Thumbnail feedback and direction of channel

[wheat pawn]

My channel with 3 past thumbnails I have done https://www.youtube.com/@KodaFrogg/videos

I am currently debating on what direction I should go for a new video. For context I make videos on 100% completing games, throughout each video I go through the game from achievement to achievement.
I recently had a thumbnail commissioned for my upcoming video on The Walking Dead Destinies. I like the direction/style this could push my video into.
However, I am unsure if I should go this route or stick to the style of thumbnails I have been doing.

for some extra context: I view my YouTube journey as a way to gain skills in video editing + my love for playing video games 100%.
If this is a good direction to go down thumbnail wise, I am capable/willing to commission further thumbnails every 2-4 weeks for a new video as thumbnails are an aspect I do not enjoy doing.

Included are the cartoon commissioned thumbnail and one I made up:

Title of the video for cartoon one I am not sure at the moment. For the thumbnail I created it would be something like "The Walking Dead Destinies Ruined Me" or something similar

[boreal mica]

You're thinking too hard about this. You can always change your thumbnails at any time. Keeping a consistent style isn't as important when you have no audience built yet, it's about expirementing to see what works and changing things to see what improves.

For what it's worth I think the one on the left looks significantly better

[wheat pawn]

Yea, I think so too on the thinking hard/ overthinking. I know over time I could become better at thumbnails, but I definitely would prefer to keep my focus on creating content/ editing. In some aspects I do like creating them, but when they do not have that great of a ctr it is tough. Thanks for the feedback