#protection

1 messages Β· Page 3010 of 1

sick sentinel
#

99% of magic damage is reflected

#

or reflect cheesed

sweet summit
#

Cleave, triad, maggots, lord and lady?

sick sentinel
#

Maggots get one shot by reflect cheese

#

lord and lady you can reflect every cast

sweet summit
#

Im not sure about wcm, hence the (?)

sick sentinel
#

you never go left side in an actual fort key if you're doing high keys

#

left side horrible count and waste of time

sweet summit
#

Yeah ik

sick sentinel
#

triad is reflectable too and purely kickable with 2 melee kicks

ionic fern
#

Can't assume everyone is doing high keys.
Most people asking advice here are in the range of 10-15.

sick sentinel
#

more of a reason not to do it then

#

null won't change anything in 15s

#

misplay will

ionic fern
#

No harm in doing it either.

sick sentinel
#

get more from other stuff

sharp lotus
#

I just got my third pair of 480 C'thraxxi pauldrons

sweet summit
#

πŸ˜‚

#

Rip

orchid frigate
#

lol

#

ive ben getting them as well

granite flint
#

How much haste do I need to have 100% uptime on Shield Block?

orchid frigate
#

before i deicded to save for specific

strong forum
#

166%

#

@granite flint

granite flint
#

Oh my

#

Thank you @strong forum

strong forum
#

Thats however SB only. With LS and Bolster in mind for actual 100% block uptime it's going to be alot less

granite flint
#

Oh what will it be around then?

strong forum
#

That number I however don't know as its not something to focus on, as there's no scenario where you need true 100% block uptime

granite flint
#

Gotcha!

#

I want as much uptime on SB as I can how much haste do you think I should go for then?

#

For m+

strong forum
#

Just as much as you can, as haste gives you rage Generation

granite flint
#

Yea I’m thinking about replacing vers enchants and gems for haste

strong forum
#

Which directly translates into shorter cooldowns of many buttons

#

You should do that regardless, unless you're pushing high keys

granite flint
#

πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘ awesome

sick sentinel
#

Am I blind, or are there not any pins for corruptions in raid?

strong forum
#

TD

daring bay
#

@strong forum what is a high key?

granite flint
#

Just don’t know if I should drop TD for Expedient

strong forum
#

25+ assuming optimal setup.
23+ if not optimal setup

sick sentinel
#

So just TD stack?

strong forum
#

For raid yes

sick sentinel
#

No ineffs?

ionic fern
#

No need.

worthy linden
#

can you get weapons or shields from visions?

strong forum
#

No

daring bay
#

@strong forum is 23 the highest key you have done?

strong forum
#

Only wrists, gloves, pants and boots

#

Yes, I'm playing a non-meta comp and I'm not pushing

worthy linden
#

cheers

daring bay
#

Ah, the exuses :P

amber siren
#

nome is a beta

still pagoda
#

Not everyone pushes for the highest keys

amber siren
still pagoda
#

he enjoys 23's

#

why not

strong forum
#

Excuses?

#

I'm doing 2-3 keys a week, if that's pushing to you, lmao

daring bay
#

:)

still pagoda
ionic fern
#

I'm not sure what this has to do with the prior discussion.

#

πŸ€”

still pagoda
#

no excuses since i don't have much time either

sturdy dome
#

im doing keys on 3 toons

#

lul

red fern
#

Why do you wanna use VoP whe u have CoF as major in raids

#

Isnt't Lucid better as minor then?

ionic fern
#

You can sim yourself for damage purposes and pick w/e fits you.

sturdy dome
#

Is Jes' howler any good?

granite flint
#

@still pagoda nice gear!

still pagoda
#

?

granite flint
#

You have nice gear on your World of Warcraft character that you linked

red fern
#

You can sim yourself for damage purposes and pick w/e fits you.
@ionic fern

#

Yea but not dmg intake, isnt lucid more defensive?

granite flint
#

Yes

ionic fern
#

Most fights in raids are not that heavy on damage intake - especially this late into the tier.
There are some exceptions to this with nukes like Illgy for example but those can be covered via defensive trinkets for example.

#

So in general there shouldn't be any need to go for a more "defensive" setup in regards to minor powers.

red fern
#

Ok, cool

daring bay
#

I feel like vex hurts when ur tanking the adds :V

#

like beam when you are dogding breaths, ouch

ionic fern
#

Beam wrecks jeah if you're 2 tanking.

still pagoda
#

beam wrecks if your healers don't dispel also

strong forum
#

Get dispelled 2-3 times and you're gucci

daring bay
#

Well, the problem is when you you cant hit the mobs becuse of breaths so you just stand there while getting lazered with ur SR up dropping :V

strong forum
#

Or once at 8-10

still pagoda
#

just had one monk from Π§Π΅Ρ€Π½Ρ‹ΠΉ Π¨Ρ€Π°ΠΌ(mostly ally RU server. Though its population is nearly extinct) ask whether "i'm going +18SoB for weekly"

#

fuck

#

man

#

you can go do +15 weekly no leavers if you want to

#

i want this key timed

#

:D

strong forum
#

+18 grants you enough TR so you can get an azerite piece from vendor every 2 weeks

still pagoda
#

I know. Not gonna sacrifice my key for some random player on RU ally dominant server from which i don't take people since 7.1.5 anyway

upper violet
#

never lucky

#

i have run lots of dungeons stuck with 445 shield

still pagoda
daring bay
#

Nice, just gotta pop a socket in there

upper violet
#

whats the addon that shows the ilvl like that called

still pagoda
#

Nice, just gotta pop a socket in there
@daring bay

pop a socket and TD3

#

whats the addon that shows the ilvl like that called
@upper violet

Addonskins. Basically reskins everything into ElvUI style

#

but you can get ElvUI itself and will boast even more

upper violet
#

eh i dont like elvui

#

im using scuffed bars

#

my ui is a huge mess

daring bay
#

I use dominos, but my UI is kinda messed up to

#

people recomend elvui so might give it a try

still pagoda
#

i use Bartender4

upper violet
#

its so scuffed

#

idk why i have 4 different mounts

#

on the bar

#

it is what it is

still pagoda
upper violet
#

man i think i forgot to do the buff thing before the dungeon

#

need a WA for that

#

im so dumb

#

checked the log

#

dude im so stupid

#

had 2 other ppl who could use the buff

dusty warren
#

Guys, I'm currently with TD5 and doing keys up to 20+. If I put an IT1 it goes to 44 corruption and I would like to be below 40. Is it worth drop TD2 and putting 2x IT1?

strong forum
#

I'd just stay above 40 πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ

#

But if you absolutely wanna be below 40, I'd run IT1 + TD3/4 + w/e you can fill in

still pagoda
#

i've just seen rogue die from cast he didn't interrupt

#

and healer DCed before second boss just now

#

RIP SoB18

obsidian mica
#

Sb here, who killed N'Zoth Mythic with his prot warri, whom I can dm?

strange tide
#

@still pagoda what interrupt tracker is that?

still pagoda
upper violet
#

ah yes this is very nice

#

any external tracker

strange tide
#

Cheers mate

upper violet
#

or like healer cd tracker

#

same ilvl

still pagoda
#

second one

ionic fern
#

Swap gemhide for RP

#

@upper violet

still pagoda
#

^

#

we're armor capped anyways

ionic fern
#

Wat

upper violet
#

nothing else what about the crit thing vs heed

still pagoda
#

smh, i'm sitting at 74,69%

#

dunno if they changed anything

#

but isn't armor cap still at 75%?

upper violet
#

ah nvm wrong piece

strong forum
#

Thats without the higher K values in m+ / raid

still pagoda
#

oh

#

funky

stiff oracle
#

Impassive visage peepoHappy

worthy linden
#

i could play with TD6 or TD5 + expedient 3, should I just go full damage or keep the expedient to help with rotation/shield blocks/whatever? this is for low keys, like 15-16 max

upper violet
#

Do a key with each setup

#

Then pick what u pref

strong forum
#

I'd run TD5 + expedient just cuz it's more fun, min maxing 15s is really not necessary

worthy linden
#

yeah I've been using the TD5 + expedient setup for the last week, and it's been really smooth and fun and I dont think the extra damage matters that much at this point

#

I'll try a key with TD6 tho

strong forum
#

Ye, I'd personally say, going above TD5 isn't really as beneficial as throwing in some IT / haste%. But that's just feelycraft

worthy linden
#

wish I had bought IT1 when it was on sale, used all my echoes on expedient for arms

strong forum
#

F

orchid frigate
#

hmm

#

got first mask on alt, did it and got two new. equipped them and did next but didnt get any quest πŸ˜’

#

full clear

upper violet
#

because u get 2 masks from each city

#

if thats ur issue

orchid frigate
#

but i should have 4 now then, right?

#

and get next one in SW next week

upper violet
#

should i run anima for the autism 30 tank

sweet summit
#

absolutely

upper violet
#

minor?

sweet summit
#

yuz 😎

upper violet
#

so uhhh anima warden null as minors and cof major?

sweet summit
#

sounds good πŸ˜‚

upper violet
#

why u being weird

sweet summit
#

😳

upper violet
#

time for indom xddddddddddddddddd

still pagoda
sweet summit
#

impending victory btw

still pagoda
#

DEVASTATOR

sweet summit
#

very stronk

upper violet
#

wdym wouldnt it be good for the tank raid

still pagoda
sweet summit
#

o wait IV is on the same row as ItF wtf

still pagoda
#

Ineffable Ravager will be a thing!

sweet summit
#

kinda cringe :/ fix prot talents

#

yes, karton, yes

still pagoda
#

i don't use this myself

upper violet
sweet summit
#

you go dragon roar with ineffable ravager

still pagoda
#

i think they should make Ravager baseline

#

make it into Dancing Rune Weapon but AOE

#

which it is already

sweet summit
#

make it do damage 🀠

still pagoda
#

ye

#

it barely does anything right now

sweet summit
#

big parry

#

dont need shield block :^)

ionic fern
#

Why are you guys like this?

orchid frigate
#

im a bit sad that my guild healers prefers BDK. i guess i must be playing both wrong. when i play warrior i feel so tanky and a lot more consistent on dmg intake than in BDK

#

and it seems to me that i take a lot less dmg as well

#

as warrior

ionic fern
#

You do.

sweet summit
#

you should

upper violet
#

i played with a healer and at the start he said like dude u have so little hp and at the end he said it was very easy to heal :P

still pagoda
#

im a bit sad that my guild healers prefers BDK. i guess i must be playing both wrong. when i play warrior i feel so tanky and a lot more consistent on dmg intake than in BDK
@orchid frigate

They are trash if so yep

strong forum
#

Healers preferring to heal bdk are masochists

still pagoda
#

like. If they can't heal a warrior in M+, then don't run it with them

orchid frigate
#

maybe its a long living prejudice that BDK doesnt need any healing

still pagoda
#

Healers preferring to heal bdk are masochists [2]

strong forum
#

Oh yes I too like my tanks hp to be a bouncy ball

still pagoda
#

maybe its a long living prejudice that BDK doesnt need any healing

We're not in MoP anymore

strong forum
#

And not know when he's actually in danger

orchid frigate
#

exactly karton

ionic fern
#

Idk, it depends.
I like to heal BDK's that know how to play.
YOu just need to keep an eye on their RP and you're fine.

#

If they have a full bar of RP then i won't even bother healing them.

#

🀷

orchid frigate
#

πŸ™‚

strong forum
#

I'd like to fiddle around with bdk but then I remember...

#

Echoes. Visions. Corruptions.

orchid frigate
#

bdk is fun to play tho

#

at least i think so πŸ™‚

upper violet
#

in legion it was very fun

#

now its kinda scuffed

strong forum
#

Everytime I've played bdk I just screamed 24/7 cuz everything is so slow, not my cup of tea

orchid frigate
#

leveled one at the end of legion but never had the chance to do anything with it

strong forum
#

Or I screamed in S1 cuz of how retardedly easy it was

orchid frigate
#

yeah, played mine a bit in S1

#

felt very easy indeed

#

then i shelved it till recently

#

mostly been blaying monk this expansion but now towards the end i tend to stick with my warrior

#

most fun for me

#

must say that BDK feels extremly easy in visions (or ive just gotten better at them)

#

speaking of visions, you can SR split personality?

strong forum
#

Na

#

Not as far as I know

#

Never tried

#

Wait, you mean the circle or the 1 thing chasing you

#

The circle thingy you can spell reflect yes

orchid frigate
#

sweet

sweet summit
#

you cant reflect the guy that chases you

orchid frigate
#

meant the guys that pops up in a circle around you

brisk ferry
#

you can reflect the circle of guys that stun you

orchid frigate
#

mhm

#

oh naowh changed to pandaren as well

brisk ferry
#

just watch for casts whiel you're trying to move through them, doesnt always end well

calm goblet
#

out of curiosity, how much haste % without into the fray is people running?

strong forum
#

39%ish

#

Is where I'm at

sweet summit
#

think im around there too

ionic fern
#

No idea..like..23?

#

Roughly..something between 20-25.

strong forum
#

Always knew mwahi was slow but damn.

#

😼

sweet summit
#

πŸ˜‚

echo bramble
#

Is there any advantage to playing pandaren?

strong forum
#

Double stats from food

sweet summit
#

less fall damage yep

orchid frigate
#

@echo bramble extra vers from food buff

strong forum
#

And a non DR stun

#

That's about it

calm goblet
#

Alright, ty

echo bramble
#

Okay, makes sense

ionic fern
#

Once you go panda you will start dying on anything else.
The fall damage reduction is stronk.

orchid frigate
#

yeah

#

would play female panda if it was a bit smaller

ionic fern
#

My Shaman's a panda.

#

πŸ‘

alpine stag
#

It seems that the big tanks like Naowh stacking Verse Amp also stil do rly good damage without TD, does the Verse amp with CnS major make up for the TD damage since they get to about 80% verse at times

amber siren
#

check pins

upper violet
#

skitra boots socketed

alpine stag
#

ah thanks

still pagoda
upper violet
#

r1 td raden pants

#

this luck is big bois

orchid frigate
still pagoda
#

Hawgz said i need more practice with TD

#

here it is

#

it's a +19 though

#

so i really need to go with no mistakes

orchid frigate
#

dont wall aggro

amber siren
#

monkaS

granite hedge
#

It is worth to use level 1 conflict and strife for M+?

sweet summit
#

if you dont have anything else ye

still pagoda
#

can old Legion jewelcrafting lockpicks open stuff in TD?

strong forum
#

If you literally have nothing, yes Velas

#

But sphere/lucid/aegis already are better at R1 than conflict R1

sweet summit
#

i doubt it, karton

still pagoda
#

same

strong forum
#

Conflicts power comes with r3

still pagoda
#

i doubt myslef

sick sentinel
#

One more reset and I get rank 3 CnS deswind

strong forum
#

Yes they can Karton

#

I'm using them

sweet summit
#

:o

still pagoda
sturdy dome
#

anyone tank like a pro

#

and can make anything possible

broken cedar
#

what's a good alternative for major in 10ish keys? Dont have rank 3 lucid yet

stiff oracle
#

VoP

#

dont bother with lucid in 10s

still pagoda
#

VoP is superior in this range

broken cedar
#

ty

potent bear
#

Hey, I have enough to buy two rank 3 essences from all available on my 455 prot warrior. Which two should I buy first for m+, 10-15's

warm plinth
#

What do you have right now?

potent bear
#

just rank1's

#

lucid / vop / rest rank1

warm plinth
#

I'd probably farm VoP normally with heroic/M+, and buy C&S and Lucid first

potent bear
#

rad ty

craggy vortex
#

Question about mythic shadhar, I was under the assumption I always take crush stacks. I get melted by dissolve, especially at 2 stacks. Should we focus on letting me get crushes and him take dissolve or should we just swap as on a what ever the first debuff to come out is?

strong forum
#

Your cotank can tank the boss 24/7 and you just intervene the crushes

#

That's 1 way to do it

craggy vortex
#

Ok, he is saying he is getting low on cds and runic power as the fight goes on? Should I ever take the boss at all?

amber siren
#

oh wow thats 2000iq ive never done it

craggy vortex
#

Ya lol same I never thought to intervene the crushes

strong forum
#

Well ofc can you help him out

#

Both of you have 2 taunts

#

So you can easily taunt swap for double dissolves properly

craggy vortex
#

Ok so maybe I'm an idiot but I can only reset taunt cd with a heroic leap right?

strong forum
#

Yes

potent bear
#

@warm plinth you rate lucid dreams rank3 is a big upgrade over r1?

#

is the leech and healing it provides big?

strong forum
#

So what you could do you be he taunts for the combo, you intervene the crushes (if crush is 3rd you just taunt it) and you take over after the combo

#

And just continue tanking the non combo stuff

craggy vortex
#

So I should tank him with the crush debuffs?

#

My co tank is insisting that I shouldn't tank with the crush debuffs cause hes gonna hit to hard

warm plinth
#

R2 is extended effect so

frail finch
#

Gentlemen, am I right saying HC Lingering Shell is better than Mythic Sigil of Warding?

amber siren
#

yes

strong forum
#

1 crush debuff is fine, if it's 2 crushes the DK can tank the boss

craggy vortex
#

Ok, so if I have 1 crush debuff that would be the best time to let the dk recover some resources?

strong forum
#

You just take all the crushes, he takes the dissolves, whoever has to take 2 of w/e debuff doesn't tank the boss

#

I would say

craggy vortex
#

Gotcha, so intervene first crush and taunt off for the second?

#

We were having issues with the crush/dissolve/crush rotation cause my taunt was on cd and heroic leap didnt finish in time

strong forum
#

You have 2 intervenes

craggy vortex
#

So that makes more sense

strong forum
#

So you can intervene both

craggy vortex
#

Awesome that makes way more sense

strong forum
#

It's if you want to taunt swap

#

You can intervene 1st, he keeps boss for dissolve you taunt for 2nd crush

#

He then taunts after crush

#

2 taunts

#

Full combo

#

If its dissolve crush dissolve you intervene crush, taunt after 2nd dissolve

#

Purrdy simple

craggy vortex
#

Ya that makes sense, never thought to use intervene there. Will make that way easier

steep bone
still pagoda
#

so much slacking from priest and hunter on last boss

steep bone
#

feelsbaldman

sweet summit
#

@steep bone ye big haste

#

id personally keep the rings you use atm tho

steep bone
#

@sweet summit which one should i replace then?

#

oh

sweet summit
#

KR is the vers heavy ring or?

steep bone
#

heavy haste

#

371/193 hast vers

sweet summit
#

hmm

still pagoda
#

KR is the vers heavy ring or?
@sweet summit

KR is the heavy haste

sweet summit
#

i see

still pagoda
sweet summit
#

ye fuck it, even bigger haste if you use the FH+WS ring

steep bone
#

giga

still pagoda
#

ye

#

and they give better stats overall

steep bone
#

28.3 into 29.5 base hast

still pagoda
#

though... I have +18ToS right now

#

guess it's an easy up

steep bone
#

maan

#

this week sucks for pugs on low keys

#

if you get 4bursting they're basically rioting

sick sentinel
#

platinum pummeler on skittish without rogue hunter for tricks/md can go die in fire

sweet summit
#

avatar>taunt>ss>tc>CoF and u good

still pagoda
#

^

#

i dunno how you can loose aggro on bosses

sweet summit
#

idk man, i tanked korgus for at least 5 seconds on one of the pulls πŸ‘€

warm plinth
#

You don't need a rogue or hunter for platinum pummeler. Just taunt on CD and spam heroic throw when you're kiting and it should be fine

still pagoda
#

^

sick sentinel
#

still have to start with charge SS right, it went straight for the healer basically

sour sonnet
#

would you guys run urchin over shell?

sweet summit
#

avatar>taunt>ss>tc>CoF kite+HT

#

i would not

#

darwin

sour sonnet
#

even with vers stacking?

grand drum
#

Use shell

sweet summit
#

even when vers stacking, vita still buffs you and your group by a large amount

#

but if you absolutely want to, sure use urchin

#

i cant stop you

strong forum
#

^

warm plinth
#

Not with that attitude you can't

sour sonnet
#

yea just trying to decide between shell/urchin + vita

sweet summit
#

both are solid, but shell has a clear ilvl advantage

#

and who does not like a big on demand absorb on a very short CD

sick sentinel
#

well, i got a 15 done this week, and bursting isn't fun

sweet summit
#

ayyy deswind

sick sentinel
#

gunna have to figure something else done for rest of week πŸ˜’

still pagoda
#

bursting is rather avoidable

sweet summit
#

just AMS yep

still pagoda
#

but lower keys...

#

man

#

they're hell anyway

sick sentinel
#

like, i got into 1 group last night, 14 WS "funrun", and we did everything good, just not enough time to kill final boss really.

#

and then shit hole group 14, ws again, where i had the aggro problem and it fell apart at 2nd

still pagoda
#

welcome to lower keys

sick sentinel
#

welcome to pugging

still pagoda
#

the higher you get, the better it becomes

#

but seriously

#

12-15 bracket is much harder than 19

sick sentinel
#

no, actually, it wasn't the final boss, the healer died 7 or 8 times on the entire run, and we basically had zero wipes until final

still pagoda
sick sentinel
#

Come shadowlands i'll actually be ready for M+ this time though

proven basalt
#

What's the minimum amount of Haste needed to get three back to back Shield Blocks?

sweet summit
#

~20% before ItF

#

like 20-23% i dont remember exactly what it is

proven basalt
#

Hmm, good starting point.

#

Thank you.

burnt night
#

hi, any tanks doing 18-20 keys playing over 40 corruption? is it manageable?

sweet summit
#

it is manageable

#

you have spell reflect for thing from beyond

strong forum
#

Doing all my keys above 40

sweet summit
#

storm bolt

strong forum
#

In the 20-23 range

#

And would play even in 25+

#

It really is a non issue if you're used to it.

sweet summit
#

the bigger issue is the slow, but as a warrior you have loads of mobility options and avatar clears the slow too

burnt night
#

storm bolt / spell reflect the thing and we gucci?

strong forum
#

Yes

prisma crane
#

i'd say it depends, and depends on comp as well

strong forum
#

Also 95/100 times Its not me that dying or fucking up

prisma crane
#

literally watched Naowh remove corruption because the slow cost him a key

strong forum
#

So I'm safe game, my group will fuck up way before tfb fucks the entire group over

burnt night
#

aha ok i see ! thank for the answer

prisma crane
#

at the end of the day i'd say it's preference, but i personally dont think the extra corruption outweighs the loss of control

burnt night
#

Yeah im going to try it for a bit and see how it feels.
Follow up question, im running TD R5 right now, i can add either a TD R1, IT R1 or surging R1 and stay below 60. ( Im waiting on versatile R2). What do you think would be best, im thinking IT or surging but i cant find any info on the uptime of that corruption.

strong forum
#

IT1

#

IT1 is the best corruption to fill

#

Followed by haste%/vers%

#

IT1 is 1 ppm, but can be incredibly handy and plays very well into AM and SR

burnt night
#

yeah i guess i also add an exp 3 i have laying around from when it was up

strong forum
#

But you can read up more in the pins for a little more indepth

burnt night
#

Ok yeah will definitly do that ! thanks

sick sentinel
#

so

#

crap, i think i have IFT 2 instead of 1

#

Not the end of the world

#

so, i think what the pin is saying is get TD any, IFT1/2 and then haste?

strong forum
#

generally yes

warm plinth
#

Specifically, IT1 x2

#

Not IT2, if possible

sick sentinel
#

okay, that's what i'm trying currently, might need to equip new sword with stats instead of proc though, since i got a 475 shield with like 53 mastery

#

and a proc that does 255 dps

primal dune
#

Boys I have finally hit rank 4 TD after the assault drop

#

It’s a 25 ilvl downgrade but 2 TD

still pagoda
#

worth it

sick sentinel
#

Anybody off the top of their head know how long between mandible slam casts on cara?

primal dune
#

Nah but it’s fairly long for a tank buster

strong forum
#

Like 13 seconds @sick sentinel

sweet summit
#

uhhhh 15 seconds iirc

strong forum
#

13-15

primal dune
#

Say 13

strong forum
#

You can reflect every 2nd cast

primal dune
#

14*

#

Why reflect the hit?

#

Healers need to pad too

strong forum
#

To... Reflect it?

primal dune
#

Can’t take all the glory with our rank 4 TDS

still pagoda
sick sentinel
#

Will that be enough time for it to fall off and solo tank fury?

primal dune
#

Normal swap is 2 stacks

#

So I would guess so

#

But I just checked the reflect table

#

It says slam is not reflectable

#

It’s only blockable

sick sentinel
#

You reflect the debuff application

#

Black scar

#

i think imma race change from tauren to BE

sweet summit
#

you sure its not a deflect?

primal dune
#

Ah that’s right

sweet summit
#

im pretty sure its a deflect

primal dune
#

Hit is not deflect

#

Debuff is

sick sentinel
#

Well meaning the debuff doesn’t apply

primal dune
#

Hang on

sick sentinel
#

I guess what I’m basically getting down to is our tank comp is prot/veng. If I can solo rank it then that’s great for adds

primal dune
#

If you run two prot

sick sentinel
#

Tank

sweet summit
#

yes admike

primal dune
#

Can’t you infinitely stack black scar damage on boss

sweet summit
#

but its a deflect

#

boss doesnt take damage or get debuff

primal dune
#

Ah

#

I can add this shit to the list of solo tankable bosses

sweet summit
#

with ineffable and a bit of rng

#

yeah

#

but thats my plan

primal dune
#

Managed a normal nzoth solo tank because the retard DH forgot he’s in dps spec

sweet summit
#

ineffable ravager solo tank carapace

limpid pawn
#

How do you handle the second psychus

primal dune
#

It’s normal

#

I just go down

sweet summit
#

have the havoc dh tank :^)

primal dune
#

Havoc was tanking the tentacle with leech

sweet summit
#

sounds about right

primal dune
#

He was 445

#

Not even that over geared

sweet summit
#

dumb spec

primal dune
#

He did die tho

#

Other dps stepped in with defensive

steep bone
#

Are there some tips&tricks gathered in one place about tanking M+ specifically as prot? I mean what's best to spell reflect, something like shield blocking tornado on sharkboss in fh etc, just general things that every begginer prot pleb like me should know to avoid stupid common mistakes

sweet summit
#

ye

steep bone
#

is there some weak aura for it :D?

sweet summit
#

the spreadsheet

primal dune
#

And block

sweet summit
#

there is not afaik

primal dune
#

None I’ve seen

steep bone
#

and that spreadsheet looks great thanks πŸ˜„

warm plinth
#

There is/was a WA for it but I don't think it's been updated in a long while

steep bone
#

I mean i could make one myself, pretty ez tho

primal dune
#

Also sheet is wrong about the maut abyss

steep bone
#

just tedious work

sweet summit
#

ye it hasnt worked since forever

primal dune
#

Spell reflection does not deflect the tick

#

But instead negates the effect of silence

sweet summit
#

thats even better

warm plinth
#

I mean

#

There's literally a log screenshot of it being deflected

primal dune
#

It could be out safest

warm plinth
primal dune
#

Dated

#

Deflection means you lose the shield

#

And I can guarantee you in H N and LFR you won’t lose the shield

sick sentinel
#

@limpid pawn what do you mean how do you handle aecond psychus

sweet summit
#

deflect means no negative effects on you, or the boss

warm plinth
#

Deflection means you reflect it but it doesn't affect the mob you reflected it from.

primal dune
#

And can do rotation normally

#

But you Lose the shield

#

You don’t now

sweet summit
#

pinky, how does that interact with the debuff on mythic

warm plinth
#

If you think it's wrong, you can tell Sense, but he tests all of these thoroughly

primal dune
#

Surely I’m not the only prot here who pops SR for abyss

warm plinth
#

I'm flattered that you think I've even been in a Mythic raid, ever Rosjen πŸ˜‚

sweet summit
#

i thought u were big gamer

sick sentinel
#

You wouldn’t think that if you saw our sky hold weekly no leaver

sweet summit
#

exactly

#

he played so well i thought he was big pumper

warm plinth
#

I am far from a big gamer. I just retain things

sick sentinel
#

Shiet I had to tank half the dungeon

warm plinth
#

I'm like

#

the perfect example of "Those who cannot do, teach"

sweet summit
#

so you're just retired and teaching the new generation?

sick sentinel
#

Ghash I tanked mythic on my dh yesterday. Why didn’t anyone tell me that as vengeance I just have to mash buttons and do 70k hps

warm plinth
#

To retire I think you have to have actually done the things to begin with

sick sentinel
#

I literally did not have to think for one single second

sweet summit
#

fair point

warm plinth
#

The only heroic raid I've done that wasn't me being boosted is heroic Ny'alotha. Though considering I have like...5 kills max of each boss, I don't think my parses are total garbage.

primal dune
#

My 1 button macro does more damage than myself for VDH

#

Makes me sad

sick sentinel
#

I found yesterday that ra den is juicy when you take that debuff at 1.3 mil hp

buoyant scroll
#

XDDDDDDDDDD

primal dune
#

Raden LFR gives you health instead of taking it

sweet summit
#

did you fall down?

sick sentinel
#

I did not

sweet summit
#

what a hero

primal dune
#

I stacked to 1.4M with TD4

sick sentinel
#

With iron bark I was able to out heal it

primal dune
#

Biggest pad

#

Shit I forgot to log it

#

Didn’t happen then fellas

buoyant scroll
#

Can somebody tell me why healer normally in hc cast all ther big cd before raden hits ?

warm plinth
primal dune
#

Cuz raid damage hits

#

They pop raid cool down

sick sentinel
#

If your healers are using any cds that heal you before ra den hits they are inting

primal dune
#

You get hit

buoyant scroll
#

and thats why pala hit ly on hands on the tank before debuff

sick sentinel
#

Yeah that’s inting

sweet summit
#

thats why you use the holy /cancelaura /sit macro

buoyant scroll
#

whats inting?

sick sentinel
#

Throwing

primal dune
#

Intentionally feeding

#

Int for short

sick sentinel
#

Bad play

buoyant scroll
#

isnt that only a thing in pvp πŸ˜„

primal dune
#

Nah bad play implies they did it wrong accidentally

sweet summit
#

onono

chilly brook
#

No you can intentionally throw a raid pull

primal dune
#

Int implies intention

sweet summit
#

ive inted quite a few times in pve

#

trust me

buoyant scroll
#

XD

#

i think i hit a bee hive with the question

sick sentinel
#

Most healers don’t use huge cds in the last phase anyway because I’m mythic it will kill people

primal dune
#

You know you dashed to someone with carapace add bomb

#

We all did

chilly brook
#

Also when you say before raden hits are you talking before the decaying strike or before a regular hit?

buoyant scroll
#

u guys using dash by cara?

primal dune
#

No the adds before cara

#

Does the pulsing time bomb thing that stuns everyone

buoyant scroll
#

ah makes sense

sick sentinel
#

If you don’t pull that whole room and intentionally murder your healers by standing non them are you even a tank

buoyant scroll
#

and no bc we ahve to pay 50k into the guildbank

primal dune
#

You just dash that shit into the raid and fuck them up with chain reaction

#

^^^

buoyant scroll
#

if guildleader or raidlead does ist everbody gets payed

chilly brook
#

Wut

sick sentinel
#

I would not last a day in that guild

primal dune
#

I’m both guild lead and raid lead

chilly brook
#

I'd be gone

buoyant scroll
#

yeah is a rule now

sick sentinel
#

I would be removed so quickly

chilly brook
#

That sounds stupid

#

Like actually so dumb

sick sentinel
#

However I instituted a policy that if you lose to my dh in damage you owe the gb 10k gold

buoyant scroll
#

well guildlead is the one that has ecces to guildbank if he deos it everbody gets a cut from the 50 k

sick sentinel
#

So now I actively try to kill people on reclears so they die and have to pay

buoyant scroll
#

XD

primal dune
#

When did this turn into woweconomy

sick sentinel
#

Faced vexiona add beam right at a hunter yesterday

#

Absolutely deleted him

#

Lost in dps

#

And he paid the price

buoyant scroll
#

i killed a shamen at 3 sec bfore pull

primal dune
#

It’s a hunter

wet fable
#

Message: [string "--[==[ Error in 'Ignore Pain Tracker':'cust..."]:12: attempt to index a nil value
Time: Thu Jun 4 19:05:53 2020
Count: 5
Stack: [string "--[==[ Error in 'Ignore Pain Tracker':'cust..."]:12: attempt to index a nil value
[string "--[==[ Error in 'Ignore Pain Tracker':'custom text' ]==] return function()

primal dune
#

They deserve that shit

buoyant scroll
#

and yes i think a stream is still out there

wet fable
#

Anyone know what this weakaura error can be?

wheat jasper
#

ask in the weakaurs discord

buoyant scroll
#

it exist such a discord

#

oh no

primal dune
#

We just know tank and spank man

wheat jasper
buoyant scroll
#

XDD

#

now get in there and share curropted wa s

primal dune
#

We sacrifice hunters to the old gods in exchange for twilight procs

buoyant scroll
#

just to see azeroth burn

primal dune
#

1 like = 1 prayer

sick sentinel
#

I have gotten to the point in this expansion where I am a raid affix, something the raid has to deal with

buoyant scroll
#

well is twilight still a must have

sick sentinel
#

You must avoid the Hawgz mechanic to kill the boss

primal dune
#

Do you want to have a damage parse that you wank to before bed every night?

buoyant scroll
#

yeah but u dont need twilight for that XD

sick sentinel
#

Uh

#

What

buoyant scroll
#

i mean just 15% dmg

sick sentinel
#

Yes you do lmao

primal dune
#

Where else are you going to pull15-20% of your current damage from

buoyant scroll
#

with rank 3

#

versa?

sick sentinel
#

No no no

buoyant scroll
#

i mean the bigger the pull the bigger the deep?

sick sentinel
#

In raid there is 0 excuse to ever run anything but twilight dev lol

#

TD6 ez

buoyant scroll
#

saw a monk his echoing void doing more dmg then my twilight at hiv

sick sentinel
#

Then you ain’t aiming it right

buoyant scroll
#

same level

#

no just didnt get more then 2 progs

sick sentinel
#

Unlucky then

warm plinth
#

I mean, EV does pretty good damage up to 6 targets

buoyant scroll
#

and these 2 where in times with no adds

warm plinth
#

But falls off after that

#

And it is a consistent area

sick sentinel
#

I am Dwayne the proc Johnson

primal dune
#

Say you get tier 9 verse corruption that gives you 36% extra verse

warm plinth
#

vs TD even when it procs it's going wherever it wants to go

sick sentinel
#

You are not going to convince me that vers% is better in raid

buoyant scroll
#

im talkong about rank 15

#

or 18

sick sentinel
#

Sure you’ll have some unlucky pulls

primal dune
#

Base verse is say 30% if you’re stacking for some reason

warm plinth
#

So just in case people don't know this

#

When it says 36% vers, it means whatever your current vers rating is, it gets increased by 36%

#

It doesn't mean you add 36% to whatever your character sheet says for vers

primal dune
#

That’s just extra 10%

buoyant scroll
#

yeah i know that

warm plinth
#

Just making sure. Like...no way vers comes close to competing with TD for damage

sick sentinel
#

Vers% in raid is beta I rest my case

buoyant scroll
#

i know that ther is a tiping point at which u gain more from versa then td

#

talking about m+

primal dune
#

With 60 corruption twilight can just obliterate

warm plinth
#

I mean, when? The reason tanks are using vers in M+ is because of survival, not because it does more damage.

sick sentinel
#

This conversation literally had nothing to do with m+ lmao you changed on me

buoyant scroll
#

yes = to more dmg

still pagoda
#

With 60 corruption twilight can just obliterate
@primal dune
It obliterates no matter your corruption rating

#

what matters is amount of stacked TD's

primal dune
#

Fact

still pagoda
#

don't be stupid]

warm plinth
#

It doesn't do more damage than TD; that is not why they're running it.

primal dune
#

No I mean 60 corruption worth of twilight

#

Compared to 60 corruption of verse

buoyant scroll
#

welll get 2 progs and die or get zero and survive with do u choose?

still pagoda
#

fuck... My second raid night as a DPS today

buoyant scroll
#

sry which

primal dune
#

I’m talking about dmg increase per corruption

sick sentinel
#

I pick the procs because I am not beta

still pagoda
sick sentinel
#

I will live and die by RNG

#

It is my destiny

still pagoda
#

welll get 2 progs and die or get zero and survive with do u choose?
@buoyant scroll

I pick procs cause no other corruption gives you enough damage to mitigate 60% of future incoming damage

primal dune
#

Your point is literally you die without verse

#

And we’re talking about pure dps

sick sentinel
#

You don’t die without vers either

still pagoda
#

Dying without vers in keys lower than 25

sick sentinel
#

I don’t push anything super high but 20-22 I run like 7% verse and pull like an absolute monkey

primal dune
#

Fortified shadow of zul would like to have a word

buoyant scroll
#

tyranical zul too

sick sentinel
#

Wut

still pagoda
#

WUT

sick sentinel
#

Tyrannical zul is buns

#

That is free zul

#

The real killer in tyr kr is spit gold

primal dune
#

I got a 17 KR I’m about to find out what tyrannical zul feels like

#

You fellas better not be ducking with me

still pagoda
#

The real killer in tyr kr is spit gold [2]

#

and axe

warm plinth
#

Yeah tyr spit gold is garbage af

still pagoda
#

but this is avoidable

#

^

primal dune
#

I was planning to walk in with some stacking verse just for zul

buoyant scroll
#

yeah one talent swap and spitting gold is free too

sick sentinel
#

Lol swapping talents to help a healer

warm plinth
#

Pfft

buoyant scroll
#

to help dds

sick sentinel
#

:omega lul:

warm plinth
#

I don't have a prot war tank so

#

No safeguard for me

buoyant scroll
#

and okay for all using last stand why not beast?

sick sentinel
#

What

buoyant scroll
still pagoda
buoyant scroll
#

sry

#

indomitable

#

if omegalul imaging choosing a talent to help a heal

warm plinth
#

Why would you run Indomitable?

sick sentinel
#

Because it’s terible compared to bolster

still pagoda
#

^

buoyant scroll
#

10% more td dmg XD

warm plinth
#

Bolster helps me survive. Safeguard helps others survive.

sick sentinel
#

And believe me ghash needs all the help he can get surviving

warm plinth
#

Listen Hawgz

primal dune
#

Of

warm plinth
#

I just kited too late

sick sentinel
#

Lmao

#

Absolutely deleted

primal dune
#

Imagine kiting late as prot

buoyant scroll
#

I just kited too late
@warm plinthfamouse last words

warm plinth
#

I'm pretty sure I went like

#

100 to 0 in 0 seconds

primal dune
#

If only we can gain large distance in a short period of time

#

If only

warm plinth
#

I literally said "Ok I'm gonna lea--"

#

dies

sick sentinel
#

In a 22 UR once I leapt into the middle of that back and got one shot from back crits lmao

warm plinth
#

lmao

sick sentinel
#

My healer was like

#

Excuse me

#

They were so far away no one else even got threat

#

Just a lil 10 second time reduction

buoyant scroll
#

so u hadnt had hots

primal dune
#

Remember that MDI run where tank was deleted by KR corridor add that spawns in

sick sentinel
#

Literally nothing makes me happier as a tank than getting one shot lmao it is the epitome of poor play

buoyant scroll
#

Literally nothing makes me happier as a tank than getting one shot lmao it is the epitome of poor play
@sick sentinel can u explain it a bit for me ?

pearl onyx
#

Hello, I have a question. So I went on Atal'dazar +15 recently and I couldn't survive Rezan's Serrated Teeth. What defensives should I keep to survive this? Thanks in advance

primal dune
#

Isn’t getting one shot the epitome of poor play for everything

unreal parrot
#

@pearl onyx Serrated Teeth is a bleed. Shield block does nothing against it (just mitigates the damage of further melees)

buoyant scroll
#

@pearl onyx shieldblock and ignore maybe pop a cd

sick sentinel
#

Since dps can play bad why can’t I sometimes

unreal parrot
#

Spam ignore pain, shield wall if shit hits the fan

primal dune
#

Communicate with healer to rotate CDs

sick sentinel
#

^^^^^

#

Always rotate cds on tyr AD

#

You should have one for almost every bleed at any meaningful key level

buoyant scroll
#

ignore pain for the bleed schieldblock for the harder hitting autoattacks

primal dune
#

If you died with at least one CD the healers garbage

#

Get another one

unreal parrot
#

If you wanna scrap the bottom of the barrel, last stand and rallying cry increase your health

sick sentinel
#

Oof ya hate to hear it

buoyant scroll
#

so fortified stealth guys in ad are 4 stacks survivabel at 22

unreal parrot
#

so that's something

#

@buoyant scroll if healer can dispel poison, sure, why not

pearl onyx
#

Okay guys thanks a lot. I guess maybe I wasn't using ignore pain enough

buoyant scroll
#

druid

unreal parrot
#

If not you're fucked

#

Druids can dispel poison

sick sentinel
#

@pearl onyx don’t neglect SB tho

warm plinth
sick sentinel
#

Cause tyr rezan will sneak up on you and whack you with those melees

pearl onyx
#

@sick sentinel im not, I try to get as much uptime on SB as I can

sick sentinel
#

Lmao did you take back melees @warm plinth I think you did

pearl onyx
#

But I guess for the bleed Ignore Pain should be spammed like crazy

sick sentinel
#

Need both

#

That’s why healer cds are important

buoyant scroll
#

and unbind devastation its useless XD

still pagoda
#

@warm plinth That's basically me

warm plinth
#

I don't think I did, but I was likely dead either way. I was at 22% before I even turned and still had the DoT

sick sentinel
#

Oh yeah you were dead no matter what

warm plinth
#

I need to get better about turning camera to leap instead of my character though because at some point I'm gonna end up dying that way πŸ˜‚

buoyant scroll
#

did u use spellreflect?

#

to give the first tik back?

limpid pawn
#

What level key was that?

sick sentinel
#

Lmao 15

#

That was the sky hold weekly no leaver

#

Tradition started last week

warm plinth
#

Yes I did @buoyant scroll

primal dune
#

Was gonna spam F but died on 15

sick sentinel
#

More important question ghash

unreal parrot
#

...I don't remember the last time I used Devastation

sick sentinel
#

DID WE WIPE

buoyant scroll
#

that the point to kite XD

warm plinth
#

We did not wipe

#

Because Hawgz is a pro kiter

unreal parrot
#

Please just make Devastator baseline, worthless talent

sick sentinel
#

who saved us

still pagoda
#

@sick sentinel US Skyhold weekly no leavers*

#

ehem

sick sentinel
#

Crankdaddy saved us

warm plinth
#

It's not our fault you're Russian Karton 😠

still pagoda
#

no EU no leavers yet

sick sentinel
#

Start it

warm plinth
#

Come NA and play with us

limpid pawn
#

Hm...

primal dune
#

What is this no leaves I’m hearing about

still pagoda
#

It's not our fault you're Russian Karton 😠
@warm plinth

IT'S NOT MY FAULT I'VE MOVED OVER TO EU ONLY WEEK AGO

warm plinth
#

πŸ˜‚

buoyant scroll
#

ehh yes ofc we all come to america right now

warm plinth
#

I mean

still pagoda
#

πŸ˜‚

warm plinth
#

I would wait

#

πŸ˜‚

still pagoda
#

Skyhold NA guild when

sick sentinel
#

Yeah I suggest coming to America after some time has passed

warm plinth
#

The worst part of that

buoyant scroll
#

u sure

primal dune
#

What is this no leaver and is it exactly as it sounds

still pagoda
#

yep 12/12M CE Class Discord

warm plinth
#

Was that I couldn't go into the portal after that

buoyant scroll
#

i want to help all these looters XD

sick sentinel
#

So I had to kite those adds for like 4 minutes

warm plinth
#

I was in combat as soon as I spawned; I even died on purpose to the tick pack and was still in combat

#

So they literally had to finish the pack without me

sick sentinel
#

Ez

#

I would run in, blur, eye beam, run out

warm plinth
#

lol

sick sentinel
#

Repeat in 30 seconds

#

Er 60

warm plinth
#

I'm ready for this week's when you guys get to see how many times we can wipe to me trying to heal bursting

sweet summit
#

when πŸ‘€

warm plinth
#

Idk, probably same time as last week

#

We're doing Shrine this week yep

sick sentinel
#

I’m gonna have to tank on my dh I think cause I have been slacking on gearing bear

#

And dh isn’t even really scuffed

proven vault
#

Is there a website that tells you how to tank each boss in the raid

warm plinth
#

Yeah you tanking on DH would be a crutch I think

sick sentinel
#

@proven vault

warm plinth
#

My druid badly needs essences though

primal dune
#

I have 1 hour 40 min 90 death shrine run

warm plinth
#

Like I think I'm gonna have to actually buy essences before corruptions on him

sick sentinel
#

Maybe I will bring my brewmaster

primal dune
#

@proven vault icy veins boss section

sweet summit
#

i timed a 15 on my 445 BrM last week yep not broken class

primal dune
#

Otherwise literally use common sense

sick sentinel
#

Hey my brew is 445 maybe I will do it

sweet summit
#

i believe deswind

still pagoda
#

i timed a 15 on my 445 BrM last week yep not broken class
@sweet summit

Did the same 2 weeks ago

#

#BrMisnotbroken

chilly brook
#

I mean it's not

#

The only thing about it that's broken is that it makes you want to fall asleep

halcyon jetty
#

Sup guys

sweet summit
#

hallo

halcyon jetty
#

Specced into prorection for the first time after years of fury

chilly brook
#

The answer is no

sweet summit
#

nice

chilly brook
#

:kappa

sweet summit
#

is he the prophet? πŸ‘€

still pagoda
halcyon jetty
#

Heard protection is pretty good in m+ rn

warm plinth
#

Prorection yep

sweet summit
#

it is

sick sentinel
#

Hate prot

#

Doesn’t heal

sweet summit
#

lee...

sick sentinel
primal dune
#

Does leech proc off twilight

sweet summit
#

no pepsihands

still pagoda
#

would redeem leech at leat partially

unreal parrot
#

I'm sitting over here with 13% vers

sweet summit
#

i have like 6% yep

strong forum
#

3%

unreal parrot
#

Thought it was in the prot channel for some reason since I have the other spec channels hidden

graceful pine
#

hey guys, just a quickie - what's the BiS azerite chest from the Vendor?

sweet summit
#

abyssal head+tank buster shoulders+mechanized chest

still pagoda
#

^

#

also Skitra shoulders are nice

graceful pine
#

awesome, thanks! Got Nzoth H helm and skitra shoulders, so will get mecha chest with my 20k!

still pagoda
#

also Ashvane chest

#

it's just superb

sweet summit
#

ashvane/vex chest is good yes

graceful pine
#

Ashvan is also considered one of the BiS for arms too right? Along with mecha

#

got 1x Mecha chasse atm

still pagoda
#

yes

sweet summit
#

mecha is generally slightly better

still pagoda
#

most arms mains run mecha chest though

#

^^

stiff oracle
#

does mecha have impassive?

sweet summit
#

nop

still pagoda
#

no

#

bulwark

stiff oracle
#

fug

sweet summit
#

longstrider/bulwark iirc

stiff oracle
#

that sucks

sweet summit
#

but S P E E D

stiff oracle
#

πŸ˜„

#

is this legion

#

speedsets in legion were so good

still pagoda
#

Ye

#

Just as avoidance stacking was a thing

#

πŸ˜‹

stiff oracle
#

my ele made it to rank 12 world

#

poggeres

sick sentinel
#

Out of 12?

#

Kek

sweet summit
#

doubleyou

stiff oracle
sick sentinel
#

Grats to your ele

stiff oracle
#

I mean

#

me on ele

#

but ye

upper violet
#

AAAAAAAH

#

killed nzoth in the 30 tank pug

#

coined the trinket

#

should i use it over scale

still pagoda
#

only if you're doing any 23+ keys and you really need one

upper violet
#

im doing like

#

15 max

still pagoda
#

then you don't need it

strong forum
#

ye thats hellouva waste in 15s

#

or really anything below 21

#

and even then its meh at best

upper violet
#

maybe if im with a healer pug ill try it

#

cuz u cant always trust these idiots

austere storm
#

Honestly, I always run it because I'm kind of new and it's a nice oh shit button to save my life

upper violet
#

exactly my thought

#

unless i play with the 1 healer i know

austere storm
#

The dps I'd gain by using scale instead is possibly substantial, but I just appreciate the oh shit button for mistakes made by either myself or the healer/dps

strong forum
#

how the fuck did my TD just crit for 1.1mil

#

when im only running TD5

#

??

sick sentinel
#

You love to see that

still pagoda
#

how the fuck did my TD just crit for 1.1mil
@strong forum

LS + stamina buff?

strong forum
#

LS, Shout and Priestbuff i guess

still pagoda
#

exactly

#

:D

strong forum
#

like im used to 1mil on DH

#

but on War thats new

sick sentinel
#

The fat meta td procs on dh are imba

sweet summit
#

did the hivemind changes go through already?

#

just saw my rank go from like 40 to 5 xd

strong forum
#

you mean wcl?

#

ye yesterday they did

sweet summit
#

yeah

sick sentinel
#

What was the change again

tame garden
#

They took more bosses off allstars

sweet summit
#

drest is off

tame garden
#

This tier is such a joke

strong forum
#

Kihra went full pepega and removed anything that could come close to padding

sweet summit
#

yeah

sick sentinel
#

Rip my psychus padpepsihands

sweet summit
#

idk why they're trying to save this tier

#

its already dead