#vrchat-general-2

1 messages · Page 593 of 1

split plank
#

aka, too lazy :P

#

@safe prism wait what?

safe prism
#

idk how to explain it better

#

you remember the shitty per-app volume control windows has had since forever?

#

it's better now in windows 10 1803

split plank
#

yeah?

safe prism
#

same place, see if it solves your problem

bright harness
#

when vrchat will add link for a video or a music?

opaque hawk
#

So windows can run aggregate devices now?

split plank
#

hmm... so you say I should be able to kind of change the output of a program in there?

#

would be awesome actually

rigid crescent
#

You can already add video and music

bright harness
#

really?

#

how..

rigid crescent
#

For a long time

#

Add it to your world or watch a video player

split plank
#

yeah, I'm wondering the same, can't change a thing in there

bright harness
#

@rigid crescent how to do it tho

split plank
#

nonono, I'm not talking about world creation (even tho I'll be having a question about that topic soon xD) I'm talking about the output to my devices from the game itself

rigid crescent
#

Find a guide on world making and follow it is my guess.

split plank
#

yeah, but if it was about the creation of a world, I would have asked in the respective channel... it's more an user oriented problem here than a world issue ^^

#

at least on my side

bright harness
#

you can create a world ingame or you have to use a different program?

rigid crescent
#

Oh thats for the other dude

#

You use unity.

#

Google vrchat world creation, probably plenty of guides.

opaque hawk
#

ask people on this discord because world creation tutorials are constantly getting out of date

split plank
#

yep rayen, basically everything you upload yourself in VRC has to run through unity first ^^

bright harness
#

oh, ok i do have unity but i never used it

rigid crescent
#

Yeah basically gotta learn using a guide.

#

I've been meaning to make s world, but I'll probably just mash some mmd stages together.

#

E z

bright harness
#

do i have to make my own 3d models?

split plank
#

I'm currently trying to build my own world... it's fun, but also quite hard if you kind of want to make a thing perfect where you don't have any Idea on how to do it xD

bright harness
#

or use someone's else models : D

split plank
#

it you're talking about avatars: you can create your own avatars from scratch, if you know what you're doing, you can use MMD models (requires blender and knowledge there) or just use models from RANDOM WEBSITE HERE, where most of them you can just load into unity and upload

#

(hope that's correct)

#

creating one from scratch without knowledge is almost impossible xD

bright harness
#

woah! that is a lot of work. (i think i'm gonna finish my world in a 2 to 3 years)

split plank
#

for avatar creation from MMD there's a tutorial on youtube from the man, the one and only TUPPER himself, might want to check it out ^^

rigid crescent
#

That's Tupper' s video isn't it?

split plank
#

on world creation, there are a couple good ones as well from the community

#

Edit: Cough!

rigid crescent
#

Yeah if you mean the painfully long but extremely informative one

#

But even that's outdated, still has some relevancy though

#

I'd just find a more recent one honestly.

split plank
#

for the base knowledge it's enough

bright harness
#

ok, i'm off now, see ya

split plank
#

OR, you can just watch a VOD of shonzo on twitch, because it's basically what keeps him alive xD

#

good night rayen

rigid crescent
#

Lol that guy

vocal shard
#

@split plank btw that website shouldnt be mentionned here

bright harness
#

what website?

split plank
#

oh? sorry, I didn't say anything then... gonna replace it

rigid crescent
#

Love the VOD of him complaining about a technique being dumb, then doing it and realizing it works. Favorite.

vocal shard
#

gib vod

rigid crescent
#

10/10

split plank
#

kay, replaced it xD

rigid crescent
#

It's an oldie now, lemme see.

vocal shard
#

ty

split plank
#

didn't know about that honestly, thanks for letting me know ^^

vocal shard
#

a bot is supposed to delete messages that mention it

#

but doesnt work apparently

split plank
#

seems like it ^^ welp, I did bot's work in that case :P

rigid crescent
#

Oof it's gone, I think. Twitch mobile app isn't polite.

#

I'll check when I get home though. One is a clip and the other is a vod

vocal shard
#

arent VOD deleted after 40 days ?

split plank
#

well, I guess almost every stream he starts with a new avatar...

#

he doesn't say what exactly he's doing, but you have to take a close look on what happens, and the result of it ^^

vocal shard
#

he did it before

#

when he started

#

he said everything he did

bright harness
#

do i need unity to make avatars?

vocal shard
#

yes

bright harness
#

ok.

rigid crescent
#

You're better off watching tutorials than an experienced person making avatars on the fly, especially for the basics.

opaque hawk
#

The VRChat website has the version of unity you need

vocal shard
#

It would be nice to have my own custom avatar, perhaps even enough so to make one

#

But sadly people will just rip it, & use it themselves

#

that barely happens

#

if you are some big shots and get some sort of special effects

#

people dont care

bright harness
#

i never made a 3d model/object.... tanabae

split plank
#

I'm planning on creating one myself as soon as I have more time, together with finishing my map I have in mind

#

yep, rayen, I'm in a similar position, but it's kind of a leap of faith, just try it, you will fail, but you will learn ^^

rigid crescent
#

No one is gonna rip your model for use. They rip it to see people's dumb reactions to having their stolen asset made avatars ripped.

#

None of these mmd assets are ours, and that's what most avatars are. I doubt anyone wants your model lol

split plank
#

I guess they (I didn't assume a gender!) meant like ripping it off of game files, rather than off of other people

vocal shard
#

Using any preexisting or edited model (MMD or otherwise) and porting to VRChat doesn't make the model yours to protect 🤔

#

If they ripped your avatar from VRChat, they'd be ripping a rip, so...

rigid crescent
#

Yep, people done understand that

split plank
#

yeah, I guess so. (riping it from vrc would be hacking and banable, I guess)

bright harness
#

no one knows who made the avatar, so they don't know who to credit

rigid crescent
#

Yes they do.

vocal shard
#

Hell if they rip a model from VRChat, more than likely it's an inferior version due to polycount optimizations anyway 🙃

rigid crescent
#

Parts usually come from deviantart, the mmd community almost always credits.

vocal shard
#

Grab from original source: 48k polygons
Rip from VRChat: 28k polygons 🤷

bright harness
#

what if, you add watermark on your avatar! vrpill

split plank
#

if you really want to be original, you would need to start the whole thing from scrath, including rigging texturizing by hand, modelling, animations, emotes....

opaque hawk
#

“Credit 3DCG”

vocal shard
#

Yeah, what Mic_Sounders said. MMD community is notorious for having credits available and simply refusing to give credits were due

rigid crescent
#

Then you look like a tool for having a watermark

vocal shard
#

That's the funny part, 3DCG isn't a modeler.

split plank
#

Rayen, those watermarks only show who uploaded it, not who created it if we're being serious here

bright harness
#

just kidding XD

opaque hawk
#

It’s a porn game lol

vocal shard
#

I love the "credit to original owners" taglines.

rigid crescent
#

Lol

split plank
#

yeah, it's so descriptive ainnms xD

bright harness
#

and they never do it themselves

vocal shard
#

Essentially "I want to pretend that I'm giving credit so people will get off my case, but at the same time I want people to think I did most of the work"

opaque hawk
#

Maybe we can credit in our pedestal images

rigid crescent
#

The list or credits is typically long

#

Base, hair, various clothing creators

#

Jewelry, etc

#

Your average avatar would have at least 5 or 6 people minimum to credit.

vocal shard
#

Assuming the model is edited, yeah

split plank
#

I mean, the only credit I take for my own models is bassically the re-colouring of my hair and the work in gimp to redesign the clothes, but the model itself is the work from someone else

vocal shard
#

5-6 is manageable. When you start editing models from parts, you're looking at adding 2-6 more names more often than not

split plank
#

(that I'm grateful that they shared it)

rigid crescent
#

Yeah, my current is at least 6

#

Oh, also your textures

vocal shard
#

i made my model from like 8-9 parts

rigid crescent
#

Sometimes they don't go with the original model

split plank
#

don't forget som possible custom shader creators

rigid crescent
#

So you've got your model meshes and your textures and textures. Credits aren't really feasible. I'm not against us judt continually ripping models from DA, but being worried about your stolen, unoriginal "work" being stolen is dumb

vocal shard
#

it's more the shaders and animations that you make

split plank
#

yep..

#

I mean if you're actually doing stuff yourself, then you can be worried about it being stolen, but honestly, most of the work most of the people do is change colors, and add a small thing to a dome model, so the only ones who should be worried about stealing are the ones who upload it for usage ^^

vocal shard
#

In some cases the credits are:
Base (typically from a game)
Eye Texture (sometimes edited/replaced)
Outfit (assuming it's not in 2 or more parts, this is being generous)
Accessory (typically at least 1-2)
Hair (obviously 1 or recolored from original model)
Shoes (if not included in outfit/base)
Physics (not always provided)
Facials (typically part of the base, but generally it's provided from a separate person)
Rigging (if it's a game rip, it's more than likely re-rigged manually)

#

This doesn't even include alternative styles/further editing.

split plank
#

exactly ainn

vocal shard
#
  • Some MMD models have modified/replaced hair textures.
split plank
#

but in the end we shouldn't really be complaining, most of us are using precreated stuff ^^

vocal shard
#

I'm gonna call this the "average credits list". It can be a lot more for a HQ model or less if the model is just a recolor of an existing character.

split plank
#

actually, if we wanted to be fair, we should create like a gesture where we can hold a paper with all the credits that respective model has

vocal shard
#

if all the parts that you used are heavily modified that nobody could even recognize the originals, can i complain if someone steal it ?

split plank
#

well, you could only say that it's based on ideas from ........

#

xD

opaque hawk
#

On this subject. Is there a VRChat community dedicated to creating model parts and accessories for VRChat avatar creators?

vocal shard
#

i dont think so

#

maybe on the japanese side

#

Rooster Teeth (at first, unknowingly) used heavily modified TDA models and everyone complained, but it depends on your audience.

split plank
#

aka, there might be, but I'm unsure due to the community being active but not extremely big

vocal shard
#

who the fuck is rooster teeth ?

#

The company behind RWBY

opaque hawk
#

And Red vs blue

vocal shard
#

A lot these days

split plank
#

well, let's be honest, every model by now is a customized version of a base model somewhere...

rigid crescent
#

Not true

opaque hawk
#

Bases are a great thing to work from, and they offer lots of flexibility.

vocal shard
#

Some bases are free to use

rigid crescent
#

There's streamers with actual custom models, as well as non streamers.

#

Full custom.

opaque hawk
#

I’ve gotten lots of mileage off of 1 tda base

split plank
#

okay, then let's go with most of the models

vocal shard
#

Then there's Tda, which explicitly says not to use it outside of MMD. But, that went out the window a long time ago. Even Crypton Future Media (the company that has the most say behind the Tda license aside from Tda himself) has used the Tda model outside of MMD, soo.....

#

Most people use Tda.

split plank
#

but in creation of a game you create like a base male and base female model, or even only one androgyneous model and go from there for your characters

vocal shard
#

I don't know if VRC users are aware, but most of the MMD community uses Tda and VRC largely borrows from MMD practices

rigid crescent
#

I've used a Rin base for a while, but I've swapped to using a Luka head on various bases.

#

Yeah, that's one thing I think Tupper mentions in his video.

#

I've seen plenty of cute full custom robots, they're usually the easiest to make since you can get away with more sharp geometry, but there's some good full customs out there.

split plank
#

I actually take a look at the terms of the uploader before using it (even if I have to translate it most of the times first to understand)

rigid crescent
#

I mean i look at it, I just ignore it lol

split plank
#

because if they don't want it to be used in vrc, you shall not use it in vrc.

vocal shard
#

I have a commercial use license for a specific base model.

#

But you don't need a commercial use license to use it, only if you plan on monetizing it somewhere.

#

But for all intents and purposes, I "own my copy" of the model.

split plank
#

nah, I actually would have liked to use a lot of models i vrc, but yeah, they explicitly said "not for VRC" so I went by it ^^

rigid crescent
#

Yeah I ignore that, ususlly they don't have the full rights to say that anyway.

#

I doubt any part owner's want it uploaded to vrc, but the person mashing them together more often than not has no right to request that

split plank
#

well ainn, if I would ever get to a point where I COULD use a model comercially, I would learn how to build one myself

#

but then again, the question is, as soon as you're streaming, you're technically using an avatar comercially

rigid crescent
#

It seems fun to learn, I plan on learning to model a few parts of my own

fervent scroll
#

A good place to start is trying to build missing mesh from models

#

atleast it was for me

rigid crescent
#

I dont think thats true, because there would be more legal issues with streaming any gsme.

split plank
#

@rigid crescent I actually know people who create that stuff by hand, and they don't want it in vrc, so yeah, even if it's not sure, I respect it ^^

rigid crescent
#

Especially people with face camd that wear brand logos they're not sponsored by

split plank
#

well, just go like 2 years back, where nintendo basically took everyone to courst who dared to stream their games xD

vocal shard
#

http://fav.me/d9geixi This is the one. Free to use anywhere for any purpose (except for NSFW stuff). They commissioned someone to create the base and released it because of all the license restrictions Tda actually has. For example, Tda models being illegally ported to VRChat but not being enforced. It's not exactly a big problem these days, but it's not a bad idea to be legally protected and to look more unique. Legally speaking, this is the ideal MMD model base. There's also a reasonable variety of head/face edits that are ALSO available for free.

elfin cloak
#

i have seriouse probelm with web payer in every streaming live and non live youtube world for 7 months of playing...from time to time i can wach and isten in some of vrchat updates but that is like a wawe after wawe it all goes in circle i strongly beliece that is not the case of my W7 64 SP1 (UPDATED) case and i try literally everything to download youtube dll,clear cache and email to vrchat support and nothing happen the screen still stays in white and without any sound,but on some world i can copy paste youtube links and it works in limited times but if i try to wach more it repeats the old url and it want accept new youtube url. why is that happen and can someone help me somehow with this problem please

split plank
#

oh wow ainn, that's acutally an awesome post that would need to get pinned ^^ if I'd search for a nice female model, I'd use it ^^

vocal shard
#

I don't wanna flood the chat, but searching for "MissMMDBase Face" will pull up all the results

split plank
#

so thanks ^^

vocal shard
#

There's also a male body edit floating around on DeviantART too.

#

It follows the same terms as the rest of the original model.

#

Aka free to use

split plank
#

wait, I actually do, starting next week... xD so I will have to look at it, and pay them the credits xD so thanks for the link ^^

#

honestly, if they put up the work for something awesome, they should get payed for it

vocal shard
#

I'm considering becoming a Vtuber after I get a full body VR setup up and running. VRChat is PROBABLY the engine I'm going to be using and making content about. I plan to do this on a separate channel than the ones on my profile to keep things tidy/organized.

#

Honestly, that I can thank VRChat for. VRChat + VTuber is the perfect mix.

split plank
#

like a vrc streamer who puts up a huge amount of work to create an awesome RP thingie ^^

vocal shard
#

Hayl yeah.

split plank
#

I mean, it's basically the same as having a TV show in the end

vocal shard
#

That and VRChat Machinima

median basalt
#

Just don't delude yourself into thinking you're a "content creator" by walking around public instances with a camera on

#

Lol

vocal shard
#

VRChat Machinima is so ideal, that I'm shocked that I don't see a lot of it

#

But content creators walk around public areas with cameras all the time.

#

What do you mean?

rigid crescent
#

In gonna do a parody of those tiktok videos, but it's a normie meme so I dont expect many people to get it lol

#

You're not creating content you're just streaming it at that point lol

vocal shard
#

How to become a content creator without a camera.

split plank
#

vrc rp isn't that far away from free tv, you have someone who creates the mask (model) you have someone who creates the story, and all the actors playing it, as well holding the camera at the same time... ^^

median basalt
#

IMO you're not a "content creator" if you just watch other people's content and film it.

vocal shard
#

Streaming IS content creation 🤔

median basalt
#

Lol.

rigid crescent
#

Content creators, to me, are people who participate and write RPs, events, etc

#

Lol

median basalt
#

I've seen a streamer perform comedy routines in public. That's content creation.

vocal shard
#

Videos = Content.

#

If you create videos...

median basalt
#

I've seen writers hold massive Danganronpa murder mysteries

vocal shard
#

1 + 1 = 2....

rigid crescent
#

No, you're literally just a broadcaster if you're just walking around with a camera

split plank
#

don't worry Rokk, I would never think that.... but honestly, you create conted, if wanted or not, soooo xD

vocal shard
#

What do you think that means?

median basalt
#

Watching a stormtrooper toucan pull a lightsaber out at you isn't creating content

split plank
#

you're a content creator, even if no one wants it xD

rigid crescent
#

You're a broadcaster at best if you're just filming people and profiting from it

median basalt
#

Yep

#

Or as our friend group refers to them as: a leech

rigid crescent
#

I mean nothing against people who do it, they found a market and got their money.

#

But its not content creation

vocal shard
#

Content creation is the contribution of information to any media and most especially to digital media for an end-user/audience in specific contexts.[1] Content is "something that is to be expressed through some medium, as speech, writing or any of various arts"[2] for self-expression, distribution, marketing and/or publication. Typical forms of content creation include maintaining and updating web sites, blogging, photography, videography, online commentary, the maintenance of social media accounts, and editing and distribution of digital media. A Pew survey described content creation as the creation of "the material people contribute to the online world."

I fail to see how VRChat Streamers aren't content creators.

median basalt
#

tl;dr

rigid crescent
#

Some are.

vocal shard
#

I'll give some slack, that it's not usually elaborate, but look at Vloggers.

#

Same deal.

rigid crescent
#

So if I go around filming street fights I'm s content creator? Lol

split plank
#

actually, we are now at a point where people on youtube and twitch create better contend than hollywood could ever do. maybe not animation wise, but surely story wise

vocal shard
#

Technically yeah.

median basalt
#

A friend of mine hosts a VR podcast that I sometimes co-host or appear as guest on. That's content creation. Filming other people isn't content creation IMO

vocal shard
#

Look at the definition lol

fervent scroll
vocal shard
#

Content creation is the contribution of information to any media and most especially to digital media for an end-user/audience in specific contexts.

rigid crescent
#

Vlogging is content creation. That's not the same as sitting in publics and watching others be funny.

median basalt
#

If your only claim to fame as "content creator" is watching other people have fun, then you'll just fall into the same endless void as any other dead-end VRC streamer.

safe prism
#

filming other people and making it mildly entertaining or thoughtful is content creation

vocal shard
#

Gee, I wonder if YouTube videos are digital media 🤔

#

or livestreams

safe prism
#

it's just first person

median basalt
#

Even if you're technically a content creator by any definition, that doesn't mean people will be interested, and that won't raise people's opinions of you either

safe prism
#

do gopro videos not count as content

vocal shard
#

Literally what okano is saying

rigid crescent
#

Depends on the type

safe prism
#

just because it's content doesn't mean it's good :D

median basalt
#

I can already tell you're gonna be one of those types of streamers

vocal shard
#

Being a different medium doesn't mean it's not a medium to begin with.

rigid crescent
#

Yep.

vocal shard
#

I hold myself to a standard, so I'm not gonna be lazy about making content.

#

Running around with a camera is considerably lazy if you don't have something planned out. Some people have a plan with no script, and others have a script with a flexible plan. Me? Script + Plan, please.

split plank
#

yeah rokk, only taking other peoples work and basically talking over it isn't really work, but if you're actually doing something in a scene, if you planned it out or not, is creating that situation, therefore you're creating content

#

react videos arent content creation IMO, they're like content recycling

vocal shard
#

As much as I don't like it personally, WorldStarHipHop is a content creator by definition.

safe prism
#

platform

vocal shard
#

It's definitely not my cup of tea, but a definition is what it is.

#

I can agree with that, vect9r

#

I don't mind for the "commentator community" or the "react community".

rigid crescent
#

So you're going for the "well TECHNICALLY I'm a content creator because of the definition of content creator despite not actually creating resl content" route? Lol

vocal shard
#

I think they're a waste of bandwidth and server space, but meh.

safe prism
#

gonna say, if you wanna do something like this, just go do it.

#

make compelling content

#

nothing is stopping you

vocal shard
#

What's technical about it?

#

It's very literal.

#

And, define "real content".

#

Gamers create "real content" using fake videogame worlds/engines.

#

Look at Game Grumps.

fervent scroll
#

Seeking the opinions for your own justification will probably just leave you in a loop here forever

rigid crescent
#

Content you actually were involved with creating.

vocal shard
#

They're a great example of content creators.

rigid crescent
#

Yes, game grumps are comedians.

vocal shard
#

They hold themselves to a standard.

rigid crescent
#

Lol a standard

vocal shard
#

That's what makes them worth watching. If Game Grumps was as unplanned as most VRChat videos, nobody would give a fuck.

safe prism
#

not true

rigid crescent
#

They're usually unplanned. They sit and play a game and be funny...

#

What's planned abouy that

safe prism
#

^

#

also see the current variety streamer tops

#

like

#

they create compelling content from nothing

rigid crescent
#

And how are rape jokes and racist caricatures a high standard? Keep in mind I uses to love watching gsme grumps and thought those jokes were hilarious, but that's not s very high standard

vocal shard
#

I never said it was a high standard.

#

I don't even like them myself xd

rigid crescent
#

So you includes that sentence for no reason.

vocal shard
#

But they're definitely content creators.

rigid crescent
#

Everyone holds themselves to a standard. Their own standard.

vocal shard
#

^

safe prism
#

i don't understand where this is going

vocal shard
#

Markiplier has a standard.

fervent scroll
#

yeah same

safe prism
#

go make stuff

fervent scroll
#

its fun to watch though

rigid crescent
#

That's just superfluous to mention it unless you mean a specific type lol

vocal shard
#

PewDewPie has a different standard.

safe prism
#

go make stuff

vocal shard
#

Fred Figglehorn had a standard.

safe prism
#

talking about others making stuff isn't making stuff

rigid crescent
#

Ok so why say they have a standard as if it means something when everyone has a standard lol

vocal shard
#

I don't even like these guys

#

but I can still vouch for what they are.

#

No "technical" definitions needed.

rigid crescent
#

They're different than what we're talking about by far.

vocal shard
#

They're content creators.

rigid crescent
#

There are streamers that just watch other people be funny.

safe prism
#

why does this label matter

vocal shard
#

But I'm not sure you understand WHY they're content creators.

fervent scroll
#

why are you trying to push this so hard lol

#

your talking in circles.

vocal shard
#

Typical VRChat videos aren't the highest caliber stuff, but is it stuff?

#

You get a Standard *!*And you get a Standard *!*Everybody gets a Standard !!!

rigid crescent
#

Because of a poorly labeled definition, yes.

vocal shard
#

A definition is what it is.

rigid crescent
#

They are content creators, by definition of the phrase. They do not actuslly create content.

vocal shard
#

If you don't like it, take that up with the rest of the internet. Go sign a petition or something lmao

rigid crescent
#

So what do I call them? Content creators that don't create content? Lol

safe prism
#

i'm a content creator but i don't care about that title. i'm a shoutcaster sometimes, a chill creative streamer other times. there's not a lot of like.. reason to be under the umbrella unless you're just really lazy. everyone can be one. not everyone can make compelling content. go make compelling content.

vocal shard
#

Remind me who "them" is again 🤔

fervent scroll
#

2018 folks

vocal shard
#

They are more like advertisers and Critics than content creators...

fervent scroll
#

👏

rigid crescent
#

Off the top I'd my head, roflgator unless that's changed.

vocal shard
#

How can someone be a content creator if they don't create content?

#

They are content creators, by definition of the phrase. They do not actuslly create content.
How is this even possible lmao

rigid crescent
#

Because by definition they are content creators due to uploading videos.

#

But they did not create actual content.

vocal shard
#

Okay, define "actual content".

#

So (Free) Advertisers, Critics, Real-time Broadcasters and Reporters count as content creators 🤔

#

I'll hear this.

rigid crescent
#

Creating something. Not just recording someone do something.

vocal shard
#

Also... We might be getting ruuubwhipped

fervent scroll
#

are these facts or personal views?

vocal shard
#

I guess the News isn't content creation either.

rigid crescent
#

If I sit in a pug and watch people rp, im not creating content. I'm just broadcasting someone's else's.

vocal shard
#

Literally what Hibby said

#

CNN, BBC, Fox News aren't content creators according to Mic

#

ok

rigid crescent
#

Uhh the news isn't the same either. Reporters are involved.

#

They report on events correct? They're involved.

vocal shard
#

But they're "just broadcasting someone elses"

rigid crescent
#

They don't just sit and point the camera at a building on fire.

vocal shard
#

Reporters talk and add context to the footage, yes?

rigid crescent
#

They report on the cause, victims, etc.

#

So they're involved, right?

vocal shard
#

Right.

rigid crescent
#

Ok, so that's not what I'm talking about lol

vocal shard
#

So what's the difference between a Reporter talking about a situation and a VRChat user doing the same exact thing?

fervent scroll
#

im actually curious to see how this ends

vocal shard
#

basically why I hate the term content creator for most vrchat YouTubers/streamers

If they were acting out things, Makin skits and such, yeah... But funny clip videos... Not really

#

I mean, I understand what he's saying, and I'm open to a new insight.

#

Nothing bad with that, just the name

median basalt
#

You're not open to new insight lol

#

Your attitude tells me as much

vocal shard
#

Personally, I'm only okay with the title "Content Creator" because I make music and animations. It's a labor of love there, but I see VRChat as a lazy way out.

#

As is.

#

I hope to change that, even

#

Could we just call YouTubers, Streamers, News etc Content sharer's or something like that

#

Okay Rokk, feel free to change my mind.

median basalt
#

A lot of streamers sit in the Pug and watch other people do funny stuff, which is a major reason I don't like streamers

vocal shard
#

Do explain, Rokk. 🍿

rigid crescent
#

Or just call them youtubers and streamers lol

median basalt
#

I already did

#

Re-read my messages because I'm not gonna repeat them

vocal shard
#

I agree with that.

rigid crescent
#

That's pretty self explanatory

vocal shard
#

I don't watch streamers for the same reason.

#

Same

median basalt
#

I also remember an instance where I was just hanging with friends

#

And then this streamer came in and screamed "OMG THAT WAS SO FUNNY CAN YOU DO IT AGAIN FOR MY STREAM?!?!?!"

rigid crescent
#

Me being funny is content. I created the content by being funny.

vocal shard
#

I dont know who any streamers are really... Lol

rigid crescent
#

You just recorded and distributed it

median basalt
#

And basically pulled half of us away into a new instance

vocal shard
#

Trendy YouTubers tend to do that as well, so I'm pretty non-mainstream.

rigid crescent
#

Sounds like roflgator

#

He's done that to some friends

median basalt
#

Never heard of him

vocal shard
#

Well, if I ever see that name, I'll stay away

rigid crescent
#

He's one thata been shoved in my face sadly

vocal shard
#

Haven't heard of them either

fervent scroll
vocal shard
#

What the heckken is that emoji

fervent scroll
#

is it over?

vocal shard
#

Jamie, what is that thing

#

,,,,,⟨\ /⟩
(っOω0)っ

#

wny one wanna play vrchat? dm meh

#

owo wat's this?

#

O.o mine?

#

@vocal shard one of the models of his ingame avatar...

#

OHHHH now I see it

median basalt
#

I have like two friends that are friends with Jameskii, a lot of times when I try to join on them I just get kicked to a new empty instance because I hit the instance's hard cap

#

Which would mean 40 people in the Pug

vocal shard
#

It just looked like imitation Kanji from the icon

#

Oof

median basalt
#

40 people in any instance sounds like low framerate hell tbh

fervent scroll
#

Well guess its over, i was fully invested in some kinda climatic ending

#

what a let down.

#

now I'll never know what real content is.

vocal shard
#

🤔

#

PLOT TWIST: FAKE NEWS = CONTENT CREATION

#

jk

#

Ainn... On what are you viewing this discord server right now 🤔

#

Discord PTB on Desktop. I'm zoomed out slightly though

#

That's Purposely Misinformed Content Sharing=Fake News

#

That zoom-out must be causing some kind of blur

#

It could be my monitor

#

But tf do I know with my random assumptions...

#

It could be caused by anything

#

I'm using a TV as a monitor

#

Because I don't feel like forking out for a new "HD Display" when my "HD TV" does almost the same thing and I already own it

#

Only if I got a bigger display would I even bother

#

Huh... Neat

#

Soo... You are writing with a TV remote right now*?*

#

I'll take that silence as a no

rigid crescent
#

i used to use my TV when I was too cheap to buy a monitor, that was a while bback though

#

i really only used my computer to play League and watch anime back then though, so it was honestly fine

vocal shard
#

I have a desktop plugged into my TV via HDMI

#

I was posting in the avatars-mmd chat about the base I mentioned earlier

opaque hawk
#

Thanks for sharing Ainn

jolly pelican
#

anyone know what ever happened to playmaker?

median basalt
#

Not happening

#

Scrapped

#

Replaced with a free system called Udon in the future

jolly pelican
#

i see

#

Is there any documentation on how to make a death match system similar to capture the flag for a vrchat world? I understand the person who made the Murder! map has somehow implemented death, guns and the like..

rigid crescent
#

probably the same way CTF does it I would imagine

#

except without respawning into the gun room

#

i think there was a guide on how to do a CTF style map, but i cant seem to find it now

#

rofl that was another game my bad

vocal shard
#

Oooooh that would be a dream

#

Imagine a dense forest with places to hide, multiple paths to check for sneaky players, a few chokepoints and terrain... Could make for an awesome map. Of course, a dense forest might not be needed lol

idle elm
#

42

indigo fern
#

🤔

plush osprey
#

How many hours do u have in the game?

opaque hawk
#

350 I think

fervent scroll
#

wait playmaker was scrapped?

median basalt
#

Yes

vocal shard
#

the group of world builders who were testing it decided it sucks

fervent scroll
#

Oh

#

well thats a bummer

vocal shard
#

I think it's a wise move to make a much more powerful vrc oriented visual scripting system

fervent scroll
#

Is that whats happening?

vocal shard
#

yes, it's a node based editor that gives you much more exposed unity components and logic options

quaint hill
#

Hey, quick question for all my VR chat streamers out there who have oculus

I’m trying to set up the first person stream window,, it’s just that the picture is very zoomed up… What can I do to fix it?

It’s not the stream camera I need help with, it’s the actual point of view perspective of the window itself… It’s all zoomed in, what do I do?
.
pls @ me xD

median basalt
#

World reviews are inconsistent as always

#

There's still "lag-free worlds" going public

indigo fern
rigid crescent
#

at least we keep seeing this gem "Some avatars are optimized, but others have an abusive amount of dynamic bones, materials, and meshes. Please optimize the remainder."

#

"Avatars have a large number of materials and a huge amount of Dynamic Bones. Very unoptimized. Please atlas before exporting for use in VRChat, and limit your use of Dynamic Bones to 30-50 transforms maximum. Additionally, do not use Dynamic Bone colliders (and if you do, limit them to 1 maximum)"

#

ooooh fuck

#

just flat out "no colliders pls"

opaque hawk
#

Wait how can I touch my ears then?

rigid crescent
#

Maybe they just don't want them on public world avatars?

#

not sure

opaque hawk
#

Like I have that on public world avatars

rigid crescent
#

I guess it makes sense, less people will go through the effort of doing it themselves vs grabbing a world one, but there's also the "Avatars you want for vr" world that has touchable stuff

#

maybe they're working on stopping new ones and reviewing old worlds

opaque hawk
#

Maybe

rigid crescent
#

"10/18/2018 6:47:40 FRIEND GROUP BOX LAG FREE
Performance Issue
World is not lag-free."

opaque hawk
#

I’ll keep doing what I’m doing. I don’t think I’m the reason the rule was made, but Ill stop if I’m asked

#

Lol mic

rigid crescent
#

I doubt it was any one person, colliders just cause a lot of issues

opaque hawk
#

Thank goodness for the great world creators here. They have always been incredibly helpful

verbal belfry
#

!cache

opaque hawk
#

!cleancache

floral flaxBOT
#

You can clean cache by deleting everything within C:\Users\%Username%\AppData\LocalLow\VRChat\vrchat apart from output_log.txt and config.json if you have them

rigid crescent
#

217
10/17/2018 16:14:37 ~ Most Optimized World In VRChat ~ Other doesn't look like most optimized world in vrchat

opaque hawk
#

As soon as you use real-time lighting you already forfeited the title of lag free

sterile drift
#

Lightmap textures though 👌

opaque hawk
#

I joke, but there have been exceptions

sterile drift
#

How to make non-laggy realtime light

opaque hawk
#

If you are making a world feel free to use real-time lighting early in development. Just don’t publish with it

sterile drift
#

@rigid crescent Send me the documentation for these

#

I wanna see this sass the devs are denying these worlds with lol

opaque hawk
#

It should be pined in worlds

sterile drift
#

I'll look there then

opaque hawk
#

Look for the public request doc

rigid crescent
#

now we just have to start yeeting that world with the full body avatars people use to dance with that has cloth hair, skirts, and colliders on the legs and probably head

#

all lag will disappear overnight

sterile drift
#

lol

rigid crescent
#

"don't have any colliders" sets a scary precedent for world declining though, not that I mind since I don't even use them on my personal avatar any more

median basalt
#

Yeah, that fullbody avatar world gives me aids

#

So much cloth and dynamic bone

#

FPS always drops when I'm with those people

rigid crescent
#

I genuinely hope they just get rid of it, they're just too popular for how unoptimized they are and need to be redone

sterile drift
#

I barely use Dynamic Bones at all, though even if I do, it's usually for something really small, and even then I don't really put colliders on anything.

#

I just have the script at the ready if I so need it.

opaque hawk
#

I use it a lot. I really don’t like having static hair and tails. Specifically hair longer than shoulder length

sterile drift
#

Wait

#

Hold on

#

Lemme delete those

#

Forgot about the rule

#

lol

opaque hawk
#

Lol

sterile drift
#

But yea, they're optimized for use for the system they're on

#

LOL

#

But anyway

opaque hawk
#

We are in the same boat no worries

sterile drift
#

MMD/PMX models do not really follow the rule of optimization

#

They're meant for animation

#

Not for use in a game

rigid crescent
#

yeah, they're just meant to be rendered in mmd

#

they're fairly easy to optimize though

sterile drift
#

Yea but

#

Think of how few people actually DO optimize their models in VRC

#

I'm not saying I don't fall in the same boat

rotund mountain
#

Well optimizing is only a good thing when you have a big world. It's not a problem to wear an unoptimized avatar if you are only 2 or 3 in a world.

opaque hawk
#

Yes, I literally just optimized a part from DeviantArt and reposted it on DeviantArt with 1/12 the polys

sterile drift
#

lol

rigid crescent
#

That's the issue with public world avatars not being optimized imo

opaque hawk
#

I see that part literally every time I’m on VRChat

rigid crescent
#

it's not just 2 or 3 people in a world since dozens are getting them from the popular worlds

sterile drift
#

Yea

rigid crescent
#

popular worlds are the worst offenders, not because they're worse than everyone else, but because the most popular ones are usually really bad

median basalt
#

I always make extra sure that my public avatars are optimized

rigid crescent
#

and also have a ton of people using it

median basalt
#

Kinda pains me that people aren't taking responsibility for the worlds they put out

#

And uploading stuff with 40+ materials

sterile drift
#

Yea I know you're really good with that Rokk

opaque hawk
#

So here comes the million dollar question. What can we do to change that?

median basalt
#

I'm not even that great at optimizing, I just atlas

rigid crescent
#

shut down more worlds duh

median basalt
#

Dynamic bone is something I gotta work on

#

Yep

#

Just start yeeting worlds that are unoptimized.

#

Don't just warn them.

sterile drift
#

^

#

Just throw them out

rigid crescent
#

It would help to have more guides on importing even a basic MMD and how and why you should optimize, not just "its laggy"

sterile drift
#

"Oh unoptimized avatars? Ye'r gone."

rigid crescent
#

or "yeah just do it"

#

but that's not really anyone's job

median basalt
#

The SDK needs to show material and dynamic bone counts

#

And should start warning about them too

#

My first avatar was 117 meshes, the SDK told me it was fine because it's only 6k polys.

sterile drift
#

Yea

opaque hawk
#

Upvote my canny post on that matter

rigid crescent
#

lol

sterile drift
#

ROKK WHAT

median basalt
#

Yeah

indigo fern
median basalt
#

It was an Ace Attorney game rip

vocal shard
#

jesus why?

median basalt
#

Every single loose part was a separate mesh, and then twice that since I also wanted the mesh outlines.

vocal shard
#

that goes against every beginner tutorial

median basalt
#

Nobody ever told me I was doing anything wrong

#

There were only like 7 materials

vocal shard
#

everybody says you should join into one body mesh

median basalt
#

Well, the SDK didn't

vocal shard
#

you knew that was cancer lol

median basalt
#

And I wasn't doing MMD's so Tupper's tutorial didn't help

sterile drift
#

lol

vocal shard
#

117 ...

sterile drift
#

Also my internet's trash rn

vocal shard
#

hats off sir 😊

rigid crescent
#

It's a good vid to watch but you cant assume everyone has

sterile drift
#

All of a sudden

median basalt
#

I mean roll eyes all you want

#

If you're a beginner and porting a random model

#

You're not gonna port a model using a tutorial that says "how to get MMD into VRC"

rigid crescent
#

I see "JOIN YOUR MESHES!111!!" but never the importance of doing it. Why should I bother? does it really cause lag? how? why?

sterile drift
#

Drawcalls

median basalt
#

Mesh renderers have some extra overhead

rigid crescent
#

I personally know that.

median basalt
#

But the real bad thing happens when you have the same material spread across multiple meshes

warm turtle
#

mesh*materials= drawcalls

median basalt
#

I only had 6 unique materials

#

But because they were spread over 117 meshes, that was 117 drawcalls

sterile drift
#

Yep

vocal shard
#

it's not just the drawcalls, it's a ton of stuff under the hood

idle elm
#

That's more than that back storage room you hate.

indigo fern
vocal shard
#

lol

sterile drift
#

I remember when I first imported a Xenoblade 1 model that I didn't join the meshes

rigid crescent
#

oh god nintendo models

sterile drift
#

It was like 32 or something

rigid crescent
#

all the meshes

median basalt
#

Yeah, mine was a 3DS model as well

#

I didn't know much about optimization back then

#

Of course, I did the right thing and fixed it

#

When I learned about it

#

The SDK needs to educate people on what is and isn't optimized

median basalt
#

Especially with avatars that are gonna be roaming around in almost every world

rigid crescent
#

wow that's a very specific meme

median basalt
#

You can leave a laggy world and never bother with it again

sterile drift
#

@rigid crescent I think the fact that it's the way the models were yoinked that separated the material points to separate meshes.

median basalt
#

@vocal shard lmao

rigid crescent
#

yeah a lot of ripped models are like that from what I've seen

#

unless someone bothered to join it before hosting it

sterile drift
#

I mean I do that all the time

#

I actually care about people's framerate

median basalt
#

Actually I'm pretty sure those 117 drawcalls would only get way worse in the realtime lighting

opaque hawk
#

No I come to expect if I see blurry textures, I know it’s optimized

median basalt
#

That's my main gripe with realtime/mixed lights in worlds, people use them and then blame the avatars

opaque hawk
#

On clearly mmd stuff

sterile drift
#

I BLAME THE AVATARS

median basalt
#

Blurry textures are a thing of the past with the new atlasing tools

sterile drift
#

NOT MY OWN WORLD

median basalt
#

@sterile drift that's true in your case

sterile drift
#

Wait what?

median basalt
#

Since your world can't be that many drawcalls

sterile drift
#

Ehh it isn't

rigid crescent
#

I genuinely see no point in realtime lighting in worlds meant to have a bunch of people in them

median basalt
#

Yeah, same

sterile drift
#

Actually rokk

opaque hawk
#

No because unity still brings it down to 2k

sterile drift
#

Lemme show you al lthe materials

#

You'll have a riot

rigid crescent
#

Horror maps, sure. They're usually meant for small groups

median basalt
#

@opaque hawk unless you set it to import higher which most people do

rigid crescent
#

but doesn't the Murder map have it?

warm turtle
#

because its stupidly hard to bake massive worlds

median basalt
#

Yes

vocal shard
#

dynamic bones scripts on each bone, dynamic bone colliders on each finger 😝

rigid crescent
#

and it has a 10 player cap, though plenty more than that play sometimes

median basalt
#

Maps like murder somehow get all the laggy issues

warm turtle
#

actually I don't understand why murder isn't baked

median basalt
#

If you're making a hangout with 20+ people you shouldn't be using realtime or mixed at all IMO

#

@warm turtle probably laziness or lack of knowledge

rigid crescent
#

Like, what's the thought process? What makes a person use real time lighting?

median basalt
#

Usually they just don't know about baked

rigid crescent
#

It has to be lack of knowledge, there's no reason you'd want your map to be laggy.

median basalt
#

I think murder could be a lot more fun if at least the environment was baked

#

Baked lighting also looks far better

warm turtle
#

atmosphere and a bunch of other factors

rigid crescent
#

They knew enough to make that map, which seems pretty complicated to be honest, it's odd that this was overlooked

warm turtle
#

mixed lighting works sort of as well

#

really depends

vocal shard
#

you're gonna want realtime shadows though

median basalt
#

Mixed lights can work well if used responsibly

warm turtle
#

it really depends at the end of the day

#

for the case of murder, baked would have worked well

#

or

vocal shard
#

just don't use realtime GI, up to 8 realtime lights can be fine

warm turtle
#

he just didn't want his pc stuck for 6hrs

#

or maybe 3

#

or unable to

opaque hawk
#

You want at least 1 mixed light. Everything else can bake

rigid crescent
#

man I'll bake it for him smh

warm turtle
#

cause baking is a damn pain sometimes

#

actually its a lot of the times

rigid crescent
#

I'd leave my PC on overnight and bake it for him and send it back, e z

opaque hawk
#

I can confirm that baking sucks

median basalt
#

Baking didn't take that long for me but my world is simple

#

If you have tons of objects it'll take a while

opaque hawk
#

Though once I found out that some assets I bought had .01 real-time emission on by default. My baking time shrunk

vocal shard
#

How does somebody get demoted in vrchat from a trusted user to a known user

rigid crescent
#

ranks fluctuate

vocal shard
#

Ok ok thx

drowsy tulip
#

Can't seem to upload an avatar right now, anyone else?

sterile drift
#

@drowsy tulip Were you able to upload avatars before?

drowsy tulip
#

Yep

sterile drift
#

Haven't tried uploading anything as of late at the moment

drowsy tulip
#

Asset bundle upload failed

true sky
#

only thing is retry to submit the avatar again

tall ingot
#

Has anybody who plays this game regularly used more than one vr system?

vocal shard
#

Meaning, just having experience using different ones?

tall ingot
#

Yes

vocal shard
#

I've use the oculus rift, and windows mixed reality

opaque hawk
#

I’ve tried just about everything through GDC and other tradeshows

tall ingot
#

Lately I guess there was an update to oculus with that dash thing and I had thought that I switched to beta and for some reason I can switch back. I only did beta so I can switch off the grid in the guardian system walls. But in beta i feel like my computer runs slower with vrchat running as well. I

#

Will talk later; battery low

lucid jay
#

So i have a problem. i am stuck at 10frames in VR and Desktop mode

#

its all other games are fine its just VRChat

#

and i have tried everything.

lime umbra
#

Does your avatar have a lot of particles or a high texture?

lucid jay
#

Nope. its just VRchat.

tall ingot
#

Your frames go low too? Lately vrchat has been running rougher for me lately. And i wasn't sure if it was oculus or perhaps there was another update to the social app

lucid jay
#

im just stuck at 10FPS

#

been like this for a whole week

ruby needle
#

are your drivers up to date? cirThink

lucid jay
#

Yes.

tall ingot
#

I was in a midnight moonlit house world and even after i turned off thr mirror and stayed on the roof where at first I had decent frames my framerate will just gradually lower until it's unbearable; I could hardly sign; I couldn't tell if anybody could see what I was doing

lucid jay
#

i have more then a good computer to run it. even though it runs on a single core

ruby needle
#

It does not run on a single core. 😃

vocal shard
#

^

tall ingot
#

All these problems got me wonderinf if it would be any different if I had a vive instead; I hear that when using vive only steam vr and whatever game youre running is on the task bar

neon flume
#

The vive in general has less overhead. The lighthouse method of tracking require less computation than Oculus's IR cameras. I don't know what the impact of core 2.0 itself is though, I've been running the beta since I got my rift.

ruby needle
#

im not sure if it is less computative generally but with the vive the hardware does track it self and basically send just the coordinate data, while with oculus the pc does the calcualtions.
you could just as well make that via hardware but... well cirPrise

#

Correct me if im wrong cirThink

sterile drift
#

VRChat does not run on a single core. Honestly how this misinformation spread is beyond me, but it really doesn't.

ruby needle
#

people tentd to asmune because one thing is A that the other is B

#

for example: The loading screen that says Dont do NSFW in public, you'll get banned.

neon flume
#

Yeah now that I think about it I'm not sure, I've never benchmarked it (I wish I had a vive to test with). My assumption is that the cv the oculus is doing would be more difficult than the timing performed by the vive's trackers but looking it up now I can't find anything to back that assumption up.

ruby needle
#

no where do they say its allowed at all

vocal shard
#

Its never B, always guess C
Jasyidk

ruby needle
#

but thats what most users make up out of it.

#

even tho that the TOS / Guidelines are absolutely clear

#

So when they hear it's mainly bound by the main cpu thread they asume its single core

#

which is just wrong

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

neon flume
#

Yeah, my poor quad core is almost always maxed out in a full pug. That's definitely multithreaded.

ruby needle
#

if you're in VR the other VR things also utilise the CPU and ofc your system is also running

#

so even if some performance critical thigns are still tied to the main thread multiple cores can still utilised by the other things

tall ingot
#

Oh yeah, that makes sense. I just wondered since the vive doesn't have it's own app running that it would mean my pc would run better bc there are less things running

rough pulsar
#

The vive does have its own thing running, it's called SteamVR. 😛

ruby needle
#

There is that thing called OpenComposite which is kind of replacing the standart SteamVR and any non important parts and forwards to the oculus directly which does help with that

#

ofc you loose any Steam VR features

#

but thats a given cirMini

#

i've been on it for a nearly a month i guess and so far im happy. cirPrise

#

unfortunate for me is that the audio routing does not work 100% for me yet (at least with vrchat) which means ill manually have to route my audio to the rift and desktop (recording on separate PC and send of trough main out)

#

But thats a rather special szenario cirMini

#

still waiting for the promised native Oculus re-release for this year cirPls

tacit plank
#

MelancholoyNeko, a few users have had that issue. One of my friends has it now and then but it's not permanent in her case.
Sadly, I don't know how to solve it, but I can at least confirm that it's a thing
(Being limited to 10FPS at all times, even when alone in a lag-free world)

ruby needle
#

"lag-free" cirBaka yeah, it was some kind of steam bug

#

but im also not sure what the solution was cirBlech

tacit plank
#

By lag free I mean something like a plane floating in the air

#

So it's related to Steam? Interesting, maybe changing steamVR settings can help it?
I've seen it reported on here every few months, it's not a common issue but it really sucks for those that has it

rough pulsar
#

The only world that has any actual claim to the 'lag-free' name is the pure blue one by TCL.

rigid crescent
#

"Posters are too lewd, some show nudity. Overall not appropriate for public. Fine for private. "

The public world list say it's allowed though. @ruby needle

lime umbra
#

Does anyone know where to find the "pokemon snap xxx" Blaziken avatar (bikini version of course)? I tried rigging one myself since I couldnt find the room it would be in but it was way too much of a headache for someone whos only done avatar development for like 2 days.

tacit plank
#

Pure blue? So no skybox?

rigid crescent
#

oof

rough pulsar
#

@tacit plank when you spawn there's no anything. It's just you, and blue.

tacit plank
#

No collider?

rough pulsar
#

Just one box collider on the floor, no mesh, I believe.

tacit plank
#

Delta I found 16 other pokemon ones if that's any help?

#

Cool, that does sound like a fast world

#

Slow refresh rate, forced shadows off, custom render settings etc could make it actually improve performance with people that too

lime umbra
#

I looked in all the other pokemon worlds but it wasnt in any of them, i think its in a room with a bunch of other miscellaneous avatars too

rigid crescent
tacit plank
#

The guideline on the website says no nudity or sexually suggestive content

median basalt
#

VRC is mostly single-threaded though

rigid crescent
#

but multiple moderators are telling me it's ok to do in private...

#

It's a little confusing, and he said "nowhere does it say it's ok" when he flat out said it's tolerated

median basalt
#

All the CPU hogging shit can only run on the main thread for now, barring a few exceptions maybe. I'm not too knowledgeable on the subject

rigid crescent
#

and it says it's ok on the public world list, which i assume is run by moderators

tacit plank
#

So by the guideline's logic, 3 bandaids on a child avatar is fine for clothes

#

I'm sure mods wouldn't agree with me on that, though

rigid crescent
#

Hmmmmm something doesn't add up.

median basalt
#

Rekt

rough pulsar
#

A general guideline is "Would this be acceptable at a regular beach?"
So a fairly revealing bikini? Sure.
Literal 2cm squares covering the essential bits? Mmmnaaaah

median basalt
#

Also lag-free worlds are apparently being allowed if you get the "right" reviewer that doesn't care

rigid crescent
#

Just pointing out that Fpaul is totally wrong lol

median basalt
#

Even if it's not lagfree at all

rigid crescent
#

"for example: The loading screen that says Dont do NSFW in public, you'll get banned. no where do they say its allowed at all"

tacit plank
#

I guess my point is, if the rules reflected what the staff thought a little better (or was consistent in the Discord, guidelines and ToS) I wouldn't have this grey area to think about

rigid crescent
#

Multiple sources, including tupper, say it's allowed. So "They" say it's allowed, assuming "they" mean mods

#

including Fpaul himself lol

tacit plank
#

So kid avatars can be nude? As seen on real beaches

rough pulsar
#

full on nudity is a no.

lime umbra
#

What kind of beaches do you go to?

tacit plank
#

Well, last one I went to was a lake, but yeah

rigid crescent
#

I mean if you wanna get technical there's certain cultures blah blah blah

#

but i know what you mean

true sky
#

@tacit plank i would probably report the user if they are doing that

tacit plank
#

Maybe some countries are different

true sky
#

thats just creepy

tacit plank
#

When I went to spain, many adults bathed nude

#

I guess my point is invalid this time

lime umbra
#

Europe

rigid crescent
#

When I ctrl+f the TOS, I see nothing mentioning "nudity" "sex/sexual" "nsfw" etc

ruby needle
#

one thing that a lot of people get wrong is that not only nudity or pornographic content can be NSFQ

rigid crescent
#

they might be using another adjective though

rough pulsar
#

I would also like to add while us discord mods tend to have a fairly decent understanding of the rules (I would hope) we're no authority on what is or isn't allowed.
That's down to those who do have moderation power inside VRC itself.

tacit plank
#

Website guidelines, search "nude"

rigid crescent
#

like Tupper, who also said it's ok

median basalt
#

I mean I'm not sure how much closer you can get, he's an admin

tacit plank
#

ToS is super vague

#

"Don't post anything which anyone can find offensive"

rigid crescent
#

oh i was under "legal"

median basalt
#

Problem is that moderation within the game and the Discord can be inconsistent

rough pulsar
#

VRChat has had a few unfortunately vague rules over the years.

median basalt
#

Just like the world review process

#

Whether worlds were marked as avatar world was solely up to how much the reviewer cared

rigid crescent
#

Just like how FPaul tried to point out that nowhere do they say it's ok despite multiple sources, including himself and Tupper and probably other Admin I didn't bother looking up, saying it's ok

tacit plank
#

"We can do anything we want, you don't have any rights, you grant us every permission we can legally get" etc etc

true sky
#

"Don't post anything which anyone can find offensive"
There is something someone will find offensive or claim it to be offensive

tacit plank
#

Like every other ToS, which isn't really legally binding for the most part anyways

rough pulsar
#

The best one was "Nothing illegal, in any country, anywhere"

tacit plank
#

That's a poor rule

rough pulsar
#

I really hope that one got properly reworded.

rigid crescent
#

LOL

tacit plank
#

It's funny, because the rules conflict

rigid crescent
#

did craig the intern write that up?

ruby needle
#

@rigid crescent cus i havent seen anyone saying its allowed

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

and the TOS to me is very clear

tacit plank
#

You can't show skin or be gay, that's illegal in the middle east. You can't descriminate against homosexuals, that's illegal in the first world

ruby needle
#

And thats what i base my things on.

#

Simple cirPrise

tacit plank
#

The ToS is clear to you? What the fuck? Have you really read any of it?

rigid crescent
#

But....Tupper said it's allowed. You said it's tolerated, which means it's allowed otherwise you'd just say don't do it

ruby needle
#

you mean the screenshot you posted right

rough pulsar
#

Okay thank fuck that one is gone. It was just so far reaching it was stupid.

tacit plank
#

That's good to hear

rigid crescent
#

also I was saying I couldn't see anything mentioning sex, nudity, etc in the TOS

#

with a few ctrl+f terms

median basalt
#

"You can't be gay in VRC"

#

RIP ERP

true sky
#

some of the ToS is understandable but the nsfw is somewhat vague

ruby needle
#

the screenshot you posted is hopefully not the thing you mean with tuppoer allowing it

#

cus thats not what he is saying

rough pulsar
ruby needle
#

yes

rough pulsar
#

Item 3

ruby needle
#

Nudity and Pronography

rigid crescent
#

oh, not the TOS, that's why I couldn't find it

true sky
#

lewd i dont have a problem with

#

but not too lewd

tacit plank
#

Everything is subjective

lime umbra
#

Erp in vrchat honestly sounds pretty cringe

tacit plank
#

Which leaves a grey area

ruby needle
#

behaviour can also be NSFW not only naked avatars and similar and that should be allowed as long as it is in public cirThink

tacit plank
#

But that's better than being overly strict

rough pulsar
#

TOS are somewhat different as that's more on the legal side of it, informing you of what data is collected, what legal agreements are present, etc.

rigid crescent
#

so the community guidelines say you can't do it....but the VRChat Community Manager says I can.

ruby needle
#

show me where he said it cirREE

rough pulsar
#

The screenshots posted earlier

rigid crescent
tacit plank
#

TOS is just a copy pasted version of a legally formatted "we want all rights that we can legally get, and we take as many rights from you as we legally can". A cover-all-bases thing

ruby needle
#

sure thing but where does he say that its allowd?

rigid crescent
#

lol

median basalt
#

Paul

ruby needle
#

oh

median basalt
#

I'm sorry but you are being very dense about this

ruby needle
#

that one is diferent

median basalt
#

"Go hog wild" is as close to "it's allowed" as you can get lol

rigid crescent
#

go hog-wild
phrase of hog-wild

informal•North American
act in an unrestrained manner.
#

please stop

#

lol

ruby needle
tacit plank
#

It's kind of allowed

median basalt
#

Realistically speaking, if you're in a private world they wouldn't even know

rigid crescent
#

oh i linked a second

tacit plank
#

As in, if you do it, nobody can or will blame you for it, as long as you don't share what you do

rigid crescent
#

you also say it's tolerated, though like you said you're chat mod

true sky
#

public = no nsfw allowed
private = go nsfw all you want

What i got soo far

tacit plank
#

They don't want you to admit to doing sexual things in private world, stream it or otherwise give VRChat a bad image (like second life has)

rough pulsar
#

If a loli is naked in the woods, and there's no mods around to see it, does it break the rules? 😜

rigid crescent
#

wow that was gold

#

According to the guidelines, yes.

#

According to Tupper, No.

tacit plank
#

Do anything you want as long as you don't harm VRChat by damaging its image or cause other players to have a bad time (or leave the game)

rigid crescent
#

I feel like I trust the official community manager with the cute anime girl more

ruby needle
#

Still depatable what NSFW means, naked? or just NSFW behaviour?

median basalt
#

Cirno isn't cute lol

tacit plank
#

It didn't the last time I tried it Gallium. That was a joke, I don't have a forest

rigid crescent
#

WOW

#

ROKK

median basalt
#

NSFW is a vague term

ruby needle
#

yes

true sky
#

NSFW = Not Safe For Work

tacit plank
#

"NSFW" originally stands for "Not safe for work"

median basalt
#

They can't start defining literally everything down to a T

tacit plank
#

I believe Reddit started it? It's a pretty new term

rigid crescent
#

the context of the conversation that screenshot is from is about avatars

median basalt
#

Nah, NSFW has been around as a term for ages

rigid crescent
tacit plank
#

People usually label things +15 or +18, the work thing started when everyday people browsed the web for fun

rigid crescent
#

so, in this context, we are referring ot NSFW imagery on an avatar

median basalt
#

I know a guy who accidentally had lewd geometry and lewd textures under the clothes, reviewers didn't notice or didn't care for months lmao

#

On a public avatar

ruby needle
#

Fair enogh

median basalt
#

Getting clapped seems mostly random

rigid crescent
#

Yeah my texture has it but it's not used at all, I just yeeted it to be sure

median basalt
#

Yeah same

tacit plank
#

One of my friends forgot to censor their model, but you need to move your head into it to see anything, and at that point it's your own fault

rigid crescent
#

So, according to the official community manager that didn't let me continue to listen in on his spotify session, NSFW avatars are OK

#

in private

ruby needle
#

Interesting to see him post that but i hope you also understand that i will stick to the TOS/Community guidlines cirComfy

tacit plank
#

Okay as in VRChat can't or won't stop you

rigid crescent
#

You also said it's tolerated though.

true sky
#

i think there should be a section in avatar menu to store your content warnings

rough pulsar
#

In case it's unclear, the content warnings in the SDK do nothing.

true sky
#

🤷

#

just a suggestion to give it a use

ruby needle
#

it is actually a leftover

tacit plank
#

They're unused. Could put them to work though

#

Like, any avatars containing such tags are forced private and will have their preview image replaced by a questionmark

true sky
#

i cant keep up how many times i accidently press a lewd avatar when meaning to select another avatar that was safe for work

rigid crescent
#

my question is why would I tag it if i wanted to be a douche

true sky
#

just an avatar i use in private worlds

rigid crescent
#

or is it more of a "well you had a chance to mark it private" kind of thing so that it's easier to ban people for it

#

instead of having incentive of letting them off with a warning

true sky
#

i mark some of mine as private for a reason

#

catch snatchers in public worlds

tacit plank
#

A concern I had before VRChar home was "what if I crash when using a lewd model? I will start in the pub with it"

rigid crescent
#

oof

#

is that the VRC Walk of Shame

ruby needle
#

can always use a launch code cirThink

tacit plank
#

It never happened, but I wondered about it a bit

#

Oh, good point

ruby needle
#

or worst case if you dont know that

#

never heard of it

#

you could delete it

#

you could also clear your settings which would send you to the tutorial room that resets your avatar

lime umbra
#

Thats why i just keep my home set to my private home room

ruby needle
#

many solutions cirPrise

median basalt
#

I always had my own world as home world since it's lag free

lime umbra
#

Not that i even have any lewd avatars, bit still a good idea in general

median basalt
#

Before home worlds I used launch options

rigid crescent
#

I think my home is STormy Cave, but recently I've been having to redownload my home every time I log in, even if it was already downloaded

median basalt
#

Yeah, if the cache is full it will simply fail to store anything more at all

rigid crescent
#

so I'll probably be back to the default home since it seems preloaded

median basalt
#

You could clear the cache maybe

tacit plank
#

Stormy cave updated a few times in the last few days

rigid crescent
#

Well, that's the thing, this happened even before when it was still 70mb

tacit plank
#

Well, maybe once or twice

#

But in those cases, the version number should change

rigid crescent
#

I'd have to load it, and one day I even cleared cache and a few days later I had to redownload it every time

#

yeah, it didn't have a new version for a while there

tacit plank
#

Oh, probably a bug

#

I've heard others mention it actually

#

Btw did you try what Rokk said?

rigid crescent
#

yeah, first thing I did was clear cache, it's been doing it for a while now

#

at least a month or two

tacit plank
#

Ah

#

Stormy cave dev just told me that the bugs should be fixed now

#

No more re-uploads needed

vocal shard
#

why has no one made a warioware map in vrchat

still lark
#

Wait, how am I gonna get beta notifications if I can't talk in that channel! :(

covert chasm
#

You don't need to talk to read. :>

#

You can use the command in any channel I'm pretty sure

#

@still lark go ahead and be a guinea pig, give it a shot in here

still lark
#

.iam Open Beta

potent sableBOT
#

Permission number #4 **.asm disable ** is preventing this action.

covert chasm
#

dang

#

.modules

still lark
#

oh my

covert chasm
#

Yep, I got lazy and used a pretty common bot

#

Don't worry, that module won't be enabled 😛

rugged kestrel
#

So I have a problem where I will join a world that has people in it and I can’t see or here anyone and everything is in place.

covert chasm
#

Are you on the right version?

still lark
#

If you open up your quick menu, what does the build number say?

rugged kestrel
#

@still lark it’s build 636

still lark
#

Yeah, we're kinda on 642.

covert chasm
#

You need to update. Do you play using Steam?

rugged kestrel
#

Yeah

covert chasm
#

Are you on a beta of some kind?

#

@still lark give it another shot btw

still lark
#

.iam Open Beta

potent sableBOT
#

ScruffyRules#0879 You now have Open Beta role.

covert chasm
#

noice

#

@rugged kestrel Your listing on Steam should look like this. If you're on a beta, you might have "[open-beta]" to the right of the text, or something.

#

If you DO have extra text to the side, right click on VRChat, go to Properties, go to Beta tab, and set it to None.

ruby needle
#

open beta role 😮

#

Fancy cirPrise

covert chasm
#

yeah, since Discord doesn't let me limit who is allowed to mention a role (add MY feature, dammit, not all these other ones), it gives you read-only access to a channel that I'll ping for notifications.

civic plume
#

i cant upload i keep getting this error?

rugged kestrel
#

Ok thanks! I thought there was something wrong with my computer... again

ruby needle
#

oh nice

still lark
#

Read only huh? 😉

thorny lark
#

.iam Open Beta

potent sableBOT
#

Celeste#9999 You now have Open Beta role.

ruby needle
#

guess im in

#

.iam Open Beta

potent sableBOT
#

FPaul#1645 You now have Open Beta role.

still lark
#

Should work in any channel yeah? should probably tell people to use #general-media for now

covert chasm
#

hmmm

golden bluff
#

.iam Open Beta

potent sableBOT
#

e-slut#0094 You now have Open Beta role.

covert chasm
#

maybe a botspam channel

ruby needle
#

im not sure if you do need a specific channel tho? you yould just make the role pingable

#

and ping em on a info update

covert chasm
#

Yes, but then anyone can ping that role.

lilac swan
still lark
#

@ruby needle Read what he said

golden bluff
#

Speaking of open beta what was that open beta push last night?

covert chasm
#

A small test

golden bluff
#

Oh

covert chasm
#

nothing significant

ruby needle
#

oh i see

#

right

#

everyone could ping em

#

discord permissions cirSlain

still lark
#

Exactly

covert chasm
#

I've asked for that feature for over a year

#

on every stream and Q&A tweet and etc

#

they always ignore it NotLikeThis

#

So instead I decided to hack together this solution

#

test successful i assume?

golden bluff
#

Works

still lark
#

Yes

covert chasm
#

noice

#

👌

#

that makes my job a ton easier

civic plume
#

tupper do you own vrchat? thonk

still lark
#

wot

civic plume
#

owo

vagrant parrot
#

my dad is discord

civic plume
#

[2, 500, Get 1] Request Finished with Error!

#

what is this

#

help D:

still lark
#

@modern sand You troll.

civic plume
#

i have been trying since last night

modern sand
#

spooked ya

covert chasm
#

I definitely don't own VRChat

#

but I work for VRChat 😃

civic plume
#

ah ok