@sudden quail See comments above
#suggestions-discussion
hollow shell
lost agate
Or you do a trick, which is not cheese that removes most of the reaction you need
low hedge
early game worm boss dies quickly to piercing weapons 
tired haven
What a big surprise
worthy fiber
@unborn latch You should elaborate more on why it should be nerfed
unborn latch
@worthy fiber Did you try the weapon?
worthy fiber
The point is you gotta put why in the suggestion so it'll be more agreeable
unborn latch
yea i just expanded on it
worthy fiber
Also, put it in one message next time k thx
alpine garnet
@unborn latch keep it all in 1 message
tired haven
Keep it in one message and be mindful that elemental quiver bug which stacks damage is gonna be fixed
unborn latch
wiat... what bug?
I don't even know what's happening maybe that isn't the Starmada's Fault...
ruby cobalt
What, the fact that you got 10 starmadas around you didn't set you off?
alpine garnet
unborn latch
I don't have multiple Starmadas
It only get's faster the more i shoot it, Is that the bug?
gusty geode
I'm noticing a lot of suggestions made over the past couple days that have 50 stars but no check
Not trying to tell the mods how to do their job but somebody should get on that
opal barn
Not every mod has access to the dev server, mind you
hollow shell
What mode are you playing on, Cryogen?
And yeah it's the devs that send em, not mods
unborn latch
Revengence.
hollow shell
I see
unborn latch
Adrenaline shreded His second phase in 4 Seconds.
hollow shell
It was intended to be made with Cosmilite, by the way
That kind of mistake you described can't really happen
(Unless it was just a snarky quip on how strong the weapon is and not an actual theory?)
unborn latch
Yes it was indeed that.
Is this some Elemental quiver thing or the gun itself?
I tried with other guns like the Chain Gun Upgrade, Phangasm, Alluvion.
All of them normal
hollow shell
Elemental Quiver had strange interactions with Starmada that caused the weapon to get multiplied and fucktuple your DPS
sleek wigeon
Some guns are treated as projectiles
Since they are projectiles they get multiplied with ele quiver
and since the projectile only despawns when you put the weapon.....
hollow shell
Try fighting Yharon with Daedalus Emblem instead, or some other accessory
and see if there's any significant impact on the fight length
hollow shell
It's alright
hollow shell
I assume he wants the orbs to home and heal more HP, judging by his wording
I would be nice for him to say it outright tho
opal barn
@placid perch Deathmode exclusive suggestions are never accepted
faint rivet
Deathmode suggestion 
delicate raft
Here we go again
hollow shell
rip, true
opal barn
Please read the rules in the pins in #suggestions-voting
hearty yew
death only drops are never accepted
lucid tundra
@cyan lagoon Sorry, i didn't see your message. Please explain what you mean by repetition.
cyan lagoon
Originally the rare sandy was the same as the regular one
It along with most of the waifus were redone for the planetoids update, rare sandy getting the biggest change
@grim stratus Yharon'll get a resprite when yharon gets one
It's not a priority though
hollow shell
They're called "sprites" not "models"
tulip parcel
Broken Blaster
"Once fired a lifeform disintegration ray."
Hardmode Magic Weapon
Drops rarely from any Astral biome enemy.
A small pistol bearing the color scheme of the astral, though smaller than other "pistol" type weapons. Similar in design to the space gun, but with less ornamentation. Fires an orange, blue, or purple energy beam at a low mana cost. The color of laser that the weapon fires is decided on pickup, but is a purely cosmetic effect. The Broken Blaster is a pre-cryogen weapon ideally, not meant to be a very strong weapon on its own. The purple beam is a thick beam which fires in a straight line, similarly to the Last Prism. The orange beam fires in a sine wave, thinner but still having roughly the size due to its curving pattern. The blue beam is the same, but flipped. All three do low damage, but ignore I-frames.
Star Eater
Hardmode Magic Weapon
Broken Blaster + Broken Blaster + Broken Blaster + 5 Souls of Sight + 5 Hallowed Bars
A fusion of three Broken Blasters. The barrels from two Blasters are completely stripped, and now slowly orbit the "prime" blaster.
The beam fired is now a combination of the blue, orange and purple lasers. This triples the weak power of the Broken Blaster, making it a much more formidable weapon for early hardmode. The weapon still ignores I-frames.
lucid tundra
It should be something unique. Like, the rare waifu doing contact damage and throwing a homing healing orb at you every 500 damage?
devout seal
Yeah, Yharon re-sprites are lower priority then sprites like Levi's.
lucid tundra
Or 1000 or something
tulip parcel
lotta suggestions today
might hold onto broken blaster/star eater for a bit
but what do you guys think of it
lucid tundra
People are unusually active today
tulip parcel
...meh, maybe not
broken blaster isn't too creative
might scrap it
yeahhh, forget it
devout seal
@placid perch 1: Death Only suggestions don't get in.
2: 7 accesory slots is the hard limit, it can't be raised at all.
hollow shell
Aw, it sounds p cool Vorbis
cyan lagoon
You could always add an extremely buggy 8th slot
Though just doing that is another story in of itself
gusty geode
Cheat Sheet did that
6 times
radiant meadow
Cheat sheet extra accs are different though
Which is why you can have the same acc in them
plush remnant
@placid perch No Death Mode specific items. 
radiant meadow
3rd ping
plush remnant
3rd time's the charm.
placid perch
Frick, forgot about that
plush remnant
Bottle of Healing Flame
Praise the Sun!
Omega Healing Potions + Darksun Fragments + Profaned Crystal
Basically an infinite use Omega Healing Potion. Maybe with some sort of added buff effect.
: Dark Souls reference.
Random item idea, just prompted myself with it.
Not actually gonna suggest it, tbh.
faint rivet
I'd star that
plush remnant
We need more Soulsbourne references.
placid perch
Lol, Praise the Sun!
teal wolf
trick gun, which would be a gun/melee
youd be hitting 2 references there
and would get bonuses for using both forms
alpine garnet
I feel like it'd need a lot to make infinite seem fair imo
but I guess post darksun is kinda late anw š¤·
frail mantle
@sacred thorn 1. if your suggestion is accepted, the devs will decide the stats, so saying "it deals this much damage" is basically pointless.
2. please put a reasoning for why you would want this in the mod.
3. having every yoyo in the recipe is a bit ridiculous, as there are a lot of yoyos.
not trying to be rude, just stating some things.
radiant meadow
perhaps, just shimmerspark+chaotrix+quagmire+yinyo+obliterator might work
ashen warren
and terrarian since it does mention terrarian-like capabilities
unborn latch
Does it add only that or does it add more?
hollow shell
It adds a lot of QoL stuff
night cradle
^
unborn latch
Idk some of that potion stuff in there Seems OPAF.
But thanks for the recomendation. I might use it for only that Purpuse.
hollow shell
The Unlimited potions?
It takes frickin hours to farm a lot of the shit needed to make them, I'd say they're worth the effort put into em
unborn latch
Alltough i still do think DoG should spawn with One Upon summon, But that's just my Opinion and the Luiafk mod will Really help.
As the Infinite Platinum coin in Infinite stacks mod says:
''The product of Multiple hours Of grinding... Or a couple seconds of cheating.''
radiant meadow
that would be kind of bad if dog did it tbh
it would kind of be messy and it might cause a bit of lag as it would be much more than scal's arena
devout seal
the infinte platinum coins is just for the coin gun
hollow shell
@umbral dune It's really not all that expensive
the Blighted Lenses I guess could be annoying to farm for if you don't have them at that point somehow
but you should already have the Souls of Fright, and Hellstone Bars are by no means hard to get if you have Angel Treads already, or a single Obsidian Skin Potion
umbral dune
eh, I took it down
lunar berry
which is 100 hellstone bars
umbral dune
I guess it's fine
lunar berry
k
hollow shell
True, didn't take re-fights into account
hollow shell
Alright I think that's all of them delivered now
except
@left crag š
fossil torrent
good boy
hollow shell
Cob did a help
left crag
FINALLY edited that key description
tulip parcel
Pointy Stick
āNot as dangerous as a bananaā
Pre-Hardmode Spear
Wood @ Sawmill
A long spear, roughly the same length as Gungnir. Otherwise, it is merely a weak spear.
Instantly kills slimes, though this effect is disabled while a boss is alive.
How does this look?
hollow shell
Seems kinda powerful actually
tulip parcel
You think so?
radiant meadow
Why disabled? Just make it not instakill Spiked Blue Slimes or Slime God summons?
hollow shell
Yeah
Especially at that point in the game, completely trivializing slimes could make it too easy
tulip parcel
Because slime god summons are also normal enemies?
radiant meadow
Well, it can blacklist stuff
tulip parcel
Also blue slimes
radiant meadow
Like royal gel
sleek wigeon
royal gel doesnt so much blacklist stuff
tulip parcel
Okay how about instead of instantly killing slimes
It just does double damage to them
sleek wigeon
As much as modded slimes dont work for it without forcing it to work
tulip parcel
Should it include boss enemies then?
hollow shell
Yeah I don't see why not
radiant meadow
Well, I guess it's more like Royal Gel had a predetermined list
hollow shell
If it isn't that strong, then other weapons would likely be better suited for King Slime
It'd be an option
low hedge
you sure about that
low hedge
ok then
tulip parcel
It's referring to uh
this sketch
as well as to the fact that the banana is a weapon in terraria
sorry if it's low quality, it's pretty old
sudden quail
Comments read. I now see where I went wrong. Thanks for the pin, lad.
delicate raft
@blissful heart That channel is not for that
blissful heart
Figured that out
delicate raft
Delete that message
lusty idol
Towards Rgmemo; I think ??? shouldn't be affected by Zen or Zerg Potion at all.
uncut jetty
what if one just wants to spawn siren+levi without having to farm all that much?
ashen warren
Then be patient
gritty kiln
That's why I recommended a summoning item of some sorts. It's either somewhat more uncommon than it should be or way too common with the Zerg Potion.
ashen warren
Siren should spawn only when you're above water
Don't know if that's possible though
uncut jetty
i think maybe ??? could spawn only until you've killed the siren
then after that, spawning item
gritty kiln
??? spawns for me even above the water. Since most Ocean mobs spawn underwater as well it makes it difficult to kill them and not the lure
lusty idol
I think it'd be better for Sirens to not be affected by zerg or zen potions. Maybe just Zerg.
marsh fiber
ashen warren
What I said was a suggestion
lusty idol
It is also true that it's your fault that you kill the Siren on accident, but doesn't necessarily mean you should lower spawn rates.
ashen warren
The siren is supposed to lure you under the water then levi noms you
If you're already underwater ??? shouldn't spawn
lost agate
Mainly corn
gritty kiln
I know it's technically my fault for killing it, but having to tip-toe around it when farming basically entails going all out is a pain in the ass. A lower spawn rate or summoning item (even post Levi) would go a long way
ashen warren
corn leviathan
lusty idol
I'd go for summoning item, although it might not pertain to lore, or cancelling effects of Zerg on Sirens.
ashen warren
Zerg not affecting ??? + Increasing the spawn rate + Not making it spawn when you're already underwater
Or change ??? to making it that she only spawns levi when you get close to her
lusty idol
No, just Zerg not affecting sirens.
ashen warren
Runs away then levi comes in
I get a ??? spawning super commonly even before plant
Zerg not affecting ??? would do fuck-all
ashen warren
Especially for the purpose of farming when you're not strong enough to kill levi repeatedly
topaz flint
2.prepare for trouble and make it 60
delicate raft
@sudden quail I'm pretty sure they already did that
sudden quail
Oh, really? Oops
sudden quail
Maybe I just need to git gud
gritty kiln
Depends on your DPS at that stage probably. I min-max to hell and back so never had that problem but with slower firing weapons or something the spawn rate might be higher
sudden quail
I used a Mana Rose for the fight. Gonna make me a Magna Cannon and see if that works
ashen warren
Use storm spray
The piercing and multi-hit are amazing until around post-perf - post-skele
@sudden quail sorry for the ping, it's so you know
If you feel like farming more than the hellwing staff is also great
yes i know i'm offtopic
sudden quail
Ooh, thank you. I'll try Storm Spray if Magna doesn't work.
tulip parcel
What
Brimmy is cutest
Just because you donāt appreciate thicc doesnāt mean she can be turned into a stick figure
sudden quail
Outside memes, Brimstone looks fine. Not everything needs to have a complex design.
umbral tendon
I looked at it again and realized it's probably fine. I do feel like the waifu and boss should look different though
It gets confusing when I'm fighting the brimstone elemental and my waifu and the boss look exactly the same
gritty kiln
Maybe change the other "waifus" as well then? Cloud Elemental also looks the same as the enemy
radiant meadow
the only ones that don't look the same as the enemy are the 2 sand waifus tbf
ashen warren
I believe that if it ends up being finished the calamity mod texture pack will change the vanilla sand waifu to the calamity sand waifu
cyan lagoon
no
hollow shell
I still don't know if I should star resprite suggestions
hollow shell
It's not in the suggestion rules though
lusty idol
I think in the old rules it said resprite suggestions would be ignored, but yeah I don't see it.
devout seal
Well, i know some resprites are being worked on.
Yharon, but unofficial
Levi, official
Polterghast, Official, but we have no idea how it's going.
radiant pawn
polter looks fine for me tbh
sudden quail
Polterghast doesn't really need a resprite imo
radiant pawn
ye
also yharon
tbh he's the one who deserves to be as it is
his sprite aged well tbh
signal ibex
His resprite should be GODLY
worthy fiber
As long as we're patient
ashen warren
Problem is you have to dodge well to do good damage with drat
worthy fiber
It's a very skill-based weapon :P
radiant pawn
its the best weapon for range as for now
but you need a lot of skill to aim well, and dodge well
ashen warren
Drat is a no-hit wep tbh
radiant pawn
for the cool kids its called a multi-task(not) weapon
ashen warren
Ranged is pretty shite in terms of dps
radiant pawn
Gale makes the work for it tho
ashen warren
But ranged is strong for the rest of the game
civic laurel
I dont find the drat skill-based
ashen warren
It requires actual aiming and requires good dodging wtf are you smoking?
radiant pawn
its skill-based because it gives you really bad debuffs if you get hit by using it
worthy fiber
radiant pawn
imagine using drat, and the damage inflicted to you is multiplied by x2
civic laurel
I still find it bad without that debuff
radiant pawn
GOHAN LEARN TO DODGE
devout seal
wow
that sounds really similar to the already existing nitrogen and explosive flasks from thorium
neon panther
@tight chasm hey look
another buff drata suggestion 
tight chasm
oof
ashen warren
IDK about the plague vials, but I hope the suggestions are different enough to be cross compatible w/ them.
I would be more interested if debuffs that aren't the lionfish thing actually dealt good damage for when you get them in the game
Err, you need permission to look at the doc
Make it public
@ashen warren
Oof
civic laurel
I got another Heavenly Gale, and tested the DPS of both on a single target. The Heavenly Gale hits 160k and the Drataliornus hits 150k at full speed and no debuffs from getting hit
ashen warren
I dunno, but the main purpose was the Ichor/Other debuff applying for large groups of enemies and then switching to another weapon, never as a main weapon itself.
Add some way to have a fill tool
Draw a box and walls/blocks are placed in the box
Then you've got a great item for a mod that isn't calamity
Luiafk or something
stop making calamity a QoL mod
radiant pawn
i dont see much QoL suggestions or items in Calamity, and it isnt supposed to be a QoL item neither
ashen warren
It is a QoL item and a QoL suggestion is made at least once a week
lost agate
Uh thats QoL for sure
lost agate
Also, theres a lot of QoL stuff already in the mod
I mean, summoners can be bought, craftable vanilla stuff, cosmolight, torrential tear, super dummies (kinda counts as QoL)
And so on
lusty idol
I gotchu guys
marsh gust
why not just make mining potion affects cutting down trees?
ashen warren
Nope
lusty idol
Ahh shit. Ehh I thought I could repasta but now I know. 
hollow shell
Repost means nothing if the original already got sent in
Reposts are supposed to be like, another chance at getting enough stars to get sent
sudden quail
As much as I like the idea of a potion that benefits lumberjacks, I doubt it will really be useful, especially in Calamity, where you can get the Marnite Obliterator, and more importantly the Wulfrum Axe, very early on, and both of them shred trees.
ashen warren
It's 95% for when you need to gather a bunch of wood before you've gotten enough wulfrum enemies to spawn
frail mantle
my suggestion has 59 stars and no check mark
ashen warren
Lol
In my honest opinion, potions for trees really aren't worth it. Especially since it's not the kind of potion you can really take advantage of past the beginning of the game. Unless you somehow find joy in mining 10 trees per second when you're post-ml. But again, the desirability of it is extremely minimal, therefor I don't really think adding it would be a good idea, since tree chopping isn't really something done often. At least mining potions exist since a lot of anything in the game to do with tools involves using a pickaxe, and mining to get from location to location is an actual REAL hassle in the beginning. Chopping trees is just very...unnecessary when it comes to potions. I do like the idea though. Just I don't really think implementing it is needed at all.
civic rampart
I just use dynamite
ashen warren
I should also mention, I know you probably have a thing for avoiding destruction, but if you really wanted a quick way to remove trees, you do have the option of using bombs, since those can blow them up in one hit
^^
lusty idol
Honestly, I didn't want to repost that potion when I was searching for it. I have better suggestion but idk if it's entirely useful and if any other mods have something like this already.
Kibisis is an item with a purpose to carry a number of potions/buffs and the like inside. ('Kibisis' is Perseus reference)
- Opens an inventory GUI that is around the same size as Money Trove
- Favorite the potions you would want to use and keep unwanted buffs unfavorited.
- Crafted with 10 Leather, 5 Glass Bottles, and 1 of each gem at an Alchemy Station
- Similar palette from the Yo-yo Bag. but looks more like a 'magical' sack
Reason: A lot of people have problems with a cluttered inventory space, and I, for one, usually have many potions in my inventory, which is a cause of clutter. This item is for convenience, a less messy inventory space, and not too grindy to craft. It could also be sold by the Wizard granted anything else happens
This was also a while back but it didn't have too many stars.
ashen warren
I got a dumb suggestion again
If you die from DOG's body segments, he'll say "You should have aimed for the head"
It almost makes sense in universe, he's being sarcastic by telling you to get eaten, while also being overconfident by telling you his weakness
unborn latch
Just click on her head loooooool!!!
night cradle
Maybe Yoyo Bag instead of a yoyo glove?
frail mantle
^
cyan lagoon
Yoyo bag already has a recipe
If anything give it to the counterweights
both yoyo glove and the counterweights are rng reliant from the temporary merchants
worthy fiber
Adding yoyo stuff to the Ele Gauntlet's recipe's going to make it more tedious, yeah
Nobody's going to benefit from it anyway
ruby cobalt
*read as nobody
worthy fiber
Fixed
ruby cobalt
And if you think someone will benefit from those - look at your yoyo options at that point.
keen nebula
Yoyos stop making contact post-ML
ruby cobalt
More like they stop existing.
keen nebula
Which means the yoyo glove loses its charm
ruby cobalt
Terrarian, Solar Flare, Lacerator, Obliterator?
keen nebula
You can try to use the yoyo glove with the lacerator but you can't land a hit with the yoyo itself last time I tried
delicate raft
It's funny
Some people want a lower spawn rate for ???, and others want a higher one, and even other stuff related to spawn
lost agate
Well, some people dont know what the community is
narrow saffron
WE NEED MORE MUSIC BOXES
narrow saffron
Oh OK.
keen nebula
Non-linearity being a world generation option?
topaz flint
...h-how deep is it?! .-.
sinful violet
pretty deep
topaz flint
heavy breathing
umbral dune
why does everyone want a resprite for brimstone elemental
topaz flint
I-I only been to the houses...
sinful violet
because brim elemental has obnoxiously large breasts and people of taste want to tone that down
umbral dune
I feel like there are other things of more importance to resprite right now
topaz flint
am I the only one who thought she has 2 eyes until I saw the video for her theme and noticed it being one
umbral dune
I thought too
topaz flint
Glad to see Iām not alone
sinful violet
people arguing over whether or not she has two eyes or one
umbral dune
it's 1 eye, look at all the other sprites
sinful violet
no
topaz flint
:c
umbral dune
I accidently read brimstone's lore before fighting her, now I feel bad about killing her 
topaz flint
I donāt imagine killing her actually killing her
More so releasing her soul from the torment
umbral dune
š¤
keen onyx
wind flicker
Maybe a post-yharon SCal themed miniboss, since providence, doggo, and yharon each have respective minibosses
topaz flint
Providence got the scorn eater
Doggo got armored digger (I think)
And Yharon got-wait does bumblefuck count?
opal barn
None of those are minibosses
keen nebula
Make the lul ignore immunity so you don't have time to remove it
topaz flint
.-.
ashen warren
I has the confused
frail mantle
same
ashen warren
@pure dove Explain yourself, mate
frail mantle
just use apothtest mod and make the lel 
hollow shell
He needn't explain himself
lost agate
Yeah lul instakills you unless you un equip it
lunar berry
yees
devout seal
@pure dove Lul only kills you if you're not of the following name:
Fabsol
If your player is not named this, it will kill you.
hollow shell
Nope
Another criteria was added
Any town NPC being alive in the world also instantly kills you
ashen warren
woah
frail mantle
lmao
ashen warren
So.. a heat effect?
Use it too much too fast and it burns you?
Yep
But with the added caveat that if you get hit you also get burnt
Well, mainly the hits, having a mandatory heat up seems a bit too much for a Apotheosis-tiered weapon.
And while the Apotheosis may have a high mana cost, Drata doesn't need to get docked like that.
Well if it was buffed to reach around 500K dps but only for 10 seconds before you get backfired...
I meant more emphasis on the hitcap
But the heating up idea seems interesting if the Drata was buffed enormously.
neon panther
@tight chasm insert another one meme here
gusty geode
To that one guy asking for lul to not kill as fast
There are benefits to making the game pause when you open your inventory
tulip parcel
Buff Pearlwood
It's maybe the first hardmode material that you see when starting, Pearlwood is something exclusive to Hardmode, yet it's also completely garbage. Why? There's no reason for it to be as pathetic as it is. Maybe make it slightly worse than/on par with cobalt? Giving it at least some reason to be used would make early hardmode a little more rich, I feel.
Thoughts before I post this? Not sure what exactly to say here
lost agate
It would be cool to at least have some sort of special effect on it
So it works like a glass cannon armor
tulip parcel
right, like it still has wood-tier defense but gives... hrm
I need to look a couple of things up but I have an idea
lost agate
Something related to hallowed like....
tulip parcel
I was thinking of holy flames
lost agate
Maybe thats too much idk
tulip parcel
Holy Flames is -20HP/s
lost agate
Whenever you hit something a star falls down like the holy arrows?
tulip parcel
that's not all that much
ashen warren
Holy flames is one of the worst debuffs in calamity
lost agate
Well fuck
ashen warren
You can add it to pearlwood with like no difference
lost agate
Then i guess that could work
tulip parcel
maybe it's like
a classless sub-cobalt set that improves damage and movement speed
like it has substantially less defense but improves offensive stats
and the weapons deal increased damage (still beneath cobalt) but inflict holy flames?
Buff Pearlwood
It's maybe the first hardmode material that you see when starting, Pearlwood is something exclusive to Hardmode, yet it's also completely garbage. Why? There's no reason for it to be as pathetic as it is. Maybe make it slightly worse than/on par with cobalt?
For the armor, it could be a classless set that still gives wood-tier defense but also gives improved stats - damage, movement speed, defense piercing on weapons, just a couple examples.
For the weapons, they could be buffed to being beneath cobalt (cobalt repeater is 32 damage, pearlwood bow could be like... 20?) but also inflict Holy Flames? It would keep with the "Hallow is Profaned" theme of Calamity without being too strong (Holy Flames is -20 HP/s. For reference, Frostburn inflicts -6 HP/s on players and -8 HP/s on enemies; Perhaps holy flames could deal more damage as well when used on enemies?).
how 'bout this?
agile cloud
Not bad
fossil torrent
did you get the idea to buff pearlwood from what i wrote, or did it just spring into your head?
agile cloud
I'd use pearlwood if it was buffed like that
fossil torrent
Me too
wise pollen
frank stratus
yeah, I completely forget pearlwood exists because it literally has no use other than building (which I don't do) so if was usable, I would use it
ashen warren
Refined wulfrum makes a new armor or is required for the current one?
summer charm
Current armor.
frank stratus
the current wulfrum armour
summer charm
Maybe with a buff.
frank stratus
oof thought so
yeah, because it would be easier to just get ore armour
if it wasn't buffed
ashen warren
I was about to say that beating cnidrions would be way better in almost every way
frank stratus
since good ore armour gives more defence
ashen warren
No damage buff
summer charm
I could figure something else out though. Perhaps it is needed to craft the weapons, which are then buffed? But that's not really how Terraria does it.
Let's just assume a buff.
ashen warren
Probably how it would go
summer charm
That's a pretty good idea actually.
ashen warren
I don't see why you didn't just put it in the original suggestion
Especially since it's part of the mini-boss
summer charm
I just figured that the weapons needed to be outside because they were different.
But I can edit/compress them.
ashen warren
You make separate suggestions for separate concepts
For example "Buff drat cuz bad" and "add exo-gun" are separate
summer charm
Well, it's fixed.
ashen warren
"add a mini-boss and some weapons to go with" is together
lost agate
@scarlet thorn they wouldnt be that good rn since the only thing that would change is the bg color
If they get a new bg that would actually be cool to have
But not now really
scarlet thorn
Alright, thank you for your feedback!
lost agate
That would be a neat idea, but idk if its already planned or not mael
placid perch
Add a Chainsaw and Drill of Wulfrum because as of now there is no real reason to get it, I usually only get one of the helms to increase my minion count
This good?
Also
lost agate
Wdym
placid perch
Add chestplates ang leggings for the other helms that do simmilar things to what the helms do
lost agate
Wulfrum pickaxe is really good
And blade is good enough to get nerfed lol
Not to mention the staff and such are pretty decent
placid perch
I usually just go straight for ores and go fishing
lost agate
Wulfrum is meant to be the non-mining alternative
placid perch
It could also be made from Condensed Wulfrum bars
Along with Shards
Then the pick and axe out of just shards
lost agate
Tbh i dont see why wulfrum needs anything new
lost agate
Drills are worse pickaxe imo
ashen warren
Pickaxes are pretty much an objective upgrade, because they can get speed modifiers
That's pretty much it
lost agate
And they dont need you to aim at things to hit them while digging
ashen warren
Actually that's not true
They both work the same, but they have different animations
Wulfrum armor is pretty good unless it's halloween and you can get pumpkin armor
Tools are ascendant
Everything but wulfrum knives are really good
"no real reason to get wulfrum"
lost agate
ashen warren
Solo you can hit an enemy behind you with a pick and not with a drill
oh that
š¤¦
It's aimed
I thought you meant hit the blocks
lost agate
Nah xd
lost agate
Thats post eoc tho
placid perch
I never really need it, I just hit the caves right away and get iron and find other weapons
lost agate
Then thats how YOU play, that doesnt mean that wulfrum is bad
ashen warren
Iron is terrible compared to wulfrum but whatever
lost agate
Wulfrum give something other than simple defense
ashen warren
Even plat is only comparable
placid perch
The thing is Wulfrum becomes quickly irrelevant, at least to me
ashen warren
Wulfrum becomes irrelevant only when you smite a cnidrion
lost agate
^
frail mantle
except when youāre mining Aerialite
placid perch
The pick cant mine Demonite or Crimtane
ashen warren
Refer to what I just said
lost agate
Molten pick is awfully slow
ashen warren
Cause it's 100%
lost agate
I prefer to just get a gelpick tbh
ashen warren
Use wulfrum for everything else
Gelpick is the same as shark are you kidding?
Unless it was changed the mining speed is the same
frail mantle
Tbh I usually just assume Calamity picks are faster and use them instead
lost agate
I dont wanna fish tho 
ashen warren
That's fair
devout seal
the reaver shark can mine anything prehm tho
ashen warren
you jungle corrupting piece of-
devout seal
even vanadite in the abyss.
lost agate
Wiki says gelpick is faster
devout seal
abyss gravel.
while it was being made, it was called Vanadite.
and i personally think it sounds cooler then 'abyss gravel'
ashen warren
I'd call it gravel unless it's changed back to not cause confusion
Though I would also suggest to change it back because that's way cooler
devout seal
it never was actually called vanadite, it got added as abyss gravel and i personally find it annoying.
ashen warren
"Vanadite, Tenebris, Voidstone.." abyss gravel
devout seal
Gonna suggest it, tbh.
ashen warren
You've got my star š
spark flax
...why would you fight king slime in the underworld?
okay, yeah, to farm the hel-fire, but STILL
frail mantle
Wouldnāt that just be a bitch to code for something that is just a little visual neatness
radiant pawn
Why would you fight KS in every biome
radiant pawn
Also king slime, he isnt the god of every slime
and tbh i dont want a king lava slime that drops lava slimes everytime it gets hit if you know the reason
@ashen warren get the Operator from AlchemistNPC and voala 
tulip parcel
KS in ocean = KS with a leviathan hat
ashen warren
KS drops hats would be A-OK in my book
frail mantle
KS in ocean=KS with a Siren wig
ashen warren
Siren for ocean and levi for sulphur
radiant pawn
... swimming
radiant meadow
I think I inspired the pearlwood suggestion
summer charm
Thinking about suggesting a Racecar Driver NPC to go with the Wulfrum Menace. But I don't think I should cause that kinda makes it a real boss.
Just, have some cool ideas for it, and it could have some unique weapons to help you early on.
marsh gust
a limo mount
rancid laurel
Hello all! Iām new to this discord server, and I joined mainly to talk to other calamity mod users and to suggest some ideas. Iām a pretty casual player, right now Iām playing a calamity + thorium game (normal mode) and struggling to beat Supreme Calamitas for the first time.
Iāve got some ideas for the mod, and Iāll go ahead and list them here, Iād really like to see some of these in the game! (If one of these things already exists please tell me, I donāt want too look stupid lol)
-An accessory that can be worn to bypass Supreme Calamitasās hitcap. If this is too OP, maybe add a -10 to 20% damage or +10 to 20% damage taken as well, I would still gladly use the accessory šš
-Bacteria that appear in the fourth level of the abyss. These would be little enemies with a small amount of health but they would be able to attach to you (somewhat like brain sucklers, but multiple at once) and inflict a damaging debuff. Maybe the abyssal diving suit could be immune to these creatures.
-Another permanent health powerup crafted with Yharon soul fragments. Pretty self explanatory, +25 max health to be used once. Maybe another one after that that requires Shadowspec Bars as well!
-In death mode, the Zerg effect can randomly appear with a small chance at any time, that would be pretty hilarious
rancid laurel
Wow itās a lot longer than it looked when I typed it
lost agate
Hitcap is gone bud
topaz flint
it is!?
lost agate
Yes
rancid laurel
It is?
lost agate
You ever checked in mod browser?
rancid laurel
Yeah Iāve got an old version of calamity, it still has the astradelgon slime
lost agate
It even got finally uploaded to mod browser
topaz flint
that isn't just 'king slime with lasers'
rancid laurel
Not sure how old it is or how to update but I got it off of tmodloader a few months ago
lost agate
Better update bud
lost agate
Ew no
rancid laurel
How do you update in tmod?
rancid laurel
Oh thatās pretty convenient. Do I just reload?
spark flax
oh yeah also
ashen warren
Or use #mod-downloads and put it in your my games directory
rancid laurel
Going to do that now, thanks š
ashen warren
The only suggestion that is allowed/interesting is the bacteria one
lost agate
Also, yeah you wanna check the pins first before suggesting so you dont end up suggesting something unallowed or such
spark flax
yeah, definitely agreed re. the bacteria one
ashen warren
The other ones are mostly not allowed and random zerg effect was heckin stupid when stress was a thing
spark flax
but yeah, absolutely check the pins both in Suggestions and Discussion
rancid laurel
Ok Iāll do that
ashen warren
Just read #rules first and follow what it says
It says to read pins in there
you technically broke "Read the pins in a channel before posting" but whatever you're nice
spark flax
anyways, welcome to the calamity server, enjoy your stay!
topaz flint
don't do DaD blind
Deathmode
Armageddon[bosses 1-shot but 9 more treasure bags]
Defiled Rune[you have 1/2 hp everything takes 1/2 damage but better loot chances]
lost agate
For your safety, avoid pins in #general-talk
strong jacinth
:norway:
ashen warren
"specter" "poulterghast"
lost agate
@lucid marsh yeah uh, the least we need is another armor at that tier
Astral gets overshadowed by the almost instant ataxia
ashen warren
An abyss-victide upgrade that's throwing-based around early Hmode would be.. ok
ashen warren
@lucid marsh what ijones said (sorry for double-ping)
sleek wigeon
xeroc
lucid marsh
But then you have the same problem since xeroc is now the throwing lunar armor
ashen warren
Throwing doesn't really need new armor for anywhere except maybe early Hmode
Ataxia is for ML
lucid marsh
Yeah
So itās ok to have 2 armors there instead of 1
Plus water buffs good
Wait also good idea
ashen warren
Variety in weapons is what they actually need
lucid marsh
Make the first fishron related, and the second abyss related
ashen warren
Throwing "needs" new weapons around golem-ish tier and that's it
reef swift
Malachite
ashen warren
However throwing is OP as fuck in post-ml
So it balances out
Terrible username: that's why i used quotation marks.. for sarcasm
And xb: ataxia is intended to be used up until lunar armors
sleek wigeon
So? Its good to have unique stuff based around chlorophyte
Like all the other cool classes\
ashen warren
Astral is weird but I guess you could try that
ijones what are you talking about?
Minions inflict calamity venom?
Though that's a bit strong at -30 HP/s
sleek wigeon
-30 hps isnt that strong
rancid laurel
A cool thing to have would be an upgrade to the cosmic car key. Craft it with some nifty post-moon lord stuff like phantoplasm or auric ore. Pretty much itās the ufo but faster, can go in liquid, and hit a certain hot key to teleport to your cursor (will get chaos state debuff)
ashen warren
Except for the RoD thing but you can just use the RoD
rancid laurel
True
Crafting special campfires with herbs would be a cool idea. The flames would turn a different color (to make it look like you are using the herb as fuel) and maybe some additional effects could take place. Iāll think up the effects if I get the approval for this to go in the suggestions tab š
ashen warren
The only gripe I would have is that campfires have a small radius
Have the herbs increase the range
Double/triple or something
wait how would a waterleaf campfire work
radiant meadow
think cursed flames and ichor 
tulip parcel
flichor? curse ich?
cursed ick
š¤
...holy shit I'm taking that
gotta think how to implement that though
ashen warren
Dunno why the daybloom campfire has souls of night tbh
rancid laurel
Well itās not exclusive to the hollow but I see what you mean
ashen warren
Hallow fyi
tulip parcel
Cursed Ick
"Rotting Burning"
50 Cursed Flame + 50 Ichor + 1 Ruinous Soul @ Draedon's Forge = 50 Cursed Ick
A hybrid material meant for use in other items, such as arrows, bullets, or perhaps weapons. The intent is to create a combination "evil" material.
Additionally, Cursed Ick weapons would inflict a debuff on hit - "Rotting Inferno" - significantly reducing DR (in revengeance/death), defense, and inflicting high damage-per-second. I would suggest 40% DR, 20 Defense and 30 health per second, to make this stronger than plague, as well as to combine/improve Ichor and Cursed Flame's inherent debuffs. These numbers are just used as examples, but the overall intent would be the same.
hmm, might reword rotting inferno as a seperate unit
waddoyouguys think?
ashen warren
One thing is that fab doesn't seem to like making bosses susceptible to damaging debuffs for some reason
Especially post ML
tulip parcel
hmm
should I remove the damage component then? what would I replace it with?
wait no
ashen warren
Checking wiki to make sure I'm not spouting bs
tulip parcel
cursed inferno and ichor are two debuffs that post-provi bosses are NOT immune to
lemme read through em all
providence isn't
ashen warren
DoG is immune
tulip parcel
guardians aren't immune
storm weaver is immune to everything except ichor
obviously CV is immune to everything
signus isn't immune to ichor/cursed inferno
polterghast isn't
dog's immune to everything
bumblebirb isn't immune, and yharon isn't immune
ashen warren
Ruinous souls though
tulip parcel
and scal isn't immune
ashen warren
So just DoG, yharon and scal mostly
Birb doesn't even count cause I don't think people would complain if it were made immune to all debuffs
ashen warren
Since DoG is immune maybe have it do the frostspark bullet thing?
tulip parcel
what if they're crafted like...
ashen warren
Deals more damage to immune thingos
tulip parcel
using unholy cores maybe?
that would make sense too, though it moves them back pretty damn far
ashen warren
That makes it post-mech
I think plant/clone would work better
So ecto or something
ashen warren
Golem
ashen warren
If you cheat then yea
ashen warren
He's actually pretty difficult when you fight him in the temple
tulip parcel
anyway what I'm saying is, this is going to overshadow plague
because it reduces DR
even if it did -no damage- outside of the bullet/arrow's, it would still see far more use than plague anything
which is kinda bad
ashen warren
Ruinous is pretty good for setting up for later stages of the mod
I just hope they're able to finish the mod
tulip parcel
me too
...wait a moment
fuck, I've been going on about plague this whole time
why not just have this crafted -using- plague cell canisters
maybe at the ancient manipulator
ashen warren
I thought of that however- ancient manip sorta fixes what I was about to say
tulip parcel
maybe something like 50/20/50
ashen warren
Makes how much?
ashen warren
Seems neat
Ultra liquidator could be one of the only sources of it to make it viable
Still a pretty boring weapon but it would be useful at least
tulip parcel
maybe it alters the ultra liquidator's recipe to include some
hmm... okay I'm gonna put this up with the "plague cans/ancient manip" change
ashen warren
I can't remember how much cursed flames and ichor reduce dr though
ashen warren
Cursed then ich?
tulip parcel
the order you said em in, yep
ashen warren
Ick + MfD is very nice
I just thought about it and it shouldn't be that big of a deal
Bosses that rely on DR will just be immune anyway
ashen warren
More defense reduction though tbh
tulip parcel
that also fits with this being the "ultimate evil" material since
y'know, 666666
if you halve that
okay I'll put it up as threes
actually you know what
I'm gonna stick to the 33/33 thing for cursed flames and ichor
but increase the yield to 66
just so it's less of a pain to get a lot
ashen warren
Plague cells are kinda the odd one out now
They're not that hard to get
Similar actually to cursed flames and ichor in vanilla
sleek wigeon
10% movement speed is useless in hardmode
Since hermes boots and their upgrades cap your speed
tulip parcel
Uhh
ashen warren
Campfire suggestion vorbis
ashen warren
Blinkroot being +10% item use speed would make it good
Fireblossom and shiverthorn are also outliers though
Maybe it could inflict glacial state
Not useful for bosses but for events
tulip parcel
hey @hollow shell do you think I could/should improve the recipe for cursed ick?
I'm asking like a "how to"
tulip parcel
Yeah Iām not sure
hollow shell
I guess its a bit expensive, even for its big result
Gotta commit a lot to the ick, yknow?
You could probably reduce everything by a factor of 10
hollow shell
Including the result
hollow shell
factor of 10
hollow shell
3 Cursed Flame + 3 Ichor + 1 Plague Cell Canister @ Ancient Manipulator = 6 Cursed Ick
tulip parcel
So 3/2/3 = 6
Yeah
Wait 1
Man Iām dumb when Iām tired
Okay lemme edit that in
hollow shell
(maybe 7 ick)
radiant pawn
33 dps
radiant pawn
''bosses who are inmune to ichor or c. inferno should probably be not immune to rotting inferno''
ashen warren
"Any boss that isn't immune to ichor and cursed flame should probably not be immune to Rotting Inferno"
sleek wigeon
Its funny because icker is the wrong technical way to pronounce ichor
hearty yew
yeah I think that was the point
"if the boss is vulnerable to EITHER, they should be vulnerable to this"
or I guess
radiant pawn
i swear i read ''who are immune''
hearty yew
if the boss is vulnerable to plague, ichor, or cursed inferno
hollow shell
Yeah Lurantys you got it backways
tulip parcel
Yeah know, ozzy got it right
radiant pawn
shit-
tulip parcel
If theyāre vulnerable to one of those three
hearty yew
Vorbis, Suggestion King
ashen warren
Would that make lilith the previous queen or something?
Vorbis has been making really nice suggestions recently
tulip parcel
He may not have intended it
radiant pawn
i really like the pearlwood buff
tulip parcel
But he gave me the inspiration
radiant pawn
and the iCK sounds fun to use
hollow shell
Electro is clearly suggestions king but carry on
tulip parcel
Does that make me the suggestions Prince
Iāll accept it
Aināt been here long enough to be king
lol
radiant pawn
the forgotten man kosaku kawajiri was the god of suggestions
fervent zealot
meanwhile i'm down here as lord of suggestions hell
marsh gust
I'm suggestion peasant
fervent zealot
idgaf about references as long as it serves a purpose tbh
radiant pawn
im suggestion star grinder
radiant pawn
if you think for a jojo item
almost everything can be broken
maybe except for some killer queen attacks, as he isnt broken
but still
hearty yew
ļ¼„ ļ¼ø ļ¼Æ ļ¼§ ļ¼µ ļ¼®
radiant pawn
he isnt THAT broken
hearty yew
( like seriously where's the exo gun )
tulip parcel
In hell
frosty kindle
Anaera was suggested buuuut
radiant pawn
a lot of people suggested it but there's no dev check yet
frosty kindle
it even got the dev tick..
sleek wigeon
Exogun never because guns are big bad
ashen warren
You mean flag?
radiant pawn
no they arent :(
sleek wigeon
Bows are the new hotness
hearty yew
i think a few exo guns got dev checked
ashen warren
Ticks just mean they were sent
sleek wigeon
Dontcha know?
tulip parcel
I didnāt know fab liked gun control
frosty kindle
or alternatively, buff the Gale so i can flex on the Drat
hearty yew
like the MGS3 reference one got dev checked
radiant pawn
or what bunjin said
sleek wigeon
"buff an exo tier to apoth tier"
frosty kindle
seriously, remove piercing on most of Gale's arrows and we're good
sleek wigeon
hearty yew
gale's issue is that it doesn't fire arrows it's just a laser gun by another name
ashen warren
Just buff both
hearty yew
and most of its lasers effects are pretty shit
radiant pawn
now im getting the self cringe 
frosty kindle
totally not biased btw
hearty yew
i mean
that is kinda happening this patch
have you seen all the vanilla weapon buffs
it's kinda mental
radiant pawn
if vanilla weapons get buffed
frosty kindle
bad meme and you should feel bad
frosty kindle
they already were
radiant pawn
nebula fist
ashen warren
"Balanced armor sets, accessories, buffs, etc. (mostly the critical strike chance) to be more in-line with vanilla." everything is nerfed this patch
tulip parcel
They always were tho
radiant pawn
the mage ones weren't tbh
frosty kindle
just not the best options, though def viable
ashen warren
uh
fervent zealot
nebula fist is nebulabad
frosty kindle
Solar and Vortex weapons are godly tho
tulip parcel
It is?
frosty kindle
Nebula not so much
tulip parcel
I thought it was good
radiant pawn
nebula fist is cool but not good for ml imo
tulip parcel
Awww
radiant pawn
but s l o w
frosty kindle
Stardust is just praying that the dragon doesn't target something random or faff about
tulip parcel
At least prism is good
ashen warren
Nebula arc thing real good
tulip parcel
I love you prism
fervent zealot
cells are just never speak to me
tulip parcel
Triangles are love
fervent zealot
ijones is a cell user?
frosty kindle
Stardust cells are good but literally everybody goes with dragon
fervent zealot
yeah cells are good but dragon is pretty much god descending to earth
ashen warren
What did you just say about my cells?! @fervent zealot
fervent zealot
they have celluose
radiant pawn
cells are good
they dont steal i-frames as the dragon does
i cant hit one eye without the frames getting consumed by the dragon 
sleek wigeon
CONSUME F R A M E S
fervent zealot
i'll eat your frames and spit out a dead boss
but back on the topic of suggestions we really need more summons
phm summoner is in a passable place, but hm summoner...
radiant pawn
thou shALL CONSUME F R A M E S
fervent zealot
you literally use 2 total summons in a normal hm summoner playthrough
fervent zealot
claspers, then go to entropy's vigil, then done
or opt to get dragon as the third but
radiant pawn
i was joking im sorry