#protection
1 messages · Page 2132 of 1
its the person behind the keyboard
how is it a personal problem when its literally impossible to keep it up indefinitely
keeping sb up should be something you do well
wtf are you saying
do you not have Bolster?
and theres a minor gap untilm the next rotation
wtf?
theres always a gap.
I think youre full of shit tbh
how are you having problems keepign any sort of blocking up with bolster?
because even with hero up, after 3 blocks? youre out son
and you ahve to use IP to cover yourself
uhh......
yeah nimchip you are 100% talking out your ass here LOL
uh fucking last stand
you can't keep 100% uptime on shield block in m+
"last stand", lul
we were talking about MYTHIC +
SB X 3 > last stand > SB X 3
using last stand as part of the rotation doesnt solve the issues
last stand, please read your bolster talent
cause you only have it for one pack
eranorz
with AM its up a lot lol
AM reduces its cd
thats our entire kit
🤷
sure, but doesnt solve the blocking problems
literally throw cd's out
the entire reason prot is bad in m+ is that our mitigation isn't up for every pack
just to get em back up to use again very quickly
it helps, but doesnt solve it
Please go back and read the Bolster talent @neat harbor
you dumb fuck I know it reduces the CD of last stand
and blocks
still doesnt solve the problems
why don't we calm down a bit
and youre full of it if you think you can keep uptime on ShB at 100%
Probably because you're talking to people like we're 5 year olds
and like the other guy said, talking out of your ass
you can, in m+
And you're wrong at the same time
thanks matta
You absolutely literally 100% cannot
plus you should have Demo up for a good deal
feels good to see reason triumph over idiocy
If you could, prot would be good in m+
how can you not?
Because you can't
does trash last 2 hours for you guys?
Please link me your raider.io page to show me how good you are at having literally 100% uptime on blocking
but anyways, as a BrM (my alt), 100% uptime on mitigation is literally braindead.
like its not even a chore, its the most braindead shit in the world
shrug?
because the ironskin brew duration, STACKS with itself now
no one is argueing that
Actually never mind
imagine if you could shield block twice and it just added to the duration
but apparently haste soft cap is somehwere around 30%
thats ironskin brew, except with 100% uptime
i dont want ot test it too much
there arent any haste caps
@neat harbor uh... that's how shield block works...
i guess its hard to press LS when you have a gap on SB.
I said soft cap
there are no soft caps
?
There are most definitely soft caps
wrong
nope, none
@lusty grotto dude please just stop you are so insanely incorrect
not for warriors any ways
if you are actually good at m+ you are constantly pulling new shit
you don't have time to regen SB uptime
nah you two don't get that you SB only on melee damage, that might be why you apparently have abysmal uptime on blocked damage
Nim you are dumb son, you get meleed and casted on all the time
I will chime in and say 100% sb uptime is probably wrong
no because you know you're wrong
because you're fucking garbage
you probably haven't timed a 10
nobody did say 100% sb actually
feel free to link it
and before I forget, thats another big problem with shield block, is that its only useful situationally as our core mitigation.
back when IP was actually good, it wasnt an issue
and we could actually enjoy having two types of mitigation
ctrl+shift+s and then paste works
now that IP is shit, we just get shredded by magic damage all the time
Please link me your raider.io page to show me how good you are at having literally 100% uptime on blocking
@lusty grotto
someone said that
............
he actually didnt, you guys did kind of put wordsinto his mouth and then ran with it
I was the one who said that not him lol
hes talking out his ass hes probably done like a +6
yea that was Mattacate
ya, you guys said it not him lol
Ah my b
But my point stands that until you link your raider.io you have no idea how keys work and are garbage
I’m fairly sure this guy did say u can keep it up 100% in M+
He probably did a +7 last week and is here giving us all advice on how our mitigation is fine
Yeah whatever dude you didn't say literally 100% you got me
nope
@round vortex i am too but i dont wanna argue
Your point was still that you should have SB up all the time which is not reality
because youre making false statements
me either 😦
and being condescending even though you are fucking clueless
Comparing PvE Epeens
literally going out of their way to invalidate any points with e-peen
is why
Because you're talking like you have any idea how to play, when you don't
he only asked how you have trouble keeping some thing up which isnt difficult to keep up, not really his fault you guys misinterpreted it
Nim, when every conversation you have here turns into a raging shitfest where everyone is trashing you
It might be worth thinking about why that is happening
uh huh
oh damn
Is there a relatively easy to use resource that will generate stat weights for prot? Cursory glances show it's generally just dps stat weights available.
TLDR: if you dont know what youre talking about please dont spread misinformation, its detrimental to balance discussions
@hallow kestrel no
question: if you're going to spend all your rage arguing over the internet, how are you going to be able to cast shield block in the first place
you are not talking about balance, you are whining @neat harbor we have all heard it before
you can only sim for DPS but i don't know if prot warrior has a working simc module
@hallow kestrel no, we have no way of gaining stat weights, our priority is really simple though
we dn't
@open bluff this is why you always spec anger management
Even though I don’t think Eranorz should not be talking to people how he is, the Nimchip guy has his facts wrong. But I think he’s enjoying defending it to someone who is triggered easily.
side note, why isn't anger management baseline for every spec
everyone loves playing with it on every spec
@chrome falcon i wish they had made it a stat like they were talking about in legion i believe, it was going to be on gear iirc and would be available to every spec
Sure, it's simple, but rings and ilvl >:| is it worth taking a ~75 haste hit for the stam upgrade on 20 ilvls worth of a ring?
yeah
20 ilvls is an upgrade on rings unless socket
the only time you really want to be concerned about ring upgrades is 10 ilvls at max and some argue thats still an upgrade
What's the necrotic buff name?
word. Thanks for the input all.
*debuff
10 seconds
So can anyone explain why 40 haste at 17.5% is a .53% increase but with max ITF 40 haste is a .61% increase?
It's not just about the stamina, you gain more total secondary stats as well unless like ironkuting said and you have a socket on the lower piece.
oh, name
tyty
hey guys, any idea why .io isn't showing up on my alt?
i usually think of 10ilvl upgrades on rings as upgrade unless im just going from a real shit itemized ring to bis
it's so tilting that LS doesn't heal us through necrotic anymore
typical blizzard making a "clarity" change and actually nerfing us a lot for affixes in the process
blockade ^^
hey guys, sorry - I've been at work all day, so I apologize if this has been asked and answered a thousand times already, but did anything change today with the updates? A rogue friend of mine said he got fucked by the changes today, so I'm wondering if prot had any changes I should know of..
@rugged plinth ITS doesnt scale linearly if im thinking about that wording correctly
ITF
a trait got buffed, that's about it
some one can probably explain it beter but it has to do with math i think
what was the trait?
Rienforced plating
reinforced plating buffed by 10%
ITF scales your total haste up. so if you have 0 haste ITF takes 100 x 1.15 (assuming ITF is stacked to 15%) and if you have 20% haste it takes 120 x 1.15.
it's still worthless garbage that you shouldn't take
in this case it actually gave you 18% haste instead of 15%
basically the more haste you have, the better ITF actually gets
Worth losing DC and going to RP 15 level upgrade for raids?
i thought it was a falt 15%? seems that way on my car sheet
Though so
Definitely not.
nope
right
i have 16% haste and when i have 5 stacks im at 33% haste
where do these numbers come from / go ? i when i stand next to people and turn it on my haste goes up exactly 15%
What's your haste at normally?
how much haste do you have?
13%
It's giving you 16.95% then.
and you should see either 129 or 130% on your sheet with 5 stacks.
in what context
assuming you lose 2 haste if you take 3 mastery, and vice versa, I'd go with the 2 haste, personally
i mean in what pieces of gear, trinkets, rings, what
just rings
same ilvl go with haste
Yea i dont think ilvl matters too much ESPECIALLY on rings
ilvl matters a lot
definitely does
maybe not as much on rings, but it still matters
same ilvl only use the stat priority
rings are the only exception, and thats only a 5-10 personal preference but i still choose 10 ilvls upgrade
So you would really use for example a 360 crit/vers ring over 350 haste/mastery ring?
is the 1k hp from stam that big of a difference
- the secondaries, we need to think more about total stat budget over just specific secondaries
not just about stam either, it's about how much of each stat is gained from the ilevel increase
stam+secondary+ secondary = total
Is there a way i can link my char and you can see whats in my bags?
our stats are very close together in terms of performance, and this expac so far secondaries arent as impactful as they have been in the past
can do /simc and use that string in compare gear in raidbots
nope
can't sim defensively
they arent asking to sim
but you can see the items he has
hes asking if he can show us his gear
to be fair
asking about sims and stat weights and pawn strings 700,000 times a day takes its toll
we go into auto mode
Yo I got this 360 WF axe off a raccoon - Kelada's Elucidation.. and I know we wanna prioritize ilvl and shit, but like.. my 340 weapon isn't that far off and has haste/vers, vs Crit/Mast on the axe... I hate that I already know the answer to this question, but is there any chance that my 340 should stay equipped and I could just sell the damn axe and make a few hundred k?
like 20 ilvls.. orrrrr a couple wow tokens... lol
and you know the week you equip it youll get one
exactly..
I'd tell my raidleader that I'll equip the axe if they pay for my sub for 2 months
I am the raid leader 😦
Still applies
Won't be hard to make that deal
Equip and buy 2 months for yourself
Hhahahaha
"Yo I got this 360 WF axe off a raccoon"
Lol i read that as that mexican guy from antman with the stories
Just be semi-lucky and semi-unlucky like me
Just got a 370 Lingering Sporepods, thoughts on whether or not to use that over a 360 syringe?
Get the crit axe off of fetid
spore is garbage, idk about syringe but its most likely better
Yo dudes
you know how we block shit?
but then we've got parry and dodge
but like.. our main shit is blocking
well.. how do druids do anything
bur.
See ya guys, Imma be bur.
I hope you like licking drywall or watching plants grow...from seed, without blinking
Both hold more entertainment
than Guardian
Nah forreal though, I was over in the guardian druid discord for a second and I asked them, for shits and giggles, how they'd rank guardian vs prot, and I got an overwhelming response that was like "Prot is terrible - we're not the greatest, but prot is worse)
Because bear is what you play
I thought that was funny.. so... Skyhold.. why are we better than a fuckin bur?
when you can't understand planning ahead
xD
Because we're more entertaining than calorie free tofu
Question about gear: Got 370 shoulders from weekly chest but the azerite traits are shit. I'd lose deafening crash upgrading from my 340 shoulders. My helm is like 370 BIS traits and my chest is 355 BIS traits. I could go with a 340 chest to get deafening crash back but is it worth it? I really depend on deafening crash in higher M+ keys so don't want to lose it but this just doesn't feel like an upgrade despite 30 ilvl
except everyone with soy allergies
@midnight citrus the general consensus here is that DC is worth 25 ilvls
but if you can always switch it in and out as needed if you think you need that DC trait
so replacing a 340 DC with a 370 Iron Fortress or BfI SHOULD be a net gain in survivability
I do not know about Bloodspout I have never used it
bloodsport my fav trait atm
have a 60k absorb up for majority of dungeon is great
still shit
why is it shit, guys?
I feel like you have strong feelings about this
I'd love to know more
its measurable impact on our survivability is considerably smaller than the other traits
there is a reason why that crappy Revenge one is above it
which requires you to USE REVENGE
I use revenge a lot to dump rage for AM
after I have SB on CD and almost capped IP
So, ya... our guild OT has a funeral to go to, so I was volunteered into being OT. I really play arms 90%.... this prot thing, I glanced at guides a quick bit, rotate some demo, ip, ls, sw, keep block up as much as I can and pray? We’re doing a quick N uldir to get my feet wet. Any Clippy advice?
I dont have rage for revenge as keep my IP rolling since stacked bloodsprot because of the gear i have. works well with way i play
ummm youre gonna have a hard time voltz
Don't layer SB with Last Stand
since I got the IP tracker weak aura I found myself using IP more
(like don't hit them at the same time)
how do i copy from pasted?
the pasted source code is super long
ddo i have to drag and copy??
Overwhelming power over strength in numbers?
ctrl-a selects all
ctrl+a
Rip me, 380 Servant Splitter out of chest, is it even worth using over a 370 weapon with crit/vers?
Strength in numbers imo, the hp can be a good buffer
you're welcome
Figured, the damage taken dropping stacks doesnt seem all that great
in necrotic week it is worth IMO because you can put bleed and kite
you dont need the hp from SIN on bosses anyway as trash is our biggest issue in terms of survival
@fair brook i suggest also looking at the spell reflect or blockables list in the guide to see what to use spell reflect on, but keep demo shout on cd, if you have dc trait you should always keep extending it with tclap weaving
dont over ride bolster with sshield block
or vice versa
I have 2 DC, I’ll keep an eye on that, ty
you should have only 1 DC
demo shout has half the cd on avatar
it does not stack
Oh
so you can always avatar + demo, then demo, then ava + demo
Anyone have a list of Azerite trait order for prot that’s up to date? I can’t seem to find one nor a sticky.
icyveins is fairly up to date
DC> BfI> IF
Thanks. Isn’t icy veins from launch tho?
Hmm cool
idk if theyve updated actual numbers with the uldir trait but the rest should be
I actually hate Brace for Impact
not gonna lie
I think it's like.. the shittiest fuckin azerite trait
Brace is my favourite trait for single target
@steel mauve "our stats are very close together in terms of performance, and this expac so far secondaries arent as impactful as they have been in the past" Interesting. I may have given too much value to haste+mastery with my tank set if this is the case. would you still rate for instance, something 10ilvls higher with crit vers over something with haste mastery 10 ilvls lower?
I mean I know, numbers-wise, it's great, but I don't like it.
Out of these 4, which would be the best combo?
yes easily
on armor ilvl ALWAYS wins, even 5 ilvls wins on armor piecesz the only circumstances are sockets, trinkets, rings and possibly weapons @neat harbor rings i would itemize 5 ilvls, and 10 ilvls would be an upgrade for me personally
do you have DC on any other piece?
shields ilvl are always an upgrade due to the block on it
No just that chest
Brace Chest + DC Shoulder
I do on a helm too but a 340 and currently have 370 BIS traits otherwise in helm
shoulder?>
how do u bring up evilui?
/elvui
no just the 340 shoulders in the pic
@winter skiff it's "E L V" not "E V I L"
it's whether to upgrade them to the 370s then downgrade chest to 340, or just go 355 and 340 and keep all good traits
got with 2nd and 4rth IMO
weird doesnt come up for me
Gah. Cant decide on which tank class
maybe i didnt download the add? but i added all diff evlui ones
@undone hollow wrong forum you're looking for the monk or dk discord
alt+f4 @winter skiff
@winter skiff If they don't show up in your addons menu, you won't be able to give commands for it
youll know if you have elvui installed and can type /elvui
@midnight citrus Yeah. But I dont play no pansy ass leather wearer
but i do have it installed
Nor do I play a bad guy
what is the name of hte actually mod?
i got elvui shadow and light, extraactionbars
@steel mauve got it, thanks man
theres so many
and download elvui there
elvui shadow and light still requires elvui base
you can't get elvui through curse/twitch
ohh
😃
Im still using a 345 shield. havent gotten anything to drop from vectis/ghuun or anywhere else D:
Elvui is like using the pre-installed OS with a Dell computer. You get it, and 80 other addons you'll never use
it's bloatware
^incorrect
Im still using the base UI
@neat harbor that was me for a log log while
I use elvui to replace basically every other addon for UI stuff
with a 340 shield doing 10s
If you make your own UI, at least you understand how to use the addons
just spam more M+ my dude
when i download it what i do now?
you have to go to your wow folder, find the "Addons" folder, and copy the files into that folder
@sick sentinel haha yeah Ive actually got a 375 heroic one hander to go with my 345 shield. wish they were reversed
one of the few useful pieces Ive gotten from my M+ chest tbh
LOL yeah end times is currently fucked.
I am an EU boy, do we get anything good from timewalking?
just make sure you dont LFG it lol
Norm uldir cache
no no, endtimes is broken
how so?
sylvanas is super overtuned
someone just told me that too
you basically have to lust to kill a ghoul
about end times
there's posts up on reddit about it as well
also gear warforging in timewalking is coming in LOWER than normal timewalking gear, lol
So, is the direbrew trinket worth using atll?
NA guinea pigs, lol
thoughts on Archive of titans vs. Brace for impact?
how buffed is the stats?
should be 3 stacks or so, generally you want 1 reorigination array trait for uldir
how is the boe boot+shield combo? is there a ceiling on the price for it?
thing is, do you use Archive outside of Uldir?
are any of the uldir traits actually worth using in m+?
i dont think so. its the reorigination array that is actually good not the trait itself
best uldir trait is archive though
I have a 355 archive, should I use that or 355 BFI in M+?
bfi
Are folks more fond of "Shimmering Haven" or "Elemental Whirl" more?
i strongly dislike haven
Just because of the need to have to be glued somewhere or is it something else?
ya pretty much
cant always stay in one spot, except maybe in raids
its got good stats, i just personally dont like it
yah for certain affixes its bad
sanguine
quaking
necrotic
anything you have to move a lot for
its probly fine for volcanic, not too high movement for it
Legion legos like Mannoroth Bracers working in TW dungeons, boy do I miss actually self healing again. I dare say its actually.... fun?
wait, they do?
YEAH MAN
LOL
they get scaled down to 108 like everything else, currently doing 20% of my overall healing
Anyone try time walking yet? Just went in there and got destroyed lol
i would actually like to see what i'm doing rather than use sco's UI
i did 4 TWs on my 118 druid healing and it was fine but i heard bad things about end times
@subtle fable use your legion legendaries
Ahh yeah was in end times
Legos would help, didn't think of that - thanks!
Mr. Pokesduhbear
did you call him daddy
Didn't get the chance.
3 seconds after the platform broke I would die through cooldowns
Said sorry warrior problems and left the pug
I'm trying to sort out some last moment gearing my first run as prot tonight. Does the block from IF stack? I'm thinking of running 1 DC and 2 IF, since I just learned DC's reduction doesnt stack
ya IF stacks
ty
Thoughts on 1 Dc, 1 IF, and 1 archive for doing uldir? I can swap the archive for another IF
man idk what to play now 333 ilvl and no one will accept me for anything
if you have been keeping up with boss kills i would probably do archive ovcer IF
my warrior is 342 but i dont want to make it a dps
@candid cove same, my group just wiped to baine as well. timewalking scaling feels broke AF atm.
he exploded your platform then everyone just melts to lava in 3 seconds
tried to heroic leap to another island
"No path available"
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
Ahahaha. Saved from tanking tonight. Raid leader is making a feral go guardian because my dps is much higher than his. whew Not that I'd mind trying prot in raid, but I want more than 1 day to prepare since I"m new to it.
Bears are a lot less of a skill need too
he can just sit there and soak with his massive health pool
yikes
@neat harbor yeah, the one time i made it out of the lava he just came up on the platform and laughed at all my cds as he gets a 6kdps dot rolling on top of his melees
gz lala
I thought you couldn't get warforged/titanforged shields anymore?
i think they can WF just cant TF
Did blizzard ever provide any rationale for that btw?
Well
I was gonna link my shield because I was happy to finally get it to drop but then @hot locust deflated my happiness
wimpy 370
i got the 370 of it from the cache, so i was happy
ya the block is massive on shield upgrades
I got a 345 but I need something for these m8 +... specially that last week with fortified...
My chest this week was literally the only slot where a 375 wouldn't be an upgrade
-_____________-
Also: what'as the angle in being hit from behind where you can't block/parry?
is it the full 180 degrees or is it more generous than that?
could someone tell me what to do against the pack with the irontide mastiff in it in freehold? I'm unable to tank them and too retarded to kite them :D?
a question on Mythrax. am I safe to taunt AS he's casting shear?
or should I wait for him to finish?
let finish
cc the adds that can be cc'ed?
@lucid kelp let him finish the cast
is it worth having more than 1 archive trait?
@lucid kelp When your taking the shear however make sure spell reflect is up it makes a HUGE difference
Noice 😄
tfw you already had mythic taloc pants with socket and tonight 395 socketless version drops
FeelsBadMan
Archive vs BFI ?
is DC worth 15 ilvls over shoudlers with iron fortress instead?
i thought i saw DC was worth like 20-30 ilvls?
i cant remember who napkin mathed it but it nearly breaks even at about 45 ilvls, and thats kind of quick napkin math, idk how accurate
wow an answer from marok himself lol
well that settles it
right now i got 370 chest with callous reprisal, 355 helm with brace for impact
and 340 shoulders with deafening crash
where can i replace the shoulders with better ones that also have dc?
or like what should i do?
hope you get lucky in m+ cache each week
hailstone construct drops the 355 ilvl shoulder with dc but its a world boss
theres no dc in uldir
your only chance is m+ cache and the world boss dropping a 355
" lets make a trait that is really good for prot warriors but don't put it on any gear of the azerite gear" seems legit
How does archive compare to brace for impact?
Prot warrior is decent for regular mythic and heroic dungeons yes?
Prot warrior is decent for anything
Alright cool. Making my way back to my warrior from all the other melee classes so just making sure
without good aoe, the first boss in tol dagor is absolute aids on necrotic
even if i can clear the first group of bugs on my own, theres no way i can clear the second one and then necrotic just kill
Gotcha. I dont really do mythic plus since I'm a casual now lol but the basics heroics mythics and lfr prot wars so fine all I care about
from your experience how does gemhide compare to impassive?
i already have one impassive and stacking sounds nice but gemhide is one of the best inner ring traits
Any1 got tips for dealing with rupturing blood on Zul?
have yet to live thru that fight
anyone got any neat hacks for zekvoz mythic?
y'all running rumbling earth or stormbolt for m+?
@devout crypt 3 tank it and swap on 2 stacks, also stay in group until about 3-5 seconds left on debuff then run out
Much easier to survive if you’re generating rage and are in range of your heals
@chilly brook my group wasnt using a 3 tank strat, i might introduce that next week. We sort of used BoP as a crutch but i still died :^)
did the math and 1 instance of 1 stack of that dot is 1 ignore pain cast 🤔
Hence why you want to continue to generate rage
At two stacks it basically one taps one IP
But that being said that’s 30ish thousand damage that you don’t take
And that adds up in that phase
vectus trinket with leech on heroic better then a normal mythrax trinket? not sure how much the leech plays in
play a class with working sims ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Considering that’s like one of the only things I have to complain about I think I’m happy with playing prot
im sorry if this question has been asked like 10x before but is ilevel still king for trinkets?
i have a jes howler and a rezan eye and both are 345, but i just got a 360 gore crusted butcher's block and it's 247 strength and gives me 15 seconds of extra crit
Ilvl has never been king for trinkets
Howler is still gonna be better than crust block most likely
Thank you, Ironkuting
Howler + Blockades still bis for DEFENSIVE.

king's rest is so tough to pug, always someone who ignores the gold spit for first boss
always
i end up having no room to kite the boss at the very end of a verrrry slow path around the arena
yep.
I always have a toss up between killing adds or kiting adds, regardless of what I tell them to do haha
In pugs that is
“Killing the adds is best” “no kiting then is best!” Everyone is an expert
Its hilarious how easy that boss is when in a guild run compared to pugs
Yep.
Doom's Fury 370 vs Bloodborne Infirmity 370 vs Blockade?
Was doing KR as Arms. So many stuff there that require you to move out of melee, cant dps for shit ;/ Rather tank it on fortified tbh.
Just so very annoying
Lol @sudden tapir been running into a lotta "experts" lately and they love seeing anyone else's perfectly valid strat fail
Is Mchimba's Ritual Bandages any good for port warriors?
Y’all talking kings rest. Time walking was a crap show tonight. 😂
Yeah did a +9 yesterday and got that trinket but don't know if the use is that great
Went to tol dagor feeling a bit overconfident, apparently, after missing 3chest freehold by 10 seconds
tol dagor 8*
Did you check yourself
buzzers giving necrotic stacks
Before you rekt yourself
My anus was not prepared
bandages is quite bad
“Hush hush carnivale, this won’t be over quickly”
Alright thx @stone crag
Tol Dagor is my new halls of valor. Something just always seems to go bad wrong.
so fo serious, how the hell do I handle the first boss, clear out space and kite?
I’d think you have to. Maybe see how Shakib does it this week
So do the little ticks on the second boss in underrot do stacks as well?
Stack in the center
To bait the charge anyway
Baiting on the sides makes it much harder for rampage
How strong is the blockades trinket btw?
Been using Mythrax + Fatoms since I've felt fairly safe
@ember arrow Yeah i suspect i am shit at DPS-ing 😉 Being melee annoys me to no end. I think, if i ever stop tanking i will be ranged DPS.
did 4/8 M on my prot warrior and just did 4/8 M on my brm monk...
the difference is depressing
Did you take a nap? I would have had to take a nap.
We already have a brm monk in our comp already; so not sure how they’d feel if I hung up prot warr for a second brm haha
our other tank is making his alt a brm monk
they're just too good at the moment for the harder stuff
any good ways for a prot warr to drop stacks for boss in necrotics?
Kite
Certainly a lot less to manage on brm. Though the sentiment for me.. I love the leaping, the slamming, the shield blocking and cooldowns coming off and on with prot.
thunderclap, leap, kite
Yeaaaa, kite. I just leap away at around 15
honestly i absolutely love my prot warrior and hope they change it
Which boss are you facing
I like managing brews, fluidity and tools of BM. Also i like that i can be more attentive to raid mechanics, positioning etc instead of my own cooldowns.
Oh on manor.. yeaaa, if you aren’t outrunning him, keep a battle res and strong dps handy haha
that's my main draw @tight tree
actually playing the fight instead of determining gcds
On BM i can do so much more for my raid. I notice more, positioning wise, can correct some people. On warr i am just clenched all the time and calculating my own globals and watching external CDs bar like a holy grail
I’ll just pop some NZT on prot warr, all good
NZT?
@empty birch If they fix warriors enough, i will jump straight back to it. Now doing BM for progress. We are not top guild, many people do mistakes, playing easier tanks makes tons of difference for us.
Ever watch that movie Limitless, where he pops the mind enhancing drug? Sorry, haha poor reference to that 😂
Playing a protection warrior right now could certainly be aided by some Adderall.
(on unrelated note, Arms wrecking shit out of people in arena. Having a blast with it atm.)
How important is a weapon upgrade for prot warrior? i dont think a better weapon affects rage generation at all, right?
Well it is importand. Defensively shields are more important, but you just want better stats.
A weapon upgrade is as "important" as any other piece of gear - it's going to give you Strength, Armor, and secondaries, which will all increase DPS and survival. A better weapon means better DPS too, which means less threat problems (should you have any / Skittish weeks).
A good weapon will be your most important piece of gear for increasing damage and threat
@tight tree imo being able to focus on the stuff going on around you becomes easier the more you play a certain class, I don’t find myself any less aware when I play warrior as opposed to BrM
But that’s just my experience
I play warrior since TBC, never been a problem. But now it is. I am not getting younger, and current prot warr micromanagement is bit too much for me to feel comfortable.
Also as i said before, i just ideologically disagree with the idea that you fight vs your own class mechanics. I want o fight with bosses.
Worst thing is, warrior feels GOOD overall (mainly thanks to sound and spell design).
Just fix issues and i will never ever think of playing alts.
Could you explain to me how you’re fighting your own class mechanics? @tight tree
I feel that my kit working against me instead of working for me.
Hard to verbalize i guess hmm
I’d assume so? Because it‘ s almost the opposite everything works together so well that if you displace something you notice it
I dont like being punished for things out of my control (example: sb is on cd, healers used externals elswhere). I always think how to work around warrior's limitations.
That’s what stuff like Last Stand and Shield Wall are for
Exactly. They supposed to be oh shit buttons. Idea that i should use them rotationally, just not to die from boss melee swings, does not sit right with me at all.
are we getting a new mastery in 8.1 ?
Then real ohshit situation happens, i will have no answer.
Tbf using a defensive cooldown makes more sense before taking big hits than after taking big hits
@candid niche no one knows
Yes. And i have to use them just not to die (drop low) from regular autoattacks.
not even blizz, kek
;D
The point of the warrior toolkit is to never be in that moment to begin with
And if that means using defensives then so be it
I actually quite enjoy it for one but hey that’s just me being opinionated
Well in a perfect world yes. That never happens (or i am just not good enough)
I fully agree that i must be just too bad for current prot warr design. I do fine in raids and m+ but i want to be more than just fine.
And i always hated and i hate and will always hate the idea of calling externals outside of critical abilities.
By all means play what you’d like I was just curious as to what your reasoning was for that comment
👍🏻
@chilly brook 👌 I like your mindset, and I will always have a warrior. Buuut i want it to be better/more fun.
if you could make any change to prot what would it be ?
and it can be anything at all
A larger absorb volume for IP
^
undo the bfa changes to ip
i'm fine with how warrior plays outside of IP feeling wimpy
I prefer the BFA IP
Minus the fact that it lasts one auto
Bump that volume up to like 90k and we’re in business
Dragon roar is à silence, ravager à vortex like ability, and every time we Block an attack we print à cat pic in the chat
Plus numbers tuning
i think its mess with the bolster talent row. Drop indom and NS and replace them with "All for one" and "One for all" The first one will make shield wall 30% reduction but applys to five targets on use and the second one makes spell reflect a 1 min cd with 30% dmg reduction but is affected by Anger management
@candid niche SB 100% uptime. IP off GCD, or, buff its size. More variety in talents. Add utility for m+ (dispells/ranged silence/banners).
should give us a reason to pick diff talents in the row depending on the situation
@old zephyr CAT PIC ok you win.
Basically i want our mitigation to be less tedious to manage, and i want more utility toys to play with.
what exactly do you consider as utility toys
Remembering what we had and comparing to what we have now is depressing really.
not to bothered by the IP shield atm since it scales with Str and its only the start of the expac but i definitely think it should be off the GCD since its what's supposed to bring our ehp to similar lvls of other tanks but we have to maintain it and it doesn't last too long especially when you have to decide between generating rage and putting yourself in a better situation to handle the inc dmg
inb4 banners
Banners, dispell on shield slam, silence on heroic throw
Vortex-like ravager would be dope too. Maybe if we have all this, warriors will be okay for m+
i don't like how our Active mit is also way gimped in comparison to other tanks who just have to go with the highest primary stat, where as with us its you better roll really well on that one item slot or your blocks are gonna be poop
yeah +1 for vortex ravager
I think prot is just the thinking mans tank, gotta figure out what is the best thing to use in each situations, as opposed to keep stagger up or face tank is and heal lul
its alright you can ignore half of the arrow, i pick the pointy half 😛
I would be fine with thinking man tank, but with all this effort, results are just average.
If they were exceptional, that would be great
But not the case now
Ok, sorry guys, i dont want to bash warriors. It is my favorite class. just venting a bit.
Okay so... I just got the 1hand that has no stats but does a DoT from my m10 cache...
probably useless ye?
gives a bunch of primary stat tho right ?
30 str 60 stam
263 ilvl
355 -> 380 ilvl. Atm I got Haste / Vers 355 weapon
yup
its probs worth, i mean you might wanna wait for one of the big boys to confirm it, but that passive armor and health you will get from its is prolly worth
how much haste would you be dropping ?
i'd use the new wep but again, its worth getting someone who played prot more this expac than me. feel free to ask me any legion questions though 😛
Frustrating.. Would rather have anything else I think
im still crossing my fingers that im gonna get a uber TF shield
ilvl > stats most of the time. since its like a 25 ilvl upgrade you take the upgrade
New weapon is better on almost all cases due to ilvl
Even if i lose on the secondary stats? I feel like haste is super important
yep, you get a ton of haste from into the fray anyway
Alright, thanks
@candid niche
make the effect from Rumbling Earth baseline, and change it's effects to drop a big slow on the ground for X seconds after you press shockwave
Make 3 talents involving DS on the same row, one booming voice giving rage+dmg/AoE silence for X seconds for utility/ idk the third but it could be ''more defensive''
@severe pond i quite like that idea, giving each talent row a more focused effect on the class, like a row based on changing DS and the ideas are pretty sick too, nothing that seems to stand out as this is the go to talent more, pick depending on the situation or your own personal play style
yea, i like the idea from talents to change depending on the situation/encounter/comp
and yeah rumbling earth should be base line, if we cant have abilitys to re position shit we should atleast be able to have a shorter CD aoe stun seems fair to me, also fits well with prots current playstyle (atleast my playstyle for prot) which is run through everything then hope you have something to press when it gets really t one of those oh so fun OH SHIT moments
abilities*
Using mannoroths and thundergod legendaries for timewalking, feels so good..
cant believe i forgot about mannoroths, that should make its way back into the spec as a talent or passive IMO, only problem as a talent is it will have to be a very well balanced row otherwise it'll probably just become a default pick
i think this is the first time in a while i've been hyped for timewalking 😄
Have manaroth compete with AM.
Give UF competitors défensive value (DR gets thubdergods or similar)
Bolster row get à silence on DS and shared SW
i hope people don't mind but I'm collecting these ideas atm, no idea if ill end up trying to do anything with them. but its interesting to see what people think could be changed about my fav spec. and from what i've read so far you guys have some pretty good ideas
For bandaid fixes just until we get a decent rework, just pulling ignore pain and maybe avatar/demo-shout off of GCD would do wonders
thats what I think at least, but I've only been playing for this expansion; last time I played was Wrath... its been a while to say the least
I don’t see how taking IP off the GCD would be a good idea, imo I think it would break us
nah you're right about IP at least, the tool that's supposed to put us into a similar EHP as other tanks that requires us to maintain being on the GCD and having to compete with defensives to stop us dying and offensives to gen rage is silly. hurts its uptime too much. demo shout could come off too, but i don't think avatar should if demo is off the GCD, cause most of the time you'll cast them at the same time so it makes it flow better and gives a a little more uptime on demo shout cause of it.
Well it wouldn’t be a sufficient fix anyway
Of course it would not be sufficient, hence the mention of a 'bandaid'. The way I see it, we are pretty starved for GCD which is why pulling it off of a GCD would help to a certain extent
since if you are using avatar and you have a revenge proc, you don't really have a rage dump if you don't intend on spending it on shield block
break us how ? there is still a cap of 1.3 casts worth of IP and its not like you'll be able to perma spam it and get us to a point where we only ever take 50% of the dmg
If you’re casting IP then you have allready made a decision to use a GCD on a less precious coolsown
a fair argument
it will literally just become a rage dump for shorter cd's after the first cast
I'm curious if they would rework the talents so there would be another viable build other than the current avatar-thunderclap build for dps
but thats what we tend to lack, it also gets rid of that stupid decision of "do you wanna have an absorb and hope the next hit you take isnt gonna be enough to kill you" or do you want to pop a defensive and hope that you get enough healing to allow you to survive til you can get some amount of IP up
I think damage wise we're fine now though
absolutely
yeah the thunderclap trait is just way beyond any of the others and it would be cool to bring dragon roar and the revenge one up a bit, but other than that we have som degree of flexibility in our dps talents
It's just that when I look at my talents and look at the fight, I only really see one, MAYBE two I can change since the rest are borderline essential
yeah thats fair
When I’m tanking 10s and my health drops below 30% even with SB up, tbh I’m not looking for an IP GCD because of how weak the spell is, so even if they took it off I still wouldn’t be using it reactively
i would love if they buffed never surrender or indomidable
More just a way to quickly rebuild my cool downs with anger management
but with the way our rotation works now bolster is prettym uch a necessity
yeah
Poggers
first boss of tol dagor is hell
So much nicer than last week
hes not that bad if you have a decent group that knows how to save their aoe cooldowns, i +2'd a 9 tol easily earlier today
Fortified and teeming can piss off
i was expecting the first boss to be a lot worse than it was
Tyrannical just punished players who don’t do mechanics
with smart dps you rarely take more than a couple hits form the adds before they die
Yea exactly, just play the fight as intended and all is fine
I think prot is very good with tyrannical
And we still have awesome aoe damage, more so this week because in theory we could potentially pull more trash
I really hope we get to keep avatar and thunderclap how it is currently
yeah prot is definitely slightly less trash with week than most weeks for m+
this week*
my group had a s-priest, BM-hunter, and a demon hunter for damage on a +8 and we had significant difficulty with the first boss
tol dagor
ew spriest
i love spell reflect on tyrannical weeks, always puts a grin on my face thinking, i wanna see any other tank fully mitigate that high dmg spell and chunk the boss at the same time
we just lacked the AOE to be able to get all the bugs down consistently
dont spriests have terrible burst aoe and only good sustained aoe? although your demon hunter alone should have toasted those adds
oh yeah he could toast them but the problem was when they spawned spread out
Ya it sounds like you just had a few bad players
and for some reason half the time the boss would upheaval on me every single time, which i have never seen happen before
i didnt even know it could happen to the tank
Yea
Is there a list somewhere of all spells from dungeons that are spell reflect able?
check the pins boyo
yep its in there
i know the mind chaps that do the nasty channel after the second boss in motherlode is spell reflectable
and if you can time it well you can reflect multiple casts at teh same time aslong as they hit at the same time
interesting
i still dont understand why 'shoot' and 'throw rock' or whatever those stupid skills cant be blocked
atleast it doesnt feel like they can be
You cant block ranged attacks
very sad 😦
i mean you cant block a giant demons fists that should crush you but you cant block a small arrow ?
how's that make any sense
arrows go fast
Guys. I have 340 shoulders with the thunderclap trait and earned 385 shoulders with shieldslam trait. What should I do ?? (If I equip those 385 I have no thunderclap trait left)
Because its not like what thats what shield has been used for traditionally
the thunderclap trait is worth 25 itemlevels
so switch to the new shoulders
probably
Ok nice. Thanks you 😃
Okok ty
okay thats interesting, Wasting Strike from Lord Waycrest can be reflected
I was not aware of this
Yup so can the shadow cleave from the guards in the hallways
so can the ? the ability that increases damage you take by 15% from the little miniboss before the final stairway
As in reflect, it just disapears right
I think yeah? you get the reflect sound, and I think it completely stops the damage, but not reflect the damage
But for sure you refelct the 15% damage increase
Same for G'Huun corruption. No debuff to drop.
Also for boss abilities, you can reflect the Nature DoT that Rixxa Flame casts on you in Motherlode.
you have to be fast for that one tho
Does she get it on herself?
cause it isnt 100% that it'll cast one you, probs doesnt help i havent done that fight with timers that show when its cast either
yea
same with wasting strike
Yeah no DBM warning, you literally have to wait until after she fires some azerite goo, attacks a couple times...then you wait...and you can hit the reflect as she casts it, it hits 2 targets.
no it's ALWAYS you and 1 other target
Oh thats good to know for rixxa
Wasting strike is also ALWAYS you.
its not always you
how long is the cast?
but wasting is
kk
i meant wasting's debuff is relfected onto the boss
plenty of time
once you start looking for it you kinda get a spidersense for when its gonna be cast approx.
Trust me if you reflect rixxa's debuff you'll always reflect it, and if you're a dwarf you can self cure the second one...then reflect the third as well.
So you can eliminate the first 3 times she casts it.
(as a dwarf)
Dwarfs op
if its cast on you*
I once tried to shield reflect the debuff on Ghuun but when I do i dont get it, then it swaps to another target as I deflected on somebody else
Idk if this is a bug or not
Khendron, it's literally 100% so far for me. Every single time I've fought her and timed it right, I get a reflect.
definitely doesn't redirect
But there is some in Uldir and plenty overall since bfa
it still targets 3 players in P2
only 1 in P3
but if you reflect it in P2, it's 2 targets
Wamari that's not true; it hits 3 targets, you just eliminate one of them (you)
then you're lucky, im jsut saying its not 100% chance to target you
Ahh ok. Mb so
The visual looks like it redirects to another player after you reflect it. Was wondering that myself
The reflect on the guards is nice though, that ability last week could hit kinda' hard.
Also you can reflect (true reflect) the ? Sand Blast? from the lizard casters in Tol Dagor.
p3 ? there isnt a phase 3 on rixxa
Thats ghuun
Hey guys, sorry if this has been answered earlier, but are any traits outside of uldir worth taking? Other than the prot traits i mean.
you can reflect chain lightning from the shaman boss in the 3 boss fight in King's Rest.
And there was the other bug I had, on zekvoz. Does anybofy had the same thing, when he is doing void tentacle lash and you hide behind a "invisible wall" which makes you out of LOS, Zekvoz stops attacking until he casts a spell
You can also reflect Chain lightning from the witch doctor add in the final fight in ...Temple of sethraliss.
Ok I will try to do it again in LFR or NM and if so, I will report that bug x)
Is Prot getting a buff soon?
Not that it matters, but any basilisk in the VolDun area, while you're world questing..you can reflect their uninterruptable petrifying stare and stone form them for a couple seconds.
I think the prot buffs are gonna be 8.1 mostly. Maybe some numbers changes prior but i kinda doubt it
🤣
Quick tip for anyone banging a 10 ataldazar this week, the pack on the left (the aztec trolls fighting the undead?) the npc undead or whatever they are? Die As you walk up, 1 is infested...if you very quickly pull that pack down the stairs and have your dps rush up to those spawn of ghunn you can prevent 2 infested mobs. Same with the totem to the right (first totem zombie) pull zombie down, dps kill totem for free.
Atal coughed up a 375 shield, 37 runs deep.
Disc of indomitable will indeed.
Is shield slam trait still better than Reinforced plating
370 mythrax sword haste+mast vs 380 tol dagor sword vers+mastery
oh yeah
?
I'd use the 380, that's str, hp..and raw damage on abilities
380
At this point, the haste on a weapon or shield is like in the 1.5% or so range
I'm like 42% haste in M+ like 44% or more in raids.
I'd lose 1/1.5% haste to gain 10 ilevels on my weapon no problem.
Do you reckon a 370 azerite chest with not bis traits is an upgrade over a 355 with Shield slam trait
?
the only trait worth dropping ilevel for is DC
And brace for impact doesn't carry nearly the weight that Deafening crash does.
Eh id drop like 5 ilvl maybe for a bfi over shit traits
I'm tied at the umbilical to a 340 shoulder, and it makes me cry.
you aren't meant to.
Yeah, seriously. I haven't seen a single mythic+ azerite drop.
Raids, World Bosses, Hitting the lottery on weekly caches. Mythic 0's and Warfronts for base ilevel stuff.
i thought only mythic 0 drops azerites, except from the chest
Zahrahk, it does not drop in M+