#Tachyon Mode feedback
1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
i see
You can try using this tool (still pretty new) [Requires the Analog SDK], it will show you the history of your analog signal for keys and can help investigate keys not behaving correctly.
- It is not code signed yet, so you will get Windows SmartScreen crying.
- Let me know if you need it for a different platform, I have Mac and Linux builds
no windows smartscreen issues here :)
Huh. interesting
I have altered my windows to bypass smartscreen things and more
but
my b key is very inconsistent compared to my V key
Was it the B key that you were observing having issues in-game?
Yes
It might give an explanation why it suddenly stopped giving input, since the actuation point is set to 0.1mm.
You're using rapid trigger as well?
Do you see any differences if you check it after replugging?
Also, when you're in the above situation, are you able to get it to max out if you press the key in harder?
Its fixed after I replugged it somehow
Also yes, that's the case here
I see, then I suspect that you may be pressing it in fairly hard at one point, which causes it to push in the end of the press calibration, so when you then press it normally, it thinks it's not fully pressed
But there is more to it, when I press it at the left side of the button it the travel value goes lower. On the right, top and bottom nothing happens. I also checked this for the V key but that one is fine. Might this be a switch issue?
Huh, so it gives the furtherst press when pressed on the left side? But right, top and bottom you don't get any signal or what do you get?
Let me quickly record this and I'll send it
Alrighty, ty
mkv is fine
aighty
I see what you mean now, interesting. It would appear that your switch has really bad wiggle, so it may be good to try swapping the switch out
In general, the wiggle is something we're working hard to improve/eliminate (in the switches themselves)
I see, luckily I have some spares so I will swap them out and let you know if that fixes anything
the problem is still there but its much better now
might just need to test a bunch of other switches and find a good one lmao
yep found a switch that doesn't have this issue, thanks Simon!
Great, glad you found a good one, hopefully we can prevent this happening in the future
Hopefully yeah! Anyway, I am also looking it at the bright side: nothing wrong with the tachyon mode/RT. 2.7.3 beta 2 is working as intended for me
Great 😁
When it's running stable on everybody's boards
I forgot to say this yesterday: Maybe pin this in this channel for future reference
this happens frequently with lekkers, for example in osu, where u press keys hard the keys get inconsistent on the one side for some reason, with raptors this doesnt happen ever
What is this
I can (almost certainly) confirm that this is a major issue. I don't know if it's software related, but after some time the keys you play osu with are getting very inconsistent as shown in the 1st picture. Now replugging the keyboard fixes this issue but that shouldn't be needed. The question here is: are you guys able to come up with a explanation/solution to this problem?
I wasnt even pushing a key like simon mentioned before, i was just playing you know, and this happened. Pretty sure who plays osu all have this issue. This needs to be fixed asap
RaptorHE doesnt have this issue.
doesnt matter how hard I press or hit a keys in osu billion BPM map
this doesnt happen with them
and this after playing osu without wiggling the switch, just pressing on it
Tried both Beta and Stable wootility doesnt matter, this is a switch issue. I swapped 20 of them still happens.
mine does the same if I wiggle it
yea everybody has this i think with lekker switches, raptors doesnt do this.
Does it make that much of a difference?
This is the key after playing osu, this matters a lot in osu this shouldnt happen
either calibration is the issue or lekkers are bad
or both
I think the latter given you said the issue goes away with raptors
Lekkers have been bad in my experience though.. I have 3-4 boxes of L45 all with some issue
Finalmouse level QC actually lol
yea
dude i had my win key on 4.0mm yesterday and i tried to screenshot
it didnt work
because it wasnt actuating on 4.0mm
it was like 3.6mm fully pressed
i replug the keyboard and it was fixed
im not even smashing my keyboard playing osu. but still the key becomes like this on lekkers
meanwhile raptor switch
hope this gets addressed and fixed
at first i thought my kb was fucked then other users experienced same issue
this happens with 1 of my raptor switches but not as much as lekkers
simply not actuating on 4.0mm
replug fixes it, and then again if i press any lekker switch like 10 times in osu this happens again
more people should be involved here because i think this is a major issue. @alpine solar @tulip tiger
I literally pressed 3 and 4 keys 10 times and then they dont actuate on 4.0mm until replug
lemme record a vid real quick
u can clearly see key doesnt actuate on 4.0mm, yeah maybe this can be wooting analog monitor issue not showing correctly, but no. ive set my key (in this situation my 3 key) to 4.0mm and tested it actuating and it struggles to actuate on it. because of what, because i pressed it 10 times or whatever
is this my kb issue or lekker switch ?
im not even slamming the keys, this happens everywhere where i have lekker switch
Not sure why I of all get pinged but okay ...
my bad: )
Isn’t that kinda weird? How does replugging the keyboard suddenly makes it read properly then?
This is more than weird, and 99% of the time this happens only with lekkers when you spam a key (not only in osu) it kinda loses calibration and no longer goes to 4.0mm and dont tell me something is wrong with analog monitor or else, there is something wrong with lekker switches and the calibration itself
there is no way this should happen, for example i have my key on 4.0mm actuation it doesnt actuate at all, if i wont set it below 3.8mm actuation
this is not ok
And yeah replug fixes this, but then it still has this, when you wiggle the switch.
Still waiting for Simon, maybe he can sort this out.
@smoky cloak that's happen to you the same way on stable 2.7.2 and beta 2.7.3 firmware?
yes, only with lekker switches and im not the only one having this issue
I know that and trust you .but just suprised you have same result with stable and beta firmware cause they don't use same calibration way .
I imagined that the problem would be more or less present depending on the firmware
for lekker switches its the same
it was always like this i think, but i noticed something was off few days ago and then checked with this software
calibration messes up and keys are getting inconsistent
Ok i understand .hope Simon can help you with this.
@rain mountain
There is not much they can do about this shafie
@smoky cloak For starters, you won't see this issue appearing on the Raptor switches, as they have a significantly stronger magnet, which fully saturates (i.e. maxes out) the hall effect sensor before it is fully pressed. So to the firmware, there's no difference between e.g. 3.8mm pressed vs 4mm pressed vs pressing it in harder and getting further travel
Hi simon, so the thing is 2 days ago i couldnt actuate my win key properly because it was on 4.0mm and was only actuating at 3.8mm iirc, then i replugged the keyboard and it was fixed.
To answer why it gets fixed by replugging, that is because the firmware resets the end of press calibration every time the keyboard restarts. In general, the wiggle of the switches will result in the analog signal being lower when compared to pressing the key normally on the center of the keycap, so it is in general not that surprising that you'll see the signal pulling up a little bit when wiggling
Currently, the beta firmware has no limit to the end value calibration, so if you press in the key very hard, it's likely you're pushing the key into the plate further, making it closer to the sensor. So you're effectively making it have e.g. 4.3mm travel rather than 4mm. So then, when you press it normally, it thinks that it isn't fully pressed, because you've pressed it in so hard it thinks that is where the end of the press is
So with that, then you'll see it not actuate properly normally when the actuation is set to 4mm, because it thinks it's not fully pressed due to it being pressed in further than that before
Yes, but im not even pressing the key that hard as shown in the video
It doesn't matter if you're not pressing the key that hard in the video, if it was pressed in hard before, it will have adjusted the end value calibration
Is this really an issue? i wanted to know if something was wrong on my side really
it wasnt pressed hard before, i replugged the keyboard before recording the video
The only way this will happen, is if the keyboard got a significantly higher signal for that key, compared to what it gets when it's pressed normally
Well this happens with all keys with lekker switches
That could happen if you're pressing it off-center after it has been pressed on the center, as then it may not be fully pressed in and not count as 4mm. In general, the firmware has a mechanism for attempting to ignore the wiggle, so for you to see it happening like this, there has to be a real big difference in the analog signal that it's getting
Is your keyboard completely stock? or do you have mods?
my keyboard is completely stock
Okay, lets continue in DMs to not fill up this thread too much
Alright
Okay this totally makes sense to me
Following this btw, because I have the same kind of issue
Different than what we went over before?
Not entirely different, kinda experiencing the same issues as shafie
With the same severity? Or more inline with what you were sharing before?
Somewhere in between so far, currently testing a bit to measure more precise values
okay so far its getting worse lmao the wiggle is very noticable, somewhere around 3.6-3.7mm currently deviations between 0.1-0.3mm
Okay I am not able to achieve such worse values lowest is like 3.8 ish
We let Simon cook
Tried to read but still questioning.
So it ok that when wiggling it's changing? Or it's not and will be fixed in future?
@fierce oasis this should give an answer to your question. I am not sure if it will be fixed in the future
👍
switch wiggle is lekker switch issue if i understand correctly, but if your keys calibration messes up after some time of use (for example after playing osu or other games) this cant be ok and needs to be fixed, lets see how this goes
@covert lodge Just met the problem that shafie has... The difference is that I swapped the case to a tofu 60 redux (The plate is still the Wooting stock one). It occurs on C and V key most often, which is my main osu keybinding. Been using it for about 8 months, idk if it's caused by the aging of the hall sensors, or slightly bending on the plate/PCB?
The situation could be a bit more complex: sometimes it can't even reach 4mm on the analog graph when I press the key all the way down as usual, I have to place my finger right on the middle of the keycap and press it a little harder to make it.
no it cant be because of aging. and this is the common problem just not everybody is noticing it. (maybe not everyone has this but im sure majority of wooting owners has this)
yeah, basically same thing as me, but Simon said he has some plans to help this, next week. Lets see if this gets resolved.
you can try replugging kb, hold the key and see that its straight line, then hop on osu play some maps and the line isnt straight anymore its kinda at 3.8mm or 3.9mm depends
how long have u been using the keys
pretty sure if u use the keys whole day in osu, it can even become at 3.7mm at max
until u replug the keyboard
u can get raptor switches until this gets fixed 😂 @solar orchid
Yeah replugging kb calibrates it, then the problem comes again after a few osu gameplay or simply smash the key dozens of times.
Not playing all the time but I barely replug my keyboard or reboot my PC .
Will try raptor, and wait for software solution😁
Not a fact this gets fixed, but 🙏
this is the result with firmware version : v2.6.21-test downgrade
the line is pretty straight and after osu (played for 5 minutes) it doesnt go down to 3.8mm
like on current beta
didnt play as much but those 5 minutes was enough on beta to make the calibration incorrect
Will post the 2.7.2 result in a moment
firmware 2.7.2
what is this on your screenshot?
Erm
I wiggled the switch there
I dont think its important, thats lekker switch issue that it wiggles like that
Im not 100% sure yet, but yes 2.72 and below versions are way way better
now Simon have all the info and can work on the next beta firmware and try to make a real fix the double clic issue on spacebar i have and the problem you have on 2.7.3 beta
@solar orchid are u on beta firmware?
No, I'm on 2.7.2 stable
Thats weird, Im on 2.7.2 now and no longer see the issue. On beta firmware i was seeing the problem in seconds, but on 2.7.2 im playing osu for like 15 minutes, still no issue
holding the key, the line is straight, and isnt dropping to 3.7-3.8mm like on beta firmware.
@solar orchid if u have this problem on 2.7.2, try downgrade to 2.6.21-test
or upgrade to current beta firmware
ok sir, will try
@solar orchid post your results after downgrade and upgrade please
👌
Update: + and - keys have the problem for some reason, swapped the switches too but doesnt fix, but atleast other keys dont have this issue anymore
I think i have tested all keys with lekker switches and compared to 2.7.3 beta, the situation is way better on 2.7.2, but on 3 keys i have still the issue where the actuation comes down to 3.85-3.9 after pressing keys, but this can be improved im sure. @covert lodge
on 2.7.3 all keys with lekker switches had this issue.
this is result i screenshotted on 2.7.3 beta firmware after pressing the keys for like 20 seconds
and this is on 2.7.2
its day and night
next firmware will fix double clic and this issue for sure
🙏
@grizzled veldt @smoky cloak Have tried the latest beta and 2.6.21 firmware, the issue occurs on both of them, and affects more keys. When I was on 2.7.2 stable, the problem comes to V key most often, others were basically fine. On 2.6.21.downgrade and latest beta some other keys starts floating on the monitor when I wiggle them, and looks V key is still the most "unstable" one.
Firmware I use in the video is 2.6.21.downgrade, tachyon mode on and RGB set to 0%, have had my kb replugged before test.
cant see the video, can u just upload here?
yeah reuploading
yeah, calibration needs to be improved, hopefully next week this gets resolved
@solar orchid can u press the keys like ur playing osu, and then just press those keys in analog monitor, without wiggling the switch.
When I hit near the edge of the keycap it's just simply not reaching 4mm. Actually I was considering that it's caused by assembly mistakes, but case swap shouldn't make it, and the plate is the stock one and is well screwed to the PCB😔
its not because of assembly mistake
It'll be great if this can be solved by fw update or switch swap, luckily there are multiple raptor HE sellers in my country, would try the possible solution next week.😤
raptor doesnt have this because of strong magnet
2.7.2 is much more stable so far for me
Yes im pretty sure a firmware update can improve or fix this issue Simon Daren and others work hard to help about this sort of problem
This shows what it acts when I wasn't pressing right on the center of the keycap, should've uploaded it before i went sleeping.
I was focusing on C and V before, actually it also happened with other keys like numbers when i press(v is still the most jumpy in the wiggle test)
Firmware is 2.6.21 test.
its not better when ur on 2.7.2?
basically the same when testing long press, and worse on older and newer beta firmware when i wobble the keys
interesting
Would you know if this supports the 60HE+ module
I was trying to help someone debug their 60HE+ module and this app doesn't seem to work for them with it
The Analog SDK needs an update to detect the 60HE+
I'll get back to all the above later when I have more time
@vivid grotto
https://github.com/WootingKb/wooting-analog-sdk/releases/tag/v0.7.5 I just released an Analog SDK update that includes 60HE+ support
Perfect
What issues did v0.7.5 fix?
Literally 3 messages above 😅
My woot60HE has been feeling funky got the last 2 betas
is there a tool to see the analog input]\
will showcase current state of the pressed switch
#1196768306602983494 message
requires the "Analog SDK" if not already installed (link Above if needed)
wait for beta update, i think its coming out tomorrow (not sure tho)
How do you know that ? So hyped
Simon is working on beta update specifically for my issue. maybe it also fixes other issues too if u have them, dont know exactly
so waht is windwos smart screen ?
No expert on the matter,
but I believe it is a Windows warning stating that the software is not registered and could be malicious or harmfull.
pretty much don't run the software unless you know its safe
when is the next beta firmware?
I have a build in testing currently, which I hope to have released as a proper beta tomorrow
alrgiht awesome
The new beta update is live now, it should show up as an available update when using Wootility Beta
where is the beta update?
my wooting who he keyboard is stopped working after v2.7.3-beta.3
how do i downgrade?
but it does see my presses but nothing coming out. tried troubleshooting still nothing
oh restarting my laptop helped 👍
👍
Did they fix this issue?
Its definitely way better now, but still needs improvement
Still wating for the stable update.......
soon
Providing feedback on what exactly could be improved would help. Devs aren't magicians lol
I already used the analog app on this thread.
Quick question:
I tried to not press the key but move my finger horizontally on the key and my analog value still gets register. The actuation point is higher so i get no input and that is fine.
But why it regidters analog value if i dont press the key? i mean i only move my finger horizontally without pressing on the key. Just having a low contact and analog value get registered.
Is that what people say about "wobbling" ?
whats the point of crossposting in 10 different channels
i assume it registers because the magnet is moving, thats normal.
this is how the wiggle looks like
if you press the key and wiggle it
note that this screenshot is old and on newer version of beta u wont get this bad of a wiggle in analog monitor
Ah perfect then
This is how it looks like
This is normal, if i touch my kb slightly it will give signal too because magnet is moving
idk if this is the place to talk about this but, if we were to hypothetically push the polling rate on the mcu that already exist in the 60he how far can we achieve maybe 2000hz or even 4000hz?
1000 is the max cause for anything above that you'll need an MCU with a highspeed USB connection.
you think wooting is eventually going to make a 60he V2 having the upgrade of the 8000hz polling rate and the snappy rappy
snappy will be added in software on wooting 60he, but i dont think there will be v2 60he.
where did wooting state that itll be added to the 60he?
in discord
could u @ me?
it was earlier today, cant find it
What software are you using to get these readings?
Ty
yes need thiso
when u guys update rapid trigger sens per key
What?
rapid trigger but the sensitivity per switch
Updated version of the monitor tool btw. Mainly just some fixes
so this is the small issue I am having with debounce on 2.7.2 (might be just my spring/key combo)
the 2nd picture is the latest beta 2.7.3.5
2f9eb1feb920e5be53a6f9441af41263840b is my profile
I was doing full press and release of my keys
I was using the space bar for this testing but it does affect other keys as well
not as significant
k-key
space key
both of those are still on beta
pretty sure this is no rapid trigger too
still was on this profie
Maybe y'all can add a debounce setting along with per key rapid trigger settings if the memory allows it
was making warlock jumping on destiny very hard
When you say your spring/key combo, what are you using?
Also, you should be able to workaround this via your Actuation point. Assuming you're not using Continous rapid trigger, then your Actuation point will essentially dictate the start of press deadzone for rapid trigger
but in general, the symptoms you're getting is a general issue that we are investigating internally, so your information is a helpful additional datapoint
Cerakeys L45’s and L60 on my space bar
I'm going to get some stronger springs see if that helps it
have u tried different keycaps maybe those keycaps are too heavy
i’ll try my take control keycaps tonight
tried the take control space bar and its the same
take control key cap on space bar with L60 .1 .15 rapid continuous
Wootility v4.6.16 (Web)
OS: Windows
Device: Wooting 60HE+, v2.7.3-beta.6
264b96b76833816de1e0e3db6ec2bb7dd072
I mean i can avoid this if I put my actuation to .7+ but then its :/
In this you're getting double presses at bottom out as well? wtf is going on with your board
Are these switches or just spring swap?
Those are the wooting lekker switches l60 is from my founders board and the l45s are from the 60+ release date
Rattle I think, I’m pressing the key down and then lifting my finger as fast as possible
I eliminated all stem wobble with the raptor geon HE switches/housing with the lekker 60 stem
This was as I was building it, it was worth it. No issues for me on the beta
install beta firmware
it will be better, but main issue here are lekker switches
consider swapping them in future with lekker v2 or jades
if you want to help me get some heavier springs from wooting let me know I'll buy some im in the US
@covert lodge how I press and release keys to get that weird affect on latest beta
l60 on spacebar L45 on the rest
its not as often on 2.7.2 but still there
what if you dont press like that, and just press normally?
Define normal me lifting my finger off my switch to turn it off fast would be normal
I tried plastic so i could not have my skin stick to the keycap
It double presses still
damn
i try to delete once with my backspace and it does 2 occasionally so annoying
yea that sucks
The downward tapping motion isn’t the issue its the release being so quick that it like vertically bounces
But i can’t humanly tap that fast myself
also strange that it happens with all firmware versions as you said
maybe return it? or you cant
i put it back to 2.7.2 through the troubleshooting feature on wootility
I’ve been flipping back on fourth
I love the speed and feeling of the beta but that double tap is rough
forgot if you tried it on different pc/laptop
not really a that type of issue power delivery is good makes no difference 0% 100% brightness
worths to try
Link me the stabilizer and switch you’re on
@fickle token I've got some ideas to help filter out some of these bounces in the signal.
Which keycaps are you using?
Take control & cerakeys I’ve tried both
Both have it
Both have it with the same severity?
Yes especially on the new firmware
its similar to this issue I’m thinking
Hmmm, I see
I'll open a DM with you, so when I have some builds for you to try, I'll let you know
is this not suppose to happen? its same for my spacebar
the bottom when it returns is not supposed to happen
well i guess im gonna cut sides from my space bar 👍
yeah download the analog graphing and test it
Which version were you on before? If it was v2.7.3-beta.6, then v2.8.0 is virtually identical.
But ye, like Grizbabez said, you should use the analog monitor tool to get some data on this
when you say ghost click it's like double click or some key press don't register?