#protection
1 messages Β· Page 2237 of 1
You can also pop avatar and demo and taunt offensively with some thunderclaps
I mean the action is literally named after our ability....
@sick sentinel try to be more specific as to in what scenario you're asking, because at a basic level you already answered yourself.
a quick tip though, heroic leap resets the CD on taunt, so... if you need to taunt and dont have it up, just leap and you can taunt the target before you even hit the ground with the leap
and, incidentally, probably the only time i wish leap didnt have a minimum range
except i guess when i have no aoe abilities up i'd just use it to jump in place for a bit extra dmg...
Usually on mythic Fetid im not getting more than 2 stracks of Into the fray, Off tank and boss. >> should I swap it to punish?
"Into the Fray Icon Into the Fray is better than Punish Icon Punish for survivability as long as you are able to consistently keep at least 2-3 stacks up on the buff, which is pretty much always the case"
generally yeah
could always experiment, 3% less on m fetid thrashes could be nice
not taking thrashes
Taunt is only important if you lost aggro. Its OK to use it for now at the start of a raidboss in its current state but I believe post patch it's better to save it. I think post 8.1 they remove the threat bonus it gives you for a few seconds
someone can correct me on that one
So are the 8.1 buffs to Prot enough to make us better for M+? I don't want to play the laughing stock tank
Play it, be good at it, laugh at the haters.
they never removed the threat bonus for taunt
it was a tooltip change to make al;l the taunts the same, they all still give you bonus to threat generation, just some didnt say it and others did, so they just corrected the tooltips for them
@pliant sage define "laughing stock"
for most people, warrior tanks will perform fine if you put the time in it
defensively we are pretty good, the reason we lack in M+ is due to our utility, we can still facetank better than other tanks, minus the raw hps of dk's
i'll probably not want to rope myself when doing KR during fort weeks
a bit less
Zul will probably still make my asshole shrink
Laughing stock tank? Prot is god tier, polish yourself up fam you have it in you.
Sorry had to do some work.
Trav coming in hot with the π’ π΅ π
I've been trying to get into some M0 to work on routes and all. I've been turned away from four groups for simply being a prot Warrior.
uh
I don't think
those are just shitters
it's because you're a prot warrior
LOL
I
would be greatful for any tank doing M0
lmao
you could be a bear for all I care
Well the reason I got in PM was 'Garbage Warrior"
Like I get that my War is at 345 in prot but it's a M0
you should be doing +5s or more (although maybe not this week...)
i mean
but if you wanna learn yeah you're doing it right
not if he's doing runs to learn routes haha
Well I'm trying to get routes and patting down, so 0 is somewhere to start
They Do?
some do
some packs are better to be pulled X vs Y week
sometimes you can pull harder
depends on your comp and comms
I'm an actual nub at mythic so
if you know you have the damage + utility to burn through some packs
this is way more advanced stuff
if you're starting out, get something you are comfortable with
then start to deviate
just remember though
confidence means ya panic less and you can perform better
the talent pool is garbo sub 12 keys usually
I believe in ya
Fair. I'm not trying to push more than 4 to 6.
i mean
And I've tanked on Warrior for a while now. I just need to learn the instances and stuff.
unfortunately, people on the internet can suck so you'll probably still deal with those types
eh
i mean, it's more of
I don't really agree with that
a lot of people that stay in those areas
That's why I was asking what the announced changes for prot in 8.1 look like they will do
the 8.1 changes will probably not change the minds of those running M0 denying warriors
I know any spec can be pushed if it's played right
to be honest
Yep
because unless you trying to push and having groups play around you
or believe in you
i can see where you might have a more enjoyable / easier time getting into groups
can anyone tell me where the tanking training dummy is in BFA?
is there one in Boralus?
horde or alliance?
ya
look at the flight path, take a left
im at all the dummies in Boralus
if you're looking at the 3x dps dummies
Raiders training dummy?
because there's healing dummies too
no
behind you
it's on the oppisote side
like it's on the wall when you walk through the gates on the right
So I should focus on getting a group together for practice then work on the bits like knowing packs and finding out what CDs to rotate etc
if you're looking at the archway to walk back up to the flightpath in the dummy area, it's on your left
that's it!
well
ty
buttons, what's your end goal?
Eventually get to doing 10s and maintain that as patch cycles go
And I'm in a social guild so I'm having to pug to get things done
It's doable as a prot warrior, it'll just not be fun to build yourself up there
gotcha, I did the whole thing solo myself
I sit at a decent IO, so getting into +10's is usually breezy
π’ π΅ π
The only other tank that sounds fun to play is Bear and they are in the same boat as far as community perception goes
I mean, have you done a class trial with tanks?
I have 110s of each tanking spec
I refuse to level another tank, becauese my gut feeling is i'll be asked to bench my warrior if I did
lmao
Brewmaster feels squishy and Stagger doesn't feel like it mitigates unless the healer knows to keep hots up for the DoT
I started in m0 and built up my dungeon route knowledge > went up to ~4-5 until I could pull it confidently > added another affix. Getting chested runs along the way will also build your r.io slowly to give you "cred" (helps while pugging)
Pally feels like a worse Warrior. I just don't like their AM
if you really like how warrior plays, stick with it, but it's not like the easiest tank to play nor the "top"
Veng has massive holes in their AM and nothing to fill them with. And I hate how clunky and odd DK feels.
so if you're cool with that, keep your head up and unfortunately brave through the inevitable trolls
eh, they're very different things
once you clear one part of the content
you'll feel like whatever earlier was easy af
feel free to try different things, get more gear, and push content
I know they don't overlap and take different skillsets
well I mean like...one needs way more people
they'll help you improve mechanically
learn more situationals
get more of an understanding of other classes
etc.
like, don't be afraid to push content
it's very doable
you just have to always remember one thing
you can always be better
the warrior class won't hold you back for what you're trying to achieve
the gaps between average->good->top tier players are usually huge
Yep. There are always higher things to do
you always have small things or even large mechanical things to improve on
so, get that confidence and just cut your teeth
like, people who know me
will know I sometimes will sit 2 hours in a key
trying retarded shit
I fucking drop SB during last stand ALL the time, but that doesn't stop me from pushing my keys
too mong to press SB during last stand
haha
LS = Good to DPS
;DDDD
too many TC + Revenge to spam
lool yeah but I still have my brain farts where I instinctively block
I thought we were supposed to let SB recover it's times during Last Stand because the talent made us 100% bkock
we are
i'm illustrating how bad I am
Oh
yet still doing stuff you want to achieve
so I know some packs need to die quick
or i'll know they'll die quick
so i'll pop last stand in opener and go hard on the DPS
because that's one of the strengths of warrior
strong AoE DPS
Like I've been a raid tank on Warrior a few times and the guides in the channel above are so great for understanding what needs to be done
but that's just something you'll learn and temper yourself
And that's what I'm trying to learn but community is what it is so I've been denied to even attempt
yeah....well you can either roll with them and reroll to a fotm
or play a class you like
I mean
I hate the FoTM classes. Like I get that Warriors aren't ballz amazing in M+
I'll have to try that.
like, if I was to make another toon
Seems like the best option available
once you get your key
but that's me having an understanding of dungeons
just ride that shit
and pulls
Warfronts are probably a better use of time at that ilv
Oh?
and m0 will give you more chances for Az pieces
tru tru
I didn't know there was a min ilv for Warfronts
Thanks for the peptalks. I'll just have to do what I can with pugs that I form
also, personal tip for pugging: add "for fun" on there
you'll get less "go go go"-ers
if he's not doing 10's people will also be in the mentality
of they just want to finish the key
like once you go higher, it's basically 2-3 wipes and people will retire the key
I spent a lot of time pugging lower keys solo mate
there's a bunch of people out there who want to do M+ but are intimidated by it
like A LOT
What's the scaling from Heroic to M0? I can live ezmode in Heoic.
Not gear. In Legion M0 was like 10% buffed from Heroc. Does that metric hold?
And I'm not so much intimidated by the content as I am irritated that my spec is barring me from playing it in randoma.
depending on your gear you will notice a slight difference but it isnt too bad to just jump from heroic into a +2 even if the group is half competent
i mean
if you
you're okay with starting your own group
then it's not your class really barring it
making your own group solves that issue
I was trying to join 2 DPS and 1 heal groups or 3dps and 1 heal and getting turned away
they made keys infinite for this exact reason
just make your own man, takes 2 seconds to fill
So forming my own solves the problems.
yep
Is cheating a thing in M0? I thought gear dropped by boss
if your goal is to get into there and learn routes etc but are worried that being a prot will bar you from invites...
Chesting*
So then times doesn't mean crap either
yep!
so you can learn your route
when you beat the dungeon, you'll get a +2 key
and from there, you just make your own keys and work on your timing
and next week, you'll have a key in your cache so you can just start off with that
Seems doable. What's the decay of keys like. I remember if you didn't time a run by x it list levels to your keystone.
if you fail its -1
K
be it by an hour or 10 seconds
week is -1 of your previous highest
that you completed in time, I believe.
actually I lied, its just -1
pro tip for this week: if victory rush isnt on one of your mouse buttons, you are playing the game wrong
I have it as a keybind....
whats it bound to?
F
I hover over it enough, my SB is shift+F
Problem with underrot on +10 is that both groups on the ramps at the start have an infested mob. Fast CC'ing is absolutely required or else the mask is getting healed
or having a DK to grip it away to be CC'd works as well
pre-first boss is just so annoying in that place
i accidently charged the ramp group and got the mask group as well, but we survived and made the timer, was a +6
the worst groups are the ticks by far
after the first boss, i just go left because the right is so much worse
oh for sure
but even then, on the left theres about 3 of the stupid worms plus a zillion ticks
it's that bridge that tends to wreck my pugs
and then you get about 5 explosives that spawn at the same time
after that though the dungeon is super easy
yeah it's super front-heavy
if you have a demon hunter, after the 3rd boss you can jump up the center section, he can mount up and then everyone can skip a few very annoying packs
those guys at the start that charge cleave and leave a bleed on you is nasty if group is idiots
i find the buff is way worse
the warcry?
yep
it buffs the priest who can heal, you have less than 1 second to interrupt the heal with warcry active
oh, honey, I got Boomie and the Tree Amigos in my back pocket
that bitch is on soothe duty
gottem
my group usually has a DK + DH, sometimes we have our boomy, sometimes we have a lock instead
i may pug, but I pick my groups with reason π
DH's are amazing for explosive
dont always have the warlock, but good to know
yeah, we had a really good lock in both of your groups.
i was doing a KR the other day and my group was all high and mighty about how we were screwed on the bridge cuz the mage / dh couldn't cc....
and I'm like....why do you think I brought a Priest?
I could hear the audible confusion emanating from their heads.
S H A C K L E U N D E A D
they legit had no idea that spell existed
most people dont know priests can do damage
heck, I don't even think the fucking priest thought of it
Love Shackle. Did DKs get Controll Undead back?
i had a +13 AD last night were my disc priest was doing more damage that the destro lock we pugged
he said he could hold is own...
Why?
the mobs they can take control of are super strong
I understand why in Atol
just some monster mobs you can grab
Oh kool
the beast master for example does like 5k dps
yeah and she's a PITA so its a win/win
if she gets barrage off, the beastmaster
cause i dont do kings rest. Period
zerker does a lot of damage through the dot if it stacks and you don't offload it
another reason to bring a DK
tyrannical weeks its nearly impossible because the fights are either massive dps checks (1st boss) or nearly impossible if the dungeon decides to fuck you (council)
what kind of healer?
the first boss has claimed ALL my pugs
hmmm, I generally like to run with MW/Resto Druid
but I've done it with every healer
which parts are hard
theres no way for me to help with it as a prot warrior; i cant intercept it and safeguard sucks for that fight for different reasons
i can only rallying cry once to save them
just a note this is on 10+ keys
dunno if you are doing those or not
i know the council in freehold is super hard because of eudora on tyrannical, but i can at least intercept that to save my healer
you cant intercept severing axe
and on high tyrannical keys it will do will over their entire healthpool
its not an issue if it targets the demon hunter cause the DH can just dodge it 90% of the time
What mechanics are we talking about? Sorry trying to learn
yeah, I mean that shit is gonna be rough on Disc
Since prepatch
man...I dunno why I always thought it was 40...i should read tooltips
@pliant sage Severing axe in King's Rest, council fight. Specifically on high Tyrannical keys
As a part of play I'm supposed to have 30ish rage in my pool so I can always use SB right?
SB should be up if you are tanking a mob(s) that will smack you
Severing axe does a scaling amount of damage and tyrannical buffs that damage?
correct
yep
Eww
it will target 1 random person who is not the tank
Sounds like the Ogres at the front of Deadmines
it can be dodged, cannot be intercepted
restro druids have 0 issue with it because they can go bear form and have a zillion hp + armor
Even more eww. Doesn't Intercept give a DR if you talent?
it does, but on tyrannical, when you get debuffed and lose most of your armor, you have to kite
even with block, the boss will hit over 100k per auto attack
The fudge
the leap talent is much better for that fight and that dungeon in general
That sounds aweful
you can outrange the debuff, btw
you can only parry it
the backhand?
parrying it will still knock you back,but you take no damage and the debuff does not get applied
and yes the backhand
guess I've got the sickest luck....
whats you're parry%?
21?
if you have a lot of crit you probably have pretty high parry
dunno what mine is but that sounds about right
I remember doing Heroic Baelock in Firelands and dodging the purple blade on my bear.
I miss 40% dodge
i use Jes' and mythrax trinkets
Eh for my ilv I'm prioritizing Haste and Strength
What is a good haste percent to be at? I know Legion had a recommended 20%
So as much haste/mastery gear as I can get at the highest ilv
And iirc into the fray used to only go up to 15%
stacking haste + mastery/versatility is what most people do
some swear by haste + crit but they're all very similar
Depends on preference
haste is by far the most important
i can respect that
For damage? I'm assuming Vers is for magic passive DR?
Vers also buffs IP doesn't it?
i wouldnt be able to tell you that
IP scales off of attack power, so mostly strength
more AP = higher IP
thats why we use strength flasks
Yep. Vers is just a passive no to damage from all sources isn't it?
Yeap
It's amazing for other tanks
Because Damage increase, increased healing, damage reduction
But that's not how we use stats
But our lack of healing as main form of mitigation makes it less valuable for us
Still good. Just not crazy
Grats (:
i am not sure about the trinket list on icy vanes...Have a good tip ? Could not open the dremgrove thing
into the fray gives more haste the more haste you actually have, and our stat priority order only takes precedence if the item is the same ilvl, except for trinkets and possibly rings, but still very close up there
and yes vers effects ip as its an absorb
there isnt really a recommended number of haste % to be at, just get as much as you can with out sacrificing any ilvl for it, and since there is no caps, having more haste wont ever hurt
MW monk DPS real MVP
The fistweaver is still alive I see
Congrats, mine guild died
@sick sentinel im currently runing with blockades and lions strength.
Guys here are often saying that Best trinkets for us are Rezans and Jess
The Mythrax eye is good aswell
main thing is you won't have a trinket combination that works in 100% of all situations
It's best to understand why people make those choices
For fortified week I think that lions strength is a good choice.
If i would hΓ‘ve Rezans aΕΎ 370 i will probably replaced blockades
@plain vapor You can do better than that.
I did a 30K Parse tonight with razdunk and a pvp trinket
because I'm lazy
I mean it's prog so it's not surprising but I mean it's p good for a progression parse
hey guys, where do i find the boss rotation for freehold this week?
lol that cow sitting out yay on tyranical hitting like a 18wheeler
I think if you stack full raid with blood dks they can do it without healers
since they wont get orbs etc
Encounter will freakin crash from that haha
2 tanks, all dps melee, mistweavers, holy paladins and then one healer that isn't mw or hpala
Everyone laughs as the one healer gets every orb
finally got my first dc azerite piece but only 340 π¦
gotta do that pvp
it shouldnt take long with the increased conquest rewards even in 2s
^
Well with me stacking ilvl, I am stacking crit/mastery, rip
VS sounds nice
multiple uses of IP do not stack right?
man normal raids give so low ap wth
@placid citrus it stacks up to 1.3x times the tooltip so you can use it after it is almost done
you can get the IP tracker Weak aura from the pins and you can re-press ignore pain when it is white to perfectly stack it
Why whould you ever do a normal raid
@sick sentinel I honestly dont know im just trying to farm ap and cba to do islands
do WQs
done all of them already
island rarefarming is way more fun than just island farming and rares give quest items for 700 AP
I farmed my AP doing m+ but it is not time efficient
yeah like doing +13 gives what 290?
around there
and takes 25-40 mins
I would suggest to not bother
Yeah but i legit have nothing else to do
farm mounts/gold/tmog/play other games/level an alt week...
i cba to even do my weekly islands anymore. that shit got old way too fast
I have done my weekly islands like 4 times
2 first weeks and then when I needed like 2k AP fast for a trait
50% to 33
what do you mean with prot is dead?
'rotation' you mean thunderclap 4Head
@storm isle elfmn is a rotating troll, he jumps around the discords trying to get folks to argue with him, one of the lucky half dozen that I have blocked in here.
I think it used to have a 50% slow
and then whey they gave us Dragon's Roar
they took it away
which has been a pretty sore spot for us
as we're the only tank that doesn't have a reliable way of slowing mobs down
definitely makes kiting way harder
since mobs run 30% faster than players
I mean - monks keg smash is only 20
right they have the option at least
but monks have RoP
which is like the best snare in the game
lasts 6 seconds
I know, I'm just trolling at this point because I want to feel better about how much they don't care about warrior π¦
if it lasted 30
Well they care
but utility is always going to be our weakest point
do they?
They've left the original tank on the bottom of the pile for well over a year with 0 love
our utility is great for raiding
opinions?
depends how comfortable you feel
^
the socketed legs obviously have more value
what's your haste at without the pants?
overall they're stronger
but if you feel slow
wear the haste ones
I got 390 legs offa Zek lastnight
wearing them over my 385 taloc pants
nice
17.66% without haste pants and 19.50% haste with pants
because at 50% I'm not feeling to bad
with 0 itf ofc
I just beat my face against mythic taloc for an hour with a horrible pug last night to remind myself why pugging is a real bad idea
@sick sentinel i'd put the haste ones on unless youre putting a str gem in the socketed ones
why str gem lol
- Str is not our best stat
yeah its going to be hard getting used to no RA in 8.1
str isnt our best stat 
RA?
- The crit/mast/socket legs will lead to overall less damage taken for a fight as long as he has enough haste to reach "effective" 100% uptime on block
reorigination array
@storm isle they mean reorigination Array
its the buff in Uldir
Thanks
Im just bad the the shortenings
@astral crystal are you memeing?
@astral crystal Str isn't haste is, str is strong, because item level carries a lot of it
but 40 str is weaker than 40 haste/vers/mast (maybe crit)
70haste > 100 str
more or less
if youre going for haste why not wear the haste pants fam
crit is still good, all of our secondaries are pretty close together
because you want as much stats as possible
Well, because the value of the haste gem + crit/mast probably outweighs it once you reach a point that you can maintain 100% effective uptime on block
like I said - it depends on his particular situation
it's not just about effective block uptime
I myself, might swap my gems to vers for Uldir
lowering GCD is op
it is though, that is why haste is our strongest defensive stat
because of the CD reduction on SB
and TC
you can never have enough
thats a bit of a misnomer, and goes against our gearing logic
haste is strong, but not strong enough to sacrifice item level, a gem, is in general worth about 5 ilvls
but, those pieces are so close
it will come down to the feel
if he feels he needs more haste
than yeha haste pants
mactier, i understand this, i'm not new to prot
well I mean, you did just suggest putting a str gem in
but again, you cant really understate how stronk it is to lower your gcds

i understand the meme behind that pic
π
@sick sentinel at below 20% haste wear the haste pants
When your haste looks like this https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/148897941883584512/512082376470298655/unknown.png
you can stop stacking rite
Helm offa mother lastnight HNGG
385 haste bracers
Anyone got tips for Vectis
Hmm dat mythrax change gonna make M prog interesting tonight
1 stack
im at 42% and i still think more haste is good
its gonna mean melee don't get shit on
I'm aware
that was horrible "primry strat - don't bring melee"
not that i really sacrifice any stats at this point, i spam enough m+ and m uldir has been kind to me with haste drops, got the sword off mytrhax at 395 with socket and avoidance opop
I'm also super wary of blizz fucking something else up
Unintentionally
Like suddenly visions will spawn in the wall
that'd be fantastic
My favorite is the folks who hump the wall /collision objects
and you can't get htem out of the orbs
because some numbnuts hits them and hten the DK can't get LOS
warriors tank use laser matrix or archive of the titans?
Archive
archive, see above image @47.79% haste
thats literally me just zoning
well I guess thats RA
but ARchive is armor, laser is garbage
which traits are recommended for mythic plus?
BFIx2 or BFI and IF + DC
but it comes down to personal preference
You can also mix up archive in there if you want
basically 1DC then BFI /IF are your next best 2
the DC trait is getting a sizeable nerf (more or less decoupling it from scaling like crazy with UF)
so it will be much more in line with the other traits defensively
offensively it'll probably remain our #1
Sometimes...when Im alone at night....I unequip my DC piece, wear 3x BFI, and smack the dummy....
Iβm sorry. sobs in shame
@uneven mason for vectis i'm a big fan of my co-tank starting the boss and taking one stack, then i taunt and take 2, and we keep swapping when he has 1 and i have 2. he picks up all adds with that rhythm and i take the boss out of the raid when he's about to transition
I have a question with regards to how archive of the titans works.. so it goes for your highest secondary stat and enhances it (ideally haste).. but this is where Iβm confused .. and I have noticed this in uldir .. Iβm sitting at 20% crit and 15% haste (without having people near me so no Into the Fray buff).. which means my crit is enhanced instead of haste.. but when Iβm around 2 or more people it means my haste becomes my second highest stat, which then gets boosted by archive of the Titans .. now if Iβm in a situation where I donβt have anyone else near me while Iβm tanking the boss, am I really benefiting from archive of the Titans? Since my haste will go less than my crit and my crit will be boosted instead ?
and sometimes i can grab an omega vector during intermission and cancel a lingering infection stack w/ spell reflect
i thought archive was based off the number, rather than the %. i don't actually know tho
i'm super mastery heavy so i don't get haste out of it anyway π
Well the higher number = higher percentage so it doesnβt really matter about the units I think
You mean reorigination array?
Into the Fray is a multiplicative Haste increase, it's not always 15% Haste.
Array also takes temporary increases into account, so for instance if you have 800 Haste and 750 Vers, and you have a Vers proc trinket that gives you 100 Vers, Array will swap to Vers when the trinket procs.
And then swap back to Haste after.
If only leech would be the highest stat Kappa
I'd rather have vers
when RA hits vers its pretty massive
quite noticeable in raw damage reduction
self healing is for tanks that take damage
@dusk locust I'll bring that up, since yeah tanking the add @2 stacks is pretty butt puckering
the flow is super nice that way
when im tanking boss + add i usually just throw up LS, demo and aks for a bark
i have an audio countdown warning me when the boss is about to transition and i just move out of the raid
I need todo that
Ya my countdown is in German so that it's super obvious
hah
man after a couple raid nights on m zul with a great deal of trouble (1 or 2 rogues), 4 of us went ham on rogue alts, including me. expecting to walk into zul tonight with 6 rogues
this should be interesting
its horrible that that fight is tuned so horribly that you're required to stack an insane amount of cheese for it
we had to do it with 4 rogues last night, still made the push alright
imo the fight is appropriately difficult if you don't have the rogues
and too easy with
ify our raid's ilvl is high enough you'll be fine
the push before second set of hexers?
we were barely beating 3rd crusher with 2 rogues
largely because we have no hunters so we had to grip 1 hexer in and dps it
RIP
yeah. we were trying with hex and polymorph but the add hops around a ton
and sometimes heals anyway
gripping 1 hexer in gave us the space that it made it ok
Hey I was looking at the patch notes for warrior, what is actually changing for prot doesn't make much sense to me all I say was a list of most of our skills and we are losing our mastery but I didn't see a replacement
dats some old notes you're looking at
yeah man, our new mastery just directly adds our rating # to your raider.io score. Mastery is now the best stat.
man, this is some good ass coffee
What coffee?
you need to calm down blade
Naw man, I'm riding on high. Decided to say fuck it and bomb my AD +10. Went full YOLO and brought 2 Frost DKs and a Boomie. Ran down Totem Alley first, needless to say we were rolling DEEP.
Reading yet another HURR WARRIOR IS UNVIABLE BLIZZ BUFF!!1 thread from wow forums and the OP runs Indomitable instead of Bolster :/
between Chuck, Larry, and the Tree Amigos, we were straight squadding up
I couldn't find it
but from the 10 seconds I spent on there...boy did that look gross
Hard pass lol
Unless it's to support a thread by a prot that knows what they're doing
or believin'
Honest question, why stack haste past the point where we donβt have downtime on CDs / AM?
Thatβs for just straight SB
Thats AM
We can have 100% effective uptime once you include bolster + CDs
Especially with pauses / taunt swaps
This may sound like a noob question but should I prevent stacking demoralizing shout with any other cds especially shield block?
As a rule of thumb I stay away from stacking cds unless Iβm having an βoh crapβ moment
But was curious about this one
Hello, what's the best race for prot warrior horde-wise?
not really, rarely would you use DS as strictly defensive, SB isn't considered a CD either
@neon tangle for various reasons, faster gcd, lower CDs, more rage, less damage intake because more ability to use IP, more damage output etc.
And haste continues to be your best stat if theorycrafting is to believed even if youβre at a point where you realistically donβt have gaps
Just theory wise, Iβm curious why I wouldnβt want more critical blocks or Crits/parries
Relative to lowering CDs that Iβm already using rotationally, and will have up
Feels like lowering that CD further, feeding AM further is βwastedβ
AM is your god
Parry/crit blocking is unreliable
you must appease it
unless you literally never use your CDs, AM is never wasted
that includes avatar and demo shout
@stone crag hear me out here, if Iβm using my CDs rotationally (defensive ones) to fill in gaps in my active mitigation
If they come off 5, 10, 30 seconds early it largely doesnβt matter because Iβm going to be delaying it
To fill in those gaps
In those cases it is certainly βwastedβ defense-wise, right?
if our cds were only defensive, maybe
well you shouldnt be delaying stuff like DS or LS in some cases
if you plan out your CD usage, with AM you can reach really high uptime on blocks
For this particular argument Iβm only talking defensively, lowering avatar is valid
Demo and Avatar should be used as often as possible really, because they feed into your AM with rage gains.
Right, my whole argument here is that there is an effective βcapβ on how much AM will provide you defensively
sure, but how will you reach that cap without AM
We need AM to get there, Iβm not sure how much value haste has once we hit that point though
but getting that amount of haste isnt practical
well our secondaries are all close enough that it doesnt matter too much
Since most of the βwhy haste is goodβ reasons boil down to βhelps get to 100% effective uptime on mitigationβ
well its also good for damage
nor the same length, so even if you somehow get LS to be up 100% of the time and it comes off cd early even, you're still contributing to Shield Wall, for instance
SS, TC cds are both reduced by haste
something like crit isnt terrible defensively, especially in a m+ setting where most of the damage you take is from auto's
but haste will help against boss mechanics
and its also pretty okay vs magic
in a raid setting, parriable damage sources are rarely lethal
inc Mac's parry image....
Just to make sure, does anyone know why you would want to lower CDs below the 100% effective uptime mitigation threshold?
you wouldnt, but haste past that threshold feeds into more IP uptime and more dps
even if you're covered defensively, there is still offensive gains
also the further passed 100% effective uptime gives you more room to make mistakes or pressure more dps
This is why i donβt understand why you wouldnβt want crit or mastery instead , both of which do provide more damage reduction
My whole theory: we have a haste cap lol
not for magic.
Or vers?
i mean you are going to be picking up a decent spread of stats gearing normally anyway
and if you have reached 100% effective AM uptime, getting a marginal increase to blocks/parries isnt going to be noticeable or required
oh jesus sco legit said on stream that getting ip off gcd is great because it allows more casts on devastate
not wrong
but devastate is so weak
^^
And to expand a little on what I said earlier, if haste is our top stat, but thereβs a point where it becomes... less useful
sounds of Prot warriors across the world slamming Devastate over TClap during Avatar
Seems like it would stop being our top stat
@neon tangle thats the case with almost every stat for every class. very rarely to do stats have increasing returns or scale perfectly linearly
if you could reach that point then you'd focus on something else
those are called caps, it's still the best stat until you reach that point
If it was guaranteed reset on shield slam sure it would be much better
so what's the opinion on the mythrax trinket?
i feel like you're completely misunderstanding how stats works
oh my lawd
@stone crag donβt we all hit 100% effective uptime on mitigation tho?
100% reset
Hnnnng
slam > dev >slam > dev
BFI would be so tasty
i'm almost positive, no
Forever 2 stack up time
that woudl be hilarious
12-14k crits on SS
way more than that
The 4th dps as prot warrior would be a real meme
Yeah but keladan the amount of times i use devastate instead of tc or revenge is abysmal
Hnnnnnnnng
you could stack BFI realllll high
partially because you would fill those empty gcds with IP @oblique garnet
9 second window every other gcd...
2 stacks as in, 2 stacks of the trait or the buff
2 stacks of trait
Not buff
Because there are moments where my crit won't insta kill an explosive
so your unstacked slams?
im at 371 and I was slapping shit last night and I was seeing 15ish
@stone crag I mean, with breaks / taunt swaps / etc I know I can tank everything in Uldir without having mitigation drop
Maybe I gotta recheck, but very rarely did I get very high crits
that's incredibly fight dependent though, thus being unreliable... there's no patchwerk style fight were you can just generalize
Ahh, that might be it.
even then i'm almost certain you can;'t reach 100% effective uptime
I get really greedy and use last stand
with zero gaps
@neon tangle you will get more uptime on avatar and demo anyways
Which are used on cd pretty much
haste isn't just about SB uptime either, there's many other uses
Having AM fueling those two is enough to make haste the better stat without cap
usually once you hit a defensive cap, you start going for the best dps option
which is still haste
Would be nice if we could sim our dps
What defensive benefit does avatar have?
givves armor
20 rage
Gives 20 rage on use
Avatar gives no armor
rage gen primarily
right now just the rage, but it will be able to auto give ip in 8.1
Avatar grants 20 rage and lowers CD on TC so we get more rage and DC uptime indirectly
^
With DC I can 100% get haste
yes
"with DC I can 100% get haste" makes absolutely no sense. Please clarify @neon tangle
with dc i can 100% understand importance of haste
Oooooh. Yes. That makes sense.
Kelade is smart
:bigbrain:
Thank you for the translation
:2000iq:
What keladan said
:2000iq:
:wesmart:
Defensive benefit of Avatar? - Pumps your RPS to new heights, speeding up your CDs through AM, extends DS, we need moar? @neon tangle
Wow I missed all the fun haste talk
Is Darkmoon Deck Blockades still a good trinket? Have 375 Lingering Sporepods and Xalzaix already
Noticed blockades going for 2k gold. Is it worth just picking up?
stay tuned puts finger up in air I think we're probably about due for a "Will Prot still suck in 8.1?" debate coming on....
Is it worth going from a 360 chest to a 375 chest even though it would mean losing deafening crash trait?
woof
Why not just roll DK
no deathray
sew that shit to your chest slot
i figured as much, oh well
come next patch, you'll get a bit more of a back-and-forth on it
but for now, get used to that shit
blockades is a good defensive trinket, and great value for its price
on the plus side i got a 375 helm today/last night that has same traits as 360 one
atm DC is worth about 45 ilvls
yeah, it's pretty insane, with heroism you can keep demo up 100%
Ty for the answers. Followup question would be if blockades is better than sporepods at 375. Don't think I value the max hp from blockades, just overall sustain vs raidbosses
it is
sporepods is trash
the healing isnt good, overheals a lot, or comes in when you dont need it, and the dmg from it is nearly an auto attack
@sand egret maybe that should be a topic for a new video for me
make sure you @ your number 1 fan
@latent widget Blockades is overbudgeted, its effect on moment to moment EHP puts it quite a bit higher than other "defensive" trinkets, because to a one they're either under budget (bandages) or RNG, Blockades has one thing going for it, RELIABILITY It provides a benefit 100% of the time when in combat, and that counts for a shitload.
I'll try it out, thanks for the insight!
... Oh yay....
IP on the ptr has its own CD to avoid double clicking/tapping it
I mean, there are very few situations where you'll be generating rage and taking damage quickly enough to need to cast IP more than once every second
doesnt it overcap anyways if you get 2 off?
Yeah, the IP cap is 1.3
yeah so youre wasting alot if you just double tap it so the 1 sec cd is basically nothing
unless you're literally taking so much damage that you lose 70% of IP in .5 seconds
You'd need to be taking a lot of damage to avoid wasting rage
helps more than it hurts, imho
Thanks @prisma crane and all else whom have provided me with Prot Warrior tips you have helped me a lot now am playing the class smoothly π
ye exactly blade
π’ π΅ π
@sick sentinel glad the community was able to help π
woo!
Should I bug people to see if I could get my video pinned :kappa
Piss off all the people who are just in here to alt a prot tank and play another tank spec
xD
ooh video?!
I mean itβs not new just my video guide lul
Itβs more of a joke comment than anything
im pretty sure we don't want an "official" endorsement of people who play Pandas
@chilly brook How are the comments on that video going?
Itβs a good thing Iβm not a panda anymore
@neon tangle I mean mostly good outside of a few dummies
Finally broke through to that dude that SB>IP
Quick maffs helps
How far are you guys in mythic now?
Not a panda? More food for me omnomnom
Switched the other day to a glitter boi (blood elf)
@neon tangle my current guild is 6/8 but Iβm not actively raiding
waiting for 8.1?
wow, didn't even go Nightborne
Well they have me as a fury warrior rn, and with the last few prog nights they didnβt want any extra cleave on Zul and mythrax was melee Light for a reason
Applied to another 6/8M guild though that wants a tank so weβll see how that goes
@sand egret you right I shoulda been a nightborne female warrior
Cuz the male animations are cheeks for that race and night elves
im going nightborne female
Iβm trying to remember what the sword and shield animations look like for nightborne females
a bit more upright
fireblooood
but think of the phat aoe dps increase Ill get with my sweet 3 min cooldown arcane explosion?1
Very useful
But heritage armor and purge π
And thereβs something to be said about having all gear look good on you lul
Post 8.1 it wonβt matter though Iβll be a trolly boi
them small heads
I donβt see the small head thing
if you don't use the default ui portraits prob
Same head size as a regular troll
Just see the neck more
Cuz they stand up straight
mmmhmm yeah not seeing that
You can see that their head/neck are basically the same with the darkspear ghost stand up image
Tfw you donβt even use portraits
hence why I said that
I guess thatβs kinda a lie
You can see the animated character model on my HP bars
But low opacity
yeah portrait =/= animated model
in terms of framing
animated models on those UIs will show helm eyeglow effects, portraits don't, for instance
So I asked earlier and people said I was looking at an old list, can someone link the new 8.1 patch notes?

just check the pins
"literally"..."basically" π hek hek hek
Wadu
Second π but thank you, gonna miss the long DS and super high DPS
