#protection

1 messages · Page 2187 of 1

sick sentinel
#

Oh well

chrome falcon
#

and suddenly we have to sit there for like 10 seconds while the druid spams wrath to get them out of his roots

sick sentinel
#

Heroic throw nerd

frosty wedge
#

I le thim tangle, then let himbreak it and taunt

chrome falcon
#

You have to do so much damage to break mass roots

#

It's like 15 heroic throws

frosty wedge
#

lol

sick sentinel
#

I mean it's not but ok

chrome falcon
#

I mean it definitely is but sure

sick sentinel
#

I mean it's not because it's taken me 3-5

#

Also I can just go and SS them

#

And then leap back to get them to follow

chrome falcon
#

Yeah just waltz up to the +15 caster packs and shield slam the infested mob

#

No worries

#

I'm not saying it doesn't work

#

Its just way more annoying than literally every other CC ability in the game

frosty wedge
#

AND way more powerful

#

tradeoffs

chrome falcon
#

But you don't need it

sick sentinel
#

Casters don't just stop castkng because their rooted

chrome falcon
#

... that's my point?

#

While you walk up to shield slam it

#

They're casting on you

#

And you're fucking dead

frosty wedge
#

man, do the first boss in KR with a boomkin that knows what he's doing - it's definitely worth it in some situations

sick sentinel
#

It's always worth it

chrome falcon
#

We're not talking about the first boss in KR

#

We're talking about trash

#

As clearly indicated by me talking about infested mobs

frosty wedge
#

oh this convo started b/c I mentioned my Boomy friend MEing first boss adds in KR, lol

chrome falcon
#

Sure there are like 2 bosses where it's useful, it is just annoying on trash

frosty wedge
#

anyway, being able to mass CC whole packs indefinitely is incredibly powerful

sick sentinel
#

Nah it ain't tho

#

It's shit

#

Super garbo

frosty wedge
#

it's not at al though, I've seen wipes saved by ME

chrome falcon
#

It's really slow

sick sentinel
#

Can't figure out a way to pull one add out

#

At all

chrome falcon
#

You would much rather just use better CC and speed up

lusty grotto
#

right its bad with sanguine

frosty wedge
#

like a healer backs into a pack and the boomy just MEs the whole pack

#

it's only bad if you ME over sanguine

#

which I don't even know how that would happen

sick sentinel
#

Fat finger

chrome falcon
#

Also if you aren't taking typhoon on a sanguine week then yikes

sand egret
#

Oh, well I had to deal with not one but TWO boomkins using Treants when mobs are at 10% hp.....like how you gonna say we pushin this key when you are literally resetting the pack every time with that shit

#

I love me some wood bois don't get me wrong, but them dumb shits will sit happy in sanguine until the cows come home

daring marlin
#

LOL

frosty wedge
#

yeah no you use that shit at the beginning of puls, not at 10%, lol

lusty grotto
#

i mean, there's too much room for error

sick sentinel
#

Use abilities intelligently.

#

Esp love it when rogues/rets stun in the pools as other mobs dying

sand egret
#

also a gem from last night:
To the DH: "can you interrupt this caster out of the pool"
"It's on CD"
"....the mob literally didn't cast anything yet....."

#

yep, he attempted to interrupt a stunned mob

sick sentinel
#

wow

#

No words.

sand egret
#

yep.

sick sentinel
#

DHs I feel def the new huntards these days since legion.

sand egret
#

meta-commentary: Boosts + artificially raised classes (Dks and DHs) are counter-productive to creating good habits with understanding how a spec works

sick sentinel
#

The two in my guilds raid try/sometimes push top DPS usually, but almost always wipe them on mechanics or fail to do any interrupts.

#

Mythic+ too

sand egret
#

I get that leveling blows, but man it's painfully obvious when you see a boosted char...especially when they're in a M+ only to "discover" they had X ability

sick sentinel
#

Reading is a hard skill

sand egret
#

it's why I'll always be a supporter of making casters, in general, way more dangerous while leveling

sick sentinel
#

Mythic Zek'vhoz comes to mind. Always failing pools, or wiping out our melee with eye beams.

#

Why bother learning what your ability does when u think u know what it does

sand egret
#

leveling in vanilla was like pull 2 mobs and you're doing some crazy shit, so I remember throwing out all my CC (played a Rogue so I was sapping, blinding and shit) to just quest

#

that's where I personally learned how impactful an interupt is

#

"Oh, i'm not taking ANY damage...." 🤔 "this seems like a thing to do"

sick sentinel
#

Evasion let's me Dodge 100%? That's crazy

sand egret
#

Kidney Shot....exists

sick sentinel
#

Gouge exists

#

Fuck you kidney shot, gouge dah real mvp

sand egret
#

apparently I'm one of the weird ones that get a straight dopamine hit when I interupt something haha

sick sentinel
#

Feelsgood

#

Just angers me whenever I talk to people and they are like I know what it does but don't know exactly what it does

#

Had warriors that didn't know prots charge can target friendly

#

Im like, did u fucking read anything in ur spellbook

sand egret
#

you're preaching to the choir

#

part of my job is literally writing those tooltips, knowing my players will most likely never read them. Seriously, it's rough haha

#

"this sucks, I can't do X"
"actually, if you use Y it allows you to do X"
"What? How the fuck am I supposed to know that?"
"It's right there in the descri-"
"I don't read that shit!"

solid mist
#

gouge, walk behind mob, backstab. HAHA I"M A GENIUS oh god this takes forever

#

lol

sand egret
#

oh....how long it took me to realize that mobs will ALWAYS face you....I spent so much time jumping around the Barrens trying to backstab shit

sick sentinel
#

Hey man, my pet cat taunts adds

#

It will work on players because the trailer told me it would

sand egret
#

Biggest offender is Taunt, imho

sick sentinel
#

Listen u kill my cat then u fight me

sand egret
#

mostly because it's a weird functionality that isn't apparent. In fact, it's probably shocking how many Tanks don't understand how taunt works

sick sentinel
#

I want to make a joke but I can't find one

sand egret
#

Yeah, that's a tough tooltip to write, tbh

#

not even meme'in

sick sentinel
#

And the problem now is that taunting in pvp is a thing because of a talent

#

Good or bad, it's like fucking hell

sand egret
#

well at least it doesn't force your character to attack you

sick sentinel
#

Yeah but it gives a really bad impression of how taunt works

sand egret
#

oh no doubt

sick sentinel
#

It make damage go up if I taunt

sand egret
#

to be fair, from a threat perspective that isn't "wrong" per se haha

sick sentinel
#

It's like no but yes but no

sand egret
#

but to me it's the concept that it doesn't give you any threat baseline

#

but rather it sets your threat to +1 of the highest current

#

so it's the people who pull with taunt alone and wonder why the fucker runs off is what gets me

#

or how aggro works diff between melee vs ranged, or even what that number MEANS on the top of the mobs' default nameplate (or the colors)

sick sentinel
#

It's why I try to never use taunt at start unless I'm going into a big add group

lusty grotto
#

haha i remember the first time i tanked in vanilla... SM - i was spamming taunt because that's how warriors tanked in EQ1

#

then friends told me to spam sunder armors instead

sick sentinel
#

Remember to stack ur three sunders before u dps shitlord

lusty grotto
#

EQ1 tanking was pretty much spam Taunt and have Avatar of War weapon

#

it was 5 tho

#

sunders

#

at first

sand egret
#

Or you have your GM also be the main warrior tank and force you (the rogue) to always open with a 5 point expose armor

#

that fucker just didn't want to hit Sunder

sick sentinel
#

Yeah well fuck you three sunders is what the time ur allowed before dps lose their mind

lusty grotto
#

lol

sand egret
#

can confirm, the true origin of why Rogues always jump when dps'ing is actually it was a method used to pace their initial burst

#

#PossiblyTrueWoWFacts

lusty grotto
#

we had salv ready for rogues

#

shit was exclusively casted on them

sand egret
#

psh

#

you didn't have dps warriors

lusty grotto
#

we did

sand egret
#

I had to Feint myself

#

they had nothing

lusty grotto
#

but they waited patiently

#

KTM was a thing

#

and omen

sand egret
#

oh yeah

#

sees Omen yelling at me
spams Feint

lusty grotto
#

i mean i used Omen for skittish in legion

sand egret
#

although, any smart Rogue back in the day just Vanished in their opener

#

as it was basically required haha

lusty grotto
#

so i probably still have it on ol

#

yeah

sand egret
#

skittish is one of my fav affixes because it reminds me of tanking back in the day. a guilty pleasure, if you will

old zephyr
#

You mean you were making sûre not to do to much threat rather than yelling at the tank ?

lusty grotto
#

it used to be fun, now i just 👢 🍵 👏 it and np np

sand egret
#

welll, I couldn't yell at the tank

#

yeah well 👢 🍵 👏 does make that a non-affix haha

#

(the tank was also my GM haha)

lusty grotto
#

lol

sand egret
#

it all changed when he got the Thunderfury....never had to worry about threat again. God Bless that stupid proc.

lusty grotto
#

haha

digital arrow
#

Lmao blade.. that guilty pleasure

lusty grotto
#

remember AQ/Naxx, having TF made you a instant main tank

sand egret
#

de-facto

#

-25% swing speed

lusty grotto
#

you could be 100% fucking trash

sand egret
#

like....imagine that mitigation value now

lusty grotto
#

and wipe the raid on Sapphiron by stepping out of your goddamn LoS iceberg

sand egret
#

and NEGATIVE NATURE RESIST

lusty grotto
#

but you were still main tank cause you had TF

#

fucking happend to us, i hated that fucking retard

sand egret
#

like imagine a weapon that was like "oh if I used this all shadow damage for the raid goes up 15%"

lusty grotto
#

people raged so much, they broke headsets and keyboard so we couldn't try him again lol

#

but he was MT because he had TF!

sand egret
#

haha oh ours was funny, as all the other senior officers who knew him IRL were like..."well now you have no excuse to suck, we just invested all that into your ass"

lusty grotto
#

lol

#

trust me after that, all Leggos went to vets and decent players

sand egret
#

we got worlds for Naxx so it worked out 😃

lusty grotto
#

nice

chilly brook
#

So just curious, why weren’t druids ever tanks in vanilla? I understand why pallys weren’t

glad tinsel
#

Crushing blows

sand egret
#

^

#

exactly this

lusty grotto
#

they became gods in BC though

sand egret
#

if you're not familiar, it was an type of hit a boss could deliver that was different than a "crit"

chilly brook
#

I remember crushing blows

sand egret
#

yeah, that was the biggest reason

chilly brook
#

They just got relegated to something you negated through gearing iirc back in Wrath

lusty grotto
#

i think they had low armor to begin with and no decent threat maintenance

#

plus agi gear instantly went to rogues

#

lots of shit

sand egret
#

with high gear levels their stam and dodge made up for it

lusty grotto
#

oh yeah

#

but again, rogues

sand egret
#

but it was like.....diceroll "shit, well I'm dead"

lusty grotto
#

lol

sand egret
#

#RNGTanks

lusty grotto
#

bears tanked really well @ heroics early BC though

chilly brook
#

It’s an odd idea that bear was originally a dodge tank

daring marlin
#

Druids were good for one thing in wrath

lusty grotto
#

mangle and armor via agi made up for it

chilly brook
#

Like

daring marlin
#

KNOW WHAT THAT IS?

sand egret
#

conceptually it is quite silly

chilly brook
#

Can you imagine a bear dodging swords irl?

#

Yea....

#

I don’t

daring marlin
#

fantastic

sand egret
#

yeah, I just think of that dancing bear gif

chilly brook
#

Same

lusty grotto
#

Bear that trains in 10000g with Goku

sand egret
#

the hilarious part was...they tried to do that AGAIN in WotLK with Blood tanking

daring marlin
#

frost dk was where it was at

sand egret
#

"You be the Parry tank!"
"uh....that didn't quite work out befo..."
"TOO BAD

daring marlin
#

all the armor and cds

chilly brook
#

I was never a fan that they moved the “tank spec” to blood

daring marlin
#

busted fuckers

chilly brook
#

I frost being the “tank spec” much better

sand egret
#

I understand why, but I did like the aspect that their specs weren't "role" definied

chilly brook
#

But their trees needed a rework period cuz like all you needed to be a tank was 10 points or so

sand egret
#

like total bullshit, but it at least sold the "hero class"

chilly brook
#

It was unintuitive that was for sure

#

I still miss the original DK it was so much more interesting

sand egret
#

OG Blood was the best. I did 3 Drake Sarth as blood when it was considered only viable as Unholy

chilly brook
#

One of the classes that really got hurt by pruning imo

sand egret
#

now that was nervewrackin

chilly brook
#

I loved the original unholy

sand egret
#

yeah, it was tough because on the one hand it did make them feel unique...but on the other hand you honestly can't have that in a game like WoW

chilly brook
#

Having defiled ground pop up with skeletal hands that slowed people was just amazing

sand egret
#

uh what about Call Ted?

chilly brook
#

But that’s gone now 😑

sand egret
#

hands down the best OG DK

chilly brook
#

And rezzing someone as a ghoul

sand egret
#

aka Raise Dead Ally Into A Ghoul

chilly brook
#

Lol

sand egret
#

the walk of shame as we called it

#

"X died...well time to bring in Ted off the bench!"

chilly brook
#

When corpse explosion was a real damage move

#

🙁

sand egret
#

we had this one raider who ended up getting multiple kills during progression as a ghoul

#

oh man he got so much shit

chilly brook
#

Lol

sand egret
#

"Dude, can you just die so we can get Ted in here for some real DPS"

chilly brook
#

Hahahhaha

sick sentinel
#

We had a death rotation in antorus to make our ret pala get 100% parce

sand egret
#

like...it got so far that our GM (who was like dead pan 99% of the time) said it and HE ACTUALLY SUICIDED

sick sentinel
#

On kingaroth

chilly brook
#

Lul

sand egret
#

poor guy

chilly brook
#

I miss the old talent trees

sand egret
#

i got a love/hate with em

chilly brook
#

TBH I kinda wanna go back and play rift

#

But I know the game is bad now

#

But they had such a cool tree system

sand egret
#

there are some really sweet systems out there

solid mist
#

they had bards

#

so I was a fan

sand egret
#

i played that game for like 20 minutes one time on a co-workers account. I was some crazy illusion battle mage thing, and it was pretty cool

chilly brook
#

I thought their raids and dungeons in the base game were awesome

#

But the expansion kinda pushed it downhill when it went free to play

solid mist
#

Their party system was like tank/healer/2xdps/support right?

#

loved that

sand egret
#

it made the mistake of trying to be a "WoW killer"

solid mist
#

support classes ❤

chilly brook
#

Yea it was @solid mist

sand egret
#

instead of trying to be its own thing, but yeah I fucking love the idea of a support character not being also the "healer"

chilly brook
#

And the hybrids you could make ❤️

solid mist
#

have bards, will play

chilly brook
#

Melee DPS/aoe healer hybrid

#

That was an awesome build that did it’s healing job superbly and also actually felt like a true Paladin from like WC3

signal plover
#

I looooved the artstyle in Rift

chilly brook
#

I did too

signal plover
#

The armor especially

#

It had rly bad release timing tho IIRC

chilly brook
#

That game was the start of the dark road that Trion is on now though

#

It was a fairly popular release iirc

signal plover
#

It dropped mid cata

chilly brook
#

I quit cata pretty early on

signal plover
#

But like before the burn out. Yeah I did too

#

Right after 25 nef

chilly brook
#

Which sucked because I loved Wrath

solid mist
#

I wish a compnay would make the dungeon/raid/boss part of an MMO w/o the massive infrastructure/world/etc. I just wanna do group content with people, that requires coordination and interesting use/combination of abilities

chilly brook
#

But I have very fond memories of Rift

digital arrow
#

sounds like u would like ffxiv

chilly brook
#

I think there’s a place for that but tbh the world and stuff are kinda a large part of the game

digital arrow
#

all i did was raid and focus on mastering my role.. didnt fuck around with the other stuff

chilly brook
#

Even though it’s only relevant to the character once

solid mist
#

ffxiv was fine. Tanking as a PLD felt SO boring. I like BRD... but it didn't really feel like a bard :/

digital arrow
#

oh yeah u gotta do something that takes practice

#

maybe monk

#

or red mage

solid mist
#

no. RDM just makes me sad and think about FFXI RDM

#

the most broken fucking amazing MMO class ever made

steel mauve
#

Rift was probably the most fun ive had tanking in any mmo

chilly brook
#

Lol I just remember being a broken void Knight tank

steel mauve
#

I was a rogue tank

solid mist
#

when D3 droped, and had like the crusader class I was hopeful, but nope it's just about running around spamming AOE as a group :/

digital arrow
#

ahh i didnt experience ffxi

chilly brook
#

And then swapping to warlord and people didn’t believe that it could be good but then I would rip threat off every other tank while also literally being the support

steel mauve
#

Idk how good they were as i never got that deep into it but it qas fun af

chilly brook
#

Yea

solid mist
#

FFXI was... old school. Would be terriblet o play now. As a college/post-college person who had time. It was AMAZING to figure out

chilly brook
#

Teleporting around was a cool thing for rogue tanks

solid mist
#

I got taught how to play the game by japanese players using the in-game translation system

#

it was bonkers

#

the whole threat mechanic with rogues, the magic burst shit, I was blown away

chilly brook
#

But I liked the cleric tank the best. Problem was it had the same problem as beginning of tbc no one wanted you because you weren’t a warrior

#

Even though you could tank perfectly fine

sick sentinel
#

god 12s shield block recharge so nice.

solid mist
#

@digital arrow rdm in ffxi was this. Burn your entire mana bar debuffing/buffing, then cast conversion ro whatever it was called to swap your HP/MP bars, then heal yourself back to full, then start casting refresh on your casters in your party, you were a dmg/buff/debuff/mana battery. Then you could subjob NIN and dual wield rapiers that you would enchant with elemental power. And you got a dope ass hat

sand egret
#

if there is one thing the FF's were good at...it's really doubling down on the concept of "execution". Holy 1-shot mechanics batman

#

a bit ago there's a really, really super good article written by a WoW raid designer (I think this was written in Legion) who was an avid FFXIV player about the fundamental differences in encounter design between the two games. If you're into the more technical stuff of game design, definitely check it out

solid mist
#

I feel like FFXI and IV do a really good job with class fantasy.

#

do/did

#

whatever

sand egret
#

well it's a crux to their system

#

after all spec = class = job basically.

solid mist
#

everyone was super unique and played in weird different ways

#

yeah

sand egret
#

so you didn't have 4 types of druids. a druid did THE DRUID SHIT

#

and that was it

#

but from an encounter perspective, Eastern-style design favors execution and layering simple mechanics to create complexity. On the other hand WoW and Western-style design favors innate complexity and experience aggregation

#

which boils down to "Simple, but binary" vs " the kitchen sink" approach

earnest zinc
#

The main issue with classes there that I have is the fact that you don't have an offspec unless you level it up like an alt

#

In FFXIV

sand egret
#

yeah, it required a lot of investment to play a diff job

#

but on the flipside, your "alt" was also the same character

solid mist
#

well in FFXIV you got the crazy xp boost at least

sand egret
#

but cross-class skills....

#

ugh

#

it's like if, in order to tank as Prot, we had to also level up a BDK alt to 43 before we could actually get the "taunt" ability

earnest zinc
#

I don't know if it's still there, but there were mandatory abilities behind other classes being leveled on your toon. Are you a tank? You better make sure you have Gladiator to 22 (or whatever level you got taunt) to tank properly

sand egret
#

(yes, i know they start at like 55 lol)

signal plover
#

Hmm 370 veiled or 370 syringe for M fetid

#

(melee tank, not TT)

sand egret
#

yeah @earnest zinc that's what I'm talkin about. You needed the taunt ability from Glad to do any tank swaps

solid mist
#

just main GLD/PLD problem solved

chilly brook
#

Jeez

sand egret
#

but I like doing stuff in a game

earnest zinc
#

Also when I played, tanking felt like you were a dps that could tank

sand egret
#

Warrior was true man mode

chilly brook
#

Just looking back at rift stuff it makes me realize just how much I want a more “classic” mmo experience

sand egret
#

predicting your own 1-shot to counter it 👌

earnest zinc
#

You were in dps stance and only went tank stance when it was required

sand egret
#

@chilly brook yeah, I feel ya. the rpg elements of the MMORPG don't really exist enough these days

earnest zinc
#

As in losing aggro or surviving a tankbuster

sand egret
#

haha yeah, the stances were fun for sure

#

esp because tuning was so tight that you really had to know what you could survive without your tank stance to keep the dps up

#

however, perfectly scripted encounters were such a snooze

#

i do enjoy the innate variance that comes with Western design

chilly brook
#

🤞🏼for ashes of creation

sand egret
#

even if it meant i'd hate RNG from time to time

earnest zinc
#

Also the fact that there are only 4 of them each tier and there isn't an equivalent to normal or heroic difficulty

#

It's just LFR and mythic

steel mauve
#

At least now i dont think you need to lvl a second class in ff14, i think they just unlock cross class skills as you level

earnest zinc
#

Though their LFR is called normal and is a bit harder than LFR here

#

Their mythic is called savage and is a bit easier than mythic here

junior ivy
#

i leveled up a character in ff14 once before i started playing wow again., all it did was make me miss wow

sick sentinel
#

I liked the stance dancing in 14. Also. Warrior fell cleave was sexy AF

#

Imma spend all my rage and buzz saw yo ass with my axe

sand egret
#

oh very satisfying. My biggest gripe with the game was the longer GCD. It just felt super slow, even with the "off the gcd" skills (which really were baked into a very rigid rotation)

junior ivy
#

eyah standing there waiting for gcd over and over doing nothing wasnt fun

sand egret
#

and they had even weirder gnomes than WoW

digital arrow
#

damn i missed a lot in ffxi

#

lol yeah that cleave was cool to look at

#

and the saw buzz sound that came with it

sand egret
#

Unchained was the best feeling

#

like Avatar x 10

digital arrow
#

Got some cross-mmo warriors up in here 🙌

sand egret
#

tried and true

heady coyote
#

hey guys just wondering is the devastator worth taking or is booming voice still the go to ?

raven kernel
#

BV

steel mauve
#

Always booming voice

chilly brook
#

@digital arrow well tbh a lot of them do offer a fun experience they just end up lacking later on at some point

steel mauve
#

Swtor was one of the most fun single player mmos ive played, i still go back every so often

#

Their end game was complete ass and bug ridden until next expacs, but it was fun af to level and the story was great

raven kernel
#

swtor levelling was legit fun

#

also huttball best bg in any mmo

cerulean geyser
#

So I got a 385 shoulder from the mythic chest yesterday that has reinforced plating on it. When comparing it to my 355 shoulder with Deafening crash, is it better to stick with Deafening crash or go with the 385?

topaz badger
#

is "Incite the pack" good for m+? or should I use bloodsport?

raven kernel
#

if you dont have alternative DC pieces on helm/chest then stick with what you have

neon tangle
#

My guild started progression on m vek yesterday

raven kernel
#

xiro use bloodsport

neon tangle
#

WoW that guy hits like a baby

#

We're swapping for the second void lash

#

so I have spell reflect up for -every- one

raven kernel
#

you can take the full combo easily

neon tangle
#

I can, my monk is afraid of it

raven kernel
#

if you're swapping on 2 then its even easier

topaz badger
#

wut, spell reflect works on zekvoz?

neon tangle
#

It reduces the magic damage of the lash by 20%

raven kernel
#

yes SR has a 30% magic reduction component

neon tangle
#

or 30%?

topaz badger
#

wow..; I didn't even know that

#

fuck me

neon tangle
#

But yeah you can take the whole combo, or if you want to make it even more trivial

sand egret
#

pretty sure its 20% but yeah

topaz badger
#

it's 20% in the toolti

neon tangle
#

if you taunt after the shatter, before the second lash

#

you will get 20% off every lash

#

plus stack a 130% IP while you're not actively tanking

sand egret
#

yeah SR gives you 20% magic reduction in addition to reflecting the next cast. in essence, two different buffs

neon tangle
#

and make sure you got demo shout up

#

and it does ~nothing

cerulean geyser
#

well all I have is a 370 brace for impact and a 370 chest iron fortress so yeah guess I'll stick with it

raven kernel
#

plus ip

dusk locust
#

i have last stand up for every 3 hit combo, and if i save the rage i can IP all 3 hits as well

raven kernel
#

and yeah SR is 20% not 30

#

remembered wrongly :p

#

yes prot can have last stand up for all 3 hits

#

ip for all 3

#

and SR for one of the lashes (save for 2nd lash if taking full combo)

#

and demo up for all 3 as well

dusk locust
#

can demo shout all of them, yeah i SR the last lash, and if you mess up and get rage starved that's what i have shield wall saved for

#

i also use my rally for the adds + rings overlap (2nd set of adds)

neon tangle
#

Zek'voz Void Lash Stieglitz 25875 (A: 75085) (R: 161834, M: 60874, 37.62%)

#

It's pretty simpy

#

wimpy

sand egret
#

see this is where I like having different flavors of tanks (obvious balance aside).
Pallies: Block hit, heal the damage.
BDK: Take the hit with a massive hp pool, heal for the harder you're hit.
Monks: Take the hit, but make it something you can deal with later.
Bears: Big hit becomes medium hit, which becomes a scratch compared to the health pool
VDH: Mitigate some of the hit, heal back the rest.
Warriors: What hit?

neon tangle
#

is true, the monk gets wacked wayyy harder from them

#

e.g. Zek'voz Void Lash Chisou 102396 (A: 40164) (R: 152817, M: 10257, 6.71%)

sand egret
#

haha 4x harder

brave jetty
#

G'huun taunt swaps bother me

#

I really don't like how they don't line up neatly with the explosive corruption

dusk locust
#

heh yeah i feel similar. haven't quite found the rhythm

neon tangle
#

I kinda like it, keeps the fight sorta dynamic

brave jetty
#

How do y'all handle? I'll let it go another stack or two if I know a cast is coming up just in case he casts it on one of us.

dusk locust
#

we kind of have a "5 stacks or active tank got explosive" swap rule

#

so sometimes we end up swapping at hardly any stacks

brave jetty
#

Maybe I should do it early then, rather than wait out the cast.

dusk locust
#

it ultimately doesn't matter as long as he doesn't go taunt immune imo

#

if anything it's better b/c less damage

brave jetty
#

Yeah

raven kernel
#

heroic ghuun?

dusk locust
#

i'm talking heroic

brave jetty
#

yeah not mythic

raven kernel
#

when i was still tanking

#

my brew took all the explosive corruptions

#

i would just taunt off

neon tangle
#

I just save some space behind me for if I need to drop one when I'm actively tanking

raven kernel
#

and he taunts back when he's back

#

when we're gonna stack for add spawn

#

i hold boss

brave jetty
#

It seems that he targets the active tank far more often with it, is that your guys' feeling too?

neon tangle
#

and run a lil' further when my co-tank can taunt

raven kernel
#

and SR the EC

dusk locust
#

yeah he does seem to target active tank

raven kernel
#

EC is always on active tank

brave jetty
#

Oh always?

raven kernel
#

yes

brave jetty
#

I thought it wasn't guaranteed

raven kernel
#

alwaysssss

brave jetty
#

Okay that's good to know lol

dusk locust
#

don't quite understand how it works p1 tho

#

i was told to get aggro on the boss in teh wall but that didn't make a diff

brave jetty
#

lmao

raven kernel
#

p1 is randomish

#

doesnt really matter though

dusk locust
#

and make sure you SR as many of them as you can

raven kernel
#

if you need to tank the blightspreader tentacle or something like i do

#

then when the blightspreader pops

dusk locust
#

esp since they're predictable which ones will hit you

brave jetty
#

Also: have you guys noticed that sometimes if you're slightly up a wall you can get the spores to go up, rather than through the main floor of the raid?

raven kernel
#

i SR the next EC based on boss timer

dusk locust
#

particularly the 4th explosive cast

raven kernel
#

it keeps me free to stay and tank

dusk locust
#

since that overlaps with the blood circle thing

#

yeah i've definitely found there are some spots on the wall that cause the orbs to not really go anywhere

ashen flower
#

Brace for impact or iron fortress?

raven kernel
#

you definitely want to be the active tank when stacking for the circle

#

and then SR that EC

#

so both tanks can clear their stacks

dusk locust
#

yeah

raven kernel
#

@ashen flower brace

brave jetty
#

Brace I think but it's like 2nd vs. 3rd place

raven kernel
#

brace is 1st place

brave jetty
#

Uh...DC?

ashen flower
#

well i got matrix/clash and can choose brace or fortress

raven kernel
#

oh well

#

i dont count that :p

#

fine 2nd

brave jetty
#

lmao

#

that's how far in 1st DC is

#

it's not even in the competition lol

raven kernel
#

i mean i take it DC is a given

#

and already there

brave jetty
#

yeah

dusk locust
#

it's the reason i have 340 shoulders

brave jetty
#

I really cannot wait for them to address how integral it is

raven kernel
#

go pvp and get the 355 shoulders

#

it has dc

brave jetty
#

I hope they do, it feels awful

dusk locust
#

o

#

i like never pvp

#

what do i need to do

raven kernel
#

just get conquest

brave jetty
#

Are 355 shoulders on the conq bar rewards?

#

I've missed a few weeks

#

of capping that out

raven kernel
#

yes

brave jetty
#

Ah nifty

raven kernel
#

remember to pick the right one

#

you're always given 2 choices

#

dont pick the non dc one

brave jetty
#

Wait, you can pick?

#

How?

raven kernel
#

yes

dusk locust
#

if i've literally never pvp'd how far out am i from getting that

raven kernel
#

when you hand in the quest

brave jetty
#

Ohhh oh yeah

raven kernel
#

shoulders is only like

#

3rd week?

#

i think

#

so 1500 conquest

brave jetty
#

Nah

#

It's at least 4th I think

raven kernel
#

maybe 4th?

#

well yea

#

1500 or 2000 conquest

brave jetty
#

Might even be 5th?

raven kernel
#

not that late i think

brave jetty
#

I've done 3 or 4 and it's not even up next for me

#

weapon chest gloves pants

#

So it's 5th or later

#

My arena partner kinda lost steam in PvP and 355/370s aren't really upgrades so I stopped with PvP

#

I kinda like the conquest system though, I think with a little modification it could be really good.

raven kernel
#

yeah the rewards suck now

#

we outscaled them

#

but you stilll get them anyway cos u want the chest

brave jetty
#

I don't really need much from the chest either though

raven kernel
#

get 2.1k

#

you can get 385 azerite

brave jetty
#

lol

next ermine
#

So tanking mythic Zekvoz, IP first tentacle, SB shatter, IP/SR 2nd tenctacles ya?

raven kernel
#

if you pop last stand(bolster)

#

you ip the shatter too

#

if you pooled enough rage

#

but otherwise yes

#

also make sure you have demo shout to cover all 3 hits

#

make sure to spend enough rage after u swap off to get your last stand back in time for next round

next ermine
#

bolstered last stand should last the whole duration ya?

raven kernel
#

its possible to last stand every combo

#

yes

next ermine
#

gotcha

heady citrus
#

stupid question but can shields titanforge? or do they fall under weapons category

raven kernel
#

they used to

#

for like 1 or 2 weeks

#

then got fixed

#

i have 385 heroic vectis shield from the first week

#

XD

heady citrus
#

jelly

next ermine
#

i didnt see a single shield drop until that week we had an emmisary with it

heady citrus
#

my worst item is shield... been running shield M+ for 2 weeks now and still havent seen 1

next ermine
#

got that 340 shield, then got a 360 shield, then what do you know...that night i got the 370 vectis shield

raven kernel
#

bl man

heady citrus
#

370equip and 355 shield

next ermine
#

i cant get a new wep for the life of me

#

but at least mines 355 with a socket

#

so its fine for now

heady citrus
#

day 1 of this warrior it got 360 weapon. just got 370 now

next ermine
#

anyone know what the storms wake azerite armor is called

#

nvm lol

raven kernel
#

its random

next ermine
#

its by zone for emmisary caches

raven kernel
#

could be helm/shoulders/chest

next ermine
#

ya

#

but the traits are different depending on what zone it is

#

was seeing if any of the storms wake ones have DC, sadly, none do

sick sentinel
#

we are taking the fact that you have at least 1 DC in your gear as a given

lusty grotto
#

was wondering what storm's wake is

#

then i realized: stares at alliance scum

sand egret
#

I'm sorry, I can't hear you over all my self-debuff removal and free strength gains

lusty grotto
#

cries in blood fury

dark lagoon
#

DC should be baseline lol. This is absurd.

sick sentinel
#

Can never talk trash about weekly mythic+ cache after it gave me the 380 wf socket underrot shield.

vagrant cape
#

D:

sick sentinel
#

me, anyway.

#

swapped my middle tier ring defensives for damage.

#

x2 gutripper x1 heed my call.

#

experiment fat damage now that I have enough haste for 12-13s SB recharge, x2 BFI x1 DC, x2 impassive visage x1 resounding

midnight ferry
#

how much is socket worth on a shield

#

5 ilvl?

vagrant cape
#

on a shield? nothing

#

well, not nothing

#

let's call it 1 item level

#

you'd never use a lower ilvl shield because of a socket

#

higher ilvl shield = more block rating

#

and block rating is the best stat

midnight ferry
#

ok

vagrant cape
#

but if I said it was nothing, then you might take that to mean you should use a shield with no socket if it had better stats than one with a socket, so I had to clarify

proven pulsar
#

What best trait's for raiding in war prot ?

plain ice
proven pulsar
#

Can link it plz dont find in all pins

sick sentinel
#

🙄

sand egret
#

just checked the pins, can confirm it says in pins

proven pulsar
#

So link it to me plz

#

Cant find it ^^

sand egret
#

(check the icy veins guide)

lusty grotto
#

rip reddit

#

good riddance

novel leaf
#

I'm on mobile and ive got all the pins @proven pulsar , you ain't got no excuse

raven kernel
#

reddit what?

lusty grotto
#

its down

raven kernel
#

no it isnt

lusty grotto
#

also security breach email

raven kernel
#

im on reddit right now?

#

date of that email?

#

i dont have one

lusty grotto
#

1 hour ago

#

it just came up for me

#

that was a PM i got

#

me reddit nickname gasp

#

just kidding lol

raven kernel
#

r/reddit.com is an archived sub

#

since 7 years ago

#

not sure if some phishing thing

lusty grotto
#

i mean it's not

#

either way i changed my pw without following any links because i'm not stupid lol

raven kernel
#

good then

sand egret
#

Ah, always be blocking!

#

the prot way

vagrant cape
#

alright y'all. I have a toughy of a question

#

it's ok if you sweat this one out

#

it's a real mind cruncher

lusty grotto
#

i swear i'm totally straight, i just like Tom Hiddleston a little bit

#

wait, what was the question

vagrant cape
#

Azerite fortification (15k health whenever I get stunned, immobilized, or knocked back)

or

vampiric speed (6k healing and 93 speed when an enemy I harmed dies)?

#

I mostly do m+

raven kernel
#

az fort

hot locust
#

don't get stunned

#

ez

vagrant cape
#

this debate is really heating up

raven kernel
#

vamp speed is pretty meaningless to me

vagrant cape
#

rei, how do you feel knowing that Lala has insulted your intellect, ideas, and religios beliefs?

hot locust
#

monkaS

raven kernel
#

i am offended

#

to the forums i go!

hot locust
#

monkaGIGA

vagrant cape
#

Lala, how are you handling the fact that Rei has been seen defecating on your front porch over the disagreements presented today?

raven kernel
#

lala the warrior reddit post better be gud tomorrow

hot locust
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

vagrant cape
#

but seriously guys

lusty grotto
#

TO REDDIT

vagrant cape
#

this choice is tearing me apart (Lisa)

raven kernel
#

we're gonna get like 500 comments about how we're wrong about prot and that prot really sucks bad

lusty grotto
#

downvote brigade go

hot locust
#

I mean even I agree it needs some changes.

raven kernel
#

of course

#

but teh reddits paint a much darker picture

#

than it really is

little rain
#

Meh, prot could use a little buff but it's nowhere as bad as everyone cries it is tbh

hot locust
#

Yeah in general that's true.

#

but class balance has always been a circlejerk thing.

raven kernel
#

any sort of positivity towards prot = YOU'RE WRONG

hot locust
#

Just usually tanks are rather immune to it.

raven kernel
#

PROT SUPER BAD

lusty grotto
#

there's really no use arguing against a vocal minority

raven kernel
#

you will have self proclaimed good healers coming in saying

lusty grotto
#

even if it seems huge

raven kernel
#

they cant heal prots

hot locust
#

I don't think we're mentioning the current viability of prot too much

#

just more of potential things we'd like to see to improve gameplay and stuff.

neon tangle
#

I mean I’ve seen other prots, and you can’t heal them

#

Like not using SB ever, or rarely

little rain
#

Just bc people think prot is bad doesn't mean it is, literally every healer I go into keys with says I'm the easiest tank to heal they've played with, all while doing about the same dmg as a dps

vagrant cape
#

as a prot warrior, I cannot heal anyone

lusty grotto
#

wait, is someone gonna talk about it from skyhold ?

frosty wedge
#

a guy linked logs in here last week asking for tips and he only cast SB 6 times during Taloc

lusty grotto
#

who do i put my upvotes on guys

little rain
#

The skillcap i s just higher, you need to know when to use mit, call for externals, and kite

hot locust
#

Travex while that can be true going from pug to pug that is 100% not true from someone of equivalently high level at the top end.

neon tangle
#

It’s really the skill floor that’s the issue

supple path
#

You're comparing yourself playing prot warrior well vs likely, other tanks being played poorly.

hot locust
#

In any form of organized manner.

little rain
#

I'm 1700 and barely do keys ¯_(ツ)_/¯

plain ice
#

just out of curiosity @little rain - what M+ key levels are you running?

supple path
#

All else being equal, a BDK is gonna have a better time in M+

lusty grotto
#

uh oh here we go again

little rain
#

16+'s @plain ice

sand egret
#

You should come out of left field and be like "Warriors need a change.....Heroic Throw needs a huge buff in damage. That's it."

raven kernel
#

give us aoe shatter

sand egret
#

but I just wanna watch the internet implode

raven kernel
#

kappa

lusty grotto
#

i gotta be honest... i'm not looking forward to seeing that topic tomorrow

little rain
#

bring back warbringer and IP off CD and I'll be happy

lusty grotto
#

i'll ocd downvote everyone

supple path
#

I miss old spell reflect here.

raven kernel
#

i look forward to reading it

#

not looking forward to the comments

little rain
#

old spell reflect, ok yea that too

lusty grotto
#

right that's what i meant - the comments

neon tangle
#

I mean, ignoring how good you can do, most pugs will simply see how bad it is possible for a player to do

frosty wedge
#

old SR, IP off GCD, buff to numbers on IP

lusty grotto
#

legion spell reflect

sand egret
#

I got my faith in our Shield Bois to lay it out straight

raven kernel
#

it kinda hurts reading how low people think of us

lusty grotto
#

older than legion SR was bad

neon tangle
#

And a bad prot is 1/10th the tank as a bad BDK it BrM

supple path
#

Well yeah.

frosty wedge
#

dude, I had a group yesterday not take my 366 warrior for heroic uldir, but took me on my 355 BDK

supple path
#

The other day I finally read exactly how bone storm works and I was just like...are you serious right now.

neon tangle
#

@frosty wedge I mean I get it, a 366 prot can be -horrible- and worse than 10ivls when played poorly

#

BDK has AM on their main damage abilities

little rain
#

95% of the people on WoW are autistic, citing their decision making for class balance is a yikes tho

neon tangle
#

If you smash your face on the keyboard you will be mostly fine

frosty wedge
#

yeah I know, but I've been playing a prot warrior for... ~14 years, and a BDK for 3 weeks

sand egret
#

woof.

frosty wedge
#

lol

neon tangle
#

BrM basically doesn’t need to press their AM

#

That’s what the community sees

frosty wedge
#

Yeah I know, I've read the fetid article.... and watched the WF race

#

lol

neon tangle
#

It’s why I get kinda burned on the “prot is fine” story

sand egret
#

the reality is, in order for Blizz to drop notes that would effectively 180 community perception, they'd basically have to be so damn drastic that it'll prob not be good for the game regardless

lusty grotto
#

right

#

that's kind of what i'm afraid of

sand egret
#

so we're going to get shit regardless

frosty wedge
#

"IP is back to how it was at the start of legion, hve fun levelling your warriors"

sand egret
#

I just hope it makes those who play the spec feel better about playing it

neon tangle
#

I sorta disagree with that

raven kernel
#

honestly wouldnt mind them making us top tank and having everyone reverse their opinion

frosty wedge
#

then balance it out, lol

#

make us OP for like a month

neon tangle
#

There was a good interview with Jotdb which touched on healer representation on m+

sand egret
#

yeah it was good

neon tangle
#

It was bad in legion and got way more even in BFA

#

The community changes its opinions

frosty wedge
#

yeah well, anyone can heal a BDK, lol

neon tangle
#

Small buff to the top end, large buff to the bottom

supple path
#

The people on the top will play whatever is best, and then people sort of sheep off of that.

sand egret
#

exactly, and it's based off of a lot of things though

#

particularly stats

neon tangle
#

And, uhh, nerf bonestorm

lusty grotto
#

i'm just dreading that they make the class ez mode to play to counteract the whole stigma bullshit

sand egret
#

unless people just straight up stop taking BDKs and stuff, BDKs are probably still going to have a high rep

supple path
#

I mean honestly prot warrior feels pretty easy to play now, it's just super punishing on mistakes.

raven kernel
#

make deathstrike cost 5 more rp 🤔

sand egret
#

so as far as statistical perception, it may take way longer to right itself

lusty grotto
#

i mean...

#

obviously so

neon tangle
#

@sand egret The whole point though is that at the end of legion 2 healer classes accounted for 95% of top end runs, bfa has almost equal

frosty wedge
#

yeah it feels easy to play.... if you're not playing right, lol

neon tangle
#

i.e. there is reason to believe it would balance out if it got better

sand egret
#

yeah, but he also states in that interview that the damage profiles of M+ changed

neon tangle
#

especially going in to 8.1 w/ another gear reset

sand egret
#

which was independent of balance

raven kernel
#

for people well versed with prot, i dont think its hard to play

#

but getting there for a new person is challenging

lusty grotto
#

ok let me rephrase that

#

because yes i agree

sand egret
#

so yeah, I do agree that the state of the game will hopefully change in 8.1 but it's more a product of many things changing perception instead of like "Warriors get X more Y"

supple path
#

The real challenge is more just the required fight familiarity about when you REQUIRE cooldown x/y/z.

sand egret
#

basically, even if we get buffed we'll probably still get flak

neon tangle
#

@raven kernel I semi-disagree w/ that, I think we're a easy enough to play, I certainly know I've missed a CD, etc when dealing w/ boss mechanics, especially while learning a fight

#

i.e. on mythic zek when you're dealing with circles while dealing w/ the combo

lusty grotto
#

if they make it non punishing at all, i will be sad

#

i guess it's a matter of perception

sand egret
#

in isolation it isn't hard, it's just when you throw in external factors like mechanics, our plate-spinning becomes harder since our plates are harder to keep up

supple path
#

are they really? I haven't really played other tanks recently, but our rotation seems super simple right now.

lusty grotto
#

rotation?

supple path
#

Ability priority list, whatever

sick sentinel
#

Our skill floor is both high and low at the same time is the issue

lusty grotto
#

heh heh

sand egret
#

it isn't hard, it's just there is a mechanical window in the baseline "rotation" that invites failure

#

there are many, many warriors who don't handle that window well

#

there are others, who Bolster etc

supple path
#

I mean sure, 50% of the warriors out there are hitting shield block during bolster probably yeah.

sand egret
#

exactly

raven kernel
#

real talk, bear is harder to play

#

because id fall asleep and have 0 apm

neon tangle
#

lol

sand egret
#

haha I like my bear

signal plover
#

I think it's much higher than 50% tbh

sand egret
#

it's very nice going from

raven kernel
#

can you prog the same boss 100 wipes on bear

#

without going on suicide watch

neon tangle
#

@supple path I've certainly made mistakes, or let SB fall off, or didn't hit IP and capped rage when dealing with encounter mechanics

signal plover
#

Also, there's a lot of warriors still playing the spec reactively and holding CDs

sand egret
#

"NOOOO DON'T HIT SB NOW!"
to
"Hmm I wonder if I can hit a button now....?"

supple path
#

Yeah, but "a failure to do things 100% perfectly" isn't really a sign of difficulty.

sick sentinel
#

It is

neon tangle
#

I think that's the definition of difficulty?

lusty grotto
#

there's also a lot of warriors, that have absolutely absurd shit uptime on Demo

sand egret
#

ive' said it a bunch of times, but Prot is currently the only proactive tank in the game.

#

when you play reactively

#

you're not gonna have a good time

sick sentinel
#

Thank legion for that

#

Aka where making mistakes was ok

raven kernel
#

i guess im super suited to play prot and it meshes innately with me because i played since vanilla

sand egret
#

whatever the reason, it's a huge reason for misplays imho

raven kernel
#

so proactive tanking is really the norm for me

sand egret
#

it's ESPECIALLY worse

supple path
#

The challenge level in performing is what determines difficulty, not a retrospective "was it perfect".

lusty grotto
#

i have played since vanilla too, i have no issues with it currently

sand egret
#

if they were like BDKs

brave jetty
#

i prefer proactive tanking but it calls for a higher level of mastery over the encounters and situations

neon tangle
#

@supple path When not getting it 100% ends up with you getting gibbed / failing a fight, that translates to difficulty

sand egret
#

that's a personal thing though, which is and should be a thing

supple path
#

Like I made mistakes on my prot paladin during Lich King a bunch...but my passive "haha get wrecked I don't die no matter what" things saved me because prot paladin was goddamn easy.

brave jetty
#

so the style suits me as well, but it makes first pulls on progression content feel pretty rough at times

neon tangle
#

We are certainly in the camp of "mistakes have a high chance of being deadly"

sand egret
#

yeah, but that's the learning curve BatShark

sick sentinel
#

If you going to say well I've played since vainilla that doesn't apply to new players and the general wow pop

#

You can't put urself into everyone else

supple path
#

So yeah, guess I'm nitpicking word use.

raven kernel
#

my regular disc healer mentioned once that she likes how i tank compared to others, because i'm way more calculated

#

and i think that word is the key point

sand egret
#

healers notice good tanks more than anything, imho

cinder nova
#

Vectis blows

brave jetty
#

i'm fine with it, I don't think anything about the role or Warriors in particular is immensely challenging to perform

supple path
#

@sand egret Except of course retadins with wisdom on themselves

sand egret
#

lol

brave jetty
#

at the individual level WoW really isn't that demanding of a video game lol

sick sentinel
#

It is

#

Lfr exists

cinder nova
#

Finished Mythic last night and I felt like I had so little control over my intake

brave jetty
#

at the individual level

#

if LFR is hard it's because others are bad and may be totally out of your control

sand egret
#

Swole, it may be worth it to drop a log in here

neon tangle
#

@brave jetty I sorta disagree, everyone likes to meme that wow is easy, but it's still taken a long af time for guilds to kill m g'huun

brave jetty
#

I'm not talking about the game in general

supple path
#

WoW's challenge is getting 20 people to be perfect simultaneously.

brave jetty
#

I'm talking about AT THE INDIVIDUAL LEVEL

supple path
#

Any task where that's even feasible, most individuals are going to be perfect more attempts than not

brave jetty
#

The difficulty of group coordination and content is a different dynamic

neon tangle
#

@brave jetty At the individual level it's the little mistakes that snowball in to a boss not dying

sand egret
#

there's one aspect you are neglecting at an individual level that many, many players take for granted

vagrant cape
#

@digital arrow hey man, sorry this is late, but I'm looking over these logs you sent me:
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/3aWFXj9TR7Kzcd82/#fight=last&type=casts&source=2

Just gotta jot as I see stuff:

Vectis:

  1. Only 1 spell reflect on heroic vectis. You could be using that a LOT more in a 5-minute encounter.
  2. On vectis, no demo shout on pull? was it on CD? just seems odd.
  3. Your first avatar on vectis is kinda wonky. You has several moments where you either had more than 1 global between TCs or no globals between TCs. You always want your avatars to be TC > other thing > TC > other thing for the full 20 seconds.
  4. Only 30% uptime on demo shout for vectis. Even with the transition phases, it's rather low. This may be due to not using it on pull.

Zek:
5. On zek, not a single spell reflect was used. Make sure you use it on every void lash.
6. Again, very strange casts during avatar. You open with avatar > TC > SS > dem shout > TC > devastate > revenge > shield slam > TC > TC > devastate > revenge > SS > revenge > TC. See number 3.
7. On a 6-minute fight, last stand was only used twice. you can actually use last stand every single void lash/shatter combo if youspend enough rage.
8. You took 23 melees and 1 shatter without having SB/LS/SW up. With the tank swapping, you should have plenty of time to have something up for the entire duration you have aggro.
9. You used shield block during last stand at one point, try to break that habit.
10. I checked your fetid pull, too. your avatar rotation appears to be suboptimal for every encounter. I'd recommend practicing the avatar rotation on a dummy. the priority during avatar is TC > SS > freevenge (or revenge if you're high on rage) > devastate

brave jetty
#

But speaking in terms of what it takes to play your character nearly optimally, just mechanically, in terms of execution and then in terms of game knowledge, WoW doesn't have shit on like, most other competitive games

sand egret
#

WoW also weighs heavily on tribal knowledge for their design

#

so saying an individual burden isn't demanding needs to be clarified

brave jetty
#

I've described the distinction a few different ways lol

lusty grotto
#

i kinda of agree with @brave jetty , but then again people in here are generally not mainstream normie gamers

digital arrow
#

@vagrant cape i really appreciate it

sand egret
#

not in respect to tribal knowledge and barrier of entry

lusty grotto
#

they want to jump in, get loot, have fun... that's something we need to see too

supple path
#

There aren't any really wonky oddball fights right now, too.

sand egret
#

the concept of "don't stand in the fire" is actually a product of teaching over years in this game

frosty wedge
#

then they made shimmering haven

supple path
#

Everything's pretty much the same standard dodge, tank, taunt, soak, drop.

sand egret
#

in fact, an entire boss fight in Molten Core was JUST this mechanic

brave jetty
#

Yeah but those meta conventions can be a thing in other games too

#

Like how you position and take cover in say, an FPS

sand egret
#

dispelling WAS a fight

supple path
#

Ahhh, Lucifron. You taught me about dispelling mind control with purge.

sand egret
#

yeah but a lot of WoW now takes that for granted, especially when asking a new player to pick up on UI conventions used for the past 10 years

#

Im not totally disagreeing with you

supple path
#

WoW ran into the problem that boss mods are bullshit.

brave jetty
#

In terms of individual performance, WoW at the highest level of group content like, can't be as difficult as a lot of other game types, because you're multiplying a margin for error across more people, it has to be a little more forgiving in a way

sand egret
#

but there most definitely is an element of a burden of knowledge that is growing with every content drop that needs to be internalized

supple path
#

So a tons of things that used to add difficulty to a fight don't anymore.

brave jetty
#

I get your point, but those things most definitely exist in other genres too

supple path
#

DBM would trivialize basically every encounter in vanilla.

sand egret
#

decursive

supple path
#

Decursive was mainly even necessary since UIs were utter shit about displaying debuffs, too.

neon tangle
#

@brave jetty I agree w/ that

sand egret
#

molten core was actually Raiding 101 when you think about it

#

First boss = Dispel 101

#

2nd Boss = Kill all adds at the same time

brave jetty
#

Like I said, the concept of cover and high ground in an FPS, or zoning in a MOBA, or footsies in an FPS

sand egret
#

but even then

neon tangle
#

@sand egret KT was bag managment

brave jetty
#

There are things that get baked in until they become instinct, all over the place

sand egret
#

those are still born out of other things

#

WoW is it's own resource

#

it literally set the paradigm

lusty grotto
#

right but those are general concepts, you still have to manage you character and others (healers)

brave jetty
#

...no?

sand egret
#

zoning in a moba came from creeping in wc3

lusty grotto
#

zoning? you mean jukes?

brave jetty
#

WoW is not the first game to have taught gameplay dynamics

supple path
#

Think 'zone defense' more - it's about keeping the enemy out of an area with valuable stuff.

sand egret
#

WoW, introduced a lot of convetions today

brave jetty
#

and not the first to have iterated on those more and more

lusty grotto
#

oh right

#

you mean tower camping

sand egret
#

especially when it comes to raid design

supple path
#

Or keeping the enemy out of range of exp, etc.

sand egret
#

that's what I meant

neon tangle
#

I'm personally a fan of the "keep two enemies apart"

lusty grotto
#

eh i gotta be honest i didn't do that shit at all in dota2

supple path
#

DotA2 - example of how a game can be hard with 4 abilities, yeah.

sand egret
#

namely the concept of the rpg element added to the Hero in wc3 and how to manipulate that based on radius-based exp tracking

lusty grotto
#

i understand

#

but denies are a thing

#

😃

sand egret
#

also a wc3 thing for that same reason 😃

lusty grotto
#

so zoning might be less valuable in dota2

sand egret
#

yeah the term is more used to team fight dynamics and space denial now

supple path
#

"zoning ult"

lusty grotto
#

i think the most important concept is Map Awareness

#

that obviously includes positioning

#

that covers so many bases in WoW and is easily developed in other genres

#

mobas, BRs, competitive FPSes

sand egret
#

yeah map awareness definitely translates into "raid awareness" in WoW

stark sage
#

its a bit different, raid awareness can be memorized after repitition

#

in a game like dota, you have to really be aware of your opponents

sand egret
#

if the pattern is the same

lusty grotto
#

true

sand egret
#

fo sure

supple path
#

If WoW really wanted to up its skill requirement, the real answer would be dynamic patterns/etc. yeah.

stark sage
#

raid encounters are very repititious

#

even with what RNG that does exist, you are prepared for several outcomes to that RNG

supple path
#

just wait until those goddamn island expedition NPCs are a raid boss

sand egret
#

most definitely, but fundamentally not as much as something like FFXIV which is literally an identical fight every time

supple path
#

oh god FFXIV

#

where playing perfectly is hitting 97 keys in the same exact order, EVERY time

#

Pretty sure I had entire dungeon runs with 100% identical globals.

stark sage
#

yeah FF14 paradigm is a bit different, they make their encounters with the express design that you can memorize the perfect positioning and rotation down to the GCD

#

in most cases

junior ivy
#

that doesnt sopund fun

#

sound

sand egret
#

yeah eastern vs western design

stark sage
#

some class do have RNG and some fights arent designed that way

junior ivy
#

i like a bit of unpredictability

raven kernel
#

ff14 fights are super scripted man

supple path
#

They also ban you for mentioning damage meters!

sand egret
#

they favor execution over complexity

raven kernel
#

only occasional RNG mechanic

stark sage
#

it allows them to make very flashy and intensely visual encounters

sand egret
#

yeah tuning is VERY tight

supple path
#

Yeah, FFXIV has legitimately super challenging bosses in spite of that, they're just more...choreographed dances than fights.

sand egret
#

because they can

#

yep

raven kernel
#

yeah

#

literally learn the dance

stark sage
#

you can watch a video and replicate the pros and succeed the encounter as long as your gear is good enough

sand egret
#

I mentioned this earlier today, but a WoW raid designer wrote an article as also an avvid FFXIV raider about the differences in design

raven kernel
#

you can play the same way almost every pull

#

part of that is also why stuff is quite puggable to a certain extent

#

like japanese pugs are pretty good

sand egret
#

and it boils down to: Western style design favors teaching a mechanic, then altering that mechanic in different ways to see how people react

raven kernel
#

because everyone knows exactly their own role

supple path
#

Is FFXIV still embracing the insanely tight enrage timer as its answer to all things?

raven kernel
#

and just does it

stark sage
#

the encounter design if ff14 isnt bad, and its not boring per se. but content remains relevant for longer and most of the time its a 50 second fight that lasts the majority of your opening rotation

sand egret
#

Eastern is all about layering simpler, more punishing mechanics

#

to create complexity

lusty grotto
#

I like insane enrage timers

sand egret
#

instead of making the mechanics complex themselves

raven kernel
#

some of the ffxiv fights still make you sweat though

supple path
#

If you enjoy leashing because one of the dps in your raid had a bad opener and is 8% below their usual numbers, you'd enjoy ffxiv.

raven kernel
#

even though you know exactly what you need to do

sand egret
#

I thik neither is better or worse

#

it's just very different

raven kernel
#

not messing up 1 step of a 1000 step dance

lusty grotto
#

I did play ffxiv up to 2nd expac

supple path
#

Yeah, that combined with potentially long fights.

lusty grotto
#

Black mage tho

raven kernel
#

yeah the fights are usually long

supple path
#

I just wish eastern MMOs would drop some of the unfun bullshit that makes them non-feasible games.

sand egret
#

but remember, FFXIV also has shit like....in combat group rez

#

haha

supple path
#

Like the inevitable "farm this for 2 years" thing.

stark sage
#

one thing i dislike about ff14 encounter design, is often times you reach a 'save point' inbetween phases so if you clear p1 and wipe in p2, you restart at p2... this also allows you to change your group composition inbetween phases

raven kernel
#

thats only for certain bosses

#

and the p2 is pretty much an entire new boss just with the same name

stark sage
#

its still something that is bad for encounter design in my opinion

raven kernel
#

i guess

#

but if you had to do p1 as well every pull

sand egret
#

I disagree a bit

raven kernel
#

holy fuck its stressful

sand egret
#

if the design was created holistically first, then segmented

stark sage
#

imagine having a 3 phase fight, where the meta group comp was different for each phase

supple path
#

I don't really get why you don't just make them distinct encounters at that point.

sand egret
#

they basically are

stark sage
#

now i know the meta comp in ff14 has remained fairly consistent

raven kernel
#

would fucking kms if i had to redo exdeath everytime i wiped on neo exdeath man

supple path
#

Still wish an actually decent game would do stuff like go in a weird direction with the combat system ala TERA

#

So tired of the choices being "WoW" and "WoW, but worse"

raven kernel
#

i do wish wow encounters would look as visually impressive as ffxiv

#

oh plus the audio

#

ffxiv best boss music

lusty grotto
#

oh yeah

raven kernel
#

on like every boss

lusty grotto
#

i remember the titan song

supple path
#

I love "Answers" and I'm not ashamed to admit it.

lusty grotto
#

my wow music has been off since tbc lol

raven kernel
#

just watch this

#

the p1 to p2 transition

lusty grotto
#

i just blasted mp3s and now spotify during play time

raven kernel
#

its poggers af

lusty grotto
#

but i def had ffxiv music on at all times

sand egret
#

I will say

#

that sound track was fucking DOPE

dusk locust
#

dang that's cool looking

sand egret
#

@supple path if you haven't looked at BDO, their combat system is very cool (similar to TERA)

earnest zinc
#

Isn't BDO a P2W piece of shit?

raven kernel
#

no

sand egret
#

eh, no

#

it's very.....MMO-y

#

like my coworker literally does one thing in the game. He runs his merchant caravan from Town A to Town B and trades

#

there's no universal bank, so imagine you had gold in Dalaran but when you showed up to IF you'd have a different account. You'd have to go to Dalaran to pull out that gold

supple path
#

Honestly probably worth glancing at next time wow has a good ol' content dearth. Thanks.

sand egret
#

it's pretty vast and a lot to take in, but the combat was really cool

stark sage
#

eastern mmo 😬

sand egret
#

it's definitely an eastern one haha

raven kernel
#

combat requires alot of skill if you want to compete at top level

sand egret
#

pvp is straight up kinda nuts

supple path
#

Yeaaah. The big concern is just that they're fun for 6 weeks then oops the end game is actually considered a warcrime in certain countries.

sand egret
#

you do grind a lot haha

raven kernel
#

id say dont go into bdo unless you plan to spend at least a few months in it

left ice
#

can I get 20k dps single target as prot?

supple path
#

Still remember the time I realized it'd take me like 2 years at BEST to get my dynamis weapon in FF11.

raven kernel
#

nobody gets 20k single target

sand egret
#

yeah, you really can't "lightly" just hop into a game like BDO

supple path
#

I hit 20k dps the other day when I used my big red button trinket on a 20k hp monster.

#

that's...basically your only real scenario.

left ice
#

if I git gud I can do 20k

stark sage
#

top parse on mother is like 18k

#

and that fight has a huge dps steriod

sand egret
#

I heard Lala's Heroic Throw nets him 20k dps....

lusty grotto
#

😱