#Better biome representative art

15 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

reef creek
#

When these art have been added it is really confusing even more so than the old single plant representations for the biomes. Must say I much preferred the old single plant reps but some updates can be;

Dessert: saguaro cactus instead of the joshua tree since cacti are easily identifiable in such a small pic.

Tropical: a coconut palm could be a better choice since as is I confuse it with temperate and mostly coastal biome; these three are too similar to each other at a distance. Also coconut palms are widely known as the tropical plant in popular culture I suppose.

Coastal: like in the tropical pic some sword ferns can/should be added to bottom sides as it is the main reason I think I confuse it with the tropical biome. This can also help with differentiating with the boreal biome more.

reef creek
#

perhaps more like this

#

not a good artist

willow glacier
#

Also, actually including Mediterranean cypress to the Scrubland biome would help out a ton

reef creek
#

scrubland needs mediterranean flora in general

livid lily
#

I feel like a kapok is more diagnostic of a tropical biome than a coconut palm

#

And I feel like adding ferns to the coastal pic makes it look too similar to the tropical one

reef creek
#

perhaps changing the greenery on the tropical to differentiate it more would help

#

but I disagree that coconut palms in such a small picture are better identifiable than the kapok

solemn flint
#

Nah I gotta agree, Kapok is more distinct here

willow glacier
#

The thing is that we should think of the most basic first glance understanding a new player might have in this game. Possibly they have only have elementary school amount of knowledge and in that case ¨palm tree¨ says tropical more than ¨tree with naked trunk¨ does: Especially in comparison with temperate, coastal, and boreal pictures which also have a focal point of one bigger tree

reef creek
#

basically this ^

whole torrent
#

ngl this is a skill issue, it took me very little time to get used to the new icons and they are very distinct imo. also coastal already has ferns on it

willow glacier
solemn flint
#

Ngl you're blowing this way out of proportion