#protection
1 messages · Page 2713 of 1
thanks
what keys did you guys farm for shields?
Atal, UR, Tol Dagor, Temple, Motherlode all drop shields
Can also get one from Mecha but obviously lower base ilevel (assuming you're farming +10ish keys)
Mmhm
I mean, most people are gonna run it anyway since visions
Unless you have r3 already
yeah but like, for most classes visions is a meme
like what, prot woyer, vdh, hpala and maybe balance use it as a non meme essence
there's a few more iirc
I know 🤔 But we're in Skyhold, so I assume anyone asking about shields in here is a prot warrior lol.
Anyway, farming keys is definitely the better strategy since as you said, higher ilevel.
and you can do more than one a week 😃
Yeah, that too
I did my first clear of hard mode yesterday (on my HDH). Was pretty fun tbh.
It was interesting seeing how much easier it was since we tried it week 1 going in fully blind XD
i liked hard mode, the last boss gave me real Destiny vibes
Week 1 we got hung up on HK-8 and couldn't pass it. Today we one-shot everything until KUJO. We wiped once on him because we didn't realize the big damage throwing the waste did. Easily killed him second time. Then I think we had like 8 or so wipes on Mecha just learning the hard mode process but overall still fairly easy.
Er, not today but yesterday I mean
Two more weeks until everyone in my group has the mount. Hoping to have rank 4 by then
Tomorrow will be my first time trying Hard Mode :P
Yeah I didn't get the mount or helm but I run with the same group so we'll eventually all get it. Not worried about it.
Love the Jetsons sound effect of the mount though
The tease of titanforge on the mechagon 'set' rings will have me running it forever.
I wonder what Mechagon M+ will be like
like hardmode prolly
Rumor has is M+ has been scrapped
tbh
Nah, I doubt hard mode will be in M+
wat? That makes me sad.
It's gonna be bad enough having the detection bots section in M+. They're not gonna have us pressing fuckin buttons every 45 seconds too
at high enough levels
If they do, they're just fuckin cruel
I mean. Detection Bots = Orbs in Temple.
Except worse because I can carry orbs if I need to
yeah the bots are a meme
I can't run other people through that gauntlet
Imeant the spinny orbs
just don't stand in em
That send you backwards if you touch them
Oh, eh. Those are way easier though
Lot less to dodge than the bots, especially if people start to get impatient with the bots
I get what y'all are saying though. I, personally, also hate "events" in m+
I wouldn't be mad if they removed the bot part from M+ tbh. They can be a bit trolly sometimes
If you start the event at an awkward time and have that horrible group up of the 3 in the start and have to wait 25 seconds or so for an opening
We can leap over them and laugh/cry as people get ported back
lol can you? I am 100% gonna troll people tomorrow.
Oh you certainly can
muahaha
I haven't tested if I can double jump/fel rush over them yet. Usually it works on anything leap does though
I love trolling my group when we're just doing whatever.
Trust me - I find ways to troll my guild members. Ideally murder them in dungeons / raids too
The true troll is one willing to die for the cause of trolling.
omg. I tried so goddamn hard to kill people in low keys with the uunat trinket
Would just leap onto the ranged, pop it and then intercept back to the mobs :P
You can’t actually kill them with the trinket unfortunately
I'd do it during unavoidable burst damage.
That can kill them. Though it’s only a little bit of damage
I never got anyone
But definitely made some people wary of me whenever I did certain pulls
I dont think the trinket is what made them wary
Swap blasters in raid next to falls that will kill them
hehe
Swap blaster someone strafing and then laugh
Oh you know what might be a good one? Swap blaster someone running forward while standing in front of the door going back toward Zul after 3rd boss in KR. Cutscene triggering while running makes you keep running lol
And it doesn't stop easily either. I usually have to spam a few different directions to get the auto run to stop
Hey guys. Recently got the itch to start gearing up my warrior alt in M+ and wondering what essences you recommend? Right now I’m just running vision major and dreams minor. Seems pretty good so far but if their are better combos out there I would love to know.
Nullification rank 3 is very good.
CoF and anima are also used by some people.
Anima / CoF pretty much only as a major.
Nullification as a minor
Crucible? I don’t think I even considered it. I know it pumps out some damage at rank 3.
pumps even before that
Which is why people use it. I tend to use it on tyrannical weeks and anima on fortified
I run visions + c&s minor for fort and visions & crucible for tyrannical
Good to know. Thanks guys!
What does conflict give as a minor?
A lot of vers
Eh, I guess that’s alright
And any crowd control effect from mobs doubles it
I've been running visions major, and either crucible or nullification minor.
I'd probably use lucid minor over c&s minor
Aegis r3 minor is good too for fort if u pull pretty big packs
It leads to a ton of wasted rage
I just want more dps
Aegis has really low max stack uptime
There is one minor that also gives u permanently over 300 haste and 30% slow on mobs
Supression
Yea
I’d have to sim, 300 haste is nice but I doubt that outdpses CoF anima / null rank 3
CoF generally is your best dmg minor
Unless you can always pop the bull barrier
Null*
Yea major is pretty shitty unless your team lacks crowd control and u use it to reset stacks on nevrotic weeks
I am pretty pumped for null rank 3. Should get it in the next few days. Gonna be nice for all the bulls hit trash mobs that cast big ass hits
Dwarf master race
My go to when I have all 3 unlocked will be vision major, CoF and lucid minor
M+
Hello my prot brothers , should prot warriors be using cyclotronic punch card for mythic ashvane?
I know. I stand by my statement
Avatar with 3x bom gives tons of survivability and dmg
Yeah, but you get more dps from other options
riki are u replying me?
Not for m+
No - archaous / bandi
CoF is not more dmg in m+ compared to visions
Anima could be, week dependant
Anima is good too
Anyone here with mythic ashvane experience? can share if its more beneficial for me to run cyclotronic punch card?
Anima on fort and CoF for tyrannical as majors imo
I just like visions more
also i see on WCL alot of warriors using devastator? is that the go to now for more dps?
Yes, if you can sacrifice the survivability you probably should use cyclotronic Obama
i would be losing the haste bonus from red punch card
i'm j usjt not so certain how much of a dps boost it is
👏
Wish they would change anima minor to reduce the major CD on each heal. It would make much more sense! And give a good reason to stay >35%.
I mean avatar with 3x bom is basically like another defensive, you basically critically block every hit
do i dare loot my cache with prot loot spec tomorrow
Avatar is another defensive 😛 we typically don’t need more of them
i really need a 1h but i really really don't need a tank trinket
inb4 
455 indestructible shield inc ?
What do you need waat?
a 1h
God.. I scrapped a 445 sporepod the other day.
rocking a 415 from world boss atm ~_~

Can't get a 455 shield from M+ weekly 😬
Running 445 edicts, and a 430 vial atm.
I'm still fishing for a shield, 430 socketed best I've gotten so far
my best dmg setup right now is 440 block and 430 barnacle
I'm really hoping for a weapon or shield upgrade in tomorrow's cache. That'd be the dream
same
Also looking forward to my first 445 azerite tomorrow :P
my chest is BFI BBI right now
I got this week 455 2h from radiance and brolled 445 shield 😁
Nice!
yeah i'm rolling fury on radiance always now
I've coined radiance every week, and orgazoa 1x, still no mythic shield
Can u even do that @toxic gyro ?
i'll take trinket or 2h
@summer dust yeah you can change loot spec before you bonus roll
I'm not running mythic raid this tier. Maybe when cross-realm pugs come out, but meh.
It was from mythic radiance
Yeah change your loot spec before bonus roll
but loot spec when the boss dies is your loot spec for the drops
can't change before looting
Second / third bosses are loot piñata
Yes u can swap loot spec for broll
Didnt know that changing specs counted after the mob had died
It dosent
It only does as long as the loot hasn't already been rolled.
only for bonus
You can for bonus rolls. Not for what came from the boss
The moment a chest spawns, or boss dies, your loot has been rolled.
The moment the loot is generated is when it checks your loot spec
Yea. That's a more accurate way of saying it.
It’s schrondingers loot - both amazing and shit until you open it up
Ah i see.. useful for gearing offspecs later :) Cheers
That is correct. It only works on bonus rolls.
did that for m champs last tier
got shield, bonus rolled weap
:D
we did a ghetto heroic split this weekend and the RL demon hunter was pestering everyone to doublecheck loot specs on ashvane
boss dies, he loots a forged urchin
and starts cussing himself
lmao
Oof
On our alt night - an alt got a 455 trinket that our main DH wanted
He was salty
one of our tanks got a coral
and decided he needed it more than our melee
while we're progging ashvane
:/
Hooray personal loot
Eh, personal loot is fucking cancer
seems like they could allow master loot for 100% guild runs only
if they really cared about ninjas
i think they just want to curb split runs
or like, mythic 100% guild runs only would be nice
Personal loot doesn’t do that though. They still did split runs with personal loot.
It just feels super shitty that blizzard says “you can’t trade this cause it’s an upgrade” but it’s not an upgrade and someone else needs it
I mean, if they really wanted to prevent splits they'd just make you unable to run heroic and mythic in the same week on the same toon.
I think Blizz just wants to feel like they know better than you or something lol
Imagine a game the requires you to own a higher ilvl item to trade loot while simultaneously making 425s bis in raid.
how many stacks should your cotank have on orgozoa before taunting off for the first time
on normal
6-7
my alt mage got lure and shiver first heroic
meanwhile our main raider casters are fishing in normal/lfr for lures
I think my guild's mythic raid got their very first venom or something just this past reset.
I dunno. I haven't been paying a lot of attention to EP loot.
On normal orgazoa stacks dont really matter tbh, dont hit 10 and don't miss soaks.
I jsut know they've been bitching about smething not dropping, then everyone was so happy when 1 dropped this week
tanks in my group are arguing about when to taunt
i dont know how much more simple it is than "just taunt when we are done dancing"
Properly done, tank 2 should taunt when adds spawn
You need to swap at 6-7 so you can soak the puddles when the adds die, iirc
Tank 1 then tanks adds until they die and soaks puddles.
You dont need stacks to soak on normal
Once the adds are done, tank 1 takes boss back
Rinse/repeat
Short answer, they swap when adds spawn, then when debuff falls off
is cruible of flames the way to go in raids?
For dps
vision for def?
CoF and Null both R3 good for raid/M+ dps?
Null is probably better for raids than dungeons, but it depends on the dungeon.
More specifically, how frequently you can break the bubble
What traits you guys running for m+ this week specifically? And essences
@warm plinth What would you run for M+ for dps?
Probably Vision/CoF/Anima major (depending on what I had/what week it is) and for minor probably some combination of Vision/Null/Lucid/Sphere
Definitely need Vision as first minor though, at least
Rank 2 is fine for Vision anyway. You get the vers bonus on r3 but it's not the important part of the minor anyway
Sounds like I should run CoF Major and Visions Minor til I hit 65 and then use Null Minor?
So with just one minor, I'd probably do like CoF major, Vision minor on tyr weeks. And then fort weeks probably either Vision major Lucid minor or Anima major, vision minor. Hard to say for sure because I haven't had enough experience with the two majors to make a good comparison
hey guys can you taunt as soon as the tide fist cast starts on radiance or do i gotta wait till the cast finishes?
Yeah but Null is highly dependent on dungeon. Like Freehold would probably be a shit dungeon to run Null for example, since you could break it on CD in some packs but most of the time you're gonna be taking nothing magical to break it
Sounds good@warm plinth , thank you for the info.
orc troll tauren or undead for classic now? 🤔
Orc for the massive shoulders of course
hmm, i guess best use would be tauren cuz more hp...
What's prot warirors main stats
not in classic
Check out the guide in the pins @crystal nexus
Even people who can are having issues getting names to go through from what I hear
The accept button won't work for them so they have to keep backing out and trying again.
I mean i cant even choose classic as option to launch 
How worth it is it to keep grinding to get the mechagon null essence ?
Very
Am I the only person who (if I were home) wants to just log in to classic to make names so other people can't have them? Like all the stereotypical shit that you know people will snatch up immediately like two-letter names and shit
Do it and sell them later
But then you have classic gold which is worthless to me
So meh
Well you could just advertise on BfA
Like WTS the name Sword on classic for 5 million gold here
lol
But then they’d have to have gold on my server (a dead server too) and want to buy a name on one specific server
Not sure how you'd really get someone to do it though
And I’d have to have that name
just grab Asmongold and Mcconnel
No one would trust the other person
lolol
The funny thing is that the streamers' fans are likely to get the streamer's name instead of the streamer
@warm plinth The type of man to snatch Late from me 😦 had to bribe my friend to use his one reservation to get it for me monkaS
I would never do that to you ❤
Got a guild mate to grab Riki on our server
Refuse to let some pleb sully my name. I can do that well enough on my own
Ten thousand queue on eu
Yeah what happens when they do better than you and then you have to improve. Yikes
Guess people know prot wars were meta before it was cool
They won’t ghash... they won’t
lol
I mean, tbf, prot war was the meta tank in vanilla because it was really the only viable one for raid content lol. Paladins and druids both have to pay the hybrid tax in vanilla; you get to be lackluster in all 3 specs
aka play your healer spec because thats the only thing you're good at
Yep
FUCK! They got it on the wrong server
RIP 😦
lol that happened for streamers as well, they got logged into the wrong servers
He has an hour and 15 minutes to resolve his mistake before there are dire consequences
So the null essence is good for the magic barrier or the damage it does? Only good rank 2 and up? Or at rank 1?
It's okay as a minor both for the shield but especially the damage. I would be hesitant to use it before rank 3.
Null Barrier was doing uh...13-15% of my damage or so on Sivara last night. Almost 2k DPS. And the same healing, of course. I'd consider 2k DPS for a minor essence pretty good, and 2k HPS to be whatever. Hence why, yes, you'd need to be fairly desperate for survivability to use it at rank 2.
still no artifact skin 😦
Sad times
what Essence combo is reccomended for Prot Warrior M+ specific
vision/lucid is the normal go-to
ok ty
What would be ya 3rd choice for minor once hit 65 for m+??
maybe conflict? not sure
crucible minor might beat out the vers from conflict ye
or maybe even ripple
for that fat str when you charge in
so for all you classic prots out here im like 80% on my spec do you think the deep fury prot spec will shine
you go down to flurry then prot
might be better off in #vanilla-discussion
what is the minimum ilvl required for +10? I haven't played in a while and I'm 420 already
curious because +9 is too easy
420 is easily enough
honestly, from a tanking standpoint 10s are hardly any different than 9s. You may have some issues on pulls with the tides emissary, but other than that, it just changes when you'd use CDs and path or pace of some dungeons
420 is good but with pugs being around 430-435 right now it may be difficult for you to find pugs
@reef fulcrum
Thanks!
Yeh exactly, it’s just the change of having emissaries to consider. It’s marginally more hp on mobs and damage taken
hi
hi
Hi
hi
hi
Hi
so reading the guides, Ilvl is above all on non-azerite pieces. What if i have a 415 socketed shield but got a 430 shield drop? Does the socket make it better or just choose the highest ILvl shield no matter what?
Ilevel on shield and weapon aren’t sacrificed for anything
Can’t socket block rating or weapon DPS
thx
how important is ilvl on shield? Is that the difference of getting destroyed and being much tankier? I just transitioned to prot for the first time since uldir and my shield is 385 and im trying to farm for a 430 right now
Is that 385 making a mongo difference?
berry important
im praying to RNGsus for a 440 tomorrow
Yeah block rating is everything for our survival. Second only to proper play.
Assuming you’re taking blockable damage which is most of the time
I have like ~30%ish block rating with this shield so ill assume it goes up a bunch
Also proper play definitely isnt there yet haha its easy to do my damage rotation but managing our 2 trillion defensives is difficult to me
I came from VDH where i have 1 defensive button
30ish, is that with nothing targeted? Or are you looking at the “against current target” thing
With nothing targeted most of us are closer to 50% for reference
And it’s halved against bosses basically so we have 25 to your 15
Damn yeah im way far behind. I need a shield
So you guys spam ignore pain when ever you have the resources for it as long as youre taking incoming damage?
Anyone else feel like sockets and bonus stats are like SUPER easy to find in m+ gear, but not ilvl upgrades?
@sharp dragon Shield Block is infinitely more important to maintain than Ignore Pain. Essentially you use SB (or Last Stand if SB is unavailable with Bolster talented) at all times you’re taking blockable damage, and with your extra rage you decide on gaining further defense with IP or casting Revenge for a bit more damage if you don’t need more defense.
what minor essence are you all running on mythic ashvane
i was gonna do vision/worldvein minor
is there anything cool that can be bypassed/cheesed by rank3 nullification dynamo in raids ?
Yeh worldvein is good if enough are running
nomeratur your UI is awesome
what exactly is that keeping track of raid cd's and externals and whatnot?
and also the huge thing keeping track of ashvane's shield - is this big wigs?
so I looted a 430 Jes tonight; I'm just wondering if it would be better than a 425 vial or a 425 gore-crusted butcher's block, mainly for mythic raiding. We just started Mythic on Saturday.
@sick sentinel sim it
I'll sim it, but I'm not particularly worried about dps at this point. Trying to get max defense while healers are gearing up in mythic
If you're not worried about damage than go with Jes
I would go vial and Jes if I were you, but idk what sims
the defensive utility of jes is basically non existant
what is it a few % dr for a 12 seconds on a 2min cd
yeah it's just pretty shit, isn't it? I'll sim it for dps just to see
yep, it's shit, 200dps loss either way, feelsbad
warriors have a bunch of cd's to rotate through, personally i dont really think having a piss weak version of a CD is worth the trinket slot
unless you got a juicy tf
yeah, makes sense
@limpid pawn I’m not sure what he’s using because I don’t have his UI open but most people use Expedia Raid Tools for raid cooldowns and a weakaura to track Ashvane shield
@old night use null r3, the damage profile is half magic damage and the dps from null helps push the dps check
Exorsus raid tools**
@sick sentinel only reason to use Jes is if you suck at doing damage and like playing as tanky as possible. That way you’re using the better defensive trinket AND helping your dps make up for your lack of dps. Otherwise vial macrod to avatar and gore block is your best setup
@willow scarab thanks man; that's how I'm set up now; I'm just going to keep it that way. I'm ready for new trinks because these are my lowest slots, but they will come 😃
Tfw 445 every slot except trinkets and weapon, and your trinkets and weapon are the worst options
f
im almost the same actually
trinkets and shield tho 😦
praying for a 445 coral when we get her
I have to tank this week in mythic raid. which two should I use?
I guess how good is the gleaming eye for prot wararior
yeah
defensively those are poop in raid
talking the urchin and diamond
of you die you'll die due to playing poorly
and those trinkets won't save you
Wait there's another way to play tank than go absolute max dps? Didn't play in a while lmao
yes it's called being a LIMIT tank
And when such tank swaps to max dps, it’s called Limit Break
🚀
Wasn't method the break-guild
Why is the diamond poop? Yeah ilvl is loe but its still our best defensive trinket isnt it? Ofc barring all defensive trinkets being quite shitty since atleast legion
@opaque vine mael said that ashvane+briny are poop defensively
Ya that was referring to the thing after
Yeah okay, that makes alot more sense
Who runs defensive trinkets in raid 😤
People who are forced to tank
I actually used diamond with socket for our hc zaqul & ashvane firstkills cause it felt like our healers were a little stretched
(Pls dont stone me)
Tank trinkets are a trap I'm convinces
You get them from raid -> but they are garbo in raid
I only run one defensive trinket right now for m+and that's because I don't have block yet and like edicts alot
Yeah see I'm an engineer so my ideal would also be rezans/gore because I like trinkets like that
Not a big fan of briny barncle and vial...I run vial on tyrannical weeks but it's fortified so /shrug
Just like Rezans + Edict this week
Thats why i play monk in raid and warr for mplus
Wasnt briny nerfed pretty badly some time ago?
All numerical trinkets got buffed with 8.2
Huh, didnt even know...😩
Or rather anything that had a does X dmg / healing / absorb got changed so it scales with secondaries resulting in like a 100% buff
Ohh right, the no longer scaling wirh primaries thing. Wow, looks like i underestimated that pretty badly
Isnt 430 edict better than 415 diamond?
One of them scales hard with haste
And one not at all
You could test them and see how much hps they are doing
question is if diamond can absorb magic damage?
But keep in mind if you're at 1,4k haste or at 2k haste its completely different caliber
Yes it can
which one scales with haste?
Diamond
Pretty sure 430 urchin does more
Diamond scales with haste and vers but edict only vers
Since its like 9k every 3 seconds
Urchin is better than both I think
Edict is better for mythic+
Ooh, btw @strong forum i did like 23 crates yesterday in 30m so thanks for that.
Will do the other 17 today.

Edict is only better once you have the fanaticism stackd
And you lose your stacks if you swap schools or die
@tawny maple all that matters is what will give you more damage absorbed at the end of the dungeon
So a 430 edict, idk if its better. 445 definetely
@sick sentinel Yeah depending on the dungeon but i average like 4.5k absorbed
with Edict
I ran a 415 edict couple weeks back, did fucking nothing, I couldn't even get max stacks in a dungeon
What do you mean average like 4.5k absorbed, diamond does like 5.2mil a dungeon, that's what I know
Diamond is straight 2.5k hps
It's all about hps but ya
@strong forum depending on haste
Well
On my vdh and my warri it's around that
Pretty equal
With huge difference in haste
Atleast I think 🤔
But vdh doesnt get 6%+ for free does it?
All I know is that Dh has more crit than other classes
Idk if that's a fact, but it sure as hell feels like it
Vdh doesn't want crit
has =/= want
Sure
Lmao
Do you guys have screenshots of urchin that shit feels bad to me
I think the last time I used it I only healed like 1 mil of damage
I have a feeling urchin scales better with brm than prot
Ya
But in high keys everybody takes enough dmg to perma cap out on urchin
I would assume
If you don't take dmg urchin obv doesn't heal for shit
Probably pairs well with brm crit
F
And someone was saying that edict is eh in m+?
That depends heavily on damage taken too
Yup
Would you say the required dtps is higher on edict to fully utilize it
is lurkers any good for prot
vs socketed venom trinket from sethraliss
415 vs 430
Edict needs higher ilvl and long encounters
Minimum of roughly 7 minutes until it at full stacks
I dont have one yet, how long do fanatical dtaxks keep going till they run out?
Everyone here play devastator?
What happens when shield slam / thunderclap / revenge all on CD and theres no rage for IP
You just stand there twiddling your thumbs until one becomes available
is there no filler?
@manic cypress Devastator is usually only played when going for ST DPS.
There are not many times where you have nothing to press so don't worry about it.
recently switched to devastator and i must say i'm not used to it
But in general if it does happen then yes - you just wait a bit.
Hey Mwahi good to hear from you , i'm actually starting to play Devastator for first 4 mythic bosses
ok ty , just making sure i'm not missing any part of my rotation
Nice. : )
really trying to squeeze out every bit of dps for ashvane
also is there a weakaura out there to make sure i'm always facing boss?
like some times when i turn ashvane it gets funny and i feel i'm not hitting boss
might be a few seconds but it bothers me
@opaque vine at max fanaticism edicts will absorb between 1 and 4 autoattacks vs a boss (assuming 12%ish vers)
i watched a kill vid where this tank had this weakaura i believe that makes a sound whenever he isnt facing boss
talking the phys absorb bit
Shouldn't really need a WA for that. o.o
it's 168k absorb, vs magic dmg it's substantial, but it could just get eaten by trivial damage since you don't control when to pop it
to put it in perspective, mchimba's is, at 440 ilvl, on a 1.5 min cd, a 179k absorb before vers
i don't see a world where edicts is remotely prefferable in any type of content
You in game @brittle owl ?
they can be
I was more wondering about whether or not stacks fall off between m+ trash groups
i know someone in dh discord kept a 410 mchimbas and when it got buffed it had a 120ish k absorb on it
so at least on mchimba it seems consistent somewhat
Also what are everyones favorite m+ trinkets? Just the highest simming ones?
Currently im using my 445 Rezans and 430 inkpod which overall does quite good damage
rezan + gore actually
Coral and rezans
Coral is big yike in keys
can you guys confirm taking barrels out of the room in tol dagor is dumb as fuck? im pretty sure it is right?
every tol dagor key i do, someone takes out barrels
Just take the left front one to the right to have a clear corner.
every. single. one
Anyone in game who can tell me their haste % and SS CD?
Trying to explain people mechanics when they are 100% sure they are in the right will never go right.
Easiest is to avoid such people.
Or deal with them. Like putting the barrels out does not make the boss impossible.
Just has you deal with barrels earlier.
has it ever been a good idea?
nah
or was it patched after release because that tactic was op somehow?
so why are people doing it in the first place? lol
We did it too back then, people told us it was great.
i remember seeing guides about during release to take them out
Ye.
No. It was a dumb strat from launch of bad that spread like wildfire. Now all the fools out there think it works.
Maybe they changed it or sth so that they respawn earlier and beginning of bfa they didn't.
But idk.
We did it like week 1 of bfa.
And never again after.
🤷
from now on im telling people to not take them out before the key starts
its just so annoying
It easier and faster to just move the barrel into the other corner
i usually move everything to the right and stick to the left
Moving out the barrels out of the room is stupid
All you do is, tank boss in the very middle
And move out the barrels that will get hit
Just barely out of hit range
Done.
Tanking in the middle is the easiest way.
Tanking in the front left corner and having healer take all barrels to the opposite side of room is the safest in my experience with pugs.
(replace with healer with any other person you are premade with)
Well I don't pug.
Oh ye.
In coordinated groups we do it in the middle too.
But too many people are not used to that.
If its not full group I refuse to do keys
Cuz it's not fun with randoms
Cuz you can't meme and do stupid shit and still laugh
Idk, we are not doing high keys, only up to 17 but we mostly pug 2-3 people and it's quite fine.
We do get them on Discord most of the time tho.
And when we want fun meme runs we just do some 11-14s with shit alts in a full premade 😄
Like, with pugs I feel like you are forced to play seriously, so cba
oh ye, definitely.
We kinda just don't have 5 people that can do 16/17s.
So we do fully rely on pugs there although we normally have 20-30 people on friendlist that we know are capable
So we can take from there.
Like, we failed ToS 15 yesterday in Alt run cuz 2 people died like 20 times to cleave
Fucking giga kek
Ya same
Like getting a cleave directly after breath in a big pull... I mean ye okay, that can happen sometimes.
Buuuuuut not there
Ye, I see it now.
But on that pull I had 55k hps as vdh
Still weird.
So that was fun
Yeee that's what I thought 😄
Do we know what affixes we will have after reset today in the US?
No.
😢
how do i promote someone to main tank in lfr
we have no tanks but a dps stepped up and swapped specs
but i want his frame in the correct place
I think you go to the raid group (O) and right click his name...but I’m not sure at all...never had to do it
how is undulating tides for prot? dmg and surv-wise?
I’m not a fan of tides due to the downtime imposed by the shield. It does pretty good damage though
pretty good in both dmg and surv, but i would not put it ahead of bom,dc or if
Yeah, on paper both the shield and damage are nice. It’s just the 45 sec of it being completely inactive that I’m not too keen on.
just noticed that the piece where undulating tides is an option is the only one available with dc.. on the same row.. thx anyways
if thats your only one dc, go for dc... if that dc would be your second i would choose tides
Same
Agree
I want to up my rider io score. Not sure how. Seem sany key above 10 in pugs we miss the timer. I think I’m going to be that guy that requires discord. Unless any one here want to help. I don’t know all the pathing etc for all the dungeon. 429 fury 427 prot.
Experience
You can't complete if you don't deplete
Just keep at it
You don't need discord until like 16s
agree, experience is the key 😃
Experience is the key for keys
Yes we’ll on ad 11 today first boss I say please run in water if fixated not on land and there’s 3 dink’s before boss does first fear.
It’s all about experience. Learning the fights, learning what’s deadly and what can be ignored
Dino’s not dink
Why not run in the water
I need to learn pathing and skips ast tank Ik ad tos ur and freehold decentyl.
He was saying they should run in water
Yes and they did not lol. Wiped if first boss. I left. All low io but problem is mines only like 600 so I don’t get invited. I try to push my own keys.
if you have the possibility just run mplus with friends (y)
Don’t have the possibility. Some of them are worse than pugs lol
Learn how to maximise your own play and then slowly crawl up in io through pugs until you’ve got a respectable enough score to go to a real key
Learn routes and how to perfectly play warrior. Research is 70% of gaining io
I have a bad ass dh and a monk when they all on at same time. Land a prot pally.
well learn routes is now kinda difficult as each week is different and not all emissary spots have been showed yet
Lol head first baby we are warriors.
Then you got educated by friends who researched for sure
You don’t just luck into skips
People tell me about them yea
90% of my routes are mine
Then people in my group tell me about something somebody did
I try it
And incorporate it if it works and I like it
Surely spam running the dungeons and studying the MDT counts as research if you’re making your own efficient 22 routes
You can’t just click mdt as a new player and have a viable route for a high key
Raider.io has the weekly routes which is a good starting point to figure out what works for you and what doesn’t
I just like finding shit out by myself
^^
Dratnos routes are lit once you’re good at keys
When you’re just starting they’re ok
That’s why I suggested. If you’re really pushing keys I wouldn’t use them
I dislike dratnos' routes
Like they are good
If you have his comp
But if you have a different comp
It's not as good
It’s a starting point. But any route is a starting point
It's a good place to get an idea
Yeah, that’s why I suggested.
Yup. But don’t be afraid to question them and change them
^ This
Yup. Especially since Emissary spawns are a bit of a gamble week to week now.
They are set
They’re fixed
I meant more that sometimes the groupings w/ packs are harder than on other weeks. Sorry if I worded that wrong.
is there anything cool we can cheese or bypass in the raid by using nullification dynamo as a major ?
My group timed our first 18 of the season last night. Shit got iffy here and there. Our Feral Druid wasn't doing that great dps. :P
I just tell my group to play whatever they want to play, and we'll try to work with it
Fair enough
Last night, it was a feral druid, ele sham, bm hunter, rdruid, and my war.
Feral does decent numbers tbh
All that matters is that the players are happy 😊 you could time an 18 with any comp
any1 find it bit hard i know its skittish this week but dps using there focusing iris breaking my agro anoyin lol
but i manage
@sick sentinel if your group is full of mongoloids who don’t understand threat then yes you’ll have issues if they use it on pull
If it's a hunter tell him to md and then beam
Same with rogue and tricks
Or a rogue should tricks and beam
If not they should wait a little bit and use it - not on pull
yeah 😃 was a mage
Had this issue last night. Rogue and monk kept going ham with cleave and iris before I could even clap. Our hunter maybe MD me 3 times during the entire run. That’s the risk with pugs I guess.
Rogue was a little better with tricks than the hunter but not by much.
Avatar+str pot on pull usually holds threat over dps, if few whatever reason I dont have avatar on pull I tell the dps
good news is that skittish is over and by the time it comes back you'll hopefully be more relatively geared 😃
It was mostly the pulls where I didn’t have avatar up that were difficult. Would have been smooth sailing if they were more consistent with tricks/md or simply waiting 1 or 2 seconds before dumping cds
Skittish only really is an issue with odd mob deaths and big boys that you need to step away from
well, bolster is handled by "simply" distributing your dps evenly. However, it's the "simply" part that DPS have the hardest time with.
All was forgiven though as I got my Underrot mount out of it😁
Well in an 8 mob pull, I generally step back as the first thing dies. Could be just long enough to lose threat on one of the later things to die
@random urchin - your DPS are window lickers
With MD and Tricks for basically every beam you should have zero issues
With skittish that generally my biggest concern
If they didn’t tricks or use MD when they use Beam it’s their own damn fault
Yeah “should” being the key word there
Don’t blame yourself. It’s their fault.
Yeah it was frustrating but I got a mount out of it so I can’t be mad
Threat isn’t just a tank issue - it’s an everyone problem - but primarily dps / tank
Yeah, I main an ele sham and have always been mindful of skittish for the tanks im with. Now that I’m seeing it from a tanks perspective I see why they’re harder for find in pugs on skittish weeks lol.
The other option is Anima. I tend to use it on fortified weeks anyway
May not be optimal - but it’s fun
Using potions on trash pulls helps a ton and really smooths out skittish
Yeah, I need to get more essences on my warr still.
Really only started using him this past week for current content. So it’s just a race to get caught up right now.
Underrot mount is the only dungeon mount I dont have now, got my tombstalker this past weekend
I’ve seen the KR one drop about 5 times and FH once. Out of all of them I’m glad I got the UR one as it’s my favorite anyways.
going to second Anima. Essentially functions as an AoE taunt button on Skittish, which is nice
I’ll have to keep that in mind for the next time skittish comes around.
Currently have 3x BoM so I was just going the easy route of VoP for avatar
Rally into last stand into anima lmao
go big or go home
The sims use last stand before anima
Yeah. I bet last stand pumps anima up a ton
I checked
Anima is prob one of the most "oomph" buttons for tanks to hit in BFA
Basically a mega clap by the sounds of it
Juicy
no VDH style bombs, but prob pretty close
prob not hard for a war to push 800k hp with LS + RC
so that's pretty close to 940k hp
cool, but your log is not that
Is there a reason I can't reflect the blood bolt cast from elder leaxa? It seems that I can only reflect the add cast?
it is a relevant point in the sense that anima does not respect the traditional 20 target cap @sand egret
that's the main distinction
Maybe I'm mistiming, but I hit reflect as she is casting and it never seems to reflect, only the add cast seems to
You should be able to reflect both. However you'll reflect the one that hits you first, even if it's by a fraction of a second. So if the add bolt hits you before the boss one, you'll reflect that instead.
Also, are you looking at logs to realize this or just basing it on not seeing an animation flying back at the boss?
I was under the impression that Details doesn't show reflected damage? Never noticed it on combat text either but I just use the default shit there
@brittle owl but no one was talkin about the cap lol. it was the damage of anima...which comes down to HP pools. Positing a log that shows the Anima damage that indicates a variance of only 140k hp off my suggested top-end is not what i’d define as “not remotely” close.
im so happy. getting so much luck from residuum vendor this season
i didn't roll the same chestpiece 6x in a row
like last season
Woo!
so far i've rolled helm of putrid path and desert guardians breastplate
still relevant, since most aoe abilities stop scaling well past 20 targets, and anima doesn't, it scales linearly regardless of targets
is there any kind of soft cap for haste on prot?
or is there a stat distribution i should be aiming for?
No, on both counts
no one is talkin about a cap, maelk. you just brought it up lol
450 spore with a socket sims lower than my 430 trinkets -_- feels bad
it leads to the 'mega tc' analogy

yeah lol
How often are you even pulling 20 targets, even if you're doing big boy pulls?
what are the current ideal prot azerite talents?
BoM x3, DC x1, something something
aoe or st?
sots&temple have such pulls
I mean, do they though
but they're not relevant
for Mythic+
Because droplets and conscripts don't really count lol
like real world application, there is none
Yeah
only memes
If you have anima major and pull that room, and you DON'T cast Anima, are you even playing the game
If I already have one DC should i take one Callous Reprisal?
Not if you have...just about any other option
Callous is on the bottom end of options for us
get a barrage helm
What site are you using for that info?
icy-veins, sims, common sense
wowhead and icyveins says CR is good
bloodmallet is reasonable i guess
Icy-veins says CR is good because it's based on survival only. And wowhead is a blah guide (though it does have some overlap with IV's guide)
since, realistically, you very rarely turtle up
you only do that ib
- bleeding edge progress
Okay so what about CR vs Brace for impact
CR is terrible from a dps standpoint
Brace, all day
- you dunno the game
one of those 2 scenarios is where you turtle up
to cover your mistakes
otherwise you go ham, since the value of survivability is literally limited to wether you die or not, whereas dps is always valuable
But stacking DC is not worth it anymore correct?
not anymore no
as opposed to grabbing ironfortress in favor
or any other dps increasing trait
like heed or op
wait those are diff ring traits i think
DC wouldn't be compared to Heed or OP though :p They're on a different ring
If all you care about is damage, I'd still take DC over IF
IF's damage is meh
But it's one of only 3 sources of block rating, so it's very strong
ive actually wondered about that. I feel like there is a point where if you can take X more hits without healing, then there may be a greater proportional dps gain via the healer dpsing instead of healing 🤔
m+ and raid are disproportionately different scenarios this patch though
a dps centric tank literally does double or triple the damage of a turtle tank in raid
I think the normal caveat there is that it would likely take too much of a sacrifice from you for the healer to gain that. And it would be pretty hard to quantify regardless since you don't know for sure that not healing you = healer DPSing
well rdruids style of healing throws it out of wack
why do 14k dps when you can do 30k and take 10% more damage
I think there's a better argument to be made in dungeons for sure because with how short fights are, you could probably do less damage and have it be less noticeable since most of your damage outside of bosses is burst anyway
But it depends on how turtley you go I guess haha
so it's binary in a lot of ways since you can get topped so fast
the thing about dungeons though
there's so many moving parts
you can't decide on a binary logic
Well, I think if you're in a premade group that you run with often, you can quantify the gain to the healer a bit better
Still not perfectly of course, but better
i know it's meme-y to bring it up, but it's the same logic behind why one would conceptually gear for leech
sure, but conceptually its there. If damage to hp ratios were different, that cost changes a bunch (as what happens towards the end of expacs)
I think there's a bit of a difference there too, as it's possible to gear for leech without any sacrifice, with some good RNG
more so than in legion
i'd imagine if we did 10x our damage (with mobs having correspondingly more hp) but the same hp pools, Leech wouldn't nearly be as scoffed at imho
What DPS essences should I be running for AoE in dungeons btw? Is it just Anima or wut
Like I don't know anyone who would be mad about having 10% leech if it was also their highest ilevel lol. I think everyone in here would have some fun with that.
of for sure
VoP is what most people run
Oh right, I totally forgot that essence existed
Ummm.... top dmg traits vs top defensive traits are not going to be massive swing in dps, you're looking at most a 5% difference.
o_o;
wut
Wut
CoF is literally a 3 k dps increase
well 5% is "massive" in the right context
on ST
Well he's talking about traits, not essences
oh ye mb
So VoP Major what minor for dps? just Conflict or wut
Traits is what the talk started on. And I mean 5% for 6 traits, less than 1 % per trait and that's if you skip all of the dmg doing traits
So I just got back to wow and currently have terrible@Azerite 420 pieces. Is it worth buying some of the random 430 residuum pieces
If you're not raiding, I'd buy 430s before I bought 445s, especially if your traits suck
Yea only doing mythic plus
I would definitely suggest 430s first then. They'll come way faster than 445s and it'll be a nice gain in the short term
I mean RF adds a lot of dps. I’d argue more than just 1% - but I’d have to math it out.
That said - when you need the dps you fight for those gains, no matter how small, because they all add up
Still want to keep about 3-4 bastion traits?
You can probably buy 2 430s and then farm pearls while waiting for your first 445 and buy a 430 with benthic
3*
Yeah
(Insert al Pacino speech from Any Given Sunday - fighting for inches)
Ok cool I appreciate it
I'm only countering the clown that said why do 14k when you can do 30k, that is a ridiculous statement in the context.
It honestly isn’t though.
You can do 14k and be super tanky or you can do - what’s your current parse @willow scarab - 34k?
Sorry Sim*
14k is auto attacking a boss with devastator, that is only barely a lie
I mean - then you’re not going full defensive
5% damage is huge lol
Being able to differentiate when you should go full defensive and when you should go more offensive, as well as how offensive, is a very important skill
If your character is capable of doing 34k sim, show me a sim of that same character doing 14k
As long as you can smooth damage out then doing more dps is generally always going to be better. Raid healing can be looked at as infinite as long as it’s smooth
Hence the entire class of brewmaster
Even if it’s swimming 20k dps when full defensive build / traits / essences instead of 14k the point stands
Hell - even if it’s 24k
Needs constant healing but it’s easy because its smooth
out of curiosity, which trinket would you guys say is better. the abyssal alchemist stone, or Ritual Feather of Uung Ak (both 410 ilvl and both have a socket)
Ritual feather trinket has base 394 str and on use mastery of 578 for 16 seconds on 1 min cd, compared against alch trink
You are making a point that I'm not arguing against
I'd just upgrade the alc stone tbh lol
In a lot of cases, we don’t need the added defensives once we reach that point. Hence why you see warriors swapping to more dps oriented builds
It sounded like you’re arguing against going more offensive
If you’re not then I apologize
k, before i can do that i need the restored abyssal focus. forgot about that quest chain lol
Even changing your full kit wont do that
there is a profanity meme somewhere in this discussion
You lose damage, but not anywhere near half
Archaous - changing your full kit - talents / essences / traits can and will make a staggering difference
Can we officially name this week #FuckDiscPriestsWeek?
depends on race
but generally i agree
also @exotic spoke depends on the content you're doing
And most of that damage loss is from changing essences, not from swapping traits as was originally suggested
I gained 5k dps by swapping to 2 Rf / devastator / using two dps trinkets and some other minor stuff
current sim 37k @exotic spoke
if you're doing trivial content then success isnt dictated by anything you mentioned
430 wep and bad trinkets
Blizzard: Alright, necrotic guys. Can't heal your tank while they're tanking.
Disc Priests: Well, at least I can get them caught up after combat if they're low.
Blizzard: Almost forgot, they're also going to take a huge amount of damage when the mobs die
Disc Priests:
Blizzard:
You get a lot from RF is what I’m saying
@brittle owl I mean - yeah it depends on what content. I’m talking mythic raids / m+
@willow scarab how much if you go full defensive? Just curious
idk maybe like 25 i ahven't simmed it
next time i'm flying between a WQ i'll sim
very busy atm because reset day
30k to 14k isn't realistic, that is the only point I was making btw
Get 65 neck Fum?
it kinda is with benthic
yeah got 65 neck
granted not 16k dps diff
Hell yeah, congrats!
but it should be like 4-5k
That's a 33% loss, long way from 50
That may be worth still
33k defensive sim seems weird
wait i did itw rong i guess, that's not the items i picked
Losing dmg% not the same as gained dmg %
just paying atetntion to WQ
ahhhhh shit
It’s how percents work. I’m looking at it from a gain and you’re looking st it from a loss