#protection

1 messages · Page 2406 of 1

oblique garnet
#

I love it when you have a game in steam but its made by ubisoft so when you launch it from steam you need to log in to your uplay and launch it from there 8)

outer dew
#

yea...

#

that shit is a meme and a half

dense flame
#

hahahah we should get die by the sword 😃 parry everything get die by sword shield wall last stand

outer dew
#

That would be bad for us

#

DBTS would be too strong of a CD so we'd have to be brought in line some ridiculous way

warm plinth
#

Yeah. Besides, if we were to get another DR CD (for some non-existing reason), I'd want it to be useable for magic.

oblique garnet
#

”Shield block now works on magic”

#

”Cries of the leftover thousand dks echoes” ”Nerf prot”

warm plinth
#

lol

hardy vault
#

Hey guys i recently started tankning on offspec. What traits do i try to go for ?

sick sentinel
#

depends on if you are raid tanking or mplus

#

read the guides

hardy vault
#

okay thanks alot

fathom magnet
#

is booming voice the clearcut talent for m+? or can a case be made for devastator?

hollow thorn
#

Booming Voice is the clearcut talent for pretty much every situation

#

and definetly M+

cobalt turret
hollow thorn
grizzled steeple
#

is the Lingering Sporepods trinket worth using or should I just stick with Rezan / Jes, all 400ilvl

oblique garnet
#

@hollow thorn ??? what

hollow thorn
#

Mythic Mekka trink xd

oblique garnet
#

niceone

thin ore
#

Is there a notable difference for us on conclave hc vs mythic?

daring patrol
#

you and pa'ku will be doing the dirty dance most of the fight

#

and you get to scream at your decursers

pastel holly
#

which traits to you like most for myth+? 1x clap and then whatever or are you focussing on "amount of trait XY" next to the clap one?

ebon hound
#

3x BoM

vocal nimbus
#

3x BoM

ebon hound
#

highfive

vocal nimbus
#

highfive

undone sun
#

👏

vocal nimbus
#

👏

limpid wadi
#

How does shield block excactly work?

undone sun
#

increases your block for the duration of the ability

limpid wadi
#

And 126% Block Chance means that you block every melee attack?

undone sun
#

yeah, % past 100% is meaningless since it doesn't factor into blocked damage iirc

#

SB just increases your block to guarantee blocks while it's active

#

granted you're facing the target, and it's physical

limpid wadi
#

So any non physical dmg from melee hits gose through?

And whats with projectiles?

undone sun
#

projectiles are included, it's a relatively recent addition

#

ranged attacks are blockable

#

meaning archer type enemies that auto cast physical

#

there have been more than a couple instances where you could block shadow damage

sick sentinel
#

throw rock

undone sun
#

but it's a case by case basis

sick sentinel
#

dies

cold owl
#

Dying to rock throwers is always a great time.

strong hill
#

^ fortified trash in neths layer back in legion.

amber siren
#

not kiting rock throws in 2017/2018 😩 👌

oblique garnet
#

throw wrench

strong hill
#

Lol @amber siren I remember doing a pug m+ and kitting the pelters. One of the dps and I quote “ you can do that???”

sick sentinel
#

At least you would shockwave the wrench

amber siren
#

honestly i just miss warlock corruption slow ring

#

i mean it was broekn

#

but i miss it

thin ore
#

Oh man I can't decide between IV and gemhide. I do mostly mythic raiding and my gear is pretty decent (408). What do?

#

probably doesn't matter either way right?

sick sentinel
#

It does matter

#

Gemhide for raids

#

Iv for dungeons

thin ore
#

hm

#

when is the first boss that hits really really hard?

#

rasthakan maybe?

#

we are at conclave

lucid bough
#

IV is?

thin ore
#

and so fart I never felt in danger

lucid bough
#

oh insp visage

sick sentinel
#

IV is 1k hps when you were constantly getting hit

thin ore
#

which you are not in raid

sick sentinel
#

Exactly

#

And how much avoidance does gemhide give

lucid bough
#

Very small

thin ore
#

150 or sth

sick sentinel
#

That's 4%

thin ore
#

4% avoidance in raid is pretty nicü

sick sentinel
#

Do we have a sheet where we can see what damage is reduced by avoidance?

thin ore
#

maybe @gaunt dawn

vocal nimbus
#

anything that is an AoE afaik

#

at least in legion 🤷

thin ore
#

Although the whole point of gemhide is a quasi perma armor plus and for most fights, the dmg profile is mostly physical (for tanks).

#

at least that's how I understood it why it is so aweomse for every tank.

gaunt dawn
#

D:

sick sentinel
#

Wait, we don't?

undone sun
#

doubtful

sick sentinel
#

Is there a way to make one just be looking at logs?

#

Maybe I can contribute to the community since I have time

undone sun
#

i don't think it's as cut and dry, i'd imagine you'd have to compare with and without avoidance

#

but even then it'd be at most a 20% difference

sick sentinel
#

@thin ore marok places Gemhide over IV in the icy veins guide and it written for raids

#

So I would go with gemhide

primal crypt
#

Yeah, gemhide is really solid choice

cold owl
#

If there was an avoidance spreadsheet it would sit right next to the SR/Block sheet on my bookmarks.

open field
#

Guys little question. So I have Pvp trinket that gives on use Vers with a socket 385 and Briny Barnacle 415. I am farming Rezans if I get it on 400 what should I remove?

quasi pagoda
#

Would u take a 370shield with socket or just a 375 shield?

open field
#

More Ilvl I think

modern pulsar
#

Do you guys use threatplates or tidyplates? What's best and any recommendations for setup?

#

Tried KuiNameplates and didn't like it

hollow thorn
#

CR or Bloodsport for M+ 🤔

sick sentinel
#

@open field use 415 briny / 400 rezan

open field
#

@sick sentinel Ok ty

sick sentinel
#

@quasi pagoda 375, always go highest ilvl on your shield

narrow abyss
#

Agree briny rezan. 375 shield. Highest ilvl. Shield a huge component of your survivability probably best pound for pound best defensive upgrade in any slot

#

Idk I like bloodsport personally

quasi pagoda
#

Alright, i suppose its back to grinding atal

open field
#

Yeah

narrow abyss
#

It’s really a good place to farm in general. Think 4 things there are really good

open field
#

Weapon shield trinket

quasi pagoda
#

Yeah i just got the weapon and it has a socket so its great

narrow abyss
#

Haste mastery gloves haste vers ring and best weapon shield and rezan

quasi pagoda
#

Now i just need the shield

sick sentinel
#

@hollow thorn even a single CR pushes Revenge push to my second highest damage source in overall

hollow thorn
#

not bad

open field
#

What's better Gemhide or Bury the Hatchet

hollow thorn
#

Gemhide

potent anvil
#

Deattu in protection channel 🤔

undone sun
sly plume
#

hwo do you play second boss underrot? I get so much dmg in there on 10

lusty grotto
#

SR when he vomits, that's it

#

if people aren't stepping on ticks = bad group = you can't tank those bleeds

sand egret
#

its also possible to dodge the indegestion completely

lusty grotto
#

its a very last minute dodge

sand egret
#

eh

lusty grotto
#

i just tank it fuck it

sand egret
#

leap back 10 yrds during cast

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

lusty grotto
#

eh

#

🤷

sand egret
#

helps during post-tantrum

#

when people be running about and he’s running back to you

#

it’s an option tho

lusty grotto
#

back to the question

#

@sly plume said "i get so much dmg in there on 10"

sand egret
#

well that and ticks are really the only big source of damage haha

lusty grotto
#

so im thinking its ticks

sand egret
#

and ticks aint really a him thing

#

but its prob ticks

lusty grotto
#

yeah betting on it

sly plume
#

yeah I sw first indigestion

final dove
#

You can walk out of the indigestion as well, just run as it winds up, don't even need leap

sand egret
#

i just like dodging it on my bear since feel cool hitting myself with a 120k swiftmend during it 😎

sharp lotus
#

He traces you though right?

sand egret
#

laterally yes

sly plume
#

@final dove ah didnt know that

sand egret
#

he stops moving tho

sharp lotus
#

yeah

final dove
#

Just strafe straight back from him and you outrange it

sand egret
#

so if you run directly back you outrange the cone

undone sun
#

how often does he cast it, ez leaps

sand egret
#

once per sequence

#

~50 energy i think

final dove
#

u can leap to cover tick spawns instead

#

helps the party 8)

sharp lotus
#

was just going to intercept heals so I dont stretch them thin instead of leaping

sand egret
#

yeah thats often the move if you’re comfortable with the run-move

#

unless the heals is directly behind you

#

but then if they get charged your melee is just chasing

final dove
#

Btw, any tips for high keys of 3rd boss in ML? Doesn't seem like you can block anything, just reflect every 2nd DoT and spam IP/+CD when you burn, chunks you down super hard

sand egret
#

you can game the DoT

#

targets two closest

#

every other you can offload to a dps

final dove
#

Ya I got that much, but the DoT applies every 20sec so you can't game every application from my experiance

sand egret
#

yes you can

#

SR it for the dps, offload it when ya dont have it up

final dove
#

Better to take it on griev tho, so the healer doesn't have to churn 2 targets?

sand egret
#

other than that yeah she hits hard with magic damage so just pump IP

final dove
#

Did her on 17 and she blanks me from full to 30% w/o IP

#

Was narly

sand egret
#

if you have a DK they can ams it, a DH in meta can prob leech thru it, but yeah that’s gonna be some stress this week for sure

final dove
#

Best solution I found was have my lock get an imp and dispel the 2nd DoT

lusty grotto
#

i like locks on these affixes

sand egret
#

thats actually pretty smart

#

tbh

lusty grotto
#

BR + healthstone 😄

final dove
#

Problem is most locks rolling demo for the burst aoe so they cut into the dps :/ Was lusting as well for her just to get it down

lusty grotto
#

and those gate skips of course

final dove
#

Yeah the shroud into gate on ML is pretty sweet

lusty grotto
#

hm

sand egret
#

yeah, guess you gotta weigh the tradeoffs

lusty grotto
#

its tyrannical though

#

so you really want dps for bosses

final dove
#

Mm, I mean with bon being an affix you still put a lot of the total % dmg into aoe, even on bolster, so idk

sand egret
#

demo can pump haaard

lusty grotto
#

yeah

final dove
#

Its just not a great demo dungeon, all bosses can force movement and 2 are 100% to

lusty grotto
#

oh you mean ML

#

yeah

sand egret
#

shadow priests can also dispel both 😃

final dove
#

But yeah, just frustrating to have a unblockable boss :/

#

O right, not had any priests in my party so far

#

Good point

sharp lotus
#

dont groups normally run rogue/priest with prot warr tank for that boss?

sand egret
#

yeah its a particularly annoying boss for us. if she casted it 5 seconds later tho....ez clap

#

i mean, not everyone has the full roster to choose from 😃

sharp lotus
#

i figure people pushing high keys did tbh

sand egret
#

generally they have their group

final dove
#

The run I did was just a inhouse guild run, nothing like a high push

lusty grotto
#

why would you have priest for one fight

#

i mean

sand egret
#

shadow is perty strong in general

final dove
#

SP is pretty beast RN yeah

sand egret
#

esp this week with bolster

lusty grotto
#

oh shadow

#

fuck

sharp lotus
#

Because from my understanding this week that boss rolls 17+ keys

final dove
#

We got through it but it was really touch and go, especially if DPS caught the AoEs

sharp lotus
#

idk why I chose 17 but I am sticking with that number

sand egret
#

sounds like a case where your dps has to ensure the healer can babysit you

#

via good play

sharp lotus
#

speaking of ML, does anyone use the strat where you get absurd % before the first boss? I think I saw people getting above 80% of their mob requirement

#

Is it worth doing if you are only pushing keys a few levels above 10?

final dove
#

Yeah, what you do is essentially deathrun from 2nd to 3rd, and 3rd to 4th boss

#

So you get around 88-95% pre-2nd boss

#

In my experience around 67% before 1st boss is fine, and you blow hero on the first pack/s so you get it again for 1st boss

#

You can do less if you want to shroud up and do the last pack before the 4th boss, but the bombs bolster so its a PitA this week

sick sentinel
#

yo

#

if you kill the engineer

#

in SoB

#

with the spotter

#

can you just kill the boss with the circles

final dove
#

Afaik if you kill the engineer it's a reset

sick sentinel
#

like drop the circles on the boss

#

they deal like 1 mil damage each

#

it damages the tentacles

#

you can kill the gripping terror with it

final dove
#

You can use it for tentacles, but I think if you ran into the water to hit the boss you'd get stunned by tentacles before you got to far

sick sentinel
#

travel form

final dove
#

Maybe with a gateway into the water or something, never tried it myself

sick sentinel
#

you can travel form

final dove
#

Its 1/5 to go on the druid tho, unless you are stacking the group?

sick sentinel
#

if everyone else goes out of range

final dove
#

Also, if you just plan the damage properly you dont need to kill the engineers do you? They give you 33% boss hp per shot

sick sentinel
#

well if you do

final dove
#

Idk if it'd hit/damage the boss, same reason you don't just multidot/kill it with ranged dps

#

If you find it does, please let us know 😃

sick sentinel
#

you can put dots on it, like agony etc for affli lock

#

or flame shock for ele

#

but I get what you mean

final dove
#

In example, looking through logs of SoB in WCL, there's no "damage" instances at all to the last boss, he just loses 33% via a health-removal mechanic from the shots

#

Same with DoTs, you do it for tentacles but I don't think he takes damage from them (?)

#

At least there's no instances of it over 3 logs I just skimmed

sick sentinel
#

oh.

#

bummer

final dove
#

Wanted to check it out to see his total HP pool, but can't gauge it from logs since he never takes any actual damage

boreal summit
#

is diamond laced good for prot

#

guide says yes but just so i can prove to retard friends

lusty grotto
#

its our best defensive trinket this tier,

#

what are these friends claiming anyway

honest canopy
#

Idd

#

Killed Opulence HC 9 times and 9 in normal

#

spent them coins

#

NOT GETTING IT

#

never seen it drop in any kill either

#

Now I am doing the same on my druid

#

Same story

halcyon nacelle
#

can shields titanforge from m+?

lusty grotto
#

no

#

weapons cannot TF

#

a shield is considered a weapon

halcyon nacelle
#

read somewhere shields are considered armor

#

but ty for the answer

lusty grotto
#

uhhhh

#

hold on

#

im 95% positive, but would rather someone else confirm/deny

silk mortar
#

It isnt possible

sand egret
#

@boreal summit let en know it also scales with haste/fers

#

vers

ivory swallow
#

Can WF up to 10ilvls tho

sand egret
#

shields are weps

#

seeing as I got a shield from a weapon cache emissarry, id say so

daring marlin
#

Good thing the first boss drops a great shield in mythic. 😃

grizzled fog
#

Any tips for the pack before totem boss on atal

daring marlin
#

run around it

#

or shroud and death skip

grizzled fog
#

As in skip it?

lusty grotto
#

yes

#

skip it

grizzled fog
#

Cus that shits been wiping me no matter how I approach it, unless if I stack ccs but feels like it takes too much time

wintry furnace
#

The one with two big mobs? If you cant skip it, I make sure to get the stalkers first, then CC one hexer, pull them back, kill the other hexer, then kill totem and one after the other, while using cds. But I dont know if that would work on super high keys. I haven't gone up that far.

lusty grotto
#

if you don't have a rogue, simply pull it to the left while your group runs in and die

#

get rezzed, hope nobody pulls it while on the boss

#

then to get out do the same thing

grizzled fog
#

I see, thanks.

outer oriole
#

375 Ritual feather of Unng Ak or do I use Merektha´s Fang 415 ? Secondary trinket is 400 Rezan trinket

sick sentinel
#

it's more efficient to just run around it on the way in

#

you don't need anyone to die

daring marlin
#

use the fang

#

40 ilvls is insane

outer oriole
#

use effect is garbage though, the extra strength worth it ?

#

its around 130 extra strength

outer dew
#

Hey nim

#

Can you guess what I'm gonna say

last mason
#

Would it be accurate to say that, any damage that gets by sb, ip, and sr (outside of cds) is the healer’s responsibility?

#

Not taking into account things like kiting

sand egret
#

restoring health is a healers job, yeah

#

avoiding/mitigating it to the best of your abilities is yours 😃

undone sun
#

since warrior is almost entirely proactive rather than reactive, yes

sand egret
#

true, those weird other tanks stealing healers jorbs!

full furnace
#

prot or blood for m+?

sand egret
#

youre in the prot discord mate

silk mortar
#

Both are good choices

#

But obviously most here are gonna prefer prot

bright pagoda
#

2 weeks now and no emote, scripts are false,true. no idea what i missing or just bad RNG. every other class thats had a similar hidden skin to this, after 7.3.5 most of them were oibtained easily within 1-3 days

#

i read the stone once, im in prot spec.

strong hill
#

The prot skin from the cavern ??

undone sun
#

yeh

strong hill
#

I’m going go with maybe bad rng

undone sun
#

very, very likely

#

hmm, now that i think of it... the only prerequisite in legion was Artifact knowledge 5

strong hill
#

I got mine on the 2nd try , walked to the entrance “ you hear something “ walked around a few mins and got it

undone sun
#

considering that doesn't carry over for bfa ¯_(ツ)_/¯

final mist
#

You have it automatically; Outlaw Rogue requires AK5 and I had no trouble farming the two pieces.

#

Just unluck.

#

@bright pagoda Is the script you're running for teh two quests?

bright pagoda
#

yeah ive been running both scripts

#

both usually show false, then when i enter the cave w/ no emote, it goes to false,true

final mist
#

If it's returning "False, True", that means it hasn't spawned. The script checks the first quest to see if it's spawned, the second to see if you failed the spawn check.

#

It'll spawn if they return "True, False"

#

You're just unlucky, keep trying. Nothing you can do.

bright pagoda
#

yeah, i just cant believe its so crazy hard, this is going on just over 2 weeks

final mist
#

I know some people had to wait months.

#

I had to wait about 2 months for the Feral appearance, checking daily.

bright pagoda
#

ill come back along in a few days i suppose, im not entirely sur eill even use that skin, i didnt see a lot i liked. i mainly wanted it to unlock the other skins using the trick

#

yeah see i did mage, feral and i think another during ABT and they were all within a day or 3

#

druid was 3rd day, mage was first day soon as research completed

final mist
#

Just luck. You have a 50% chance of it rolling either way.

bright pagoda
#

it just felt like in 7.3.5+ the rates of that stuff were increased greatly

final mist
#

You have a rather large chance of it rolling in your favor, that's why. 50/50.

bright pagoda
#

ive been camping him at thunder totem, fly over. buti dunno when i hear the emote even though it doesnt matter where. cause ive heard people taking flight path in and getting in

final mist
#

It doesn't matter which entrance you go into, but the script will only check the second quest if you're at the entrance (just after the zone changes to Neltharion's Vault).

#

If you're outside, it won't work.

bright pagoda
#

yea i guess il just finihs off to 120, gonna get todays invasion buff victory, drink a draught, and spam a dozen IEs and ding 120, equip my gear. run some heroics to replace my 360 weapons, not sure min ilvl on lfr draz

sleek roost
#

Yo can someone point me in the direction of a m+ prot tanking guide

#

as in for general rotation and ability useage, tanked with DH at 1.5k io but new to warrior

sturdy sable
#

Well as a warrior your more tanky without block up then DH is with spikes

#

At least in my experience prot feels tankier

sharp lotus
sick sentinel
sleek roost
#

Awesome, thanks!

vocal skiff
#

Can you backpeddle Cragmaw's indigestion in UR or only heroic leap to dodge it

primal steeple
#

is icy-veins what we got for guides. IV has not been reliable in the past

undone sun
#

yup, they got new writers for BFA

marble cipher
#

@vocal skiff can't backpeddle

#

Intervene back, or leap back should work

lucid bough
#

u can walk back

#

or strife back i guess

forest vapor
#

Arms warrior here, but I'm trying to start building a Prot set to be able to switch and stuff when needed or when I get bored. Currently 396 arms, traits all locked in, no 1H or shields lying around in my bank.

#

I feel it would be ideal for me to build a new set, but Im going to have to take a ilvl hit then rebuild it back up

#

Any advice on maybe what lvl mythic+ lvls are good to start on as a somewhat new tank would be helpful, ty

daring marlin
#

10s should be fine assuming you understand what pulls are appropriate. It's pretty hard to fail a 10 of any key that isn't a select few.

#

As long as you don't forget about reaping lol

#

Sometimes I do and tragedy happens.

forest vapor
#

Gotcha, yeah I'll have to be mindful of that

sick sentinel
#

whats reaping?

forest vapor
#

M+ affix new to season 2 I think, some mobs come back from the dead basically

vapid rapids
#

Every 20% trash killed they spawn

sick sentinel
#

100k DPS

trim bay
#

Is it worth stacking 3 brace for impacts? Or am I wasting a trait on the third? What’s everyone’s thoughts. I’m talking more raids not mythics as bastion of might is more important

warm plinth
#

@forest vapor Important to note that what level dungeons you will be able to tank comfortably will strongly depend on what ilevel your shield is. The higher level your shield is, the more damage is mitigated every time you block. You could be 395 and if you have a 320 shield, you're still gonna get hit pretty hard.

forest vapor
#

Yeah, as a blacksmith I was wondering if I should just craft the 340 to start as quickly as possible then hitting some low keys or something for practice

#

Or just changing loot spec till I get a better one running through something as arms

warm plinth
#

Yeah 340 should be fine to start with, but 10+ you will likely start feeling it with a shield that low. I'd shoot for a 380+ if you want to start doing any serious pushing.

forest vapor
#

Okay cool, thanks, I appreciate all the info I can get

warm plinth
#

@trim bay It's fine to stack 3 BfI. It's a strong trait and it stacks so it's not a waste. A lot of people are using BoM in raids at this point as well. 3x BoM, 1x DC and 2x BfI would be a good setup. If you're more interested in defense/survival traits, you could go for Iron Fortress or Bloodsports as well.

outer dew
#

main reason bom is popular

#

is because raid drops bom

#

by the fuckton

warm plinth
#

That's true

primal crypt
#

3 BoM, 1 DC, 2 IF

warm plinth
#

But then we just drop claps like a fuckton 😉

primal crypt
#

For m+

#

Thats what I want right now

warm plinth
#

Yeah IF is better than BfI for M+, but he was speaking about raids primarily

#

asking about raids*

primal crypt
#

Oh yeah, raid Id run the BFI

trim bay
#

Ahhh yes. For mythic plus. That does makes sense. But over all In a raid sense

primal crypt
#

im even considering dropping 1 BoM

trim bay
#

Sucks re picking traits every time I jump to a mythic

primal crypt
#

To keep engineer helmet

warm plinth
#

Yeah I mean it depends on what traits you're running and the level of keys you're doing. If you're just doing 10s I wouldn't really bother swapping traits every time you do a dungeon.

#

It'll be a nice difference especially if you're going from 0 BoM to 3x BoM, but you can do the dungeon just fine without it

#

You're just sacrificing that beefy avatar window

#

And BfI isn't worthless in dungeons; it's just less effective in AoE situations than IF because you aren't slamming as much in AoE.

primal crypt
#

Yeah, im at the point where I really want to start min-maxing

#

18s are proving to take forever

warm plinth
#

If you want them to go faster, just trash talk your DPS and ask them why they're being outDPSed by the tank 😏

primal crypt
#

Its funny because theyre out dpsing me now :(

warm plinth
#

RIP

primal crypt
#

My outlaw rogue is bursting 350k

warm plinth
#

Tank spec being put back in its place

primal crypt
#

Consistently

warm plinth
#

Phew!

#

That's some nasty deeps

primal crypt
#

My assassination rogue is pulling 200k bursts

#

I feel inadequate

warm plinth
#

We're gonna be back to Legion numbers by the end of the expansion at this rate lol.

primal crypt
#

Yup

sand egret
#

i was thinking about this today: how are hp pools scaling vs dps per tier?

old zephyr
#

Last tier, high gear people wer epulling 100kish DPS with 190k hps

#

this tier it's 220k hps for 200+k DPS

#

be we can do much bigger pull now as well

shell pulsar
#

What are the go to azerite powers now that we have two rings to choose from? Whats worth stacking?

distant meadow
#

When you're talented with Bolster and it "blocks all melee attacks", does it include the mobs you aren't targetting? Or just the one that you're targetting currently?

undone sun
#

it works the same as normal block

#

target doesn't matter

distant meadow
#

Ok. But I thought if you were going to block something you had to be targetting the mob thats attacking you?...I'm still learning prot warrior lol

sturdy sable
#

You just have to have what ever is attacking you be in front of you

undone sun
#

^ you just have to be face the target

distant meadow
#

Gotcha. Thanks yall!

errant oriole
#

hey guys

#

is best served cold any good vs the other 2?

#

i know unstoppable force is the go to talent

#

but im just curious

undone sun
#

very unlikely, with Deafening crash being a thing it's hard to beat

errant oriole
#

oh ok

#

what if i am not using defeaning crash? lol

#

😛

undone sun
#

then you should rethink your decisions

errant oriole
#

lol

#

so with defeaning crash i should use shout then avatar then spam clap?

#

i only have one thing of defeaning crash does the dmg on that trait just stack?

vocal nimbus
#

all the info is there

#

and yes, stacking deaf crash only increases damage

calm root
#

hey guys. is magic damage the weakness of prot war? Just went through Motherlode+13 and was getting enormous damage from 3rd and last bosses magic attacks.

astral crystal
#

yeah magic dmg can wreck us, just be judicious with IP, personals and externals

#

13 shouldn't pound you hard enough to be undoable

#

also you can spell reflect every other dot

calm root
#

ye i survived. it's just that damage intake was extremely smooth during the run - apart from these 2 bosses. I guess i need to memorize more spells that can be reflected

#

thanks

warm plinth
#

Yeah, last boss of Motherlode is the worst because all the damage you're taking is magic or unblockable. Shield Block is really only helpful for the damage increase on that fight, so if you need more rage to spend on IP, you can sacrifice some Shield Block casts since it's not helping defensively anyway. And as Atticus said, you should be using SR basically on cooldown because it will completely mitigate his "auto attack". The only time you need Shield Block up is if you get targeted by Drill Smash. Face the boss and put up SB to block it.

vocal nimbus
#

Those two bosses autoattacks are magic so its unblockable

merry cave
#

Just don't use sblock on those two

remote tusk
#

does Reckless Flurry work for Protection and procs of Devastator?

sick sentinel
#

it does work with melee attacks

warm plinth
#

It works for our regular auto attack damage. Highly doubt it would work for Devastator procs; that being said, you shouldn't be using Devastator anyway.

supple path
#

Ugh man, third boss on motherlode is my personal challenge right now. Trying to get my reaction time fast enough to only spell reflect when he's targeting me with dot, but that is a fast f'ing cast.

warm plinth
#

Well, the extra devastator damage, that is. I'm pretty sure it is a separate thing, rather than just increased AA damage.

undone sun
#

correct

warm plinth
#

Is there a timer for the DoT? Might be better to just use SR when she's about to cast it. Best case, you get the reflect, worst case, you reduce some of her auto attack damage.

remote tusk
#

ok cause i saw it was using on mythic jaina, just curious

warm plinth
#

Someone was using Reckless Flurry? Or Devastator?

remote tusk
#

both

errant oriole
#

someone used devastator?

#

thought that talent was poop?

undone sun
#

for damage, it's competitive on pure st

errant oriole
#

oh but rage regen wise it blows

lofty drum
#

I downloaded the WA that some guy made for tracking spell refelct but i dont see it popping up

#

do i have to enable it somehow?

#

Marok was the creator

warm plinth
#

Yes, @errant oriole. And note Thyme said "pure" ST. Any additional targets would negate its advantage, and you lose all the rage generation you have with Booming Voice.

errant oriole
#

oh ok

mossy dew
#

hey guys how is protection warrior these days I haven't played in a months

hybrid zealot
#

hey fellas im struggeling with azerite traits for progression: i choose my 415 head with DC and BoM, my 400 chest with IF(over 2nd DC) and BoM(over Treacherous Covenant) and I have 2 shoulders 385 with either CR&IF or Blood Rite or 2nd one with BoM/BfI and CR. my question is whats your suggestion for either deff and off for opulence and conclave? and does the tier 3&4 traits make a greater impact?

warm plinth
#

Prot warrior traits are better than generics; always choose your pieces based on those unless the prot traits are the same on both pieces.

For the shoulders, just to clarify, outer ring on one is CR or IF with Blood Rite (and what prot trait?) in the second ring, and outer ring on the other is BoM or BfI with CR in the second ring?

hybrid zealot
#

so one is outer ring CR or DC and next ring IF or Blood Rite and the other shoulder is outer ring BoM or BfI with next ring CR or Incite the Pack

#

but am i right choosing ilvl over traits?

warm plinth
#

Yes, always ilevel over traits unless you have no DC traits, then you can drop some ilevel to pick up the first DC trait

hybrid zealot
#

aight

#

so i prolly take BfI and CR on that 385 instead of the other ones

#

it also has lifespeed of earthlink so another good choice on 3rd ring i think

warm plinth
#

Yeah, Lifespeed is great

hybrid zealot
#

aight

#

oh and what about shields? an 5ilvl upgrade without haste is better anyways right?

sick sentinel
#

ilvl on shields

warm plinth
#

Any ilevel upgrade on a shield is worth it

sick sentinel
#

is huge

warm plinth
#

No matter what

hybrid zealot
#

kk

#

so time for some trinket discussion? 😄

warm plinth
#

It's either that or actually do work

hybrid zealot
#

😄

#

as i said im focusing on opulence progression and conclave after

#

i have lingering sporepods on 410ilvl

#

bwondsamdi on 385

#

mythrax on

#

375

#

opulence hc trinket

#

and darkmoon decks for dps and tank

warm plinth
#

Well, definitely gonna be using prism

hybrid zealot
#

think that are my best options

oblique garnet
#

prism and bobsalami for progression

warm plinth
#

I had to reread that to make sure I was reading it right 😂

hybrid zealot
#

sorry 😄

warm plinth
#

Nah I meant Late calling it bobsalami

hybrid zealot
#

oh

#

just read first 2 letters

#

😄

warm plinth
#

Yeah for prog bwonsamdi is okay. Prism is easily our best defensive trinket by a mile. It's incredibly good.

hybrid zealot
#

aight

#

so i hope its gonna be a kill tomorrow and i can get my hands on a juicy mythic prism 😄

warm plinth
#

I was really hoping to get a prism from the mythic dungeon weekly, but no such luck

hybrid zealot
#

guild mate got a 425 dice with socket from chest 😄

warm plinth
#

Phew!

hybrid zealot
#

wiat i think there is a clip he linked

warm plinth
#

What spec?

hybrid zealot
#

rogue

warm plinth
#

Nice. Can't watch unfortunately. Work hates twitch

hybrid zealot
#

or maybe his dh

#

but think it was his rogues 😄

warm plinth
#

I'll actually have a chest this coming Tuesday. 💪

hybrid zealot
#

there is no option to sim prot for dps actually right?

warm plinth
#

First one on my warrior this expansion 😅

oblique garnet
#

there are sims

hybrid zealot
#

good luck for tuesday!

oblique garnet
#

but idk if they are 100% working

warm plinth
#

Eh, you can but I would take it with a grain of salt. I don't think everything is ironed out yet.

hybrid zealot
#

hm, so just try and error i think

#

for m+

oblique garnet
#

idk i sim 27k in hectic add cleave which seems pretty accurate

hybrid zealot
#

but actually you dont need any good trinkets or stuff when you have TC 😄

#

simming for m+?! @oblique garnet

oblique garnet
#

well you can sim prot

#

but like

#

idk

warm plinth
#

Use HAC, not dungeon slice though. I feel like it's asking for trouble using a beta module with a beta sim type lol. I for one am not going to take any sims 100% seriously until there's an announcement made that we should do so.

hybrid zealot
#

with how my targets?

warm plinth
#

Just do 1 boss target. I think it assumes 5 targets for HAC sims anyway.

hybrid zealot
#

some mate just sim patchwerk or light movement with 5-7 targets and 20/40s duration for m+ sims

sick sentinel
#

light movement is wack

hybrid zealot
#

just sims about 16k 😄

oblique garnet
#

on hac?

hybrid zealot
#

ye

oblique garnet
#

o.o

sick sentinel
#

How many boms?

hybrid zealot
#

let me try more targets

#

works 😄

#

i think im prepared for tonight

#

so thx @warm plinth

supple path
#

@warm plinth Yeah, problem is that it comes more frequently than every 25 seconds and only targets two random people each time, so if you just spell reflect when it's due, you run the risk of reflecting nothing + not having it up for next cast. Basically just a "room to overfinesse this more" challenge - it is possible to reactively just reflect when she targets you, but you have like 0.2s to react.

I probably need to get some WA for it that blares a REFLECT NOW at me rather than staring at cast bars though.

narrow abyss
#

I just check pho ability timeline or whatever

#

And in my experience. Rarely does it not go on the tank

warm plinth
#

You won't reflect anything but you'll mitigate her auto attacks (which are also magic). That's the only reason I suggested just chancing it when it's about to come off CD. That way you can cast SR as close to on CD as possible. If you're missing a lot of the DoTs anyway, you might as well get as much mitigation from SR as possible by using it on CD.

narrow abyss
#

The bfa targeted spells WA might actually display which two are being targeting with that border glow animation so u can check during the cast time. I just recently installed it and haven’t done an ML this week so don’t know for sure.

shut summit
#

@supple path if you're talking about 3rd boss in motherlode, it's always closest 2 players to boss

narrow abyss
#

🤯

warm plinth
#

Pro M+ strats!

shut summit
#

So can reflect one, have rogue cloak next, reflect again, monk diffuse, etc etc

#

Basically just cycle through group using CDs when reflect won't be up

warm plinth
#

The healer will still have one DoT to heal doing that, right? Since it goes on 2 people? Or can they just dispel it off the other person?

shut summit
#

Can dispel

warm plinth
#

Gotcha.

summer chasm
#

You dispel one and avoid the other

narrow abyss
#

It’s always 2. So if u reflect one. Healer dispels other. Second set. You don’t have reflect. Rogue cloak. Healer dispels on you

warm plinth
#

Ohh okay. I was thinking of it in a weird way lol. Thanks for clarifying.

hybrid cipher
#

Does anyone know of a list of spells in M+ that are reflectable?

warm plinth
#

It has noteable trash mobs in the bottom right corner of each dungeon page

hybrid cipher
#

Awesome thanks!

supple path
#

@shut summit Awesome, thanks, never noticed it was distance based, appreciated.

night halo
#

Does anybody know if they patched leaping out of Crushing Leap? Not sure if I am just bad but I missed every single one that I tried this week

sullen drift
#

is Bloodsport a must have trait?

sand egret
#

NO

#

err

#

no, sorry caps 😦

sullen drift
#

its ok

warm plinth
#

Quit yelling at people Blade, gosh

oblique garnet
#

smh blade wheres your manners

sullen drift
#

shall i stack 2 deafening crash or they dont stack?

warm plinth
#

The damage stacks, but not the Demo Shout extension

#

Likely better to use a different trait after the first one.

analog swift
#

hey what's the best way to drop necrotic stacks as prot warrior on necrotic?

warm plinth
#

Heroic Leap away and kite when your duration is relatively low. Group can help with any AoE snares/stuns they might have. If you're a dwarf or nelf, you can drop the stacks with racial abilities.

sullen drift
#

so i have on head deafening crash + callous reprisal shoulders bastion of might + iron fortress and chest brace for impact + iron fortress how is that ?

#

for m+

warm plinth
#

Could be better, but also could be much worse. If you had more BoM in place of CR and BfI (for M+) that would be ideal, but those are fine.

#

My ideal traits would be 3x BoM, 1x DC, 2x IF for M+

sullen drift
#

i could also go for x2 BoM x2 IF x1 DC and x1 CR is that better ?

warm plinth
#

Yeah, that'd be better

narrow abyss
#

Rop or treants

sullen drift
#

@warm plinth actually i managed to get x3 BoM x1 DC and x2 IF as u told thank you fellow warrior!

warm plinth
#

Sweet! You didn't lose any ilevel to get those, did you? ilevel is still the most important thing.

sullen drift
#

all 3 azerites are 400 ilvl

warm plinth
#

Nice, perfect then!

edgy linden
#

Are sockets worth any ilvl?

undone sun
#

depends on the piece, roughly 5 ilevels at most unless it's on a shield

#

then zero

edgy linden
#

OK thanks! This is 10 ilvl drop so will stick with what I have

last mason
#

is intercepting the powder shots on 2nd boss fh something I should be thinking about doing normally

dense plover
#

The trink from KR not super great for Prot? Mchimnas bandages?

merry cave
#

It's not fantastic unless it's considerably higher ilvl than others you have

sick sentinel
#

@last mason if you have safeguard you should

#

and you should use safeguard anyway its good defensive actualy

sick sentinel
#

@last mason yes and safeguard is not required

shut summit
#

yea you should be doing it, makes fight incredibly tame

#

oops didnt see how long ago that was

vocal elm
#

P3 of Jaina when should we be taunting for Ice Shard?

#

Heroic^

limpid wadi
#

Intercepting what on the second boss in free hold?

warm plinth
#

Powder Shot

daring marlin
#

tbh I’d probably roll 3xBoM, 1xDC and 2xBloodsport if I had the ideal setup.

#

don’t sleep on that leech, that shit adds up

warm plinth
#

Isn't 2 bloodsport only like 2% leech at 415?

potent anvil
#

425 jes' howler deswind

warm plinth
#

Whew!

daring marlin
#

It adds up with other leech effects

#

lol deswind I think I heard shak talking about that earlier

#

when I was watching Nerf

sick sentinel
daring marlin
sick sentinel
#

double BS gives less leech than a single item with leech on it

daring marlin
#

You wouldn’t use just the bloodsport lol

#

That coupled with blood siphon and leech on your gear will really add up

sick sentinel
#

leech middle traits are pretty DansGame tbh

daring marlin
#

Deswind with the double 425 trinkets

#

kappa

sonic saddle
#

O' Experts of Protting... what will be YOUR top two trinkies from this lackluster(?) list of trinkies?

Mchimba's Ritual Bandages (390)
Gore-Crusted Butcher's Block (385)
Jes' Howler (385+Socket)
Doom's Fury (375)
Rezan's Gleaming Eye (370+socket)
Darkmoon Deck: Blockades (355)

sick sentinel
#

gore block +jes

lavish oracle
#

Depends on what you're using them for. Butcher's block is great for damage, Mchimba's is good for survivability, Jes' is a fairly strong dps and survivability cooldown for you and your party in 5-mans

modest wedge
#

butcher is also good for block

last mason
#

@shut summit would you mind pming me your dungeon WAs? Watched your freehold vid and really liked what I saw

ornate blade
#

Ritual Bandages are utter meh lol

#

400 ilvl gives like 60k shield. My IP gives 70k absorb and have no CD.
Howler is cool thing

#

Rezans eye for haste procs

#

Haste is surv

lavish oracle
#

Couple of things: bandages is 72k at 400 ilvl, there's basically no way your base IP gives 70k shielding, and bandages costs 0 rage

ornate blade
#

Bloodsport...

lavish oracle
#

I'm running double bloodsport and mine is 50k, lol

ornate blade
#

cost 0 rage but have like what1 or 2 min cd? 😄

#

whats your ilvl

lavish oracle
#

405, my dude

ornate blade
#

im 403 and have IP worth 70 with procs

#

65 without

lavish oracle
#

It's 60k if I pop Vial which is 2k extra attack power

ornate blade
#

lmao

#

im at work atm but can give ya screen as soon as i get home xD

lavish oracle
#

Pretty sure you're double casting, lol

ornate blade
#

u cant stack it lol

lavish oracle
#

1.3x base IP

#

is the IP cap

ornate blade
#

didnt know that. But i doubt that when it says 70k in tooltip

#

im doublecasting

lavish oracle
#

Glickz is 409 and is getting 45k with 1 Bloodsport

#

If you tripple stack it, that's what? 12k more?

#

at 415?

ornate blade
#

sure try to convice me im seeing things in my tooltips 😄

lavish oracle
#

I'm just not confident you know what your tooltip says, lol

ornate blade
#

6k for 415 bloodsport

lavish oracle
#

Yeah, so tripple stacking it is 12k above 1x Bloodsport

ornate blade
#

3x 6 is 12?

lavish oracle
#

Glickz is running 1 atm

ornate blade
#

ah

#

I know what am i using

ripe crow
#

boys

#

are the engineering goggles worth?

sick sentinel
#

they are good

#

esp if you raid

#

I have actually used them in some keys, I am not currently using them because I have them tuned for fury, probably will either make a second pair to use for prot or something

#

the Gismo trait is super good

ripe crow
#

nice

#

thanks ❤

#

2x DC or 1 DC 1 block?

sick sentinel
#

block as in BfI?

ripe crow
#

iron fort

atomic kindle
#

hey folks... I hate the champion of light fight on my warrior - I can't reliably reset the stacks on the boss

#

is there a trick I'm not aware of?

sick sentinel
#

1DC 1 IF

#

mythic or HC?

atomic kindle
#

on my VDH I have two leap charges so it's easy peasy

#

HC

sick sentinel
#

you can charge to a healer or a ranged and then leap

#

and when she approaches you can spell reflect one application

atomic kindle
#

uuu spell reflect!

tardy berry
#

YOU CAN SPELL REFLECT APLICATIONS OF THAT SHIT?!?!??

sick sentinel
#

yes

tardy berry
#

This is the most critical information I have obtained today, and I'm sitting in complex numbers education rn

sick sentinel
ripe crow
#

\

sick sentinel
#

there are people that work extremely hard to make this information as available as possible

#

please go through it

atomic kindle
#

thanks a lot 😃

#

also

#

seems that if you catch one disorient from the blinding light it instantly resets the stacks as well

sick sentinel
#

you have to time correctly and it works like that yes

#

if you get disoriented you completely drop threat

#

so a poor dps will die

#

and will also probably the highest guy in the meters

atomic kindle
#

unless this is the moment when the other tank taunts for a bit

#

ideally the boss won't even make it to other tank before I taunt back

#

without the disorient the tank swap requires more time to drop the stacks

ornate blade
#

On mythic you can reset stack just as boss cast that long cast (dont know the exact name) wich buffs living (and dead) adds. Just pop reflect on end of that cast and u r golden

sick sentinel
#

exactly

#

tanking this boss on mythic is easier than on HC

ornate blade
#

yep

#

definitely

tardy berry
#

I saw the ressources

#

Guys

#

I had no udea you can spell reflect the dot on bestial throw

atomic kindle
#

well I wont ever tank it on mythic, but thanks anyway :p

tardy berry
#

Critical AF information

sick sentinel
#

it is

ornate blade
#

u can reflect that dot? the fck 😄

tardy berry
#

Critical

#

Informatiin

#

Information

ornate blade
#

lilbit

sick sentinel
#

you need to press SR when the boss is casting his 3rd cast

#

if the cast is on you ofc

atomic kindle
#

the throw happens immediately afther the 3rd combo ability?

sick sentinel
#

well the cast is extremely fast

prime rivet
#

pick 2:
400 vial
400 razan
415 lingering sporepods
405 howler

#

i can't decide 😃

#

for m+

outer dew
#

vial/rezan

ornate blade
#

howler/rezan

neon tangle
#

I’d sacrifice 5lvls to get the 90s trinket

prime rivet
#

which?

sick sentinel
#

vial rezan imo

#

with proper rage gen/not overspending you can get avatar to 50s CD

neon tangle
#

Vial has a 90s CD, which lines up well to have it every other avatar

lavish oracle
#

I'm with Vial Rezan's

neon tangle
#

Jes is way more useful to tanks with 1min / 2min CDs

#

Or tanks who value vers more

warped moth
#

Blood siphon or winds of war for M+

lavish oracle
#

Whats tue order of operation for DR calculations?

sick sentinel
#

there is a sheet

#

but its a bit out of date

#

I went and updated mine, lemme fetch it

lavish oracle
#

So like if I have 55% armor reduction, shield block, shield wall, IP, demo, and 5% vers, what order are reductions applied in?

#

Or does it even matter?

sick sentinel
#

uhhh ping somebody who knows?

warm plinth
#

Absorbs get consumed after damage reductions; reductions happen at the same time

#

I dont' know how to do the math though

#

don't*

sick sentinel
#

this is mine

#

if you go and replace the value on the "stat increase" box you will see how much DR will X stat give you

#

use mine instead of marok's for your calculations btw

#

marok has not updated for 16 base shieldblock and vanguard buffs

#

I did

warm plinth
#

#

Order of reductions doesn't matter though, to answer your question @lavish oracle. It's just a multiplication problem either way.

lavish oracle
#

Okay, so absorbs last might be the only part that matters, that'd make sense

warm plinth
#

Yeah, that should be all that matters assuming it's all % damage reduction. I'm honestly not sure about something like the HMT racial since that's a fixed damage reduction afaik.

lavish oracle
#

I need to stop thinking about this before it keeps me awake all night

#

% DR -> fixed reduction -> absorb?

warm plinth
#

Like to save my brain, if you had a 100k hit, had a 50% reduction from block, had 40% from shield wall, and had 5% vers, you'd take 28,500 damage before IP. I would imagine that static damage reduction like the HMT racial would take place after %DR but before absorbs, yeah.

#

But I'm not 100% on that

lavish oracle
#

If they came before % DR they'd be basically worthless

warm plinth
#

Yeah, you'd be taking (for example) 200 damage from 100k vs 200 damage from 28,500

#

It'd be essentially insignificant

lavish oracle
#

Okay, time to sleep before I think of another kind of damage reduction to fit in there

warm plinth
#

Haha

sick sentinel
#

So I was taking treeboy in manor

#

And I shuffled a bit to help kill the snare on my healer

#

The boss literally walks behind me

#

And fucking slams me in the back

#

250k slap

#

I took more damage on that single hit than I had taken the whole encounter

silk mortar
#

It's fun on pugs when you see tanks walk into every single fire they see on tyrannical

#

And basiclly kills group

#

And after that tank goes wtf

mental tundra
#

quick trinket question boyz

#

for m+ what trinkets would you run? got 400 ilvl rezan+diamond(from opulence) and vial from UR

#

is rezan+vial better or is rezan+diamond better? :/

silk mortar
#

Would personally run Vial and Diamond, dont know if others agree but Diamond feels good and absorbs much damage over the run and vial lets us burst really good

mental tundra
#

dropping rezan? 😮

#

that feels bad man

#

might be worth mentioning that the rezan got +84 leech aswell

sick sentinel
#

Rezan+diamong is better

#

unless you wanna pad meters

mental tundra
#

i guess like it could differ for dungeons, if im doing lower keys in like ML/FH/WM vial+rezan could be good for padding

sick sentinel
#

if you want to be in an overall better shape then rezans is better

mental tundra
#

yeah i feel rezan cant be droped

sick sentinel
#

we burst so good anyway

mental tundra
#

but diamond can maybe be dropped in some situations where you have good affix and you wont need survivability that much maybe

silk mortar
#

We may burst good but can always improve ;D

sick sentinel
#

that is actually not that true

#

even in +15s and +16s, most mobs dies before avatar ends

silk mortar
#

While that may be true it depends on how well your dps is doign also

#

The ones i run with are kinda meh ;P

mental tundra
#

always feelsbad tho

#

when you avatar a big pack

#

and then reaping comes

#

and u got nothing

silk mortar
#

Yeah its really important to plan ahead ^^

mental scarab
#

Btw on jadefire master Mythic do you guys use more vers gear?

mental tundra
#

ilvl > over all

#

haste is generally better even tho

mental scarab
#

Same ivl then😛

mental tundra
#

cause its gives you surv+damge

mental scarab
#

Aha

#

Hurt like a train dho

floral tinsel
#

The boss ain't that bad, you just gotta realize that the mage only does fire damage to you when you tank him, so don't spen your rage on anything but IP and you are fine.. monk is blockable damage so there you obviously use shield block

#

If you still feel like you are struggeling getting a BoM (free IP casts are stronk) and/or a Bloodsport Azerite trait helps

daring patrol
#

try not to get more than 10 stacks, if you're the one tanking him during bombs, abuse the LoS and basically ignore his damage for the duration

old zephyr
#

What is your cotank ?

#

What we do on jadefire is swap right before and right after the monk mechanics that send the tank on trial

round vortex
#

Hye guys looking for a hot tip here on Jaina Heroic. Her ice lance is hitting for 120k every 1 sec. Is there anyway to mitigate that more other than shiel dblock?

urban walrus
#

Swap as soon as you can with the attaching ice Lance debuff

#

Stacking*

#

The other debuff you can ignore by either clearing from the ammunition or killing the ice cube quickly

round vortex
#

Yeah its only phase 3

#

we getting there with whole raid every time then getting ruined

urban walrus
#

Other than that other DRs personal or otherwise still work

round vortex
#

made last phase on 2nd pull lol

urban walrus
#

Other than timing your SB usage for higher stacks or asking for personals that's about it

#

I'm assuming you didn't swap with the ice lance correctly if you are getting destroyed

#

It's not low damage but quite manageable

#

Are you getting the other stuff by standing with the other tank?

#

That might cause issues with the ice blocks on tanks

#

Debuff*

sick sentinel
#

you might want to hold your shield wall and/or last stand for p3 anyway

#

and use spell reflect for 5s of DR on the dot if you are at high stacks of Chilling touch

round vortex
#

yeah we are struggling with the last phase and timing ice bloacks

#

any advice?

sick sentinel
#

get one group frozen before everyone else

#

get them soak first orb and stand inside ice ground that will be left by glacial ray

round vortex
#

ok awesome

sick sentinel
#

so when people get frozen those guys can get you out

#

also make sure that group has bigger aoe then everyone else like outlaw rogue dh and such

round vortex
#

yep legend we went double DH ele shaman DK pally

#

ill advise in 10

#

best time to lust?

sick sentinel
#

i think people do what method did nowadays even with heroic

#

hero on wall but still ranged attack boss and use cds

#

just melee and tanks hit the wall

#

also ignore nathanos and go for add first then nathanos that should make entrance to last phase easier

#

or you can hero either 2nd or 3rd image to make the fight easier during the phase

round vortex
#

13% wipe

calm root
#

hey guys. why do some people pick devastator instead of booming voice in BfD? I thought booming voice is mathematically more damage and rage generation per minute.

formal vine
urban walrus
#

I think it comes down to preference, with current hate levels we aren't struggling to have a good mix of up and SB?

eager phoenix
#

How good is Jainas dps trinket with the stacking dot compared to 400 Vial or 400 Rezans in M+? I don't have either 400 Vial or Rezans to compare but 385 Jaina trinket was doing around 650 dps overall in +15 WcM and SoB this week. Mainly curious if I need to make it a bigger priority to slam UR and AD to get these trinkets if they performs a lot better in M+.

sick sentinel
#

@eager phoenix jaina trinket does very solid damage

#

@urban walrus you should focus on keeping SB up at all times and IP second

#

even with mediocre levels of haste I can keep both up at most times

#

@calm root BV is more rage generation so it's better defencively and it's better in AoE dps but with one or more instances of BfI devastator can bring very solid ST damage

#

@mental scarab Vers is very, very solid defencively in raids after haste and if you do the calculations/spreadsheet it might be actually the best defencively for you

eager tartan
#

I'm actually experimenting with 3 IP traits plus the jess howl trinket (got one at 425)

#

THICC IP

sick sentinel
#

I opted in using a second DC over a BS, because most of the time my IP either runs out or I have to overcap it for rage

#

so having even more would result in not that much

#

I still use all of it in some scenarios, the one I am in most danger actually but it has a very decreased value overall

#

if you are doing mostly raids, then it is good, since there is so much magic damage in them

eager tartan
#

ofc for mythic + I go with 3 BoM

#

being pretty lucky with loot overall

robust bronze
#

At what haste level would devistator beat booming voice in rage generation?

sick sentinel
#

none probably

#

it got super nerfed with the release of bfa

#

it used to give rage when it procced and SS was giving 20 rage

#

now it does not give rage and SS generates 15 rage

calm root
#

@sick sentinel Thanks. But i don't see any connection between devastator and BfI in logs. Some are running multiple BfI with booming voice. Some are using devastator without a single BfI trait.

sick sentinel
#

also " Devastator’s chance to reset Shield Slam is reduced, from 30% to 20%"

#

it got absolutely fucked

#

I just described the ideal scenario where it's good

molten raven
#

Hey guys. I

#

I've seemed to have hit a wall with my warrior. Could anyone have a look at my toon and give me some criticism. Salleen- Frostmourne

icy flax
#

if you make a raid with only protect warriors. can you reflect jademaster's pyro and hit for 100M ?

sick sentinel
#

not tested if pyro is reflectable

runic fractal
#

@molten raven give us specific problems you are having...?

#

your ilvl is incredibly low for a start

molten raven
#

398 is low?

sick sentinel
#

398 is not low by any means

runic fractal
#

wow logs not updated for me then

#

apologies

sick sentinel
#

can't really look at your character right now, have you read the icy veins guide etc

molten raven
sick sentinel
#

your gear is ok

modest wedge
#

what wall do you think you've hit?

sick sentinel
#

your shield's ilvl is pretty crucial so you want to try to improve on that aspect

runic fractal
#

^

molten raven
#

I can't seen to get past a 10

#

Or time a 10

#

And I feel like I am the issue

runic fractal
#

group dependent most of the time

modest wedge
#

team effort but that gear can do +12

#

this week

sick sentinel
#

^^

modest wedge
#

at least

sick sentinel
#

again, before we start saying stuff, have you read the guides and checked the available resources

#

if you haven't we can't really help you

#

it will be better for you if you ask more specific questions

molten raven
#

I guess it's hard without logs

#

I can't really learn anything from then

round vortex
#

GOT IT!!

#

we did a burn strat

sick sentinel
#

logs REALLY help

molten raven
#

You can log M+ yeah?

sick sentinel
#

@round vortex grats!

#

you can log a mplus!

molten raven
#

I think I will have to start doing that

#

I will learn a fair bit from it

sick sentinel
#

if you come back with logs we can actually help you

molten raven
#

yeah that's fair enough

modest wedge
#

I think you can go far without logs but they help in niche places and things that are nice to know. So dont expect to get suddenly better by just logging things. never logged my mplusses. I would but im lazy

sick sentinel
#

because right now sadly there is not much we can do other than a) point you towards recourses and stuff to read or b) tell you to go check stream/youtube of sense or deswind or other stormforged that do keys

sand egret
#

for ref, i just timed a +12 last night. im also 398

#

twas also a pug

round vortex
#

@sick sentinel I can post a kill video soon

tardy berry
#

What are the names of noteworthy prot warrior streamers and youtubers to look up for educational purposes?

sand egret
#

Sense streams for sure (he’s also in here as well)

#

in fact, a few warriors in here stream. could just creep on the sidebar lookin for links 😉

modest wedge
#

Can one promote his/her stream on #promotion ? just askins for maybe future reference

#

or what are the rules

sick sentinel
#

Sense,deswind,lala steam prot

sweet kettle
#

Marok sense lala and deswind stream

sick sentinel
#

Late streams if we beg him enough

#

Also Marok

sweet kettle
#

cough Bugatsa streams cough

sick sentinel
#

You do?

sand egret
#

@molten raven My best advice for getting those +10s in time are to go watch some streams and see how they pull. Pull path, pacing, the setup, things to interrupt, etc. are really how you end up timing a key (esp if you dont know how to deal with Reaping). Once you got the knowledge, it’s about building the muscle memory of the spec to ensure you can actually tank the pulls. 😃

sweet kettle
#

From time to time

tardy berry
#

thanks bro's I'll check out these names

#

😃

narrow abyss
#

This season is so route dependent

#

Just have a good route and the m+ plays itself

sand egret
#

proper group placement is huge for reaping to get a handle on the swarm

sick sentinel
#

Not wiping also helps

sand egret
#

-_________-

#

thanks, Madden.

modest wedge
#

4Head

sand egret
#

“If you keep your hp above 0, you won’t die!” - sagely advice from peerless master, Kaege.

#

😛

sick sentinel
#

I will have you know

#

I am very smart

sweet kettle
#

Keep claping and all will be Gucci

daring patrol
#

pay attention to when you're close to each reaping pack and save avatar, ezclap handles the whole pack

#

feels like that scene in LotR where gimli literally blows away the ghosts

waxen talon
#

u could just get a shammy or a druid and they will negate atleast half the reapings.

sand egret
#

“When there’s something strange...in your Mythic key....who ya gonna call!”
👢 🍵 👏

tribal schooner
#

Actually shammy's elemental will not aggro reaping mobs from protwar

#

Because avatar + clap is too much

daring patrol
#

it will round them up for you if you don't have avatar up and clap is on cd

tribal schooner
#

Yeah, but I mean scenario, when you save avatar for them, which you should do for every reaping

sick sentinel
#

Primal earth ele have a 15yard aoe taunt on a 5 sec cd

#

They will pick up the mobs off of you

tribal schooner
#

It builds aggro very slow, so it won't pick up mobs from protwar with avatar up

tardy berry
#

appropos reaping, how do y'all negate that fuckton of damage?
Do you kite a lot, or do you just use CDs and don't stand in purple shit?

tribal schooner
#

And primal ele isn't stronger than basic ele as I recall. It only receives a decent save for shaman and itself

daring patrol
#

it's really not a lot of damage unless you have a lot of the caster ones

#

if you're taking a ton of damage its either that and/or your healer isn't dispelling you

sick sentinel
#

Primal ele can tank the reaping like a champ

tardy berry
#

hmm, alright. I think the stacks are usually what gets me

sick sentinel
#

Then your healer is dispelling badly

#

Try to shockwave when you are above 25 stacks or right after you get dispeled

#

healers should dispel around 20 stacks

#

and if reaping adds meleeing you alot kite and stun a bit until you get dispelled again

#

high stacks will just kill you

#

I have survived a 63 stack tick before

#

It did hurt, but I survived

tardy berry
#

noice

marble wave
#

@tardy berry glikz streaming too

#

And he answered for every question in chat ;) very informative

tardy berry
#

noted 😃

mental scarab
#

@sick sentinel yea i mostly thinking magic dmg lower some of it🙂

narrow abyss
#

There really isn’t much damage if you’re being dispelled correctly

sick sentinel
#

Sabel is talking about mageboy in JFM

mental scarab
#

Yea

modern brook
#

I just realized how fucking unlucky my warrior's drops have been

#

I have 3 times as many tidal cores as my rogue

#

and am 9 ilvls lower than it in bags

#

feels weekly chest man

fresh valley
#

Hey guys, i'm getting into tanking for my group this season. I had a quick question for tanking in shine: on fortified, the normal spell casting mobs were chunking me for over 30% of my life in one spell cast (specifically all the casters before the first boss) and this was on a +10. Any tips or tricks to mitigate this? We're interupting/stunning as many as we can but it still gets dicey. I'm worried as we push for our +15 achievement that this could be a block for us.

#

Am i better off maybe starting off with a stam flask then swapping to a str flask after the first boss?

modern brook
#

The water guys?

prisma crane
#

spell reflect 😉

sick sentinel
#

the water blast hurts yeah you can reflect it

modern brook
#

Make sure you're not shieldblocking during those pulls unless u have a real reason to

#

Spellreflect blast

#

fucking walk out of the swirlds

#

make sure you have Demo shout up as much as possible

#

spells hurt

sick sentinel
#

use IP not block also use shout and wall if needed

fresh valley
#

yeah

modern brook
#

SotS is one of the harder dungeons for us

daring patrol
#

coordinate interrupts, don't interrupt the sea swell, just move out of it

modern brook
#

^

#

if u wanna get super technical

#

your DPS should be kicking the blasts

#

you should be kicking the mends

narrow abyss
#

Interrupt the hell out of water blasts. Get out of deep smash. And wait for a good tyrannical week

#

😂

fresh valley
#

I think that's our issue, we're just interupting everything

#

instead of interupting the direct damage casts

#

and just moving out of shit

modern brook
#

Im p sure waterblast always targets the tank

#

so thats just rude of your DPS

#

it also makes great memes with Spell reflect

#

EZPZ 150k damage

fresh valley
#

yeah, love some spell reflect

primal crypt
modern brook
#

but yeah that entire dungeon is a pain for prot tbh

#

well thats not true; we're basically other tanks inverted

fresh valley
#

yeah, we timed a 10 last night. never want to step foot in there again lol

modern brook
#

We really dont care about iron sides

#

but everything else hurts a lot

primal crypt
#

Wat

#

Shrine is easiest dungin

#

🤔