#suggestions-discussion

1 messages · Page 1212 of 1

eternal escarp
#

its simply to remove nuisances when you like, just exist somewhere and a random projectile that didnt get deleted destroyes a larva 20000 blocks away

#

i had this happen multiple times aswell, its quite annoying

sleek turret
#

pmuch everybody dislikes summoning QB by just using a weapon

#

esp. on pre-hm with stuff like starfury

crude geode
#

Imagine if Plantera spawns could be destroyed by weapons

eternal escarp
#

pain.

green spindle
#

What are you on about, im with him

#

I'm trying to save you time, is that too much to ask?

fossil finch
#

In any case, no, nucleogenesis recipe is fine
If crawmag mire is a problem in t3, fix that, don't change the nucleo recipe

eternal escarp
#

anyhow, with the new way the sugg star stuff works, how does sugg reposting work?

#

is it still like, a week after?

fossil finch
#

like normal

#

yea

eternal escarp
#

alright, cool

#

i think its been more then week since some of mines HDfailure

crude geode
#

It’s gonna be weird for a little while Byeah

small timber
#

I think it might already happen no? since they are removing restricted items

crude geode
#

Yeah it’s less useful than an accessory, so it should be easier to craft. Endogenesis is like one of the only endgame accessories I would consider complex enough, along with Rogue’s Nanotech.

small timber
#

I dont see laudanum staying rev since it really has nothing to do with rev

green spindle
#

all items are becoming accessible to every difficulty

#

except for demon heart

violet dagger
#

also why hasn't the new bot sent this yet

small timber
#

wait they changed stress pills and heart of darkness?

fossil finch
small timber
#

since they are exclusively ripper effect

violet dagger
#

oh

fossil finch
#

well tbf it is automatic

violet dagger
#

but it still has been a few days

fossil finch
#

It just doesn't happen instantly

small timber
violet dagger
#

its not my suggestion

eternal escarp
#

afaik Laudanum wasn't specifically mentioned, so im not fully sure on its fate

violet dagger
#

it just has a very high star count

fossil finch
#

I'm unsure that sugg is even affected tbh

eternal escarp
#

the recent talk was Malice and Expert items, not Rev once more

#

so idk

fossil finch
small timber
#

ya in that case I think just keep the suggestion, just in case

crude geode
#

@small timber Remove Necromantic Scroll, it’s already naturally obtained via pumpkin moon farming.

eternal escarp
#

(Also Rev will definitely keep some exclusive items seeing as other then Laudanum, they are all ripper related)

small timber
#

wait I accidently put it in because I brain farted it to be the combined with beetle version

violet dagger
#

it does seem the new bot did send some old ones

hollow shell
#

We currently have the bot delivering all highly starred suggestions since the 270 raise, in chronological order.

exotic stag
#

(also laggye)

hollow shell
#

So it is only a matter if time.

fossil finch
#

Cool then

hollow shell
#

Not suggs that're above 270, rather it's the top 20% of all the suggs in that period

eternal escarp
#

since i have the cooldown ill post the second repost here for now

hollow shell
#

(I think it's 20% for the catchup, it might be 10%.)

eternal escarp
#

Differentiate the Dank Staff from the Blood Clot Staff
The Dank Staff and the Blood Clot Staff currently posses the same AI and Statistics, with the only difference they currently hold being their appearance.
This was before excusable, due to the Perfect Dark / Vein Burster and Shadowdrop Staff / Blood Bath acting the same way, though as of the latest update, both of these pairs have gotten slight variations, like how Rot Balls and Tooth Balls both have different effects, to make them different , namely the Perf counterparts being slower but slightly stronger hitting.
Another weapon combo that was recently changed is the Night's / Carnage Rays, while not directly drops from Hive Mind and The Perforators, act similarly to their drops in theming.
Due to this recent change, the Dank Staff and the Blood Clot Staff remain to be the same weapon with a different skin, which makes them feel a bit off in relation to the rest of the pairs in Hive Mind's and The Perforators' drops.
The suggestion is to somehow differentiate or add some slight variations to each weapon, to not make them a carbon copy of each other like done with the other pairs mentioned of the same weapon pools.

anything to add to this or is it fine as is?

sleek turret
#

Good suggestion.

crude geode
#

yeah this is valid imo

eternal escarp
#

alright, nice

gray nebula
#

just saying slight variance kinda crungo you could ask for somthing more original ✨ as well but yes

crude geode
#

@small timber

The recipe is simply way too complicated to the point that the complexity of the recipe only exist to restrict stacking all minion slot downgrades in the game.
this isn't logical reasoning with how minion slot stacking has been removed

gray nebula
#

wowowowowwww turn the blood clots (cringe) into mini hives (awesome) that throw worms between one another

eternal escarp
#

i would have tbh

#

but that would have less of a basis

#

other then "hurdur boring"

gray nebula
#

wowowowowww turn dank thingies to have neuron things hanging below them

#

its ok

fossil finch
#

just have iban rework them anyways

eternal escarp
#

true!

small timber
#

I think it is logical no? the recipe complexity exist so that you basically cannot stack anything by making sure that all minion slot accessory are their downgrade

fossil finch
#

no lol!

gray nebula
#

im busy making the coolest sword you ever saw

#

🤬 i dont have infinite time grr

eternal escarp
#

wtf no way ANOTHER sword

gray nebula
#

not another

eternal escarp
#

:floshed

gray nebula
fossil finch
#

Just get more time 🙄
Just delay the update infinitely as you rework everything

crude geode
eternal escarp
#

alright there we go

exotic stag
eternal escarp
#

zenif with an f

crude geode
#

the recipe complexity exists because there's a lot of summoner accessories out there, not to "prevent minion slot stacking", because that's already been done by removing the ability to do so

exotic stag
small timber
#

then I will phrase it differnetly: let's say star-tainted generator only use jelly-charged battery, then you can stack minion slot with nuclear rod and starbuster core

#

the thing is since it use all 3 of them you cannot stack minion from any of them, basically it covers all minion stacking option

robust eagle
#

hey before i post an idea i have is suggesting vanities disallowed?

exotic stag
#

probably?

#

if its an SIS yes

#

(also just go calval)

crude geode
#

usually you get told to use calval

exotic stag
robust eagle
#

i mean it’d be a new one but you’re probably right

small timber
#

Wait flesh totem?

eternal escarp
#

so that you wont dodge and activate totem on the same hit?

small timber
#

Not aegis dash etc?

eternal escarp
#

if so then yeah proc is the right word

west jackal
#

Should I post a sugg about merging corro and crimslime staff or making them unique

small timber
#

Oh ok I got the order wrong, I thought he dont want a mirror to proc on a hit that is reduced by totem

eternal escarp
#

unique is obviously the better idea simply because summoner has the least amount of weapons in the game

west jackal
#

Ight

eternal escarp
unique vector
#

it was everything above 160, in ascending order

sonic sigil
#

I'm gonna go through that and vote since I haven't done that in a while

#

Alright crimslime and corroslime

#

Yeah

#

I just agree

hollow shell
inner lark
#

Why was my suggestion flagged @hollow shell

#

Hurry I need to go to bed I have school tomorrow

hollow shell
#

I actually do not see what you're talking about with the eyes 🤔

#

They look.. fine to me?

exotic stag
#

its one pixel off

#

thats what it is

#

the blue part around thanatos's eyes is one pixel off

inner lark
#

The left side is slightly lower than the right

exotic stag
#

(and ozza already stated its a troll)

inner lark
#

This is why I cant have nice things

hollow shell
#

Here's the real sheet so we don't gotta rely on that crusty one

#

Alright. I see. It's the little eye in the front

inner lark
#

Yep

#

I'm trying to draw a sketch of thanatos (still havent finished the head) and noticed that

exotic stag
#

(ozza stated it was a funny trole)

hollow shell
exotic stag
#

(no wait iban)

#

(not ozza

#

right upa here

hollow shell
#

Okay thank you

exotic stag
#

(i keep getting ozza and iban confused.)

violet dagger
#

iban moment

crude geode
#

To not be ironic, Iban is a massive troll

hollow shell
#

Krab you may as well acknowledge in your suggestion that it was an intentional decision but you would still prefer that it be changed for X reason

inner lark
hollow shell
crude geode
#

(It just looks unprofessional and unintentional)

hollow shell
#

Much better, thank you 👍

inner lark
exotic stag
#

(iban when they did an exo level trolling)

hollow shell
#

Ah I see

inner lark
#

Got maths intervention tomorrow

hollow shell
#

Sleep well CalSleep

inner lark
#

Thanks you toohellyes

unique vector
#

gonna notify everyone here all the suggs that got some sort of status change so far

exotic stag
#

coole

#

(i disagree'd with all but the bottom)

unique vector
exotic stag
#

subclass be like

violet dagger
#

I don't remember this suggestion but cool

unique vector
#

oh theres a bunch of unknowns that actually still exist here

#

oops

#

im going to test something dont get mad at me

#

@drowsy plank

#

okay discord is just stupid

exotic stag
#

yep discord stopide

grim tusk
#

Ranger needs to not be boring on accs

#

Its always sniper scope + artemis/magic quiver/elemental quiver + DSO/General dmg accs

crude geode
#

ranger and mage have always not had that many accessories

grim tusk
#

At least mage’s are interesting and sort of dynamic

#

Ranger is dmg go brrr

hollow shell
#

@wintry whale Can you elaborate on why you would like a late-game sentry build (or more sentries in general)? What about it is appealing to you, or how would it benefit Calamity?

crude geode
wintry whale
#

well it adds another way to play summoner

#

like how theres true melee and then normal melee

sonic sigil
#

Summoner has very little variety, sentries are really fun and you have like 3 max after Valhalla is unusable

hollow shell
#

That would be a good point to bring up yeah
Variety from typical mobile minions

wintry whale
#

i find the ability to have a different summoner entertaining and i think others would too

hollow shell
#

You should express that in your suggestion

sonic sigil
#

I agree

wintry whale
#

i can do that

sonic sigil
#

It could be as simple as just having an occasional accessory that gives like +1 sentry and a small buff and maybe armorsets giving an extra sentry like fearmonger or omega blue

crude geode
#

sentries are already hard enough to balance as is

#

they exist to give variety

sonic sigil
#

I don't know why they're seperate from summons but they are

crude geode
#

up until OOA happened and fucked sentry balance up the ass for the rest of time

sonic sigil
#

Yep

#

OOA is h

#

Basically

crude geode
#

thorium does sentry summoner pretty well

sonic sigil
#

Maybe they should just be tied together

#

Sentries taking minion slots

#

But maybe an extra free sentry slot like you have a summon slot

wintry whale
#

I would really like something like a later game armor set for sentries

boreal shoal
wintry whale
#

but even just like one or two more accesssorys for sentries would be nice

boreal shoal
#

always sniper scope and magic/elemental quiver

wintry whale
#

just to expand what summoners can do a little bit

sonic sigil
#

As it stands, ranger has about the same variety as summoner

#

(About 2 options)

unique vector
#

okay

#

prepare for a text wall

drowsy plank
sonic sigil
#

I'm prepped

grim tusk
#

Did i just got ghost pinged?

sonic sigil
#

Yes @grim tusk

unique vector
#

@feral ruin - #suggestions-voting message alternative spawn method for skeletron to be refought before first kill, approved
@crimson sonnet dupe suggestion topic
@sleek wadi dupe suggestion topic

@drowsy plank - #suggestions-voting message non consumable event spawners, approved (outdated, already exists)

@weary ledge - #suggestions-voting message more post-yharon rogue weapons, approved and on dev's todo

@pulsar marlin - #suggestions-voting message replace current yharon's theme with the newer version, approved and completed

@cobalt pewter - #suggestions-voting message unique furniture in Jungle Lab to spawn PBG, approved and on dev's todo

@grim hawk - #suggestions-voting message prevent cultist theme from overriding other music, approved

@full thistle - #suggestions-voting message give cryogen a unique summoning altar, approved and on dev's todo

@orchid turtle - #suggestions-voting message give amidias more use, approved and on dev's todo

@scarlet axle - #suggestions-voting message fix cnidrion spawning in the ocean, approved and completed (already in-game i think?)

@ripe owl - #suggestions-voting message give charm of myth's upgrades health regen, approved and completed

sonic sigil
#

That actually scared me somehow

unique vector
#

@eager hollow - #suggestions-voting message make cryogen's projectiles more visibile, approved and on dev's todo
@eager hollow dupe suggestion topic

@shell grotto - #suggestions-voting message remove or nerf timed DR, approved and on dev's todo

@grim tusk - #suggestions-voting message add more late-game tools, approved and on dev's to-do

@frozen hornet - #suggestions-voting message allow god slayer dash to ignore platforms, approved

@echo lion - #suggestions-voting message make charred idol craftable at a mythril anvil, approved

@mellow comet - #suggestions-voting message remove guide's dialogue about altars, approved

@earnest raptor - #suggestions-voting message reduce item prices to be closer to vanilla prices, approved

@cosmic musk - #suggestions-voting message remove providence becoming invincible outside of hallow / hell, approved

@cobalt pewter - #suggestions-voting message make ore slimes not slimes, approved and on dev's todo

#

thats all of them so far

#

ill be doing this more frequently so that it wont be a text wall

silver silo
#

nothing from me 😭

hardy dock
#

Oh sweet

grim tusk
#

Pixl about to get banned for mass ping PensiveDoGCowboy

unique vector
#

if ur sugg has a high star count then it probably hasnt gone through yet

silver silo
#

whats the required star count atm

unique vector
#

they're being sent from lowest to highest stars, post 160+

#

uhh

jagged spade
#

it was so far away

unique vector
#

so RIGHT NOW every suggestion after the 270 star count changed is being forwarded

#

if they have 160+ stars

sonic sigil
#

Whooo boy that's a lot of accepted changes

exotic stag
#

HDfailure sugg verification system so we dont get stupid dupeys

#

(y'know the old google form thing i had)

#

(a while back)

unique vector
exotic stag
#

i mean

unique vector
#

unless u like program some sort of word checker

exotic stag
#

you can..?

unique vector
#

whcih is like

#

work

exotic stag
#

some bots have it

unique vector
#

shrug

silver silo
unique vector
#

just suggest less dupes lole

exotic stag
#

like "complete this google form to get access to this"

unique vector
jagged spade
#

so the check mark means its gonna get forwarded right

exotic stag
#

(uh pink. thats moderator voting not sugg voting)

sonic sigil
unique vector
#

✅ --> its been sent to devs and is undergoing voting

jagged spade
#

alright thanks

unique vector
#

👍 --> approved, etc etc

exotic stag
#

pixl you..

#

well

unique vector
#

fuck

exotic stag
#

(i dont think many of us have that channel)

#

yep

unique vector
#

thats the correct one lol

ripe owl
exotic stag
#

casually leaking mod chats confirmed

unique vector
#

so true

sonic sigil
#

Yo let's meet up in mod voting

crimson sonnet
#

@unique vector thank u so much man 😄

exotic stag
#

(numbers but not wits)

unique vector
#

yus

silver silo
crude geode
#

That is indeed how it works ngl

unique vector
#

btw "on dev's to-do" either means someone is actively working on it, or has already been under development for a little while

#

smile

exotic stag
#

(i.e the nerf rdr thing)

sonic sigil
#

I think stuff gets sent after a week of it's over 160 stars

crude geode
#

Finally that piece of shit gets reworked

exotic stag
#

which. theres like 6

west jackal
#

crystal

grim tusk
#

Finally being able to not carry astral pick AND blossom/lunar pick at all times for mining fast will be quite nice

exotic stag
#

theres still like 56.

sonic sigil
#

Also I appreciate all of the work you put into making the people who play the mod happy

west jackal
#

Yharim crystal

unique vector
#

yus

#

just keep in mind that like

exotic stag
unique vector
#

even if its approved, it doesnt mean it'll get done right awaay

#

since it may be slotted to fit with a future update we already planned on doing

crude geode
#

Approved is barely “it will be done”

sonic sigil
unique vector
#

approved is "we like your idea and we'll do it at some point"

silver silo
#

approved is ''we like this'' flag is ''we're doing this''

crude geode
#

It’s merely “we like this :)”

unique vector
#

flag is "its already done"

#

you're looking for 🛠️ which is "we're actively doing this/have already planned this"

silver silo
#

ah

unique vector
exotic stag
#

okay but

#

hear me out

#

if we have point blank

#

why not damage falloff

grim tusk
#

True (not even a single point blank acc?)

unique vector
#

at the moment we do not like that idea

exotic stag
#

(make ranger players suffer even moar)

grim tusk
#

Also going the “more projectiles” route like rogue had before 1.4.4 also boring

unique vector
#

we don't consider it a fundamental aspect of ranger right now to manipulate the class around it

grim tusk
#

AND LAGGY AS FUCK

exotic stag
#

well uh

silver silo
#

''we''

exotic stag
#

make ranger players mad by adding damage falloff HDfailure

silver silo
#

the developer hivemind

unique vector
#

yes, we

#

aka eveyrone that voted no

#

whcih was like 6-7 people iirc

silver silo
#

I like to imagine its the royal we

unique vector
#

dont think it got a single upvote

exotic stag
#

pfft

#

rip that guy

unique vector
exotic stag
west jackal
#

Ranger just needs an overhaul in general

#

Most boring class

boreal shoal
#

I don't get it why Empyrean knives is melee, why not make Solar sword but rogue daryl

unique vector
#

@slate turtle - #suggestions-voting message easier spawning methods for duke fishron and old duke, approved (??) we did discuss that like, you can literally buy truffle worms and bloody worms arent too hard to farm either

#

but i guess it got approved

#

we may deny it again depends

exotic stag
#

(oh btw. i always wondered but why is ranger considered this "long range class" when 90% of its weapons are close ranged anyway?)

unique vector
#

bc ranger sucks

exotic stag
#

well yes

#

if it sucks. make it suck more then

west jackal
#

It’s because getting the bloodworm during an acid rain is annoying as hell

orchid turtle
#

Wasn’t my vanilla npc store suggestion put in for voting?

boreal shoal
#

Actual long range class is summoner lol

orchid turtle
#

Or is that not done yet?

grim tusk
exotic stag
#

every class no matter what ends up being long range

west jackal
#

Make it so rangers only have a certain amount of ammo for each boss:Troll:

grim tusk
#

(Onyx blaster line doesnt count, they become machineguns)

exotic stag
boreal shoal
#

even sword has long range projectile

west jackal
#

Mashotguns

exotic stag
#

(and yes they do. cause the AA12 exists. and its real)

west jackal
#

Ight who’s gonna make the burning sky sugg

orchid turtle
#

Ranged is a kinda strange class when you put it like that. Literally everything can become ranged damage and the only thing separating ranger is ammo and the weapon has to be a gun or bow.

grim tusk
#

Rocket launcher

exotic stag
#

rocket launchers are ech

grim tusk
#

Also dart

crude geode
#

mfw a class doesn’t have 50 accessories to it’s name hage

orchid turtle
#

I don’t think there’s a calamity dart weapon

boreal shoal
#

melee but throw knives

orchid turtle
#

Although there really should be

exotic stag
#

there is

#

like one but

#

there is

grim tusk
sonic sigil
#

Gun, Bow, Rocket Launcher, Flamethrower, and Etc.

#

The 5 ranger types

#

2 are used

boreal shoal
#

Charged dart blaster can shred deus easily

sonic sigil
#

Oh wow one boss

exotic stag
boreal shoal
#

an example

orchid turtle
#

Darts are so good though

sonic sigil
#

Cannons such as

exotic stag
#

bunny gun

unique vector
#

suggestion discussion on their way to ask for another subclass weapon bc its quirky and cool

sonic sigil
#

Those are Etc

unique vector
#

when do we ban suggs that focus on adding a subclass weapon

orchid turtle
#

It’s an extra ammo type so you can easily apply more debuffs without having to set up your inventory with ammo for 20 minutes.

#

Are there calamity darts though?

#

Like acid darts instead of acid bullets?

west jackal
#

I don’t think so

crude geode
#

Ranged already has the most distinct subclasses and is second best in terms of weapon why does it also need more accessories

unique vector
#

i will say something about burning sky @west jackal oops never mind i will not

exotic stag
#

(all im sayin is make ranger not just the same as all the other classes. give it something like the scout from tf2's power. hes a range class that can snipe but do little and when hes up close he does like funny)

#

(Because point blank doesnt work right)

unique vector
#

i will simply let the suggestion go through for now pretend i said nothing

west jackal
#

What

unique vector
#

we do a little trolling

crude geode
#

(Burning Sky is probably already on the list of shit to be fixed)

orchid turtle
#

Now that I’m thinking about it, more dart types isn’t that bad a suggestion.

grim tusk
deft yew
#

imagine if burning sky swung normally and landing hits gave you charge
and at full charge you could perform a windup animation that summons the meteors
gorbbrain

west jackal
#

I mean it’s hard to say anything about other than it isn’t melee

exotic stag
#

but resentful is cringe

unique vector
#

look at all your lil brains go

#

im going to steal them and enslave them as idea tanks

exotic stag
#

no

silver silo
exotic stag
#

(just hire some people as idea tanks)

deft yew
#

take mine (at the same time, don’t)

west jackal
#

I’m filing a lawsuit call your lawyer

crude geode
#

Ranged users when they only have 4 pretty damn distinct subclasses and the second most number of weapons: hage

exotic stag
unique vector
#

we dont hire people

#

tbf

west jackal
#

The problem with ranger isn’t the amount of items it that it’s boring as hell

crude geode
deft yew
exotic stag
sonic sigil
#

Pay me $1 per good idea I give you towards the mod

exotic stag
#

darts

sonic sigil
#

Easy deal

crude geode
west jackal
orchid turtle
#

I feel this is a good suggestion.

ripe owl
orchid turtle
#

A sideweapon to apply unique debuffs without swapping out your main ammo. Makes dart guns actually viable late game.

crude geode
west jackal
unique vector
boreal shoal
#

Ok summoner is the most popular here

#

Rip ranger

unique vector
#

our team is built on inviting trusted members that show they like, actively care to work on the mod for more than two weeks

orchid turtle
#

When’s the last time you used a flamethrower?

exotic stag
unique vector
#

we dont outright hire people

exotic stag
#

hire uh

#

hire jimbo

ripe owl
unique vector
#

true

exotic stag
#

(ok but seriously you guys really need idea tanks so uhe)

full thistle
#

Ranged users when photovosceratorgets nerfed

crude geode
crude geode
unique vector
#

i dont take care of suggs

jagged spade
unique vector
#

thats rover's job

exotic stag
unique vector
#

we need more time is what we need lol

crude geode
exotic stag
#

(then take more time lol. make players wait)

unique vector
#

no bc it adds developer strain too

exotic stag
#

(its just like all the people begging for tml 1.4. make them wait)

hollow shell
#

What why

exotic stag
full thistle
unique vector
#

we had a huge issue with how long 1.5 took bc we just wanted the update out but we kept adding more and more stuff

#

so it became too stressful

crude geode
west jackal
#

Plan stuff and add shit in later updates

grim tusk
# unique vector im going to steal them and enslave them as idea tanks

Ideas:
Monsoon’s Dystopia as a rogue weapon
Ranged acc that makes every xth bullet explode
Upgrade to mana polarizer
Rework Deific Thunderbolt to not suck balls
Buff Resentful, Persecuted and Indignant
Nerf Ephemeral and Oblatory
Auric shurikens
A post-ML shotgun that FEELS like an actual shotgun that is not Angelic shotgun nor a Machine-shotgun
Pre-hm explosive magic staff
Rover drive reworked to be more like temporary hp point shield that then breaks and has to reload
Adamanite setbonus changed to: the more hits you do, the more dmg you do (capped at 10)
Mythril setbonus: leaf shield from mega man
Cobalt setbonus makes you fast similar to how palladium makes you heal
An enchantment that makes rogue unable to stealth strike but hits far harder when stealth is full

exotic stag
#

(how about none of those)

crude geode
#

Wall of text in sugg discussion (cringe)

exotic stag
#

(Because 90% of them reference either specific shit)

#

(or stuff that shouldnt be needed)

novel belfry
west jackal
#

Not all ideas from the tank are good

hollow shell
#

also yeah @west jackal , Burning Sky was deliberately made to not swing, as a cynical lambast of "projectile melee".
Nobody would ever hit something with the true melee swing of it. It was a sword that covered the entire screen with projectiles. So why even treat it like a sword?

But, don't worry. We do have plans to make it into a real melee weapon (or at least less of a mage weapon) while still keeping its identity.

jagged spade
west jackal
hollow shell
#

yeh

deft yew
#

Oh nuts

full thistle
#

I think you guys should just cut your losses and make the megaman leaf shield

deft yew
#

Provi no longer invincible outside hallow/hell

#

Provi is now an everywhere boss

crude geode
#

Shouldn’t the latest suggestion count for subclass don’t

orchid turtle
#

Similarly to the dart suggestion, does calamity already have more flamethrower ammo then just normal gel?

crude geode
#

Based pixl

grim tusk
west jackal
#

More flamethrower ammo would be cool as hell

crude geode
#

Coding wise

unique vector
#

also rover never said they're banning subclass sugs

novel belfry
unique vector
#

i was half joking when i said that

crude geode
#

Fair

exotic stag
#

burning sky cringe

unique vector
#

did u read more than 5 words into the message or

orchid turtle
#

Maybe not a craftable ammo, but it would be cool to use more mob drops as ammo.

#

Like depth cells as flamethrower ammo, even if that doesn’t make too much sense

novel belfry
full thistle
crude geode
silver silo
#

calamity fans when words gone

deft yew
full thistle
#

Maybe I’m remembering wrong then

exotic stag
#

your health is a drop technically

#

because hearts are a drop

west jackal
#

A flamethrower that uses planty mush

orchid turtle
#

Honestly I just think more unique ammo weapons would be really cool.

west jackal
#

Could make it at a furnace or something

#

The ammo not the thrower

hollow shell
#

Anyway yes Slice of Ham your reasoning needs to be more expanded

west jackal
#

Cause planty mush is pretty useless unless you forgot a couple life fruits

hollow shell
#

We do have a Don't that says you can't make suggestions solely for the purpose of making a subclass playthrough viable
But if you can provide enough reason for why a subclass should be expanded without relying on "Well I was trying to do a thing where I used only this weapon type-", then the suggestion is fine

unborn siren
full thistle
#

More ammo for some of the more boring ranges weapons would be good, because the whole point of having different ammo types is to add variety to weapons that are boring on their own

hollow shell
#

Yes I think your suggestion looks good

sonic sigil
#

Yea

wintry whale
#

Thank

crude geode
#

Also it’s more valid mainly because summoner lacks a lot of the variety that something like ranged has

hollow shell
#

You put enough focus on Summoner playthrough variety

wintry whale
#

Coolio

hollow shell
#

Untapped potential, options

boreal shoal
#

Even without summon, summoner still on the first place I bet

west jackal
#

So about my corroslime sugg

#

They really need a change

orchid turtle
full thistle
west jackal
#

Yeah

full thistle
#

Massive difference

west jackal
#

And they drop from the same boss

full thistle
#

Where else would they drop from tho

west jackal
#

I say either merge it or unique it

full thistle
#

Make one drop from piggy I think

crude geode
#

Unique is preferable

exotic stag
#

aew

west jackal
#

Yeah I didn’t put merge in the sugg

full thistle
hollow shell
#

Stop

exotic stag
#

(okay but what would be your guys' opinions on making critters more useful lo)

hollow shell
crude geode
#

Golden gun exists for this specific reason.

west jackal
crude geode
#

If you want a cursed variant ask for it.

orchid turtle
#

Just the ability to use more types of ammo without arranging bullets in groups of 20 in your inventory.

exotic stag
#

cause so far their used for what? decoration and food right?

orchid turtle
#

Debuffs yeah, but it kinda takes the big point in ammo away from ranger if I just make a stack of acid bullets and use nothing else until the next bullet type.

full thistle
#

And powerful weaponry

hollow shell
crude geode
orchid turtle
#

Maybe a ammo shuffler accessory

exotic stag
#

theres like 20 or so critters.

orchid turtle
#

That’s specific but really cool actually.

exotic stag
#

and only 2 or 3 uses

sonic sigil
#

That'd be probably really hard to make

west jackal
#

And bugs for fishing but that’s about it

#

I think they are fine the way they are

exotic stag
#

(Their bugs and very tiny so what are you going to do with them? make a potroast?)

hollow shell
#

(I am entertaining the idea of whether or not Golden Gun's existence is harmful
But, I'd need to look into it more)

eternal escarp
#

critters add to an ambiance of the enviroment

#

they do that well

crude geode
#

Not everything in terraria is about boss fights. Some of it is just decorations/aesthetics/ambience

eternal escarp
#

dont think they need more uses

west jackal
#

ichor trumps cursed flame in everyway possible

eternal escarp
#

some of them are already fishing bait aswell so

sonic sigil
#

I don't see a use for golden gun outside of summoner

hollow shell
sonic sigil
#

Every other class has consistent debuffs

hollow shell
#

Cursed Inferno reduces enemy DR

west jackal
#

I thought the dr thing was removed a while ago

sonic sigil
#

Nope

hollow shell
#

Nope

west jackal
#

I guess not

hollow shell
#

Well, it was on Ichor

#

But then it got moved to Cursed Inferno

#

iirc

sonic sigil
#

Relegated to malice only soon I think

exotic stag
sonic sigil
#

RDR not DR

west jackal
#

I’m not talking about rdr though

hollow shell
#

Yeah no, not talking about Reactive DR

sonic sigil
#

DR is staying everywhere

eternal escarp
sonic sigil
#

Flames is better than ichor now imo

full thistle
#

And also not a weapon

eternal escarp
#

same effect as a normal weapon that spawns like, rabbits and squirrels to fight

west jackal
#

Dot debuffs are usually very useless against bosses

full thistle
#

That is very wrong imo

west jackal
#

Except worm bosses which are shredded by em

#

Ones that aren’t immune at least

full thistle
#

Especially with the soon coming elemental rebuff change they’re gonna be even better

eternal escarp
hollow shell
#

But we're working on fixing that in the coming future

west jackal
#

Terraria class be unique challenge

eternal escarp
#

summoner exists already

west jackal
eternal escarp
#

and is quite remarkably the most unique

west jackal
#

Yeah but the 3 others are the same

#

Projectiles

#

True melee is a little better

hollow shell
#

We will
slowly
make melee great again

#

Less proj spam

eternal escarp
#

happy.

west jackal
#

But it is difficult to make a class unique

exotic stag
#

(melee was never great)

eternal escarp
#

also mage and ranger follow the same principle in different ways
thats what makes them atleast differ which is fine

full thistle
#

Relogic making their melee class shoot projectiles

hollow shell
#

Magic Ranged and Rogue are indeed quite similar in primary gameplay
Though Rogue and arguably Magic have the incentive for you to modify your movement to improve your combat ability (stealth and mana regen)

west jackal
#

Rouge is getting better tbh

hollow shell
#

and Ranged can modify almost all their weapons with different effects using ammo

#

But generally
they do often boil down to
"click and hold your cursor on the boss"

west jackal
#

Yeah

orchid turtle
#

Yeah but that’s just terraria I’m general.

boreal shoal
#

So many people hate useturn

eternal escarp
#

i also look at the fact Mage usually has more interesting weapons that act uniquely and Ranger is more streamlined in its weapons byeah

west jackal
#

I don’t know how orchid plays but those classes look like the most unique that’ll be seen in terraria

#

Gives some strategy instead of getting the strongest weapon

orchid turtle
#

Also mage weapon designs. Your using a gun or a bow if your ranger.(rocket launchers and flamethrowers are visually similar to guns). Mage weapons can be almost anything.

hollow shell
#

(but they usually fall into 3 archetypes as laid out by the wiki)

#

(staff, book, magic gun)

eternal escarp
#

tbf mage's Wand/Staff archetype is

#

incredibly vague

orchid turtle
#

Sure, but it can also be a skull, or a flower, or a prism, or a gauntlet.

eternal escarp
#

Brimstone Wand/Staff i forgot is wildly different to say, Arctic Bear Paw

#

both behaving like wands vaguely

#

or Eldritch Tome to say, Abyssal Tome

orchid turtle
#

It’s mostly like that, but there’s no limiting factor for future weapons either.

orchid turtle
# eternal escarp Brimstone Wand/Staff i forgot is wildly different to say, Arctic Bear Paw

Yeah, that’s also true. A staff can hit an enemy and lightning will smite them from the sky and they’ll turn into an explosion while spawning tentacles, a gun might have a unique color of fire debuff it can inflict or shoot an extra bullet per shot. There’s very few unique fire methods, especially early game. At least compared to mage, but that may be the best to keep mage so unique.

unique vector
#

mage weapon designs are sucky

#

im personally going through them to make some cooler

violet dagger
#

old mage weapon designs mainly

#

newer ones are really cool

#

in particular rancor is really fucking cool

unique vector
#

yeah

#

everything in HM is kinda like

#

bland or "staff/book projectile #47"

exotic stag
#

or "die instantly"

sonic sigil
#

Yeah it does kinda feel that way aside from some cooler concept weapons

#

Ion blaster and the flower that hurts you are cool concepts

violet dagger
#

also isn't there that one dungeon book that is literally a sentry

sonic sigil
#

From malice plantera I think

violet dagger
#

wrath of the ancients

sonic sigil
#

Yeah

violet dagger
#

has it been suggested before to make that a sentry

#

best suggestion to ever be posted

unique vector
#

@surreal ermine im just

#

deleting that

cobalt pewter
#

Miasma is a downgrade from Nimbus Rod

unique vector
cobalt pewter
#

what was it

unique vector
#

find something else to do

surreal ermine
#

xD

unique vector
#

like idk play a game

cobalt pewter
#

bruh HDfailure

unborn siren
surreal ermine
#

school

#

and i cant focus on anything for some reason

cobalt pewter
surreal ermine
#

ok

exotic stag
surreal ermine
#

ok

cobalt pewter
#

that too

exotic stag
#

listen to music while sleep?

surreal ermine
#

PETITION TO ADD WHIPS TO CALAMITY MOD

exotic stag
#

future content

#

no

cobalt pewter
#

no

silver silo
#

no

exotic stag
#

no

cobalt pewter
#

@unique vector looks like another job HDfailure

exotic stag
#

aw you ruined it loki

unique vector
#

que

gray nebula
#

next update adds a whip i think

unique vector
#

yeah the 1.4 update

#

://////////

cobalt pewter
unborn siren
unique vector
#

@surreal ermine stop with the suggestions from your boredome

unique vector
#

im going to warn you for that, please just find something else to do

exotic stag
#

listen to music.

silver silo
grim tusk
#

Also wh*ps

grim tusk
cobalt pewter
cosmic musk
#

oh good that suggestion made it to the team after all!

#

sick

crude geode
# grim tusk How much was it nerfed?

not as much in terms of dps, though frankly idk, moreso in design/uniqueness. It goes from being a cloud spawner that rains down onto enemies into a random shotgun blast that looks like clouds.

novel belfry
#

that's a very odd sugg but i do like this, especially given how calamity changed wings

copper crow
#

Sniper scope should show a Lazer beam of where your bullet will go when you shoot it

#

And a dotted line of where your gravity affected arrows will go

#

After you shoot them

#

To make it more useful

cobalt pewter
#

no one really goes to sniper scope for the scope anyways

#

they're going for the stats

#

and the stats is way more than enough

#

unless you want to nerf the stats as well

copper crow
#

Just replace the extra view that no one wants

#

With a red line

#

That some people could use

#

It doesn't have a game breaking change to have a stat nerf

crude geode
#

no one wants
some people could use
I love completely unprovable statements like this

cobalt pewter
#

making ranger more braindead ikz

copper crow
#

Also it would be useful to have some sort of item that projects where arrows will go

crude geode
#

it's impossible to prove that nobody wants the extra range of sniper scope, or that anybody would use a laser scope

copper crow
#

Well I'm obviously not stating that statistically

#

0 people use the extra vision

#

Of the scope

#

But almost no one uses it

#

Unless in pvp

copper crow
cobalt pewter
#

what does summoner have anything to do with the suggestion

#

it is braindead

hollow shell
#

@ashen warren I assume you mean a display for wings equipped sprites?

ashen warren
#

Yes, I do

#

I'd love that to be implemented

#

I have an entire armor room built, showcasing all of calamities armor sets.

#

So wings, would be a great addition

#

@hollow shell

hollow shell
#

Alright. Could be a bit clearer in your sugg that that's what you want, cuz I saw your sugg and was tempted to say "just use Item Frames"

ashen warren
#

I see... sorry..

#

I'll go edit.

#

Maybe some way to add them to armor statues?

#

Is more of what I meant.

pure fiber
#

Ok, so what suggestions do I make here exactly?

frail mantle
#

Suggestions for things or changes you want in the mod

pure fiber
#

Is that correct or did I miss something?

#

So something more vague?

#

Ok cool, got it!

grim tusk
#

Which is worse in terms of everything

unique vector
#

the tl;dr is: suggest something as if you were the one actually designing something in-game

#

does it make sense?

#

and also just dont be overtly specific with like “oh this does X damage with C effects”

eternal escarp
#

there is pretty much a whole rework planned for the crags so im not sure how needed this sugg is

tardy harness
#

Really?

#

Ok

eternal escarp
#

ye

#

details are in the art server as part of a submission event if you want to go read on it

tardy harness
#

Where is the art server

eternal escarp
#

darn

unique vector
#

explode

exotic stag
#

ka BEWM

boreal shoal
#

I simp scal

exotic stag
#

@wicked prism formatting and reasoning please.

keen zealot
#

So, for this thanatos eyes thing...

#

I'm pretty sure those aren't his eyes, but I still agree they should be symmetrical

#

the implied spheroids directly below the "eyes" make much more sense as eyes

boreal shoal
#

I thought there is no perfection guy

sonic sigil
#

What

boreal shoal
#

what

exotic stag
#

(okay but the snowball cannon is good for like. two bosses)

robust eagle
#

yeah but like

#

why not

#

i needed it and again

#

used in crafting other weapons

exotic stag
#

its used in like two recipes and thats it.

#

flurrystorm cannon being one

robust eagle
#

yeah so add a crafting recipe

#

it’s a pretty good weapon

#

used in crafting another pretty good one

#

there are already crafting recipes for a ton of other items obtainable in chests

neat linden
#

that uses snowball cannon

exotic stag
exotic stag
neat linden
#

as for the ench boomerang sugg

exotic stag
#

ench is fine

neat linden
#

that one is fairly good

#

it's used for an endgame weapon

exotic stag
#

because more then one weapon use enchanted boomerang

neat linden
#

(celestus)

exotic stag
#

and isnt flurrystorm a dev item?

neat linden
#

donor item

#

close enough

robust eagle
#

i mean there’s a recipe for the slime staff

exotic stag
#

because slime staff is more useful

#

used for more then 2 bosses.

robust eagle
#

it’s the like 2nd earliest summon in the game

neat linden
#

ds, ks and uh

#

what else?

robust eagle
#

idk it seemed like i really needed it

gray nebula
#

simply put it in c rates

eternal escarp
#

also i could have sworn its jn cratse already?

neat linden
#

(ok fr too many people hate fishing)

eternal escarp
#

too bad for them

gray nebula
#

ok then explore

eternal escarp
#

trol

gray nebula
#

i stg people are playing on ultra small worlds or sth

#

every time i find multiple of every chest item

#

3 shoe spikes before hermes

stiff wren
deft yew
#

enchanted boomerang issue uhhh

just wait until 1.4 hdflr

exotic stag
neat linden
#

The whole "this boss takes reduced damage from x weapon" usually doesn't even do a lot

#

For example, deus takes reduced damage from tenebreus tides, yet the weapon is able to shred him

#

I feel like that's more of a "being a worm boss" issue rather than specifically Lazhar being the issue

eager hollow
neat linden
#

Also from what i've noticed

#

Deus has a funny tendency to get bullied by weapons that would normally be considered outdated kek

exotic stag
#

deus is naturally just the worm boss to bully

neat linden
#

examples include hydraulic volt crasher, sea's searing, orichalcum spiked gemstones (especially if you hit his spawn clump), blazing star

exotic stag
#

because of the fact he has a high HP pool. isnt as fast as DoG. and thick

neat linden
#

possibly even stormfront razor, idk i can't get it to work that well

exotic stag
#

any weapon can beat deus.

#

(infact its funny. because even explosive weapons beat him)

neat linden
#

pretty sure star cannon would unironically work decently well

exotic stag
#

(yeah im fine with the aurora sugg. its just a little qol thing)

still zodiac
#

I was thinking about something, is there any particular reason why butterfly dust is sold by witch doctor after golem

sonic sigil
#

Deus just dies yeah

sonic sigil
neat linden
#

Not sure about calam

fossil finch
#

Yuh can't even add it,
That's why this is sugged here

neat linden
#

the accessories were on tier

#

the weapon wasn't

sonic sigil
#

What is osgs

#

Not Old Duke God Slayer

#

Orichalcum Spiked Gemstones?

neat linden
#

Yes

sonic sigil
#

Yeah maybe deus needs a teensy bit of pierce protection

violet dagger
#

wait what does a lock reaction mean

exotic stag
#

probably something already does that

urban smelt
tawny garden
#

wow holy shit

exotic stag
#

is that the most starred sugg during the 270 thing

tawny garden
#

it's one of the most starred overall lmao

eternal escarp
#

the system was already changed though iirc

exotic stag
#

(it is but its funny)

tawny garden
#

guess so

tawny garden
#

the OCD was strong on that one

exotic stag
#

yeah screw the icicle arrow in particular

spare prawn
#

im thinking of a suggestion for true melee

#

that true melee should be given more options for parrying

#

because iirc only the brand of the inferno can do the "perfect parry" right now

#

but it would make sense for true melee, while making it more suvivable but still skill based

exotic stag
#

(ok but imagine a countering mechanic)

quaint stream
#

Yes just imagine countering moonlord laser and one shoting it

exotic stag
#

well no thats-

#

you'd have to hit him

drowsy plank
#

i think it was pretty obvious this was talking about countering contact damage

spare prawn
#

im mostly talking about like

drowsy plank
#

last i checked don't think you can parry projectiles with brand lmao

spare prawn
#

take the inferno brand parry mechanic

#

and apply it to true melee in general

crude geode
#

Pretty sure that’s been brought up b4

spare prawn
#

boop yahrons nosy wosy and then hit him for a few dozen thousand damage

#

yep

#

thats the exact suggestion i was gonna do

#

it has been over a month

#

should i ping the og suggester?

#

also, darksouls has a parry right? fabsol is a DS addict, its perfect

exotic stag
#

(oh shit turkey tom uplaod woo)

spare prawn
#

who?

exotic stag
#

turkey tom the guy who makes long good videos

#

anyway cya

grim tusk
hot zephyr
#

my best suggestion 🥺

#

wtf embed

exotic stag
#

wtf embed!?

spare prawn
#

i mean

#

ori spiked gems are just kinda op

crude geode
#

excuse me discord wtf

grim tusk
hot zephyr
#

i fixed it

#

simple I just remembered how I worded that suggestion

crude geode
exotic stag
grim tusk
hot zephyr
#

use ID

grim tusk
#

Nothing

exotic stag
#

well it works for me and not for youe

grim tusk
#

Maybe mobile moment

hot zephyr
#

skill issue

unique vector
tawny garden
#

which one's that

dapper coral
tawny garden
#

you know it

hot zephyr
#

mmm stars

unique vector
#

the one i pinged ppl with if their sugg got a status update

#

rover will write an official pinned legend by friday iirc

tawny garden
#

searching from you pinging pogseal doesn't return much of anything

crude geode
unique vector
#

wtf

#

god

#

update yus

#

i asked them if they wanted me yo write it for them and they said they’ll write it on friday once we’re done with the sugg backlog

#

so yea

crude geode
#

Fair

tawny garden
#

ah

unique vector
#

gimme like an hour or two and ill notify all the new suggs that got status changes

exotic stag
#

@drowsy plank your sugg has a lot of "1.4 rolls around" points in it. dont do that as thats a future content sorta thing

#

(also most of those items you mentioned are kinda useless.)

#

(ooh a spear so useful.)

drowsy plank
#

so?

#

and i get that part, but i mostly was saying it (only twice) as the point that the devs might've already had plans for some of the ideas, so those could easily be passed over

#

it would be weird to say "add a crate for the ice biome" considering that is a feature that has already been implemented in an update the mod has every intention of moving to just to have a single ore drop, and honestly the spear and boomerang could just straight up be craftable with iron or wood considering how bad they are, but the more important issue was that the crates randomly just have different drop tables with a ton of items removed (making them unsustainable) for literally no apparent reason.

unique vector
#

i think its

#

fine

#

i could be wrong

sleek turret
#

I agree

#

Good suggestion.

drowsy plank
#

thx

unique vector
#

prepare for

#

text wall

crude geode
#

Pog

unique vector
#

when the unknown user

#
Approved

@stable wedge - #suggestions-voting message [Despawn boss minions if the boss is defeated]
@cobalt pewter - #suggestions-voting message [Make Aero Slimes spawn in Space, Underground, & Cavern layers]
@earnest raptor - #suggestions-voting message [Add better/more thematic Abyss chest loot]
@wintry wharf - #suggestions-voting message [Rename the Unstable Prism to the Unstable Granite Core]
@lean parcel - #suggestions-voting message [Reduce Yharon's invincibility time when transitioning between phase 1 to 2]
@crude geode - #suggestions-voting message [Add more situations where hordes of enemies are the main difficulty]
@half kayak - #suggestions-voting message [Remove Lead Core from Silva Armor Recipe]
@shell grotto - #suggestions-voting message [Change accessories that give bonuses for standing still to fluctuate their stats based on movement speed]

#

@paper torrent @lapis canyon repinging bc discord fucked up

half kayak
#

cool

dusty path
crude geode
#

Finally barrels will not be called trash

dusty path
#

I see

unique vector
#

it depends on 1.4's flexibility but we have an indirect solution to the limited buffs problem

#

the only issue was that we did not want to outright give you more slots, since that can infinitely make the player more powerful and broken

dusty path
#

Understood

#

A fusion of buffs or making slots for only debuffs, perhaps?

#

Or idk

unique vector
#

likely the latter

dusty path
#

Hmm

#

Better solution

exotic stag
unique vector
#

i like my emotes

crude geode
#

It’s like the one reason to get nitro

exotic stag
#

(i dont even have many good emotes)

#

this is my best one

dapper coral
#

(it do be 61 in the secret chats)

unique vector
#

so true

exotic stag
unique vector
#

its cute wtf do u mean

#

:(

exotic stag
#

the goose head

#

looks very

#

strang

dusty path
drowsy plank
#

hella

wintry whale
#

Congrats lol im glad its approved too since fighting the phantasmal dragon after lunatic cultist is already despawned is incredibly annoying lol

granite sphinx
#

cosmilite drop rates suck right now and have for awhile so hearing that is awesome

unique vector
granite sphinx
#

something i just thought of that i wish i could put into the original suggestion

#

maybe it would be wise to raise the drop rate to 65+ bars now and add in Cosmilite Ore during a later large mainline update?

unique vector
#

it may depend on what we do with the distortion biome

granite sphinx
#

remind me what the distortion biome is

unique vector
#

buffing it to 65+ bars seems a bit much though lol at that point u might as well reduce the amt of bars each item needs

stable wedge
granite sphinx
#

i literally woke up barely 15 minutes ago

unique vector
#

post-ml subworld that we've mentioned here and there publicly

granite sphinx
#

ah

stable wedge
unique vector
#

we havent mentioned any specifics yet though

#

basically yea

stable wedge
#

the thing braelor and statis was thrown into

#

(and died in)

granite sphinx
unique vector
#

(to be fair braelor and statis are kinda like old calamity lore i have no clue if that still applies)

unique vector
#

we might do something abou tit

granite sphinx
#

its not unreasonable to craft more than 15 items after killing dog requiring cosmilite

#

i say 65+ cause the entire armor set is 55 and the anvil is 10

unique vector
#

you dont ever get enough boss mats to craft a full armor set in any other tiers anyway

granite sphinx
#

the anvil is directly required for progression, and the armor is needed for Auric Tesla

unique vector
#

i dont think that really

#

changes anything though

fossil finch
unique vector
#

many other things are also needed for progression lols

fossil finch
#

(real

granite sphinx
#

sorry, i dont think i understand your point

unique vector
#

i mean its been mentioned as distortion in the past

fossil finch
#

(ozz has already said that post dog tier will be split up in progression as biomes and events get added to post ml

unique vector
#

you arent getting any details though so get fucked

fossil finch
#

i do not believe so, no

granite sphinx
granite sphinx
fossil finch
#

we have known of dog subworld and just post ml biomes existing but