Yeet every boss out of existence
#suggestions-discussion
lunar berry
plush remnant
Yote
lunar berry
That’s...just stupidly overpowered
hollow shell
Stream Gouge?
lunar berry
^
Combine anti material rifle with world shattered
With muninite
Luminite*
Infinite pierce, i frame ignoring 4000 dmg bullet
gusty geode
Post-SCal stuff doesn't need to be balanced, at least not yet, right?
lunar berry
That’s not post scal
neon panther
post-scal stuff isnt even allowed lol
neon panther
calamitous essence
hollow shell
ye
also you should never say "it doesn't need to be balanced"
That only causes many problems
lunar berry
Who remembers that one glowing mushroom gun from anti arias that ignored i frames
ashen warren
hali🅱ut
lunar berry
Fungi boomgun i think it was called
That shit melted EoC in about 1 second
And it was pre-boss
ashen warren
Cannon with 1 usetime isn't that strong
hasty wigeon
Arkhalis is just a reference weapon :3
placid perch
It looks like Arkhalis is made of them
ashen warren
Yes but there's no point in crafting arkhalis when you can have terra shiv
placid perch
I mean, its just a idea
hollow shell
All #suggestions-voting posts are just ideas
Some people put more thought into them than others :P
placid perch
Also I said for collectors
hollow shell
It'd be way more useful if you allowed it to be obtained at a point where it's somewhat useful
instead of, yknow
useless
livid coral
I'd like Arkhais to be useful pre HM since that is where its at best. What /I/ want is a viable HM Arkhalis type weapon, and a late HM, and post ML Arkhalis weapon so I can do my close melee swingy run
placid perch
Well the Enchanted sword is also a hardmode item and Arkhalis is meant to be found, so I just did it like that
hasty wigeon
Murasama is lategame arkhalis
placid perch
Crafted hardmode I mean
hasty wigeon
Endgame*
ashen warren
Arkhalis is one of the most interesting vanilla items and calamity only adds 1
So sad
livid coral
It's endgame I'm NOT gonna use an endgame weapon that whole game
round walrus
Isn't enchanted sword already craftable?
livid coral
I believe it is
marsh gust
i think it drops from cosmic elementals in calamity
round walrus
There's also a recipe, though, I think
lunar berry
isn’t arkhalis already craftable
lunar berry
and enchanted sword is a hardmode craftable beaucse ark of the ancients
hasty wigeon
But it doesn't >.>
ashen warren
I have checked
marsh gust
it wouldnt rlly matter imo
marsh gust
buff destroyer = player nerf ? 
hasty wigeon
Yes
marsh gust
ingrish is hard
ashen warren
That's silly way to think about it but fine
hollow shell
Wait, the changelogs buff?
That shouldn't affect any normal players' playthroughs, really
lucid oracle
You know, one thing i've noticed about suggestions chat, is that there's no easy way to sort it. Has anyone ever considered using a bot to categorize suggestions and let people easily access them
ashen warren
Categorizing suggestions sounds like have suggestions be off discord
lucid oracle
Not necessarily
hollow shell
How could it be done in discord?
hollow shell
What would the bot do?
lucid oracle
Have commands to look up suggestions. Which it would then PM you all the suggestions of a specific type. Although personally I would just prefer something out of discord, I imagine people would prefer to keep it within discord
i.e if you want to know what swords have been suggested, just ask the bot
hollow shell
uhh that would be like 80 PMs
lucid oracle
The end goal here is to give older suggestions more attention.
That's true
A spreadsheet would be a more elegant solution
ashen warren
Have you seen what the hamstar mod thing does to the mod browser?
lucid oracle
nope
ashen warren
That would work
hollow shell
What
hollow shell
I don't know what you're talking about
lucid oracle
Neither tbh
lucid oracle
Anyway, at the very least a bot that lets you add suggestions to a database, as well as listing their votes etc. Viewing would need to be done out of discord though, I guess. I mean, if you wanted a reasonable system
80 PMs is always on the table though 
hollow shell
Suggestions do get categorized when they get sent to the dev server
The effort required, what's needed to implement it, what type of change it is, etc
So a dev could look for suggestions of a specific type just by using Discord's search bar
if they wanted
ashen warren
This is what I mean
hollow shell
What in the world
lunar berry
Wtf
lucid oracle
Hm, but that doesn't affect anyone here. Older suggestions become much harder to view as time goes on and new ones get posted, as well as the searching not being very... reliable. i.e, you can't exactly filter suggestions, any suggestion that involves that word would be included
the fuck is that
cool
hollow shell
tbh I think it's a good thing that older suggestions get forgotten
Leaves a lot less work for me needing to check what's reached 50, for one, and somebody is bound to repost a good idea whether they knew of the old suggestion or not
lucid oracle
Well my friend, do I have a great solution for checking when something reaches 50
Automation!
hollow shell
Hahaha we tried
lucid oracle
(Reminder to always shill automation)
ashen warren
The bot is broken btw
lucid oracle
Tried? What went wrong?
ashen warren
Discord api or something
hollow shell
We tried to set up a bot but Discord's bot programming didn't quite allow for it
yeah
lucid oracle
Huh, that's weird. From what I've heard Discord is pretty flexible in what you can do with bots. I'd be surprised if something that basic wouldn't be possible
hollow shell
ikr
marsh gust
@sharp spade this bot?
hollow shell
Yep
marsh gust
what we need is a bot to warn people automatically just to tick them off even more 
that'll be super annoying to have
lunar berry
‘Online - 5946’
hollow shell
?
reef moat
heh
only did it cuz im a bitch and got hit a few times by them when they spawned in boss rush
plus think of all the nohitter it would save
earnest raptor
Increase summon damage cap in rev+
Summoners have a naturally higher damage bonus, that other classes, but mostly in post-golem their has been devoured by damage cap. Simply, a Auric summoner helmet have 120% summon damage, 1/3 from it cuts by cap. That's not a normal.
digital sparrow
The cap is only inflicted when you hold other weapons
You’re not supposed to use other weapons as summoner, that’s the point of the cap
radiant meadow
He means rev dmg caps
Not the summoner penalty
Good idea though
Summons can't crit making the dmg cap hurt more
digital sparrow
Oh yeah those, I agree the caps are kinda dumb
lucid oracle
I wouldn't agree entirely
I think caps are a good thing to have, but their implementation is poor.
radiant meadow
they're good for other classes
but summoner gets hit hard without crits
they should still exist, but they should be higher on summoner
plush remnant
Man, my Profaned Armor suggestion isn't gaining as much attention as my other stuff.
Anyone mind helping me make this armor more desirable?
marsh gust
someone needs to check the titanic
heady comet
It was already buffed last update but i guess that doesnt matter does it?
Fucking memer
@tight chasm
ashen warren
ashen warren
Frantically checks update logs
heady comet
Syg, again
frosty kindle
hollow shell
Muted?
ashen warren
I can't find the buff in changelogs.
frosty kindle
big brain frenchcore
heady comet
from:Fabsol#9706 Amr
ashen warren
Huh.
Didn't know it would be listed as amr, and not Anti-Material-Rifle.
So should I just delete my post or..
frosty kindle
i wouldnt delete it so soon tbh
tight chasm
nah, no need
frosty kindle
have a playtest with it, and it still feels too lackluster then your point will still stand
tbh, i feel the AMR could, or should be a viable option for yharon even
ashen warren
Alright. I think I still have my save if I didn't delete it by accident.
tight chasm
for a weapon that boasts 7,000 fucking damage you'd expect it to be able to kill yharon
frosty kindle
weapon with 7k base damage and ability to spawn more bullets
ashen warren
Wait it deals 7k?
frosty kindle
7,000 base damage/bullet
ashen warren
It did what.. 4k how long ago?
sinful violet
Pre astral update
frosty kindle
i feel the weapon has great potential if it were to have a slightly better RoF, as it is tied with the eviscerator for highest (slowest RoF) use time
ashen warren
I mean a slow RoF makes sense in real life considering the sheer size and weight of an AMR. However in Terraria I don't think it should be that abysmally slow, considering you can carry a forest in your inventory.
fervent zealot
you can carry a lot more than a forest
ashen warren
You get my point.
fervent zealot
yes, i'm just saying the pc can also carry around a small planet's worth of metal and not be weighed down by it in the slightest
ashen warren
Which goes into the point that slow RoF on a rifle (usually bolt action and magazine fed) is kind of odd.
The barrett is an exception to that.
M99 that is.
Oh yeah this feels a lot better than I last used it. But I still remember that slow RoF..
Eh, I think it's pretty well balanced now.
placid perch
Question, Im new here so I dont know the functions of this server very well, but in suggestions what do the checkmarks mean?
lunar berry
Star means you agree
hollow shell
Looks at this channel's pins
hollow shell
Blue tick but okay
ashen warren
smh the rules say read the damned pins
placid perch
Rip im on phone and the layout sucks
lunar berry
Suggest it then 
placid perch
I mean I completely forgot pinned messages were up there, I would have if I had acknowledged it
ashen warren
The reason you forgot was probably because you skipped the rules
sleek wigeon
And all the shit telling you to read pins
ashen warren
"Read the pins in a channel before posting"
sleek wigeon
We have a channel with "read_pins" in the name
ashen warren
~~forgot how to underline 
~~
sleek wigeon
You can underline in discord?
pine solar
_
placid perch
Nah I read the rules
ashen warren
Put 2 _'s between the word fyi
lunar berry
dd
placid perch
I may be dumb, but not that dumb
lunar berry
Hey it works’
pine solar
ye
placid perch
Cool
I have a idea, basicly a flail of the Slap Hand: the Sticky hand, good reach, huge knockback, but 1 or 0 damage, available pre-hardmode
Now multicolored
lunar berry
Make it look like one of those hand slap toys you can buy
placid perch
Exactly
Good idea?
Obtained from King Slime as a rare drop from his treaaure bag possibly?
placid perch
Gn
frail mantle
Vorbis’ Titanic idea has 60 stars and no check mark 
raw patio
it's at 50 now :p
lunar berry
nice
astral gust
didn't know people liked my idea that much
guess that's what happens when i put too much time into a damn suggestion
ashen warren
Just 5 more come on
astral gust
ikr
ruby cobalt
Ew, star begging 
marsh gust
ggwp, scissors beat paper
marsh gust
can someone send titanic to the devs
frail mantle
Yay Flareon has 50 stars now 
marsh gust
ashen warren
You're allowed
astral gust
^^
ashen warren
Frowned upon is all
tulip parcel
I mean you're allowed but
frail mantle
spark flax
@dire remnant no point making suggestions for things that aren't in the game yet and that the devs probably already have a plan for
dire remnant
ok
bitter flower
inb4 making a suggestion about something that doesnt exist
quasi fable
marsh gust
44 :cri:
echo parcel
oh rip
ashen warren
"Jopo put my size limit really high, that's not the issue. The issue is that my internet connection, or the browser's connection, cannot handle it."
tulip parcel
you know if you want to do a sky dungeon
there's only one place you can really set it now
the jungle side of the map
probably main-planetoid sized, maybe larger
ashen warren
Why jungle specifically?
tulip parcel
Due to how the sulphurous sea works now it’s basically a giant biome column
You couldn’t have a sky dungeon biome above that
ashen warren
That's right at the edge though
tulip parcel
I was thinking this would be at the edge
ashen warren
But I guess i see your point
tulip parcel
I dunno. There’s probably a better way to make new dungeon-esque lategame content
tulip parcel
Big Stick
Pre-Hardmode True Melee Weapon
Wood (50+) @ Saw Mill
A gigantic club (roughly as long as a tree’s height) with abysmally slow swing speed. When swung, the Big Stick starts incredibly slow before accelerating as it reaches the end of its swing arc. Enemies may be hit multiple times per swing of the Big Stick. The player may not change direction, or switch weapons, while the Big Stick is swinging.
wicked swift
Soo... it's like a Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin Claymore-type weapon?
wicked swift
Those are actually my favorite type of weapons in that game so I like it
tulip parcel
Should I add its upgrades in? I was going to add two
First would be an ebonwood+shadowscale upgrade that turns it into a spiked club
Then pearlwood, hallowed bars and light/dark shards to make it into a light-dark weapon
wicked swift
Oooo
Double nice, because it's a new type of weapon with high-risk high-reward AND it gives Pearlwood a purpose
I like it a lot
And also the idea of slapping eyes with sticks
tulip parcel
You wouldn’t bat an eye
frail mantle
That should be the tooltip
wicked swift
tulip parcel
Okay I’ll write it up proper in a moment
wicked swift
I don't really know about making the Big Stick available pretty much from the start tho
tulip parcel
Well no
It’s crafted at the sawmill
So you have to at least mined five iron bars before being able to get it
wicked swift
Yeah but still, that's really early
tulip parcel
Though maybe it could be crafted with like...
wicked swift
gtg now, hope others like it
astral gust
i got a long weekend ahead of me, so i can put in more time on things i really shouldn't be putting alot of time into
umbral dune
Is that a One Piece reference I see
lucid marsh
Should I redo my lichy trigger finger idea to make it 10x fire rate (so use time divided by 10) instead of setting it to 1? If I did, I would repost it instead of edit it so it isn’t buried
Nevermind, I edited it
But should I delete it and repost the edited one if it isn’t noticed?
rich prawn
Meteor Mash
HM Meteor Fist like weapon
- Left Click : Acts like Meteor Fist, very slight piercing.
- Right click : The user dashes over a short distance, dealing higher damage than the left click attack. Releases star on enemy hit and grants a temporary damage boost. Unsure about if it should work like Asgard's Valor ram or like Shield of Cthulhu.
Why should this be added : Melee kind of suffers in early hm and doesn't have that many options for Cryogen. It would also give more reasons to explore the Astral biome early on.
(unsure about which color for the claws should be used, hence why the 2 pictures)
hollow shell
Oooooo
I like this idea
lucid marsh
Agreed, except corruption worlds
teal shoal
msot of people use qol mods anyway so they can swap weapons and things like that
rich prawn
baghnakhs dum, don't count
hollow shell
Fetid is hardly an intended option like ever
teal shoal
i wonder why
but even if
for cryo you can just grab offtank amidias spark setup and yourdidit
rich prawn
anyway may i post it
devout seal
lucid oracle
@lucid marsh The fire-rate bonus is complete bullshit, an item like that would be the best accessory you can get
lucid oracle
No weapons have a fire-rate high enough where you could get use out of the accessory
Well, most weapons don't
elder kestrel
@rich prawn :hellyes:
ruby cobalt
meteor fist memes, me like
elder kestrel
Look brrp it's a good suggestion >:(
shadow prism
Awoken or Empowered boss summons crafted from 1 (boss summon) + 1 calamitous essence by hand. Summons the boss rush version of that boss with all AI changes, buffs, etc. Gives people a way to practice certain BR bosses without having to go through a ton of other bosses first. The summons are not consumable and don’t have biome restrictions. Killing these bosses drops nothing except maybe money. In the case of Wall of Flesh, it still has to be dropped in lava in the underworld. For Siren & Levi, make it crafted with various ocean materials or one of their drops or something since they don’t have a dedicated summoning item.
thoughts?
summer charm
Any thoughts on the nunchuck idea?
queen sail
I think dog is on his death mode ver
Since he apparently instakills if you touch his head
opal barn
Some bosses are on Death AI while some of them are on a combination of Rev and Death
lucid marsh
Should my lichy trigger finger suggestion be nerfed a ton?
I think I’ll make it double speed instead
Nerfed it to 2.5x speed. Still crazy but you’re not MEANT to get max possible use out of it, and someone could get an auto clicker but that’s cheating so shame on them for cheating I guess
opal barn
I smell meme suggestion @ashen warren
ashen warren
it wasnt meant to be a meme
opal barn
Well it sure is one
frosty kindle
Sounds too ridiculous for it to actually be possible
(Also teragat im still on mobile, so if you could...)
night cradle
Is my suggestion a bit too short?
real parrot
nope
opal barn
do i warn too or do we pass it
frosty kindle
Just pass it tbh
He didnt mean for it to be a meme in the first place
Though farfetched, we’ll slide it by first time
Delet but dont warn
opal barn
Yeah already did delete it
low hedge
semicircle depression 
night cradle
?
wicked swift
Hey @tulip parcel, are you thinking about your big stick suggestion or did you forget to post it in #suggestions-voting?
wicked swift
I was going to star but then saw it wasn't in #suggestions-voting
wicked swift
Well, at least I saved it from being lost forever
wicked swift
What was it?
radiant meadow
wouldn't it be better for the wof summon to be like Fargo's fleshy doll?
for a non-consumable item, dropping it in lava would be a chore
unless it's supposed to burned, then its a waste of calamitous essence
wicked swift
@chrome badger Just download recipe browser if you want that
chrome badger
That' doesn't tell me what armor I should go for after getting (for example) hollowed armor
wicked swift
Oh like that. Well, that's what you get for not being specific I suppose
lost agate
Thats why you have wiki guides and #help-advice-read-pins
chrome badger
I should not have to look up in a wiki to figure out something that should be plainly laid out in-game
@wicked swift How should I phrase the suggestion then?
lost agate
Uh, so we should tutorialize the game and prevent experimentation?
Well ok then
And just look at the guide npc whenever you get new stuff, you will run into a new armor sometime
chrome badger
No, but knowing if Xerox armor is the next better armor after terragon or the other-way around would be nice
hollow shell
@lunar berry Just change that to Truffle sells Truffle Worms
Cryo Key was suggested an hour ago
plush remnant
Pitch Black Looking Glass
Focusing the raw energies from a tear in the fabric in reality through profaned crystals humming with unholy power and converging them on a single point? What could possibly go wrong!?
Made with Dark Plasma, Divine Geodes, Profaned Crystal, and Cosmilite Bars.
Mage weapon.
Fires several beams of both profaned and dark energy in a fashion similar to the Last Prism, only with a longer windup before the beams solidify into one. As these beams converge, they start to react with each other, creating an AoE at the end of the beam instead of having the beam being infinitely piercing. This AoE pulls enemies not immune to knockback to the center of it and rapidly damages them.
: More uses for Profaned Crystal/more Prov based content, and it seemed like a fun concept for a weapon.
Thoughts?
I might add the Last Prism as a requirement.
tulip parcel
last prism is getting an upgrade soon so don't do that that's a cool suggestion,t hough I'd do away with the
it's kinda tacky
plush remnant
I've been using it for too long, it's a part of my normal format
And alrighty, I'll yeet it into suggestions
hollow shell
@lucid oracle What are you actually suggesting?
More True Melee weapons?
lucid oracle
Yes, although ones that have effects attached to them rather than just swinging a sword.
Short-ranged effects, but still something cooler than just swinging a sword
tulip parcel
I just thought of a melee wep that'd be pretty cool
though I need to think about it for a bit
it involves invulnerability dashing
lucid oracle
@hollow shell Grand guardian seems to be a bit too long range. I'm talking more, say
Imagine you had a spear, and that spear shot a jet of flame about 30% the length of the spear
that should count as true melee
I admit the suggestion may be a bit too broad.
hollow shell
Nah True Melee has been pretty well defined as only having effects on hit (if any), never having effects on swing
If you start having swing-effects that are just kinda short
then the definition begins to get a bit arbitrary
lucid oracle
That's true, although it would be a decision for the person designing it to make, one could say... a balance decision?
I dunno, I mean there's more wrong with some swords than whether or not they can have true melee on swing, anyway
lucid oracle
@chrome badger I'm not sure what the purpose of such a thing would be
Especially since you have the actual guide, and the wiki.
hollow shell
The Recipe Browser mod also does a way better job at that than we could ever implement into Calamity
(probably)
chrome badger
The guide is about as useful for telling me armor progression as the Bethesda loading screen trivia is to plot progression
And I shouldn't need to tab out of the game and look up "what armor do i make after X" every time I need to upgrade
And the weapons are even more problematic due to how many of them there are.
radiant meadow
that's why recipe browser is what you go to, not the dumb npc
the npc is just wof fodder
chrome badger
The recipe browser only tells me how to make the armor and the individual armor stat, It doesn't tell me what the set bonuses are or what the total armor rating(s) is/are
radiant meadow
well, idk how an ingame guide would be implemented
unfortunately, the wiki is your best option regardless of how inconvenient it is to tab out
chrome badger
Well a book starting with "here's wood armor and what it does" and then going up the line would be helpful
placid perch
Maybe you could craft a Frost Compas like item that gives a rough direction of where you should go next
Not exact, very broad
chrome badger
Same for weapons to, start with the basic, a short blurb of what they do, then go on to the next.
placid perch
Also if you have a secondary device that can be used for wiki checking
chrome badger
A player should not need 2 devices to play one game (Excluding the TV/monitor and whatever game platform they are using), That's getting into Nintendo levels of absurd
placid perch
Fair enough
Exploration Compass
It seems to know where its going
Crafted w/ 7 Iron Bars, what else?
It needs more than that, but my brain cant come up with anything
ashen warren
Why the hell does my 'Buff AMR' suggestion have 33 votes when I learned it already was buffed?
umbral dune
@placid perch I mean, you could do an Urchin Stinger for the needle
placid perch
True
Exploration Compass
It seems to know where its going
Crafted w/ 7 Iron Bars, 2 Urchin Needle, Celestial Magnet? @ Anvil
umbral dune
ye, not sure what it does tho.
hollow shell
Yeah, it'd help to get some examples and/or clarifications
Like, would it always be pointing to Hell/the Dungeon in pre-HM?
Where would it point once HM begins?
lunar berry
What does it do
lunar berry
What about like, compasses or treasure maps like in minecraft
hollow shell
@placid perch Normal Beds are crafted at Sawmills, not Loom
lunar berry
Like they point you to somewhere
Maybe an enchanted sword shrine or a normal shrin
Idk
Why 2 different crafting stations tho
placid perch
Ah
placid perch
I was thinking of cloth being made at loom
lunar berry
Maybe scrap the loom recipe, but the workbench recipe is replaced by loom
So 2 beds, other stuff at loom
hollow shell
*sawmill
placid perch
What if you have 2 beds, and want a bunk bed instead
hollow shell
I think having two recipes is fine
sour hornet
Its supposes to be a challenge
placid perch
Well for giving more time it would reduce everything else to instant
hollow shell
Bosses do have extended rest periods in the final and 2nd-to-final tiers
Only as high as 6 seconds though, iirc
placid perch
Maybe in revengence mode if a boss has a specific biome to spawn they will enrage if they leave it
placid perch
EoW
placid perch
BoC
hybrid viper
that's what calamity feels like already
placid perch
A bit
hybrid viper
idk I'm thinking too outside the box rn
plush remnant
What's the consensus on my Pitch Black Looking Glass suggestion?
Pretty fun, meh, ?
sullen flame
I mean if the cutscene was toggleable, I would love having a cutscene at the start of a playthrough
lunar berry
Hmm
plush remnant
Yeah, I'm debating adding Last Prism to the recipe.
sullen flame
personally
plush remnant
To make it an upgrade
lunar berry
Done
placid perch
Then its good
lunar berry
Sometimes you just gotta star your own suggestion to kickstart i
T
Ill unstar when it gets more stars
plush remnant
I just like the idea of a weapon that can pull groups of enemies into a single area. If this fails, I'll probably make a Black Hole Gun suggestion.
spark flax
i'd be lying if i said i've never done that before
plush remnant
Same
placid perch
Maybe the lore will play a cutscene, and instead of a cutscene in start a lore in the Starter Bag
Not really a cutscene for lores, maybe just a picture to do with it as a backround and the words on the screen
plush remnant
My Profaned Armor has ended up being my most well received suggestion so far.
Hopefully it gets the last 7-8 stars it needs to hit the milestone.
Plz star, it would mean the world to me to have one of my shitty suggestions get sent to the dev server 
plush remnant
Well, hopes and prayers to bolster the Profaned Flame, then.
little raptor
@pure dove its called bossrush for some reason
hollow shell
Someone already said that
lunar berry
That someone was me
hollow shell
@ashen warren Bonus points if your character is male
hollow shell
Exactly 😎
hollow shell
ashen warren
so traps?
hollow shell
more like mtf transformation, but equally degenerative
ashen warren
WHEEZE
placid perch
When someone gets more Stars than you have gotten ever instantly
nvm, the Blob Wand has 20, but only now does it
I mean I have bad ideas so that would make sense
placid perch
Just make a goo suggestion
Like the Goobow?
placid perch
Ik
lunar berry
Btw, i would say that non-weapon suggestions will get the most stars
placid perch
Just making a joke
lunar berry
It’s hard to tell online
placid perch
Well I made Bunk beds, they did not too bad
lunar berry
Yeah
sinful violet
bunk beds aren't likely
placid perch
Ik, but I mean it may inspire smth
hollow shell
Alterra would do it
sinful violet
do what you'd like, i can't stop you
alterra could indeed
dunno if that's a priority compared to the other tiling atm though
keen onyx
@ashen warren honestly exactly what i've been wishing for kinda??
lunar berry
Wtf
ashen warren
Wrong channel?
Yeah we need that in Calamity. NOW
Calamity is not a QoL mod
Disregard this
lunar berry
- Why do we need it
ashen warren
Nor is it an omni-mod
lunar berry
- Post it in #suggestions-voting
lunar berry
Well isnt that t most detailed suggestion I’ve ever seen
placid perch
Also is the Meteor Mash going to be sent to the Devs? Or did no one put a Checkmark
cyan lagoon
@foggy vapor elaborate
quiet abyss
@umbral tendon The flame pillars always spawn beside you
And they, along with the flame pillars, always spawn whenever Ravager stomps on the ground from a jump (every 2nd stomp when he start jumping twice as rapidly)
Watch him or his icon on the map
If you see him jump prepare to slowdown/stop and move up/down
Imo it’s fine rn
Stops you from just running to avoid attacks and make you have to watch your movement/be aware of your surroundings a bit
ashen warren
I think you've just made me able to fight ravager on summoner
Flame pillars always got me
heady comet
when #suggestions-discussion becomes #help-advice-read-pins xd
umbral tendon
I didnt realize that. Now I might be able to beat it without spamming the nurse
ashen warren
fuck dreadmine that shit is boring
heady comet
Considering the possibility that this suggestion gets implemented, fab would do something like double dr to compensate
crimson cove
Tru dat
heady comet
Always compensations. Always
crimson cove
Fair
Honestly, I don’t know if an infinite throwing knife was even useful
as in me suggesting it
I mean, most throwers start with other things
sinful violet
@keen nebula That's more suited to the art server, but if that gets 50 stars, I'll be sure to let em know
plush remnant
Aaaaaaaaaa 2 more stars, I can feel the anticipation building.
umbral dune
I mean an art contest would be really cool, but I feel like 1/2 of the entries would be the waifus
I would love to see some calamitas art
keen nebula
art is art
umbral dune
(and I think that yharon is cool)
cyan lagoon
@noble violet putting stats in the suggestion isnt required btw
Their stats come down to Fabsol and the other devs' decisions
lunar berry
hmmm
noble violet
lunar berry
The stats are inconsistent and unrequited
keen nebula
I had a cool idea for a double-pistol weapon that is the phoenix blaster and the undertaker combined but i scrapped it since both weapons already have separate upgrades
heady comet
smelly suggestion
radiant meadow
unfair to those who paid
hmm...
$20 or grueling hard work and dedication
which one is more unfair? 
ashen warren
I'd pay $20 to have scal just no hit herself
ashen warren
It's $20 on patreon
lucid marsh
Is my suggestion bad? Or are people just not seeing it since it got burried
teal wolf
probbo buried
ashen warren
Might be both
shadow prism
smh just be the first to nohit boss rush
marsh gust
ashen warren
Although in all seriousness it doesn't mean a suggestion is bad
teal wolf
like the america is a great gun idea
ashen warren
Just means it either got buried or it just wasn't something slot of people wanted
teal wolf
its just burried now 😭
shadow prism
politics tho
teal wolf
dude its a fucking minigun+a rocket launcher
marsh gust
is it funny that my paper plane suggestion gets more stars compared to a sickass gun that screams america?
teal wolf
is that not enough america for you?
shadow prism
about 20 or so of my suggestions have been sent, 1 got implemented and it was a cheese fix
ashen warren
What's your paper plain suggestion
shadow prism
no offense but no gear suggestion will ever get in
marsh gust
like an early hm throwing weap
ashen warren
I got 11 sent and 3 implemented
teal wolf
Ima probably just pay more money
teal wolf
I think with patreon this mods developement became pay to win
shadow prism
no lol
teal wolf
throwing does need love
ashen warren
It needs more love in hm
shadow prism
cheatsheet exists, therefore it will never be pay to win
marsh gust
agree
teal wolf
celestus is great just getting there is sluggish in terms of progression
shadow prism
SotC and executioners exist
marsh gust
your choices for early hm throwing is limited tho
ashen warren
Not anymore they dont
shadow prism
valediction?
ashen warren
teal wolf
you have no choices basically
shadow prism
brimblade is god tier tho
ashen warren
Yeah but it's the only good hm weapon
neon panther
@keen onyx yes
marsh gust
@keen onyx there's a flight time increasing booze
ashen warren
Needs something golem tier
Yeah but the booze one is bad
Since it makes you floaty
keen onyx
i mean like something reliable and just gives you more flight time
shadow prism
no it doesn’t
marsh gust
it didnt for me for whatever reason
ashen warren
It says it does
willow dagger
i think I found a graphical error with ataxia armor
shadow prism
it doesn’t
marsh gust
its just good
keen onyx
would probably be best in post ml fights
ashen warren
Oh sweet
shadow prism
yeah it’s epic and lowkey broken
radiant meadow
I mean caribbean rum is already pretty reliable
marsh gust
yep
placid perch
Im thinking of a new Hardmode mount that like the Shrimpy Truffle gets a speed boost in lava and has infininte flight in it also, but outside it is limited flight.
Something along the lines of Guide Doll
Summons a Demon mount to carry you around
As expected it would be dropped by Demons
It would just be holding you, instead of you riding it
lucid oracle
@unique vector The one thing I don't understand
Is why did you compare it to a Minecraft book?
Why not just... a book
placid perch
Because of the way the guide in the Minecraft books are, and it was the most simmilar to what he was talking too
unique vector
^ yeah that
lucid oracle
I really wouldn't pin that as a major difference from an actual book, but okay
placid perch
What do you guys think of my mount idea?
hollow shell
@keen onyx Sorry I'm late but could you add some reasoning why to your suggestion?
As in, added to the message itself
keen onyx
Oh
lucid oracle
@placid perch What benefit does it have over the shrimpy truffle
keen onyx
Well I thought it would be genuinely useful, especially post-moon lord to have extra added flight time. To compensate the potion could be rather expensive, possibly use more than 10 blood orbs when trying to craft from orbs, but
placid perch
Well it can be obtained early on easily
keen onyx
It could benefit you when dealing with certain bosses. I came up with the idea on the spot and didn't necessarily think through it much, so
Poke holes in it as you will, I'd like to hear criticism
lucid oracle
What would the use of such a mount be, then? A limited flight mount that has no benefits over other mounts isn't going to be useful, unless it's better than a pair of wings.
placid perch
Also it could give lava and fire resistance
hollow shell
To the message in #suggestions-voting, Artezui
lucid oracle
I guess that gives it a unique benefit.
placid perch
That way you wont get hurt when going in lava
lucid oracle
Very specific use case and I don't know if it would be good, but at least it's something.
Could use it against Providence I guess?
heady comet
Carribean rum
placid perch
Could also help with exploring the Underworld and Brimstone Crag
keen onyx
@hollow shell yeah I... understood that a little too late. My apologies.
lucid marsh
Should I repost my suggestion since it was burried within minutes but got 10ish stars in those few minutes?
placid perch
What is it?
lucid marsh
Lichy trigger finger
ashen warren
etg ref, i love it
placid perch
Sure
lucid marsh
Removes auto-fire from all guns but makes them do 2.5x fire rate so the faster you click, the faster you shoot
Ok did it
lucid marsh
I won’t from now on
astral gust
i've seen that suggestion alot of times already
hasty wigeon
mhm
placid perch
Guide Doll
Summons a Demon mount to carry you
Dropped from Demons in Hardmode
Gives infininte flight and enhanced speed while in lava. Also gives lava resistance and will sometimes fire a demon scythe at enemies, also has limited flight.
: I think a early hardmode easy to get mount would be nice, and super helpful in the Underworld or used in arenas as you can put lava in bubble blocks replenishing the flight time and enhancing speed like Shrimpy Truffle
This better?
radiant meadow
except limited flight time makes it less useful in the way you would use fishron
placid perch
The main point of this guy is a early on mount
placid perch
42 - 45
placid perch
I really have no clue what it should be
hearty yew
@lucid marsh you have reposted that suggestion 3 times this week, does that not violate the repost rules?
placid perch
Im not too good at balancing
worthy raptor
Holy shit I just saw that sticky hand weapon idea and I love it
placid perch
Would flight speed count as stats?
I mean, its just one of my badly made weapon ideas, it will probably not go in as it is now
But the concept its okay
worn bay
Concept:
Corrup/Crim/Hallowed Cnidrions
Their water spray is replaced by a cursed fire, ichor, or crystal spray, and they became harder ofc
on kill, they drop various resources from their biome; corrup drops cursed flames, worm teeth, rotten chunks, and possibly demonite and its accessories, crimboi drops their versions of those, hallowed drops crystal shards, unicorn horns, and pixie dust
they also drop their related souls and shards
Thoughts?
placid perch
Hmmm
Only of the hollow version is hot pink and neon teal
Hot pink as the base and neon teal on the armor like stuff
Then yes
worn bay
Lmao
spark flax
i like this idea tbh
might wanna remove the "thoughts" tho, makes it look weird :/
also oof third repost of litchy trigger finger in nearly as many days when you're supposed to wait at least a week before reposting
tfw it's a badly designed that turns everything overpowered if you have a rapid click-bot and makes everything a pain in the ass to use if you don't. 0/11
marsh gust
eek 49 on paper plane 
placid perch
Brb gonna go through suggestions and star it
marsh gust
astral gust
hey star mine too
marsh gust
i starred yours
astral gust
same with yours
placid perch
So
marsh gust
i dont feel voting for myself is wrong cause presidents do that
placid perch
Now the Paper Airplanes have 50
marsh gust
ayy \o/
astral gust
it's optional if you want to star it or not sjd
it's not like i care much about it anyway
oh how the tables have turned
placid perch
Nah I like it
astral gust
paper in fact does beat scissors
placid perch
Swear is did star it tho
Brb
Back for 1 sec, can someone star the biome cnidrion, because I cant find how to add a reaction on mobile for the life of me
placid perch
Ah, that makes sense
So for it to get any stars at all a mod has to star it first? Fair enough
astral gust
yeup
spark flax
oh yeah i gotta upload Disco Balldohr sometime soon
marsh gust
yes
astral gust
biome cnidrions is now starred bois
placid perch
Should I put down a list of un checkmarked but over 50 stars ideas?
marsh gust
uh.. just let the mods do it themselves, give them time
lunar berry
Hasn’t xbxbxb reposted that like 3 times now
hollow shell
Yeah
gusty geode
Is it considered spam if I post several suggestions in rapid succession so people can star the ones they want?
hollow shell
What are the suggestions for?
gusty geode
This newest update appears to be all about rebalancing, so I was going to post a bunch of buffs, nerfs, and reworks to weapons that I think could use them
hollow shell
Put em in a doc
gusty geode
K
worn bay
Removed the “thoughts”
ashen warren
"all throwing items will split into additional projectiles" Celestus
astral gust
tfw choco's planes get sent first over mine
placid perch
I kinda get why Royal Gel is needed
astral gust
placid perch
But it realy isnt needed
Like, I know it has to do with the ninja armor, but it didnt need that
astral gust
that one gel armor that someone suggested was great
marsh gust
slimy
placid perch
Yeah
astral gust
why statigel?
ashen warren
Why not just statis'?
alpine copper
I wrote statigel?
astral gust
Statis' Gauntlet
ashen warren
Since one requires the other, make it 1 message
alpine copper
I thought of homing but i some how felt it wasnt correct
lunar berry
The Axe is a tool, not a weapon
placid perch
Them go in a chamber and throw rotten eggs everywhere with npcs with you
ashen warren
A plague beekeeper would be real nice for true melee
astral gust
oh fuck
ashen warren
Relevant memes nerf/buff whatever made me think of it
ashen warren
Already been suggested quite a few times iirc
astral gust
really?
ashen warren
Look up "plague armor in:suggestions"
astral gust
i mean yeah that'd make sense
ashen warren
Making the aqua scepter act as a storm spray would be way better
marsh gust
.>
astral gust
hm aqua scepter?
marsh gust
storm spray carried me to perfs
astral gust
it sure did
ashen warren
I only ever used the beekeeper for a normal mode WoF kill so eh
marsh gust
aquascepter acting like storm spray would be amazing
ashen warren
It was pre strong
marsh gust
too good tbh
marsh gust
the thing is storm spray alrdy has a hardmode upgrade
alpine copper
Its not an upgrade if you dont craft it
ashen warren
then they need to buff the AS staff
ashen warren
Neptune's bounty
marsh gust
ultra liquidator?
placid perch
Slime Gun 2.0
alpine copper
Mega solidificator
placid perch
Or Slime Gun Mk 2
astral gust
because you're a mage main
marsh gust
it is a mage weap 
ashen warren
I'm a throw main though?
marsh gust
maybe add a right mouse attack for a stream like storm spray to it
astral gust
slime gun gives a debuff
gusty geode
Any thoughts on my stuff?
ashen warren
I don't agree with the optic staff nerf
astral gust
i haven't looked at your doc yet
ashen warren
I don't care about the beekeeper
alpine copper
Slimed: increased dmg from all kinds of flames and infernos
placid perch
Except upgrade to a better hardmode version
ashen warren
The axe is a tool
placid perch
Thorium
alpine copper
Thorium ehm
astral gust
uh fuck
ashen warren
Phoenix blaster is eh right now anyway
gusty geode
Wait really
placid perch
Yeah
ashen warren
I'd wait for the update
astral gust
i don't play thorium anyways
ashen warren
Golem weps are also wait for update
astral gust
possessed hatchet buffs?
astral gust
then again
terra weapons exist
astral gust
it gets so sadly overshadowed by the things
i love hatchet so much
ashen warren
We're talking calamity buffs
placid perch
Slime (Debuff)
Fire Debuffs do 25% more damage and the inflicted NPC is 10% slower
Too much slowness?
ashen warren
It wouldn't work on bosses anyway soo it's fine
crimson dirge
I feel as if the sole purpose of the debuff is to either A) Love it or B) Hate it
sinful violet
tbh make titanium railgun like an actual railgun
heady comet
yes
crimson dirge
I have ideas but I’m 99% sure none are gonna be put in
heady comet
All perennial weapons but everglade spray are one big meme
astral gust
i'm writing about slime gun buff already
lunar berry
We need to buff bar weapons
crimson dirge
Perrenial Weapons exist?
lunar berry
Like things crafted with bars
Exactly my point
Perennial is shit compared to other stuff u can get at that point
Except for Everglade spray lol
crimson dirge
Anything is shit compared to the meta
heady comet
Cryo stuff is decent and chaotic stuff is good but the lances are meme
ashen warren
Perennial is not only bad but also boring
lunar berry
Exactly, so we should buff frigid weapons, cryonic weapons, perennial weapons and chaotic weapons
lost agate
Ranged reaver is cool
lunar berry
And maybe other stuff
heady comet
Nah, just perennial
ashen warren
The shotbow is bad shucks
heady comet
Maybe cryo a bit
placid perch
Slime Gun Mk 2
Crafted @ static refiner w/ Slime Gun, 30 Purified Gel, 9 Hellstone Bar, 70 Gel
sinful violet
I'd say that if you guys want buffs, test the weapons on bosses of their tier with the appropriate setups for that tier, and repost the kill times
heady comet
Rev?
sinful violet
It's what terry does, and it's the most effective way to get the things which need balancing, balanced
And yeah, rev
astral gust
Slime Gun Buffs
Make it inflict a new debuff: Slimed
When affected by Slimed:
-The target will recieve 25% more damage to the On Fire! debuff
-The target will also be Slowed for 10% of it's movement speed
Why?: The Slime Gun, a "weapon" that is literally useless as of current, would finally get some use as an early game damage-amplifier similar to the Golden Shower and the Everglade Spray. I feel like that the gun could be used for so much more than just shooting harmless slime to people.
placid perch
Inflicts Glued, basicly a buffed up version of slime
lunar berry
25% more damage?
Haha what a joke
Btw the slime gun is a novelty item, not a weapon
crimson dirge
It seems the Flarebolt mages would gravitate toward that
astral gust
firestorm cannon rangers too
lunar berry
Hmmm
sinful violet
Next we're gonna have people asking us to make stink potion and water gun do damage
placid perch
Slime (Debuff)
Fire Debuffs do 25% more damage and the inflicted NPC is 10% slower
Slime Gun Mk 2
Crafted @ static refiner w/ Slime Gun, 30 Purified Gel, 9 Hellstone Bar, 70 Gel
Inflicts Glued, basicly a buffed up version of slime
crimson dirge
Fire Greatsword Melee too?
ashen warren
please make stink potion do damage
lunar berry
No one uses that lol
ashen warren
Demons
astral gust
placid perch
Put fire debuffs out
lunar berry
Also, maybe something that can reduce bosses’ speed? Since there is literally nothing in the game that can d that
ashen warren
Nononono
crimson dirge
Theres a good reason for that
ashen warren
Don't do that one
placid perch
Yeah
ashen warren
5% would be enough to break everything
crimson dirge
I don’t think you knoe how big those numbers are
astral gust
some bosses' speeds are extremely calculated
imagine reducing perf worms' speed
it's a literal free kill because you can outrun them horizontally
crimson dirge
I fought those today and they become real fast at low hp
crimson dirge
Whatever argument you have is invalid due to the fact one cannot simply change the boss speed within seconds that’d break alot of things
lunar berry
Why
crimson dirge
Best thing you got its to turn autopause on and spam esc
lunar berry
Give me one boss that will ‘break’, according to you
crimson dirge
astral gust
what would happen to the charges of bosses?
lunar berry
Yes
crimson dirge
Providence
ashen warren
Twins
astral gust
literally anything that can charge
lunar berry
They will be slowed down by 5 percent
ashen warren
Fishron
astral gust
which is utterly broken