#lore-discussion
1 messages · Page 330 of 1
Id rank sidon higher than yunobo
although lower than riju
yunobo may be stronger but sidon deffinetly has better combat skills
I wouldn't as Gorons have really strong hits lorewise, and they are incredible in sturdiness
Link devouring a rock meat thing:
tbh riju is a dps, tulin a support, yunobo a tank, and sidon is another dps
1 hit from sidon might do like half a red bokoblin, yunobo just sends several flying
Ignoring him rolling like crazy
Sidon just grants water
Like, it's 1 hit absorber but the extra attack is just water 
lol
bro aint even on mud level
crazy we speaking of zelda totk sages ranking in a calamity mod lore discussion channel
Riju is like town level, being able to use lightning is epic
Lightning is infact very cool
tbh lorewise riju would just be good for her combat skills
lightning may be epic
but if you cant control it its kinda mid
like those unknown superheroes vids on tiktok
Point is Riju can control it
erm actually
she cant
the reason lightning hits the enemies its cause riju sends lightning and arrow attracts it
Mineru is practically immortal and has a powerful mech, idk how she would place
Don’t think we see any way for ghosts to get hurt in totk
Which is the practically immortal part
but if she is a ghost that means she shouldve died already
Although she does pass to the afterlife in the ending
Yeah and now the mortal part is gone
mineru is fr just mechamaru
Pfft what
nah
Link solos yharim???????
Reminder that link didn't solo ganondorf
hol up
link soloed ganon
the sages helped against shadows
else it wouldve been a 6v1
Can’t you skip the sages and deal with it all anyways?
Mineru:
Also you can turnoff the sages
imagine a dark souls player complaining about using sages against ganondorf
No they're forced for Ganondorf
:(
Yes and no
what about third phase?
Link hmmmm
Why is there a discussion about Zelda lol
idk
it says lore discussion
Y’all need jolliness
doesnt specify which game shall the lore be discussed about
Evolved from TotK Ganondorf vs Xeroc to this
link soloes
The channel description says which
Smh
Xeroc Wins
Continent Level vs City Level
The God of Primordial Light
Xerocs power is “the unmatched power of the sun” so I think he wins
Yes, but that has little meaning of strength in calamity
Xeroc is stronger than continent bro is the strongest being on the terraria planet
has a god ever been fought against in zelda games
Yharim who is strongest guy other then xeroc on the planet isn’t even mountain level
actually yeah in skyward sword
I mean you fight the moon in Zelda does that count
nope
You save it
You fight something bringing the moon down
wdym no
demise isn't a god
Never played Zelda
He's a demon
he's a demon
fr?

Only played botw and a bit of totk (prefer botw)
yes
Yeah
I've played through the original like 3 times
Demise is like
The strongest demon though and is godlike in power iirc
not quite godlike
if majora's mask is that powerful imagine majora himself
Demise is continent level at the very least
he needed the triforce for his plans to ever succeed
isnt demise like the incarnation of chaos
So Demise lowest equal xeroc max
nope he's stronger
even his half reanimated corpse could destroy the world
Ah demise busted I see
ALttP Ganon is the strongest being in Zelda lore though, besides the Golden Goddesses
Full triforce
wasnt ganon the reincarnation of demise
Demise when revived though didn't want destruction, he wanted dominion
yes
Chaos isn’t destruction
I remember demise setting a curse so zelda and link would reincarnate
so a loop would begin all over again
idk I saw a zelda lore video
yes he does
I think they would reincarnate anyways
He just makes it so he will always plague their lives with his reincarnation I think???
botw and totk are the last one
Those are not canon games
like then after skyward sword it gets divided into three timelines
which
he sets one that makes him, zelda, and link constantly reincarnate until Demise's reincarnation wins
Totk and botw aren’t canon?
BotW and TotK
they are
not
Whar?
Deconfirmed in like september
^
They exist in a seperate canon
thats cause there was no place for them to be put in the timeline wasnt it?
No probably
SCal would just think she saw a ghost and Amidias, maybe but likely not
Amidias be mad because his home is gone because of her
They are in the official timeline, no???
No
nope
I mean
they're their own seperate thing
^
wait hold on this would be funny as hell
I could have sworn they were
scla meeting amidias and think he's jsut a ghost that came back to haunt her or something at first
SCal sees right trough Adidas
Hey Cei if you don't mind answering what part of development do you do?
Lore
damn it
I am getting so amadias from continuously mispelling amidias
Cei is lore person
Been tryna figure out which dev does music stuff because I'm tryna figure something out
Heart Plus Up
HPU is pretty much the only music dev
Thriplerex and Skippy
Those are devs?
Ok so they changed it again, but the imprisoning war is still mentioned in the official timeline on the website
here's hoping I can find HPU in chat some day
They made music for the last update
Luckier off in the music server in #info
there's a music server?
Yes
Is there like a google doc or something with the lore?
The Calamity Lore Document Hello, and welcome to the new Calamity Lore Document, also known simply as CAL. Here, I have collected all of the lore currently in the mod, and have curated it for easier consumption, including building a timeline based on the information given to us by the Lore i...
I swear people don’t follow the rules and don’t look at the pins
The heck
calg
Fair
something I've been wondering about btw
You have confirmed you have no access to the secrets
the color of a flame can correlate to its heat right?
Yeah, though I think calamity’s other fires (brimstone,holy,dragon and godslayer) don’t abide to that rule much
I am so confused right now
godslayer is the most likely to
Definitive confirmation of a lack of access to sscls
sscls
It’s secret :)
Its a server
Super secret even
Don’t think so
Cause it would endlessly be full of charge
But it should be able to power a artificial one
this specific line about them made me ask for reference
"Instructions and information are processed at lightspeed in a distributed fashion, not unlike a cerebral network taken to its theoretical extreme."
Does the "ss" stand for super secret?
Can’t tell, secret
another thing by the way
Sacred Sacrilegious Crustacean Loom Spores

I REALLY hope we get something akin to the Draedon talk feature for SCal or Braelor
calamity reinvents the npc talk ui ?!!!
^
Calamity prob will have something like it but not as big as draetalk
My friend that had come here plans on playing calamity at mine before getting more into the lore
So he can experience it at the intended rate instead of me sending him as much text as the bible whenever he asks a question
also something I just realized during the draetalk
draedon says yharim deduced that draedon was the one behind the steel and oil creations from 400 years before him
how good was communication between continents for him to know about that?
i mean people from england heard stories about shit going on in america in like the 1500's and the world of cal's level of tech before the crusade was like 1800's level
also hi :D
Word does indeed travel
unique and strange stories from other places would surely reach around
Hello Cei how goes things
Nice
I can already imagine her saying "Am I ever gonna stop being haunted...." in the tone of Alucard saying "Oh my God... I'm turning into Belmont."
Pfft
Oh hey Cei is here
There'll be similar things but not on the same scope, yeah
Like
I am treating Exhumed Items tooltips as, essentially
Calamitas' Talk
Has anyone else been able to get ahold of and figure out some of draedon's tech before? Even older stuff?
The Calamitalk
Also: there are no major characters in lore that use ranged weapons, but there are for all the other classes
John wulfrum has clearly
Technically Draedon uses Ranged
Draedon uses ranged weapon
Pulse Rifle is his personal baby
Yharim and Braelor: melee
Permafrost and cal: mage
Statis: rogue
Anahita and kind of draedon: summoner
Draedon kind of sometimes: ranger
Gunslinger cowboy guy?
Draedon is a summoner ranger hybrid
Yharon
That would be weird
Tbf now that I think about it Silva might be a good representative for Ranged
Huh interesting. Bow?
Mage Ranged hybrid
DISAGREE
GUNS GUNS GUNS GUNS GUNS GUNS GUNS GUNS GUSN GUNS GUNS GUNS GUNS GUN
Silva = healer class
what the FUCK
Can y’all stop using me for violence
Turns cheese into swiss cheese
Melong gun is the ranger calamity character
Imagine if fovos killed dragons with a swarm of SDMGs
I am the class stpuid

I am ranger John damage
i have one character that's primarily ranged but uses melee weapons as a backup
also speaking of the sdmg
I kinda hate how fast the moon lord drops get thrown away
I feel like some kind of gunslinger could work but idk where you'd put it
Maybe some older historical character
They last like 3 bosses
Folly
Guardians
Providence
not all of em
the reason they're ranged is that they are by nature paranoid of everything (even if they don't show it) and so prefer to do confrontations over long distances where they're at very low risk whenever possible
the ranger weapons don't hold up at all in my experience
but sometimes being close is unavoidable (such as when SCal sentences them to The Box), which is why they also carry melee weapons with them
Blossom Flux is funny because it might honestly be my favorite Legendary description in concept
it's my 2nd favorite bow in hardmode
Supreme brimstone witch calamitas sentences you to the box™️
ngl though
I feel like you could make a ranger character and have them be a veteran from yharim's army
Scal the only jujutsu sorcerer in calamity to have a domain expansion
And it’s her opening move
Like, recently we went over and thought
Ok
Every Legendary Item is gonna be narrated by a character
Most of them, at least
When applicable
they don't even need to be a major character
Binding vow where the domain isn't a guaranteed hit until you leave it
The only ones I am like
Absolutely certain won't have a narrator proper
Are Cosmic Discharge
remind me what that is?
I'm curious, what do you mean by a narrator here?
An in-universe character
why not have the pirate captain narrate it?
Because I'm going to fucking tell you who's going to narrate each right now fuck you
geez sorry
I didn't mean to be aggressive sorry lmao
It was more a
"Fuck you I'm telling you every narrator"
Reb trying to get the FPMs up
Disagreed
Robin Hood:
Fucks per message
At least 5
Crosshair (Bad Batch):
would the doom slayer count as ranged?
It's just a matter of writing them well
Does greenarrow count or Hawkeye XD
YEAH, GREEN ARROW
Aegis Blade - Unspecified Lihzahrd Sage
Briny Baron - Actually not decided yet
Blossom Flux - Silva
Pristine Fury - Providence
SHPC - Draedon
Vesuvius - God of Sacrifices
Yharim's Crystal - Yharim, maybe Yharon
Glacial Embrace - Permafrost
Leonid Progenitor - Unspecified Deus Cultist
Malachite - Plaguebringer Goliath
Old Reaper - Unspecified Dragon Hunter
Hawkeye isn't as explored
Ah yes, Jeremy Renner
Who
Hawkeye actor
I think Yharim's Crystal being narrated by Yharon would be good since bro has like
Nothing characterization-wise rn
Ah yes
Bee narrator
I need to know their secrets
THIS IS MY MEEEEE-
The pirates actually getting some lore for once would be sick
Pbg is able to narrate?
Kinda
I misread that as 'THIS IS MY BEEEEEEEEEE'
Is the narration just Buzz buzz buzz
It honestly goes fucking nuclear
I imagine PBG "talking" would be more so just. robotic commands. like. the fucking. ALERT! RED SPY IS IN THE BASE
is it the bee movie script?
I mean pbg does say things like launching nukes
Wher old reaper
rebecca?
According to the chat
I forgor Old Reaper
Maybe..........
Old Reaper
Old duke
that pause made me very concerned rebec-
Clearly
There
rebecca that was a joke is this actually a thing?
You open the weapon and your entire screen is filled up by the bee movie script
by making a statement regarding ranged characters you enabled me. sorry
Cheese is a range player confirmed
also lihzahrd and deus lore is based
that would be great for gfb
Yah
I need to know more about the
Lizard people
Briny baron could be narrated by amidias or the pirate
wait
yharr thar fishron stole me booty
isn't the community a legendary item too?
Briny Baron is actually the only one who is likely to be entirely unrelated to its current Boss
Dedicated Item
oh
It'd be
Tyrian, Otonilou or Amidias
Idk which one
Well, ok
Leonid Progenitor too
I feel like the briny baron is tied to the royal family of illmeris
And legendary I think, someone mentioned it while talking about how they all used to be 1% drops
Amidias had a pet fishron in old lore
But it's still remaining Astral Infection related
It's just jumping from Aureus to Deus later down the line
Actually I could have sworn someone said old duke was amidias' pet fishron in old lore
I'm ngl i forget the fact old duke technically existed in old lore
i genuinely have 0 clue what his lore was
if he even had any
Aureus both already unlocks a fucking special Rogue Item
And like
Come on
Leonid Progenitor
I sure do wonder what this is becoming

Sprite is a motherfucking egg
Clearly nothing
astrageldon?
Astrum Deus children
💥
Clearly
If I tell you "It's being moved to Deus"
It becomes INSTANTLY OBVIOUS what the fuck I'm going to do with it
i love throwing baby dei at my enemies 💥
I can't tell what you're gonna do with it tbh
Tyrian tried to fight Duke Fishron and lost.
And also lost his sword.
do you have the stupid bug gif?
Yeah
Like, it's just
Lol
Lmao
OF COURSE that's what I'm doing
I can't tell if that's sarcasm

It's not 
if it works for spider starfish it works for star eating space worms
I'm outright telling you Leonid Progenitor is going to be a Deus Egg
Which, hey
Lore Drop technically
would it be immoral for me to fry it?
Yes
Yes.
i don't imagine it'd taste too good but i'm not gonna stop you
Which tbf I personally always thought was also obvious
ngl
I'm surprised there isn't a predator or alien reference in the astral infection
Ok but then why can't we hatch it and why can we throw and break it infinite times
vdeogame
Space worm
Deus is obviously a species, unless the universe was small as fuck there'd just be no way that one member of its species could clean the entire fucking universe
Why does making one Supernova grant you access to infinite Supernovas.
That'd imply Deus was just fucking cracked
If deus was still a light year long worm it would make sense, but now that's no longer the canon
It doesn't actually get destroyed and is designed to just make a giant burst of energy or alternatively there's ubiquitous object duplication magic for weapons in calamity
However
So you're just chucking its kids at your enemies?
This revelation does still leave one question in the air
Draedon's theory was that the Deus we see ingame might just be a juvenile, but if it can lay an egg, that either means Deus' species either reach maturity incredibly early on in its lifespan
Or that it's just not a juvenile
Oh.
Then its stupid.


Am I wrong?
I mean astral infection could have gotten it even if it was smart
I have an idea
dog is a girl
The deus' are pack hunters
It has no gender
does yharim have gender
Yes
yeah ik what species is he
does he belong to earf

Huh. I wonder if that question has an answer
Not one worth answering
ok in calamity lore what is this guy supposed to be
Doesn't it normally have a harder time infecting sapient creatures?
It just can't
Maybe it got infected and then grew up
Sorry I meant the "why was deus infected" one
Because I told him
Aureus resisted quite well, but sooner or later he fell on the Astral Infection.
I think it was infected pretty quickly iirc
Got overwhelmed by the influx of stars due to fovos bringing a shit ton of mana into the world
(throwing shit at the wall)
Eating one moldy bread won't turn you into crabulon but maybe eating thirty would
Maybe that's how long it takes for mana to turn into stars and grow old enough to get infected
It is assumed that for Draedon it was unforeseen that he was controlled by the Astral Infection, the model was made to resist it
How do you know that
Do we currently have the information to answer this question? Will we on SSO?
I don't think you do, no
Hm, ok
Anyways, has anyone in the world developed significantly better technology by reverse engineering things made by draedon? Or by his creator?
john wulfrum
Third passage just dropped
none that we know of
The guy that made Cyborg wanted to best Draedon, but we don't know if he did that or not
How do we know that
Dialogue
MoonLordDefeated2: Draedon? The guy who made these upgrades on me said he wanted to best him. But I never cared about that, I just wanted to shoot lasers from my eyes.
Not Cyborg itself, just its upgrades, my bad
its me
So is most of the calamity scaling is based on the burning the ocean feat and it’s all relative from there?
Maybe?
But we also have direct dev statements
Burning the ocean took like a week
Yharim and calamitas are comparable to living nukes
Yharim could punch a person through a mountain at his strongest
Slime god, though weak for a god, would still take a small army of ordinary people with normal weapons to kill
woah i actually recognise all of those trial mods
wasn't expecting prikki to apply for some reason
Lol
Neither was I
Now we can’t call Garbo stinker without them shower reacting us :(
you say 'we' as if you aren't responsible for 99% of recent instances of garbo being called stinky and as if i have participated recently
(slight exaggeration of figures for dramatic effect ✨
Garbo is stinky
Shut up >:(

Random but do y'all think draedon ever experimented with guns that need physical ammo?
probably
Also do we know what weapon Yharim's snipers used?
anti-materiel rifle jumped into my mind but that isn't a schematic weapon
Ngl with how many gaps there are in the arsenal compared to the types of troops I feel like Draedon took some the schematics with him
encountered an issue...
phoenix flame barrage and the burning sky are the same weapon, and both stellar striker and lunar flare have identical falling projectiles as a large part (or all) of their identity
i'm not getting any inspiration for something different by considering their functions because of that
E.g. a distinct shortage of sniper rifles, shotguns, grenades, flamethrowers, and heavy weaponry
guh
The lack of grenades, snipers, and flamethrowers are prolly the worst
posted this in the wrong server
lol
Considering we know that there were divisions of Yharim's forces that specialized in those weapons
Arsenal gear is prob not every weapon on that tier draedon made
Prob just what fit in one schematic
If I was Yharim I would be kinda disappointed if Draedon can only come up with ~20 weapons during his 70 or so years of service
Yeah
did yharim ever ask draedon to help with the evil biomes
We don’t know but I doubt it
That won't stop me
none of these people having moderator will influence the way that I act around them
because I ain't no bitch
actually it will because I will ask them to change my nickname very often
We’ll see about that
:D
I don't know about that, but the steampunker has solution that can erase it for some reason
wonder how she got god essence-erasing powers from
Blows up corruption with mind
can you change my name to StinkyChugus25 green guy
Won’t stop me either tbf
@mighty zenith ya stinker

Take a shower
How it feels to chew trash
Yummers
that was eggulent
mod is mad
trial mod btw
I have a question: How did an electric goddess rule a sea? There might be a lot of accidental electrocutions in sea water. Was she extremely careful about that? or was she ectremely cruel? or did she give all the Ilmeran creatures protection against electricity?
bro is fodderous
trial mod is slower to type than mod 
iirc ilmerans did have protection, and that electricity was mainly used to protect the place from outside threats
idk though lol cant rember
yes but it's funnier
Electricity in water, man
I think she was a
yep
Illmerians we’re just shrimply immune to electricity
shrimply immune...
in real world, putting powerful electricity in water simply kills all the fish in a very wide range
but ilmerians are better than average fish
I'm the beat-upper when I see someone who is in need of a good beat-upping, I oblige them
yes, but there are not only cityzens but also regular foolish fishes
She gave cheap electricity prices
That’s kinda benelovent to me
lmao
We know that when godly essence is left to fester, it results in biomes like the crimson, corruption, and hollow. So what happens with the godly essence of Providence and Slime God? They both die but we neither see their essence or see it get consumed.
i eated it all
slime god didn't die
also Slime God becomes Slime Queen before being truly killed, byea
i assume theres just not enough of it to spot at that point
Slime god does die when we kill queen slime though.
well you can argue that crim and corr are several gods and iirc hallow too
since some bestiaries do say that they are several gods
at least for both crimson and corruption, can't remember hallow but I'd assume same
when providence died... there was uelibloom
was is a good way to put it
imagine if Providence dying doesn't create stuff like crimson and corruption and instead she immediately blows up like a nuke
that'd be peak fiction
she doesn't create she just destroys 💔
Imagine if providence got a low taper fade than erased xeroc
Peak fiction
This is so chease
And meeee :3
I should release a book


the information about the god or gods of the hallow might be intentionally hidden by yharim since they might not be evil
yes
as of the writers, that's the entire reason why Yharim doesn't mention them
The hallow is more evil than every other biome cus it has unicorns
And those fuckers do too much damage
but they are unicorns, man
Unicorns are mid anyways
should've done like Ark Survival where Unicorns are just absurdly rare horses with no differences other than being unicorns and only being white
Whatt it’s ture :(

Yaya
This guy....
It has cute flying light bulbs tho
Mid
YOU are mid
The M stands for mid
It stands for metvox
check again.

Its a nickname my name is still legally metvox
don't believe you
peak fiction
That was mid actually
true
This image begs to differ
does clamitas know about the 4 unholy machinations draedon brewed up
which ones
oh yeah
Exo mechs were recently built
I forgor
the bigger ones
i think she definitely knows about clone
i can imagine she'd at least hear about the normal mechs
as for the other ones i doubt it
It’s stated Calamitas broke into the facility with her clone, freed it and gave it a part of her magic, (wich drove it insane)
Calclone? She literally freed her
Spends five yharillion years typing
Message is two sentences long
Removed in 5 seconds
you didn’t not
You did
what if I uncloned calamitas twice
there would be zero of them
the world can finally be at peace

That is a really bad way to describe calamitas
no
if you do that
how will you have exhumed

the energy of that emote is off the charts
No that’s the most accurate
No
based
What is
the fact that you don't like that description of calamitas
Lame…
Cus it isn't true anyways
how mfs feel after calling an ex-genocide witch a silly relatable girlfailure
Calameitas if she were lame or something idk I haven’t watched the show yet
idm if people like calamitas or sympathize with her but lord have mercy she is not "just like me fr"
nor is she really a girlfailure
we made a sea kingdom experience hell at some point of our life
the reason i call her that is because i imagine she was pretty sheltered during her time in yharim's army so when she left she had basically no concept of what it's like to be a functional adult
When you think about it she prolly never had time to learn any day-to-day skills considering she was a child when recruited, and because of her status she prolly had a boatload of servants doing the menial tasks for her. This renders her a girlfailure
in my mind it makes sense that such a high ranking member would have servants taking care of things such as cooking, cleaning her living space, washing her clothes etc.
I simply feel like it's pretty insulting to call someone who has experienced horrors beyond what 99% of people ever will a girlfailure
Must’ve been the gods faults
I don't think she's a girlfailure because I believe that being a supremely powerful mage who can beat nearly anyone in a fight and is widely known throughout the world sorta disqualifies you from being a girlfailure
It isn’t an insult necessarily
I also just kinda hate the word girlfailure in general...
True
It doesn't insinuate anything good in the first place
wdym I also genocided an underwater civilization

In my eyes it's another internet way of making something bad sound good
I dont even know what a girlfailure is
A girl who fails at doing stuff
Hai pcorpnop
I liked the idea that Calamitas is basically useless in any skill outside of using magic
Hello
But after some revelations from Rebecca I’m now more leaning towards ex-delinquent Calamitas
and killing
Calamitas is secretly koshitan
I am also a genocidal failure smh
this is the kind of comparison I find tired and overdone and also just not really accurate or amusing because its just so like
not true at all
That was a joke 
lol
why tf do people want to compare calamitas to a quirky whimsical anime girl
Insanity
No it's society
(specially cal players)
Realistically I do not find Calamitas to be like that

I think she’s just an introverted quiet girl who tries being nice to others
calamitas is so me I also killed thousands of innocent people...omg..
When people say they are literally Calamitas, nobody bats an eye...
But when I say, that I'm literally Patrick Bateman from American Psycho...
I do think she horribly fails at shit but not in a quirky silly way
Actually
I'm literally Yharim guys
I just feel like her past of actual provable genocide sort of disqualifies her from being classified as that type of person
I don’t really understand what you mean, what do you think she is like then?
I think she is just careful and tries to redeem herself by trying to be polite and nice
Scarred child soldier who killed millions but suffers because of it
This is after she had left Yharim
Mm yeah makes sense
that makes sense
I mean she was like
15
in fucking war
Whenever I draw calamitas I always give her tired eyes

Except when Caloro
Doesn’t look tired
Fuck
exposed
You will erase that from your memory
You will now explode
I sentence you to explode

💥
Like idk bout yall but why we making fun n shit on for saying Literally Me to shit like the many characters Ryan Gosling plays or Batman or Patrick Bateman but then we ignore when people say literally me to Calamitas dawg
What
Is there an actual character in calamity that is realistically relatable
yharim is so me omg...
I make gun of everyone who says "I'm literally x"
Cus i think it's dumb
uuh blue slime
Don't wanna start a war but this lowkey feels like double standards idk
That's much better already
@mighty zenith
What was that again
Garping
?

Number one hater
What did bronkler oofy say
Hi
@gritty kraken run that shi back
Too much mcdonalds
Bingus
sometimes you just need a calamity addon mod that allows you to make the choice to kill calamitas yourself
why
What :(
Violence
I think slave calamitas is better than kill her
What ☹️
just apply slavery smh
I guess? But like, why
Exhumed weapons
Addon to make her eat a popeyes buiscuit with no drink
slavery is always the best option 
Instantly turns to dust
Until you bring massive fucking insects into it
Real
she simply drops a crafting station that lets you do it yourself
“I don’t get it it’s just a biscuit why are you looking at me like that?”
Takes a bite
Intense coughing fit
💀
Public execution
-100000 hp/s
Dawg what
I suppose in a certain point of view slavery is better than death
Adunno
But like
what would you do by killing her? sent her to hell? I think thats what she wants
Just don’t do both
She deserves a garden and a teleporter to Perma’s house
Put her on house arrest
Ok idk about that either tbh she is still a war criminal
No
Id rather die
I’m not gonna argue about the moral absolutism of death vs slavery
terraria house arrest is the same as slavery
Depend on what kind of slavery it is lowkey
Make her have a redemption arc
Is calamitas a cat or a dog person
Simple
CAT
Hell yeah
Bird person
Like what if the choice is between death and a chill ass owner who properly provides for you and loves you
Duke Fishron is just Piscine Wyvern easy, as Old Duke should be too
Folly, Wyrm and Weaver to Elder Dragon as well
Leviathan lmao lol
Fish, probably yea
Rest is correct methinks
Supreme meow catlamitas
Unfortunately i killed the only bird in the mod
You make the latter sound like you are a pet
Some people are into that kind of thing
I was thinking more traditional type shit

arent there like 2 birds
man I haven't pinged garbo in nearly 10 minutes
Oh yeah i forgot about the small one
Yeah in that case it would suck
and the smaller versions of the small one
Theres plenty of them i cant kill them all but there is just one yharon
Oh that too
Man too many birds
I want bunnies
get a lepus idk

Mayeb put her in community service
death. break. freedom. do not bow. burn the house of the one who "owns" you.
What if you like it though
But wouldnt that make it harder to live
-# mreow
do not think of the consequences
Oh okay
if someone believes that they rightfully own you, then they should die.
no remorse
no forgiveness
kill them
That's certainly a take
- Yharim
To which i both agree and disagree
But i don't feel like talking about the moral complexities of that take
The government
And parents
if all slaves killed their masters, then the masters would no longer be able to have slaves
Does that truly make you better than them
because they would either be dead, or the slave that tried to kill them would
If you even can be a better person than someone
yes
murder is not worse than slavery
This is too morally complex for me to think about right now
Its also an interesting conversation cus is it truly worth killing to free yourself
amend that to is it worth killing your owner to free yourself an the answer is unquestionably yes
I mean if I’m correct he does see slavery worse than genocide
While yes I do think that is worth it you also gotta take into account that not all people who did it where evil outright and they have their own life beyond that
So I don't think it makes you better than him to kill
they threw that life and all their morals away when they decided that they were entitled to own another person
Although my brain is not functional enough rn for this typa convo
Both slavery and murder are inherently evil acts
I said that murder is not worse than slavery
I did not mention genocide
Genocide is different
My brain isnt functional enough like always
killing someone is not inherently evil actually
That's killing an entire race of people
self defense etc.
Its taking the life of another person
yeah
Is an animal hunting another evil?
in the case of self defense, that person is attempting to take your life or otherwise harm you and so it is not evil
There's a big difference between a person and an animal
it is natural
Comparing animals (literally needs food) to humans (moral being) doesn’t really work imo
objective morality does not exist and so therefore neither does inherent evil
If you need to eat another human to survive is it evil?
I mean in an extreme case it might be the only way to survive
the things we attribute to objective morality are actually just the overarching subjective morality of our society
It’s not evil necessarily
But killing a person is never a good thing
Its always a bad thing to do regardless of how you put it
Idk i think evil people kinda deserve it
It may not be evil but it is at the very minimum bad
I think it’s never a good thing but conditions can make it less bad
Yeah
what's the topic here
Like i dont wanna bring real life examples but i would 100% kill a dictator if i could
It can be less bad but it's never good
Philosophy part 3
You're still killing someone
Fucking moral philosophical discussion
Murder
oooooo interesting
no slavery is not my one exception to that, its just my belief that you should make people suffer for attempting to own you and that you should have the self-righteousness and dignity to attempt to make them pay for that
Thats like batman saying no i wont kill joker cuz killing bad
Always the same question
Meanwhile joker over there killing 40 guys
Gotham resident watching Joker kill his entire family just to get Batman’s attention
ask your slaver to free you immediately and at no cost, and if they refuse, torment them until they free you or they die
Aaand get punished severely
And die most likely
Then what would be the scenario where slavery is not evil?
if they kill you, then they lose as well
if every slave subscribed to this philosophy then slavery would be impossible
I don’t think there is one
Unless you count forced labour as a punishment slavery
I dont think there is one
Shit he typed faster than me
BUT they also are beat down into submission and had their individuality erased
And at that point it's hard to actually do anything
Very few people have the will to go through that and stay themselves
most slaves would never have the chance to build such a philosophy in the first place
It is treating one as an object rather than a person and thus preventing you from doing anything
Because what can an object do but stand there and take what happens
The only way slavery is not objectically evil is acording to those who practice it


