#Spell Card: "Soul Exchange" and Precious Cards from Beyond

5 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

hoary echo
#

In this replay (https://duelingnexus.com/replay/15ed727d-6d80-4398-9453-6699de407ef6), turn 3, I used Spell Card: "Soul Exchange" to Tribute Summon the Winged Dragon of Ra using 3 of my opponent's monsters. By a literal reading of Precious Cards from Beyond, I Tribute Summoned a monster using 2 or more Tributes, so each one should have enabled me to draw 2 cards, yet I did not. Why is that?

harsh ridge
#

Its likely a result of Ancient Chant's effect to change Ra's Atk/Def when it was summoned, therefore making the Tribute summon no longer be the most recent thing to occur, which makes Precious Cards From Beyond miss timing.

hoary echo
#

Interesting, would that be an intentional effect, or a bug to be fixed? I see nothing in the relevant Wiki pages for any relevant rulings, except that Precious Cards from Beyond does start a Chain Link.

#

I also do not draw any cards if I Tribute my own three monsters, and activate Ra's effect of paying LP for ATK/DEF.

hoary echo
#

It also doesn't work when I summon Slifer, so it may be the standard Egyptian God effect of, "When Normal Summoned, cards and effects cannot be activated." I had overlooked this because the Wiki's Card Tips for Slifer specifically recommends Precious Cards from Beyond to trigger on Slifer's summon, it may just be entirely a mistake on the author's part.