#protection

1 messages · Page 2583 of 1

sick sentinel
#

having a bit of mastery is still good

exotic spoke
#

Oh, so, funny experience yesterday.

#

I pugged heroic BoD cause I was bored waiting on GoT.

Went in on Grong

#

We wiped. Eh, whatever no biggie. Then some dps was saying tanks sucked and didn’t know how to do the fight because on a triple bite one tank got two stacks of the bleed

#

“We should taunt after every bite then it won’t stack”

#

Obviously I’ve been doing that boss all wrong if that’s the case.... right?

mortal brook
#

shoulda been dorf. sheesh. get good

tropic wharf
#

Tell them to tank it

exotic spoke
#

I just changed to dwarf. But used it earlier on a triple bite lol

#

Leader kicked them. Since they actually knew the fight

#

And the dps also where shocked when I said a second crush isn’t much damage.

oblique garnet
#

I mean 2nd crush will oneshot

#

Undergeared tanks

lime mantle
#

Honestly when that happens I just taunt shield wall sd and hope

sick sentinel
#

you can solo tank hc grong tho

lime mantle
#

Then die because healers straight up refuse to heal because they are used to Bdk and Paladin. Then say I randomly use SW lel.
I mean on mythic sorry.

exotic spoke
#

SB / IP is enough to survive a second crush in mythic - for me

I want to try taking 3 in mythic but they won’t let me

willow scarab
#

How

#

500% increased damage?

#

SB/IP is enough?

exotic spoke
#

Yes

#

I mitigated 90% of it. Between armor, block, IP, diamond it did like 140k

oblique garnet
#

yeah

mortal brook
#

add in reflecting the grip dmg and you're golden 😄

oblique garnet
#

the 2x smash on mythic wont drop you below 50% with sb up

willow scarab
#

I have never tried but like... i'm shocked?

exotic spoke
#

Second one if I demo + last stand + shield wall

#

Should be good

#

Sorry, third one

willow scarab
#

350k damage x 500% is mitigated to wet noodle damage from just regular AM?

#

i am shocked

exotic spoke
#

Yeah - block is OP OP

willow scarab
#

and probably gonna try it this week

#

Surely 1.7m damage

exotic spoke
#

I have a 415 shield with BfI, and IF

willow scarab
#

is there a log of this

exotic spoke
#

Of the one stack of crush?

oblique garnet
#

yes

mortal brook
#

minus armor. minus vers. minus block/crit block. minus ip/trinkets.,

oblique garnet
exotic spoke
#

Mine didn’t have SB up but I had avatar so still blocked it

#

Off tank fucked a taunt

willow scarab
#

holy shit

#

Also just realized a crit block is a 100% block at my block value

exotic spoke
#

Up to 85% mitigation max

willow scarab
#

damn blizzard doing me dirty

#

i want my 50.16x2 to be 100%

exotic spoke
#

It doubles your block mitigation up to 85%

willow scarab
#

not good enough

sick sentinel
#

ehm

#

target a raiding dummy

#

and then check again

exotic spoke
#

Throw in armor mitigation. Throw in IP, and yeah... it’ll be a joke

#

Also; what kaege said.

#

Cause that seems really high

willow scarab
#

It still says 50.16

exotic spoke
#

415 shield and what are your traits?

#

Like how many BfI and IF?

willow scarab
#

3x tc 2x bom 1x dc in this set

#

415 shiled

exotic spoke
#

So no extra block value?

willow scarab
#

correct

#

should it have recalculated to like 35% or somethign

#

I've never looked at my block values I just... know how block works

exotic spoke
#

You should be at 42.8 for m+ 38.1% for heroic bod and 35.7% for mythic bod

willow scarab
#

I saw the K values spread and figured numbers similar to that

#

I was ready for my character pane to recalculate after what Kaege said is all

exotic spoke
#

2 If brings mythic up to almost 39%

#

So yeah - any thoughts on buying random ones versus saving for next season?

willow scarab
#

I was saving, had 4k and got a helm because other than that I had perfect azerite

#

Got perfect helm so now i'm saving, I think even if I didn't I would have kept saving

strong forum
#

I just kept buying azerite like a motherfucker spending over 10k on that shit at this point

exotic spoke
#

I bought a specific piece so I could have double IF a couple weeks ago. Just not sure if it’s worth saving or not

willow scarab
#

Doing a 20 each week means you'll have barely enough for a 445 item on 8.2 launch

strong forum
#

You'll need 17k atleast

exotic spoke
#

Yeah, I think I’ll save then

willow scarab
#

Current popular date is july 2nd

#

which give you like what 6-7k TR if you do a 20 each week

strong forum
#

So you can get ahead by 1 week in the best case

willow scarab
#
  • whatever you scrap
exotic spoke
#

Buying 445 off the bat is kinda nice

strong forum
#

It's 1 week lead, nothing more

sick sentinel
#

you cant buy 445 insta tho its after mythic raid opens so

#

you got time

willow scarab
#

I'm at 4.5k atm so +6k from farming until patch drop + 3k from DEing my current azerite

#

Still short

strong forum
#

I have like 3k TR in form of azerite in bags at this point

willow scarab
#

So really if you're not already saving you're too late

exotic spoke
#

Whatever I have +8k (just under) from doing at least a 20 each week. + scrapping 415s from BoD play scrapping whatever else

willow scarab
#

You're in the best place out of all of us then

exotic spoke
#

I’ll be close to buying one when it comes out. I think I have 4K -5k now

willow scarab
#

I would save as much as possbile because if it's 19k and we all saved 17k like chumps then you win

oblique garnet
#

how much is one 445?

strong forum
#

17-20k

willow scarab
#

unconfirmed but popular number is 17k

strong forum
#

It's 10x of current + a bit

willow scarab
#

with neck levels being removed

#

are you just buying a 450

oblique garnet
#

so i might get enough for 2

willow scarab
#

how do you have 35k azerite

strong forum
#

Powerful

oblique garnet
#

havent needed to reroll at all and played alot?

strong forum
#

I could be at like 15k if I didn't spend as much as I did

#

Maybe more

willow scarab
#

not needing to reroll is th real trick

#

I went through 6 shoulder tokens

strong forum
#

6 shoulders 2 chests and 4 helmets here

#

Ama

willow scarab
#

What's gonna be graet

#

Is when 8,2 drops and we roll the same dog shit items we rolled on 8.1.5

strong forum
#

But with 1 more Ring

willow scarab
#

and higher ilvl

#

worth?

#

i mean obviously

strong forum
#

Insanely worth

willow scarab
#

but it still hurts

exotic spoke
#

I had to buy 1 specific piece to get a second IF. Otherwise the randoms where fine

strong forum
#

🤷

sand egret
#

are they adding another ring?

strong forum
#

AFAIK yes

willow scarab
#

yeah they are

sand egret
#

so 3 big traits per item?

strong forum
#

Every tier of azerite gets a new ring

willow scarab
#

so when you cut the item in half you can see how old the xpac is

exotic spoke
#

Outer ring). Holy fuck

strong forum
#

Yes

oblique garnet
#

wait?

#

So

#

6x BoM the dream?

exotic spoke
#

Holy shit that’s crazy

strong forum
#

You get 9 class traits

willow scarab
#

how could you get 6 bom

sand egret
#

so 3x DC 3xBoM 3x MS

willow scarab
#

that would be 6 azerite items

strong forum
#

I doubt you'll get twice on the same piece

oblique garnet
#

if they will be 9 class traits

strong forum
#

And in 8. 3 we'll have 4 class rings

oblique garnet
#

eh

#

well

#

we will see

sand egret
#

has this confirmed...

exotic spoke
#

3 BoM, 3 Dc, 3 If.

sand egret
#

been*

willow scarab
#

I read it in prot discord so it's fact

exotic spoke
#

More aoe damage

willow scarab
#

I will treat this as confirmed

strong forum
#

Its literally been said by ion that they will continue the trend of adding more rings

sand egret
#

when

willow scarab
#

Maybe they jump to 5 rings for 8.3 to give us nice power creep for strong players

strong forum
#

Idk couple months back

willow scarab
#

or alternative: every azerite item gives you every azerite trait

#

so you end up with 3x every trait available

strong forum
#

That's boring

willow scarab
#

me strong

sand egret
#

more rings would change the AP requirements, something they confirmed they aren't increasing

willow scarab
#

warrior smash

oblique garnet
#

bois

#

: )

strong forum
#

There aren't ap requirements

sand egret
#

so this would just be "extra" ring

exotic spoke
#

Oh grats man

sand egret
#

still seems weird, but i mean more shit is welcome

willow scarab
#

Feelsbad getting it this close to 8.2

strong forum
#

They are getting rid of ap requirements for armor, are you living under a rock @sand egret

willow scarab
#

The only eye I've had this entire tier was 425 about 6 weeks ago

sand egret
#

that is what I said, yes

strong forum
#

From 8.2 on, you will have all traits unlocked

exotic spoke
#

The extra ring of primary traits seems fucking OP for certain classes

strong forum
#

And just farm ap for your titan essences

exotic spoke
#

And meh for others

strong forum
#

Warri will continue to scale insanely

#

Bdk will get worse and worse

willow scarab
#

Have any of you tried the avatar proc trait on ptr

#

40-45% uptime on avatar

exotic spoke
#

The exact examples that came to mind

strong forum
#

60%

willow scarab
#

maybe i press my buttons differntly to you

exotic spoke
#

It’s already ~40% fumeyio

strong forum
#

I haven't been on ptr but that's been the proclaimed numbers, on live it's 40% ye

exotic spoke
#

20 seconds up about of 45-50 cd

strong forum
#

If you don't have 40% on live you're doing something very wrong :D

willow scarab
#

I think my essence broken

#

I got 43% on logs from the 1 dugneon I did

strong forum
#

Well dungeon is somewhat different

sand egret
#

👏 stealth 👏 nerf 👏 ???

willow scarab
#

40% is on a dummy yeah

#

I'm looking at my raid logs and i'm definitely not at 40%

worthy dagger
#

you dont generate as much rage as you do during m+s

#

that means your burn less rage, AM has a lesser effect, etc

willow scarab
#

That I understand

#

What I don't understand is why my uptime is 30.8% on Jaina

#

Or why I only used 8 in 8:28 fight

#

I also just found out I'm 7 allstar points off being on top 10 world

#

that's kinda cool

exotic spoke
#

There’s down time on Jaina isn’t there?

willow scarab
#

ish

#

But not really

#

If you do 1st avalanche in P2 you have to hold it but i don't think that counts for this much

exotic spoke
#

Haven’t done mythic? But in heroic running out the ice rebuff, time spent running out in the ocean, etc

#

How much do you intervene?

willow scarab
#

As often as possible for maximum boss uptime

#

In a 30s shorter kill Boost used it 8 times as well

#

Food for my own thought I guess

#

Other warrior used it 9 times in a 10 second longer fight

exotic spoke
#

Question - why not use it on CD?

willow scarab
#

It's up straight out of transition and I have to run avalanche 10s later

exotic spoke
#

Well, one charge to your OT on CD and leaving the other one up

#

That way you could intervene back after avalanche?

willow scarab
#

i charge my escort on the way out and charge the ordnance on the way back in

#

or something similar

#

I don't understand what Boost does to smash everyone elses logs by so much every single fight

#

because it's more than just cheese

sick sentinel
#

i can't find anything at all to confirm that were getting another ring of traits with 8.2

#

we're not

exotic spoke
#

We were lied too!

#

By ourselves

last mason
#

Anybody have a super simple avatar cd wa

#

Wago doesn’t have any

#

And my set of WAs has everything but that for some reason

sick sentinel
#

I have weep's wa

neon tangle
#

@last mason It's pretty easy to make one that just shows a CD

last mason
#

I don’t really know how

#

That’s why I asked in case anyone just had one on hand they could just dm me real quick

honest canopy
#

For SW

desert gust
#

is the skyhold.gg site better than icyveins for all warrior specs?

honest canopy
#

What you think about drop DC and a IF

#

To get 3x RF

sick sentinel
#

don't drop dc

#

@desert gust use icyveins for prot

desert gust
#

OK, thanks!

last mason
#

Rf?

#

What is that

#

Not reckless flurry right

lusty grotto
#

RF is reckless flurry yes

last mason
#

Wait why would you want that?

#

For some cheese devastator st build?

exotic spoke
#

Pretty much

#

Some people use it for Jaina

sick sentinel
#

supposedly its one of the better, if not best ST trait to stack with BfI

honest canopy
#

@sick sentinel I know The DS uptime is gucci but i was thinking there aint really and dmg going on at SW

#

I was on The DK today and my sides dps was shocking

#

We are swsppiing some for weds

#

If I get some more brains i dont have to lead, i can do more dipps

#

I am on boss all The time at p2

lusty grotto
#

its only good if you need to push ST and to of course cheese parses

#

to get higher rankings etc

exotic spoke
#

Next week - gore crusted butcher block is our friend right?

lusty grotto
#

i always use block anyway

exotic spoke
#

Listen here Stewart

#

Fuck

lusty grotto
#

😄

unborn island
#

sanguine

#

fuck sanguine

lusty grotto
#

ive been swapping between rezan/anchor paired with block

unborn island
#

I look forward to my TD key

exotic spoke
#

Obviously, just trying to get the best trinket combo

lusty grotto
#

knot + block :p

unborn island
#

so I can just smuch my sanguine everywhere

exotic spoke
#

Have 410 in a couple - pretty sure gore crusted is one of them - though it could be knot - and diamond

lusty grotto
#

nay!

#

knot + block ftw

#

remember diamond loses value to necrotic as well

exotic spoke
#

Mm true

#

I’ll check if I have knot at a good Ilvl

honest canopy
#

Idk what i run

#

Block and prism i think

exotic spoke
#

Thinking block / knot if I have both at 410+ and I think I do

last mason
#

im m+ if i have the choice between 3 dc and 1 dc 2 IF, which should i take

#

in*

lusty grotto
#

what lvl key

exotic spoke
#

Do you need survivability or no?

lusty grotto
#

^

last mason
#

if im not fantastic at the spec yet

#

should i take IF till im more comfotable

exotic spoke
#

It comes down to what you think you need. If you and your healer are confident in keeping you alive without IF then take more DC

If you’re not then take If

lusty grotto
#

yup

neon tangle
#

@last mason what are your other options besides for the 2x DC anyhow?

exotic spoke
#

Personally, I’m happy it’s time to start swapping for more dps.

honest canopy
#

Silly question but

#

👌

#

Whats that called in english?

last mason
#

@neon tangle the main piece in question is the champs chest

honest canopy
#

Sleepy go If, pull more, do more dpa

#

Dps

lusty grotto
#

i use IF for anything higher than 15

honest canopy
#

If owns

lusty grotto
#

if 10 to 14...or lower i go DC

honest canopy
#

Tomorrow we Will talk about tis again with sleepy 2.0

lusty grotto
#

not that i run those a lot anymore but yeah

honest canopy
#

I do 1 a week

neon tangle
#

@last mason You have 2 DCs on your other slots, what are your options there?

exotic spoke
#

Nim, what do you think about idol this week - given I’m now DiD. Every other idol I can use did and then idol for ~ 150k

neon tangle
#

Lots of stuff does more damage than 2nd and 3rd DC

exotic spoke
#

If was one of the options

honest canopy
#

Get if

#

Pull more

#

Do more dps

#

Be tanky AF

exotic spoke
#

I recommend IF to pull bigger. Get comfortable pulling bigger. Swap to DC and continue with pull sizes the same way

honest canopy
#

Question is

#

Do you enjoy beeing an unstoppable force that smashes and clappa shit into fkn mauled pices?

#

Get If

exotic spoke
#

Why not both?

neon tangle
#

@exotic spoke Right, but, he might have two pieces that he's choosing DC over like, treacherous covenant, blightborne, etc

#

DC is near the top for dps, but 2nd/3rd stacks are less valuable

honest canopy
#

Get If be this

oblique garnet
#

dont think theres any pieces with 3x Bom + blightborne at 415

neon tangle
#

DC might be the right option for the chest, it might be the wrong option for the other 2 slots

last mason
#

well im using the engi head as well until i can get a better poece

#

piece

#

so i take dc on that

exotic spoke
#

@honest canopy Nod all the way - fuck the GDI

neon tangle
#

@last mason shoulders?

last mason
#

lockjaw

#

so if and bastion on those

neon tangle
#

once you're comfy tradewinds maybe not a bad choice instead of IF

oblique garnet
#

tradewinds is meh

storm marlin
#

hey guys what WA do you use usually? I just changed to Prot and every tip is useful

last mason
#

holy shit i love the crucible tank trin

#

trink

#

the heal is massive

exotic spoke
#

It’s about 150k

#

I don’t use WA sischo

#

So I can’t help with specifics

#

However, I believe there is a list of WAs in the FAQ or pins

zinc spoke
little ravine
#

how are you supposed to pull both of the 2 constructs together before they start channeling in KR before the 2nd boss? I think we're doing something wrong

outer dew
#

@zinc spoke shoulders if you want to hunt for bastion. Chest If you want raw stats

zinc spoke
#

bastion i think then

#

thanks my man

sand egret
#

eyyy, randomly decided to solo heroic ToV....and the transmog set dropped off Helya

#

wordddd

mortal brook
#

eyyy

sand egret
#

also found out I can easily farm the LFR one solo now too

onyx trout
#

is the servant splitter bad for prot?

sand egret
#

bad as in, the proc isnt good

#

but hte damage is damage

#

(weapon damage, that is)

#

so at equal ilvl take another weapon

#

if it's your highest ilvl, use it

onyx trout
#

would i be better off with a 385 adulation enforcer or a 400 servant splitter?

sand egret
#

not even close

#

400 splitter

onyx trout
#

gotcha wasnt sure if losing stats would be that bad or not

sand egret
#

the weapon damage you get from the weapon due to ilvl is the most important part of the weapon

#

and both have main stat/stam, so it's really a matter of 2ndaries. In that case weapon dps > 2ndary stats

onyx trout
#

oh ok fair enough thank you

sand egret
#

np

ornate wagon
#

I used servant splitter until grong dropped the mace

honest canopy
#

@sand egret old

#

I got all 3 versions. The dsrk bworn/blue is The Bis tho

#

Wich one you got?

#

Have 2x cloth and 2x mail ones to. The mail one is quite decent, green/Grey. Gold one looks meh

sand egret
#

just got the heroic one, working on the light blue LFR one. I'm not too impressed by the no-longer-attainable mythic one, so overall i'm just going to grind out all 3. Almost done with the quest to get the normal one as well

oblique garnet
#

@sick sentinel Stop stealing all my customers smh

sick sentinel
#

man

#

for last 10 mins people asked and no one bought

#

i even lowered my key for this

#

@oblique garnet gimme 20k so i dont steal your customers :)(:

oblique garnet
#

No man i need it

#

Im broke

sick sentinel
#

I just got accepted into oblivion

#

same 😦

#

i have 60k i need money for pots started raiding again

oblique garnet
#

yeah they declined me when i applied last time due to having too many people already

sick sentinel
#

same

#

i got declined from oblivion

#

also from gallywix 😦

#

no love for leech users 😄

#

well I did not get accepted

#

but like

#

a guy who is in

#

wanted me as a leader

#

and I got in like that

#

yeah they have so many boosters on horde EU side

plush pagoda
#

what azerite powers are gonna be solid in 8.2

sick sentinel
#

same ones

plush pagoda
#

i mean minor/major powers

sick sentinel
#

oh

#

nobody knows

plush pagoda
#

truth

sick sentinel
#

they are going to be changed like a million times

bold marten
#

I just read that our AE-DPS will still be the best in 8.2 (but not by far), but we will get beaten by every class (except BDK) in ST-DPS. Do we have players here which have done some testing on ptr to comment this?

sick sentinel
#

our ST dps is pretty good tbh 🤷

spice ferry
#

there is no point doing any serious testing on ptr because its ptr and will be guaranteed to change

limpid pawn
#

hey yall

#

i have a question about M+ king's rest

#

everyone in the pugs insists on invis'ing past the first group right off the bat

#

all the way to the gong. I get it - but if we wipe or someone dies later on

spice ferry
#

if you wipe

limpid pawn
#

is the second graveyard only available after we defeat the council boss?

sick sentinel
#

you can still take the taxi

limpid pawn
#

like each time someone dies, that's one more invis pot we need to get back to where we are?

spice ferry
#

^

#

nope

#

you can walk past and take bird

limpid pawn
#

what about those golems and whatnot

spice ferry
#

regardless of having killed adds

#

you dont pull them to fly

#

unless your a monkey

limpid pawn
#

where do you spawn exactly?

#

after you kill the serpant boss

sick sentinel
#

start

#

you kill fear adds

#

then you stealth

deft narwhal
#

hi, i've a question that probably was asked multiply times but i cannot find it anywhere: I cannot wrap myself around idea that Overwhelming Power is A tier trait for prot, how that's possible if u r hit a lot - wouldnt that make it lose all the stack almost instantly if you tank few mobs or it does some hidden icd before it allows to next stack be removed?

zinc spoke
#

i would trust the math

undone sun
#

1s icd on dropping stacks

zinc spoke
#

there's a spreadsheet with maths in pins somewhere

undone sun
#

so the amount of stacks that drop is limited

#

per second

spice ferry
#

if only the game put information like this on the tooltip

deft narwhal
#

ok, thx for info, was not aware of that 1s ICD and will look for that spreadsheet

primal sable
#

Blizzard doesnt like "bloated" tooltips

#

Thats why they created CoS gear

sick sentinel
#

Lmao

shadow timber
#

are there any addons that help a new m+ tank with routes and stuff

mortal brook
#

method dungeon tools. has route planning, and can share routes as well

oblique garnet
#

Doesnt really help for actual tanking

#

Just in general dungeon weakaura package

#

And shieldblock tracker made by Marok and IP tracker

potent anvil
#

423 equipped deswind
only need to replace 1 415 now

spice ferry
#

Jesus big boy

#

Thought I was doing wel at 420

potent anvil
#

I should be world ranked 2 for ilvl according to warcraft logs.

#

423.00

oblique garnet
#

Yeah

#

Theres one guy

#

From argent dawn eu

#

Thats actually higher?!

#

Fucking rp dudes

potent anvil
#

i lost a roll on a 420 shield, but that shouldnt be enough. i think its pretty much being almost full 425s

oblique garnet
#

I have 410 weapon

#

Ive had that weapon

#

For so long

#

And i cant seem to be able to get better one

willow scarab
#

The only slots that I don’t have at 425 are the only slots my BrM has at 425 and it’s mad tilting

sick sentinel
#

Farm grong my dude

willow scarab
#

Been 419.88 for like... a month

oblique garnet
#

@sick sentinel dont you think i have

#

I have coined all the weapon bosses

sick sentinel
#

Farm harder

oblique garnet
#

Says the man who had 400 shield for how long?🤔

sick sentinel
#

405*

#

And I was not farming

#

I was benched on jaina

#

Going in for like 10 pulls a week

#

So I couldn't farm mythic champs

outer dew
#

Be like me

#

Quit after jaina

#

:^)

sick sentinel
#

Also farming grong and conclave is easier than farming champs and stormwall

#

I got my first stormwall kill today

cinder fjord
#

Probably a super noob question - As a new ish (385) prot warr I have blockades and a 375 ancient tuskarr sea charm - Is the charm better in most scenarios than blockades?

sick sentinel
#

What's your other trinket

cinder fjord
#

385 prism

sick sentinel
#

Blockades is better defensively

#

But I would use sea charm over it

cinder fjord
#

Gotcha - If I'm playing well I shouldn't need the stam from blockades, yeah?

sick sentinel
#

Yeah

oblique garnet
#

Kage mekka drops a weapon aswell

#

Ive been coining

#

All 3 bosses

#

Never luck

sick sentinel
#

F

charred vigil
#

how's prot looking on ptr so far? any changes that are significant yet?

undone sun
#

no

oblique garnet
#

Literally over

#

Only viable tank will be vdh

astral crystal
#

this tbh ^

#

vdh and bear will reign supreme

#

reroll now if you want to stand a chance

undone sun
#

just dont look at the essences 🙃

oblique garnet
#

Shh thyme

#

Its time

#

Warrior will be gone

#

And we will all be free

warm plinth
#

I'd be fine with only viable tank being DH XD

#

But I think you meant HDH not VDH 😏

barren marsh
#

Reading that as HxH

#

I need to drink coffee.

undone sun
#

just get a sandwich

barren marsh
#

Right this is Skyhold.

#

The Memebargo is in effect still.

undone sun
#

for forever

warm plinth
#

If you kill Runecarver, how do you handle him on bolstering week? Just do your best to ST him down or would it make sense to have someone drag him away while you nuke initiates or what? My group likely won't even try to skip him even if I ask them to so

oblique garnet
#

Tank takes the initiates

#

I mean rune carver

#

And dps takes the initiates to previous room

#

Runecarver wont do carve flesh on tank

#

For some reason

#

And even if he does tank can reflect it

warm plinth
#

Ok

#

Thank you sir

urban briar
#

good evening

#

got a question

#

410 crushers block or 400 rezans with socket

oblique garnet
#

🤔

warm plinth
#

Don't you 🤔 me sir

undone sun
warm plinth
#

I don't even know what the fuck I'm saying apparently. So tired.

exotic spoke
oblique garnet
#

@warm plinth 🤔

open bluff
#

🤔

warm plinth
#

🤔

urban briar
#

u guys still thinking?

oblique garnet
#

Oh i thought @warm plinth answered you already

#

@urban briar what other trinkets you have

warm plinth
#

I answered poorly because I'm exhausted, so I deleted it. You answer him 😅

urban briar
#

410 block, 410 idol of new raid, 400rezans socket 400 jes howler 400 vial 400 everchill anchor socket 400 diamond

oblique garnet
#

@urban briar just use 410 block and either everchill and rezans

urban briar
#

seductive power any good? or take iron fortress?

warm plinth
#

Seductive Power can spawn like 20 yards away; it's bad

sick sentinel
#

i'd prefer if over sp..... i dont like the moving aspect of sp at least in m+ as bwonsamdi sometimes stays in shit ( sanguine, etc. )

ionic fern
#

I'd still keep IF.

warm plinth
#

Mainly because it's super hard to maintain stacks in a realistic setting

round vortex
#

I am pretty lucky atm with traits.
1x DC, 2x BFI, 1x BoM, 1x IF and 1x BS

Got all the good ones with plenty of resounding and improved rally in the bank 😃

full spruce
#

Finalllly got a 425 upgrade today on warrior. Get to finally do a reclear and hopefully jaina kill this week. It’s been a long 4 weeks of no raiding

round vortex
#

niiiiiiiice !

full spruce
#

So quiet.

lime mantle
#

Say the magic word and it’d get revived

#

Also I’ve told patch is at the end of the month, what de@fug?

autumn pendant
#

One word

#

leech

full spruce
#

Usually mwah and kaege are chirping back and forth

ionic fern
#

I had a meeting and no one had any questions regarding Prot so i was just afk. 😂

autumn pendant
#

I see

#

I got your attention

umbral forge
ionic fern
#

👌

undone sun
#

oh is is jettom doesn't like other races o'clock

#

😄 kidding

ionic fern
#

I feel like i've missed something.

#

😂

umbral forge
#

I love russians

neat crypt
#

The mother country

mortal carbon
#

halp i'm our m+ tank now

#

any good Wa's i need?

ionic fern
#

What?

umbral forge
#

I no longer like Russians.

mortal carbon
#

ahahaha

undone sun
#

🤣

umbral forge
#

I think a more fair statement would be that i do not like my luck

#

getting a Boralus key

ionic fern
#

My experience is that they either are godlike players or they fail miserabely at everything.

#

No in-betweeners so far.

#

:/

#

@mortal carbon
Regarding WA's.
Go to the #ui-addons-manager and click the first pin.
Out of that list i'd advice you to get:
Auto Marker
Externals on Me
Interrupt Tracker
Party CD Tracker

umbral forge
#

don't help him hes german

ionic fern
#

I'll help anyone. 🤷

mortal carbon
#

racist bich

umbral forge
#

ok fair

#

hey

ionic fern
#

No swearing.

#

😒

#

Plz

umbral forge
#

mwahi he called me a bish

#

help

mortal carbon
#

racism is fine :smug:?

ionic fern
#

No.

#

We're all friends here.

#

Kiss and make up.

#

😄

full spruce
#

So Russians are like playing with ragnaros players in NA huh?

ionic fern
#

Is Ragnaros really that bad?
I've heard stories.

undone sun
#

yes

#

mostly

#

Rag and QT are the big ones

#

pulled a really good DK out of rag early HFC

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

lime mantle
#

Russians suffer from an extended Balmer peak

#

If either they are too drunk they play like shit

#

If they are not drunk enough they play like suit

#

If they are exactly as drunk as they must be they become reality altering god’s who read the boss ability damage before it happens down to the decimal and will drop to 2HP and skyrocket again without issue

sand condor
#

when jettom doesnt ask you to tank his keys ):

mortal carbon
#

@ionic fern ty for your help

marble cipher
#

@lime mantle I like that, a lot, stolen as a quote 😉

lime mantle
#

@sand condor when nobody asks you to tank their keys ;-;

sand condor
#

;-;

sick sentinel
#

@umbral forge But you are one

umbral forge
#

what

sick sentinel
#

a bish

umbral forge
#

well yeah

#

I don't want Germans calling me that though

sick sentinel
#

"I'm not racist"

umbral forge
#

am not

sick sentinel
#

"but"

lime mantle
#

If loathing Germans in WoW is racism, I’ll make Jim Crow look like a BITCH.

sick sentinel
#

(And russians)

drowsy relic
#

deadly navigation is best enchant now right?

#

over siphoning

ionic fern
#

Yes.

#

Haste is never wasted on a warrior even if it's RNG proc based.
Especially compared to something like a tiny % of leech.

stoic pilot
#

Deadly nav is crit

ionic fern
#

OH,

#

Deadly

#

Not quick.

#

Smh

stoic pilot
#

It’s ok it’s early

ionic fern
#

I got too used to answering to people when the leech discussion was on point here and then it was always Quick navi vs Siphoning. 😂

stoic pilot
#

Yeah I can understand that lol

full spruce
#

But come on leech annnd never surrender!

sick sentinel
#

I would use deadly over siphoning

#

but quick over deadly : P

lime mantle
#

Quick v deadly v siphoning

sick sentinel
#

siphoning is out of the question

orchid token
#

your face is out of the question

#

rofl gottem

worthy dagger
#

60% uptime of masterful instinctics on ptr for guardian bear, if you have the correct traits you can have 2200 mastery on guardian pretty much all the time, bear is the new meta bye prot

brisk ferry
#

yeah do this, go reroll bear ^

worthy dagger
#

i was being sarcastic, im a main prot

#

lmao

#

its to scare away the new people

#

im also a leech prot

brisk ferry
#

I was too lol

#

though if that is actually decent I might play my druid a bit

lime mantle
#

Remove frenzy from gcd

umbral forge
#

if you'rre not a leech prot you're just trolling at this point

versed widget
#

Is bonded souls good for m+?

sick sentinel
#

not that good

marble oak
#

How good is sirens tongue as a tanking defensive trinket?

#

I imagine it procs more in aoe

umbral forge
#

Hanayama is a total bamf. I wish warriors had a brawler specc.

drowsy relic
#

quick navigation is an option?

#

i thought it was literally deadly vs siphoning

#

youre trolling if youre enchanting haste lol

#

for M+ atleast

ionic fern
#

🤔

steel mauve
#

Uh what

#

You're trolling if you arent

marble oak
#

Haste is best?

#

what

#

Guys, how good is sirens tongue trinket?

ionic fern
#

Legit first time hearing about it..so it's probably some World trinket?

steel mauve
#

Probably not very, idk the math nor have heard of it so i would assume its not on the radar

#

Chance on heal is pretty bad considering it can easily overheal

#

Or proc at the most worthless times

marble oak
#

thats the thing, is in legion best lego for prot was man wrists

#

for healing

drowsy relic
#

@ionic fern for M+ crit is technically better offensively and defensively

ionic fern
#

Looks pretty bad.
Should be easily replaced by anything else due to higher ilvl being available.

marble oak
#

I cant find anything on the proc

#

well yea idealy, unless the healing is so broken

steel mauve
#

Best prot lego were gloves, and near the end bracers were easily replaced as they were 80% over healing

ionic fern
#

@drowsy relic - Sure, not arguing with that - crit IS good. But so is haste + it's more versitile when it comes to raiding as well etc.
If you wanna roll around with a crit enchant on your weapon go ham but don't come here stating that people are "trolling if you're enchanting haste".

steel mauve
#

Personal preference doesnt equal fact...

#

Or i guess opinion not preference for that matter

brisk ferry
#

I'm also not sure where he's getting crit being better offensively in M+, at 1600 haste it's still almost double the following stat weight when simmed.

ionic fern
#

Stat weights depend on your current stats tho.

brisk ferry
#

right but 1600 is a ton of haste, and it still wants more lol

sick sentinel
#

@drowsy relic you unironically were using ravager in necrotic weeks and going siphoning
in the TR because the #1 prot warrior in raider io was using siphoning

#

I'm sorry but I can't take you your opinions seriously

drowsy relic
#

ravager is literally the best talent, im probably gonna push again next week with ravager lol

#

for necrotic

ionic fern
#

Oh no ..

brisk ferry
#

what in the misinformed world

brittle owl
#

whatt are you pushing exactly

#

15's?

drowsy relic
#

its 35% parry on a 1min cd, its going to be bis in the row

#

for 12 seconds

brittle owl
#

again, what is the use case

autumn pendant
#

🤔

brittle owl
#

cause there is a range where it doesnt matter what you pick

#

keys will get finished in time

wooden radish
#

ravager is bis memes poggers

brittle owl
#

you could literally use healing trinkets

#

and still do 15's in time

autumn pendant
brisk ferry
brittle owl
#

so what exactly

autumn pendant
#

Ravager is big meme indeed

brittle owl
#

are you pushing

#

is it the limit of memes?

#

because sorry to say but ravager won't make you LeSs hEaLeR ReLiAnT

#

you need leech/vers for that

drowsy relic
#

no its for necrotic stacks

brittle owl
#

3/10 meme sorry

#

real woyers spell reflect necrotic

steel mauve
#

@brisk ferry technically this expansion almost always the more of a stat you have the more you want, im willing to say if you have 1600 crit instead chances are stat weights would then tell you that you needed even more crit instead of haste

wooden radish
#

imagine thinking taking ravager is ever better than taking anger management

#

200 iq plays

brittle owl
#

what's your io shawrus

#

gtfo lincoln, go mod HoW channels, stop memeing here

wooden radish
#

make me 😉

brittle owl
#

i will make you a pie

drowsy relic
#

i said its better than am for necrotic weeks

autumn pendant
#

Not even for necro weeks

drowsy relic
#

you can argue about 15s in time all you want lol

#

people ran ravager in 20s during necro week 3 months ago as well lol

#

i dont really push keys thse days but Im keen to push this week on necro just to show you guys what youre doing wrong lol

autumn pendant
#

🍿

brittle owl
#

😂

#

aight boi, show us

wooden radish
#

y i k e s

#

pack it in guys

brittle owl
#

was gonna argue but lmao, i wanna be here next week

#

for the lesson

#

imagine having a prot warrior tank your key

autumn pendant
#

Isnt ravager doing less dmg in ST than revenge?

brittle owl
#

and he does brewmaster damage

autumn pendant
#

I mean, you have leap and slow

#

To deal with necro

#

And you are shooting yourself in the knee if you take ravager

wooden radish
#

more like, shooting yourself in the head

brisk ferry
#

@steel mauve hey sorry just saw ur msg, I didn't know that. Interesting. Thanks for the info!

autumn pendant
#

Consistent survivability + big dmg

brittle owl
#

nah dude you're memeing obviously

autumn pendant
#

Vs poop dmg and once in a while parry just for packs

brittle owl
#

just wait for next week

#

he'll show us

#

with is big 17 done in time

autumn pendant
#

Okay, enough banter about it

brittle owl
#

maybe he'll even do a 20 who knows

glacial plover
#

and i'm sitting here feeling bad about myself not clearing +13 in time ... 😄

autumn pendant
#

You have no reason to feel bad

brittle owl
#

yeah

autumn pendant
#

Unless its you draggin whole group down every pull

#

Haha

brittle owl
#

self awareness is the first step towards improving

#

rest is just practice

#

and common sense

drowsy relic
#

yeah but I understand my gear/talent setup which is why I know how to use it in M+

brittle owl
#

clearly not

autumn pendant
#

@glacial plover you would be suprised but big % of player base doesnt even do beyond +10

brittle owl
#

seeing as you set up your talents to deal with a non existant affix

#

for warriors

#

for most tanks, actually

#

that you can deal with no problem with your base kit

sick sentinel
#

@drowsy relic weren't you dying on tr on wcm?

autumn pendant
#

🤔

brittle owl
#

aw man gimping yourself for necrotic is something i would never think to see

umbral forge
#

TR?

drowsy relic
#

@sick sentinel and crit saved me

#

its the best stat

#

i literally played the same and ran crit instead

brisk ferry
#

wait you're solo'ing these?

sick sentinel
#

Tournament realm

brisk ferry
#

OP

sick sentinel
#

Nobody argues against haste/crit build

drowsy relic
#

we managed to time the WM on tr

sick sentinel
#

We're arguing against ravager

worthy dagger
#

ravager is bad

#

no arguement about that

drowsy relic
#

its not on ravager weeks tho

#

necrotic*

worthy dagger
#

not that its bad, AM is just so much better

brittle owl
#

RAVAGER WEEKS

#

LMAO

eager hollow
#

Imagine not wanting avatar every 30sec and shield wall more often

#

🤔

worthy dagger
#

and last stand with bolster

eager hollow
#

You just kite with high necrotic stacks or

worthy dagger
#

literally shockwave and leap away

#

or ask for treants

timid jay
#

Ohman

steel mauve
#

No lans, ravager is outright bad, the damage from it is abysmal and you shouldnt need the parry, because if you're that desperate we have tools to literally keep things from hitting us

timid jay
#

Crit + ravager

#

Pepega

drowsy relic
#

yeah im pushing 70% parry for 12 seconds every 1 min

sick sentinel
#

but still not dropping stacks

eager hollow
#

With 6k DPS or

brittle owl
#

like i said

worthy dagger
#

or you could have AM and have almost a minute of block

brittle owl
#

imagine being a sword n board chad

sick sentinel
#

you would do more damage while kiting but using AM

brittle owl
#

but limp dick dps

sick sentinel
#

than facetaking with ravager

brittle owl
#

you'd think that would be pretty obvious after tanking 2 or 3 dungeons on necrotic

#

after 5 you realise it's a non existant affix

timid jay
#

You're hitting 70% parry with ravager

#

How much crit do you have 🤔

worthy dagger
#

-3

#

he actually heals the mob if he crit

mortal carbon
#

yikes

drowsy relic
#

im running knot as well

#

to sync with ravager

timid jay
#

Is that a crit trinket?

brittle owl
#

the plays

sick sentinel
#

yeah

ionic fern
#

Aaand i'm home.

sick sentinel
#

1min cd crit trinket

eager hollow
#

What's your overall dam like with that

sick sentinel
#

@ionic fern enjoy the chat

eager hollow
#

🤔

sick sentinel
#

it's amazing

brittle owl
#

15k probably

timid jay
#

Tbf, if you go for parry stacking it with crit is probably a good idea

ionic fern
#

I'm sorry but if you're thinking Ravager is a good option on ANY week you are just playing the class wrong or not utilizing all the things that a m+ team brings.

timid jay
#

Since ravager is additive

worthy dagger
#

so lets talk about CR build

timid jay
#

Not saying its a good plan overall, but if you do it thats definitely the way to go

brittle owl
#

that's like saying

sick sentinel
#

yeah, if I could get to 65% crit then I would run ravager to hit 100% Kappa

brittle owl
#

if you're gonna eat rotten leftovers, might as well use a dirty plate

brisk ferry
#

I mean, don't put rotten leftovers on my clean plates

mystic whale
#

what's this reckless fury meme I've been seeing around ? If there some real value to it ? Devastator-style ?

sick sentinel
#

@mystic whale pure ST dps yeah

brisk ferry
#

for parsing raids

worthy dagger
#

memeing raids*

brisk ferry
#

^

sick sentinel
#

you drop a bunch of surv for it

#

it's just logs memes

final mist
#

There’s literally no reason to ever run Ravager, ever.

brittle owl
#

there comes a point where survival is the meme, in raids

final mist
#

If you do, you’re delusional.

mystic whale
#

ah ok, that's what I thought, but just wanted to be sure that it wasnt the new hot thing

brittle owl
#

so you just go damage

timid jay
#

Dont forget memes Sal

#

Important

worthy dagger
#

The blue name has spoken, its official Ravager is a meme.

brisk ferry
brittle owl
#

you guys don't understand

mystic whale
#

what about that sweet parry ?

final mist
#

The only meme here is people who think Ravager is a good talent.

brittle owl
#

@drowsy relic will show all of you

timid jay
#

Ravager has been a meme for ages

brittle owl
#

next week

mystic whale
#

PARRY AND AOE DAMAGE

sick sentinel
#

50% party 🎉

mystic whale
#

what more could you want

brittle owl
#

when he's r1 ravager warrior

final mist
#

Ah yes, I too enjoy having my 100 talent doing less than a Revenge over 6 seconds.

sick sentinel
#

more than a revenge's worth of damage

final mist
#

Totes beats AM.

#

😬

brittle owl
#

think of the parry tho

sick sentinel
#

run 3 GS as well

ionic fern
#

Oof, look at @final mist giving Protection the monthly blue visit. Right on time tho. deswind

sick sentinel
#

6k str for 6s

#

LMAO

timid jay
#

6k str is a lot of parry mate

mystic whale
#

but but... AOE

final mist
#

If I had the ability to use external emotes, I’d tip my hat to you @ionic fern

mystic whale
#

also, think of all the sick parries

worthy dagger
#

im between BfI and meticulous

#

what to take

sick sentinel
#

wait not even valkyr can use global emotes

final mist
#

Nope

timid jay
#

You lost admin Sal?

#

ooof

final mist
#

Marok is truly a fun sucker

#

Sucks the fun out of everything

#

:triggered:

brittle owl
#

he probably just wants to push his own emote agenda

sick sentinel
#

@worthy dagger bfi for raids and meticulous for mplus

worthy dagger
#

im gonna stack 3 MS

sick sentinel
#

MS got buffed, I get like 35-40% uptime in mplus

worthy dagger
#

for 2500 haste

brisk ferry
#

meticulous has been great in my M+ runs

ionic fern
final mist
#

Start my own Skyhold, with blackjack, hookers, and emotes?!

ionic fern
sick sentinel
ionic fern
#

I don't care about the first 2..as long as it has emotes. 😄

timid jay
#

Make one for FFXIV warriors instead

#

:smart:

autumn pendant
#

When half of ranks in skyhold tell you ravager is bad every week

steel mauve
#

I mean, i all for "you do you" but you should never come in here with fundamentally wrong opinions and spout them as fact, new players may happen to just come in that day, glance at it and then figure they may be right

autumn pendant
#

Lul

exotic spoke
#

Oh shit son. Are we rioting?

ionic fern
#

No, we are uniting.

brisk ferry
#

Riki you're late to the party

ionic fern
#

Against Ravager.

near ivy
#

need to split up for clues

exotic spoke
#

Burn ravager to the ground!

autumn pendant
#

@drowsy relic ravager promoter

near ivy
#

maybe we can find this guys brain cells faster if we split up

exotic spoke
#

And yeah, I just woke up an hour ago and got to work

near ivy
#

also @autumn pendant

#

👋

autumn pendant
#

👋

exotic spoke
glacial plover
#

This conversation.... laughs and giggles for everyone 😄

autumn pendant
#

Oh my

brittle owl
#

i like how

ionic fern
#

21 for HR

brittle owl
#

prot warrior is better than the other 2

exotic spoke
#

Correlation is not causation

brittle owl
#

literally a dps loss

sick sentinel
#

bringing up logs for mplus is not a valid arguement tbh

timid jay
#

Well it does show something

final mist
#

“It’s not me, it’s the mods who are wrong!”

exotic spoke
#

Lol

final mist
#

The problem with people is they like to see things

exotic spoke
#

Mods and plebs are natural enemies.
Like mods and mods... mods and streamers.... mods and strangers

final mist
#

You don’t see any direct impact from AM because most people are monkeys and somehow manage to not hit shit on CD

worthy dagger
#

im gonna run a +10 with ravager and see how it goes

#

later

autumn pendant
#

Or mods and mods

sick sentinel
#

or they stay ragecapped

autumn pendant
#

Damn mods

final mist
#

And then they try Ravager and see all these big dammies and parties and are like

#

“Wow this is so good”

#

Like lmao nah fam, you just suck

sick sentinel
#

they look at the 🎉 s

drowsy relic
#

you dont need to use stuff on cd in M+

autumn pendant
#

Ravager with GS

#

Big meme

brittle owl
#

i am screencapping that

timid jay
#

Well then you arent pulling big enough

final mist
#

^

timid jay
#

Or not planning your pulls well enough

brittle owl
#

pls you need a meme channel

brisk ferry
#

wait where's @lusty grotto quote of the day here

brittle owl
#

and put

ionic fern
#

There's still time.

brittle owl
#

"You don't use stuff on cd in m+" as the first entry

sick sentinel
brittle owl
#

gold

brisk ferry
#

yeh sorry I tagged wrong person

final mist
#

Please don’t bully too much

#

We do want to teach, not drive him away

autumn pendant
#

Damn

brittle owl
#

that's what the faq is for

autumn pendant
#

Sticks away boys

brittle owl
#

in regards to ravager at least

sick sentinel
#

dude has been here for more than a year sal

final mist
#

I’m the only one allowed to bully all of you vel

timid jay
#

What you gain by picking ravager is parry and insignificant damage. What you lose is a big amount of damage due to demo and avatar cooldowns being a lot longer, not to mention all the defensives that you'll get way more free access to

wooden radish
sick sentinel
#

he never learns

autumn pendant
#

@timid jay i think he knows that

timid jay
#

So the question then becomes if the parry you gain is enough to offset the massive amount of damage loss and defensive CD loss

autumn pendant
#

He just fundementally thinks avoidign necro is legit strat

final mist
#

Cosmo was speaking to Ravager Man, not me

sick sentinel
#

I thought y'all were memeing

#

Seems like this got srs

wooden radish
#

@timid jay but but but parrying necrotic kappa

autumn pendant
#

@final mist i know

final mist
#

It’s always serious when Ravager is taken seriously

near ivy
#

for this whole conversation ive been thinking AM only reduces the cd of avatar and still thought going ravager was stupid

final mist
#

It’s always a joke otherwise

near ivy
#

its just clicked

#

i dont play prot much dont judge

timid jay
#

If your parry starts reaching 50%+ or so before parry I could see it actually being somewhat legit for only necrotic weeks only because its additive parry

autumn pendant
#

I judge

final mist
#

No judge

#

U good fam

timid jay
#

But thats even without thinking about the damage loss

sick sentinel
near ivy
autumn pendant
#

Im actually always in prot

timid jay
#

With the amount of damage you can pump out with AM its a massive loss in m+, damage matters a lot in m+

autumn pendant
#

You just never see me

brittle owl
#

necrotic 👏 is 👏 a 👏 non 👏 existant 👏 affix👏

#

that's should be the end of it

near ivy
#

mobs dont give you necrotic stacks when they are dead

sick sentinel
#

Tell that to all 80 Necrotic Stacks :>

brittle owl
#

you don't gear or talent for it

#

ffs

autumn pendant
#

Whole talent tree works together with AM

sick sentinel
#

I just go out at 40 stacks

#

and run goreblock

near ivy
#

at 80 + necrotic stacks the ravager parry isnt going to help

sick sentinel
#

I can't kite. Gotta slap some more. That DMG

near ivy
#

even with the extra parry you would still have so many stacks that you get 0% healing anyway

autumn pendant
#

@near ivy 4head just kill them before they kill you

near ivy
#

@autumn pendant shame you couldnt do that to mythic opulence 🤷

brittle owl
#

the moment you start autistically thinking about "uUUUUUhhhhh what should i pick for nEcRoTiC"

sick sentinel
#

with crackling thunder you can thunderclap our of melee range

brittle owl
#

you really should just reroll to a diff role

autumn pendant
#

Thats low, bird

near ivy
#

👋

#

saw the opportunity

#

took it

autumn pendant
#

😡

brisk ferry
#

I know stats are mostly a meme but in this case, is having literally zero vers a problem?

wooden radish
#

no

stoic forge
#

out off topic ... what is your greatest spell reflect ?

brisk ferry
#

okay just wondering

near ivy
#

is there something special about having 2% vers that would magically change your gameplay from 0% vers

strong forum
#

3% vers here, ama

brisk ferry
#

0% vers here, but ask that guy questions ^

strong forum
#

Greatest spell reflect would have to be ghuun

steel mauve
#

Basically as long as you have stats you're good

strong forum
#

This ^

autumn pendant
#

Haha

#

Just dont un-equip gear

sick sentinel
#

@stoic forge I never got to do the SR on ghuun but I did a double reflect on first boss on +21 underrot

wooden radish
#

relevant ilvl is the only thing that matters for tanks.

sick sentinel
#

half a mil damage on both boss and add

strong forum
#

That's also joocy

stoic forge
#

@sick sentinel jucy

brisk ferry
#

okay, my thought was just if you gain some sort of "stat boost" and it is looking at add to a zero stat, would I be better off having "some"?

strong forum
#

There's no increase or decrease in value in stats at point X