#suggestions-voting
1 messages Ā· Page 21 of 1
grav is fine hes just giving modifications to bosses, more of unique addition ot balancing
kind of my new addition to AS to make him more unique
What about a DM Dokuro branded weapon?
Already been suggested endlessly.
that's for him to decide, not us
Dev weapons are come up with by the specific dev themselves and themselves only (and if the coding can handle it), not by the community btw
^
Bloody Edge is basically the only sword in the game that looks awful, it should really get a graphical upgrade
And I guess all the shortswords up to True Night's Stabber except Leeching Dagger and Bloody Rapture also don't have the "Calamity" feeling to them but they don't really look bad
Nice
Brimstone Cacoon
Equipable
Press a certain button to surround yourself in a Brimstone cocoon that drastically increase defense and damage resistance and sufficiently increases life regeneration while in it
While in this mode, you can not attack or move
While in the cocoon you will shoot brimstone fire balls at enemies that Inflict abyssal flames
Drops from brimstone elemental on revengance mode
Death mode drop suggestions aren't accepted
Oh
Isn't this abyssions item but with brimstone fireballs
You can stay in the air while in it
why is the 'no deathmode items' rule not pinned in suggestions
add no dev weps as well since everyone keeps suggesting dokuro's DEV weapon
Just make a pin for it and mention that he should add it to his thingy in the pin
Alright
Just tag him
I'd do it but mobile is the worst and i'm also lazy
@scenic laurel sorry but add ^^^ to the rules (no deathmode suggestions)
done
š
Add a method to craft a metal detector
And the climbing claws
I know "Silence before the storms" is not meant to be included in the mod, but what about putting it in an easter egg-ish music box?
i'll add to this, but as an alt-title theme might be a good idea
Music boxes for all the non-ingame ost would be nice, but themeing and accessibly would be difficult. Seeing as it's meant to be listened to after doppel cal is defeated, possibly as a drop from her could work.
Oh uhhh yeah now that I think of it a The Tale of a Cruel World music box would be really gucci too
they should make it so the carbulon DOES NOT spawn on top of you
Pretty sure it doesn't damage you right away
(I an new here and i dont know if you have already talked about this but) Isnt the Polterghast supposed to look like that for reasons like: you need to kill 30 Phantom Spirits to summon him (and farm Phantoplasm to make the summon for him) as well as overall it looks better ?
Eh, make than an enraged state.
Like Plantera, except donāt make it so much like it.
to be fair i dont know why does it have the tentacles like plantera instead of flying like calamitas
Or the other ones
It should literally be a floaty-
Hence the fact itās basically Ectoplasm, and the armour covering the Phantoplasmic part.
.-.
from what I've heard it's supposed to be the angered amalgamation of souls that you free after you kill plantera
so it basically being a ghost plantera is intentional
it's not the souls in plant, it's the souls of those that yharim had slain iirc
the souls in the plant are the people who died in the underground jungle iirc
yharim would be the hardest boss
deemn
All super bosses are supposedly on the same tier
tbh i'd rather see yharim as a true finale rather than on the same tier as Scal
same
don't make fun of my garbo internet 
but yharim's been told to be pretty much a pseudo-demigod
the player slays gods like they're nothing at this point
The players only killed 2 gods though
slime god barely counts imo
dog prov moon lord(technicially) and slime god
Provi and slime god. and arugably moon lord
dog is a god you can't really deny that
DoG is NOT a god
DoG is a demigod by definition iirc
Not a demigod by definition
oof i though demigod was as powerful as one but not one
isnt he supposed to be just a ... Devourer of Gods (im sorry i had to do it XD)
Doggo is not a god. If hes a god, whats he the god of?
From scrolling up.
eating gods 
basically just a rly strong being
They ARE the souls released from Plantera, Plantera is the āhostā for these wandering, slain souls.
citation needed
we've moved on from plant/polter 
sHut
dokuro stated that they were slain by yharim though iirc
my thing likes to scroll way too far up sometimes
plant is dead people in the jungle
Dokuro aint canon
wait
dokuro knows lore we don't though
Youtube comments are not a source of canon lore
are we still talking about plantera and polterghast
Unless the comment is from fabsol
guess that's fair enough
good
Yes Polterghast backstory shit is DEFINITELY a suggestion you genius people.
imo hive mind should be buffed because the attacks are kind of easy to dodge and compared to perforators its way easier
and make providence's beam attack pass through blocks because if you fight her in hell most of the time it will just fire in blocks and pose no threat
Why are feather knifes just worse in every way than rot balls? make it so they fly strait forever and possibly lower def by like 2 or 3 idk 2nd one might be unballencd but just give them some advantage over rot balls, rot should =more dps and cc, feather knife should = snipeing and utility
Arent rot balls harder to farm and stuff?
not realy two hive kills = enough for life and if thrower you only need them from true shadow scales and nothing else
yeah
any way someone of higher power sees this? cause this seems to be a no brainer to me
ooh give em good crit cuz paper cuts n stuff lol
can draedons remote special item be added
its a challenge and i think it deserves an item
A "Playthrough 2" Item, once Calamitas is beaten she drops this item, Using this item in a new world will make all enemies and weapons stronger. This way having all the endgame items isnt pointless and u can enjoy the entire mod with them without making the bosses too easy and the incentive to get even more powerful versions of the items
so ng+ terraria edition
^
Unstable Shield Emitter
An arcing throwing weapon that sticks to enemies and blocks that generates a shield. When one USE is stuck, only the thing it's stuck to will be affected by the shield. When two are stuck, a line is drawn between them and everything on the line + the things the USEs are attached to are affected by the shield. With three or more, the biggest possible shape is drawn between every stuck USE and everything within the shape + on the line + stuck by USE is affected by the shield. All enemies affected by the shield take a flat percentage less damage from all sources (maybe 15%?), but also take damage over time that linearly scales with how many USEs make up the shield. The USEs last for a while, but they're not supposed to expire like that. Instead, when you right click, all USEs "detonate" (no damage done, that's the animation) and the shield brightens in intensity while it collapses in upon the mean position of all USEs. Anything hit by the shield while it collapses takes high damage that scales exponentially with how many USEs made up the shield. If a USE is stuck over about half a screen away from all other USEs, everyone but the one just thrown down detonates.
The idea with this weapon is a small to moderate DOT at the expense of damage and when you detonate, massive damage but you lose the DOT.
On a side note, I don't really know how the USE would fit in the progression, maybe somewhere around DoG?
Actually, it should be called the Unstable Shield Emitter.
Think of your own. Or talk with the normal members of the community
So how bad/broken is my idea?
Though if theyāre available and free you can talk to the mods/devs/admins/owners too
oke then ty
make your did it an emote
Your weapon idea sounds cool, but as for bad/broken I have no idea. One thing I do notice right away though, is that your USE will probably be very painful to code
Buff calamitas
Its really weak om first phase
Ok thanks 
I kind of figured that.

Calamitas is meant to be weak in first phase anyway.
Yea, thats not the real fight
Ok
Sort of a fake out thing
^^
Hence "doppleganger"
^
U h h h s o r r y m a n i d o n t k n o w
M u c h e n g l i s h
Dont type like that please
k
Thats fine and all, but dont type like that its a bit hard to read
K
Also, #general-talk or #calamity-mod-talk
š°
Idea: more food buff items. Maybe fried bumblebirb?
Should increase speed and hp regen
Chicken tendies when
We need Bard Class weapons like an Uber-Tier Weapon I made called "Draedon's Gravikord of Lament"
If you don't know what a Gravikord is go here: https://www.google.com/search?q=gravikord&rls=com.microsoft:en-US:IE-SearchBox&rlz=1I7GGHP_enUS578&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjgt5resoTcAhUB3IMKHT1uCHgQ_AUIDCgD&biw=1366&bih=605
i dont think calamity will participate in thorium's bard class
I think they have more important things to focus on then thorium support.
And yes, npcs are one of those things.
It still is, a unique, good class. Just doesn't need calamity support.
I just realized that sacredtools mod has a bard weapon!
But that is irrelevant.
So I won't say anymore.
is a mod still here?
i have a suggestion that slightly enhances throwing experience and is't difficult to code
may i cpy paste it pls?
Sure
ty
Why are feather knifes just worse in every way than rot balls? make it so they fly strait forever and possibly lower def by like 2 or 3 idk 2nd one might be unballencd but just give them some advantage over rot balls, rot should =more dps and cc, feather knife should = snipeing and utility
maybe instead of def lower they lower dmg if non boss enimies by a tad
idk somthing to set em apart would be good
Idea: add an item similar to defiled rune, but with the opposite purpose. It doubles your damage reduction and increases some other stats too, but makes enemies drop less loot. Call it @lucid drum mode

No joke suggestions pls but I love it
This way you can play revengence with the difficulty of expert mode or expert with the difficulty of normal mode
Heart of gold.
The name was a joke but the idea is not, I would love this item
Doesnt feel like it fits within the spirit of calamity
I think itās ok as long as the trade off is decent
Not really, as boss treasure bag drops are always certain.
Not the treasure bags, but the items inside them perhaps. For example, you get half the demonite from the eye of cthulhu
Or half the yharon soul fragments from yharon
But youāre always guaranteed to get one of each guaranteed item, so you still always get a worm scarf from the eater of worlds
They have increased drop rates in upper difficulties, meaning you can get more than just one.
Weapons would follow the same rule unless multiple are dropped maybe?
So it could just go back to normal mode rates.
That sounds good
Also note that the double damage reduction would be calculated before the rev mode damage reduction cap, so if you had 50% dr you wouldnāt get 100% dr
I personally don't think that's something Fab would ever add, but I guess it'd be cool if you just needed to get acquainted with Rev AI but can't handle the damage/defense and DR changes.
Yeah, I can handle the AI of rev or the star changes but not both, and I want rage and adrenaline in expert mode
But also rev drops
Rage and Adrenaline is completely overkill for Expert unless you're straight-up bad at the game.
I'd rather get rid of these suggestions 
^
I just want calamity mod to have bard class weapons.
Suggestion:
The Trusted role
a role given to people that's not disruptive, or that has earned the trust of most of the staff
Allows the user that has it to post pics/embed links in #general-talk
cant that music loop bug not be fixed simply by providing a way to patch your wavebank to replace the main menu theme?
or provide a premade one until the bug has been fixed? or is that a copyright issue since it would include original soundtrack aswell
no meme suggestions
i wish there was a meme channel
regarding this channel
There was one at one point. It was such a shit show that it was deleted.
I suggest you go and refined your ideas first, before posting it.
Yeah most likely
No scal related stuff
First off...Kill SCal every time you have to change its damage? That's already kind of ridiculous
well idk just thought about it a few secs ago
or few mins
i lose time rather quickly
I repeat: Try to refine your ideas before you post it here

Jesus it's cancerous to read
wait what?
Learn to read the pins
No death exclusive items
ye read the pins
There are rules there
that I totally didnāt state before
made it into revengeance mode
Weapon Name : Herald Of The End Tool tip : The Gods Have Cursed Us... Weapon Info : This Weapon Alternates Into 4 Weapon Damage Types Signifying The 4 Classes. In Order To Change Its Damage, You Need To Right-click it on a world where Death Mode, Defiled Rune, And Demon Trophy Is Active. Each Damage Type Has A Special Effect like Ex. Melee Damage Type Inflicts All Debuffs Available And Reduces Enemy Life By A Percentage And Ignores Damage, Ranged Damage Type Spawns Life Seeking Void Arrows From The Bow Causing Enemies To Deform And Lose Health Quickly Over Time And This Effect Also Applies To Bosses. Magic Damage Type Creates A Black Hole At The Circle Deteriorating All Enemies And Providing Buffs To The User. Summoner Damage Type Encircles You In A Very Large Ring Of Darkness That Automatically Spawns Minions Over Time That Disappear After 20 Seconds But Provide The User With Health. Additional Info : Dropped By All Bosses In Revengeance Mode At A 1/500 Chance. Cannot Be Reforged And Damage Multipliers Do Not Affect It.
you donāt need to resend it
i deleted the old one
Holy shit that's cancerous and painful to read
My eyes hurt.
Suggestions like this will neverbe accepted
99% of ppl get this question worng.
What is the strongest terraria enemy/boss?
ml
Wrong chat for that
oops
@eager vortex This is #suggestions-voting not #calamity-mod-talk or #general-talk just wanna say
Damnit Tera you ninja'd me
too the general talk mobile
cool idea i came up with for implementing dokuro's new "silence before the storms": What if Calamitasā lore item was a material that turned into another lore item about the player thinking about the future and what not and then that lore item could turn into the music box for this theme? š¤ hmmmmmmmm
add one (1) calamitous essence or syntax error to super dummy recipe kthx
Repost of my suggestion, please update what requirements for nohits in the #mod-announcements section, prehaps in a google document.
It should be explained a bit more due to the current changes, and while some may understand what is and is not limited, others may not know that.
@tawdry condor wtf no meme suggestions reeee
@agile smelt š«
O-oh shit.
A post DoG buff to Cryogen, but making it drop the frost moon essence would be a nice alternative way to farm for it
Same buff could happen to the Calamitas doppelgƤnger with the pumpkin moon essence instead of giving it the same buff as the brimstone elemental
^
Something like that, or maybe if you were to add a spooky boss at the same tier as cryogen and use that? Like how thorium has the lich.
That sorta tier is already super crowded tbh
yeah
i love love the throwing class but it could use more weapons. i propose a post caldoppleganger upgrade to the crystaline it has 3 more spits, 2 happen half way through the no grav travel same as the main two that happen rnow, and the 3rd happens at the same time as the shard that goes back accept it's on the other side.
the recipe needs ashes of calamity crystaline and crystal shards and maybe another hallowed theme item and ofcs celesteus would need this and not crystaline
This is likely to have been suggested already, but for the Demonshade armor, I would find it better if the little red devil could be removed and summoned with an armor ability by double-tapping down/up(depending on your settings), similar to the stardust armor's guardian.
It can already be removed with chibii devourer.
please make provs death box smaller, having it as big as it is has no effect other than being annoying to mine
^
WoF's box isn't anywhere near as big, so i don't see why provi needs to create an entire jungle everytime she dies
Suggestion: make the fact that you can summon Providence in the Hallow instead of just in the Underworld a bit more obvious
The only indication being the presence of the mobs in the Hallow
i think the enemies spawn there as well
and the guardians can't be summoned in the underworld 
atleast i couldn't
they can be spawned in the hallow just fine
@cosmic zenith Iām guessing that you forgot about the time of day
you could always summon donuts in the underworld
yeah guardians and prov can be summoned in both biomes
Donuts?
guess i can't look at the ingame clock anymore
the guardians used to look like they escaped from a krispy kreme
I mean the fact that it has to be daytime
(Idk if that was supposed to be sarcastic)
(old sprite for ref)
apoth and friends should change the sprite back tbh

Now that I think about it, they remind me of the cloud god trio from PokƩmon gen... 5? 6?
Landorus, Thundorus, and...
winderous 
It was after I stopped playing PokĆ©mon, but I remember seeing the one thatās a Flying monotype and thinking
āFucking finallyā
Took them long enough
Tornadus
But this is a convo for #general-talk
Scavanger Drone - Would spawn in Ravager's phase 1 everytime he stomps and summons 2 at the same time. They shold get close up to you and use flamethrower as a weapon and inflict the on fire debuff on hit. If you dont kill the remaining ones in phase 1 they go invincible through the whole fight. 3000 hp 30 def 15% dr. I might make a sprite for it when i got time.
my idea: either make Ravager's bullshit stone block things that are impossible to dodge not move until they spawn again, or make the little fireball things not spawn on top of you without warning, or both
it has a pattern
the flame pillars can deal damage half a second after they spawn iirc
and since they always spawn on top of the player, unless you react perfectly they're a cheap hit
āImpossible to dodgeā
Tell that to Levi 
@gleaming dove I wait patiently
Exo Brick
- placeable tiles that take -0.2 seconds to mine with a Gallant pickaxe (minimum)
- Can only be removed by the owner/placer of said tiles
- Give speed/health/damage boosts to any player on your team (PvP team colours) standing on them (or near them)
- Damages any enemy player and enemies/bosses (to damage players, the owner can turn PvP on to damage other enemy players)
- requires one nightmare fuel, endothermic energy, darksun fragment, Phantoplasm, yharon soul fragment, auric ore and 1 asphalt block to craft (Yields 50 Exo Bricks)
Perfect
just a thonker 
Really damn expensive for a brick
oof
sorry, ill make it able to yield 50 bricks @slow kettle
Perfect
Sounds much better
or PvP battles
i left the damage caused over time by the brick as empty so the devs can think over how much damage it causes, if the idea even gets through in the first place
so i left it empty
@gleaming dove make it so that it can trap boss monsters too
NO
Thatās too op
just as normal enemies can't move past tiles
That would be nightmarish to code
you mean, that most bosses that normally fly through tiles can collide with exo bricks?
nightmare to code in C#
yep
That suggestion for a suggestion will not work
What if you could make a Plague Hive block, but it wouldnāt spread

or maybe it could spread to normal hive blocks but nothing else 
That would be cool
Having a Plague biome without adding a biome
Oof
auric bricks:
require 25 stone, 1 auric ore
radiates a little bit of light but its really just for decor
There should be more mud based grasses
Also thatās a nice suggestion
would be cool if it had walls and a matching furniture set
I mean Astral is getting a furniture set
would like to have an auric themed house
nie
nice but I don't really like the design of it's bricks
WDYM?
The astral bricks don't look the best
They look better than most Vanilla tiles in general
PBG Furniture set when?
@tawdry condor Exo Chair
exo bricks and a furniture set would be cool
what did you think of my fancy exo brick idea though
kind of like a black brick with a rainbow design
Wait, what about my Plague Plating suggestion?
Iām sad now
where
pretty good but I think there should be a cheaper version for decor + furniture (Maybe only 1 endothermic and 1 nightmare fuel + 50 gray/chaotic bricks)
Exo Chair:
every other god damn chair in one for all i care.
that would make some sense.
Should add some extra thingies with the pirate invasion maybe
Like what
A way to summon the frost legion without having to be in the Christmas season
Easy, code it so that itās always Christmas time ingame
fargo(?) auto enables seasonal enemies
luiafk seasonal items.
luiafk
also donāt c r a f t e m t h e n
l u i a f k
yes
You donāt have to make the Souls you do realize that
^
Maybe add a boat mount that you can get from the pirate ship
someone realises
that'd be cool tho
A boat mount that only works in water and is also the best mount
Obviously best mount
Because water travel is not a god damn thing
nohit leviathan with boat
I would love to see SCal killed by someone in a boat
lmao yes
death by copper shortsword
Oof
Letās get back on track before we get off topic
@gleaming dove here it is BTW. My Plague Plating suggestion
what is this
Smh
Read
what is this supposed to be I don't know what plague plating is
Itās a block
That I suggested ages ago
Hereās Plague Platings crafting recipe:
1 Plague Cell Canister
2 Iron/Lead Bars
This yields two blocks
Ok Iām done now
One iron bar per block is pretty awful.
Why?
Most material-based blocks use an ore per block.
Too much of a resource cost per block.
Should I change it to something more renewable, like Hallowed Bars?
Cause those are literally infinite
probably.
Or an ore per block.
Why an ore for something that is and industrial block?
Ore isnāt refined. A bar is
Consistent with other material blocks, for one.
@tawdry condor or you could make it yield more blocks per craft
That too
like 10-20
I was just about to say ten blocks
make it cost 1 hallowed bar + plague canister and make it give 10 blocks
15 and we have a deal
Well, the reason I chose Iron/lead was because of the PBG summon
btw imitable what template did you use to make the sprite sheet for that (if at all)
I wanna make the exo bricks
Iām on mobile at the moment
;-;
oof
I have the template, just that I canāt send it
Iām going offline now
See yall
bb
make the Sentinels' theme play when they show up in DoG's fight
just a minor QoL change
Nah
They die pretty quickly anyway. Plus this way scourge of the universe get to play longer so itās long duration is less wasted
Yee
@tawdry condor yeah, one bar per block isnt very good
i'd do 2 iron bars and 3 plauge cell cannisters makes 150 blocks
it's never over
Should be per 25 or something like that, 15 stack is awkward.
I canāt beat the eye of Cthulhu please help
Oh shit
:/\
Then give me suggestions
What if you could fuse banners together so your entire base isnt covered with banners like mine
Oh that would be sexy awesome
Id actually have room for stuff again
And Fabsol may actually add banners 
Just make a large chest area and have a couple chests where you dump banners into. If you're talking about placing banners just make a bunch of banner space on the top and bottom of the space you want them in (preferably an actual arena)
Smh
Banners are a cluster if you don want them as decoration and want functionality out of them
true, I just never used them because by time I set everything up I didn't even need half the banners because I was already stronger than most enemies that you'd need them for.
Oof
Pretty sure there was some mod for this
Suddenly the Post Yharon Solar Eclipse arrives
Add a bed wars mode to calamity
smh
exostabber
There's one being sprited already, may get in
THERE EILL BE
CHECK PINS
SPRITERS CANT WORK AT LIGHT SPEED AND GET ALL OF THEM DONE IN A SNAP

did somebody suggest adding more...SHORTSWORDS
if you read, yes
._.
Possibly a Night Flail, which could be called Night's Wrath.
Doesn't matter, though
wait, does calamity already have a night/bloody yoyo?
FLAIL.
Not yoyo.
Lacerator is pretty bloody lmao
Besides, there's a shortage of flails, if you couldn't tell
https://calamitymod.gamepedia.com/Flails
I believe there is a yoyo for perforator stuff, I dont remember if there is one for hive mind
No
Im aware there's a difference, Im askin a question as like "is there a night's throw" or something ._.
o
Doesnāt Thorium mod or SacredTools add a Nights Edge equivalent of a flail
You absolute fucking walnut
...flails and yo-yos are different, guys.
Smh zach no bulli
granted, not by much, but still.
Im acutely aware
as flails have larger hitboxes but are affected by gravity while yoyos have one tile hitboxes but aren't affectd by gravity
You're a fail
Yes
Get out of this channel
yes and this now offt-
damn
"Soul's chain"
Basically a reusable resurrection potion, dropped by brimstone or hell themed enemies. (Or abyss, really I don't care.)
You're a persistent one.
oh boy
solar eruption isnt a flail
tbh because of WeaponOut i'd name them "whips"
and second of all
even tho they're named after flails
the fuck kind of whip is has that shit at the end
they're not "flails"
re logic made a shit weapon style and gave it to 3 or 4 prehardmode weapons
i'll remove the argument then
here's a line fromthe wiki about the eruption
It seems to have much lower knockback than most other flails, but its knockback is enough to keep most enemies at bay.
they realised their mistake and made the next """"flails"""" much more useable
it's not a flail
ahem
GET OUT OF THIS CHANNEL
Out
thanks
rip
k but to general or calamity mod talk
Calam talk is fine

how about no
Everything has gon off topic here
if u put an x on the boss, it dies
actually
Also, having others here isn't helping, so when staff is there, try not to add to chat too much.
Dude, he just told you to read pins.
that gives me an idea
What happened to No Joke Suggestions?
Nope
SMFH
Imitable, not helping
Ok sorry
I think he was pretty clear in what he said. To both of you.
Now, get back to real suggestions
Maybe a post-Yharon flail that acts like a typical flail, like Sunfury. All it does is destroy things.
that guy
pls dont make me go on an autistic rampage explaining why i hate flails again
add something that includes the architect gizmo pack as a item in the recepie
Flail that only destroys blocks...
What? It'd be unique.
Even if the idea is TERRIBLE.
Guess what, bucko: I like flails.
i was really surprised that the item wasnt used in a recepie
Can we get some kind of buff to the Wall of Flesh? Right now, it's as simple as run backwards with Spectre Boots and spam Bee's Knees.
or just make something that helps with building
would you prefer that we walk forward captain?
Calm down on caps
And please don't go offtopic
new wall of flesh buff: it moves vertically
I'm bad at the game but had no trouble against the Wall.
The Wall was easier than pretty much every boss before it.
@ivory tree read pins
@silver chasm I don't mean his HP, I mean give him some new attacks, some kind of resistance to Bee's Knees, something like that.
Joke suggestion sorry mods Summoning WoF actually summons two Walls, one on each side of the map
Why are you telling them to read pins
yo wait
Also that guy 
I've read them already
cause
i know
it includes stats
Zplos suggestion doesnt go against pins
and i've fucking explained 1000000 times why i suggest PRELIMINARY stats
It includes preliminary stats
thank you
what
Right, can ya'll shut now.
A basis of the strength of the weapon for devs to work off of should it be added
Also yeah this chat needs to calm the hell down
yeah sorry about that
Just, nothing like sell price or item rarity. For gods sake, please.
^
infinite cobwebs as a sell price
but on a side not
wall of flesh x2 would be a decent idea
give it a bit of overall resistance
Isnt item rarity broken in Calamity anyways
Like hell it would
half the hp
also imma repost so ppl will actually see it and i can feed my ego for the day
Witch's Pen (yea yea ill come upw ith something better later
Preliminary Stats:
365 Magic Damage
Very Fast Speed
Uses 200 Mana
Casts a cursed, controllable glob of ink, similarly to Magic Missle or Rainbow Rod
The glob leaves behind and flings smaller ink particles that home in on enemies, similarly to Azathoth, but at a slightly faster rate
Drop from Collosal Squids post-Polterghast
I said it's a joke suggestion for a reason
But whythough
i dont see the issue with it
besides the fact that it's already proven to be hell to code?
well first ofall
365 damage is fucking weak
Right, so, unless you have a thought out suggestion, leave.
Mostly cause of the potential glitchfest that would occur when both walls collide with the player
And with 200 mana..?
dude
Wall of Flesh needs some way to counter Bee's Knees / the Bee Gun.
did you even read
to make it even more difficult to code, and second because the boss is kinda boring
it drops homing glob shitlets
and that would add a time aspect
Yes
faster than azathoth
But still
So? Raw damage doesn't make up everything
im surrounded by idiots
lowkey warned for staff disrespect
no but seriously
oh no
Would it be possible to reduce the laser spam but allow the lasers to pierce blocks on WoF?
you guys always explain stuff that i already know
nice idea actually
Do you realize how fast it'd need to spew those for it have a proper effect of DoG where it should be tiered.
well
It's a matter of balance where it's either fucking op or useless in this case.
i leave the fine tuning to you then
useless like throwing class
tfw i'm not a dev who can code 
which should have some more infinite throwing items btw
Defined if you don't have anything useful to contribute go to a dif channel
This is the busiest Iāve seen this channel yet
i was using that comment to segway into a suggestion fob
Thanks for pointing that out imitable, now leave please.
Thank you
like the throwable items from the hive mind
and perferators
just make them infinite
tooth and rot balls are fine as is tbh
nu
Not hard to farm, and easy to craft.
And you also immediately have access to the new throwing knives.
Because otherwise it loses a lot of the aspects of throwing, and becomes even more of a discount ranger. 
it already is though
its literally just
ranger minus the gun
its like having no minishark but just throwing the bullets quickly
farming for tooth / rot balls doesnt take long
again
read what i said last time
i get the idea of it all
but throwing is just a cut the middle man ranger
and as far as actual new weapons go
i have an idea for that
you mean a shitty ranger
It is a subclass of ranger, yeah
different words same meaning
Cept you cant
the fuckin spear
You arent fabsol
ok back to my idea for throwing weapons
make weapons like the crystalline
except they dont just break at some point
if you hit, then they break and it does extra damage
if you dont hit well, it does nothing
there arent any homing weapons for throwing
i believe
Doesn't valediction home?
That kinda doesnāt make sense. The breaking projectiles bit
home?
home in
Why is throwing even a thing
because people wanted it to be
but its a really difficult thing to code
and make unique
If you aren't going to suggest something.
Get out of here @tawdry condor
it kind of is a suggestion though
"Why is throwing even a thing" isn't a suggestion.
Throwing isnāt exactly ranged, and it doesnāt fit any other classes bill
Enough said
Throwing was invented so ranged would have early game weakness
Throwing needs to be made more unique. At the moment I feel like going with ranged is a far better option.
Okay can we cut it out with these 'suggestions'
I'm tired of em atm, just go somewhere else or stop.
again if you want to make throwing unique
just make it so it doesnt home and so that it rewards accuracy
have weapons that have difficult to master patterns
and make them extra useful
ranged is already fucked
its just
spam spam spam
plus chlorophyte bullets
I like the idea of an accessory that rewards consecutive throwing hits with more and more crit chance.
Ranged is just that: Attacking from far away
oh thats a good idea
Rangers have guns and bows
an accesory which raises crit chance by like 5-10% if you land your shots consecutively
starts out with 0 but then gets to those points, and resets (or gets a few points removed) if you miss
Plus, if rangers are spam, then warriors are spam and mages are spam and every class is spam
though its more of a ranged/throwing accesory since mage would just not care
well i mean
Could you really bring the class discussion outta here? It doesnt have much to do with suggestions
The argument doesnāt make sense
Just take it to #calamity-mod-talk
And yes Waluigi
melee is (supposed to be) close up damage, mage is just a different melee where you dont have to be up close but you need magic, ranged is the same thing except you need ammo, and summoner is the same except it has the minions to make it more unique
good job not moving chats
had to get it out there sorry
what did waluigi just say
anyways
Did I not just tell you to move class discussion elsewhere.
Final verbal warning @full haven
oh boy
nvm
oh my god lmao
back to suggestions
Living Cursed Flames/Ichor, just living balls of cursed fire and ichor than spawn in their respective evil biome, maybe in hardmode, that attack like the Angry Nimbus mobs
fresh out of the retard oven but hey it is a suggestion
Reaper Shark Gun
500 Ranged Damage
Very Fast Speed
Fires an even spread of 5 homing mini-reaper sharks to attach to enemies and damage them over time, inflicting Crush Depth debuff
Crafted From: Barracuda Gun, 8 Reaper Shark Teeth
Alternatively, they can stay in place for a while before throwing themselves at the player, like the Enchanted Sword mob.
Interesting
so literally a reskin of already existing enemies?
Hm, I dunno if living stuff like that would feel... unique enough. Its kinda like saying "lets put living fireballs in hell"
maybe with slightly different stats?
Wait
Actually living fireballs sound much cooler
it might be hard to code but i'd make it so they ram at the player
What if the living Ichor/Cursed Flame was a water based enemy
and if they ram into a tile, they splatter a bunch of ichor/cursed flames everywhere
That too
As for uniqueness, I'd say it's alright to recycle vanilla mob AIs, so long as they're not overdone.
Calamity has loads of them
But that's not for this channel.
Yeah
Magic/summoner weapon
Book of the dead
Post yharon
uses 500 mana
Upon use, it respawns all enemies that died on the screen in the last 10-60 seconds (i have no idea for what value would make it balanced) and the enemies will be friendly twoards the player and will have aggro twoards enemies/bosses
Thatās too op
sounds kinda cool
oh and the respawned shit lasts for like 5 mins
Thatd be hell to code
otherwise you could stack a lot
Even if it was balanced it would be hell to code
Ooo, that would require adding friendly ai to every single enemy
^^
yea
Yup
And it might not even be that good
You cant suggest something that tough to code and just expect it to get in, smh
You can use Yharon to cheese SCal
Spawning a preset minion for every enemy killed might be better, say, some kind of Soul of the Damned or something
expect it to get in, smh
actually i can, expectations are an opinion
But yeah i know it'd be hell to code
That is a much better idea than every dead enemy
no
spit
summoner
that's just a summoner specifically
it doesnt do anything that unique
but i get the idea
For each enemy you've killed in the past X seconds, you will summon 1 Soul of the Damned that lasts X seconds and attacks enemies.
Didn't walu say to stop the class discussions?
Do you have any idea how many suggestions are made per day that aren't accepted?
So unless you put a lot of work into it, you really shouldn't expect your ideas to get it.
i'll stop now
This idea being discussed is so unfathomable I cannot wrap my mind around it
In terms of scope and time
Name change again?
Yes
alternatively though
Ban
Them
All

no dont
you could lower the mana cost to something like 20
The whole idea is madness
ok fine
and make it damage all the enemies around you in a certain distance and make them released homing "shadow fragments" of their soul or whatever tf
if you want something easier to code here's this
how long until this dude gets tired of getting his suggestions shot down like the others?
Idk
give it time
same shit except you get points based off the hp of the enemies you killed, and based off those points a minions spawns
Making things that aren't normally friendly into friendly npcs would take years to pull off and not have it be a broken and buggy mess.
^
i feel like that would be easier to code
The idea is OK if it just spawns a generic ally, but otherwise it would be absolutely bonkers.
great job, youāve made it sound just as bad with your new suggestion!
Speaking of "friendly enemies" I'm gonna repost a suggestion of mine from a few weeks ago:
either way its utter hell to bother coding
you can't do anything like
Imma just leave before shit hits the fan
make their hitboxes friendly and make then not attack you
As a programmer with a degree in this shit and who has looked at the vanilla AI code for more than a few years, no.
ok
By the time that coding was done the new Terraria update would be out
Bumblestaff: Basically a Herring Staff, except it summons Bumblebirbs. This helps support the idea that Bumblebirbs create clones of themselves, and that they're rabid motherfuckers.
in terms of script it'd be something like
if hp >= 100 and hp < 500
points=points +1
what are you even talking about
yes because thatās how close works
As it has been said before, you'd need to make new AI for every single enemy.
how do all the other games like Gungeon and TBOI do the "charmed" thing then
script
dude script is my favorite laungauge
Lol
Zplo please
@ivory tree they have far simpler ai and probably built for it
does he really think he knows what heās talking about????
no
^^
i dont know much about coding tbh, so my idea for the points with the example i gave of a script arent really that
how about
you move to a different channel
before I ban all of you :)
Okay I know there are multiple mods here already, but... #general-talk or #other-mod-talk yeah?
It's the same way Dark Souls and etc have enemies that can target other enemies
The engine is built around that idea
XNA/Terraria isn't even close
All enemies in Terraria target the closest player, they are built ENTIRELY around player targets
In order to make them attack other enemies you'd need to literally rewrite all of their AI
~~Besides having minions target other players in PvP situations is soooo much more important at the moment
~~
and the AI method in Terraria is tens of thousands of lines long
so no, never would I do that
So essentially shit tons of work
i know that's not my idea though, i changed that
Still
have points distributed based off enemy hp or something
then a minion summoned based off the points earned
youāve given such a bare-bones idea as is
I actually like the general theme of the idea but it will probably be a pain in the ass.
Can you stop with this suggestion
Please
It's getting nowhere but towards a punishment
cough #general-talk cough
also Fab would still have to write code to keep track of enemies that have died previously, so Iād give it up if I were you
Bad luck be quiet
Sorry
i still think its a good idea but i'll stop now
Bumblestaff: Basically a Herring Staff, except it summons Bumblebirbs. This helps support the idea that Bumblebirbs create clones of themselves, and that they're rabid motherfuckers. Reposted from a few minutes ago just to get the channel back on track. Apologies if I shouldn't have done this.
Guy you just posted that before
NO MORE BUMBLESTAFFS OH GOD
Can't you don't repost do soon
My bad.
if there's any weapon that deserves to come from Birb, it's Murderswarm
it had a sprite and projectile and everything
Bumblebirb summon staff, each one could take 1/4 minion slot so they can swarm the heck out of everything with an AI similar to vanilla crows
That's kinda the point of my suggestion, hence Herring Staff
shh
I swear to god 
I'm thinking of another Bumblebirb-themed staff, but this one just rains Bumblebirbs from the sky and they explode upon enemy/tile collision. Although there's already a fair few weapons that work like that so eh
speaking of Murderswarm tho
Decay Cannonade
80 Magic Damage
Uses 10 Mana
Insanely Fast Speed
Fires off overwhelming swarms of homing death plankton that dissapear after enemy or tile hit
Fires a festering bubble about every 1/2 a second that flies straight foward and explodes into 9 death plankton
Crafted From: The Swarmer, Black Anuarian, 8 Cosmilite Bars, 10 True Shadow Scales, and 10 Plauge Cell Cannisters
Juggling between "Corrupt" and "Plauge" pallete/style and yes this is a repost
80 damage smh too week 
bruh it's like shotgun+minigun speed
automatic shotgun?
Shredder: Magic edition
not to mention the occasional frag bubble thingy
havent made one
give some love to the corrupt boys
crim already has more than plently exclusive items
Auric bricks
Pretty self explanatory basically just auric ore and some stone for a set number of bricks.
Would be kinda cool to make a nice looking auric house and would make sense considering there's uelibloom bricks and astral bricks
Who the fuck is gonna make a house when you have 1 boss left
Okay on a completely different topic- you know what vanilla buff doesnāt seem to get any love? Electrocuted
Iād love to see an electric sword that could inflict it, maybe dropped by Cal doppelgƤnger in revengence or something
Or heck, maybe it could be an extra weapon from the Martian madness or crafted from a current Weapon and some other things
Insanity Chainsaw: A melee weapon that acts like that one OOA weapon that swings around the player, but instead of a staff it's two giant chainsaws. Hitting an enemy with this would cause a large DoT effect.
@errant fable I make a house when there is 0 bosses left
Basically it's what a player would use if they just wanna have some fun and slaughter everything.
@errant fable Pretty sure more bosses post yharon are getting added as well
Really?
Lotta people cheat in building supplies esrlygame
And some might still want to build after all bosses
it is a tease for another boss
Yeah on par with SCal
Goozma, Yharim, and Andromidus iirc
How long has SCal been a thing?
about a year
@tawny peak i actually like the idea but i think there should be some sort of chance to lifesteal/damage reduction buff on hit, since it's an up-close weapon
other than that what tier would it be
I like the lifesteal idea, gives the player a reason to stay in the thick of battle. As for tier...
I'd like for it to be post-ML, but give it a simple design.
made of luminite in other words?
Itās not Andromidus. Itās Andromeda. And she hasnāt been confirmed
Ooh, being made purely out of Luminite would be nice.
What weapon is this?
Scroll up.
Iām sorry for being lame and not being able to tell what is what
Iāll look again
The Chainsaw?
Aye.
So yes?
It's sort of like the Sleepy Octopod (I think that's its name) but it just spins around the player for as long as the button is held. The player would be swinging two chainsaws around him that would tear everything to shreds.
nope
Oh like the Thorium scythes?
Yeah.
you're thinking of Sky Dragon's Fury
Nice
or calamity's Typhon's Greed
Noice
Suggestion: Shredder + P90 + 50 Shadowspec Bars
Let their PC melt after they finish the playthrough
just me, but since it's blood themed and all, i'd make the chainsaw called Abbatoir (slaughterhouse in some language idk) and make it out of Bloodflare Cores
thank
Nah. Adding Bloodflare would force spriters into making it look all mutated and weird and stuff. I'd like for the design to simply be giant steel murderers.
with blood all over it
oay but
Maybe include some stuff that isnāt blood stone
why would'nt you want it to be all fleshy and stuff
That sounds like the Crimson tbh
Cause there's enough stuff like that in Calamity already.
Build out of 2 Butcher's Chainsaws?
Calamity's a bit lacking in the "simple" department.
dude
Simple, maybe?
clamtea doesne't exist to be simple
Lol
clamtea
You're right, but it doesn't exist to be abominable aswell.
uuuh
Calamity is the sweet mix of almost everything
try using fargowiltas with calamity 
die
Yharon soul bullets/arrows
They seek enemies, inflict several debuffs, and have increased armor piercing

Boom fixed
Divine Macerator
An exo-tier gun on par with Heavenly Gale and the Photoviscerator.
Crafting recipe:
-Disseminator
-Onyx Chain Blaster
-Shredder
-Dragon's Breath
-Storm Dragoon
-3 Yharon's soul fragments
-25 auric ore
-5 Nightmare Fuel
-5 Endothermic Energy
-5 Darksun Fragments
-5 Cosmilite Bars
-5 Phantoplasm
This gun would fire out a wide spread of random exo-bullets, with different but weaker effects than Heavenly gale's exo-arrows. Any target hit by these bullets would be hit by another spread of 2 more homing exo-bullets from all around the target. Effects vary per exo-bullet.
make SCal's theme a space jam mashup of RUC pls

