#protection

1 messages ยท Page 2827 of 1

neon tangle
#

nor does "having to wait to press a button"

strong forum
#

for me it does

neon tangle
#

imaging having different opinions than me

#

yikes

analog zinc
marsh musk
#

Bonk

obtuse marsh
#

but can me staggered vel omegalul

#

be*

tame garden
analog zinc
#

welp time for pvp strats

#

just los every single cast behind a pillar

#

it recasts tho

#

so have fun ๐Ÿ™‚

marsh musk
#

How long does the lt live

distant crystal
#

prob gonna be hell on high tyr

sharp night
#

iirc they had just under 3m hp on a 10 key so they live decently long, for reference a void has that much on a 17 key or so right now

distant crystal
#

but you can have a dps immune taunt or something to give you a reset

#

or i guess you can run away to range it until your stacks drop to reset too

autumn pendant
#

Well only one who can immune taunt is pala or dh

sharp night
#

well the debuff shouldn't stack since it lasts 8s and cd is about 10, problem is just the sheer damage it does atm

distant crystal
#

i thought the whole mechanic was that it leaves a debuff that makes tankbuster do more dmg

#

are we talking about 4th boss mechagon right?

sharp night
#

no the new lieutenant in s4 affix

distant crystal
#

dohh

sharp night
#

hits protwarr for 500k every 10 sec and can't be blocked

#

on a 15 key

#

can los or range it but it just chain recasts until it lands apparently

sick sentinel
#

isnt there only 1 per dungeon

sharp night
#

yes

#

but you have to deal with it at some point

sick sentinel
#

doesnt seem that bad tbh

sharp night
#

on every key

#

500k is manageable

#

800k when you start pushing 20s isn't

sick sentinel
#

is 500k not even accounting for demo

#

you will obv want to save some personals and have externals avail. i guess if it lives a really long time it's not great

sharp night
#

it has 5m hp on a 15 iirc

sick sentinel
#

this is definitely not a shadow of zul in every dungeon tho

distant crystal
#

ilvl will help on the 20s tho eh

#

more armor/hp and healer throughput

#

might be able to do some rdruid bearform taunt pingpong shenanigans too

#

at the end

sick sentinel
#

The idea of a dangerous tank buster is appealing imo. You are phased into fighting these mobs alone

sharp night
#

healer doesn't matter if you get oneshot

#

i think it'll get adjusted before live

sick sentinel
#

I haven't fought the mob in question but it sounds like a lord waycrest dmg profile

sharp night
#

it's just a single hit that does 500k without cds on a 15 every 10 sec, not a dot or anything

potent anvil
#

He's not terrible. The debuff won't stack considering its 8s long and the cast is every 10s. His auto's didn't hurt as much before the debuff iirc. He spawns malicious growths that make a patch of purple stuff that slows and ticks dmg so you want to kill those so your tank can kite. His other ability is dark fury and deals aoe shadow dmg.

sick sentinel
#

is it more like 3rd boss in kr @potent anvil

potent anvil
#

Yeah pretty much, you can outrange breaker if you're 21+ yards.

#

But he'll recast it until it lands

#

And he stands still while doing it

warm plinth
#

So I guess if you're planning on moving him somewhere for a skip you can avoid it for a bit while you're doing that

sick sentinel
#

yikes. seems way overblown

potent anvil
#

The fear obelisk add is kinda annoying too. He spawns adds that apply a stacking bleed. But they die pretty quick so meh.

warm plinth
#

Just dwarf it off 4head

empty nacelle
#

I mean what are the chances you just skip it and do it with the final boss?

#

The tank buster

#

On a dungeon like tos where you have a central pillar

potent anvil
#

I dunno where all the specific obelisks are located, so it depends. But dunno if it's feasible to do so, 100% increased dmg taken from all sources seem kind of spooky to deal with.

distant crystal
#

just skip it and fight it with the last boss deswind

potent anvil
#

And it's not just that, he'll spawn purple puddles that deal ticking dmg and apply a 65% slow.

empty nacelle
#

I mean Is it not possible to just los the casts in that room? Or am I being retarded

toxic gyro
#

You guys panicking, with some gear and Stan buff we will have like 700k hp, and you can double ignore pain, spell reflect for 20%dr,demo , or call for external

distant crystal
#

it's physical

random urchin
#

You canโ€™t reflect it

distant crystal
#

but otherwise ye

potent anvil
#

No one is panicking, at least I don't think. But most people are looking at it pre-mitigated (via DR/personals/externals).

broken isle
#

Defensive trinkets

distant crystal
#

it's gonna be a slapper for sure but it'll be manageable

#

gonna be way easier for other tanks tho, but we can't be the best at everything

#

๐Ÿ™‚

broken isle
#

just thinking of ways to cheese it atm

potent anvil
#

With current ilvl (450~) and doing a 13 key on ptr, it drops me to like 30%~ health with demo shout.

random urchin
#

Can these lieutenants be cc/knockback? I havenโ€™t paid too much attention to what they are susceptible to

distant crystal
#

i'm sure they can't be cc'd

#

maybe ring/phoon tho

random urchin
#

I figured no stuns. Yeah was wondering about ring/thunder/typhoon

distant crystal
#

MDI needs an all-stars game

#

for funsies with all of the seasonal affixes

#

change my mind

#

infested/reaping/beguiling/fortified

broken isle
#

Sounds fun to watch

potent anvil
#

Inb4 1 hour+ long keys.

distant crystal
#

viewers vote for the allstar healer/dps/tanks

#

top 2 healers/tanks go to teams, top 6 dps

#

put some minor prize in there so the players actually try

tame garden
#

Infested+beguiling yikes

strong forum
#

enchanted + reaping

distant crystal
#

they might need to manually make sure there's no tides + infested packs

#

:p

tame garden
#

Melee taunt tides away, cc infested mob like s1

#

Just cant sap

sullen valve
#

Daily reminder i hope you all had a good holiday and wowA is amazing :)

distant crystal
sullen valve
tame garden
mortal brook
brittle owl
sick sentinel
distant crystal
#

what have i done

#

we're turning into the guardian discord

tame garden
#

๐Ÿป ๐Ÿ‘

sick sentinel
#

Donโ€™t say that

#

The guardian discord has no will to live

#

We still have a glimmer

tame garden
brittle owl
#

no glimmer is a holy paladin ability

#

u lose kthxbai

chilly brook
#

We also are mildly helpful

tame garden
#

What you trying to say

chilly brook
#

That the guardian discord is dead

#

And not helpful

tame garden
#

Fake news

#

Its about as active as this chat

chilly brook
#

I don't trust bears

oblique garnet
#

Wdym you guys are very helpful ๐Ÿ™‚ Hardly ever the SF have to intervene

manic scaffold
#

which azerite trait do i wanna stack

distant crystal
#

bom

manic scaffold
#

ok

#

ty

distant crystal
#

or bfi/rf if you're trying to parse st

#

but bom is always a good choice

sick sentinel
#

Brace for my impact

warm plinth
#

And trust me

#

Elitism hits hard

unkempt condor
#

has anyone been setting up a BiS prot gearlist for nyalotha raiding?

oblique garnet
#

@ionic fern maybe

analog zinc
#

@unkempt condor i have, gimme a min to bring it up

sick sentinel
#

BiS prot gear list includes a helmet, shoulders, and chest. As well as a neat new cape

graceful linden
#

We still capping 20-22% haste next season? Iโ€™m speaking mostly for mythic plus

strong forum
#

nobody is capping haste at those levels

analog zinc
#

^^

strong forum
#

that has been a bad recommendation ever since people started to think its a cap

unkempt condor
#

@analog zinc i requested access to your spreadsheet

analog zinc
#

how do i allow access

strong forum
#

you want those levels MINIMUM but thats about it

#

no cap at all

#

you want as much haste as you can get

unkempt condor
#

i've been on 13% haste and had no issues so far

strong forum
#

thats really low

#

might wanna work on that

unkempt condor
#

waiting on 8.3 to start farming again

strong forum
#

the only thing that 20-22% haste allows you is chaining 3x SB

analog zinc
unkempt condor
#

no point in farming now as the ilvl will go up anyway

strong forum
#

obv

graceful linden
#

All top warriors are stacking crit, since season 2 though

strong forum
#

that has nothing to do with haste

warm plinth
#

I mean, you have more than 13% once ITF comes into it though

unkempt condor
#

@analog zinc thanks man, now I can compare to mine ๐Ÿ™‚

analog zinc
#

people stack crit?

unkempt condor
#

crit builds are fun, but you're sacrificing either haste or vers for it

strong forum
#

the 20-22% meme has started with streamers saying that, because it allows you to chain 3x SB, while crit gains value if you reach that point, its by NO MEANS a cap

analog zinc
#

the only cap prot war has

strong forum
#

people are at that point more crit oriented for dmg output and parry

#

but calling it a cap is wrong

analog zinc
#

is 2199 mastery

#

giving you 100% crit block chance during avatar with triple bastion

strong forum
#

you want to aim to have 20-22% minimum, not cap it there

unkempt condor
#

so you want to stack haste on your haste?

strong forum
#

generally yes

#

since haste works so well with AM

unkempt condor
#

i should really look into getting more sockets

tame garden
#

๐Ÿ™‚

#

Easier said than done

analog zinc
#

i have 2 sockets on this char ๐Ÿ˜ฎ

unkempt condor
#

same here

strong forum
#

2 sockets but 1.8k haste chad

#

ama

analog zinc
#

i have 1673 haste with 2 sockets

unkempt condor
#

ouch, 851 haste here

#

at ilvl 438

warm plinth
#

I have 1510 haste. Only one socket, which has my 120 str gem

#

But I also have 1468 crit so I'm okay with it ๐Ÿ˜„

unkempt condor
#

damn

#

guess i'll be swapping my rings to haste/... instead of vers/mastery

warm plinth
#

You should use your highest ilevel, whatever that gives you. Remember you have ITF giving you haste too

strong forum
#

not having haste on rings is a sin

warm plinth
#

But yeah, I'd drop like 5-10 ilevels on a ring if it was like a haste ring vs a no haste ring

strong forum
#

i personally wouldnt use a non haste 455 over a 410 with haste

#

lowkey

tame garden
#

Same

#

Screw math all about the feels

warm plinth
#

Listen guys

#

Ily

tame garden
#

More haste = more fun

strong forum
#

i just think being at subpar haste levels hurts more than having mastery vers

#

but hey

analog zinc
#

do wars use strength gems?

strong forum
#

yes

analog zinc
#

aight i'll slot one in next time i'm on

#

been using full haste

unkempt condor
#

I have 430 rings now, would it be better to get the crafted rings from rustbolt?

#

420 but i think guaranteed socket

analog zinc
#

prolly

#

if its 420 haste socket

strong forum
#

yes the socket + haste makes it giga worth

#

and it can titanforge too

oblique garnet
#

imagine not having 9 sockets ๐Ÿ™‚

unkempt condor
#

alright, just went up to 1409 haste lol

#

did sacrifice 11% mastery

warm plinth
#

That's what Bastion is for

strong forum
#

mastery is our worst stat

#

cuz of bastion

analog swift
#

man i can't wait to go back to warrior

#

such a fun tool kit for tank plus big damage

short temple
#

how many ilvls are Defening clash worth?

analog swift
#

15~ on your first

warm plinth
#

15ish

#

Why aren't you playing warrior Danger?

analog swift
#

zero on your second

#

swapped to monk for my guild (was gm/rl at the time) and we didn't have one

#

had to regrind all the essences like week 3

warm plinth
#

Oh

analog swift
#

also i felt monk was better in high keys this season tbh

#

one i first ring of peaced out a tide i felt like such a fucking god

warm plinth
#

How'd you do score-wise?

analog swift
#

monk got to 2686~

warm plinth
#

Nice

analog swift
#

yeah

#

thanks bb

#

was 2.3K last season from full pugging on the warrior

#

probs should have stayed warrior, legit in the first 3 weeks, got a 440 socketed shield, 440 weapon, 445 socketed pants and 440 socketed belt

warm plinth
#

I was pretty proud of myself this season. Only 2103 but it's the highest I've ever been by a long shot. Love having a stable group

analog swift
#

that's awesome man

warm plinth
#

That was my warrior lol!

analog swift
#

yeah i ended up pugging one key trying to get 2.7K and timed a 21 AD

#

but the feeling doing it w/ randos vs. doing it w/ a group is completely different

warm plinth
#

Literally 445 shield first cache, 440 wep 2nd cache, got a 445 rezan not long ago, 445 recal card. So silly and not even what I play ๐Ÿ˜ญ

analog swift
#

LOL

#

oh yeah 430 socketed gore crusted first week LOL

#

but yeah like we always timed 20 underrots

warm plinth
#

The fuckin alt luck man

analog swift
#

and last push week

warm plinth
#

We've only timed one 19 so far, but we also basically missed the last push week ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

analog swift
#

we got a 20 frehold then failed the 21 underrot, then 20 freehold timed it and did the 21 and it was our first 21 and it was just so awesome

#

RIP

warm plinth
#

My tank was out of town the first half and I was out of town the 2nd half

analog swift
#

because that feeling of fucking up a key knowing exactly what you did wrong and then fixing it

warm plinth
#

Yep. We actually got the luckiest 20 we could have gotten lol

#

We did 19 UR and got a 20 FH

#

Missed timer on the FH by 5 mins which I think is pretty good for our first one ever

analog swift
#

yeah absolutely

#

i think our first 20 was an underrot as well, that has quickly turned into the easiest dungeon

#

i think also it's pretty much the same each week

warm plinth
#

Yeah we're always really happy to get Underrot

analog swift
#

regaridng of beguilign or affixes

#

so we got tons of practice

#

actually a 20 KR was our proudest key

warm plinth
#

Oh damn

analog swift
#

so clean, zul skip all that jazz

warm plinth
#

We've only timed a 16 KR and AD LUL

analog swift
#

LOL

warm plinth
#

But mostly because we just never get them tbh

analog swift
#

yeah, we got really unlucky a few times

#

the last push week

warm plinth
#

We got a lot of KRs this week but well, it's this week

analog swift
#

we legit had 3 fuckign shrines

#

yeah

warm plinth
#

We ended up just doing a 19 FH and calling it

analog swift
#

that's one thing i don't like about beguiling

#

it nullifies 1/3 weeks

warm plinth
#

Yeah, and sometimes it's on weeks that are otherwise not bad

analog swift
#

yeah we tried a 20 td (one of our last 20s) and scuffed it twice

#

yeah

#

like raging necrotic

#

normally good week

warm plinth
#

Yep

analog swift
#

then void

#

void also with necrotic

#

is fucking evil

warm plinth
#

It's okay though because we got FIFTEEN DAYS

analog swift
#

I KNOW

warm plinth
#

And then beguiling can fuck off forever

analog swift
#

i like beguiling just not void

#

like enchanted and tides are fun

warm plinth
#

Yeah, I don't mind beguiling. It was interesting but I won't miss it

analog swift
#

take strategy

#

easy counterable

#

like

#

void would be interesting, at least kind of, if the damage was removed by like

#

a quarter

warm plinth
#

Voids would've been a little more tolerable if they didn't have so much fuckin HP

analog swift
#

it still fucks up your shroud

warm plinth
#

Or yeah the damage could just be reduced a bit

analog swift
#

it also shouldn't be the most deadly

#

or better yet

#

enchanted sees stealth

#

that would be balanced

#

also as dratnos said at one point

#

they put voids in packs that are skipped

#

WHICH ARE ALREADY THE HARDEST PACKS

#

THATS WHY THEY ARE SKIPPED

warm plinth
#

yeah it's super weird because some dungeons you can damn near skipe very void

#

skip every*

#

Like FH on void week you do what, 3 voids maybe?

#

The start, the one by Harlan, and the one before harlan

analog swift
#

yeah

tame garden
#

Void in front of volkaal proves that no1 at blizz plays the game

analog swift
#

yep

#

or

#

fucking

#

void

#

in with dervishes

#

with quaking

#

WTF

tame garden
#

Lmao

autumn pendant
#

Pack before volkaal is literally hellspawn

analog swift
#

it was THIS close to being in there during teeming quaking

tame garden
#

Or how about

analog swift
#

at least you CAN deathskip

#

you have to kill the dervishes

tame garden
#

Void with windspeaker heldis on BOLSTERING so you cant even do the smallies separately

analog swift
#

oh yeah

#

fucking

#

EVIL

tame garden
#

Cant burn void cuz then you'll bolster. Have to pull smallies away from heldis, kill out of bolstering range, kill her, deal with void

#

Basically forced to just death skip it

toxic gyro
#

Or have Druid mass root smallness, and you deal with them and void after heldis is dead

#

You can also skip that pack without dying but itโ€™s a bit tricky

warm plinth
#

Can you? With the void there?

strong forum
#

what does void have to do with the smallies being rooted

#

just run tf away

distant crystal
#

void is to the left isn't it?

#

you can shroud right

#

or if void is to the right, you can do the mount hop thing

strong forum
#

void is on left

tame garden
#

It's to the left

strong forum
#

afaik

distant crystal
#

unless it's impossible to pull smallies w/o aggroing void

#

but shroud right will work then

tame garden
#

Pulling smallies does pull the void

distant crystal
#

it's just that you usually want shroud for runecarver

tame garden
#

Which pulls heldis

distant crystal
#

but 2 rogues works

tame garden
#

Yeah if you have 2 rogues

#

๐Ÿ˜ญ

distant crystal
#

could also invis pot it :p

tame garden
#

But them I'm stuck doing runecarver

#

Better off just deathskipping it all

distant crystal
#

man the no-death "tank riding druid" thing is so cool in that dungeon

#

it's ridiculously easy to pull off

warm plinth
#

Where do you stop for that?

#

Also pretty sure any 2 seater works; you don't have to ride your friend you sicko

#

๐Ÿ˜

distant crystal
#

rocket works

#

prob yak/mammoth too

#

but why when you can ride ur frens

tame garden
#

Exploiting Pepexecute

distant crystal
#

people snap in MDI :p

tame garden
#

Ban them all

warm plinth
#

Where's the spot that you stop though?

distant crystal
#

it's where the stairs form a point

tame garden
#

Top of the bridge

distant crystal
#

if you're asking me

#

you dip to that spot to make them evade then haul ass to top of stairs

tame garden
#

The snap is on the stairs ye

distant crystal
#

if anyone fucked up and didn't drop combat, they run down to die

#

for some reason our hpal kept combat 2nd time we did it

#

first time we all dropped

#

if you're slow to get up the ramp is when it can happen

#

i think it's like 10-15 seconds after the evade that you need to be clear of the mobs

tame garden
#

Idk I'm fine with snapping to group a pull but evade bugging to skip is iffy

distant crystal
#

both shouldn't be a thing tbh

warm plinth
#

It's still so crazy to go from them fixing a snap in Legion to letting it have free reign in BFA

distant crystal
#

along with the healer/ranged getting somewhere unpathable to make a trash ability not happenn

tame garden
#

What did they fix in legion

warm plinth
#

The cats in DHT

tame garden
#

Ah

#

Did wolves in HoV ever get fix

warm plinth
#

The thing in the water? I don't think so

tame garden
#

Where youd go in the water and they'd leap to the bottom

chilly brook
#

@warm plinth tbh I put it down to them not knowing what they want or just simply not caring

warm plinth
#

But it wasn't widely known til toward the end iirc

#

So they probably didn't care

chilly brook
#

My money is on the second

warm plinth
#

Probably Griff

#

Later on they'll scold us for it

#

and ban people

#

Because they're super consistent

chilly brook
#

Especially since BfA hasn't been their most popular xpac I think they're staying away from rocking the boat too much on m+

#

But that's just me

#

Sooo

#

Got an hour and a half left on my shift, all my work is done and I have my switch....

toxic gyro
#

Iโ€™m scared of kr in 8.3... they fixed dh skip, nerfed some abilities but didnโ€™t nerf shadow of zul...

tame garden
#

6% hp

chilly brook
#

I mean

#

Our hp pool is gonna go up a decent amount too

tame garden
#

Not as much as his damage

random urchin
#

Our hp pool going up doesnโ€™t really matter

distant crystal
#

it's not going up more than M+ dmg scales

random urchin
#

His dmg is going up by a base 45% lol

#

Itโ€™s gonna hurt

toxic gyro
#

His dmg will go up too...

tame garden
#

Back to lusting him I suppose

distant crystal
#

maybe healer throughput will outpace it

chilly brook
#

What's new

#

They'll just nerf it a month and a half late

toxic gyro
#

Last time Iโ€™ve done it on I think 20 tyr , my Druid did 80k hps and I did 35 or 40

#

And I still died at the very end

#

We barely killed it

random urchin
#

I just want to get my hands on that new essence that heals us when we block. Interested to see how it works in a live setting

chilly brook
#

Probably not that great tbh

random urchin
#

Yeah, but I can dream right?

toxic gyro
#

Interesting essence ๐Ÿค”

chilly brook
#

In the moments where we could use self sustain like non blockable damage it won't do you any good

toxic gyro
#

I havenโ€™t looked into new essences yet

chilly brook
#

In the moments where you are blocking your self sustain won't be more useful than the damage you could have from another essence

toxic gyro
#

M+ wise healing on blocks sounds great

analog swift
#

Why?

chilly brook
#

At least imo

#

You don't need healing on block as a warrior

#

We don't need self sustain

analog swift
#

Need heals when youโ€™re taking the least amount of damage

chilly brook
#

We aren't self sustain tanks

toxic gyro
#

Majority of dmg we take still comes from melee

analog swift
#

sure

chilly brook
#

Yes and we mitigate a helluva lot of it

analog swift
#

And we take like no damage from that

warm plinth
#

yeah but the point is that a blocked hit does next to nothing

#

So you're getting healed when you already weren't taking anything

analog swift
#

Itโ€™s the unlocked hits that hurt

chilly brook
#

Hence why it's not good

toxic gyro
#

Does the essence do healing based on dmg taken or flat amount for just blocking

analog swift
#

Thatโ€™s effectively like getting heals when you arenโ€™t tanking a raid boss

chilly brook
#

It doesn't matter if it's a flat amount or based on damage taken

analog swift
#

^^

distant crystal
#

just make it work like valanyr

analog swift
#

Same reason why I feel urchin is overrated for prot warrior

distant crystal
#

overheals grant a bubble >:D

analog swift
#

Itโ€™s all over heals

distant crystal
#

naw

chilly brook
#

But urchin doesn't overheat

#

Overheal*

analog swift
#

Well contributes to more overhealing generally

chilly brook
#

It only does anything if you're not at 100%

#

It can be less useful but it never actually overheals

analog swift
#

I mean itโ€™s not bad but rezans imo is better defensive

#

Yeah I didnโ€™t say bad just overrated

distant crystal
#

naw

toxic gyro
#

If you take constant healing your healer donโ€™t fall behind

chilly brook
#

Your healer should never fall behind when you're a prot warrior and you can block most of the damage in m+...

toxic gyro
#

I guess weโ€™ll see in 8.3

chilly brook
#

Ever

#

I can live a helluva long time against physical damage with no heals

distant crystal
toxic gyro
#

Most mobs in m+ do some sort of magic dmg

chilly brook
#

@toxic gyro we haven't needed help in self sustain since legion, it's not going to change in 8.3.....

toxic gyro
#

Maybe not most but a lot

distant crystal
#

also holy shit did i use victory rush poorly there

chilly brook
#

Which is it? You say the majority of the damage we take is melee but now you're arguing for magic damage making us need self sustain now?

#

And unless it's long term magic damage we have tools to mitigate it

toxic gyro
#

Majority of dmg we take is physical but there is still good amount of magic..

#

Youโ€™re pretty defensive lol

chilly brook
#

No your logic just doesn't make sense

#

We wouldn't even benefit from the essence in the magic cases

#

Since you won't be blocking it

ionic fern
#

What essence are we talking about?

chilly brook
#

Somethint about 8.3 heal on block essence

distant crystal
#

i mean it would be in situations where you're getting meleed and also taking magic dmg

toxic gyro
#

Idk how high keys youโ€™re doing but I find trinkets like urchin pretty good in m+

distant crystal
#

but yeah i think the essence will be pretty dookie

chilly brook
#

Urchin is good

distant crystal
#

the most dangerous magic dmg we take is often times when we aren't getting melee'd at all

ionic fern
#

Heals you when you block? ๐Ÿค”

chilly brook
#

No one said it wasn't

distant crystal
#

rixxa n whatnot

ionic fern
#

There's one that heals you when you dodge/parry.

distant crystal
#

zul

#

i guess if it's strong enough that you could just pull giant with it and live easier

chilly brook
#

The difference between urchin and most other defensive/self sustain is that urchin is always useful as long as you're taking damage

toxic gyro
#

For ml I usually go but more haste vers instead of haste crit and use minor null barrier

ionic fern
#

Have i missed a new essence coming out or are you guys messing something up with the "Heals when blocks"?

chilly brook
#

But there are also better options for trinkets

#

@ionic fern idk bandi mentioned it

ionic fern
#

There's this.

#

But that's only dodge/parry.

toxic gyro
#

Not me, someone else mentioned it

#

I said it sound interesting lol

chilly brook
#

Ah my b

tame garden
#

Jebaited

chilly brook
#

It was @random urchin

random urchin
#

Iโ€™m at work and had to step away. Definitely mistyped when I said block. Thatโ€™s the essence I was referencing though

ionic fern
#

Ah, okay. ๐Ÿ™‚

toxic gyro
#

Jebaited

chilly brook
#

So even less useful tbh

toxic gyro
chilly brook
#

If its only parry/dodge

#

Dodge or parry at full health and overheal omegalul

toxic gyro
#

I mean we have around 30% parry , depends on your crit

#

Would be nice if it worked like urchin

chilly brook
#

But that's even more opportunity for the healing to be wasted

toxic gyro
#

Prob good one for brm

chilly brook
#

Just give us an essence that restores IP to legion 99% and stacking 6x

#

๐Ÿ™ƒ

#

We'd be broke

#

But hey

analog swift
#

Gives us battle cry

chilly brook
#

Other tanks get to be broke for an entire xpac

#

We get one patch if we're lucky typically less

analog swift
#

Warrior tank was mega sleeper in antorus

chilly brook
#

I loved prot in antorus

#

So many shield slams

toxic gyro
#

Bc slam slam slam slam Pepexecute

analog swift
#

Battle cry on a 20 sec cd

tame garden
#

War had 1 bad patch this expac

#

Meta for 2 and second best for 1

distant crystal
#

did we even have a 1 bad patch tho

tame garden
#

Not rly

distant crystal
#

warr still felt fine in s1

#

it's just th at BDK was broken

toxic gyro
#

Early on prot was a bit squishy

#

Before buffs

distant crystal
#

what got changed for s2

#

besides BoM existing

tame garden
#

Reaping

#

Dungeons got nerfed

toxic gyro
#

During uldir we got buff

distant crystal
#

what got buffed

tame garden
#

Can block ranged attacks

warm plinth
#

Projectile blocking, Vanguard buff

tame garden
#

That was big

toxic gyro
#

Stam and armor I think

distant crystal
#

guildy and i were talking about that but i couldn't remember any

warm plinth
#

block CD got reduced at that point too I think

distant crystal
#

ahh

warm plinth
#

From 18 to 16

tame garden
#

IP off gcd

toxic gyro
#

And rage gain ? I think

#

Yea and ip off gcd

chilly brook
#

@toxic gyro we were fine in uldir

#

The stam/armor change was in 8.1

distant crystal
#

imagine being prot in uldir

#

when you could be arms deswind

sick sentinel
#

Classes in uldir were fine it was the raid that needed fixing

oblique garnet
#

Uldir was fine

#

outside of ghuun

toxic gyro
#

Not saying we werenโ€™t, but we we were way more squishy than other tanks before buffs

oblique garnet
#

also not tur

#

true

chilly brook
#

No

#

We weren't

strong forum
#

warri was already a physical god back then

sick sentinel
#

Are you sure your level of play was t buffed by experience cause prot in uldir felt normal

chilly brook
#

We took way less damage than any tank in uldir

toxic gyro
#

When the buff went live?

chilly brook
#

No

strong forum
#

before

distant crystal
#

EHRPS tho?

#

cause comparing dmg taken doesn't really mean much eh

chilly brook
#

The "buff" happened in 8.1 after uldir

sick sentinel
#

EHRPS my bum

strong forum
#

i had to get swapped off of add tank on zul cuz the adds died passively cuz they didnt get any healing from attacking

#

so our bdk tanked em cuz he took way more dmg

distant crystal
#

i brought my arms warrior for our only M Zul kill

chilly brook
#

@distant crystal we didn't require much ehrps in uldir

distant crystal
#

because our normal warrior was out and somebody had to buff the rogues

#

felt real bad having to dodge the adds with my bladestorm tho

strong forum
#

i never got to play DPS on zul

#

was always boss tank

distant crystal
#

bending over backwards to only hit Zul xD

chilly brook
#

And the stam/armor buff was essentially nothing it was essentially just to changes the community perception of the class

distant crystal
#

ip off gcd was prob the biggest buff there

sick sentinel
#

Aka nerfed bdk and people said hey prot seems fun

distant crystal
#

forgot about that one

strong forum
#

it was mainly the bdk nerf and ranged block

tame garden
#

Idk

#

Blocking projectiles ye

#

Seemed biggest imo

strong forum
#

ye

#

it really was / is

sick sentinel
#

Can you imagine Jaina without that

chilly brook
#

IP off gcd was a welcome change

strong forum
#

it was welcome obv

distant crystal
#

is that portugese

tame garden
#

Are those shields

strong forum
#

max ilvl

tame garden
#

Always ilvl

strong forum
#

thats shield

surreal oak
#

what is best?
shield>430 + critic + mastery
our
425 = critic + haste

strong forum
#

on shield ALWAYS ilvl

surreal oak
#

@distant crystal u like?

#

@strong forum ok!

distant crystal
#

ye

#

it's like a cooler version of spanish

surreal oak
#

hahahahah

sick sentinel
#

I feel like I just got assaulted by pictures of shields

#

Thought I was having a stroke

vagrant flame
#

in soviet russia Portuguese, shield hit on you

sick sentinel
#

I do not understand

surreal oak
sick sentinel
#

Also is that a howler and a vial I see in the background

chilly brook
#

There's mythic Zekvoz

sick sentinel
#

Donโ€™t say zekvoz I get war flashbacks

#

Iโ€™m convinced mages and warlocks unbind their movement keys on that boss

chilly brook
#

And I was on thrash duty for this

#

Honestly the only time my ehrps spiked that tier was vectis

#

Oh and the attempts on zul because his stupid bleed

#

Oh wait jk

#

I quit because my guild died xD

strong forum
#

on basically any boss besides Taloc Mother and Zul i had less EHRPS than BDK tank

#

and ghuun was even

chilly brook
#

I had less ehrps on most against my old cotank who was a brm that tier

#

Prot was legitimately more than fine that tier but for some reason people drank the "prot was squishy and garbage" koolaid

oblique garnet
#

from QC

chilly brook
#

Lmao

strong forum
#

thats interestingly low

chilly brook
#

I kinda wanna look at oit qc kill now

oblique garnet
#

i mean thats if you go full defensive

strong forum
oblique garnet
#

i did 20k dps only on that

#

yeah

#

thats the difference

strong forum
#

i dont recall playing turtle

#

my 1st kill is 28k dps

#

the above was 34k

chilly brook
#

I went really turtle

strong forum
#

Warri bad for court btw xDDD

oblique garnet
#

only if you stay outside

chilly brook
#

Monk good btw xD

#

I did stay outside

#

And still required less

strong forum
#

i stand outside once

oblique garnet
#

im never outside

chilly brook
#

Our monk couldn't stay alive somehow

strong forum
#

during obey and suffer

#

rest is bear

tame garden
#

๐Ÿป

chilly brook
#

I was the no healing decree outside shield bitch

strong forum
#

ye same

chilly brook
#

Otherwise we lost a tank every time

strong forum
#

i just shield walled there

#

and youre fine

chilly brook
#

Shield wall before transition

#

Ez pz

strong forum
#

na not even

chilly brook
#

I just made sure I got externals

strong forum
#

i get bopped before zealous

#

so i get rid of Debuff

chilly brook
#

I had to make sure the bop was saved for him

strong forum
#

then i pop shieldwall as the cast starts on Zealous

#

and im fine

#

no other cds needed

chilly brook
#

Because somehow he had a talent for dying in that phase

manic scaffold
#

should i have all my slots haste and enchants

#

im switching from fury

strong forum
#

yes

#

you absolutely need haste

manic scaffold
#

no versatility?

strong forum
#

no

manic scaffold
#

alright

strong forum
#

haste is our best stat

manic scaffold
#

ty

strong forum
#

you have almost no haste on gear

manic scaffold
#

ik

#

i need to re-gear

#

at least its keeping me busy until the new patch

strong forum
#

ye

#

get many haste

#

is guud

manic scaffold
#

got it

chilly brook
#

@manic scaffold well make sure you have 2 strength gems

#

Strength is good too

#

Oof

#

I just checked our guild discord

#

My cotank got hit with the night night

manic scaffold
#

alright

sick sentinel
#

What does the night night mean

manic scaffold
#

i need to swap my 1h badly and my shield

#

lol

chilly brook
#

He got tucked in permanently

#

Aka he gone

sick sentinel
#

Ya hate to see it

manic scaffold
#

ive been running atal dazar for like 4 hours now

#

no shield yet

#

:(

sick sentinel
#

Run ML

#

Guaranteed shield if you ask nicely

chilly brook
#

Or TD

#

Or Temple

#

Or UR

sick sentinel
#

Or pug bosses in mythic

chilly brook
#

Tbh

#

On a shield

#

You want ilvl

#

You can fuss around about trying to get good secondaries after

tame garden
#

4 hours isnt that bad

sick sentinel
#

Just get 450 socketed week1 4head

tame garden
#

Took me weeks to get a shield

chilly brook
#

Could be worse

sick sentinel
#

I had a shaman get a 455 socketed shield off radiance on our first kill

chilly brook
#

Could just never get 3x bom

sick sentinel
#

A piece of me died inside

chilly brook
#

@sick sentinel that reminds me of uldir

tame garden
#

I also only have 2 bom

#

Patch is over in 3 weeks

#

๐Ÿ˜ญ

warm plinth
#

Need to work on your elitism Hawgz

chilly brook
#

Our shaman who was enhancement

#

Got a 385 shield in heroic

warm plinth
#

Elitists take all the loot

chilly brook
#

That he couldn't trade

tame garden
#

At least bom is in every piece next tier

sick sentinel
#

I threatened to ddos if he didnโ€™t give it to me and when he said โ€œI canโ€™t trade itโ€ I didnโ€™t accept that answer

chilly brook
#

Before they changed shields to not be able to tf

tame garden
#

Did I see correctly that theres only 1 shield in nyalotha

sick sentinel
#

I hope itโ€™s off the 11th boss

chilly brook
#

Stop

tame garden
#

Yikes

chilly brook
#

I hope it's off the 1st

oblique garnet
#

Its from like one of the last ones ๐Ÿ™‚

chilly brook
#

Since k value is dumb

#

Jk

sick sentinel
#

K VALUE

chilly brook
#

I know it's not

oblique garnet
#

actually

#

im not sure where its from anymore

toxic gyro
#

I was from one of the last boss

#

First boss drops 1hander

chilly brook
#

But I'd actually just like to not deal with feeling worse off with the same gear until I get another shield to be on about the same spot I was before the patch

tame garden
#

Shield is from ilgynoth

#

Which is like 10th boss

sick sentinel
#

Oh good at least Iโ€™ll be able to slice the boss harder while it is kicking my shit in due to bad shield

chilly brook
#

Facts

toxic gyro
#

You can get decent shield from m+

#

Youโ€™ll be fine

sick sentinel
#

Yeah but then I have to m+ so

chilly brook
#

@tame garden I think this is a conspiracy to stop prot

#

@toxic gyro uhhh I guess?

#

Your only mythic quality shield is going to be out of mythic

#

Cuz m+ no longer tf

sick sentinel
#

Yeah but m+ cache is mythic quality to balance now isnโ€™t it

tame garden
#

Having it on ilgy is so troll

#

End of the raid but not on last 2 so no ilvl boost

toxic gyro
#

I think base m+ ilvl is like 5 below mythic?

chilly brook
#

M+ cache is in between heroic and mythic iirc with a 15

toxic gyro
#

Or 10

strong forum
#

10

#

465 from a 15

#

with 475 weekly cache

#

460 from 10 with 470 cache

sick sentinel
#

God I have to run m+ every week now vomit

strong forum
#

more like

#

yes i get to play without being forced to raid

#

POG

chilly brook
#

What does mythic nyalotha drop? I can't be bothered to do the math

sick sentinel
#

7

tame garden
#

475

strong forum
#

485 from last 2 475 from rest

tame garden
#

^

toxic gyro
#

I think some trinkets from raid seems pretty nice

broken isle
#

Mythic lvl without doing mythic raiding tho

strong forum
#

8.3 is gonna be an amazing m+ season

chilly brook
#

So you get 5 ilvl better than heroic for doing 15s at the end

toxic gyro
#

There is one good for mitigating magic

chilly brook
#

Oof

strong forum
#

yup

#

amazing

sick sentinel
#

Does it make me do more dps

strong forum
#

lowkey the best they coulda done without making m+ loot completely irrelevant

tame garden
#

Agreed

toxic gyro
#

U canโ€™t do dmg when ure dead

chilly brook
#

I still think m+ should reward something closer to mythic raid at a certain key level

sick sentinel
#

Quit dying then

tame garden
#

Its 10 ilvl below

strong forum
#

its fine like this

tame garden
#

That's p close

strong forum
#

475 weekly chest with guaranteed corruption

tame garden
#

And you get mythic from weekly

strong forum
#

is pretty fucking good

toxic gyro
#

Itโ€™s only shadow of zul

sick sentinel
#

Youโ€™re pretty fucking good

strong forum
#

iknow

#

thx

#

for noticing

chilly brook
#

I think 5 below would have been better but that's nitpicking at this point

broken isle
#

Anyone not raiding because the weekly cache got better?

tame garden
#

5 ilvl below and the raiders would cut

strong forum
#

i wouldnt have raided regardless

#

i hate raiding, but that only manifests that

sick sentinel
#

No because I wallow in self loathing so I will continue to raid

chilly brook
#

Raiders are entitled babies

strong forum
#

ill only do like 5-6 easy mythic bosses

#

and then piss off

toxic gyro
#

I only raid bc of gear and mounts

strong forum
#

if at all

tame garden
#

I will still raid grudgingly for trinkets and weapons

chilly brook
#

At least the ones that think mythic raid should be the only Avenue to highest ilvl

sick sentinel
#

Only reason i raid is so I can link cutting edge when people tell me Iโ€™m bad in pvp

tame garden
#

Lmao

toxic gyro
#

Lol

broken isle
#

Difference between m+ and raiding is that u tolerate 4 spergs instead of 19 of them

toxic gyro
#

Git Gud

strong forum
#

^

#

exactly ziggy

sick sentinel
#

Their is only 2 non spergs in a raid group

#

The tanks

#

Anyone else has no brain

tame garden
#

Easier to find 4 spergs you enjoy playing with than 19

strong forum
#

^

#

10 man mythic when

#

i beg

chilly brook
#

@broken isle tbh at a certain key level m+ is definitely harder

strong forum
#

gib

#

that shit would be so much fun

chilly brook
#

Fun content when?

strong forum
#

never

chilly brook
#

F

sick sentinel
#

๐Ÿ‡ซ

tame garden
#

10m mythic would be so good

strong forum
#

yup

sick sentinel
#

Teams would blow through it so quickly

chilly brook
#

I just want them to start designing systems and dungeons and raids with fun in mind not with "engagement" in mind

sick sentinel
#

Lul blizzard and fun

chilly brook
#

I know

sick sentinel
#

Rip reaping

chilly brook
#

I want a company that doesn't exist anymore

hallow belfry
#

how bad are the mechagon bracers?

chilly brook
#

๐Ÿ™

sick sentinel
#

Do people still run mechagon

tame garden
#

Yes I sell hardmode every week

#

Ez 90k

chilly brook
#

I will next tier

hallow belfry
#

yes, because ppl are like help me on my alt

chilly brook
#

For that juicy haste proc

sick sentinel
#

Hate gnometown

tame garden
#

And ye ppl need visions on alts

sick sentinel
#

Mwahi is here

#

๐Ÿƒ

ionic fern
#

@hallow belfry if it's base ilvl and you got anything higher take higher ilvl.

hallow belfry
#

i have it in 445

ionic fern
tame garden
#

Noice

ionic fern
#

And your other bracers?

chilly brook
#

AND THAT HELMET WILL BE BEAUTIFUL OFF THE VENDOR

tame garden
#

What do the plate bracers even do

hallow belfry
#

450 with socket

#

vers/crit

sick sentinel
#

When will I get this guys luck

tame garden
#

When you git gud

sick sentinel
#

See ya never

broken isle
#

@chilly brook I can see how the timings to interrupt/stun multiple mobs at once can be very difficult, without a doubt if one person messes up in a huge pull its over

sick sentinel
#

Get your bear turd boy bum out of here

ionic fern
#

I'd use the mechagon bracers for dps purposes only but for general usage i'd go with the 450 ones.

chilly brook
#

@broken isle wat?

hallow belfry
#

thank you very much

broken isle
#

M+ being harder than raids?

chilly brook
#

Oh

tame garden
#

You cant speak to me like that hawgz

#

I have a warrior alt

chilly brook
#

Well in general m+ at a certain level just is harder, damage intake is higher, things become one shots, you're under a timer etc.

sick sentinel
#

M+ is harder than raiding after like the 19 level tbh

chilly brook
#

Like past a certain point you simply just can't mess up

#

And you don't get a do over

sick sentinel
#

But harder is a weak term cause it is comparing apples to oranges

broken isle
#

Did azshara have the same lvl of difficulty?

sick sentinel
#

Azshara wasnโ€™t as hard as people made it out to be imo

#

All about positioning

tame garden
#

Raiding you can try over and over

chilly brook
#

You wipe on a boss you lusted on too bad you don't get it again until sated is gone

tame garden
#

Key you get 1shot then its bricked

sick sentinel
#

I feel like they are just different

distant crystal
#

it's cliche but the harder part about mythic raiding is rounding up 20 competant players

manic scaffold
#

ngl it feels nice being a tank cause everyone is usually desperate for one lol

chilly brook
#

They are different

#

But on the high end of play

manic scaffold
#

only part now i gotta re learn all the fights

chilly brook
#

M+ is harder than raiding

broken isle
#

Difficult for different reasons

distant crystal
#

M+ is also unncapped difficulty

ionic fern
#

There's plenty of material out there luckily @manic scaffold

chilly brook
#

@distant crystal right which is part of why I don't think there's a valid argument that mythic raiding is more difficult or any more deserving of better rewards

broken isle
#

The recruitment officer gets the rewards lol

ionic fern
#

And if you got any specific questions about encounters then ask ask away.

sick sentinel
#

Yes I will answer your questions poorly and then be shooed away

tame garden
#

Raiding and m+ have same ilvl rewards on weekly lockout next tier

#

Besides last 2 bosses ofc

sick sentinel
#

I like that they added the 15 loot buff

distant crystal
#

the loot disparity isn't really about which is harder

#

it's about not wanting to force everyone to spam M+ for loot

#

to use in raid

chilly brook
#

Technically not the same both will be feast or famine but one will have more chances of more rewards

distant crystal
#

and raiding is the sort of iconic top-end content of this game historically

broken isle
#

I mean the concept of being forced to do anything in wow is complicated

chilly brook
#

@distant crystal technically you're forced to raid for m+ competition

#

Especially next tier

distant crystal
#

yeah i think they're ok with that

#

moreso than the opposite

chilly brook
#

Which is stupid

tame garden
#

Idk

sharp night
#

the one bad thing about the loot buff is that on ptr, people who only do 10s for weekly are screwed because a 10-11 now gives relatively 5 lower ilvl than it did in the past

tame garden
#

Plenty if ppl push high keys without raiding

#

And plenty will do so next tier as well imo

ionic fern
#

I don't mind you guys chit chatting about this but please do remember to give adequate feedback to protection specific questions that may pop up in between your chat.

sick sentinel
chilly brook
#

@tame garden yes but next tier is different since weapons and ilvl difference on the last two

tame garden
#

Oops

manic scaffold
#

should i run ML or atal dazar for the shield

chilly brook
#

Either

#

Ilvl brother

distant crystal
#

normally i'd say ML

sick sentinel
#

ML is better stats but atal is easier to farm

tame garden
#

Technically ml

distant crystal
#

cause if you're spamming might as well spam for the good piece

#

but fuck ML this week

ionic fern
#

I'd run Atal..since it also has Rezans.

sharp night
#

15 drops 465/475 weekly, 12-14 gives 460/470w, and 10-11 drops 455/465w

distant crystal
#

that too

tame garden
#

Yeah I spammed atal instead cuz faster runs

broken isle
#

Atal has the best gear overall for u

tame garden
#

When I was going for shield

sick sentinel
#

Bears donโ€™t use shields

tame garden
#

Smh

peak lily
#

what do you guys think about blightborne for m+?

tame garden
#

I have an alt

distant crystal
#

i got 445+s atal shield from weekly chest deswind

#

bbi slaps

sick sentinel
#

Blightborne gud

distant crystal
#

@peak lily

broken isle
#

So long as u got 3 bom and 1 clap, that's a nice one to have too

left hatch
#

irrc only reason Blighborne isn't in our ideal BIS is because it isn't on BoM pieces

distant crystal
#

not sure if there's any BBI pieces with a better trait on that row

broken isle
#

Wouldn't sacrifice a bom for a blightborne

left hatch
#

or maybe its because theres no BBI pieces with OP but either way it gud but there's better

peak lily
#

yeah, currently have vengeful and deep den chests ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

distant crystal
#

i used it on my chest forever

#

ye vengeful

#

until i got ashvane cuirass deswind

strong forum
#

vengeful is good chest

#

bfi + bb

#

prolly the best chest without bom

sick sentinel
#

Deep den is turtle city I love it lol

peak lily
#

so my options are blightborne+bloodsport or BfI+IF

strong forum
#

๐Ÿข ๐Ÿ‘‰ ๐Ÿšช

distant crystal
#

nono

strong forum
#

bfi + bb

#

not bloodsport

distant crystal
#

^^

sick sentinel
#

Bloodsport is yucky

broken isle
#

I use bloodsport and it's not fun

sick sentinel
#

Well thatโ€™s fake news it is ok there is just better

distant crystal
#

bfi bbi gutripper

left hatch
#

its great for padding them HPS parses.... just like leech

distant crystal
#

or CC if you must

sick sentinel
#

LEECH

broken isle
#

U know someone is gonna have all corrupted gear full of leech

#

Vampire prot warr

distant crystal
#

๐Ÿ˜Ž

peak lily
#

my shoulders would be bastion+bfi

#

would you take 2x bfi then?

#

instead of one bloodsport?

distant crystal
#

sure

left hatch
#

BFI stacks great

distant crystal
#

bfi stacks well

sick sentinel
#

Bfi is a great trait

broken isle
#

Bfi stacks

distant crystal
#

i hear that multiple copies of it stack with eachother too

sick sentinel
distant crystal
#

if you wanna do a topgear sim @peak lily and link it

#

we can take a look and suggest trait swaps

left hatch
#

or even just saying what pieces you have

urban briar
#

what do u zim az prot?

distant crystal
#

deeps

urban briar
#

what kind of zim

strong forum
#

top gear patchwerk 1 boss 5min

distant crystal
#

i do 5 target patchwerk, st, dslice

#

just to look at things

strong forum
#

too much effort for too little gain

#

denied

distant crystal
#

you're too much effort

strong forum
distant crystal
#

so ashvane helm DC + bom + OP

strong forum
#

just make a screenshot of that part of the sim

#

with your available azerite

distant crystal
#

scorcher shoulders bom /BFI / UF

#

can do UC if you're feelin saucy

#

vengeful BFI BBI gutripper

#

imho

peak lily
strong forum
#

ye so helmet is fine

distant crystal
#

the link works fine ๐Ÿ˜›