Which of these thumbnails do you think is the best?

[whole crypt]

Also, what would improvements should I make to it (if any)?

[thin needle]

I like the first one better than the others. I like the text "follow the line" in the red line. it captures my attention for sure.

The 2nd one is a bit confusing, I'm not sure what im looking at.

[whole crypt]

yeah i was thinking the same. What about the contrast? I've had people tell me they preferred it with contrast

[thin needle]

hmm i think in the contrast one the blue is very blue, it kind of takes my attention away from the "follow the line"

That could just be me though. I do think the contract on the red line in the 3rd one does pop so it looks like!

[whole crypt]

here's contrast but not on terraria side

vs full contrast

[heavy narwhal]

I like the contrast on the line itself but the background doesn't need it

[thin needle]

yeah i agree with this

[whole crypt]

the left side of the screen feels empty, and the character doesn't seem like the right thing to fill it. any thoughts/ ideas?

[rare bay]

Whats the title?

[whole crypt]

“I beat terraria in minecraft” or something similar

[rare bay]

What does the line have to do with this then?

[whole crypt]

it’s like terraria because it’s basically 2d to an extent. I’m not too set on the title and I can always change it

What would a better title be?

[heavy tiger]

maybe minecraft if it was played in 2D

idk

[whole crypt]

something like that might work