#protection

1 messages · Page 2953 of 1

mild ore
#

so it's 2nd best next to nzoth helm

left hatch
#

mhm

mild ore
#

alright gotcha

carmine heron
#

meticulous scheming vs 2nd def crash for m+?

hallow phoenix
#

MS always

#

you only want one DC

strong forum
#

MS is one of the best traits you can get

#

thats not even a choice

carmine heron
#

pog

strong forum
#

imagine buying empowered proximity

nocturne nacelle
#

im new to tanking so im trying to find best tank for pve content esp high mythics that would not get boring and looks cool at the same time
going back in forth between prot war and blood dk. I also want something that will be good to carry into shadowlands

still pagoda
#

holy crap... @strong forum

#

is it really that bad on your server?

strong forum
#

no im just joking

#

yes thats how it is

still pagoda
#

142g on Gordunni-EU

#

better of buying out all dirt-cheap early BfA strength potions if so

#

118g for Superior battle potion of strength

#

early BfA stamina potion for 3g30s wadner

sharp night
#

oof

left hatch
#

hard to give you any input given that both "what wouldn't get boring" and what people consider "high mythics" is very subjective

#

personally i find BDK horribly boring and slow, while Prot Warrior and VDH are a ton of fun but thats just me

#

and for most people 'high keys' are like 12's while for others even 20 is low

#

if you're just looking to push up into the like 18 range (or anything lower than that) what class you pick has absolutely no bearing on your ability to push that high

#

if you want to break into the 20 range then you might want to steer clear of BDK

#

while its capable of the content its much more difficult and you have to work harder to complete it than the other classes

exotic spoke
#

Thats a pretty good summary Morrison

left hatch
#

and as for 'what can i bring in shadowlands'

#

theres no telling whats going to be good

#

tuning isn't finalized and wont be till late late beta. and were still missing so much info on the core workings of every class between soulbinds nad legendaries

vapid flare
#

Hello everyone, what minor essences should i use in mythic lower keys? Specifically, is it worth swapping dynamo lvl3 with C&S lvl2?

left hatch
#

dynamo isn't worth it till yo'ure close to the 20 range period

#

so it depends what your other options are

#

CnS doesn't really shine till 3

vapid flare
#

it still absorbs a ton of damage overall
i do have every other essences available with lvl 3 except CnS

left hatch
#

absorbs/hps is meaningless to your surviability

#

or rather its a next to meaningless metric given where our tankiness comes from

#

null is great in raids because of 2 reasons
its reliably consumed on cd, or almost on cd
and it does great st dps

#

in M+ such a low portion of the damage profile is magic damage, its so infrequently consumed, even on the more magic damage intensive dungeons like shrine that it ends up being dead slot for 90% of a key

vapid flare
#

well, i'm dpsing in raids and tank only in keys 17 and below 🙂

left hatch
#

and for the damage component, between it rarely being consumed, and it not scaling into aoe its just a weaker pick than the stat essences all around

#

until you get r3 CnS id go with VoP major, Sphere minor, Lucid Minor and SoTW

#

and once you get r3 on it swap it in for either Sphere, or SoTW depedning on if you need the resistance or not

vapid flare
#

until you get r3 CnS id go with VoP major, Sphere minor, Lucid Minor and SoTW
@left hatch pretty much what i use now, but dynamo instead of sphere. i was thinking about aegis tho

left hatch
#

aegis is as niche a pick as null

#

it seems great on paper, but unless you're constantly in combat with 6+ targets

#

its worse than the other options

#

and i mean CONSTANTLY like.. pulling mobs into boss fights

vapid flare
#

do sphere proc from bosses hits?

left hatch
#

yes

#

its just a constant 350+ haste

#

with 100% uptime

vapid flare
#

nice nice

#

i see now that honor farm payed for itself

#

thank you

left hatch
#

np

vapid flare
#

and another question, i have MH from wrathion, is its corruption good?

left hatch
#

its ok

#

if you have nothing else its passable but its no TD, GW or EV

river kettle
#

So CnS major is only really good in high keys with a lot of kiting correct?

left hatch
#

its not even good there

#

VoP is the superior pick until you get to around 23's and have a very coordinated premade and know how to use lucid

vapid flare
#

Well i have TD3 on a ring, but i have the same ring with truth lv2 which IMO makes gameplay smoother

left hatch
#

TD is infinitely more useful than Ineffable truth

#

the defensive benefit of IT is almost unnoticable unless you're specifically stacking it for SR memes

#

like using it so you have SR up for every reflect on rixxa or Lord Waycrest

vapid flare
#

the problem is TD+wration MH gives me 42 corruption and it's somewhat uncomfortable

left hatch
#

59 is perfectly safe

#

but in that case just cleanse wrath weapon

#

TD is your bis corruption bar none till you get into exceedingly high keys

vapid flare
#

nah i'll kill nzoth tomorrow and will have 39 corr 🙂

left hatch
#

or full clear a vision

vapid flare
#

did it already

left hatch
#

ah rip

vapid flare
#

the point is should i keep faralos corruption or replace it with smth? i have only 800 vers proc

left hatch
#

when it comes to corruption just sim yourself

#

the defensive benefit is negligible until you get to a point where you NEED stacking verse %'s and procs to survive one shots

#

which doesn't happen till like

#

23/24+

vapid flare
#

hm, ok i get it, i think faralos corr will result in more dps then

left hatch
#

in most cases yeh, but i like to double check myself

#

esp sicne the more resistance you get and options you have

#

the harder it becomes to give a confident answer

vapid flare
#

yeah
the same with trinkets?

left hatch
#

trinkets will almost always be some combo of Vita with Butchers Block, Rezan or Dragonscale

vapid flare
#

dont have vita

nocturne nacelle
#

best race for prot warrior?

vapid flare
#

kultiran?

wet fable
#

Tauren master race!

left hatch
#

racials have very little impact on your performance

#

so pick what you like best

neat rapids
#

they do

#

shadow meld wipe 😄

left hatch
#

technically DA dworfs and normal dworfs have a small edge because of the cleanse

#

and nelfs have meld if your entire group is running it, but thats become more or less irrelevent with awakened

neat rapids
#

huumaahns for more secondary stats

left hatch
#

on the horde side Belfs have an aoe cleanse, and the vulpura's racial is nice in higher M_'s

modern brook
#

aoe purgE*

left hatch
#

but yah outside of those utility examples the differences are pretty nonexistent

#

so pick what you like hte look of

nocturne nacelle
#

alliance only

neat rapids
#

I think human passive is pretty impactful on very high IL

vapid flare
#

trinkets will almost always be some combo of Vita with Butchers Block, Rezan or Dragonscale
@left hatch what about some on-use damage trinkets like merekhta, remote from mechagon or drestagath segment?

left hatch
#

remote bomb is shit because it has BFA damage split

#

fang is very strong but you can't block when you channel

#

so its a risky pick

#

for alliance, if you really wanna min max for keys the choice is dwarf or DI dwarf

neat rapids
#

what about the mechagnome self heal?

#

that one is actually good

left hatch
#

the passive racials are balanced

#

the difference in performance is very. very. small

neat rapids
#

its a 15% heal when you fall below 20% lol

left hatch
#

if you're falling below 20%

#

something is going horribly wrong

neat rapids
#

happens with current affixes

left hatch
#

happens with misplays*

neat rapids
#

well I only twink my prot warrior

#

huge shortage on tanks lol

#

its just that my main class cant tank

sick sentinel
#

guys would you downgrade a shield from 475>460 for one more td1? doing 20-22keys

left hatch
#

no

#

shield ilvl>all

nocturne nacelle
#

im really trying to learn everything about tanking and which tank is the best and which race to choose with said tank and go for high mythic cause every tank i see is hot garbage

neat rapids
#

race does barely matter compared to class lol

left hatch
#

^

#

like i said the only impactful racial differences

#

is utility

neat rapids
#

tanking with dh or warrior makes a big difference

left hatch
#

you wanna min max go dwarf for your cleanse that works on Bleeds and necrotic

neat rapids
#

you'll forget about it anyways if youre not a tryhard lol

#

my main is a shaman dwarf so I use it sometimes

left hatch
#

its a godsend in KR

nocturne nacelle
#

wait is dwarf or di dwarf than gonna be better

left hatch
#

or if you're lazy on necrotic week

neat rapids
#

lol literally doesnt matter

left hatch
#

pick what aesthetic you like more

nocturne nacelle
#

di dwarf lol

left hatch
#

stoneform and fireblood are functionally the same

neat rapids
#

I think its just that special case where fireblood increases parry chance haha

left hatch
#

fireblood gives mainstat not parry

neat rapids
#

funny to think about it

ionic fern
neat rapids
#

mainstat gives parry

#

afaik?

left hatch
#

no it doesn't...

#

it gives armor

#

parry is from crit

neat rapids
#

crit gave parry right?

#

I'm clueless

nocturne nacelle
#

prot war uses plate right lol

left hatch
#

yes lol

neat rapids
#

lol

#

what an odd question

left hatch
#

mighta been a classic boi

#

using mail till 40

nocturne nacelle
#

nope just a new boi

#

semi new

neat rapids
#

and use leather at 60

#

because itemization sucks lol

maiden ravine
#

You used leather until cata when they finally added the primary stat bonus to using only your armor type

sick sentinel
#

Best prot warrior tank you can get for horde is vulpera

hallow phoenix
#

cause of their 5% DR from first hit or cause of 8 extra bag slots?

sick sentinel
#

5% DR from first hits

#

prot warriors suffer majorly from that

#

and vulpera covers it

maiden ravine
#

I noticed that on my DK

#

it was crazy

hallow phoenix
#

yeah 8 extra slots is huge

#

pay to win game

maiden ravine
#

in a +10 UR on a 446 DK, Nose for Trouble was a flat 5% reduced damage overall

sick sentinel
#

What do you guys think is better. Massive amounts of haste with rank 4 TD or rank 5 TD

#

same corruption

#

amount

strong forum
#

TD5

sick sentinel
#

From a defensive and damage standpoint

strong forum
#

eh

sick sentinel
#

I was around 100% haste an entire dungeon with up to 150-200% haste with lust and procs

strong forum
#

too small of a difference to make a difference

sick sentinel
#

felt massive

strong forum
#

mh idk

still pagoda
#

vulpera this, vulpera that

#

for fuck sake, let me play dreanei on every char i make Pepexecute

tame garden
plucky cove
#

any MUST have Weak aura's for prot pala?

tame garden
#

Pala?

plucky cove
#

warr

#

lmao

#

my bad

sick sentinel
#

Must have weak auras depends on who you ask

lean arch
#

is ineffable truth worth caring about?

sick sentinel
#

It's pretty bad

#

for the amount of corruption it is

lean arch
#

12?

sick sentinel
#

a rank 3 is 35 corruption

lean arch
#

oh dman

#

and that's only 20% more reduction

sick sentinel
#

or is it 30

#

something like that

lean arch
#

is it decent for any war spec?

sick sentinel
#

still not good

#

no not that I know of

#

maybe arms?

neat rapids
#

Guys I'm not sure on what to take. I have a regular 465 belt and a 430 with twilight devastation rank 1. Should I use the corruption instead?

sick sentinel
#

if that's the first TD you got; I'd use it

neat rapids
#

The other corruption I can use with it is ineffable truth

#

On a 475 leg I got from chest

#

Meanwhile I still have a 415 shield

opal python
#

any prot warr on eu horde that wants to get hertz locker rn?

#

need gear and xp both!

sick sentinel
#

versa nav>force for me on patchwerk, patchwerk 5t and dungeon slice, still go for force?

#

Then use vers nav

cinder fractal
#

Been trying to farm 1h and shield from m0 so i can go from 400 > 430 for 2 weeks now, do shields not exist?

#

are shields a hoax by blizz

#

or something

#

I don't get it, I've even had shield wearer stacks

sick sentinel
#

make sure you are in prot spec

cinder fractal
#

4head

sick sentinel
#

You can also buy a shield

cinder fractal
#

players have the ability to, but no, i can't, i have no gold

sick sentinel
#

460 ilvl shields go for around 200k

#

ah I see

cinder fractal
#

can you craft decent shields?

sick sentinel
#

no shields can be crafted

neat rapids
#

you get a 440 shield from the first conquest choice

#

I already took the 2 handed axe sadly

mild ore
#

i heard visions are easier on prot, that true?

sick sentinel
#

no

#

Fury is the easiest

#

prot right behind it

neat rapids
#

prot is pretty easy compared to other classes yes

#

but not easier to other warrior spec

strong forum
#

prot is pretty easy

#

easier than other warrior specs id say

#

🙂

neat rapids
#

I main shaman and every vision feels awful

#

as prot I can just jump there and roflstomp

#

as ele I feel like I die to a breeze

strong forum
#

tanks have the easiest times apart from specific specs

#

like havoc, rogues, fire mage

mild ore
#

well im asking if prot is easier compared to dps specs

neat rapids
#

yes everyone knows dh's are retarded

sick sentinel
#

Fury is def the best

#

Things melt, you don't big pull in 5masks anyway

#

you self heal

strong forum
#

who doesnt big pull?

#

what

#

you pull half of a zone everytime

neat rapids
#

only except would be if you have multiple twilight devastation with your prot lol

strong forum
#

if not entire zone

sick sentinel
#

You definitely don't have to do that

#

and doing that is even worse in stormwind

strong forum
#

ive never done any vision as non prot, so i cant say if fury is better, but its incredibly fucking easy as tank

sick sentinel
#

Fury is def better lol

#

don't say prot is easy than something you don't know

#

You can do big pulls on fury also

#

you just need to

strong forum
#

sorry i didnt catch that, the some words seems to be blurred out

sick sentinel
#

just don't need to*

strong forum
#

people also say havoc is better than VDH

sick sentinel
#

It is better

distant crystal
strong forum
#

but i struggled way more as Havoc

distant crystal
#

welp

strong forum
#

like so much more

distant crystal
#

i've peaked

sick sentinel
#

Havoc is vastly easier

neat rapids
#

first socket?

strong forum
#

felt way slower

#

as VDH is just oneshot everything cuz nothing has HP, Havoc needs to giga spam

sick sentinel
#

🤔

strong forum
#

and can actually drop below 90% hp

sick sentinel
#

I think you're doing something wrong lmao

strong forum
#

idk fam, had a terrible time playing havoc

sick sentinel
#

I think that's a you thing

strong forum
#

shit can actually dmg you

polar thistle
strong forum
#

crit mastery though

#

rip

polar thistle
#

fuck if i care, i can use it for fury aswell

#

and for fury its decent

#

stats

strong forum
#

the evil word

#

get it out of here

polar thistle
#

fury or fuck?

mortal brook
#

'care'

strong forum
#

Fury

#

Fury is the evil word

neat rapids
#

fuck with fury

sick sentinel
#

smashburger

wintry pendant
#

Anyone run spark of inspiration to coordinate CDs with the group/is it worth losing a big surv/dps personal major?

#

In keys, that is.

mortal brook
#

it only boosts dmg based ones like cof, breath or memebeam, but wont amp minors/majors like cns that grant stat or do non-dmg effects. in general its not gonna pay off with how many ppl run non-dps majors like vop or memory

wintry pendant
#

I felt like a group wide 45% essence dmg boost seems good

#

Better to run with 3 memebeams and coordinate during non bursting/bolstering weeks?

mortal brook
#

maybe last season before corruptions took over for major dmg

wintry pendant
#

Fair

#

Aight, ty.

red sequoia
#

if i have 1 Reckless Flurry do i HAVE to run devestator?

mortal pond
#

Im having issues selecting the best essences for me

undone sun
#

no @red sequoia

#

RF doesn't directly increase deva's damage, people just run deva and rf together because they're both AA focused

red sequoia
#

ok, was just playing around with it and some people said yes and some said no. i guess pressing not having to use devastate would mean more AA, but im running a more dungeon centric build anyway

undone sun
#

you don't want to run deva in a dungeon

#

both RF and deva are ST focused builds, not exactly ideal for dungeons

red sequoia
#

yeah i figured, was just playing around with it, other traits arent exactly ideal on that ring

maiden ravine
#

Spark sounded great til corruptions

#

In theory it should be good to have at least a couple in a raid for the cdr and lining up big ones, but meh

#

Then they just gave us botd

onyx vessel
#

Formless void copy it use it as prot

#

🤔

sick sentinel
#

being over 40 is actually a trap this week

#

necrotic and bursting both proc thing from beyond

onyx vessel
#

Spell reflect it

sick sentinel
#

It's not that

#

2-3-4 of them

#

spawn

#

very frequently

onyx vessel
#

And hope you dont get them more then 25seconds

sick sentinel
#

you can't spell reflect 4 of them

onyx vessel
#

I died in a normal temple

#

Heart guardians got 3 things

#

Did 400k a peice

#

474 btw

#

I was kinda shocked that happened so i never run 40 corruption as prot

#

👀

south osprey
#

does expedient buff into the fray?

#

or is it a hard 15% cap

maiden ravine
#

It's all haste as far as I'm aware

sick sentinel
#

all sources

#

so enchants, gems

#

fray

cosmic canyon
#

is there any WA that shows current amount of mitigation?

#

that updates after each spell/debuff you make on your target?

#

real time?

#

:p maybe too much to ask for hehe

wicked orchid
#

I know there is a WA for warriors that shows how much damage can still be mitigated by Ignore pain

#

I'm not too sure about the spells/debuffs though.

modern brook
#

does expedient buff into the fray?
@south osprey into the fray is a multiplier not haste so I'm fairly sure it doesnt loop

mortal brook
#

only things that grant haste rating

#

so talents like into the fray, or racials that grant percentage of stat rather than rating, or like, heroism/lust, will not get amped

cosmic canyon
#

is this really accurate? afaik expedient buffs all sources

#

including 'static' ones like bl etc

mortal brook
#

lemme check actually

cosmic canyon
#

I don't want to contradict you, but i'm fairly certain when i did some testing on my hunt that it did work for all

mortal brook
#

good point actually, I'm just passing along what i was told. lemme throw on haste items and pop drums real quick

cosmic canyon
#

you can jsut take off all haste items and use drums too

mortal brook
#

yeh

#

okay so, ive got 21% haste amp on, so 25% drums should put my haste at, 31.25%?

#

looks like drums at least dont get amped

#

so likely other non-rating percentile boosts dont get amped

formal thunder
#

Quick question guys, I'm still learning prot and is the HPS for prots tied to IP usage or just based off of VR and essences/leech?

spare loom
#

is DPS important for a prot warrior?

mortal brook
#

ofc

flat jackal
#

Would you guys trade in surging vitality r3 for an extra TD r1 + gushing wounds?

#

For 22-24s

mortal brook
#

you'll find that hps for a prot war can come from all sorts of things, including IP, leech, leech from Memory major if you run it, and allllll sorts of other sources like azerite traits. but its not really the best metric for prot performance @formal thunder

formal thunder
#

Yeah I thought so

sick sentinel
#

I'd do the extra TD r1 and gushing

formal thunder
#

But for example in a run yday on 17KR I had like 12k hps

sick sentinel
#

necrotic week HPS will be significantly lower

formal thunder
#

my IP uptime was bad as well, but im not using any healing essences because its necrotic idk

#

yeah thats what i thought

sick sentinel
#

and healing essences?

#

What do you mean

formal thunder
#

I was running: Major: Everlasting, Minor: Aegis, Nullification and Vision

sick sentinel
#

YIKES

#

You don't ever use aegis on tyran, and barely ever on fort unless it's teeming week

#

Nullification is pretty bad in all dungeons

#

besides maybe ML

#

or ws

formal thunder
#

So Lucid instead of aegis?

sick sentinel
#

Yes

formal thunder
#

even green lucid lul?

sick sentinel
#

Do you not have CnS/

formal thunder
#

nah

sick sentinel
#

what about sphere

formal thunder
#

this char is like 2 week old

#

so i dont have any EP/pvp ones

sick sentinel
#

two weeks you could of got rank 2 CnS

#

🤔

mortal brook
#

its likely that VoP major will pay off best there in general. more SB more rage gen more clap

#

biggest problem with touch major is it comes with a dead minor slot

formal thunder
#

yeah i agree

mortal brook
#

not to mention giving up a major power like vop or others for a 'in case i die' that might not even happen or have happened if you had a stronger major

formal thunder
#

i prefer running vop

#

but yeah idk cheat death is nice since im still learning a lot of the mechanics and can get almost 1 shot in 18s

flat jackal
#

It’s a crutch

#

If you got 1 shot in an 18 that means you’re doing something wrong

#

Best change it to something else so you can adapt

amber siren
#

what tofu said, better to learn what you can pull safely while doing as much damage as you can than do less dps for the full dungeon and have your cheat death proc once when you overpulled

formal thunder
#

ye agree

#

gonna run more with vop today to see how it goes

cosmic canyon
#

well, isnt there an argument to be made that if you can tank more, and take more risk, you can pull bigger allowing others in your group to do more dps, clearing larger portions of the dungeon at a time: thus lowering the dungeon runtime?

#

not arguing against VoP here, but in general. Dealing more damage yourself isnt nessecarily the most optimal way to view things imo.

#

this is also an argument for Surging Vit > TD in some cases, no?

#

or stat procs in general

mortal brook
#

ofc. gonna depend on your group for sure. if you have more survival, its more downtime for the healer to do damage. If that extra healer downtime is more dmg than a TD, then yes

#

but what would the avg DR of a surging vit be, 2%ish? 800 vers for 5%ish dr with an uptime of 40~55%?

#

idk if thats significant enough healer dps potential to beat out a TD and a GW, but maybe?

cosmic canyon
#

800 vers should be 9%~~ in damage and half that in dr

#

no?

#

50% uptime, 35% corrupt

#

erhm 35*

mortal brook
#

okay so 4.5% DR with an uptime of about half. so safe to round to 3%ish average DR with good uptime

cosmic canyon
#

td3, 75

#

1x td3 =

mortal brook
#

oh, thought it was vit3 vs TD1GW1

#

if its like, full budget of TD's worth of vit, that's oodles of vit

cosmic canyon
#

well, dps/dr per corrupt i guess

mortal brook
#

but td is also oodles of dps

flat jackal
#

Right now I’m at r3 TD + vitality 3. Figured I’d cleanse the vita 3 for an extra TD1 + GW

mortal brook
#

TD4GW1 is no Thing next week 😮 hot

flat jackal
#

What??

mortal brook
#

should be at 40 this week

flat jackal
#

Yeah, but I’m done pushing for the week, so I think I’ll be set for next week

mortal brook
#

2 weeks from now, TD5GW1 without cascading!

distant crystal
#

TD6 in 3 weeks

flat jackal
#

Hell yes

distant crystal
#

gonna dual-wield n'zoth weaps as fury

#

also posting again for posterity

cosmic canyon
#

just did a expedience test on my main, BL/NOBL.

#

expedient6.

#

41% from the BL.

mortal brook
#

so drums no, bloodlust yes? wtf

distant crystal
#

huh?

#

lust/drums multiply by your haste rating

#

expedient adds to your haste rating

mortal brook
#

keen getting expedient haste from lust, but I tried drums with expedient and got no extra haste %

distant crystal
#

erm

#

expedient give rating from your existing rating

#

doesn't really interact with haste buffs like lust/drums

mortal brook
#

sure looks like they're getting more than 30% from lust there

distant crystal
#

that's because of the way lust works

#

with or without expedient

#

it's (1 + % from rating) * (1 + 30%)

#

the more rating you have the higher the total haste % will be

#

iirc

#

i did a lot of haste experimenting years ago when i was a haste stacking rsham in wrath :p

cosmic canyon
#

just saying, a lot changed from wotlk :p that's when i quit playing before coming back in bfa

mortal brook
#

lust stopped stacking like that when ppl were abusing power infusion in arena iirc

distant crystal
#

p sure it still stacks the same way it always has

sharp night
#

different sources of haste are multiplied, but expedient only affects rating

distant crystal
#

all of your rating combines for another %haste effect on your char

mortal brook
#

so lust gives 30% flat, plus 30% based on rating?

distant crystal
#

and expedient is just a modifier for your rating

sharp night
#

you can think of it that way sort of yes

#

but for a warrior for example

mortal brook
#

okay then expedient isnt affecting it

#

ish

sharp night
#

it's (1+rating%) * 1.15 (ITF) * 1.3(lust)

#

and then expedient fits into the rating portion

#

other haste buffs also multiply like last boss temple proc

cosmic canyon
#

this is nice info, thanks

distant crystal
#

1.344 * 1.3 = 1.747

#

math checks out 😄

#

guess you weren't standing near anything for ITF in that screenshot?

mortal brook
#

that was a shammy

distant crystal
#

ohh

daring bay
#

Whats the range for bursting?

#

12 yards?

distant crystal
#

much more

#

75 yds per wowhead

sharp night
#

life would be so easy if it were 12 yds lol

#

just leap away whenever something is about to die

strong forum
#

Lamo 12 would be so good

distant crystal
#

ranged dps would be bis

#

laughs in mage

#

there was a fleck of dust on the ground in front of you, enjoy shimmering to nowhere

hidden plaza
#

Stairs the true enemy of warriors and mages

flat jackal
#

“Path not found”

mortal brook
#

'id like to jump in wraith walk'

maiden ravine
#

Just go Revendreth next expansion

#

Teleport everywhere

ivory barn
#

Naw the teleport will cancel because there is a rock on the floor

rigid mist
#

can shield block blocking necrotic stacks?

sweet summit
#

nop

forest fern
#

you have to dodge or parry an attack i believe to negate a negative effect it would leave

halcyon nacelle
#

is masterful good for prot since you multiply the mastery gained from bastion?

#

as a 1 of

forest fern
#

block you are still getting "hit"

rigid mist
#

how to not get necrotic stacks as warrior? i mean i saw MDI warriors got less stacks

forest fern
#

i mean i guess if you used ravager and dropped it you wouldn't get stacks cause of the dodge rating adjust from it

#

otherwise kiting slightly out of range shrug

sweet summit
#

ravager is not good enough to replace AM

forest fern
#

well might be in the next expansion, but yes right now was just a theory for what he was asking, i doubt they are not using AM

rocky linden
#

Is it a safe assumption that for shields ilvl pretty much trumps anything?

sweet summit
#

yes

obtuse meadow
#

Hey guys why are we using conflict and strife as a major this week for M+?

strong forum
#

we arent

#

but the reason some people run it is for the root

#

every TC roots the target with CnS Major and grants you double vers off of CnS

still pagoda
#

unless you have assassination rogue, DK or someone else with roots stronger than 35%

strong forum
#

=30%

lofty widget
#

which trinket should i pair with the psychic shell, rezan at 465 or vita at 460, both socketed?

stiff oracle
#

Use rezan and vita

strong forum
#

Unless you absolutely need psychic shell, use rezan + vita

stiff oracle
#

I think its safe to assume people dont, but yeah. Unless youre doing 23s and higher you shouldnt need nzoth trinket

#

Probably not then either

sweet summit
#

👁️

stiff oracle
#

^

sick sentinel
#

Guys how do I force the first boss in shrine to cast the sea thingy? I tried to move out of his hitbox, sometimes it works, sometimes it melees the melees

finite bolt
#

is lucide dream good for major? insted of vission of perfection and what proc chance of it?

sweet summit
#

@sick sentinel it will only cast salt blast or whatever, if noone is in melee range

#

@finite bolt pins TL;DR - VoP is the best unless high keys and coordinated group

sick sentinel
#

@sweet summit ty

sweet summit
#

i think the rppm of vop is like 1 ish? peepostudy

autumn pendant
#

You think?

#

YOU THINK?

sweet summit
#

i do, sometimes

autumn pendant
#

Good

finite bolt
#

for wrathion that all was thinking more rage = more reset cd of avatar

#

on mythic

sweet summit
#

nah, never lucid major in raid

#

you take VoP or CoF major in raids

finite bolt
#

is there a way of siming a proc

#

or no

sweet summit
#

what do you mean?

#

you wanna see how much damage you get from a VoP proc?

strong forum
#

Lucid proc chance is 15% flat

#

It's only used as major for turtle gameplay in 22+ m+ keys

#

Vop is the best overall major essence

finite bolt
#

the cd rate of avatar and anger magnment

strong forum
#

Vop is 25% cdr

#

AM equals around to 50% cdr

finite bolt
#

tht more aint it?

strong forum
#

Vop proc rate is 0.952ppm

sweet summit
#

i was close

strong forum
#

Idk what you want to hear

#

Lucid is a 2min CD that let's you squeeze in 1 more avatar in those 2 minutes

finite bolt
#

if am is 50 cdr

#

in comprasion to vop

#

?

strong forum
#

No

#

It's 50% on average

#

If avatar is 1.5min CD, till take you 0.75 min to get avatar back up

#

With vop, Avatar is 1.2min CD

#

So with AM, it'll take you 0.6min on average to get avatar ready again

finite bolt
#

ty

still pagoda
#

Vop proc rate is 0.952ppm

Honestly, it feels like the whole 2ppm

ebon hound
#

feels

still pagoda
#

yeye

#

but still

autumn pendant
#

Do you feel it?

still pagoda
#

sometimes i get 2 back-to-back procs of VoP and other shenanigans

mortal brook
#

and other times you hit a 4 minute scarcity D:

#

rppm for ya

limpid flax
#

obvious answer I think but want to check before I strip corruption off my highest ilvl item... which corruption effect better? 1,275 haste for 4 sec proc, or ramping up 72 crit x 5 stacks x 30 secs? I assume the haste proc. both . cost 35 corruption

stiff oracle
#

I love me some crit this week

strong forum
#

Both come down to the same value over 1min

#

So it's really just haste vs crit

sick sentinel
#

deadly momentum uptime is basically %100

#

i tried racing pulse alot even tho it procs alot 4 secs is a low duration

#

it procs you get use 3 gcds and its gone

strong forum
#

racing pulse has roughly 30% uptime of 1260 haste

#

deadly momentum has 100% uptime on 360 crit

#

aka both have roughly same stats over the course of 1 minute

mild ore
#

does necrotic have an icd on application of some sort?

strong forum
#

no

#

but parry/dodge can prevent application

formal meadow
strong forum
#

ilvl

#

the mechagon bracers underperform on equal ilvl

mild ore
#

how's the uptime on surging vitality in m+

mortal brook
#

40~55%

#

bless rppm

wicked orchid
#

Is the Sigil of Warding off of Maut something I should go for?

mortal brook
#

no

#

LPS is the superior absorb trinket in most cases

#

nothing lines with sigil's cd in raid, and 2 minutes is a big heck in m+

wicked orchid
#

Ok, Thanks!

mortal brook
#

double dps will generally do better in most content anywho, esp things like vita. even defensively. big haste is big rage gen, sb uptime, anger management

wicked orchid
#

ah, ok, gotcha. Thanks again!

stoic zenith
#

if you want tanky trinks, the order right now is like LPS > codex > urchin everything else is trash

wicked orchid
#

Ok, thanks!

left hatch
#

at this point haste trinkets are tankier in most cases than urchin

#

and i don't think codex has been relevent for awhile

wicked orchid
#

What are some good haste trinkets I should go for?

left hatch
#

Vita>Rezan/Scale

wicked orchid
#

Ok, thanks!

left hatch
#

its a bit misleading to infer things like Vita are 'dps' trinkets

#

since at least legion stat trinkets are consistently some of our stronger options defensively

#

and they drop on the tank loot table

chilly brook
#

Well, tbh haste sims highest for my warrior

left hatch
#

right but like

#

vita is a general purpose trink

#

torment in a jar is a 'dps' trinket

chilly brook
#

Unfortunately its general trash on the one character I have it on :(

#

Literally dead trinket for my BrM

left hatch
#

lul the only tank allergic to haste

#

oof

chilly brook
#

Facts

mortal brook
#

bdk is half allergic

#

tbh

left hatch
#

at least its not a totally dead stat though

#

like... all monks get outta it is a faster ticking RJW

chilly brook
#

I thought blood liked haste cuz of rune regen

left hatch
#

since you can get more than enough brews from baseline haste

chilly brook
#

Honestly I hate bloodlust phase on fights on my BrM lmao

sick sentinel
#

I never noticed it when we lusted lmao

chilly brook
#

Having to refresh RJW way too soon

left hatch
#

lol everyone else is zooming and you're stuck in 1.5 GCD

sick sentinel
#

Press button same speed as normal fun class

left hatch
#

and don't forget having no use for OP

sick sentinel
#

Not like the chad prot warrior absolutely booty clapping

left hatch
#

the (or close to the best) trait for basically every class

sick sentinel
#

When lust is up I feel invincible

chilly brook
#

I'm looking forward to it not being necrotic

sick sentinel
#

Necrotic isn’t bad

#

It’s the combo with bursting that makes it ass

#

Neither is bad on its own

chilly brook
#

It's just annoying as BrM

sick sentinel
#

But together it is toxic

chilly brook
#

We have plenty of tools to deal with it

#

I just dont like it

sick sentinel
#

First problem, brm stinks

chilly brook
#

It feels bad when you start noticing your HP steadily drop after 10 stacks

sick sentinel
#

Second problem, I feel it

chilly brook
#

On bosses though it literally doesn't exist

sick sentinel
#

Yeah but tyr sucks anyway

chilly brook
#

True

sick sentinel
#

It’s a weird and unfun combo of affixes this week tbh - not super hard , but annoying and slow

chilly brook
#

Yep

#

I wanna pull big

#

But like I spend 80% of the time kiting if i do

sick sentinel
#

It’s good tho, I needed a week to chill lmao

#

I’ll run 3-4 keys on Monday and call it good for the week

tame garden
#

This is gear my alt week

sweet summit
#

same

#

im gearing a bear

#

lowkey fun tbh

still pagoda
#

i'm gearing my warrior and getting YEETed by bursting+necrotic

#

pretty painful, but doable

tame garden
#

Gearing my mw and watching others get yeeted

earnest mist
#

is there a place where one can discuss routes

#

as a new 15+ tank

flint tiger
#

Random question for you folks, has stoneform/fireblood always been able to remove necrotic?

earnest mist
#

or do I just ask here

sweet summit
#

@flint tiger afaik, yeah

#

@earnest mist whats up

mortal brook
#

Yes always

#

Dorf op

earnest mist
#

what's the best way to share a route I made here

#

idk if it makes sense to describe it bit by bit 😄

sweet summit
#

win+shift+s

earnest mist
#

idk if I'll have BL for both vol and yazma

stark scroll
#

That looks like the standard route

earnest mist
#

with this

#

like defo vol and rezan have BL here

#

but not sure about yazma

sweet summit
#

i usually stay away from the pack at the top left there. double bleedman is scary

earnest mist
#

at vol obelisk you mean

sweet summit
#

yeah

stark ruin
#

you should avoid pulling a double honor guard pack

rustic tinsel
#

With it being tyrannical I’d do that obi on boss

earnest mist
#

like dratnos' route for this week pulls the mid pack with two dinos

stark ruin
#

sacrifice someone if needed

earnest mist
#

which I really dont think as a good idea

rustic tinsel
#

Yazma spell queues long enough for you to drop stacks if you’re careful about it

sweet summit
#

middle pack is monkaS with necro AND bursting

stark ruin
#

pull the second pack on the left from the entrance as well

#

and the 2 mob pack should be pulled in the priestess' room

earnest mist
#

augur jugger confesor ye?

stark ruin
#

yes

rustic tinsel
#

Atal is just painful this week

sweet summit
stark ruin
#

atal is painful this season

rustic tinsel
#

You lose a lot of time trying to recover from bursting with saurids

stark ruin
#

well, this last 2 seasons

#

the void emissary at volkal was cancer too

rustic tinsel
#

Ah emissaries

#

How I don’t miss those

#

You’d have to be careful with the 6 pack this week

#

But yeah that route is basically what I’d do for atal on any non-teeming week

sweet summit
#

its ok, i have a holy pala for BoP to remove necrotic 👌

earnest mist
#

changed it

#

but still unsure whether I got BL for both vol and yazma

#

like this

sweet summit
#

volkal kills himself, if youre not sure if youre going to get hero back for yazma just hold it

earnest mist
#

I mean if we follow the route properly we should kinda have the idea right

#

and this just seems like it wont happen

stark ruin
#

it also depends o nthe dps

earnest mist
#

no way it's 10 mins between vol and yazma

stark ruin
#

if you kill volkal 3rd, you won't

rustic tinsel
#

If vol is the last wing you’re doing then yeah there’s very little chance

earnest mist
#

yeah

sweet summit
#

oh yeah thats a thing people do

earnest mist
#

volkal is third

stark ruin
#

you can start with volkal, do rezan then priestess

sweet summit
#

i do volkal 2nd peepostudy

#

if im not doing priestess first

stark ruin
#

I kinda like going priestess first

#

you get a big clapping pull early

sweet summit
#

so do i

#

yeah

rustic tinsel
#

Feels like your 2nd lust is always a pretty shitty value lust

stark ruin
#

and it's a nice change from the previous seasons

rustic tinsel
#

Whenever you go priestess

#

But I do the same

sweet summit
#

nah, you lust rezan

#

lust first pull->rezan->yazma

rustic tinsel
#

Ah that would make sense

sweet summit
#

ye just pull both packs at the left together, make sure one of the ranged players are at the safespot and its ez

earnest mist
#

lust first pull, then go priestess and then drop down to rezan?

tame garden
#

I'd rather lust volkaal

rustic tinsel
#

Yep

tame garden
#

Than a trash pack

#

This week

strong forum
#

i just did the fastest kick/interrupt in the world

earnest mist
#

I kinda would as well

rustic tinsel
#

What’s the key level

#

Is it a 15?

tame garden
#

Rezan - volkaal - yazma would be my preferred lusts

earnest mist
#

15 for now yeah but I am trying to figure out the dungeon for higher too

still pagoda
#

i just did the fastest kick/interrupt in the world
@strong forum wadner

earnest mist
#

@tame garden I am trying to make that work

#

check what I linked above

strong forum
#

ye i have a giga clip Karton

rustic tinsel
#

For a 15 I feel that your healer shouldn’t have issues keeping up with the volkaal damage

strong forum
#

thats a literal 0.001sec kick

#

you dont even see the castbar

still pagoda
#

holy crap

rustic tinsel
#

But I’m sure you can go vol’kaal -> rezan

still pagoda
#

calculated

sweet summit
#

WTF

strong forum
#

best kick in the world

#

big gamer here

#

ama

tame garden
#

You just do rezan first then clear trash til lust almost up and take a pillar to volkaal

#

Lust volkaal then clear rest of trash do priestess then lust yazma

rustic tinsel
#

I wish that double honor guard obi was just in a different place

still pagoda
#

^^ typical pugs won't understand this

earnest mist
#

@sweet summit regarding your screenshot, when do you do rezan?

sweet summit
#

1st

earnest mist
#

and then you come up to priestess?

still pagoda
#

do it Deswind MDI style

#

JUST DO IT

#

I don't myself

tame garden
#

Lul

rustic tinsel
tame garden
#

Manliest pull

undone sun
still pagoda
#

literally late Legion VotW pull reborn

earnest mist
#

is there no shortcut to add pulls on mdt btw

#

or am I missing sth here

strong forum
#

shift + click

#

adds the entire group

cold oxide
#

What are the best major and minor essences for prot ? my ilevel is 460

strong forum
#

vop major

#

cns/lucid/sphere/aegis minor

cold oxide
#

cns|?

sweet summit
#

VoP major for m+
CoF major for raids/visions

CnS/Lucid/Aegis(m+ or visions)/Sphere(m+/visions)/void(raids/m+)/warden(m+/visions)/null(raids) [VoP minor for raids if you have CoF major]

Pick 3 minors, only 1 corruption resistance one void>warden if you have someone with CoF major in the group

#

conflict and strife

cold oxide
#

i emean for mythic plus]

strong forum
#

yes

cold oxide
#

actualy i meant tospecificv

strong forum
#

i was specific

cold oxide
#

just checking

#

what does CNS stand for?

strong forum
#

conflict and strife is the strongest minor essence

#

^

#

thats cns

cold oxide
#

wow thank u

#

just took minute to digest it

#

my conflict is only rank 2 now

#

the worst

#

so isntead im using sphere

strong forum
#

thats fine

#

cns r2 to r3 is 60% increase in effectiveness

#

so get on that

plucky cove
#

anyone have the link to the list of spells able to reflect with spell reflect?

plucky cove
#

ty

undone sun
sick sentinel
#

Hey guys, is the sword from Wrathion ever worth it as Prot?

distant crystal
#

it's not the worst corruption

#

also not the best, just depends on what else you have for your budget

sick sentinel
#

It seems to me like it's a more expensive TWD which is also not as great as the worst rank TWD

strong forum
#

yes

mild ore
#

should IF be mandatory if i have a low ilvl shield

#

460

south spruce
#

Hey guys, when can I reset stacks on Gunker? Trying to figure out mechhagon with necrotic

sweet summit
#

not mandatory, no

#

just parry 4head

still pagoda
#

just pray for your DPS peeps

#

smh, i don't get many stacks on bosses

#

my 24% crit maybe...

south spruce
#

Mmm my crit is only 18%

#

Would there be a way to reset the stacks tho?

wooden radish
#

@ionic fern bonkcat

drifting wren
#

Hey! New to prot warrior, was checking out the guide resources, but it doesn't seem to specify the bis dungeon gear

still pagoda
#

BiS doesn't really exist

sweet summit
#

there is no bis anymore, go for ilvl

left hatch
#

almsot every boss you usually reset stacks naturally

#

either with parry or casting times

copper lion
#

any tips on how to kite the blood of the corruptor, it hits me so hard with the shit on the ground and tentacles dont seem to die fast enough

left hatch
#

you should be able to reset whenever he does his casting stuff +parrying

south spruce
#

@left hatch even with my crit chance?

left hatch
#

yah you shouldn't have an issue

#

the only kinda yikes bosses are ones with adds

#

like queen in TD

#

or last guy in KR

#

in those cases its a dps race to kill the adds before your stacks get too high

south spruce
#

so nothing I can really do with necrotic vs bosses

left hatch
#

shouldn't need to

#

like i said stacks reset naturally in ST

south spruce
#

alright mate

#

thanks for the advice

#

❤️

left hatch
#

anytime

strong forum
#

it really hurts

sweet summit
#

???????

strong forum
#

i have 470s with crit haste socket + expedient 3

#

so these are just inferior in every way

sweet summit
#

aahh

strong forum
#

really a shame

hallow phoenix
#

what if one day you have a setup where you can only squeeze in 15 corruption

#

but not 20

#

then you'll wish u kept them

strong forum
#

thatll take another 5 weeks

hallow phoenix
#

just u watch

still pagoda
sweet summit
#

how long have yep been a thing

strong forum
#

a couple months

#

oh you mean here

sweet summit
#

yup

strong forum
#

1day

#

idk

sweet summit
tribal knot
undone sun
sturdy valve
#

second deafening crash or second iron fortress?

strong forum
#

IF

ornate magnet
#

is Merektha's Fang good or nah?

#

for mythic +

strong forum
#

you cant block during its channel

#

so its not recommended to be used just randomly for dmg

#

it can pump in aoe

ornate magnet
#

ty

cobalt matrix
cosmic canyon
#

CnS for warriors, how does the root work? dimishing? break on minor hits?

strong forum
#

scroll up a bit

#

it never breaks

#

its a 1sec root

#

without DR

#

=30% slow will make targets immune to root

cosmic canyon
#

ty, too bad about the immune, mobs are often slowed more than 30%

still pagoda
#

The best way to kite is to bring good assassination rogue or frost mage to your group

#

Just get this extra slow to make things eligible

strong forum
#

na

#

thats inting

#

you wanna bring dmg

still pagoda
#

Heh

#

Ye

#

even though frost was god tier in 8.1

main shoal
#

got wrathion h sword is the corruption good?

still pagoda
strong forum
#

its mediocre

main shoal
#

F

#

should i just cleanse it?

sick sentinel
#

if you have better stuff sujre

last mason
#

anyone just have a simple cd wa for avatar

#

wago doesnt have any

strong forum
#

?

#

create it yourself

#

theres a very simple template

#

right ther

#

just add template spells CDs avbatar

lean arch
#

rumbling earth/stormbolt for m+?

strong forum
#

stormbotl

lean arch
#

are there certain dungeons where you take one over the other?

#

hm ok

sick sentinel
#

no

#

Hey what’s the name of the WA that auto marks trash packs?

#

Thank you!!

cinder fractal
#

I've noticed that ignore pain gets eaten up very quickly in m+, should I be taking lucid dreams if i find that to be the case?

strong forum
#

no

#

Ignore Pain is a rage dump

#

and dmg smoother

#

not your main midigation

#

unless youre talking Lucid Minor, that is very much useful

cinder fractal
#

no i meant major

strong forum
#

Major is only used in 22+ keys when you cant survive pulls otherwise

sick sentinel
#

more like 25s

#

lmao

cinder fractal
#

ok thanks

sick sentinel
#

lucid is buns

strong forum
#

or that even

#

giga high

#

only the highest of keys

cinder fractal
#

so for 25s or if playing with rshaman, got it

strong forum
#

i dont have issues with my rsham in my 21s

sick sentinel
#

rsham is fine

sharp lotus
#

Is warden minor favored over lucid minor due to corruption resistance?

sick sentinel
#

yes

#

if you need it

#

if you have a rdruid you can run formless

sharp lotus
#

would I run lucid with formless in that situation?

sick sentinel
#

CnS, sphere

#

last is corruption resistence

sharp lotus
#

thank you

formal meadow
#

rezan better then nzoth?

sick sentinel
#

If you know how to push your buttons and when to use the shell

#

shells better

#

but if you know you're going to forget to use it

#

I'd just use rezans

royal rune
#

@sick sentinel how much dmg can shell mitigate

#

800k?

#

I constantly use mine

#

Just not that sure how it works

sick sentinel
#

nowhere near 800k

#

it's like 300k

#

299k

strong forum
#

its 420k if your cloak is lvl 15 and youre inside a pillar / fighting a last boss

sick sentinel
#

but otherwise 300k

strong forum
#

^

royal rune
#

Fighting a last boss?

#

A pillar boss?

strong forum
#

in dungeons, the last boss counts as inside nylotha

royal rune
#

Oh

#

Do you take dmg as well while it mitigates

strong forum
#

20%

#

the trinket is insanely strong if paired with DRs

royal rune
#

Isnt sigil of warding better then?

sick sentinel
#

no

#

sigil is worse

strong forum
#

not by a long shot

sick sentinel
#

by far

strong forum
#

sigil is 2min CD for the same absorb

royal rune
#

Paired with dr?

#

Like if u IP?

sick sentinel
#

Damage reduction

#

Cd of sigil is booty

#

demo shout, IP

#

External

#

shield wall

#

Vers build

royal rune
#

It absorbs dmg post mitigation?

#

Post armour?

sick sentinel
#

yes

strong forum
#

most do

#

most shields do

royal rune
#

Vers build is good for 20+?

sick sentinel
#

not realy

strong forum
#

bit higher than that

royal rune
#

Ah

sick sentinel
#

Eh prob higher

#

it's never good to be exact

royal rune
#

I'm still trying to crack 20

#

So haste?

#

N td?

sick sentinel
#

TD will always be better

strong forum
#

haste all the way baby

sick sentinel
#

Again people who run verse builds have reasons for it

royal rune
#

Haste and?

sick sentinel
#

Crit for most situations, or verse

strong forum
#

only haste, really, avoid mastery get haste > vers=crit

sick sentinel
#

But always ilvl

strong forum
#

tbh

royal rune
#

Avoid mastery? Why

strong forum
#

cuz of bom

sick sentinel
#

No value to it cause of how much we get from bom

royal rune
#

Still worth running the combo mechagon trinkets tho right

strong forum
#

yes

#

cuz its mainly crit and haste

#

however they dont sim better for me without sockets, ill need a while for them to be useful over my crit haste + socket rings

sick sentinel
#

combo mechagon trinkets?

#

You mean rings

royal rune
#

Sorry rings

#

Yeah

sick sentinel
#

And prob won’t aim higher at lower ilvl

#

If you have corrupted rings

#

Or at all, haven’t tested tho

royal rune