suggestions-discussion

[fleet grotto]

granite

take it or leave it

[oblique otter]

marble elemental

[drowsy plank]

i dont know any bosses with elemental in their name what are you talking about :)

[fleet grotto]

@'ing red on Twitter to get this thing added

[oblique otter]

if i get slammed by a marblemental i will boil your belongings

[novel belfry]

https://tenor.com/view/final-fantasy-chaos-square-enix-gif-21948103

[misty lichen]

cosmic elemental

[fleet grotto]

rip sweet baby boy

missed getting enchanted sword from you on the first night mining 🙏

[glass arch]

no

[grim tusk]

granite elemental

It would be funny if there was a related boss on another big mod

[fleet grotto]

thorium my beloved

[buoyant idol]

Uranium mod.

[novel belfry]

Me omw to add a “cosmic” elemental (it’ll probably be redesigned to be literally swords) to my future calamity addon

I mean, if catalyst can add the goddamn wulfrum slime of all things back then yeah

[drowsy plank]

hm

i prolly shouldnt have let that through

their reasoning is inaccurate

[grave zinc]

@glad tundra - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Remove Ruinous Soul from the "Acid Rain - Tiers 1 and 2" Music box, and make it craftable at an iron/lead anvil]

It has been decided that your suggestion can neither be passed nor denied; either the devs have already made plans that conflict with it, or they have decided to implement an altered version.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[drowsy plank]

cool

[crude geode]

Wdym calamity is the only mod that exists

Everything else is just an add on to it, like infernum and nameless deity

[echo leaf]

So, I want to suggest a tweak to the Counter/Evasion scarf's effects but since they're donor items, do I have to run it by the original donor first?
I plan to suggest a bit of a buff since their dodge doesn't seem to stack with other dodges anymore.

[wide river]

As Evasion Scarf is a donor item, yes, you would need to get permission from the donor to make a change to it

[misty lichen]

i thought only the upgrade was donor

[wide river]

Ye, Evasion Scarf is the donor, Counter Scarf isn't

I have to ask though, what kind of buff were you thinking of?

[echo leaf]

Not sure. But at the moment, it just feels objectively inferior to the master ninja gear and its upgrades

[glass arch]

isnt it actually better than them or am i misremembering

[echo leaf]

It used to be a neat sidegrade since its dodge stacks with other dodges, and it had a 30 second cooldown compared to their 90 seconds

[glass arch]

dodge stacking :WhereIsMySalad:

[echo leaf]

But now that dodge timers are dynamic, it seems like in order to have both dodges proc, you need to unequip the first dodge, proc the scarf, then re-equip

[glass tide]

He many votes does a suggestion need to be considered by the devs

[glass arch]

no solid number

[echo leaf]

Its stated in the pins, BUT
It's unclear

[glass arch]

needs to be in the top 20%

[glass tide]

I checked the pins but it didn’t say a clear number so I asked here

[echo leaf]

The top 20% of suggestions are zipped to the dev server, but there's nothing stopping a dev from coming over here and reading the other 80% and considering them independently

[glass tide]

Oh ok

[glass arch]

clear numbers were inefficient, they kept having to be adjusted so only the top 20% went to dev

[echo leaf]

now I don't wanna suggest dodge stacking as a fix for this since that would be incredibly stupid with the dynamic dodge cooldowns, but without it the scarves feel outclassed

(and i love the scarves)

[drowsy plank]

yeah it is better

[glass arch]

a third of the cooldown for a dodge you can choose to proc is amazing actually

[drowsy plank]

also if both dodges are proccing at the same time

that is a bug

not an intentional feature

[glass arch]

no the "bug" is one cant be procced with the other on cd which i dont think is actually a bug

[royal tapir]

That’s just because they use different cooldowns

[echo leaf]

It's not that both dodges are proccing, it's that I can't get the scarf to proc at all if I have a different dodge accessory, so I assumed that such a behavior was removed

[glass arch]

yeah that kinda synergy is horrifically unbalanced

[echo leaf]

exactly, yeah

[sand marlin]

MNG can go down to 15s

Which is kind of huge if you're tanky

And there is no attached dodge condition

[misty lichen]

yeah massive dodge nerf rapidly approaching when people actually process how insane it is

[sand marlin]

Shhhhhhh

Amalgamated Brain needed a nerf now it's even crazier ngl

MNG needed buffs but not to this point

Definitely appreciate the approach on making MNG line better byeah

[echo leaf]

yeah dodges now are incredible

i love the master's ninja gear

[misty lichen]

dodge was already incredibly undervalued

bc of adren conservation

[crude geode]

Adrenaline doesn’t exist it’s a myth

[echo leaf]

I have never heard of this word in my life

[glass arch]

how about epinephrine

[median scaffold]

How 'bout stress

[fleet grotto]

Yeah, I play in expert, what's an adrenaline

[buoyant idol]

No hit things for a while to deal incredible damage (bosses only.)

[fleet grotto]

i was joking

[fervent orbit]

how is a rage

[fleet grotto]

Buff for berserkers

[golden sonnet]

@visual plume just don't use master?

if something is too difficult for you, you can just not do it

nothing is master exclusive

[visual plume]

but i beat malice

[golden sonnet]

ok?

[visual plume]

The Problem is I'm in hardmode Fighting the twins on master When i started the world it didn't seem that bad but now im in hardmode and i cant exactly turn of master

[buoyant idol]

Make a suggestion about that then asking for a way to change the difficulty.

[grim tusk]

Just install Fargo’s or Dragonlens

[golden sonnet]

I kinda disagree with that, if calamity makes changes to master, it should have a way to toggle it

[misty lichen]

changes of master that it DOESNT TELL YOU ABOUT for the record

[hollow shell]

@lone ravine You need stronger reasoning than "it would be cool".

How would this addition benefit the mod / benefit the ranger experience post-Providence?

[lone ravine]

Well it would provide an alternative to blood flare bullets in case you are bad at aiming.

[wide river]

I should probably point out how there are two bullets already at the post-Providence tier, being Holy Fire and Bloodfire

[lone ravine]

But neither are homing

[hollow shell]

That's something I suppose.

You can include that in your suggestion. That there's no "scrub" option, no low-damage homing bullet, around that point

[lone ravine]

Ok sure

[umbral gazelle]

@lone ravine #suggestions-posting message IT IS NAMED POLTERGHAST NOT POLTERGEIST RAHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[lone ravine]

Dang it I hate autocorrect

[fleet flume]

"...that inflict dryads bane..." why?

[grim tusk]

What the hell is dryad’s bane?

The debuff she inflicts on the enemies while casting?

[wide river]

The debuff the Dryad inflicts on nearby enemies iirc

[grim tusk]

Alr i was correct

But still why?

[drowsy plank]

@brisk solstice you need to explain what exactly you want changed and why

just saying "nerf boss bc hard" isn't helpful at all

[brisk solstice]

oh ok

[olive saddle]

i hope its a decent sugg

honest to god this whole sugg could be completely waved by "calamity is vanilla overhaul expect different stuff" and my only retort is "expert mode isnt too different"

[drowsy plank]

true

[coral carbon]

flashback to that one short that said stars above was an addon to calamity because it had compatibility with it

[novel belfry]

a short?

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/746859277641187390/1234967336734167113/togif.gif

[sand marlin]

What's wrong with chlorophyte bullets?

[frail mantle]

Isn’t half the gimmick of holy fire bullets that their velocity is so high, as long as you point at an enemy and click it’ll hit

[coral carbon]

youtube short

[fervent orbit]

Isn't half the gimmick of _ _ bullets that their velocity is so high, as long as you point at an enemy and click it'll hit it

[frail mantle]

Yea but especially holy fire

Most bullets are fast, holy fire as far as I remember are practically hitscan

[misty lichen]

no that’s all bullets now

[frail mantle]

It is?

Damn my year old knowledge of cal is really lagging behind

[sand marlin]

Funny enough Holy Fire is slower than Tungsten

Wait actually why

Why is it slower when wiki says tungsten is 4x and holy fire 5x

Ohhhhhhhh they have different base velocities

[odd geyser]

Wtf Mizutsune Monster Hunter

[river lily]

#suggestions-posting message

besides the fact that tarragon is gonna die aside

i don't see the reason for this tbh

the dryads bane debuff is... negligible

there is the appeal of homing though but i'd assume someone who's post ml could probably already get by without homing

and if you really need homing that bad it's not like chloro bullets where that low damage, are they

you're trading off damage for guaranteeing hits - If you can aim you get more damage overall, though

It seems like a good trade to me

[median scaffold]

Wait, the entire tarragon ore will die, not only the armor?

[mossy flower]

npc idea, they gives you better loot chance but you have to take on curses. you pick what curses you want. the bigger the curse the better the loot chance and you can stack curse for better loot.

[oblique otter]

❓

[fossil finch]

We love stealing mechanics from games

[lone ravine]

Wait but if the tarragon ore is gonna die, what will auric tesla use

[olive saddle]

Not tarragon

[grim tusk]

So just Cursula Enter the Gungeon?

[river lily]

the entire ore is gonna die

[olive saddle]

That's...kinda lame actually

[grim tusk]

Pretty sure hyperrius is quite sluggish

Then there’s hailstorm with limited range

Also most of the bullets being fast as fuck issue is actually Deadshot brooch’s fault

[drowsy plank]

i love extra updates on ranged projectiles

this feature has never caused any issues ever

[fervent orbit]

just give folly and storm weaver their own electricity buffs

[buoyant idol]

Remove electricity from any category.

Solves all the issues.

[echo leaf]

I like giving dragonfolly and storm weaver their own brand of electricity more.

[oblique otter]

Dragonvolt

and um

[fervent meadow]

Thunderstorm

[oblique otter]

Watt

[echo leaf]

Dragohm

Wormwatt

[royal tapir]

🔒

[buoyant idol]

🔓

[wide river]

🔏

[fervent orbit]

🔐

[fossil finch]

Better yet, remove the categories

[buoyant idol]

At this point remove the vanilla changes

[wide river]

Kinda true?

[fossil finch]

Sure

[fervent orbit]

At this point remove _ _ vanilla

[serene vapor]

At this point remove yharim

[wide river]

Yharim doesn't exist wdym

[echo leaf]

Remove all mention of yharim from the lore

[fervent orbit]

whos yharim

[echo leaf]

the protagonist just fucks shit up for no reason

[wide river]

He's a myth made by Big Calamity made to sell more Silksong competition

[fossil finch]

Literally true

[grim tusk]

Clearly a moment

[fleet grotto]

yharim? who's that

I only know yharon

[buoyant idol]

His brother

[echo leaf]

Yharim is the chicken nugget, right?

[drowsy plank]

didnt this already get rejected

godslayer surge coming 200never

[fleet grotto]

awwww

didn't know

i think it's just more thematically correct

[worn coyote]

godslayer inferno seems like a sickness thing for me

[echo leaf]

Godslayer inferno is cool as hell, though

[glass arch]

yeah

[drowsy plank]

considering storm weaver exists electricity definitely felt like the most likely change but we aren't getting it

instead it is

just part of the fire debuff slop

[echo leaf]

I like the fire debuffs, but we definitely don't need more

[oblique otter]

ok but

draetalk confirmed storm weaver ≠ devourer of gods

[echo leaf]

Maybe Ares' gauss nuke can inflict Electrified

[oblique otter]

also this exists. But dog is getting a rework anyway

[fleet grotto]

i need to watch more lore shenanigans

[oblique otter]

nah, read it

[fleet grotto]

also, just unfortunate that THIS is the debuff spread

11/30 heat, 9/30 sickness

[oblique otter]

water debuff...

sunken sea oberhaul, gibe one debuf pls

:praying rn

[fleet grotto]

where's my clam debuff

[drowsy plank]

electricity out here with ONE

[echo leaf]

I think electricity needs one more since at least water has two

[drowsy plank]

galvanic is a stun so it doesnt count

[echo leaf]

And they're both reasonably strong

[drowsy plank]

at least water has 2 now

[oblique otter]

Obviously to balance this we make an exclusive to amidias spark debuff

[fleet grotto]

anyways what the FUCK is eutrophication

[echo leaf]

It's like, an algae bloom

[oblique otter]

gogle is your tool

use it well

[fleet grotto]

i prefer the wiki

[oblique otter]

it's a real thing though

[echo leaf]

The wiki also explains what eutrophication is IRL and in-game

[fleet grotto]

considering my phone let me auto select it, it just might be real

[oblique otter]

if you were asked what's a lionfish irl would you say it's a rogue weapon

[fleet grotto]

so it's just a. Stun

[echo leaf]

Yep

Just like Galvanic Corrosion

[fleet grotto]

So lame

[grim tusk]

@fleet grotto you should read the new Draedon dms about DoG

[fervent orbit]

damn

draedon dms

[grim tusk]

Draedate
Drae discord chat
Same thing

[fervent orbit]

draedon slips into your dms post exos

[buoyant idol]

What does he mean when he wants to "study" me with a 😉 emoji?

[fleet grotto]

i should

is there an easy way to find them

[echo leaf]

yeah, the codebreaker wiki page

[fleet grotto]

alr

[echo leaf]

alternatively you can cheat in the Codebreaker and its components, then use godmode to kill the mechs

Or you can go onto a world which already defeated them

[grim tusk]

Probably dissect you like a frog

[fervent orbit]

lore doc

[sharp sky]

#suggestions-voting message Glad to see this was suggested already

my GF was incredibly sad that the Bio-Lab theme was changed, I'd love to surprise them with a legacy music box

New theme isnt bad, just much prefer the old one for its feel

She used to have the music box play at our lab and just chill for hours lol

she doesnt like the new one

[hollow shell]

this DoG suggestion is smart methinks

[fervent orbit]

its been denied before iirc

[hollow shell]

I'd even accept turning it into a cold debuff
Doesn't even need a re-theme. Frostburn is a "cold fire" already

[fleet grotto]

alright, read all of it

so yeah

storm weaver isn't relatedtk dog

storm weaver potentially being older than dog is funny to me though

[drowsy plank]

yeah it's so good it's almost like i made the exact same suggestion and it got rejected despite being a great idea

who knows maybe third time's the charm

[buoyant idol]

Idea: Merge cold and water debuffs into one category.

Water is so small already and could easily be merged since they typically have similar resists and weaknesses.

[misty lichen]

water used to be merged with sickness i think

[topaz light]

Me when I ask mod developers to make a mod that removes 98% of the original mod because I'm too lazy to search for and configure quality of life mods

[novel belfry]

Hang on, rejected?

i forgot about that

[distant gyro]

sadly fate of gsi is turning out to be typeless i think

theres still red lightning and auric lightning however

[sleek turret]

godslayer stuff is being moved to eldritch design stuff or smth?

[distant gyro]

and weaker phm lightning so that stormlion doesnt gopsmack you with 16 dps worth of dot

[royal tapir]

Funny thing is that making GSI typeless is a direct buff because Yharon and SCal are resistant to heat

[novel belfry]

That’s boooring

[sleek turret]

weaker phm lightning is understandable yea

[novel belfry]

We already have an endgame type less debuff (exo mech debuff)

[crude geode]

New “eldritch” debuff type lesgo

[novel belfry]

New “eldritch” debuff type lesgo

[crude geode]

Same hat

🤝

[novel belfry]

🤝

[sleek turret]

😐

[novel belfry]

[sleek turret]

peak

[crude geode]

Anyways memes aside merging water and ice makes sense

[sleek turret]

Voltaic Jelly being the strongest pre-hm summoner acc to ever exist prior to SG feelschungus

[crude geode]

@buoyant idol one of your sentences kinda ends abruptly mid thought “for players when most of the time. Not to mention…(blah blah blah)”

[buoyant idol]

Fixed, thanks for pointing that out.

[crude geode]

Np

[echo leaf]

yeah, voltaic jelly is insane. Maybe a Sparks effect for that alongside with Amidas' Sparks

[sleek turret]

old Unstable Granite Core reincarnation

[north oracle]

old UGC was funny

[golden sonnet]

So like, I know this isn't the only franchise to do this

But reminds me of Skylanders typing

Where all ice characters are just under water

Ice is just hard water smh

[drowsy plank]

@lone ravine specific item suggestion; please review our rules in the pinned document

[buoyant idol]

Shadowspec *Tier * Ammo would likely work better.

[unreal orbit]

I'm pretty sure the devs want to polish everything from early game and then go up from there it doesn't really make sense polishing "END-END" game yet

[crude geode]

Early game has indeed been a focus for devs as of late

The only real late game thing I want addressed is auric but that takes a rework of the armor sets composing it, so it has to wait

[worn coyote]

shadowspec tier is never touched at all

[violet sierra]

Most lategame accessories dont stack with their downgrades, right?

[echo leaf]

Right, yeah

[violet sierra]

really???

thats dumb

[drowsy plank]

nah

[worthy lintel]

i dunno man preventing summoners from having 12+ extra slots because of stacking accs from the same tree sounds like the opposite of stupid

[drowsy plank]

it prevents you from just

yeah that

[worthy lintel]

(and yes im aware 12 is a randomly thrown number lmao but you get my point)

[violet sierra]

oh wait

i forgot what i said

yes thats good

so why

is Sigil of Calamitas an exception

I thoguht they were confirming they stacked

my b

[worthy lintel]

very likely just

forgor

[drowsy plank]

no mage accessories 😇

[worthy lintel]

mage aint having shit fr fr

[violet sierra]

dont care i hate accessory downgrade stacking

im mkaing a sugg

[worthy lintel]

you know what, valid

it either stacks or doesnt

make 'em consistent

[violet sierra]

yes

[north oracle]

Recon and Sniper scope do the same thing

[worthy lintel]

ok now thats just a vanilla moment

[north oracle]

true

however cal changed all the gauntlets

[violet sierra]

Should i just make a remove accessory downgrade stacking general sugg lol

i didnt know the scopes stacked

[crude geode]

yeah

idk how many it's applicable too, but it seems completely reasonable and consistent

[worthy lintel]

sigil in particular screams forgotten moment

[violet sierra]

yeah for sure

I was checking class setups for yharon mage accessories

and i was like

"what"

idk how to phrase this

"Accessory Downgrade Stacking"???

[echo leaf]

Evidently yeah, sigil of calamitas stacks with its upgrade

[golden sonnet]

it isn't

in the same way gauntlets stack damage but nothing else, sigil stack damage but nothing else

and all summoner items stack damage and nothing else

[violet sierra]

thats wrong

mana goes up too

[golden sonnet]

oh, that does seem like an oversight yeah

I would specify the damage stacking should stay though, as that's pretty thoroughly established with other classes

[violet sierra]

my point stil stands even if it was damage

i think its dumb to stack downgrades for damage

[golden sonnet]

I mean sure, but that would be quite a few changes for every class

[violet sierra]

if we can confirm its jsut sigil that has this oversight

i can change my sugg to just being

"fix sigil"

[golden sonnet]

I mean, if you want damage stacking removed too I think it's good as is

if you only care about sigil could just do that

I think either is fine

[violet sierra]

I sympathize with how big a change removing damage stacking might be

is all

lmao

then again

this is the first time ive seen it

[golden sonnet]

to be fair, it is literally never used

[violet sierra]

so

[golden sonnet]

it is as best a second class emblem

like, literally they all max at 15% damage

[violet sierra]

yeah let me just

change this

[golden sonnet]

there really isn't a reason for damage to stack either

[violet sierra]

hmm

you right actually lmao

[golden sonnet]

destroyer emblem and class emblems already exist

[novel belfry]

nooo i dont want stacking removveeeddd

/s

[fleet grotto]

curse of the shadowbeam staff recolor

[crude geode]

mfw the last beam explodes (this drastically changes the weapon)

[crude geode]

Can we actually just delete the shadow beam staff clones (including fabstaff)

[drowsy plank]

fabstaff isnt a shadowbeam clone?

isn't it more like magic missle at this point

oh wait

no it is a bouncing beam

wild

[ripe owl]

It still has something unique to it tbh

[drowsy plank]

yeah

[crude geode]

I’d prefer it less as an endgame weapon compared to some of the other wild shit that’s present but dedicated stuff be like it is

[sleek turret]

yea viscera is just copying an alredy existign vanilla weapon and then just giving it a niche effect (Best weapon design at the time it was made)

[crude geode]

viscera and shadowbolt staff are so depressingly dissapointing

like woo my shadowbeam staff gets more damage for doing the things it was. already going to do.

[sleek turret]

these are also weapons meant to be used on DoG too?

[crude geode]

viscera you could argue polter, which makes a lot better usecase in the cramped dungeon

[sleek turret]

or like half of the fights on their stages that don't have a closed space

[crude geode]

as well as ceaseless

[sleek turret]

storm weaver, signus, od, DoG

[crude geode]

yeah

signus kinda but only if you haven't cleared space

[sleek turret]

the random 2 tiles that were left untouched since the Giant Hellbridge Construction happened:

[crude geode]

literally

[sleek turret]

Seriously speaking now

These are desperate of a rework

Like the vanilla weapon it atleast has some decent use on Golem if we talk about bossfight and just some niche exploring in some Dungeon parts

At the point you get viscera it's decent against Polter (I assume it is) and Ceaseless but even then there are vastly better options to take out Ceaseless stuff and leaves this weapon as a small health recovery option

[drowsy plank]

this could be
better

but i get the point that it's boring

[crude geode]

the fact this shit hasn't mechanically changed since astral was added is wild

I just don't see a world where something significantly better can't be made with it, especially with how fabstaff has changed

[novel belfry]

owait

they already mentioned viscera

😦

[oblique otter]

Deathhail could, in theory, perform well against the Exo Mechs

[olive saddle]

you know... i forget this thing exists...

[fleet grotto]

What's a phoenix flame barrage

[languid pollen]

i quite like the viscera rework because it reminds me of piercing blood from jjk but yea the weapon is mid performance wise

not that i really have a problem with that tho,

[prime karma]

funniest thing thing about pheonix flame barrage for me is that it has always been a shit weapon

and yet its last change was a nerf

[olive saddle]

Balance be wonky at times

[prime karma]

the only thing it had going for it is that it could do great damage once in a blue moon when the bosses were standing still

[olive saddle]

If you stand still during exo mechs you're gonna get fucked unless its ares doing funny business

[prime karma]

or twins solo

[olive saddle]

Scal is understandable because that fight can be mostly beaten at above 30% going up and down

[prime karma]

as going up or down doesnt change much

[prime karma]

yeah but you press A or D once and you dps dissapears

[olive saddle]

Unlucky

[river lily]

#suggestions-posting message

This is so real

Godslayer voltage,,,

[fleet grotto]

why would the non-statigel accessory be made at the thing that only makes statigel items

[buoyant idol]

@atomic mauve You'll need to provide reasoning why the developers should add it.

[atomic mauve]

i sent it accidentally i forgot to press shift to add another line

[buoyant idol]

Oh.

Fair enough.

References aren't allowed.

[atomic mauve]

oh sorry

[river lily]

Reference suggestion moment,,,

[atomic mauve]

ok

[umbral gazelle]

what is this even refer to

i only know shooting other people's coin with a gun which is ultrakill reference

but shooting other people coin with coin is uhhhh idk

[glass arch]

it would be an ultrakill 4-2 reference iirc

[wide river]

I feel like a good rule of thumb is that if the suggestion involves shooting coins there's a 90% chance it's an Ultrakill reference

[frail mantle]

i was gonna say what if it's killer bean but that's shooting an unspent bullet i think

[buoyant idol]

*4-4 (I had to.)

[sleek turret]

ok This one is funny

Good joke

[umbral gazelle]

#suggestions-posting message isnt yang just one side and equanimity is both yin yang

it cant simply be named yangmerang because it will miss yin side

[nocturne bolt]

What about yin-rang? The rang is in place of the yang

Or even yin-yangarang

[oblique otter]

little bit on the nose don't you think

[umbral gazelle]

mayhaps

[nocturne bolt]

But it's funny and punny and easier to pronounce, catchier too.

[oblique otter]

i..disagree

but you do you

[nocturne bolt]

awh

[sleek turret]

It's peak

[frail mantle]

i mean

this is very "it would be funny" but i'm pretty sure we've had similar suggestions before that have passed

like renaming the plantera summoner to portabulb and maybe renaming slag magnum to the slagnum? not too sure about that one but i'm pretty sure it was at least a suggestion at one point

[nocturne bolt]

pfff

slagnum is great

[drowsy plank]

cit said no and cit is a dev so

good enough reason for it to be a no for me

[nocturne bolt]

Shit...

[frail mantle]

hard to argue with that

[sleek turret]

unfortunate

[grave zinc]

@echo leaf - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[More Electricity Debuffs]

It has been decided that your suggestion can neither be passed nor denied; either the devs have already made plans that conflict with it, or they have decided to implement an altered version.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[echo leaf]

womp womp

[buoyant idol]

Removal?

[serene vapor]

Still crafted with the same materials

[fleet grotto]

ok?

not everything crafted by purified gel is made in a static refiner

all of these items use purified gel but have nothing to do with statigel

[misty lichen]

radiant oozes ONLY materials are purified gel and blighted gel, which matches all other statigel items

[grim tusk]

Wait why the fuck was this marked with lock

Should’ve been 🛠️

[echo leaf]

🛠️ is better for my ego

[fervent orbit]

blame cit

[serene vapor]

trash

[grave zinc]

@echo leaf - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[More Electricity Debuffs]

It has been add to the devs' to-do list and planned for implementation!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[wide river]

I think this was the one that was meant to be locked if I had to guess #suggestions-voting message

[river lily]

I mean tbf

Radiant ooze is
Well
Ooze

So it fits much better with static refiner than any of those other items

[fleet grotto]

no?

[river lily]

I don't agree or disagree with the suggestion just wanted to point that out

[fleet grotto]

static refiner literally only makes statigel things, nothing else

only thing radiant ooze has in common is purified and blighted gel

[river lily]

It's a ooze

[fleet grotto]

it'd need a resprite for it to fit imo

[golden sonnet]

The entire recipe of statigel items......

[fervent orbit]

its a refiner

you use purified gel to refine blighted gel

therefore

radiant ooze should be made at static refiner

[fleet grotto]

then I think it should get a statigel themed resprite

[sleek turret]

A recipe change would be better to reflect the sprite honestly

It could use a honey bottle instead of blighted gel since it's a regen item

[fleet grotto]

That makes it pre boss

[sleek turret]

Keep the purified gel

Doesn't make it pre-boss anymore

I was ONLY mentioning a replacement for blighted gel, not purified gel (material dropped by SG).

[wide river]

I made a suggestion about this but it didn't garner much support

#suggestions-voting message

[sleek turret]

I remember.

[wide river]

In retrospect I could have improved it somewhat but meh

[echo leaf]

Another note about accessory downgrade stacking is the Papyrus Scarab

[sleek turret]

Fucked up

[golden sonnet]

eidolon tablet is a pretty high chance

it's not hard to get at all

not everything needs to be craftable

and you can just, use the cultists at the dungeon?

[drowsy plank]

ew

awful idea

what raesh said

everything doesnt need to be craftable and like. cultists are right there if you really cannot be bothered to go get it in the abyss

[umbral gazelle]

craftable calamitas

craftable drunk princess

craftable bandit

[drowsy plank]

😱

[umbral gazelle]

and lastly craftable yharim

[fleet grotto]

how do I craft sans

[drowsy plank]

bones

[fleet grotto]

ok

how do I craft YOU

[drowsy plank]

https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/User:CognitiveAfflatus

[fleet grotto]

why do you drop virili 😭

[drowsy plank]

[buoyant idol]

Eaten.

[fleet grotto]

this wiki page is also how I found out the noseless popo debuff exists

[echo leaf]

No defense?! 🥺

[golden sonnet]

glassius smh

[violet sierra]

craftable ores when

[golden sonnet]

shimmer is considered a form of crafting, so it already exists

[grave zinc]

@novel belfry - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Laboratory Reinforced Crates able to be stacked on top of other Reinforced Crates.]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[drowsy plank]

FINALLY

[rose cloud]

yay

[hollow idol]

(I pressed the random page button on the wiki, saw a note in the trivia saying they couldnt be stacked, and took initiative)

[umbral gazelle]

NOOOOOOO

WAUGHHHHH

[ripe owl]

Can crates be stacked on top of different crates?

[echo leaf]

@bleak mesa I think you should flesh out your suggestion a bit and explain why it'll be a good idea and worth the effort beyond "it'd be cool"

[bleak mesa]

cuz the exo mechs are like a better mech bosses so exo mech minecart

[umbral gazelle]

please do note that mech cart no longer has laser since it has been moved to upgrade kit

[bleak mesa]

it does tho

right??

[fleet grotto]

no

[bleak mesa]

NOOO

[fleet grotto]

the lasers are features of the upgrade kit now

[drowsy plank]

@bleak mesaSiS and also lack of reasoning

[fleet grotto]

not the minecart itself

[bleak mesa]

bruhh

thats dumb

still

exo mech minecart

it would attract the ladies

good business idea

keep it in mind

[fleet grotto]

nah I have a better idea

Cirrus minecart

ride cirrus

[bleak mesa]

i disagree

theres a cirrus mount already

exo mech minecart

is better

[umbral gazelle]

[fleet grotto]

there's also a cirrus couch

[umbral gazelle]

nevermind that

[fleet grotto]

keep the cirrus themed items going

[echo leaf]

there's already an exo mechs mount

the gamer chair

[bleak mesa]

a chair

chairs are boring

minecarts

are better

[echo leaf]

it's a FLYING chair

[bleak mesa]

boooo

woah! exo mech minecart

woooo

[fleet grotto]

instead of an exo mech minecart theme it as a car

[bleak mesa]

no

exo mech minecart

it shoots lasers

big lasers

[echo leaf]

knowing draedon he probably uses fuckin teleportation for mass transit of supplies

[bleak mesa]

and it has thanatos on the back

like the dog minecart

and it shoot big lasers that deal 9999999 damage

[buoyant idol]

Add an Exo Tier Minecart

Currently, the final Minecart is Cosmolite tier, leaving an endgame gap in the minecart lineup. Since cleaning up the final recipes can be a hassle, especially if an inadequate pylon network is set up, there'd be incentive to continue using minecart tracks at the end of the game and potentially boss strategies using it. By adding a minecart at this tier, there'd be an alternative travel option to diversify transport in the endgame.

[fleet grotto]

ok but hear me out

[echo leaf]

Ooh, look. Neat suggestion, with elaboration and reasoning and not SiS..

[bleak mesa]

what does sis mean

sissy?

[echo leaf]

Specific Item Suggestion

[bleak mesa]

ok

[echo leaf]

It's specifically outlined as a no-no in the pins

[fleet grotto]

Momentum Capacitator

[bleak mesa]

still exo mech minecart

[bleak mesa]

No

[buoyant idol]

No.

That's boring and cannot be used during bosses.

[fleet grotto]

tbh draedon missing out he shoulda decked out thanatos with 50 of those

although he doesn't want to kill us tbf

[umbral gazelle]

but but minecarts are just skin

[bleak mesa]

https://tenor.com/view/xenoverse-goku-super-saiyan-angry-dbz-gif-1416275111944307575

[umbral gazelle]

please dont Goku me thats relogic idea not mine

[fleet grotto]

actually I have an idea

nvm

i regretted that as soon as I posted it cuz it's stupid and more of a bug

mechanical upgrade overriding cart of gods

[echo leaf]

tbh i'd love to have more draedon stuff... like a draedon dating sim, or a rare drop from his post-battle lecture

[bleak mesa]

become draedon

[echo leaf]

already done

[bleak mesa]

kill him and wear his skin

[echo leaf]

calamity vanites does that

[umbral gazelle]

draedon calling you a failure asmr

[fleet grotto]

there is a draedon dating sim if you're unhinged enough

[echo leaf]

YES

Draedon, please berate me for my terrible naming skills!!

[bleak mesa]

just imagine your dating draedon

and there you have it

[echo leaf]

Man, now I'm thinking about grinding the exos just to murder Draedon afterwards for a 1% drop for some stupid weapon

Like Draedon's Arm or something. Minimal damage. Crappy range. Utterly obscene knockback.

titan's arm upgrade

Maybe I could mod in a Pulse Rifle drop on gfb

[buoyant idol]

Rework vanilla minecarts to have different stats

Vanilla Terraria has a total of 27 minecarts. However, there are only a small selection of ones with actual differences, often being negligible differences that don't matter. Since progression extends far further than vanilla, each cart ends up being relegated to skin rather than actual different item. By giving them their own bonuses such as extra speed and other effects such as releasing projectiles (and perhaps spacing them out to fill up more of progression,) there would be far more diverse strategies regarding minecarts that would expand their usage beyond niche strategy and pylon alternative.

Ping me and I will write a suggestion.

[oblique otter]

toiletcart

[buoyant idol]

Leaves poison clouds behind.

[echo leaf]

Finally new tech for on-tier profaned soul crystal????

[oblique otter]

(idk if this is actually good or not, it feels a bit too forced)

minecart's sole purpose in a regular playthrough is not needing to press a key to move around quickly

[fleet grotto]

Bee minecart gives honey buff, sunflower and ladybug decrease enemy spawnrates

[umbral gazelle]

relic of deliverance:

[oblique otter]

and that is already not needed with wings / momentum capacitor

[oblique otter]

(what that)

[fleet grotto]

((the thing that makes you go fast from guardians))

[umbral gazelle]

i dont know thw name but its spear dropped by profaned guardians

[buoyant idol]

That's the issue, it's boring to do that.

[oblique otter]

eh i never got it

[oblique otter]

placing rails...

[buoyant idol]

That's being improved in 1.4.5.

[oblique otter]

guess im living under a rock

[echo leaf]

I haven't heard much about 1.4.5

[buoyant idol]

They fixed platform placing.

[echo leaf]

WOOHOO

[buoyant idol]

Skybridges are easy now.

[fleet grotto]

If you use a certain mount

[buoyant idol]

Molecart isn't needed anymore.

[coral carbon]

cirrus furniture set cirrus blocks when

[fleet grotto]

Devs get on this

[fleet grotto]

"Cirrus lives in a Cirrus block house. Is she made of house? Or is the house made of flesh? She screams, for she does not know."

[buoyant idol]

@devs Do this.

[oblique otter]

cirrus block

1 fabsol vodka + 50 stone blocks

draedon forge

[novel belfry]

YEEEEEEAAAAAHHHHHH

[odd geyser]

Massacre Demon Diablos Walmart Edition

[sturdy basin]

They really did my boy dirty. Bloodbath is so fucking peak and apex just kind of exists

[novel belfry]

They should’ve just dropped bloodbath himself

He’s already basically an apex

If it’s any consolation mini bloodbath was still easily one of the most fun fights in rise

[hollow idol]

my exocart is better than yours
(Not for calamity)
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/716867315869810770/1242059811919630479/2024-05-20_03-21-27.mp4?ex=664fc197&is=664e7017&hm=ad7d3238969dbec0986ccb4a11a386070ac47bc340d7069be8c8e5ebd7fd5bdf&

[frail mantle]

We have auric Tesla and exo cart

What’s next, terminus hoverboard?

[glass arch]

that last frame tho

[ripe owl]

Traindon

Draetrain?

[median scaffold]

Exomechagodziĺlatrainmadeoutofexocrystalsandshitdraedomdraedonaresthanatosartemidapollothanatostrainfallwithinmycalculationsandcalculateyourselfsomebitchesshithitittkart

[drowsy plank]

finally a nerf request with actual design intent

whether it will make it past voting is another question entirely however

[median scaffold]

Well, he's hollow

[buoyant idol]

@lofty dragon That's a bug.

Try #1052323733961977947 instead.

[topaz light]

🐛

Why didn't I know this emoji existed

I love this little guy

🐛🐛

I regret scrolling up in the suggestions channel

I'm never un-seeing that guys pfp

[buoyant idol]

Not the minions!

[novel belfry]

https://tenor.com/view/gondal-my-beloved-gondalmybeloved-heart-locket-gif-20440761

[median scaffold]

Prikki is cooking

[crude geode]

@echo leaf the reason they’re cheap is because of reforging

[echo leaf]

I assumed so

[crude geode]

You probably want to address it in your sugg

[echo leaf]

Is there even much to spend money on in the endgame?

[wide river]

Enchantments and Reforging are really the only two

[echo leaf]

huh

[wide river]

Most NPCs stop selling new items at like, immediately post-Moon Lord (Bandit is an exception, plus a single item here and there from others)

[echo leaf]

I know the Cyborg sells one post Polterghast

But that's... all I can think of

[misty lichen]

weapon sell prices are all standardized specifically for reforging

[wide river]

There's Lion Heart from Cyborg, Bloodworms from Sea King, Celestial Reaper, Venerated Locket, and Dragon Scales from Bandit; and legacy vanity helmets from Clothier

[echo leaf]

Ooh, right

[wide river]

Plus, on the vanilla side of things: Universal Pylon from Zoologist, Music Box (Journey's End) from Princess, Portal Gun Station from Cyborg, and White, Yellow, and Brown Solutions from Steampunker
(Some of these don't strictly need Moon Lord alone to be dead, but you will need to kill it for the requirements to be fulfilled under normal circumstances)

Byeah

Side tangent aside

[worthy lintel]

terraria coins are items that exists

[misty lichen]

reddit slots gif

[grim tusk]

Miracle matter being worth that much is probably an oversight

[echo leaf]

Well, my concern with it still stands- the incredible difference in value between miracle matter and whatever it's an ingredient for

[royal tapir]

This suggestion has outdated sell values which is funny

[echo leaf]

really???

I got all the numbers from the wiki and not in-game, so that might be it

[royal tapir]

The wiki hasn’t been updated with it yet

[echo leaf]

Ah

[royal tapir]

Which I should do

Anyway Violet rarity stuff is 48 gold

[golden kayak]

Cit
Officially a 5head now

[royal tapir]

https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/882803762144636970/1061724738084405268/ezgif.com-gif-maker.gif

[golden kayak]

long time no see

bad channel for that but just wanted to say hi

[royal tapir]

Hi to you too

[restive wharf]

h

i hope my suggestion's embed is allowed

[buoyant idol]

You can always prune embeds.

[crude geode]

This suggestion is surely one of them

[drowsy plank]

truly one of the suggestions of all time

not breaking the rules, but i have a feeling it will get denied

not for any specific reason just

the devs will add them when they want to

[crude geode]

Might get a ✅ and then sit there for like a year

[grim tusk]

perhaps

[grave zinc]

@echo leaf - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Have Tax Collector give a bonus for defeating Brimstone Elemental (or a quote as to why he doesn't)]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@fervent meadow - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Stop Lunatic Cultists from naturally spawning after progressing enough]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@outer sandal - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add acidwood fences]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@drowsy plank - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Move the Mecha Mayhem aspect of Death-Master Skeletron Prime to the last Mech in Progression Instead]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@median scaffold - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Enchanted Starfish shimmerable]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[novel belfry]

cool stuff

[drowsy plank]

seriously why did i let that lunatic cultist one through

it's so bad

i thought it wasn't going to get enough votes but

oh well

acidwood fences is also funny

hopefully the other 3 pass

[golden sonnet]

People are bad

[echo leaf]

neato

[restive wharf]

#suggestions-voting message

Dementia

[golden sonnet]

Cog thought the suggestion was so good they wanted it in voting 3 more times

[drowsy plank]

ugghghghghg

@inland saddle

[restive wharf]

Holy shit it's John no-hitter

[drowsy plank]

@copper turret i would suggest removing the references to exo prisms and draedon and focus more on why calamity needs more traps, and how that improves the game
you already do a pretty solid job at this, but those last few details feel less like an example of what the implementation could be like and more like saying exactly what it should be, which would make it a bit SiS-y

like mentioning post-ML stat scaling is a decent start, but why can't you just like, use lava or something like most afk farms do

most AFK farms only use traps to proc movement from docile mimics to free up spawns, rather than as the actual source of damage, considering lava is just so much better

[copper turret]

alright, thank you for the criticism 🙏

[drowsy plank]

also dont forget that placeable turrets still exist

https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/Turrets

[copper turret]

perhaps an upgrade to the turret? i have used them and they simply do not do much against post ML events sieging my base

[drowsy plank]

well

they're not supposed to really let you handle events that well

regardless the upgraded moons are dying anyway

they are simply a remnant of old cal

but even plague's 100 DPS prolly couldnt handle an event, but it should be able to handle the average mob

during blood moons or some such

if you're building a farm correctly

[copper turret]

true true

[olive saddle]

art server request #49

[drowsy plank]

mhm

[serene vapor]

Rebalance the Baroclaw to early hardmode

The Baroclaw feels designed to be a mirror of the Giant Tortoise Shell, yet it’s unavailable until after Anahita and Leviathan. Changing it to Mollusk Husks would keep an underwater theme while not locking it behind a mid-hardmode boss. Of course, its stats are too good for early hardmode, so change the effect to Riptide and nerf the damage bonus to 7% to have it still be a buff.

This is just a draft, and it might not even be a good suggestion in the first place

But let me know your thoughts

[north oracle]

don't specify how exactly it should be changed to rebalance it, that goes dangerously near SRS territory

i like the idea, though there might be other issues with that

[misty lichen]

it’s unnecessary to say what exactly you’d nerf about it yeah

like it’s somewhat losing to emblems regardless right now, it might not even need a nerf

[bold wave]

I want to complain about what draedon says

Specifically the line "...I sought perfection. Fate must favor irony, for that must have been my first mistake."

I think it's stylistically clunky to use "must" twice in the same sentence

I don't think the repetition adds anything

Just makes draedon sound kinda silly

Better alternatives, in my opinion, would be "appears to" or "seems to"

[rancid saffron]

To clarify, this mod is amazing, and I know that they're not even CLOSE to finishing it, but I really hope that going forward the mod will update the boss spawn mechanics.

I mean if you think about it, every boss in vanilla had unique mechanics, like Plantera with the bulbs, Golem with the temple, The evil bosses with the orbs and hearts, Lunatic cultist with the dungeon and the Moon Lord following it, even something as simple as EoC and the Mech Bosses spawning randomly at night.
Nearly every single boss in Vanilla Terraria had something unique to go with their spawning. Calamity? Not so much. Most bosses require you to spawn them manually. Especially most of the Post-ML bosses.

Sure, there are exceptions, like Anahita, Polterghast, Evil Bosses #2, Aquatic Scourge, Astrum Deus, Polterghast, The Old Duke, and Draedon along with Supreme Calamitas, but other than the mentioned, they require you to create their respective summoning items.
Newer players may not even realize that the boss even exists until they open up their inventory in their homes.

So yeah, really hope they'll change that, sooner or later. This update has been great by the way, did you guys enjoy it?

[echo leaf]

Yeah, I believe that some spawn mechanics are going to be adjusted to be less simplistic in the future

[drowsy plank]

yeah a suggestion about this already passed

@ spawn methods thing

[drowsy plank]

hm

i really feel

like this is similar to tooltip inaccuracies

and should be in #1052323733961977947

idk

@dense ferry @jovial spire idk yall are the writers this seems like a minor grammatical error lmk what you think

[bold wave]

It's not a grammatical error to my knowledge

It's just clunky language

[drowsy plank]

effectively a grammatical error then
the point is this feels incredibly small and easy to fix to need to go through the clunky suggestion system
ill see what reb and cei think ig

[golden sonnet]

Harassing them is easier than going through voting for sure. (This is a joke don't do this unless you know them or have permission)

[bold wave]

Yeah that's what I think too

It's really minor

But it's technically not an error, and you could theoretically argue that you prefer it the way it is

That's why I thought I'd make a suggestion

[dense ferry]

I'm changing it later

[golden sonnet]

Thanks Reb

[bold wave]

Ok thank you, I'll delete the sugg

Here it is if it needs to be referenced: Alter one of Draedon's lines during the Exo Mechs fight

Draedon is known to be quite talkative, and his utterances can be considered an iconic part of the Exo Mechs fight. In my opinion, however, there is one line which doesn't suit Draedon as well as the rest: "...I sought perfection. Fate must favor irony, for that must have been my first mistake."

The repetition of the word "must" makes the sentence sound somewhat inelegant, which is characteristic of a non-proficient speaker. However, Draedon otherwise sounds like an extremely proficient speaker. For example, in the very sentence, he uses the word "for" to mean "because", which is considered quite formal in modern English.

I propose changing one of the "musts" to a synonym or a near-synonym in order to make Draedon's level of language proficiency consistent, such as like this: "...I sought perfection. Fate must favor irony, for that appears to have been my first mistake."

[buoyant idol]

I’d change it to Fate favors irony; that being my first mistake.

[bold wave]

I don't think it's befitting of Draedon to speak in absolutes regarding "fate"

He's a science man

[buoyant idol]

True.

[bold wave]

I read "must" as meaning "this is very likely" in this context

[bold wave]

If Draedon thought it were certain, he would say it like this.

[fleet grotto]

It appears fate favors irony, for that was my first mistake.

"fate favors irony" is such a raw line

[bold wave]

REAL

How about

"Fate appears to favor irony"

[umbral gazelle]

Fate must be appear to a must-have irony, for that must have been a must-have my must first mistake

[fervent orbit]

Must fate must must must favor must irony, must for must have that must must must have must been must my must first must mistake.

[restive wharf]

I don't think the fate must favor irony is that big of a deal

[buoyant idol]

That's my version, I think it works better that way.

[bold wave]

It's the pettiest of all things petty

[grave zinc]

@golden sonnet - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Remove Profaned Guardians Biome Enrage and Despawn]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[crude geode]

Beautiful

[drowsy plank]

[golden sonnet]

Let's go

W

We support bosses not despawning on you

[grave zinc]

@lapis canyon - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Vanilla Boss Healthbar display all three Profaned Guardians total healthpool]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[royal tapir]

I specifically didn't flag this because I only removed the enrage

[fervent orbit]

whar

why

[royal tapir]

Because I had no idea what to replace it with at all

[golden sonnet]

So it still despawns?

[royal tapir]

Currently ya

[fervent orbit]

why are guardians even a daytime boss

[distant gyro]

profaned guardian just vibing at night

[fervent orbit]

they arent related to day

[royal tapir]

Can the Profaned biome be real already...

[golden sonnet]

Any thoughts or plans to remove/change it? Or no

[royal tapir]

I have not thought about it since then

[golden sonnet]

Alright, was just wondering if it was discussed with any other devs so it's still a possibility for the future, or just you being Mr speed

[grave zinc]

@drowsy plank - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Rework Mana Polarizer to Actually Behave Like Spectre Armor or Change the Tooltip]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[drowsy plank]

[distant gyro]

i just have to mention

"spectre healing" is such a weird way to simply mention lifesteal

[drowsy plank]

yes

it is

[fervent orbit]

yea can we not do that i hate it

why is lifesteals mechanic entirely named after spectre heal

[drowsy plank]

cause that's how it works internally

[fervent orbit]

i hate it!!

ghostheal that ghostheal this

WHY IS IT A GHOST

[distant gyro]

vampires and ghosts

[grave zinc]

@median scaffold - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Enchanted Starfish shimmerable]

It has been voted upon, and the devs decided it would be a good idea to implement it. This doesn't guarantee implementation, as plans may change/alternate plans may be made, but it does highly improve chances!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@median scaffold - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Enchanted Starfish shimmerable]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[sleek turret]

is this real

[misty lichen]

i love old cal

[median scaffold]

It's weird how these 2 posts were posted in the span of 1 minute

Hehe, haha

[serene vapor]

Still waiting for my craftable gladiator armor suggestion

[restive wharf]

Hi

[novel belfry]

does anyone have a single clue about what the profaned biome will be, aside from the fact it wont be too much like the infernum one?

[frail mantle]

cit probably

[golden sonnet]

Naw

[frail fox]

Lots of Profanity probably

[golden sonnet]

Wtf, you can't say that

[wide river]

Heck

[golden sonnet]

Blocked.

[crude geode]

Dang

[fleet grotto]

you guys need to stop letting me cook

[crude geode]

This is likely just a result of the recipes not being adjusted when hardmode progression changed, but still valid

[misty lichen]

i think it’s specifically like that just so if the rework is off you can’t get those items immediately after killing a mech

[crude geode]

Oh true

Mod conflict and whatnot

Though would it be possible to tie the recipe changes to the rework config?

[fleet grotto]

hallowed rune, valkyrie ray, catastrophe claymore, exorcism, and spear of destiny use all 3 souls and hallow bars

[novel belfry]

i thought you said "you guys need to stop letting me cock"

[stone compass]

i think there should be more whips for summoner in calamity

[buoyant idol]

Planned.

[echo leaf]

In the meantime, consider Catalyst mod- it adds a few extras in addition to its other content

[olive saddle]

im going to angrily shove gravel inside your cabinet out of frustration

[sleek turret]

womp womp

[stone compass]

free graveL?

sign me up

[sleek turret]

buy a truck of gravel for 50$ this sunday

[stone compass]

i want free gravel

[sleek turret]

Good.

[olive saddle]

you will eat your words miss. I will make sure every cabinet, every bowl, every glass, and every drawer is filled to the brim with unsellable gravel that smells extremely rancid

[stone compass]

you even pre fill my cups and bowls with gravel?

you make eating it even easier

[olive saddle]

what

nevermind fuck your gravel im keeping it

[stone compass]

then ill consume you

[ripe owl]

Do not the gravel

[olive saddle]

i am going To The Gravel.

[umbral gazelle]

#suggestions-voting message spelling mistake 🥹

please dont execute me

[median scaffold]

Hi

[restive wharf]

#suggestions-voting message this has exploded in less than a day

Never got that many votes so quickly

Nice

[gray bone]

sunken sea menu theme would make my month ngl

[restive wharf]

May I ask what your pfp is

[weary bane]

it's probably cause calamity's menu is kinda boring

[sand marlin]

I'm more amazed that people don't get the (good) chills when they look at cal's title menu

[weary bane]

it's just a static image

[sand marlin]

And

It looks cool as hell

Can do better

[violet sierra]

people think its not cool?

[sand marlin]

But that doesn't say much in terms of what it actually is atm

Kind of disregarding how good it already looks, just because of standards

[weary bane]

i'm not saying the image isnt good, just that it's not interesting

[violet sierra]

I feel like its a perfect title screen for Calamity, though I do think having title screens themed for major updates coild be cool

kinda like mmo login screens

[gray bone]

yeah current menu theme is very cool

[restive wharf]

I would really like to see one for the distortion, sunken sea and brimstone crag though

[gray bone]

as are the ones added by VCMM (i think it's that mod?)

[restive wharf]

Oh yeah those

I like the resurrection of a cruel world theme

[gray bone]

but themes focused on calamity biomes would be very cool

[restive wharf]

The song is fire

[gray bone]

technically irrelevant but very cool

[restive wharf]

#suggestions-voting message

This is the aforementioned sunken sea calamity title

Too cool to just be in an obscure sticker pack

[gray bone]

those stickers seem genuinely mint

what

[olive saddle]

This is awesome

[fleet grotto]

shit

[restive wharf]

What character is that

I asked earlier

guh

[fleet grotto]

whh isn't it replying

[restive wharf]

???

[fleet grotto]

im trying to reply to when you asked me but it's not working

[restive wharf]

Just say it without replying

[fleet grotto]

but this is my pfp, credit in about me, name egg

wtf offtopic

[restive wharf]

Bald

[buoyant idol]

@rose flower Please read the don’ts document before posting.

New bosses are a don’t.

[eternal escarp]

and regardless adding more bosses wouldnt really help progression thats not really how it works

all bosses inbetween existing progression points dont lengthen progression, they just stay in the gap

[buoyant idol]

See: Fargo champions as an example on why this wouldn’t work either.

[eternal escarp]

...see almost all bosses that exist inbetween vanilla progression points aswell

[rose flower]

fine

[buoyant idol]

It’s simply too much effort to add anyways.

[rose flower]

just a question gearsaw

also im new so i didnt read that

[eternal escarp]

it happens to roughly 70% of suggestors, dont worry about it

just be sure to check it if you want to suggest something the next time

[rose flower]

wait wheres the donts bit

[eternal escarp]

its pinned in this channel

[rose flower]

oh ok

thanks

[eternal escarp]

np

[rose flower]

what would could as ''effort intensive''

[rose flower]

hey

[daring flame]

Hello, I wanted to know: How can I optimize the mod (except for particle settings)?
I have an almost complete build of Calamity as well as TSA, SOTS, MOR and a little more

My PC specs:
CPU: i7-3770 (Overclocked)
GPU: GTX 1660 Super
RAM: 16Gb ddr3

[drowsy plank]

#help-advice-read-pins

[drowsy plank]

what exactly do you are you trying to suggest

[rose flower]

new weapon but small :/

[drowsy plank]

no

[rose flower]

ok

[drowsy plank]

that's a specific item suggestion

you can describe a niche or tier you think might be lacking but you cant ask for a specific weapon

[rose flower]

am i blind or do i not see that

[drowsy plank]

5th bullet point

on the rules doc

[rose flower]

ah

[daring flame]

i cannot find any yet pins

also i try search

[drowsy plank]

it's not in the pins

this isnt the right channel for what you were asking

[daring flame]

oh, srry

[drowsy plank]

im redirecting you to the help channel

[eternal escarp]

ah whoops i tabbed out, seems youve already got an answer though

[median scaffold]

Bounteful Harvest getting a giant as it's menu theme (not a major theme, just hype)

[violet sierra]

You know, thats true

we could make the hallowed bar themed items only require hallowed bars theoretically no

[drowsy plank]

possibly
i think it'd prolly be better to make it just souls tho
for compatibility in case people disable the hardmode progression rework

[violet sierra]

That feels weird

the items look like they are made of hallowed bars

ultimately i don't really think it matters though

probably best to just keep it for theming

because you are correct

but all the weapons look like they are made of Hallowed Bars lmao

[drowsy plank]

so yeah, best to just. not do anything then

im pretty sure the soul costs are awfully low anyway

[misty lichen]

the recipes could just be different when the rework is on

[fleet grotto]

all 1

(seperate from vanilla where the rainbow rod costs 20 souls of sight wtf)

[drowsy plank]

[drowsy plank]

valid point

[gray bone]

light disc costs 25 souls of might, even worse

also isn't rainbow rod 15 souls not 20

[sand marlin]

I mean what else are you gonna use the souls for

Beat the boss one time and you got all the souls you need for the entire game? That's kinda wack

[violet sierra]

yeah if you play one class only

you get every soul from one boss kill