#protection

1 messages · Page 2204 of 1

clever swift
#

Or rather you’re under the person tanking it

sharp oriole
#

Do you have any good shield which is similar to mage tower appearence?

clever swift
#

It should show how far you are from pulling

opaque harness
#

what is the difference between gray and red?

lusty grotto
#

meh i use Elvui

#

😄

#

don't even know if nameplate colors are the same

dusk locust
#

i think gray is "an opposing faction tagged this"

#

or whoever else tagged it and so it's not available to you

lusty grotto
#

yeah gray means you won't get credit for the kill

#

in elvui at least

dusk locust
#

yeah

#

that's the only other possibility it might be i think

lusty grotto
#

it also turns gray if the max number of players on your own faction tag it

#

so you still won't get credit/loot

#

blue is usually a friendly unit

#

pets / other players etc

oblique garnet
#

FeelsBadMan the guild im trialing for will rather take undergeared blood dk than use prot warrior with gear for zekvoz

frosty wedge
#

:/

#

I mean... AMS does laugh at zek

#

but so does SR+IP

oblique garnet
#

Yeah but the tank is dying : (

vocal nimbus
#

I felt like the most dangerous part of zekvoz are the aas 🤔

earnest zinc
#

Those are what you call meta monkeys

azure perch
#

Prot warriors doesn't take damage on Zek'voz

#

Be it the combo or the melee swings

earnest zinc
#

Still, both DK and Warrior can make that combo a joke (esp Warrior)

oblique garnet
#

Yeah and im 378

#

Where as the dk is 360

junior ivy
#

im scared of zek tonightttt

dusk locust
#

you're gonna be fine

earnest zinc
#

SR reflects it right?

dusk locust
#

it mitigates the lash

#

doesn't hurt the boss

azure perch
#

You can block the physical one, and SR the magical one

earnest zinc
#

Also it's nice to have demo up for that if you can

azure perch
#

^

#

And you might aswell rotate last stand and shield wall, as there are like no other point to use them at

dusk locust
#

i generally focus on having last stand up for the whole thing, and try to save enough rage to ignore pain 2 or 3 of the hits

#

and SR the last lash

#

avatar actually lines itself perfectly that it's available again right when the adds spawn

earnest zinc
#

Then again monk can also make it a joke

digital arrow
#

can one last stand block two terrible trashes? anybody know?

dusk locust
#

from fetid?

digital arrow
#

yeah

dusk locust
#

yeah it's up for lots of them in a row

#

6 seconds per thrash

digital arrow
#

ohhh

#

thanks

dusk locust
#

and last stand lasts however long i forget

#

lol

#

but it's longer than 6

digital arrow
#

i think its like 14

#

everytime i off tank fetid i just save cd for each thrash but never noticed if i had blocked more than one during bolster lol

dusk locust
#

ya you do

digital arrow
#

oh its 15 seconds whoops

dusk locust
#

shield block is 6 seconds and so is the thrash, so 1 block 1 thrash

#

you can get 3 thrashes then with last stand

earnest zinc
#

You also want to make sure you keep up demo for thrash on enrage

#

Use Shield Wall for gaps in that situation

digital arrow
#

alrighty

earnest zinc
#

You should have Avatar ready for that to keep it up constantly

#

Though go with the boss if it jumps to keep TCing it

#

Make sure to go with it back to the MT though

digital arrow
#

thanks

earnest zinc
#

I'm not sure about the timing on his jumps since I use a braindead monk for it

#

Though I would try to avoid using Last Stand when he's about to jump

digital arrow
#

i'll keep an eye out, maybe dbm might have a timer on it

earnest zinc
#

It probably does

#

What difficulty are you doing it on?

digital arrow
#

heroic

earnest zinc
#

You should be fine if your shield is decent (340+ min)

#

The higher the better

#

Also I think you might be able to use shield block to block 2, but I don't remember for sure

#

If you can, you need to use it right before the first

digital arrow
#

yeah i wanna try that but it's risky. maybe if i shield wall before i try it, healers wont have a heart attack

sand egret
#

:evil-kermit: do it anyway.....

digital arrow
#

lmao

scenic bolt
#

How people feel about the proposed changes positive?

sick sentinel
#

It's a start but more changes are needed

old night
#

@digital arrow use BigWigs. I can't stand DBM and became a much better and in tuned raider when I switched

#

but could just be me

sand egret
#

when I used addons i remember liking BWigs over DBM

junior ivy
#

i prefer dbm 😦

#

unless i can figure out how to make big wigs tell me when to taunt

dusk locust
#

imo it's better not to have it tell you when to taunt, because strats might be different

junior ivy
#

big wigs tells me how many stacks i have but not when to taunt

sand egret
#

I need to break out my old WA videos, I had a tank swap one where you could assign X stacks of a debuff and it'd shoot off a "MOVE BITCH GET OUT THE WAY" audio clip to you so you'd know when you're about to lose the boss

junior ivy
#

soem bosses you taunt at 2 stacks, some 1, some 3, some 5...

#

i cant memorize how many stacks to taunt at for each boss

dusk locust
#

then write it down! 😛

junior ivy
#

actually lemme see if i can memorize

digital arrow
#

@old night i'll give big wigs a try tonight.. does it also have the voiceline "Run away little girl.... run away..."

junior ivy
#

taloc, taunt at first enlarged heart. mother, never taunt. zek, taunt at 2 stacks.

digital arrow
#

?

junior ivy
#

vectis.. i forget how many

#

fetid, never taunt

#

zul, taunt at 2 or whenever i can

#

mythrax taunt at every thingy

#

ghuun, taunt when other tank gets thing to take out

#

so the only one i forget is vectis

sand egret
#

it should pocky, BW literally had everything DBM did including an option to "fake DBM" haha

grim prism
#

Sup nerds

junior ivy
#

wait, vectis is tuant at 2...

grim prism
#

Spicy shit inc

junior ivy
#

zek is taunt at shatter

digital arrow
#

the taunt now alert from dbm is never when my own group wants me to taunt

#

it varies

grim prism
#

Did they really take IP off GCD on PTR

dusk locust
#

vectis is one that i bet changes based on strat. we do it so i taunt off the other tank when he has 1 stack, and he taunts off me when i have 2

digital arrow
#

zek, i taunt after shatter... dbm yells taunt after the void lash

grim prism
#

inb4

PTR

digital arrow
#

im like TOO SLOW DBM

#

then i stopped paying attention to it

astral crystal
#

they did, ballsack

digital arrow
#

co-tank and rl just tell me when they want to do tank swaps

junior ivy
#

also i like dbm casue one day i was super frustrated over hounds in antorus. and i went into dbm discord and complained about how dbm doesnt have an audible countdown for the maws

#

and the dbm developer guy was like

#

il ladd it for you

#

and sure enough like a week later he msged me to say it was added

digital arrow
#

damn i forgot the dbm guy is really dedicated

junior ivy
#

yeah hes very helpful and nice

south yarrow
#

@junior ivy you actually tank swap taloc?

#

wot

junior ivy
#

yeah

#

at enlarged heart

#

when other tank gets it

#

unless my cotank is a pally

#

then he tanks entire time

#

but when i tank with my normal dk cotank, we taunt swap at enlarged heart

#

on heroic we dont swap ever

dusk locust
#

we swap taloc on mythic too, though it isn't strictly necessary

south yarrow
#

Oh we never swap him, hadn't even crossed my mind tbh

astral crystal
#

you dont have to swap at enlarged heart

junior ivy
#

yeh ive done it before without taunting

astral crystal
#

just sit on the mt and help him soak

junior ivy
#

but usually we do

south yarrow
#

Like if dps can survive soaking enlarged heart, you can as well even while still tanking boss

junior ivy
#

taloc is so much more stressful on mythic than both mother and zekvoz tbh

dusk locust
#

lol i feel the same. elevator is so dangerous

junior ivy
#

YES

#

last phase is stressful too

dusk locust
#

it's just the elevator for me

junior ivy
#

mother is my favourite fight of the raid i think.

#

but i also kinda like zul

digital arrow
#

anybody remember the title of that one writeup with the brewmaster log that was playing poorly but still had a clean kill on heroic fetid? i think it was

solid mist
#

"the fetid log"

#

or something like that

digital arrow
#

thanks

#

this is it

junior ivy
#

what does clean kill mean

dusk locust
#

probably just that there were no sudden deaths or other unexpected shenanigans. boss died without much trouble

junior ivy
#

why is it acting like heroic fetid is so hard

#

or did this maybe happen a while ago

astral crystal
#

clean kill ie tank didn't die even though he was literally drooling on his keyboard

digital arrow
#

unexpected shenanigans is my favorite

dusk locust
#

it was hard for this particular player

#

so they were looking his log over

#

and they discovered that even though he was playing totally wrong, it's hard to tell the diff b/t him and an excellent player

prisma crane
#

Cat, it'd be like you doing heroic fetid a month ago without using SB once

digital arrow
#

"bring the player not the class" -blizzard

#

maybe that was their trial with warrior

junior ivy
#

i think it was heroic zul where i used SB only 6 times or something

#

lol

prisma crane
#

Yea but he barely melees

open bluff
#

until you have a brm afk fetid and it's literally bring the class vel

digital arrow
#

resident BDK sleeper lmao

#

@signal plover

signal plover
#

Ayyyy

digital arrow
#

still thinkin about that one

sand egret
#

pfff

#

Day 7. Finally learned what this "shield" thing is. Surprisingly, they aren't typically made of bones.

digital arrow
#

LOL

dull pilot
#

need advice

#

should i use the new trinket

digital arrow
#

huh, it seems you need to raise this shield thing up for it to be useful.. and here i thought all shields magically floated in circles around me

waxen cradle
#

Granted I can just look at the pins and go to the trinket list but as for trinkets you can reliably get at a decent chance how does the crit on use trinket from Doom Howl rate for Prot ?

#

as a dps trinket obviously

#

I mainly ask because I do not have it and have not tried it out

sand egret
#

@dull pilot as far as I'vve heard, that tenticle sucks

waxen cradle
#

@dull pilot I still use Blockades as its still for now one of the best pure survivability trinkets for Prot warriors. Also the haste from Rezans is just too good to pass up for me to be honest

sand egret
#

@waxen cradle for Doom's Howl, there's been a some good positive feedback from others around here about it being useful burst of crit

#

err parry

#

specifically noting it as a boon for stuff like parrying off Necrotic

#

howevver, RNG mitigation is still RNG

waxen cradle
#

@sand egret nice yeah I have not gotten it to try it out and considered trying to get it and see how it was for dps/burst

frosty wedge
#

the fetid thing was that the ONLY difference between a BrM with 23% ISB uptime vs a BrM with 895 uptime was that the former's damage intake was a tad spikier

#

89%*

#

basically there's no punishment for not knowing how to Monk

sand egret
#

yeah that's the TLDR of The Fetid Log as far as I recall

#

really bad guy pulled off clean kills despite being bad and after inspection, turns out the performance gap between bad and good was a) not really noticed and b) specifically shifted to the healers instead of the tank

solid mist
#

yeah

#

very little to no feedback to the tank

sinful bay
#

quick question: stand as one or reinforced plating ? Unfortunately I don't have anything else (gearing up my warrior)

frosty wedge
sand egret
#

doesn't really matter @sinful bay (not super helpful). take the higher ilvl

frosty wedge
#

Top one is 23% uptime, bottom is 88%

waxen cradle
#

@sinful bay reinforced plating

solid mist
#

I saw something similar the other night, playing an alt, my buddy on his resto. hop in a random M+ with a BrM. he's on voice with me just shooting the shit and is like "dear lord, this dude is getting crushed, I'm having a hard time healing him I thought BrM was supposed to be easy to heal?" and I"m like "yeah I'm watching party frames. He's not using ISB that much, have fun buddy!"

sinful bay
#

thanks

waxen cradle
#

@sinful bay as Bladesong said its really based off item level with those traits neither are great

sand egret
#

yeah, the lack of feedback is actually the bigger take-away imho

frosty wedge
#

honestly don't understand HOW people don't have ISB up like 100% of the time

sand egret
#

as its a product of Stagger as a mechanic

#

well Mike, at lot of it is mental hierarchy

signal plover
#

Also over purifying

sand egret
#

if you don't feel the need to hit it

frosty wedge
#

yeah the top guy purified like 4x the bottom

sand egret
#

then it simply isn't up there. Take a look at Prot, SB is our lifeblood

frosty wedge
#

oh I know - just like... what are you pushing if you're not keeping ISB up? lol

sand egret
#

I'm a fuckin crack-head looking for a fix when I don't have that buff up

digital arrow
#

lol well put

sand egret
#

"Yo man....anyone got a Shield Block"

digital arrow
#

scratches arm

sand egret
#

"I'll suck yo dick for a cooldown"

frosty wedge
#

they need to make like, the base level of stagger 205 instead of 50+

#

20% *

sand egret
#

doesn't solve the feedback prob imho

digital arrow
#

"cmon man just need one more second of some SB"

frosty wedge
#

then you'll get fucked without ISB up

#

and people will learn to hit the button

solid mist
#

will they though?

sand egret
#

I think ISB should extend the length of stagger

frosty wedge
#

and you'll be able to tell if your monk is afk

solid mist
#

will they?

waxen cradle
#

scratches neck and quotes Dave Chapel anyone got some crack

sand egret
#

so not using it means the tick rate is way more frequent, which gives urgency

solid mist
#

prot war has some pretty profound feedback right? still people not hitting SB apparently

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

frosty wedge
#

yeah, but you can tell when a prot warr isn't hitting SB

sand egret
#

eh, for some the "Release" button aint enough

frosty wedge
#

because they're dead

sand egret
#

then again, not everyone is prone to go "HMM HOW DID I MESS UP?"

frosty wedge
#

if monks took 60% more damage to the face without ISB people would stop taking bad monks

waxen cradle
#

For me if your dead that is a good sign shield block was not used

solid mist
#

"healer didn't heal me good enough"

sand egret
#

very easy to find any excuse

#

"oh that extra add did it!"

solid mist
#

"ugh we have a resto shaman in the group, that's the problem. I read they are garbo"

sand egret
#

^

waxen cradle
#

Or my favorite yeah... Warriors are just bad right now... I mean Sco said so

solid mist
#

Still needs to be feedback, but I think a lot of people are still gonna faceroll and just go "UGH C'MON HEALERS"

worthy karma
#

Woop woop tiny changes that combind with DC being nerfed are actualy probably a nerf

frosty wedge
#

yep

#

the stuff currently on PTR is probably a net nerf

#

and doesn't at all address our lack of utility

supple path
#

It's not a net nerf, but agreed on utility.

worthy karma
#

Or ravager or our other useless talents

sand egret
#

I just think if Stagger was a shorter duration without ISB the monk, healerless, feels the full force of the ability sooner. Thus it adds to their urgency. ISB extends the period which also extends the cushion healers feel

frosty wedge
#

I dunno - nerfing DC into the floor hurts our survivability a shit ton

supple path
#

Sure, but gaining passive hp, passive armor, and most importantly the -cd on shield block counters it and then a bit more, from the math thus far.

worthy karma
#

Demo still om gcd, IP still on gcd, No taunt sprint, no aoe taunt

#

Charge still on gcd

frosty wedge
#

IP is off GCD

supple path
#

Even before getting into the harder to quantify gains from IP off GCD and blocking projectiles.

worthy karma
#

It has its own 0.5 which is still bs

supple path
#

try it out on PTR

waxen cradle
#

I do not feel it is really a nerf.. I mean a nerf to DCrash of course, but once again our armor is going up, our health is going up, we are getting better uptime on shield block and then add in the yet undocumented ability to block ranged melee attacks it does not feel like a nerf to me

frosty wedge
#

... that's to stop you from spamming it

supple path
#

it's a self-ICD - only applies to ignore pain.

solid mist
#

that's... to prevent you from double tapping

supple path
#

it's not like the charge 0.5

solid mist
#

that's a safeguard

waxen cradle
#

OH and yeah IP off the GCD

signal plover
#

IP off GCD, more passive mitigation, SB CD reduced and ur saying net nerfs wot lol?

frosty wedge
#

it's a safety so you don't accidentally blow IP twice

sand egret
#

latency protection, really

worthy karma
#

Whoa whats this about ranged attacks?

thorn yarrow
#

I mean it feels more of a nerf because of the downtime on Demo shout

waxen cradle
#

Maybe not huge but will make the spec play and feel better as we do not lose a ability we would rather use from a GCD spent on IP

heady citrus
#

dc needed a nerf. having azerite trait worth 45+ ilvl was rediculous for balance

thorn yarrow
#

but ya we did get buffed

frosty wedge
#

6 second max extension of DS from DC hurts a lot

supple path
#

Undocumented PTR change, can block ranged attacks now

sand egret
#

@worthy karma we can block Rocks

signal plover
#

Ranged physical*

thorn yarrow
#

@heady citrus dont talk about balance when DKs literally blow everyone out the water

frosty wedge
#

that's 20% dmg reduction and 10% dps boost

thorn yarrow
#

balance isnt an argument

heady citrus
#

dks got nerfs to there redic big pack pulling

supple path
#

Oh hush, just because one thing is OP doesn't mean give up on all balance everywhere

#

it was a dumb trait that forced us to use ilvl 340 gear over 385 - that's not balanced

sand egret
#

saying you can nerf one thing because something else is strong is the opposite of how you balance

#

can't*

thorn yarrow
#

Im not saying that at all

sand egret
#

yikes

#

sure you did

#

can't nerf DC because BDKs are strong?

heady citrus
#

i dont think warrior was ever in bad place other then how fluid spec plays.

thorn yarrow
#

but if "balance" is ur argument thats pretty weak considering how the top tier tanks vs low tier tanks are balanced or handled

supple path
#

Now whether or not our end power result ends up at the appropriate spot...harder to say, but DC needed a nerf on its own merits regardless of our actual power level.

worthy karma
#

I agree DC needed to be nerfed. But we need extra buffs to make up the diff

thorn yarrow
#

@sand egret not even close dont put words in my mouth

earnest zinc
#

Warrior is not in a good place

sand egret
#

"@ Xastin dont talk about balance when DKs literally blow everyone out the water"

#

pretty sure you said that

waxen cradle
#

honestly if I am being 100% honest passing up 40 item level upgrades for certain slots because DCrash is that much better than any other trait feels 100 times worse then a truthfully justified nerf

earnest zinc
#

We require much more skill for no extra benefit at all

heady citrus
#

thats fine

frosty wedge
#

meh the BDK nerf isn't that bad - bonestorm has a cap

thorn yarrow
#

@sand egret I said that in the implication if u wanna argue the reason DC was nerfed is balance then dont ignore the entire top tier tanks

frosty wedge
#

but they get more AOE DPS now

charred void
#

Get good or play something else

thorn yarrow
#

if u cant see that not my fault

heady citrus
#

do you really want to be 1 button tank?

frosty wedge
#

when standing in D&D they hit 3 additional targets with heart strike

signal plover
#

Time to close prot warr discord for a bit.

sand egret
#

but that's what i'm saying

thorn yarrow
#

DC needed a nerf thats fine but the other shit doesnt make up for it

earnest zinc
#

Actually, that is sugarcoating because we are actually weaker than other tanks when at max skill level

sand egret
#

DC getting nerfed doesn't have anything to do with BDKs being strong

thorn yarrow
#

so ur changing the argument

sand egret
#

conflating the two is the issue

thorn yarrow
#

nice

sand egret
#

no, that's exactly what i'vev been saying

supple path
#

I mean...mathematically, the stuff Marok and whatnot have typed up so far show it strictly does make up for it.

sand egret
#

bringing in BDKs when we're talking about DC is the issue

signal plover
#

We're also not "weaker"

charred void
#

BLADESONG VS KECKLEONKING ROUND 2 FIGHT

thorn yarrow
#

no I was bringing up the argument of saying "balance"

earnest zinc
#

Maybe not the worst, but weaker enough to be considered obsolete to Brew and BDK

thorn yarrow
#

u changed the goal post

supple path
#

You were trying to deflect to a different balance question in order to justify saying balance should never be used to justify a nerf.

signal plover
#

Obsolete wot?

supple path
#

Trying to pretend he's changing the goal post now is just eyeroll.

sand egret
#

basically

thorn yarrow
#

nah

waxen cradle
#

@signal plover people are beyond clueless if they think a 15% increase to SB uptime, more armor, more stam, IP off the GCD and the ability to block ranged attacks is not worth a small nerf to a trait that made us pass up 40 or so item level upgrades

signal plover
#

Right

heady citrus
#

im 100% excited by ptr changes

signal plover
#

Maybe ppl just got bored

supple path
#

It's because the nerf is bigger than any of the individual buffs, but there are like 5 distinct buffs

thorn yarrow
#

if you wanna say its balance to reduce our best trait that helps out Mit out more then anything else for the sake of "balance" there shouldnt have ever been a big gap from top tier to bottom tier tanks to begin with or allowing it to last this long without changes

supple path
#

So people get nerf-stickershock

earnest zinc
#

There's no reason to bring a prot warrior to mythic uldir when brew does everything they do but better. Pally is the same way, but they are faceroll enough to get more representation

signal plover
#

U can still extend DS up to 14 secs per cast and AM didn't get touched so the trait is still solid

earnest zinc
#

Also they get a "get out of jail free" card with Divine Protection

supple path
#

Yeah, the trait "only" increases demo's duration by 75% now.

#

When people say it was imbalanced, they're not saying "so it made warriors overpowered" they're saying "it was 4x more powerful than all the other traits"

earnest zinc
#

There needs to be a buff to compensate

signal plover
#

Literally worth like 40 ilvls

#

There ARE buffs to compensate

supple path
#

And balancing around traits like that sets up a shitty dynamic where you NEED the trait to be 'balanced' - so I'd rather they nerf the trait now while they're making other balance adjustments, because they're going to nerf it eventually anyhow

signal plover
#

And they do more than just compensate

earnest zinc
#

Those buffs were more to put us on par without that nerf

zinc mauve
#

Demo shout uptime was nerfed by 20% over a while fight

thorn yarrow
#

then bring up the other traits an make them actually worth using or dont center such a power trait around 2 abilities an make so strong

sand egret
#

How is DC out performing at a massive disparity (~45 ilvls) have anything to do with balance between overall tank in tiers. For one, it's a totally different system. Class balance and trait balance.

#

An ability that is literally uncapped adds a whole lot of headaches for the future, its even worse when you gotta design traits that now have to be >= 45ilvls of power just to compete

supple path
#

Making other traits balanced with one that triples the duration of a CD is uh

#

probably not a great idea going forward

sand egret
#

when ultimately that is the exactly opposite of what they want for the system as a whole

earnest zinc
#

Give Warriors a 10% damage reduction, or you can make the nerfed version baseline and allow the trait to give us infinite increases like right now.

sand egret
#

as been stated

thorn yarrow
#

that would be a valid excuse had all these things not been tested during Beta "headaches" are avoided by the testing done already prior to release

sand egret
#

and here we go again

thorn yarrow
#

it was ignored an allowed to slide

supple path
#

I mean you're not going to find anyone arguing that Blizzard's initial balance in this expansion was good, but that's not relevant to the point.

lusty grotto
#

ptr changes are a net buff according to Marok

waxen cradle
#

How do people not get that nerfing a trait that is currently making us pass up 40 or more item level upgrades in favor it not a big deal when were getting more armor, more stam, IP off the gcd, a increase of 15% uptime to shield block and the ability to block ranged melee attacks not a sky is falling situation in comparison

lusty grotto
#

just responding to someone earlier

earnest zinc
#

It wouldn't be a problem if they actually listened to feedback

#

They don't listen to it

supple path
#

@waxen cradle I also want a pony. And I want paladins to not have one anymore.

earnest zinc
#

Months of this stuff being brought up in the Alpha/Beta and they didn't do jack shit about it

sand egret
#

to be fair, outside of these meta threads, feedback is fucking awful

earnest zinc
#

Now the problems they warned of are happening

waxen cradle
#

Look at what were getting in comparison of a slight nerf to a trait that will still be our best trait

sand egret
#

"Spec is shit"

earnest zinc
#

It's MUCH more than a slight

lusty grotto
#

how do you know people didn't simply have unreasonable demands Garun

earnest zinc
#

The last time they tried removing something, we were CRIPPLED

lusty grotto
#

do you actively give feedback ?

earnest zinc
#

Remember 7.1.5?

#

We were dogshit until ToS

sand egret
#

more important is how feedback is given, tbh

earnest zinc
#

Even in ToS when we were good, we were a shadow of what we were before

thorn yarrow
#

welcome to the knee jerk balancing that is blizzard in every game

#

ever

sand egret
#

pff

#

I like you

earnest zinc
#

Just abandon ship and roll that Brew or BDK

charred void
#

BLADESONG VA KECKLEONKING ROUND 3 FIGHT

zinc mauve
#

ok now i can type

thorn yarrow
#

ROFL

sand egret
#

👢 🍵 👏 .

lusty grotto
#

jesus we get it, you two don't like prot in patch x.xxx, what does that even accomplish here anyway?

sand egret
#

your move.

thorn yarrow
#

got him

#

sand egret
#

can't reflect Bootyclaps boi

thorn yarrow
#

bet

signal plover
#

Garun needs some spaghetti cuz he is upsetti

sand egret
#

is it mom's

waxen cradle
#

@supple path If un nerfed people need to consider where that trait would be a few months into the new raid when a ham fisted nerf was damn sure to come down with the fierceness

signal plover
#

Only mom's

earnest zinc
#

You can't trust Blizz to not make your spec dogshit

lusty grotto
earnest zinc
#

That's why you always have alts ready

supple path
#

@waxen cradle Yeah, Blizzard clearly is interested in balancing azerite traits vs eachother, DC was never going to last - only did this long because they knew prot wars were underpowered/relying on it I bet.

signal plover
#

Or u just clear 8/8M on prot warr

#

And party on

lusty grotto
thorn yarrow
#

@lusty grotto show me how its done ❤

lusty grotto
#

the arrow will show you

thorn yarrow
#

nah I need a play by play like a video

waxen cradle
#

@supple path Uptime for the DCrash DS extension would be ridiculous and people think it was nerfed now... imagine the nerf we would have received when the extension reached near 100 % uptime levels... it would have ended up a spec breaking nerf

lusty grotto
#

that would take more effort than SHIFT+windowskey+S

plain vapor
#

so many salty people today lol

signal plover
#

Check the pins keckle

supple path
#

Oh yeah it was only going to get uglier with haste.

digital arrow
#

LOUD NOISES

plain vapor
#

prot war till the day i die lads

digital arrow
#

high fives krook

sand egret
#

to be fair

thorn yarrow
#

@signal plover already have

sand egret
#

ive died A LOT and i'm still prot, @plain vapor

signal plover
#

Then follow the arrow bb

solid mist
#

right. 20% DR, if people were able to keep that at 100% that fundamentally changes the spec, and then how Blizz woul dhave to design around it.

zinc mauve
#

the whole DC nerf was a necessary evil; overall our current changes on the PTR are an overall buff, allow me to explain
DS uptime for a good prot warrior is between 50-80%, the higher ranges are more difficult to achieve and only achievable in a raid setting from 5 stacks of ITF; Post nerf, the uptime is about 40-50%, falling somewhere in the middle of that range. The nerf mostly hits us during avatar; sincen ormally when you are using demo shout, you arent going to get much more than 6 extra seconds out of it in its current state; with avatar and any haste buff, you can get MUCH more

now lets look at the other changes; first, the undocumented 'Warrior can now block ranged attacks' change is a very solid buff for m+. SB CD changes will be even better as time goes on tahnks to ever increasing haste this expansion with less downtime between block charges

thorn yarrow
#

@signal plover nah need video am war dumb we smash

zinc mauve
#

balancing an entire spec around an azerite trait that is worth 45 ilvls would be too much to trust blizzard with

#

they'd fuck it up inevitably

solid mist
#

either it's a.) a maintenance buff that we keep up at all times... and if so why have it or b.) it's temporary DR that's meant to be used strategically

sand egret
#

ya know, coming off yesterday this channel is a ball of fluff and sunshine. hot dang

waxen cradle
#

One thing people have to realize is with increased haste levels that would come from continual gearing up throughout the expac that the extension DCrash was giving would have gotten such a massive nerf that the irritation you feeling now would be unrecognizable later on when the extension it granted DS reached near 100 uptime

zinc mauve
#

yes it was a necessary evil

thorn yarrow
#

I mean like I said fine with the nerf just they really needed to give us more in return for this

earnest zinc
#

That means we take an average of 6% more damage. 0.2*(0.8-0.5)=0.06

sand egret
#

look at all these hopeful buggers

lusty grotto
#

what in the everliving f..

signal plover
#

:math:

zinc mauve
#

@thorn yarrow the only place we got even slightly nerfed is mdmg heavy encounters

#

otherwise got buff all around, especially in m+

thorn yarrow
#

call me skeptical then because I have seen enough blizzard nerfs to know shit goes wary too fast

waxen cradle
#

AND that nerf that we would have received would have paled in compare to what your seeing now so my advice is set back and chill out because it could have been worse

oblique garnet
#

God damn its hard to find a raiding guild on draenor that takes prot warriors

thorn yarrow
#

even with the "buffs"

earnest zinc
#

It's hard everywhere

#

Prot Warriors are basically blacklisted from mythic progression

#

The only chance you have is to show them logs of you doing great in heroic Uldir

zinc mauve
#

then make your own stack

lusty grotto
#

it's hard to find a raiding guild as a tank generally

#

it always has been

#

raiding guilds usually have 3 tanks tops

earnest zinc
#

It seems a bit easier than usual now though

lusty grotto
#

vs a shitton of dps/heals

thorn yarrow
#

dungeons can never have enough tanks but raids can always have too many

zinc mauve
#

dungeon = 1 tank per group, raid = 2 tanks per raid

#

simple maffs

thorn yarrow
#

WOAH WOAH

#

dont u maff at me

lusty grotto
#

two different things

zinc mauve
#

2+2 is 4 - 1 thats 3 quick maths

lusty grotto
#

doing dungeons vs being in a raid

supple path
#

Well as a general rule if a guild is recruiting a tank something went wrong.

#

So it makes it rough in general.

waxen cradle
#

If you are any kind of Prot Warrior veteran you know that no one us on top forever and should either accept it or pick another class... because you can either and try and be of the people who plays the class very well or be someone who jumps ship.... either way if your progressing Mythic at any level near cutting edge your going to have multiple geared tanks anyway

thorn yarrow
#

we have about 6 people who can tank at any given time

#

I think maybe 2 of them are off specced but eh

lusty grotto
#

but are you recruiting more tanks?

thorn yarrow
#

I mean we never turn them down

#

real life happens

earnest zinc
#

It would be nice to have 10 man back

#

Or design raids around 3 or 4 tanks

waxen cradle
#

hang on a second 2 + 3 does not equal chair ?

lusty grotto
#

i guess you don't turn them down, but I doubt they see much raiding action as tanks

#

so they probably leave

sand egret
#

I'd rather have more Karazan's

lusty grotto
#

or they offspec

zinc mauve
#

my guilds got 3 tanks, but my guild isnt a huge mythic raiding guild

#

we do 10 man raids lmao

#

i only tank, the other two dps occasionally, on and off

thorn yarrow
#

@lusty grotto thats what we aim for really is have people with multiple specs an since most content is on farm getting that gear isnt hard

#

especially with 2-3 active raid groups

#

an m+ runs

waxen cradle
#

@signal plover People are such sheep... heard them to the edge of a cliff and give them a little nudge and off they jump... the sky is falling mentality =.=

sand egret
#

from my experience tanks just can sour fast, as it's often a role of passion (those who choose to tank, usually prefer to tank) but the slots are so limited that playtime as that role is often not optimal

queen owl
#

i saw there are prot warrior additions to simc according to commits

signal plover
#

Just gotta read shit n play well

queen owl
#

are there any sim-backed prot warrior facts yet?

sand egret
#

like i've been offered guild spots as prime dps and i could "tank" but like fuck that shit

lusty grotto
#

sim-backed

#

you do know the simc devs are here right?

thorn yarrow
#

Ive played every expac an dps/heal I enjoyed tanking last expac an this one is no different

lusty grotto
#

so they are making decisions due to this channel's advice

final mist
#

Sims would be used solely for DPS anyways.

queen owl
#

sorry if i rustled your jimmies and used bad english

lusty grotto
#

that's perfectly good english though

sand egret
#

Nim really fucking loves his jimmies

#

so chill on the rustlin

final mist
#

Enough.

queen owl
#

last time i asked, people were like ¯_(ツ)_/¯ and "there are no prot war sim so we dont know"

final mist
#

Sims are still being worked on, and when they're done the only thing they'll be used for is DPS metrics.

native monolith
#

With the current PTR changes on SB and nerf on DS, does Heavy Repercussion a possibility?

oblique garnet
#

No

lusty grotto
#

but... why

twin eagle
#

Definitely a role of passion, I'm not a mythic raider, but I genuinely enjoy the fantasy of standing as the shield going 1 v 1 with the big baddie.

#

Class efficacy be damned.

sand egret
#

for sure, its definitely a more "rpg" oriented playstyle

lusty grotto
#

@native monolith DS was not nerfed, DC was

native monolith
#

But that implicates on a respective nerf on DS Uptime

oblique garnet
#

"all exceptional players may apply" "Except if you play prot warrior then its a hard pass"

lusty grotto
#

with a reduced recharge on SB why would you want to go HR

#

DC is still good

native monolith
#

WIth 8.1 Haste, maybe SB uptime may look a better Mitigation than extras DS

supple path
#

Because HR is a linear increase to SB uptime so having reduced downtime makes it a more valuable % increase in uptime

lusty grotto
#

except SB doesnt mitigate magic and DS does

#

so not really

supple path
#

And the nerf to DS duration makes it less powerful as a CD so anger management is a bit less strong on it - not saying that makes HR the right choice or anything, but it's...less worse now?

signal plover
#

Not to mention losing AM from bolster

hushed cobalt
#

If AM reduced dragon roar cd, me gusta

lusty grotto
#

Nah, as long as our magic mitigation remains reliant on DS, I don't think HR would be considered - unless there's a boss that just trucks physical damage

final mist
#

Why would you lose AM from Bolster?

supple path
#

If you were picking up HR

signal plover
#

Cuz u specced HR

final mist
#

Ah, my bad, read that wrong in context

#

xd

#

Yeah, the downsides to not picking AM are worse than the upsides of picking HR.

#

Extremely so.

queen owl
#

all these acronyms

signal plover
#

Sal leave my Jimmies alone bb

#

NO RUSTLING

queen owl
#

i need to write a notepad to figure out wtf some of these acronyms are

final mist
#

You get a marginal SB uptime in return for losing... everything AM gives us.

signal plover
#

Right

oblique garnet
#

AM = angermanagement HR = heavy repercussions

lusty grotto
#

DS = Demo Shout, HR = Heavy Repercussions, AM = Anger Management, DC = Deafening Crash @queen owl

queen owl
#

i keep thinking headlong rush

#

that'd do it

final mist
#

Yes, we're Combat Rogues now.

signal plover
#

bb = BaBay

lusty grotto
#

😱

signal plover
#

Like ayyy babbay

sand egret
#

👢 🍵 👏 = how warriors say hi around here

lusty grotto
#

ya

#

bootyclappin' everywhere

queen owl
#

foot soup clap?

lusty grotto
#

boot tea clap

queen owl
#

foot soup clap sounds like an STD\

final mist
#

🤔

lusty grotto
#

rofl

#

i can't imagine how disgusting an STD with that name would be

final mist
#

I can't imagine how this relates to Prot either, but here we are.

lusty grotto
#

dang

signal plover
#

Bear with us for a sec

oblique garnet
#

hmm maybe if i join into a promising heroic guild and carry them through hc i could get into mythic progression 🤔

sand egret
#

creating a common language to foster comradery amongst fellow warriors

queen owl
#

how did bears get into this chat

thorn yarrow
#

every step I take should just auto TC for double damage

queen owl
#

is this druid discord now?

lusty grotto
#

(psst you mean paladin)

signal plover
#

No one even remembers bear memes :*(

thorn yarrow
#

unbearable

#

🐻 💨 💩

supple path
#

When warriors feel bad they need to think about bears.

lusty grotto
#

oh you mean the spec that disappeared after Legion?

supple path
#

This'll learn you guys for being overpowered in early TBC.

lusty grotto
#

plsdontban

sand egret
#

I like my Bear 😦

thorn yarrow
#

wait druids are a class still after legion?

#

wut

supple path
#

Yeah, owl tree tanks are really great right now.

thorn yarrow
#

nice

supple path
#

Seriously, m+ with a druid tree'ing on CD is so night and day compared to not having it.

digital arrow
#

i love trees!

sand egret
#

damn hippies

cold owl
#

Omg, I rolled boomkin as an alt for the fun of being the saviour the group begrudgingly needs.

#

I usually run with a priest healer too, so all 4 dispels and huge mitigation through trees with just 1 boomkin

trim sentinel
#

So Icy veins recommends using the STR flask instead of the Stam one, is that because of Vanguard?

zinc mauve
#

its because of IP and for damage

#

ip scales off of attack power

#

so therefore more str = more damage = bigger ignore pain

elder tusk
#

STR increases your mitigation effectiveness so actually helps out with healer mana

zinc mauve
#

plus you do more damage

#

so double whammy

elder tusk
#

plus damage

trim sentinel
#

Oh, that makes better sense, ok, i was curious about that. Thank you!

zinc mauve
#

no problem B)

trim sentinel
#

And im guessing battle pots of STR for the same reason?

lusty grotto
#

right and coastal heal pots since they don't share the cd

steel mauve
#

That and stam flask gives barely any hp

waxen cradle
#

Is a booty clap that warriors do like a super powerful fart that cracks the ground because dude mad respect to that

lusty grotto
#

booty clap is slapping your booty on the ground sir 👢 🍵 👏

waxen cradle
#

But that sounds painful.... I mean I have never tried to do it but it sounds painful so generating rage from it makes even more sense

lusty grotto
#

but our booty is stronk

waxen cradle
#

irl of course

#

true

#

This is true

#

Admittedly Thunderclap sounds like a awful STD to be honest

#

Try explaining that to a gf I have the thunderclap

tiny sphinx
#

i like shortening it to "t-clap"

lusty grotto
#

t clap is why people call it bootyclap actually

#

i was just applying some reasonable explanation

tiny sphinx
#

it used to only hit 4 targets, so it was less contagious then

lusty grotto
#

lol

uneven mason
#

Thunderclap is an STD That is caught by using gympie-gympie as toilet paper

waxen cradle
#

Of course my safety word is pineapple and also what I identify as so hey they might be into the real freaky stuff...

lusty grotto
#

you obviously "make it clap" when you avatar

waxen cradle
#

Thunderclap all over them

sick sentinel
#

Finally got the mythrax trinket, goodbye Darkmoon, hello double tank trinket

digital arrow
#

dont u mean foot soup clap all over them 👢 🍵 👏

regal island
#

cmon 8.1 titangrip for prot

vocal nimbus
#

dual wielding shields

sand egret
#

eyyyy

sick sentinel
#

confused turtle

waxen cradle
#

Shield Storm ?

#

Prot Warrior version of Blade Storm ?

wraith hemlock
#

just wanna be sure but maximun block is 85%, right?

junior ivy
#

one chested waycrest 5 😄

#

on my druid 😄

wraith hemlock
#

block as in blocked damage

waxen cradle
#

@wraith hemlock When crit blocking the maximum amount of damage we can block is 85% yes

ember arrow
#

max block is double your block rating

#

it is 85 now?

#

i had 88 with 7 bastions in legion

waxen cradle
#

@wraith hemlock It is capped at 85% for BFA

wraith hemlock
#

I just remember I read somewhere that even if you have 100% damage blocked you will only go up as high as 85%

#

I mean, my war is at like 50% normal blocks with 2 stacks of BfI

waxen cradle
#

@wraith hemlock The only real benefit to continue to push block rating is to increase the normal amount of blocked damage outside of crit blocks

steel mauve
#

Most mitigations have always been 85%

junior ivy
#

is it weird i prefer healing tyrannical over fortified?

wraith hemlock
#

Just wanted to be sure, I know that pushing it is still good since it ain't like you crit block 100% of the time like we could with the artifact ability

waxen cradle
#

@wraith hemlock Your crit blocks cap at 85% but how much you block when not crit blocking can go up and is never really a bad thing

wraith hemlock
#

Fortified is AIDS... bosses are easy so that's the only time you've to worry about real healing

waxen cradle
#

@wraith hemlock @junior ivy So if your blocking 50% when not crit blocking then awesome but that does not change how much damage you crit block as it will always be 85%

junior ivy
#

what im not even part of this conversation

#

lol

waxen cradle
#

@junior ivy Miss tell to catfriend

junior ivy
#

hahaha

wraith hemlock
#

lmao

#

thanks for ur time @waxen cradle , then I shouldn't worry too much on my traits atm

#

Already capped lmao...

sand egret
#

the benefit is that your less subject to RNG

#

as your baseline blocks are better

waxen cradle
#

@wraith hemlock Yeah capping is not that hard however like I said its never a bad thing to get more block rating because like I said it just means you block more damage when not crit blocking

wraith hemlock
#

oh yeah, I normally hit around the 50-52% cuz double BfI on dungeons and it is really good for not being shitty

junior ivy
#

got a group of 1500 score people willing to hel pme with my atal 13

#

😄

#

im very excited

lusty grotto
#

sometimes i wish i was a girl

#

and that my nickname in discord was catfriend

#

😿

junior ivy
#

😦

#

i dunno if i should be offended by that or not lol

lusty grotto
#

lol

oblique garnet
#

I tried to pug my kr+12 got to the dungeon and our dps said prot warriors dont deserve high keys and left

#

10/10 experience

lusty grotto
#

jesus

digital arrow
#

his loss

gray patrol
#

It's not that bad without fortified

lusty grotto
#

easy affixes this week yeah

oblique garnet
#

But on the bright side i got into a mythic guild as a trial

junior ivy
#

grats !!

#

whats their progress

oblique garnet
#

4/8

junior ivy
#

very nice

gray patrol
#

Grats 😃 Not many people like us

lusty grotto
#

gz

junior ivy
#

this is not something i get told often...

#

lol

#

thats a new thing for me to hear

oblique garnet
#

I got an recommendation from one of their raiders who i apparently did some m+ with xD

cinder nova
#

Bloodsport or matrix?

oblique garnet
#

In which situation?

cinder nova
#

Yes.

lusty grotto
#

careful with matrix

cinder nova
#

I'm not hurting for survival.

#

But if matrix does garbage damage

lusty grotto
#

still pulls shit through walls

cinder nova
#

what's the point

oblique garnet
#

Matrix does whatever matrix wants

lusty grotto
#

matrix does not do garbage damage

#

it does decent

cinder nova
#

Oh cool

lusty grotto
#

but it's a nightmare in M+

cinder nova
#

I'll go matrix then

oblique garnet
#

It can pull every single mob in waycrest before the tree

cinder nova
#

LOL

#

That sounds like a good time on bolster

#

I might do it just to goon my guild mythics

oblique garnet
#

Even the ones on the basement

cinder nova
#

That's fucking gold

oblique garnet
#

Caught me by surprise when the army of fucking witches came to the courtard

cinder nova
#

A+

oblique garnet
#

”Laser matrix is coded to not pull the bug doesnt exist” - blizzard probably

lusty grotto
#

lol

oblique garnet
#

It causes more oh shit moments than does good dps

cinder nova
#

Well

#

I could give a fuck tbh, I'm not doing M+ more than a few times a week

#

Gotta scumbag my zek parse

junior ivy
#

i tanked this fight

amber siren
#

are your dps part snail

junior ivy
#

lmao

neon tangle
#

@junior ivy It's your punishment for playing alliance

signal plover
#

Also gnome

neon tangle
#

@oblique garnet "It was probably lazer matrix" as I watch my ret pally horse across half the zul packs

limber tulip
#

@green isle

green isle
#

yo

#

gamers

limber tulip
#

whats up gamer!

#

imu

green isle
dull wave
#

2 things,

  1. these changes to Prot I’m assuming are really nice. Are we still lacking in something though?
  2. if I want to play devastor instead of BV and just do some mid range keys (7–10s) will I be okay? I just hate the devastate spam playstyle.
lusty grotto
#

youll do a shitload less damage with devastator

#

so i wouldn't recommend it

quartz pond
#

You never actually spam devastate

dull wave
#

Feels like it sometimes.

lusty grotto
#

the extra rage from BV helps AM

#

no reason to use deva

#

no, you're doing something wrong if you're using devastate too much

dull wave
#

I know BV is the best. Just seeing if devastator was a choice I could use. And never said I’m using it all the time lol. Just feels like I’m hitting it a lot outside of procs.

lusty grotto
#

i mean it's your game, you can do anything you want

#

but there's no reason to use devastator over it

#

other than preference in your case

dull wave
#

Clearly. But there are some talents that are just wasted talents and are so beyond broken you shouldn’t use.

prisma crane
#

devastator only shines MARGINALLY at best in ST situations

#

pure ST

#

otherwise, use BV, profit

#

you'll use devastate more once changes hit, but tbh, we barely use it

dull wave
#

I want to know if devastator can still be used and I can still do +10s well enough. Or if it’s just mathematically not there

#

@prisma crane thank you

prisma crane
#

anyone can do 10s with enough effort, but you're gimping yourself not using BV in M+

lusty grotto
#

you'll be doing relatively low damage on aoe

#

damage that helps do keys faster

#

consider that

prisma crane
#

especially since fortified is the new tyrannical

#

trash is much worse in BFA than it was in legion

dull wave
#

Thanks

lusty grotto
#

and once again more rage means faster cds due to AM

dull wave
#

I’m aware of that

lusty grotto
#

which in turn helps your damage output by lowering avatar cd

prisma crane
#

yup, you'll get used to it, no argument that it feels shitty to go back to having to use it, but you'll get used to it

dull wave
#

Kk thanks

prisma crane
#

i hate having to use it, but i like BV more than i hate deva 😉

dull wave
#

I think just with being GCD locked it made it feel bad and like I was just smacking my keys. Maybe with IP changes it won’t feel like that

prisma crane
#

well GCD locked is exactly why we rarely use it in the first place

#

you'll still be GCD locked once IP goes off the GCD

#

you'll just use devastate more

dull wave
#

Kk

prisma crane
#

it feels claustrophobic compared to legion

#

but that's the world we live in.. "yay...."

cinder nova
#

Devastate casts should be pretty low. Like... 3 to 4 a minute.

#

If that.

raven kernel
#

In a m+ you really hardly press devastate

#

Devastate also isn't crucial to us at all and you pretty much only hit it when there's nothing else to press

#

So all youd be doing is just giving yourself empty gcds sometimes

zinc mauve
#

at the very least your GCDs should be nearly filled

#

if you are sitting there for 1 full gcd doing nothing, you are wasting damage and potential rage

#

less rage = less defensives too

raven kernel
#

And anytime you kite the value of devastator plummets

dull wave
#

Okay thanks for the tips. I’ll get back in and rework my playstyle!

raven kernel
#

Don't feel like you're losing out if you don't hit devastate

#

If that's why you feel devastator might be good

junior ivy
#

yay 😄

#

380!

prisma crane
#

damn gurl

junior ivy
#

lol just got a new ring

#

haste/mast, 380

prisma crane
#

👌

lucid kelp
#

is a 385 Disk of Systematic regrssion worth anything on any spec?

prisma crane
#

it's not bad for aoe dmg

#

and you get a shitload of STR

#

outside of aoe there are better options

sacred roost
#

ptr change to deafening crash, is the 6 seconds with 1 peice having that trait, or all 3 pc's having it.

#

meaning they made it stack?

lusty grotto
#

duration doesn't stack, that didn't changte

hazy flame
#

6 seconds is the maximum you can extend by, not the amount you get per cast. and it doesnt stack.

amber siren
#

it's a static 6 seconds

lusty grotto
#

it's max 6 seconds no matter how many traits you have

sacred roost
#

ok, so you don't need the trait 3 times, you just need it once and it's giving 6 seconds

lusty grotto
#

you never needed it 3 times....

amber siren
#

yep

sacred roost
#

right now it 2 seconds

hazy flame
#

No

lusty grotto
#

nope

#

it's written very clearly in the Icy Veins guide

hazy flame
#

I repeat, 6 seconds is the maximum you can extend by, not the amount you get per cast. and it doesnt stack.

#

You still extend by 2 seconds per cast, up to a maximum of 6. ie, the change is that there is now an extension cap.

lusty grotto
sacred roost
#

generally I think you can only get 2 casts of thunder clap in a single cast of demo anyway.

lusty grotto
amber siren
#

Nope? Rn you can get 80% DS uptime roughly

brittle timber
#

With lust and avatar you can keep it up longer than it's CD....that's stupid strong and being fairly nerfed

amber siren
#

Much more than 2 casts

vivid drum
#

It just reduces the ability to use the Avatar cooldown to massively bolster it

lusty grotto
#

DC will still be one of our strongest Traits

#

just not enough to hold on to lower ilvl for it

amber siren
#

Which I'm v happy about

neat harbor
#

wait theyre nerfing TC, what the actual fuck

#

prot isnt shitty enough lets nerf the only thing that gives it dank meme value

#

🙄

amber siren
#

I mean we weren't expecting DC to last this long

neat harbor
#

I swear the blizzard prot warrior class lead team are a bunch of clueless fucking ponces.

amber siren
#

A trait shouldn't be worth 45+ ilvl

neat harbor
#

literally no idea what they are doing

junior ivy
#

how hard are uldir achievements?

steel mauve
#

I mean we are getting other buffs, so its not like we are getting nerfed for no reason, or our best trait is getting nerfed and nothing else is happening

neat harbor
#

o theres buffs

#

didnt realize lets read that

#

🤞

sacred roost
#

so the major changes are , 2 seconds less on shield block charge, 5% more health and armor, and .5 of a second less gcd on ignore pain?

brittle timber
#

sort of

#

IP is off the gcd, the 0.5sec cd is not the gcd

#

and...most importantly

#

#blocktherock

sacred roost
#

?

brittle timber
#

physical projectiles are blockable in 8.1

steel mauve
#

Ip woll no longer be on gcd, but given a .5 second cd so you cant jusg spam it

#

And its 5% more stam, and 5% more armor coefficient on str not 5% armor

prisma crane
#

slight nerf to magic damage for us, buff to phys/blockable dmg (more forgiving), IP is a feel buff and helps our rage floods in aoe, does almost nothing for our ST still, but it'll feel better. the ranged blocking is honestly the best thing out of all of this for me personally

steel mauve
#

With possibly more on he way, we dont know, and we dont know what they have planned or are testing

prisma crane
#

overall though, nothing that will make anyone go WOW I WANT A PROT FOR M+

#

but it's a raid buff for sure

brittle timber
#

didn't the mastery get changed 2 or 3 weeks ago too? to scale base block chance with ap instead of mastery?

prisma crane
#

not sure

#

we also got a slight dps nerf with the nerf to DC

#

particularly in aoe

steel mauve
#

Mastery wasnt changed, afaik they only changed the tooltip

prisma crane
#

since you could argue that we'll SS crit more often now

#

and slight rage gain since we wont lose a global every time we IP

brittle timber
#

and can revenge hit harder please? it feels so bad that our 'damage rage dump' does less damage than a Tclap

steel mauve
#

Not by much, i think revenge is our second hardest hitting ability iirc under tclap and if you count a shield block shield slam

prisma crane
#

i'd rather have SS hit hard again

brittle timber
#

yea that would be nice

prisma crane
#

or change tooltip to shield slap or something

sick sentinel
#

Holy shit, today is a good day for me for raiding

#

Got both the normal and heroic mythrax trinket

prisma crane
#

so you got one trinket

#

lol

ember crest
#

shh

#

unique equipped is a imagined

sick sentinel
#

yeah but im glad i got both at least

prisma crane
#

i approve your optimism, but be more happy for the heroic one lol

#

i just got it last night, havent used it yet

#

i like jes' and the anchor

green sky
#

did I miss something? is that trinket actually worth using now?

steel mauve
#

Depends on ilvl and what you have

prisma crane
#

I hear it's decent for aoe

#

gimme my fucking Diima's back

#

that with BC was a joy

ember crest
#

i like my mythic zek tentacle rape trinket

prisma crane
#

4m crits, oof

steel mauve
#

The answer usually is not really, unless you just have shit trinkets, i would probably still use blockades and howler over it unless the myhrax trinket was like 380 or so

prisma crane
#

you wouldnt use that trinket for surv though

#

just like you wouldnt use blockades for dmg

#

technically blockades is amazing for surv, but if you find you dont need the additional heals, it's a wasted slot

steel mauve
#

The heals arent even that great, its the stam on it that makes it good to use

daring marlin
#

The healsa re just the icing on the cake

prisma crane
#

i guess, i just dont find myself missing the stam once i swapped to fathoms

#

but then again, i havent done much that really pushes the limit this tier

#

only a bit of mythic, and a few 10+ keys

steel mauve
#

Ive been considering fathoms, im wanting to try to switch over to dps trinkets

prisma crane
#

i'm just used to going dps with trinkets

#

most trinkets are fairly shit anyways so i'd rather get what i can out of my output

#

that said, ofc stuff like blockades has its place

neat harbor
#

"physical ranged attacks are now blockable"

#

may I just say for one

#

ABOUT fucking time.

#

you could dodge them since what, vanilla?!

#

at least we are getting something.

#

not blown away by anything yet sadly but hey

prisma crane
#

on the bright side, a lot of the mobs that do that dont even always target the tank anyways...

neat harbor
#

I guess its better than nothing (?)

prisma crane
#

that's where i'm at

#

it's "something"

neat harbor
#

🤞 😬

merry cave
#

It's actually quite strong buff

sick sentinel
#

Hey has anyone done Heroic Ghuun this week

#

cause my raid right now is having a problem with orbs 1st phase

#

its not registering

merry cave
#

Just gotta hope they adjust for the big dc nerf

neat harbor
#

exactly, Im not convinced yet

stuck oxide
#

PROG ON mythic GHUUUN

ember crest
#

gl

stuck oxide
#

im kind of proud that only sense and lala killed it in US

final mist
#

Working on it, lads.

marsh beacon
#

Did someone say they’re nerfing deafening crash in 8.1? If yes, source?

final mist
#

Datamining / PTR.

stuck oxide
#

yes they do

#

there is a max extend of 6 sec on demo now

#

look the pin

marsh beacon
#

😢 I understand the rational, but that’s disappointing. DC is a legitimately fun trait, and the system would be better if there were more traits of its caliber

stuck oxide
#

it will still be very good tbh

#

you will still need this trait on one piece of gear minimum

#

but you will not feel like sh!t if you dont have that trait

marsh beacon
#

Yeah, exactly. Right now I’m wearing a 340 DC item instead of a 370 item in my bag, which goes against their overarching design philosophy.
Ultimately, this nerf is necessary because of the limitations/bad design of the azerite trait system. It makes senses, and it’s not unexpected, but it still sucks
Rip the prot warrior dps meme dream

merry cave
#

DC holds back there gearing for children mindset

#

In a sense it holds back war balance buffs too, as long as they adjust for it and not leave it

steep river
#

So DC will do less AOE damage now?

#

or can you still keep the damage where it is?

marsh beacon
#

It will last for less time, so you will do less sustained AoE damage

plucky rapids
#

DC will only add up to 6 seconds extra i believe

merry cave
#

Id be more concerned about the m+ DR nerf side of it rather than the dps nerf

marsh beacon
#

Can’t take damage if everything’s already dead (kappa, I appreciate your valid concern)

neat harbor
#

@marsh beacon "Ultimately, this nerf is necessary because of the limitations/bad design of the azerite trait system." Precisely, but IMO the issue with the azerite system is that there's too many shitty traits. Like there's spec traits that aren't even situational, they're just complete and utter dogshit, no reason to take them ever. That's the personification of bad design, and having half the traits be unviable is doing way more to limit gearing options than having a single outlier like Deafening crash ever did (imho)

empty nacelle
#

arms has to be one of the few specs that has interesting traits

#

that have gameplay impact (specifically Executioner's precision and Test of Might)

neat harbor
#

It's as if blizzard doesn't have access to any sims themselves. "Beta for Azerite", indeed: How can they get the actual # tuning for all the traits so horribly wrong? Some of them would be viable, with nothing more than tweaks to the numbers. I stand by my original statement, that they didn't have time to properly test it all before release.

steel mauve
#

To point it out prot war doesnt even have a working/accurate sim module to even have...

digital arrow
#

do u guys ever get stuck with 4 stacks from zul p2 and still live lol

#

friggin cleaver add kept comin out before transition so co tank had to handle her off to the side while i got 3+ stacks every time

prisma crane
#

leap and bop it off

#

otherwise stay in once they taunt off you, spam that IP, use SR first, then shield wall while you go out

merry cave
#

You can live through 4 with decent cd usage

#

But it's not worth

prisma crane
#

if you don't have a BoP, save leap for getting back once it's dropped

#

walking through that pool while you're already weak is ass

#

or intervene if a range/healer is nearby

merry cave
#

Do many raids not have any pally at all? Seems crazy

thorn yarrow
#

we always transition with Cleaver still up an normally 1 or both hexers

#

its never clean for us but u manage even if ya got just 1 paladin

merry cave
#

We just hold finish cleaver, then push quickly

#

Works better tbh

steel mauve
#

We just push as fast as possible and just deal with cleaver

thorn yarrow
#

I mean I take zul first regardless since Warrior

steel mauve
#

As soon as the cleaver spawns we nuke it and cleave onto boss still pushing

thorn yarrow
#

an our BDK has zero movement we just grip him back in

steel mauve
#

Usually we push wkth cleaver, beats getting another set of adds too since we dont kill the first spawn of hexars

thorn yarrow
#

we also have like 8 hunters sooo

#

traps for days

steel mauve
#

Ya we just cc the first double hexar spawn and keep it cc'ed the entire fight amd push before the second spawn

merry cave
#

Isn't that pretty much everyones Strat now lol

steel mauve
#

Not every ones

#

Still some try to kill all adds and stuff even though its harder

cinder nova
#

Should I be autismo spamming IP on M Vectis?

#

Because I just did that and the smoothing was fucking YEARS different.

digital arrow
#

we do have a pally, gonna try asking for BoP and leaping

#

i just hope i'm within range when im at the edge

raven kernel
#

Tell the pally to follow you out

lusty grotto
#

forgot about the pool

median wigeon
#

Anyone fill me in on tanking vect ? I see some logs where war is taking all adds and boss is being taunted back and forth on CD but others it's like ppl are just winging it

#

Mythic btw

cinder nova
#

Honestly

#

I just went full defensive

#

And I kept up IP as much as I could for the dot

#

And it smoothed out my damage signifcantly, but fucked my DPS

chrome harbor
#

SR for when the cotank taunts and you hav ethe dot

cinder nova
#

^

#

I try to save my SR for when contagion and the second stack applies

#

So that I'm helping curve burst and it still is helping reduce a lot of the dot damage at its peak

neat harbor
#

just got a 12.2k DPS parse on zek, RL corrupted the logs

#

feelsbadman 😢

cinder nova
#

It's okay

#

Probably wasn't even 95th percentile

#

last I checked that's ~13.7K iirc

#

Still trying to get mine

#

💤

pallid axle
#

im still trying to kill zek... guild is meh. monk co tank with 378ilvl who "cant" take full combo x'D

zinc creek
#

why though lol

ember arrow
#

Are you sure that hes a living human being?

crimson sentinel
#

just switch then if he cant take a full combo?

#

xd

#

better then him dying

ember arrow
#

Monks can take combo without anything up

#

Stagger cant kill them

neat harbor
#

@cinder nova apparently 12.2k DPS is about 30th in the world

#

...on normal

#

which is what it was 😄

cinder nova
#

Oh, I was talking Mythic

#

12K on normal is ez

#

I was top 10 worls H zek prot parse for a hot minute

#

That faded quick tho

topaz ember
#

fill the raid up with blood dks and have them keep gripping the adds in one spot while not attacking them and you just aoe for max cheeze

ember arrow
#

Why do you need more than one gg

neat harbor
#

yeah my guild would never let me tank in mythic lul

#

hopefully this patch wil change some of that...

#

gonna have to be better than what Ive seen so far though

#

I dont see 30th in the world as being easy by any means though

#

even if it is an underplayed class/irrelevant difficulty 🙃

pallid axle
#

yeah i know can take that zekvoz combo with easy, she's just bad probably tanking cause she bang the raidlead and is playing monk lel

#

*monk can

neat harbor
#

lmao

#

bang the raid lead, become mythic tank

#

seems like pretty natural progression path to me.

pallid axle
#

yeah since he's allowed to raid her shes allowed to raid mythic ... ty

neat harbor
#

😁

#

guild politics are hilarious

#

bunch of manchildren/hoes

pallid axle
#

yeah but thats on me i decided to leave hardcore raiding behind and settle with casual progress .... but a 4hours/week raiding guild and doing mythic doesnt seem that bad aye could be worse xD

wary burrow
#

hi my fellow warrior collegues. i am risen by my guild to tank zul the crusher on mythic. in normally play arms or fury, and tanked last time in MoP. Do you have any advises for me?

pallid axle
#

face crusher away, cleave can be blocked , rest is up to ur guild i guess.

wary burrow
#

okay, is there anything about trinkets i have to do, cause i only have darkmoon card, and rest are high ilvl uldir dd trinkets :/

#

also i think i should reforge my azerite gear

pallid axle
#

darkmoon does just fine, might try to get Rezans trinket from atalr dazar and that how trinket from toldagor

#

but the tol dagor thing feels more like an offensive tool though

#

*howl trinket

ember arrow
#

Versa is dr too

wary burrow
#

args, then in need to get a group for it before raid, and hope, that it will drop ^^. i read about azerite gear, high ilvl is not always the best, the traits are worth more?
i got g'huun tentacle 😮 this should do it?

pallid axle
#

there is a trait called "deafening crash" u should get one peace of that

#

*piece

wary burrow
#

okay, i think i saw it it some of my gear ^^