#protection
1 messages · Page 2110 of 1
Keep 360
Secondaries don't outweigh primaries.
Riot shield brotato
literally no reason to ever take lower on shield
Block >>>>>> all
Ilvl>everything on Shield
thanks 😄
Higher Block is important
ever tried to bake a cake in an electric oven but the power got cut halfway through?
What do you mean?
it's a metaphor for the design process of prot warrior during the beta 😃
Can’t say that’s untrue
basically they got halfway to where they wanted it to be and ran out of time
so what we got is half-baked
I mean technically, depending on the cake and the quality of the oven, the cake would probably be fine
if only slightly undercooked
i'm sorry did someone say cake?
and yes I am a b l a s t at parties
fine?
depends on the cake's build and gear
D:
but they're selling 5 star cakes in the same shop at the same price
my warrior's name means cake in danish so that is pretty accurate (Kage)
I was confused
Hi cake
Why the fuck is the PepeGCD emote not allowed here of all places?

Wait is the Pepe emote not allowed?
that' s the beautifull thing about chocolate baking
Blame the hacker known as 4chin
a failed cake is a moeuilleux or a browny
wait I have another gear question
D:
Exactly @valid gorge
Marok doesn't like fun, so he doesn't allow external emotes.
conclusion: we are brownies
But PepeGCD...
We have 2 cat emotes.
the frosting aint chocolate
Those are server-specific emotes.
azerothian champion seems better in every way on first sight

Tell Marok times are a changin'
the helm i mean
:moon2A:
AZ veins or ablative shielding
I want to say azerothian champ
I'll :moon2A: him all day.
aaaand now I'm hungry 🍰
resounding protection is probably the deciding factor
argument for both veins and plating
Didn't you start this whole cake thing? YouPlayedYourself.gif
but t3 on the other ones is dogshit
what addon is that btw that show the ilvl in a big font on the slot
i've seen it so many times
but it's not in elvui afaik?
I do not use elvui
Deja Character Stats.
no i know but I do
^^
It reworks the character sheet to be more like what it used to be, pre-Legion.
i'll check it out thanks
Many options for what to show/hide as well
It’s a nice addon
Basically unprunes blizzard's pruning
is it easily combined with elvui?
Yes.
it should be from the looks of it


Impassive is probably better for a tank tbh
Shield would obviously be better for DPS where you can avoid a lot of damage
Impassive basically sheds 3k off like every third auto
the shield is attractive as DPS since you're less likely to constantly take damage (and it has certain other issues, like interacting with things) but Impassive is better if you expect to take constant damage
I'd take veins/resounding over of the ablative and impassive on that other piece, but honestly those two pieces are so close to each other I dont believe you will notice a difference between the two.
like on Vectis
Reason being that the armor granted from ablative is useless on magic, the other setup is going to work in all situations.
But again, those two pieces are so close, I don't think there's a wrong answer.
Good lord doing keys this week in bfa's tightly packed dungeons is the first time since tomb i dont want to play my war
What’re your other options?
the flat str is good
@merry cave bring a monk and tell them to spec RoP. It's a barricade in almost every hall of bfa dungeons.
Then yea prolly
The level of cheese enabled by RoP is ridiculous.
Yeah would of if one was around, but its the first week ive really felt far inferior to my dk and dh and im usualy the first to defend war
dhs get smashed too tbh
Ahh yeah, it definitely feels bad without some assist from your group, for sure
Flex on that intercept key bb
and you know... make sure at least your healer (or some ranged person) knows to be a good intercept target for you lol
I love intercepting to some ranged DPS that’s near the cudgel drop point on taloc makes them flip out so hard
They’re always so worried
Lol
I’m a mean man
Spamming heroic throw in taunt windows this week feels solid though tbh
lol I did that to my warlock last night
hell it doesn't feel terrible outside of them either, honestly
I use heroic throw all the time
yerp
I guess this week is making me appreciate it more, since before I didn't really have to watch threat plates nearly as much from range, etc.
Until my dumb fury warrior decides heroic throw means charge in 😑
Bombing mobs with throw that are getting nuked by dps and barely seeing the threat meter shift
feelsgoodman
Lol ya thats a tough one. Always DH that do that for me
even when you say "pulling this back"
or
"LoS pull"
no means yes, and all that.
I really hope 8.1 will be kind to prot warriors because otherwise I have to think about bringing other tanks to 120
If I open with heroic throw chances are I’m trying to los or reposition
And I love my orc shieldbearer
to be fair, DH have sacrificed everything, so I need to cut them some slack
the los pull is a lost art
They sacrifice their life everytime they run in when I’m LoSing
lol i thought i was the only one
why is it every time u try to LOS the party stands way in front
herp
communication
Gotta los when you lack grip
i've asked the question "can i LOS back here guys please"
"Hey guys, stand over here on this world marker. I will pull the adds to you so you can do big dick aoe dps"
What I have noticed, at least this week, is this scenario cropping up far too often: 4 of 5 members hugging a wall to skip a certain pack, when suddenly, the mage decides to blink to the middle of the hallway"
dude I los pull everything
DPS need their hands held dawg
skittish week was hell for me
so guys are we doomed to use 340 piece with deafening clash or am i missing something?
"Bro why you standing over there TANK HELLO"
"oh idk, I just like tanking stuff behind this trashcan, no particular reason"
LOL
vov more or less
My favorite
except if you are a lucky ass
bepends if you are lucky on caches
Until you get lucky with the cache or you get the conquest shoulders @unkempt fox
and get DC on your chest
Is when ranged actually TELLS you to LoS
and then when the pull gets fucked up, and u get another pack because you had to move up and steal aggro
I want a 385 freehold head
then the groups like You SUck
And then stands in the open and gets casted on
to actually use other shoulders
@digital arrow if they're telling you that you suck after that, they probably don't understand tanking lol
@chilly brook can you elaborate on the shoulders? i there a way to get them that do not involve rng?
Yes do rated pvp
^
feels bad
It's so funny how we can all look at the same key and have totally different reactions. I look at Teeming/Quaking and think "Sweet, we can push this week" whereas last week I tried to just stay out as much as humanly possible. I'm sure it's far far worse if you're playing above a +10, but to me this definitely looks like a nice break from the horrors of the 1st 2 M+ weeks.
last week was pretty nice tbh
I am more or less skipping this week already had disgusting experiences
Ugh...I haaaate Skittish weeks. Couldn't bring myself to last week.
last week was absolutely free affixes besides tyrannical
@wild bolt true. I was in love with last week, as it was pretty much a godsend for me (and I assume most prot warrs) since skittish is basically nonexistent
probably easiest possible combination
aye
guys i've a noob question dont laugh: does me having a regen spell on me mid-pull generate more threat to the healer who put the regen on me? or does it not matter like it matters in final fantasy 14?
well it was nice after fortified sanguine lol
skittish is ok if you can coordinate with dps to contain themselves
cant wait to get curbstomped by sanguine again in tiny hallways
The ice world boss also drops DC shoulders @unkempt fox
skittish as a warrior is really fine
Really? I roll with this Arms/Ret combo that pretty much did ll the tanking for me last week. Fort/Sang in Waycrest though has been the worst experience of the new M+ for me.
But he’s not up this week
in ff14, when u'd charge in while regen was on u, mobs would ignore u and walk straight to healer. bad healers regen tanks before pulls in that game
that's not the case in wow, pocky
@wild bolt base your pulls around Avatar to warm yourself up to the affix, and I think you'll quikcly find how much of a joke the affix is for protw
if you have problems with skittish you need to fix your rotation, unless you have some monster top tier dps in which case get a rogue or hunter
@limber perch Sanguine requires you to master the art of backpulling and back pedaling
@chilly brook i got the shoulders with 3 very good traits from arathi WB so probably not worth replacing them
thanks blob
healers generate threat, but it's so minimal that you could just auto attack and regain it
lol you will lose aggro to an arms mongoloid bladestorming when your avatar isnt u
guaranteed
up&
I mean it’s worth replacing for DC to replace whatever 340 DC piece you have @unkempt fox
Why wouldn't avatar be up every time their bladestorm is up?
@uneven mason Sanguine also makes you master the art of checking your dps and making sure they arent rolling with passive slows (looking at you, rogue with crippling poison)
if your arms is 3x low bladestorming then yeah he has to wait
brace for impact , azerite veins and impassive visage, and they are 370 @chilly brook
It’d be an overall ilvl increase
It's actually up more often than Bladestorm is, but that' s the problem, it gets desynchronized
Carnivale - My favorite was the warlocks who kept stunning shit in pools, and in doorways, and then killing said stunned mob in the doorway
since his low can crit for like 100k or whatever
so we had to walk through the sanguine
nothing oike making your healer drink twice between pulls
omfg @knotty ermine @uneven mason yeah dude.. the number of times I had to say "guys stop stunning the mobs in the sanguine pools, it heals them if they stand in them"
Honestly though, soon as your group figures out that a pack dying at the same time basically removes Sanguine as an affix, that week becomes butter as well
Like I said it’s better to replace your lowest DC trait with a higher ilvl DC even if it means not using your 370 shoulders
100% true @knotty ermine
^
In your case it’ll likely be shoulders with DC helmet from mother with BFI and the chest from another boss from Uldir with archive
Other niche stuff too, like, knowing which mobs are a pain in the ass to move Sanguine week (since we dont have the luxury of grip)
@chilly brook all this indicates to me that DC is super boned when 8.1 rolls out
Like the snipers/marksmen in Siege, for example. Basically, hard to move targets are the ones you want to kill first, if you group isn't swapping around to kill everything at the same time.
like prot were not fucked before, lets not put the bis trait in raid gosh
@keen spire you’d think so but they didn’t nerf it this patch
Unlike everyone else’s broken trait
if they dont change it you actually just have to get lucky from chest at some point
@chilly brook I was a little surprised by that myself.
If they nerf DC that severely hurts prot period
sup ravnu
Yeah, the uptime on DS is like.. crucial
maybe put a cap on it of between 30-40sec
Old player back to the frame
yeah there is a really big difference between DS being up nearly all the time and DS not up
I have a feeling prot warriors will be nerfed even more
If anything I would bet they cap the max extend on DS, but leave the dmg component the same, which is still nice for tps. Nerfing DC would be a huge dickpunch to a class that is already looking to be in line for positive changes
^
I don't feel like they've been nerfed much at all @torn gulch
I playd from vanilla to cata.. and know for some reason.. i can´t hold aggro anymore on BFA
can i get some help?
Like as it is currently with the way everything is interacting with prot its an uneasy balance
Make DC 1 second - increase DS base uptime to 15 seconds, leave CD the same.
@iron grove give em the clap
nerf BV to 10% damage
But if you look at their nerfs to traits so far, almost all of them have been due to how broken they are in PVP environments
👏
@iron grove Thunderclap the shit out of all dem mofos
tell that to peeps that decline prot warriors in m+ and raids
lol
Does anyone still think there's any chance we might eventually see whatever IP replacement they were working on pre-launch?
"no we are fine really"
Because everything about us synergizes so well we’re viable, you pull one piece and we fall
😦
so I wouldn't put very much stock in "x class got these nerfs but we haven't, why"
I don't mind I played prot warrior even if we were scrapping the bottom of the barrel
God, I wish Prot would just get deleted already...
Just start your own M+
@wild bolt prolly
why deleted? 😦
Well then....
But, what happend? I want to understand.. everything changed so bad. i feel like a noob now
@keen spire that works until your key stops being atal dazar
Can’t tell if troll or serious
@errant thorn how does it feel to do less DPS than your leader who is a Prot warrior?
@modern brook Do what I did and start your own guild - then you've got a bunch of people you can round up to clear whatever you want
@final mist I wouldn't know
u put his health to 0 @limber perch
@iron grove what do you mean?
wow
ty
Start your own guild and fill it with nothing but wars, spriests, and shamans
I mean prot warriors are dying the most in ULDIR and have the lowest representations among tanks in higher m+
Call it "The Outsiders"
@chilly brook they changed the threat generation or somenthing?
anyone here farmed those conquest shoulders or is that just a myth?
it went from 900% to 350%
Oh boy here comes that metric again
from 900 to 350% ravnuslock
@iron grove yes they changed threat
unless you fall asleep every 3rd global you shouldnt be dropping aggro
Your damage done matters much more now
yeah @raven kernel me too! congrats on that
Kiting now is hard.
grats all ya undergeared bois
@raven kernel grats
oh
So therefor a nerf to DC is a nerf to our ability to generate threat and we already deal less single target damage than other tanks in my experience
These affixes really hurt this weeks m+--- 365 prot warr, getting almost 1shot by trash in underrot 7 with Ignore Pain, Shield Block and Bandage trinket active 😒
just titanforge it with socket and avoidance
lol i was thinking u were referring to the mythic emissary weekend cache woops
@iron grove You shouldn't really need to kite much in most situations. You should default to using your toolkit to reduce incoming damage before just turning tail and running away. What's your ilvl?
@limber perch hold aggro on the guy, watch out for cleave, and never let him on your team
teeming fortified is a bad time to be sure
or they will wipte
@keen spire kiting is a common strat in M+
my oh shit button is heroic leap
I mean Teeming is fine, but with Fortified it's hell
Depends @chilly brook . I have to hold way back when OT'ing in Uldir to not rip aggro from our DK tank on Taloc, Mother & Fetid. The only ones I can't seem to pull off of w/out taunting on a regular basis are DH. I'd say other than that our ST damage is pretty on point (in my experience.)
don't go into underrot if you dont have a shroud
@vivid sage he's saying that he's come back from playing in cata - seems like he is not talking about M+
yeah i know fernan i've charged into packs with shield wall first lol
@keen spire i´m doing M+ 8 already
@wild bolt thats my experience too
Sometimes I have to kite (it´s not usual
was kiting in raid ever really something?
But over the course of the fight our DK ends up being higher in damage for sure
I have to pump the breaks in avatar when im not active tank
Yeah, anytime Avatar's up it's time for the kid gloves, heh.
i took a break after wotlk
kiting in a raid is mechanic-specific
but as I remember, it was easyer to hold.. My ILvl is 352 atm
in Taloc, for example, you kite in P2 on the elevator
At least it’s not like legion though where I’m on average doing 400-500k more DPS than the average tank
Yep, it seems like damage is closer than its ever been
@iron grove I misunderstood - are you talking about your ability to maintain aggro this week or last week?
Unless you're a bear, maybe.
In legion, i played VDH and by the end of normal antorus i was able to maintain 900-1m dps avg in a raid environment
@keen spire overall
i just mean if i saw someone say "kiting is hard", i'd pretty much assume they were talking about M+
Yea I did about 1.1m DPS ST on my BrM
nah dude this is the place @iron grove
but.. like, everything changed since cata
No bother at all, @iron grove 😄
dont be sorry
THe problem is like "do better" is sucha a broad topic we cant really give advice past "press your rotation, block the damage, dont die"
it was like.. 8 years ago (add private ryan's gif)
So, when are you losing threat? Is it right at the start or is it a gradual thing over the course of a pull?
@modern brook Ok, got it.. SO let me explain my situation.
I got my rotations right, BUT secondary mobs (no the one I´m hiting) lose threat like ez (when I got my thunderclap on cd)
How early into the pull is that happening
I tend to keep my aim on those I have to interrupt
Ahh, ok. You want to cycle your targets then.
remember that you can HL to reset taunt
You want to cycle through them with your shield slam and devastate
rotation : 😡 👏 😱 👏
👏
HL ?
still trying to make my group hold back their stuns for actual casts.
heroic leap
i forgot about that!!
Heroic Leap
and tab target shit to spread threat more
ty sal
particularly ones that cant regular be interrupted.
OH
s'what I do w/ shockwave/stormbolt/warstomp
SO leap generate lots of threat now?
no
no.
Wait you can actually reset taunt by using leap?
you taunt, leap and leap resets taunt
yes
Huh I learned something new
oh i also fear in last resort, it helps me buy a couple of seconds too
then TC is back up
@vivid sage Kiting the spider in SSC
Yeah the taunt reset is nice.
but leap also does damage so it does generate threat
Yep, and it's aoe
which is sometihng
On lady vasjh
gonna start leaping in my rotation
HL + TC is a good start to a pull
prolly not enough if you're losing aggro but eh
got it
i know you kited things but it was a specific mechanic every now and then
Unless you're chain pulling i dont think you should ever open with HL
@shut summit 8.1 spoilers when
I use leap sometimes on big adds to reset taunt on 2nd dude
Especially if you don't need rage from Intercepting
intercept rage is super important
@iron grove without something specific to discuss, the best broad advice I can give on playing Prot well is to maintain the habit of being most knowledgeable person in the group about the particular encounter/dungeon. Specifically, ProtW shines brightest by knowing what's coming and planning ahead with their abilities. If you get behind, your healer gets far behind, and the group is about to have a really bad and stressful time.
avatar pre-pull + HL + tclap
why does leap reset taunt? 😮
nice aoe start.
But like kiting is usually TBC mechcNics
@cinder bridge it just works - Todd Howard
I often taunt +leap-charge tho
to get 30ish rage before avatar + leap.
@knotty ermine I´m studing and learning all I can.. I always was that person.. but.. since it´s all "new" for me.. I´m having a hard time atm
Leap/clap is great until you get into an aussie server group and clap keeps going off midair because yolo
If you're fighting 2 large guys, like bears before first boss in Dark Heart Thicket (irrelevent content, but its the scenario so whatever), taunt your off target, charge the main, and tclap
Omg #Hoping
@iron grove You'll get it, bud. There's a lot to take in, but it all starts to make sense as you go.
@sick sentinel I charge and tc to start a pull all the time
Kelthuzad?
@keen spire thanks bud
@iron grove It'll be gravy once you get the hang of it. I'd say stick with it since your attitude towards it already appears an order of magnitude better than most people's approach to the spec haha.
I also tend to stay off Nemesis, Tolbarad, Ragnaros and another one, no idea why tho 🤔🙄
Honestly though, you guys can use Charge - TC - Rev and the whole pack will be stuck to you for like 5 globals lol
Not with DH or Arms
@knotty ermine fun fact.. Prot warrior.. it´s the only class I played since vanilla... i love being a warrior tank
Oh, and one more thing. Use WAs if you aren't, and make a WA to yell at you for casting shield block during LS in an "oh shit" moment. It will break the habit before it has a chance to form ;P
Pretty much have to ask them to tab target or get ready to soak a few hits
as long as i have avatar i never have problems with threat
Yeah
@vivid sage true
@knotty ermine Great idea 😛
But on lower keys you wont get it back for next pull
if he wants to CS-Bladestorm afteer charging he better have a paladin friend
I mean trust me when I say monk is fun
hell yeah @iron grove i've only ever played prot. high five
On the next pull, they won't have their burst @dark junco
I have more issues on lower than high keys, since high keys pulls takes more time
@digital arrow SWEET
@dark junco You got it all wrong. You adjust the pulls to your avatar cycle, not the other way around
😛
xD
Don't have it up for the next pull? Means you've graduated and can pull 2 packs now.
3h +10s lol
We’re depleting 9s and 8s this week i’m sad
And the 14 we have is a waycrest
Gonna be a 12h dungeon lol
you guys really wait for avatar to pull? i'm always trying to pull in a hurry so sometimes i cant wait 😦
I do not, Pock
but most times its up
He's saying that you should be pulling so that your avatar cd ends once the pack dies
plus, as long as you have AM and you're using your rage, even if you don't start the pull with avatar, it should be off cd within a few seconds anyway
yeah thats usually the case with me
@digital arrow nah, Once I start seeing how quickly things are dying, I just keep adding to the pull count so that Av is up every pull, basically
Wut
not the pushing keys strat, but the 6-7s strat
25 second CD 🤔
and if your dps is so trigger-happy that they can't resist blowing their load on a pull that you might struggle with aoe threat, they deserve to die, imo
ayo this guy spending 80 rage per secnd
We need a new azerite traits
eatin beans and spending 80 rage/s
Each TClap enhance the duration of avatar for 1 sec
"He prot war"
Hahahahaha
Imma rename myself to Thor lawl
That would be hilarious @dark junco
I've been using avatar on CD, but i dont wait for it to starts pull
And I’ll do m+ with “Thunderstruck” playing in loops
That with DC
Lol
would be so fkin broken lmao
Thats a proper Tier 22 =p
im starting to see just how important it is to generate more rage to spend it asap, hopefully get avatar back up asap too. gonna start randomly charging to teammates during mythics when i can for that sweet rage bonus
I am ok with trigger happy dps, as it pushes me to be better. Derp dps that ignore mechanics are far more annoying to me than tryhards flexin their deeps switch
“and are you Thor god of hammer?”
@digital arrow wronk
xD
nah nah - each TC extends DS like it does now, but then each revenge proc extends avatar - 2cds used and you pull the whole dungeon nonstop
You don’t want to spend it as soon as possible
^
You want to spend it when needed and when it’ll cap you
You don’t lose any value from AM if you have 40 rage and don’t press IP until you’re at 90 rage for example
Have enough rage so you can use the abilities you need the moment you need them, dump off the excess into making dps classes feel bad about getting rekt by a prot warrior
lol yes
WAs helps with getting that habit formed btw
You basically just want to be able to use a defensive ability when you need to
Eventually it becomes automatic, but WAs helps with the learning curve significantly
is there any point logging M+? my exorsus raid tools does it automatically
well
there are few people logging m+
even fewer prot warrs
flex on them rankings bb
this is where I'd use a dab emote if they weren't disabled here :/
I can't play a prot warrior, i'm unsubbing fuck this game....:)
just kidding of course i'm bored at work
hahahaha
If you want to review your mistakes and get better then why woundnt you log @sick sentinel?
i think we had our daily troll earlier
Conversely, if you dont read your logs then why even log them?
Got into an argument with a RL friend, no bullshit, over the fact that I use details and log, and those things "aren't needed to be better"
lol, ive never read logs, i guess maybe i should
to argue semantics, they arent needed to be "better" but they sure as shit help a whole lot
TBH though they are needed
and how much better, if he wants to get 2% better, na, not needed
actually better, def
Its like an athlete watching a video of their game to review
Except with a fat neckbeard instead of an athlete
This is a guy btw that was a 99%er mythic raiding rogue for a few years. But the basis of his argument was "if you are executing your rotation perfectly, what could a log tell you? If you aren't executing perfectly, you would know that without a log"
It’s much more than that
there's just too many things we cant feasibly pay attention to
I was so far beyond perplexed when I realized he we completely serious, lol.
It’s like an athlete actually timing themselves etc. and pushing themselves and having the tools to actually see it they can measure up to the competition
Instead of showing up to the competition and getting smoked
Right, there's a difference between "noticing you did something wrong" and understanding exactly why it happened and how to fix it
Logs allow you to do the latter
@manic sentinel welcome to 8.0
i've been removed a couple times after being invited
probably because one of his friends read dem there prot warriors no good
only time i have trouble in high keys is w/ disc priests. holy pallys, resto sham, holy priest... w/e, they all keep me above 80% np in most cases. prob just bad luck on the disc priests ive gotten, but either way, they act like prot just cant do it
"apparently they have to like... know what the enemy abilities are.. and get this, use things pre-emptively" "ugh fuck that get a brewmaster"
i feel like most disc is just dpsing all the time
yeah my smite heals you for 5k man
dont worry
lol
idk im considering rolling brewmaster til 8.1 drops. at least i can get in groups a bit more quickly that way
I just chalked his argument/viewpoint up to the same way I view studying. All through school I was in AP/GT classes graduated with honors and never studied a day in my life, get to college and struggling with a statistics class. "You should study" "WotHow.gif" Just something that never entered his mind as necessary or beneficial I guess
definition of 2cool4school
whew same carnivale, are you me
on the real
Im pretty sure disc priests just arent a good match up to heal us, ive had good disc priests from my guild heal me in 5 mans and i didnt feel great about it
360 haste/versa vs 370 crit/mastery? Guide says 370 always, but its basically best stats vs worst stats
for what slot?
Rings. 28 stam difference
my thing is i have no idea how to read them...yes i suck, and what add on is used to register them
Protip for getting into mythic pugs, apply and get accepted as DPS, change your role after entering the group
Lifehax
hi
i'm 348 atm, whats the max M+ for me to tank efficiently
I did +4's at +2 when i was high 340
@marble pelican probably +15
I suck, so you should be able to do something similar if not better
I think the key is for you and you healer to get to know each other.
At the beginingy druid friends were like "Man healing you is so hard" 1 few runs latter it was "okay you go pull all this crap mean while i'm gonnadrink"
@modern brook you were high and 340 or high 340's? 😃
@modern brook Let's just call it God's/FSM's cruel joke, also known as Dyscalculia. Basically numeric dyslexia.
@marble pelican 34x; I jumped when i upgraded my shield from a 288 -> 345 so idr what the last digit was, @knotty ermine I was mostly joking, lol
yeah we are finishing up my basement where my office is atm, so i'm stuck to a lap top for now. probably be 2 months before i'm back to my pc
Also it was Atal'dazar, if dungeon matters to you
If you're joining stuff, I'd just spam atal for gear
i don't like to raid on anything but my PC. it just give me more freedoms
348 is gonna have a bad time this week, but I would suspect you'd be fine with 5s. Not sure I would push above 7s unless you're feeling stronk, just because your healer is going to be needing to focus you pretty intently, and DPS going full "diferently abled" will draw the healer's globals and can nuke a key rather quickly.
Like @modern brook said though, I would just spam AD.
the silenece from (teeming?) make it a bit tougher in combination with the constant aoe damage as well
quaking
awesome, i do appreciate it. the only downside is having to talk to people over headset i hate that poop
yeah quaking
When you're legitimately pushing up and fine-tuning your gear there are only like... 3 items in there you wouldn't consider an upgrade. at 348 literally any item that drops from there will be great for you.
last week was def a good time to grind out some higher keys, much easier
this week is aids on toast
I miss anything?
Only thing I hated about last week pushing up keys is that some bosses were absolute brick walls.
i loved the slam jam 2 matron befouled pull in underrot makes me want to die
fuckin teeming fort
tree soul boss in waycrest fuking destroyed me last week
Avatar intensify
we lost a chest in tos on a +8 bc there were like 5 guardians in the room snatching the orb
was like whaaat the fuck
lol
DPS insisting on pullin ticks makes me hate underrot far more than anything
I actually really like that dungeon
god the ticks truck
Guardians in ToS are à joke as protwar
was doing a shrine and the big boy tentacles the dark ritualist spawns was hitting for like 55k a piece
with a quaking 1 shot our dps
Underrot is lovely. Is it because I like reflecting huge blood bolts to the first boss? Or perhaps because handling mushrooms almost completely solo on the 3rd boss makes me feel like a god? Maybe it's because I get to spam victory rush like an absolute madman on the final boss? The answer is D) all of the above.
@steel lotus yeah cant you skip that part though?
yeah chose to do that later didnt realize how fucked it would be tho
also the non rezan path in atal is dead
2 voodoo guardians in a pack of 5 yikes
is ToS the dungeon with the first boss the 2 guys with the lightning shield? If so i was on a +3 or 4 there and left, the dps wouldn't switch targets and kept getting destroyed from the LS and then blaming me for not taking agro....
yeah that happens a lot in lower keys
@steel lotus bring a brez or ankh of some kind to shrine when pushing high keys. That last room before the bridge, where the 2 guys spawn tons of tentacles, you can huge the right wall and ignore them entirely, then get on the bridge. Once there, mount up and run to the room with all the little tentacles right before second to last boss
@knotty ermine how do you handle the shrooms by yourself?
just run through em with IP and SR?
Die, rez up the group, and continue. Eel packs give gobs of % but you should be nearly complete by that point anyway.
but what about the ritualist on bridge lol with all the aids guys thought you couldnt finish without one of those packs
@mellow bridge his shockwave has a ridiculous arc to it, you can clear out at least 1/4 to 1/3rd of the present shrooms with one slam, and he generally slams 2 times between each harvest
yeah I use the shockwave but I only manage to clear like half at best
Make sure your group stays directly behind the boss, move him incrementally while also popping a few shrooms on yourself (fewer ofc on tyrannical, but you can still take a couple on your own)
Paint diagram inc
I love paint diagrams
So whats your worst experience as a tank since launch of BFA? Mine is and always will be the Hybrid DPS, that think they can dps and that helps more than actually healing in mythics, so they'll queue Healing, then dps and spot heal...usually 1-3 wipes
Jes
Feel really sad about my chest, I am not even sure if its good
My chest was okay
got 380 since I did +10
but was only 10 ilvl upgrade and I have other slots where I would have needed an upgrade way more
like rings or trinkets
gz, I am not that good yet.. mostly getting carried by a friend that got me into WoW just recently... but he does not really knwo the prot warrior class that well, so I wanted to ask you guys if that trinket is an actual upgrade to anything I have?
Vial is a good trinket but I'm not sure about which 2 are the best
okay, so its at least not bad 😄
Ill prob just swap it for Jes then just to get more Ilevel so people will take me in their pugs 😛
Equal ilvl is Jes or rezans trink better
how much was that darkmooon trinket?
you can keep it in your inventory for ilvl
I think Jes howler and blockades are BiS for where you're at, but the iLvl upgrade on the vial is pretty big
~27k on my server last I checked. as such I'm still rocking a generic 325 trinket
I got tired of repair costs, so i bought a wow token.. spent it on a shield and trinket upgrade as they fucking never drop.. gave 30k for the Darkmoon one
accoridng to Icy veins
you should take vial over jes
because of the ilvl difference being that big
damn, Blockades is going for 18k on my server
ahh thanks 😄
"If you have a Jes' Howler Icon Jes' Howler, and you can obtain one of the above alternatives at a significantly higher item level compared to it (say, 15+ item levels), then use that alternative instead."
just get a 380 big red button, its pretty good 😛
@stiff lance I think it depends on what you're running into. More survival off Jess and more threat off rezans
nice.. I had one of those at a much lower ilevel .. its the one that blows up stuff in AOE right?
Underrot: Charge in and face boss immediately away from grp (he will be anyway because thats just what happens, probably), clear A shrooms by yourself, clear B with slam1, clear C by yourself, clear D with slam 2, and your group will be handling E and any others that may crop up along the path, but aren't many. Just make sure they know to stay behind the boss, and that they need to pop whichever come up after he's already slammed
its not a hardfast rule for who handles those zone, moreso just chew off as much of the circle with slam positioning as you can, soak as many as you/your healer are comfortable with between slams, and the dps with the targeted thing can handle, easily, the shrooms that remain or pop up behind the boss after he's already slammed and you've moved him
But in practice, you can account for almost all the mushrooms by yourself this way.
I've seen many pugs that just hold the boss in the middle and turn him for slams, and it is so much more stressful on the group and healer that way.
👍
Harder to coordinate with dps too
I dont tank in the middle but being near the middle gets you the most clearing on shockwaves (the arc of the frontal is longer than the axis it is cast on)
Also reduces stess on the heals since dps shouldnt be eating shrooms and all they gotta heal through is the mountain of spores the dps will inevitabley wander through
Honestly as long as you pick a place to clear and hold him there, and DPS dont clear behind you like idiots, it should be easy
You can pop SR to clear out the couple that get missed
Just have to pick your zone early and dont move him at all
And hopefully communicate. Lol
Keeps him close to center to maximize the arc of slam, but also you gotta be out there popping shrooms so he inevitably moves away from center
I need to make a prot warrior paint meme
I made some MS Paint strats for 8.2
Those were the days m80
I wonder if i still have my skorp diagram
idk if that changed
yesterday's fixes included a change in how mushrooms spawn on that boss
Do you have avatar? If yes Thunderclap if no Thunderclap anyways
i found my Maw of Souls glitch diagram lol
Hey bois, which trinkets would you use for 10+ M+ between 370 Jes, 385 rezan's eye and blockades ?
(That's a nice diagram)
@rain bridge the two that arent blockades
Oh hey speaking of glitches
Anyone else experiencing charge going off, but not actually charging a LOT
^
if there is basically any type of terrain change
Yeah
or your pathing sends you through Albuquerque
No but I experience myself zig zagging in odd ways to charge to council boss in KR
Do you use a macro on it
On charge no, intervene, yes
Yeah KR council has goofy hitbox. But at least its just them and not every boss like it was last expac
@knotty ermine yeah thats what ive seen as well
I honestly don't recall the issue occuring with intervene other than wierd pathing
Honestly it could be happening as prot, It is just far more aggravating as fury because it seems to happen when I pop reck and then charge, but charge goes off and doesn't actually send me in, and I have to spend 2 seconds of reck now running toward the boss or trash pack
and let me tell you
that feels AH-MAAAAAZING
ye
a guildie got a titanforged 2h weapon from his m+ chest
that's always going to be the case, yes
refer to the ilvl rewards chart
the correspnding ilvl reward is taken as a bace
base*
and can still forge +10 ilvls
damn 1.8% on G'huun from method
That's rough
If I don't have any of the uldir azerite trait(i.e. Archive, lazer matrix), do you guys think it's worth getting one over "Brace for impact"?
So I can pick between archive and brace for impact and I am unsure about which one to pick
ashvane chest from tol dagor, mother uldir headpiece and then ... eh.. freehold shoulders I think?
as it's universal (raid and m+) and the reorigination isn't that high yet
Does Archive stack stam or str for us?
yeah, you gotta drop a cooking fire next to where you will tanking to really get the full effect
Str btw
lol thank god they decided that stam wasn't the RA stack
"Oh yeah.. tanks use stamina as their primary"
lol
stupid food buffs
stupid cauldrons
Thank god
Step one is to go to battle.net and open "accounr management"...
something something unsub memes. No kick pls @mods
Question before I give advice to a friendo- aside from hard hitters like thrash coming (which is a different issue altogether) when tanking it is better overall to let a SB charge go off completely before popping another, rather than potentially overlap, right? Was asked without being given specifics and it's kind of hard to answer, since, if it's an ability you would want to have 2 SBs back to back on, the moment between the two could possibly hurt like hell, but also if it's a long-term thing, you have more effective uptime by letting cast A complete it's duration before casting the second.
@keen spire get a time machine back to 2014 i guess?
If you layer them, Carnivale, they stack the duration up to a certain point
@knotty ermine they dont overlap, they extend
so it's not necessary to have them drop off before clicking again, to a certain extent
The question was "is it better to let SB fall off before casting again, or should I overlap by a fraction of a second" but there wasn't any other info given, so I was going with iverlao/extend is the better choice
Tell them it doesnt matter, it wont overlap
Coolio thanks, just wanted a sanity checm
Yerp
Check**
I had someone in my raid team admit to me that he was "a clicker" after I asked him why his dps was low
I told him to learn how to use hotkeys or he wasn't going to raid with us anymore
lol
The cap for SB extension is like 18 seconds or some shit, there's literally nothing to worry about for the duration - just capping charges.
(side note: I'm far better at answering questions about specific moments/problems than speaking in general terms, lol)
we recently learned one of ours didn't know you could right-click and drag to turn the camera
Thanks @final mist
Keyboard turning is arguably worse than clicking lol
went 10/11M last tier keyboard turning
how do you even..
One of our hunters (of course) in wotlk was playing on a laptop touchpad
what the shit
Guys performance was generally solid so we always thought he was joking
I mean if youre just positioning mobs and not doing a big move
Why strafe and risk an accidental back hit
Faster isnt always better
if i need to strafe i hold right click and hit a or d. i don't like the idea of changing a and d to be strafe only
Get to LK, or maybe it was Blood prince, I can't recall, and the problem really showed itself
One of the "don't stand in that" Olympics fights in that raid
sometimes i gotta reposition something and scratch my nose at the same time ;P
defile on lk
I just have my q and e as strafe
that's shield slam and devastate for me
I unbound the keyboard-turnig keys years ago.
I keep s bound to backpedal because of what balsaq said
Just W and S for forward / backwards, and strafing.
sometimes it's best to backpedal if you don't need to gtfo out of a spot and you don't wanna take back hits
Ahh man. Thats another thing for the pug highlight reel
backpedal is most useful for tanks imo, and sometimes backpedal speed is perfect for certain mechanics
like M spellblade
shield slam is 2 for me
"haha omg tank you're backpedaling? What a scrub"
if i gotta go fast i'll strafe back but often times backpedal i find better
🤔 keeping mobs in the "block arc" (in front of me) totally nub tactic
Especially after blizzard changed mob pathing in 7.0 where they were constantly trying to step around behind you if your hit ox overlapped with theirs
If only we were all like DHs and took 80% of our health per melee round anyway no matter what direction we were facing
honestly if it needs to be that fast, I generally just heroic leap directly behind me and then immediately right click-jiggle the camera so my dude faces the correct way again
oh that shit in 7.0 triggered me
"yeah u right, I gotta l2p boss"
it was like every npc in the world suddenly became a rogue
I got yelled at in NH for moving bosses too quickly
Ended up becoming a habitual backpedaler
Yyyyyyyyep
I killed a DH on my first HC Fetid kill cause I Lept and the monk was like WAIT BRO I AINT THAT FAST
WELL SOMEBODY HAS TO KICK THE DAMN ADD AND IF NOBODY IS OVER THERE THEN I DONT KNOW WHAT YOU EXPECT GUYS
I miss raiding
lol
My turn coming up on kicking Vezax... Mouse battery dies. Oh boy good times
Having kick and other things bou to your mouse buttons is amazing, except when it isn't.
that's why you bind your mouse keys to things that are on the keyboard already
Bound**
my kick is middle click
or get foot pedals
my kick is G
as has been discussed
on every class, I put my kick on G
Ran a +2 kr at 352 ilvl... its like healers forget prot wars need heals lmao. It eas a 2. Felt like an 8... joyful
Kick f. Stun g.
I have 3 extra buttons on my mouse - I use shift, alt, and ctrl modifiers to turn those 3 buttons into 12. 😎
king's rest is really interesting on teeming fortified
Mouse bindings feel sloppy
My moude has 12 button. I use it for leap and push to talk
leap is great
And oh shit pots
don't use it for spam abilities
like, keep your main rotation on the keyboard
put your cds on the mouse
I shift bind my cds
Since i have to ude em on trash. And not rrally on bosses lmao
Protwar problems
I don't use mouse binds for abilities I spam (closest thing would be SB), but I love having bindings over there as well.
and if you can take less damage, why wouldn't you?
Let's see...
I use mouse binds for stuff that I use often, but not necessarily spam.
I find that having the space around WASD be for rarer abilities nice because it means you don't have to do finger acrobatics if you have to strafe while doing your rotation.
I still use QERF for main rotation abilities, but I wish I didn't...
I do. Saying i use em so damn much i habe em shift bound. Not a mousd fan.
to each their own
Qertfg are all bound lol. Fuck strafing
o.O
I once knew someone who shift-bound WASD to abilities while unshifted was normal movement. they were nuts
I have ten abilities on my mouse
I worry about you Kalryn
Im on drugs
Can't find much on trinkets is a 360 [Lingering Sporepods] any good? Or should I stick to a 355 [Syringe of Bloodborne Infirmity] with blockades?
Its ok
And I dont use one of those Naga mouses
those are great keys, karlyn
@vagrant cape that is up there with people using right click for foward movement in FPSs and shit
guys we need to do an intervention for Kalryn
So I have Revenge, IP, SB, SR all on mousebinds/shift+mousebinds.
they are heathens and wrong
U can still strafe with mouse if ur not dumb
SB, Interrupt, Hero Leap, storm bolt, taunt, and intimidating shout are all on my mouse
i have IP on the mouse lol
Rotational abilities on mouse binds is a bit much for me
had it on mouse in legion as well
If I use Q and E for abilities, where will I bind my "turn" keys?!?!
lol. "several people are typing"
I use like... similar themeed abilities on the shift modifier, the shift version is like the next level.
q = kick, shift+q = spell reflect
r = shield block, shift + r = shield wall
e = IP, shift+e = Last stand,
etc.
No shit, told a druid tank to backpedal a boss instead of strafing and giving em his back, and he said "S is bound to sit"
q is devastate you heathen
q = shield block
Anyway that's the day I found out he came from an RP server
e = ip
I started listing all 10 binds i have on my mouse
e is shield slam you idiots
Then I realied nobody cares
@knotty ermine man I sort of respect that level of shit-baggery though
1 is shield slam you dumbass
1 is IP you mongrel
1 is for afk
2 is TC
aw
2 is taunt you flatus
3 is for wrapon unsheathe
I agree 2 is TC
I care, @grim prism
4 is sit
1 is for devastate you shits
3 is revenge you moron
shift + R is TC
I mean, it's prot warrior channel. might as well bind every key to /camp till blizz fixes us RIGHT BOIS?
middle mouse button is taunt you mongoloid
5 is teabag macro
4 is thunderclap
y'all are dumb
F is for Family is a good show
@vagrant cape 3 is indeed revenge
3 is ignore pain
Okay well how about something a little more useful: what macros do you guys use regularly in PvE?
3 and shift + R are both revenge, just in case
Mouseover interrupts, mouseover HThrow, anything else?
/sit / stand /macro teabag (repeats macro)
i used to have a mouseover intercept but it kept getting me in trouble
@vagrant cape But only if you're an IDIOT
@brave jetty mouseover heroic throw gets more mileage than anything else I have
for easy safeguarding allies
strafing is faster and doesnt put mobs behind you if done properly though
I actually don't use macros, either. I should look into some
Mouseover charge is nice too
Mouseover heroic throw is the only one I don't think I woudl want to live without
oh, I use a mouseover intercept. that's about it
Mouseover intercept probably pretty good too
I should get the heroic throw
I might do that now that I'm regularly kiting in high keys but yeah
pffffft people using intercept. tryhards
anyone use mouseover taunt? if so, how is it?
Macros are for shit stains that can't tab target
I think I have those two and the rest are just modifier cast macros
I also have @ stormbolt but i dont run bolt often
Because im bad
And lazy
And i'll take the passive that makes my team's stuns DR harder
But how many of you macro your abilities with RP-chatting though?
Back by in BC was the golden age of mousebinds though. I had a BM Hunter that I co-mained depending on what we were doing, and let me tell you.... Having a class that could do maximum DPS with a 1-button macro was amazing. I had a Logitech mouse with a free-spinning mode for the mousewheel. Scroll up was bound to Beastial wrath I believe, and scroll down was the dps macro. Go into combat, spin wheel, and the wheel stayed spinning for a solid 20-30 seconds on its own.
I've been considering macro'ing my spell reflect to be a yell/say to remind people not to interrupt and running it alongside normal SR
I had /train macroed to a lot of things before I got threatened with a permanent benching
but I realize nobody would ever fucking read/react lol
TFW you top dmg in sunwell progression while eating and halfway AFK
dude I think I have that same logitech mouse. it's great
I still have it on Last Stand
oh, not that
I once ran some flavor text on certain abilities but all it did was expose the fact that I mash the fuck out of my buttons sometimes prior to GCD
But they use that wheel in a lot of their mice now. Cept now it is plastic, maybe acetate. Spins well and for a bit, but missing the weight of that metal OG MX with the nice bearing that would literally spin for a solid 20-30, easily
There's the actual APM required to play the class optimally and then there's about 30 stories up, and then there's the APM I play it at because I spam like an idiot instead of just using the buffering windows.
@brave jetty Right there with you man 😄
I'be been trying to break myself of that, but like any habit it just takes time.
Turn your sounds down, except your error notification, blare that shit
TBH I just like being able to easily zoom in or out
"I CANNOT DO THAT"
I can’t bind things to scroll
Yeah I had to use a script that checks the cooldown on my last stand to keep from spamming the /yell that went with it @brave jetty
Then again this has a scroll wheel
Same, I keep my mouse wheel free for zoom, as borked as the camera angles have been lately.
@chilly brook you gotta upgrade to PowerGlove bro
I use alt-mwheel for binds. I scroll zoom too much to rebind that
Oh, nah, definitely couldn't do it again. But... When you have that perfect situation of "I can play my class at maximum performance with one button" and couple that with "I have a mouse that allows me to not even have to interact but 1-2 times per minute" well... The temptation was too great.
So you mean brewmaster monk 🙃
Yeah.... TBC Hunters with that Shot Macro were where it was AT.
I peep that corsair board tho
Corsair Mat and keyboard
I have one too. Bummer I spilled an entire cup of water into it a month ago and now my lower few macro keys dont work
Ugh. I had to take the palmrest off of mine. Hour into use and that matte rubber looked disgusting even with the slightest hint of oil or dirt on it.
I used to use their m65 as well but I broke the scroll wheel on it in the middle of a competitive PUBG match
Thats what I deserve for spending $170 on a keyboard tho
We'll, mine is similar. Lux K70, or something.
Man I love M65w
Love it otherwise though
I loved it too
Ive had two, i gave the old one to my brother years ago and it still works lol
But then I got a steelseries rival 600
And my god
That thing
So well shaped and balanced
🍆
Lol
steelseries is a really underrated brand
I'm still hunting the ideal mouse. Logitech (g700?) was decent, but the thumb buttons were a bit annoying for me. Live my naga hex right now, except I really dislike the scrollwheel and the weight, coming from a Logitech mouse.
I want something with thumb buttons as intuitive in use as the naga hex (I think the kids call my grip style as 'claw'), a clean and crisp scroll wheel, and some decent size/weight.
Ergonomics in the Hex aren't bad either, it just has zero heft to it, which I'm not completely thrilled with.
grats method
Gg method
wowprogress down lol