#Are we a fan of this logo?

37 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

glossy relic
#

Created in illustrator and photoshop, I spent a while on this one. Does it look alright?

GrainofTruthDocumentariesLogo.jpg
#

I did try a few variations (of both increasing the size of the wheat plant and not increasing its size) but I wasn't a fan of the look so I just stuck it in the back lol

#

I think it conveys the same message either way

#

Thanks man

vagrant anvil
#

So for more context what kind of documentaries do you do?

#

I like the seemingly daek yet simplistic background which represents facts and straightforwardness, and also the pun included in the logo and title which promises an entertaining video/viewpoint

glossy relic
#

Thank you for your feedback

limpid echo
#

o i like it, very nice!

mystic galleon
#

Warning: Bluntness.

This looks AI generated to me honestly. You said it's not and I trust you on that, but there's a level of sheen/shine to it that doesn't quite sit right with me.

Your text is going to be unreadable when the logo is being used as a standard icon.

Overall though, I quite like the concept you've got for it with the magnifying glass, but it just feels a little uncanny in it's current state.

limpid echo
#

it contain a lot of errors that a designer of this skill would not make

#

it looks good tho, which is what matter most to me

#
  • a designer would've made this in a vector app
#
  • it is pixel based and low-res / dpi at that, just like ai imagary
#
  • it contains over 20 tiny graphical errors that ai often makes
#

alternatively it's made by a decent photoshop enjoyer but idk, the skill shown is to such a degree these mistakes should not happen

mystic galleon
limpid echo
#

Illustrator is a vector app, perhaps they gave discord a crappy version on purpose idk

#

Unless he shares a screenshot of the sauges i'm gonna bet it's ai

mystic galleon
#

Discord only takes rasters/standard distributable formats for thumbnails/embeds afaik

limpid echo
#

like this you can see it's made by moi

#

right but this makes no sense

#

this doesnt happen in vector

#

and even in pixel based app it's only happening if you use way to low dpi

#

discord makes it more blurry sure but it's flat

mystic galleon
#

Either way my original feedback stands

#

I'll also add: Why the gimmick? It doesn't really make sense with the channel theme

limpid echo
#

yee i think it will be hard to see in the yt logo as well

#

to small

glossy relic
#

anyways, I actually ended up remaking it as I felt it didn't really resemble the "grain" feel

#

It has less detail, yes, but I like the more simple look of it

#

i'll post a ss of my artboard ig