way for players to help out newer players without a way to power level, I think this would help the longevity of the game if newer players would not feel left out without playing in groups due to potential lack of other players around their level.
So an opt-in system that could allow a higher level player to nerf themselves to avoid power leveling the newer player and to help newer players play with others without a massive hit to their exp gain and/or loot drops.
odd pine
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
supple harbor
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
swift isle
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wary wind
Top 3-5 Most Critical Bugs:
Caravans
Mob Aggro
Weapon Bonuses
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Full Drops
Current Viable Path
Guild Storage & Resource Warehouses
muted hill
Feedback / Bugs A2 II
1. Buff bar
The buff bar should be revised. It makes no sense to display the buffs, some of which are over 20, as little bags and the most interesting buffs or debuffs for the fight disappear in the plus display.
2. UI group / alliance
It would be nice if every group or alliance member could adapt the group user interface. e.g. sort members according to individual order, size, group/alliance view. It would also be advantageous for alliances if co-leads could be assigned to sort the groups and the function to determine whether all group members can invite or not.
In the alliance view, the out of range display also does not always work. (The colors of the members are always the same.)
3. Resurrection stone
It would be helpful if there was some kind of "resurrection stone" to buy or craft. Otherwise, the cleric is the only class that has to get up at Emberspring and cannot be resurrected. This is also a big disadvantage for the cleric when it comes to looting the corpse. It is also a disadvantage for the group, as they have to wait a long time for the cleric.
4. Target from target
The target from target key function would be important. The function is planned, but does not work yet.
5. Map
The map should reliably show the group members. The mobs are also not shown as they actually appear. All functions should be checked here. The map is a bit rudimentary.
Conclusion: For an alpha version, the game exceeds my expectations, even if not everything works perfectly yet. There is a lot of content to test (I am far from finished), the gameplay is interesting, the character skills (at least the ones I can judge) are playable and well thought out, and the balance in all areas is already well set (combat power to class, rewards to level, etc.).
All in all, a big compliment and many thanks to Steven and his mega hard-working team. I especially celebrate your efforts between the holidays... nice Christmas present!
hard current
-== Alpha Two Phase II Feedback ==-
I have only two issues, that bother me at this stage:
Leveling and Questing
I have experienced an unusually high number of deaths in this MMO, especially during the early stages of progression. The balance feels significantly off. It seems like either mobs are too easy to defeat (dying in one shot) or players are unexpectedly surrounded by elite mobs capable of one-shotting them. This inconsistency could make the experience highly frustrating for new players. A more structured and linear main questline for onboarding new players is essential to ensure a smoother and more enjoyable journey.
Crafting Bag
The current crafting bag design, reminiscent of older games like Diablo, is likely to generate substantial backlash from players. The small and limited storage space, which fills up quickly after gathering a few resources (e.g., three trees and a rock), feels outdated and impractical. Without improvements, this could become a significant gameplay hindrance that negatively impacts the overall experience.
torpid goblet
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
fickle wyvern
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.) Caravans from the Desert Cannot sell to the other nodes. They are not connected to the Riverland nodes.
2.) Caravan disappearing out of no where
3.) Bugged mobs stuck in terrain or behind invisible walls at Tower of Carphin
flat escarp
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
agile meteor
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
mob training / griefing, forever following mobtypes
treasure maps
freehold ressources
inventory and loot bugs
caravans in general, no sense/value for random players to defend (share some gold/xp?) - loosing whole caravan is pointless (repair cooldown, rebuild by percentage of ressources?)
pvp exploit abuse in general (flaggin / not flagging heal etc.), possible exploits in crowd control effects while moving / jumping
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
actual "endgame" consists of ruining other peoples experience with almost no gains when helping others
long term concepts to prevent domination scenarios by single guilds/alliances on server like a power debuff system
player expectations right now are to play the game almost as a whole, for me it sould be more focus on smaller parts of the game more deeply and in increased number of steps
mailsystem player to player, account vault, guild vault (only materials?)
market search needs more working filters
clear coral
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
final juniper
Marketplace Issues
Search needs to search for items in shop, not the store descriptions. I like the fact that it doesn't automatically search each store for the best price, you've got to hunt for it yourself. However, you miss a lot of good deals when you aren't able to search for the correct items
Too Few Tier1 Resources
Primarily Zinc and Copper. There just isn't enough of it to get through 1-10 in any crafting profession easily. I have made it to 12 mining, while my jewelcrafting is still at 2. I haven't focused on any other crafting professions that use those materials.
Caravans
Wish we had Beast of Burden working properly - would love to see the bear I crafted!
Water navigation is boring, but easy. Some resistance, wind or current related, would make it so much more enjoyable.
PVP is great! Love it. The very first caravan you do should be immune to being raided. The first quest to introduce you to caravans asks you to crate 60 wood and 60 stone and xfer it somewhere. Not sure you have to do it that way to complete the quest, but I did it that way and was attacked for nothing! Ha!
Been a WOW player for 20 years. This game is the only game that has grabbed my attention in the same manner. I am so stoked to see what comes of it! Well worth the money. Thank you and the team for everything you do!
candid ingot
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
shadow flame
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Mob Spawn / AI is a main issue, many of them dont have the ability to go back to their spawn and get stuck, even through walls. Named dont spawn after a moment ( or spawn beyond world ? ). As usual server restart fix this but only for a few hours.
All Dual Wielder Minotaurs stop attacking after few hits. So its way to easy for some testers to level way to fast and breaking the normal "level progression" that you should be analyzing ?
UI : Cant see Buffs / Debuff , it dont show enough of them , can't you at least pack nodes buff in one ? Also Debuff should appear first in line ? Raid UI dont show anything about them also.
Economy is broken, again some peoples seems to have been able to duplicate.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Guild : At Least need to be able to transfer the leadership, also some ranking should be available like officer. Suggestion : a guild vault will be great
Due to the overcrowded area not enough place to xp ( since you got the data for overcrowded area/server, some new servers will be great ).
No more season cycle ?
Need a chat channel for LFG !
knotty heath
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
**1. **Caravans disappearing, be that at turn-in or along the road. At turn-in, two of my caravans (and I've heard others say they had some impacted) completely disappeared after the turn-in countdown finished. They are not at any caravansary at any node. Along the road, it seems that SW boundaries have a low-medium probability of despawning the caravan or sending the driver to Carphin. The SW boundary thing seems to be recoverable, with enough log-out, log-in, run to a diff SW and back, and similar actions. Logging out or crashing with the "launched" caravan in your bag, prior to placing it on the ground, seems to be a big issue, too.
**2. **Tank mitigation bug is allowing tanks to stack up to 95% mitigation, based on the use of certain skills. Please DM for which skills, specifically, though I have submitted a bug report in-game as well. This stacking seems to persist until relog.
**3. **Cooking consumable recipe for Oatmeal requires oatmeal consumable as one of the ingredients.
4. Hunting. Collection of carcass or animal does not seem to proc rarity above Uncommon 99% of the time.
**5. **Pyromancers/Firestarters. I really hope their damage output is a bug. They insert an insane amount of random death into the grinding spots. They could use about 30% damage reduction, as a single skill usage from an non-named non-boss mob feels highly over-tuned when it wipes 7/8 of a party.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
**1. **Tank needs some love. While Ashes may not be balanced around solo play, it should be doable to a relative degree across the classes. Currently, Tank struggles to effectively solo mobs of comparable level and gearing (as compared to stars on a mob). Perhaps more survivability or self-sustain might be helpful, as opposed to higher damage output, but slightly higher damage output would not be unwelcomed. Vengeance seems like a waste of a skill bar slot, as it is currently setup. If the shield gained were 5x-10x higher, it would be much more worth the courage cost. This change alone might fix the survivability concern, too.
**2. **Too much RNG in some skills/features/stats. Lifesteal, for examples. 25% chance to steal the stated % of life that is gained from gear pieces. Why not just reduce the % stolen and make it 100% chance? Animal and carcass is another example. Hunting from a % chance of huntable target in the world results in % rng chance of receiving carcass or animal. That animal now has a % chance of becoming a mount or beast of burden. Perhaps some stats on artisan gear that sway the odds of: spawning a huntable target when slaying beasts in the wild; looting carcass or animal from the huntable; and returning a beast of burden or mount? Collecting enough bear meat for cooking recipes seems like a daunting "eventually I'll get a 20 stack of food" situation. Could hunters, maybe, be able to collect meat from dead beasts but hunt mounts/beasts of burden from live beasts?
**3. **Death penalties feel a little bit excessive at the moment, as it causes an extreme hesitancy to push exploration. Especially in the case of finding "pugs" to bring along. Bringing an unknown person (or people) from general chat into the group for dungeon delves is risky, as they could wipe everyone by acting unpredictably. It is relatively fair, though, as it is applied to everyone evenly.
**4. **The most important feedback: You folks are doing great things. This is an alpha, and it does feel like one (lol), but seeing the systems and the direction they are going is a great experience. My typical adventuring friends and I have been loving the exploration experience, the skill inter-dependencies, the party dynamic experiments, and diving into the complexities of the artisan system. Please keep up the amazing work!
======================
cerulean plank
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Even with all this I'm really enjoying the game and the bones that the game is based on. Its really fun and I'm loving my time testing :D
======================
plain sable
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
cinder cape
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
1 - Citizenship and Taxes are bugged. Immediately upon paying you get hit with a new request to pay that has it's due date being the same as the one you just paid. This is impossible to keep up with
2 - Excess items vanishing when processing. If I have 160 ore in my bag and I start processing the 150 of them - the extra 10 I had vanish
3- Gatherable items spawning too deep within the ground or spawning in cliffs etc. This is extremely frustrating as it also often seem to be the rarer items such a willow doing this
dense sierra
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
carmine tide
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Freehold gatherables are incorrect.
Inventory bugs/lockouts that require despawning out of the world (restarting over relogging) to fix.
Resources spawning inside of rocks or underground; to a lesser extent trees spawning on top of stone as this seems unrealistic unless the stone is cracked and the tree roots can grown down through it.
Can't always cast when fishing, occasionally it requires multiple attempts (without moving) before the cast goes through, I notice this more frequently in highly populated areas (outside Halcyon).
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Resource distribution and availability feels like an issue, though much of this will likely be addressed with population redistribution; one I'd like to see is the ratio of t2 to t1 resource spawning with lumber, in particular, as weeping willows seem rarer to me than braidwood at this point.
Enhancements to the AH systems:
dry glacier
Greetings, Glorious Alpha Two Testers!
Please share your top 3-5 most critical issues in the thread below using the following format:
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
clear lotus
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
green nebula
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
vernal wind
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
winged arrow
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.inventory not working properly,stopping to work
2.Npc mobs getting stuck whilst assaulting you, only buffing,not attacking, ashen flame ones namely
3.various objects being stuck inside other objects, like badly placed npcs,gatherables below ground
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.taxes based on when you join being a citizen? some pay 5 some pay 200, whilst I am not sure if it is a bug or is intented, it doesnt feel good to me
2.the amount of effects on screen when playing with a group is confusing at times
3.render distance feels weird as things pop in at times
4.thank you for your hard work and passion, game is fun, combat system is awesome, progression feels meaningful to me
night axle
Bugs:
Feedback:
sinful acorn
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
amber ibex
1: inventory bugs - often have to get out of the storage menu and mount then dismount to clear the bug
2: caravan will periodically disappear while driving - have to relog a couple times to fix - happens 2 or 3 times on a run
3: guild bank would be nice 🙂
4: I've noticed that not all my hits register when lag is present - feels like missing or unprocessed packets being sent to the server
5: mouse will bug out and not function for a few secs in high lag, happens multiple times
6: not sure what the intent for end goal of the ranger class is but feels like dps is a little low overall
7: looting/xp group bug - often have to relog to another toon and back over to fix the group (all members)
8: mobs getting stuck from trains and not going back to their designated spawn point
9: random porting of the mobs and getting stuck in walls ect.. pathing
10: great game so far, doing great work with it!
topaz lance
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
night gazelle
For phase 1 & 2 i have mostly wandered solo and gathered/crafted.
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
inventory desync, when we can't loot or move item inside inventory, It need each time a log/relog.*
"ghost" monsters that are targetabe, but ability don't damage them. Some ressource (i seen ore or tree) seems to suffer to this ghost state too (gatherable, but at end of timer don't drop ressource and don't disappear).
still inconsistant mob leash, sometime time they drop the pursuit very easely, other time you parcour half of a node before stopping
the font are too small, make everything hard to read
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
i am very worried by inventory size, we only have riverland ressources, only three tier of ressources, and inventory feel already far too small. 6 rarity of ressources is maybe too much. Plus all variety of intermediate craft (log/plank/ingot/etc...).
I known this is probably to avoid too much hoarding and favore exchange, but i feel inv management will be become fast a nightmare.
copper bottleneck. Too little copper in the world, too much in the recipes.
And it's needed by tools upgrades. In phase 1 i have finish to use all my copper/zinc to evolve smithing, and i had finish with a level 4. Even with what i lost or give it don't think i will be able to reach level 6. Some craft are atm only accessible if you have a complete guild (and not a small one) to sustain it.
It's even worse in phase 2 with the overcrowed servers, i have found copper but not that much, so i keep it for my tools.
i'm bit annoyed by node design, the "parking area" reserve for node developpement, make the layout very repetive, it's a bit sad. Exploration take a hit because of that. I dream about unnoded aera free of the constraint to the town/freehold reserved spaces.
crafting don't feels rewarding atm, drop are easy to get than resources to craft equivalent items.
gilded jacinth
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
desert tendon
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Thanks for the awesome alpha and keep up the good work. Hadn't such fun in a longtime 
shut magnet
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
cursive mica
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
sudden mesa
covert pollen
shut stream
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
candid pawn
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
By having the respawn location randomized across all potential nodes, there would be no pre-determined routes, but high-density resource areas will remain hotly contested, as intended. This also ensures that a balance of resources remains whether users are searching for only specific resources, or clearing the entire area of all gatherables. Both roaming and camping methods will remain viable, as a gatherer can search for specific resources across all heatmaps, but the respawn rates will be lower, or they can clear entire sections of all resources, and raise the respawn rate, but the respawns will be of all material types, including lower tiers or undesired mats.
Additionally, this would allow for the easy modification of drop tables for these heatmaps based on the game world's Node level, such that if a Node levels up or downgrades, higher tier rarities could be changed to have different spawn rates. It would also allow the templating of certain types of terrain, so that one area may have more stone spawns than usual for mining, say for along a valley, while gemstones might be more common along a river heatmap.
bitter rapids
The experience gain rate needs adjustment, particularly for levels 20+. Consider significantly increasing the XP required for level progression (e.g., x5 for each level).
Reaching level 25 from 24 should demand approximately 12 million XP. Currently, players can grind 24->25 in 3 hours (Tropics xp party), which undermines the sense of achievement.
Progression to max level should take 500-1000 hours of dedicated play. This ensures that reaching max level feels like a rewarding and significant accomplishment.
junior dune
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
peak nymph
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
broken birch
Most Important Bugs:
Most Important Feedback Topics:
valid patrol
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
More rewards for those engaging in Caravan defense. Could be based on value of caravan, number of attackers, or a fund set when launching.
Longer forced PvP flag when stealing loot or attacking a caravan. Would like to see more system for retrieving stolen loot or targeting players with stolen loot on them.
Crafting feels really imbalanced between professions. Armor smithing feels really good since NPCs can only make 3/8 pieces. I've been able to make a market with those remaining pieces even at common.
The amount of copper required to make a weapon sold by NPCs is too high. I think the amount of copper should be reduced or the basic recipe should be more powerful.
Crafters being able to train with some form of consumable would also be nice.
I'm really enjoying the state of Tank right now, but I would like to see a few tweaks.
Balance of courage feels really good right now. Loving the class fantasy with my mitigations and still needed to rely on a healer to keep me up.
I'd like to see the courage costing abilities do more damage or more shield, especially Vengeance.
Tomhawk never feels worth picking up with the "From behind" stipulations. Grapple is incredibly satisfying.
I'd like to see more choice in the Slam and Charge passives. Right now the knockback could be useful in some situations, but not many.
======================
stuck portal
silent kraken
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
weak gale
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
visual hill
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
unborn solstice
1.Caravan
2.Inventory.
3.Caravan desert
dire lintel
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1 - 3. Caravan system related, like disappearing, participation without flag, but also remaining flagged indefinietly
brazen veldt
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wintry pulsar
Bugs:
(1) Broken class abilities; Tank Grapple fail, Mage blink upgrade, et al. A signature ability not functioning undermines the class and likelihood to engage in pvp.
(2) Party/Raid issues related to no exp, inability to receive healing, or leave party.
(3) Caravan bugs that impact deploying, travel, and turn in.
(4) Death upon heal if debuffed.
(5) Broken NPC pathing/respawns that accumatively reduce viable grind spots.
Feedback:
(1) UI advanced options: filter, resize, and relocate self and target (de)buffs. Cast bar should be movable. And more! This allows focus on class specific mechanics and less eye strain with tiny icons.
(2) An option to filter graphic efx.
(3) Marketplace search filters.
(4) War Dec is currently a method to avoid corruption. Corruption system inhibits aggressive individual PKs, but War Dec bypasses and mocks the system. It allows the same action that would otherwise apply corruption for individuals, but permissible if it's scaled up to group enabled. Impliment an initialization phase that atleast briefly delays free kill so one group cannot abuse it to immediately commit acts of war instantly PKing without corruption.
(5) Mining node clusters appear arbitrarily placed in a ridiculous way. Most people understand metals, gems, and rocks occur in specific terrains and conditions. For example, gold is often found near rivers or alluvial deposits, iron in hills or mountainous regions, and gems in volcanic or metamorphic areas. It would enhance exploration and surveying if mining nodes were distributed according to geological features, encouraging players to seek resources in certain terrains that organically align with their characteristics.
solar dawn
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
I will be making a more comprehensive post on the forums, but heres some highlights
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wooden pollen
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
jovial thorn
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
• 1. Keybindings suddenly vanishing – unable to switch weapons, open options, etc. (some restored by just waiting, for some you need to logout/login, others do not even appear in key binding options)
• 2. Game options such as Video Setting are not stored properly and lost after a while or after switching chars / logging off and on again
• 3. Inventory (no need to explain as it was mentioned multiple times already)
novel talon
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Fix Desert Caravans
Inventory failing to update and requiring you to relog to fix it
Some resource nodes cannot be harvested (most often seen with Willow Trees, especially when the base of their trunk spawns inside a low rock).
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The design philosophy may be to force people to interact in Global, or using /shout in the marketplace, or contacting Guildmates, but that is time consuming and doesnt always work.
Add resource nodes and POIs to the Desert sooner rather than later.
Attacking caravans is currently very low-risk. We need more stakes for Attackers.
dusky gale
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
restive lantern
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
robust jacinth
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Bugs
Feedback
ripe eagle
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
long shuttle
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
I know some of these are either broken systems/placeholders or systems that will always be worked on to improve, but these can go a long way to prevent frustrations and/or burn-outs of your testing population, even if it takes some resources away to deal with it.
Keep up the good work and improve the game along the way!
obtuse crane
Top 3 Bug reports
Top 3-5 feedback
stuck merlin
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
frail hemlock
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
icy wigeon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
true robin
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
midnight marlin
Top 3-5 most important bugs:
Mob aggro. Mobs seem to be switching between targets without any changes in aggro table, making it easy to run mobs into a different parties, resulting in an easy way to grief.
Inventory/Storage management. Unreliable interaction between the storage and inventory UI. Finding it unclear in which container my items are. Logging in and out much to force updates.
Crafting "uneven" amounts. finding that i have 81 of a certain material combo for a craft in my possession, but having to split the crafting up in a 50, 25, 5, 1 craft, and also wasting fuel in the process is a bit frustrating.
Looting glint. The bug where you need to mount and dismount to be able to continue loot glint.
Caravan/cargo dissapearance.
Thank you for considering!
heavy nova
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hearty ridge
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
woven minnow
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
ember hedge
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
steep monolith
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
spring mortar
=====================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3 Most Important Bugs & 2 General Feedback/Requests:
1- The Anti-heal bug (or unannounced change) where those affected by it (zombie puke, etc) receive damage when healed. I got corrupted 3 times. First time I had no idea how or why it happened. Second time I found out that the cheerful melody jumps to people OUTSIDE the party. Third time I tried to help a stranger with a heal over time and the smarty decided hey let's jump in vomit. I lost my best gear this way. Give "hide helm" option pls, balding is not cool. xD
2- The trade bug. Last time I got corrupted (see above), I let myself die to a mob so a guild mate could collect my dropped gear and trade them back to me. My best weps and head gear. Trade appeared completed to him (I was watching him stream it) but to me it said it was cancelled. The gear was removed from his inventory, never to be seen again. Twas not a happy new year.
3- The Freeze (Memory Leak?). Never fun when adventuring and the game freezes on you with no way out but to alt-tab and close game via launcher. Even less fun when you log back on to see you died to a random mob.
4- We URGENTLY need a guild bank/storage. Complete with logs, perms and a massive storage for mats and gear. Guilds currently create alts to manage this. I understand it would be something that would be worked on down the line but we need it much sooner in order to continue testing optimally. Please.
5- Fixed resource rarities when spawned. I'm sure you know about this as others have mentioned it. I look forward to freeholds being more useful to alleviate this issue.
Not gonna mention the several invulnerabilities and exploits as we all know that you know that we know you know. Love you long time, keep up the good work. (please replace my lost gear, ty) ❤️
long oak
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sly charm
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
gentle glade
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wintry gull
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
meager pagoda
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
atomic pine
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs (That I have not seen listed yet)
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics (That I have not seen listed yet):
formal tree
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
rich sundial
Alpha 2 Phase 2 Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs :
Server stability and performance during large-scale PvP events. Server stability and performance insights around major POIs like the Wreckage of Carphin and the city.
Many quests are bugged, and the spawn times of some mobs for certain quests are either bugged or very long.
Treasure maps are not working.
Inventory desync or bugs.
Group and raid UI bugs and XP group bugs.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback :
Change the search feature of the marketplace: I want to search for items in the market, not just in the title of the player's name market to find what I want.
Clarify the flagging system: It's not clear when we use Alt+F if we are flagged, and it's really unclear when we use Alt+F to unflag.
Improve the group member visibility on the map: It's unclear where our group members are on the map when we press M, and it’s currently bugged.
Improve town board quests: Make town board quests offer better XP and gold rewards to make them more viable.
steep stone
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mint acorn
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
lyric jay
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.The status system is not very clear on how the status affects the actual numbers. Instead of a rating ammount i would personally prefer the status to be displayed as a percentage or flat value.
2.Pvp duels, to the death or not, would be a really fun feature. Maybe in a similar system to caravans where pvp flagged players outside the encounter cannot interfere on the duel in any way.
tidal bolt
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback (Solo Tank Perspective)
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tranquil wadi
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Keep up the good work
ionic gust
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important **Feedback **Topics:
vital star
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
solid compass
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
brittle viper
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Multiple bugs around caravans (mostly flags on players if caravan gets stuck/stays unresolved for one reason or another)
Inventory bugging out regularly (can't see changes in inventory, cant exchange between pouches of same type when they are full, sometimes can't loot drops w/o relogging beforehand)
Mobs getting stuck in or under environment
Gatherables spawning inside/under terrain
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The whole artisan system feels lifeless. There is little to no actual interaction while being an artisan other than maybe for the gatherers. For a game that deems it's artisans "the shit" this is a bit disappointing. I could write a lot about that, but for a good visual example take a look at FF 14s approach. Actual interaction with your craft. You can see other artisans inside cities doing their work, sparking interaction in terms of requests or competitions. The feeling of actually influencing your product and a proper choice between quantity or quality through skill usage. Currently AoC feels like crafting just got pushed in as a sidenote, cold receipt clicking is not enough imo. At least if you want your artisans to actually feel like they are as loved as the combat classes.
Material gathering is highly frustrating with how the spawning of gatherable nodes is handled currently. Firstly the rarity being defined by the node instead of purely by the gatherers skills and tools feels bad and leads to camping on those spots. Secondly the spawn mechanism in general leads to frustrating gathering sessions due to completely depleted areas and actual hour long walking simulation. If the player actually wants to level crafter or refiner instead of just gatherer, this will hit double as even early crafting needs decent amounts of raw resources. This goes primarily for everything metal and jewel mining and with the T2 woods as well - at least as far as I have witnessed. The timed respawn on a multiplayer map is imo generally to be avoided and a dynamic system should be used instead. Obviously materials should not respawn in visible range to the player while gathering, but a new node could respawn randomly anywhere in a larger area when one is gathered for example.
The market stalls are a severe headache to actually browse. At the very least the search function should not only look at name and description, but also offered items. Ideally add filter options for price range and rarity at the least. There should also be a "favored" list to easily become a repeat customer imo. Additionally a filterable statistic on what was sold in what quantity and to what price in the recent past should be accessible ingame, preferably directly connected to items via drop down menu or something similarly quick and easy. This will make offering items for new artisans easier, as they can better gauge the value of their products, while it also let's customers avoid being abused by the too greedy merchants. I understand the feeling of an actual marked will be replaced with some sort of online market feeling but the reality of hundreds of player stalls will make that unavoidable imo.
Crafted gear is not "soul bound". This will lead to a saturated marked for new crafters on older servers, as old gear can be sold the same as the newly crafted. This should be handled in some way. A more natural way would be to only be able to repair gear a certain number of times before it becomes "worn", reducing it's boni or some other mechanic to make new gear more attractive without going the soul bound route.
quests should be shareable to make playing in spontaneous groups easier. To avoid loops/exploits maybe limit sharing to inside a group and only for the duration of the group existing or something similar.
======================
grim sleet
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wet bramble
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
desert willow
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
crisp pumice
Top Important Bugs
Mage Blink
range exploiting
grave oak
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
proven ridge
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
• 1. Inventory/storage items sometimes not moving correctly/not updating when placed or moved, especially when in a populated area
• 2. Revive placing you back where you died sometimes, reported this one when it happened but sometimes I’d respawn on top of my body (where I just died) only to then get killed again doubling exp debt, lost materials etc…
**Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics: **
thick turtle
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
-4. Large material loss on recovered corpses that were not looted by others - I have noticed a large amount of permanent material loss on death to NPCs (Upto 25%) that happens sometimes, so I am assuming this is a bug. Glint can be a permanent loss, but materials seems odd.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
worthy lichen
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1, Inventory bugs, unable to move items in and or between inventory and storage.
2, Caravans, known issues but deserve to be highlighted again.
3, Party members seem to be dead when alive.
4, Graphical bugs turning my dwarf into a yellow minion.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1, Time to add a Trade chat, and or a LFG chat. Global chat is unreadable. Adding to chats, ability to link items in chat please.
2, Nodes and guilds rely on discord servers to operate, would be great with improved communication channels ingame between guilds, citizens and nodes.
3, XP for gathering is fairly low for the carachter.
4, UI for ongoing processing when out of town, and a personal worklist.
4, The game is awesome, keep up the good work
whole haven
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
shell pewter
====================================================================================================================================
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
~(I understand its alpha, no bad blood, Loving the game)
====================================================================================================================================
waxen ocean
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Message to the Intrepid team: I have been having a blast with the testing despite the issues listed above. This game already has most things I look for in an mmo and will be a great game once it is completed. Thank you very much and good luck.
covert crater
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback Top 3-5 Most Important Feedbacks:
peak oak
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
This is a disability concern for me due to how I play (Using my mouth, cheek, and feet). When trying to rebind Q and E to act as turn left and turn right respectively, only Q works and E as like Q. Both keys will make you turn left. Additionally, you can't rebind Q or E to anything else. The only way to reset them is resetting all keybinds.
Can't steer Caravans with Unlocked Camera on.
NPC pathing and leashing. A number of NPC bugs really take a way the grandeur of places like Carphin when you can simply run by all the bugged NPCs and reach the top of the tower solo.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Marketplace needs better search functionality like filtering item types and searching for specific items
Mob leashing takes way too long and shouldn't leash to non-combatants so easily.
More camera options like having the camera follow the direction the character faces when using keyboard controls. This is a big accessibility issue for me and many others. I was shocked to see the functionality missing since it's standard in other games/MMOs.
======================
tulip coral
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
cloud geode
Subject: Bug Report: Weapon Bonus Exploit
Description:
There is an issue with weapon bonuses that remain active even after the corresponding weapon is unequipped.
Example:
If I unlock the burn damage bonus by progressing through the talent tree of a book weapon, and then completely unequip the book to switch to a sword, the burn damage bonus still applies to the sword.
Since these bonuses stack with other weapon bonuses, even from unequipped weapons, some players are exploiting this bug to deal disproportionately high damage.
Expected Behavior:
Weapon bonuses should only apply when the corresponding weapon is equipped. Unequipping a weapon should immediately deactivate its associated bonuses.
maiden pier
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Mount animation bugged
2. Some nodes are visible but not always minable
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
muted relic
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
In general, we see a good foundation with a huge potential, but also a very ambitious project
abstract yarrow
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravan System Bugs!
a. Random teleporting to Carphin and needing to recover your caravan (I have a video if you want me to upload)
b. Attacker/Defender not working properly
c. You cannot actually leave the event after you select attacker/defender (thus you get attacked hours later if the caravan is bugged)
d. Not being able to attack caravans once the driver dies
e. auto attacks (Q) not working when attacking
Inventory Bugs - Moving items doesn't work or you have to relog for them to show. This happens in regular inventory, cargo inventory, and material inventory.
Party Experience/Loot Bugs - Party members have to completely relog and reform group to get XP and loot again.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Caravan PVP Dynamics - Let party/raid leader set attack/defend for the whole group (maybe the group members have to all agree before it starts to avoid griefing).
Exploiters should be reset to level 1.
silver mantle
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1 - Highwaymen Snipers jumping randomly to nowhere.
2- Green visual effects on mobs during combat, they get very shinny greenish lightnings coming out of them.
3- Treasure maps not usable.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1- I think we should have a new server, currently servers are pretty crowded, and as a non-competitive player, feels really awful to play agaisnt competitive guilds in a map this small, where we cannot spread away from them
======================
unreal inlet
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
noble wolf
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
torpid coral
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Keep up the good work, we love you guys and what you are making are awesome! ❤️
rapid forum
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
drifting gorge
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Scaling/levelling seems way off. With this I mean the difference between player levels and crafted gear / node progress. It’s kind of stupid that we can only craft lvl 0 gear will most players are already near or over lvl 20. Or the node level/buildings need to be faster so crafters can scale with the players levels or the player levelling needs to slow down a lot. Prefer the last one.
There needs to be a clear line / statement about abusing systems and what is called testing. Currently there are to many players using the term testing for abusing a broken system to gain advantages or griefing others. I’m a fan of a cascading ban system for people misusing the alpha.
Better communication about the upcoming testing weekend. So tester won’t get caught with surprise if something isn’t present yet or half-present.
======================
craggy ravine
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
• 1. Bugs that force you to re-loging
• 2. Some times heal don’t heal at all for some seconds
• 3. Bugs with mobs in general (some of them don’t attack back and just look at you)
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
• 1. The lighting some times is going very weird, I can’t recognize some times the ruby color from distance and I must go very close to be sure.
• 2. We need better map UI and mechanics (find party’s member as example to know where your group is fast)
earnest root
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory bug - The inventory sometimes doesn't update, this prevents seeing, moving and looting/adding items. It is temporarily fixed by mounting/dismounting, as that "forces" the inventory to update. It appears to be dependent on server workers, as it sometimes fixes itself (or breaks) when changing server workers). Restarting the game fixes the problem, and appears to be the best "long-term" fix.
Bite attacks do not need to be "in range" to hit. This is especially clear with grems. You can be 10-15 meters away and the bite will still damage you. All other types of attacks do not appear to have this issue, and feels very good to kite/dodge
Sometimes losing the rest of the wood in inventory when lumbermilling. Do not know what causes this, but sometimes (not all) I am left with nothing in inventory after starting a lumbermilling stack, it does not appear to be the inventory bug, as it isn't fixed by mounting/dismounting or relogging. This problem also happens with carpentry, if I add 10 timber (and had 16), I usually lose the extra 6.
It does not appear to happen, if you have additional stacks, only if you have something "leftover" in the stack
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The game feels very good to play! Keep it up!
Resources like willow seem very scarce, which can be very constricting for the smaller guilds/lone players etc. As the big guilds will hoard it. This problem is only being pushed further by the ability for freeholds to have willow trees. Every freehold on the server right now has willow trees, even though they apparently are broken and can't be harvested
iron briar
Bugs
1: storage and cargo issues. (ie, bought cargo having no value until after closing and reopening the window.
2: weapons and hair randomly disapearing. (hair moreso than weapons.) (seems related to server worker transitions? I've noticed it popping in and out when I cross borders.)
Feedback
1: Animal husbandry shouldn't be random. (Maybe higher ranks decreases randomness? or just do away with it completely.)
2: Escaping from accidentally or maliciously pulled mobs (leash range).
3: A visible indicator on the UI when your gear is broken / damaged. (not just on the character screen.)
grave carbon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
spice sapphire
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Memory Leaks- the game gets stuck in an infinite loading screen
2.Treasure map system don't look done from what i've seen. but i'm not sure if it's intentional yet.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.making this game more accessible to people with more mid Rigs. for some of us, it doesn't have to look good. we just want to be able to play it and the game be stable.
2.consider at some point putting this game up on a streaming service like Geforce now. some people can't afford to buy a whole new computer. but i really like what you people got going on with this game.
3.a lot of the systems here even in this alpha phase are good. so. damn. good.
faint hinge
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Please, please, please make sailing ships realistic and technical (from a player perspective). The thought of being able to outsail an opponent with skill (rather than simply buying better parts) is very interesting to me. Including things like realistic sailboat performance vs. wind direction and ocean currents (https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Sio-Hoi-Ieng/publication/265139871/figure/fig4/AS:613919513141249@1523381226064/Speed-polar-diagram-of-the-sailboat.png) or even requiring party members to manage and trim the sails to match changing wind conditions or heading. I think that including systems like this (easy to learn basics/difficult to master) would make the naval system really pop in this game and I'm really looking forward to it.
Inventory management is engaging and really helps to emphasize the power curves in the professions. I like how the novice bags feel small and cramped and the Apprentice bags get much bigger. This feels good and I hop to see this trend continue to the higher tiers.
Caravan inventory sizes feel good. Novice caravans are not very profitable, but this just reinforces the need to upgrade. Non-upgraded novice activities shouldn't be very profitable.
Emergent PVP is very difficult to distinguish friend vs. foe. When an organized group attacks a bunch of randoms, its difficult for them to fight back without taking the time to form a party, which takes valuable time in combat. Maybe this is intended, but it feels bad when your PVP attacks hit targets you were not aiming for or can't tell who is grouped with the original aggressor.
PVP friction around rare resources feels great (Raptors, pocket dungeons, etc.)
======================
vague lily
Top 3 Bugs:
CARAVANS - Being killed off a caravan despite having the rider buff. Clerics outside of attack/defend healing the caravan making them unkillable without going corrupted removing them. Caravans randomly disappearing. Caravans you're riding causing you to randomly dismount, which can result in the rider buff bugging out.
STACKING WEAPON ABILITIES - You can stack all weapon finishers and multi-choice talents from all weapons and have them apply to your current active weapon. You can have 7 finishers proc at once and stack the +crit chance and +crit damage from the various weapons and just obliterate everything in combat.
3 STORAGE & INVENTORY - I am totally disappointed with the ongoing farce that is Inventory. This has been bugged since P1 and gotten progressively worse with each patch. My inventory now bugs out and fails to update after moving a single item. It is a pain to keep relogging to make the inventory refresh.
Top 3 Feedback:
RESOURCE GATHERING - If you know how the current resource spawning works the gathering of resources descends in to spreadsheet and stopwatch tracking. This is not an immersive system and leads to key resource spawn points being farmed on a timer with gatekeeping by the few who find them.
GUILD WARS - Either the costs of making a new guild is too low, or the cost of war scrolls is too high. Right now if you go to war with a 'griefer' guild they can simply drop guild and laugh at your waste of 25g, then can simply go create another guild for next to nothing. This is also an issue with non-guilded griefers being exempt from war declaration meaning they can do what they want without risk or repercussion.
PARTY & RAID FRAMES - There needs to be an option to have Raid Frames on as default while in a party. For Clerics, the raid frames and mouse-over-healing is a key healing feature/capability. I would also love to see the option for the Raid Frames to populate horizontally first, rather than vertically.
native spade
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
solid ridge
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
dusty verge
Top Most Important Bugs.
balmy coral
dusty verge
Discord will not allow me to make this a simple message
smoky ruin
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
thin plume
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Treasure map bugs. Similar to an ond caravan bug, after failing to complete a run due to different issues you will be unable to ever use a treasure map. Even when you would complete the treasure map quest, it would remain in your journal until removed manually.
3.Bugs regarding different status effects: Healing a person while they die (and have the anti-healing debuff from a zombie) will result in corruption of the healer. Stats fluctuate for no apparent reason, getting low movement speed, negative evasion, negative lifesteal, etc. (these ones can be solved by relogging)
4.Class/skill bugs: Archer Scatter Shot sometimes uses the animation of the Concentrated Scatter Shot, Bard: Saga-Apocalype sometimes has the animation but dosent do the fire cone and deals 0dmg; When having Dance Mastery-Energy, Mesmerizing Dance sometimes dosent reset Flourish cd when it should (this can be solved by relogging)etc.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.VERY IMPORTANT!! End of phase one there was an option to make auto-attack a toggle, this feature seems to be currently missing.
pvp guilds abuse as many bugs as possible and as often as possible to get ahead (like the non stop abusing of guild wars and the gold dupping present in phase1)======================
chilly spindle
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
I know you're insane dev's so you're able to fix a sixth bug too 😉
6) Caravan
lone folio
Alpha 2 Phase 2 Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
idle minnow
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1- Bow animation do not flex the bow and string anymore (was working fine in phase 1)
2- Graphics settings being reset everytime start the game
jade glacier
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1: --TANK- Chain pull not being able to pull enemies over ledges, or just outright not functioning.
2: Being able to train NPC mobs onto other groups/people easily- if they don't attack mobs should focus target the first person that interacts with the mob. and ignore all others outside of it's zone until it resets as long as they don't attack it.
3: if I PVP up and attack someone. i should go corrupt if they die in the next 60 seconds. even if I'm not the thing that kills them. (can give examples of things that allow me to kill people without consequence)
4: Buffs stacking/duplicating- being unable to see all buffs on any character/npc due to too many active buffs.
5: TANK- Chain pull not being able to pull enemies over ledges, or just outright not functioning. <--- repeated because it's seriously annoying.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1:---not enough random drops of items. even basic stuff would be nice. so many people are having difficulty gearing up, and it would be nice to see more basic drops.
2:--- glint being the only source of income, while effective, also means a loss of money if you're farming and die, and the amount you drop also means people are more likely to be jerks and try to steal it. which is okay, if not for training mobs onto people. and 25% complete loss of the glint. this seems like an extraordinarily high loss.
2.5:--- the game counts each glint as an item. even it they are of a larger tier. personally i'd rather the game calculate my total glint, and split my stacks to drop 20% and lose 20% on 100% of total glint. instead of a random drop chance on all items.
3:--- ADDING METAL DROPS TO STONES OF THE SAME TIER.
THANK YOU! this is the single most useful buff to mining you could of done. it might need some tinkering on the amount that it drops. but 10/10.
marble marsh
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Storage and inventory bug when you transfert many items : they are transfert but invisible, and you have to wait for update bag or
storage but mostly you have to relog for working
2.Mob who are stuck in wall or pat throuhgt the wall will in combat
3.Lightning ball who path through many wall (maybe intentional) but in place maybe control the lightning ball to make it stand in place or go back to you
4. Weeping Willow tree not gatherable du to the spawn in rocks or ground ! And they are too few in number
5. Citizenship Dues are bugs in some ways or not clear at all
outer cliff
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top Most Important Bugs:
Top Most Important Feedback Topics:
ashen kayak
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs: (CARAVAN EDITION)
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback:
Thank you!!🙏🏼
jovial thorn
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
potent stone
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
swift panther
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Combat bugs like scattershot sometimes hitting twice, consuming one charge if one is available (the second is a simple raw uncharged shot). Some cleric spells as well like wings of salvation not hitting because of terrain or the first spell (small balls) not being hover-able.
2. Mobs not here for whatever reason, very less impactul than the 1. imo but it's kinda frustrating at low levels when there aren't that much good spots to grind to (at various size of group or even solo). Although this has been fixed on some areas.
Inventory and storage desync resulting in losing items
3. Raid and groups frames becoming invisible
valid summit
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Treasure Maps don't work for some players
Mob agro range is too long, which some players abuse to train mobs onto other players
Tree nodes that are not collectable( not talking about in the desert).
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The journeyman mining materials aswell as trees should be toned down in the world until the journeyman advancement is available in the server. This creates a lot of excess mining nodes that are just unable to be used until journeyman access happens. As a player it is frustrating that the map consists mostly of these unobtainable resources.
dense gazelle
Feedback:
Bugs:
Caravans: When attacking, it’s not possible to deal damage to caravans. It’s also not possible to leave the caravan event, accept the event while in a party, spawn a caravan, or teleport while riding in a caravan. In general, caravans need some attention.
Inventory and storage bugs: Various issues persist.
Even though we have some issues and limited content in Alpha, it has been a long time since I’ve enjoyed a game this much. I really appreciate your great work and approach to Ashes of Creation. I am excited to see what the game will become in the future. 🙂
coral iris
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Bank and inventory Items often get bugged and are unable to be moved back and forth needing a relog to fix
2. Mob agro and loot drops inconsistencies (sometimes loot doesn't get rolled on because people can just pick it up)
3. Treasure maps are unable to be used, acts like I have a quest for one already.
4. Camouflage still doesn't work for the Ranger.
5. Cannot join a Caravan defense or attack without leaving the party and reforming.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. Extremely lacking resource nodes in large parts of Halcyon, Joeva, New Aela, Tropics, and every desert Node. (No point to be in any of these nodes unless doing something very specific.) Only certain amount of crucial resource spawns like Raptors/Willow/Copper/Tin. Only 6 raptor spawns for the entire server? On a 1-2 hr respawn? RIDICULOUS! Creates a throttle where only the biggest guild wins.
2. Exploiters are not being punished. You know who they are.
3. Lack of viable options to level solo. Quest rewards suck and are not worth the time.
4. Time to kill in PVP is incredibly too short. Mages rule all and need a major adjustment. They have a ton of offense, defense, and mobility while every other class only has one of those three.
5. Corruption is entirely to harsh. You should be able to kill a white with little to no penalty within reason. Corruption is supposed to MITIGATE GRIEFING, Not create MORE!! The amount of PVE griefing I have seen in this test and in phase 1. It is ruining a lot of peoples experiences because they have no way to interact
======================
warped herald
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
0. have a way to prevent spawing of nodes that cant be harvested (idk how easy it'd be to be but something like if theres an apprentice (gathering profession) station in the world then the gatherables from this profession can spawn or it can spawn the moment a node begins the construction of the station or smth like this
Currently there is WAY too many t3 nodes that cant be gathered and it is quite frustration seeing so many braidwood and iron when it could be willow or tin
twin siren
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Most Important Bugs:
⚠️ Some players and I had their characters deleted without reason. #alpha-two-bugs-issues-old message
If you are not able to recover the lost characters then I imagine this is a top priority issue.
Search this discord for "Waiting for character data validation" to find others who had their characters deleted.
lethal plover
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
drifting idol
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
light dust
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sinful pagoda
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1-Some resources being very rare, it would be good if the treasure maps worked: impossible to reach the chest, quest which is not validated then disappears when the server restarts then impossibility to restart a new quest.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1-A few Bad-intentioned players aggro lot of mobs in HL zone and passes through the others groups, theirs objectives is to wipe the group and loot theirs bodies… They are not in PVP, so impossible to kill
2-A few Bad-intentioned players throw few projectil against heal member that be not in PVP to provoke the wipe of the group and finish the boss or loot theirs bodies. They should switch to pvp!
3-The flag PVP timing for people having looted the bodies must be increase, the rez point is not near and we can't take revenge.
Thanks you for your job, continu!
sand wing
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
verbal thorn
Storage and Inventory Issues
Monsters Getting Stuck
Mob Clipping and Exploits
Corruption Mechanics and Toxic Behavior
Alt Abuse in Voting
Uneven Event Distribution
sudden coral
what seems like it would be a simple fix is the size of the quantity font in inventory, can you please increase this? I think I'm getting a retinal damage
dry garden
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Game is excellent so far! Love what you guys are doing!!
errant vigil
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
tranquil marlin
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
brazen cloak
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Overdesign of Profession levels.
A design needs to be stated simply so that anyone can understand it.
For example "Professions. There are 22. You start with them all at Novice. You can have 5 Apprentice, 4 Jouurneyman, 3 Master and 2 GrandMaster."
Instead, "You can have 5 at Apprentice OR ABOVE..."
This is so confusing I have not seen it explained properly anywhere. And, the lock tooltip on Novice Skills at Level 10 is completely wrong and misleading.
When the consensus in forum chat was that you can have no more than a total of 5 Professions above Novice, I stopped playing immediately.
Overdesign of Inventory and Storage.
A design should solve real problems, not create them.
Give players ways to automate their storage management, including one click to merge inventory into storage and crafting from storage.
Start with a simple design, and then figure out how best to introduce the restrictions and complexity you want.
For example, make stack sizes universal. Then find an elegant way to store different qualities of the same item. Only then tackle the issue of increasing capacity with profession level.
My advice as a professional software developer for 50 years is: GET RID OF SATCHELS NOW. Bags, etc, will naturally follow. Give players a grid of the appropriate size while you examine what you are actually trying to achieve with inventory and storage, and then implement that.
With the current full-of-bugs scheme, you will add more bugs than you remove as you try to move forward with it.
Mental exercise: How many automated unit tests would your devs have to write to cover all of the edge cases in the current scheme?
sick orchid
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tight marten
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
warm topaz
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
fast pond
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Most Important Bugs:
1 inventory/storage system bugging
2 Being unable to loot from the ground (happens mostly with glint)
3 Treasure Maps stops working forever if u start them on full quest log or open a hidden a treasure that doesn't belong to the location shown on map
4 Apprentice creatures not spawning as of (shell of the ancients, and Oathbearer is rarely seen) Journeyman Creatures are missing a big margin (comparing to their location on codex/previous phase)
5 groups getting messed up that can either be fixed by turning the group into raid vice versa, or sometimes requiresa full reset and a wait time of 10 minutes since one guy can't receive invites
6 cannot see HP bars in PVP
7 Cannot loot dead bodies in Water
Most Important feedbacks:
leveling system needs tweaking, grinding mobs for hours for 1 level is not enjoyable, most of the quests are not rewarding or just a place holder for now,
this can be fixed by simply adding a quest infront of every major farming spot that asks you to kill 100 mobs there for 1 level and afterward the mobs there start giving you too few Exp that you have to move to a different area for effecient farming,
last levels you have to stay at 3 areas that are over contested because of 1 europe server holding all the population, this makes leveling really boring.
some mobs for example in the desert after killing them they spawn 15 levels lower (level 10 instead of 20+)
some apprentice mounts respawn every 4 hours or so, this makes leveling up hunting and animal husbandry really tough in over populated servers, there is also the frogs lake south of steelbloom needs 1,5 minutes to respawn, which is your only viable option though it might be unintended, but taking into consideration the respawn time of ravens/grems it might be a game mechanic though it has to be mentioned.
Mayors getting Flying mounts from the big beginning is a massive advantage, and need to be either when they reach max level or when the node develops as of every mayor maxed their gatherings and gathered everything while still at lvl 10 making every other player unable to gather rare RSS like weeping willows/Copper/ mounts
Mobs can hit you even if you are out of their attack range.
Most importantly buffs are annoying, if the node has several buffs active and u are using food/milk/scrolls/pots especially if you are a bard aswell, u won't be able to see most of your buffs
fleet zenith
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
dry kite
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravan Issues (Mostly them Dissapearing in water to ground transfer and becomming unrecoverable.)
The treasure map system. I havent been able to use treasure maps at all this alpha phase and know others who have had the same bug. Missing out on lots of stuff. (Pretty sure its b/c map was used then quest timed out can never do again after.)
The inventory bug that has to do with mounting and dismounting over and over. Seems to freeze up all inventory unless you mount to refresh and same for looting glint.
The trees in all the Node village plot zones. This one just bothers me. I know its probly something simple but it just bothers me. All the trees are half in the ground. Makes the scenery look dumb no real issue otherwise.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
I feel like quests could use more detail or have more uniqueness to them rather than the same old go here grab this come back style.
I feel like there should be some form of change to mob agro to make it so that people cant just run a train of mobs in your group and wipe you for whatever reason. That or make it so your heals/spells/buffs do not effect people outside of party so you dont pull agro. Just the whole training mobs into groups in general gets very stale.
Love the combat in the game. Both the PVE and PVP. Would be nice if there was a way to see all the buffs you have on you or possibly remove some when you are at +39 buffs from gathering its hard to tell what procs you're getting or what is making you do certain types of damage.
wise gyro
Top 5 Most Important Bugs:
1- Caravans disappearing, not being able to be restored; drivers teleporting to other places; beast of burden speed not affecting raft speed (possibly intentional, not sure).
2- When the server is crowded, looting glint from the ground sometimes becomes impossible unless you relog—really frustrating.
3- Planting trees in freeholds only yields common oak, regardless of the tree type and rarity. Additionally, planting flowers seems unaffected by the rarity of the root ball, at least not directly.
4- As a level 26 hunter, I've "hunted" at least a few hundred animals, yet the highest quality I've seen was one heroic, along with a few rares. This feels buggy, especially since miners report finding significantly more legendaries and epics. Lumberjacking feels slightly better but is still nowhere near mining's success rate.
6- Inventory management is sometimes buggy and laggy, especially with materials. While I've rarely lost items (except once), I often need to relog after every right-click or drag action involving materials.
Top 5 (+1) Most Important Feedback Topics:
1- Attacking caravans feels like a very low-risk (time spent, hence opportunity cost), high-reward activity. Unfortunately, "bad rep" isn't enough to balance this.
2- Combat is really fun—thank you! I leveled a mage to 25 twice. Combos feel good and are usually easy to set up. However, I only have three skills left to unlock in my skill tree. We need more active and passive skills to allow more versatile builds. It would be great to choose between control mage, DPS mage, etc. At least three distinct "main" builds would add a lot of variety. Additionally, mages should be slightly better when playing solo.
3- I love that there are many people around and that I have to interact with them, whether friendly or hostile. Fighting for resources, farming spots, and loot is engaging, and the lack of instanced dungeons is fantastic. Current player density feels slightly too high, but this will likely balance out with a larger map.
4- Leveling by mob grinding is fine—this is how I started playing MMOs, and I usually enjoy the process. However, the game would benefit from viable alternative leveling methods, such as questing or artisanship, for those who prefer other paths.
5- Low-level mount redundancy is an issue. After reaching higher-tier mounts, lower-level mounts become largely obsolete, rendering half of the trained animals essentially junk. Beast of burden animals avoid this fate because caravans can be destroyed, creating ongoing demand. However, once players upgrade to T2 mounts, T1 mounts are largely useless.
6- Sorry for adding a sixth, but this is important. Griefing mobs onto other players is unfairly problematic at the moment. While I am not against mob training, there must be some form of counterplay to make it fair.
silk berry
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
unborn axle
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravan despawning when transitioning server workers and "caravan recovery" not functioning afterwards
Inventory stability, being unable to move items or have them reflect properly in storage & bags along with items disappearing in some trades
"False flags" or "flag timeouts" in PvP, especially around lawless zones, that result in unwarranted corruption
Mob leash ranges and time to drop combat
Mob spawn stability, some slowly become bugged or disappearing after extended farming and leashing
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Processing amounts set at fixed amounts is quite cumbersome at times, much preferred to able to process "total/current amount" of items available
Marketplace filtering and searching capabilities
Review of processing artisanship leveling/experience, tanning in particular from novice to apprentice feels heavily unbalanced compared to something like lumber milling in regards to material availability/amount required
UI Buff & Debuff customization, buff & debuff visibility on nameplates along with frames, status effect tracking in floating combat text, etc
Along with target markers, a marker flare or ping system would be great for in game communication
======================
uncut shell
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Storage / Inventory issus - Put in storage or pick up from storage doesn't show change in inventory.
Treasure quests issus - Can't complete Treasure Quests when treasure founded.
General Quest - In some quests PNJ is not present in location show in Map.
Can't loot materials from ground also when inventory it's empty.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Menu to manage group (Group looking for people, people looking for group, ...) would be nice.
Teleport between attuned Emberspring would be nice.
Balance material spawn rates.
hoary bluff
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
untold raft
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
rich stone
Exploiting(safe spot exploiters), rubber banding, war exploiting
untold raft
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Also, it's been stated that higher level crafts will require in quantity lower level materials to ensure that lower level crafters are viable, especially later in a server's lifecycle. This doesn't seemto be true at least yet, and in particular granite and basalt are just pointless, with stacks and stacks being vendored because the have actively no use in the economy. also, having every gatherering profession's gear gated on the same rare drop mining spawn and the same uncommon+ logging spawn puts incredible pressure on those resources early for the entire profession community (while simultainiously leaving herbalism behind). The fact that novice herbalism has 2 common and 1 rare spawn, and the rare spawn can just be grown with farming really tanks the demand for herbalists. (this in fact promotes the need for more droppings, and further depreciates herbalism).
2. The marketplace needs a massive UX overhaul. The target system is very good, but even if search worked we eneed to be able to see a list of all of the searched item, prices, quantities and sellers (see FFXI/FFXIV, CoH/CoV). This will greatly improve the experience for buyers and sellers. I approve and am excited for the the regional unlinked markets, but it can take 15 minutes to scan all the stores for a single item presently, it is often faster and more economical to take to /global or /shout
3.Chat needs the ability to spawn multiple windows and there are still missing granularity controls
knotty shell
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
leaden mica
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mint owl
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sweet lodge
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Render distance for pvp needs to be fixed, enemy players do not render until you are in their midst during large scale pvp events.
Remove guild war events until it can be fixed, people can bug events by declaring war multiple times against one target, breaking the event neither side can concede and it results in exploitative measure to grief any guild it is used against.
Improve guild ui and management system for invite privileges, ensure some security and protection from bad actors.
Feedback:
Combat finishers need to be worked on, unable to determine at times if effect are applied properly to targets.
Please work on inventory bugging, makes the game tedious when you have to relog every 5 minutes to fix it.
Add filters for the market place as a QOL to reduce the scroll/search time.
paper folio
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravan-Bugs (bypassing the Red Barrier with a Caravan-Raft, being unable to attack a Caravan if the Driver does specific Things, being able to bug into and hide in the Terrain so you can´t be attacked, etc.)
Crafting-Quality-Rating and Profession-Rarity Increase-Rating not really working ( from the Math we did it seems like 1% per 100 Quality-Rating, which makes it completely irrelevant and useless to craft any Profession-Cloths)
Mob-Aggro not working making training them and griefing super easy, combined with the insanely punishing Death-Penalties and being able to loot 25% of other Players that is a big Issue.
Weapon-Passives of all Weapons being applied and increasing the Damage by a lot + adding tons of more Debuffs then intended
Freeholds and especially the Ressources on them not working properly
(Kinda have to add Inventory and Storage Problems aswell, such as not being able to right-click-move them, Items being shown incorrectly meaning disappearing or visually duplicating themselves and the specific Item-Storages not applying the higher Stack-Sizes in the Storage + not enough Storage and high enough Stack Sizes so you fill up super fast from playing actively for 1-2 Hours)
Feedback:
The Death-Penalties are way too punishing and tbh shouldn´t exist in the First Place imo, especially with griefing being so easy (training, flagging for PvP and sleeping the Healer, etc.)
Death-Penalties have never felt good in any Game and most Players allways disliked them, especially if you can lose most of your Loot very fast and with that nearly your whole Progress of your Play-Session.
Leveling is too tedious for most, especially since you are missing Core-Mechanics like Questing and Daylies and rather want to test the current End-Game.
Class-Balancing. I know it´s an Alpha and Stuff like that is probably rather for later down the Timeline, but Bards are pretty overtuned right now and Mages can nearly Skill every Skill they have when they hit LvL 25.
half agate
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
azure token
@slate mica
Alpha Two Phase II. Feedback
Most important bugs:
MOST IMPORTANT INGAME TESTING ISSUE!!! Zerg Guilds exploiting to an advantage and unbalanced testing.
red thunder
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
robust glen
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
nocturne otter
Top 3-5 Bugs:
Top 3-5 Feedbacks:
bleak valley
Most bugs have been mentioned by other folks. I just have a few ideas that may or may not be useful...
Metals rarity seems a little low. I've farmed for hours just to ha e enough copper to upgrade a single tool let alone work on smithing. Maybe let there be a small 0.1% chance of gathering copper or tin from basalt or granite. This could also incentives people to clear those nodes for more chance of metal spawns.
Can we please get a slider for the amount of items to process. Or atleast make the crafting amounts match the stack size.
Fully support losing resources when you die. But maybe make it so there is a small grace period if a team member is able to rez you on the 25% of resources that is deleted
Been following this game for a long time and I love the direction it's been heading great work and I can't wait to see more
warm canyon
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
floral compass
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
stuck portal
sterile agate
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
stuck portal
timid horizon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
glass flint
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sand rose
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
heady parrot
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
warm garnet
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
bleak fog
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.
2.
3.
round jungle
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
modern flower
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1. Inventory bug ~ Unable to loot glint unless there is a stack already in your inventory, it also does not create a new stack or update the UI to reflect what's in your inventory.
2. Treasure maps still seem to have a myriad of issues.
3. Monster training to circumvent PvP
4. Freehold mob suppression appears to be affecting specific zone kill quests
5. Quests overall seem to still be in a rather bad state for interactable elements being present, mob presence or even being able to complete them.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1. Caravan ZOIs are relatively small and are not conducive to PvP. Attackers can declare at will while within a throng of defenders and the defenders cannot act without incurring corruption.
2. Node and Guild Wars have a similar issue of non-involved parties acting as pocket healers and scouts. While arguably invulnerable to attack unless you would like to incur corruption. I would argue for less PvP flag restrictions during times of war, especially in affected zones for all parties present. I'd also argue a return of the 'Enemy of State' idea, as recently citizens were relaying information during a war without punishment. A mayor should be able to revoke their citizenship and potentially mark them as hostile; of course for an associated cost.
3. Caravans need a more robust system to allow player agency regarding who may defend a caravan and a possible payout system (player coffer). Random passersby can be nice but not all defenders are acting in the interest of a caravan.
4. Freeholds should have more of a tie actual citizens in the nodes, rather than an associated gold cost. Whether that be an auction using requisition slips or only letting a high ranking citizen have the ability to buy them. As well there should be an upkeep fee if there already isn't one, seems like Freeholds can be a resource printer.
5. Node wars and guild wars should have a preparation timer once declared. Instant declaration has been shown to be highly abusable thus far.
trim pebble
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
warm canyon
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
ivory mauve
Top Bugs- 1. Inventory disappearing in trades causing item deletion.
2. During trades, inventory constantly asking for more space even though more than enough space is available
3. Caravan flag state lasting far beyond the time the caravan existing, and no ability to leave said event, causing issues till a server reset.
Feedback- 1. Caravan attacker registration feels very bad right now, requiring the entire group to disband/reform as new caravans must be attacked or defended. Should be under the control of the party leader flagging as attacker/defender for the entire raid or group when the leader picks, and operate as normal if you are alone.
2. Fighter feels very lacking in larger scale pvp, see many who where fighters now playing as rangers, or waiting for rogue.
3. Hunting needs a rarity bonus to bring it into line with the other gatherables. It's very annoying to see mostly blues and greens when miners and lumberjacks get epics/legends far faster.
4. Npcs should not leash by proximity when running through a group that has done no damage or taunt to them, making it more difficult for griefing mob pulls.
5. Crafting shirts/pants need to be redone to actually do something worthwhile, not add an armor point. Either that, or the effort in attaining them needs to be far less.
half hinge
Top 3 most important bugs:
Top 3 Feedback:
teal yacht
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Caravans disappearing on mesh server lines.
Inventory consistently bugs out. For example when in your storage and you switch items from your player inventory to node storage sometimes it will not allow any items to be switched from inventory to inventory and it requires a game restart to fix this issue.
Mob aggro seems to last an ungodly amount of time sometimes and will follow you until you are across the map and sometimes mobs will de-agrro right beside where they spawn. For example the shamans at Oakenbane will de-agrro if you walk 15m away from where they spawn and the mobs at highway men will follow you for it seems 150-250m. Not sure if this is a bug but where is the consistency?
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Add a proper search and filter option when in the player market. Currently you have to manually go though every shop to find what you want.
Getting to Journeymen hunting requires about 250 gold total. Maybe this number could be tweaked slightly as it is very expensive at the moment or adding a stat to wearable hunting gear to decrease the gold amount needed (depending on the rarity of hunting gear worn)
Right now end game is getting BIS then doing caravans for PvP and doing the world bosses/dungeons. Adding arenas would be a good idea so there is more to do in end game. Possibly adding ranked so when you win a match at a higher rank you get a currency for item trade at a specially made ranked market that you can trade your points in for materials or weapons/armor.
======================
bronze coral
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
winged nest
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
strange marsh
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
night kayak
Most important bugs:
compact horizon
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
limpid fiber
Top bugs:
buoyant patrol
Pasted from a friend who couldn't post for some reason Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
neat swallow
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
timid beacon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1: Caravans disappearing or commodities not being worth anything when the caravan arrives. Also, the caravan bug after logging out and logging back in makes it so the caravan can’t be attacked or defended.
2: Mob leashing issues of all kinds.
3: Inventory issues that require constant relogging.
4: Mobs and resources spawning in or under the ground.
5: Party issues where the party gets bugged and stops receiving loot and experience until the entire party relogs.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1: The corruption system needs some tweaks. As it stands today it hinders PVP, encourages griefing, and punishes people just trying to defend themselves. It should encourage healthy and fun PVP encounters. To start with, if someone flags up and attacks another person the person who is attacked should be able to kill the person who initiated combat without fear of corruption.
2: Exploiters need to be dealt with harshly. It was said that they would be banned. The problem is rampant and makes many elements of the testing environment unavailable to the average person.
3: Griefing in general and more specifically the constant leashing of mobs onto parties in all of the points of interest.
4: The marketplace is a mess. We need a way to search for specific items.
5: Player draw distance in pvp battles.
======================
delicate turtle
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hardy plinth
alpha two phase II Feedback
top 3-5 most important bugs:
top3-5 most important feedback topics
wise remnant
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
fervent mortar
Bugs:
Feedback:
Smoother Leveling (mobs/locations) from 10-25 for solo(more my experience)/group play. More xp grinding locations. The "good/best" locations become saturated quickly and grinding for significantly less xp takes a toll on morale when only getting a third or less xp per hour. There seem to be too few locations that 'feel good', meaning good mob density, good respawn rate, good areas to pull or kite mobs. Mob placement/variety in the wild is often scattered together in a shotgun pattern making pulls harder and fighting the mob that your gear/setup/skills can handle more challenging. From lvl 1-10, even with the rush/crowds of a server wipe/restart everything feels smoother. The power curve for gear/skills feels better from lvl 1-10 as well. A single skill can effectively double your dps/survival early on, making the lvling feel smoother and more meaningful. From 10-25 skill gain is(and feels) less significant. Part of this could be lack of knowledge of good hunting/grinding spots on my part, but I do try to make a point to explore a fair amount looking for good, less frequented areas. Perhaps with more dungeons/subterranean areas you'll balance this out. Increased drop rate for gear could help. Once an established trade economy(ability to better sell/buy) is more fully implemented it may not matter as much.
Aggro from pulled/trained mobs. Please increase the aggro 'focus' to be maintained on the original player so that mobs are less likely to target you when someone, intentionally or otherwise runs them by. Especially when you aren't attacking that mob.
Having to hunt/grind gold/lvls before you can "be" a crafter feels bad
Draw/load distance for mobs/players
Better Targeting options, a way to know when you're being targeted by mobs/players
quiet creek
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
storm dune
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
kindred oasis
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
severe marlin
Bugs
Feedback
fervent mortar
Bonus Feedback:
Making a corpse no longer a flagged/stealing event after 'x' amount of time. Giving friends or party members looting rights so they aren't flagged if you die.
polar mason
Character Buffs constantly changing positions is a big issue. Need permanent placement in the front of the list for class specific buffs. I’m playing Bard atm and focus on my resonance stacks and if melody is active, so I want to know where to look for those. Needs to be first in the list imo. Also – generally – the FONT IS WAY TOO SMALL – I can’t see the numbers in the buffs (or inventory/storage) boxes.
Storage/Inventory – numerous bugs; can’t see or move items, items disappear. Can’t always view items in other towns. This causes constant relogging throughout the day.
Crafting – should be able to pull mats for crafting from that towns’ storage.
Mount gets caught and won’t move or jump on the tiniest pebble.
Swimming - Mount surfaces and swims well. Character doesn’t surfaces and drowns without a mount. (bug)
Timers needed for crafting (what, where, remaining time) and for cool downs for guild and citizenship changes.
I could write a lot more, but trying to keep the list short here.
Great game! Keep the improvements and communication coming!
fair coral
Top Bugs:
Caravan instability - Caravan cargo de-spawning. Caravan bugginess around deployment and recoverability. Unable to select “Defend” if already in a group.
__Drop Instability __- Glint becomes unpickable, even when soloing. Treasure map chest drops disappear or are bugged.
Mob Instability - Mobs stuck in terrain. Ashen mobs will aggro then stop attacking. Mobs too close to terrain walls or bodies of water are unresponsive.
Character Avatar Instability - Disappearing hair. My character’s avatar looks completely different to my friends view but stays the same on my screen. We run the same computer stats. Character model reverts to the default model.
Feedback Topics:
-The gear gap in PvP should not be as vast as it is. A max level player should still be at risk when attacking low level. This would reduce the number of high levels hunting/bullying lower levels for sport.
-When you take back your goods from someone who has stolen them, those materials that belong to you should not be “stolen” to you. Ideally, if all stolen goods had an original owner tag, it would add to game play an option to return stolen items to their rightful owner.
-Perhaps consider “Fast Travel to Home” on a very long cooldown (2 to 4 hours or 7 to 10 in game days?).
-High level character training mobs into low levels has to be addressed. Maybe having mobs only aggro on the original source and requiring their leash to reset before they can aggro on a new target?
-Increase mob and gatherable resources to player ratios similar to levels in phase 1. (Props on adding copper, zinc and ruby to T1 stone resource nodes. I haven’t tested how it feels yet, but it was a brilliant idea!)
-If you win a loot roll, it should just appear in your inventory.
subtle hemlock
Top 3 Most Important Bugs (more like the only bugs I have seen more than once):
Top 3 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tame flint
(Bug) Rare gatherables spawning in ungatherable locations. I know this is known but this is probably the most important bug to remedy as the negative gameplay loop it feels as some are already sparse.
(Feedback) As they were presented lawless zones were higher risk for higher reward. Right now it’s only risk with no reward. It would be fairly easy to put some copper spawns, weeping willow, raptor spawns, etc. This would give a good incentive for more friction in these areas.
(Bug/Feedback) Caravan fixes. Using alt f4 to hold people hostage with attacker/defender flag. Not clear information on which caravan you’re flagging for. Perhaps add a name to the event. Clearly showing guild affiliation of caravan drivers.
keen dune
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mental willow
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sleek knoll
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Flying mounts should be restricted to specific area's or removed entirely. I would be okay with only allowing the mayors to fly inside the city limits. Or they should be changed to gliders with only a bit more HP then most mounts. These mounts can give a hugely unfair advantage in both PVP and gathering. Or if they continue to exist as flying you should debuff the person getting off the mount so they can not gather and they have a stat debuff for a minute.
Loot feels bad if "Round Robin" is just changed per mob kill even if nothing drops. If there's nothing to loot then it should just stay that players turn until they get glint. Currently if a player waits until the roll times out there's only a small window of time that it will become free for all loot meaning the loot can be stolen even by another party member. The available window for the player who won the roll to have exclusive rights to the item should be extended.
Bard feedback I played this almost exclusively so far. AOE/ Single target spells should hotswap on the action bars as i respec. The talent that allows you to maintain two songs at once up to 24 seconds each is not very useful when you cant see the buff timers. This should also allow you to get the benefits of both resonance procs when using finishers. which would allow better bards to still provide mana through procs to the party and damage/debuff. Bard music notes should not be jumping through walls the floor and spacetime itself to reach mobs you arent trying to hit. Finisher system with the resonance procs feels bad to try to balance the potential for extended finishers and properly consuming and maintaining resonance stacks. Marionette ability should turn off auto attack or properly be broken on 10% hp like it says. It feels clunky to play without auto attack on and breaking your CC immediately because of an auto attack just feels awful. Saga skills. Extremly underwhelming for abilities that take 90 seconds to prep. The flame book doesnt finish the cast if you auto attack wasting your time. If you do turn your auto attack off or target yourself and the cast does go off it also goes through the floor and ceilings in rooms pulling more mobs you're not trying to. The healing one was nice i guess since it always worked. The buffing one was impossible to see through ground effects and also had a tendency to be on the ceiling and walls. You also couldn't read which color did what due to the buff bugs.I would rather this just be a party wide buff giving a lower amount of all of the buffs without having to run into the circles there's enough ground clutter aoe spell effects already. I dont even remember what the other tier 1 saga's did because they felt useless and that i was better off grabbing more utility skills in the wide skill tree. For the Tier 2 songs the damage/knockback did not feel high enough to represent a 90 second cooldown. The movespeed and low gravity was fun to play around with but it would only have a small use case. I could not see my self staying specced into saga 2 for this as it requires 4 total skill points to let me run faster then mounts for 15 seconds.
======================
loud pivot
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
rigid maple
Bugs:
Feedback Topics:
slate robin
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3 Features to add:
1- Group member looting of your corpse should NOT flag you
2- Guild Management tools (any would be amazing)
3- Somehow penalize large mega multi-guilds working together, or at least add a mechanic for the smaller guilds to compete (for mayor, resources, PvP zerg tactics, etc...)
paper elm
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Caravan Crashes There are several caravan crashes, one that will teleport you from the tropics to Miraleth mid-trip, ones that poof your caravans, and add 30-40 minutes to an already long and boring endeavour. These need to be fixed in order for the caravans to feel somewhat exciting and rewarding.
2. Permanently Deploying Bug If your caravan bugs out in "Deploying" you're simply fucked. You cannot purchase or start a caravan until the server resets. It feels terrible when there are things like a race to buy limited freeholds in the game, if you cannot devote yourself to getting those things before other players due to a fault in the game's programming.
3. Unable To Trade Other Players, Inventory Bugs, Re-logging constantly to fix these desync bugs There are several bugs related to some sort of de-sync with the server and client, where your inventory doesn't update until you mount up (guessing this is a ping to the server that refreshes the data), and the mount workaround is just a temp fix, you need to relaunch the entire client to fix it, which is a long process due to how slowly the game loads.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
daring sierra
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sweet nimbus
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
cinder yacht
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
errant shard
Adamu's Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
feral mist
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
round jungle
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
4. Remove the hidden timed out treasure map quest ('A Curious Cache' I think was the named)-- if you do a treasure map and don't abandon it prior to some invisible timer running out, that blocks you from being able to do more treasure maps, and you can no longer abandon it because it has removed itself from your journal. Many of us are bugged in that fashion and can no longer test your treasure maps. The quest should also auto complete when the treasure chest is fully looted.
tribal bluff
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
gaunt ice
Bugs:
Most Important Feedback Topic:
UI needs some serious work, I imagine this is on the roadmap however the current state of UI and visual clarity is extremely barebones and lacking.
I think not only is the current implementation reminiscent of 20+ year old mmo UI's but it's also difficult to navigate and hard to read.
A lot of UX/UI principles are not being maintained, contrast is not good enough in a lot of places, and even attempts where it is being thought of (like the backdrop shadow behind nameplate names) it's lacking due to font selection.
I think the choice to capitalize every first letter of a title world and increase it's size/weight in regards to the rest of the phrase just takes away from readability.
There's a lot of click debt incurred when attempting to navigate the UI, often times having to click in and out of elements. Similarly whenever click debt isn't incurred we do not have any auditory or visual feedback to our actions. A good example of such design would be World of Warcraft's "I can't use that yet." or "I don't have enough mana." combined with both audio and text to inform the end user of the current state.
Obviously that ideology can be pushed further forward by implementing highlights or visual animations when hovering, or interacting with various elements.
I'm happy to provide more feedback if requested.
sweet heron
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
• 1.Monster AI that enables mob trains
• 2. Gatherable materials in low supply (Willow) / need to respawn if not harvested in X time (too many iron nodes early on).
• 3. Bugged Mob spawns in walls or in the air.
• 4. Hover heals don’t work sometimes
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
• 1.Griefing/training has to stop. Punish those that exploit
• 2.Need to be able to generate all forms of resources for everyone. The Freeholds will have a monopoly, and small guilds/groups will be unable to advance. Applies to caravans as well.
• 3.Hunting needs more rares and the mounts need to scale with rarity.
• 4. Make Jewler viable and worth while.
• 5. Low level mobs attacks are an annoyance, grems attack and hit when they aren’t even close to you.
• 6. Fix the Guild Tab. More features please.
• 7. More Quest level gains.
• 8. Loot pick up should be automatic when won. Don’t have time to pick up if your in a long fight and it de-spawns.
karmic hornet
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
nimble ridge
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
full scaffold
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
median oracle
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
idle bluff
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Tank needs love: Tanks are at a disadvantage for a number of reasons and there are lots of posts about it in discord, the forums and reddit. As someone who loves tanking, its tough to play. Aegis was broken, but fixing that will highlight the shortcomings of the class even more.
Tier 1 Resource Rarity: It is way to rare, whatever the reason. It causes a bunch of secondary issues, from leveling artisan skills to equipment prices in the market. Who is going to make copper wands when you can sell just the common copper required for a gold+ and the vendor sells them for a few silver? its out of balance.
PvP Flagging for looting is too short and is no real consequence. If a player loots a number of corpses in a fixed amount of time, then flag them as corrupt. People are literally farming players for mats with the current setup and it feels bad.
Corruption for killing people who's pvp flag dropped during combat feel unfair: If you flag to attack someone who looted and their flag drops during combat because of loot timer and you kill them... then you go corrupt. As a player trying to "do good" it is a huge punishment. The PvP flag is also being exploited to get players to go corrupt and then groups loot them for their gear.
Caravan Attacker consequences and defender rewards. Caravan attackers really have very little risk for a ton of potential reward. There really is no reason to NOT attack a caravan when you see it and its far enough away. Caravan Defense has no reward except "the word" of the person turning in the caravan. Automate the attack/defense mechanics to take more from attackers and give more to defenders.
opaque falcon
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
civic flint
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Take you pick from all listed so far. They all look important to me.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Ember Springs:
Problem: Ember Springs current implementation are a source of griefing. Whether it be spawn camping during wars or training mobs on people who are still loading in after death.
Idea: Make Ember Springs a type of sentient defender. Perhaps have them fling extremely powerful lightening bolts or some other extremely powerful attack scaled to greatly warn and punish any flagged combatants (npc or player) that venture within its protective range and do not have a respawn protection buff.
Spawn Camping:
Problem: This form of griefing is encouraged by the current open ended war design since the most efficient way for a group to gather kills during a node/guild war is to spawn camp and/or kill low level crafters in town then spawn camp them.
Idea: If spawn camping is a desired form of engagement by the community during node wars, then embrace it by making spawn points capturable/defendable during wars. Think along the lines of towers and capture points in Planetside/Planetside2.
shut gate
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sacred river
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
neat void
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
static jasper
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
obsidian adder
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
olive jetty
Top bugs:
Top feedback:
oak zenith
3-5 Bugs:```
Crashes. Cant play the game if its crashing. This is the biggest issue, when the server kicks you off or for whatever reason you fall all the way out of the game you will be dead before you get back.
Visual Bugs with Gathering. When you run up to a tree that isn't really there it sucks, especially if you have to clear a group of mobs to get to a rare tree that isn't real it makes you want to just go fish for a while.
Movement and rubber banding. Quite frustrating as a bard, with lots of movement abilities, to dash away from something only to rubber band the moment you start running. Riding through the world is very satisfying, until all of a sudden your rubber-banding across a crossroads.
Inventory bugs - Having to log out for 15 seconds because your inventory cant move things around is one thing, but how often it happens is what brought it to the list.
Key Binds - Key binds are lacking, and the default bindings kind of take away from modifiers. Control being used, by default, for a dodge ability means control cant be used by default for ANY other button. It feels like someone realized this with shift, since sprint is C and not shift like every other game with sprint - but the same applies to control. Also, not being able to bind to mouse wheel up or mouse wheel down is a core MMO key bind.```
Feedback
Gathering XP shouldn't give level xp. The idea you can just sit in the starting zone and fish your way to level 5 is probably not intended - but maybe it is. Also, mining or lumberjacking being the same xp as hunting which is the same as fishing doesn't seem right to me.
A lot of care given to how the overlapping systems allow for war with each other. If you are in a guild, and a citizen, and a religion all of whom are at war with varying other groups it is going to be VERY important to give a clear indication of the diplo status of different groups. The UI for this should be provided to players, and iterated often.
royal sandal
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Server worker issue where you rubber band back and forth at times is very annoying. Commonly happens when you cross from one server worker to another.
Servers get overwhelmed over time causing issues many weapon and ability attacks to not register at all making it difficult to fight anything
Enemies and mob AI needs to be fixed they will often stick in place, teleport underground, not show an animation when attacking etc.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The community really needs a win right now, please release Rogue this month as promised. It will up morale of the community
Get some kind of questing system functional for riverlands to break up the monotonous mob grind
Get nodes level 1-4 up and running. Currently Nodes are clearly not functioning as intended.
Apart from that love yall, and good luck
rose valve
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
languid echo
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
desert barn
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
robust wigeon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sand sphinx
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
floral jetty
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
I personally do not believe gems should be as massive as they are in the overworld, that is simply my opinion. That size may make more sense in the underworld but it's insane to see a ruby the size of a smart car. It would make more sense (to me) if over world gems were essentially an extra found in your typical stone/metal node. Perhaps obtaining a geode and cracking it open at a station to obtain gems.
I think the exterior of the area maps need some love. More small unnamed locations such as towers or ruined huts/buildings dotting the foothills would make the world seem more lived in. Old mossy stone foundations with goblins or gryphons roosting on them and so on.
The strange use of armor classes gets me. As a DPS you'd think medium would make more sense to wear. Starting out, it does. It has dex and strength. Going into later gear, however, you come across a strange patch of medium gear that benefits casters and much less so physical DPS classes. Skulker gear for instance. Then you get the heavier Forsaken gear that makes sense for a Fighter to wear in many cases. Maybe it's because there aren't as many POIs with drops that stand apart from each other but I do hope to see a wider variety of medium and heavy gear specifically for phys DPS and tanks respectively.
This is coming from someone who yearns to play a Tulnar berserker.
eager onyx
===
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mint flax
Alpha Two Phase II Bugs
Important Feedback Topics
charred hare
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
tame lagoon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Inventory Bug- It seems to predominantly happening when I would mine a metal or stone. Then I would constantly be having to get on my mount as when I would loot or harvest anything you could not see what was picked up or harvested without calling your mount and getting on it.
2. Character Graphics- After trying to get my character to look like I would like and then loading into the game and others would not see me as I made myself. I would have a default or totally different look that would occasionally fix itself after a time but if I rendered out of their view when I come back I look totally different. Even for myself sometimes.
3.Caravan System- Being stuck in defender mode hours after a caravan because one would glitch out and no matter if you left the even you were stuck in a defender state and vulnerable to those who had been attacking said caravan.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Flesh out and balancing of crafting systems- Gathering/Crafting harder to level then processing, artisan skill trees ,etc.
Training of mobs from higher level characters onto lower. I know we need to be aware of our surroundings and do my best but it seems if a higher level character is pulling something higher behind them it will peel off and onto the "Weaker" thing as it see you.
Clerics need a bit more heals that do not have a cooldown or maybe more charges for the flash heal. Having 2 or 3 is just not enough with the kind of damage being brought by most 2 to 3 star mobs.
======================
vague prism
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory bug - Moving or dropping an item from my materials bag does not register the action (the item appears not to move). I have to constantly log out and log back in to fix it. Sounds like this might have been fixed today with the latest update.
Map bug - The mini UI map gets covered with large black squares at random. I have to log out and back in to fix it.
Crafting station bugs - a) Items will not process even though I have the correct amount of fuel and currency. Logging out and back in doesn't fix it and I'm locked out of the station. b) I'll have materials recognized as fuel (green check mark,) but when I go to add them they won't show up in the menu, even though they are in my bag.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Players camping right on top of hunting spawns, especially rare creatures, is frustrating. Suggestion: Randomizing spawns within a certain area might help spread the love around.
The congestion around a single market vendor or a single storage vendor has gotten out of hand. There's been a few times I couldn't access either space because of the wall of players blocking the npc. Suggestion: Please allow us to tag the tents/building instead of a single npc.
The caravan UI system is not very user-friendly. It took me a long time to figure out how to open/load a crate. (Crates are also bugged at times and won't accept items in certain slots.)
Mob respawn rates are too fast in 90% of areas. Having mobs instantaneously respawn on top of you while in the middle of finishing off a second is annoying.
jolly plinth
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
half talon
magic crater
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
steep elk
static horizon
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
twin siren
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
sage kraken
Caravan Lockout
When launching a caravan, if the player/server crashes during launch, the player can be locked in the state of having an active caravan, unable to purchase/launch another one forever. A function to reset the flag on a player's currently active caravan event would at least provide a failsafe for this issue.
Cargo Mass-Deletion
If the player selects Samia's Hope/Lionhold within the cargo menu, it deletes all cargo at all other locations. Disabling the cargo window entry for these two locations would prevent this.
Inventory Desync
After spending a while logged in, or perhaps moving across server workers, the inventory desyncs and sometimes prevents new items from being picked up. You can force an inventory update by mounting up, so maybe forcing a character state update upon looting would fix this issue until a larger fix can be deployed.
PvP Flag Dropping Mid-Combat
While an active PvP flag is in the process of dropping off, being hit doesn't seem to reset it's timer, leading to a situation where an attacking player gets corrupted despite 90% of the fight being while the enemy was flagged. Taking a hit while your PvP flag is active should extend the timer back to at least 30seconds each time they take a hit, or at least have a visible timer if this is intended design.
EXP Debt is more punishing sub level 25
EXP debt currently acts as both a progression blocker and a stat dampener, where I feel it should really only be the latter. At max level there isn't anything to progress towards, giving you way less reason to avoid EXP Debt than a level 20-24. I feel like EXP debt blocking leveling progression disproportionately effects lower level players, and discourages those players to take on any risk. EXP debt feels roughly equivalent to losing experience for a leveling player, and feels more or less meaningless to a max level one.
Small Render Distance Under Heavy Load
While I imagine culling is a necessary evil, the render distance for characters gets very low when there's ~80 players fighting in an area. This makes it difficult to get a feel for large scale battle tactics when you can't see the enemy force while on the backline of your own team.
I'm enjoying the hecc out of Alpha! I didn't expect to be playing much of a game during the alpha, but here we are, sinking ungodly hours into the game way-way-way before release. Keep on rocking it devs!
twin siren
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
rose storm
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
brazen kraken
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The first feedback I need to give is related to what I interact with the most in the game, which is Storage. In short, the experience is terrible, especially if you're a processor. We urgently need a way to see the quantity of a specific item we have stored, and the bugs related to it need to be resolved, such as right-clicking and the item not being moved to storage, the lack of an organizer in storage, and errors when trading. For instance, the calculation of available spaces in the recipient's bag needs to account correctly for items that will be merged with broken quantities. I've had multiple issues with trades where I couldn't complete them even though I had enough space to receive materials.
Another issue that needs fixing is the error that occurs when processing 250 materials, which ends up consuming all materials of the same type in your inventory if you're carrying more than 250. This also happens when processing coal, where it consumes all Oaks during the process, regardless of the amount ordered to be processed.
Another thing that has been very frustrating in the gameplay is that the game has become PvE. The theme was supposed to have open PvP; however, the only PvP options we currently have are in Lawless areas or during wars. Spot disputes are resolved only through griefing; there isn't even an option for PK (Player Killing), as the system is so punitive that the mere thought of doing PK is already discouraging.
Guilds with 50 slots and no storage are unfeasible! The logistics for this are simply horrible. Ashes is a game made for guilds and massive wars, but we can't have a guild that accommodates most of our players without creating endless problems. Issues arise within the guild itself, such as people without ranks inviting others at random, and the problem of having to create multiple guilds and buying war scrolls, when we could simply have one guild and simplify everything. I understand that the system isn't fully implemented yet and that 50 members is the guild's minimum limit, but why not allow more slots and make life easier for players who are already under a lot of stress due to the many problems in the alpha?
======================
eternal ibex
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory desync - While harvesting occasionally the storage bags will not update. It would require me to mount my horse. This would make it so I couldn't harvest any more materials or move things into those slots.
Spawn locations for trees - There were a few locations where rare trees would spawn in rocks or floating in the air. This would make it impossible to harvest.
Enemies warping - While running away from some wolves, I was able to climb up on a building and escape their range. Only to find out that 10 seconds later, they were not having it and warped next to me on top of the building I was using as safety.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
ROI on crafting resources - You can take a piece of T1 wood and turn it into a T2 item (sawdust) that sells for 80c. If you take that piece of T1 stone and turn it into a T2 item (clay) it sells for 8c Iost 55c on this. It makes no sense to spend time doing stonemasonry for money at this time. This just needs to be balanced
Timer for PvP flag after attacking another player - The PvP timer after attacking a non PvP player should be longer based on the level difference between the two players.
Market Price Visibility - I have spent a majority of my time gathering and processing materials. It is really hard to figure out how much I should charge for an item on the market. It left me just wanting to sell directly in chat and avoid using a system in game. I suggest that when you go to post a product on the marketplace, you can see the lowest price, median price and the most expensive price on the market so you can make an informed decision on how much to sell your materials for.
Lots of raw resources on the Market - Give the mayor some ability to purchase raw materials on the market that can be used for progressing the node.
fast adder
Bugs:
whole magnet
op 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Processing stations often take more materials than are needed when there is more of the needed material in the players bag.
for example one can have 200 stone in the bag to put in 2 orders of 100 and the station will take 140 for the 1st order instead of just 100.
The game often takes 95% of my 32 Gig memory after playing for half an hour orso. this causes the game to freeze and i can only close the game via the task manager.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback:
uneven spread of scenery and materials.
The difference between how finished locations on the map are is just too great.
for example: The area around Miraleth is very well developed. It looks good and there are a lot of monsters to fight and resources to gather.
The area around New Aela is just barren and ugly. (sorry, but there is no better word for that)
This leads to players flocking to the new nodes that are better developed and have more to do around them leaving the other nodes far behind.
Mounts (specially horses)
They cant seem to lift their legs! and the map is is full with, often hardly visible, things they can get stuck behind. it's frustrating!
( it's useful when someone is chasing you though, just put a twig on the road or draw a line in the sand and their mount stops moving! )
The market place as it currently is is very difficult to work with.
probably not an issue fr most.
for me straining my eyes often leads to migraines
short fulcrum
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
**Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs: **
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
radiant galleon
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
indigo sandal
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Boss Spawns – Many of the boss respawns have been bugged and can result in large groups of players waiting around for bosses that never spawn. Especially frustrating if you are wanting to do a quest.
Inventory not Updating – The inventory not updating properly is pretty frustrating, the fix of getting on and off your horse is a way around but pretty tedious. While not terrible the frequency that this affects players is high since you are often interacting with your inventory.
Caravan Bugs - While I haven’t interacted with the caravan system this does seem to be a pretty big issue and it seems like it is impacting a lot of people, I see it a lot in global chat.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Mining – By the sounds of the recent patch notes this has been addressed to a certain extent, but the novice metals need to be more available such as copper and zinc.
Marketplace Stalls – Great addition, obviously does need a better search function as I find myself spending a long time looking for materials, both to buy and to work out what price I should be listing at.
Quests – A lot of quests are bugged and they also do not offer enough rewards for their time commitment. Would be nice to have a bit more leeway to go off and do some quests and not feel like I’m being very inefficient.
Node Lag – If you can, maybe some targeted systems to reduce load in nodes? Timed despawns for mounts and that sort of thing. I do get lag issues elsewhere but it is most noticeable in nodes and can make it quite difficult to do tasks.
gleaming sphinx
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Most Important Bugs:
Most Important Feedback Topics:
dark geyser
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
oblique zephyr
Top Bugs, 1) When in action mode and any UI window opens I get stuck not being able to move the mouse around, this happens whenever loot windows open, 2) Mobs not leashing properly and becoming glitched out. 3) Mob attacks becoming out of sync with animations and/or dumping a dot all once. 4) Mobs stacking abilities from ability spam. Feedback - world is too 2 dimensional, everything in X and Y with no Z need mines and crypts and stuff
patent grove
Top 3:
Marketplace searching is horrible. Please let us search by items, not keywords, or give us more than 50 characters to list items
Chat - I know this is low priority, but PLEASE PLEASE give us a LFG & trade chat if nothing else, or at the bare minimum, let changes we make save and be persistent so we can turn global off
Exploiters going unpunished. If they violated the ToS, they should be gone. I'm not interested in debates about what they're contributing. Either change the ToS, or abide by it and remove them from the testing environment.
true egret
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
safe hazel
Top bugs:
Feedback:
glass cedar
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Gameplay is king, content and features come secondary.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
digital crater
grave wolf
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
stray abyss
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
cold ferry
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
frank vapor
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
mint saddle
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sleek idol
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1 Recourses has stable spawn location with same rarity.
2 While running caravans you have a chance to teleport to Carfin.
3 All other caravans issues, disconnecting / despawning right after launch
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1 Please make Wednesday and Thursday offline days, it's more usual for many MMOs, and we use start playing on Friday
topaz aurora
aLpHa TwO pHaSe Ii FeEdBaCk
ToP 3-5 mOsT iMpOrTaNt BuGs:
CaRaVaN eVeNtS aRe VeRy BuGgY oVeRaLl:
• PlAyErS cAn GeT sTuCk In ThE eVeNt As A dEfEnDeR oR aTtAcKeR iF tHe EvEnT nEvEr EnDs (E.g., WhEn SoMeOnE lOgS oUt).
• CaRaVaNs MaY fAlL oUt Of ThE wOrLd AnD/oR bEcOmE uNrEcOvErAbLe.
• CrAsHeS oCcUr WhIlE dRiViNg A cArAvAn.
• CrAsHeS hApPeN wHeN tOo MaNy CaRaVaNs ArE nEaRbY.
aRrOwS oF pLaYeRs ArE uNaBlE tO bE sEeN oN tHe MaP wHeN yOu ArE iN a RaId.
MoBs BeCoMiNg BrOkEn DuE tO pLaYeRs PuLlInG mObS aNd GeTtInG tHeM sTuCk. ThE mOb NeVeR rEtUrNs To It'S iNtEnDeD sPaWn CaUsInG pLaCeS (cArPhIn ToWeR eSpEcIaLlY) tO bE mIsSiNg SpAwNs.
ToP 3-5 mOsT iMpOrTaNt FeEdBaCk ToPiCs:
turbid blaze
1.) Caravans
2.) Ghost nodes
3.)shield being invisible
balmy violet
Top 3 Most Important Feedback Topics
Mob (De)Buffs Visibility Feedback:
Buffs and debuffs on mobs should always appear consistently below the health bar, with all active effects fully visible (no "+X debuffs" placeholder). This helps players quickly identify resistances and debuffs, making skill usage more efficient and less random.
PvP Feedback:
PvP feels unbalanced and lacks meaningful incentives. Fighting back is punishing, as stronger players exploit weaker ones. Exploits like stunning and letting mobs kill targets bypass player-killer status, enabling griefing without adequate consequences.
Training mobs to kill players or CCing healers to cause deaths also needs stricter penalties, like long-lasting murderer flags. Actions resulting in deaths should flag as murder, as the intent is clear.
The lawless area concept and the meaningless PVP risks alienating casual players, who are essential for AoC’s success due to the subscription model. Allowing a few hardcore players to dominate may harm player retention and revenue in the long term.
Loot Distribution Feedback:
Loot pickup timers feel clunky and disrupt party flow. The "free-for-all" transition is problematic during extended fights or exploitable by party members waiting to bypass rolls.
Loot systems could improve by showing loot to all players immediately. The first player to inspect triggers dice rolls "while appearing to pick it up and handing it to the winner". The winner gets the item directly in their inventory.
Clearer settings for automatic distribution, like for runes, are also needed.
mild canyon
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
There's something going on with weapon skills. For example, I have a wand build that I was using at lower levels, but now I have a longbow. My wand build skills are still getting procs when it's not equipped. I'm getting volatile, echo, burning, dazed?
Caravans. Being stuck in a caravan event. I think this is from the person alt-f4ing while being out of combat (we were focusing a different caravan). Also requiring us to drop group and select attacker/defender, and then grouping up afterwards is really annoying.
Fix CC breaks not working on certain classes, or fix the wording around what they are meant to break us out of!
Bugs relating to run speed and stamina, sometimes I'm moving slower than everyone else in my group. One time we all RP walked in a line and I was noticeably slower than everyone else. Other times I'm watching my stamina instantly recover to full or being able to indefinitely sprint, I think somehow relating to run speed/stamina buffs.
Changing settings on my chat box don't save. It would be nice to have tabs that aren't flooded with loot messages so I can more reliably see messages.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Class color nameplates so that I can have better vision when pvping in big groups. Or at least better ways to quickly identify and track people during the chaoticness of 40 people fighting.
CC'ing non-combatants should be allowed in the long-term, but I understand changing this in the short-term. Rather than make people immune, increase the risk of doing this. For an extreme example, I probably wouldn't do this to steal a copper node if flagging made me stay flagged for an hour.
When competing for spots, I think this is okay because it flags you up and forces pvp for the spot. As much as I wanted to level up and got annoyed by other groups wanting to compete for a leveling spot, this follows the philosophy of what this game is all about, right?
I was in the non-lawless desert while leveling and a group rolled up into our spot. Our group didn't want to pvp. They flagged and started doing damage to us and cc'ing our healers. Eventually we flagged up and counter-attacked, which we were able to do on our own terms and it gave us a huge advantage. This was a fun experience! Conversely, I had an experience in seph where my group was getting wiped due to healers being cc'd. While that was frustrating, I would rather have this than have basically no spontaneous pvp situations.
clever nacelle
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
placid pebble
Bugs that I found during few days of playing:
Feedback:
Keep up the good work, as more and more I am amazed of fundations that you have built.
fading ice
Freeholds are economy breaking in current form due to ability to grow unlimited higher tier trees. need to either make them invadeable or add the ability to grow trees via farming in nodes to avoid a complete economic bubble and future collapse.
pressing esc for any reason cancels bard melodies, including closing looting windows, inventory, quest window, clearing combat target etc.
looting player corpses is an act of desecrating remains and should be punished accordingly by corrupting you, or at least causing a much much longer pvp flag of 10 to 15 minutes. looted players should receive a notification of the name of the person that looted them and have a 24h corruption amnesty in which to seek revenge without being corrupted when attacking their desecrator.
corpse looting PVP flag frequently drops mid PVP combat. this should never happen.
jade compass
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
lilac barn
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
brisk spear
crafting needs a a top to bottom rework asap. the requirements for level 10 gear is wayyyy too high. i can understand it getting much harder to craft each thing but wow i need a lot. bad formate cause low on time also add skinning
mossy hound
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
carmine roost
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
worthy yoke
magic plover
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
flat nest
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
elder wasp
maiden fossil
Visual bugs
some of these incluse when zoomed in on character, sky box, and some terrain bugs such as some roads nto spawning correctly causing road blocks
mob glitching
i have noticed an improvement on this area however still needs work.
Clipping
some of the clipping will rubber band characters specially on a higher ping. also some clipping issues with rocks and other terrain such as water
combat momentum
sometimes momentum in the fighter class will bug out and not operate as intended
Caravans
issues with despawning or glitched caravans dissapearing along with the goods it is transporting
Merry Christmas and Happy New year to you all thank you for bringing back the spark to gaming and my child like wonder you are all leaders of your time! ❤️
vapid osprey
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
flat nest
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
royal plover
I think everyone has done a good job relating what they feel are the most important bugs so far so i dont want to add to much to what they aee saying. I will only add something i have noticed as a bard. When i do my cone heal i will sometimes also heal things that aren't in my party like random mobs around me and enemies.
Also when tab targeting the system will target something far away or through walls.
Sometimes when using bard skills it will drop whatever I've been attacking and i will have to re-aquire the target, i think it will most happen if im using the shielding skill or mana battery skill.
feral sorrel
Unequiped weapons being added into the finishers and deadly finishers, huge impact and should be a main focus to fix
flat nest
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
fallow briar
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
karmic stone
whole magnet
feedback:
I personally dislike the rarity bonus for processing materials.
nothing so annoying as when smelting mats to make bronze to have to go back to do a few single smelts because out of a 100 tin 3 or 4 decided to become a higher quality.
trail osprey
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
icy violet
FEEDBACK: War needs a timer for start. Love getting killed at the marketplace by a large group waiting for the war to be declared.
ionic ruin
PvP Flags falling off in combat causing "accidental" corruption NEEEEEEEEEEEED changing. 🤣 Preferrably in the form of a reset of the countdown on the PvP flag while engaged in PvP combat, and/or an increase in the base timer of the PvP flag when stealing to ~3 min.
little river
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
fathom oriole
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.node traversal stuttering bug
2.inventory frozen & party issues requiring restart
3.needing to loot after roll ( someone has already gone to the trouble to loot so why does it need to happen again )
idle bluff
O BIG ISSUE- I just logged into my character, I am dead at Storage in Halcyon. No combat... just dead. Find out Halcyon is at war with Miraleth. I got killed at the bank and no indication of combat... i was just dead and looted. I had 4 gold glint on my character... now I have 2. I know its a test and who cares.. .but it really sucks. That is totally bad... I am gutted. It took me days of effort to get that... and its gone. I just gave my feedback today already.. .but this is at the top of the list now. As a player, I expect to be safe in a city for at least enough time when I log in to be able to react to a situation after being gone from the game for awhile.
limber ginkgo
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
grave drum
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
true aurora
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
unique compass
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
The fact that people describe mob training as a bug: I believe the mechanics enabling mob training are crucial for maintaining a significant portion of PvE conflict. However, I would support an alternative mob behavior that preserves the essence of this conflict
The current camera movement lacks fluidity when switching from tab-target to action-combat mode or interacting with in-game assets that introduce pop-up windows, such as menus, maps, or NPC interactions. This lack of fluidity arises because the camera does not continuously follow the mouse movement during these transitions; instead, it becomes fixed at a specific point, requiring additional actions like moving sideways to regain proper camera control.
The targeting mechanics also present challenges, particularly with skills that require mouse input to place an area-of-effect (AOE) ability, such as Hoarfrost. Using the mouse to place such abilities does not integrate well with tab-target mode, where clicking on enemies inadvertently selects targets instead of accurately placing the AOE skill.
Auto-attacking interferes with the casting of certain skills. For instance, when playing as a tank, allowing your character to auto-attack while casting the Reflect skill often results in the skill being interrupted by the auto-attack. While animation canceling mechanics can add depth to gameplay, the current behavior appears to be an unintended consequence of synchronization issues, leading to a frustrating player experience.
I would appreciate further clarification on the design intention behind the casting mechanics of abilities like Leap Strike and other ground-targeted AOE abilities. At present, these abilities only cast if the mouse cursor is positioned within their maximum range; attempting to cast beyond this range prevents the ability from activating. Is this limitation intentional, or is it a design inconsistency?
wraith island
Top 3 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Artisan Experience. In my opinion, I believe how the artisan skills worked are very well done and are such a unique insight to the game. If there were two things I would prove upon, is that first to adjust experience for all crafting branches. For example, I feel like crafting different rarities should give varying XP with the higher the rarity the more XP you recieve. As in my experience least with scribing, there is no difference in XP between crafting a common and heroic scroll (least that I can tell with my naked eye, I could be wrong).
Another suggestion I have towards artisan progression is maybe give certain rewards or benefits for every level you gain in any XP branch or at least more than every 10 levels. Right now, if you exclude the difference in certification there is nothing different from a level 11 artisan than a level 19. The certifications system feels perfect; however, maybe give a little reward or temporary buff to those who recently leveled to feel like there is more progression instead of just every 10 levels.
I feel that this is more of Beta issue rather than a Alpha issue, but I really do wish there was a sort of central place where you can see every market. Not an auctionhouse, but a way to just see what items are in the market but you cannot buy them. I just ask of this because although I find very fun of the scarcity of markets, one downside is it makes it very hard or unfun for those who love to flip items.
sour stream
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Whoever is in charge of tanks needs to do a deep dive with tank players.
2. Mages being able to SOLO steal mobs from 2-3 other players fighting it needs to go. This is heavy griefing and people are sick of it. Rework mob tag mechanics or give everyone who hits a mob XP.
Bard mobility is way too high. They can keep up with a horse indefinitely.
3. Gatherables are too scarce. There needs to be a significant increase to gatherables and they need to be random spawn not in the same spot to avoid sit farming.
4. Keep ADDONS AWAY from this game. As long as there are options for us to customize UI and respectable tells for mob mechanics then we don't need them. Absolutely NO DAMAGE Meter. These kind of addons kill fun in games. And this is coming from a WoW player with 100+ addons. I dont want them here. And no "Wow Logs" type sites, ban those.
5. Gear drops are too low in general and caster gear is VERY low.
======================
merry reef
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
slow lance
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
autumn nexus
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
feral gorge
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
patent radish
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
finite gale
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
oak turret
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
silver remnant
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
placid matrix
Top Most Important Bugs:
Top Most Important Feedback Topics:
gentle wharf
IF YOU ARE READING THIS. PLEASE LEAVE THE THREAD ONCE YOU HAVE POSTED YOUR FEEDBACK.
THIS IS A TEMP FIX BECAUSE DISCORD HAS THREAD MEMBER LIMIT
PLEASE DO THIS TO ALLOW OTHERS TO POST FEEDBACK.
THANK YOU FOR READING THIS.
ornate bloom
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
solemn summit
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
polar garden
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hot oar
Important Feedback
1 Bug? Loot seems not to drop at all. Feels bad not getting amything after 8 houers of grinding.
2 Open World PvP penalty is to hard and tou basicaly removed it from the game.
3 we need other avenues of getting xp and gear. Game feels bad, not getting my dopamine hit from it.
wispy adder
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
timid fossil
The hunting bow should be a hunting knife when considering how the hunting mechanic works.
fallen rapids
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
cursive ridge
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
strong geode
Inventory<->Storage issues
Various party joining/leaving bugs
MOB aggro leading to griefing
Fast travel - how about a one hour ‘return to home’
More places to get L20 gear
Mark your own ‘death loot’ with a different colour
uneven bough
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
earnest marsh
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
quasi shoal
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback :
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
orchid bane
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
1.Fix mob agro. Mobs should not agro onto other groups/players. Running mobs onto other to grief them shouldn't be a thing.
2.Treasure maps need fixing ASAP
3.Group leader accepting attacker or defender for caravan events needs fixing. It's awkward trying to leave a group accept the event and reform the group whilst simultaneously fighting
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
1.Power levelling. Let us power level our friends and alts if we decide that's something we want to do. Early game will die eventually and solo grinding is gross. Let us power level. On this note high level mobs should alwyas give xp. We killed some mobs 12+ levels higher than us and no xp was rewarded. why?
2.Market place functionality needs adding. Make it like DAOC player housing consignment merchant with detailed search functions.
3.POI levelling spots need expanding. I understand the stress testing that has been happening but there were too many players for the levelling spots and server in general. Not enough mobs for the players at these POI levelling spots. Too much player and mob culling made looking for open field spots an annoyance. More open field levelling spots need adding.
native fulcrum
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
wise tendon
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
fast cedar
====================== Alpha Two Phase II Feedback Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
• 1. Inventory doesnt update if you move stuff inside the Inventory or between the Inventory and the storage. Only option is to relog or hop on/of your mount.
• 2. Rarity of gatherabls is to low while having good equip. I have a epic huntig bow with a 111 rarety rating and out of 25 Animal today i only got 2 uncommon (rest common). For the material put into the bow this is not good enough of a return on the investment
• 3. Gatherabls (especially Weeping Williow) often spawns inside rocks that are over the terrain and cant be harvested. Give the Weeping Williow a sweet spot like the Ash trees infront of the cities.
• 4. Caravans disappear when bumping into objekts (stones, other caravans etc)
• 5. If opening to many UI menues at the same time the game freezes or completly shuts down.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
• 1.Citizen of a node shouldnt be able to attack caravans from the same node. Only give them the option to defened the caravan or make it an expensive item they need if they want to attack citizens like the guild war scrolls. This would improve the player commuity of the indiviuall nodes and stop spreading toxicity in the game. On the EU server the Mayor guild of Windstead was seen using the flying mount to spot every caravan and directs its members to attack them. They dont distinguish between citzens and non citizens.
• 2. Inside Nodes like Miraleth it gets very laggy during the evening when many players are in the node at the same time. Perhaps adding more servers to the nodes might help with that.
• 3. Lower the costs to do of enchantments at the lower levels. It is a massive goldsink with only littel return on value
• 4. Please give the aquatic mounts the option to „Dash“ while in the water. It is quit annoing to allways have to jump out of the water and klick the „Dash“ icon.
======================
hybrid dock
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
• Raid Frame no appear no fun
• Mouse button 4 bind on guard cannot no fun
• Pyro to high dam no fun
• Caravan no can attack cuz blinking button no fun
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
• Fighting for spawn no fun
• Tank no skill very bad no fun
• PVP no fun PVE game only good much fun
• Damage meter plz for big bang boom, no meter no bang boom
• No like game lvl 25 no do
karmic zodiac
==============
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Cant really think of anything else as not had much time to test, as having to focus on exp or grinding of anything to get anywhere to test anything...see point 1 of feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics
General quality of life/ease for players to test content. Having worked in QA in SW development for over 20 years, just seems crazy to me. Should be filling players bags with loot, exp, gold, materials so everyone can test everything to its fullest. You only need to create a couple NPCs, that automatically boost your character to lvl 10, 20 and 30 and give 100 silver and basic armor & weapon or something when creating a new character. Also provide similar NPCs for crafting to raise levels. Then Beta is used for fine tuning the economy and exp gains etc.
Rant out of the way, general pointing of player progression is not signposted very well. IMO, mob level should get progressively higher from the two starting camps, towards the settlements, obviously can have open world dungeons, small areas that are higher level, but having this provides a natural path for players and allows players to meet those of similar levels.
I dont get the point of having a Home emberspring, unless you can teleport there. I am all for having them as local spawn points, but it would be nice to have the ability, say once every 60 minutes to spawn at your home emberspring, which I will presume be your home town.
Quests. Enough said and I am running out of characters
balmy pollen
Top bugs:
inventory bugs like not being able to try picking a material up after making space for it
friend list bug. Keeps removing everyone I add and makes me my only friend, also can’t delete me from my friend list
More general feedback
Leveling a crafting prof even just to 10 is brutally slow. Really expensive (silver wise not material wise)
Buff consolidation needs to be overhauled. Seeing +38 buffs and having no way to tell what’s in there really hurts the flow of combat since I can’t tell if my bard stuff is actually in effect.
violet lark
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
jolly haven
Bugs and issues
Storage bugging out is the most frustrating issue. The storage randomly stops working with right click, it is unable to place stacks if there is an opened stack in place in the storage already, and the type selection does not work.
Not sure if it is a bug, but I would say memory leak or other performance related issue. I have an old PC with a 2070, but in the fist 6 weekends in P1 the game ran flawlessly. After that it started to lag and it is unplayable now if I visit a node. A full restart helps a bit, but overall the performance is gradually getting worse.
Resources spawning inside rocks making them unnoticable or unharvestable.
Cannot change turning or strafing right in the options. When I change it to "A" for example it stays "None" and when I change turn left/strafe left to something from D it changes to A.
Fall damage should not cap at 150.
Feedback:
Resource rarity should be based on the tools and stats of the players instead of how currently the system works for most gatherables.
Unstuck should be changed. In a game where distance matters so much, teleporting your nearest attuned Emberspring is a very easy way to exploit movement. Unlocking 2 distant embersprings and ignoring the ones in between essentially halves the distance needed to travel. Even giving it a cooldown does not solve this issue. I think moving to a nearby safe location/road should be how it works.
Nodes should be interactable with a longer distance, even if it means the character runs closer to start the animation. It would help with stuck trees and overall would make the feel of gathering better. It is quite annoying currently that you need to be on top of the resource at a set angle for it to work. Any time the player needs more than 2 inputs to gather something, it feels bad.
Marketplace search improvements are essential.
frosty bloom
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tall python
Alpha 2 phase 2 feedback
Random minerals drops from stone nodes helps. But copper availability is still a fraction compared to oak availability for example
crisp comet
Alpha 2 Phase 2 Feedback
Bugs:
Feedback Topics:
inner jasper
=== BUGS ===
=== FEED BACK ===
What is the intended endstate of PvP going to look like? Too many people avoid PvP in its current state. Blurred lines of allegiances. Mob/Area campers don't flag. Corruption is the same no matter who you kill. Be it a "friendly" or a "foe". But who's friendly and who's foe even?!? Religion will only convolute this more.
Suggestions:
1. Make a reputation system for the Nodes, node should be able to become hostile to players.
2. Flagging purple removes the Exp loss if killed by a player.
3. Flagged players of the same node as you should have a different color showing they are part of your node. It's just hard to tell who's on what side.
4. 1 hour war is WAY too short.
Fishing: Is boring and an auto afk activity for a second monitor.
Suggestions:
1. Leave in the auto part of it. Lower the catch rate, by about half to start.
2. Add in an interactive fishing that ups my chances to rarer materials.
Hunting: Petting an animal to death is weird. Animal resource nodes are weird.
Suggestions:
1. Make a "Track" ability that will allow me to track pray.
2. Once I find an animal I should get a chance to "tame" that animal.
3. Harvesting an animal should be done after killing it to get the corpse.
compact yew
Top 1: fix combat indication for mobs that are far away
Top 2: disable combat indication for caused by fall damage
Top 3: fix conditions that prevent people from trading with each other
bleak harness
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
E.G: have the spawn manager check the number of copper nodes and over write a new spawn if the number of current copper nodes is below threshold. this would allow there to always be x number of metal in each zone.
3. Fighters need to have a knock down or small stun(.5 seconds) to allow them to prevent being kited. Currently when PvPing you do not have enough time to snare your target after a charge, resulting in being kited by better players.
worthy arrow
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
river pawn
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
neat cove
BUGS<<
1.) Character Model bugs. Most noticeably the DISAPPEARING SHIELD on Tanks. Honorable mention to the paralyzed sliding and gliding mounts, neon armor pieces and weird hair.
I realize this may seem cosmetic and 2nd tier to some, but they are distracting enough to make testing far less fun for me.
2.) Aforementioned inventory lag.
3.) Terminator mobs that refuse to leash even after making get away moves that rival Harrison Ford in the Fugitive. Give us a chance to book it after an overpull!
FEEDBACK/SUGGESTIONS<<
1.) Remove the Dwarf-flip on jump. It's immersion breaking and awful! (make it an option or an augmentation if it MUST stay)
2.) SOME kind of naming convention. Again, PAINfully immersion breaking to see "Crunchytaco" and "Boogerflinga" in a role playing game. More seriously, some names are just bad taste and perhaps offensive. "Urmommysbox" will get over it, it's an RP game, and they chose to play an orc. Disallow names that include class names. Again, apologies to "BestCleric," but better can be done!
3.) Please re-examine the "Tank," STARTING WITH THE CLASS NAME! Guardian! Warrior! Vanguard! Yeesh, even Protector is better than naming a fantasy class after a post industrial revolution armored car. If other classes augmented with (boo!) "Tank" will be able to hold aggro and support a group, let us know, as this might render a lot of this criticism invalid. OK here goes in no particular order: *Vengeance is not worth hitting
*The repair tax for dying is almost prohibitive.
*Weapon Swapping between sword and board and a 2hr to do damage (soloing, in a group but not MT, etc.) is cumbersome
*Some of the choice nodes in the class tree feel redundant
*Tomahawk? Wut? Disarm! Body Slam! Shield Throw! Final Stand! Sacrifice! Challenge!
Having a lot of fun on Verra, and will stick with it for sure - can't wait to see what comes next! Thanks for soliciting feedback and including us players and backers in your decisions!
olive oracle
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
hollow kettle
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
dry zealot
Alpha 2 Feedback - Do parcels you can buy instead of the freeholds. Let ppl build their own homes like in Valheim. It could even have a own skill tree. - The world is empty. Theres nothing to see or explore - Enemies that are 5 levels above yours are still challenging. is this intended? it makes you feel powerless. - Some synergies dont feel powerfull at all - open world pvp is just being abused by high level players without consequences. WOW has the better option
storm geyser
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Gatherables respawn in exactly the same location with exactly the same rarity - leading to a very unhealthy resource gathering mechanic that will eventually lead to a proliferation of bots
General caravan bugs
General render distance issues
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Lack of guild storage means that the complex value chain to produce items (which by itself is a very good thing) becomes an absolute nightmare to handle logistically
World bosses predictably respawning on server restart means that the biggest guild on each server camp the spot each night and reliably get
Enchanting system gives too much power to apprentice level items with 2+ attribute stats, which become more powerful than journeyman versions
Not being able to mix resources of different rarities when processing makes the process terrible, especially when there's a multi-stage process where 1 out of 25 components upgrades, and you cannot use it for the next step
runic heart
for me the top annoying bugs are
treasure maps not working
random weapon switching during fight when there isn't even a key assigned to switch between weapons
render distance of players and npcs
stuck granite
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
solar saffron
Important Feedback Topic:
sinful belfry
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Cannot loot some mobs. They appear to have items and you can see them when selecting them but attempting to collect them does nothing.
Bug with shield disappearing on Tank when hopping off a mount or when using the Devastate ability.
Mob appear stuck inside walls or objects found around the map.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The marketplace should be easier to filter to find the items you want. Currently, it works by searching the descriptions that individuals create, however without a uniform system of naming it’s impossible to search this way. I think it would be easier to search by using premade tags or just allowing the search function to search by the items listed on the individual marketplaces.
Tank seems to have issues holding aggro. A lot of the abilities state that they generate additional threat but it’s still quite easy for a DPS class to pull threat off of them due to their burst potential. I think the threat generated by the tank should allow them to hold aggro through DPS burst windows and maintain it through longer engagements.
Tank damage is rather low and that factored in with an ability like Grit that lowers damage to increase mitigation and they definitely aren’t clearing mobs quickly. I understand that they are not intended to match or exceed DPS character damage, but I think increasing the damage of their abilities would help them be more solo-play viable. Currently, tank does not feel like a class someone can play outside of a party and I think that can be a barrier to entry for many players. I think that by lessening the damage reduction on Grit and by buffing some abilities that the tank could become more solo viable and allow the tank to maintain higher levels of threat while in groups.
sullen crypt
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
inventory, need te relog to get eveything back
2.lots of common items, what can i do with it?
3party hud is easily gone
4 cant use ` for chainging weapon
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
If I had only 1 or 2 gathering options and 1 or 2 processing options, it would already feel much more manageable. This would also leave more resources available for others. A proper auction house would then be essential, allowing me to sell my materials and find the ones I need. This way, you’d also support the economy and ensure that lower-XP items could still have value, as they might be required for other processing skills.
lime drift
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
robust crown
Top 1 Most Important Bug :
exotic coral
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
glossy peak
Thanks for all your hard work. You all are doing an amazing job and creating an incredibly awesome experience. Keep up the great work. 👍
autumn swift
My Most Important Bugs:
My Most Important Topic:
We want to thank the Dev Team and Steven for the great time so far and its really enjoyable to be a tester!
Best moments were the interaction with GM Steven ingame, the events and i wish to see some other GM's in the future!
I hope everyone had a great time at their holidays!
karmic copper
feedback topics: mostly mob issues 1. For example carphin after some time the mobs don’t spawn in their location and over time becomes less and less viable to farm. 2. Mob AI, atm you can just train mobs to a group and if you get out of their visions they just start attacking people in the area. This should be fixed so the mobs attack the initial aggressor until they reset however if another group hits the mob train with aoe then they should pull the Agro from the initial aggressor still but if they don’t hit the mobs they should not unfairly get Agro. 3. Mob densities in general need a good look at, for example carphin is an example of where mob density is done well however there are many many other areas in the world where mob density is just bad even for a single group and for example in the desert I feel many areas haven’t been thought about and mobs just plonked there super spread out. 4. Ensure caravan system works in all areas as it’s the main end game loop at the moment, attacker/defender flagging etc.
enchanting also needs a look at, you basically get the same increase in stats from jewellery as from Armor but enchanting jewellery is way way cheaper - I think the cost of enchanting needs to be closer in terms of armour / jewellery
also a major issue killing a purple then going corrupted, assuming split second the combatant goes not combatant need some kind of countdown or something to know when a player is going to become non combatant
CC times need to be reduced especially bard CC, the TTK time and CC time don’t match at all.
increase speed of all mounts/caravans a little. Atm travel time is too slow.
lament crater
Bugs. 1. mobs 2. visuals bugs. Game changes 1. balance overall economy 2. change pvp to zones/risk vs reward
rugged tangle
Bugs:
Top 3 Most Important Bugs:
wicked parrot
1 - Corruptioon stacking too fast, only 1 kill getting you corrupt is way to little. Maybe 3 kills to get you corrupted IF the enemy is close to your level, 1 kill if he is a lot lower.
Imagem
2 - Item stack size font in material inventory is way too small, Im having trouble reading it.
3 - Loot concil options for party leader and a option to random loot so we dont have to need/greed everything
strange nest
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
unborn turret
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
loud prairie
pallid prairie
paper linden
Bugs:
Feedback:
Crafters got really fucked with condensing the servers. ~4x the population. Same material amounts for the first 1 to 2 weeks, then reduced timers. Higher tool rarity rating not working = no increase in rare mats to offset the reduced nodes available with more pop. Hundreds of gold sunk into processing to level professions guild-wide, but now blood thirsty lvl 25s with nothing to do but hunt caravans = almost no gold generation. It's been rough...
night anvil
IMPORTANT FEEDBACK
Ashes of Creation is in a very important position to secure the MMO space off of one specific thing.
The classes feel fun. Not fun in the sense of just fun to play, but fun in the way that other MMOs kill their game. Take Cleric for example. They have the ability to create a skill gap that can move a fight from pure chaos back to complete balance if played strategically. Other MMOs would take this and nerf the class instead of build up classes to immitate the amazing feeling that Cleric gameplay provides. IF AoC can capitalize and nurture this feature, it will be the best MMO ever!
Every MMO player wants to feel powerful and like their class has a purpose and place. Not just that they are a part of a group but that their presence impacts the group in a way they are actually needed there. Nurture this. Focus on this and the game will be the best ever!
cloud glen
bugs:
features:
honest marsh
Bugs
Feedback
alpine grove
Top 3-5 bugs: 1.
Top 3-5 most important feedback topics: 1.
coarse wasp
indigo dune
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
I'm a very new player so I haven't encountered as many things as other players. Also need to get in the habit of taking notes when I do...
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tawny cloud
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
For the context, I've only gone up to lvl15 during the beginning of this phase.
To be honest, I've
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Crafting is seemingly useless before "end-game", as unless high rarity materials are used, the items are at best equivalent to what can be dropped more easily through monsters. I'd love to see crafting being necessary very early on, encouraging people to rely on crafters from the very beginning. Given how long it takes to find enough high-rarity materials, lvl10 is quickly reached, rendering the craft before lvl10 useless, and too time consuming.
Griefing in POIs/farm areas is too easy for players, due to both the aggro range of the monsters, as well as the fact that the temporary flagging upon looting is very short-lived. I'd sugges increasing that time, as well as increasing it for each subsequently stolen player, making the "thief" more and more vulnerable to retaliation, similarly to the corruption (but not as punitive in the end ?) Or maybe griefers should somehow become corrupted, though I'd understand it's hard to evaluate.
Market UI is very simple for now, and though useful, it very much lacks a proper search feature, allowing for instance to look for a specific material/item, at a given rarity, and providing a very easy way to scroll through all the sold items that match, facilitating price comparison.
While I like the death cost, I often perceive it as very costly, as the longer the farm session in a POI, the costlier the death becomes. farming for, let's say 4hours, one death can cost a lot. I wonder if this should be reevaluated or not, and my negative perception here might be due to the fact taht griefers agggravate this aspect, that everyone is focusing on grinding XP to reach high levels, and so on. But in the end, as a mid-level player, it becomes quite difficult to amass riches by simply grinding with teams, and I feel like going for gatherables may be much more efficient in the current economy
======================
mental lagoon
Top #1 Thing to fix.. FIX THE TERRAIN
Mobs under the terrain, Trees under the terrain, treasure maps under the terrain, feet getting stuck under the terrain, caravans getting lost in the terrain,
whole swallow
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tardy knot
======================
======================
hardy plinth
alpha two phase II Feedback
top 3-5 most important bugs:
top3-5 most important feedback topics
1.when killing a monster with a much higher level than your own it currently does not give exp and while I do believe it is intended this is a very feel bad situation for those that have to gather in areas where these monsters spawn and sometimes get targeted by them and after finally working it down with much effort you get nothing in return for it
2. when making tools currently you can mix and match the rarities of the parts where it kind of just averages out the rarity of the product but this can not be done for components it would be a nice change if we could have that applied for the components as well since some parts of components are very hard if not almost impossible to currently get at high rarities
3. when processsing materials the rarity does not seem to impact the amount of profession experience you gain from it or at least not for metalworking while for garthering the rarity does impact the amount of experience I would be nice if for the processing rarity would also make an impact
oak cosmos
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 impotant bugs
mossy hound
1. FIX THE DOUBLE CARAVAN FLAG SYSTEM Right now there is a SERIOUS issue with member from easily named guilds bug abusing. The bug is You are able to flag as attacker on 2 caravans. If YOU the defenders. Flag as attacker on a caravan... Then summon a caravan to take the loot. (You will then hit defender on YOUR allies caravan) Moving forward. You are now attacker on 1 carvan and defender on your own. NOW!!! Your enemy rolls up. They can hit ATTACKER on THEIR caravan AND ATTACKER on yours too... This allows you to not only attack the people who are defending YOUR caravan. But you CANNOT attack them back because they flagged as attacker on THEIR own allies caravan.
split wyvern
jagged pebble
Caravans disappearing / teleporting to carphin, mobs eventually stop spawning (stuck elsewhere?)
gear repairs not updating stats immediately
mob training (aggro breaking into other groups instead of hard resetting back to original pos) , hard cc working on non combatant players
pyromancers/Firestarters do way too much damage
lilac bloom
Bugs
Feedback
mighty bay
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
stray sparrow
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
worldly meadow
smoky helm
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
======================
kind wolf
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Monster AI training/griefing
PvP Flag dropping mid combat therefore the result is an individual going corrupt
Turning in Mayoral Commissions via the chest
Inventory/Storage bug & inability to loot corpses unless relogging to fix either.
Treasure Maps shouldn’t be consumed until the loot is gathered. Constant bugs of being consumed then unable to find and/or loot the container.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Resource spawns need to be randomly placed with a buffer of 20-30 minutes so nodes aren’t spawn camped on timer. This opens the door to botting resources. Also, if intended that certain nodes respawn as "x" tier, that is a horrible design. It eliminates the necessity of the rarity stat on the artisan tools/gear.
Ban repeat exploiters. Ban those who continuously and intentionally grief. Continuous warnings do nothing. Warning > 30 Day ban > Ban til next phase or launch.
Please, Please PLEASE remove the knockback from Scatter Shot. It is the most obnoxious thing to reposition 2ft forward every 5-10 seconds when you’re PvE’ing for hours at a time.
Allow the ability to view all storage whether node storage or inventory storage at once - ie: stretch the UI window so I don’t have to scroll up and down to view or reorganize my storage. It’s extremely tedious.
Add additional Market search functions. The current structure is pretty lacking trying to search for items to buy & to list items to sell for people to discover.
icy violet
PLEASE Institute a Warning for Node wars, people just build raids and declare then wipe out the market and storage to collect goods and farm kills for battles they otherwise wouldnt win. Even 5 mins so people can stow stuff/Leave Groups/ Etc.
This goes for guild wars too
prime glen
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
paper elm
Bards resonance stacking does way too much damage for a class that can stack several CC's and there is no counterplay (even in group pvp) to a bard cc-chaining you and bursting you with resonance stacks. The class needs to be re-evaluated in terms of output or the amount of cc's they have available/their duration. By far the strongest class in PvP. Most classes' cc breaks simply do not work right now, so I'm hopeful that this changes things when you guys address the lack of cc breaks, though.
ashen sable
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
lilac timber
there needs to be something in the log in that says your character is in a war.
icy violet
a /reload command
keen silo
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory issues - Items lock in place, gatherables not appearing in the inventory
Resource respawn - timer & location - I've noticed that rarer resources tend to respawn at exactly same location with locked timer on it (eg. 2h). That causes some players to farm them with a stopwatch in their hand preventing other freely roaming the world from gathering in these locations.
Can't turn in resource commissions
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
Resource rarity system - I'm JM miner and almost JM gatherer, and the amount of resources and their variability both in my inv and storage is close to insanity (even when keeping just one stack of each). Additionally, some rarities are useless when moved forward to crafting, who needs uncommon pickaxe for instance 
I don't think removing the rarity system would be good idea either as gathering legendary resources and feelings while obtaining them are worth remembering. However, simplifying to to Common -> Rare -> Legendary would free up so much space, simplify crafting and make these tiers more meaningful.
Tax system - I remember arriving at Halc as a freshly baked lvl 10 (new player as well), becoming a citizen full of hope and then realizing that there's more tax to pay than glint I'd collected through my lvling process (over 100 at that time, heard of ppl with over 300 now). As the system to prevent nodes from overpopulation makes perfect sense, however, there should be ways to mitigate that significantly through commissions, resource donations, participating in building construction, etc. Additionally, there should be a way to pay in advance, for cases of taking longer breaks from the game.
Market item filtering - difficult to navigate while purchasing items, would love to be able to filter by categories and item names.
And lastly, thank you all for building the incredible game that brings sweet memories of a good, old MMO<3
topaz grail
Two things I would really like to have, would be:
Other than that, here are some issues and notes I've got:
I've mostly only encountered shader issues and haven't encountered many crashes to be honest, huge kudos on that.
Would love to see some Linux support in the future, not a dedicated Linux specific build, but, ensuring some decent compatibility when running it through WINE/Proton. I am honestly unsure about a lot of bugs I encounter, and if I even should report visual/shader issues while I'm running it on Linux. A lot of these issues don't seem to be a thing when running it natively on Windows
I like the game a lot and am very excited to see where it goes in 2025 and beyond!
night anvil
Denouncing Citizenship needs to be clearer on which storages go away. To delete 10s if not 100s of gold worth of mats for paid storages without being clear those are going is wild...
candid nacelle
It's a 50-50 coinflip whether AoC loads properly to even be able to get into the game or not. Extremely frustrating.
Mob aggro distance should be nerfed.
Thank you
paper elm
Bards' Resonance Stacks are proccing off of each individual tick of the wand finisher and it melts other players 100-0 in under 1 second while they're silenced. For classes like mage or cleric without a functioning CC break there's no counterplay. Please look at that interaction.
uncut prairie
I'm not saying we need Phase 1 levels - that was wild, but it should easily be 5x, or more, as effective as it is today.
granite vale
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
tawdry linden
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Inventory bug
Training/aggro
Recently the game has been stuttering when entering in different "servers" either getting caught walking or mount is caught in between and wont move unless you resummon, this only started maybe a week ago and got progressively worse.
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
The absolute best is the feedback from the devs to the community, i love the communication between us even if it becomes a little "chaotic". To add to this i believe you guys are doing a great job (all staff) and continue to pursue greatness
Gathering some things like copper as a stage 1 mat is real scarce, i know alot of people go for it, but its still too scarce at times. Stage 1 mats i would think would be more abundant, even if its only common/uncommon mats.
Market is super unreliable and would like to see changes on how it operates.
night anvil
From level 1 to 25 and bugs aside, the only real negative experience is had throughout it all was the griefing. Players intentionally grabbing masses of mobs and dragging them through groups farming to kill them wastes so many peoples time, gold and enjoyment in the game, whether you believe in greifing being a problem or not. It doesn't enhance the game in any way. If you can fix this, it will be so much smoother.
inland garden
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 1 Most Annoying Bug:
grand depot
Alpha Two Phase II Bugs
Top Bugs:
Feedback:
frail quest
Top Bugs:
sharp fable
Feedback on Emberspring locations:
Embersprings outside every dungeon are bad for PVP. If two groups PVP over a spot in a dungeon, the losing side can just continually respawn and swarm / harass.
Harder pill to swallow: also bad for PvE. Either decisions matter or they don’t, being able to simply respawn outside of a dungeon you die at takes away from the difficulty of the world. Making people run back or have to get a res forces people to be more careful and analyze their situation.
Would recommend either only having embersprings outside cities (maybe a couple landmarks scattered about as well), or make PVP death respawns only in cities.
sonic yew
Feedback on Emberspring locations:
Embersprings outside every dungeon are bad f...
I agree that embersprings should be tweaked. One odd thing that stood out to me is that during Node wars the attackers are allowed to respawn at the emberspring of the Node theyre attacking which leads to a pretty crap experience imo. The attackers should be blocked from spawning at the towns emberspring during a Node war imo, i think it would lead to the attackers having to make more strategic pushes and the defenders would have more time between pushes to rally people to defend.
buoyant eagle
Feedback on current node progression pacing: Crafting feels pretty good at the moment power-wise, however it seems to get bottlenecked more than it should from node progression. Because all the crafters need mats from each other, crafters will always lag behind player level. Even worse, to keep up, most crafters just burn the most efficient recipes over and over to progress because of the tiny exp rewards, and so they aren't actually crafting for other players. Until there are other ways to get the higher level tools and workbenches (freeholds, guild houses, or wherever we'll be allowed to get them) crafting will always be less valuable than simply getting the higher tier gear to drop from bosses, other than the odd legendary item once they've reached the current limit through making 100+ pairs of common boots and gatherers get some orange mats.
idk, I just feel like it makes the crafters choose between actively crafting armor for their guildies, and being efficient with shared resources
scenic flower
Seems to me an Adventurer/PvPer looks at a Grem and goes "Hmmm... Glint and mats -- good kill" and when they see a gatherer /crafter the same thing goes through thier minds currently because they do not have the need for a crafter currently -- they advance - with gear to the higher levels they desired without assist from crafters at all - they just need mobs and the vendor. This has to change or crafters will vanish -- they must have a need for crafter/gatherer before they will have any respect for them. -- just saying.
steel wadi
Feedback on current node progression pacing: Crafting feels pretty good at the m...
Over all gear needs to be nerfed from dungeons it’s so good/easy to farm crafters are pointless right now why even bother when you can get it other places and much easier. Crafting system should be left alone but how easy gear is to get needs to be nerfed or make it a lower quality compared to crafted gear.
buoyant eagle
Over all gear needs to be nerfed from dungeons it’s so good/easy to farm crafter...
the issue with that is that unless the mayors all coordinate perfectly, the crafters will be 1 tier below dropped gear (as they are right now on Vyra at least). only being able to upgrade one crafter at a time means that without removing useful drops from bosses (which I hope they don't, maybe just top them out at rare if anything?) you have to choose between having something level appropriate or something crafted.
steel wadi
the issue with that is that unless the mayors all coordinate perfectly, the craf...
Maybe this could work if they made the gear BoP then it wouldn’t conflict with crafters/sellers.
patent grove
Over all gear needs to be nerfed from dungeons it’s so good/easy to farm crafter...
I think part of this has to do with the scarcity of resources, too, especially lacking high rarity mats necessary to make gear better than dungeon drops. If crafting heroic/epic items were easier, then that would incentivize people to craft. I'm really leary of nerfing mob drops, because that could affect the drop rate of other things that we do want as artisans
steel wadi
I think part of this has to do with the scarcity of resources, too, especially l...
I understand this, maybe matching it to the rarity could work if it’s BoP and not something a crafter has to compete with also another good idea is to make the set bonus a lot better for crafted gear maybe? Trying to think of ideas to help the balance any more idea guys? Something that doesn’t make crafting stupid easy part of the reason I enjoy crafting is it’s a a challenge and I feel I earned something even better when I make a good sell.
blazing perch
======================
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
buoyant eagle
I understand this, maybe matching it to the rarity could work if it’s BoP and no...
maybe limiting how much dropped gear can be enchanted? wouldn't hurt as much in the short term but crafting would win out overall
rotund trout
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
Top 3-5 Most Important Bugs:
Top 3-5 Most Important Feedback Topics:
sharp fable
Alpha Two Phase II Feedback
CC duration, MOB AEing, and crowd control "classes"
In alot of classic MMOs - EQ enchanters, bard, and shaman / DAoC bard, sorcerer, minstrel / WoW sheep somewhat but this is when it started to turn) multiple trash pulls were a problem that was solved by having classes that could CC or single pull (mez, slow, sheep, lull, etc).
Currently there is a bard AE mez and single target mez, and also a mage sleep...however the durations are so small as to be completely useless in PVE. Also, mobs are simply AEed down rather than needing to be controlled.
Feedback - Make higher end content more difficult and bring back crowd control necessity. Make PVE mez, sleep, lull, etc durations much longer and make PVE trash mobs much more necessary to control rather than simply round up and AE over and over again.
olive quarry
Seems to me an Adventurer/PvPer looks at a Grem and goes "Hmmm... Glint and ma...
very wrong: In our case all the guildies organized to promote 5-6 dedicated crafters which get all the materials they need aswell as gold in order to then craft the gear for us.
scenic flower
very wrong: In our case all the guildies organized to promote 5-6 dedicated craf...
General crafter/gatherers dude - of course guild members are treated different. Kinda stupid not to.