#protection

1 messages · Page 2115 of 1

grim prism
#

You can sim to find your TMI, EHRPS, max spike, etc, but it only applies to the exact fight that you have written the sim for, and none of those numbers is holistically valuable. It gives you data, but not information

undone sun
#

It's the actual backend that doesn't support prot

#

We aren't banner

prisma crane
#

it's a priority, no weights

knotty ermine
#

So a few extra globals is what is causing the issues with prot? Because the argument I'm making is that IP coming off the GCD isn't going to fix the problem, and people keep countering with "but it will free up globals"

prisma crane
#

i feel like you didnt actually read what i said

knotty ermine
#

When in reality, it would only free up a small handful over the course of an encounter, which, like I said, isn't going to fix the problem.

grim prism
#

Free up globals for... all those ICD-gated abilities we have lolol

#

Dev dev dev dev

knotty ermine
#

That's why I'm asking you to ellaborate 😛 I very well may not be understanding you

primal crypt
#

🤔

prisma crane
#

off GCD IP would leave potential for more rage gain (marginal imo) and slightly buff AM in some scenarios since it'd be a lot easier to rage dump, but it still wont fix how useless it is

sick sentinel
#

Wait. We talk about sims every day? wadner

knotty ermine
#

Oh hey, missed that last part. Yey mobile 😉 so we agree then, /rejoice

elfin apex
#

what the fuck are we supposed to do to work out what's best for us?

prisma crane
#

simply replacing every cast of IP with devastate and you'll end up with more SS procs throughout the course of the fight which means more rage and more AM and more CDs, etc

#

nothing major, but it would make a difference

#

but 1000:1 people will then be blowing too much rage on IP and not have SB when they need it, calling it now

#

but i'd welcome that "choice" over what we have now i suppose

#

still, IP wouldnt feel great to hit

#

would just be an AM fuel

grim prism
#

@elfin apex welp, armor is our most important stat by far for damage reduction because IP scales like shit, so it's ilvl > all on armor pieces assuming youre keeping one Deafening Crash trait (which should be obvious why it is so powerful; it's way overtuned)

prisma crane
#

i mean, we're exaggerating a bit with IP, it's not completely wasted, it just doesnt feel good enough for the rage we spend on it

grim prism
#

And the other traits that increase block are preferred because block is our most scalable defensive stat

prisma crane
#

i wouldn't say it's overtuned, personally

#

should be baseline

#

spell interaction is what makes classes fun to play

grim prism
#

It's worth more than 30 ilvl

#

That is de jure overtuned

#

Lol

prisma crane
#

by that logic, everything is supposed to lack impact enough where ilvl wins no matter what?

elfin apex
#

@grim prism ty

prisma crane
#

it's only worth that much because the alternatives arent up to par

grim prism
#

Thats like saying gold is only valuable because mud isnt expensive enough

prisma crane
#

it's very strong, don't get me wrong, but having choices is better than making one item mandatory

grim prism
#

Welp, DC is mandatory so I dont understand your point

prisma crane
#

particularly since it's currently not "farmable"

#

mandatory =/= overtuned

#

that's my point

grim prism
#

Mabdatory and worth 30+ ilvl = overtuned

prisma crane
#

agree to disagree then

grim prism
#

Sure I can do that

chilly brook
#

@elfin apex there’s no much to work out ilvl>all haste is actually better per point than strength but you’ll always take ilvl even if you lose haste. The only two exceptions being rings and whatever piece has DC on it. Basically never replace DC unless you have another piece with DC and for rings maximum sandbag would be 10ilvls if you have perfect stats on them

knotty ermine
#

I'm not saying all mandatory traits are overtuned, but you ever notice that overtuned traits are always mandatory?

#

(both of those statements are capable of being true btw)

wild atlas
#

Guys I’m back. Is all the toxicity still here?

chilly brook
#

Overtuned? Or the rest simply are just boring and don’t interact with anything and as a result undertuned?

grim prism
#

Anyway @elfin apex just to be clear, we frankly dont have a good answer for valuation on secondary stats, we just know that haste is our most valuable secondary due to napkin-mathing the benefits that it provides. All secondaries are closer in relatively value than last expac so we don't know precisely when one outweighs the other, but we do know haste is best due to cooldown reduction and rage gen

#

@chilly brook both?

chilly brook
grim prism
#

@knotty ermine its mandatory because it's overtuned /shrug

soft bridge
#

Did anyone read in the AMA where he spoke about traits? Removing some, adding new ones, bufing underused ones

chilly brook
#

Yes

grim prism
#

No trait should be worth keeping a 30 ilvl upgrade in the bags

chilly brook
#

And I doubt they’ll touch DC

soft bridge
#

Really hope it works in prot's favor

prisma crane
#

@grim prism i agree, but it's more that other traits aren't good enough, not that DC is too good

brave jetty
#

DC is too good.

#

It's ALSO the case that the other traits aren't good enough, though.

chilly brook
#

If they put T21 4 piece on azerite that would be mandatory as well

grim prism
#

@soft bridge it was the usual bullshit Ion non-response. The only "outlier" prot has is DC, which could only possibly be tuned downward, but prot is so underrepresented right now that I would be INCREDIBLY surprised if they do anything to the detriment of this spec

chilly brook
#

DC is actually like a tier bonus

prisma crane
#

rather have 2p

chilly brook
#

The rest are just meh

grim prism
#

Anything is possible though

soft bridge
#

Agreed

brave jetty
#

But DC is a clear outlier in terms of massive impact to our class, it's just that balancing it by the same standard they are talking about applying to everyone would fuck one of the weaker tank specs into the ground even further.

knotty ermine
#

Honestly I don't mind DC being basically mandatory atm in one of the slots, but I also have a piece with it for each slot to swap around, so the issue doesn't affect me. I'm basically one of those fury warriors in Legion that said "What, you don't have the angry hat/Convergence/Draught? Well just get it and you'll be fine"

soft bridge
#

lol

brave jetty
#

I don't agree that it's like a tier bonus, either, I think that's underselling it. If that were a tier bonus, it would be a 4pc one and would be considered an extremely strong one.

grim prism
#

They did a shit job with balancing azerite, across the board. Thunderous Blast is BiS or near-BiS for literally every DPS spec in the game, only with the exception of hilariously broken shit like Lord of War (rip) or that one that turns Boomies into sunfire spamfactories. Now all that is invalidated and its lazer matrix for everyone! Gg bliz

prisma crane
#

still not as good as T21 2p was

knotty ermine
#

Nah their "first tier bonuses suck so we we kind of aimed low with early expac azerite traits" was 100% a copout

grim prism
#

Wew lad I'm gonna tone down the negativity now

#

But damn

#

Az blows haha

cinder nova
#

So

#

Lemme be straight here

#

I know bear damage is memeworthy compared to prot

brave jetty
#

Well there are always a few outliers in the tier sets across the board but DC is definitely way stronger than most set bonuses we would normally be happy with.

prisma crane
#

imagine if we had a buff to SS like we do TC during Avatar, oof, ST wet dream

cinder nova
#

But on M mother my bear cotank can't hold aggro. I used 3 ss, 4 tc, and 2 rev when autos over ~ 20 to 30 seconds

#

And still ripped

#

Is this expected or an operator error

grim prism
#

Arent bears supposed to do more ST than us?

#

😬

#

Also, he has a threat meter, tell him l2taunt

knotty ermine
#

Difference is that DC is stronk, but isn't breaking us to be ridiculously stronk as well. Like... if Warriors had the m+ representation #s instead of DKs right now in m+, I would bet my next paycheck as well as yours that DC would be getting a visit from Ion very quickly.

cinder nova
#

Because right now I'm literally afk first room

#

Because he can't hold aggro

grim prism
#

That sounds like your cotank might be kinda shit m8

prisma crane
#

you the first tank that crosses?

cinder nova
#

Yes

prisma crane
#

then just

#

start with Mother

#

have him taunt when you cross

cinder nova
#

They want me to be there for booty clap cleave

knotty ermine
#

But DC is doing great things to make up for shortcomings of the spec, so it would be in Blizzard's best interests to leave DC as-is until they figure out a path forward

prisma crane
#

yea so just start with her

cinder nova
#

But I'll offer that solution

prisma crane
#

once you cross he'll have so much time to pull ahead it shouldnt be an issue the rest of the fight

leaden carbon
#

Do u guys have problems getting invited into pugs? :C

cinder nova
#

Fucking hope so

#

Yeah I do

#

3/9m and people still tell me no

prisma crane
#

even if it is though, just have him taunt on CD for the threat boost if it's still an issue

cinder nova
#

For H fresh runs

prisma crane
#

it's been that way for a while with warriors

#

we're like spriests and shaman now

cinder nova
#

"hurr hurr warrior bad"

prisma crane
#

but in reality it's the hurr hurr i want an easier time and other tanks just better

knotty ermine
#

@leaden carbon search "discord" and scroll up to where I was posting earlier about the Mythic + discord. Had decent success using that instead of trying my luck at LFG.

#

Seeing a prot warrior app right now is similar to seeing a ragnaros app to your group, unfortunately. Are there really good Rag players? Sure. But overwhelmingly right now there exists a strong chance that the player sucks, and therefor the tank will suck, and the run will suck.

leaden carbon
#

ty

sick sentinel
#

Lol ragnaros

grim prism
#

BR

prisma crane
#

for EU, what's a universally "bad" server

knotty ermine
#

Tarren Mill obv

grim prism
#

Not gonna lie, the smoothest pug group I ever ran was an Azralon premade

prisma crane
#

for NA, nemesis is actually worse than Ragnaros, and Q'T has been a lot better lately, and they're good pvpers

plain vapor
#

mother was being fucky with threat last night for me as well

vocal nimbus
#

I find french people hard to communicate with 🤷

grim prism
#

They were angrytyping at each other in spanish the entire time and one guy would occasionally type something like "tank pull to here plis ok?"

plain vapor
#

mother would start attacking my cotank when he didnt even do anything

vale basalt
#

I actually came from rag but moved realms just because i was getting denied a lot and got tired of the rag toxicity

wild sandal
#

can i a prot solo the orb for ghun hc?

plain vapor
#

yes

knotty ermine
#

Smoothest Siege I have run to date was an 8 with a Ragnaros tank, and an aussie priest healer

grim prism
#

Shit you not, smoothest pug of my life

knotty ermine
#

That constant 300ms lag was fun tho let me tell ya

prisma crane
#

aussies are usually great

plain vapor
#

their even better when you get on comms with them

#

joined a pug raid from frostmourne. funniest raid of my life

prisma crane
#

and yea, i think a lot of ppl on BR realms get a lot of hate for no reason, but, that said, it's less surprising if they end up bad

grim prism
#

Aussies are god's gift ro the internet

knotty ermine
#

Oh yeah, its the lag that you sometimes get in their group that sucks. Dude's on my bnet now and a go-to healbot for me late at night lol

grim prism
#

200 ping and 98 parse

prisma crane
#

i like the Kiwis even more lol

grim prism
#

God bless Oceania

knotty ermine
#

Like the... second boss? idk, the one with the ship

prisma crane
#

never see the word cunt more often in my life, it's like a complement there

knotty ermine
#

Getting targeted with her barrage and having that baked in lag the whole run

#

s t r e s s

leaden carbon
#

@knotty ermine I am from ragarons...

grim prism
#

ragarons

knotty ermine
#

Nice, do you suck, or do you wish fewer people on your server sucked so that it would stop being given a bad name

neon tangle
#

so

knotty ermine
#

because that's rpetty much a 1 to 1 comparison for playing prot right now

#

😛

neon tangle
#

345 motherlode shield

#

vs.

grim prism
#

Deathwish has done more for the prot community than 99% of the shitters in this channel

neon tangle
#

340 shield w/ a socket

prisma crane
#

honestly, a lot of it is that people just dont know how to effectively work with people when there's a language barrier

knotty ermine
#

Well there ya go

leaden carbon
#

Normaly I am a more than decent tank, right now I just suck and I am also a ragnaros player....

grim prism
#

Namely making a spell reflection spreadsheet and an addon that sprays confetti when you shield slam for over 1M damage

knotty ermine
#

Mmmmm idk man, there have been a MOUNTAIN of bad runs that I have had from rag that have nothing to do with language barriers

grim prism
#

Both of which are critically important tools

knotty ermine
#

such fun things as "the cafe player that goes afk randomly and for varying lengths of time"

leaden carbon
#

yeah, there are a lot of bad player around here

knotty ermine
#

which seems crazy popular btw

leaden carbon
#

but there are good players too

prisma crane
#

i did a 6 atal'dazar last wk with all BR players, was the best group i've had in ages

#

everyone CCing, interrupting, doing mechanics, no communication required

grim prism
#

@prisma crane that might have been the same group I had lmao

prisma crane
#

was my best pug run to date in BFA

grim prism
#

Were they typing at each other at all?

prisma crane
#

here and there, but sometimes in english

knotty ermine
#

Yeah for sure. That was my point though. Unfortunately a stigma exists (largely founded in direct experiences) where players from Rag have lead to a bad time for the group, for one reason or another. Same can be said for protW right now.

grim prism
#

"Tank pls wait i am explain m+ mecanic"

prisma crane
#

there were all in different guilds and servers

grim prism
#

"Ok"

#

They were all same realm for me lol

#

Azralonian premade

#

Guy was typing at me in broken english and i was responding as simply as possible

#

Fucking smashed the timer

#

It was amazing

neon tangle
#

would you take a +5ilvl shield, or one w/ a socket?

grim prism
#

+5 ilvl

leaden carbon
#

At least now I understand why I am not getting invited into anything lol

#

prot from ragnaros

#

nice resume

knotty ermine
#

People just aren't willing in many cases to roll the dice on their key being popped because they got a bad warrior, of which there currently appear to be more bad than good.

grim prism
#

Block is so ridiculously important its not even funny

knotty ermine
#

ilevel on shield, for sure

grim prism
#

@leaden carbon double whammy triggered

digital arrow
#

im surprised nobody asked about the state of prot warriors in the ama, unless i missed it

#

sham was asked about though

leaden carbon
#

yeah they asked

#

it just got burried down

digital arrow
#

ohh

knotty ermine
#

You hordeside or alliance @leaden carbon

leaden carbon
#

ally

knotty ermine
#

Ugh.

neon tangle
#

tbh every time I get a pug people are surprised that 1. I'm not dying

#

and 2. I'm beating them on dps

knotty ermine
#

I was gonna say to hmu and I'm fine swapping to dps (our group pretty much always has one opening) so you can tank some m+ buuuuuuuuut how bout Lok'Tar and gfy kkthx

dusk locust
#

it can be hit or miss for me. in a good pug i feel pretty hardy, in a bad one i feel like i'm constantly dying

knotty ermine
#

😛

leaden carbon
#

haha lol

#

ally + prot + ragnaros, it just keeps getting better

dusk locust
#

what race

cinder bridge
#

mfw a guildie gets 370 haste/mastery shield from warfront quest -_-

knotty ermine
#

Worgen

#

Is my bet

#

Idk why

prisma crane
#

alliance prot here as well, there are literally dozens of us

knotty ermine
#

but it would just make you that much more punchable

dusk locust
#

can confirm am one of the dozen

leaden carbon
#

NE

knotty ermine
#

Lol everyone laugh at the homeless refugee

#

At least you have ashes to dry your tears

#

Jokes aside sucks about your situation bud, really got the triple whammy there haha

leaden carbon
#

at least they don't have way to know I am a clicker!

#

(my current keyboard does not have function keys)

knotty ermine
#

Hahaha

#

I always found it interesting when some guilds require a pic of your UI before they would review your app. Like, on some level I get it, but at the same time logs are gonna tell you a hell of a lot more about the player than a cursory glance at their UI and whether they have "good" bindings

leaden carbon
#

hahah lol

sick sentinel
#

ex dee

#

24 neck, no unlocks. Hate life.

leaden carbon
#

I may be inviable but look my ui , theres conffeti !

#

best job interview ever

knotty ermine
#

Yeah but it really ramps up that sense of accomplishment when you hit 25

#

I don't think you're properly appreciating the design here

grim prism
#

Who tf asks for a UI screenshot lol

#

"Applications" for guilds are so stupid

#

I saw one on the realm I xferred a toon to

#

It was a google doc with like 28 questions on it

digital arrow
#

lol applications

grim prism
#

One of them was "what is your favorite meme?"

digital arrow
#

i'd rather have that to a guild with an invite bot

#

to filter out people tbh

#

lol

grim prism
#

I left every question blank except that one. I put the link to the application as an answer

digital arrow
#

LOL

#

got those nerds!

grim prism
#

Yeah they never got back to me

#

Weird

#

As my former GM put it, what could you possibly hope to learn in an application that you wouldn't learn in an hour of trialing?

#

Maybe they just do it to weed out the illiterate or something

leaden carbon
#

but

#

whats ur favorite meme?

knotty ermine
#

The last guild I applied to was in BC, and the application went "Raid leader for my current guild, the people I like have left due to real life circumstances, and the people that remain are mostly cancerous human beings. Ran with you guys to help gear up a shaman transfer for you guys in exchange for clearing my guild's raid lockout, and was told to apply here."

grim prism
#

I lost the link @leaden carbon

#

"This is my toon name, check my logs and let me know when I can trial"

#

Application completed

knotty ermine
#

Exactly lol

#

BC was a fun time to be evaluating apps

#

Tank app that you want to trial? Take em to Gruuls (when it was relevant) and see if they can handle the Maulgar pull. Pass/Fail

#

Had one guy back then tell me he didn't use (shield block, I think?) because he would generate more rage without it

#

Like, adamantly refused to use the ability

signal plover
#

That was a fun way to get one shot by gruul

leaden carbon
#

My offtank in legion was like that, but he didn't had any clear reason to do so

grim prism
#

If someone is a toxic player or a shit communicator, you probably arent gonna learn that in a paper app. I just dont get it

#

All an app does is establish they passed 6th grade reading comprehension

#

Well...

undone sun
#

nah, the application is a screening process for competence, the process to determine if they're toxic or not is the interview after said application

grim prism
#

My last app clearly established I am toxic

young harbor
#

lol

knotty ermine
#

Had a hunter apply to the guild in BC as well that put on his app he played with a trackpad on a laptop. Didn't realize he was serious until ICC.

grim prism
#

"He said he was an orange parser but it turns out he was just colorblind"

knotty ermine
#

lolololol

#

Had a shaman that we carried through SWP (or did he carry us?) that literally did nothing except cast chain heal on himself, always

uneven mason
#

that's how you played shaman

#

in TBC

#

not fucking kidding

knotty ermine
#

No no

uneven mason
#

stack MP5 - spam 1 rank down Chainheal

knotty ermine
#

He literally did nothing

#

ever

uneven mason
#

on yourself (Because shaman have low hP)

knotty ermine
#

didnt even move out of anything

#

because "i needed to cast heal"

uneven mason
#

I Mean

#

he wasn't wrong

mild olive
#

hey guys im new in this spec, and i'd like to know the stats weight, do you have any idea? i need it for pawn addon, ty guys

knotty ermine
#

Doom fires on Archimonde? "I can heal through it"

#

spoiler alert: he could not

uneven mason
#

well

knotty ermine
#

He sat upon a throne of lies

uneven mason
#

having done resto shaman in TBC

#

I could see where the hubris might come from

#

but nothing outhealed the hotstreaks

knotty ermine
#

Weights are largely irrelevant @mild olive , outside of maintaining 1 DC trait on your gear, you will almost always take an ilevel upgrade

uneven mason
#

@mild olive Don't use pawn, or weights ever

#

as warrior

#

You either Sim yourself for DPS gear (just DPS)

#

or you take the item levle upgrade

#

with very very little exception

grim prism
#

Cant sim for DPS either

#

Prot, remember0

uneven mason
#

you can SIM for DPS

plain vapor
#

you can forgo the DC trait if the piece you are replacing is like 15-20 ilvl higher

uneven mason
#

I Mean DPS

#

like ARms/fury

#

boy

#

DON"T YOU GET TECHNICAL WITH ME

grim prism
#

I mean...

knotty ermine
#

@plain vapor nah f that, we went over that a bunch today. DC or delete char

#

😉

plain vapor
#

had to replace a 340 with DC with 385 helmet

#

felt bad

grim prism
#

Sure, but i should clarify that you still cant sim prot for DPS

#

Lol

uneven mason
#

Krook

plain vapor
#

cus i had no other piece wit hthe trait

neon tangle
#

welp I figured out how to fund my flasks and stuff for a while

uneven mason
#

put the 340 back on

knotty ermine
#

Nah go back to the 340

#

Thank me in the morning

grim prism
#

Or at least, you wont get get a real number

uneven mason
#

because DC is after doing some actual shield math

neon tangle
#

apparently I had an un-soulbound blackrock bulwark in my bags since WoD

grim prism
#

@plain vapor DC or riot dude

neon tangle
#

and its selling for 600+k on my server

uneven mason
#

worth like, 50,00000000 item levels in situations where block is not usable

knotty ermine
#

Grats on the gold stash

plain vapor
#

i cant tell if you guys are memeing or not

knotty ermine
#

No we really aren't

grim prism
#

I am 100% serious

uneven mason
#

@neon tangle my rogue that I rolled in vanilla, had one item in his bank

grim prism
#

DC is worth at LEAST 30 ilvl

uneven mason
#

the Thug shirt

knotty ermine
#

Search "DC" and scroll up through today

uneven mason
#

ez 900k

low stratus
#

Hi what's a DC.

uneven mason
#

Deafening Crash

plain vapor
#

it was the mother helm that i put on for what its worth

grim prism
#

^

mild olive
#

mm okay i ll follow the icy veins stat priority then , ty mates!

uneven mason
#

its a trait that causes Thunderclap to extend the duration of Demoralizing shout

low stratus
#

Oh is that the demoralizing shout + clap one?

grim prism
#

@plain vapor doesnt matter if it replaced DC

low stratus
#

Yeah shit is cash.

grim prism
#

@low stratus thats the one

low stratus
#

I didn't realize it was so highly prio'd

knotty ermine
#

yep.

low stratus
#

tmyk

uneven mason
#

So Krook - for Myth, Zek, Taloc and Ghuun the Mother helm MIGHT win out over the DC trait

knotty ermine
#

Inb4 @chilly brook links a screenshot with 80% uptime

uneven mason
#

but for Zul and Vect

#

DC tops the item level

#

because block does like, nothing vs the DoTs

#

obviously Fetid you want the block 😛

knotty ermine
#

Shame tanks don't have lifegrip of some sort

#

Would never get tired of killing my friends on fetid

marble pelican
#

Howdy Prot boys....whats the Emissary Quest for horde for today?

knotty ermine
#

2h mace

#

high roll crit, lowroll haste

#

340

#

For... honorbound?

#

Can't recall. Think its honorbound.

exotic spoke
#

@knotty ermine Swapblaster. But that's only if you're not in combat unfortunately.

uneven mason
#

@knotty ermine When 2 prot warriors intercept eachother

knotty ermine
#

fracture the space/time continuum?

exotic spoke
#

Did our alt run in normal yesterday. I helped out for a bit to see some of the recruits initial numbers.

I was bored.. I swap blasted people off the Zul's platform while we were clearing trash

uneven mason
#

you swap places

exotic spoke
#

They were not amused. But I was.

simple kiln
knotty ermine
#

Not that I miss playing my pally, but I do miss DI shenanigans

uneven mason
#

post snips man, bnet links are cancerous

exotic spoke
#

Truth

simple kiln
#

I mostly just wanted item name, but yeah

marble pelican
#

Pally Prot fun?

exotic spoke
#

Almost as cancerous as the public opinion about Prot warriors

plain vapor
#

syringe

uneven mason
#

I mean, Grimmy uh, Syringe is better more than likely

#

Eyeball is pretty shit even post buff

#

"Oh boy a 2min CD on 1.5x IPs"

plain vapor
#

veiled eye is ass

marble pelican
#

I guess as this is my first tank that I've ever ran if you could be a tank of any other class what would it be or would you stick to prot?

uneven mason
#

uh

simple kiln
#

Word, even at 77k bubble? The Syringe does have decent uptime

uneven mason
#

Well, I'm a masochist so

#

I play prot

marble pelican
#

lol

uneven mason
#

2min CD on a 77k bubble

#

like we 100% have the ability to play any tank we want

simple kiln
#

Yeah and it does proc at kind of a high % hp

uneven mason
#

but we pick prot

knotty ermine
#

@marble pelican I always come back to prot.

marble pelican
#

well I picked it cause my main was a fury warrior so instead of leveling or paying to boost a character I just switched over lol

uneven mason
#

overall the crit from the synringe will logically reduce the damage you take more than the bubble

plain vapor
#

hope the m+ chest blesses me with a DC azerite piece

uneven mason
#

but its RNG

#

that being said - at least the synringe deals damage

exotic spoke
#

Never Stop Never Stopping playing Warrior. Started this char day 1. Will be the only one I ever raid with.

plain vapor
#

same here

#

warrior was my first character

exotic spoke
#

I have dark moon deck and the lion's roar trinket or whatever. Can't get other things to drop. Just using highest strength.

#

The crit on use is blah imo

sick sentinel
#

I use a base mythic Rezan’s and a dark moon deck myself

knotty ermine
#

Aside from my rogue, my alts are always tanks, and for any number of reasons I always enjoy prot more. From what I played of the other classes on beta even, I enjoyed prot more. In regards to levelling an alt versus just playing prot for tanking, I'd stick with prot just because you can still be progressing your main if you want while playing your alt spec.

simple kiln
#

Thanks @uneven mason

sick sentinel
#

Also.... let’s be real. Warrior has BiS mogs

grim prism
#

^

junior ivy
#

i disagree so hard on that

#

i hate plate mogs 😦

prisma crane
#

as a whole i think DK and Pally have better plate options, but warrior have a few that are just amazing

junior ivy
#

i always liked leather mogs

rugged plinth
#

Is there a list for what m+ boss spells are blockable/reflectable?

grim prism
#

@junior ivy thats because youre a gnome and everything looks like shit

rugged plinth
#

Specifically Motherlode

#

Coulnd't find it on pins

prisma crane
#

it's in the pins

junior ivy
#

im aobut to do the bfa opening scenario on my horde warrior

#

casue i got nothing to do

prisma crane
#

go to the tabs

#

click on motherlode on the top

sharp goblet
#

guys, what is the best trait for warrior prot?

prisma crane
#

last two bosses are a "treat"

sharp goblet
#

for M+*

prisma crane
#

@sharp goblet it's in the pins, and IV guide, but Deafening Crash is best overall

knotty ermine
#

If you spell reflect the 3rd boss's dot, you get imaginary achievement points

prisma crane
#

after that go for dmg ones

sharp goblet
#

@prisma crane Thanks!

prisma crane
#

like revenge, or TC ones, or even the block value one

knotty ermine
#

Mmmm imagine a talent or trait that reduced the CD on storm bolt if it also interrupted a spell

#

Make SB baseline and have it replace the SB talent

#

So you choose btween CDR on shockwave for number of targets hit, or CDR on Bolt for interrupting

prisma crane
#

fear should be off GCD

knotty ermine
#

agreed

junior ivy
#

demo shout should be off GCD 😭

undone sun
#

lots of things should be

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

knotty ermine
#

Stormbolt has no cd when Avatar is cast, go full Vann mode

dense flame
#

question. So can anyone comment on what healers are best ran with a prot warrior? Haven't tanked this expansion and am told our health is pretty ping pong in m+.

#

thinking probably mw/pally?

knotty ermine
#

From my own experience Monk feels fantastic, druid feels blegh, and all the others are somehwere inbetween.

dusk locust
#

monk is great, disc is not

mellow bridge
#

yeah I have good experience with monk as well

undone sun
#

definitely monk

mellow bridge
#

Pally seems good too

#

Bad experience with Shaman but I think the issue were the players

knotty ermine
#

Just be aware that a lot of Monk's stuff is hardcast, so even though they have great mobility they don't have great healing on the move, and plan accordingly.

undone sun
#

shaman almost definitely isn't a tank healer

knotty ermine
#

If the monk you're running with has RoP, you're in for a treat.

mellow bridge
#

a good RoP is so nice

dense flame
#

May be a general question. What makes it so that warrior isn't wanted in m+? I mean in legion some ppl didn't want warrio but from my experience warrior was fucking great in legion.

#

and thanks for the responses.

#

is it simply due to not high enough active mitigation or same utility arguments?

undone sun
#

still not terrible, just not ideal by comparison and it's because of utility

dense flame
#

okay thanks!

heavy cairn
#

hi

grim prism
#

RoP is so goddamn good

#

@heavy cairn sup

knotty ermine
#

Mmmhm.

#

So good in all dungeons, god-tier in hallway dungeons

elfin apex
#

rop?

knotty ermine
#

Ring of Peace

elfin apex
#

ahh

sand seal
#

anyone remember when we used to tank with daggers?

clear sapphire
#

Anyone haonv issues with druid healers? I have one good one but a number of bad ones.

knotty ermine
#

Yes. Warriors and Druids mesh particularly poorly.

sand seal
#

i think most druids are talenting for raiding not dungeons

#

i notice a huge difference between the 2

static pilot
#

^

#

druids can run a tank healing spec, but most dont pick those talents

sand seal
#

yeah, just grab you a pvp druid they'll keep u alive in dungeons

clear sapphire
#

Mmm. I left a 10 atal last night before totem boss as he could barely keep me up for rezan and he couldn't keep me up for a trash pull with 1 big guy and a priest.....
A guild priest I usually run with has 0 issues on fort or tyrannical on any boss.

grim prism
#

@sand seal you mean the start of this expac because all that fucking dropped from WQs was 2Hs? 🙃

sand seal
#

lol, i meant in like ubrs lbrs in vanilla

#

was gonna say that was more fun for me than prot atm

mellow bridge
#

I mean I'd expect people to be able to switch talents between raiding and dungeons lmao

#

unless you mean azerite, then I can understand it with the rising gold cost

sand seal
#

they just try to rely on hots too much

#

instead of givin up that juicy rejuv crit

grim prism
#

@clear sapphire i had a real bad Atal pug this week... ordinarily I hate torpedoing people's keys, but we were 40 deaths deep on a +7 and this guy SINGLE-TARGET TUNNELED the totems after the party leader who owned the key said to wait until witch doctors were dead

#

Cue instant wipe to avoidable party damage

#

I left that one

clear sapphire
#

Lol

dusk locust
#

i always tell people what the totems actually do

#

just telling them to attack totems last isn't enough

clear sapphire
#

We wiped about 4 times on a group with one big guy and a priest....... He couldn't heal for shit.... Though I don't think the DPS were to good either as alot of casts were getting through

knotty ermine
#

Mmmmm I'm not sure it's so simple as just talent choice though with RDruid. iirc you only change 2 talents for M+ versus raiding. Their class in general just not being well equipped for sustaining both a tank and the group. They can do one pretty well, they can do the other fairly well, but doing both is rather difficult for them atm

mellow bridge
#

I usually skip that group

grim prism
#

I mean if its a month into the expac and youre in a highish key, I would expect "kill totem after witch doctor dies" to be clear enough

dusk locust
#

dps won't listen to that. they have to know why

knotty ermine
#

and a serious lack of on-demand single target burst heals.

grim prism
#

@mellow bridge didnt have any skippy classes in the group

dusk locust
#

otherwise it's "this tank is an idiot those guys are immune unless the totem is dead"

grim prism
#

Except me, skipping the fuck out of that instance

mellow bridge
#

you can skip it via dying gg

#

you pull the group to one side, while your group hugs wall

knotty ermine
#

Had a hilarious bug in KR with totems the other night. Killed totem bro first, he comes up with his ghost form nova, and we interrupt ofc

mellow bridge
#

then you die and healer rezz

knotty ermine
#

Next time he comes up he pops his totems, and all of them were evading when you tried attacking them

mellow bridge
#

I almost always skip with shroud to the boss and then from the boss back I do the death skip

grim prism
#

@knotty ermine 🇫

knotty ermine
#

all 4 totems popping at once when they shouldnt be there anyway

#

feelssogoodman

grim prism
#

We missed timer on an atal 8 because one of the perched pterrordaxes was evading attacks and wouldnt come down to us, but was still able to cast its fear and bodypull the triceratops pats

#

Which, by the way, dont feel good on 8 fort

knotty ermine
#

Lollllll

grim prism
#

We BARELY missed timer, and 25 sec worth of deaths would have made the difference

mellow bridge
#

yeah I had to do that group earlier today in a +9

grim prism
#

Pepehands

mellow bridge
#

was kinda yikes

knotty ermine
#

Ate a fear from the triple ptero pack last night, and the lock in group dismissed his pet just before it pulled the big dinos

#

I offered to have his babies

mellow bridge
#

I'm legit so confused cuz of teeming

#

did atal twice today

#

First time I did normal route, works out perfectly with trash

grim prism
#

Whats funny is we handled the shit out of the ptero threepack on the runback

mellow bridge
#

Second time there's randomly one group missing on the route and we need to kill smth extra lol

#

Literally just a whole group missed

grim prism
#

We put markers on two of them, I said "i got x", pug said "i got skull" and we nocomms smashed that pack

#

I was amazed at how smoothly it went

knotty ermine
#

Aye. One someone didn't get stunned by shockwave even though they were all grped up. Either stun immune at the time because reasons, or just another dungeon bug

#

I'm inclined to just assume the latter

grim prism
#

Couldve been DR'ed

knotty ermine
#

I was the only person capable of stunning in the grp though, cept the lock I think? And he definitely wasn't doing it

grim prism
#

Hmm

#

Bugs prolly. Lol

mellow bridge
#

Dungeons feel very buggy tbh

grim prism
#

^

knotty ermine
#

Because they are

grim prism
#

^

knotty ermine
#

Had a wipe late in Motherlode tuesday

#

we all release, and when we come up we're in combat

dusk locust
#

i evade bug mobs with the cannon on tol dagor half the time

knotty ermine
#

should note that we had skipped quite a bit of trash at that point

#

30 seconds later the entire dungeon is coming for us

mellow bridge
#

lmfao

grim prism
#

Yeah ive had ML and freehold not break combat on rez

knotty ermine
#

somehow, when I died, everything stayed aggroed onto me

#

and came to me at the entrance, picking up every gdamn thing in the zone on its way

#

Jumped down to fight rezan in AD 8 last night

mellow bridge
#

Every time I get to the first boss in Boralus

#

we're stuck in combat

knotty ermine
#

Some random roguebro jumps on my back, waaaaaaaaay off his normal route

#

but he kept porting me back up, stabbing, and I would fall

#

halfway to the ground I port back, get stabbed, fall

uneven mason
#

TFW you jump to Rezan

dusk locust
#

is there a relevant potion you can use to find invisible patrols?

knotty ermine
#

repeat until dead, then he did it to the next group member

#

then the next

uneven mason
#

and the hunters pet dies about 8 seconds later

knotty ermine
#

longest drawn out wipe in history

grim prism
#

Lmao like that episode of futurama with the 10-second time rewinder

uneven mason
#

the ending of Doctor Strange

#

"I'm here to bargain - stab"

knotty ermine
#

@mellow bridge So you know the courtyard before the first bosses courtyard, with a bunch of NPCs fighting each other?

grim prism
#

@dusk locust Potion of Route-Learning and Greater TC Spam

mellow bridge
#

yea

knotty ermine
#

There are 2 mobs to the far right

#

left**

#

Non elites. Those are what you're stuck in combat with

mellow bridge
#

really

knotty ermine
#

THey aggro ((((((somehow)))))) andyou gotta kill em

mellow bridge
#

jesus..

knotty ermine
#

Even though they dont actually come for you

dusk locust
#

lol well i know about where they are, but sometimes a pull went wrong and the timing is all off, and i want to know where the invisible guy at the beginning of temple is

#

or a few of those patrols in atal

mellow bridge
#

whelp thanks for the info @knotty ermine

#

I assumed it was a bug because no matter how long you wait, nothing shows up

knotty ermine
#

Those assholes

brazen sequoia
#

Which horde race is the most optimal for prot btw?

grim prism
#

I feel like the AD rogues are definitely in different places on teeming @dusk locust

#

@brazen sequoia literally doesnt matter

mellow bridge
#

they are

#

there are more rogues in AD

#

there are 2 at the bottom of the stairs up to totem boss

dusk locust
#

the ones on the stairs i generally jump down and find. there's the one just before stairs walking around i always get surprised by

mellow bridge
#

right behind the pack

#

then there are two more on the stairs

#

at least that's how it was in my last run

#

but teeming seems really random

dusk locust
#

walking around the totem guys

knotty ermine
#

What are you tanking @brazen sequoia ? If m+, BE is quite good. Same with HMT. The slow from NB is decent as well.

sacred wharf
#

Hey guys can I ask what is our BiS trinkets? Is it blockades and jes howler?

grim prism
#

Oh yeah sorry @brazen sequoia. I forgot belf racial is stupid right now. Pick that one

mellow bridge
#

belf racial is really useful, can confirm

grim prism
#

Itll change again next expac tho after all the complaints from alli lol

mellow bridge
#

Purging off gilded claws in AD lmao

#

boneshields in underrot, lightning shield in temple

#

so good

brazen sequoia
#

@knotty ermine I'm maghar right now but I feel like they are a joke... would roll iron dwarf but alliance cringe.. It's for m+ and raids

grim prism
#

Maghar racial is just a shittier version of greenboy racial

#

Kind of a bummer tbh

knotty ermine
#

I need to see the BE heritage armor before I make a final decision. Was going to throw usefulness of racials out the window and go MagHar because they look fckin sick, but the monk in my group beat me to it

#

So now we have no AT

#

I really don't want yet another BE char though, lol.

grim prism
#

DID racial is sicknasty, but half the plate looks like shit on dwarves and your weapon clips through the ground

#

(Not that plate looks good on elves)

knotty ermine
#

Weapon clipping on BEs is attrocious as well

#

Weapon/shield clipping

pliant tangle
#

Well, is the prot warri really that bad? Everbody from my friendlist told me that lol

grim prism
#

I mean if youre deadset on minmaxing the active racial, youre pretty much shoehorned into belf or DID

#

@pliant tangle no

#

It could benefit from some tuning but it is viable in everything including M+ and mythic raids. It's just harder to play than other tanks

knotty ermine
#

@brazen sequoia BE racial is far and away the winner for M+ but, honestly just roll with what you like the looks of the best and dump dispel duties onto people in your group 😛

grim prism
#

I agree, roll with maghar

#

And try not to QQ that the racial is shit

mellow bridge
#

o

#

one more really good use for be racial

#

the MC after the first boss in KR

#

is purgable

#

makes that group really easy

grim prism
#

Oh sick

knotty ermine
#

Pardon me

#

But fear immunity and shockwave also makes those packs a joke

#

(I know BE is a single cast, just let me live my excuse to not play BE)

mellow bridge
#

you cant even shockwave those two guys

#

I think we're talking about diff enemies

knotty ermine
#

Wot

#

OHHHHH

grim prism
#

You are

mellow bridge
#

In the room youre stuck

vagrant cape
#

I forgot to look before I started pooping just now, but what's the order of most stats to least between the azerite armor slots (assuming equal ilvl)?

knotty ermine
#

On the way to the first boss I was thinking

#

I cannot read

mellow bridge
#

The whirlwind guy and the mindcontrol girl

knotty ermine
#

thought you meant the zul minion dorks

grim prism
#

@vagrant cape uh what?

mellow bridge
#

nah

prisma crane
#

@vagrant cape if it's like spots in the past, base stats on helm and chest are =

grim prism
#

You mean which has the highest total stat?

prisma crane
#

shoulders less

vagrant cape
#

Yeah

prisma crane
#

so if you have a piece with DC that's low, make it your shoulders

vagrant cape
#

I'm basically deciding between using my 340 helm or my 340 shoulders

#

Okie dokie, thanks!

ember arrow
#

finally

#

ghuun down

knotty ermine
#

eyyyy

vagrant cape
#

Grats!

#

you traitor 😃

#

#OnceAWarriorAlwaysAWarrior

ember arrow
#

100% healing parses

#

feeling good

#

traitor? didnt i answer questions in acherus from you? wadner

stark sage
#

😬

grim prism
#

:hardyikes:

prisma crane
#

today on Jerry Springer....

ember arrow
#

CSI SKyhold

grim prism
#

Jerry Springhrrllgh*

ember arrow
#

who is jerry spinger

grim prism
#

Some American

#

He's like Steve Erwin, except for people who live in trailer parks instead of animals

ember arrow
#

so he got stabbed by a trailer and died?

digital arrow
#

😭

prisma crane
#

i like that analogy @grim prism

soft bridge
#

lol

steel mauve
#

People living in animals?!

undone sun
#

wat

prisma crane
#

make context great again

grim prism
#

Yaknow @steel mauve

#

I typed that out and immediately thought "i should rephrase that"

#

But its too late now

static pilot
#

I'll be honest, if someone had asked me ten years ago who was more likely to get stabbed on TV, Steve Irwin or Jerry Springer - I'd definitely have picked Jerry

#

in other news Prot Warrior is on the front page of reddit/wow again, in meme format this time ^^

chilly brook
#

Steve Irvin

#

I’m offended

magic zephyr
#

how do you guys feel, is the ilvlup still better than looking for better stats?

chilly brook
#

Yes

#

Always

static pilot
#

you got that wrong mate, it's spelled with a W 😃

chilly brook
#

Unless you’re losing DC

wide juniper
#

My prot war is in the garage until I see 8.1

chilly brook
#

Lol da edit though

static pilot
#

and an E

wide juniper
#

We'll see if the tarp goes on it

chilly brook
#

I wouldn’t expect a complete rework with 8.1

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

wide juniper
#

Not expecting a complete rework.

static pilot
#

guess we'll know tomorrow

#

I look forward to the memes if prot is unchanged on the PTR ^^

chilly brook
#

Lol I wouldn’t expect class changes tomorrow either

#

I’d be decently ok with them leaving prot alone

static pilot
#

nothing wrong with that, play what you enjoy 😃

magic zephyr
#

ignore pain out of the gcd and its okey

chilly brook
#

The thing prot could benefit from the most is a more potent IP

#

IP off the gcd isn’t going to change anything

#

Objectively

#

That is

magic zephyr
#

but now the gameplay feels so stiff

#

it would make it alot smoother

chilly brook
#

Subjectively feels stiff

#

I don’t find it stiff

static pilot
#

subjective or not, it's massively the most common complaint about prot atm

graceful mason
#

I want a cd that buffs IP on the same tier as bolster

chilly brook
#

I thought the most common complaint was that we’re bad :ahi

#

Wut

static pilot
#

@maiden cliff I didnt think warriors stacked dodge these days

chilly brook
#

Why would you take that over bolster

graceful mason
#

On fights that don't benefit from blocking as much

chilly brook
#

Hmmm? @static pilot

static pilot
#

It was a reference to the way you dodged that response 😛

chilly brook
#

From my experience it’s not the most complained about thing

#

And they’re not going to change it

static pilot
#

then our experiences differ markedly

#

that you're probably right about, they seem committed to this GCD ship

chilly brook
#

They’d need to take FR, LOTP and other things like that as well

spice musk
#

iwhich is better Shoulder ilvl 340 with DC trait from Temple or 370 Shoulder from Warfront ?

chilly brook
#

And I’ve never dodged it I’ve always said that it wouldn’t fix anything at the bottom line

#

Whichever has DC

#

DC>ilvl

static pilot
#

subjective or not, it's massively the most common complaint about prot atm
I thought the most common complaint was that we’re bad :ahi <-- Dodge

chilly brook
spice musk
#

really i mean that 30 ilvl difference

chilly brook
#

There’s the reason

#

30ilvl difference doesn’t give you 75% uptime on Demo Shout

#

A 20% damage reduction

#

You can consider going with the 370s but you’re most likely better off keeping DC

spice musk
#

mh okay

chilly brook
#

@static pilot I mean I’ve stated several times why that complaint isn’t all that relevant to prot’s current situation

#

Just because it’s common doesn’t mean it needs to be taken seriously by the devs

#

Or that it actually addresses a problem

spice musk
#

i will hold the 370 for the time blizzard will nerf it. Which trait would you than prefer in that 370 shoulders Bloodsport or Liberatormight?

quartz lake
#

I did an Atal Dazar this morning +5 and the healer kept telling me to kite the adds. I didn't see anything regarding an affix that is needed me to kite them. Am I special needs? Do you guys have any idea?

chilly brook
#

Bloodsport

static pilot
#

you were dismissing his view because it was only his subjective opinion - I pointed out that it was an opinion shared by a very large amount of people that are currently unhappy with prot warriors

chilly brook
#

Fortified? Teeming?

#

Most of people’s unhappiness with prot has to do with their perceived performance not their playstyle

static pilot
#

it's worth acknowledging that "I feel" is not a statement of fact, but it's also worth acknowledging that when 80% of the movie customer feedback says "your movie sucks" then it may be worth following up on, subjective or not

jovial reef
#

i'd bet that most people who enjoyed prot in legion dislike it purely for the gcd on IP

spice musk
#

i really need a ranking of all traits would be much easier for me xD

jovial reef
#

the fact that prot is also the worst tank for all content is just icing on the shitty cake

prisma crane
#

@spice musk it's in teh pins, in the IV guide

chilly brook
#

@static pilot movies=/=video games

prisma crane
#

well, im not a fan at all of how slow the class has gotten @jovial reef so im in that camp, everyone slowed down, but i feel like it hit us with a larger culture shock

static pilot
#

all that said, I dont see the point in discussing prot with you. I believe that we both agree that prot could do with some tweaks, I'm happy to leave it at that

prisma crane
#

@chilly brook except opinions of customers matter

#

regardless of film or game

chilly brook
#

One is completely player interaction based the other isn’t

static pilot
#

especially since I'm guessing Sal would rather have us leave the topic alone for the time being

chilly brook
#

Yes and most peoples opinions are driven by performance in an mmo

#

Not by “flow”

static pilot
#

do you have any proof of that?

prisma crane
#

at the high end, i'd agree, but that's a small % of players

chilly brook
#

Uhhhhhh we have proof of that everyday

static pilot
#

I saw plenty of people play BM in Legion even though it was parsing bottom because they liked the class mechanics

prisma crane
#

there's a lot of ppl who just want to play the game and enjoy it, playing a class that's punishing with little reward for mastery isnt fun to those people

static pilot
#

indeed

chilly brook
#

Then don’t play that class

prisma crane
#

at the top end, 100% agree Griff, ppl play what's best because they must, but that's a small amount of players

chilly brook
#

🤔

static pilot
#

that's a copout and you know it

steady dock
#

Howdy! How does Jes' Howler (355) compare to Xalzaix's Veiled Eye (355, socket) ?

prisma crane
#

well it's evident that people jsut simply arent playing the class

#

that's the point

#

Jes is better

steel mauve
#

use howler

chilly brook
#

Except that the opinion of that top end clearly shaped the perception of the community @prisma crane

static pilot
#

what they said, go with the howler

#

how about the opinion of the individual player?

spice musk
#

when i understand the uldir traits right they are in mythic plus weaker than IF etc?

steady dock
#

Hm, ok ty

chilly brook
#

The opinion of the individual player also shows that

prisma crane
#

of course, but again, that also only affects aspiring "good" players, not your average WQ, LFR, 5 man for fun players

chilly brook
prisma crane
#

@spice musk they only work in Uldir, so yes

jovial reef
#

the hidden bonus buff only works in uldir*

chilly brook
#

It’s almost an exact mirror of said videos

spice musk
#

no the array works only in uldir but not the not buffed trait

stable elm
#

I have my ass royally crushed in kings rest today. And then shadow priest soloed the whole pack

digital arrow
#

whats a decent raider io score? everyones starting to use it and now im worried if i ever want to pug higher keys

chilly brook
#

And that’s overall not just top end

static pilot
chilly brook
#

@digital arrow if you don’t have 700+ good luck my friend

jovial reef
#

1k is p much required by now

digital arrow
#

lol rip

prisma crane
#

@digital arrow just do what you can, start with completing all dungeons at your best and incrementally improve

jovial reef
#

i see no keys asking for less than 370 and 1k score

prisma crane
#

simply doing all dungeons will net you the most points at the start

jovial reef
#

no 10 keys*

stable elm
#

You can always organize pug yourself on your own terms

prisma crane
#

a more useful link

static pilot
#

thanks Krotos 😃

stable elm
#

Tank is sweet place to be pug leader

prisma crane
#

np

sick sentinel
#

If they made IP able to crit on cast

chilly brook
#

Anyways to wrap up and get off the topic objectively one of the best things they could do for prot warrior is to buff the potency of IP regarding it’s absorb amount (not the percentage mind you)

sick sentinel
#

I'd be happy.

spice musk
#

@prisma crane not really i get the 240 stats buff outside of uldir but the array that buffed these higher is not active.

static pilot
#

If I understand you correctly your argument is that m+ tank rankings match what youtube creators ranked tanks at because the m+ community slavishly follow the video rankers?

prisma crane
#

tbh Griff, that'll change almost nothing about our M+ representation

sick sentinel
#

40.6k IPs at cap atm though unbuffed, cant complain. Feels good

chilly brook
#

Well I’m not really talking about representation on that point @prisma crane

prisma crane
#

@spice musk ah, right, well part of it then, true

stable elm
#

IP off gcd is bad idea btw

chilly brook
#

The only reason I brought up the Mythic + representation is that it’s fairly similar to how a certain someone ranked the tanks

prisma crane
#

but that's our greatest weakness and where teh lion's share of players fall as far as content goes

static pilot
#

couldn't that also mean that "a certain someone" knows what he's talking about?

#

I'm not sure who you're talking about btw, there are a lot of wow streamers

stable elm
#

We have huge dps and moving IP out of gcd will make it even less balanced to other classes

chilly brook
#

The only thing that’ll actually fix representation would be a change in perception

static pilot
#

afaik Preach, Asmon, Sco etc all have tank rankings

chilly brook
#

@static pilot Sco specifically

prisma crane
#

it's the same debate as in legion, we can be amazing, but if we dont provide a certain utility, we wont go as far

static pilot
#

Sco ranked warriors at the bottom for m+?

stable elm
#

So blizzard will have to tone down our numbers

static pilot
#

who did he rank second last?

chilly brook
#

Nah he ranked Druid bottom

#

Iirc

static pilot
#

okay... To me, that says he had a decent grasp on tank balance

chilly brook
#

Top 3 for him was DK, DH, Monk iirc

static pilot
#

I havent played much with guardians but I'd agree that warrior are less attractive tanks for m+ atm

#

and yeah, I'd probably put those 3 in the top 3

mellow bridge
#

I'm surprised to nee barely any guardian druid talk on reddit

static pilot
#

@opaque pawn how would you rank the tanks for m+?

mellow bridge
#

Saw a couple of comments at the start of bfa but now it's kinda quiet

prisma crane
#

well, the big issue with Sco, for me at least, was that he was ranking us with piss poor talent choices, so even if ppl chose that tank, they'd use the wrong talents further hurting our image, but idk if that's the case now

static pilot
#

oops, sorry Griffin

#

wrong griff

chilly brook
#

But he also put those rankings out admitting he hadn’t played all the classes

prisma crane
#

which imo he shouldnt do

#

but clicks are clicks

chilly brook
#

And he didn’t even use optimal talents on his warrior

#

So there are plenty of bones to pick with that

static pilot
#

okay, so... here's what I'm thinking

#

if he released a video ranking beta tanks in m+

steel mauve
#

wasnt it him who rated down DH's in legion because he was referencing their cd's and was basing his rating on the havocs meta which is a 2 min longer cd?

static pilot
#

and they were released and the balance was wildly different

quartz nebula
#

has anyone tried tanking KR +7 this week? feels like im made of paper

static pilot
#

I think the community would adapt to that

#

like if Deathstrike healed for 3% of total health and didnt scale to damage taken it doesnt matter if DK was ranked top in beta

#

because on life it would be fucking trash

chilly brook
#

TBF the community doesn’t adapt to anything without a push

prisma crane
#

most people won't just swap mains

stable elm
#

KR is pain this week

chilly brook
#

That as well

static pilot
#

I did

#

Prot used to be my main tank

#

hated it in the prepatch, but told myself it would be better at 120

#

hated it at 120, told myself it would be better with better gear

#

hated it at ilevel 350 and decided to retire it for the time being

#

and I played prot warrior for the entirety of legion, loved it, even when things were rough at times

#

still love prot, first class I ever played in WOW

#

just can't stand playing it atm

prisma crane
#

i mean between tiers

#

it's a pain

#

even more so mid tier

#

but others have many classes and play what they enjoy, too many generalizations

native monolith
#

Does it worth to have 2 Azerite Veins Traits?

#

Or the Proc chance doesnt stack?

prisma crane
#

either way, we're not shit as many assume, jsut because at bottom doesnt mean not viable, tanks are as a whole (in raids) quite balanced compared to years past

#

but if we want a chance in M+, utility changes must happen

#

chance at top end*

stable elm
#

Dungeon exp and gear mean much more then class balance anyway

static pilot
#

arguably warriors werent in a great spot for much of legion either but I didnt really mind that as long as the gameplay was fun and engaging

prisma crane
#

@stable elm disagree once you get to high keys

#

yea @static pilot same, i think what hurts now is that there's little to no payoff for the change in game play

static pilot
#

I'm incredibly bummed out that you can buy a 50g scroll to copy battle shout at 70% efficiency but there's no consumable to replicate, say, battle rezes

stable elm
#

Do you realize that most ppl just can’t reach high keys right now?

#

Class regardless

static pilot
#

Agreed. Objectively all the tanks took a hit in survivability from Legion but I feel like the prot thing goes way beyond that

storm valley
#

I just died to a pack that had a mob CC'd despite having 7 cooldowns (4 of mine, 3 of the healer's) on me

#

I think our survivability might be in a bad spot who can say

prisma crane
#

it's because most tanks arent DKs and most heals arent disc /druid / pally, and most dps arent frost mage, rogue, etc

mellow bridge
#

What Pack

#

@storm valley

storm valley
#

one of the packs in Siege next to the giant

#

+10

mellow bridge
#

The monkeys?

storm valley
#

like I don't expect them to be easy

mellow bridge
#

Ah

storm valley
#

nah the soldiers with the commander

mellow bridge
#

Wait you mean the boss

#

Yea

storm valley
#

yeah

radiant wolf
#

isn't that the poison pack?

storm valley
#

yeah it had 2 poison guys, a sniper, the commander

mellow bridge
#

Well those should be survivable with 7 cds 🤔

storm valley
#

YOU'D THINK

#

like idk I don't play optimally or whatever, but that dungeon took 69 minutes :v

prisma crane
#

if you put the best players behind all classes, there will be ones that just cannot do what others can, class balance in M+ means more than gear and dungeon knowledge is simply expected at top end

static pilot
#

in all fairness teeming fort is a shit show no matter what tank you bring. This is not an enjoyable week for m+

mellow bridge
#

I mean I did a +8 today and needed both CDs for a double pull

prisma crane
#

^

storm valley
#

I don't know why Fort exists

#

who enjoys this?

mellow bridge
#

So idk how you can't handle one group with seven

storm valley
#

Wiping Tyrannical actually feels like you're learning and doing cool PvE stuff

prisma crane
#

because fort was what everyone wanted in legion lol

radiant wolf
#

that poison hurts if it's not dispelled though

prisma crane
#

but now trash is awful and tanks are nerfed

storm valley
#

I don't care how optimal it is

#

I care how fun it is

mellow bridge
#

Tyrannical is better this xpac imho except for when some boss mechanics start oneshotting the rest of the group without much counterplay

storm valley
#

what's fun about trash being hard

#

it's trash

stable elm
#

Some dungeons like setralis is not affected by teaming much

storm valley
#

if you wanna make hard trash, make a boss with a bunch of adds

prisma crane
#

you're looking at M+ wrong then @storm valley

stable elm
#

So I don’t agree it worst

prisma crane
#

trash is what makes them interesting

mellow bridge
#

I mean trash is supposed to be difficult and require proper cc kicks etc

storm valley
#

I think you might be looking at game design wrong, mate

prisma crane
#

you're thinking of raids

#

and loot by bosses

static pilot
#

how is temple this week? I havent tried it yet but I have a +9 on my shaman that I'm really really not looking forward to trying

prisma crane
#

trash affects how you move through the dungeon, how you pull, how much you pull, pace of CDs

#

bosses are bosses are bosses

static pilot
#

"trash" really is misleading when it comes to m+. On high + a trash pack can be its own miniboss

storm valley
#

None of that makes it enjoyable to fight

static pilot
#

learning what each mob's mechanics are and how to counter them is a big part of the m+ experience

prisma crane
#

well that's your opinion and it's 👌 for you to have that

mellow bridge
#

@static pilot well it was pretty fine for me until one of the packs double spawned and we couldn't clear it properly without one dd leaving

storm valley
#

Is there genuinely a pack in the game right now for which the counters aren't AOE stuns and interrupts

prisma crane
#

i personally don't find bosses that just one shot once you get to a certain key level fun either

mellow bridge
#

+9 as well

prisma crane
#

in legion, no, in BFA, yes

static pilot
#

100%

storm valley
#

Closest I can think is the artillery boys in Siege

static pilot
#

purging the fear adds in King's rest

#

kiting berserkers to reset bleed stacks

#

soothing enrage effects all over the place

storm valley
#

You can just stun the berserkers

prisma crane
#

i mean, infested alone forces CCs or at least focus dps

static pilot
#

@mellow bridge well, that fucking sucks

mellow bridge
#

Yup

#

Dungeons are so buggy

static pilot
#

did you make a ticket or just leave it?

mellow bridge
#

Infested in WM..

#

The worms literally walk through the walls

storm valley
#

Enrage is countered by one class, that isn't an outplay, it's a guy pressing a button.

mellow bridge
#

Or you can pull stuff from the cellar while being above lol

storm valley
#

Whatever, I'm glad you guys enjoy it more than me because at least there's some use to it.

mellow bridge
#

Nah I didn't, I'm 100% blizz is aware

#

The double spawn bug has been around since bfa release

static pilot
#

I had that happen - fighting in the courtyard of Waycrest, got adds joining through wall

storm valley
#

Waycrest has some insane random stuff with pull areas, we had the tree despawn because a DK Frost Dragon ran through a wall

static pilot
#

then realized that we somehow pulled the named add in the basement

#

and she got 4(?) stacks of the +50% damage & haste buff they cast

mellow bridge
#

Ya the matron

#

Is so easy to pull

static pilot
#

we didn't have a purge class and that buff is fucking permanent

mellow bridge
#

Somehow

static pilot
#

there are times when its tempting to take a break and come back in six months

#

there are things I like about BFA but it feels so half-baked

mellow bridge
#

Yea

#

Feels like I'm playing a beta

#

Which is sad

#

Legion felt good, the last xpac I played before that was tbc which felt good lol

#

Their other games feel good when released

#

But bfa just feels unfinished

static pilot
#

I was absent for most of Draenor so I came into late draenor with a fresh mindset

#

Im sure Legion was busted in places at launch too but I didnt realize it

#

but I've been playing nonstop for two years and enjoyed every minute of it

#

now... Eh

mellow bridge
#

I'm not even talking about any balance issues

#

Just Design choices and bugs

static pilot
#

tbf I didnt get so lucky with my mains - I play enhancement shaman and (used to) prot warrior

mellow bridge
#

Like azerite gear, not tuning dungeons correctly with the affixes and the 5 million bugs

static pilot
#

I think a fair few complaints would be put to rest if you add 15% haste baseline to every spec ^^

#

with the way secondary stats scale atm it still wouldnt reach legion levels

#

anyway, I gotta duck out. See you later folks 😃

sick sentinel
#

@storm valley the Invaders in those packs do retarded poison damage that stats to a x5 dot.

#

Itd kill any tank w/o constant depoison/CDs.

#

Either CC them on pulls, or kill them asap. A lot of the dungeons at higher mythic+ w/ affixes just comes down to player knowledge. Dont blame it on your class.

junior ivy
#

is there an addon or weakaura that will make it obvious which way a boss is facing

#

for shockwaves and stuff

next lagoon
#

basic target selection have an arrow not?

junior ivy
#

on the floor, if its a tiny boss like a goblin with a bunch of people around

#

its hard to see

#

its very small

prisma crane
#

there used to be stuff like that

#

but blizz changed some stuff that basically banned all of those

#

since addons like that can essentially play the game for you in a way

#

addons that would put overlays on your map or screen so you know what places are safe and stuff, like last boss of motherlode

#

and you're prob talking about the 3rd boss there

junior ivy
#

aww

#

lol yeh thats the one

#

i play zoomed way out

#

and its so hard to see where shes facing

sick sentinel
#

lol

neon tangle
#

If you’re zoomed out you can’t see your super awesome transmog

uncut fractal
#

why is sco leveling up a warrior

#

could it be

#

the dream

ocean acorn
#

for fun?

neon tangle
#

Winning hearts and minds

uncut fractal
#

imagine one of the most popular tanks to main a warr tank

ocean acorn
#

wasnt he a warrior main til legion

undone sun
#

yes

uncut fractal
#

maybe he thinks warriors will be buffed or smth

ocean acorn
#

hey, i remember reading here a calculation on block value and block rating does anyone no where that is

gaunt coyote
#

why is there so many prot war complaints on leddit

neon tangle
#

There’s nothing but complaining on reddit

sick tree
#

Because we do have balance issues compared to other tanks

ocean acorn
#

i think the only issue i had was finding a shield

solid mist
#

proactive tank vs. reactive tanks

ocean acorn
#

i was using a 325 til yesterday

neon tangle
#

If you didn’t know this is the worst expansion ever

solid mist
#

worst game, worst expansion, worst class, worst spec

neon tangle
#

^^

#

Everyone hates this game basically, and yells about it

#

People like to say that Wrath was great

#

But 95% of what I heard back then was people bitching about how it got easy

#

And “welfare epics”

stark sage
#

people bitch every xpac