Does This Thumbnail Style Feel Good?

[lofty radish]

Howdy, been a while since I've posted in here.

Wanted to come and get some general feedback on some thumbnails I've been working on for a video titled "The Pirate Game That "Ruined" Assassins Creed" I currently have two versions.

i've been putting a lot more effort into my thumbnails in an attempt to produce better packaging.

Let me know exactly which one you'd prefer to click on, any ideas you have for improving them,

Thanks in advance.

[heady dome]

dang!
you really put more effort on these tns🔥

[heady dome]

I would click on the one with the dude lying
but both could work

also, make the game cases a little bit bigger, since in suggested you can't see those at all