#suggestions-discussion
1 messages · Page 688 of 1
Shucks did tease a sandnado change a while ago iirc
Yes
epic gamer moment
Yeah
sandnados and butterflies are getting balanced out which is pretty cool
They got nerfed dmg wise but can do better at attacking
neat.
Now fix the Stardust Dragon to not have the IQ of a peanut when flying around a boss.
Lowkey 2 and a half minutes for ML pre nerf

https://discordapp.com/channels/225030931008847874/263382359397761025/617884060659875840, https://discordapp.com/channels/225030931008847874/263382359397761025/615251116988563477, https://discordapp.com/channels/225030931008847874/263382359397761025/612548695103111178, https://discordapp.com/channels/225030931008847874/263382359397761025/610842988515557377
@worthy viper
There
what
a
Some examples of weapon suggestions
Not as specific as the one you're going for, so I'm sorry they're not as much of a help there
I thought some weird dude was spamming
Actually I felt pre-hardmode summoner was alright, referring to that third link Rover sent.
Weapon suggestions are usually to fill lacking tiers
I wish the evil bosses minions were... good for skele?
It's really Destroyer where it cannot do anything.
I used Imps for pretty much most of Pre-Hardmode, even Skele
...idle note: I keep asking myself if I should eventually try and push a post-Birb yo-yo simply so fighting Provi with the subclass isn't like a visit to the Four-Armed Dentist but at the same time 1) I don't really care to and b) even if i did I have Entropy's Edge to at least partially solve that issue.
Maybe that's why I don't really throw weapon suggestions in here much. hm.
Well thank you Stardust Sors, I’ll keep that in mind
You're welcome
also why the fuck do people do entire playthroughs with only one weapon type
why the fuck do people use nothing but ark of the cosmos on scal
.
actually, don't answer that, I already know why.
It’s a lot simpler to use 1 weapon type
It's really not a good reason for a specific variety of weapon to be added to any given tier
in my opinion
I've seen a lot of suggestions that use it as the sole reason
when it's a really arbitrary self-imposed limitation, of course there are going to be weak and strong points
That’s true probably
Adding stuff just so you can do your sub class run 
Like i get an entire class missing weapons is a problem, but sub class? 
i dont even see that many people doing sub class runs
Also using ark of the cosmos on scal is a completely different deal
Its called viability
ye a bit of false equivalence there
People dont use ark of the cosmos cuz of a sub class run, its just that good of a weapon
Did you actually complete DAY, Thomas
please
there's, you know, 'give flails a bit of love' and 'a couple more sentries please'
we have enough sentries
You were the one that started it thomas
but then there's the fucking MORE YO-YOS, UPGRADE YO-YO BAG, BETTER YO-YO GLOVE
about what
I don't know why people (including you apparently cuz this was the conversation sparker) care about yoyos so much
If I'm being entirely honest, at this point I couldn't tell you myself why I give half a fuck about yo-yos.
Or any of the subclasses, really.
I just kinda
do. I guess.
It's weird and I'm not sure how to describe it.
^
(also what is DAY may I ask)
yoyo nohits
Yoyo nohits basically
and what is CCC
death-armageddon-yoyo
nohit journey
also known as "hello, i am a masochist"
oh
Change it to EE, I guess ?
also CCC is his massive suggestion doc iirc
CCC is god damnit I need to get my nick changed the old name of Entropy's Edge.
To what
or rather, I don't remember why
change CCC to EE I guess
or just have it say "Entropy's Edge guy" instead of "DAY/CCC guy"
so I can have people stop asking me what DAY is and keep my masochism to myself. a
Chaotrix/Pandemic exclusively to kill Providence does sound like fun
nah. Terrarian.
ah
In which i-frames ruin everything.
also thanks Shucks
I haven't pushed a sugg about it because it's a really complicated thing
(also yes thank you shucks much appreciated)
(nobody saw the first name change) 

perhaps
Indeed, I was boutta bring that up
just to suffer
so
new abilities for Bloodstone bosses.
yeah.
That's a thing that I'm surprised doesn't exist yet.
thomas, fishing in open air? tf
tl;dr subclass expansion for its own sake is bad, yes?
Might add to Don'ts but I'm not sure
I feel like I recall a lot of reasons being that subclass runs are difficult due to points lacking in tiers
but
i mean
a tier lacking a certain thing is a valid reason in some cases
nearly all classes and subclasses suffer at some point in the game
(that's the fun of playin different classes)
as long as nobody suggests that another early-Hardmode throw be added I'm good, there are already more than enough of those
(different points give you harder times)
Anywho.
@ashen warren Catching the player off-guard is the entire point
It wouldn't be a surprise attack if you saw when they spawned and the indicator remains on the screen until they despawn or you find them
Are they the only minibosses that have the factor?
They were an intentional exclusion when the boss health bars were added.
@ashen warren Add a reason.
I was wondering, are Vanity accessory slots hardcoded to not work or it's possible to work around them?
@fierce hedge there is a reason >:C
it's literally right there
mainly so they can be more than just stat buff memez
still a reason
But iguess you're right
It's good enough. It's basically the only reason there is.
My concern are Music Boxes, it would be nice to have them work even while in a vanity accessory slot, but before writing a suggestion I want to be sure there are no hardcoded obstacles.
If it said "In order to keep the boss from just being buffed through stats" you'd be fine with it smh 
^
I get it.
Also you could definitely suggest that teh
too many carrots from me as it stands it's the same message but conveyed in a very special calamity way
I do think it may cause some trouble, but it doesn't hurt to put it in there.
Don't know until we try after all.
iirc the mod Better Music Boxes already has this as a feature
i'M NOT DOING THE "OH BUT THIS ALREADY EXISTS, GO AWAY" THING
just saying that it's been done so it's likely doable
Yeah we know
considering it's been done
So there's your answer, I think it's a good idea.
Oh. Does it work with Calamity boxes or?
If it does I don't think there would be a purpose to suggest it tho 
i've seen this logic used before but i think it's kinda faulty considering we have boss health bars
everyone knows about fk's YABHB and until Calamity introduced its own everyone used it
but, yannow, multiple mods having the same qol features isn't anything new and i reckon it'd work here
not sure if many people know if the better music box mod exists
Alright then, how to bold text? 
@thick cedar herd of antieocial?
@thick cedar Actually, I just cheatsheet to get more accessory slots.
oh wow, it's exactly the "this already exists go away" thing that i mentioned earlier
I asked in this channel before posting and it was judged as an actually presentable post, so I posted it.
Do what Simon did
the ping thingy they just did
Don’t think a music box slot would fit Calamity, but we’ll see
Even better, both of those proposed options have been suggested in the past
mrrp: hell yeah go ahead i'd star that
willow: just use other mods as a crutch
rover: no.
Hey it's bluecheck, you can still star
a bluecheck is the kiss of death to a suggestion
it's essentially seen as a "we've already said no to this one >:c"
(Only the music box slot suggestion was rejected)
(note that when pitching the idea to mrrp that part of the suggestion wasn't mentioned 👀)
Idk one may have brought up the "bruh I need all the 7 slots to look cool af"
if you need all seven slots for vanity methinks you're compensating for something 👀
also the visual noise 
this coming from someone whose many-hundreds-of-hours original super-character wears plat armour with no vanity accs to look as flat as possible
i might be biased away from it but that's because anyone who thinks seven vanity accs is a good idea is an idiot who needs to be shot
I normally use 4 slots for aesthetics, the lens flare from Yoraiz0r's spell is majestic 
I tried to make my character look like Neo from Matrix but the Aegis keeps ruining my plans
yharon's* fuck you
my favorite accessory
Yharon's Shackle
ily rover bby uwu
thanks
i'm missing something 
Are they CV accessories
yes
ah
Haven't used it, wouldnt know

iunno why I'm still in that server but I could say that for a lot of servers
anyway
Why.
there’s already a pin like that
i mean
They already have like 3 sentences each in the Legend
which is 3 times longer than the other reactions
❕ is often seen as dislikes and i've seen multiple people take down suggs because they have more ❕s than stars
I don't think that's the reason
I think that suggestions that are due for taking down tend to get a lot of ❕ because people know they're invalid
Like "nerf halibut cannon"
[⭐ 2] [❕ 18]
there's just already a few instances of mods having to clarify "❕ is not a downvote button"
It does get annoying having to click X on them all when reviewing
especially on mobile's slow ass which automatically switches to the other reaction when you've cleared all of one
I've accidentally removed a star or two cuz of that shit
You've specified yourself that you personally just use it as an indicator of validity regardless of whether you agree, but it's really quite a clear trend that people use ❕ as an "I disagree" rather than "hey, I reckon this needs an authority to review it"
all i'm saying is that it might be good to remind people that NO
suggestion: replace ❕ with
so that only the stupidest and least valid suggestions get flagged rather than every remotely objectionable proposal 
that would sound really aggressive
(but then there'd be
whenever any new suggestion gets made)
i'm a good administrator, i know what i'm doing 
(silence)
that aside, i think it's slowly becoming more and more of an issue that needs addressing (the ❕ = "i hold a different opinion" rather than "this is a really wonky suggestion, someone review it please")
Unfortunately I don't think that an announcement or pin edit is really gonna stop people from doin that
well, it stopped people from calling self-stars
It's a natural reaction
You see the "I agree" button and you see the one next to it, the only other option
EXCEPT ME
You were the only person calling self-stars smh
i reject your reality and substitute my own
although in refuting that point i proved your overarching one
pinnouncements aren't perfectly comprehensive, yeah, and people do still go against the reminded grain
but at the same time if you look back over the history of "self-star" in this channel before and after the pin most of the messages apart from me continuing to call them out in strikethrough because irony is the best defence are just statements of "yeah, some people do dislike it, but it's not disallowed" rather than "self-star, you're bad >:C"
i reckon a new pin could make a difference
your call, though
¯_(ツ)_/¯
let's see how the next couple of weeks go regarding reacts and disc responses
reminder that this channel's shortened name is #sugg-disc
because it's a suggestion
Let me rearrange it: Is it possible to have a vanity item of demon horns?
just a ver bad one
dude, that suggestion is from january
CONTROVERSIAL SUGGESTION
make summon weapons not lose damage if you're holding a rogue weapon
because class synergy and also statis exists
maybe rather Statis' Belt of Curses reduces the summon penalty while holding a Rogue weapon
yeah, I think it should apply to that item only tbh
also i'm pretty sure someone's already suggested that before
@ashen warren deus*
i'm not really sure what that suggestion means
An alternative progression boss
Alt astrum deus fight for people with trash pc
Like a different boss with the same drops
boss suggestions aren't allowed
I'm not suggesting King Crown of the abyss
Just more reasons why Deus needs to be reworked hahayes--
Config option to decrease projectile spam and or shorten segments/delete some worms entirely would be better
deus needs to be reworked
but up stats i guess
why the fuck does everyone hate on my boi deus is a good boss >:(
Lag
I can't fight him
You think I'm kidding but when a Siren and Levi drop (Atlantis) can get good DPS because there are worms everywhere
you've done something wrong.
Deus isn't required iirc?
I got 1 fps for maso goblin army too, it's okay.
deus is required if you want
For what? I can't remember
b i g
Do you want to make Astral Gear or
l o o t
It's not a necessary boss, but Astral Bars are kind of a huge help going into the ML fight.
Are you prevented from fighting Provvy, DoG, Yharon, or SCal by not killing Deus?
I forgot about Deus before doing ML
Yeah we needed Astral Bars
Okay yeah I'll just kill the last boss with a copper short sword
what
deus is fine where it is, and although it is, admittedly, a deeply flawed fight, it's still what and where it is because it works although it still does need a bit of tweaking
The reasoning for your suggestion is fine JustCrimson
however you cannot suggest that an alternate to Deus be added because that would mean a new boss
Suggest that he be reworked, or specify that this alternate method would not constitute adding a new boss
I find it weird how everything refers to it as a single entity when you're fighting like, 10 separate ones
not, you know, great, but no need for an entirely new boss
eleven bodies, one entity
Fixed
If the alternative is ending the run, just cheat in some bars and penalize yourself in some way
¯_(ツ)_/¯
That's better
I did end the run lmao
(again, Astral Bars not required)
If deus tanks your FPS, so will other bosses
Astral Chest: <contains six bars>
Me, a multiplayer addict: ITEM FRAME AND ANVIL TIME
Deus is the only boss that has tanked my fps
have the later bosses done that?
Can't say, I haven't beat them
lmao
when your only placeable bars are eye-bleeding rock candy
so 'the only boss'
<calamity noises>
isn't the only boss
I guess the astral ore hypothetically could be unlocked if you defeat ML
(but then it requires AD to give you luminite too, and even without that the idea in general is a balance hell)
Astrum Deus as an alt of Moon Lord 
(no he doesn't)
(I mean as the fix to that suggestion, ya goof .>.)
(I’m p sure that was just a suggestion I made)
I'd enjoy Deuces as an alt of ML if Deuces wasn't a a pain in the ass in its own right.
(bracket hour bracket hour)

wtf is deuces
oh right
by that logic let’s have another way to obtain cosmilite bars because DoG eats frames
ok but what if 10 DoGs

If anything the best option i can suggest for you is to turn off frame skip
get this cursed idea off my dash
@ashen warren
oof
yeah, turning off frame skip will make ur game run in slow-mo but it’ll be functional
Fuck mobile
10 DoGs will never happen

a
I was pinged
Look up
you were ponged indeed
Someone wanted you to turn off Frame Skip so the game is playable but slowmo
Multiplayer
or just lower your settings
ok now that’s another can of worms, literally and figuratively
hehehe, worms
pun definitely intended
If you both turn off frame skip does it work
hueh
kill deus on singleplayer and return to multiplayer
Is there any way to make frameskip off work in multi?
I don’t think so
bc both devices aren’t the same which means that latency presents itself in different ways
Unless everyone has FS turned off then I think. I haven't tested it before
frameskip off and autopause are pretty much single player things
frameskip off just makes you teleport backwards
autopause flat-out doesn't work in mp
(not sure how it would)
^
Unless you coordinated your pauses
game doesn't pause if any amount of players less than all of them are autopaused simultaneously
frameskip off means that while the server thinks you're moving at, say, 100mph, your shitty 6fps computer will be telling you you're effectively moving at 10mph, meaning the server will loop you moving that distance ten fucking times until the clientside finally decides you've reached the end
frameskip is for pro gamers, don't disable it
I disable it since t makes my game run smoother 😛
I mean i kinda have to turn off frame skip
My laptop begins to lag as the game progresses
@ashen warren you gonna love devourer of gods
no
But you can just mine the ore after Deus
but he can't beat the boss because lags
@ashen warren why are you using hornets & imps against WoF?
you're intended to use the herring staff against it
I mean
if you accidently summon it in hardmode wouldn't you be able to kill it easily
i summoned him during destroyer fight, i got mad and posted this suggestion
🤔
mayhaps
i think that's a fair judgement. often you can accidentally spawn it if you're mob farming since the cyst is hiding behind a bunch of enemies
I do that all the time with queen bee
half my attempts fighting the devourer summoned one
More end game armor due to the lack of it currently
We have like
aren't they multiclass anyways
5 helmets foreach class though
yeah
the base armor is, but the helmets aren't
and also demonshade is multiclass
demonshade is multiclass, OBA is multiclass
So they’re just not listed on the wiki
yes they are?
Tarragon, Bloodflare, Omega Blue, God Slayer, Silva, Auric, Demonshade
There’s only demonshade listed
@ashen warren I feel like you could suggest lowering the projectiles on the screen in the AD fight
Also have you tried to set quality to low or auto
Crimson doesn't get a break, lmao
ffs yeah
There are a lot of mods that add renewable altars
Fab has stated before that he assumed at lowest that you are playing pure calamity and maybe some lesser qol like checklist
like all the item recipes and boss health bars are in plenty of other mods
I mean, sure what's the harm in giving Calamity one too
It'd be nice if we did it in a bit more of a unique way
but, wishful thinking
or at the very least, even though its useless by that point in the game, draedon’s forge
whats the latest you even need them anyways

Perhaps change crystal ball to be the same
Anything crafted at demon altar could also be crafted at a crystal ball
There is a mod that does that
I don't know what mod does that
but I know I've seen it in playthroughs of mine
We could do it too but iunno how that'd interact with the existing one
(it'd probably be fine)
I got 90 reactions now what
wait
k
fargo's lets crystal balls act as demon altars
lots of mods add exactly that
"other mods already add [xyz thing]" isn't really a fair counterargument so like
hueh
@ashen warren hello other rogue weapons exist
post-desert scourge you can get he seafoam bomb which will carry you to post-skeletron
then you get the lionfish until you obtain the spear of paeolith in hardmode
plus rogue expansion is already been planned out
What's wrong with there being a gap in this specific weapon line
People just really like crystalline ig
crystalline is hot the way it is
has large range for a rogue weapon at its stage of game and decent dmg
Also looks cool
Prismalline doesn't do good damage if you are too close to targets, because the splitting only occurs a distance away.
Prismalline is the best weapon in the line
Quasar is a joke, Crystalline is iconic but hard to aim and falls short of its own status, Shattered Sun is divisive regarding whether it's good or underwhelming but fun, and Radiant Star is outclassed by other weapons at the same point in the game
Prismalline is the most solid entry in the set
Don't hurt my boy >:C
Yees
But who wants to aim
When you can fill half your screen with projectiles
or commit norfleet and fill it all with one projectile
... fill your screen with what projectiles?
what’s wrong with aiming?
We are talking pre hardmode, whatever youre using to fill your screen with projectiles
Also,the people who want to aim often get better dps
@ashen warren Don't worry about Radiant Star and Shattered Sun, they both get big buffs next patch.
Prismalline is fine as is and didn't need any buffs
So yes, the crystalline line is getting the love it deserves
I don't think we need a late hardmode crystalline, there's already 4 weapons in the line
I figured I just should let you know that we already looked at the crystalline line
technically radiant star is late hardmode
He prolly just forgot the "pre-"
oof
profaned crucible is unholy as well as holy and thus should work as an altar
Okay but like with all due respect most renewable altars are obtainable way earlier than post-ML--
make a slime altar from sg tbh
it's still an altar bc it's a god and you're pretty much done with phm
Not a bad idea
it looks like my suggestion may be up for review, yay
that's why i said "may be" :p
I like the altar idea, I often need one and I'm not keen to travel to the crimson
I had to make a base above one once
What happened to suggestions with blue marks that reached 90 stars?
they simply don't get sent I believe?
afaik bluechecked suggestions that reach 90 stars are added to the Frequently Suggested section of the Don'ts doc
not sure
Ah
if it doesn't get accepted then it gets a 🚫 ? If that's what you mean
@lethal roost
refer to the pins 
^

there already is iirc
@full compass We do indeed do that. The "weapons" page is separated into many sections, and each individual weapon page has a Categories section at the bottom, which each link to a page showing weapons with the same category
i see, thank you ^^
https://discordapp.com/channels/225030931008847874/263382359397761025/621560912129818644
When is this supoosed to get "delivered"
well, it’s a manual process
I can do it I guess
so whenever lurkalto or someone else who can see it can send it
Is Merk even able to send it? I'm honestly not sure.
Yeah he's been doing it for months
Kinda became the main suggestion sender
alongside Achilles and Pixl
it's nice that it's not just me alone lmao
feedback plz
What are you suggesting
imo the whole conditional minion slots thing needs to be changed since it causes a lot of bugs
I can't tell if you're listing their current function or if these are things you want
@rain estuary can you give examples?
@rain estuary I recommend more professional language or people are just going to dismiss you for being rude
I am trying to list all the stats down and doing a comparison
You put your reason before the suggestion?
I mean, what hitboxes are so shit tho?
Uh, yes ?
perhaps.
how are the hitboxes bad what
Removing the HP-based minion slot changes are a good idea
@placid moth Have a summary of the suggestion in the message, alongside the link
Ah, okay.
Leviathan has the worst hitbox of the entire mod
All of Astrum Aureus' projectiles have hitboxes larger than them.
you should probably give examples in your suggestion, as well as fix up the language since it's hard to think the suggestion is serious
Yeah, I kinda think my wording is not great.
your frustration is understandable though!
Don't use the word "shitboxes", remove the "fucking"s, and don't compare it to Tremor
Try to seem like you're being constructive and not just complaining
I can make a better one.
It will be amaaaziiiing!
It'll sure be something
dw fab's changelog was very vague
Usually vague = big surprises
@rain estuary why not give some sort of addition/change to the boss to make it harder
you seem kinda salty the way you're suggesting stuff
Doesn't matter anyway
Here's my idea:
Have Golem start as normal, except you can't attack the arms. And once you "destroy" the head, it becomes quad-pedal and start crawling around the temple. It's at this point you carved to look like a lihzahrd. It then flees temporarily until noon the next day, doesn't matter where you are.
It retains all attacks of normal Golem, but now it can create beams of sunlight that are able to go through ground.
Jesus
What ?
I don't think Calamity is able to do that
bro @rain estuary this is a mod for terraria, not the freaking mayhem war by hhyper
what
i feel like golem should start normal, but when it jumps/the fists punch the ground, it causes a small quake like the ravager ones
@hollow shell look up "the mayhem war geometry dash"
golem rev+ rework is planned already
that too^
I don't think that's the most apt comparison
imean if you compare it to a normal geometry dash bossfight
it's so far above it
which is what i mean, in terms of complexity for a late hardmode boss
ok
No one is ready for new golem iirc 
Ye
@placid moth honestly a LOT of the post ML armors (basically all except Auric) need better effects. a lot of them are super underwhelming compared to the lunar armors.
though yes, the summoner sets are in DIRE need of change because any effect that removes summoner slots dynamically is super ugly in practice
@rain estuary Don't worry. Seriously, don't. I can ASSURE you Golem is handled.
I'm just gonna delete that suggestion since a golem rework is already done
Hm.
wtf embed link
This emote sounds like a lot of work to use and prolly won't get used a lot
The suggestions that are "we will implement this" are usually implemented on like, the same day they get sent
because those ones are usually quite easy to implement
Honestly this would be great
a lot of them aren't really set in stone
I can only think of like 2 or 3 suggestions that are planned to be implemented
and they are like 5 months old or something
oof
so said reaction wouldn't really be helpful
We don't have a lot of ones that take long to implement
Any major new stuff is usually already planned, or conflicts with stuff we already have planned
and yeah
The last few months of suggestions that were implemented were all easy changes
and the big ones that haven't been implemented but were planned to
haven't been implemented yet, and are from a long time ago
because other priorities came first, like the rogue update
@hearty yew I find the bloodflare summoner effect kinda lackluster personally, the three mines are just sorta... there
If they exploded into tendrils or maybe did damage while they were over an enemy like an orbital that would at least be interesting
I’d lean towards orbital
on top of that, maybe their rotation could depend on your horizontal (or vertical) speed so you could pause it and keep it on an enemy for a moment
that'd be interestng
Ooh, maybe it starts with 2 orbitals and if it deals enough damage within a short period of time it adds more to the circle up to 4
That could be annoying
because making the circle have 3 orbitals from 2, and 4 from 3, would mean that they would get repositioned
so you couldn't keep the orbital(s) on the enemy/enemies while it transitions
Hm, maybe make it like electron orbitals where it adds a second outer ring
heh
“Why tf my armor sp3 hybridizing”
if we wanted it to be more accurate to electron orbitals, the Polter mines wouldn't exist in any one place at a time, but instead might be attacking any enemy in a radius around you
that sounds fun actually

stupid, but fun
Get ready to program superpositions, Ozz
Honestly the increasing orbital idea could work if done correctly
it could be doing something, but the only way to know for sure is to observe it
It'd be more likely to get implemented if you just suggested that they deal DoT instead of explode
and maybe you could control the rotation
Anything too complex will just get ignored 😔
Unless ozz decides he wants it too
Indeed
iirc i once suggested that you could control the distance between yourself and the orbs
Press left and right to rotate it (like a wheel as you move)
press up and down to change its distance from you
maximum control
like, they stayed close to you and pressing Armor Set Bonus would make them go further out
yea
You could make it almost as much control by making radius match the current cursor position when pressing the set key
Oh shit
make them block shots and turn them into a cube of meat 
Exploding after dealing enough damage would be cool
that way they can still be "mines"
Nah it’s more like one of the fly orbitals guwa
Inb4 bloodflare is just the solar system challenge
Astral Armor rework 
Tbh make summon weapons also summon a small star minion that gains damage the more minions you have with astral armor, Luxor’s gift proves we have the technology
It’d make it less useless for summoners
friendly stargazers :0
... deus probes
!! Orbiting probes
Just make yourself a mine trailing nightmare like deus
There should be an Astral upgrade to Abyssal Tome which fires a bunch of lingering mines like Deus
Astrageldon tome
oof
sorry, that's -1 brain point for you
but yes lingering mine tome with slight homing would actually be godly
Slight homing probably not needed considering it'd be a big shotgun spread
hard to miss
hard to miss, but lingering projectiles that go nowhere are a recipe for disaster
They won't last forever
not enough homing to matter on the firing, but enough homing so that missed shots aren't worthless
Honestly an astral tome made from a slime themed tome is too similar to astrageldon for me to not make the joke
when a suggestion gets "delivered" how long does it take to either get implimented or denied
depends really
usually it's a couple of minutes for a suggestion to get approved or denied
or just ignored
depends on what people are online
also boss suggestions as a whole are a straight don't iirc
^
If you want more bosses just play with other mods
Or make your own boss
Making your own boss is the superior move because then you can decide how hard it is and where it is in progression hue--
Cute Fishron gaining the speed boost during rain sounds op tbh
i mean, one click of the Torrential Tear=15% more damage and 86 mph max speed
the downside is rain hurts fps
It does?
Cute Fishron buff for rain only applies if the Torrential Tear hasn't been used in the last ten minutes, and it's Heavy Rain specifically.
...please tell me there's a way to check for that second one.
considering cloud elementals do, yes
It also does not apply under rain if Storm Weaver forced it in--
If the weather radio can check for heavy rain, then anything else can do
Makes it too obscure to even bother ngl
"oh yeah I'm gonna wait for a natural rain which is gonna also reach Heavy phase while using this one mount and also hopefully this type of rain doesn't end suddenly with me getting screwed up in result"
it's still a nice boost sometimes
I feel like just a limitation of first minute of rain as not being "strong" would be sufficient
Rename Slag Magnum to Slagnum
Reason: I mean...is there really any reason it shouldn’t? It does fit it a bit more with its theme (and makes it a more of a pun). Also, it sorta rolls across the tongue better.
congrats, you win suggestions
suggested before i think
Hah it was January
😔

Nice reference however it does break two rules
No specifics
No reference for the sake of reference
~~wait what
did i miss something
please tell me i didn't miss a potential opportunity for a bad pun~~
Don't know why Dovahbear deleted that, it wasn't even in #suggestions-voting, it was here.
a
It was the Force'a'Nature from TF2
ah

i've grown an enjoyment of digging through #suggestions-voting for ideas the past couple days, don't mind me
that would be stupidly fun the force a nature
trying to get the force a nature added would be forced in nature
oh i scrolled all the way to december last year
there you go, you get your bad wordplay tomas
wait is turq a dev
Yknow what it would work because Dovah wanted it to be an RIV of the Boomstick
which you find in the jungle
i mean,the hardest part would be the when fired you get nudged in direction coding
there's no h because nobody's laughing
I mean, it wouldn't be that difficult, to be quite honest.
Not sure on Turq's dev status
he's not, iirc
He used to be
Simply get the player firing the gun, nudge their velocities slightly in the direction opposite that they fired, and boom, done.
he stepped down last i checked
tbh,i wouldnt mind the fan to be added to the mod
Turq’s busy with Varia and the Evil Earthquake remaster iirc
he also resigned from being calamity dev yeah
Who even uses star cannon?
i once used it in masomode
Was it really so broken though?
@fierce hedge there's a reason why the star cannon is powerful and that's because its ammo is hard to get
The same goes for a coin gun with platinum coins or the special limited ammo weapons like hydra
Meteor stuff is post EOW in nohits anyway, right?
I forgot that the star cannon existed
well yes and no
What's the no?
Oh well. Iguess you're right. I forgot about the star collecting
byeah, the star cannon is already somewhat balanced by the ludicrous ammo
I'll remove the suggestion since i get that now
It's recommended to post a suggestion here first to get the best out if it
And also to bring up problems
Is coin gun broken too?
coin gun is in the same field as star cannon in terms of usefulness
coin gun has capacities to carry to post-providence at the condition you have plat coins to supply it
nice balance

extremely powerful if paired with good ammo, but a really small niche
pretty sure it was no exception ban at some point (that's lifted now)
anyways that's offtopic already; I think the rest you can look it up yourself in the doc
Btw. Its super easy to stack up on platinum with Armageddon enabled
Surprisingly the desert scourge is amazing for this
that’s well-known yes
I felt so smart when I discovered it out on my own
now hol up..

I feel like a better solution would be to make Brimstone Slag drop from crag enemies, so it's renewable
Rather than fucking like 1/4 or 1/3 of the Underworld
Probably yea
Idea:
BRIMMY BOX
(it's like provi's box but brimstone slag and small like WoF's)
BRIMMY BOX

honestly brim crag being way larger would be nice
Just a random idea.
Or 20 ash and essence of chaos
opens up the door for many actually cool things in the biome
brimstone crag actually feels strangely small
The Crags feel like
really small.
And not too terribly complex (or really, significant) either, it's just a bunch of simple houses with some chests and a really fat rectangle of Brimstone Slag. You go there to fight one boss, once in early Hardmode and once post-Provi, and never look at it again.
Isn't crag being expanded on later anyways?
Just more things to why the inevitable Brimstone Crag update can't come soon enough, I suppose. 
it could really do with being a fourth or fifth of the underworld
This is like the 10th time crags is mentioned to fell empty and it always boils down to "shit is being worked on" 

Ah yes 3 enemies and one boss
Yay, people agree with me :3
I would do something for Crags but that implies I have any ideas for things for Crags in the first place.

thomas
you're working on too many things at once you libtard
i will DESTROY you with FACTS and LOGIC my guy, i'm working on just enough at once

Like my base takes up 3/4 of the biome
Im not joking
It wouldve taken 2/4 but i had to remove 1/4 for the furniture
though tbh crags have already come far from what they used to be
Also thank god for tranquility candles, makes this place livable with the decreased spawn rates
brim slag didn't used to be obtainable and there was no furniture
question.
the only way to make the biome was with charred ore
Why does ashen chest exist again?
Now it has 2 sets of furniture
Ashen and ancient (a destroyed version of ashen)
ashen chest exists because having a complete set of furniture is important
Ashen id use to recreate the civilization
Ancient youd use to create the destroyed civilization
AND THERE IS NO TOILET
i don't think an ancient society of non humans needs a toilet tbh
I NEED ONE FOR THE BATHROOM
Also explain this to me
WHY is the astral biome bigger than the brimstone crag
Even though its the most uselessbiome ever, with only stardust and astral ore being used (but you can skip the armour anyway)
The biome expands underground but has nothing to offer, plus, it doesnt even have a furniture set
I thought the trees astralized could be used to make some cool furniture but no it isnt. The crag on the other hand has lots more items and a boss that can only be spawned there and has 2 sets of furniture . You go to it 10× more than the astral
But, is probs the smallest calamity biome in the mod
I do hope for Crag Justice
tbh, just make the crags larger, have the area currently taken up by crags stay the same, and have the expanded area be more like the old one
astral is gonna get more stuff
I hope the astral then makes up for the amount of space it takes
Browsing #suggestions-voting to check out for any new shit
Ashen Toilet
:echthink:
Crag has nothing unique unlike Astral
they have lava
It's biggest point, Brimmy, might as well be a Hell boss instead
smh
It has 2 bosses, many astral enemies, and it make sense
But you can fight the bosses anywhere
The devs agree it’s pretty lackluster so they’re planning to go redo it sometime
hey is crags could spawn in it's own arena that'd be great, thanks
astral needs help and so does crags
Crag needs more help than anything else
Their plans were to give aureus and deus a proper drop pool and make the crags yknow
Which makes it less unique for how good it looks
And pls
I want astral wood furniture, like i wish you can grow trees on the astral dirt
More than a brimmy arena
Crag Justice
My waifu doesnt have to die for nothing
thanks
cuz Astral already has a bit
when is this planned?
In the future
more specifically?
If astral biome doesnt use the amount of space it takes up when it lands, thats just wasted potential
Not for a while
Like, next major update is Rogue and then we'll have another major update after that, and then we'll probably be doing Crag stuff
Ah,k then
There could be some lil expansions in there though
like how some rogue content kinda dripped into recent updates
Galaxy Smasher, Scarlet Devil, etc
coolio
The major update after Rogue is Draedon, right?
Yep
Also, add this to the list
Ashen toilet, profained toilet, Void toilet.....k
We get mech boss rematches plus him so we’re probably in for something
Reason why im defending Crag is because the furniture also has this very cool item
Its the brimstone monolith, which has a floating red eye on top Which actually follows the players movements
They mustve put in alot of effort for a small detail like that, with all the other furniture having eyes with some thats also animated
But yet its underrated and nobody knows about it
i was the og crag man, because i literally discovered h ow to artificially make crags before brim slag was obtainable
I didn't know it actually looked at you
Its like the eye of soaran (or something like that)
Heck, theres an ancient version of it in the second set of furniture
With the eye spazzing and glitching out as if it was damaged
So many cool items but yet nobody uses
And also, have the void stone in the top and bottom layers of the abyss
Cause watcha gonna do with abyss gravel
Void stone is used to make the abyss furniture set
Which looks very cool
And its probs the hardest set of furniture to obtain in the mod
Requires you to go to the deeper paet of the abyss and collect the voidstone that makes up that deeper area
You need alot of this to make a good base which makes it harder since its the deepest levels
AND
My biggest problem
It is (in my opinion) horrible to have the (profaned rune, void) slab blocks with the slab wall
The wall looks like the block which makes it hard to see and looks bad
I mix the smooth stone with the slabs to make it look better
Maybe abit of an update to the texture would be nice
Heck, i think the furniture needs a look at and changed abit
I was unable to tell what was wall and block
They do not mix even though they should
There's a pretty significant brightness difference
but, I personally haven't used them in-game
so maybe they don't look as distinct in practice
Use them, make a box of voidstone slab and add the wall @hollow shell
Ah Voidstone yeah that's pretty much the same
I have the slab blocks and smooth void stone walls, makes it actually nice
I was looking at Profaned, which you also mentioned
I maybe got mixed up with profaned slab and profaned rune block
Can ya yeet the profaned rune block and wall out the game
Just my opinion, i dont like them
The Ashen slab block is BEAUTIFUL
When you have them 2 blocks thicc, theres an actual symbol (God of war symbal) on the block, which i found amazing
This unique thing isnt implimented for the other slab blocks in the mod
Tbh, a fuck ton of effort was put into the crag furniture
Who ever made it, i wanna give them a hug and a kiss for their amazing work
(AlterraKira)
(Would be more fitting to do so in the art server tho)
We do indeed need an ashen toilet
@devout lava i actually redid profaned furniture for next update
exo toilets is what we really need
exo furniture when
Because... ?
PBGs sprite is only 4x4 in-game, it's actually 2x2 in the source iirc
that's mainly to make it bigger/a Goliath
ye but h
🤔
meme suggestion?
Im honestly not sure
"ye but h" gives me meme vibes
Someone should resprite the pbg
:bruh:
A PBG resprite may come eventually
so basically you want it to be the same size but instead of 4x4 you want it to be a 2x2 that's detailed to the size of the current
ok if that is what you want, say "I want a pbg resprite"
but for now, it's not happening
done
consistency dab
I feel like more explanation on the post would make sense
just "for consistency" doesn't seem like a good reason to me
Yeah i dont get this suggestion at all
Isnt there a resprite being worked on anyway?
probably
There are like, 50 pbg sprites tbh
Ah i see
Just none of them are used so we're stuck with this one
The big main one with the jet boosters can no longer be used because of drama situation
there's been some new proposed designed a lil while back but no sprites yet
drama?
Yeah
Best not to go into detail
ouch
Vanilla Mini-Bosses Rev+ Changes
Wyverns
- Moves slightly faster
- Grants immunity to debuffs that slow them down
- Shoots fireballs at you, which has slight movement prediction
(Very cheese-able and easy to dodge)
Ice Golems
- Lasers ignore blocks
- Ignores blocks when shooting lasers
(They're way too cheese-able)
Sand Elementals
- Shoots four sandnadoes instead of three
(Not much needs to change, as they're already quite strong)
Moths
- Ignores blocks
(They pose no threat at all, but isn't that significant of a mini-boss)
Why should these changes happen?
Right now, vanilla mini-bosses are a bit too easy and don't feel like mini-bosses anymore besides the high health. These changes should make them more harder to fight, giving back the role of mini-bosses to them.
Thoughts?
i agree with just about everything except wyverns
wyverns should just have something other than charge directly at player
wyverns should have another attack yeah
Edited
slight movement prediction?
Ah Doppio. Did I not give you the ability to use King Crimson's Epitaph?
No seriously, how would that work
Hmm now that i think about it
that make wyvern little bit harder, but... can doge him easy probably
Ok now he shoots fireballs at you

hm
But he has slight prediction so if you jump up right before he shoots it, expect it to meet you
isn't yharon also a 4x4?
No.
He may be scaled up in code but his source sprite is 2x2
(actually it doesn't look like he has any scaling either)
Wyverns do not need to be more annoying
They're super easy for sure but I don't need them wasting more of my time when I'm trying to do things in space
Can destroyers lasers naturally go through blocks in calamity? I forgot if that was a thing rev+
Well in that case, might have to be careful about how the frost beams work in destroyers fight if the projectiles changes will carry over
Unless they are different proj?
ice golem and destroyer use the same projectile, yes
do NOT with that ice golem thing
dsajkflasjlkfsajlsfdlka
if you're doing that you're also making the lasers perfectly accurate
or i will personally shrivel up and wither away
idk, ice golems are incredibly easy to get
@hollow saffron I’d suggest using a different emote since the emote you chose looks like a cooking timer on ios
lul
ice golems are pure rng
they serve no function as an enemy other than a "get two minutes of slowness" lottery in the event a laser rng's you in the face
so if we're going to make the ice golem different and more capable of doing so, get rid of the garbo rng spread and make it a consistent enemy
"oMG jusT DODge"
haha, good meme
besides, ice golems are too easily cheesed at the moment
yes i'm cool with them being an actual enemy, but if we're changing them to be worse, at least make them an actual enemy
if you don't want to fight one, a magic mirror/recall potion should always be available in your hotbar
or at least ask yat to make the laser spread more accurate
that was my request, yes 
imeant ping @ Yatagarasu and make your request known
@queen delta hi please also make ice golems perfectly accurate thank you dearly
hmm.... NO
oof
I want ice golems to be dangerous 
And they're more dangerous when they're not as predictable
why would you want rng difficulty instead of actually gameplay
the conic rng literally just forces you to be further away and nothing more
Plaguebringers are just annoying when you're grinding
grinding for plague cell canisters
Not everything has to be accurate 