#protection

1 messages · Page 2758 of 1

sick sentinel
#

and it's fine

#

I guess I'll sit on a dummy and run heroic with booming

#

so I learn how to do it again

#

Get a weak aura

#

I do

#

I just forget lul

#

To remind yourself to press demo shout

#

Yikes

#

I dont payattention to my weakaurs

#

basically

#

lmao first thing I do

#

I forgot to push dev on dummy after a minute

#

So basically, Null Major. Conflict/VoP minor. Booming voice for more avatars

#

?

#

I wouldn't go null major

#

No?

#

What should I do then

strong forum
#

Kaege he means for zaq

sick sentinel
#

as off tank

#

with no edict

strong forum
#

Either null or undying gift I'd say

#

I think you'd get more out of gift, given tether doesn't have huge uptime

#

And gift is 45sec CD

sick sentinel
#

Even though the armor portion (minor) of gift would be kinda useless

#

I like it a bit more

#

You basically recover for free

#

"Press when bad" with a 45 sec cd

strong forum
#

I don't think anyone picks gift for the minor, ever unless maybe Dh and dk

sick sentinel
#

so undying gift, VoP, Null?

strong forum
#

Ye that sounds good

sick sentinel
#

That's going to interesting

#

There's basically only one part of the fight I die tho

strong forum
#

Psychotic split 🙃

oblique garnet
#

Do you take the split or monk?

sick sentinel
#

I do

#

No

#

it's not split killing me

#

I die around phase 3 start before we go down to delirium

#

My main tank says its' him soaking the portals

#

so he gets increased stacks on accident

#

If the tank soaks the portals

#

And you die as a result

#

He's just playing badly

oblique garnet
#

^

sick sentinel
#

I guess so

#

The adds don't really hurt me that much

#

as I save most of my cds then

#

and I nuke it

sick sentinel
#

For booming voice

#

Do you want to revenge over shield on aoe?

#

over 3+ targets

#

or does the rage you get does more damage overall because more avatars with rage gen

strong forum
#

Depends on the situation, do you have enough rage to spend, do you have IP up

#

In pure dmg output revenge does more on 3 targets than 1 SS

sick sentinel
#

what about 2 target

#

and you're forgetting rage gen for more avatars so more overall mastery and thus does that out way the dps loss for you to shield slam over revenge

strong forum
#

If you are at 80 rage

#

You don't waste it by pressing revenge over SS

sick sentinel
#

you use IP so you don't over cap while doing SS/revenge

#

so you get both the damage

#

without capping

#

and reducing avatar cd

strong forum
#

Obv

sick sentinel
#

I'm talking

#

does it overway the dps loss shield slamming for t he benefit of more avatars

strong forum
#

Idk what to tell you

#

In m+ you heavily prefer using revenge over SS in aoe situations

sick sentinel
#

and why's that

#

especially if you have BFI

strong forum
#

Cuz you have enough rage gain

#

From clapping and getting hit

#

To perma revenge/TC

#

And from booming

sick sentinel
#

I've never experienced that

#

I was starve for rage

#

and I don't IP spam that much in keys

#

I always starve*

strong forum
#

I'm not saying to use revenge at 30 rage if you know you cant afford to upkeep SB/IP

#

It's all situational

#

9/10 revenge is free anyway

#

Like, you get so much rage with booming voice

#

Idk how you're starved without inting

sick sentinel
#

I'm always starved

#

like always

strong forum
#

Wtf

sick sentinel
#

I have just enough for SB and maybe 1/2 revenges

strong forum
#

What

sick sentinel
#

then the rest is IP into sb again

strong forum
#

I cap IP so often

#

It's not even funny

#

Im finally starting to use revenge more in aoe situations like I should, during Avatar you can literally go tc->revenge->tc->revenge

#

For like 10 seconds if not longer

#

With the occasional upkeep of SB obv

#

Cuz I was prioritising rage gain from SS, which made me lose like so much dps in aoe

sick sentinel
#

the main thing I want to know with booming is

#

Do I only deva when I have no proc and is IP starved?

#

err

#

rage *

strong forum
#

You deva when you have literally nothing to press

sick sentinel
#

what if I'm max rage

#

and can revenge

#

id' revenge?

strong forum
#

Yes.

sick sentinel
#

st wise

strong forum
#

Yes

sick sentinel
#

kk

strong forum
#

If you're at 60+ rage

#

You're safe to press revenge

#

Even in St

#

If you just used SB, and have IP up, you're safe to press revenge at 30 rage

sick sentinel
#

What if you don't care about IP

strong forum
#

Then you can use it too

#

Your main focus is

#

To have enough rage by the time you need to press SB again

sick sentinel
#

Is there a way to sim frequent add switching in raidbots

strong forum
#

Hectic add cleave I'd say

#

Is 1 boss with frequent add spawns

sick sentinel
#

isn't that just cleave

#

with main boss

#

being p riority?

strong forum
#

Gotta ask mwahi for that

#

I don't sim aoe

sick sentinel
#

I wanna know how bad dreams is compared to another 430 same ilvl

#

but my dreams is socketed

strong forum
#

You mean dreams end

sick sentinel
#

yes

strong forum
#

Phew.. Good question

sick sentinel
#

of course

#

it sims higher

#

no matter what I do or how many targets

strong forum
#

I think it was said

sick sentinel
#

because it's just 1 main target

strong forum
#

That as soon as you swap targets once, normal weapons are better

#

But don't quote me on that

sick sentinel
#

@ionic fern

#

we need u

#

or well I need u

#

Kappa

ionic fern
#

Hi

#

Best

#

Bed*

sick sentinel
#

How do I sim dreams end with target switching

#

I have a dreams end with a socket and a no socket regular weapon

#

same ilvl

#

can't get regular weapon to sim higher no matter what

strong forum
#

Ah, take the socket

#

The socket is the reason

sick sentinel
#

socket on weapon big

#

?

strong forum
#

Not big

#

But bigger than no socket 🙃

#

It's more stats

#

No matter how you look at it

ionic fern
#

Have you checked the uptime on the buff of dreams end from html report?

sick sentinel
#

100% updtime

#

uptime*

ionic fern
#

Also,why wouldn't you take dreams end if it's same ilvl + socket + effect?

sick sentinel
#

Frequent target switching. Doesn't it have reduced stats or some other negative option?

strong forum
#

There's no downside to dreams end

#

Besides you not getting max value out of the effect

#

And maybe sub optimal secondary stats

ionic fern
#

You have the stats right infront of you..just check the weapons.👀

sick sentinel
#

ah so same ilvl it doesn't matter

#

Thought it had some negative side to it

oblique garnet
#

Nome do you prio revenge over ss in aoe?

strong forum
#

Na

#

Depends on rage

#

All depends on the situation

oblique garnet
#

Your revenge hardly ever costs rage in m+

strong forum
#

Ye ikno

oblique garnet
#

So it doesnt really matter if you want to use it to spend rage because you cant

strong forum
#

Sometimes you can peepostudy

oblique garnet
#

Yes sometimes you can

#

Most of the time not really

strong forum
#

Idk fam I don't do intricate math, I press my buttons

#

And given that I did 42.9k overall dps in FH yesterday I think I did pretty decent, could to better but it's a satisfying result

sick sentinel
#

only 42.9k?

#

Feels bad

strong forum
#

Don't have triple bom :(

sick sentinel
#

Feels bad

#

whats' more feelss bad

#

is I don't have a piece to replace my BFI

#

it's either BFI or Catalyst

#

for M+

strong forum
#

BfI is good tho

sick sentinel
#

maybe defensively

#

I'm talking pure numbers

strong forum
#

Decent ST

oblique garnet
#

Its still good in pure numbers

strong forum
#

I'd love BfI over if

#

Tbh

sick sentinel
#

I'd rather have MS

#

or DC

#

LUL

strong forum
#

Dc, yikers

oblique garnet
#

Well yeah pretty much nothing beats MS

sick sentinel
#

I got kraken

#

but 415 Kappa

strong forum
#

Bro im running cthraxxi in m+

#

Know my pain

sick sentinel
#

Das giant for defensive mang

oblique garnet
#

No

sick sentinel
#

who wouldn't want that sexy blood sport and swirling sands or dc

strong forum
#

It's if + SS

#

So it's something

#

But SS uptime is so bad

#

Like 19%

sick sentinel
#

btw

strong forum
#

soon

sick sentinel
#

hmm

#

uh oh

#

not even do the big pulls yet

strong forum
#

14mil

sick sentinel
#

Only half way

#

🤧

outer dew
#

????

#

Wtf are these overalls

#

Your dps slacking

sick sentinel
#

50k not good

outer dew
#

Its shit for this weeek

#

Lmao

sick sentinel
#

maybe if you're in a actual group

#

and not a pug

outer dew
#

??? I pug a lot.

#

But I meme with a tank and maybe yeet a friend dos now and then

#

Comes down to what you know what you can survive too

#

Did retard shit with no lust

#

And priest sitting at 65k in FH

#

All them pulls were scuffed since no lust for mega packs

sick sentinel
#

my group

#

did negative dps

#

I'd just run out defensives by that point lmao

outer dew
#

Lmao

#

The brew I meme with

#

"I don't like it went you tell me you have nothing"

#

Lmao

#

Not my fault we didn't have lust for that pull

#

:^)

sick sentinel
#

:4head:

#

just have things

outer dew
#

Wtf

#

My roommate is shouting at 2 am

#

Tf

#

I know I'm awake slaving at the pot

#

But I got another one sleeping

#

Sometimes I question people's sense of decent

#

Decency

#

Smh

strong forum
#

Ye, same as my when my neighbours keep shouting at 3am for no reason.
I just wanna play my drums in peace...

sick sentinel
#

LMAO

strange arch
#

hey peeps you got any recoms for cd management and uptime of defs

#

kinda get alot of dmg input

outer dew
#

??

sick sentinel
#

Shieldblock shieldblock shieldblock last stand shieldblock shieldblock shieldblock shieldwall shield block shieldblock

outer dew
#

3x sb -> LS -> 3x sb

#

Sw to cover a gap or to use for high damage intske

#

SR when magic wants to tentacle fuck you

sick sentinel
#

press IP to compliment your block not instead it

outer dew
#

Use IP when you a bitch

#

And didn't press revenge

#

:^)

#

@sick sentinel so when we matching, daddy

#

😉

sick sentinel
#

🏃

#

🚪 🏃

#

😢

lethal lark
#

I need help

strong forum
#

With what

sick sentinel
#

With getting a girlfriend 😢

strong forum
#

unluck

sick sentinel
#

Unluck

#

Just get egirls

#

I have many of those

#

No actual one tho

near ivy
#

One egirl is enough

exotic spoke
#

Ughhhh

#

It’s too early for this shit

warm plinth
#

A-fucking-men

sick sentinel
#

You need atleast 5

wintry olive
#

How many e-girls do you have Kaege ?

sick sentinel
#

probably like 10

#

he's an elitist

undone sun
#

👀

wintry olive
#

That’s odd, I thought an elitist would go for quality over quantity. 🤔 I guess I’ve misunderstood the concept !

sick sentinel
#

He wants all the pad numbers

#

Of e girls

wintry olive
#

Haha, and here I was thinking he was a 1 egirl kind of man

outer dew
#

Only one I need is @warm plinth

#

😉

sick sentinel
#

@wintry olive depends

#

quality over quantity is what I would recommend

#

1 is optimal but up to 3 is pretty acceptable when you're in a transition period

#

as in, choosing the right one

#

maybe 4.

warm plinth
#

Is this a real conversation right now? Lol

exotic spoke
#

Yes and I’m not hungover enough for it

sick sentinel
#

no

exotic spoke
#

Quantity has a quality of its own

sick sentinel
#

ghash when was the last time I've been serious

warm plinth
#

How much of that liquor did you drink last night Riki?

sick sentinel
#

for non-prot stuff

wintry olive
#

Haha, lol riki

warm plinth
#

Idk you're getting pretty naenochip lately for prot stuff

#

But I guess someone has to take his place while he's immersed in classic

exotic spoke
#

Four of us started with opening up a bottle of wine from 04, finished that, had a little whiskey, and maybe half of the beers, oh and a second bottle of wine

sick sentinel
#

Quantity has a quality of its own
that's not necessarily wrong

exotic spoke
#

Went to sleep around 230 - they crashed in the assortment of beds / futons

Then I got up at 630 to go to work for some reason

warm plinth
#

Riki is never wrong. Haven't you heard? He's a big kid woyer now because he did Hertz Locker

exotic spoke
#

^^

#

It’s why I wasn’t sure if I was still drunk when I first woke up

#

Thankfully, I wasn’t

#

And there’s liquor / beer for next time so that’s good too ghash

warm plinth
#

You can have my Coors Light if you want

exotic spoke
#

I will throw that shit straight out

warm plinth
#

😂

exotic spoke
#

God damnit - why does my group want to meet today to work on our project

People - learn from my choices and know that Karma is a bitch

warm plinth
#

Yeah that's what you get for shit-talking free beer

exotic spoke
#

Sir

#

I wouldn’t call that shit “beer” more like piss water

outer dew
#

I'd probably take the piss water

#

Shits free

#

And probably cold

warm plinth
#

Yep

exotic spoke
#

There’s at least 12 beers still in the fridge at home.

warm plinth
#

Are you a craft beer fella Riki?

outer dew
#

Then again. I don't mind drinking coronas

exotic spoke
#

Sometimes. About the largest chain beer I’ll drink is Yuengling

#

But I guess I’ll drink others after I’m already drunk

Cheaper to keep the buzz going when you can’t taste the difference

warm plinth
#

Get you that Natural Light. $6.50 for a 12-pack 😂

exotic spoke
#

Natty Boh around here is the typical go to

wintry olive
#

You from Illinois Riki ? Feel like yuengling was the beer of choice back at UIUC

exotic spoke
#

Maryland. Yuengling is a PA beer but it’s huge on the east coast

outer dew
#

No wonder I havent heard about it

#

Tsktsk

#

Could be just I dont drink beer often

exotic spoke
#

I do more liquor / wine now usually but for parties it’s easier to get beer

#

Picked up a Japanese whiskey and tried that yesterday

That shit is good

outer dew
#

Aite. Time to stop being a dumbass and go to bed

#

Go do work

#

Smh

warm plinth
#

But

#

I'm up; why are you going to bed

outer dew
#

6 am and i no sleep, I'm not thyme

warm plinth
#

Pfft

#

Fine

#

💔

exotic spoke
#

@outer dew I’m here and running a report. Above and beyond that they can bite me

undone sun
#

hmmm

outer dew
#

Need my beauty sleep to look fresh for you 😗

warm plinth
#

Night bae

exotic spoke
#

Tofu - number one e girl obv

outer dew
#

Only share pics if you PayPal me $200

#

😉

exotic spoke
#

That’s a deal!!

warm plinth
#

I get them for free

exotic spoke
#

Sure you do

#

No gonna lie - best part about waking up this morning is that my friends cleaned up last night while drunk

undone sun
#

only $200

near ivy
#

Quality > quantity I guess

sick sentinel
#

tofu is way out of my league

exotic spoke
#

Tofu is in a league of their own

near ivy
#

Checks out

exotic spoke
#

Thanks friend

karmic plinth
#

hi, everyone. im playing protection as the linked tank on za'qul heroic and i'm struggling a bit with the damage - i'm running undying gift as my major and nullification barrier / memory of lucid dreams as my minors and have been swapping to indom to deal with the magic damage - is there anything else i should be doing to smooth this out?

random urchin
#

What is your MT?

sick sentinel
#

Don't use indom

brittle owl
#

what's the other tank?

random urchin
#

Warr does better as MT on that fight

karmic plinth
#

MT either another prot or guardian

brittle owl
#

guardian is better as ot

#

double prot is yikes

warm plinth
#

I don't know much about the fight but Indom is not the right play. Even if you're only using Last Stand for the heal, it's still going to do more for you against magic damage than having more HP

brittle owl
#

warrior is probably the worst add tank

random urchin
#

Oof yeah. Double prot warr is rough for that fight

warm plinth
#

Only time you should use Indom is if you're getting 1-shot while playing properly and that 10% HP makes the difference.

karmic plinth
#

i can link some logs if theres something im missing

warm plinth
#

Which is basically never

karmic plinth
#

will swap back to last stand as a start there

brittle owl
#

use never surrender

#

that's the only thing you can optimise as add tank

brittle owl
#

but really

sick sentinel
#

I wouldn't even do that tbh

brittle owl
#

should not add tank at all if you have literally any other tank class available

sick sentinel
#

Never surrender Pepexecute

brittle owl
#

oh wait

#

it's heroic 🤔

undone sun
#

never surrender 😡

sick sentinel
#

Yikes

warm plinth
#

I'd swap to 3x Bloodsport before I'd run NS. Problem with NS is that it's not good for preventative measures really, especially in that situation where you're spikey

#

Because its "optimal" effect is using IP when you're low on HP, which is kind of counterproductive to that situation

#

And the fact that it blows dick in general.

sick sentinel
#

Having an IP bigger than your health doesn't do anything

undone sun
#

it's not even great for it's optimal scenario, which is constantly being low without being topped off

sick sentinel
#

You'll die before it's depleted

brittle owl
#

looking at the log

#

it's mostly healers lagging behind tbh 🤷

sick sentinel
#

@brittle owl look if the mt is standing in shit

brittle owl
#

ye doing that now

karmic plinth
#

ive been a bit shit on the tether as well

brittle owl
#

mt is taking crazy dmg

warm plinth
#

I don't even think it's possible to get an IP bigger than your HP anyway is it?

sick sentinel
#

@warm plinth bigger than your current hp

warm plinth
#

Oh, right. That makes sense XD

sick sentinel
#

If IP was still 90% then NS would make lots of sense in more situations

warm plinth
#

Yeah I agree

#

Still largely not used, but at least more useful in the couple of situations where it might be worth taking

karmic plinth
#

for now. not much else i can do?

sick sentinel
#

Tell your tank to play better

#

You're at the mercy of him playing prot correctly

warm plinth
#

We're just not really optimal for that role. But if your MT is taking a lot of damage, that makes your life worse.

#

Phew, 1260ms what is this

karmic plinth
#

thank you for the help either way

brittle owl
#

@karmic plinth your ip casts vs mind thether damage

#

you cast ip alot when theres no damage incoming

#

and you have a full tether phase with 0 IP casts

karmic plinth
#

ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

brittle owl
#

mt is doing fine for the most part

sick sentinel
#

Track the debuff and your ip

#

So you don't unnecessarily overcap

brittle owl
#

watch timers, play the encounter

karmic plinth
#

should save ip for the tether?

brittle owl
#

no, but you should have it for tether

warm plinth
#

You don't need to save IP; just make sure you're using it during tether

karmic plinth
#

got it

brittle owl
#

you shouldn't be rage starved in general, so you can cast it during high dmg phases

karmic plinth
#

alright

#

that's very very handy thank you for pointing that out

brittle owl
#

np

grizzled vale
#

does the block gain from Brace for impact stack if you have more than 1 trait?

warm plinth
#

Yes

grizzled vale
#

so would it be better to have Brace for Impact x2 or take one and then bloodsportx1

warm plinth
#

I'd take the Brace for Impact x2 @grizzled vale

sick sentinel
#

@grizzled vale 99% of the time, you take the trait that is not bloodsport

#

Hey, new to the game. I have a question. Is there a build calculator that can inform me what stats I'll have with certain gear, traits, gems etc.?

#

And also some guides and resources

#

I would suggest the icy veins guide

#

Yeah checked those already, I am asking for something different.

#

Something like, creating a simulation character, equipping it with items I choose and it will show me the stats I'll have.

strong forum
#

sounds highly unnecessary

warm plinth
#

There's nothing like that that I'm aware of. Not that would be up to date anyway.

sick sentinel
#

Ok, thanks!

#

If you have in-depth knowledge with using the raidbots website something like that is possible

#

But there is very little reason to do it

#

You should care more about what's the limit of what your character can do now and how to imporve it

#

Instead of what is the highest potential of your spec

#

I won't be looking for the highest potential, just wanna see all my options

#

What I can get with what

#

If you know what I mean

#

Your options are extremely limited because of itemization rng

warm plinth
#

I think droptimizer basically does that doesn't it? I don't exactly know what that's about. It wouldn't show you what stats you'd have or anything but it tells you what's optimal to go after next or some shit

strong forum
#

so you want to aim for a specific setup, thats beyond unlikely

#

unless you literally spam m+

#

24/7

sick sentinel
#

I'm not aiming for anything, for curiosity

#

Anyway, I got my answer already. Will check the raidbots and droptimizer, thanks for help

strong forum
#

for that youd have to get access to tournament realm

sick sentinel
#

What you can do it you're curious is see how much haste % X amount of haste rating gives you etc

strong forum
#

there you can equip ever thing in the game

sick sentinel
#

Using the googledocs spreadsheet

#

Marked under the "stat analysis" sheet

#

Also access to the tournament realm

#

Is actually the best way

#

Ok, that actually sounds like exactly what I need

strong forum
#

or just check out wowprogress max ilvl characters

#

and see what kind of stats they have

warm plinth
#

That's not realistic for someone who is brand new to the game though, especially since there's no way you could get on the TR right now is there?

strong forum
#

but only very few people in the world have access to tournament realm, so thats not possible unless youre a literal god

sick sentinel
#

Again, I am not looking for the max potential of what I can do

warm plinth
#

The MDT time trials have already started so you'd have to wait for the next one, and then qualify for it

strong forum
#

yes so just check out high ilvl people i suppose

sick sentinel
#

Hmm, isn't there like a Public Test Server for such purposes?

strong forum
#

no

sick sentinel
#

Damn

strong forum
#

that only uses your copied characters you already have

warm plinth
#

The PTR doesn't typically give gear unless it's testing something gear-related. Usually you just copy what you have

strong forum
#

theres no "cheat" gear

#

i can show you my stats if you want?

#

if that helps you in your curiosity

warm plinth
#

Wow Nome, you guys just met

strong forum
#

#

guess not

stoic pilot
#

For some odd reason I have a feeling Liofa plays monster hunter cause iirc they have a tool that lets you see all that

zealous epoch
#

BE still tops for PvE?

stoic pilot
#

For Racials LFD / UD still sim highest for ST. Also probably better to just sim your own char and add in the races manually

#

BELF / NE / Dwarf for utility

zealous epoch
#

Thanks!

sick sentinel
#

zandalari troll for style

#

Anyway, I checked a lot but it just doesn't exist unless I can get into tournament thingy

stoic pilot
#

Close! The best you could do in comparison would probably be fiddling around with Raidbots or Simulationcraft program itself

sick sentinel
#

I didn't check the simulationcraft yet, will do that tomorrow

stoic pilot
#

It’s what Raidbots uses but Raidbots presents it better for new users.

#

If you’re new to the game though, realistically you don’t get to target most of your drops outside of a few specific pieces. They basically pick your gear based on what titanforges and what doesn’t

sick sentinel
#

Yeah, learning that the hard way currently lol

#

Did 5-6 m+ runs and didn't get any items except azerite while all other 4 members had some loot

#

One of them dropped an essence for off spec lmao

strong forum
#

ye you get essence from timing 7+ or higher if you didnt time it yet

stoic pilot
#

At least you’re tanking (at least I’d assume from you posting here) so you can reliably farm pieces relatively quick deswind

sick sentinel
#

Yeah, still need to learn mechanics and routes in dungeons, I keep getting lost ^^

stoic pilot
#

Oh also, do keep in mind that using Raidbots to sim your character for prot does not do anything but show you potential dps

sick sentinel
#

Especially in that prison dungeon, don't remember the name

stoic pilot
#

Survivability gains can’t be simmed

#

Or survivability at all

strong forum
#

pretty sure he hasnt touched simming whatsoever

sick sentinel
#

Nope

stoic pilot
#

Nah, but he's asking about the tools.

#

It's better to know this beforehand so he doesn't potentially scrap or sell gear lol.

strong forum
#

well simming is exclusive to wow, afaik no other game has it automated

#

get yourself familiar how to use raidbots liofa, and you dont need that website input stuff to do manually

outer dew
strong forum
#

everything will be self explanatory

sick sentinel
#

send food

outer dew
#

Come over

strong forum
#

lacks meat

sick sentinel
#

actually brb coming over

outer dew
#

Theres plenty of meat

sick sentinel
#

😍

outer dew
warm plinth
#

That meat is mine 😉

outer dew
#

Just traditionally you dump a ton of veg

stuck crown
#

Can you get 100% uptime of shield block with Heavy Repercussions?

#

(and bolster)

warm plinth
#

Not sure, but you lose a lot by taking Heavy Repercussions. And you don't need 100% uptime; just 100% effective uptime.

stuck crown
#

Raidbots doesn't sim heavy repercussions correctly because it prioritizes revenge over shield block

#

I guess I lose a lot...

#

On Orgozoa it might be worth it though with how the fight works

solemn kelp
#

Wondering whether to swap a 415 Bloodthirsty Urchin with a 430 Chain of Suffering

stuck crown
#

what fight

#

Chain of Suffering is situationally much better, but you have to actually use it.

#

the ilvl (str) increase means you should use CoS if you have no need for more mitigation

chilly brook
#

@stuck crown you should have enough shield block uptime on orgozoa to not need HR

icy garnet
#

Just need Block up for taunting orgo with 0 stacks.

stuck crown
#

My healers are struggling even when I have 2-3 stacks

#

M orgozoa hits like a truck even with 2-3

stoic pilot
#

Do you have a rdruid healer?

stuck crown
#

Yeah, but ironbark is usually being tossed on someone else

#

I end up with cocoon

#

I want to try 2123332

#

on orgo even though everything says not to

inland mesa
#

I just did normal build lead with last stand as I was lazy and never had problems

stuck crown
#

same thats what I was spamming last stand

#

that got me to two stacks if I taunted at the right time

#

but 2-3 I was still getting hammered

inland mesa
#

Did you let block drop on a hit? Or are you just undergeares

stuck crown
#

I'm just block wasn't up at some point

#

sure*

#

I could toss undying gift as the major

hallow phoenix
#

Is 3x sb > LS > 3x sb not enough time to get high stacks?

stuck crown
#

well I am like Chew

hallow phoenix
#

With like an external or sw at the start

stuck crown
#

lazy, lead with LS

inland mesa
#

I just like the extra health to start if healers are distracted and bigger IP

#

I tank him first that usually he does the dance and I can get like 5 or so in a row active blocking

stuck crown
#

but if I do Undying that should get to 4 stacks

chilly brook
#

Don’t ever EVER lead with LS @stuck crown

#

Ever

#

You have enough rage on charge/avatar to have shield block up

#

If you need the extra HP just weave in a commanding shout

#

But don’t use LS off the bat

inland mesa
#

Mine is assigned at a specific part of the fight and commanding isnt up enough

stuck crown
#

I'd get kicked out of raid if I used commanding at start

inland mesa
#

To each their own, you only tank orgozoa long enough to get last stand up once at a time

chilly brook
#

I just don’t see why you’d need to extra hp to begin with tbh

inland mesa
#

That's when he hits the hardest?

stuck crown
#

Will it's more about bolster and last stand combined

chilly brook
#

Yea he hits hard at the start when you have no stacks

#

I know how the fight works

#

But block should be more than enough

inland mesa
#

You sure dont need it when you have 5 or 6 stacks to be filled for an recharge

#

And if you know his timings they naturally recharge to get you 6 in a row which is usually right at tank swap

chilly brook
#

It’s not the first boss this xpac that hits hard

echo swan
#

6

#

so I've been lurking while I learn prot warrior and my car decided to send ya'll a 6, hope you enjoy

#

cat*

inland mesa
#

Hi kitty :)

stoic pilot
#

I have literally 0 issues going full dps build on Orgo, just triple block + last stand lol

#

If you actually need an external (I used ironbark on each of my goes) then call for it

#

But leading with Last Stand then saying you’re getting chunked /shrug

#

You should have shield wall for every other (iirc)

stiff maple
#

What's a good build for M+

#

I'm wanting to improve as a warrior tank and get good at it, I'm only good as a Dk one at the moment

#

So kind of trying to expand

distant crystal
#

talents?

#

1123211

warm plinth
#

Not much variety in builds for us.

distant crystal
#

you can tinker with other ones on the 75 row

stiff maple
#

Into the Fray, Crackling Thunder,Unstoppable Force, Bolster, Storm Bolt, Booming Voice, Anger Mangement

#

And Essences?

warm plinth
#

Looks good to me. There's some choice on the 2nd row and the 5th row. Essences vary. Depends on affixes/dungeon/what you have

stiff maple
#

I'm running visions of perfection as main

#

Not sure what the minors should be for M+ tanking

warm plinth
#

Sometimes Vision is more appropriate as a minor. Just depends like I said. What else do you have available?

stiff maple
#

Memory of Lucid Dreams, Cruicble of Flame, Anima of Life and Death.

#

Oh and World Vein residence.

warm plinth
#

All rank 3?

stiff maple
#

No, still working on it

sick sentinel
#

Lucid and flame

#

If you could do the "win 1bg, 1epic bg and 1 pvpisland" quest that also gives you a good minor, even rank 1

#

Replace flame with it if you get it

sick sentinel
#

For zaqul, should I run coral or cyclo for punctured burst phases

#

IT's either or

#

coral sims way higher tho, just wanna know if it's better for the 30% damage phase

#

and echos

#

I'll be using urchin for the other trinket slot

distant crystal
#

both vel

west kayak
#

If you need me tomorrow just let me know. GrevAeo#1371

sick sentinel
#

I'm not using both

#

LMao

#

I'm offtank as a prot warrior

floral sphinx
#

Who’s main tanking?

sick sentinel
#

Monk

#

I already went over this

#

it's nto going to change

floral sphinx
#

Sorry just toned in lol

distant crystal
#

i would say coral though

#

its duration is the same as puncture

sick sentinel
#

So is cycllo

distant crystal
#

so if it sims better it should also perform better on puncture

#

like you rip off coral right as the puncture happens and big crits for the duration

sick sentinel
#

I mean

#

I'll try using both but

#

It wasn't going well yesterday

#

but I changed somethings

distant crystal
#

well one will put the other on cd for the duration so

#

i had an idea of cyclotron critting its face off but that's not an option

#

unless you can somehow have it rip from a mob dying instead of using it

sick sentinel
#

I meant me dying

#

but turns out it wasn't really my fault

#

just tried it, it only does like 3% of my damage at the end

#

before we wipe

#

Cyclo does

limpid pawn
#

For mythic ash using cyclo and razor coral trinket

#

One puts other on cd, how are you guys using it

#

I’m just popping Coral first

#

And then as soon as possible hitting cyclo

distant crystal
#

rip coral with avatar and demo shout i guess

#

and then use cyclotron after ava's down

#

as close to on-cd as you can

sick sentinel
#

Could I use nerver surrender for zaqul since I'm taking PURE magic damage

#

and not a hint of melee?

#

No point not to

exotic spoke
#

Why would you be the OT

#

Do you have another warrior as the other tank Mvpg

sick sentinel
#

no

#

Don'teven try

#

it's not going to happen lmao

exotic spoke
#

So your raid leader is an idiot then for not utilizing tanks properly. got it

sick sentinel
#

No

exotic spoke
#

I mean if they are having the monk mt it then they are but whatever

sick sentinel
#

No

#

He's 8/8m

#

he knows timings

#

so he is the one doing the mt

#

I'm not even dying

#

it's not a problem anymore

#

so it's not happening

exotic spoke
#

I mean whatever

sick sentinel
#

What we are wiping to is most of the time people not killing echos

#

and if we do, people just panicing after

inland mesa
#

We died to so many tentacles

#

First time we killed 2nd split we actually killed it, think we only got to split once or twice before that

honest frigate
#

BRM MT/Prot OT is just as viable

#

With prot OT it’s just spikes of magic damage whereas with Prot MT it’s stable damage but if you compare the logs they take roughly similar DTPS

hard vault
#

Hows cyclo

sick sentinel
#

good

hard vault
#

M+?

sick sentinel
#

Bad

#

Get rezans or block

#

tank trinkets

#

maybe vial

stone trail
#

hey guys, what macros do you use ?

sick sentinel
#

none

spice ferry
stone trail
#

nah BFA

#

🙂

spice ferry
#

oh, yeah none

stone trail
#

🙂 ok

stoic pilot
#

I think the only macro I have just adds cancelaura to blessing of protection into devastate

sick sentinel
#

I have a intercept target of target macro

#

And interrupt mouseover

stoic pilot
#

Oh that’s a good one actually

#

Target of target would be super handy for Eudora

sick sentinel
#

Target of target is bis for eudora

#

And safeguarding first boss

stoic pilot
#

I need to make one of those next time I play, I always just use mouseover intercept but it’s still a bit hard to react in time for some of the spells lol

strong forum
#

i have mouseover for taunt, pummel, intercept

#

and then just QoL macro for heroic leap @cursor

sick sentinel
#

Wait, femclap uses Lucid on high keys?

#

minor

undone sun
#

who

sick sentinel
#

Who?

oblique garnet
#

Nothing wrong with using lucid

strong forum
#

^

sick sentinel
#

defensive wise?

#

they do like 23s and stuff and I figured you wouldn't use lucid

#

Why wouldn't you

#

Your IP gets depleted fast there

#

So you don't waste rage

#

Because you dump IP just to get rid of it

#

You actually use the ragw

#

The issue with lucid minor is that you get so much rage that you have to dump

#

I figured aegis would be better

#

because of how big they pull

#

the amount of vers you get

#

especially with teeming

strong forum
#

dont forget

#

lucid also gives 360 vers

#

and has 30%+ uptime

sick sentinel
#

Ah

#

I forgot about the rank 3 thing

#

I don't have rank 3

#

.

#

I just have rank 1

strong forum
#

ye thats why i said it

sick sentinel
#

..

strong forum
#

also heals for like 15k

sick sentinel
#

aegis heals you for like 1.1k every mob there is every 4 seconds

strong forum
#

not saying aegis is bad

#

im using lucid + aegis

sick sentinel
#

not cns?

strong forum
#

dont have r3

sick sentinel
#

is lucid only good if it's rank 3?

strong forum
#

r2 is the bigger one i'd say

#

but every upgrade is good

#

usable at r1 already

sick sentinel
#

vs aegis and cns?

strong forum
#

na

#

wouldnt say so

thorny talon
#

Rezan's Gleaming Eye vs Vial of Animated Blood?

sick sentinel
#

Eye

onyx vale
#

Hello

#

i'am curious why this guy uses Recklessfury for raiding

#

?

undone sun
#

for more damage

onyx vale
#

more single target damage to have good logs ?

#

maybe ?

undone sun
#

yeah, that's what more damage means

tidal blaze
#

hey guys, any tips on Orgozoa? Essence and Trinket wise?

#

Orgozoa Mythic it is

onyx vale
#

ı saw a warrior using Everchill Anchor from jaina and Vial as trinkets

#

oh u re not prot

#

it's prot channel

tidal blaze
#

i am prot mate

#

that's why i ask here 🙂

#

have to tank it tonight

#

got a 400 trinket from Jaina and the Vial as 440

onyx vale
#

i try for a week

#

go vial and rezan

tidal blaze
#

i'll be 1 of the soak tanks, so don't have to worry about the adds

onyx vale
#

null r3 vision 3 crucible r3

#

soak tank means u will tank the boss as well

#

adds are more fun and easy btw

#

if u gonna tank boss and soak

#

go vial and urchin

sick sentinel
#

Adds are a lot easier

#

Phase 1

#

I think it switches phase 2

#

Adds are harder phase 2 as you get so many of them and have to keep aggro and get them taunted and stacked

#

Micromanagement

tidal blaze
#

i get to tank with a paladin and a monk, so monk is on add duty with his statue

#

thanks @onyx vale for the tips. Let's see if they help tonight

civic holly
#

why do you say vial for orgo? just for dmgs?

sick sentinel
#

That's just what he has

civic holly
#

ah right

sick sentinel
#

I think

ebon lark
#

I should know this but I never really pay attention, do you need to get the last hit on an enemy to trigger victory rush?

undone sun
#

Yes

#

@ebon lark

junior ivy
#

hi

sick sentinel
#

hi cat

undone sun
#

hi

oblique garnet
#

Hi

ionic fern
#

Hi.

exotic spoke
#

hi cat

jagged bay
#

hi

spice ferry
#

hi

vestal edge
#

Whats essence combo for highest dmg parse possible crucible major vop and null minor?

strong forum
#

yes

vestal edge
#

cool

strong forum
#

if you have CnS r3 that might outsim VoP

#

but for me it doesnt for example

vestal edge
#

yeah i have rank 3 everything except for like the meme ones lol

strong forum
#

ye

vestal edge
#

and the pvp one

pulsar crypt
#

do you have a good youtube video or even a stream I can watch that shows spells cast>? I am mainly looking for rotation guidance

sick sentinel
#

CNS outsims for me by 0.4%

#

over vop

mint locust
#

Hello friends

#

Are Protection Warriors still Haste > Vers > Mastery > Crit?

ionic fern
#

ilvl->haste->what ever.

mint locust
#

@ionic fern Mwah ❤

ionic fern
#

Haste/crit is prefered for m+ from secondaries.
haste/mastery for raids etc.

sick sentinel
#

Isnt it haste vers dor raids

#

For

#

As vers affects cof

#

And adds dr

brittle owl
#

if you're looking for stuff that affects damaging essences and shiz

#

just sim

#

🤷

lunar bramble
#

Are there any advanced guides or streamers to look out for on m+ tanking? Apparently warriors are better than monks but I'm finding i seem to die alot on my warrior and guess I'm playing it badly

#

I main vdh and am lookin at tank alts and the monk seems insanely easy

#

But feels like every e points at warrior

ionic fern
#

100% uptime on AM and stagger overall makes it easy jeah. 😂

hallow phoenix
#

Radsrad is an informative streamer i find

lunar bramble
#

Twitch? @hallow phoenix

hallow phoenix
#

yeah he's on twitch

lunar bramble
#

Ty

ionic fern
#

There's not a lot of "guides" for m+ tanking in general but a ton of streamers since warrior is in a good place right now.
Just go to raider.io and check top warriors m+ wise. They usually have twitch linked to it.

lunar bramble
#

Right OK, like I want to like warrior but I'm just not enjoying it right now

#

It feels really clunky, and I'm expecting I'm doing something wrong

ionic fern
#

Probably.
Warrior is smooth gameplay wise and fast phased.

hallow phoenix
#

1 second GCD will do that to some people

strong forum
#

Monks are starting out to be better for high key pushing and easier to start out on.

Warrior is very punishing if you fuck up or play badly

#

You have to know everything about what can / will hurt you and you have to use everything at your disposal properly before you take dmg.
As warrior you cant do shit after the fact

#

So the complete opposite of vdh/bdk

lunar bramble
#

What about revenge use, wait for procs or use without? Especially during avatar

ionic fern
#

Procs mostly.

strong forum
#

Depends on the situation, how much rage you have, how much you can get before SB runs out.
How many mobs you are attacking

lunar bramble
#

So thunder clap on cd?

strong forum
#

Yes

#

No exceptions

lunar bramble
#

And shield bash?

strong forum
#

Unless you're in ST and have Shield Slam

lunar bramble
#

Sheild slam sorry

strong forum
#

If you are in ST SS>TC

lunar bramble
#

Nah I'm mostly having issues pulling bigger packs and staying alive, not that I'm doing BADLY, I just feel like I'm not doing something right

#

What should I do with ignore pain?

ionic fern
#

Are you using SB? Are you facing the mobs in the way that non of them are hitting you in the back?

#

Are you using SR to reflect/reduce magic damage?

lunar bramble
#

Nah non of that, I timing 15s atm on the monk and DH

#

I can tank but just seem to struggle with warrior

ionic fern
#

Hence the questions i asked.

strong forum
#

IP should me up most of the time and should be used as rage dump

lunar bramble
#

But should I be using rage on ignore pain all the time?

strong forum
#

You don't want to cap rage

lunar bramble
#

OK so revenge on proc

#

And not on cs

#

Cd

#

I noticed that seems to drain my rage

strong forum
#

Ye that's not good

lunar bramble
#

So thunderclap / ignore pain, revenge on proc,

strong forum
#

You should always aim to generate alot of rage and spend it accordingly

lunar bramble
#

While keeping sb up

ionic fern
#

Just to be on the safe side..you are using Bolster+ Booming Voice + Anger Management as talents je?

lunar bramble
#

Is there an ideal time to use last stand or have it as emergency?

strong forum
#

Yes, if you don't have SB ready, don't be afraid to use last stand to fill the gaps

lunar bramble
#

Right ok

#

Sec let me show you my rio for warrior

strong forum
#

Last stand should be almost used on CD

#

It's basic part of your defensive rotation

lunar bramble
#

OK so would using it after my 2nd use of sb generally work?

strong forum
#

Ha I knew your name was familiar, we:re on the same server

#

3rd SB

#

You can chain 3 shield blocks back to back

lunar bramble
#

Because of the recharge time

strong forum
#

Cuz by the time your 2nd charge runs out, a 3rd one will have come up again

lunar bramble
#

Yeh ok

strong forum
#

Unless you have literally 3 haste

lunar bramble
#

What sort of prio should I be looking to open with in trash pulls

#

I've been doing avatar - charge - tc, demo, sb

strong forum
#

Well get SB up as soon as possible

#

Pre-avatar is good yes

#

So It'd be avatar - charge - SB - TC - Demo - TC/revenge

lunar bramble
#

Does charge generate enough rage to put up sb?

strong forum
#

Avatar is 20 rage

#

Charge is 15 rage

lunar bramble
#

Ah

brittle owl
#

so yes

strong forum
#

You also get 40 rage from demo, so you can use IP

brittle owl
#

purely for damage purposes you would want to avatar-clap-demo-clap etc etc

#

but it's a 1 gcd difference

#

so not that much

strong forum
#

You also wanna atleast revenge once early for the bleed application

lunar bramble
#

Ok

strong forum
#

if you want to min max dmg a bit more

lunar bramble
#

Kinda sick of not getting invites because of maining a non meta tank outside of guild groups

brittle owl
#

idk, rio is enough 'cred' for most groups

lunar bramble
#

You'd think that

brittle owl
#

but i get you, warrior gets way more invites

lunar bramble
#

But I rarely get into 16-17 keys as vdh

brittle owl
#

🤷

#

people be dumb

#

you don't wanna do 16/17's with dumb people anyway

lunar bramble
#

Yeah true that

ionic fern
#

I haven't found people being picky when it comes to tanks tho since it usually takes forever to find one. 😂

brittle owl
#

people are still meta flags

#

and by that i mean they want mdi comp ideally 😂

#

also i peace on the profanity filter

strong forum
#

Pretty sure I saw bdk and resto sham

#

:hahaa:

#

And a couple hunters

sick sentinel
#

just started doing keys this week

#

edict blocks quacking

#

helps you keep max stacks

hallow phoenix
#

Is orgozoa add tanking supposed to be kind of hectic? We did a few attempts last night and quite a few times had a wave spawn before the last wave was killed. Had to scramble to pick up adds that were going after heals/DPS near the spawn points while making sure to keep the near-dead adds clumped

mystic whale
#

so, any tips on how to maximize the fuck out of your dps output during Mythic Ashvane ?

#

Also, does anything give out more dps than Vision/NullBarrier/Flame ?

hallow phoenix
#

CoF as major

wintry olive
#

In that order ?
I’d think CoF major, null barrier and visions minor would be close to if not the highest you can go

hallow phoenix
#

Make sure you soak a bubble on first wave

#

So your null mantle gets popped continuously

mystic whale
#

hmm thats not a bad idea

hallow phoenix
#

If you zerker rage the moment brinyb bubble is applied you'll still immune it and should have it up for the next bubble too

wintry olive
#

Does clapping while in bubble still work ? I never understood why I could do that

hallow phoenix
#

Ummm, you can tclap while bubbled and should make your cotank take azerite beams. We just got ashvane down tonight and that's really all I noticed. You should have near 100% DPS uptime

#

Yeah @wintry olive it still works

mystic whale
#

"If you zerker rage the moment brinyb bubble is applied you'll still immune" -- wait what

wintry olive
#

Berserk rage immunes the bubble. So you just walk out of it

hallow phoenix
#

Briny bubble takes about 5 seconds to actually bubble you

#

Zerker rage lasts 6 seconds

mystic whale
#

whoaaaaa what

#

what kind of effect si the bubble

hallow phoenix
#

You want to zerker asap because if you don't, you stand a good chance of not having it up for the next bubble I noticed

#

It's an incapacitate

mystic whale
#

man thats a game changer

#

why is this the first time I hear about this haha

hallow phoenix
#

Kinda mad, I had a top 6 parse going but then some DPS decided they wanted to die so we wiped. Screwed up a bit on our kill and didn't get as high as I'd like

#

@mystic whale it's why you should do the bubbles and your other tank the beams

#

Killed her just last night

#

Are you using cyclotronic?

mystic whale
#

yeah

#

cyclotronic, devastator, flame/vision/nullbarrier is my setup right now

hallow phoenix
#

You can probably get away with using it at the very start of the fight

mystic whale
#

yeah I pull wiht it

hallow phoenix
#

And still get it off during the burn phase

#

A little trick with CoF is to get the third application (cast with 2 existing buff stacks already) to pandemic

#

So you CoF, then wait until you have almost 2 charges again. Then CoF, wait until 1.5 seconds or so remain on the debuff, and then CoF again

sand egret
#

🤔

hallow phoenix
#

The last CoF will hit the hardest and you'll extend it's debuff time by a good 1.5-2 seconds

sand egret
#

unless they changed it...it doesnt work like that

mystic whale
#

yeah ill have to practice using CoF, never really used it before

hallow phoenix
#

CoF pandemics pretty sure

sand egret
#

nope

hallow phoenix
#

... I've been lied to

sand egret
#

it overwrites it

#

so its a huge loss if you go from the 200% one and slap a normal one on

hallow phoenix
#

Whelp guess I can stop paying attention to that shit

#

Im not saying slap a 0% one on

sand egret
#

doesnt matter regardless

hallow phoenix
#

Tru

#

Makes me kinda sad actually

mystic whale
#

how do you use it then ?

#

do youu spam 2 charges right off the bat ?

sand egret
#

as it doesnt pandemic you’re still losing X damage not letting it tick out

#

let the dot tivk

hallow phoenix
#

@mystic whale use CoF off cd without overwriting. I suppose you can delay a bit to use SS and TC as long as you're not sitting on 2 charges

mystic whale
#

so, use once, wait until almost back one charge then keep a charge rolling

sand egret
#

Yeah, there's probably a niche scenario or two where you'd want to double tap to prep a 200% damage one for a specific moment but if you're talking about maximizing it's use overall, just make sure to a) don't let it cap on charges and b) don't apply it when the major DoT is ticking

hallow phoenix
#

@mystic whale use unbridled fury if you're not. They should do more DPS than other pots

sand egret
#

honestly it's just "don't hit it within 6 seconds of itself"

mystic whale
#

ok perfect, thanks

hallow phoenix
#

And probably don't use during avatar unless you'd reach 2 stacks

#

Assuming avatar doesn't buff it

sand egret
#

it does not

mystic whale
#

prolly not

hallow phoenix
#

Are you looking to parse for fun or does your guild have dps issues

mystic whale
#

hmm why not both

#

yeah we need more dps

#

and i dont have any trouble surviving so

hallow phoenix
#

What are your azerite pieces and traits?

mystic whale
#

hmm all i remember is I have 3 of that avatar boosting trait

hallow phoenix
#

Reckless flurry is something to look at if you're not using it and really want more damage

mystic whale
#

i think i have a piece with that

#

(as an option)

hallow phoenix
#

BfI and RF on your shoulders might sim higher

#

Definitely sim though

mystic whale
#

yeah lets say meticulous scheming wasnt my first option

#

stuck with that for now

#

aaah but its on the reckless flurry row

#

definitely gonna try that then

hallow phoenix
#

MS Sims like 150 below RF for me, I wouldn't bother changing it really

mystic whale
#

meh

#

anyway i have enough new things to try with CoF major and one stack of the bubble debuff to get max powered nullbarriers

sick sentinel
#

@mystic whale MS is like

#

bis

#

1dc 2ms 3bom is bis

mystic whale
#

wut

#

since when

hallow phoenix
#

Talking raid dps @sick sentinel

#

Strictly st dps

sick sentinel
#

Oh I didn't see raid dps

mystic whale
#

thats what I have already kinda, 3 bom, 1 dc 1ms and... one brace for impact i think

#

but yeah were talking big deeps

sick sentinel
#

It's bis for dungeon dps

#

ST just sim lmao

hallow phoenix
#

I know a warrior with 12 sockets, 3 BoM, 2 MS, 1 DC

#

And 425 benthic boots bracers gloves

#

I hate him

mystic whale
#

haha